Public Hearings on the Barron Report.
Contributions 194–388 of 568. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
He was the one who went to Forkhill whereas my mother did not. The abduction would have happened to whomever had gone there. It was a traumatic experience for him to be put in a helicopter and whisked away. Not everybody wanted to get into a noisy machine like a helicopter over south Armagh in what were dangerous times.
Comment on this
She was only questioned at the door of the house. They were there for 20 to 30 minutes demanding information from her. She was disgusted because it was none of their business. They were not police and although it did not even happen in the North, they were making it their business. They came in a party in the name of the RUC, who were not interested and have not bothered us about it since.
Comment on this
Mr. Donegan said it appeared to him that there was British interest in the case. What other conclusions has he drawn?
Comment on this
At the time, I believed the SAS was involved. There was a famous incident on the south Armagh-north Louth Border around that time when eight SAS officers were taken by the Garda. Their weapons were checked to see if they were used in this case which indicates a level of suspicion that the SAS was involved. My radar was definitely pointed in that direction and, possibly, at loyalists. I do not know what the cover-up is about and why the Garda spread lies among the family, tried to split us apart, kept us away from the inquest, withheld new information which came forward and has refused to apologise. A public inquiry is required to get these people in front of us to tell us how it was. They seem to be running away from us.
Comment on this
Has Mr. Donegan come up with any reasons as to why the false impression about Seamus was not rectified by the Garda or the British authorities?
Comment on this
He was a lone victim and, as such, vulnerable to being defamed. He was not killed in a bombing and was the clear victim of a random act, somebody picked him out. We know who picked him out but they did not know or care who he was. The implication is that if he was picked out, maybe he deserved it, from which idea I totally disassociate myself. That is the source of the rumours. It was felt that he was a likely one and that he could be framed while matters it was wished to keep from the public could be covered up. I do not know why they wanted to do this or what was their motive in failing to go after the killers when they knew who they were from fairly early on. Apparently, they knew within three months that it was not the IRA, but they never told us that. They harped on throughout the years — not to me but to my relatives — that it was the IRA and they even named a member of the family as a person involved in the killing. That is hard to take.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Donegan for his account. The British army personnel arrived at the home of Mr. Donegan's parents the day after the burial. How did they arrive? Were they in uniform or plain clothes?
Comment on this
They were in uniform. I do not know if they walked to the area or came by helicopter, but they stood at the door in uniform.
Comment on this
No, I was not present. I was at work and it was all over when I came home.
Comment on this
Mr. Donegan's father never mentioned their rank and the soldiers did not identify themselves as ranking officers.
Comment on this
No, they were just soldiers. I imagine one of them was a junior officer but I cannot vouch for that.
Comment on this
Yes, they said that as a fact. They came to establish as fact that Seamus was killed by the IRA and must have deserved it and that he must have been a bad man.
Comment on this
I think it came from whomever sent the soldiers to our door. I do not think the soldiers who came to our door knew anything about the case. They came to do a job and were told what to do. They were sent by somebody to deliver that message and drive that point home, whether they knew it was right or not. Somebody in Forkhill, Bessbrook or wherever sent them to do it. They wanted to establish the fact that Seamus was killed by the IRA and must have deserved it. The implication, of course, is that he was an informer.
Comment on this
Yes, but he did not go toForkhill because they told him. He went because he wanted to sort out the matter with the RUC.
Comment on this
I do not think any members of the RUC were available. If they were there, they were not interested in him.
Comment on this
It was a military operation which apparently had nothing to do with the RUC. They bundled him onto a chopper and sent him to Bessbrook where he was interrogated.
Comment on this
The Barron report states that the line of inquiry pursued related to the Garda line of inquiry. Had Mr. Donegan's father already spoken to the Garda at that stage?
Comment on this
I do not think so. He had discussions with some detectives over a subsequent period of months. I think this incident took place on the day after the funeral. When there is a death in a family, particularly a very traumatic death such as Seamus's, families become very closed in. I do not think my father had any discussion with the Garda. I do not even think he saw any gardaí.
Comment on this
Yes, he did so on several occasions and gardaí convinced him that the IRA did it.
Comment on this
Yes, they were singing from the hymn sheet on both sides of the Border. The same message was coming across. They wanted us to believe the IRA killed Seamus and that somebody in the family was involved. If the family is divided, by definition we are not united and in no fit state to oppose the censorship taking place around us or question what is going on. To some extent, that worked over the years.
Comment on this
The impression given to Mr. Donegan's family from the beginning was that the IRA was involved.
Comment on this
That is a fact. My father got that impression on both sides of the Border.
Comment on this
Why did the security authorities on both sides of the Border come up with the same false statement or allegation?
Comment on this
If I were a conspiracy theorist, I would imagine that gardaí in Dundalk probably knew more than they are still letting on and that they were probably aware that something was happening in Dundalk that night. We have information that a certain individual was being sought in Dundalk that night. There was a target. The cover story we have been told is that there was a drinking spree and they just happened to find themselves in Dundalk but we know they were there to kill a man whom they subsequently did not find.
Comment on this
The four loyalists were in Dundalk to kill an individual. They could not find him and it was while on their way home that they came upon our uncle.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Donegan believe that the British army was connected in some way with this case?
Comment on this
I believe the British army and the RUC have been always connected with such cases and evidence is growing all the time about their involvement with the loyalist death squads. I am convinced of that.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Donegan believe that the questioning of his father was related in some way?
Comment on this
I do. I believe people in the British army in Bessbrook or Forkhill also had knowledge of what happened or what was going down in Dundalk that night and they wanted to know what we knew and, more important, what the Garda knew.
Comment on this
There was an initial visit. Mr. Donegan's father travelled; then he was taken in a helicopter. It all took place in the space of one day.
Comment on this
Yes. That was it. My father continued to have meetings with the Garda, south of the Border, over the following months but never again with the British army or the RUC.
Comment on this
Is it Mr. Donegan's belief this was a quite deliberate attempt by the army to find out what it could in relation to it——
Comment on this
I believe it had knowledge, if not prior knowledge. It just wanted to know what we and the Garda knew. I believe it was checking its cover.
Comment on this
How firm is Mr. Donegan's information that there might have been a different hit target?
Comment on this
It is very firm. As I said, we have a name. I have a note here. Does Deputy Peter Power wish to ask a question?
Comment on this
I have just one very brief question. Everybody here was impressed by Mr. Donegan's command of the detail of what happened at the time. However, he said he did not know why the Garda would come up with a tissue of lies. With his knowledge, could he not speculate in order that we could examine the possibility of why the Garda would go through an elaborate sham when it had no evidence to back it up?
Comment on this
To be quite honest, I do not think speculation would be very useful. That is why we want a public inquiry, in order that we can get away from the speculation. Let us get to the facts.
Comment on this
We have to stick to policy in this matter. We will move on from there and come back to that point. Deputy Costello will ask a brief final question.
Comment on this
My question relates to the inquest. Was any attempt made to contact Mr. Donegan's family?
Comment on this
Not at all. The first we heard of the inquest was in the following weeks in the Dundalk Democrat. That hurt a lot. We heard along with the rest. People came up to us and asked what had happened but we did not know. It was embarrassing to find we did not know what had gone on at the inquest into how our loved one had been murdered in such foul circumstances. We knew nothing about it. Nobody else was approached. My aunts, Mrs. Nan Sharkey and Mrs. Eileen Fox, live at Thistle Cross, next door to each other where my uncle, Seamus Ludlow, had lived. The garda responsible for informing the family was stationed at Dromad. He would have had to drive past their houses to go to Dundalk, yet he could not drop in to let them know about the inquest.
Comment on this
I appreciate Mr. Donegan might not be able to answer this question but to the best of his knowledge, did the Garda ever interview or take a statement from his father with regard to that whole episode?
Comment on this
To be quite honest, I do not know. I know he met them on a number of occasions. He met them once or twice in a car. A statement would hardly have been made in that kind of situation but he went to the barracks at least twice.
Comment on this
Regarding Mr. Donegan's oral submission on the murder of Mr. Seamus Ludlow and his suspicion about security forces involvement, would he agree the answer to his question is that because members of the security forces were involved in the murder, we will not get the answers? There is a whole murky field on the issue of the security services operating on both sides of the Border at the time.
Comment on this
Thank you, Mr. Donegan. It is very difficult for everyone here, especially, as Mr. McGuill said, with the constrictions in regard to the Ardagh v. Maguire case. Mr. Donegan’s remarks have been very illuminating and helpful.
Mr. Brendan Ludlow is a nephew of Seamus Ludlow. Perhaps he will give us some information on how the family felt.
Comment on this
I thank the sub-committee for the opportunity to attend and to speak. In 1972, two gardaí came to stay in our house and they were put up by my mother and father. This is how my mother and father treated the State. They put them up between 1972 and 1976. I joined the 27th battalion of the Defence Forces in 1977 and operated on the Border where Seamus was killed. I operated there from 1977 until 1999. This is how we treated the State. The State has treated us as described from 1976 to date; we have had nothing else but the same treatment from the Garda Síochána.
Comment on this
Given Mr. Brendan Ludlow's experience as a member of the Defence Forces when the RUC supplied names to the Garda Síochána — a matter on which there was no follow-up by the force — does he believe there was a policy in the Twenty-Six Counties at the time to the effect that leads given by the RUC to the Garda would not be followed up or that the Garda would not interview people in the Six Counties? Does he believe that a political decision was made in this regard?
Comment on this
There was never any effort on the part of the security forces, the Garda Síochána or the Army in the South to interview people in the North.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Ludlow believe the Garda was under instructions on foot of a policy not to interview the four people the RUC mentioned?
Comment on this
Does Mr. Brendan Ludlow believe that decision was correct or incorrect in the context of the period? The excuse has been made that the UK authorities were seeking other concessions, including the right to overfly the Republic's territory, at that stage. In that context, politicians down here made a decision based on the belief that if they sought rights in the Six Counties, they would have to concede rights to the British in the Twenty-Six Counties.
Comment on this
I did not join the Defence Forces until a year later, 1977.
Comment on this
Given Mr. Brendan Ludlow's understanding of the circumstances at the time, does he believe that was the only alternative?
Comment on this
I would say that was the alternative they came up with.
Comment on this
I would like to ask about something that has been discussed before. What is Mr. Brendan Ludlow's reaction to Mr. Justice Barron's finding that the Garda investigation, as a clinical investigation, was carried out properly?
Comment on this
Would he make a distinction between the actual investigation and the manner in which the Garda behaved towards the family?
Comment on this
Basically, the Garda told my father nothing. They treated my aunts and uncles with the utmost disrespect.
Comment on this
There has been no contact whatsoever from the Garda about any of those issues since then.
Comment on this
There has been no apology and nothing has come forward at all.
Comment on this
When it became clear to the Garda that it had misinformed the family and that the initial allegations or rumours were incorrect, no efforts were made——
Comment on this
Thank you, Brendan, for coming in to assist us. We received a helpful document from your solicitor prior to our hearings which indicates that Brendan Ludlow's contribution will address the sense of betrayal experienced by the family. We can all understand that. The document states that your contribution will address how ordinary citizens fell victim to what appear to have been State policies which did not spare the most deserving. Could you elaborate on those State policies?
Comment on this
The document from your solicitor states that your contribution will address how ordinary citizens fell victim to what appears to have been State policies — Irish State policies — which did not spare the most deserving, presumably your uncle.
Comment on this
I do not understand, but I think what you mean is my mother and father had put up two gardaí in the house. They were very helpful to the State. I was very helpful to the State when I took a job in the Defence Forces. From 1976, however, until 2006 we have been treated in the same way by the Garda Síochána, we do not get any information from them.
Comment on this
The document says there was a State policy. I am trying to find out what that policy was. Was there a policy——
Comment on this
That addresses Mr. Justice Barron's observation that security branch had a policy decision and that policy decision in effect meant that this crime was not investigated and this family was not protected. That is obviously something this committee will wish to examine. It is the classic big policy question, something we are anxious that the committee explore.
Comment on this
We will not do that immediately. We would like to stick with Mr. Brendan Ludlow and what he has to say.
Comment on this
The family obviously had issues with the Garda and the State from early on. Why, on a personal level, did you feel it appropriate for you to become a member of an organ of the State? The Garda is similar to the Army.
Comment on this
Why did I become a member of the Defence Forces?
Comment on this
I said to myself that my uncle had been shot and perhaps I could go out and stop other people from being shot. As that is how I felt, I decided to join the Defence Forces.
Comment on this
That is very admirable. Because of your knowledge of activities along the Border at that time, did you ever come to your own conclusion as to why the Garda would lie to you? What was their motivation behind lying to your family?
Comment on this
I think they did not want to know about the Ludlow family. The statement was made that it was political and he was shot by his own.
Comment on this
Thank you. You have been very helpful. We now come to Ms Briege Doyle, a niece of Seamus. Please tell us what you want to say.
Comment on this
I am Mr. Jimmy Sharkey's daughter, I was reared in the same house as Seamus. I was only 16 when he was murdered. When you are 16, it was an awful thing for your uncle to die and it was worse that he was shot. I remember the special branch questioned me in a car on my own. I was taken into a car outside auntie Eileen's house and I was asked who did I think killed my uncle. I was only 16, I had not a clue. I did not know anything about the troubles in the North. He was a quiet man. I was reared with him — as was Jimmy — and he would not harm a hair on your head. It is sad to see a young man die like that. He did not deserve what he got.
Comment on this
We loved him. I loved all my uncles but because we were reared with him he was like another father to us. Although there were ten of us he never scolded us. He was a lovely person. I was only 16 and could not understand who would shoot my uncle.
Comment on this
Ms Doyle was obviously very young and impressionable at the age of 16 and this was probably her first experience of bereavement.
Comment on this
Can she recall whether there was much interaction with the gardaí coming to the house after the murder?
Comment on this
I recall them calling but when one was aged 16 one did not stand listening to them. I recall them taking me into a car on my own. I was afraid because I was only 16 years old and neither my mother nor father was with me.
Comment on this
That was near the time of my uncle's funeral, shortly after he died.
Comment on this
The family has acknowledged that there was some contact during 1976 but can Ms Doyle recall whether there was any further contact with the Garda Síochána in 1979 or 1980?
Comment on this
People called to the house to see my mother or father, not me.
Comment on this
Was Ms Doyle unaware of the likely suspects involved in her uncle's death until the events of the mid-1990s?
Comment on this
I was led to believe that Uncle Seamus was shot in mistake for somebody else. Now I know that was not true.
Comment on this
Ms Doyle is very welcome and I extend my sympathies to her. Ms Doyle said that she was 16 years old at the time of her uncle's death and she was very close to him. One can tell from today's submission about Seamus that this is a case of the slaughter of the innocent. The more I listen to the family the more insight I receive. It is important that we understand what a nice, decent, kind person Seamus was.
Will Ms Doyle give us more information about the kind of questions the special branch officers asked her when she was 16 years of age and how she felt at the time?
Comment on this
I was afraid. I was in the back of the car and they were in the front. They asked me repeatedly who did I think killed my uncle. I said I did not know. They repeated the question and said the IRA shot him. I did not know what the IRA was. I knew nothing.
Comment on this
Years later when Ms Doyle discussed this with members of her extended family did she understand the significance of what the special branch officers tried to do when she was 16 years old?
Comment on this
Did Ms Doyle think they were digging deeper to see whether the family thought Seamus was involved in an internal paramilitary feud or something of that kind? Were they hinting at that?
Comment on this
They probably were but I was only a child. That is not to say it did not bother me but I did not understand it at the time.
Comment on this
When Ms Doyle reflects on Seamus's murder does she think this was a murky cover up by the security forces of this State and in the North? Does the family feel that this was a case of gross incompetence and mismanagement by the security forces and senior gardaí in respect of Seamus's case? What is Ms Doyle's considered view now?
Comment on this
It was just bad policing. The police did not care.
Comment on this
We are not investigating that issue because Mr. Justice Barron said that it was competent and diligent.
Comment on this
I accept that; I accept that we have terms of reference.
Another insight from today, which many people will not necessarily have tapped into previously, concerns the messages that were put out on the night of Seamus Ludlow's murder. It was suggested then that the loyalists and members of the security forces, whoever they were, who killed Seamus were involved in some kind of drinking spree whereas, from the family's perspective, that was not the case.
Comment on this
It is important that is made public, given that many people were given impression that those who murdered Seamus were on a drinking spree and that his murder happened only by accident. We need to go into all those questions. That seems to be the family's considered view as well.
Comment on this
I thank Briege Doyle for her evidence. I know it has not been easy for her, but we appreciate her coming here to give evidence.
We will now hear from Mr. Jimmy Sharkey, who is a nephew of Seamus Ludlow. I welcome him to the meeting.
Comment on this
I thank the sub-committee for inviting us here today. I also thank Mr. Justice Barron for compiling his report, although it has left us with many unanswered questions. We hope that some of those questions will be addressed today, but I must reiterate that the only proper forum in which those can be addressed is an independent public inquiry. That is our bottom line, nothing less and nothing more.
I will go back over what Kevin Ludlow and Eileen Fox said about the informer thing. The first time I ever heard about that was when Mr. Justice Barron told us about it at a meeting with him. I do not have a clue where that came from. It is stated on page 18 or 19 of the report that it came from a "source", but Mr. Justice Barron did not tell us who that source was.
Briege Doyle said she was questioned by the Garda Special Branch in the back of a car. I, too, was twice questioned in the back of a car by Special Branch officers. On the first occasion, they took a softly softly approach, as they tried to get to know what I knew and things like that. The second time, they took a more hardline approach when they asked me who I thought killed Seamus. They kept saying that it was the IRA, but I said I did not think it was the IRA. When I mentioned to them that I thought the SAS or a loyalist group killed him, one particular garda got very agitated about that. He kept pointing and gesturing to me in the back seat saying things like, "You know f-ing well who killed Seamus Ludlow. You tell us it was the IRA".
I did not get agitated about that because I knew what these guys were up to. Their whole persona and body language told me a different story. I was probably more streetwise than Briege Doyle, so I knew about being taken into a car with strange people. I knew what was happening in the north of Ireland at that time, with loyalist groups, the IRA and the SAS operating along the Border. However, that was the line of questioning from the gardaí. They did not want to hear anything about loyalist groups or the SAS; all they wanted to hear about was the IRA.
The reason for that, I believe, is that it suited the climate at the time. As the IRA was a threat to this State at that time, anything that the gardaí could use in their armoury to fight against the IRA had to be used. Here was a family, a member of which was killed, but the gardaí did not care about that — they had no interest in that whatsoever — as they were using it as a political means in the war against the IRA.
Of course, we lived in an area that was close to the Border — the nearest point to the Border was probably two miles away — and there was a lot of loyalist and republican activity on the Border at that time. Numerous killings took place. As this was six months after the bombing in Dundalk, security was high in the area.
Those people came down from Belfast that night. They did not come down to kill Seamus. I know who they came to kill. Mr. Justice Barron was very interested to know where I got that person's name. I would not tell him and have no intention of giving that name here today. I will give it when a proper forum is set up. I did not tell the Garda at the time who that person was.
The people involved would not have taken the chance of driving into a hotbed such as Dundalk town or even into County Louth. It would be like us going to the Shankill Road to kill someone. One has to know where one is going. These guys, two members of the British security forces, were in the town that night, in the car, heavily armed. As their target did not appear, they picked up Seamus. It could have been anyone, but they killed him.
As a member of the Ludlow family, I can accept that Seamus was a victim of the fall-out of the Troubles in the North, but I cannot accept the lies and deceit which the Garda has spun for 30 years and which it is still spinning. It has not even apologised. When I started all this, I was followed by gardaí. They asked me what I knew and so on. The Garda has a lot to hide.
When the journalist came to me with the information, he did not have a clue who killed Seamus. He was told by a Garda source that it was fellows from Comber-Dundonald direction. He did not believe that. He asked me who I thought killed Seamus, and I said I thought it was the SAS. He said this was wrong, that a Garda source had told him who it was, and that the Garda had known this for a long time, perhaps 20 years. The garda who gave the journalist that information was one of the gardaí who questioned me in the car.
I also met that garda in 1978 in the Derryhill Hotel in Dundalk where I was at a meeting. He recognised me in the hotel toilet and addressed me by name. I asked him how he was and he said he was okay. I said to him that I did not think he would know who I was. He said he did know and that in his job he had to know who I was. I said to him that if he knew who I was, could he tell me who killed Seamus Ludlow. He said I knew effing well who killed him and he then walked out the door.
Joe Tiernan told me that he thought it was loyalists from the Portadown area who killed Seamus and he gave me a list of names which I handed over to the Garda. I had the name of the driver of the car that night, but I did not hand it over. The committee should not ask me why, but I did not hand it over.
I will now fast-forward 20 years to when I met the head of the gardaí in Dublin who had charge of the case. I met him in the Ardboyne Hotel in Navan. I was on my own. He asked me about the case and told me that the names I passed on were not those of the people involved. I asked him if he knew the names of those involved. He said he did and that they were known for a long time. He was able to tell me the car those people were in that night, where they were seated in the car and the conversation that went on in the car that night. About three weeks later I met him again in the car park of the Garda station in Balbriggan. It was a cordial meeting and we certainly got to know each other. He said I might as well forget about it, since the names I had handed over were not the correct ones. That is what he said. It was around that time that I produced another name and handed it to him. His face went white. He asked me where I had got it but I would not tell him. Personally, I feel it was from then on that the case took off.
The gardaí involved said we had to deal with the families, taking those boys in to see if they had any other information. It was then that they started to meet us in the house. They met Kevin Ludlow and me there, as well as the mother. Of course, they were gathering intelligence all the time and we were given only so much. We were not getting very much back. They did not tell us at that time who had killed Seamus Ludlow and it was the garda with whom I was in the car who told me that the Garda Síochána had that information. Then the case took off and they started to interview different branches of the family, including the Sharkeys, the Donegans and the Ludlows. He told us he would come back and tell us everything, but he did not do so. I did not believe him, but I could not say that to the rest of the family.
The case took off at that time and people were arrested in the North of Ireland and England. Someone liaised with me and told me that the people in question were being interviewed in Castlereagh. I met them in the car park of the Fairways Hotel one Saturday afternoon. They kept saying to me that the interviews were going well enough but that the suspects were not saying very much. Two were talking and two were not. The worst that they thought I would get out of it was a file going to the DPP. I think a decision had been made that a file would be sent to the DPP and that they would not prosecute the suspects. They were obviously protecting whomever they had been protecting from 1976. I felt they would not come back and say the suspects would be charged, even though two of them had implicated themselves in the murder. I ask why those two were not charged and that if one charges two, why does one not charge the other two? It opens a can of worms.
In general, the Garda Síochána's behaviour towards us over 30 years has been nothing short of terrible. It has been a terrible experience for us all and even harder for Kevin Ludlow, Eileen Fox and Nan Sharkey. It is also hard for the rest of us at times. I was not surprised that the Garda did that or that the State acted as it did. They have done so in similar cases, including the Monaghan and Dublin cases and, as we will see, that of Dundalk. They simply did not care. The only way that one will ever get answers is through an independent inquiry — it must be an inquiry. That is all I have to say.
Comment on this
I, too, thank Mr. Sharkey for that very clear account. How old was he when Mr. Ludlow died?
Comment on this
Therefore, Mr. Sharkey would have been absolutely aware of everything that was going on.
Comment on this
Yes, but I was trying to get on with my life. Events were unfolding in the North of Ireland and I was aware of them. I was more streetwise, but I was aware.
Comment on this
Was the rumour out from the beginning that Mr. Ludlow had been murdered by the IRA? Was there awareness in the community about it, or were rumours spread, or was it just something that the gardaí said to Mr. Sharkey?
Comment on this
It was something that the gardaí said to me, especially the second time when I being interviewed in the car. The second time, I was put into the back seat of a car for nearly two hours. I was not taken to the barracks. I was questioned, which in itself can be very hostile. They did not mention the IRA the first time, but they did the second time. I think that once the gardaí were satisfied that some of the Ludlow family — not all of the family, but certain members such as Kevin Ludlow here — believed that it was the IRA, then they were happy enough. In general, the people who lived around Thistlecross and Ravenshill in Dundalk were listening to what the Garda were saying and what was in the paper.
Comment on this
Was Mr. Sharkey's view that the gardaí had misbehaved, that they had misinformed him and that they were also blackening Mr. Ludlow's good name?
Comment on this
Yes. They were blackening his good name for a reason. I had a good idea that they had a reason for it, but at that time I had no clue what the reason was. The family had not had any contact with the Garda before this. The Garda Síochána is the law in this State and we would have respected the Garda, but the gardaí had no respect for us. I still cannot understand why they were so hostile to us.
Comment on this
Why does Mr. Sharkey think that the Garda Síochána did not pursue the investigation when there was firm information and evidence to follow?
Comment on this
In 1979. Mr. Justice Barron came to the conclusion that they did all they could in 1976, but they had substantial information to follow in 1979. Would Mr. Sharkey agree with that analysis?
Comment on this
No. The failings lie in 1976. If the committee members look three years further on to 1979, then they are missing the whole thing. They are not seeing the wood for the trees. In 1976, the Garda probably did not know who killed Seamus Ludlow as they did not have enough concrete information, suspects and so on, but they knew the IRA did not do it. There were only two groups carrying out killings at that time — apart from the SAS, which came on the scene around that time — and they were the republicans and the loyalists. The Garda would have known that the loyalists were involved in the bombings in the town in December 1975, six months before Mr. Ludlow was killed. They had to be channelling their intelligence elsewhere, but they kept a spin on the incident the whole time that it was the IRA, for the reasons that I outlined earlier.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Sharkey believe that the Garda Síochána deliberately chose not to pursue the investigation in 1976 and 1979?
Comment on this
In 1976, when they ran into the sand, they did not come back to us with what they had been told. They did not come back to us and say: "This is what we have been told." They kept up this spin that it was the IRA all the time. That is all I ever heard.
Moving forward to 1979, when the gardaí received the information, they drove to Belfast. They had to pass our house on their way back to Dublin. They had the names. It was for a reason. It was probably due to the Cabinet at the time. One must remember who was in power in 1976 and what their agenda was. That is what I think should be considered.
Comment on this
We do not want to apportion responsibility now. We want to stick to the policy issues, Deputy Costello.
Comment on this
With all due respect, I think that is what the feelings were in 1976. The information was gathered over a period. We had a meeting with the ombudsman in the North of Ireland. She told us there was intelligence information from early 1977. The question must be asked whether that was passed on to the Garda Síochána in Dundalk. I believe it was. It would have been passed on to certain gardaí and probably also to Garda Headquarters. However, the information was confined and only started to leak out after a while.
In early 1976 there was no full presentation by the Garda Síochána. Up to the present day, there is no trace of where his clothing went, where the bullets were sent and matters like that. The gardaí failed twice. They had chances to do their job in 1979 and 1998 but they did not do it. The only way we will ever know why they did not do so is through an independent inquiry.
Comment on this
Mr. Sharkey stated he withheld from Mr. Justice Barron the name of a person he thinks the assassins intended to assassinate. Has other information not been presented to Mr. Justice Barron? For example, the information that the ombudsman had further information about 1977, to which Mr. Sharkey referred, does not seem to have been available to Mr. Justice Barron. Are there other issues which Mr. Sharkey felt should be withheld because a public inquiry is the way to proceed, or for any other reason?
Comment on this
Mr. Justice Barron does not mention the ombudsman in the North of Ireland having intelligence. It was there in the form of RUC special branch intelligence. Again, this is where a public inquiry would come in. Given that Mr. Justice Barron's report was held in private, we do not know what he heard or from who he heard it. We cannot turn around in one year's time and go back to a private inquiry — it must be a public inquiry. We must be able to ask the questions we have been waiting 30 years to ask.
To answer the Deputy's question, it is hard to know what evidence Mr. Justice Barron heard. He was very coy when I asked him anything. He had his way around my questions. However, when, during the meeting he had with us, he wanted to know whether I had the name of this man, he kept asking me from where I got the name and how I came by it.
Comment on this
No, we are not and I do not propose to do so. I have a further question for Mr. Sharkey. What happened with regard to the coroner's inquiry?
Comment on this
That was part of what I consider to be a cover up. The aim was to keep the family away from the inquest.
Comment on this
No. There was contact with Mr. Kevin Ludlow and there seemed to be a belief that once he was present, their job was done. However, he was unable to be there. The inquest was held without any of us there and without a legal team to represent us. That answers everything.
Comment on this
Everything was deliberate; it was all a plan. We were to believe it was the IRA. This was the information being thrown out.
Comment on this
No, I do not believe the coroner would have known.