Road Safety on the Motorway Network: Discussion (Resumed)
An Garda Síochána said its priority in wrong-way motorway incidents is to prevent or end pursuits safely, using continuous risk assessment, control-room coordination, stingers and air support. It has 660 dedicated roads-policing personnel and more than 2,000 members trained to deploy stingers, but no officers yet trained in pursuit driving; instructor training is under way, with the scale of future training uncertain. Committee members raised concern about reduced roads-policing numbers, limited access to motorway CCTV and the slow rollout of safety cameras. The Garda supported stronger deterrents in principle and said better identification of social-media users would assist investigations.
Contributions 1–148 of 295. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
The purpose of the meeting today is to resume our discussions on road safety. Our engagement today is with An Garda Síochána to discuss recent incidents on the motorway network. On behalf of the committee I am pleased to welcome from An Garda Síochána, Assistant Commissioner Denis Ferry, roads policing and community engagement, and Chief Superintendent Brian Sugrue, director of training and development at the Garda College. The format of the meeting is that we will hear their opening statement first, followed by a question-and-answer session with the members of the committee. I ask members to be concise in their questions to allow witnesses the opportunity to participate.
Witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make changes against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in respect of an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make changes against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Members will have seven minutes for questions and answers.
I ask Assistant Commissioner Ferry to make his opening statement on behalf of An Garda Síochána.
Comment on this
I wish the Cathaoirleach and members of the committee a good morning. I thank them for the invitation to appear before them today to discuss recent incidents on our motorway network. I welcome the opportunity to outline the response of An Garda Síochána to these incidents and, importantly, to update the committee in respect of the measures we have in place to keep people safe on our roads.
Recent incidents involving vehicles travelling against the flow of traffic on motorways have understandably caused considerable public concern. Motorways are high-speed environments. A vehicle travelling against the normal flow of traffic presents an immediate and potentially catastrophic risk to other road users, including An Garda Síochána personnel and other first responders. Whether such an incident arises from deliberate dangerous driving, a mistaken entry onto the motorway network or another reason, our priority is the same, to bring the incident to the safest possible conclusion.
A key principle underpinning our response is that, wherever possible, the priority is to prevent a pursuit from developing in the first place or, where one has commenced, to bring it to an end as quickly and safely as possible. There has been much debate regarding the pursuit of vehicles engaged in this type of deliberate reckless driving. In regard to this, there are of course occasions where pursuit may present more risk. There are policies and procedures, together with a range of operational and tactical options, available to respond to incidents such as this, which will be considered as part of our response.
As the committee will appreciate, pursuit driving is inherently high risk. That risk extends to public safety, the safety of our members and also the risk to those in the vehicle being pursued. Our objective is not simply to follow a vehicle. It is to use the information, resources and tactical options available to us to bring that vehicle to a stop while minimising the risk to others.
When the Garda becomes aware of a vehicle engaged in dangerous or reckless driving on the road network, our response is co-ordinated between gardaí on the ground and our trained personnel in our regional control rooms. Our four regional control rooms operate on a 24-hour basis and play a central role in co-ordinating resources and supporting operational gardaí. An Garda Síochána introduced an updated policy on spontaneous pursuits in December 2024. That policy provides a clear governance framework for the management of pursuits and places continuous risk assessment at the centre of the Garda response.
Gardaí must continually assess the behaviour of the vehicle concerned, the road environment, traffic conditions, the danger being presented to other road users and the potential consequences of either continuing or discontinuing a pursuit. That assessment is particularly important where a vehicle is travelling against the flow of traffic. In those circumstances, we must consider not only how the vehicle can be stopped but also the risk to other motorists. These are dynamic operational decisions, sometimes made in a matter of seconds, with the protection of life at their centre. A pursuit may be discontinued where the assessment is that continuing it would create an unacceptable level of risk. Depending on the circumstances, Garda resources can be deployed ahead of the vehicle and appropriately trained Garda members can deploy vehicle stopping devices. These are commonly known as stingers, and they form an important part of the operational capacity. They can be deployed by specifically trained and certified Garda members where their use is considered appropriate and safe. More than 2,000 gardaí are currently trained in the use of these devices.
Our Garda air support provides another important tactical option and can assist in monitoring and tracking the vehicle, while other Garda units can be strategically positioned. Where such an approach can be deployed, Garda aircraft can track a vehicle over considerable distances and provide gardaí and our regional control rooms with information on its location and direction of travel. This can reduce the requirement for ground units to remain in close proximity to a dangerously driven vehicle and allows further Garda resources to be co-ordinated ahead of it.
The effectiveness of these operational capabilities was demonstrated as recently last week. Gardaí conducted a managed containment operation in Dublin involving a stolen vehicle that was being driven dangerously, including against the flow of traffic on the M50. The vehicle was ultimately brought to a controlled stop and two people were arrested. This demonstrates the importance of having a range of operational options available to gardaí to respond to changing circumstances and bring incidents of this nature to a safe conclusion.
There are currently 660 Garda personnel assigned to dedicated roads policing units nationally, making it the single largest specialist policing unit within An Garda Síochána. However, roads policing and road safety are not solely the responsibility of those specialist units. Every front-line garda has a role in keeping people safe on our roads. Approximately 75% of roads policing activity involving an arrest is undertaken by front-line gardaí rather than members of dedicated roads policing units.
Approximately 4,500 Garda members have been trained to competency-based driving level 2 standard, enabling appropriately trained members to respond under emergency conditions using lights and sirens. That provides An Garda Síochána with a wider national response capability, supported by our dedicated roads policing units, regional control rooms, air support and other specialist resources. We are continuing to build that capability. Garda driving instructors are undertaking initial phase pursuit training. Two of the three stages of that programme have been completed, with the final stage expected to be completed in the final quarter of this year.
Once those instructors are qualified, An Garda Síochána will be in a position to begin delivering that training to operational Garda members and to further build that capability during 2027. This will complement the policies, training and operational structures already in place. Enforcement is further supported through the use of technology such as the automatic number plate recognition, ANPR, capabilities in-built in our roads policing fleet, the traffic applications our members have access to on their mobility devices, and the increase in speed cameras and in our expanded safety zones monitored by Go Safe.
Enforcement and operational response are only part of our work. We must also seek to prevent dangerous behaviour from occurring in the first place. There have been incidents where extremely dangerous driving behaviour has been recorded and subsequently shared online. An Garda Síochána is engaging with social media companies to prioritise road safety and to seek the removal of such material from their platforms. We also work closely with Transport Infrastructure Ireland, the Road Safety Authority, the Department of justice, the Department of Transport, local authorities and other stakeholders on matters relating to road safety. Partnership and information sharing are important elements of our response, alongside our core functions of prevention, operational response, enforcement and investigation.
I understand why recent incidents have caused concern. Nobody travelling lawfully on our motorways should expect to encounter a vehicle coming towards them against the flow of traffic. I want to reassure people using our motorway network that it is safe and that An Garda Síochána has a range of options available to respond when these incidents occur. I reiterate that we have dedicated roads policing units, supported by front-line Garda members across the country. We have four regional control rooms operating around the clock. Garda members have received emergency response training. More than 2,000 are trained in the deployment of vehicle-stopping devices. We also have air support and other specialist resources available to assist Garda personnel on the ground.
Taken together, these resources give An Garda Síochána a range of options to respond to incidents of dangerous driving, adapt that response as circumstances change and, wherever possible, bring an incident to a safe conclusion. No single measure can remove the risk created by an individual who decides to drive dangerously. That is why our response combines preparedness, operational response, enforcement, investigation and prevention. An Garda Síochána will continue to police our road network to prevent and respond to this behaviour.
I again thank the Cathaoirleach and other committee members for the invitation to appear here today and I welcome any questions that they may have.
Comment on this
I thank the assistant commissioner and welcome him and Chief Superintendent Sugrue. I apologise for being late. On my behalf and that of the other committee members, I acknowledge the crucial role of members of An Garda Síochána. I am always conscious, as I said at the justice committee, that more often than not gardaí are the first to appear in the aftermath of a collision. Those collisions are not easy situations. In terms of what we are trying to do around road safety, the perspective of the witnesses and other Garda members matters.
Since February of this year, the committee has held a series of focused meetings. We have met many stakeholder groups, including vulnerable road users and victim impact groups.
I am delighted that we have representatives of PARC Road Safety Group in the public gallery today, Ms Susan Gray and Ms Fiona Clancy. We have met academics, medical personnel, the assistant commissioner's predecessor in the role, the Garda Commissioner, other road users, the Road Safety Authority and the Minister. Today's meeting is the culmination of those meetings, after which we will produce a report with recommendations that we hope can be taken on board in the short to medium term. We look forward to further engagement with the assistant commissioner. We thank him for his presence today and wish him well in his new role.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being here. I echo the words that gardaí do a fantastic job. They are front-line, and they take the abuse as well as the praise when it comes their way.
I was listening to the figures. My first question was going to be how many roads police we have, but the assistant commissioner has already given the answer of 660. I know that a lot of front-line gardaí will also tackle roads policing. How many are needed overall to sufficiently and effectively police the roads?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for the question. As the statement outlined, it is the largest specialised unit in the organisation. It has 660 personnel, 649 of whom are outside, with the remainder in my bureau to assist and support those members. The important thing is that, as we get an increase in overall Garda numbers, which the Commissioner has committed to, all specialised areas will look for additional members. We would welcome any of those as well.
The important thing that has happened over the last month or two is a review of the resourcing capabilities. We have now ensured that there are dedicated inspectors within every division with responsibility for roads policing. There are 24 inspectors in total, with two in the Dublin area. My team meets with them every two weeks to look at tasking and co-ordinating to try to ensure that we are maximising all of the resources available to us.
The other important thing is the introduction and use of technology in this area. That gives us more opportunity to have people out there, doing enforcement that is targeted through the use of, say, road safety cameras, mobility devices and ANPR. We will continue to look at that to see how we can utilise technology to support the work that our members do and allow them to maximise their time for enforcement.
Comment on this
The assistant commissioner is answering my questions before I even ask them. We spoke with TII, the RSA and other groups. I want to hear the Garda side of it. When it comes to improvements in infrastructure, is there something that is missing that the witnesses think might assist gardaí in reducing the number of road deaths? Is there something that is missing?
Comment on this
That is not within our remit. We are focused on the enforcement and policing element. I have been in a number of meetings with our colleagues in TII and Road Safety Ireland. We are all talking about the same things, for example, improved signage so that people are aware. What is surprising to all of us is that quite often, when people go the wrong way on roads, particularly motorways, it is a genuine mistake. You look at that and wonder how it could happen. Did they not see the signage? We continue to look at signage, markings and road design. Again, that is within the remit of the RSA and TII. Anything that can be done to review the existing road network to see if improvements can be made from a road design or signage perspective will make it easier for us as well.
Comment on this
I understand how somebody could do that, not that I have ever done it, or at least not in Ireland. I have driven in places like Spain. It is disorientating to drive on the wrong side of the road, so I can understand that. Maybe the road signage is not bright enough for those situations. However, I accept that when somebody is going out intentionally to do something, it is difficult to have everything in place that could stop that. That is when it comes down to keeping everybody on the road safe and keeping the Garda's own staff and drivers safe. That was one of my other questions. Are more training and resources needed? Do gardaí have enough spec to do what they need to do, or do they need more?
Comment on this
Chief Superintendent Sugrue is the director of training at the Garda College. Any opportunity we can get to provide additional training is helpful. What training brings to every member is an improvement in their decision-making and communication. All of that is central to what we talk about here in terms of trying to prevent pursuits. That is the key piece - to try to prevent a pursuit by not turning on your lights or allowing something to develop. However, once you engage in that, there will be a knock-on series of events. We are prioritising the training, and we will prioritise in-pursuit training for our members once the instructors are available to do that. Again, there is going to be an additional level of training to aid communications for those in our control rooms, who have that overall governance and oversight of incidents, and have that independent expertise to understand what is appropriate and at what time these things need to be stood down.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses. I want to talk about social media. Do the witnesses believe that some drivers are being influenced by social media content that normalises driving recklessly?
Comment on this
There is always a risk when people are viewing material, whether it is a movie or online. There is always a risk that people think they can do that type of driving. It is certainly a risk, and I do not think any area is immune to that. There is a responsibility on all of us to remind people of the risks, and that goes across the board.
Comment on this
How often do reels or videos that are posted to social media depicting dangerous driving in Ireland assist gardaí with their investigations? Can they be used in prosecutions?
Comment on this
I do not have that figure to hand, and it might be difficult to give a correct figure. This happens regularly in investigations, and it is open to gardaí in all cases to seek evidence from social media platforms or any other platform. That does happen. When it happens, the challenge is often the identification because people may not be identifiable, which creates a problem.
Comment on this
How does that work? Let us say there is a random username on TikTok, and gardaí contact the social media company. Does the company assist with identifying the user or providing information to identify that person?
Comment on this
The request is made by a member of the Garda Síochána seeking the information, and then any additional information that the platform can provide is also made available, where possible.
Comment on this
Do gardaí find those interactions positive? Do the companies come back swiftly? Will they take the content down as a result of the Garda highlighting the issue?
Comment on this
In most cases, there is a legal request, so they comply with those requests. Generally, what we have done is meet with some of the social media platforms, and we continue to do that. I have only been in the role for a number of months, but I have met one of the key platforms, and we have another one scheduled in the next couple of weeks. I found that engagement very positive, and it was interesting to see how they dealt with these incidents. We will try to build on that engagement. The requests kind of look after themselves, and it is really around the notification. When we become aware of instances of concern or instances that will be in the public domain, we need to ensure there is clear interaction between ourselves and the platforms.
Comment on this
Would the Garda request that a certain piece of content be removed?
Comment on this
In some cases, that has happened. In the most recent incidents, the content was removed because there was engagement by An Garda Síochána, but there was also a responsibility on the platforms themselves, which have their own moderator facilities in place, to take down content.
Comment on this
Are there any measures that the assistant commissioner thinks the Oireachtas or the Government should bring forward in terms of assisting the Garda in that process?
Comment on this
Again, it might not be exactly prescriptive, but the biggest piece in terms of the questions the Deputy has asked is around identity. The most significant challenge with people posting content is if we can strengthen how they register on the platforms and how we can identify them within the platforms. The content can be provided, but if we cannot ascertain the true identity of the person, then obviously it goes to the investigation team to see what it can tell from the video footage it has or from other information that is available from the social media platforms. That piece around the registration identification is something that would strengthen our ability - or anyone's ability - to ascertain the identification of people on platforms.
Comment on this
We are the Oireachtas committee on transport. Are there particular measures the Garda would like to see the Oireachtas more broadly introduce to assist the Garda to deal with reckless driving and road safety?
Comment on this
At all stages we are looking to strengthen the offences and the penalties, as they are probably the biggest deterrent. We spoke at previous committee meetings about the protection of our members. The Commissioner sent his submission on that to the Department to look at strengthening the protection of Garda members who are involved in pursuits in particular. Some of them, having done their duty, followed their training and followed the policies and procedures, have found themselves subject to prosecution. That submission has been made to the Department and hopefully it will be supported and those changes will be brought in. That would give greater certainty to the members and allow them to do their duty without any concerns.
Comment on this
I do not have an exact date. It was probably made last month or before that.
Comment on this
Would Mr. Ferry be happy to share it with this committee?
Comment on this
I expect there is no reason not to but I will check that.
Comment on this
It would be very helpful if we saw it. Has a response been received?
Comment on this
The Commissioner's office probably received a response. I recently met the Minister of State, Deputy Canney, and he asked about it at that meeting. I understand his officials received the submission as well.
Comment on this
The submission was made to the Department of justice and Mr. Ferry subsequently met the Minister of State, Deputy Canney, from the Department of Transport?
Comment on this
The Garda obviously engages with both Departments on this topic.
Comment on this
Yes. There have been a number of meetings in relation to this and a lot of correspondence. We formally send correspondence to the Department of justice and if it is relevant to the Department of Transport, it goes to it as well.
Comment on this
I acknowledge the 141 lives lost on Irish roads so far this year. We are talking a lot about statistics today, but behind every one of those lives lost is a family and a community devastated. Seven of those lives have been lost on what are statistically our safest roads, the 1,300 km motorway network. I also mention the more than 1,000 people who have been seriously injured.
I have a number of quick questions and I ask the assistant commissioner to give short answers if he can. Would the Garda support the introduction of a specific new aggregated offence with stronger penalties for deliberate wrong-way motorway driving?
Comment on this
We always support greater deterrence, and if that involves a graduated response, I think we would welcome that.
Comment on this
Does the Garda support the proposals on the table to increase from ten to 14 years the current maximum sentence for dangerous driving causing death?
Comment on this
Again, anything that offers a greater deterrent is obviously something the organisation would welcome, but that is for the Legislature to decide.
Comment on this
Persons who are convicted and get a custodial sentence are also disqualified from driving. Does Mr. Ferry agree that the disqualification period should only begin after the offender leaves prison?
Comment on this
That is outside our remit. Our job is enforcement. We do not want to get into the space of how the Legislature works. Again, anything that can provide a greater deterrent is obviously something that we would support.
Comment on this
How many members of An Garda Síochána are specifically trained in pursuit training as opposed to emergency response driving?
Comment on this
At the moment nobody has done in-pursuit training. We have 4,500 people who are trained to respond to calls using their lights and sirens, which we call CBD level 2. We also have over 200 specially trained officers in the specialist units that deal with containment and stopping vehicles. We have spoken about that on previous occasions. By the end of this year, we hope to have trained instructors in place to train our members in in-pursuit driving. This will provide additional training so that people are better placed to make better decisions to try to prevent pursuits. It will also mean better communication with our control rooms. The important issue there is that if we can provide better information, we will, hopefully, bring those pursuits that do occur to a quicker end.
Comment on this
What we are talking about between now and the end of the year is training the trainers and that involves trainers going to the constabulary in Devon and Cornwall. The Commissioner spoke about this on 15 July. Is that correct? Will Mr. Ferry tell me how many trainers undertook training in Devon and Cornwall or are in the process of doing so? How many trainers will we have trained by the end of this year?
Comment on this
I will hand over shortly to Chief Superintendent Sugrue who will talk about the detail. I do not have the nuances of who went over and who came back from Devon and Cornwall, but it is the police force we are utilising at the moment to help train our trainers. That would be normal enough in terms of training our instructors. Just before I let Chief Superintendent Sugrue come in on that, separately we are also engaging with other UK police forces. Some of them have been in contact with us previously around events. We are looking at their capacity to try to maximise their capability to train additional instructors. We have not formalised that yet, but we are hoping to do that through other police forces in the UK. I will let Chief Superintendent Sugrue talk about Devon and Cornwall Police.
Comment on this
Members of Devon and Cornwall Police visited the Garda College in the summer and are due back before the end of the year to finalise training for some Garda members and to continue other people along tat pathway. There are a number of modules in the initial phase pursuit instructor course. At this time, I have 15 members, Garda driving instructors, who are very highly trained in other areas and have completed some of the modules. By November a number of them will have completed all modules and others will have completed one or two of the three modules. There is a pipeline of them in progress.
Comment on this
That depends on the engagement with other UK police forces. At the moment we are engaging exclusively with Devon and Cornwall Police but, as the assistant commissioner mentioned, there has been interaction with some other UK police forces which have indicated willingness to assist us. I am, therefore, hopeful that we will get a larger number of Garda driving instructors trained up.
Comment on this
It will be dependent on the interactions with the other UK police forces. The aspiration was to get as many Garda driving instructors as possible trained up so we can roll out pursuit driving.
Comment on this
Would that figure be in the region of ten, 15 or 20 Garda members? Will Mr. Sugrue give an approximate figure for the number of instructors who will be fully trained by the end of this year? What will the capacity be then to train others in a full calendar year, say, 2027?
Comment on this
It is difficult to give an exact number because it is dependent on interactions and agreements with another UK police force. Devon and Cornwall Police have committed to having a cohort trained by the end of the year. It is in single figures.
Comment on this
By the end of the year, with Devon and Cornwall Police we are talking about single figures but we are hoping the interaction with other UK police forces will significantly increase that number.
Comment on this
Transport Infrastructure Ireland, TII, spoke last week about its operational control centre. Are those control rooms digitally integrated in real time?
Comment on this
No. That is the simple straightforward answer. There are interactions between the control rooms but our four control rooms are stand-alone.
Comment on this
Apologies, we do have access to some of those cameras. I do not know off-hand the exact number. There are cameras that we share with different authorities and we have those in our control rooms.
Comment on this
Are there any plans to integrate the regional control centres with the TII control centre?
Comment on this
Not formally. We could always look at that integration and the use of cameras because we rely on providers and the authorities to provide those cameras to us. Again, it is something-----
Comment on this
I have one final question. Can a Garda controller responding to a live wrong-way incident directly access TII's motorway CCTV feed?
Comment on this
Not the entire feed. There is access to a limited number of cameras. I need to check the scale of that. Again, generally, when gardaí are dealing with that they have access to certain cameras, but then it is also more about the actual pursuit-----
Comment on this
I would take the slot because I have to get to the Chamber.
Comment on this
The Cathaoirleach has not had his Weetabix yet this morning.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being here and for all the work they do. According to the opening statement, 2,000 gardaí are trained in relation to stinger operations. There are also aircraft available. In addition, 4,500 gardaí have undergone competency-based driving. On a yearly basis, how many stinger operations are undertaken? Mr. Ferry might describe how it works.
Comment on this
What happens is that when an incident is occurring, the control room will generally co-ordinate a response to that and try to co-ordinate the responding cars to attend at certain locations with the view they have available to them. The gardaí have the stingers available to them and have the training to deploy them. Their use is obviously dependent on that is happening, so we might have stingers at different points and locations in the hope that we will be able to intercept, if you like, and deploy a stinger. We record the figures on deployment based on when they are actually deployed and intercept a vehicle, so where there is an actual hit. That is in line with use of force, where we use a stinger to actually stop a car or the car has driven over the stinger. It often happen that a stinger is deployed and the vehicle does not actually make contact with it, so that incident may not be recorded. That is the reason the numbers are lower than what Garda members would say actually happens.
Comment on this
I will check for the Deputy while I am talking. The numbers are quite small in terms of the number of deployments. Perhaps I will come back to the Deputy with that number in a moment.
Comment on this
That is fine. Obviously, it is great that gardaí are trained to do it. How many times are stingers deployed and how many deployments are successful? Where I am going with this, and it is the same with the aircraft, is that it sounds great but Garda figures show we have gone from having around 1,000 gardaí in the road policing unit in 2009 to having 649 active gardaí in roads policing now, and I wonder how quickly and effectively gardaí can reach these incidents to intercept what is happening.
Comment on this
The key message we have communicated previously in public but also at the committee is that the real aim around pursuits is to prevent them happening and try to reduce the likelihood that the driver of the vehicle we are interacting with decides to take off and maybe causes a bigger problem. The challenge is always about that early engagement and reducing the likelihood that the car is going to take off in a pursuit. That is the biggest part of it. Where possible and where it is available, we have the benefit of air support. That air support, with the control rooms, helps to provide information to decide whether it is safe then for pursuit to occur and for members to be authorised to do that pursuit. Again, we have given the figures previously that about 80% of pursuits are authorised. Obviously, they then often come to an end either through the control room or the vehicle coming to a stop of its own volition. They are likely to end up crashing, which is the biggest risk we have.
Comment on this
I get that, but it is important that we know not just how many people are trained but how many times that action is deployed. While I take the assistant commissioner's point that it may not be necessary to complete an operation for it to be successful, we need to know how many times these are being deployed. The figures on roads policing numbers show an decrease, which has to have an impact on interventions on the ground, and on a national basis as well.
Comment on this
The number of incidents we record for the use of stingers is probably not reflective of the number that actually occurs. Quite often in these incidents, there are cars that are available that have the stingers and the members are trained and ready to deploy them but, because of where they are located, the vehicle may not take that route or may not reach that destination.
Comment on this
The chief superintendent has just found it for me and spared me from having to look through my folder. The number of incidents recorded where there was use of force using a stinger where the vehicle has run across it for this year to date is nine. Last year, there were 17 incidents. In 2023 and 2024, there were 11 incidents recorded of the use of force using stingers.
Comment on this
Is that when the stinger is deployed or when it actually completes it?
Comment on this
That is where the member has deployed it and the vehicle in question has run over the stinger and, hopefully, come to a stop.
Comment on this
How many cars would have that technology?
Comment on this
In terms of stingers, we previously issued around five per division. We have 20 divisions so 100 have been issued across the country. There are 2,000 people trained to use them and our probationers who are going through the college are also being trained to use them. That should increase that number.
Comment on this
However, gardaí can only use a stinger if they are in a car that has one.
Comment on this
Yes. Obviously, the equipment has to be available. I have had discussions to increase that number in our fleet and we have budgeted to do that. We hope that every uniform car, in particular, will have a device available to it.
Comment on this
How many times is the Garda aircraft used?
Comment on this
It is used quite often, when it is up there and flying, subject to conditions. I do not have an exact figure but we can provide the Deputy with that.
Comment on this
Is that aircraft available nationally?
Comment on this
It is but, generally, because it departs from Baldonnell, there is a time issue in terms of it being available. As incidents happen and evolve, however, the control rooms can look to whatever resources available, including air support.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in. How many helicopters are available? Are they available 24 hours per day?
Comment on this
There is a second aircraft. There is a second helicopter with aircraft capability. There are three. My understanding is that there are two helicopters in operation at the moment. That is the number we generally have, subject to availability, and they are available 24-7.
Comment on this
Correct. I assume that, operationally, there are two. I know there was a period where there was only one operationally available because of servicing or whatever.
Comment on this
There are two currently. Members of another committee on which I sat visited Templemore a few years ago. I was very impressed by the driving courses that were being taken. I do not know whether it is still the case but at that time, police from other jurisdictions came to Templemore to do the advanced driving course. Is that still the case?
Comment on this
At the time, there was a long waiting list of gardaí trying to access the advanced course. Is that the CBD level 2 course that was mentioned earlier?
Comment on this
CBD2 has replaced the standard driving course. It is for front-line operational members to respond to scenes.
Comment on this
CBD3 is the advanced driving course, generally for high-powered cars used by the emergency response unit, the armed support unit and the ministerial pool, most commonly.
Comment on this
There was a long waiting list at that time for gardaí to access those courses. Is that still the case?
Comment on this
Yes, there is a demand for driver training.
Comment on this
It would not be formed as a waiting list. We allocate spaces and places on courses to divisions, regions and national specialists units, and we seek and get nominations. There is not actually a waiting list.
Comment on this
Could the Garda do with more resources to open up the list and make more places available?
Comment on this
The more resources that are available, the more places can be provided.
Comment on this
From reading the opening statement, the behaviour of a vehicle, the road environment and traffic conditions and the danger are continually assessed to make sure there is no unacceptable level of risk. There is an abundance of caution there around the life of a person. Reading into what Chief Superintendent has said, there is a lot of caution involved in proceeding towards a pursuit. Around the time of the M9 incident, two constables in England unfortunately lost their lives. Caution and preventing loss of life are built into-----
Comment on this
The procedure is dangerous. Driving at speed on roads is inherently risky. Driving instructors provide training to an extremely high standard but there is risk. The policy on spontaneous pursuit sets out that the first priority is to prevent the pursuit from taking place in the first place by using pre-emptive tactics and the use of a stinger. If the pursuit commences, we try to stop it as soon as possible because it is risky.
Comment on this
As for the engagement An Garda Síochána had with TikTok and those companies, did the Garda meet TikTok? Was that the result of complaints the Garda received or does the Garda have people checking the system to see what videos are up there?
Comment on this
When An Garda Síochána asks TikTok to take something down is that usually due to a complaint from a member of the public or is it from-----
Comment on this
It would be from a number of avenues. It may well be due to a complaint from a member of the public but it would generally be to an investigating member who is looking at a particular incident. They would then engage with those companies to seek the removal of content or to seek the provision of that content.
Comment on this
I thank Assistant Commissioner Ferry and Chief Superintendent Sugrue for coming in. I want to pick up on a question Deputy Currie asked about the number of stinger deployments. Without going into too much operational complexity, are there parts of the country where stingers are most often deployed or is there a fairly even national spread in terms of the Garda regions?
Comment on this
I would not have exact figures on that, per se. I am sure we could probably break these figures down but they are quite small. What is important is that the members are spread out across the country in terms of the 2,000 gardaí who are trained, but there are also instructors in every division who are available to train up members. The capability to deploy singers is available right across the country. It comes down to the event that occurs and the opportunity to deploy and co-ordinate cars in a way that prevents-----
Comment on this
Pardon my ignorance on this, but we often hear the armed response unit target is ten minutes. That is the operational guideline. What is the stinger deployment time, from the moment wrong-way driving is detected on a motorway network? If a stinger is required, how long would it take to deploy one to any part of the country? What is the mean lead-in time An Garda Síochána has?
Comment on this
I do not have a specific time and I would be cautious to give one. If you think about how the event develops, it is really about the control rooms when the call comes in and the member is saying there is a vehicle they are looking to stop, effectively. That brings in the question of who is available. The members who are driving the cars will also then know they have stingers available and the person in the car is trained to deploy that stinger. It is then for those in the control rooms to co-ordinate that as to where the stingers are at the moment and where we can position them to be on the route the car is likely to take. In that situation it all depends on how quickly the car gets there. If it takes that particular route, we will have a car there that is in a position to deploy the stinger. Stinger deployment takes a matter of seconds and that is what the training is about, namely, how to deploy it. There are different lengths of stingers because you have road networks, narrow roads and motorways so that is another part of the capability that is there.
Comment on this
The wrong-way driving is detected and the report goes into the control room. At that moment all of the information is gathered as to how far away a stinger is and whether the members in question responding are trained in its use. All of that stuff is ready to go from the minute that wrong-way driving detection is made.
Comment on this
That is what the policy and training are trying to do. They are to make sure we co-ordinate that and bring that governance to it. The other important part-----
Comment on this
Before we move from that, is the assistant commissioner confident that is the case at the moment or is it just the objective of the policy?
Comment on this
That is absolutely what happens, if I may reassure the public. To add to what Deputy Moynihan said, and I apologise if I interrupted, is that the other thing is to stop traffic going onto the motorway. The biggest part of it is to stop traffic getting onto the motorway, if we can, if there is somebody going the wrong way down a motorway. That then makes it sure it is safe for others who are on the road at that particular time. Then, obviously, it is about co-ordinating the likely points where the vehicle will exit the motorway or another roadway the stinger could perhaps be deployed on. That comes down to that risk assessment and making sure of the safety of other road users and our members.
Comment on this
For sure. When we had representatives from Transport Infrastructure Ireland here last week I asked them about whether there was technology that could be put in place on the on and off ramps, such as spikes. They answered that they did not believe this was an effective use of technology or that it seemed to work in other jurisdictions. Does An Garda Síochána have a view on that?
Comment on this
An Garda Síochána has looked at that as well and at all technology. As I said to one of the other Deputies, the Road Safety Authority and TII are best placed to advise and implement that. We see the risk of putting in a device that might prevent or impede access to the motorway is that it could also impede our members going onto the motorway the wrong way, if they had to. If we deploy a device that will stop someone going on to the motorway the wrong way, that will also affect first responders. It may not be that we are chasing somebody but even to respond to an incident, sometimes if there is an accident the only way to get down there is to go in the wrong way. Again, if we put devices that would impact that, prevent us from doing that and burst the tyres of the patrol car, that would be a problem as well. They are not at that scale, generally, but evidence shows that the devices, when going at speed, can damage or deflate tyres as well, which would be a problem.
Comment on this
In terms of the graduated response when a wrong-way driving incident is spotted on a motorway, I presume the response does not go straight to deploying a stinger. What steps are walked through to engage with the individual, again within operational guidelines?
Comment on this
The whole piece comes from what information the control room gets. Basically it is a member who has come across a car that is of interest or a car that has been involved in committing a crime. That is often the challenge, namely, what information is available to the members who come across a car and the car maybe takes off the wrong direction or something else. That information is then relayed to the control room. The control room people are trained to consider that. There is generally a sergeant and an inspector available to make those decisions around continuing to authorise that and to allow the pursuit to happen. As the chief superintendent spoke about earlier, the policy is all about prevention and if it does take off as a pursuit, the policy then is about how quickly we can bring it to a stop. The best way to do that is to use stopping devices like stingers.
Comment on this
Does An Garda Síochána use drones to assist in the survey and tracking of wrong-way motorway driving or is it reliant on the current air support unit?
Comment on this
The drone capability is something we now have available to us. Much of the drone use has been around events. The capacity of drones will probably limit some of these situations because their range and the time they can spend in the air, etc., are different. Although we have used drones for some operations, particularly in urban areas where they give a lot of coverage to an area from a camera perspective, you will probably find that air support from the helicopter has greater capacity if somebody is driving at a distance and away from a particular area.
Comment on this
By this time next year, how many gardaí will be trained in the pursuit training in which the instructors are undertaking a module at the moment?
Comment on this
I will hand over to Chief Commissioner Sugrue on that. As I said earlier, the hope is that we will have enough instructors trained before the end of the year to allow some of our members to commence training. We said that in a previous committee meeting. I am hoping to have a small number of members trained. From my perspective, as assistant commissioner, we will also be working with the other members of the senior leadership team, SLT, to prioritise where we get the best return in prioritising who we train and what locations we train them in.
Comment on this
In terms of the scale, how many Garda members will be trained by this time next year?
Comment on this
We have committed to rolling out permissions-based pursuit training but the scale of the roll-out will depend on the number of instructors who are trained.
As I mentioned in an answer to the Cathaoirleach earlier, we are engaging with police forces other than Devon and Cornwall Police that have offered assistance. We are waiting to establish the extent of that assistance, how many extra instructors can be trained and at what scale we can roll out pursuit driving training.
Comment on this
Is there a baseline for what is place at the moment? If Chief Superintendent Sugrue does not get any engagement with other police forces, does he have a baseline for the worst-case scenario for the numbers who will be trained next year?
Comment on this
I will have a certain number trained by the end of the year. As the courses continue, I will have additional instructors. There is no single definitive number trained now. The number of instructors will gradually increase. I hope we will be able to increase the numbers significantly so we have a larger cohort of instructors and can introduce this at scale instead of gradually building up the number of instructors who complete the modules.
Comment on this
In a course, there would be three instructors for six participants.
Comment on this
Yes. There is capacity to introduce it, but to do it at scale we will look for additional support.
Comment on this
I thank both witnesses for being with us. The assistant commissioner set out that there are now 660 gardaí in the dedicated roads policing unit. I am glad he was able to say today that he is looking to grow that number. Could he give us a sense of what he wants to grow that number to or the annual level of growth he would like to see in the roads policing unit?
Comment on this
The Commissioner has committed that as we grow our numbers to 15,000, we will have the capacity to allocate additional members to all sorts of areas, including roads policing. I said in my statement that roads policing is probably the largest specialist unit, with 660 members. We would obviously welcome additional members if there was additional capacity. I do not have a specific figure that would solve-----
Comment on this
I understand there were five added this year. Is that correct? There was reporting of that earlier this month.
Comment on this
We have that number of 660. What generally happens is that when people are transferred or promoted, or retire, we allocate additional members to backfill those positions. When those figures were quoted, there was an increase to 660. That may have involved the addition of five members. When recruits come out of the Garda College, what happens is that we bring in people from the panels to maintain that number of 660. Sometimes when you look at those numbers, it might be the case that the five members are replacing another five who left the area.
Comment on this
We could take a step back and look at that 660 number in a slightly more long-term context. It is estimated that the number is approximately 40% lower than it was 15 years ago. How can we reassure the public that An Garda Síochána is able to do better roads policing with what now seems to be a significantly smaller unit?
Comment on this
I will talk about two important elements. One is that we also have the availability of probationers, who do a period within roads policing. That is called Operation Intro. It gives probationers the opportunity to work in roads policing.
Comment on this
That supplements the 660 members.
Comment on this
Yes. It often comes down to capacity and where probationers are in their training. At some points, there are greater numbers and at other points some divisions have fewer numbers. That is another way of giving people an opportunity to develop their skill sets within roads policing and develop an interest. They may well then want to join roads policing.
The second part to the question relates to the use of technology. That is something we now have available, as I said earlier.
Comment on this
I might come back to the technology piece, if that is all right. It is good that probationers are getting experience but we also know, and Assistant Commissioner Ferry set out earlier, that some of the roads policing actions are highly complex and are probably well beyond the ability of probationers coming in.
Other members have focused on the question of numbers. In the nine months that the committee has been focusing on road safety, we have heard from organisations such as PARC and others, and enforcement has been a consistent theme. Enforcement needs to be enhanced. When we see a unit that is significantly smaller than it was 15 years ago, at a time when we are seeing carnage on our roads, with deaths last year and this, it is of real concern that the growth of numbers in that unit is not seen as a priority. I asked the Commissioner about the issue when he was before the committee in July and he said it was not a priority. He focused on getting as much work from the team as possible and the issue of technology.
These deployment questions are obviously a matter for the Garda. However, there is a real concern, shared by those on the committee, about the size of the roads policing unit. Notwithstanding the fact that all front-line gardaí are involved, there are many other demands on their time. The witnesses might reflect on that as the view of the committee on the size of the roads policing unit, going forward.