Engagement with Commission for Victims and Survivors
Commissioner Joe McVey and Tina McCann warned that victims’ confidence is exceptionally low and that legacy legislation must ensure independent, fair and transparent processes, with meaningful support throughout. They raised concerns about political involvement in investigations and the lack of detail on information recovery, while urging governments to centre victims’ needs and acknowledge past harm. Support services in the South remain fragmented, the purpose of the €25 million commitment is unclear, and Northern Ireland’s support infrastructure faces funding uncertainty. Members stressed the committee’s role in scrutinising legislation and promoting an all-island approach to support, reconciliation and education.
On behalf of the committee, I welcome Mr. Joe McVey, the Commissioner for Victims and Survivors, and Ms Tina McCann, director of policy and development. We look forward to their opening remarks and questions. The format of the meeting will be that I will invite Mr. McVey to make his opening statement, after which each member will have five to seven minutes for questions and answers.
Before I begin, I remind members of the constitutional requirement that in order to participate in public meetings, they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex. Members of the committee attending remotely must do so from within the precincts of Leinster House. This is due to the constitutional requirement that in order to participate in public meetings, members must be physically present within the confines of the place where Parliament has chosen to sit. In this regard, I ask any members partaking via Microsoft Teams that, prior to making their contributions to the meeting, they confirm that they are on the grounds of the Leinster House complex.
Members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, I will direct them to discontinue their remarks and it is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
As the witnesses will probably be aware, the committee will publish their opening statements on our website. MPs participating in this committee session from a jurisdiction outside the State are advised that they should also be mindful of their domestic law and how it may apply to their participation in these proceedings.
I now call Mr. McVey, Commissioner for Victims and Survivors, to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach for the opportunity to meet him earlier in the year and for this opportunity to join the committee this morning. As the Cathaoirleach has said, my name is Joe McVey and I am the Commissioner for Victims and Survivors. With me is Ms Tina McCann, who is our director of policy development, research and engagement. As the Cathaoirleach has identified, we have already submitted to the committee a short paper with some opening comments. Mindful of the committee's time, rather than regurgitating those comments, I will offer a few opening observations to frame this morning's conversation.
As members of the committee are aware, very shortly, within the next two years, it will be 30 years since the signing of the Good Friday Agreement. For everyone, and certainly for my generation, it was a watershed moment in the history of this country. This places a duty and a responsibility on the members, as the people responsible for the committee that has oversight of the implementation of the Good Friday Agreement, to make sure that time is not lost in delivering for victims and survivors over the next two years.
The next two years will also be a great time and a great opportunity for victims and survivors if we can get things right. By that, I mean that we have succeeded in establishing the legacy framework. We have the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill going through the UK Parliament and there will also be legislation here in the Oireachtas shortly. Hopefully, we will be able to create a range of mechanisms that can be transformative for victims and survivors if things are done correctly. The next two years, therefore, will be a time of great opportunity.
It is important to balance that optimism with the reality that victims and survivors have been let down, betrayed, ignored and forgotten by successive Governments. It is imperative that the committee ensures this does not happen again. We have both opportunities and threats for victims and survivors. I know all the members in their own constituency work will engage with victims and survivors regularly. It is important for all of us who do so to recognise that they are not a homogeneous group. Victims and survivors will all want different things based on their lived experiences. A golden thread does run through those conversations. Victims and survivors want to ensure that whatever policy, legislation or mechanisms are brought forward are legal, independent, transparent and fair. That is fundamental to the work we do.
In engaging with victims and survivors, I am struck all the time by their humanity, their compassion and their willingness to look to the future. What motivates them more than anything is to ensure there is no recurrence and that we do not go backwards. As we have seen recently in Northern Ireland, that can happen very easily. The second thing that motivates them is that they want to build a better place for themselves and their children and grandchildren.
In short, this committee has an opportunity over the next two years to see the 30th anniversary as both a beacon and a watershed for victims and survivors. It is a heavy responsibility but, with the committee’s support, it is an opportunity to get things right before victims and survivors run out of time, patience and trust. I thank the committee. I am very happy to take questions and comments.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. McVey very much for his opening remarks and for the statement provided in advance of this morning’s meeting. Both witnesses are very welcome to the committee. I call Senator Conor Murphy.
Comment on this
Cuirim fáilte roimh na finnéithe. The key issue currently is the legislation going through Westminster in relation to this issue. Based on an agreement made previously between the Irish and British Governments, certain tests were to be met in relation to that legislation. The Irish Government has retained the capacity to bring an interstate case on the grounds that it is not satisfied in that regard. Serious concerns have been raised about the early issues encountered in this regard and some of the amendments brought forward by the British Government. That is against the backdrop of the family of Sean Brown still having to go to the Supreme Court in Britain to get the British Government to do what a court in Belfast has ordered it to do, which is to hold a public inquiry into the case of Sean Brown. That is the context in which we have been operating.
The focus of the British Government appears to be entirely in relation to veterans. We had a Northern Ireland Office Minister at the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly the other week. In her scripted remarks, she said veterans needed to be treated with dignity, fairness and equality. In her subsequent off-script remarks, she said that applied to all victims. However, we can clearly see the measures undertaken by the British Government and its statements regarding what it has done. In particular, this concerns the imposition of the Attorney General, who is a political appointee of the British Government, into this process. The British Secretary of State said that one of the key things lots of veterans’ organisations in the North and elsewhere had asked for was that the Attorney General should be the final deciding point. He then referred to Hilary Benn, the previous Secretary of State, and said that the safeguards being supplied had been specifically designed for veterans following close consultation with veterans, and that some will necessarily apply to others, including former police officers, while others will apply only to veterans. Mr. McVey, in the statement provided to us, posed the question of whether the provisions are "suitably independent and free from political interference".
Does Mr. McVey consider that some of these developments match up to that?
The question that this committee must consider is the standards that were set in the agreement between both Governments about transparency, fairness, adherence to human rights provisions and the compliance of the investigations that would come from this with human rights provisions. We can make a judgment on that, in the round, when we see the final outcome of this legislation. Clearly and unsurprisingly, there is significant disquiet among victims' organisations about the direction of travel in this regard. The British Government has not hidden behind a rock in setting out what its priorities are in relation to this. What is Mr. McVey's assessment of where that has been to date? What might that do in terms of the agreement between both Governments and where that inter-state case would rest? In Mr. McVey's opinion, in terms of his representation and advocacy on behalf of victims, what provisions are required for victims? I agree with him that victims have been let down over many decades. It is one of the big flaws of the Good Friday Agreement that there was not enough focus put on that at the start. We did have an agreement, of which I was part of, in 2014. We would be a long way down the road in dealing with these issues at this stage if that agreement had been followed through on rather than unilaterally walked away from by the British Government. Does that provision, specifically in relation to the Attorney General, allow provisions to be suitably independent and free from political interference, as advocated for by Mr. McVey?
Comment on this
Maybe I will invite Ms McCann to comment as well. It would be fair to say that when the legacy framework was launched, its first soft launch was in our office in Belfast. Simon Harris and Hilary Benn came along. Tony Benn was a different character. On the day, as a commission, we were there with members of the forum that represents victims and survivors. Our response on the day was to welcome the framework. Going back to the Senator's reference to the Stormont House Agreement, other than the disastrous 2023 legislation, all that good work seems to have been shelved and forgotten about. We thought that was a really positive development. We were delighted to see that. Our response throughout has been to say that we welcome the framework and the troubles Bill, but with a very strong caveat that we want to see what the detail is and what the amendments are. If the troubles Bill does not go ahead and the legislation does not progress here, where are we, 30 years on? We are very mindful of that as a big concern.
For us, the whole debate in Westminster has been terrible. I think it has been toxic and completely misjudged in terms of the false argument of pitting veterans versus victims and survivors. We do not make that distinction. In our view, veterans can also be victims and survivors, and are. We think the very well-funded lobby in Westminster that focuses on certain veterans ignores the lived experience of veterans in Northern Ireland, by which I mean people who have served in the RUC, the PSNI, the UDR, etc. Sometimes that whole argument gets completely overplayed both at Westminster and in the British media. That is something we were very disappointed about. As the Bill has progressed, those concerns remain. I think the 150-odd amendments that were proposed two weeks ago caught people by surprise, first because there are so many of them and second because the focus seems to be on veterans. For us, there needs to be a recalibration to ensure the debate focuses much more on clauses that are truly victim-centred and give protections and support to all victims and survivors rather than, unfortunately, setting one group up against the other. We are, at this point, very concerned with some of the amendments and proposals.
I will pick up on what was said about the Attorney General. Senator Murphy is quite right when he says that this has been highlighted by many groups. Relatives for Justice, RFJ; the Committee on the Administration of Justice, CAJ; and Amnesty have raised issues around that because it appears to be contrary both to the spirit and the law in terms of the Good Friday Agreement. My reading of that - this has been raised in conversations we have had with the Secretary of State - was very much to say that this might gain support from the veterans' lobby. In doing so, the danger is that you again appear to be creating a hierarchy. That is not something that we would approve of at all.
Our current position is that we want to see a much strong focus on victims and survivors and we will be seeking support to ensure the amendments reflect that.
Comment on this
The conversations we had with officials at the time of the joint framework were about the tests of whether it was ECHR-compliant and whether it would carry the confidence of victims and survivors. On ECHR-compliance the jury is very much out. The British Government will say this is the result of a joint committee on human rights report, whereas other NGOs, as Mr. McVey has referenced, and other victims and survivors have said that is to be tested and it will probably be the courts that will ultimately adjudicate on it. As for the confidence of victims and survivors, anything that has a hint of political interference in it will cause a chill factor if it looks like there is political interference at any point. We have heard arguments from some officials who say the members of the PPS are public appointees but that is not the same thing as being appointed by a Prime Minister or being a ministerial appointment. Mr. McVey is a ministerial appointment but there is potential for a chill factor among the families who have no confidence. The Senator mentioned the Brown family. There have been documents full of black. It is not going to encourage confidence and we could face again waiting years to build something and then people simply not using it because they do not have confidence in it.
Comment on this
In dealing with victims and survivors, as we regularly do, their currency is very much confidence and trust and at the moment those are at an all-time low. To pick up Ms McCann's point, it is also about perception. At the moment the perception and the optics do not look good. If I were sitting here and advising the Secretary of State and the British Government, I would say that is where they need to pay attention. Senator Murphy referenced the Sean Brown case. I think we all understand the niceties of who makes decisions about a public inquiry but how that plays out and how it is perceived, in terms of how a woman in her eighties is treated, is grossly unfair.
Comment on this
Cuirim fáilte roimh na finnéithe. I thank them so much for coming here. As they have quite rightly pointed out, we reach a pivotal deadline or milestone next year, for want of a better word. It is incumbent on us to ensure our work here is meaningful. The witnesses have spoken in the past about the lack of support for victims and survivors in this jurisdiction so I will focus on that as a Government representative. What does Mr. McVey see as the most urgent gaps we need to address? How would he want that €25 million commitment to be used to make a tangible difference to the lives of victims and survivors here?
Comment on this
I thank the Senator very much. She will have seen reference in our submission to some recent research we have done here which builds on the research we did in 2023. When we looked at the €25 million, a concern raised on the day and subsequently was how you arrive at that figure. What needs assessment and what research has been done to show that would be an adequate figure to meet the needs of victims and survivors in the South? Frankly, up to this point we have not received an answer to why that was the case. On priorities, the piece of work we did was in some respects quite a modest one with a sample size of 2,000 people. In our view, perhaps that is there as a starting point for the Government to look at and take that information and the themes that are in it and do more investigation, identify where people are and what their needs are, and learn from the experience in Northern Ireland. On those issues of health and well-being, psychological support and wraparound support, some of that is currently being provided to victims and survivors in the South by groups based in the North. Also, and again without going into the minutiae of the research and statistics, some really important themes came out of that.
This is where society is perhaps ahead of Government. What people were looking at was the importance of the Government here addressing legacy issues. There are also the issues of acknowledgement by State and non-State actors during the Troubles and the conflict, and the importance of looking at education about the Troubles. Everybody, North and South, has a commitment and interest in looking at a payment for the bereaved. Particularly for a woman, that is an important issue. For us, there are practical issues of support and wider societal and Government responsibilities. Our interest and plea to the members of this committee is that the research be taken more seriously and built upon by the Departments here.
Comment on this
As Mr. McVey mentioned, the Tánaiste and the Secretary of State, Hilary Benn, came to the commission before going to Hillsborough to make their announcement. The members pushed the Tánaiste about what the €25 million was for. Is it for the processes that will emerge from the joint framework for getting information from An Garda Síochána’s legacy unit or the independent commission on information retrieval? Is it for a more holistic approach to supporting the health and well-being needs of victims and survivors in this jurisdiction? There was not any clarity. It was more indicative of a commitment that the Government would support victims and survivors. However, we need to see a more meaningful and tangible process come forward on that because, as it stands now, there are significant unmet needs among victims in this jurisdiction.
Comment on this
We could seek clarity on that once more. I am always wary of asking people how much money is needed. It is like asking how long a piece of string is. Mr. McVey described €25 million as quite modest. What are we talking about here?
Comment on this
I would always avoid naming figures. If we look at the experience in the North, its Executive is probably spending between £8.5 million and £9 million per year. We also have significant PEACE funds supporting that. For us, it was about taking a serious look at what the needs may be. I referenced some well-established groups in Northern Ireland, and they and we stand ready to try to support and ensure learning and experience from our regional trauma network, for example. There are good models of practice North and South that we would be happy to share and build upon.
I am reluctant to pluck out a figure and say it is €25 million. It is €25 million over three years. Once you break it down, it is not really significant. It is a starting point, but the important thing is to do the research and see where the needs are.
Comment on this
We have had victims and survivors in here. We have heard their stories and know the hurt is still very much there. We can see that the situation is always precarious north of the Border and quite fragile at times. I know that families have waited decades for answers. Many of the victims and survivors are ageing now and they may never see that, which is something we would like to see happening. What practical steps should both Governments take over the next year or so so that families might see meaningful progress? How can this committee help to hold the Governments accountable and make this happen?
Comment on this
I refer back to Senator Murphy's point about the legislation and mechanisms that were established. They need to give victims and survivors confidence that mechanisms like the Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery, ICRIR, or the proposed information recovery commission are done properly. If you have mechanisms and commissions, there is sometimes a sense that families will simply come forward. Our experience in the North is that families need support - legal, psychological and wraparound support - to allow them to engage meaningfully. These engagements can last for years, and sometimes for decades. It is really important that we do not just set these things up. We saw how the ICRIR was set up in a way that did not seem to be victim centred, and that has a cost on the families.
I would also say that the infrastructure for support for victims and survivors, while it may sound as if it is relatively well-funded, has fragile funding. This is about looking after the sustainability of the PEACE funds. The PEACEPLUS funds will run out in 2028. If we are planning, we must be clear that we are doing long-term planning so that people do not reach a cliff edge in two years' time and there is a mad scramble to see how we are going to make up the shortfall.
Comment on this
In addition, the new mechanism of the ICIR, the information retrieval body, will be established. We know what good support looks like. We know the victims and survivors who have engaged, for example, with Operation Kenova. There is a partnership between groups in the victim sector and those bodies that provide holistic wraparound support. They are looking at their advocacy support and helping them to navigate difficult processes. They also provide the health and well-being support that those individuals need. There are good models there to look at and say that this is what we need to consider. We do not see that on the face of the Troubles Bill or in the general scheme of the legacy Bill. We are not seeing the vision that means it is a victim-centred process that will be supporting people from end to end. We would like more engagement. We would like to see on the face of the Bill a more meaningful commitment to those people's journey.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. McVey and Ms McCann for their contributions thus far. I will pick up on some of the points mentioned by Mr. McVey in his opening statement. In his view, confidence among victims and survivors is at its lowest point since the Good Friday Agreement. The big challenge for us, and where we need to be more ambitious, is in respect of how to provide leadership towards establishing a better society in which communities can have trust in the institutions of the state, trust in each other and respect for each other. It is about moving on from a society in which the absence of violence is the mark by which success is measured.
Senator Murphy made reference to the recent plenary meeting of the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly that many of us attended. We were addressed by the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State in the Northern Ireland Office. I was encouraged by some comments that she made about progressing and dealing with legacy issues where the state might have been at fault and taking responsibility for the wrongs of the past.
Mr. McVey also made reference to the dangers of setting one group up against another. I would like to get a sense of the progress being made in moving on from that because, going back to the same meeting in Sheffield, a lot of the contributions and the questions came from people with a particular political perspective. They asked questions about the wrongs of the other side. If we are looking for the British and Irish states to take accountability and to help the process of reconciliation by acknowledging the wrongs of the past, the groups that were directly involved need to be braver and stronger in calling for justice for all victims and survivors. It is only when we get to that stage that the partisan and sectarian politics of the past can be parked and we can move on progressively to try to build a better future for future generations, as Mr. McVey referenced in his remarks.
That is a long-winded way of asking to what extent are the witnesses seeing groups that might historically have been connected with one side or the other advocating on behalf of victims of their communities or groups that carried out acts of violence in their names.
Has there been an improvement in that regard, or is it very much a partisan approach when it comes to people engaging directly with the commission?
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. He raised some interesting points. When we meet victims and survivors, a lot of the time they feel a heavy level of responsibility and burden to, in a sense, be responsible for reconciliation. People say to victims and survivors that they need to move on or forget what has happened in the past as if it is their responsibility to make this a better place. That is deeply unfair.
I have been in this post for just over one year. I will defer to Ms McCann, who has much more experience. We work with a whole spectrum of victims and survivors, as well as a whole spectrum of victim and survivor groups. I find them, as I said in my opening comments, to have great levels of compassion and humanity. When I meet them, both individually and collectively, they are looking to the future. They want to make this place better. I do not find them stuck in the past or engaging in tit-for-tat conversations. They genuinely want to build. Therefore, I argue that there is, both in the legislation and how we frame these things, a much stronger case for victims and survivors, as well as civic society, to be leading and at the heart of the debate. Frankly, it is hard for politicians to try to do that because, by the very nature of being politicians, they have political parties and constituencies. The common ground and purpose is very much there among victims and survivors to move forward.
From meeting victims and survivors on a regular basis, I am always surprised at how gracious they are and how they look to the future. They are not seeking to score points. That is where the whole debate around veterans and setting one group up against the other was so unnecessary and, frankly, toxic. It almost brought us back to a situation where people were literally being set up against each other. As a commission, that is not something we would have ever approved or supported. It is important we try to move the dial away from that.
With regard to the broader reconciliation piece, victims and survivors want to make sure their views are heard. They want to make sure people respect their views and, as I said earlier, that the mechanisms set up are victim-centred and have the things we almost take for granted in place, such as independence, fairness and transparency. They should be a given but so far, that has not been the case.
Comment on this
I accept Mr. McVey’s point completely because he is, ultimately, dealing with some of the most vulnerable people who have suffered, either directly or through a family member, appalling atrocities. In order for us to give them confidence into the future, we have to ensure their voices are heard and acted upon. It cannot be platitudes.
In the brief time I have remaining, is the commission seeing any progress? Is there any hope that those directly involved, while seeking justice, are also being a bit more generous in accepting responsibility?
Comment on this
I go back to what we said at the beginning in terms of this research. Society is saying there is an onus on the governments, both North and South, and on all players to come forward with statements of acknowledgement about the harm they have done. As members will know from their constituencies and constituency work, one of the key things for victims and survivors is acknowledgement. Some people want other things, such as information, truth and justice. Fundamentally, however, it is about an acknowledgement and recognition of the harm that was done.
Comment on this
We have a victims and survivors forum that is made up of a broad representation of victim experience. When they have engaged with officials and ministers in the Irish and British Governments, they have pressed them very much around the information recovery body and the need to ensure the process is set up around interlocutors who will access information. They see it as the governments’ responsibility to put in place confidence-building measures so that people can come forward and share information.
They have models like the Independent Commission for the Location of Victims' Remains. Getting the information from many victims is so important, but as Mr. McVey has said, they are not a homogeneous group and some want different things. However, for those who want information, they see it as incumbent on the governments and have pressed the governments to make sure they set up a process that allows a broad range of people to come forward and share whatever information they have. The sense that victims have given to us is that they do not think the governments are treating the Independent Commission on Information Retrieval, ICIR, with the gravity it should be accorded. The focus has always been on the legacy commission, and it really needs to be more on the ICIR, as well.
Comment on this
Members will know that the legacy commission document refers to the information retrieval commission as a three-year pilot. Describing something as a three-year pilot to victims and survivors does not engender confidence. It almost appears to be an afterthought. For victims and survivors, the information piece is really important.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas le gach duine as teacht anseo inniu. We have to remember exactly what is involved here. In many cases, we have the British state, through adjacent organisations, involved in the murder of citizens of that state. We also have 20, 30, 40, and 50 years of those families seeking justice and truth in relation to those murders. At the time, it was stated by the British state that there was no connection between that state and the murders of these individuals. Then we have a state which is strategically, in my view, looking to distance itself from the actions taken on those occasions.
I think the Sean Brown case is a shocking example of the modus operandi of the British state in relation to this, in that there is a British Secretary of State still using all his legal powers to prevent a proper investigation into the murder of Sean Brown. I believe the initial actions were the actions of a rogue state. The initial legacy Bill was a Bill of a rogue state. What we are now seeing in the transition of this particular Bill is movement in the same direction. We should be abiding by the rule of law, by the rule of justice and by the rule of truth, and it is clear that these steps by the British state are trying to avoid those aspects.
In terms of a British attorney general having a role to play on consent in this, as has been stated, this is a political appointee who has an opportunity to have political effect in relation to this. Even the British Secretary of State having any role on whether or not certain information is of national security puts a politician at the heart of whether or not information can be brought to bear. If there is anybody who should be placed in those two roles, it is a judge or somebody from that space who is removed from the political system. We have a responsibility in this committee to keep a watching eye on the developments of this moving feast. If they do incorporate those elements within the Bill, this committee should oppose the Bill and should communicate with the Taoiseach on its opposition to it.
One of the sad things, and correct me if I am wrong, is that the initial legacy Bill is still actually in place. So, even the length of time it takes to replace this is leaving an unjust situation in place. During all of this time, and I am thinking of Sean Brown's family, loved ones are getting older, less able to fight and, in some cases, are passing away. Even the length of time passing is, in itself, a horrendous injustice and a strategic tool to hide the wrongdoing that has happened here. To hear the witnesses' views on those aspects is important, especially on the issue, which I do not believe has been discussed here, of the British Secretary of State having the right to determine what is within the national interest and being brought into play within an investigation.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy very much. Again, they are very relevant points. When we look at the legislation going through the House of Lords very shortly and then we look at the heads of the Bill coming forward in the Oireachtas, there are issues in both jurisdictions – the importance of the rule of law and how consistent that is, who gets to make decisions, and things like national security vetos, which are at play in both jurisdictions, and will be at play in both jurisdictions. For us, when we look at the amendments going forward, there is a sense of the role of the Secretary of State and perhaps a degree of overreach in terms of appointments, whether it is judicial appointments or the Attorney General. As the Deputy knows, we would very much focus on clause 9 of the current Bill, looking at the role of the Victims and Survivors Advisory Group. Therefore, there are elements which we would like to see changed and amended.
The Deputy highlighted the Sean Brown case, which I mentioned earlier. For families, it is cruel. They are waiting 30 to 50 years. We also saw families some weeks ago who received an apology from the Secretary of State and the British Government in Springhill in west Belfast. I go back to my point about acknowledgment and how powerful that was. There are positive things that could be done by politicians and governments to make amends and to recognise the harm that was done. Equally – I go back to my earlier point – when we move forward with the legislation and mechanisms, it is really important that this committee keeps a very watchful eye both on the legislation going through the UK Government and its own legislation as it comes forward. Again, we are mindful that the heads of the Bill as they stand at the moment have not been without criticism from human rights groups. That is important. It is incumbent on this committee to keep a very vigilant eye on both Houses.
Comment on this
It should be an objective of this committee as we meet with our counterparts in Westminster to make sure that we impact those points in that discussion. Mr. McVey mentioned the support for victims, survivors and families. Will the witnesses tell us more what that should look like, in their view?
Comment on this
What we know is that as victims and families go through these processes, they require advocacy support. That is the technical support to navigate an information recovery process or an investigation process, and for someone to advocate on their behalf. For example, at the minute we have the Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery, ICRIR. We previously had the Historical Enquiries Team, HET, and Operation Kenova. We have always had groups that have been there to advocate for families. We know that it is very valuable. It is about information processing - what questions they should ask, what information they should have and what they are entitled to know.
Going through these processes can also have an impact on the health and well-being of individuals and their families collectively. The kind of support that we see when it is most effective is that families are supported to go through it. Sometimes it can just be some social support – meeting like-minded people who have had similar experiences who can help them navigate the process of how it makes them feel but also health and well-being support in terms of talk therapies or complementary therapies that support their well-being. It is a holistic package. When it works best, the individual is supported through the journey.
Comment on this
I want to emphasise the sense of wraparound support. We have a whole range of groups that are operating very successfully at the moment. I know that in one of its recent meetings the committee had evidence from Relatives for Justice and the Ashton centre's Bridge of Hope. There are lots of examples such as the South East Fermanagh Foundation, SEFF, The Ely Centre and other groups which provide that support. Again, I would say that the infrastructure in Northern Ireland should not be taken for granted. It is quite fragile. When we look at PEACEPLUS funding at the moment, it remains to be seen whether we can be confident that infrastructure will be there in two years' time.
That infrastructure is learning from those experiences that may be of interest to members here.
Comment on this
I propose that we write to the Taoiseach and ask how the Government can help bridge any gap in funding for PEACEPLUS.
Comment on this
Thank you for that. In terms of the PEACEPLUS part of your remarks, that came up at the North/South Inter-Parliamentary Assembly, NSIPA. There was correspondence from that body supporting PEACEPLUS as it goes forward. Thank you, Deputy Tóibín.
Comment on this
I would suggest that it is maybe more than bridging PEACEPLUS. If the funding is phasing out, it is a complete revamp of a new programme and maybe conversations with the EU and the British Government about that substantive funding. It is not that it is just going for a short period of time; it will be gone altogether.
The witnesses spoke about the various organisations offering services in the North for mental health and the infrastructure around trauma response. What is it like in this jurisdiction? We have people who became victim survivors in this jurisdiction or people from the North now living down here and all of this stuff. What does the all-island approach to that look like? Are we doing enough in the South to address that? I get the impression that maybe we are leaning on services quite heavily in the North and not offering that for people down here.
My next question is on the impact of failing to really deal with reconciliation on a whole-island basis, so it is linked to the first part as well. What are the impacts if reconciliation is not dealt with in a timely manner? What are the long-term impacts on intergenerational trauma the witnesses see through their work? We see that the victim survivors are getting older. Information retrieval and its importance has been mentioned.
This is my third and final question and then the witnesses can reply. It was mentioned about information retrieval not being victim-centred. Please speak a little bit more about that and the different challenges around information retrieval when it comes to state and non-state actors. Has information retrieval from non-state actors been more challenging? What conditions need to be put in place for that to be successful? I am thinking of things like the high-profile stuff that members will be aware of, such as the Boston tapes. That may have made a lot of people anxious about coming forward with information on legacy issues. It would be interesting to hear the witnesses' perspectives on that as well.
Comment on this
These are very challenging questions. I will take the first one, if I may, on the all-island approach to services. I think it would be fair to say that there is not one. There is an infrastructure network in Northern Ireland and I have alluded to some of the groups there that are working very effectively. The services that are provided in the South of Ireland are fragmented. Some of them are provided by organisations in the North. Others are provided through voluntary organisations here, some of which are very well known. For us, it is a case of unmet need. I do not think we are very clear as to the breadth and depth of victims and survivors in the South of Ireland because significant research has not been done to find out what the quantum is. Until we are very clear about that, it is very hard to say what the infrastructure should be. Ms McCann set out earlier the types and range of supports that are required. The point about reconciliation North and South goes back to the earlier conversation. The great thing about having a joint framework is that it recognises that both jurisdictions have responsibility for reconciliation. Therefore, anything that would be proposed has to be on an North-South basis. Otherwise we end up with reconciliation saying we have got that sorted out there, but there are still severe problems and issues in the North, which we have seen recently. It has to be seen on an all-island basis. As I said earlier, we should not be putting reconciliation on the shoulders of victims and survivors. It is a societal issue, and therefore we must deal with it at a societal level. It will not simply be done overnight. Even if we get all these mechanisms in place and the proper legislation, that is not to say things would be better.
I will pass over to Ms McCann to pick up on the other questions.
Comment on this
On information retrieval, we know there has not been significant detail on what that process will look like. Victims and survivors are exceptionally keen that it is got right. Information is prime, rather than the perpetrator or the incident. People want to access information about what happened. Questions we hear from victims and survivors include, for example, “Why was my daddy targeted?”. They are not looking for a judicial process or a criminal justice investigation. They are looking for a specific answer to that question. They have seen models work before, such as the Independent Commission for the Location of Victims’ Remains, where the information is used to find and then is destroyed. It is of no further value beyond that purpose.
We have seen that this works best when there is a process involving interlocutors and information is firewalled. When we engage with officials and ministers alongside victims, this is what the victims describe how it should look. They were subsequently disappointed when the legislation came forward without that detail. It is primary legislation, but ultimately you want to see the infrastructure put in place, including the draft clauses that will enable information to be collected for that purpose and then disposed of.
On reconciliation and the joint framework, Part 4 of the Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act 2023 still stands. That concerns oral history and a memorialisation strategy. There has been real concern that the Troubles did not stop at a jurisdiction or respect any border. The idea that oral history projects and memorialisation would develop as a strategy confined to one jurisdiction is bizarre to victims and survivors. We need to understand the interdependencies across governments, which should all be working together towards that common purpose. That includes oral history projects and education and how, with regard to the intergenerational impact, we raise awareness of the impact of violence, what it has done to families and how it affects us, our society and our behaviour. Legislatively, victims expect a greater degree of commitment and acknowledgement across the jurisdictions of what meaningful working together should be. It should not just be about how information flows from one place to another, which is what it currently looks like, and a focus on criminal investigations. It is about acknowledging what happened and the impact it had.
Comment on this
On education, we were interested to see, in the research we did, the support for more education on the Troubles in the curriculum in the south of Ireland. Not by coincidence, there is a review of the education curriculum in the North at the moment which suggests, and we recommended this very strongly, that the Troubles should be introduced. We have done work recently on an oral history toolkit, which is helpful. On information retrieval, our experience over the past two and a half years with the ICRIR and the Legacy Commission shows the importance of ensuring that whatever mechanisms are put in place are, to put it bluntly, family-friendly. We must not create mechanisms and bureaucracies that require people to jump through excessive hoops and talk to and meet numerous members of staff to get the answers they want. We need to put ourselves in their situation and ask, if I were seeking information, how would I like to do that? How would I make it as simple and transparent as possible without creating another bureaucracy?
Comment on this
Not all members might know that the Troubles is not on the curriculum in the North, and there is more advanced education on the Troubles here. That is an interesting point to flag. Peace and memorialisation are so important. I would love the committee to explore what memorialisation means on an all-island basis across diverse communities.
It is a really important way to look back on the past and remember it in a way that can be as inclusive as possible. Moving forward, it helps to have that acknowledgement.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being with us this morning. I will confine most of my questions to the legacy legislation that is going through at the moment. As the witnesses rightly say, this committee needs to have a role in that and keep a watchful eye on it. The original promise by the Labour Party Government in the UK in 2024 was to repeal and replace by returning to the principles of the Stormont House Agreement. The legacy Bill refers to the principle that human rights should be respected. However, in the Stormont House Agreement it was the principle that human rights and obligations should be complied with. How would Mr. McVey and Ms McCann interpret the difference between being respected and being complied with, in terms of international law, and how important do they think it is?
Comment on this
For us, going back to the Stormont House Agreement, two things strike me. I will pass over to Ms McCann to pick up on that as well. The Stormont House Agreement was incredibly impressive, not only in terms of the content, which the Deputy has alluded to, but also the implementation and the work that went in to taking it forward. One of the biggest disappointments is that the work just foundered and here we are all these years on, ten or 12 years later, having made very little progress at all, if any. In fact, we have gone backwards. For us, looking at the current legislation, there is a concern that things are going backwards in that as well. That is something we should be mindful of - ourselves, this committee and the legislators in Britain - to make sure we do not do that.
Comment on this
As we indicated in our submission, when we have engaged with victims and survivors and those who work with them in the sector, we are very much hearing about the issue of independence. If we are saying that victims and survivors want to have confidence, one of the indicators of confidence is independence, which is a prerequisite for human rights compliance as well. To have an Article 2 investigation, there needs to be independence built into it. That is where the rubber hits the road when it comes to some of these provisions - are they suitably independent? Do they give confidence to victims and survivors? On the difference between respect and compliance, it is probably judicable as well and will come before the courts. On what it actually feels like for victims and survivors, if they do not think there is a suitable degree of independence, for example in the person who is going to be looking at their case, they will be continually failed because they will not present to these bodies.
Comment on this
Respect and compliance mean two completely different things. It is a play with words, so as not to do what it is pretending to be doing.
On Article 2 compliance, all families and survivors have the right to Article 2-compliant investigations. Section 59(3)(a) of the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill, which is being debated at Westminster, states that the relevant judicial panel member "must take into account any investigation (of any kind, including an inquest) of the death that has previously been carried out by any other person". Does that mean investigations carried out heretofore that were not Article 2-compliant are excluded? There is a whole volume of inadequate investigations that have been done.
Does that preclude them from reopening that inquest? There is a reference to new evidence emerging, but who decides what is new evidence? In my view, that just makes a farce of Article 2 compliance in respect of where injustices have been the subject of inadequate investigations heretofore. How is that going to play out?
Comment on this
Going back to Ms McCann's earlier point, we could perhaps take those things at face value if we were in a climate of trust and confidence, and say that, with good intentions, people would get what they need. At present, however, that is not only open to interpretation but feeds into the question of what the intention behind it is. I am referring to the way that language is being used rather than making it watertight. Again, what is new evidence? What does that mean? The lack of detail can cause people concern. In the climate we are in now, people are saying that does not give them confidence. That is the danger, if I may say so.
Comment on this
This very question was asked of the Secretary of State the last time he met the Victims and Survivors Forum. Its members asked him to define what new evidence would be and how people could go about getting compelling new evidence in the absence of an investigation. I think the answer is that there is no clarity in this regard, and that is part of the confidence problem. There is no clear determination or definition of what it means. What will fall within the scope of what is considered an effective investigation? What will be determined? There was no clarity on those questions, and that is part of the problem.
Comment on this
To give a brief response, and to go back to where we started, on the one hand, the legacy framework, the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill and the legislation in the UK, and the legislation to follow here, provide, as I said at the beginning, great opportunities. The danger is the extent to which we and the members of this committee can support the process. If we do not get behind and support what is happening in the UK, and the Bill does not go forward, what will we be left with? That is the tension we are all living with now. We want to get this right, but so many things are either open to interpretation or give victims and survivors cause for concern. We are trying to balance that against the question of whether we can improve the legislation before it becomes law. That is the real tension for us now and for victims and survivors. There is almost a sense that people are asking whether they should hold their noses and hope they can live with some of those things, rather than, in different circumstances, saying they would want all those things tied down. There is a real tension in this regard. People want the Bill to go forward and pass because, in its absence, what comes next? How many more years will they have to wait? That does not take away from poor legislation.
Comment on this
I understand what Mr. McVey is saying, but we cannot give absolute power to the Attorney General. The committee cannot stand over that. I keep asking myself whether the Ballymurphy inquiry could have happened under this framework, and the answer is that it could not have happened. It would not have happened. The success of the Ballymurphy inquiry has given rise to all of this and to ensuring that such an inquiry never happens again and the truth is kept covered. That should be a concern for every legislator across these two islands and beyond. There are many other questions, but I want to give my colleague an opportunity.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in this morning. I remember talking to someone about the victims. The person said they felt that they were listened to but not heard. That was the view of many of the groups. Whether we are talking about Governments, organisations or whatever, they were listening but there was no sense they were hearing what was being said. There was a gap between the two. I think it was a profound statement for victims to make.
I refer to what was said about the danger now being that what is done will not satisfy anyone. I imagine there must have been highs and lows. We can mention different campaigns.
Deputy Conway-Walsh was talking about the Ballymurphy families and there probably would not have been those apologies if the families had not campaigned for all those years. The next generation took it on and so on. There are so many different victims' campaigns and then there are others no-one is campaigning for. No-one remembers them except maybe their families and so on. Governments might apologise once on a particular case but are they apologising for their role? It is almost like that phrase from the Birmingham Six case, the "appalling vista". There is still that sense. It was sort of the judicial system and the political system at the time that these men would have been beaten up by the system, or whatever else. I am just using that as an example.
With the legislation that is going through at the moment, the witnesses mentioned the word "Troubles" but it was a conflict. "Conflict" is probably nearer to what actually happened than "Troubles", which seems a very passive sort of thing. "War" is maybe too far but if you talk about ex-combatants from all sides, they see it as a war. Maybe not families. The language is important but it looks like we are going to leave people behind again with what we are facing into. There is a challenge for anyone old enough to remember the challenge of the Good Friday Agreement. We cannot agree on it as it is the Good Friday Agreement to one community and to someone else it is the Belfast Agreement and someone else probably has another name for it. All those challenges are still there years and years later and the families are getting older, as are the victims. Some of us went up to the Garvaghy Road. Putting aside what that was about, it was clear to anyone that the trauma those people went through was reawakened and those were just the people I was talking to. There are other families as well.
We are not good at reconciliation and the onus but the structures have not been there to reconcile. We have not reconciled. Our political system has not reconciled with itself. I go back again to the potential of the Good Friday Agreement. Anything was possible. Surely something like acknowledging victims was one of the simpler things we could have achieved. I do not have the answers but is it down to the political systems or governments not going the extra step and acknowledging the appalling vista they were involved in, or the groupings and so on? Would that help move it on? I am scraping for answers here in relation to how we could resolve this.
The witnesses mentioned victims in the South of Ireland. I could not believe the State did not try to give the families of those killed and injured in the Dublin and Monaghan bombings medical cards or other basic things. It was almost like the State was to blame for something that happened to them or their loved ones. I do not think the State here has acknowledged that. The danger is if we start apologising to one group, family or whatever else there are others left behind or not mentioned. I really do not know if we should have a day of mourning for all those victims, or something like that.
We are not good at solutions. We are still way behind on the reconciliation aspects. We talk about the victims but reconciliation is an even more difficult journey. Decades later, many would say we still have not started. That is more of a statement than anything else.
I am churning around what I have heard this morning and what I have seen, heard and experienced in my life in respect of some of these matters and from talking to families. The statement that "They listened to us but did not hear us" is an appalling indictment.
Comment on this
That phrase of people being listened to but not heard is very powerful. It would resonate with many of the victims and survivors whom we work with and listen to. It is important to remember, as the Deputy highlighted, that there are hundreds, if not thousands, of victims and survivors who are not linked to any groups. Those are individuals who suffered, and continue to suffer, in isolation because of their circumstances or lived experiences. Those individuals are quietly living at home. Some of them have been suffering badly for generations. Those individuals, and I frequently meet such individuals, just want to be acknowledged. There is great power in states and governments to acknowledge the harm done and for those who were non-state actors to acknowledge the harm they did. It means a lot to people.
I do not mean to make it sound as if this is easy. I apologise if in any way this is difficult and depressing. It is not my intention. As I said at the beginning, when I meet victims and survivors, I do not get a sense of depression or pessimism. They are people who want to make this place better and build a better future. However, they obviously need to feel heard and seen. It can happen at a societal level. Days of reflection are important.
It is also important in the context of legislation, including the Troubles Bill, to ensure that whatever mechanisms are set up are focused on victims. To use the phrase, they need to be "victim-centred". We have the example in our own legislation of the Victims and Survivors Advisory Group. As currently framed, it comprises a handful of people who were selected by the Secretary of State. We have not asked how to make the group truly victim-centred in terms of the skills and numbers of people involved and the support required. There are societal things that could be done and practical things that could help victims and survivors.
I talked a few weeks ago to some of the families of the victims of the Dublin and Monaghan bombings. Their sense is that they have been completely forgotten by the State. That happens and is not unique in recent years. We saw the contributions a few weeks ago from the people of Aberfan in Wales. They talked about their experience of a disaster over 60 years ago when the state covered up and colluded. They are still looking for answers and apologies. I could mention Grenfell Tower or the haemophiliac blood inquiries. Unfortunately, it is almost institutionalised that states do not readily come forward. That should not take away from the need to ensure that people are listened to properly and heard and that their voices are not lost.
Comment on this
I will come in on the legislation and the joint framework. In respect of the sequencing around the statements of acknowledgment, they cannot be done until information has been provided and investigations have been completed, and until families feel and believe that they have had the opportunity to have their questions answered or to have information recovered or to have an investigation conducted. There should be no attempt to make a statement of acknowledgment in the absence of the full picture. There is so much that we need to understand. That was where the Stormont House Agreement got it right. It included the full infrastructure that should be in place, the access to truth, information and justice. With that full picture, we would be able to consider the full experience of people, including the experience of people living in rural areas, the gendered experience and the experience of women and of different groups of men. We need to understand and then, as a society, acknowledge the harm done and consider how to memorialise it.
That needs to be done in sequence because you cannot jump to the end bit and say, here are we memorialising and acknowledging it now. That needs to be done within the fullness of the picture. That is why we encourage elected representatives to make representations that the sequencing of all of these provisions have to be comprehensive but have to be done in the right order as well.
Comment on this
The Deputy mentioned Drumcree and the people he met there. For us, it also brings in the whole issue of intergenerational trauma. While we highlighted earlier the fact that a lot of victims and survivors are old and getting older, their children and grandchildren are still suffering. Therefore you might argue that you might sort out a particular generation and it is problem solved, but it is an intergenerational issue. Sometimes in the history of this country we need to remember that we do not forget very easily the hurt that has been done.
Comment on this
The challenge when putting through or discussing the legislation at the moment is that they do not have any idea of Ireland or what happened there. That is also a big challenge, that they probably have preconceived ideas in relation to what happened or whatever else. They do not really understand the challenges there. I suppose you could say the same about those who made the decision on Drumcree. I will park that but they just really do not understand it. They are maybe younger or were not born then. There are all sorts of reasons. You are relying on them to come up with solutions and I do not know if they are capable of that.
Comment on this
In terms of Ms McCann's point about section 4 of the Legacy Act of 2023, which still stands, given the earlier remarks from some members, it might be no harm to have a note from the commission on what it envisages for that section, particularly around oral history and memorialisation. I accept the point about the steps the commission has to take first in order to get to that point, but given some of the remarks earlier, it would be no harm to get a sense from them as to what that might entail.
I was struck by some of the commentary around the Troubles Bill itself, even calling it the veterans Bill, as if it were all about veterans. To say the least, that is very worrying because it gives a trajectory for the legislation that is not what it is intended to be. Some of the amendments were quite surprising, to say the least. From what the witnesses have both said this morning, have they had the opportunity to engage with committees, be it in the House of Commons or House of Lords, in advance of that? If so, what were the kind of questions put to the witnesses? Those are my initial questions.
Comment on this
We took a group of victims and survivors over to Westminster the day the Bill was being debated again in the House of Commons. My sense before that debate was that there would be a more balanced debate and discussion that would focus on victims and survivors. I sat through four and a half to five hours of debate on the Bill and I have to say that, at a personal level, I was quite disappointed that the focus of the debate across the House of Commons was very much focused on veterans. As politicians, the committee members will all be aware of why that was the case, but I had hoped that, on the day, there would be a bit more balance. There was the speed of getting the amendments. From memory, they came out on the Tuesday and the following Monday people were debating it, so there was limited time for people to reflect on them.
A small group of parliamentarians spoke to the victims and survivors we brought over. They were making the case, as you would expect, that this is a much more complex and nuanced situation than perhaps those leading the veterans' lobby would have you believe. We had veterans with us on the day who had served in Northern Ireland and were very proud of their service.
There is no ground to be gained from setting victims and veterans against each other. That has been a really difficult aspect of this process. I said earlier that the veterans' lobby does not reflect the experience of veterans who both served in Northern Ireland and continue to live in Northern Ireland. That has been very unfortunate. As with other groups, our intention is to seek amendments as the Bill goes through the House of Lords to try to recalibrate the debate so there is more of an understanding that this is legislation to try to deal with very difficult aspects of the Troubles. It is not legislation to support veterans on their own. It is very unfortunate that the debate has gone down that road. I understand why it has happened. The lobby has been very well funded and, to give credit to the people involved, very well organised, although it does not represent the totality of veterans.
Comment on this
On the engagement prior to the amendments, what kind of engagement have the witnesses had with parliamentarians in Britain?
Comment on this
We have regular discussions with parliamentarians and, to give credit to the current Secretary of State, with officials from the Northern Ireland Office. It is fair to say there was a general sense from those discussions that the veterans debate was not going to get the oxygen it did on the day. I was disappointed that it did. There was a sense that we had tried to manage that as best we could, that enough had been done to get the Bill over the line in the House of Commons, which it was, and that the things others referred to earlier would be sorted out in the House of Lords. Given the limited amount of confidence in governments, and in governments there, that is a big ask. In terms of the amendments, optics and presentation, the British Government has a lot to do to continue to gain support.
Comment on this
Parliamentary scrutiny involved a committee of the whole House. Given the way it works, there would not have been Northern Ireland MPs. There was no line-by-line committee scrutiny, but Mr. McVey did meet the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee twice as part of its inquiry into the Bill. He also had a session with the Joint Committee on Human Rights.
Comment on this
Specifically on the commission's 2026 population survey in the Republic of Ireland, some of the statistics that have been elicited are quite interesting. For instance, 96% said that it is important for the Irish and UK Governments to issue statements acknowledging the harms for which they were responsible. Some 97% said it is important for loyalist and republican paramilitary groups to do likewise. For the victims at large with whom the witnesses have engaged, how important is that particular aspect of an apology? We were talking about the oral and memorialisation aspects, but prior to getting to that point, people want to hear an apology for what was done by State actors and non-State actors. Will the witnesses elaborate a little more on their own work and their engagement with victims on that issue?
Comment on this
It is critical. I take Ms McCann's earlier point that there is a sequence in these things regarding whether an apology given is true and abject, and all the other associated words, and we have heard some of that before. However, if you talk to families who have received a statement of acknowledgement or an apology, you note it can be cathartic for them. It can make a considerable difference. It does not take away from their pain or suffering. Again, as Ms McCann said earlier, there may still be some families who get an apology and say that while it is great, they want to take things forward and are seeking justice or a day in court. However, for the majority of victims and survivors I meet, it is about somebody actually recognising and acknowledging their pain. At a human level and a societal level, it is fundamental.
Comment on this
I do not believe we have ever come across victims and survivors who have said an apology is not important to them, but they want it in the context of fully understanding why.
Comment on this
With particular regard to the paramilitaries, is there a willingness? We are 28 years on now. You would think it would have been forthcoming for both sides to say that this was wrong and they apologise. That would have meaning for families in particular. Do the witnesses think that is forthcoming? Are we close to that point? Going back to the sequencing element, is that something we are close to?
Comment on this
By my understanding, there are discussions ongoing with paramilitary organisations to say that might be a possibility. Again, it sounds very glib to say there is a sequencing. People doing that - whether it is an acknowledgment or a sharing of information through interlocutors - would want to make sure their positions are secure and safe. I think it has to come from both sides. If it came purely from government alone, in the experience of Ireland, it would be meaningless for a lot of people.
Comment on this
Okay. I am in the last few minutes of my time. In regard to the information retrieval infrastructure - Ms McCann alluded to this earlier on - and an all-island or multi-jurisdictional approach, how do the witnesses see that architecture being formed to try to satisfy those who are looking for information? Reference was made to Stormont House and how it got that aspect quite correct. In respect of all jurisdictions included in this process, what is the best way to start framing and operationalising it?
Comment on this
As I referenced, there is a model there in regard to how information can be handled and firewalled. It is about confidence for people to come forward and give information. What we have learned from other models that are maybe not working as successfully is that they have not been done through engagement with victims and survivors on what they want their experience to be. There needs to be a degree of consultation that we have not seen to date. We have not had any substantive engagement with either of the Governments on what this organisation will look and feel like, or how it will be populated. There is no discourse happening on it at all and that is concerning. There is a way of starting to look at the work programme behind establishing it that is not visible. The fact that there has been a loss of the voice of victims in all of this legislation is to be lamented. We have lost that from Stormont House to here, to the sorry state that people are now referring to it as the veterans Bill. What we need is a reorientation back in. We hope that when the legislation comes forward, this place will be more aware of the need to shape these mechanisms with victims at the centre of them.
Comment on this
I will go back to the earlier point. It is described in the framework as a three-year pilot and, again, that does not give much confidence. If and when it is set up, what is the role for victims and survivors? Will they be at the heart of designing it, rather than, as I said earlier, their voices being listened to and not heard? It must be in the design stage, looking at models that have worked elsewhere and saying, "Let us get this right". From my experience over the past year in regard to the troubles Bill, there was a desire to move it forward and get things done. For things like information recovery and part 4 regarding oral history and memorialisation, it is almost a case of once we get it through, we will start doing that work. In contrast, in the Stormont House Agreement, as I understand it, a lot more focus was on implementation and pre-planning. A lot of that seems to be lacking at the moment.
Comment on this
To that point, does Mr. McVey think the two Governments have an ability to work together, along with politicians in Northern Ireland, to try to create jointly a system that people can buy into? Clearly, you cannot have two different jurisdictions working on a similar system but not together.
Comment on this
It was suggested that we look at the model of the North-South Ministerial Council. It looks at issues that are cross-jurisdiction. That may be an area of looking at the things that we talked about earlier, such as the needs of victims and survivors; how mechanisms are victim focused; information recovery; and how we get the victim's voice at the centre of that. It is about looking at mechanisms that are currently there. To go back to the Good Friday Agreement - all the members would know better than I would - victims and survivors were certainly mentioned in it, but it was very much a cursory mention. We have seen the trail of that over the past 28 years where there has been a focus on victims, survivors and legacy and then that has been forgotten about.
Yesterday, Jon Boutcher talked about how it was 25 years since the PSNI was established. Up until a few weeks ago, we would have said that the establishment of the PSNI and the Parades Commission were two of the solid outworkings of the Good Friday Agreement. The Parades Commission is perhaps less so at the moment. There has been no consistent support or engagement in the funding of victims and survivors which is why we are in this situation. As I said at the beginning, there is a real opportunity for the committee to look at the 30th anniversary as a way of saying, "Can we do better and can this committee keep a real focus on it?". That would make a great deal of difference to victims and survivors.
Comment on this
We can do better. We need to do better. We need to leave the interstate case on the table. I ask this committee to seek a note on where the interstate case is at and what the trajectory of that is. It may be the only hand we have left to play.
Comment on this
We have correspondence out to the Department on that from our previous meetings. We are awaiting the response to it.
I thank Mr. McVey and Ms McCann very much for their evidence this morning before the committee. I thank them for their time and willingness to participate with us. I hope it is not the last time. It may be in the next couple of months that we will be engaging again. If the witnesses do not mind, I ask them to furnish a note on the oral information and memorialisation. I thank members for their engagement this morning.