We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Justice, Home Affairs and Migration

Criminal Legal Aid: Discussion (Resumed)

Summary

Justice Minister Jim O’Callaghan defended the new flat-fee criminal legal aid scheme, arguing that multiple certificates had driven excessive District Court payments and that reform serves the public interest. He said the scheme was operating nationwide, but acknowledged service withdrawals and court disruption; members challenged his claim that rape cases had been deliberately targeted and urged meaningful negotiations. The Minister said he would meet the Law Society and consider adjustments, particularly for Children’s Court cases, but would not restore multiple certificates. He confirmed that no data records who sought adjournments, leaving the causes of delays unanalysed; no agreement was reached.

Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Apologies have been received from Deputy Paula Butterly, for part of the meeting, and from Senators Ruane and Kelleher. Deputy Barry Ward will attend in substitution for Deputy Butterly for the engagement on criminal legal aid and Senator Frances Black will attend in substitution for Senator Ruane for the engagement on the prevention of unprovoked assault.

We have an incredibly busy agenda. We are discussing two very important matters and I ask for the full participation and co-operation of all the witnesses and members. The meeting will be convened in two separate sessions. Our first engagement will be on criminal legal aid and it will be followed by an engagement on the prevention of unprovoked one-punch assaults and sentencing frameworks for such assaults.

The purpose of this part of the meeting is to resume the engagement on the topic of criminal legal aid and related matters. On behalf of the committee, I welcome the Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration, Deputy Jim O'Callaghan, and his officials to the meeting. The format of the meeting is that the Minister will make an opening statement of a maximum of three minutes, after which I will call members of the committee in the order in which they indicate to put their questions. In order to manage the committee's time effectively, I propose that each member will have a five-minute engagement with the Minister.

I remind members of the tight timeframe and that we are dealing with two important topics. If that is all in order, I will invite the Minister to make his opening statement.

Comment on this
Jim O'Callaghan Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration Fianna Fáil

I thank the Chairman and the committee for inviting me back. As members will recall, I was here on 30 June when we discussed the criminal legal aid scheme in the District Courts. I now have an opportunity to give the committee further information. I am conscious that I only have three minutes, so I cannot read out my whole statement. I ask that the committee take it as read.

On the developments since 1 July, the scheme is operating nationwide. Legal aid continues to be granted, solicitors continue to provide representation and legal services are being provided throughout the districts. I acknowledge, however, that, particularly in Dublin, a number of solicitors have withdrawn services, which has impacted on court hearings. That is regrettable. Despite this, in the Central Criminal Court yesterday, the majority of cases proceeded without issue. Five trials continued in the Central Criminal Court in Dublin, with both Waterford and Limerick unaffected by the strike and the cases listed there continuing.

There were also 12 new trials listed in the call-over in Dublin yesterday. In two of these, the jury were sworn in and are to commence today. A guilty plea was entered in a third case. Three trials were adjourned to 20 October because of applications that were unaffected by the withdrawal of services. Six cases were adjourned due to the withdrawal of services by solicitors. Every one of these was a case involving an allegation of rape. I should place on record my deep concern that the only cases deliberately affected by the withdrawal of services in the Central Criminal Court yesterday were those involving allegations of rape.

Since 1 July, 3,385 criminal legal aid certificates have been issued in the District Court under the new arrangements. Certificates have been issued across the vast majority of districts. These account for a total of €1.76 million for District Court cases. In the three and a half months since the scheme commenced, including August when a lot of the District Courts were closed, the top three earning solicitors under the new scheme have earned €163,000, €132,000 and €109,000, respectively. Some 51 solicitors who resigned in July have been reinstated and 177 solicitors have engaged with the new system.

Further information has become available to us regarding the cases concluded under the new scheme. As of 2 October 2026, 75% had concluded with one appearance only in court and 99% of concluded cases were finalised within five appearances.

I am conscious that I only have about a minute left so I will take members to that part of the opening statement that contains examples from 2025 of multiple certification for one accused. I am putting this in because I am conscious that one of the suggestions or criticisms made against me was that I could only come up with three examples. There were 900 individuals who, in 2025, had ten or more certificates issued to them by way of multiple certificates. This is an example of what was happening under the system as it operated prior to 1 July. If one looks at it, one can see that in the Dublin District Court, there were money laundering charges where 131 certificates were issued, there were only two appearances in the District Court and the fees payable to the solicitor would amount to €26,800. What I want to emphasise is that in a huge number of these cases, although they start in the District Court, because of their seriousness, they will go up to the Circuit Court so a Circuit Court fee will be payable as well. In the Cork District Court, 112 certificates were granted, there were eight District Court appearances, the fee payable in the District Court was €63,200 and then the Circuit Court fee becomes payable as well.

The data set out in the schedule and in the examples from 2025 make it absolutely imperative for me to act. I would be remiss in the performance of my duties if I did not act. When people then have cases transferred up to the Circuit Court, the Circuit Court fee then applies. I have included detail of that in my statement.

I am also conscious of the issue of engagement with the Law Society. I met with the Law Society in May and July. It wrote to me last Tuesday after the adjournment of Mr. Quinn's case. I have written back to it. I will engage with the Law Society. If there are issues that I can tweak, as I have done before, I will tweak them but the regulations themselves are in the public interest and the best interest of court users. I know that reform is difficult but I have to look at what is in the best interest of the public and court users, not what is in the best interests of legal practitioners.

Comment on this

I will start with what the Minister said about the multiple assignments. I do not think solicitors expect there to be multiple assignments where there are multiple charges, but where there are distinct issues before the court, such as different dates, different gardaí or different sets of charges, does the Minister agree that should and could happen, that it is permissible under regulation 7(4) and that, if it is permissible, it is the scheme's fault and not the solicitor's fault?

Comment on this

There are occasions where there are distinct charges. For instance, a garda may come in with a number of charges. For example, with an individual who is charged with stealing a bottle of vodka from three shops, there are three charges in respect to that. When that arises, there will just be one certificate even though the theft was from three shops. If subsequently An Garda Síochána says it wants to add a further charge, in those circumstances, another certificate - another €520 - will become payable. There are circumstances where distinct charges that come before the court, separate from the previous charges, will attract a separate fee. I have indicated that this is an issue that I recognise should be part of the scheme, but it is possible under the scheme for that to happen.

Comment on this

If the Minister wanted to change the way the scheme operates, would it not have been easier to simply delete regulation 7(4), rather than start from scratch and do all the damage that has been done?

Comment on this

I disagree. First of all, I am not going to get into the damage that has been done. In terms of what was happening under the scheme, applications were being made for the purpose of getting a further certificate. A good reason had to be put it for that and in many instances, that was not happening. People were just being granted multiple certificates without good reason being set out and even when that was refused, as the Deputy knows, judicial review applications were brought challenging that. It is better to put in the new scheme, rather than just amend regulation 7(4), as the Deputy suggested.

Comment on this

They are a tiny proportion of the number of assignments. We are talking about single figures in terms of percentage points and in almost all instances, multiple assignments under regulation 7(4) are simply not paid, so it is not something that is affecting the cost of the scheme.

Comment on this

My statement contains a section entitled "why reform was necessary". It establishes, and this is new data for the committee, that in 2025, approximately 100,000 criminal legal aid certificates were issued in the District Court and 25% of certificates issued in 2025 were multiple certificates for cases heard together. It is, therefore, certainly the case that at least 25,000 of the 100,000 certificates issued in the District Court were part of multiple certificates, attracting further payments. There is further detail set out there in terms of the number of certificates and the number of individuals who have received certificates of multiple numbers.

Comment on this

The Minister mentioned that reform is hard. Nobody has a problem with reform. The issue is the nature of the reform. The Minister reiterated that rape trials were deliberately targeted in the Central Criminal Court yesterday. That is grossly unfair commentary on the defence solicitors in court. For starters, every trial in the Central Criminal Court yesterday was a rape trial, so there is no evidence to suggest that solicitors were deliberately targeting that. It is very unfair and I think the Minister should consider withdrawing that remark because he does not have a basis for it.

Comment on this

Can I give the Deputy the facts? I am not trying to get into a further dispute but I just want to set out the facts for the Deputy. Yesterday, and I have set this out in the statement, there were six cases that were adjourned because of the withdrawal of services. All of them were rape charges. In the week before that, on 12 October, there were four cases that were adjourned because of the withdrawal of services, and all of them were rape charges.

Comment on this

How of the cases were rape trials?

Comment on this

On the week before that, on 5 October, there were five cases that were adjourned on the basis of withdrawal of services, and each one of those involved rape charges. The Deputy will know from the legal diary that when one looked at the Central Criminal Court yesterday, a series of cases was listed to go on for hearing but, similarly, there were also seven cases that were not rape cases. They were trial continuing cases and none of those cases was affected by the withdrawal of service.

Comment on this

That is because they were trials continuing. Is it not deeply disingenuous to ascribe a deliberate targeting of rape trials? It is hugely emotive, it is very unfair and it is also wrong because the evidence is not there to support it.

Comment on this

Look at yesterday's legal diary. It shows-----

Comment on this

All the cases that were available were rapes.

Comment on this

Can I be allowed to answer the question? When one looks at yesterday's legal diary, one will see that 11 Central Criminal Court judges were sitting. There were seven cases that were not rape allegation cases and none of those cases were affected. I am not trying to antagonise solicitors but I do have a responsibility to point out information that is given to me by the Courts Service. It would be unwise of me not to have said that because it is a concern of mine that the only cases that were affected in the Central Criminal Court on 5, 12 and 19 October were cases involving allegations of rape. That is not for me to-----

Comment on this

All the new trials in the Central Criminal Court yesterday were rapes.

Comment on this

Can I bring the Deputy back to 5 October-----

Comment on this

It is a simple question.

Comment on this

The same happened on 5 October. There was a series of cases that were not rapes-----

Comment on this

That is because there are far more rapes than murders in the Central Criminal Court.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Could the Minister clarify something? The Deputy is stating that all new trials available yesterday were rape cases. Is that true?

Comment on this

Yesterday in the Central Criminal Court, the allegation that was made by the solicitors was that they were going to disrupt custody cases. There were seven cases ongoing in the Central Criminal Court yesterday that were not rape cases and none of them were affected. It is the case in terms of new cases coming in that those new cases were all rape cases but there was no disruption of the existing cases that were not rape cases.

Comment on this

I will follow on from that line of questioning. The Minister implied that criminal defence solicitors targeted rape cases. Would it also be true to say that there were other cases that did not proceed in other courts, such as the District Court and the Circuit Court, yesterday because of this dispute? Those included cases involving robbery, arson, fraud, burglary, violent disorder, drug offences and money laundering, and I am sure there are more. It would be correct to say that all the cases before the Central Criminal Court yesterday were rape cases. The Minister mentioned that. He has cherry-picked one court and had a look at one court because it suits his political agenda at the moment. Will he clarify why he zoned in on the Circuit Criminal Court rather than the other courts?

Comment on this

I did not zone in on the Circuit Criminal Court. I zoned in on the Central Criminal Court-----

Comment on this

It was the Central Criminal Court, I apologise.

Comment on this

-----which is the High Court sitting in its criminal division.

Comment on this

The reason I did was because that is where the coverage was and where the campaign was yesterday. There is no doubt about that. That is where the campaign was yesterday. There was disruption-----

Comment on this

Let me finish, please. There was disruption to six rape trials in the Central Criminal Court yesterday and the only cases that were affected were rape trials that were going on yesterday. There were seven other cases that were not rape trials, which were ongoing, that were not affected. It is important that I point that out. I am conscious that maybe solicitors did not want me to point that out, but I thought it was important for me to point that out.

Comment on this

Okay, but to go back to my original point, there were other cases in other courts going on yesterday that were involved in this dispute that did not go ahead-----

Comment on this

-----including all the ones I mentioned relating to arson, fraud, burglary and violent disorder. Why did the Minister focus directly on the rape cases?

Comment on this

Because the campaign from the weekend was on how Central Criminal Court cases are going to be affected. The coverage yesterday was all about disruption to rape cases in the Central Criminal Court. I was perfectly entitled to make the point I did. I fully accept, by the way, that when we look at Dublin, there is disruption in the District Court hearings. Obviously, the Circuit Court is just back. There may be disruption in Circuit Court hearings as well. However, I also want to point out to the Deputy that when we look around the country, this scheme is working very well in other districts. We do not hear from any of the solicitors from around the country who are working in those districts, and it is important to hear them. As I have indicated to the Deputy in the data that I have put out there, already to date in the District Court, we have expended or become liable for €1.7 million and 3,400 certificates, so the scheme is working in districts around the country.

Comment on this

Again, the seven rape cases the Minister mentioned that were in the Central Criminal Court yesterday-----

Comment on this

-----were all new cases. They were all new cases; they were not continuing cases. They were all new cases.

Comment on this

They were continuing cases that were going on. There were seven cases ongoing in the Central Criminal Court yesterday. They were not rape cases. None of them were affected.

Comment on this

We were at this committee a couple of weeks ago. We have discussed this numerous times. We have heard of people who have been accused of sexual assault and rape being able to cross-examine witnesses because of this dispute that is going on. We were talking to other people and witnesses who were here at the time and they said that has never happened before, as far as they know. This is, therefore, a consequence of this action.

Comment on this

First of all, I am conscious this is a political forum. The Deputy is entitled to criticise me and hold me to account. I would have to say, however, that it is my view that solicitors should be representing people in cases like that. People should not be withdrawing their services from crucial cases like that. I compare it to the intensive care doctor or intensive care nurse. They do not withdraw their services in respect of that. That is an important point.

Comment on this

Will the Minister hold meaningful engagement with solicitors and their representatives instead of just tweaking this and that? Will he sit down and have a chat with them about what these tweaks are because we do not know?

Comment on this

It is language.

Comment on this

I will just say to the Deputy that I have no difficulty doing that and I will sit down with them. I have sat down with them before. I will sit down with the Law Society again. I have to point out as well that there are diverse views within the solicitors' profession in respect of this. Obviously, as I have indicated, a lot of solicitors around the country are operating the scheme and are happy with the scheme. We do not hear about them in the media.

Comment on this

When did the Minister last meet the Law Society?

Comment on this

I met the officials on 27 July.

Comment on this

Okay, so that is nearly two-----

Comment on this

Come on; it is not like-----

Comment on this

-----and a half months ago.

Comment on this

I met them at the end of May as well. As Minister for justice, I meet them once every two months. I will meet them before the end of October. I am prepared to meet with the Law Society. I have to tell the Deputy, however, what I am not prepared to do. I think people are confusing failing to engage with agreeing with what they want. I cannot just give in to them. I am not going to give into the demands of the solicitors.

Comment on this

The Minister is not going to tweak anything then.

Comment on this

I will certainly have a look at it and tweak things, but what I will not do is go back to a system that allows for the type of system I have pointed out in the schedule with the examples of cases from 2025. As I said, I could provide the Deputy with 900 examples of where people are being paid €26,000 and €62,000 for cases in the District Court, and those very same cases then go on to the Circuit Court where the higher fees are payable. If that had been revealed on "RTÉ Investigates" and I had that report, the Deputy would be the first to say to me that I was aware of that and ask how I could possibly allow that to continue, and he would be right.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank the Deputy. Deputy Gannon will be followed by Deputy Brabazon.

Comment on this

I just want to establish whether it is still the Minister's contention that this dispute is resigned to a group of solicitors in Dublin. He used it in his opening statement and said it several times in the media. Is that still his contention?

Comment on this

It is the case that the opposition to the scheme is most virulent in Dublin. That is unquestionable.

Comment on this

The Minister basically said it is mostly just solicitors in Dublin. I want to point the Minister to Castlebar court yesterday and also to Trim, Kerry, Wicklow, Cavan, Monaghan, Leitrim, Roscommon, Donegal, Sligo, Galway, Mayo and Cork county. Does the Minister dispute that they all had serious impacts in legal services yesterday?

Comment on this

I have here a series of 3,400 entries-----

Comment on this

The Deputy has to let me answer the question.

Comment on this

I have five minutes. The Minister has to let me say it in time.

Comment on this

I know, but the Deputy has to let me answer the questions. I have here a list of 3,400 cases that sets out the districts all around the country where certificates have been issued, including Dungarvan, Portlaoise, Kilkenny, Wexford, Clonmel, Waterford - there is a whole series of-----

Comment on this

Is it still the Minister's contention that this dispute is resigned to a number of solicitors in Dublin? Does he want me to repeat where disputes took place yesterday again? I can list out the counties for him.

Comment on this

I just want to make sure we are all on the same page here.

Comment on this

I said it is particularly a problem in Dublin.

Comment on this

It is particularly a problem. Therefore, we will just dismiss all those other counties. Okay, great. It is just so we know where we are all starting from.

When the Minister said yesterday that the solicitors are deliberately targeting rape cases in the Central Criminal Court, what evidence has he got that solicitors who withdrew their labour were also specifically targeting those cases? What other options does he think were available in terms of other cases to target in the Central Criminal Court? Is he saying that the solicitors took on work in other areas outside of rape?

Comment on this

I will say to the Deputy that the only cases deliberately affected-----

Comment on this

-----by the withdrawal of services yesterday were rape cases.

Comment on this

The Deputy might let me finish.

Comment on this

Let me ask my question. In which court?

Comment on this

In the Central Criminal Court.

Comment on this

Which other cases were being tried in the Central Criminal Court yesterday?

Comment on this

Okay, I can give the Deputy one. I can read out the person's name - the DPP v. Robert O'Connor. This is a public document here.

Comment on this

These are trials continuing?

Comment on this

The DPP v. Seth Whelan, the DPP v. James Spendley, the DPP-----

Comment on this

These are trials continuing.

Comment on this

I know. I am sorry, but why is it those trials were not affected?

Comment on this

The Minister is aware of the withdrawal of labour. He understands what happens in the Central Criminal Court. He understands the nature of the cases there. He specifically chose to attach himself to the most horrific cases in order to win sympathy for an argument, which, actually, he has not won by any sort of logic on the merits.

I am going to move forward to look at some of the outstanding-----

Comment on this

That is not a question. The Deputy really has to allow me to respond to allegations he makes like that.

Comment on this

The Minister can respond in his own time.

Comment on this

I am going to move forward. Is the Minister aware of the two outstanding issues the solicitors and the Law Society have levelled and which would bring resolution to the dispute?

Comment on this

I am aware from yesterday. Ms Connolly was on the radio. She said multiple certificates are no longer an issue. I thought that was a positive development in that if it is the case that multiple certificates are no longer an issue-----

Comment on this

That was not what the Law Society wrote to the Minister. It was about separate certificates for separate cases being tried on the same cert. That was the case. Therefore, people who have committed multiple offences were being tried on the same cert outside of Dublin and oftentimes being tried in separate courthouses. Does the Minister think that is a fair-----

Comment on this

I have inquired about that and that does not happen in the instance where the individual may have committed an offence in Wicklow, then in Wexford and then in Dublin.

Comment on this

It does not happen.

Comment on this

I have been informed. I am talking about what my officials have informed me. Generally, what the gardaí do is that they will-----

Comment on this

There is one other question. I have a minute and a half.

Comment on this

I actually have not finished my answer. They will bundle the offence together and bring them before one court.

Comment on this

Bundle the offences together and bring them before the court. Actually, I will just stop on that. Bundle the-----

Comment on this

Before one court.

Comment on this

Bundle the offences together and bring them before one court. Therefore, multiple offences are going to be tried on the same cert. That is going to require separate investigations and separate processing of data. The Minister accepts that. Great, we will move on to the last point

Comment on this

I do not see why Deputy Gannon needs me here; he answers my questions.

Comment on this

The Minister will have all the time in the world to answer. We have discussed cases of extended duration previously. We talked about cases that are going to go on above five adjournments. Typically, the Minister has referenced children, mental health, domestic violence and addiction. The Minister does accept that there will still be adjournments that go beyond five adjournments in those difficult cases. In a scenario where it goes to eight, nine or ten, he is basically factoring in an assumption of altruism whereby people will just take cases.

Comment on this

I have always indicated that it is something I am prepared to look at, particularly in respect of the Children's Court. We are looking at data on this. I said to the Law Society in the letter before the one I sent it today that I would be back to it shortly in respect of that. I am accumulating data in respect of it. It is the case that the review I did previously, which was done within the Department, showed that the average length of time for a District Court criminal prosecution with criminal legal aid is about five appearances. That is the basis for the fee that I put in. If it is the case when it comes to cases in the Children's Court that there is a higher average, I will amend it to deal with that.

Comment on this

That dataset also pointed to the fact that there are going to be more complex cases involving people on legal aid just by the very nature of it.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank the Deputy.

Comment on this

Generally, the more complex cases are the more serious cases and they get transferred to the Circuit Court or the Central Criminal Court.

Comment on this

Not all the time.

Comment on this

That is where the most complex cases get sent.

Comment on this

It is more often the District Court.

Comment on this

On the original proposals on criminal legal aid reform in the statutory instrument that came into effect at the end of July, there were discussions about this and there have been a number of reforms to the original proposal. Originally, a flat fee of €455 was proposed, which was increased to €520, reflecting the average of five court appearances per case. The Minister withdrew the proposed payment of €100 for cases sent forward for trial following concerns raised during the consultation process. The payments for photocopying, travel and subsistence have been retained. The €520 fee is now payable in two instalments, the first payment at the commencement of the case and the balance payable later, at its conclusion or after 12 months. These are welcome reforms. The picture that has been painted outside this room is that the Minister has been completely and utterly intransigent on this, which is clearly not the case on the evidence of the things I have just listed.

The Minister has said that he has informed the Law Society that his officials are finalising a preliminary review of data related to the Children's Court and will be inviting submissions on it shortly. Where exactly is that at the moment?

Comment on this

The officials in my Department are finalising the data we have on that. I hope to be in a position in the next week or so to ask the Law Society for its submissions on the Children's Court. The Deputy is right. It has been presented as though I am somebody who is completely intransigent and who will not move. I am not worried about what people think about me personally, but it is not true when you look at the changes I have made already. A serious media campaign is being run here. Many public relations firms have been hired for the purpose of assisting the solicitors-----

Comment on this

I am listening to the answer and I cannot hear with people interrupting.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Senator Rabbitte wants to say something.

Comment on this

I was just answering the question. I am saying that public relations firms have been hired by the solicitors to try to present me as being intransigent. I have no issue with people criticising me. I do not take criticism that badly, but I want to emphasise that I have changed things. As Deputy Brabazon has indicated, I have made a whole series of changes. As I said, I am happy to tweak and make minor changes to it. I am not going to change the fundamental principle of retaining a flat fee and trying to cut down on the scandal of multiple certificates.

Comment on this

There was another issue about more complex cases. Have there been any developments in respect of that?

Comment on this

I am conscious of that, as the Deputy knows, considering his profession. If you look at the cases I have put in the schedule here, the very complex cases are the money laundering cases, the sexual offences case where 112 certificates were granted, and the fraud or deception cases. They will all go up to the Circuit Criminal Court. That is where they are heard. If one reads the data in my opening statement, the fees are much higher or, rather, should be higher in the Circuit Court than in the District Court. The real anomaly of this system is that when you look at the examples from 2025 that I have put out in the opening statement, the fees being paid in the District Court because of multiple certificates are much higher than what people would get in the Circuit Court. That is completely anomalous and indicates that there is something wrong with the system.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

A vote being called in the Dáil Chamber. I do not know what it is; I am trying to get clarification on it. I call Deputy Kelly.

Comment on this

The Minister is under pressure. One can see it. He is tetchy this afternoon, if he does not mind me saying so. I have to deal with him week in, week out and he is much more tetchy than normal. I am not going to even ask-----

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I have been excused by my Whip, so I can remain if the Minister can, as can any members. There are a number of Senators.

Comment on this

I will chance my arm. I come from the point of view that reform was necessary, so I will meet the Minister halfway on that one. However, from a negotiation point of view, to say what he said about rape trials was a massive misstep. If one is trying to de-escalate a situation in negotiations, to say something like that was only throwing fuel on the fire. The Minister might be factually correct as regards a certain number of cases that did not go ahead, and there are new cases. However, to isolate that to one court and put it out there as a line of argument to prove his point was beneath his role. The Minister should reflect on it. I do not expect him to withdraw it, because he will not, but I do not think that sort of tactic is justifiable. It was wrong. As I said, I will meet him halfway on the actual reforms that are needed here, because I believe much of this reform is needed.

Regarding what the Minister is willing to do, I took note of his comments about PR firms. I must put in a parliamentary question to ask how much his Department and all the agencies underneath him are using PR firms as well, while we are at it, now that he has flagged it. The Minister has spoken about what he is willing to do on children's cases. He has not identified exactly what areas he is looking at in detail once the report comes back to him. Will he list off, once and for all, the areas he is willing to negotiate on? Can he do that in 60 seconds, please?

Comment on this

First of all, I apologise if I am tetchy. I do not intend to be tetchy.

Comment on this

No, it is fine. I am used to it.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy is used to me being tetchy. We generally, I thought, have an engaging interaction with each other. On what the Deputy said about the comments about the rape cases, I cannot get away from the fact that on 5 October-----

Comment on this

This has been covered already.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy just accept what I said earlier?

Comment on this

I think it was a misstep by the Minister.

Comment on this

The reason I said this is because, factually-----

Comment on this

I know. I said it was facts, but I think it was a misstep. I do not think it was appropriate.

Comment on this

That is the Deputy's judgment. My own view is that it is important for me to be straight with the public as well.

Comment on this

I am being straight with the public too. The Minister isolated one section.

Comment on this

I hear what the Deputy says about PR firms. I have no objection to people using PR firms.

Comment on this

It does not matter, but the Minister should not comment; again, it is a show of flightiness and tetchiness. It is unnecessary.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Allow the Minister to finish.

Comment on this

On the children's cases, as I said, I will conclude the summary that is going on in the Department about children's cases. If it looks like the average length of time it takes for a children's case to conclude is more than the five appearances, I will reflect that and change it.

Comment on this

Anything else?

Comment on this

The real issue here, and I am allowed to speak frankly, although sometimes I am criticised, is the removal of multiple certificates. As can be seen from the table, it will mean that there will not be any more cases where people can earn €20,000, €30,000 or €40,000 in the District Court.

Comment on this

I said I will meet the Minister halfway on that.

Comment on this

I am not going to go back to permitting multiple certificates, but I will keep an open mind. I am not going to negotiate it here with the Deputy now. I have listened to the Law Society. I have listened to it before and I have acted positively in response to what it had to say. This is an area that needs reform, and I appreciate that the Deputy recognises that. He knows and I know that reform is difficult.

Comment on this

I have no doubt about that, but the Minister will have to make some compromises on the certificate issue in some way, where there are examples whereby there is a need to tweak what he is doing there. If he does that, we will go a long way. On long-term consequences, given where the Minister is at, what he is stating here today and his performance here today, it looks like this is going nowhere fairly fast. If this escalates further, which looks likely, and we end up in a scenario where some people who really should not be on the streets or around this country because of what is happening in our courts, specifically in relation to some serious issues, commit additional serious crimes, what will the Minister do then?

Comment on this

I hope it would not have long-term consequences.

Comment on this

I hope so too.

Comment on this

If one looks at the detail in my opening statement, certificates are being issued every day of the week in District Courts around the country. It is wrong to present this system as not operating. It is operating. It might not be operating to the extent that we all want to see happening. On the points the Deputy made about people on the streets, the administration of justice is still continuing. The courts are continuing to hear matters. You hear it in the media. There are some courts where there is an issue in respect of it. The judges are still refusing to grant bail and are remanding people in custody. The administration of justice is ongoing and that will continue.

Comment on this

The likelihood, though, is that, given where this is going and as it goes on longer, situations will arise where people will fall between the cracks and people who should not be on our streets will end up on our streets.

That is just a natural-----

Comment on this

Let me finish my time. That is just an obvious consequence of the fact we have this dispute. As I said, I am trying to meet the Minister halfway here but it is an obvious consequence. That really falls with the Minister then to be the bigger person and say, "Right, what are we going to do here?" At the end of the day - and in fairness, I respect this - the Minister's job is to protect the people. The likelihood is we are going to get to that scenario moderately quickly, despite the administration of justice and the point the Minister made. In that scenario, it would be unique in this State. What is the Minister going to do?

Comment on this

I disagree with the Deputy because I have confidence and faith in the Judiciary in Ireland. I keep a close eye on the cases. When a person is charged with an offence, presumption of innocence obviously applies in respect of them but where there are applications in respect of bail or applications to be remanded in custody, they are continuing, and I believe people who should be remanded in custody continue to be remanded in custody by the Judiciary.

Comment on this

Nobody will fall between the cracks.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank the Deputy.

Comment on this

A person can always fall between the cracks, even if they are legally represented. Judges can make decisions to grant bail to an individual-----

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank the Minister. I call Senator Rabbitte.

Comment on this

-----and can be seen to be wrong subsequently.

Comment on this

As I say to everybody when I talk in this forum, I am not a solicitor or barrister; I am just an ordinary layperson trying to understand how it works. I have no vested interest and I have nothing to declare.

In the Minister's opinion, is there a need for a public defender office?

Comment on this

That is something they use in other countries. On what we spend at present, I have provided in the budget this year for €123 million for criminal legal aid. When the Senator talks about a public defender office, the issue is whether we should have an office equivalent to the Director of Public Prosecutions, DPP, that would do the solicitors' work on behalf of those being accused of criminal offences, and they would then be able to brief barristers for the purposes of a trial.

There are advantages and disadvantages to it. The disadvantages in places like the United States are that you do not get the best trial lawyers doing cases for a public defender office. Here, however, would be different, because you would still have access to senior members of the Irish Bar, who are at the top of their profession.

I would prefer if we did not have to go down that route. Deputy O'Dea mentioned it previously and it is something I will keep under consideration. If the cost of criminal legal aid keeps rising as it has, it is something that will have to be considered. In respect of the District Court, in 2015, we were spending €19 million on criminal legal aid in the District Court. The number of cases has decreased, yet last year, we were spending €41 million. There has to be some restraint put on this. I have great admiration for solicitors. I admire and recognise the role they play but, as Minister for justice, I have a responsibility to ensure the public is getting value for money and that there are efficiencies in the system.

Comment on this

Backing that, I am sure the Minister's officials have looked at what is happening right across Europe and everything else like that. Is there a difference between the length of time cases are dealt with in Ireland compared with the rest of Europe?

Comment on this

There is. One of the things I am trying to do here is speed up the administration of justice. When you look at the cases in the District Court, if you have criminal legal aid in the District Court it takes, on average, five appearances and, I think, 313 days. If you do not have criminal legal aid in the District Court, it takes an average of three appearances and 120 or 130 days. There is obviously something distinguishing criminal legal aid cases from non-criminal legal aid cases.

There was an excellent report produced by the Law Society in February of this year. It is called Justice Indicators. It compares times in Ireland for criminal cases with times in the Council of Europe. In criminal matters in 2020, the average for Council of Europe countries was 131 days and in Ireland it was 396 days. In 2022, the average in the Council of Europe was 115 and in Ireland it was 520. It appears to be the case, when you look at the data in the Justice Indicators report - for instance, it goes up to 2023 and 2024 - that cases are getting slower now. We have to speed up the justice system in Ireland.

Comment on this

I have a final question, if the Chair does not mind. In the Minister's opening remarks, he said that 51 solicitors who resigned in July have been reinstated to the panel. How long does it take to get reinstated or is there a process?

Comment on this

I will reinstate solicitors immediately and promptly. There is no reason a solicitor who was on the panel before would not get back on the panel.

It is also important to point out how this is being presented. Deputy Gannon is not here but at one stage he said to me that I cannot expect people to work for nothing. I am not expecting people to work for nothing. There is very good money to be made under the criminal legal aid system. Under the new scheme I have introduced, the three top-earning solicitors since 1 July, which is three and a half months ago, earned €163,000, €132,000 and €109,000, respectively, for District Court cases under the criminal legal aid scheme. That includes August, when there are limited hearings.

Comment on this

The Minister is welcome here with his officials this afternoon. He outlined that back in 2015, the budget for criminal legal aid in the District Court was €19 million and in 2025, that increased to €41 million, which is a staggering increase in anybody's book. However, the number of cases actually decreased. That prompted the Minister's review and we are all in agreement that a review was needed. If that was allowed to continue, we would likely be hauling the Minister in here and asking him what he was doing about it. I think we are all in agreement with that, as are our colleagues in the legal profession. What other examples can the Minister give us of where he felt the system was being abused?

Comment on this

I am obviously trying to lower the temperature as well, but look at the table I produced in my opening statement around the examples of multiple certificates for one accused person in 2025. I looked at the first three of them. If you look at the fourth one for Dublin District Court, one person is being prosecuted for gain or loss by deception. They got 93 certificates. There were two appearances in the District Court in Dublin before the case goes to the Circuit Criminal Court, where the higher fees apply. For the two appearances in Dublin District Court, a fee of €19,100 was payable to the solicitor. It is the same in Kilkenny. You see 49 certificates for money laundering and indecent assault; in Carlow, it was 41, and the fees respectively for the solicitor in the District Court were €10,000 and €8,400.

As I mentioned, when the cases go up to the Circuit Court, solicitors get higher fees there than in the District Court. That system cannot be allowed to continue, where you get paid more in the District Court for two appearances than you would get paid in the Circuit Criminal Court.

Comment on this

The statistics the Minister gave in his opening statement show that so far, since the new system was introdued, 75% of cases concluded within one appearance only in court, and 99% of cases concluded were finalised within five appearances. How does that compare with the old system, as far as you can compare one with the other?

Comment on this

The reason I set upon the flat fee of €520 for the District Court cases was because the average appearance number for District Court cases is five. The old fee, as the Senator knows, was €240. You got €60 for a second appearance and subsequent appearances. For five appearances it would be €240 plus €60 four times, which brings it up to €480. I also wanted to apply to the District Court the 8% increase I gave to all criminal law practitioners in the Circuit Criminal Court. With that 8% on top of €480, I got it up to €520. It is a fair fee, I believe, for cases in the District Court. Many cases in the District Court are cases where people come in and plead guilty promptly. It takes a matter of less than 15 to 20 minutes.

Comment on this

Is the Central Criminal Court working, in the Minister's opinion?

Comment on this

Yes, it is working, certainly in the context of yesterday in the Central Criminal Court. It is a good sign. I think everyone will agree here on that. There are 11 judges hearing cases in the Central Criminal Court at present, which is a huge number. I remember the days when we had only one or two judges in the Central Criminal Court. There are 11 judges hearing Central Criminal Court cases. All of them had cases yesterday that were either ongoing or allocated to them. The Central Criminal Court is operating effectively.

Comment on this

I have the greatest respect, as the Minister does, for people from the legal profession who operate in the District Court system. I will take that as a given. I am conscious that the problem seems to be very acute here in Dublin.

That is not to say there are not issues elsewhere around the country as well. From a rural perspective, if I am a solicitor operating in a rural area and the Minister asks me to take on this scheme, try it and see how it is working as others are doing, if after a period of three or six months I come back to the Minister and say we have taken on the system and invested in it as best we can, but here are the issues we have discovered up to this point, would the Minister be willing to take those issues that may arise on board and try to reach a resolution?

Comment on this

Of course, I will always take on board the feedback I get from the legal profession, but it is important to point out that I cannot let the legal profession dictate how the scheme operates. The scheme is not designed for the benefit of the legal profession; it is designed for the benefit of the Irish public and for the people who find themselves prosecuted for offences before the District Court and other courts. That is the purpose of it. I cannot allow the interests of solicitors to dictate how I respond and how I mould the scheme. I believe the scheme is moulded in the bast way from the point of view of the public interest. It may not suit the business model of some solicitors but I believe it is a fair scheme.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister. Senator Rabbitte mentioned the possibility of a public defender scheme and I want to put on the record my view about that. I was looking recently at American television. It was one of these reality crime programmes and I saw a public defender in operation. To put it mildly, it was toe-squirming horror to see how incompetent this person was. They were at the bottom of the ladder. The only thing I said to myself when watching it was that you could probably employ them as White House Press Secretary and they would be just as good.

I want to make this point. People forget the point the Minister made that the standard of representation of people charged with criminal offences is a matter of public concern. The Minister and I know, and everybody here in this committee should realise, that the very best senior counsel are available under legal aid for people who are accused of serious crimes. A public defender system would collapse that. Would the Minister agree that if we have delays in the criminal justice system, and some of them are at the DPP level, to add into that a bureaucracy whereby civil servants effectively would defend criminals, who would have no choice among them, would probably double or treble the delay in most cases? At least, presumably, unless there a fee issue involved, most people on the legal aid scheme, be they solicitors or barristers, actually want the case to be over with relatively soon. Few enough of them want it to be delayed.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator. Just to clear something up, I am not planning on any public defender system.

Comment on this

I am trying to bring harmony to this hearing.

Comment on this

The Minister is doing a good job.

Comment on this

In respect of the point the Senator made, I made that point about the United States of America. He is right that the advantage Ireland has is that no matter who you are, where you are from or what your resources are, if you are accused of a serious criminal offence you will have the best representation available in the country because of the scheme that operates here. That is something to be valued and something I want to see continue.

No one mentions it here but it is important to point out that is why on 1 July I gave an 8% pay rise to all criminal legal aid practitioners - barristers and solicitors. That was not easy to get from the Department of public expenditure, as I am sure the Senator can appreciate. I fought for it because I believed the solicitors and barristers deserved it. I believed the financial emergency measures in the public interest, FEMPI, cuts should be reversed for them and it was anomalous that they had not been reversed. I am not looking for appreciation but that is the reason I did that and it was a significant increase.

Comment on this

The other thing is the delay figures compared with the Council of Europe averages. We are very relaxed. It may have something to do with the fact we have a more liberal bail regime and there is less urgency, generally, across the system. Does the Minister agree we need some study to be done? When I was in the Minister's position, I wondered about the same thing. We need some public study as to what precisely is delaying the completion of criminal investigations and trials in this country to such an inordinate degree.

Comment on this

Yes, and I do not know if the Senator was here but I said earlier that the Law Society produced an outstanding report called Justices Indicators from February 2026. I appeal to people to read pages 63 to 69 of that. It shows how Ireland compares unfavourably with other European countries when it comes to the prosecution of offences.

However, I believe I was contributing to delays in the system because of the payment system I operated in the District Court prior to 1 July. That payment system incentivised adjournments. The initial fee of €240 was very low. The only reason that scheme operated and people did not want to change from it was because of the adjournments, whereby you get paid for further adjournments, and also because of multiple certificates. That is why it was important for me, for the case of efficiency, to change that scheme.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I have a few questions. Just to clarify, Deputy Kelly raised an issue in respect the Minister's own Department's communication theme. The information I received previously is that there are 16 staff working on communications in the Department at a cost of over €1 million per year. I would not disparage them by suggesting the Minister is taking any of their advice on this issue because I do not think he is.

Ultimately, when there is a dispute of this nature, two things can happen. Either there is an agreement or somebody capitulates. It appears to me the Minister's entire approach to this issue is an expectation that solicitors will capitulate and that he is looking for a victory rather than an agreement. Here is the issue I have because I am not here to defend solicitors or any given sector. I know in my constituency, in Cavan and Monaghan courts, that there are serious disruptions that I am told by everybody within the legal profession locally will take years to fix. Then I hear the Minister on the "Six One" news saying this is only an issue in Dublin and is only affecting particular incidents.

On Thursday evening, and I hope the Minister will be here for it-----

Comment on this

I have to talk to the Chair about that.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

-----we will be having a debate on the civil legal aid report this committee has produced. Across this State there are what have been described to this committee as legal deserts because of the lack of legal practitioners. The number one reason cited for that is the flat fee model. A member asked the Minister if he would listen if people told him of issues. People have been telling the Minister and his predecessors for years of issues in respect of civil legal aid, with no response. In fact, the only response I can see is that the Minister is applying the exact same model now to the criminal legal aid system and we will potentially have the same outcomes.

My question is very simple. Rather than seeking a capitulation, will the Minister actually engage meaningfully? That means, in the heat of a dispute, not leaving it the guts of three months to sit down with the people participating in the dispute. Do it every day if that is what it takes to ensure we do not end up in the situation where people who should be imprisoned are at large, or people who should not be in prison are locked up because of failings and the fact people do not have representation.

Comment on this

I am not looking for anyone to capitulate but, at the same time, what the Chairman seems to be suggesting to me is that I should give in to the demands of the solicitors who are operating under the scheme. I have engaged with the Law Society already. I had direct meetings with them at the end of May and the end of July. I will meet with the Law Society again. Also, as is contained within the opening statement, I have indicated the changes I have introduced as a result of representations made to me by the Law Society, which I have listened to very carefully and acted on. I keep saying I respect the Law Society and the work done by solicitors. I do not want anyone to have to capitulate.

Again, I appeal to the Chair, and I know this is a partisan political forum, but when we look at the table I set out in terms of multiple certificates and the costs payable in 2025, it is unanswerable that there must be reform. I would like to hear the Chair say he accepts there needs to be reform.

The Chair also mentioned civil legal aid. He will be pleased, and I am sure he is aware, that in the budget I fought for €14.5 million extra when it comes to civil legal aid. Civil legal aid is very much the poor relation of legal aid. People who are forced into situations where they have family law disputes or divorces need to be given greater financial support by the State. I am seeking to implement the report prepared by former Chief Justice Frank Clarke, which recommended increasing thresholds, and I have got €14.5 million in order to do so. I am happy to engage with the committee again in respect of this.

I do not believe that the flat fee payable in criminal cases in the District Court is comparable to the flat fee in the other one.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I have a brief question.

Comment on this

If we look at the earnings of solicitors in criminal legal aid, any of the solicitors in civil legal aid would happily take half of those earnings.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

In terms of reform, I do not know whether the Minister heard me but I have said on multiple occasions that nobody disputes the need for reform.

Comment on this

I did not hear that.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

In fact, this is our third hearing and we have not had a single witness who has disputed the need for reform in the system. However, this reform has to be evidence-based. There has been a lot of discussion around the number of adjournments that have been seen. In our previous engagement the Minister was asked by a number of members whether an analysis had been carried out of the cause of these adjournments, as in whether they came as a request of either the DPP, An Garda Síochána or the courts, and what proportion emerged from requests from defence solicitors. Has the Minister, in the time since and during the disruption that we have seen since, actually carried out this analysis?

Comment on this

No, there is no record of who applied for the adjournment when a court adjourns a case.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

So the answer is "No".

Comment on this

It is just that this information is not available. Cases are adjourned and there is no record in terms of the Courts Service saying on whose application it was adjourned.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

What the Minister has done is brought selective instances repeatedly to the committee as opposed to the full analysis that would be warranted.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Of course.

Comment on this

If we look at the last three examples from 2025 in the schedule that I have set out, which were two cases in Ennis and one in Balbriggan, we can see that there were 16 appearances, 12 appearances and 12 appearances in each of these three cases, respectively. That is far too many. We need to get District Court cases concluded. The average is five appearances and it should conclude within five appearances.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I agree. I want to know why there were 16 additional things.

Comment on this

My view in respect of this is that the system for which I am responsible was incentivising adjournments because people got paid more if they adjourned the case and particularly if they had 28 certificates in the case.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The Minister cannot make that statement because he just said he carried out no analysis.

Comment on this

Sorry, I am aware that the system that is in place, which makes payments for adjournments, is necessarily going to incentivise adjournments. That is my assessment.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Deputy Pa Daly, who is not a member of the committee, is here. I propose that we allow him three minutes of interaction before we complete this session.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for coming in. Would he not accept, with regard to where there is a case of multiple certificates, that for many years we could be reliant on the discretion of the local District Court judge as to whether or not people got certificates? In many of the cases where there are multiple certificates, it might be in a case where the DPP has directed trial, in summary jurisdiction only, on a signed plea. Someone could be dealing with 20 different cases involving 20 different burglaries or fraud offences, with 20 different sets of CCTV footage, and they are going to have to spend the time looking at all of those, so it is merited. There has been some movement and I do not think anybody is going back to the old system. The Minister himself has raised on many occasions the issue of multiple certificates. Would he not talk to the Law Society this week or next week about putting in place a system with safeguards? Would he agree to putting in place a review, maybe after six months, to see how it is working and put guardrails in place so the District Court judge or whoever is dealing with it can be supervised or ask questions about it?

Unfortunately, sometimes the more the Minister has said on this issue, the worse things have got. He said that the system is working. In Killarney District Court this morning, there were 350 or 360 cases, and they were all adjourned. It is not just a Dublin issue, it is a west Cork issue, a Kerry issue, a Monaghan issue and an issue around the country. I appeal to the Minister to sit down, sort out the issues that have not been agreed just yet, and put in place a review three or six months down the line to see how it is working, rather than trading over and back across RTÉ.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Daly for his contribution and I value his insight into this.

Comment on this

I should say that I worked in the system.

Comment on this

This is what I meant. If we look at the examples I set out in my opening statement, and I do not know whether Deputy Daly had an opportunity to do so-----

Comment on this

If he looks at them, he will see the number of cases or the number of certificates issued. For example, for a money laundering charge, the charge is that someone laundered X amount of money on such and such a date. Money laundering is necessarily going to have a whole series of charges. It is not acceptable that there is a fee of €26,800 being paid in the District Court for two appearances.

Comment on this

Is that not the type of case the Minister should be sitting down and ironing out over the next week or so?

Comment on this

If somebody is charged with money laundering and the case is going to go on to the Circuit Court, where the solicitor and barrister will get higher fees, it should not be the case that for two brief appearances in the District Court, people get paid €26,800. This is a system that is clearly not working and I cannot stand over it. Similarly, if we look at the issue of sexual offences, there is an example of 112 certificates being granted in such a case. Obviously it involved a series of sexual offences over a period of time. Again, this case will go to the Circuit Court where higher fees will be paid but for eight appearances in the District Court, €63,200 is payable.

Comment on this

Would the Minister accept that there are other cases where certificates were granted by the court but the Department refused to pay them out, despite a number of appeals? For every one of the types of case the Minister is showing, there are solicitors who will say the opposite. They will say that they were granted certificates but they were not paid for them.

Comment on this

If the court grants certificates, I would have thought it would be very difficult for the Department to say it will not pay them.

Comment on this

That has happened and it is what needs to be spoken about.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I was going to say we will follow up but I sincerely hope this is the last hearing we will have on this issue, particularly in the context of a dispute. Our appeal to the Minister, again, and I think all members will agree on this, is that we want to see our courts operating effectively and we want to see this dispute brought to an end. Nobody has more influence and power to do that than the Minister, and we are imploring him to do whatever it takes to bring it to an end.

I propose that we publish the Minister's opening statement on our website. It has been on many websites already but that is beside the point. I thank the Minister and his officials for attending. We are going to suspend for five minutes, after which we will have a very important and lengthy hearing so I ask members to come back.

Comment on this

I thank the Chair and members.

Comment on this