We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Social Protection, Rural and Community Development

Meals on Wheels Service and Provision: Discussion

Summary

Meals on Wheels providers deliver vital nutritional support, social contact and welfare checks, but services face growing demand, volunteer shortages and uneven provision. The network estimates a €19 million–€21 million annual funding gap, with HSE support varying widely and often covering only a fraction of costs; providers also report waiting lists and areas without a service. Witnesses welcomed increased Government funding but called for a consistent, adequate funding framework, national standards and service agreements, support for staffing and volunteers, capital investment, and a role in emergency planning. No formal decision was taken, though the committee was asked to advance the providers’ recommendations.

John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I will read the note on privilege and deal with housekeeping matters before we begin. Witnesses and members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that would be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction I may make.

Members attending remotely are reminded of the constitutional requirement that to participate in public meetings members must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex. This is due to the constitutional requirement that to participate in public meetings, members must be physically present within the confines of the place where the Parliament has chosen to sit. In this regard, I ask any members participating via Microsoft Teams to confirm they are on the grounds of the Leinster House complex if they wish to contribute to the meeting. I remind all those in attendance to make sure their mobile phones are switched off or placed on silent mode.

Today's meeting is to discuss the Meals on Wheels service and provision. On behalf of the committee, I thank our witnesses and all the Meals on Wheels providers, staff and volunteers who make that service such a success. I speak for all members in acknowledging the significance and value of the services delivered by Meals on Wheels right across the country. These services, which are predominantly community led, are critical in supporting the social and nutritional needs of people all over the country and we understand the importance attached to that provision, often for the most vulnerable in our communities.

With that in mind, I welcome the following witnesses to this morning's meeting: from the National Meals on Wheels Network, Ms Tracey Noone, national development officer, and steering group members, Ms Deirdre Waldron, manager of Castlebar Social Services CLG, Ms Catherine Lenihan, chairperson and director of Knocknagoshel over 55 services Knocknagoshel Community Centre, and Ms Maria Jackson, former manager of the Northside Home Care Services. We are also joined by Mr. Briain Smyth, CEO of Irish Rural Link. I invite Ms Noone to make her opening remarks.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

I thank the committee for the opportunity to appear here today on behalf of the National Meals on Wheels Network. The network was established in 2015 and operates under the umbrella of Irish Rural Link. Every month, meals on wheels services deliver meals to more than 18,000 people across Ireland. These figures are taken from a survey we did prior to this meeting and it is a small screen shot. Most are older people and many live alone. For some, the person delivering the meal may be the only person they will see that day. The meal matters but the knock on the door matters just as much. It provides social contact, reassurance and an informal welfare check that can identify problems before they become crises. In other words, it is more than just a meal.

The National Meals on Wheels Network represents over 300 providers. This year those services will aim to deliver more than 3.3 million meals. Meals on wheels is not simply a food service. It is a preventative health service that supports nutrition, combats loneliness, promotes independence and helps people remain living safely in their own homes.

Ahead of today's meeting, we surveyed HSE-funded providers. Thirty-six services responded, collectively delivering almost 9,000 meals every week to more than 2,500 people. Their responses paint a clear picture of a service that is highly valued but increasingly under pressure. The first challenge is sustainability.

Across those 36 services, 813 volunteers, 169 paid staff and 109 CE and Tús participants support delivery. In other words, approximately three out of every four meal deliveries are carried out by volunteers. Nationally, that equates to an estimated 4,500 to 6,000 volunteers giving their time every week to support their communities. Providers repeatedly tell us that recruiting and retaining new volunteers is becoming more difficult, particularly in rural areas.

The second challenge they let us know about is funding. Providers reported that the average cost of preparing and delivering a meal is around €8.57. Average HSE support amounts to €2.73 per meal, falling to approximately €2.17 when weighted across service size. One in five providers receives no per-meal funding whatsoever, and two thirds receive no contribution towards their staffing costs. Overall, HSE funding covers only around a quarter of the reported cost of delivery. The remainder is funded through fundraising, client contributions, grant applications and volunteer effort. Across the country, providers estimate this funding gap at between €19 million and €21 million annually. There is also a significant inconsistency in how services are funded. HSE contributions range from as little as 44 cent per meal to €8.29 per meal. Some providers are funded per meal, others receive block grants, while others receive support only for specific costs. The result is a postcode lottery where funding levels often depend more on historic arrangements and geography than on need.

Recent emergencies have also highlighted the essential role Meals on Wheels plays in community resilience. During severe weather events and fuel supply disruptions, providers continued to support vulnerable people despite significant operational challenges. Yet, Meals on Wheels is not formally integrated into national emergency planning structures, despite the fact that local services already know where many of the most vulnerable people in their communities live. We have shared a national standards document with the committee which was proposed to the HSE in October 2024. We are urging all stakeholders to adopt the proposed national standards as a priority action to enable service enhancement and rapid provision of new services in areas of the country that are not currently being supported. Demand is also growing. Across our membership, 35% of providers are operating waiting lists while other communities have no service at all. Expanding provision requires the seed funding, practical support and a clear pathway to recognition and funding.

We welcome the Government's increased investment in Meals on Wheels. Dedicated funding has risen from just over €3 million in 2022 to €8.25 million this year, with a further €2 million announced in budget 2027, bringing the total allocation to €10.25 million. This is an important and welcome recognition of the value of the service.

Today, we ask the committee to support six key recommendations: first, introduce a nationally consistent Meals on Wheels funding framework that is supported via a standardised service agreement; second, ensure funding reflects the true cost of delivering the service, including staffing, transport, energy, insurance and administration, as well an infrastructure and equipment; third, invest in workforce development, volunteer recruitment and retention, and succession planning for service; fourth, provide capital funding to improve resilience and formally integrate Meals on Wheels into emergency planning; fifth, provide seed funding and streamlined recognition processes for new services in underserved areas; and, finally, provide sustainable core funding for the National Meals on Wheels Network, which currently supports 308 providers with just €100,000 annually.

Investment in Meals on Wheels is investment in prevention. Every meal supports health and well-being. Every knock on a door provides reassurance and early intervention. Every person supported to remain safely at home reduces pressure elsewhere in the health and social care system. We are asking for a fair and sustainable funding model for a service that communities, families and the State increasingly rely upon. I thank committee members, and I welcome their questions.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank Ms Noone.

I remind members participating remotely to use the raise-hand feature and to cancel it when they have spoken. I will offer seven minutes to each member for questions and answers. If they raise their hand, I will note it accordingly. The first member to speak is Deputy Guirke.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming before the committee. I thank all of the volunteers for their valuable contribution to the fantastic service. I have seen how many elderly people in my constituency of Meath have used the service and benefited from the Meals on Wheels programme. The regular contact with people is important.

The crisis coming down the line is the ageing population. At the moment, there are 532,000 people over the age of 65 and it is estimated that by 2046 the figure will be 1.4 million, an increase of 167%. The number of people aged 85 and over will almost quadruple, by 273%. There will be a massive demand on services down the road. How will the witnesses address that into the future? It is difficult enough to recruit people at the moment. What is the situation regarding recruiting and retaining volunteers? They deserve a serious amount of credit for the work they are doing. The money spent on this will have to increase accordingly given the numbers involved. Have any Meals on Wheels services closed due to a lack of funding? Where are the blackspots around the country? There are probably more in rural areas. Where are the worst blackspot?

Comment on this
Ms Michelle Noone

The cohort of volunteers currently involved in the delivery of the service comprise those who are the age of retirement and older. That cohort seriously diminished as a result of Covid and a lot of the cohort did not return to volunteer with service delivery. Some of those people may need the service themselves in a number of years' time. The volunteer input is dwindling. It is very difficult to get younger volunteers involved. Due to the fact the network advocates and lobbies for a national standard across the board, we would push for it to be a paid service in terms of the people involved in delivering the meals and organising all of that. We do not want to get rid of volunteers because they are such a vital part of the service. We need to have a balance.

There are gaps up and down the country. We had a gap in Portlaoise four years ago but we are now in a position where, with the help, support, guidance and advice of the network, Portlaoise is up and running. There are gaps in Dunmore East where there is no service. We had a gap in Croom where there was no service but that is now up and running. The service operated for a number of years without HSE funding. It is now in receipt of funding.

Even in counties where there is a dense service, due to human resource restrictions - that is, volunteers ageing, and financial resource restrictions - services are not able to deliver to everybody. There are people going without a meal and there are waiting lists established. It is evident across the country. There could be 40 providers listed in a county but there are still areas of the county which are not serviced. The providers here today will be able to give an explanation as to how that affects their services and what they are trying to do to address it.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

I represent a group providing services for older people for over 32 years. Our committee and directors of the charity are volunteers. I am the youngest; some others are aged in their 80s. It is impossible to get new members. We have paid staff since Covid because the demand for Meals on Wheels went from 100 to 700 meals a week during Covid and has stayed there. Our group covers north-east Kerry, west Limerick and north-west Cork and provides services to 300 older people, over 200 of whom receive Meals on Wheels.

When it comes to gaps, 33% of our clients live in Limerick. We operate from Knocknagoshel, which is five miles from the border between Kerry and Cork. We get our funding from the HSE in Cork and Kerry. We cannot get funding from Limerick. Kerry and Cork cannot give us any funding for those 33% and Limerick does not want to know about it because we are not living in Limerick. There is no provider in the area we are covering that is able to deliver Meals on Wheels. We are doing that and we do not turn anybody away. That is where our funding falls down. When I send back my numbers, I have to send back the numbers for Cork and Kerry. We are even allowed to go to Rockchapel, which is way out of our area. We can do that because there is no provider there.

Comment on this

I just have a couple of questions because I have limited time. I will ask them together and the witnesses can answer afterwards. What impact has inflation had on food prices and fuel costs? Surely this increased cost has impacted the daily operating budget. We know that in many cases volunteers use their own cars to deliver these meals. Does the current grant model give enough certainty to plan long term or is the service operating on short-term funding allocations? What specific legislative or funding changes - for example, dedicated fuel subsidies or multi-annual ring-fenced budgets - would make the biggest immediate difference to the operation to ensure it can operate well into the future? What did the Meals on Wheels programme ask for in this year's budget talks? How much did it receive and is it happy with the allocation?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

Mr. Smyth will answer these questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Briain Smyth

Regarding inflation, it is running close to 4% at the moment. Earlier in the year, the fuel increase ate up overnight the €2 million that was announced in budget 2026. For the next €2 million that we are hoping to talk to the HSE about this year, we anticipate that a lot of it will be swallowed by the increase in the cost of fuel, operating the services, insurance and running the vehicles that are out on the road. Unfortunately, we are running to stand still. We have an ambition to expand the services to 3.3 million meals and we are working hard to get there. However, the problem is that trying to chase the inflation tail is almost like throwing water into a barrel of sawdust, so it is an issue.

In trying to plan to move forward - and this is something we could put on the table - the steering group is trying to discuss how to put a floor under the services. That is perhaps a single figure on a national basis for the meals but just for the meals alone. We cannot necessarily say that we will have the same delivery distances in Mayo that we might have in Dublin, etc. Fuel costs and operational costs may be different in certain areas. One thing we would ask the committee to recommend is that we get a baseline figure for the individual meals, and that this then tracks the rate of inflation or a little bit above it, at all times. We would then have to work separately on individual costs bases for subsidies in different areas, depending on the mode of transport, traffic, etc.

Comment on this

I have a couple of questions. First, I echo what everyone has said about the work the witnesses do. Recently, we referred a woman in Balbriggan to the Balbriggan Meals on Wheels service, and it is not an exaggeration to say it changed her life. She has someone to talk to and she gets decent, nutritious meals. It has literally turned her from a woman who was rapidly turning into a recluse and retreating from the world into a lady who I now see walking around, happy out, when I am in my office in Balbriggan. It has literally changed her life. I know there are thousands of stories like that across the State.

The submission states that the HSE support ranges from 44 cent to €8.29. That is bonkers and does not make any sense at all. Are service level agreements with the HSE common? Do they exist? Are they standardised? Everyone said that RTÉ should get multi-annual funding. I think it is a very good thing but possibly better deployed to the witnesses' service.

Can the witnesses give me an explanation - and I know it is not their fault - as to why there is such a wide variety, from 44 cent to €8.29?

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

There is absolutely no consistency across the country. Every area and Meals on Wheels provider in each area is in receipt of a different amount of money for the Meals on Wheels service. Some providers are in receipt of a subsidy per meal while others are in receipt of a yearly grant. They may not get that grant in January. It could be May before they get their grants paid and they are back-pedalling.

To reiterate what Mr. Smyth said in response to an earlier question on inflation, there is no Meals on Wheels provider in this country that is receipt of exactly what it needs from the HSE. We have talked at length about the inconsistencies across the country and there are many of them but funding is a big deal. Some providers are not in receipt of any grant from the HSE whatsoever. Approximately 35% of our providers do not get any HSE funding whatsoever.

We are absolutely delighted, as Ms Noone said, with the increase in funding for Meals on Wheels this year of €2 million. That will bring next year's amount of money up to €10.25 million. However, that is not ring-fenced for Meals on Wheels only. That includes day centres. One of the questions we have is: what exactly is the amount of money that is being allocated to Meals on Wheels? However, nobody has been able to tell us.

Comment on this

The announcement was made on the day of the budget, on 6 October. It is now 21 October. Is Ms Jackson saying that the service providers have not been told how much money will be getting directly?

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

Yes.

Comment on this

That is absolutely shameful on the part of the Minister and the Department. That does not make any sense. November is coming, providers have to plan for next year and they do not know how much they will get. That is no way to operate. I know the witnesses are not running a business but that is no way to run a service at all. It is not their fault but that is very worrying.

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

In fairness, the Meals on Wheels service should be run like a business. It is totally reliant on volunteers throughout the country and that is not sustainable going forward. As Ms Noone and Ms Lenihan said, some of the volunteers around the country are managing services and they are in their eighties. They do not have the time or the skill set to be able to bring their services into the future. There is no sustainability. A question was posed earlier about whether any Meals on Wheels services have closed down. They have and Covid was a huge factor in that across the country-----

Comment on this

A lot of services did not open up again after Covid. Again, this comes back to the issue of putting the services onto a sustainable footing. The one fear I have, and I say this as someone who used to represent home helps, is the privatisation of the service. That is not what is needed at all. The not-for-profit model works very well. Every cent that the services raise or receive goes into the direct delivery of service. They are not skimming off a load of money from the top and making a massive profit. That is not what motivates them, and I get that, but I would have a fear based on what happened to the home help service. It was privatised and the people who run it own big, shiny corporate buildings and make a lot of money but the service did not improve. That would be a big concern of mine.

On the implications of fuel and utility costs, we all know that the cost of fuel went up. Has that impacted on the services' capacity to budget? Were there any interventions? We all know that a rake of tractors rolled down O'Connell Street and there was an intervention. Meals on Wheels service providers are not in a position to do that, nor should they have to. There was a package there and I wonder whether the providers benefited in any way from that. Was there any bespoke package for them to acknowledge the rising costs?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

I thank the Deputy for that question, which is very valid. Myself, Mr. Smyth and the steering group have had a conversation about this. We were not included in any of the supports that were put in place. The Meals on Wheels service definitely was not included. I am not 100% certain but I do not think any members of the community and voluntary pillar who offer a delivery service or use transport to deliver community services were at the table. So, the answer is "No". Nothing was given.

In fairness to the Minister, he was on top of it. We were in constant contact with him to let him know if there was anything critical happening. We need to be part of that conversation.

The next fear, even though we have not heard anything about it, is that if fuel prices continue to go the way they have been going, because a lot of the volunteers use their own vehicles, we may see people reluctantly saying to a service that they cannot do it anymore because they cannot afford to.

Comment on this

We can see that as the inevitable consequence. If people do not have the money to put diesel in the car, even if they want to volunteer, they simply cannot when the cost keeps going the way it is.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

As an example, our service has its own wheelchair-accessible vehicles. We have a contract one day a week with Local Link to bring our clients into our day centre. We got €54 last year as a subsidy.

Comment on this

As well as running the Meals on Wheels service and all the other services, these organisations are having to fundraise on the side. That is a distraction from doing the job that they should be doing. Ms Jackson wants to come in.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I ask Ms Jackson to make a final point.

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

The Deputy mentioned home support and the private organisations. The budget for the older person's home support between 2016 and 2026 went from €349 million to €920 million. That is to provide care to approximately 60,500 people. We have over 300 providers in our Meals on Wheels network. We provide meals to 228,000 clients across the country. In 2026, as Ms Noone said earlier, we will be providing 3.3 million meals. We are funded at €8.25 million this year but, as I said, that includes day centres. The allocation to older person's services for 2027 is €3.4 billion. The Meals on Wheels service will hopefully be in receipt of €10.25 million. We are grateful for the increases we have had since 2015. However, when you look at the overall budget for home support services in the community and you look at the Meals on Wheels service, it is not just about the meal. It is about the social interaction rather than a welfare cheque landing on the doorstep. That is a preventative measure so that people are not being admitted to hospital and are not ending up, in a lot of cases, in receipt of home care.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in. It is good that they are here. The meeting has been informative. The people outside understand the great work they are doing. That is the first thing.

The second thing is to acknowledge the great work that is done in Portlaoise. There was a gap in Portlaoise and I thank everybody who attended the meetings. It was hard work to get a service up and running. What happened was that as a result of the day care centre closing - it never reopened after the Covid-19 pandemic - the HSE brought down the meals. I was involved years ago on a voluntary basis. The community entertained the people who came in. They came in on buses from very rural areas. That all stopped. They were forgotten people. The service is now coming back. I salute the Meals on Wheel service that is up and running in County Laois. It does great work. No words of mine or anyone else could describe what it means to those people. They are making a contribution and that needs to be acknowledged.

I have a few questions. What additional State funding would close the gap between €19 million and €21 million to provide a greater service from the service providers?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Waldron

We are not running at a loss. We are all not-for-profit organisations. With community services programme, CSP, funding, we are supposed to run a social enterprise. In one breath, we are not allowed to make a profit but we have to break even. The €10 million sounds fantastic but as an organisation, we run a seven-day service 365 days of the year. We get €75,000 when it costs us nearly €500,000 to run the service for the year. We are lucky that we have a building where we can rent out rooms. We have a day centre.

Comment on this

Not everybody has that.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Waldron

No, and even at that we are struggling.

I will give an example. Our vehicle is three years old and it is nearly coming off the road. With regard to relying on grants, we are relying on CLÁR funding. I saw one grant specifically for a Meals on Wheels vehicle. I applied in January but was not eligible because they cut off anyone who got funding in the past three years. It took them until October to tell me I was not getting this. I was reliant on that vehicle. It has now gone back to the Minister, Deputy Calleary's office and I have to beg, borrow and steal now to try to get it. It would then have to go to tender.

Comment on this

There is no guarantee the network will get it.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Waldron

I rang the HSE and said that our service for meals may shut down because we do not have a chilled van. We cover a 40-mile radius.

Comment on this

The network's report says the meal is costing €8.57-----

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Waldron

Yes.

Comment on this

-----and the support is €2.17 per meal. There is a contribution in between. Will the witnesses explain why the State is covering only a fraction of the cost of a service that supports people to remain at home? The network obviously has discussions, so can the witnesses tell me why that is the case?

Comment on this
Mr. Briain Smyth

In real terms, the added cost is just covering the energy. This is what the added State subvention is providing. Everything else has been fundraised for or provided locally from the other services and they are doing such a fantastic job. There is, however, an historical gap on. To answer the Deputy's question directly, we would see that the subvention premium needs to be in excess of €10.

Comment on this

That is grand. That is the answer.

My next question is on dedicated funding, which has increased to €10.25 million following the additional €2 million announced in budget 2027. Does the network consider that sufficient? What measurable improvement should the Government expect in return for this investment?

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

On the funding shortfall, Ms Noone has referred to the €8.25 million funding in 2026, and a projected 3.3 million meals. Divide that and it is €2.50 per meal. The Department of Social Protection is providing €3.25 per hot school meal for kids, which is one third of the portion size we deliver, and it is delivered in bulk to the schools so there is no delivery cost. How can that be fair?

Comment on this

That answers my question. It is not fair. The network reported that 35% of providers operate waiting lists, while some communities have no service at all. How many additional people could be supported if adequate funding was provided? What is the most urgent barrier to expanding capacity?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

Human and financial resources are the most significant barrier to expanding capacity. We get a lot of inquiries in to the network, thankfully, from community groups that want to set up a service, which is great and we welcome them with open arms. The amount of work that goes into setting up that service is massive. It is not a case of having a group today and a service tomorrow. We advise them to register as a legal structure and to get charitable status, which in itself is a huge undertaking. Then, when they get there, they need to look at the volunteer input, whether it is going to cook from a premises or not, whether the premises meets environmental health requirements and whether the environmental health officer will put a restriction on the number of meals that can prepared in the kitchen. Then there is the HACCP training, the safeguarding training and the manual handling training. All of these are additional. That is where the challenge lies because we do not have that sufficient funding model.

Comment on this

I have one more question, and I may get in again in the second round. What practical measures would enable providers to recruit and retain volunteers while reducing the dependence on unpaid labour?

Comment on this
Mr. Briain Smyth

I spoke with the steering group about this. We are seeing that there is an ageing out of the traditional volunteer network. We are seeing it in certain parts of the country. Every second day I am getting calls from groups having problems with services that are on the verge. I had one a couple weeks ago in Fingal where a woman in her 90s was running the service and, unfortunately, she just was not able to continue on with it. This is where the network comes in and we have to find a solution to amalgamate services.

We have a similar problem in the south midlands at the moment where we are seeing people ageing out. I do not like using the word "professionalise" because it is a business term but the people who provide these services are professionals. They should be remunerated to do it. Getting volunteers in rural areas is a problem because everyone is doing something else, such as with the GAA team or whatever else is going on, and the time just is not there for the volunteer cohort. Therefore, we invariably rely on retired people and people with that type of profile, so there needs to be some type of medium. As we go on, I think we will find ourselves closer to a paid staff as opposed to volunteers. That is unfortunately how things seem to be progressing at this point.

Comment on this

There are fewer and fewer people and it is harder and harder to get volunteers to do anything. That is across all communities. As a result, will someone out there not get dinner in a few weeks' time? I put that question to Ms Lenihan as she is hands-on. Might someone in each of our communities be told that it will not be possible to bring their dinner after Wednesday week?

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

Yes.

Comment on this

That answers my question. I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We need to move on. The next speaker is Senator Goldsboro.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their presentation this morning. It is alarming. We are talking about cost inconsistencies, funding and volunteers but my priority is the elderly, those in receipt of services. Some groups receive funding from the HSE on a yearly basis, some monthly. A lot of fundraising is going on and it is being left to a significant number of volunteers.

I live in south Tipperary. We have the excellent Millennium Family Resource Centre in Glengoole. We also have a day care centre in Fethard, which does Meals on Wheels. In Carrick-on-Suir and Clonmel, to name a few, the service they provide is a lifeline. It is invaluable and it is the only connection some people have on a daily basis. We cannot take that away from people in rural communities because of pounds and pence. That cannot be allowed to happen. On a national basis, we are becoming reliant on volunteers. Volunteers are the unsung heroes of society. We will see on Friday when the tidy towns awards are announced all the work volunteers do.

A lady of 90 in Fingal and others of 80 and 90 years of age were mentioned who are retired and should be relaxing but are out delivering these services. On the other hand, we have a significant issue with getting names from social welfare to put a lot of people on the community employment, CE, schemes, tús schemes and rural social schemes, RSS, which would alleviate a significant amount of pressure on the Meals on Wheels waiting lists. It would take away the pressure to be so reliant on volunteers. Is that an issue on a national basis? Have the numerous groups seen it in terms of getting names released? I know from other groups that it is a significant challenge.

Looking at solutions, the main thing is not to lose the people in the middle who are reliant. Our elderly are our society. We need to look after them well and to know they are getting a nourishing meal on a daily basis is a lifeline for many families. Some people's sons or daughters are abroad, away from home, and knowing their mother or father is getting that meal every day means a lot to many people. We have to compliment everyone who is involved and acknowledge the great work they do on a daily basis, including in fundraising.

We know with inflation and the cost of living that fundraising is becoming more and more difficult for many organisations and groups. If the witnesses could answer that query, I would appreciate it.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Waldron

On retention of volunteers, we could not run the services without them. Board retention is a difficulty now. With the governance issues coming on board, the onus is increasing. People ask, "Really?" They are a vital part of our services. Mr. Smyth was right that we cannot privatise it because it would just go to pot. Our volunteers work through several services. We have day services and Meals on Wheels. We also do a discharge service from Mayo University Hospital which we piloted only 18 months ago. It is working fantastically. Once a week we collect names on three of the elderly wards. We potentially call those people the day they come home. A lot of people might not have a public health nurse if they do not have an open wound, so they go home to nothing. We call them and ask them if they would like a telephone befriending call, Meals on Wheels or day service. We do not bombard them. We start with a telephone call so they know there is someone there at the end of the phone. That can be rolled out across all of our services but it is down to getting the volunteers in place, to training them and to knowing what they want to do. The service is a lifeline for so many people. We have volunteers in their 80s delivering to people younger than them. We could not run the services without them. They are all doing it at their own cost, using their own vehicles, etc.

There is the RSS but we cannot get anyone now under the new rural dwelling scheme because there is nobody available. We rely heavily on them. They can only work according to certain criteria. They will not work bank holidays or Christmas. Our staff have to take up the slack and work those hours but they are fantastic - they do their 18.75 or 19.5 hours.

Tús participants come for a year. They only have their HACCP and manual handling training and they are gone. It is a great initiative for somebody to get back into the workforce. It is not really suitable for voluntary services. The RSS is amazing but there is nobody there.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

As I said earlier, we have paid staff cooking and delivering the meals. All of our delivery drivers are retired men. They work three hours a day - it is ideal for them. Our kitchen staff are trained. We train from within because we could not afford to pay chef rates. We have one chef. She is a catering manager and she trains the people below her and brings them along. It is a model that works. We would not afford it if we had to hire qualified people to do all of these jobs or young people. We have very few volunteers. Our committee is all volunteers but we are all elderly. In the past year, I have trained three staff members who are now trained to do what I do in case anything happens to me. That is the future of our service because we will not be able to get volunteers. Younger people are not volunteering and we are all getting older.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I call Deputy Roche.

Comment on this

I thank the Chair. The witnesses are extremely welcome. I really appreciate the conversation we are having today. I have often thought about the tremendous work volunteers do not just with Meals on Wheels but also community volunteers. If they were taken out of that space, society would be so sad and left so short in terms of a vibrant community. I thank the witnesses for what they do because it is not easy. The last thing you want is to be penny-pinching or fighting for more financial resources when you know what you are doing is a vital intervention to support people. I am always taken with the level of love, one might say, that people do it with. I am familiar with some of the Meals on Wheels communities.

Going back to Covid, we all want to forget about Covid but I am always reminded about what happened then and of the enormous benefit to those communities when they had volunteers who were able to go out and offer that bit of comfort.

It is not about the hot meal; it is about intervention and checking in with that older person to ensure they are all right. It is not simply a matter of arriving and leaving the meal on the back step or the table. That checking-in aspect is an invaluable piece of community watch.

I apologise that I did not arrive in time to listen to the witnesses’ opening statements. Since I have come in, however, I have realised the enormity of the work they do and the number of people their organisations reach out to. They almost run like institutions. They still wonder what next week, next month or next year will look like in terms of the structures. I noticed the Minister, Deputy Calleary, was speaking in the Dáil earlier. Any time we have engaged with him on the matter of supporting local communities, I have always felt that he possesses the empathy and capacity to be able to do more. It behoves all of us - this committee especially - to be able to make that call on behalf of the witnesses' organisations.

People working in An Garda Síochána, the health system or who are in the business of driving and caring must be Garda vetted. In the context of having to have all of those things in place, is it a requirement for volunteers in the witnesses' organisations to be Garda vetted? The witness is saying “Yes”.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

Every one of our staff has to be Garda vetted. They must also have child protection vetting because we provide a hot school meals service.

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

Not every organisation across the country has all of their staff or volunteers Garda vetted or gone through safeguarding training. In some cases, in some rural areas, there may be a volunteer driver, who is not Garda vetted, driving to an elderly person living in their home down a bóithrín.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

The issue of Garda vetting has come up a number of times in the National Meals on Wheels Network. It is a recommendation. It is a no-brainer as far as we are concerned. I made inquiries at higher level in the HSE in this regard. The service level agreement advises, but does not stipulate, it. I am not in any way, shape or form disrespecting the HSE and that service level agreement but it has been in place for such a long period of time. As Ms Jackson alluded to, there are a number of groups out there that are not Garda vetted. When we mention it to them, they panic. There is such tight regulation around Garda vetting. Depending on how the application is put forward and the wording in it, some might not qualify. Does the Deputy understand what I am trying to say?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

There is also a charge for it.

Comment on this

Who bares that charge?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

It is the service itself. The volunteer centres, as the Deputy will be aware, are responsible for Garda vetting. They are the contact. The charge is not consistent, however. One volunteer centre might charge a certain amount, while another centre might charge a different amount. In fairness, the majority of centres are flexible enough in this regard. They allow individuals to pay the charge when they are able to do so. It is not the case that they cannot be Garda vetted as a result of that. That is the kind of challenge. It is not stipulated as a requirement in the service level agreement. Rather, it is an advice. As Ms Jackson said, some of them are not Garda vetted at all.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

An issue we have with Garda vetting is that we have staff who work in a local day centre three days per week and come to us at the weekend. They may work at their kids' sports club as well. They have to be Garda vetted in every single one of those places. Why can there not be a single Garda vetting that would cover a person for a certain amount of time where they would get a card or whatever that stipulates they are Garda vetted? Why does it have to be this way?

Three different groups have to pay for the same person to be Garda vetted every year.

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

There are huge inconsistencies across the country in every piece of Meals on Wheels, or in the network. Earlier, we talked about the inconsistencies in funding. The Deputy mentioned the piece around the Garda vetting. They are just small examples of the total inconsistencies across the country. There is the sustainability piece with staff volunteers. We mentioned earlier about CE and tús and succession planning funding. Regarding the network, we developed a draft national standard of guidelines for providers to adhere to. That was provided to the HSE following a huge amount of work back in October 2024. That is still sitting with the HSE. That has been placed on hold. There was a planned series of five different standards that providers would reach as well as guidelines because there is no legal requirement on Meals on Wheels providers across the country to adhere to any standard. A lot of providers have section 39 funding, and they would have a service agreement with the HSE. However, a lot of it is guidelines with a lot of providers across the country. It is not a case that we are trying to shock people. We are very grateful for all the support that we get from everybody. However, there is a huge number of providers that are operating possibly with unsafe practices. If the standards we developed were supported by the HSE and shared with our providers, they would be guidelines for them and they would know the things they should be adhering to.

Deputy O'Reilly mentioned the home care piece. Home care providers are all standardised across the board now. All of that came about because of the home care tender. In relation to the meals on wheels piece, there is no legislation and no standardisation across the country in any way, shape or form. There are a lot of providers that do not have Garda vetting.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are out of time now. We will move on to Senator McCormack.

Comment on this

I thank each and every one of the witnesses so much for all the work they do. I am in Portlaoise. I have met Ms Noone a few times. I have attended two different Meals on Wheels conferences. The most recent one that I attended was in Tullamore last year. It was such a job to get Portlaoise up and running. I commend the witnesses on all the loopholes that they have to jump through.

A lot of my questions have been asked. I am glad that Ms Jackson touched on the draft national standards in October 2024. I have read that. That is still sitting with the HSE and nothing has ever happened with that. Another point I want to raise that I could not get my head around is the inconsistencies in the funding, such as how someone in Galway gets paid one set fee and then someone in Laois gets something totally different. What the volunteers were doing was creating miracles out of the money they were getting. Regarding the stories I heard at the conference, there was this fabulous group in Galway and it was creating meals from such little money and inventing ways to go forward. The volunteers were out of pocket and that is where we are at. It is a real big worry now that we are in a cost-of-living crisis and these are all the things that the witnesses have talked about. No one has this extra money anymore. It is not fair that we are requesting that.

Everything has been discussed and everyone has commended all the work of the Meals on Wheels. I am glad the welfare has come into it because that is the biggest part that I would have seen so much of in the community. From one end of the week to the next, a lot of people are alone. If someone is checking in and if they can let know the public health nurse or someone else know that something is not right with Josie today or something like that, it is a massive piece to social inclusive.

As a committee chair, I want to see if we can put the forward the asks from this group today and can we share the transcript of this committee with the Minister and ask for proper input here for this service. I am really concerned.

We have heard that this is a risk to this service being able to continue. Is this something the committee can do anything about? Could we also ask for intervention on that October 2024 draft report? I have a copy of it but I ask the witnesses to submit it to the committee as well. I am wondering whether there might be something we could do as a committee to try to help. We work very well as a committee and we want to see what we can do to help. That would be my thing.

I missed the start of the meeting, and I believe the witnesses made some requests already. I ask that each group give even just one line about its request because I know I am caught for time.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will start with Ms Noone.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

I am going to let the providers deal with the on-the-ground Meals on Wheels stuff. From my perspective and that of the network, I will put forward one of our requests. We are a national Meals on Wheels network in operation since 2015, and we did get funding through in 2021. My position was in place in 2022. We currently operate to support 308 providers nationally on a budget of under €100,000 annually. While we are managing, I am the only member of staff in the network. I have the support because we operate under Irish Rural Link but it is involved in its own pieces. That is my one request on behalf of the network so we can serve better the providers out there.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

Can I give an example?

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

We operate a paid staff and a volunteer committee. We get a bulk section 39 grant every year. It is just about 80% of what we need but it is not allocated to any particular service and we have a lot of different services. In 2023, the Workplace Relations Commission, WRC, agreed a running increase in staff wages for section 39 staff. The HSE agreed to fund this. However, in our case, our wage bill is larger than our section 39 funding, so only 80% of our wage bill is covered by the HSE. The HSE then says that not all of the funding we get is for wages, so we get 66% of the WRC increase. Now, because the increase is not allocated to any particular staff, we have to pay it to all our staff. This means that 34% of what we need has to be found from our own funding every year. That is going to continue on into 2027. We have no reason to believe it is not.

As well as that, the minimum wage is going up again in January. It went up last January and the January before that. The problem with that is that because our wages are low, once the minimum rate goes up, all of the wages have to go up, as well as the 2% or 1% or whatever the WRC increase is. Our wage bill is crippling us.

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

My request is in relation to the budget for 2027 of €10.25 million concerning the amount allocated towards Meals on Wheels. I mention this because it is not ring-fenced.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Waldron

In that regard as well, pension auto-enrolment is another bill that is crippling for services. On capital funding for essential infrastructure, we should not have to be begging for the essential things. I will not even go into problems with Uisce Éireann, sewerage and other issues. I would bore the committee to tears. It is such a huge bill for us, never mind just the normal day-to-day running costs. My request would be the capital funding.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses very much.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Does Mr. Smyth have a final comment?

Comment on this
Mr. Briain Smyth

Yes. We are trying to use the Portlaoise Meals on Wheels service as a template for how it should be done moving forward. We are really delighted with the way things are working there.

I think we need a standard service level agreement, SLA. That is to say it straight out. We have providers which do not have any service level agreement and we have ones with good service level agreements but we do not have a national standardised service agreement. We need the standards adopted. For want of a better term, we are looking to be "regulated". I will not say it is the Wild West but we are all trying to do our best from the perspective of training, hazard analysis and critical control point, HACCP, procedures and all the other good stuff that goes with it.

We also want to be included within the national emergency co-ordination group, NECG. That is something that we would look to put forward. We have the teams on the ground whose members walk around 51,000 townlands every day and who are able to give us a report before any of the emergency or blue-light services as to what is going on in a storm event, if there is a local weather event or whatever. We can respond quicker than anybody else on the ground.

It is small things like these, which might not seem like a whole lot, that are very important as to why the organisations should be supported.

Comment on this

Sometimes I say that we all age and that if we are lucky, we will get older. If we are lucky, we will all be in a situation whereby we will be reliant on these services at some point in our lives. To set the scene, there are 190,000 older people living alone in the country. It is estimated that there is a consistent poverty rate of 10% and an at-risk of poverty rate of 30%. This is 19,000 people in consistent poverty, some of whom are probably watching at home, and 60,000 people at risk of poverty. This is not just about poverty or deprivation. As the witnesses have eloquently put it, it is about connecting with people, tackling loneliness, societal connection, making sure people are okay and making sure they are all right in emergencies as has just been referenced.

One of the really heartening things I really want to add to what others have said is that the witnesses have stepped up where the State has not. Volunteers have stepped into this breach. The organisations represented by the witnesses were not founded by the State; they were put together and are led by the witnesses, and I am so grateful they are doing so. I know that so many clients of theirs are as well. I was really struck by Ms Lenihan's point that nobody is turned away. This is an incredible thing to be able to say and I hope it is something that can continue to be done across the service. I know it is something that not all services can do but it is an incredible motto to have.

I have some specific questions. Ms Jackson mentioned the number of clients who are met across the course of a year but I did not quite catch the number. It is the number of people who are served by Meals on Wheels throughout the country.

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

It is 228,000.

Comment on this

This is a huge number of people. I have some questions on some of the submissions. The transformation and capacity building document is excellent and I am really impressed by it. I would like to hear what the reaction to it has been from the HSE agencies. Have they engaged with it? It is extremely well argued and I do not think there is any criticism I could possibly offer.

My next question is on the sustainability of funding. Budget funding for 2027 will be over €10 million. The witnesses have said there is a funding gap of about €20 million. I assume this does not necessarily take account of the 4% inflation rate or it could be higher. Effectively, the witnesses are working with one third of what is needed to be able to run these services and they are plugging the gap with a series of volunteers and, I am sure, the witnesses' own mental health in terms of running these organisations. It would be helpful to know whether this funding gap is for certain levels of service, or for expected levels of service as populations age, or for the demand the services have? I would like to understand the content of this funding gap.

That €2 million is swallowed up by inflation is genuinely really shocking. I do not doubt it for a second and it goes to the heart of the question on the inflation of costs that is affecting the community and voluntary sector. Volunteers on the ground are affected in terms of fuel, energy, food and utilities. If €2 million is not plugging the gap, then we have a huge problem not only in terms of the €20 million gap but also how we plan for the services on a multi-annual basis.

I would like to hear from the service providers the stories of the people they have helped. It would be very helpful for us to hear some of these. We meet these people all of the time in our constituencies and I find that sometimes personal stories are the best example of understanding why we need to do better in this space.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

There is a lot there and I thank Deputy Hayes for his questions. I will hand over to Mr. Smyth for the question on the pre-budget submission because the majority of putting it together was his brainchild. Deputy Hayes will hear significant stories on the ground from the other witnesses.

The funding piece is in crisis. We welcome every increase with open arms because anything is better than nothing. What we are trying to do in the network and on behalf of the providers is to be able to put that social value across to the relevant stakeholders, that is, the HSE, the Department of Health and the Minister - trying to quantify that because at the end of the day, this is all going to boil down to policy change and available funding. With the limited budget on which we are operating, we are working extremely hard utilising our steering group and the proactive providers - it is not that providers are not proactive across the country - that is, the larger ones that have that skillset and paid members of staff. They are feeding us back all of the relevant information and we are trying to put it together in a shape or form that we can put forward. That is my piece. I will hand over to Mr. Smyth regarding the pre-budget submission and the piece the Deputy mentioned as part of that.

Comment on this
Mr. Briain Smyth

When we had the fuel crisis earlier in the year, the Minister rang me and told me that €2 million was allocated. He said that would have to go towards trying to shore up elder services at the moment. The ambition was to try to increase the number of meals being served but in reality, it was swallowed up straightaway by the fuel price increase free. There was €2 million last year. The figure for this year was very quickly subsumed into the cost of running things from an energy perspective.

There are other things there as well. I wrote to the Tánaiste last night about LPG and how the carbon tax cap that has been put on things like home heating oil has not flowed through to LPG. The service runs on LPG. The cookers run on LPG, so it concerns whether we can get something done on that. Perhaps it is a lacuna in some way, shape or form that was not picked up in the budget.

Regarding the capital allocation programme, we are looking to try to build resilience into the network. What happens during a weather event? If the power goes out, we do not have a generator and we cannot get fuel. That is why we are looking to try to put in upgrades into the kitchen, solar panels and batteries. This is all the smart stuff we should be up to. It is simple and a no-brainer. By extension, we would be able to offer those to the people who require the services, for example, a small battery on a counter beside a fridge that one is able to plug in, in the event that there is a power outage. Following Storm Éowyn, €3 million worth of milk in the west of Ireland was just thrown out while there was €150 million worth of food that went to waste. Regarding the cost associated with that for the people most at risk of poverty and throwing out an entire freezer's worth of food because power has been lost, one can get a small €600 battery that one puts on the counter, one plugs the fridge in and one has it there to charge the phone. It provides one with two or three days worth of support. Small smart stuff like that goes a long way, so that is what we are looking for from the capital approach to it.

The feedback has been mixed to say the least. The Minister did say that there is traction on it, so I am waiting to hear about that. I am delighted with that. The Minister has been very good in trying to communicate. Since he has come into office, we have had a bit of traction with the way things are going, so we are looking forward to working with him on the ground to do that.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are out of time in regard to Deputy Hayes's points. I might ask the witnesses to come in with some personalised stories from their own area in a minute. I ask that they keep the names out because they might be identifiable.

I thank the witnesses, particularly Ms Lenihan, Ms Jackson and Ms Waldron, for coming in and explaining the situation. I know Ms Lenihan. I am very close to Knocknagoshel and I know she looks after some of my constituents in the Cork north-west side, which is very much appreciated. I appreciate all the work that Meals on Wheels providers provide. The witnesses said that it is a network of 300 groups. What is the overall figure? Are there many outside that group?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

We would have details on our interactive map - 308. From figures we get from the HSE, there would be 317 HSE-funded providers. Some of those providers would not be detailed on our map. We would not have them in under the umbrella of the network either because they do not know about us-----

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is it a very small number?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

Yes, it is a small enough number.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Perhaps Mr. Smyth and Ms Noone might comment on the national standards that have been mentioned. It is disappointing that they are in since 2024 yet there has not been any movement on them. What is in those standards and how can we, as a committee, bring them forward?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

I will hand over to Ms Jackson because she had the main input into those standards and is more versed in them than I am.

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

I developed the standards and they were to be a series of five different standards. The first starts with the basics of "then" and "now" and explains how Meals on Wheels started. By way of background, the organisation I had managed started with volunteers in 1965. Quite a lot of the organisations around the country are in operation in the community since that piece. The second chapter is on how to start a Meals on Wheels service. If this was available to certain groups around the country, it would be very useful as it is very detailed in terms of the steps to set up a Meals on Wheels service. It then goes into a lot of detail on food. The next piece is on nutrition. There is a lot of information in this for a Meals on Wheels provider or for people who are thinking of setting one up. It then goes into a lot of detail on staff and client service, again for a Meals on Wheels service starting up. For the likes of Portlaoise, when it was set up, this would have been the "how to", basically. The nutrition piece is a big piece. The last piece is on resources that can be accessed by a provider.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Has there been any engagement with the HSE on why it has not acknowledged that or not taken it on board?

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

The HSE acknowledged it back in October 2024. The HSE said that because it was developed through the network, it wanted experts in their own field, such as nutrition and so on, to look at this and then to bring it forward. That has not happened as far as we are aware.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

It has been mentioned that a number of different supports are available. Some might have providers funded per meal, some are funded by block grants and some are funded by just receiving supports for specific costs. Is that variable through the HSE areas or are there specific HSE areas doing very different things within their own HSE area, for example? I see that everyone has raised a hand.

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

Every area does things differently and within each of the areas, they are still doing things differently. There might be a provider in one of what is now called a regional health area, RHA, that is in receipt of a subsidy per meal and a grant and there may be some providers in that same area which are not in receipt of any funding.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

What is the network's preference?

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

Enough funding for an organisation to continue what it is doing.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is it an SLA based on numbers rather than a meal or a grant? What is the preference? Senator McCormack mentioned sending the transcript. We will send the transcript of today's meeting to the Minister plus a cover note on what was mentioned. Can we, as a committee, recommend that a standardised SLA is put in place for all the Meals on Wheels network based on whatever?

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

I mention again that most of the figures in our opening document are based on 36 providers which had answered the survey questions. There are more than 300 providers across the network and every single one of them is funded differently. At our conference, we talk to providers on the ground. If you are in a round-table environment, you learn that there are providers receiving quite a lot of money for a smallish number of meals while other providers providing a huge number of meals are getting less money. There are no standards across the board in relation to that.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

In Cork and Kerry, as members will know, we have a community work department. The community workers attend most of our meetings. They went out during Covid and since Covid in the vans to see what we deliver. Most other health service areas do not have that, so we are in a brilliant position. The problem is that our community workers know what we need, know what we do, advise us and write policies with us - other groups do not have that support - but they cannot get us any extra funding because the funding is allocated. That is the issue we have.

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

The question of what we are looking at for a baseline is a very difficult one to answer. We are putting this forward on behalf of all providers. We were discussing this last night and this morning and asking whether it is a case of us trying to get a certain level for the actual meal and then there being a subsidy available on top of that for all the additional costs and for everything to be linked to inflation because at the moment, that is non-existent. Meals on Wheels providers are victims of inflation and every other crisis and shock the country goes through but on a much larger scale because its funding level is so low. It is about trying to get that balance, the standardised service level agreement, baseline funding for the meal and then knowing there is an extra subsidy for all the additional costs as per provider because every provider is different.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

That gives us good food for thought. Ms Lenihan mentioned her organisation provides school meals as well.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

We provide school meals. No extra staff are needed for them and the delivery is passing the school for the Meals on Wheels. It is a bulk delivery, so there is no extra cost other than the cost of the food and that subsidises our Meals on Wheels.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

How many out of the network also provide school meals? Do we know?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

There are a few. Ms Lenihan’s organisation is one of them. Another provider in Monaghan is doing it.

Comment on this
Mr. Briain Smyth

There are a few who have tried to-----

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

They are trying to break in.

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

If I could add, HSE funding for Meals on Wheels services is only for over 65s so you cannot incorporate your school meals in relation to your funding.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

People with disabilities are under 65 as well. Could I have one final comment from Ms Lenihan because I am out of time?

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

There is always the risk if we cut back, they will see what we get in for it. We are getting that separately. The HSE might say that it is going to the same staff, the same food and the same everything.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is good that Cork and Kerry are working so closely together. That is great.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

We work closely together.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is the first round done. A few members have indicated for the second round. I will give everybody three minutes because we are running out of time and I am conscious members want to mention specific cases in their own areas. I have four speakers and Deputy O’Reilly is first.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses again for all the information they have given us. I would like to suggest that when we send the transcript to the Department,t we also ask for a breakdown of that money because it is very reasonable at this point in the budgetary year that people would at least have an idea of where they fit and how much it will be. I hope the Chair can get an answer for the Meals on Wheels people from the Department.

Do the witnesses negotiate as a group with the Government? How is that done? Meals on Wheels is not at the table as a social pillar or anything like that. It is not sitting down as a group to put forward its case, so it is very much done on a local basis which is where the inconsistencies are.

Would the network be up for that kind of centralised negotiation? There are drawbacks to a standardised service level agreement too. When you do something on a much bigger scale, it can represent an element of compromise, perhaps. I am taking it from the nodding heads that is something the network would be interested in and up for.

On the hot school meals programme, the Cathaoirleach and I are both massive fans of the not-for-profit delivery model which is delivered by the witnesses. They are already there and they have the kitchens. It makes complete sense. It is good food for the kids and money in for the providers but it also takes the for-profit motive out of it because when you start to chase that, that is when you end up with the turkey twizzlers as we saw from Jamie Oliver and all that other stuff. If you have people who are not chasing profit, then they can provide high-quality decent food. Where are the providers at now? Are they up for that national negotiation? Are they up for expanding the service if the money comes with it?

Comment on this
Mr. Briain Smyth

That would be the preference. We discussed this long and hard in relation to the national standards and the ability to have a national service level agreement. There are pluses and minuses and we are very much aware of that.

We get told after the fact as opposed to being involved and being in the room. The voices the Deputy will hear around the table here today would much rather be in the room putting their own case forward. There is a big challenge moving forward as to how we expand the service. The ability to keep people in the home moving forward is something we all want to try to expand. The Meals on Wheels service is a vital part of that.

As we see the service develop, we have ambitions to try to make it a true national service. That is where we might get some bulk savings, whether it is the ability to have bulk insurance, bulk purchasing or other elements such as bulk energy elements and all the rest of it. That can feed into the service as well. By coming together in that group, while we may give up some elements, we get stronger on the ground. From the perspective of being a charity under a co-operative structure, that is the important part of it - that we invest the co-operative profits back into the services on the ground. That is the only way we will do it.

Comment on this

The perfect model on this situation, whether it is hot school meals or Meals on Wheels would be quality nutritional food produced and prepared locally. That would be the perfect model. What mechanism do the witnesses use to identify people? There is a constant shift in population and people moving in and out, particularly in urban areas. What research do the witnesses have to do to identify somebody who might need the service? They may not know where to go themselves. They may be brand new into an area. How is that done?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Waldron

No more than Ms Lenihan, we never refuse anybody a meal, even if they are under 65. As far as I am concerned, if you need it, it is there for a reason. Sometimes it could be a family in crisis where a mother might have gone to hospital. The meals are provided for a period until she comes home. You cannot block somebody from something if they need it. A lot of homeless people come in. They are under 65 but they are in a desperate situation. They are referred to us by the Society of St. Vincent de Paul. It would pay for the meals on the client's behalf for a period, which is great. There are massive scenarios. It is not just old people; it is people in need. Nobody wants to come looking for a meal. They would not come looking for it unless they really needed it. We are able to keep people out of hospital, at home and into whatever mental health services they needed to tap into.

During the storms, we were lucky and got our electricity and water back within a day or two. There were two weeks in rural Ireland where people were without it. One man was identified who we never delivered meals to. Our driver took his life in his hands going to his house. Out of that, we were able to get Sage Advocacy into his house. We took him out of the house for a period. It was dismal. It was so bad. We cleared out the house. That man is living happily now but nobody knew about him before this. This is going to happen again.

Mr. Smyth talked about the power banks. Companies such as Energia showed us these. They were fabulous but we could not afford them. The council could buy a base of them. People had oxygen tanks. It is not just a meal. The amount of work our volunteers and staff do on a given day is more than just a meal. I know we say that a thousand times a day.

Comment on this

I will ask something out of pure curiosity, and it is not in any way a suggestion that the witnesses should do it. Are people who benefit from the meal ever asked to contribute towards supporting it?

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

We have a charge of €7 per meal. For a large meal, if a person has a big appetite, is €8. A small meal is €6. There is no way we can do anything else.

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

There is a client contribution towards the meal. It is not in every area. It is within the HSE. Certain areas across the country are not appreciative that clients are asked for a contribution towards a meal. The organisation I was managing provides over 3,500 meals a week. In north Dublin, the cost of producing that meal was over €10. You are not getting that kind of money from the HSE. The clientele has to contribute towards it. A huge issue is when you have to increase the price of a meal you are charging the client for, and nobody wants to do that.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Ms Lenihan mentioned a great option because there are people with small appetites. We see with the school meals, in particular, that some are getting more. Children who are younger may eat less than children who are older. It is a very good option.

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

In a lot of cases, our clients are in the age bracket where, unfortunately, they are either eating or heating. In some cases, the Meals on Wheels meal that is delivered is doing them for two meals.

Comment on this

Anybody listening today would think the organisations are getting €10.25 million but that is not the case. That needs to be said. I thought at the beginning that they were getting an extra €2 million but they are not. What we need to find out is how much is actually being given to them out of the €10.25 million. That is fierce important. From what I know about Meals on Wheels and the people they are delivering to, if it were not for Meals on Wheels people would be finding it difficult. They are not in a position to cook for themselves or to provide the right meals for themselves. Everybody needs to know that. The charge is nowhere near what it is costing to provide the meal. If this committee could secure one change from the Government over the next six months, what would make the greatest practical difference to Meals on Wheels providers and to the people who depend on them?

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

It would be that we would know that for next year, we would be okay. That is the big problem. This past year we asked the HSE to divide the funding into 12 instalments instead of giving us one bulk sum. Before that, we would get our bulk sum in April. The HSE would have allocated it in January but we did not get it until April. By January the following year, we do not know if we have enough money left to go to April. In some years, it could have been May or June before we actually got it. It would be a huge thing to know that we are going to get a certain amount of money for the next year, so we could plan for that. Even if we do not get the amount we need, we could budget, fundraise and look for grants of some sort to make up the difference. We cannot do that if we have no idea what we are getting.

Comment on this

That is totally unfair and it is good that we, as a committee, know that. When we are sending our paper to the Minister, we can stress how important that is. There are an awful lot of people out there in the communities whose health does not allow them to have carers coming in, the people in the middle. I know that those bringing Meals on Wheels to these people are, in a lot of cases, also maybe making a bed, bringing in the sticks and the turf and making sure they are all right. If there is a problem and if there is a relative or a friend living a good few miles away, they tell them to come over in the evening if they can as Mary or whoever is not well. That is what is going on out there. I want the witnesses to know that I know it is going on. As public representatives, we have to acknowledge the great work that is being done. When the volunteers dry up and the money dries up - Ms Lenihan can see it coming; I know by her words today that she is nervous - the 10-10-20 will hit the fan. It will probably cost 20 times as much money to look after those people because they are going to have to be looked after. I am delighted and so is everybody else. We are speaking on behalf of the people who are getting that service every day, and we want to thank the witnesses for the great work they are putting into it. We have to ensure that we do our job here as public representatives.

Comment on this

I want to follow up on the personal stories from the service providers. I would like to hear from them about the people they are helping and the things we and the public should know about them.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Waldron

We are going above and beyond. In one instance, a volunteer went into the home because it was a key code. There were no family members in the locality and, unfortunately, the volunteer found the person deceased inside. We had to arrange for counselling for the volunteer. It was not a normal day-to-day thing. That person was doing this out of the goodness of their heart and it was very difficult for them.

Some family members say, "Mam needs this." I say, "Let me ring them." When you tell an older person to do something, it is like the parent and the child saying, "Stop telling me what to do." I ask, "Will you just try it once?", and they do and they say they are so glad they did. You empower them to make the decision themselves instead of their being told what to do. A lot of retired nurses who come in to us are brilliant. I could not run the day service without them. They say, "That patient cannot do that." I say, "They are not patients, they are clients." We are here to enable them to do what they want to do. The nurses have to change the whole dynamic of the clients coming from the HSE, where the nurses look after them. You are not looking after them; you are helping the older person to be empowered and to live at home for as long as possible. That is all they want to do. It is to be in their own corner. That is all any of us want to do.

Comment on this
Ms Maria Jackson

I will give the committee an example of the service that, as I said, I managed in relation to volunteers delivering meals and no answer at the door. We had a very stringent assessment process whereby we took a lot of details when we were taking any of the Meals on Wheels clients on board. We asked them to list two next of kin. This person did not have a next of kin, did not have any family, and their public health nurse was down as next of kin. One bank holiday Friday, a meal was being delivered and there was no answer at the door. There was follow-up. Our co-ordinator in the office took it upon herself to leave the office, got herself cover with one of the office staff and stayed at this house until she found out where this person was. The lady was after being admitted to hospital, so you are ringing around all the hospitals to find out and to make sure. There is a lot of all that in relation to support and going above and beyond. As Ms Waldron said, volunteers are finding people who are deceased or who are very unwell. We had another volunteer driver who called to a lady and said she was not herself. When the volunteer driver went the next day, she said, "She is rambling. She is really not herself." It took some time to get a hold of a family member. The elderly person had a UTI, and that was what was causing the confusion. It just meant a trip to the GP's and a set of antibiotics and she was back on the road again. It is very simple but that is the welfare check at the door and the caring.

Comment on this
Ms Catherine Lenihan

As I said, I represent a very rural community. Our drivers go out and in some cases drop the meal in a box at the gate simply because in 90% of cases, there is a single elderly man living in the house. The house is so bad that he does not want anyone to see how bad it is because the only choice he has is, as he thinks, to be put into a nursing home. We do not have social housing in villages. Social housing is put mostly into towns and cities, so he has nowhere to go. He has no family. We put the meal in the box and he puts the money into the box. We have a lot of those very sad cases. He does not engage with anybody. He might be seen going to town on a tractor or whatever to pick up a few groceries, but that is all. Those people need to be looked after. We are decimating rural Ireland. All the young people are going to the cities or going abroad. There is nobody to support our older people. We need our community enterprises to step up. They need to be funded.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Thank you, ladies, for those three stories. We appreciate it.

Senator McCormack, have you a final comment?

Comment on this

Yes, I do. I just want to put on the record the incredible work of Michelle Tuohy and Karen Bambrick with Laois Volunteer Centre as well as Connect Laois for the incredible work they did in ensuring we got Meals on Wheels and all the incredible volunteers we have. They are incredible.

I am familiar with the story of a certain man. As the witnesses have mentioned, many people do not want contact because the elderly community can be so afraid of going into a nursing home or, as this man calls it when telling me about this, a concentration camp. The witnesses give people the ability to live out their lives in their own home, and what more of a service can anyone do? It is the most incredible gift you can give someone to let them live out their life in their home. That is all I wanted to say.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Have you any final comments, Ms Noone or Mr. Smyth?

Comment on this
Ms Tracey Noone

On behalf of the network, we are very grateful to have had the opportunity to meet the committee so members could learn more from the providers on the ground, because at times that can be what is missing. We have a wonderful steering group, which these three ladies are part of. They represent the providers and know what is happening on the ground. They are able to give us the information to present to the HSE, the Government and the Minister. As I have said already, it is about trying to get Government to understand the value and the costs. It is the older vulnerable person who is most important in all this but for that cohort of people to be looked after the likes of these providers need to be sufficiently funded and in a position where they are able to sustain that service moving forward. Having the opportunity to speak to the committee has been absolutely wonderful and we look forward to hearing what members get back from the powers that be. If there is anything else the committee requires, please contact me and I can supply anything that is being looked for. Our conference is on 18 November in the Aisling Hotel and if members are free, they should pop down. They will get a really good feel for what is happening on the ground. Thank you very much, everybody.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

No problem. Go ahead, Mr. Smyth.

Comment on this
Mr. Briain Smyth

I echo Ms Noone's thoughts. Irish Rural Link support the National Meals on Wheels Network and we have done for over ten years now. We are delighted to do it. It is one of our favourite sides of the organisation and we are continually blown away by it. Obviously, we need more money for the network and more support but we also need it to be integrated with the county councils, the water services and everything else. Not only do we have issues with funding for the service, we have other issues as well and I am going to bring up one that is on my agenda as an example, which is Ballyheigue down in Kerry, where there is a do not consume notice on the water. That has been going on since 7 October. The Meals on Wheels service in Ballyheigue supports I think 120 clients, supplying approximately 70 meals a day. The service is getting the water but the clients are not. The water is not even appearing in the village. It is important we are able to integrate with services like Kerry County Council, in this case, and Irish Water. We trying to bring the service more into the blue lights side of things, so we can have those interventions. Those could be with the people down at the end of the boreens but also so we could have the ability to ensure there is dignity in the form of providing water to people. For instance, the current notice in Ballyheigue is a do not consume one which means the water cannot be used for laundry, washing or hygiene as well as not being suitable for drinking. With the cohort we support on the ground, we want that to be available for everybody. The importance of the network, not only for the provision of meals but also the provision of all the other services that are not being picked up, has to be stated.

Comment on this
John Paul O'Shea An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Thanks very much, Mr. Smyth. Thanks in particular to Ms Waldron, Ms Jackson and Ms Lenihan for representing your Meals on Wheels groups and also representing the network here. It is important we hear from people on the ground and one clear of aspect of our committee is that we like to bring in the people who are operating the services to get a view of things on the ground. Many thanks to Mr. Smyth and Ms Noone for accommodating our request today as well as for providing the briefing materials in advance, which is very important for our committee. As I said earlier, Senator McCormack has requested a transcript of this meeting be sent to the Minister along with a cover letter on the discussion that happened and the need for clarity about the funding for 2027.

Thanks again to everybody for attending today. It is really appreciated.

Comment on this