We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Social Protection, Rural and Community Development

Roadmap for Social Inclusion 2026-2030: Discussion

Summary

The Roadmap for Social Inclusion 2026–2030 sets targets to reduce consistent poverty to 2% and child consistent poverty to 3% by 2030, supported by 63 cross-government actions and 25 indicators. Officials said progress would be reviewed quarterly, tracked through a traffic-light system and reported annually, with oversight from a minister-chaired steering group that includes community and voluntary representatives. Members questioned whether the targets and actions would deliver timely improvements, and raised concerns about housing costs, child poverty, social welfare adequacy, disability employment barriers and income disregards that can discourage work. Officials cited existing supports and committed to benchmark payments from 2027 and phase out the carer’s allowance means test during the Government’s term.

John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I will read the note on privilege and deal with housekeeping matters before we begin. Witnesses and members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that would be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction I may make.

Members attending remotely are reminded of the constitutional requirement that to participate in public meetings members must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex. This is due to the constitutional requirement that to participate in public meetings, members must be physically present within the confines of the place where the Parliament has chosen to sit. In this regard, I ask any members participating via Microsoft Teams to confirm they are on the grounds of the Leinster House complex if they wish to contribute to the meeting. I remind all those in attendance to make sure their mobile phones are switched off or placed on silent mode.

Today's meeting is to discuss the Roadmap for Social Inclusion 2026-2030, published and launched by the Taoiseach and the Minister for Social Protection in May 2026. The roadmap outlines the Government's plans to reduce poverty and improve social inclusion over the next five years, and is also aligned with the EU's first anti-poverty strategy. The committee looks forward to engaging with the officials today on the new strategy and on the goal of delivering improved outcomes for people living in poverty or experiencing social exclusion. I welcome the following officials from the Department of Social Protection: Mr. Rónán Hession, assistant secretary; Mr. John O'Toole, principal officer; Ms Denise Ryan, assistant principal; and Ms Karen Henry, higher executive officer. I invite Mr. Hession to make his opening remarks.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

I thank the committee for the invitation to appear before it to discuss the Roadmap for Social Inclusion 2026–2030. I am assistant secretary in the Department of Social Protection with responsibility for budget and finance and social inclusion. I am joined today by my colleagues Mr. John O’Toole, principal officer in the Department with responsibility for social welfare policy and social inclusion, Ms Denise Ryan, assistant principal in the area, and Ms Karen Henry, higher executive officer in the area.

The Roadmap for Social Inclusion 2026–2030 was approved by the Government and published in May 2026. The roadmap is the latest in a series of anti-poverty strategies dating back to 1997, when Ireland became the first EU member state to put such a strategy in place. It outlines the Government’s plan to reduce poverty and improve social inclusion over the next five years, with the ambition to reduce consistent poverty to 2% or less by the end of 2030, reduce income inequality and make Ireland one of the most socially inclusive countries in the European Union. The roadmap also encompasses the Government’s child poverty target agreed in 2025 to reduce child consistent poverty to 3% or less by the end of 2030. In setting these targets, the Government was clear that no level of poverty is acceptable and that these targets should guide and focus our work to reduce poverty.

The roadmap aligns with the EU Anti-Poverty Strategy, which was published in May. This strategy aims to ensure greater coherence between national and EU social inclusion objectives and calls on member states to have strong anti-poverty policy frameworks in place to prevent poverty over the life course.

As a developed country, poverty in Ireland is measured officially on a relative as opposed to an absolute basis. The Central Statistics Office, CSO, produces official poverty data through its annual survey on income and living conditions, SILC. This is part of a wider EU survey which surveys approximately 5,000 households and 11,000 individuals in Ireland to derive indicators on poverty, deprivation and income inequality.

The survey measures those at risk of poverty, which is households whose income falls below 60% of the median equivalised disposable income, enforced deprivation, which is households experiencing two of more of 11 deprivation items, and consistent poverty, which is the above two measures combined. Both the national and child poverty targets are based on consistent poverty, which provides a valuable dual measurement of poverty in Ireland.

SILC has a time lag, with income based on the previous year. The most recent SILC data is from 2025 and was therefore based on 2024 income. The data shows a decrease in consistent poverty from 5% in 2024 to 4.7% in 2025, a decrease in enforced deprivation from 15.7% in 2024 to 15.1% in 2025, and an increase in at the risk of poverty measure from 11.7% in 2024 to 12.6% in 2025. Child consistent poverty also decreased from 8.5% in 2024 to 7.8% in 2025.

The new roadmap was informed by the experiences of people affected by poverty and social exclusion. This included engagement through the annual social inclusion forum 2025, a public consultation process which received almost 500 submissions, and engagement with community and voluntary organisations.

Delivery of the roadmap’s high level objectives is supported by 63 cross-government actions. These actions focus on groups most impacted by poverty: children, lone parents, disabled people, those who are unemployed, older people and people from marginalised communities, including Travellers and Roma. Reflecting the multidimensional and intersecting nature of poverty, these actions span a range of areas, including housing, education, transport, childcare, employment, health, income supports and community services. The actions are drawn from existing or future Government strategies and action plans. They do not represent the totality of Government work across these areas but identify and bring key actions to reduce poverty and social exclusion into a whole-of-government framework with clear timelines and indicators.

The roadmap is focused on measurable outcomes. Progress will be tracked by 25 headline indicators based on data from the Central Statistics Office and Eurostat. The indicators establish both a baseline and an ambition for 2030. They will enable the monitoring of progress both nationally and across different groups while also giving a benchmark with EU counterparts. Oversight of implementation will be provided through the social inclusion roadmap steering group, chaired by the Minister for Social Protection. The group comprises senior representatives of relevant Government Departments, together with representatives from the community and voluntary sector. Progress will be monitored throughout the year and reported in annual progress reports. These reports will be brought to Government and provided to the committee.

My colleagues and I look forward to our discussion today, and we are happy to help the committee with any questions.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank Mr. Hession for his opening remarks. I invite members to discuss them now. I remind members joining remotely to use the raise hand feature and cancel it when they have spoken. I can offer each member seven minutes back and forth for questions and answers.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Hession and his team for the opening remarks. I will start where Mr. Hession finished off in relation to the 63 actions and 25 indicators. How were those 25 high level indicators selected? I know Mr. Hession referenced Eurostat but not everything will be Eurostat. Where is the Irish marking within that?

Will Mr. Hession demonstrate a clear link between each of the 63 actions and the 25 indicators? Will he give us an example of that?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

I thank the Senator. I will ask my colleague Mr. O'Toole to speak to that. He was very involved in the development of those indicators so he will be happy to help.

Comment on this
Mr. John O'Toole

I thank the Senator for her question. The 63 cross-government actions are in the areas of core essentials such as housing, healthcare, transport, food, energy, digital inclusion and financial literacy. They are targeted at specific groups: families with children, working age people, older people, lone parents, disabled people and members of the Traveller and Roma communities.

In regard to the 25 official metrics, in the process of putting together the roadmap for social inclusion, we looked at a number of metrics, both from Eurostat and CSO, and at what other European Union member states were doing in this area. We liaised with the European Commission in the context of its drafting of its EU anti-poverty strategy. The 25 official metrics cover income inequality, which is now one of the high level objectives in the Irish roadmap for social inclusion, poverty rates, income distribution, health, employment, education and housing. The 63 cross-government actions will impact in positive outcomes in those 25 areas. That would be-----

Comment on this

Moving on from and understanding that, what happens if one of those indicators is going in the wrong direction? How often is there a meeting convened to discuss it? Are meetings held half-yearly, every three months or every second month? Is there a stakeholder arrangement as part and parcel of it? I know I am throwing a lot of questions at Mr. O'Toole.

Comment on this
Mr. John O'Toole

Those are very valid questions. The first point is that the Department of Social Protection carries out quarterly reviews across Government. We write to all Government Departments on a quarterly basis to find out how progress is going on those commitments. Second, those quarterly reviews culminate in an annual report that is produced each year and forwarded to Members of the Oireachtas.

The roadmap steering group meets three or four times a year. It contains representatives at senior level from Government Departments and has members from the community and voluntary pillar. There are three representatives from the community and voluntary pillar who attend the meetings that are held. Those meetings are chaired by the Minister for Social Protection and he holds colleagues in Government Departments to account on progress in specific areas. He looks for regular updates. The community and voluntary pillar also has the opportunity to examine and question colleagues from Government Departments as to why progress is not being achieved as quickly in some areas and more quickly in others.

Comment on this

Is it done on a traffic light system - red, green and orange? Is that how it will be tracked? What is the rank of the official who will be the representative from every Department? Is it at assistant secretary level? Does that person have the decision-making authority to be able to report back and run a team beneath him or her or work with a team so he or she can give clear direction to them? At the same time, when the Department talks about public engagement, is it three people from transport and three civil society people from housing and disabilities, or is it just three representatives overall within the stakeholder piece?

Comment on this
Mr. John O'Toole

The first part of the Senator's question relates to the rank or level of the representative. Each Government Department is requested to send a representative at senior management level, either at assistant secretary or principal officer level. The person will have specific power to get things done and take action.

The second part of the question relates to the tracking system. We use the red, green and orange tracking system and that is regularly updated and reviewed. Does that answer the Senator's questions?

Comment on this

Yes. Just on the last piece about the traffic light system, I do not have confidence in it. I just want to say that. I believe you are continuously chasing the colour as opposed to chasing the action. If you feel you are spending all your time at your quarterly meetings discussing whether we have gone from green to red or red to orange, is there another mechanism you also use for tracking other than the traffic light system?

It is an awful lot of talking for all the officials because they just spend their time talking about the last traffic light.

Comment on this
Mr. John O'Toole

What gets measured gets managed. The traffic light aspect is just one element of the tracking system. The Department of Social Protection carries out quarterly reviews and looks for progress reports from the various Departments on a quarterly basis. That means there is a continuous review and reporting mechanism showing what is being achieved. If there are difficulties in a particular area, the traffic light system highlights them and puts pressure on colleagues in other Departments, many of which now have social inclusion units. It puts a spotlight on the areas where further action is required.

Comment on this

I know by the way the witnesses are answering my questions that they have worked with Departments on this and have used the traffic light system. Which has been the weakest Department to work with in that regard? They should not be afraid to tell us.

Comment on this
Mr. John O'Toole

I would not identify any particular Department as the weakest. A chain is only as strong as its weakest link but I believe there is a genuine commitment to social inclusion across the Government. People see its usefulness and its validity. As my colleague said, our annual social inclusion forum brings together people with lived experience. The Department of Social Protection has partnered with Community Work Ireland and the European Anti-Poverty Network to organise a series of regional workshops in Dublin and around the country on the lived experience of persons with disability, Travellers and Roma people, lone parents and all the other vulnerable groups. We have a genuine understanding that it is not just a Dublin phenomenon. We are seeing what the issues are right across the country.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. I have two questions regarding the objective to reduce consistent poverty from 4.7% in 2025 to 2% in 2030. What specific measures will deliver that reduction? What annual milestone will allow the committee to assess whether sufficient progress is being made?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

The survey on income and living conditions, SILC, which provides a measure of consistent poverty, is published annually by the Central Statistics Office. There is a time lag in that data, with the 2025 SILC published this year using 2024 data. There is always that two-year lag. The reporting on those measures is delivered objectively by the CSO. In terms of the measures specifically listed, as Mr. O'Toole said, we have the annual report.

There are very specific targets in terms of how we are going to address poverty. Obviously, from the perspective of the Department of Social Protection, our role is primarily in the area of income supports. The at risk of poverty statistics show that in Ireland, income supports play a huge role and do a lot of the heavy lifting in poverty reduction. The before and after social transfer statistics are quite notable, showing we are third in Europe in terms of the extent to which we rely on income supports. There are other aspects that are important too, including housing, healthcare, childcare, etc.

Comment on this

For whomever is sitting here in 2030, if the 2% target is not achieved, will anybody be called out for that? This is a quick question that just requires a "Yes" or "No" response. The witnesses have told us the consistent poverty rate will be 2% by 2030.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

Yes, it is the Government's target to bring it to 2% by 2030.

Comment on this

What happens if the target does not reach 2%? If it is at 8%, say, will anyone be answerable for that? I am taking it the answer is "No". That is grand. I will move on to my next question.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

The Government and the Minister are accountable for reaching the target.

Comment on this

The roadmap aims to reduce child poverty to 3% in 2030. Which interventions will have the greatest impact on children experiencing poverty?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

What we see with child poverty is that those children are concentrated in low-income households. Child poverty exists within household poverty. We have had a real focus on addressing that in the past couple of years. There was €320 million allocated in last year's budget for child poverty measures, including to continue significant increases since 2020 in the child support payment, which is now at €58 and €78. Half of the people on the working family payment are lone parents and the thresholds for that payment have gone up significantly. Since 2019, we have gone from there being 39 schools in the hot school meals programme to a situation where the scheme is available to all primary schools, which is a massive increase in provision. There have been enhancements to entitlements, such as the fuel allowance becoming available last year to those on the working family payment.

There is a huge focus on this issue from our Department's point of view. We get very good support from the Department of the Taoiseach, within which the child poverty office was established specifically to ensure there was a priority and a focus on the issue across the Government. As the Taoiseach has said repeatedly, it is a very high priority for him.

Comment on this

I acknowledge all the work that was done on that.

What impact will the proposed cost-of-disability payment have on social inclusion? What level of financial support is envisaged when it is delivered? How can the Government ensure the payment reflects the actual additional costs experienced by disabled people?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

The size of the payment and how it will be structured is a budgetary matter. The Minister has said it is an important priority for him going into the budget. Disabled people in Ireland face a number of specific challenges, including very high poverty rates, low levels of employment participation and a high cost of disability. A huge amount of very detailed work has been done in recent years to try to put figures on that. The ranges are quite broad in terms of how the cost is borne by people.

There is a mix of policy responses recommended to address it. Income supports are an important part, and that is where the cost-of-disability payment comes in, but it is also to do with services, including access to transport and broadband, health services, medicines and therapies, and also access to employment. All of that is really important and we have done a lot of work on it. The system in Ireland for disability employment is a double voluntary system, which means it is voluntary for both the employer and the participant. We have enhanced the work and access scheme and the wage subsidy scheme. We have allowed people, for instance, to keep their fuel allowance for five years after they close their claim. There was a real concern among disabled people that when they went back to work they would lose secondary benefits. We have introduced all those measures.

As to the cost-of-disability payment, that will be a budgetary matter.

Comment on this

How will the roadmap ensure that social welfare payments provide an adequate income and keep pace with the cost of living? What benchmarks will be used to assess the adequacy of payments? How will the Department address the risk to people receiving social welfare of staying in poverty despite receiving income supports?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

In terms of how we can ensure that the rates protect people from poverty, there is a specific commitment under the roadmap to look at a benchmarking analysis for working age payments and general social welfare payments from quarter 3 of 2027. We already do what is called a smooth earnings calculation for the Government every year ahead of the budget. We do a calculation that is roughly based on 34% of earnings, checked against inflation. There is a sort of formula we use for that. There is a programme for Government commitment to protect core social welfare rates. Broadly speaking, they have kept pace with inflation in recent years. There is cause for concern for us when we look ahead to the risks around fuel prices, alongside the various cost-of-living pressures to which the Government has had to respond in recent years.

It is through the programme for Government commitment and those two benchmarking exercises that the Government will be kept informed and will be able to make informed decisions around social welfare rates relative to earnings and prices. One of the factors from a poverty point of view is that the risk of poverty rate is measured by reference to median income.

Comment on this

Does the Department take the inflation rate into account?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

Yes, when we are doing our analysis.

Comment on this

Inflation is running at 3.2% right now. On that basis, the minimum increase old pensioners should get in the upcoming budget is €10. That is just to keep in line with inflation.

The Cathaoirleach is indicating that my time is up. Will he put me down for the second round, please?

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I will, of course. The next speaker is Deputy O'Reilly.

Comment on this

I thank our witnesses for being here. I have a couple of questions and I suspect, similar to Deputy Aird, that I will be looking to get in on the second round. I have something to note. A total of 41 out of 63 of the actions have an end date or conclusion that stretch out beyond the term of this Government. It is interesting to note there are 66% of them for which the term of the Government will probably sort out much of it not getting done.

With regard to Mr. Hession's statement, he said that the purpose of it is to identify the actions that are most relevant to reducing poverty and exclusion and place them into a coherent and accountable framework. My position would be that a coherent and accountable framework has to take account of the lived reality of people. We have no choice because of the actions of the Government. We live in a housing crisis, something which is completely ignored. I spoke to a woman yesterday who works part-time. She is also a student and three quarters of her income goes on rent. That leaves her with 25% of her wages, and she works hard. The housing costs are a massive part or chunk of the income, particularly for people on low incomes. This is not included in the data. I know that Mr. Hession may tell me he is limited by the SILC data, and I understand exactly how tracking works, so I do not need that explained to me. Does Mr. Hession not think, in terms of accountability, that excluding the cost of housing when it is such a huge element, particularly for people on low incomes, is masking the true level of poverty, deprivation and exclusion that exists within the State at the moment?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

I thank the Deputy. The figures we are using in the SILC are CSO figures produced that take account of housing costs. What they do is adjust the income level for mortgage interest and rent payments. The median is not adjusted. That is one of the questions. In other words, it is being measured by reference to median income, but the median income is not adjusted for housing costs, whereas the income figures are. There is a slight difference there when reflecting the housing costs on both sides of the equation. It is obviously a big driver. If the Deputy looks at the CSO statistics, the poverty differential between those who are in owner-occupied versus rented accommodation is there. Housing is important. The Department of housing is an important part of the roadmap for social inclusion.

The issue with the measurement of poverty is it can get quite technical. In the housing area, there is a conversation around how housing costs should be reflected in it and whether clarity or further complexity is being brought into it. For example, if I am paying my mortgage, it would count the interest payment. If a renter is paying a rent amount and that is covering the landlord's costs, which could include a mortgage, the full amount is covered. Therefore, there is no perfect measurement. That does not stop us trying to measure it-----

Comment on this

No, but there are imperfect measurements and those are the ones that are being used. I respect that this is difficult, but I also understand that there are plenty of people working within the Department of Social Protection who are economically literate and capable of producing that information. In my opinion, the Government is not interested in this information because it reflects very badly on it.

On page 66 of the roadmap, under access to affordable quality housing, action No. 1 is to address homelessness and provide more social and affordable housing. In terms of targets, it states that it will address homelessness. Clearly, the Government is not doing that. A total of 18,000 people are in emergency accommodation, which is up to 25,000 people when you add people who do not know where they are going to be sleeping next week or the week after, such as people in refuges and stuff like that. It is patently obvious to anyone with eyes in their head that housing is a massive factor that is ignored by the Department of Social Protection, particularly for this roadmap. It is a roadmap for social inclusion that has a target of ending homelessness, which is pretty vague. Based on the current record of the Government, it strikes me that a very deliberate attempt is being made, either at Government level or somewhere, to exclude information that reflects very poorly on the Government.

I will switch to child poverty. The ESRI tells us that this Government is far from meeting its 3% child poverty target by 2026. That is the ESRI. I am assuming Mr. Hession will not quibble with its opinion, but the Department seems intent on ignoring that particular criticism and just pressing on with what has been done thus far. What has been done thus far gets us to the position where the ESRI tells us that the Government is very far from meeting the 3% child poverty target. In terms of the target for child poverty, does Mr. Hession accept the ESRI evaluation of the progress to date?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

On the previous question, we are not trying to disguise the figures. I am not going to make a political point around what the Government is trying to say about housing statistics. In terms of the roadmap and our work, there is certainly no disguising of the figures. The figures that are produced are produced by the CSO independently. They are not Department figures. They are relied upon. There is a significant body of work in the area of housing and housing delivery that the Department of housing is leading. This is a question of positioning that one in an overall Government framework to address social inclusion. What is in the roadmap for social inclusion is not the only thing the Government is doing in housing. Nevertheless, we have to make sure that we are consistent in what is happening. The ESRI figures are not ESRI figures; they are CSO figures-----

Comment on this

I am just asking Mr. Hession about the estimation of the ESRI when it said that the Government is very far from meeting the child poverty target. Does he accept that?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

The child poverty target is 3%. We are currently at 7.8%. It reduced from 8.5% to 7.8%-----

Comment on this

That is very far. The actual figure is more than double what the target is.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

Mathematically, of course, 7.8% is higher than 3%-----

Comment on this

It is not about mathematics. It is about children living in poverty, the measurements and the progress, or lack thereof.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

The ESRI last year proposed a proposal on a second-tier payment of child benefit. It has moved on to a different proposal now. Our Department had engaged with the ESRI on the previous proposal, but the ESRI itself was upfront that 100,000 children would lose out under that previous proposal. The new proposal published very recently has come off the back of an extensive public consultation process run by our Department. There were some 270 submissions on a restructuring of our payments in terms of a targeted child payment and a working age payment. That has a specific motive around trying to target and improve the situation of children in poverty.

In the last budget, there was €320 million worth of measures. They do not appear in our current statistics. The figures before us are from 2024. None of the budget 2026 measures are included. The child support payment for children over the age of 12 has increased by 90-something percent since 2020, which is in the time I have been working in this Department. I am not saying it is down to me, but since I have been working in this Department, the child support payment has gone from being a lower add-on to a main payment to a significant payment in its own right. A total of €78 a week is paid for children over the age of 12. The age difference is also recognised. There is also the extension of the fuel allowance to the working family payment, which has been an issue that has been raised for many years. There is-----

Comment on this

I appreciate those measures. It is not Mr. Hession's job to defend the Government, but I do wonder. I asked him to comment on the evaluation of the ESRI that the Government is very far from the targets. The fact is the Government is. I will come back in again.

Comment on this

I will get straight into my questions. I will ask them all together and the Department can come back to me then because I am conscious of time. We have this roadmap with 63 actions and 25 indicators, but can the Department tell us what concrete improvements a family experiencing poverty now can expect to see by the end of 2027? I am worried that by the time it gets to 2030, the Department will discover that this report did not succeed and will decide to do another roadmap for 2040.

Two new families went into homeless accommodation in Laois yesterday.

They do not care about the technical details. They are in real poverty now. We need to know the differences people are going to see right now.

This brings me on to my next question in relation to carer's allowance. The Department outlines in action 51 that it will "Continue to increase the income disregards for Carer's Allowance in each Budget with a view to phasing out the means test during the lifetime of the Government". The Irish Independent reported yesterday that Government sources said that it is likely there will be no change in the income disregard in budget 2027. I know there has been a lot of talk about this and there were changes in July, but when will there be no means test for the carer's allowance? Can the Department give us some figures? Will it be in 2028, 2029 or 2030, or is it just a case of pushing it down the road to when a new government is in place and no real actions are taken for people who cannot survive on carer's allowance today?

Action 50 relates to empowering people with a disability to enter the workforce. While it is of course welcome to see employment supports for people living with a disability, the sheer number of reviews that I see coming in and out of my office's appeals and investigations relating to a disability allowance is of concern. Will the witnesses outline the measures being taken to strike the proper balance between empowering people to enter the workforce and protecting the welfare of those unable to?

The same logic applies to action 19 which relates to lone parents joining the workforce. Every single action in the disability section of this report has the estimated timeline of 2030. Deputy O'Reilly already touched on this. Why are so many important measures being put on the long finger?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

I thank the Senator. I know she wants to make use of her time. In terms of tangible measures, I will ask Mr. O'Toole to talk through some of the specific commitments, but I will look through what was done even under the previous roadmap because people sort of think, "Well, these are all plans. It is another thing that sits on the shelf. Does anything ever really happen?" We had the introduction of the national childcare scheme. We had the Connecting Ireland bus services, free access to public transport for children aged five to eight, free GP visit cards for children under eight, free schoolbook schemes, the expansion of parents' leave-----

Comment on this

I am sorry. I do not mean to interrupt Mr. Hession. I know these are all previous things that are very good, but what differences are we going to see for people living in poverty today who are looking in and cannot think how they are going to get a meal on the table tonight? What are they going to see? They do not want to hear about 2030. They want to know what actions they are going to see now.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

I will ask my colleague to take the Senator through that. I will deal with a couple of her other questions because I am better placed to deal with those. I will then ask Mr. O'Toole to talk her through some of the formative ones.

When we are doing a plan people think that they will wait to see what happens, but I just want to point out that things did happen under previous plans. We have been doing this since the mid-nineties. We were the first country to do it. They are intended to be delivered and have tangible results. I assure the Senator on that point.

The carer's means test income disregard has increased enormously. I previously held responsibility for carers' policy and the means test had not changed in many years. We are now in a situation where a couple with an income of €100,000 get a full payment and I think it goes out to €120,000 or something before they lose the payment entirely. The Minister has been very clear, and it is something we get parliamentary questions on almost every day, that over the lifetime of the Government the means test will be removed. We are now at a stage where almost everyone on the scheme is getting the full extent of their entitlement and there is an inflow into the scheme. Budget by budget the Government has, in terms of its initial moves, made significant steps and built on what was done in the previous government. This will be a budget decision every year for the Government to take in terms of how much we are able to go.

In terms of disability allowance, we tend to get more appeals on medical and disability schemes. One of the reasons for that is people tend to submit their applications early because that will be the backdated date for when they get the claim and they apply based on the information they have. If they are not successful, for example, because they do not have sufficient medical evidence, at that stage they will then get whatever doctors' reports they feel they need. At that stage, new information can come to light and therefore the appeals office has additional information. That is one of the reasons there are a lot of appeals. These are complex schemes and it is very much individualised.

On the employment side, we are not where we want to be in terms of the disability employment gap. When we talk to disabled people and employers, there are a number of different reasons for this. An element of it is that there is a perception of risk for the person. They think, "What if it does not work out for me? What if I lose my secondary entitlements? What if I lose my medical card, etc?" What we have tried to do is put in a situation where if a person tries working and it does not work out, they get fast-tracked back onto their previous payment. We are trying to look at the area of free travel. We introduced a measure a couple of budgets ago where if a person is unable to drive because of their condition, they can keep their free travel whether they are working or not. They get to keep their fuel allowance for five years. It is about de-risking it for the person.

For the employers, what we have tried to do is enhance the wage subsidy scheme. The rate of subsidy has increased. We have reduced the hours. The work and access area, which is really about what adaptations people need in the workplace, is incredibly complex. If we look at the profile of the invalidity pension, that is, the inflow and the PRSI-based system, about seven or eight out of ten of the conditions are physical disabilities.

Disability allowance, which people can go on from 16, has an entirely different profile. It has to do with ADHD, mental health issues and the autism spectrum, so the kind of adaptations and employment supports needed are very different. We are at a stage now where we are trying to work with disabled groups to try to enhance the supports, see what works and then work as we go.

On the Senator's first question about what specific things people can expect see under the roadmap, I will ask my colleague, Mr. O'Toole, to add a few points on that.

Comment on this
Mr. John O'Toole

I thank the Senator for her questions. The roadmap recognises that poverty is multidimensional and has to be addressed across a broad range of measures, including income supports, employment, housing, education, health, transport, childcare, etc. The Department is fully aware of the challenges facing individuals and families at the moment and has consistently ensured that core social welfare rates increase at or above the rate of inflation. For example, the core rates increased by about 20% over the period between 2021 and 2025, more than the rate of inflation, which was about 18.5% over the same period. The increase of 4.1% on most payments announced in last year's budget exceeded the CSO's inflation rate of 3.2% over the 12 months to November 2025.

In terms of the challenges facing families, households and individuals at the moment, fuel and heating are real issues. According to the most recent CSO data, there are just over 1.8 million households in Ireland. Of those, 465,000, or 26% of the population, are currently in receipt of the fuel allowance. Eligibility encompasses 23 qualifying schemes demonstrating the comprehensive nature of the supports available to eligible households. People over the age of 66 do not need to be in receipt of a payment from the Department to qualify for the fuel allowance, subject to a means test.

As my colleague has said, eligibility for fuel allowance has been extended and changed extensively over the last number of years. In 2020, there were just 375,000 households in receipt of fuel allowance and by 2025, this number had increased to 420,600. Furthermore, the weekly income threshold has been extended from €100 in 2021 to €200 today for those under 65 years of age. There has been a reduction in the eligibility from 15 to 12 months in terms of qualifying recipients of jobseeker's allowance and supplementary welfare allowance. New means test thresholds for people over 70 have also been introduced. As the Senator mentioned, carer's allowance became a qualifying payment for fuel allowance in January 2025.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in. This roadmap and report are very important. I thank the witnesses and all the people in the Department of Social Protection who have worked on this. I also thank those in the community and voluntary sector, who the Department have integrated into a lot of this. That is critical for tackling a lot of these measures.

The Department identifies a few different populations here in relation to poverty in Ireland and the question of social inclusion: lone parents; older people, particularly those living alone; disabled people; marginalised communities and the children who are within those family units. That is really good. There are two that I want to mention and ask the officials to focus on. Point 40 refers to the benchmarking of core welfare rates. How do we do that well and make sure it is indexed against inflation, particularly the high inflation low-income families are experiencing? Point 42 is the removal of the cliff edges in working age income supports and employment supports. That is critical.

The officials said that child poverty exists in the context of household payments. I cannot agree more. There are a lot of factors in poverty. Some are within the control of the Department of Social Protection and some of them notably are outside of its control, such as affordable housing. A thing that comes up again and again when I talk to constituents is that housing costs are a major factor. One person who came to me is a grandmother who is on the guardian's payment and taking care of her grandchildren. She sleeps on the couch because there is only one bed in the house and that is where the children sleep. That is not a payment issue. It is a major structural issue on how are we providing proper housing to people. I do not put that at the Department's door but it is a huge part of it.

I have to point out one thing. I am a total nerd and I go into huge detail with things, sometimes to my detriment. Something I have got really focused on is this question of eligibility means testing and income disregards. This report does not seem to have sufficient mention of that. I think that is a glaring omission and a huge oversight. You hear about disability allowance or lone parents and how the ability to access certain supports is reduced because the income disregards have not sufficiently changed. I will give an example. My office and I were looking at the question of benchmarking. The payments have kept up in some ways with inflation but the income disregards have not. Let us go back to the groups the Department identified: lone parents, older people and disabled people. The lone-parent family payment weekly rate income disregard is €165. If you benchmark that to CPI it would be €191. If you benchmarked it to how the national minimum wage has gone up it would be €250, which is nearly double. It is the same thing when you look at the non-contributory pension. It is €200 but it should be €348 if you were to look at the national minimum wage. There are huge issues with disability allowance. So many disabled people are not going into work because of this. The income disregard means test threshold is €165. It should be €210 if it were pegged to the national minimum wage. This is fundamentally an anti-work measure because people will not take on employment, even into minimum wage jobs, because they are going to lose their benefits. That is hugely problematic because the best way of social inclusion and getting people out of poverty is helping them to get into work.

Will the witnesses talk about the question of eligibility, progress on income disregards, progress in keeping up with inflation and the national minimum wage, making sure that people are not choosing between staying on a social protection payment and going into employment and that we are able to do both? Again, I do not want to be too critical because this is an excellent report and the Department is doing excellent work but this is one thing that has come up repeatedly from advocacy organisations. I would love to hear a little more about it.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

As one nerd to another, I am very happy to talk about this. The Deputy is right that the disregards have not moved in the same way that rates and wages have moved. A review of means testing is being done in the Department. It is near completion and will be submitted to the Minister shortly. It is incredibly complex. Some of the disregards are deliberately different. We discussed the carers one earlier. With others, it is just because of the incrementalism of the budget process so some schemes got it and others did not.

Looking at the behavioural aspects of the disregard, taking disability allowance, you can see that among those working there is a kind of a clustering around the €165 level. There is almost a perception issue that if someone goes above that they will lose their payment. The payment does get adjusted after that but they do not lose it. It is possible to go over €500 before someone loses it fully. As long as you have some form of disability allowance, you have all the secondary benefits that go with it. However, there is a perception issue. People think they will only go up to the disregard and stop there. It is similar with lone parents.

The means disregard is part of the benchmarking conversation, which will be in the third quarter next year. A better solution is probably what is in the current proposals around the working age payment, which are based around working family payment. The way working family payment works is that for your family size there is an income threshold and you get to keep 60% of the difference between whatever you earn and that threshold so there are not cliff edges. It is much smoother. The other thing is it is not linked to the days worked. For instance, somebody who works a 20-hour week might do it on a Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday and can claim jobseeker’s benefit for Thursday and Friday but if someone works 20 hours over five half-days, such as in the home care sector, they get nothing. One of the design issues with social welfare policy is that things that are there to try to act as incentives or to protect people from losing things can feed into behaviour, become embedded and become a problem after time.

The working age payment is trying to do two things. One is a targeted child payment, to separate out the child bit into a separate payment so that whenever you want to target benefits to children you can just turbocharge that and try to use that model more generally for the working element. Working family payment has two obvious exclusions, which are single people and childless couples. There are also hours requirements, so you have to do 38 hours per fortnight or 19 hours a week. That can be shared between a couple. There are some risks to that. You want to make sure you do not get to a stage where you have low-quality, low-hours employment where an employer will say, “Okay, Mr. Hession, we'll give you 10 hours, but don't worry, you can keep this payment so the total package between welfare and us is a certain amount" and therefore they pay four people on lower hours instead of two people doing full-time jobs. Those are things we have to be careful of.

At the centre of that proposal is the idea that there is a sliding scale and it is always in people’s financial interests to work. People are smart. People behave as anyone would in that they are not going to work for nothing. They will not work unless it is better for their families. We want to make sure our system supports that and they do not face all these cliff edges where if they spread their hours differently or go over them-----

Comment on this

I am conscious I am running out of time. A really important part to it is that question of if somebody is going to work five or ten hours, and the ten hours puts them over the threshold, they cannot get payments. It could be 20 hours or whatever. They are also making a mental calculation that if they get childcare for five, ten or 20 hours then it costs X so it is not worth going to work for five or ten hours. It needs to be 20 hours but then they will lose their social protection payments and they might as well not do it. That is part of the issue here. There is inflation of cost of living as well as getting punished for thinking of going back into work. We need to think about that a bit better. I welcome the Department’s way of thinking about it with the working family payment.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I have a few questions. The officials mentioned there were three representatives from the community and voluntary sector on its oversight committee. Can they say who they are or who they represent?

Comment on this
Mr. John O'Toole

The three external organisations on the steering group have been confirmed as the Society of St. Vincent de Paul, Outhouse LGBTQ+ Centre and the Limerick City Partnership.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

How were they selected? Was there a consultation process or did organisations make a submission?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

It is a ministerial decision from a range of options. The Minister is trying to get a balance. There is a wide range of groups. There is a degree of continuity but also change. At departmental level, we sit down with a wide range of community and voluntary groups every quarter. That is at deputy secretary and assistant secretary level. Every quarter we sit down with all those groups and they set the agenda. They give us questions in advance, we give written answers and then we meet in the room.

We also have the social inclusion forum, the carers forum', the disability consultative forum and the pre-budget forum. We have a lot of engagement. It is an important part of what we do. The composition of the group is a ministerial choice.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

On the consultation process, Mr. Hession mentioned in his opening statement that the Department had 500 written submissions. Will the witnesses give us a flavour of where they came from, what parts of society, etc.?

Comment on this
Mr. John O'Toole

They came from a broad section of the community and voluntary pillar organisations such as Social Justice Ireland, the Society of St. Vincent de Paul, the European Anti-Poverty Network, groups representing particular cohorts, people with specific conditions and people directly affected by poverty. They also came from individuals with an interest and a point to make and suggestions to the Government as to how the issue of social inclusion and poverty reduction might be best addressed. It was a broad spectrum.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Was the Department happy with the consultation process. Five hundred seems a lot of written submissions.

Comment on this
Mr. John O'Toole

It is a lot but it reflects the interest, engagement and commitment of people to try to address these issues. As part of the consultation process and as part of Pathways to Work, the national employment services strategy, there were five regional workshops. The primary focus was employment services but a lot of points were made on social inclusion. In that whole area there were many relevant points as well. As part of the social inclusion forum, in 2025 there was a questionnaire for each of the 200 participants as to what issues they would like to see addressed. There was an extensive consultation process. As my colleague said, one of the Department of Social Protection's distinguishing characteristics is the broad degree of consultation with affected groups the Department carriers out quarterly with the community and voluntary pillar such as the pre-budget forum and the carers' forum. We also had the disability summit in May.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

We really appreciate the submissions we get. We also got 277 on the working age payment and 1,100 on the cost-of-disability payment. The standard of the submissions was very good. The people who work in the organisations, the policy officers, put a lot of thought into it and do a lot of work to with their cohorts. It is important for us to acknowledge that. It really helps us. A lot of policies have emerged from suggestions through them. We really value it.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is very good for us to see that as well. With some public consultations, there is not too much consultation as part of it. It is good see there was significant input into this.

I will focus on the unemployed for my next question. We have a significant number of people employed in the country, with up to 4% unemployed. The challenge is working with that cohort. Will the witnesses outline the key features of the roadmap in dealing with that percentage of unemployed to try to see if we can get them back into the workforce?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

I will make a few points and then I might ask my colleague to come in. We are at 5% unemployment. We have been oscillating between that and 4.75% over the past period, which is what we would call full employment. Some groups have lower employment rates. Bear in mind, when we talk about the live register of people who are unemployed, there is a huge amount of churn. People come in and out very quickly a lot of the time. Even though the total may stay the same, it is not the same people necessarily.

For short-term schemes like jobseeker's benefit and jobseeker's pay-related benefit, we assess people according to a probability of exit, PEX, score. Then we focus our supports at Intreo level on employment advisers for those with a higher risk of longer term unemployment. We have tried to target particular areas where there is higher unemployment or lower employment participation. For example, in disability, we have put over 60 specialist disability employment advisers in place. Every Intreo office has one.

We are looking at what we can do to help lone parents. We talk to groups like SPARK and One Family. We did a pilot two years with One Family on what works, which was very successful. It is tricky for lone parents. With the time they are available to work, for example, when their children are in school, it is hard to get a morning-only part-time job. We are looking at the harder to reach cohorts. We are also trying to make sure those who come through our general employment service are redirected and have a limited time in unemployment.

I will ask Mr. O'Toole to comment on the roadmap.

Comment on this
Mr. John O'Toole

Youth unemployment was over 9% in 2025, which is lower than the previous year when the rate was 9.9%. Youth unemployment in most economies is about twice the level of general unemployment. This is because the youth labour market is impacted by participation in education. When that is taken into account, the results of labour force surveys show the rate for those not in education, employment or training stands at around 6%. This rate includes not just young unemployed people but young people who may be disabled. It remains low by historical standards and favourably compares with other European countries.

Work is progressing within the Department on the production of the next labour market national employment services strategy. That is the Pathways to Work document. The document is scheduled to be published in the last quarter of this year. There were 430 public submissions to this call for views and five regional workshops. Over 110 organisations attended those meetings.

The Department is guided and advised by the Labour Market Advisory Council. It is chaired by a former director of the OECD. It comprises representatives of Government Departments, employers, union groups and some academics who are experts in labour market policy. The Labour Market Advisory Council is helping with the production of the Pathways to Work document.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am out of time. We will have supplementary questions. Four members have indicated. I will give seven minutes because we have the time this morning.

Comment on this

What changes are envisaged in the carer's allowance means test and income disregards to ensure carers are not financially penalised for undertaking paid employment or living with a partner who works?

How will the roadmap improve the financial security of carers while recognising the essential contribution they make to society?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

The means test level for carers was increased significantly in the previous budget. The Government commitment is that, over the lifetime of this Government, it will be removed entirely.

In terms of the current position, a couple on €100,000 get a full payment. It is over €120,000 before they would start to lose their payment. What was the second question?

Comment on this

How will the roadmap improve the financial security of carers while recognising the essential contribution they make to society?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

The carer's allowance payment is paid at a higher rate than general social welfare payments. There is also the carer's support grant of €2,000 paid per caree every summer. That is the highest ever rate. In recent years, long-term carer's contributions have been introduced. People caring for more than 20 years and who are outside the workforce can get social welfare contributions which help them qualify for a pension.

Comment on this

The roadmap identified a disability employment gap with a baseline of 30.5%.

What concrete actions will be taken to reduce this gap by 2030? How will the Department address the barriers faced by people with disabilities in the context of accessing, entering and remaining in employment?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

There are a number of aspects. For a disabled person it is a case of whether they feel capable of or are interested in working. It is entirely voluntary from their point of view. Where they have that interest, we are happy to help them. We have the specialist EmployAbility service to help people with disabilities. We also have officials in every Intreo office to advise disabled people. I mentioned a few things we are trying to do. One is to try to remove the anxiety of losing secondary benefits. You will keep your fuel allowance for five years after you go back to work. We have made changes to the free travel. From the employer point of view, a big part is bringing them on board. We have some good employers-----

Comment on this

Will Mr. Hession address the following, please? If a person with a disability is on a housing waiting list and gets employment, that employment will put them slightly above Laois County Council's threshold of €35,000 and they will be taken off the list. Does he agree with that?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

I understand that this is always an issue. This matter formed part of the discussion with Deputy Hayes. With every means testing system, there will always be a cut-off point.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Hession think the cut-off point should be the same for a person with a disability as for a person who does not have a disability?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

I am saying that in any means-testing system, whether for disability, lone parents or whatever, there will come a point where there has to be a cut-off. The purpose of means testing is to make sure that the limited resources available are targeted at those on the lowest incomes. The higher the threshold, the more people on higher incomes continue to benefit. As a result, the money is spread more thinly.

Comment on this

I am sorry. A person with disability incurs more expenses using taxis and everything else. I see this. I use public transport and I saw it during the week. My point is that people with disabilities are being treated the same. If they get a little job, they go above the threshold of €35,000 and are off the waiting list. That is disgraceful and shameful. Will Mr. Hession please keep that in mind when he is discussing this matter with Ministers?

In the context of the roadmap, what commitments are in place to enable older people to continue to live independently in their homes and communities? How will the Government address gaps in home support provision, affordability and access, particularly for older people in rural areas who live alone?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

I might ask my colleague to speak to some of the commitments in that regard. From a social welfare perspective, the Minister is focused on those who live alone. The living alone allowance is payable to those over 66 who live alone. That is also payable to individuals under 66 who have a disability. They are a group at risk of poverty. That is acknowledged. The Minister is particularly concerned about couples. For example, if one person passes, the other is left with the same cost base but is on their own. On specific commitments, I will ask Ms Ryan to say a few words.

Comment on this
Ms Denise Ryan

While the roadmap in its totality identifies different cohorts most impacted by poverty, including older people, it is worth bearing in mind that many of the 63 actions have benefit across wider society and different cohorts. If we look at older people from an income adequacy perspective, we can see that there is a commitment to continue the smoothed earnings paper as an input to the annual changes, which look at pension changes. There is also a commitment to examine improvements to key ancillary income supports. As my colleague mentioned, there is the living alone increase. There is also the household benefits package. There is a media campaign being launched by the Department in respect of that particular support. The fuel allowance is to support older people, particularly those who live alone. We obviously have the roll-out of My Future Fund, which is more relevant for future older generations.

The Deputy is right that the need to support older people to remain in their homes came across strongly in our consultation process. We engaged on it significantly, particularly with the Department of Health. There is an action to increase the provision of support services for carers of older people, including respite. It is not just respite; there are counselling, training services, carer supports and online supports. That also came across strongly in the context of non-income supports to enable older people to remain in their homes. That is an action we will be following up with the Department of Health. There is a simultaneous action for services to support people living on their own, including meals on wheels, home support and day centres. That also ties into social isolation and tackling loneliness and isolation for older people.

Comment on this

How will the roadmap tackle energy poverty among low-income households, older people and those with disabilities? What measurable outcomes are expected from the energy affordability action plan? How can the Government ensure that energy supports reach those most at risk of choosing between heating their homes and meeting other essential costs?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

The energy affordability task force sits within the Department of climate and energy. As I understand it, the relevant report is expected to be published in quarter 4. It is awaited. In terms of our Department, the Government decided to extend the fuel season by four weeks this year at a cost of €72 million. We have also extended eligibility for the fuel allowance. Carer's allowance is now a qualifying payment for the fuel allowance. Last year, the working family payment also became a qualifying payment for fuel allowance. Heating supplement, which comes under the supplementary welfare allowance, is also available. We also have additional needs payments. I am not sure if my colleagues wish to add anything with regard to the broader Government picture.

Comment on this
Mr. John O'Toole

The roadmap aims to reduce energy poverty through a combination of income supports, carbon tax redistribution and supports for retrofitting, energy efficiency and fossil fuel reliance. As my colleague said, the Department provides supports to assist people on low incomes with energy costs, including the fuel allowance. We have discussed the household benefits package, additional needs payments and the heating supplement.

Comment on this

I will follow up on some questions that were asked already. A number of the 63 actions have completion dates long that are due to fall long after this Government's term of office expires. What are we doing annually? Are we setting annual targets to be achieved? Are these being measured on an annual basis? When I say measured on an annual basis, I do not mean retrospective to the previous two years but in current time.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

I will ask my colleague to pick up on this. While they may have a finish date of 2030, it does not mean nothing is happening until then. For example, the roll-out of My Future Fund is already under way. The moves relating to the carer’s allowance means test are under way. There is progress being made. It is not that they are being left until 2030.

Comment on this

The focus of my question is that we know where we are with child poverty. We know where we are with employment rates for disabilities. We also know where we are with regard to hard-to-reach communities. There has to be an annual target to ensure we will actually achieve the outcome of the roadmap from the strategy at the end.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

My colleague will speak to some of those points.

Comment on this
Mr. John O'Toole

The performance and results are monitored quarterly. They go into an annual progress report that is sent to the Oireachtas. Through the roadmap steering group, the Minister for Social Protection regularly reviews the progress being achieved. I refer back to our earlier discussion about traffic lights highlighting particular areas of concern. Performance is continuously monitored and reviewed; it is not being left until the final year, namely 2030. This is a five-year strategy.

Comment on this

The basis of my question is that we have come into this strategy knowing where we are with child poverty. We know where we are with people with disabilities and the cost of disability. Actually, that is where the work was also commenced for people with additional needs. However, we are behind. We started behind and that is where we have come in from. We are out of sync. As a result of the fact that this is cross-government, how is there an plan for actions to address specific targets?

I will focus on child poverty for a moment. There are approximately seven Departments involved when it comes to child poverty. Every Department has to carry an action. If we see slippage in the first year and again in the second year, how is that going to be addressed in a budgetary cycle across Government? It is the same with the cost of disability, particularly with the action plan for people with additional needs to get into the workforce.

We made some progress in the previous iterations, but we have a long way to go. How are the officials going to measure that in the context of accountability? The traffic light system is a talking shop; I am talking about actions.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

I might ask Ms Ryan to say a little about the indicators, which, I think, start at page 37, and to talk through some of the concrete measures, as the Senator says, rather than just the RAG status. Then Mr. O'Toole might come in and say a bit about the dashboard of indicators in the Department of the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

That is the one I am really interested in. It is critical for this committee to understand how that dashboard works because it is cross-departmental and cross-agency. It is the route to our addressing child poverty.

Comment on this
Ms Denise Ryan

As my colleagues mentioned, there are 25 high-level indicators derived or directly taken from Eurostat and CSO data. They do not cover everything. They are high level but do not cover every group. What they show us on a year-to-year basis is the progress or lack of progress made, as the case may be. They are the performance indicators that we will be using from year to year. Some of those are, as I said, based on data from the CSO survey of income and living conditions. Apart from that, we also have the progress in delivering the actions which, as my colleague said, will be collated quarterly, produced in annual reports and brought to Government.

The indicators are important. They show us progress made at an official level and allow us to benchmark in terms of our EU counterparts. They will be the official annual progress indicators we will use from year to year. There are indicators at national level in terms of the median equivalised net income per person in purchasing power standards. Then there are the at-risk-of-poverty or deprivation and consistent poverty figures. At EU level, we are looking at things like the employment rate and very low work intensity households. We are looking at labour force participation, which we have mentioned before, and the disability employment rate gap. Our aim is to have, at a high level, a view of what the trends are and where the progress is being made. That will help us see, as the Senator said, on a year-to-year basis where more work needs to be done or where things are working.

As my colleague flagged at the outset, there are some issues with time lags with the data. We know that the data, particularly where they rely on income metrics, will not tell us everything. That is where - to Deputy Hayes's point - non-income support, cross-government services are really important. That is where we will be engaging with our colleagues, led by the Minister at the steering group, to see the progress in the actions that have been committed to and that get at a lot of the non-income progress we need to see.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Ryan.

Comment on this
Mr. John O'Toole

As we know, in September of last year the Government decided a new national child poverty target of 3% or less to be achieved by 2030. This is a reduction of 4.8% from the 2025 rate, which was 7.8%. The roadmap for social inclusion will report on this target and outline actions to reduce child poverty. In conjunction with the setting of the child poverty target, the Department of the Taoiseach's child and well-being programme office has developed a set of indicators, namely the dashboard, to capture a wider set of metrics that reflect the various dimensions of child poverty. The indicators are illustrative with the understanding the dashboard is organic and will evolve through periodic review to ensure the most reliable and valid data sources are used.

The purpose of the dashboard is to understand inequality of outcomes in the lives of children who are living in consistent poverty or who are at risk of poverty. The 18 indicators that comprise the dashboard are divided into five different areas. The first is income support, which comes under the Department of Social Protection. Early learning and care is another area, along with education, housing and homelessness, health and participation in sports and the arts. Those are the indicators.

Comment on this

The cost of living is not taken into consideration, however. What if rents are going up? It was Deputy O'Reilly who raised this. We know what we are giving out, but we are not measuring what is happening in the real world at the same time, or are we? Can the officials shed light on that?

Comment on this
Mr. John O'Toole

What is happening in the real world is what guides Government's policy because everybody is aware of the increase in housing, energy and food costs. Those are the real-world aspects. In the statements that have been made in recent weeks, those factors have been recognised by the Government.

Comment on this
Mr. John O'Toole

In terms of housing and homelessness, the indicators include the number of children and families in temporary emergency accommodation. That is the Department of housing data that is published on the last Friday of every month. There is also the child-specific deprivation rates in owner-occupied and rented households, which is SILC data that is produced every three years. This is an attempt across government to reflect, as I said, the real-world lived experience of children, and not just in one figure. Clearly, 3% child poverty is too high. In an ideal world, the figure should be zero. The dashboard of indicators is to get an overall comprehensive view across the lived experience of the child.

Comment on this

I want to ask about people in the workforce and the Department's engagement with the Department of Health. We know that there are 2,500 people who have spinal injuries and who cannot return to work because they will lose their medical cards. This is not to do with disregards or anything like that. It is to do with their medical cards and access to care. Where is that reflected in the roadmap? We have a cohort of people who have acquired injuries of the spine. They have been educated and have been in the workforce. Now, they are out of the workforce due to whatever accident that they had. They cannot return to work because they will lose their medical cards and their access to care. At the same time, they could be contributors. It is not about disregards. They want to work but they fear the loss of their medical cards. I would love to hear what the engagement with the Department of Health has been, because this has been rumbling on for years.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Does Mr. Hession want to answer that briefly? We are out of time.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

I might ask Ms Ryan to say a few words about the Department of Health. From our point of view, people who have been working, who acquire an injury - most disabilities are acquired - and then go back to work, are in a different scheme, which is that relating to invalidity pension. This goes to Deputy Hayes's point about the disregard. It means that when you go back to work, you go onto a scheme that involves partial capacity benefit. That payment is not income limited. It depends on the assessment of your condition and how serious it is. You will either get to keep 100%, 75% or 50%, unless you have a mild condition, in which case you will not keep your payment but you will keep a proportion of your payment, and that is not related to income. The Senator's point was about the medical point and Ms Ryan will say a bit about the engagement with the Department of Health.

Comment on this

It is because the medical card is means tested.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

The invalidity pension is not.

Comment on this

The medical card is means tested.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

Yes.

Comment on this

That is the point.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Ms Ryan can answer and we will then move on.

Comment on this
Ms Denise Ryan

It is certainly something we can engage with the Department on. My colleague mentioned that the roadmap does not represent the totality of the Government response or the very particular and real challenges for particular groups, including this group. It provides a mechanism of accountability for the 63 actions therein and the 25 indicators and then also the issues that, as the Senator says, may come up that affect particular cohorts. We will also have a mid-term review in 2028. Again, that will allow for a period of reflection and a review of what has been done so far. We have engaged with the Department previously, for example, on the retention of benefits such as the medical card when moving from disability allowance to employment, so there is precedence. It is about engagement and doing what we can, as my colleague mentioned, with the limited resources that are available. Where we can we will certainly engage.

Comment on this

I am looking at action No. 18, although I hesitate to use the word "action". It states that the Department will:

Continue to invest in enhancement of child specific social welfare supports, such as the Child Support Payment and Working Family Payment, while exploring alternative approaches for targeted payments to support families with children on low income, following a public consultation process.following a public consultation process.

The Department has given itself until 2028 to do that. I appreciate that these are not necessarily the officials' priorities but those they implement on behalf of the Government. To say that there is a lack of ambition would be very kind.

Regarding exploring alternative approaches for targeted payments, my reading of that is that it will be at least 2028 before targeted payments arrive. I genuinely hope I am wrong and witnesses should feel free to correct me, but my read of it is that the Department has set itself the target of exploring alternative approaches for targeted payments by quarter 4 of 2028, which is the year after next and edging closer to an election, not that the witnesses are on an election timeframe, of course - as civil servants they would not be - but others are. In terms of targeted payments to support families with children on low incomes, when does the Department envisage those actually happening, given that the exploration of the alternative approaches only has to be completed by quarter 4 of 2028?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

The consultation process has already happened. We got 277 submissions. The proposal is for two different elements, one being the working age payment. We are effectively restructuring what is already there under the proposal for discussion, and there are other alternatives where we would effectively adapt the working family payment into a working age payment and remove the child element and combine it with what is the child support payment. That is the basic proposal. It is very complex, so the submissions are being reviewed.

The Deputy mentioned the ESRI. The ESRI has made two different proposals, one in 2025, which I referenced earlier, where there were sort of winners and losers. The more recent proposal involves a targeted child payment and a taxable child benefit, so there is a taxation element. This is a fundamental re-engineering of those payments. I was involved, for example, in the development of-----

Comment on this

Sorry, my time is limited as well. Mr. Hession and I both know, and as everyone knows, the way to solve poverty is either to reduce costs or arrange for in-cash transfers. There is nothing happening on the reduction of costs; they are just going up. In terms of in-cash transfers, which is what families living in poverty obviously desperately need, particularly where there are children involved, because we all know how expensive children are and getting more so, and in terms of the target of exploring the alternatives by quarter 4 2028, and Mr. Hession is telling me that a significant amount of work has been done, including the consultation and evaluation, which is fantastic work, if that is ready to go, why are people in poverty, especially children, given the targets, which are getting missed but at least there are targets, having to wait until quarter 4 2028 for something as small as exploring alternative approaches? I am genuinely flummoxed by that.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

Exploring alternative approaches is already under way. It is not that the exploration is going to wait until 2028. If we were to make that kind of change, as I was about to say, and I was involved in the jobseeker pay-related benefit proposal, and we have also delivered other reforms, for example, auto-enrolment, social welfare policy legislation and the system development involved in an overhaul, which is going to be a long-term restructuring of social welfare policy, is extremely complex. The IT element alone as well as the testing and redesign takes time. The legislation of an enormous 2005 Act-----

Comment on this

I am very aware of that. I am not making myself clear, so I will. I am really aware of how complex it is. I know there are thousands of staff working to make sure this is done. The Department has a lot of very clever people working on this, which is brilliant. However, I am looking at that figure of quarter 4 2028, and that is to allow for all of that work to be done. What Mr. Hession is saying, essentially, is that there will not be any intervention on targeted payments until all that work is done, and the target for that is quarter 4 2028. Therefore, the Department is looking at quarter 1 2029, realistically, to get that done, or even further out than that. Is this going to be another thing that will go beyond the lifetime of this Government or, given the amount of work that Mr. Hession rightly says has been done, is the scope there to move a little bit quicker, or is the Department going to stick to that and just have the exploration done but no actual in-cash transfers for people who are in poverty today?

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

With the elements here, we continue to invest in child-specific social welfare supports while all that is going on. It is not as though we are pausing child poverty measures or child poverty income supports while we figure all this out. The Government still has to take a decision based on the analysis that has come in and the options, and as I say, the ESRI has submitted two very different proposals in the space of two years. These are important long-term decisions and the Government will have to take a view on where it goes. In the meantime, there was €320 million in the last budget in terms of child-specific measures.

Comment on this

That still leaves you far away from your targets.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

The consistent poverty rate has come down, and the point is that for families or children in poverty, what that commitment is saying and what the Government is saying is that it will continue to prioritise addressing child poverty. These are long-term design issues. It will not be the case that once you introduce or restructure your payment, all your problems go away overnight.

Comment on this

Nobody is suggesting that.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

In the meantime, the Government has delivered a lot in recent budgets to try to enhance the child support and working family payments. Lone parents became eligible for the working family payment for the first time last year. There is a lot going on in that space. I reassure the families of that.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are out of time. Ms Ryan?

Comment on this
Ms Denise Ryan

It is worth noting that, in terms of that €320 million, we have not yet seen that reflected in the data. The latest available SILC 2025 data is based on 2024 income. It is just worth bearing that in mind.

Comment on this

The data is based on 2024 when the energy credits were being paid. So, anything thereafter is without the energy credits, right? Okay.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their responses. I want to pick up on something in particular, the question of the technical measurement of poverty. Forgive me for getting too operational on some of these things, but the implementation of policies is often just as important as the policies we decide on. I asked this question before in the committee. What does it take to get consistent child poverty from that 8% down to 3%, 2%, 1%, and down to zero? It feels quite far away, particularly when you go into communities. I am a big fan of going into communities and talking to people. I do it all the time. I do it every week.

In particular, I want to highlight two statistics or technical measurements. For families with children under five, the at-risk poverty measure has increased from approximately 20% to 25%. I would love to hear the witnesses’ assessment of that. It gives me a lot of pause because it means that newer families are now most at risk of poverty, and that may scupper the measure to deal with consistent poverty over time.

On the topic of the working family payment, which I am a big fan of, I have to say, because it is genuinely a really welcome measure and 50% of the recipients are lone parent families, but also at this committee, we heard that about 50% of those eligible are not taking it up. That is about 50,000 people, and that figure came from the assistant secretary a few months ago. In all of this, what I am trying to say is that we can actually sometimes identify those people. We know who the lone parent families are. They get the one-parent family payment, or apply for it at least. We know the people who have children under the age of five as there is Revenue data. There is data sharing across Departments and all that. How should the Department do better at going out to communities and to those individual households and individuals and saying to them they might be eligible for the working family payment or they might be able to look at other eligibility measures. For example, their child may be transitioning to a different age and therefore those people are going to go to a different payment, so we should get that all set up now. If we are really trying to tackle poverty, that proactive engagement with those targeted families would be really welcome. I would love to hear from the witnesses a little bit on that, and any other measures they can think of that take that consistent poverty measure down.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

We definitely agree on the need to be more proactive. Obviously, people have their entitlements; they can apply. What we need to look at over time is the fact that our systems are getting more and more sophisticated in terms of access to Revenue real-time information. We know more about where people's earnings are at as well as their entitlements and qualifications.

We need to look at the extent to which we can proactively either contact people or, in future, just pay entitlements. Maybe that is where we end up in future as regards good information. Sometimes there are other things that we do not know about, for example, whether somebody is actually living alone or whether their children are still living with them, etc. The future should look like that in a way that a person who is oblivious to the social welfare system receives the income supports he or she needs based on what he or she has already submitted in terms of their income.

We do the promotion campaigns. We have done them on working family payment. We are doing one, as Ms Ryan said, on household benefits. The community welfare service is a really important part of our Department. It is on the ground and very well networked locally. We often get referrals from Deputies, Senators and other groups of vulnerable cohorts. There are referral pathways there. There are people who are very hard to reach. People who have an income problem may have other problems in their lives. There are people who have fallen out of the system, and it can be difficult, even when they are identified, to provide the supports needed. The community welfare service is our connection to all those knottier problems and the people who have those more complex needs. Over time, we would like to get to a better stage. Even on the back to school clothing and footwear allowance, there are about 130,000 or 140,000 payments and about 100,000 of those happen automatically because we just know. We use a lot of automatic processing on those. As our systems and our information get better, it should involve fewer people saying, "I think I might be eligible so I must fill in a form and let somebody review it", and us saying, "Actually, we know enough already-----

Comment on this

Yes, and that would be so welcome. The question of eligibility and the onus being on the applicant sometimes makes it more difficult for a lot of people. To echo something Deputy Mark Wall says all the time at this committee, community welfare officers are important to engaging with them more and giving them more resourcing. Covid changed how people interact with the social protection system a lot but the question of proactiveness and making sure that people are getting that information and are able to access that information and are encouraged, even, to apply, is quite core to social inclusion. It is not just a question of what payments we are giving to people because they have applied for them but how we are moving the system and society in a way that cultivates inclusion. I encourage Mr. Hession and the rest of the Department to do that as best they can.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

My final comment, to follow on from Deputy Hayes's comment, is how to get that message out to the public. I see it in my own office, as I am sure all the other Deputies and Senators who are present do. Someone comes to my office with one query and I end up doing six queries for them because they are eligible for the household benefits package and the fuel allowance and they also have not applied for a medical card. I end up asking them. Sometimes they themselves do not know, so I end up querying it with the Department first to know what they are in receipt of. Could Mr. Hession outline how this roadmap will be publicised and communicated? There is still a communication barrier regarding how people can access the supports and how we can actually deliver on these actions.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

People have legal entitlements. We are keen that people would get the supports they are entitled to. We run targeted communications campaigns. We also need to have on the ground engagement. We have very good engagement through public representatives and local councils at national level in making the information available. We run a series of campaigns to try to raise awareness and to try to give air cover for the ground troops. Then, through our network of Intreo offices, we offer a service to try to make sure people are aware of their entitlements. The system is complex. We have over 100 schemes. I have been in this Department almost ten years, and every day is a school day as to how entitlements work. As bureaucrats, we always aspire to simplification, but we also realise that the reason the situation is complex is that we often have to make exceptions to take account of vulnerable cohorts. We do not want to lose that. We have done quite a few information campaigns. They sometimes have mixed success. When we did the previous drive - it might have been for working family payment - we got a lot of applications from people who turned out not to be eligible, and that just creates a bad aftertaste. We always try to learn from that and see how we can target it. In some schemes, it sounds old-fashioned but we have learnt that a letter is still the way to do things and that people open post in a way they do not open emails or their applications on mywelfare.ie or see communications on social media. Everyone's costs are a bit more expensive now, their plans can be more expensive, but in some schemes it is the tried and trusted methods sometimes that work the best.

I do not know if my colleagues want to add anything.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Mr. Hession mentioned that the Intreo offices have people dedicated to do that. Sometimes it is a matter of bringing the Intreo office out into the community as well. Sometimes there is a kind of stigma or an association about going to the social welfare office or the Intreo office. We have a number of community and voluntary organisations that provide very valuable services right across our communities that would have an opportunity to bring the services to them rather than taking people to the Intreo office.

Comment on this
Ms Denise Ryan

Absolutely. It is worth mentioning that, as well as the national network of 62 Intreo centres, as my colleague mentioned, we have over 90 citizens information centres funded by the Department and managed through the Citizens Information Board. They are very important partners in terms of getting messages out there. Again, to the Chair's point about community, they have, for example, started opening services in libraries where people can speak to an information adviser via video call. There is progress there. In the roadmap as well, there is an action on digital inclusion specifically in relation to public services to make sure that we reduce the complexity where we can and make them user focused. We will follow up with the Departments of public expenditure and reform, and the Taoiseach on that. It is certainly something where there is a lot more work to do and there is work being done.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Deputy O'Reilly has a supplementary question.

Comment on this

Yes, it is just to confirm something because I was a bit rushed at the end there. Am I correct that the SILC data the Department is working off at the moment include the energy credits? They have not yet factored in the withdrawal of those credits.

Comment on this
Ms Denise Ryan

I think that is right and, as the Deputy said, the next set of data will not include that but will include investments such as the €320 million. If we look at the impact of social transfers, where it comes across the most - and that is measured by the EU and by the CSO - is through social transfers. The cost-of-living measures had a significant impact but on a much lesser level than the social transfers in general, but the Deputy is correct.

Comment on this

That is great. I thank Ms Ryan.

Comment on this

Mr. Hession gave an answer earlier to the question of the second tier of child benefit and the ESRI giving the Department two different proposals. There was a question of re-engineering the whole scheme. He was just about to talk about how the Department had been involved in some of the earlier deliberations on this. I would love to hear a little more about some of these concepts around the design of a potential second tier of child benefit. I will allow him to finish that point.

Comment on this
Mr. Rónán Hession

What I previously mentioned was just that because I was involved in jobseeker's pay-related benefit, I saw how long it took to get a scheme from start to implementation. It took four or five years. It just does take that time. It is one of those things that benefit is designed carefully because the system is so complex. It is very difficult to fix things late, so we are better off thinking it through and testing it. In the working age payment and the targeted child payment, the difficult thing in social welfare policy is that it is done in the real world and real time. In designing a new social welfare system, if we were to set up a brand new country or, as the World Bank often does, take a country that does not currently have child supports and has to just introduce them from scratch, there are things that can be done that cannot be done in very established, networked, interconnecting aspects of the social welfare system. We want to avoid a situation where anybody loses out. The complexity really comes around how we make sure we get to a new system that is stronger and more flexible and reflects the real world. We do not have any vanilla customers.

Everyone has some combination of work and welfare. They will have supplementary benefits. Their life situation will change. Their children do not stay the same age or their partners do not necessarily always stay together. That is where the complexity comes in. Forgive me getting too poetic, but to some extent, the analogy I often use is with catwalk fashion. Sometimes when someone wants to make a design leap, he or she has to just park the practicality and talk about the concept for the moment. With catwalk fashion, they do incredibly elaborate clothes that could never be worn on a rainy day. Then when one of those works at conceptual level, the high street will translate that into wearable clothes. Likewise, when doing policy work, sometimes if we are always saying, "Yes, but what about the person who is getting half-rate carer's allowance on top of their pension and who also is a guardian?", we have to say, "Let's just look at getting the concept progressed." If we can establish that we feel generally that will be a stronger, better system, we then have to try and ask all those knotty questions and see how it tests. The process is really one of trying to do the conceptual design first, which is done in an open-minded way.

We are grateful to the ESRI, by the way. We do not see it as a rival or something like that. I have been a civil servant for 30 years. The best thing about being from a small country is we can get the right people together quickly. We need to harness the brain power of everybody because we are a small country. The ESRI putting in thoughtful proposals is very helpful and some of the C and V pillar is extremely helpful. It is about processing all of that and coming up with something that looks like a viable prototype. Then there are a few decision points. I always say to the people in my Department or talking to new people coming in that the schemes we are dealing with today are because our predecessors 30, 40, 50 or 60 years ago said maybe we need a payment for our lone parents. Maybe we should do it. People would have said that it would be too difficult, that it will take too long or it will be too expensive, but now we have those schemes and the system is the way it is because people who did our jobs before said that we need to do something on this.

I have been involved in a lot of reforms over the years and there is always a certain impatience for them but when they happen, people forget about the time it took to develop them

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Hession for doing that. I know that is hard and complex and takes a lot of brain power and a lot of good heads around the table. When considering the catwalk fashion model, I think of the idea of personalised budgets. I know I am talking about something that might seem to be pie in the sky or something to be done five or ten years from now, but that is something the disabilities organisations have been talking about in terms of how we think about that in social protection more generally. It would be really welcome to be sensitive to all those different nuances for the individual.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

That concludes our deliberations on the Roadmap for Social Inclusion 2026-2030. I thank Ms Denise Ryan, Mr. Rónán Hession, Mr. John O'Toole and Ms Karen Henry for their attendance this morning and for providing the briefing materials in advance for the deliberations. We appreciate it.

Comment on this