Prevention of One-Punch Assaults and Sentencing Frameworks for such Assaults: Discussion
Families of victims and a survivor described the lifelong devastation caused by unprovoked one-punch assaults and called for sentences that better reflect their consequences. They and legal experts supported offence-specific sentencing guidelines, more consistent sentencing data, transparent judicial reasons, and free access for victims’ families to sentencing remarks. Witnesses also urged a coordinated, evidence-led prevention strategy, including public awareness, early intervention, better research and action to reduce alcohol-related harm. Families highlighted the lack of support and guidance through court proceedings; no committee decision was recorded in this section.
I again confirm that Senator Black is substituting for Senator Ruane and Deputy Ní Raghallaigh is substituting for Deputy Ward.
The purpose of this part of the meeting is to have an engagement on the topic of the prevention of unprovoked one-punch assaults and sentencing frameworks for such assaults, and related matters. We welcome all our guests who have taken the time to discuss what the committee has agreed is a serious issue that has not had the level of public attention it deserves.
I inform viewers that some of the testimony they will be hearing will be incredibly distressing. This issue has had profound consequences for far too many people's lives. I must say, with the indulgence of the committee, that this is a matter of personal interest to me because two people I knew very well, Graham Tobin and Seamus Bell, two young men from my home town, were killed as the result of unprovoked one-punch attacks. In both instances, the families have been left bereft of a father and brother and a loving part of their families. In both instances, the families feel that justice was not forthcoming and that while people were sentenced, the sentencing was nowhere close to matching the level of hurt and turmoil caused by the devastating loss of their loved ones.
The representatives before the committee today are: Mr. Brian Hogan, who is a survivor of a life-changing one-punch assault, and is joined by his sister, Ms Nevis Hogan; Ms Sharon Lynn, sister of Martin Lynn, who was the victim of a one-punch assault in 2023; Mr. Bryan Gallagher, brother of Cian Gallagher, who was killed as the result of one of these assaults in 2022; and Ms Courtney Mullally, niece of Mr. Patrick Mullally, who was a victim of such an assault in 2016.
Dr. Reena Sarkar, who will be attending remotely, is an injury and forensic medicine research fellow at Monash University in Australia. Dr. Sheila Gilheany and Mr. Eóin Ryan are here representing Alcohol Action Ireland. We are also joined by Dr. Ian Marder, an associate professor in criminology at Maynooth University; by Dr. Chris Luke, a retired consultant in emergency medicine, author and commentator; and by Dr. Niamh Maguire, senior lecturer in law in the South East Technological University, SETU. They are all very welcome.
I will invite each group or individual to make an opening statement of three minutes. As I mentioned earlier, our time is very limited, unfortunately, because we have to deal with two important matters at today's meeting. I will then invite engagement from the committee members. I will indicate the time available to members when we have heard the opening statements, at which stage I will know how much time we have left.
Before inviting the witnesses to make their opening statements, I must explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practices of the Houses as regards to references that may be made to other persons in any evidence. The evidence of witnesses who are physically present or who are within the parliamentary precincts is protected, pursuant to both the Constitution and statute, by absolute privilege. Members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
I will now call on each organisation or individual to deliver their opening statements, starting with Mr. Brian Hogan and Ms Nevis Hogan.
Comment on this
My name is Brian Hogan. I am a 49-year-old Limerick man and a survivor of a one-punch attack. I lived in the UK, in the midlands near Nottingham, 17 years ago. I was working and my life was good there. I worked there as a senior quantity surveyor. I was very fit and healthy and was in the gym four mornings a week before work. One night, I was out with a group of individuals I would have called friends at the time and on the way home from a night out, a stranger was walking in my group. I did not know this man. I did not invite him. I asked him what his name was and where he was going. He said his name was Martin and that he was coming to my house. I said, "Look, I don't know who you are, I'm afraid to say. I didn't invite you. You'll have to go home". I was not rude to him but this man was a bully. I did not know this. He drew his fist back. He wanted to come back to my house. He drew his fist back and punched me hard to the face. I fell but he ran off into the night. I fell back suddenly and hit my head on the kerb. I was unconscious momentarily but when eventually I did receive medical attention, I had my head scanned. I had suffered a massive brain bleed. I was taken in for surgery, which took five hours, to allow the pressure to go down on my brain. Then, in order to stabilise me, I was put into an induced coma for months. During this time, my broken-hearted, retired parents sat at my bedside wondering why on earth this had happened to them. My siblings sat at my bedside, speaking to me and trying to get some sort of reaction from me. One neural nurse told them that I was in a coma but that I could still hear so they should talk to me. They would talk to me. They would sing to me. They would try to make me laugh by doing something unnatural and all the time I was fighting for my life. I am very glad that I came out of my coma. I learned that I had lost my sight due to the impact with the kerb. I lost my sight and my speech. I was brought for intensive rehabilitation in the city hospital in Nottingham. I had to learn, at the age of 32, how to walk and talk again. Learning those things over again, things that we learn naturally as infants, was very hard as an adult who was wondering why this had happened.
I want to say to Sharon, Bryan and the other family members here who have lost loved ones that grief is the price we pay for love. I survived my assault but the person I was before my assault - the successful, happy, fit man - is gone. That man is no longer here. Did I give up? No, I did not. My family was determined to get me home from the UK. I was brought home from the UK and went into a nursing home in County Limerick that had advertised itself as a brain injury unit. I was living there a week when I realised it was an old folks home. There I was at 32, depressed out of my tree in an old folks home. I was grossly misplaced. It was from there that the lights came on and a wonderful organisation, Acquired Brain Injury Ireland, visited me. They rescued me from that nursing home and brought me to their wonderful rehabilitation house in Clarecastle outside Ennis. I lived there for 11 years, working really hard on my rehabilitation, learning how to walk and talk again, getting independent and getting myself dressed again, which sounds bizarre but I had to start from scratch. Their rehabilitation assistants were absolutely wonderful. They really were the icing on the cake. They were angels to me. They were amazing. My rehabilitation got better and better and two years ago, Acquired Brain Injury Ireland, through its subsidiary housing organisation, Anvers Housing, gave me the key to my beautiful bungalow. I have been there for two years now. It is amazing.
I found out after I came home that the man who assaulted me was gifted a suspended sentence. Me and my family were the ones given a life sentence. We were given life sentences. There is a bizarre disjoint when the scales of justice are unbalanced in favour of the perpetrator and innocent people have to rebuild their lives and build their lives back up again. I urge everyone here to take one look at me today, to look at my face. If I was their brother or their loved one, what kind of justice would they want for me? The scales of justice are unbalanced. We need to do more. Laws need to change because unless they do change, then perpetrators of violent crimes will get off. First off, whether they are a flight risk or not, they should have their passports removed from them. I cannot decide to go to my favourite holiday destination on a whim. I can only do that in my memories and my imagination. Why can perpetrators of violent crimes not be punished? Their passports should be taken from them and there should be a record of them so that they do not ever get to live the life they want to live again. Unless we have proper sentencing in place, the merry-go-round of madness is going to continue. Lives will continue to be ruined. Please give us a break and switch the lights back on for those of us who have been left in the dark, questioning what we have done. All I can say is that when I was very sick in hospital my mother used to repeat this mantra: "Brian, keep saying to yourself, every day in every way you're getting better and better". Every day, in every way I am getting better and better and where there is life there is hope. Thanks very much for listening to me today.
Comment on this
I thank the Chairman and committee members for inviting us here today. I am Brian's sister, Nevis, and I am here to speak about the devastating impact that one-punch assaults can have on a family. The unprovoked assault on my brother in 2009 changed our family's lives for ever. As his family, we have had to live with the heartbreak of knowing that nothing can undo what was done to him. At the time my brother was living in the UK. We travelled every week to be by his side, desperate to support him. My father took early retirement so he could be there for his son. The savings he had worked so hard for - the money he had put aside to enjoy his retirement with my mother - was spent on travel, car hire and the enormous costs of living between two countries. His own plans for the future were sacrificed because his son needed him. It broke my parents' hearts. It broke ours as his siblings. We watched our family suffer in ways we could never have imagined. The physical injuries were visible, but the emotional pain, fear, grief and helplessness carried by our family were just as real.
Since then, we have also lost our mum, five years ago, and our eldest sister to motor neurone disease, two years ago. These losses have left another deep emptiness in our family. The assault happened in 2009 but its consequences have never ended. We continue to live with the reality of what was taken from my brother and what our family has endured. No words can adequately describe the pain of seeing someone you love lose their independence, their sight and so much of the life they should have had.
My brother deserved to live his life without this happening. Our parents deserve to enjoy their later years without this heartbreak and our family deserves better than a lifetime of consequences caused by one unprovoked act of violence. We ask that the full and lasting impact on my brother, our parents and all of us as his siblings is recognised and never forgotten.
I also believe that our justice system must recognise the true and lasting consequences of unprovoked life-changing assaults. When an act of violence leaves a person permanently blind, paralysed and dependent on others for the rest of their life, the seriousness of that harm must be reflected in the consequences for the perpetrator. I believe Ireland must continue to examine whether its sentencing laws adequately reflect the devastating and lifelong impact of these crimes. Other countries have taken different approaches to sentencing serious violence and I believe we must have an honest conversation about whether our own approach goes far enough. A prison sentence cannot give my brother back his sight, restore his independence or return the years of peace and happiness stolen from our family, but justice must recognise the enormity of what has happened. It must recognise not only the crime itself, but the life of suffering left behind for the victim and everyone who loves them. I thank the committee.
Comment on this
I am here as the sister of Martin Lynn, my only sibling, who was killed in an unprovoked single-punch assault. People often say that when a traumatic event happens, your life suddenly becomes divided into the before and the after. That date for me was 30 July 2023. It was an ordinary Saturday night. Martin went to the cinema with friends, followed by drinks in town. Martin was always cautious and sensible. Even as a teenager, he was quiet, polite and hardworking. That night he took a taxi home, as he always did. Just steps from our front door, a motorcyclist, who believed the taxi had obstructed his path, approached Martin in a rage and punched him, knocking him to the ground. Martin’s hands were in his pockets. He never saw it coming. The attacker fled. It would be a year and a half until we learnt his identity and two and a half years until he admitted his guilt. He was a local man with 23 previous convictions who was out on bail at the time. Martin never regained consciousness. Three days after the attack, we sat holding his hand as he passed away in the ICU. A young, healthy person who only ever treated people with kindness and respect had his life taken for no reason. Every one of us, whether male or female, has the right to make it home safely. Martin did everything right that night and he should still be here.
When somebody is killed in one of these unprovoked assaults, the story often makes the headlines. There is shock, public sympathy and sometimes debate about the sentence imposed. As those headlines fade, though, so too does the public’s attention. Too often, these cases are treated as isolated tragedies rather than as a public safety issue which requires sustained research, awareness and a co-ordinated response. Nobody can say how many men have been killed or seriously injured in this way because nobody is recording it. They are the forgotten victims. We faced two and a half years of confusion, fear and uncertainty as we navigated a criminal justice system we knew nothing about with no legal support. When Martin’s killer was sentenced, my family was devastated to learn that the offender would likely serve just over four years after remission. The offender sat there smirking at sentencing while our lives continued to unravel. We struggle to understand the sentence, particularly the aggravating factors, including his previous violent convictions and callous behaviour after the assault. Other bereaved families I have met have expressed that they too have felt unheard and let down by the State. This is what led to me developing a proposed framework for structured manslaughter sentencing guidelines called the Martin Lynn sentencing framework.
No family should feel that justice is a sentencing lottery. I believe the lack of sentencing guidelines has a significant role to play here. The Martin Lynn sentencing framework proposes three pillars of reform: greater consistency, improved transparency in sentencing decisions and stronger recognition of victims’ families within the justice system. Consistency does not mean identical sentences. Every case is different and judicial discretion must remain. It means applying a structured approach to assessing the circumstances surrounding the offence, both the aggravating and the mitigating factors, and clearly explaining how those factors influence the sentence. I ask policymakers to support structured guidelines for fatal assault manslaughter through the sentencing guidelines and information committee. That was the route used for the recent section 40 domestic violence guidelines adopted in March of this year. I also ask for a publicly accessible database of manslaughter sentencing outcomes and free access to written sentencing remarks for bereaved families.
Sentencing, however, is only one part of the problem. This issue needs to be tackled across multiple levels. Bryan Gallagher and I are developing Walk Away Siúl Leat, a violence prevention and awareness initiative in honour of our brothers. We have connected with Australia’s national campaign, the Coward Punch campaign, and it has provided valuable insight into this widespread issue. There is much we could learn from that campaign and the ongoing research led by Dr. Jen Schumann, associate professor at the Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine, VIFM. That campaign also highlights the often overlooked ripple effect associated with the financial, health and economic impacts arising for both victims’ families and the cost to the state. I thank criminologist Dr. Ian Marder, senior law lecturer Dr. Niamh Maguire and retired emergency room consultant Dr. Chris Luke for their expert guidance. I acknowledge the bravery of Brian Hogan in representing one-punch survivors who are living with devastating lifelong injuries and all those who are here today supporting us and representing their loved ones.
Martin and Cian’s stories are not only about violence and loss. They would not want to be remembered that way. It is about the kind of values we want to promote in our society. It is about trying to reduce the number of families who will receive that devastating middle-of-the-night phone call. Today we are asking the committee to help us to understand the true scale of these assaults, including serious non-fatal injuries; develop a co-ordinated, evidence-led, national approach to prevention; support a structured sentencing framework for when prevention fails; and ensure that victims, survivors and bereaved families have a meaningful voice in that process.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for the opportunity to address it. Along with Sharon Lynn, I am a co-founder of Walk Away Siúl Leat, a violence awareness and prevention initiative. I come here before the committee first and foremost, however, as the brother of Cian Gallagher. Cian was the youngest of four brothers. He was shy, hardworking, and when he was your friend, he was your friend for life. Our parents raised us to know right and wrong, to choose kindness over hostility and to always look out for and protect each other.
Cian was 26 years of age and was from Dublin. He had been working on a construction project in Tallow, County Waterford and was walking back to his accommodation after spending some time in a local pub when he was punched by a man he did not know. Cian did everything right that night. He even tried to walk away from that individual, but even everything Cian was taught to do was not enough. Eight days later, in the ICU at Cork University Hospital, CUH, Cian died, surrounded by his family. Our parents were left heartbroken and the bond between brothers was destroyed by one heartless act of violence.
Since November 2022, our family has lived through four years of trying to navigate a very complex criminal justice system, which has included two murder trials and an appeal. Throughout these proceedings, we have heard evidence that still haunts us every day. To hear that the man responsible for killing your son and brother boasted about what he had done and compared himself to a well-known Irish mixed martial arts fighter sums up a fundamental issue with unprovoked violence and gives weight to the very complex issue of the definition of "masculinity" and the role models men are faced with in Irish society.
As a family, our deepest instinct is to protect one another. That night, we could not protect Cian. We were not there. When Cian lay on the cold, wet ground, three young men saw Cian being dragged off the road and they stopped. They did not walk past. They did not take out their phones. They did not video it and they did not post it online. They showed integrity, compassion and they protected Cian. They did for Cian what we as a family could not that night. Those three young men are genuine role models to all young and old men across Ireland. Yet their names and actions will never be shared millions of times or glorified on social media. The image of my brother’s killer standing over him boasting is not incidental. Footage and imagery glorifying one-punch knockouts circulate freely and largely unmoderated on social media. The language men use to describe violence increasingly echoes that content.
We see it every day in life at social events and sporting events, and outside pubs and nightclubs. There is a significant problem across all our communities in Ireland, not just the cities and main urban areas. Ireland is letting down a generation of young men by allowing this material and attitude towards violence to reach them unchallenged, with no equivalent counter-message about the reality of what a single punch or a violent act does to a human skull, an individual, a family and a future. If we are serious about supporting our young men, we need to challenge this toxic behaviour, starting with awareness and a zero-tolerance approach to violence through our legislative and legal frameworks.
Two very different pictures of masculinity and role models were present the night Cian was punched. One saw violence as something to boast about. The other saw a stranger in need and three young men who chose courage and compassion. We need to ask ourselves: who do we want as role models for our young men in Ireland? Unprovoked violence is not confined to any one group or social background. Young men from vulnerable backgrounds must not become scapegoats for this issue. It is carried out by men of all ages and backgrounds. Men from good, decent homes who engage in violence, be it at a nightclub or a football match, are often heard saying again and again, "I didn’t mean to hurt him" or "I didn’t mean to kill him."
This is precisely why awareness of consequences is a must. A single punch can end a life or change it forever. Too many people live with life-changing injuries and disabilities, and too many families are left without a son or a brother. The truth is that we do not even know the full extent of this issue in Ireland. There is no data because, to date, this issue has never been treated as anything more than a headline or tragedy. Australia, Scotland, England and Wales have made that shift to include a zero-tolerance approach and a public health approach towards this issue. It is time for Ireland to do the same. I respectfully ask the committee to consider a national awareness and prevention campaign with a zero-tolerance approach towards unprovoked violence, a cross-government public health strategy modelled on Scotland's violence reduction unit and Australia's Stop the Coward Punch campaign, independent research to understand the full scale of this issue, escalation of the Martin Lynn sentencing framework and dedicated support for survivors and families. Cian's story, along with those of Martin, Brian and the many other victims, must be heard and never forgotten. We all live with a life sentence of loss. I ask this committee to ensure that no other individual or family has to join us.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for inviting me and giving me the opportunity to contribute to this extremely important discussion. I am here not as a legal expert, but as a family member whose life has been permanently affected by fatal violence. My written submission was not about enforcing harsh punishments, but making sure we bring the conversation back to the families left behind and achieving the level of justice they deserve after a person decides to take another life through violence.
My uncle, Patrick Mullally, was killed in a one-punch attack in 2016. It was completely unprovoked. He was on the way home from his retirement "do" after working 40 years. He intervened in a violent dispute between a man and a woman. Prior to that, a passerby had been threatened. The man said that he would kill him and stamp him on his head. Moments later, he was killed by multiple punches while the man yelled "Bang, bang." After that, we found out that the man was a trained fighter and used his fists as weapons.
Through my family's experience, I have come to understand not only the devastating impact of losing someone, but also the uncertainty families face when trying to navigate the criminal justice system. A focal point of my submission is sentencing. When someone is convicted of a crime - manslaughter, in my family's case - families need a clearer understanding of what that conviction means and what sentence may follow in the pursuit of justice for the victim.
I referenced cases where sentences were subsequently increased on appeal after being found unduly lenient. This raises an important question for me. Why should an appropriate sentence not be reached in the first instance to avoid further trauma for the families who need to seek an appeal to get the justice they deserve? I recognise that every case has its own circumstances and that judicial discretion is necessary. However, families should not be left facing further uncertainty while a sentence is challenged or reconsidered. The seriousness of the offence and the permanent impact on the family should be properly recognised from the outset.
I am asking the committee to consider the possibility of a statutory minimum sentence for fatal assaults, supported by clear sentencing guidelines, judicial discretion above that minimum and a requirement for judges to explain the reasons for the sentence imposed, including why any portion was suspended. This is not about treating every case identically. It is about creating a clearer, more consistent and accountable framework so families can understand the possible outcomes and have realistic expectations of the process. I believe this would play an important role in prevention, particularly in addressing male-on-male violence. The term "one punch" can make fatal violence sound less serious than it is. If someone chooses to use physical violence, the potential consequences must be clear. A defined minimum sentence could help reinforce the gravity of that decision and may act as a deterrent. My belief is that sentencing alone cannot prevent all violence. Early intervention and education must also play a role.
Ultimately, this is about accountability and the families left behind. A person who is convicted should face consequences that reflect the seriousness of the offence, and that should not be left solely to a judge's discretion. Families should not be left trying to understand an unclear or unexpected outcome at an already devastating time. My uncle's life was taken, and the consequences for my family are permanent. No change can undo that. However, I hope these recommendations can help ensure greater clarity, consistency and accountability for any unfortunate families who will have to go through this experience in future.
Comment on this
Thank you. I think it would be appropriate if the committee showed our appreciation to Courtney, Bryan, Sharon, Nevis and Brian. They were deeply moving testimonies, and we are all better for having heard them. Thank you.
The rest of our panel are all professionals, so I am going to hold them to professional standards and ask that opening statements be confined to three minutes so we can ensure that we have adequate time for interaction with the members afterwards. Our first speaker in that regard is Dr. Sheila Gilheany from Alcohol Action Ireland. She is very welcome.
Comment on this
Alcohol Action Ireland is the national independent advocate for reducing alcohol harm. I very much appreciate the opportunity to engage with the committee on the issue of unprovoked assaults. I am the CEO of AAI and my colleague, Eóin Ryan, is our head of policy.
Alcohol, crime and violence have a closely interconnected relationship. Alcohol plays a key role in crimes such as public order offences, domestic violence, assault and murder, as well as rape and sexual assault. While alcohol use is neither necessary nor sufficient for violence to occur, many studies have demonstrated significant and positive associations between alcohol consumption and rates of criminal violence. We can say with confidence that more drinking tends to result in more violence, and less drinking tends to result in less violence. Indeed, laboratory studies have shown that alcohol increases aggression. For example, it increases the willingness with which individuals will administer electric shocks to others. Such research is important when analysing the nature of unprovoked one-punch assaults, especially late at night.
Unfortunately, as others have remarked, there is an absence of consistent data collection around such assaults in Ireland. However, Australia has collated excellent systematic data sets over a number of years, finding that alcohol can be involved in up to 80% of such assaults, which predominantly involve young men. Interestingly, despite assertions from the alcohol industry that many assaults in Australia were linked to illegal party drugs, most cases reviewed solely involved alcohol.
In this context, it is important to consider Ireland's overall high level of alcohol consumption, rising youth drinking rates, which have gone up by 12 percentage points in the last decade, and highly concerning levels of heavy episodic drinking, particularly among young men, with two thirds of 15- to 24-year-olds regularly binge drinking or being classed as hazardous drinkers.
Availability of alcohol is one of the main determinants of alcohol use and alcohol-related harm, and the World Health Organization identifies restrictions on availability as among the most effective and cost-effective measures to reduce that harm. However, in Ireland, alcohol is very widely available, with three quarters of the population living within 300 m of an alcohol outlet. Even with the very well-flagged recent pub closures, Ireland has the third highest level of pubs per capita in the world, with one pub for every 684 adults nationally, and with rural counties having an even greater density. International and Irish evidence consistently shows that increasing the trading hours and density of licensed premises leads to more alcohol-related crime, violence and public disorder, while reducing late-night trading lowers rates of violence.
It is of note that after licensing hours in Ireland on Thursdays, Fridays and Saturdays were extended in 2000, a near 17% increase in alcohol-related crime was reported.
More recently, comprehensive Australian research found restrictions on alcohol trading hours to be successful in reducing violence outside pubs and nightclubs by 37%. In Scotland, 38 bars and clubs in Aberdeen recently had trading hours extended to 3 a.m., which led to an increase of 11% in ambulance call-outs and 8% in reported crimes. Our written submission sets out the national and international evidence on alcohol use and violence. Our suggestions are to set a cap on the maximum density of alcohol outlets, to reduce alcohol trading hours, including off-licence hours, and to introduce specific education programmes highlighting risks around alcohol and violence.
Comment on this
I thank Dr. Gilheany. Our next speaker, who must be coming to us at an ungodly hour, is Dr. Reena Sarkar, whom we are delighted to have joining us remotely. Dr. Sarkar is coming to us from Monash University, which I understand is in Melbourne, Australia.
Comment on this
I am an injury and forensic medicine research fellow at Monash University. I am thankful for this opportunity to participate in this deliberation on the prevention of unprovoked coward-punch assaults.
At the outset, I respectfully pay tribute to the victims of fatal, cowardly and unprovoked punch assaults in Ireland and extend my sincere condolences to their families and loved ones. I stand in solidarity with all those affected by such tragic acts of violence and recognise the profound and lasting impact these deaths have had on families, communities and Irish society as a whole.
The interdisciplinary paper that contextualises today's statement was designed and first authored by me. It forms part of a broader programme of research conducted at the department of forensic medicine at Monash University on coward-punch assaults. Further details are available in my written submission, dated 1 October.
This study adopted a combined forensic, epidemiological and legal approach to examine fatal coward-punch incidents and sentencing outcomes in Australia. It tracked incidents from their occurrence through to court outcomes. We studied a comprehensive range of proximate circumstances, such as perpetrator demographics, location, mechanisms, offences and sentencing outcomes for 287 perpetrators. This research does not establish causation or representativeness. Its primary contribution was methodological, demonstrating a scalable and replicable framework that integrates forensic, epidemiological and legal data and can be applied in comparable coronial jurisdictions.
Let me refer to the summary findings. Injury mechanisms provide an objective bridge between the circumstances of the incidents and court outcomes. Most perpetrators were charged with a manslaughter offence, with a median sentence length of seven years and a range of 3.8 years to 11.5 years. These findings should be interpreted with caution, as offence selection in one-punch fatality cases is influenced by the wording of the applicable law and the evidentiary burden associated with securing a conviction. As a result, recorded conviction patterns may not necessarily correspond to the full spectrum of offending behaviour. The application of coward-punch law varied across Australian states and territories and the uptake has been low since its introduction. Where applied, the median sentencing length was six years, with a range of 4.3 years to 7.5 years. I thank the committee.
Comment on this
I thank Dr. Sarkar very much for joining us at such a late hour. I now invite Dr. Ian Marder, from Maynooth University, to make his statement.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair. I am a criminologist and researcher, and I am grateful for the committee's invitation to participate today.
In the context of what the committee has heard, I urge members to recognise and investigate the research on how violence can be prevented and how we can respond to violence in ways that can meet victims' needs and make society safer.
In preparing this statement, I drew on a range of research and practical expertise in areas adjacent to this topic, including restorative justice, victim support, policing, sentencing guidelines and the broader question of applying research evidence to criminal justice policy and practice. I will make six opening observations relating to those areas.
The first is that there is a lot of research and data on how we can prevent violence. I urge committee members and other justice leaders to explore some of the following resources: the College of Policing What Works database, the Youth Endowment Fund and the violence prevention database. There are many different resources that outline which interventions are effective at preventing and responding to violence.
In the Irish context, as my colleagues have said today, there is a lot that can be done around improving data collection so we can understand sentencing better, improve sentencing policy and target services and public awareness campaigns.
Community violence intervention is one area that can help prevent violence. It is well understood now that exposure to violence is an important predictor of committing violence and that people at risk of using violence can be prevented from doing so, often by violence intervention workers and targeted health and social services. There is a community violence intervention project in Canal Communities – I disclose that I sit on its advisory group – that uses conflict resolution, intensive outreach, rapid crisis response and referrals to prevent serious incidents.
Third, I will not labour the point because the committee produced an excellent report on victim support recently, but Ireland does still lack basic victim support infrastructure. There is clear research showing that victim satisfaction is more closely tied to how people are treated than to legal outcomes. Something like Victim Support Ireland, which would provide universal generic support and co-ordinate social, health and victim services, would help to ensure that nobody falls through the cracks.
Fourth, restorative justice is something that can both reduce reoffending and help victims to recover from crime and answer questions important to them, including after violence. Far from being appropriate only for minor crime, it has significant potential in cases of serious crime. Unfortunately, Janet O'Brien was away today, but I urge the committee to review her submission to this committee and watch her speak on "Ireland AM" or listen to her on RTÉ talk about her experience of restorative justice after her son died as a result of violence.
I will briefly note that we cannot design and monitor effective sentencing guidelines without sentencing data. The guidelines that were created recently explicitly stated the bodies responsible for them did not have data that would allow them to fulfil the statutory obligations around taking sentences into account and monitoring them subsequently. I urge members to consider the Scottish Sentencing Council's work in that area.
Finally, some of these things exist in some form, but it is very difficult here both to introduce new interventions and to scale up existing ones. I urge the committee to consider justice reinvestment. Through very marginal and minor reallocations of funding, we can scale up effective interventions that either do not exist or exist only on a very small scale. I thank the committee.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for the opportunity to make a brief statement on the prevention of unprovoked one-punch assaults and sentencing frameworks for such assaults. I speak as a retired consultant in emergency medicine with considerable experience of violence in Dublin, Edinburgh, Liverpool and Cork. My specialist interests have included injury care, toxicology and public health initiatives aimed at reducing the workload of overcrowded emergency departments.
My activities in this respect have included a car-offender programme in Liverpool addressing joyriding, the biennial Club Health conferences promoting initiatives to protect the health of people on a night out in town, drug awareness education in schools and universities, and the Club Cork initiative of the early 2000s, which trained bar staff in the prevention of violence and drug emergencies. I was editor of the 2003 Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland report on the initial management of the severely injured patient.
As a former front-line clinician, one of my greatest concerns remains the prevention of interpersonal violence, especially one-punch assaults, which so frequently result in tragedy. The consequences include death, permanent brain injury and an enduring fear of going out at all.
Current medical thinking is that one-punch violence is abrupt and involves an overwhelming confluence of disinhibition, impulsivity and paranoia, so prevention must focus on reducing intoxication and aggression, creating safer nightlife environments, intervening early in disputes and raising public awareness, not just on tougher prison sentences.
Based on the patchy science of one-punch assaults in Ireland, and my own experience, I recommend four interventions. The first is collecting more refined hospital admission and discharge data and information from the coroner service involving a hierarchy of diagnoses with treatment and follow-up. The second is undertaking more toxicology screening of suspected perpetrators, in pursuit of a better profile of the role of alcohol and drugs in impulsive violence. The third is to identify a leading role for the National Office of Clinical Audit in describing the physical, financial and forensic impact of one-punch assaults here over a period of years. The fourth is to invite international experts to contribute to the debate like, for example, Dr. Jennifer Schumann, a specialist in one-punch assaults in Melbourne, Australia; Dr. Gwen Adshead, a forensic psychiatrist in Broadmoor Hospital, London and a specialist in how ordinary human beings become capable of extreme violence; and Mr. Jacob Dunne, a perpetrator of a fatal one-punch attack in the UK, and now a prominent exponent of restorative justice who has presented a number of powerful recent BBC Radio 4 programmes, which explore "the slow, invisible work of steering young people away from crime".
Comment on this
I thank the Chair and members of the committee. I am grateful for the opportunity to participate in today's discussion. I am a senior lecturer in law at South East Technological University, and my expertise relates primarily to sentencing law, policy and practice. Accordingly, I will focus my remarks on the need to support the role of the Judicial Council in producing sentencing guidelines and the need to empower victims to meaningfully participate in the sentencing process. Consistency in sentencing is an important principle of Irish sentencing law and should remain a key priority for policymakers. Public confidence in the criminal justice system depends not only on fair outcomes but also on the perception that similar cases are treated similarly. Where sentencing appears inconsistent, this can undermine the rule of law. Over the past decade, significant progress has been made in improving structural coherence of sentencing in Ireland. The development of guideline judgments by the appellate courts has increased sentencing consistency in sentencing. However, existing guideline judgments do not cover all offences, and important gaps remain. The sentencing of one-punch assaults resulting in death is a good example of such gaps. Existing guidance on manslaughter was not developed with these specific cases in mind and does not fully address the particular circumstances that arise in such cases. In my view, there is a strong case for the development of offence-specific sentencing guidelines dealing with one-punch assaults resulting in death.
While the Judicial Council is best placed to undertake this work, its ability to develop robust sentencing guidelines continues to be constrained by two significant factors. First, Ireland lacks comprehensive and structured sentencing data and, second, the Judicial Council does not currently have sufficient research capacity to support the development, monitoring and review of sentencing guidelines. Properly resourcing the Judicial Council by, for example, fully funding the establishment of a sentencing research unit would make a significant contribution to the development of evidence-based policy in sentencing.
My second point concerns the rights of victims within the sentencing process. Effective participation requires that victims are not only informed of sentencing outcomes but are also given meaningful access to the information and procedures necessary to understand and scrutinise those outcomes. While Irish law provides certain rights of information to victims, important gaps remain. In particular, victims do not currently enjoy a statutory right to receive a transcript of sentencing remarks. As a result, many victims may be unable to fully understand how a judge arrived at a particular sentence, especially where they chose not to attend a sentencing hearing or where attendance itself may be distressing or retraumatising. Providing victims with access to sentencing transcripts would represent a practical and trauma-informed measure that would enhance transparency and promote meaningful participation in the sentencing process.
If the committee wishes to strengthen public confidence in the sentencing system, there are two practical and achievable reforms that merit particular consideration. The first is supporting the development of evidence-based sentencing guidelines through increased funding for the Judicial Council, and second, strengthening the rights of victims to understand and participate meaningfully in the sentencing process. I thank the committee for the opportunity to address it, and I am happy to answer any questions members may have.
Comment on this
I thank Dr. Maguire and all of our professional speakers for being so concise with their time. I hope they have set an example members will follow. Because of the time constraint that we have to be out of here by 6 p.m. at the latest, I suggest four-minute engagements and ask members to try to adhere to that.
Comment on this
I say a huge thank you to all of our witnesses and especially to Brian and Nevis Hogan, Sharon Lynn, Bryan Gallagher and Courtney Mullally for their wonderful statements. They were very moving. I am standing in for Senator Ruane, who is a member of the justice committee, but I feel really privileged to have heard their stories. I thank them for their courage, their strength and their spirit, and for continuing to fight in memory of their loved ones. It was so moving and I really appreciate them sharing their stories.
I will go to the families, but Dr. Marder might also touch on the questions. Traversing the judicial and justice processes can obviously be a difficult experience for families, victims and survivors. It can have a retraumatising effect. As a result, information shared in these settings can be hard for people to absorb and process in the moment. From their experience, how important is it that survivors and victims have the opportunity to access court documents and transcripts in their own time as is the case in Wales and England? What difference would having access to these records, including decisions made by the court, make for families, victims and survivors engaging with the judicial process?
Will they also speak to the importance of collecting robust and consistent data on tragic deaths of this nature? How does the absence of accurate data currently affect our ability to understand the scale of the problem, to represent the experiences of families, survivors and victims and to campaign for change to develop effective prevention measures to stop these tragedies happening in the first place? I put that to Ms Lynn first, and then it is for anybody else who wants to come in.
Comment on this
From my family's perspective, the court process was extremely distressing. We went into it not really knowing what to expect. None of my family has a legal background. There is no one to really explain things to you as you are sitting in court. Also, from a family perspective you have to remember you are sitting close to the perpetrator who has destroyed your family. It is extremely distressing. You are often sitting there, and a lot of the information is going over your head. The end of the trial is also not the end of the journey for us. In some cases, it is just the beginning of the healing and coming to terms with what has happened. It is difficult to absorb what the judge is saying at sentencing. In our case we felt there was a huge emphasis on the mitigating factors as to why a certain portion is being suspended, but little time spent on the aggravating factors. What struck me afterwards is that I was unhappy with the sentence. I felt it was unduly lenient. The process is that you contact the DPP and it appeals the sentence if it agrees. I came out of the hearing so overwhelmed that I could not really remember what the judge said. The first thing I did was ask for a transcript of the sentencing remarks, thinking this was a straightforward request and nothing unusual. I was told that I was not entitled to receive it. I was blown away by this. Of all the people who receive this, the victims' families should be top of the list. It is something I also really needed. I needed to go to the DPP to argue my case. I had to rely on my memory and the memories of other people in the room. We are trying to piece the information together. It is an additional stress that families do not need. It makes you feel excluded from the process. When I was looking into it, it seemed that England and Wales have a process in place. You have the right to a free transcript of the sentencing remarks, and I think that is the very least victims in this country deserve.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Lynn. There may be time at the end where other witnesses can respond to Senator Black's questions.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas leis na finnéithe as ucht a ráitis tosaigh. I thank the witnesses for sharing their stories and giving us their time today.
I thank my colleague, Deputy Ward, who gave me his slot to allow me to be here. I wish to represent a constituent of mine. He emailed me. His family saw the loss of their son last year through violent crime and saw the perpetrator receive a five-year sentence with a 25% remission. I will read some of his words:
This is bigger than one case. This is a national crisis for many families. Every day families across Ireland are left grieving loved ones lost through violent crime, dangerous driving, domestic violence and other serious offences. These tragedies touch every county, town and every village. It could happen to any one of us - to our son, our daughter, our mother, our father, our sister or our brother. Too many people feel that the sentences handed down for the most serious crimes do not reflect the life-long pain suffered by victim's families. Confidence in the justice system is being tested. People are calling for greater accountability, stronger sentencing where appropriate and meaningful reform. Justice should protect the innocent, support victims and hold offenders properly accountability. Families deserve to know that their loss matters, and their voices are being heard. Enough is enough. It is time for our leaders to listen, to act and to restore public confidence in our justice system. This is not about politics. It is about protecting lives, supporting victims and ensuring that justice truly means justice.
I will forward on the entire statement from the parents for the committee's consideration. Perhaps, the committee might consider this in terms of the report that it completes regarding this engagement. The witnesses might not be familiar with this particular case or wish to comment on an individual case, but I ask Dr. Marder and Dr. Maguire for their thoughts on this type of situation regarding sentencing generally. I welcome any comments from other witnesses who may have thoughts based on their own experiences or engagement with other families and advocates.
Comment on this
Sentencing consistency is a concept that has been raised several times today. That is something which has been defined and explored in terms of the research in some countries and the relationship with sentencing guidelines. Sentencing consistency can be considered in two ways. One could be that the process that the judge uses for sentencing is consistent; that is, they are taking into account the same factors in the same order and applying similar weight. Another way of looking at sentence consistency would be in terms of the outcome and ensuring there are no unwarranted disparities between different cases. There would be warranted disparities at the same time.
There is a difficult relationship or an unclear relationship between sentencing guidelines and sentence consistency. One of the challenges here is that we do not have the data to be able to explore the extent, nature and causes of sentence consistency. Even something like the guideline that was published recently could increase the transparency of sentencing, perhaps, if that is something that is taken into account and can be accessed. Whether it can increase the consistency of sentencing, however defined, is very difficult to say unless one has a baseline of what that sentencing is that he or she can monitor. The impact of sentencing guidelines is one of the statutory obligations of the Judicial Council's sentencing guidelines and information committee.
Comment on this
I thank Dr. Marder. There is not much time. We will hopefully have an opportunity at the end. I call Deputy O'Sullivan, followed by Deputy Dolan.
Comment on this
I express my gratitude to the witnesses for coming in today. It is profoundly moving to hear their testimonies of what has happened to their families. It is very powerful, and it is appreciated.
I ask the families who are victims of these crimes for their experience of the justice system on reflection. How did they feel? How were they treated through the Garda process and the court process? In Mr. Hogan's case, how has he dealt with his disability since? I ask the witnesses to briefly attest to it.
Comment on this
From my families' perspective, it is quite unique in the sense that the person who killed my brother was charged with murder. There was intent. They could prove intent behind it, which is very unusual in these circumstances with these unprovoked assaults. There was evidence to say that there was intent. Trying to deal with the initial message that my brother was intentionally killed was very difficult. With the greatest of respect, An Garda Síochána was absolutely fantastic in terms of supporting us with that. We had the victim support services within the courts. We had to go through two murder trials because there was a conflict within the jury in the first trial based on evidence that was dropped at the last minute. This evidence was allowed the second time around, which basically convicted the person with murder straight away.
I work in the health services. I have worked in health and social care for the past 20 years. If we look at any aspect of any health service, there is a dedicated social worker who is there for families to support them to navigate through a system. It is not for there for victims at this moment in time. I am very conscious that there is a lot of positive work that has been done with this committee in relation to victims, which is very positive, and we welcome that. However, for us, we were left in limbo. We felt that Cian was just a pawn throughout the court case. We felt that there was victim blaming as well, which was very difficult to hear. Alcohol was maybe being used as an excuse as well. It is absolutely a risk factor within this, but we have to be very careful not to get a message that alcohol is the cause of these unprovoked issues as well. For us, we were broken by going through the first trial, which lasted nearly the guts of three weeks. To hear that we had to go through it again, and additionally another appeal as well, was very difficult. The victim support services that are out there are provided by volunteers. They are unfunded. They are a great group of people, but they do not have the specialised training that is required to support the grievous nature of what we experienced, to say the least. I am speaking as a victim, but also as a professional as well. This is an area that needs serious investment going forward.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Hogan wish to speak about his experiences with the health systems and disability services?
Comment on this
From the point of the view of rehab, I had the best treatment I could get. I was happy with that. Regarding the legal system, I felt a bit let down.
Comment on this
I am not sure if Ms Mullally and Ms Lynn can come in briefly.
Comment on this
From my experience, it was an out-of-body experience. I did not understand what was being discussed, how it was being discussed and the different dates that were happening. Our family liaison officer was amazing. He walked us through a lot of the process. Other than that, we would not have had any information at all. We had to doorstop the legal team in the criminal courts to ask for a meeting to understand what was going on. Halfway through, he had let go of his legal team, had not pleaded and had admitted to it within Garda questioning. There was a lot of back and forth and a lot of changing of dates. We were very confused. We did not understand a lot of the jargon. We found it very clinical. When we were in the courtroom, it really upset my entire family that when we were starting on the first day of the trial, certain situations were being talked about between the solicitors and we felt like the seriousness of why we were there was not being taken into account. We were struggling to understand a lot of what was happening. We did not really have somebody to hold our hand or guide us. We felt like the man who had killed my uncle had a lot of legal representation and knew what going on and what was coming, but we did not find out until the first day of the trial about the seriousness of what had happened that night. That traumatised us in the sense of hearing that in the courtroom, dealing with the grief afterwards and then trying to digest exactly what had happened at trial and why the sentence was given in the way that it was.
Comment on this
I thank all the witnesses for being with us today. My deepest condolences go out to them and their families for what they have been through. It is never easy to rehash it and come and have this conversation. I thank the witnesses for the open and honest approaches that they have taken here today to emphasise to us that these situations are horrifying.
It is horrifying to hear what has happened. The witnesses are a representation of only a small portion. As Deputy Ní Raghallaigh highlighted, in every constituency and corner of this country, there could be a person or family who are left reeling with the impacts of this. I am a big believer in data-driven and informed decision-making. I am also a big believer in victims being able to access whatever data they need. That data should absolutely be available. It is very difficult to hear about Ms Lynn’s experience trying to get the transcript. We want the country and State to be an open and transparent body that people can work with to get to the bottom of an issue, whatever it is.
Mr. Gallagher referenced the approaches of Australia and Scotland in this regard. He specifically mentioned the zero-tolerance approach. What would a genuine zero-tolerance approach to unprovoked violence look like in practice?
Comment on this
In the case of Australia, from talking to counterparts based there, the biggest success in its campaign was its focus on a cultural change towards violence. There were significant issues in Australia with these unprovoked assaults and they started with a campaign looking at the language used around them. At the time, they were known as “a king punch”. They do not use the terminology “one punch” now but, rather, “coward punch” because it was specific in challenging the conversation around violence among young men at that moment. There was an issue around the definition of masculinity as well and what was happening on nights out and everything else. From speaking to the likes of Professor Jennifer Schumann and anecdotally with people living in Australia at the time, it was like there was a light-switch or light-bulb moment once people’s attitudes were changed with the awareness campaign. That campaign was led by a professional boxer who is a respected, world champion boxer and role model in society. Having him say that it was cowardly to throw a punch had a significant impact on the culture in Australia at the time. As a starting point, it started a conversation, which was very positive.
Comment on this
Mr. Gallagher talked about the campaign, the impact of social media and the lack of male role models for young men in particular who end up making these decisions, for whatever reason. What is critical from the point of view of education? Is it educating about the legacy impact these actions can have, including the dangers and consequences of them, or how does that look in practice? What can we learn from other jurisdictions?
Comment on this
We are not trying to reinvent the wheel here. Australia, Scotland, England and Wales have a proven track record in this regard. It is about gathering and understanding the data from a cultural Irish context because we are different jurisdictions. That is a fact. We must use the information our counterparts in different jurisdictions already have and tailor it to Ireland. That is all we have to do. We need to start with that data. We do not know the scale of the issue at the moment. Anecdotally, we hear of cases all the time. We see them in headlines and newspaper articles, but they are forgotten about until it happens again. It needs to stop.
Comment on this
I have spent time in the past 17 years going into schools trying to speak to transition year students, which is the age group where folks are going out socialising and involved in sports. I speak to the students about my experience of a punch from a night out. The feedback I have received from students has been profound. They really have been engaging and some have told me that never knew the effects of one punch. These young lads are out play-fighting and messing and never realise how much damage they could do. If they strike someone the wrong way, they could cause so much damage. Getting into schools, and the Government getting the message out there more, might make folks think and start a conversation.
Comment on this
I thank all of the witnesses for attending the committee this afternoon, particularly the families for their moving and powerful contributions. My heart goes out to them all. I think it was Mr. Hogan who said that nothing can undo what has been done. Unfortunately, that is the sad reality of it.
There is probably a data vacuum on the incidence rate of these assaults on a yearly basis. Do we have any information – any of the witnesses can answer this – on whether these assaults are on the increase or decrease? Broadly, do we have any idea at all on what the extent of the problem is?
Comment on this
I can comment generally because I actively went looking for this information. It was difficult to find cases. I went looking for cases similar to Martin’s because I came out of the sentencing not understanding and wanting to compare it with other cases to understand whether we were unlucky, let down or whether it was normal. We do not know whether the number of cases are increasing or decreasing. We suspect it is a much bigger problem than anyone realises. That was one of the lessons learned from Australia before research began. One of the big things that came out of that research was that the scale of the problem was far greater than anyone anticipated. I imagine it is the same here.
As I have been trying to gather information, people will mention cases to me in passing and I will add them to my list. Families also reach out to me personally on social media to tell me their stories. Despite many hours of googling and searching for cases, they are not showing up in Google searches. There are many more cases out there that I happen to stumble across. That data is simply not available.
Comment on this
Is there a difference between a one-punch assault and a fight or whatever that breaks out where the net result is that someone gets fatally injured? Is there anything that differentiates between those two cases?
Comment on this
The ones we are specifically looking at are the unprovoked assaults. They are typically committed by a complete stranger and the victim is going about their ordinary social activities or whatever. Generally, they do not even see the punch coming. They have no time to-----
Comment on this
It is the surprise factor. The person does not expect to get punched. They do not see it coming. If a person were in a fight, they would be ready and would know a punch would be thrown at some point. With unprovoked attacks, however, the victim does not see the punch coming.
Comment on this
Absolutely. The person does not have time to prepare. There have been some cases in which people have been hit on the head from behind. In my brother’s case, he had his hands in his pockets trying to get to his front door. These are the types of cases we are specifically looking at because they are one-sided. It is not someone entering into a fight. They are completely innocent parties.
Comment on this
Any witness can answer my next question. From experience, is there frustration among victims that an individual going before the courts and convicted of the crime can have the sentence subsequently reduced as a result of a character reference being brought forward detailing how the assault was completely out of character or that a red mist fell over the individual, provoking the assault to happen?
Comment on this
In that instance, there is also a reflection of how the accused has behaved since the incident occurred, such as whether they hold their hands up, are apologetic and say they did not mean for it to happen, or if they drag a family through hell for years on end and then apologise at the end. That is when it is an issue.
Comment on this
It must be hugely frustrating when a judge takes that on board and reduces the sentence.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach for facilitating this most important conversation this afternoon. I thank all the witnesses who have come before us, particularly the families. As Deputy Dolan said, my condolences go to every one of them. Many people will also be watching these proceedings this evening on Oireachtas TV. There are many families sitting at home who are walking in similar shoes to those of the witnesses and they are being retraumatised because the witnesses have had to share their stories. I have no doubt that this will have an effect on all of them when they walk out of here later on as well.
I acknowledge the work Ms Lynn and Mr. Gallagher have done in bringing us all together and having this conversation. Ms Lynn is a powerhouse with the framework she has developed and I acknowledge Mr. Gallagher and the work he has put in on the campaign around how we can be positive with our younger men and provide good role models. Deputy Dolan addressed a lot of that earlier. When this document is produced, what would the witnesses like it to say? How would they see the three pillars sitting within it and how could those three pillars be rolled out? If the Minister for justice listens to this or reads the Official Report later on, it is important that he hears how they would like to see it done. We have heard how it could be done.
Comment on this
I put this document together not just based on my own experience. It is based on many victims' experiences and as many cases as I could find. Of the three pillars, consistency was touched on earlier. To clarify, we are not talking about identical sentencing. We are talking about consistency of approach. Of course there is going to be variation in sentencing. Each case needs to be assessed based on its individual characteristics. There are certainly common characteristics with these types of assaults that need to be highlighted within the guidelines, for example the unprovoked nature of the attack. We have mentioned instances where the victim did not see it coming and did not have a chance to prepare. There is the question of whether the offender had previous violent offences. In a lot of these cases, unfortunately, there is quite callous behaviour by the offender, sometimes dancing around the victim, celebrating or glorifying what they have done, or fleeing the scene, as happened in my brother's case, and leaving the victim there without seeking help. These are the types of things that we want to have recognised within the guidelines as very serious, aggravating factors. We want to see equal weight placed on the aggravating factors and the mitigating factors. It is about fairness, at the end of the day. On the transparency side, that is about bringing the families more into the process, giving us more of a voice. I mentioned the written sentencing remarks earlier as well. That is a very basic reform that could be put in place. Finally, in respect of the role of the victims' families, it is about giving us a greater voice, more information along the way and more support. That is what I would like to see wrapped up. We have done it with the section 40 domestic violence guidelines earlier this year. That is essentially what I would be hoping to replicate.
Comment on this
In the 15 seconds I have left, Mr. Gallagher said he does not want to reinvent the wheel and that he has seen good models. How does he see them being adapted? Australia keeps coming up here. Can that model be replicated without reinventing it?
Comment on this
Absolutely. It can be replicated very easily. The conversation needs to start with how and when we are going to do it, and who is going to lead it out. This is where the victims have a big part to play. We have gone through the lived experience of it. Us sharing that message is going to carry a lot of weight, especially speaking to young people and the work Mr. Hogan has done in the schools. There are lots of other families around the country who have been raising awareness on a local basis, and their experiences of this have been very positive. However, this is a national issue and we need to take a national approach to it. We cannot do this in isolation. It cannot be done from the good will of victims, either. We need Government support and backing, and we need belief that this is an issue. It goes back to the fundamental problem that we do not know the scale of the issue at this moment.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for joining us, especially those who gave lived testimony. It will last long with us. I am conscious that I had to step out for a little bit, so if any of my questions have already been answered, please feel free to answer whatever question you would like to have been asked instead. I have spoken to Ms Lynn and Mr. Gallagher previously about the difficulties facing families navigating the criminal justice system following these attacks. Often this experience is retraumatising and there is confusion around different courts. I would ask them both to speak about their experiences of the court process, and whether they felt the seriousness of what happened to Martin and Cian was adequately reflected in how those cases were dealt with. Looking back on the experience, what change do they think would make the greatest difference to families going through the same process? I thank Ms. Lynn and Mr. Gallagher for helping me to develop legislation I am working on.
Comment on this
That is okay; I will ask a different question, about the perception and presentation of these incidents. Even the phrase "one-punch attacks" and the nature of that kind of description seems to undermine the seriousness of this. That is no reflection on the committee or whoever came up with the phrase. It is also just about the language that is embedded in us. Could we do a better job when we legislate, to also penetrate through language? Language matters and if we are using terminology that is not reflective of the gravity, I think that is a failure.
Comment on this
The term "one punch" is very specific. In a lot of cases, it has not specifically been one punch, it has been an unprovoked attack. We need to change and look at the language around that. There are instances of people who have been hit with bricks, for example. There is a gentleman living in a nursing home in Galway who was hit with a brick while walking his girlfriend home. His family have gone through years of fighting for supports and have been advocating for change. That needs to be named as well. There have been instances of people being kicked. We see a lot more people nowadays and the the impact of social media as well. If the Deputy googled "one punch" today, he might hear about our campaign but he will also get the top 100 punches on YouTube coming up in the same search. It is very disheartening, especially for the likes of Sharon and me, when we are trying to research this and coming across the glorification of one-punch assaults or unprovoked attacks. It simply needs to change.
Comment on this
The media have a huge responsibility here as well in how they report on these cases, especially when they are initially reported. In my brother's case, for example, the first media report that went out said that it was a late-night, drunken altercation between two men. Anyone who knew my brother would have known that could not have been further from his character. The media do have responsibility in how they are reporting on these cases. It is the same with social media, which is of huge concern. As we mentioned before, in Australia, the language does matter. They have changed their terminology over there. It is worth considering.
Comment on this
We should change our terminology here.
Comment on this
Thank you. Deputy O'Reilly has been very patient. She is not a member of the committee but she has an active interest in this area.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for giving me a chance to make a contribution. I want to say a special thanks to Mr. Hogan, Ms Hogan, Ms Lynn, Mr. Gallagher and Ms Mullally. I know it is not easy to have to relive the trauma and share it with us, but it really does help and I thank them. I also thank our other witnesses for their professional expertise. I was very struck by what was said about the need for good, decent and proper male role models. It is something I had not thought about so much but I have a grandson who will be 11 next month. It becomes that bit more important as I look at the world young boys in particular are growing up in.
On the WalkAway - Siúil Leat project, the violence awareness and prevention initiative, I was glad to hear Mr. Gallagher say this is not about scapegoating young men from vulnerable backgrounds but about accepting where people and talking to them. My questions are for Ms Lynn and Mr. Gallagher initially, and also for Dr. Gilheany and Dr. Maguire. To what extent do they think that education is going to play an important part? Does it at the moment and should it? How young do we start with our young men? Do we start at the very beginning or wait until they are teenagers? I am struck also by Mr. Hogan telling us that he is talking to transition year students. Is that where we need it to be? What do we need to do to make this better and bring it into the classroom?
Comment on this
I think it is a matter of the younger, the better. Obviously, that message needs to be targeted and appropriate to the age group, as we do not want to scare young children. However, I do think the younger they are, the better. I do not think there is very much happening in schools at the moment in this area, and that needs to be looked at. It is important to highlight that there is no single solution to this issue. It is not going to be solved just by education, justice or health. It needs to be a co-ordinated approach across multiple levels.
Comment on this
We were struck by a meeting we had with our counterparts over in Australia from a group called the Pat Cronin Foundation. Pat was a 19-year-old who was kicked in the head and unfortunately died. His father set up the equivalent of Walkaway - Siúil Leat over in Australia. They have provided awareness and training to over 900,000 young people, both male and female, across the school systems. This year, they released a children's book aimed at primary school children to talk about violence in the playground but, again, it is directed and age appropriate. It is a very positive reflection of how they targeted their awareness campaign, focusing very much at sports level. Pat was a great footballer and he loved football. The person who killed Pat was involved in mixed martial arts. I am not picking on that as a sport. There are a lot of local clubs in communities that provide excellent support for young people, but they have proper role models within those clubs to guide them and show them that if you are training in these kinds of sports - be they boxing, kickboxing, taekwondo or whatever - there is a responsibility around it. We have to look at our own sportspeople and our celebrity sportspeople in society. They have a role to play in terms of the messages they are sending to young people. If you are watching a GAA match and a fight breaks out, there need to be consequences for that. If you are watching an FAI match and there are issues, there need to be consequences. The message also needs to be very clear at these sporting events that there are consequences for the victims as well.
Comment on this
I have a couple of questions before we conclude. Is Dr. Sarkar still on the line? I would like to ask a question around language and the term "coward punch", because I think it much more accurately describes the real context in which a lot of the attacks happen. Will Dr. Sarkar speak about the experience in Australia of changing the conversation and the words that are used to describe these incidents? Is it her belief that had a material impact on the prevalence of these types of attacks in society?
Comment on this
I strongly believe that it had an impact. I joined this research programme in 2021 and I saw a shift from the usage of "one punch" and "king hit" to a more socially appropriate usage and condemnation of those acts by shifting to the phrase "coward punch", because nobody wanted to glorify these horrendous acts and behaviour. This overall shift then spiralled into a social media frenzy, which was a surge event, fortunately. We researched around various parameters. For instance, the perpetrator dataset was complemented with the victim dataset, for those both fatally injured and non-fatally injured. The non-fatally injured survivors of these heinous acts were also brought into the picture. All of this then contributed to the social media campaigns, to the cool.org-driven secondary school and sportsperson education system. It all clicked into place. In Australia, I also work in domestic violence and homicide research and I have seen homicide researchers quoting the success of this programme in bringing down the fatalities, and emulating the system and framework that has been put around these events to then be reflected in the domestic violence space, in the form of active societal and community intervention.
Comment on this
One of the interventions Dr. Luke proposed is to identify a leading role for the National Office of Clinical Audit, NOCA, for describing the full impact of "one-punch" type attacks and assaults. What would that look like?
Comment on this
That is a relatively young organisation. I think it is located on St. Stephen's Green. It is led by Professor Conor Deasy, who is an emergency physician. It is responsible for driving the quality of hip fracture care, for example, and basically collects data from all the hospitals in the State. It compiles, collates and analyses the data and feeds it out to the practitioners on the front line. It establishes metrics of quality and excellence and drives forward the application of that.
In terms of NOCA and this issue, it is like head shop drugs. It is an example of something that, at the moment, is anecdotal, but the more that people affected talk to one another, the more they realise it is a nationwide issue. To begin with, this would need to be an appeal to the National Rehabilitation Hospital, Beaumont Hospital, people like that, and all the leaders in emergency care and front-line care, to feed back the data through a preliminary trawl of the data in emergency departments of the State.
Comment on this
That would be useful. I know from speaking to Ms Lynn and Mr. Gallagher previously, collecting the data in terms of the legal process is a nightmare. They are having to google things like "one-punch attacks" and then there are all the things that come up. In Dr Maguire's experience, are there any improvements how this data is collected, particularly regarding sentences for specific types of crime?
Comment on this
There is the Central Statistics Office, CSO, on the one hand, which I cannot speak about because I do not think there are any improvements on the way, but it would be an easy fix to ask the CSO to collect this data. Looking at sentencing, I think that is where we need the investment. Recently, however, the Judicial Council got the ability for its own researchers to collect digital audio-recorded, DAR, transcripts and to analyse those. So, it would be possible to use that legal ability to actually research and do a trawl. If you have the transcript of a whole case, you capture deep data on all of the evidence, all the injuries and all the factors. That could be a really excellent source of data to do a deep dive on these types of cases and how they have been dealt with in the system, and let that inform how we should move forward.
Comment on this
Thank you all. Unfortunately, we have run out of time. I thank all our guests for being here and making invaluable contributions. I assure them all that their written submissions will form part of the report and deliberations that the committee will be undertaking, if our Minister stops sending legislation our way and we have time to work on some reports. This was an incredibly important intervention. I have to thank Ms Mullally, Mr Hogan, Ms Lynn, Ms Hogan and Mr Gallagher. This committee has a policy of ensuring the voices of real people, particularly victims, are at the heart of any subject we are discussing. Their contributions today will really help. I think it is fair to say the work of Ms Lynn and Mr Gallagher is the reason we are here today at all, and certainly Ms Mullally, Mr Hogan and Ms Hogan brought very important dimensions to the debate. It was hard to hear, if I am honest. It was difficult to hear those stories, but they have to be heard and are critically important if we are to take the types of actions that are necessary to deal with this. Is it agreed that we will publish all of the opening statements on the committee website? Agreed.