We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Transport

Road Safety on the Motorway Network: Discussion (Resumed)

Summary

An Garda Síochána said its priority in wrong-way motorway incidents is to prevent or end pursuits safely, using continuous risk assessment, control-room coordination, stingers and air support. It has 660 dedicated roads-policing personnel and more than 2,000 members trained to deploy stingers, but no officers yet trained in pursuit driving; instructor training is under way, with the scale of future training uncertain. Committee members raised concern about reduced roads-policing numbers, limited access to motorway CCTV and the slow rollout of safety cameras. The Garda supported stronger deterrents in principle and said better identification of social-media users would assist investigations.

Contributions 149–295 of 295. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Mr. Denis Ferry

What I am reassured by, and this is a matter we need to reassure the committee and the public about, is the detection and work rate of An Garda Síochána generally, not just in roads policing but across the board. Some 75% of arrests are carried out by gardaí who are not in roads policing. Every member out there has a role to play in the overall roads policing function. I am reassured when we look at the figures. For drink driving, detections have increased by 3% since last year. There has been a 27% increase in detections for drug driving. It is a concern that we are seeing an increase in that area, as opposed to drink driving. However, those figures show that a lot of good work is being done by the organisation.

Comment on this

I only have two minutes so I will bring the assistant commissioner on to the question of enforcement. He specified the issue of cameras. The national camera safety strategy was published earlier this year. An Garda Síochána is part of the oversight group. Is that correct? Does the assistant commissioner sit on that group?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

Yes.

Comment on this

How often has the oversight group met so far?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I have not had a meeting but I think one is scheduled. I can check the figure. Generally, the group meets on a quarterly basis. I can check that.

Comment on this

At what point are we going to move from a strategy to seeing the large-scale deployment of red-light cameras and static cameras? I engage with two local authorities in my constituency, namely, Dublin City Council and Fingal County Council. At their level, they are not hearing anything about the imminent arrival of cameras focusing on those junctions that they and local gardaí recognise are a source of concern. Has the assistant commissioner a sense of when we are going to see the roll-out of that technology that he has already said is important to supplementing the work of the roads policing unit?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

That is a matter for the overall steering group and engagement with local authorities. We would support the use of that technology. It will go to answering the first question. The greater the use of that technology-----

Comment on this

Are there funding streams available to start to roll out those cameras?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I would not have direct information on that point. I do not think there is any inhibitor there. The technology is obviously well proven. It is about making sure that we prioritise to have that technology in the right areas and ensuring we have all of the capabilities supported by legislation to use cameras for-----

Comment on this

As a final point, my concern is that the assistant commissioner has said that technology is going to help to bridge the gap between what numbers were and what numbers are. I have a real concern that the roll-out of this camera technology still seems to be theoretical rather than us having a clear line of sight of when local authorities are going to see the delivery of large-scale camera technology.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I am supportive of the use of technology where we can use it. That gives an opportunity for us to be more targeted in respect of where we deploy our members. We can allow the technology to do its job and function to reduce speed and have an impact. There are two parts to it. The first is about using our members and ensuring we are fully tasking and co-ordinating our members to focus on roads policing. At the same time, we must use technology where it is available to us, subject, as the Deputy said, to capacity and budget.

Comment on this

I thank both witnesses for coming before us. The former Garda Commissioner, Drew Harris, said at one stage that he wanted an increase in the police force dedicated to roads policing by the end of 2025. Is that target still in place? A target of 150 by the end of 2025 was given.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

That target was mentioned at a previous meeting.

We are the largest specialist unit-----

Comment on this

Yes, I understand that.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

-----and from my perspective, we would like to increase numbers, subject to capacity, as the Commissioner said. As we increase the numbers, hopefully there will be-----

Comment on this

What does An Garda Síochána need to increase the numbers? Is there interest in increasing the numbers and for An Garda Síochána to specifically allocate officers to go into roads policing?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

There has always been significant interest from members looking to join roads policing because there is a particular skill set and that is where it is useful to have probationers getting that exposure so that people get an interest in the various areas. It is not just roads policing, but other areas as well.

Comment on this

What is preventing the numbers from going up and increasing the capacity in that particular area?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

As the Commissioner said previously at another committee, where we have additional capacity and as we increase the numbers to over 15,000, there will be a greater latitude to look at all sections. The priority is having our front-line members available to us. The specialist sections are the next priority after that, and roads policing is one of those specialist areas. It also happens to be the largest. Whether it is dealing with sexual offences or organised crime, all of those areas have to be considered as a priority by the Commissioner and the executive.

Comment on this

If there is a demand for more gardaí to be trained up, would the assistant commissioner say that there are enough driving instructors to meet those demands? This has nothing to do with pursuit training but just driving instructors.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

There is a significant number of instructors. Overall, our agreed number is 50. I think there are 45 in place at the moment, with opportunities to bring in other instructors.

Comment on this

Is that meeting the need?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

It is meeting the need. In the last 12 months with the Presidency, we had to look at the prioritisation of different driving training, etc. Again, that is what we will be focusing on now. When we have instructors trained to do in-pursuit training, we will need to look at that prioritisation of-----

Comment on this

It is not even just in-pursuit training; it is about general driving instructors. Could the assistant commissioner verify whether it is true that three instructors have been trained up since last December and are waiting to go Templemore, but they have been told there are no vacancies.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

It is likely that there are. We quite often have competency-based competitions and have people then who have been trained, but that is always then subject to allocation to a particular unit.

Comment on this

I am just wondering if this is true. According to my information, they are ready to go but are just dangling there. They want to be stationed in Templemore and be part of this, but they have been told that there are no vacancies.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

There are 45 instructors in place at the moment. What we generally have across the board-----

Comment on this

Is that true though? Will the assistant commissioner check whether it is true?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I can check what it is exactly, but generally-----

Comment on this

It would be great if the assistant commissioner could.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

-----we have people who are successful on panels and have maybe been trained, but that is always then subject to allocation. The one thing we always have to remember is that when we allocate somebody to something like that role, they are coming from somewhere else. That is where we often have that challenge of backfilling.

Comment on this

It is interesting. The assistant commissioner says that An Garda Síochána is continuing to build capacity and, I know from an answer to a question from Senator Collins, that it is maximising resources. However, these gardaí are trained. They took the time to train, and money was spent training them. They want to do it, but they have been told there are no vacancies. Will the assistant commissioner return to the committee with information on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

We can confirm that. If the person is not brought in but has the skills-----

Comment on this

There are three people.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

-----it is likely that at some point they will be allocated to a vacancy when it comes up.

Comment on this

If they have been trained and An Garda Síochána wants to build capacity, why would there not be a vacancy?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

Again, it comes down to that agreed prioritisation of numbers within each of the units, so whether it is instructors, roads policing, drugs or organised crime-----

Comment on this

It has been recognised that there needs to be more gardaí dedicated to roads policing and a target was set by the then Garda Commissioner, Drew Harris.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

The Senator made that statement and I know Commissioner Harris made it previously. What we are saying at that we are trying to maintain roads policing strength at 660. That is what the focus is. It is the largest specialised unit. As the assistant commissioner in charge of roads policing, I am looking to make sure we maximise the use of the members within roads policing.

Comment on this

Has that target of 150 officers changed?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

The Garda Commissioner, Justin Kelly, has committed to maintaining the number at 660. As capacity increases overall in the organisation, he and we will look at all areas and, hopefully roads policing will be one of the areas that will benefit from an increase at some point.

Comment on this

Will the assistant commissioner verify if the information about the three officers is correct and then come back to us on when it is expected that they will be able to take up positions?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

We will do that.

Comment on this

The assistant commissioner said it is hard to give a straight answer on how many people are going to be trained in specialist pursuit training, but will it be six, three or four officers by the end of the year?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

By the end of this year, I expect that we will have run a pilot course. The aim was to roll out initial phase pursuit training in 2027.

Comment on this

How many will have been trained on the course?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

Given the timing of Devon and Cornwall Police coming over in November, we are hoping to run one pilot course before the end of the year.

Comment on this

How many are on a pilot course?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

As I said earlier, there are three instructors to six participants, so there will be six on the course. Between six and 12 people - that kind of a bracket - will have participated by the end of the year. Realistically, six officers will participate in the pilot course. We may get to run a second course but six is probably achievable-----

Comment on this

In 2027, there will be a second one.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

There will be a larger roll-out in 2027, the scale of which is dependent on additional support, which has been offered by UK colleagues, to train additional instructors.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I propose that we have a second round, but I want to give the witnesses an opportunity to have a bathroom break. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will do a second round of five minutes for each member.

We need to be honest that there is no single solution. I used the term "single bullet" here. We can talk pursuit training and technology, but I am conscious when an individual decides to drive the wrong way down the motorway at 120 km/h that individual is travelling at 2 km every minute, regardless of what the response is or how good the response time is. Should we do more to educate drivers who are facing a vehicle coming towards them the wrong way, particularly at night-time when visibility is such that they will only see the oncoming vehicle very late on? Do we need to do more in that area?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

Yes, absolutely. We should do anything we can do to make sure people are aware of what they can do. The Road Safety Authority has given advice in relation to that. The advice we can give to road users if they see someone coming towards them is limited. What is important is that when members of public make calls to say they have encountered a car going the wrong way, it is about our people being fully trained to deal with that as quickly as possible and having every possible resource available to try to notify people of oncoming traffic. As I said earlier to one of the members, it is about then making sure that our members co-ordinate the stopping of traffic, where possible, so that we do not have people on the roads.

Generally regarding education and information, it is about communicating with every member of the public, in particular young people, and doing everything we can to tell them about the risks. We have the schools programme. Generally in relation to road safety, we need to make young people aware of the risks and dangers and do everything we can to ensure they do not do this.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Last week, in its evidence to the committee, the RSA said it is looking at the German model and incorporating maybe four hours of motorway driving in learner driving. There is no motorway driving incorporated in the learner process. I presume the assistant commissioner would support that as well.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

As I said, anything we can do to improve the standard of driving and driver education is going to be welcomed. There is a time and a cost to that, but we would all welcome a greater ability to train our young people and people learning to drive to the highest possible standards, including motorway driving.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Let us acknowledge that the vast majority of drivers adhere to the rules of the road and do not exceed the speed limits, do not take a drink or drugs, wear seatbelts, do not use a mobile phone and insure and tax their vehicles. However, there is a minority for whom the rules of road are optional. That is why we are talking today about enforcement and the strength of our roads policing. For that minority, it is only enforcement that will shape their driving behaviour. We heard earlier that detections are up. I looked at the quarter 2 figures on An Garda Síochána's website yesterday. There were in excess of 6,000 fixed penalty notices issued for speeding alone. I could not get over that there almost 9,000 vehicles were impounded, 50% of which did not have insurance. That reflects the level of non-compliance and the extent of that minority.

I ask the assistant commissioner to reflect and engage with the Commissioner on the strength of the roads policing unit. One thing I have learned over the past six or nine months is that driver behaviour is the biggest cause. We can point the finger at different statutory agencies. I accept that there is an issue there and the whole system is designed such that there is no one in charge. Ultimately, this comes back to driver behaviour. We have one member of our roads policing unit for every 150 km of road. In my local division of Clare and Tipperary, it is one for every 250 km. I ask the assistant commissioner to engage. Let us set targets for the next 12 months and the 12 months after that. Let us get back to where we were in 2009, so we can shape driver behaviour, particularly as it applies to the minority who do not obey the rules of the road. I do not need the assistant commissioner to answer that unless he wants to make a comment.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

Everyone has to take personal responsibility. It is a societal issue that people have to have personal responsibility about their behaviour and how they make decisions that may impact other road users. From a roads policing perspective, my priority and the priority of the Commissioner is definitely to maximise the use of all the Garda members who are available to us. It is not just roads policing. It is every member of An Garda Síochána. We reiterate the importance of everyone playing a part in dealing with public safety, including road safety and the prevention of crime.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I call Deputy Daly, followed by Deputy Currie.

Comment on this

Following on slightly from what was said about the schools programme, it transpired recently that the RSA has spent €7 million over the past number of years on advertising campaigns, the effectiveness of which has been called into question by some of the other groups that have attended the committee. Does Mr. Ferry have any view on the effectiveness of the TV and media advertising campaigns? Do they work?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

There is evidence that they work and are effective.

However, that effectiveness has a time period associated with it. Sometimes, when people see an advertisement on a regular basis, after a particular period, they may no longer pay a lot of attention to it. I have been to road safety events, most recently in Limerick with transition year students, and we see that they are very impactful. We hope that particular event will have a real impact on those young people in helping them to understand the risks of driving and the importance of driving safely. We always need to keep an eye on the effectiveness of any information-giving measures, which we always welcome. Information and education will be key to this. It is not just an enforcement issue.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Ferry agree that the effectiveness of certain advertisements diminishes after a while?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

The evidence tells us that is true of certain advertisements. We also see that when advertisements are not shown for a period and then are replayed, they have an impact again, perhaps on an audience that did not see them originally or they remind people of something that happened to them. We have to use all the tools that are available to us.

Comment on this

Across the EU generally, the number of road deaths is decreasing, whereas, unfortunately, the number in this State is increasing, particularly in the past two or three years. Why does Mr. Ferry think that is happening? Some people think it is because there are fewer gardaí engaged in road traffic policing. We heard evidence last week that approximately half of road deaths occur at the weekend, with half of those deaths happening in about a ten-hour period late at night. There is a ten-hour period in which a quarter of all road deaths occur. Many people say that the Garda visibility is not there on the roads, no more than it is in public order. Where there are gardaí on the street, it has a deterring effect. We heard evidence at a previous meeting from Alcohol Action Ireland about visibility of policing in Australia, for example, and how it does tend to affect behaviour. People are much less likely to get into their car if they feel they will meet a garda as opposed to a speed camera. Will Mr. Ferry comment on that? Does he need more resources to enable him to put extra gardaí in place at those crucial times at the weekends when the road deaths are occurring?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

As we have already said, the important thing is to maximise the use of the members we have available to us. I agree there has been an increase in road deaths. There is an increase generally in the number of people on our roads, and that has to be a factor. High visibility certainly is at the forefront of policing at the moment for the Commissioner. We have introduced high visibility across a lot of our urban centres, from Dublin to Galway, Cork and Limerick, and, we hope, to other locations over the next number of months. That is to address the Deputy's point about the importance of visibility. It is important not just for roads policing but for every instance where gardaí are deployed when we need them.

As I said earlier, we are targeting, and co-ordinating that targeting, of our roads policing units in particular. It will not be just roads policing; we will be looking to those inspectors to co-ordinate other available units as well in order to increase visibility across the country. Obviously, we will focus on the hours where we will see the biggest impact. We are looking at that. We have spent a lot of time looking at reports provided by our analysts and we will continue to do that.

Comment on this

What is the reason for the reduction of approximately 40% in road traffic policing units since 2009, when their number was around 1,000?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I assume that what we are seeing is an impact of recruitment at a particular point in time when there probably was a reduction. We had a period during the Covid crisis when recruitment stopped. We then had retirements of a certain cohort who joined back in the nineties. All of those factors reduced the number of members available to us across the organisation. What we generally do is look at prioritising the available members for allocation where we need them most.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Ferry.

Comment on this

I am looking at Garda resources for the roads policing unit. In 2009, there were 1,046 roads policing gardaí. By August 2026, that number was 644 and it has now gone up to 649 in terms of active policing. In Dublin metropolitan region west, which is my area, we had 22 units in 2009, with that number now reduced to nine. That is a 60% drop. When I look at road offences for the same period, I see there were 12,806 back in 2009 compared with the recent figure of 4,808, which is also a drop of 60%. There is a direct correlation between how many gardaí are on our roads and how many roads offences are enforced. In Blanchardstown, the figures are similar.

We cannot overstate the importance of the numbers of gardaí on our roads when it comes to catching offenders and deterring people from bad behaviour. Such behaviour is increasing and we are seeing an increase in road deaths. The committee members feel it is really important to highlight the importance of roads policing. It is the biggest unit within the Garda but we just do not have enough roads policing gardaí.

I was under the impression that gardaí had to be in the role for two years before they could join roads policing. Has that changed?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

Generally, in terms of roads policing or any unit, members who have joined the organisation have to complete their probation. The probation period is two years from their passing their test in the Garda College. That may be the two-year period to which the Deputy is referring. We are looking for people to develop experience and competencies within the area of roads policing and other areas. When we run a competition, we look to select people who are qualified in terms not just of service but who also have shown an interest, capability and competency in a particular area, including roads policing. There would be an open competition for members to join those units.

Sometimes, there may well be a sort of service restriction but, generally, once members finish their probation, they are open to join any areas within the organisation. It depends then on the numbers who apply for a particular area. I mentioned earlier the opportunity that exists for probationers. It is not just in roads policing but we do have a particular operation within roads policing whereby people doing their probation training can do a number of weeks within that unit. It is dependent on the number of probationers who are available, where they are at in their training and how we are set up to give them that sort of opportunity.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Ferry quickly summarise the escalation process in roads policing and how it works when an incident happens? Are the roads policing gardaí out on the road patrolling for the duration until something happens? My understanding is that they are always out on the road monitoring and then they also respond to situations. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

All of our members, not just in roads policing, are out on operational patrols from their station. As long as they can be available to be out there, that is what we want them to be doing. It is really about high-visibility patrolling and prevention. When an incident happens, the response will be from whatever resource - whatever car - is available and will be the quickest to respond. It may be a roads policing car or it could be a general front-line unit that responds. The staff in the control rooms will look to the available resources that are there to respond to whatever incident occurs. If it is a road traffic collision, they generally would look to roads policing personnel to attend because they may well be better skilled and equipped to deal with it.

Comment on this

Are there gardaí on duty in those units on a 24-7 basis?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

Yes, generally. The roads policing units work slightly different shifts in terms of their roster but they do the four on and four off. Sometimes, it comes down to the number of people available in units, but they are there on a 24-7 basis. Again, who responds depends on who is available and who is nearest to an incident. I reiterate that all our members are focused on every matter of policing, including roads policing.

Comment on this

May I ask just one more question?

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I will allow a very quick question.

Comment on this

How important are photographs on licences? I believe this was requested seven years ago and officially asked for last year. I am talking about the licences on the national vehicle and driver file, NVDF, and the-----

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

We have received additional information which is now available on the mobile devices. We are still working with our partners on the actual availability of photographs. I will be following up on that in due course.

Comment on this

Will the pursuit training also cover e-scooter pursuit and scrambler pursuit?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

Yes, exactly. Again, it is about making sure our members are trained to consider the policy, the decision-making and communications around any pursuit.

Comment on this

In terms of that training being rolled out, obviously we do not want to encounter a situation like this again where we have a gap and we need to then rapidly ramp up. The opening statement referred to it as initial phase pursuit training. Is there another level of pursuit training after that where we are already thinking about how to train the trainers to roll that programme out across the Garda? Is that plan in place?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I will hand over to the chief superintendent on that, but it is exactly that. There is a second element to that course which is about containment. The chief superintendent will talk to that. The initial part is to do the initial training and then there is another level of training required around containment.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

The initial phase pursuit is focused on decision-making, communication, feeder vehicles, co-ordinating the stinger and pre-emptive tactics to try to prevent a pursuit, and to stop it as soon as possible. Once that has been introduced, the plan will be to get trainers qualified as instructors in TPAC, tactical pursuit and containment. A significantly smaller number will be trained in TPAC, likely to be members in advanced cars like the CBD2 drivers we mentioned earlier.

Comment on this

Why will there be a smaller number? Surely it would not make sense to have-----

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

It is particularly intensive and a significantly higher risk. It requires the use of advanced cars. That is the model that is rolled out in the UK and it is the model that we are introducing here. The policy aligns CBD2, the standard driving course, with initial phase pursuit and the TPAC with the CBD3, which is a smaller cohort but really highly trained in very powerful cars.

Comment on this

My understanding is that with CBD2 a garda can operate a normal patrol car with lights to respond to an emergency situation. CBD3 is a higher level of pursuit and a higher level of advanced tactics in a different vehicle from a usual patrol car.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

Correct.

Comment on this

Let us consider an instance of wrong-way driving on a motorway. Mr. Sugrue is telling me that we could have 2,000 gardaí, for example, in three or four years' time, who are qualified in this initial phase pursuit training, but with regard to containment tactics, there will be a smaller group who will be able to be deployed because they would not----

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

Yes, and as the Commissioner stated recently to the authority, I think it was, the policy allows members to drive contraflow on motorways, but that will happen in exceptionally rare circumstances because of the risks to the public and to the members involved.

Comment on this

However, once the initial phase pursuit training is rolled out across members, that would be more likely because they would be qualified to pursue.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

It would depend on the risk and the crime. They need to assess the risk against the offence. Is it a dangerous driving offence, a murder or a marauding terrorist? There are significantly different crimes and require a different response and a different risk rating. In general, I do not envisage members regularly driving contraflow against traffic on the motorway because it is that dangerous.

Comment on this

Will the introduction of this training mean that control rooms are less likely to instruct gardaí to desist from pursuit?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

Further to Deputy Currie's point, it is likely to see an increased use of stingers around the country because the members will be trained to seek opportunities for pre-emptive tactics to stop a pursuit. They will not be automatically turning on blue lights and sirens, tucking in behind the car and initiating pursuit but will endeavour to stop a pursuit before it starts. That is the training.

Comment on this

Am I right in assuming that it is not just members of the roads policing unit who will be qualified in the deployment of stingers and for phased pursuit training? For example, with a wrong-way driving incident on the motorway, the roads policing unit will not necessarily deal with that. It will be any member of An Garda Síochána who is available.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

At the moment, any member is trained. At the moment, 2,000 members are trained. We have master trainers in the Garda College. We train stinger instructors across all the divisions and then those instructors train the members. Several hundred instructors are trained.

Comment on this

It is not necessarily related to the number of roads policing gardaí.

I have received feedback from local Garda members in my constituency about removing someone from an e-scooter who will not stop on the direction of a garda. I think tactical intervention is the phrase used. Is that e-scooter piece included as part of the training? Garda members are wondering if they are supposed to lash on the sirens and go chasing them. If they do not comply with a direction from gardaí to stop the e-scooter, what should the gardaí do then?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

The tactical piece the Deputy is talking about there is TPAC, tactical pursuit and containment. Our colleagues in the UK have an element of tactical contact. The risk is obviously higher when dealing with e-scooters. They are more vulnerable road users. They may or may not have a second person on board. They may or may not have head protection. In the UK some police and driving instructors were prosecuted while engaged in pursuits. That speaks to the Commissioner's engagement.

Comment on this

There is no way to stop-----

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

It shows the importance of the request to update legislation to provide Garda members who are trained to a particular level to be assessed against their peers.

Comment on this

In his opening statement, the assistant commissioner talked about An Garda Síochána's engagement with social media platforms on the issue of road safety. How often would the Garda contact the platforms on a specific road safety concern about an online video?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

The purpose of most of the meetings I have had, and will have in the next number of weeks, is to have those discussions about how the platforms moderate content and then how they interact with An Garda Síochána when we seek to have content removed. The other piece is about ensuring that platforms are informed of what I would call incidents of concern that happen. They have their own ways of doing that. Again, to look at formally how An Garda Síochána notify them-----

Comment on this

Is there a specific protocol in place at the moment with each platform? People might see something on TikTok or Instagram. Is there a protocol in place for how that gets escalated, both within An Garda Síochána and the platform, to the appropriate level?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

What we have in place is the legislation, with a process where people look at content removal. What I am looking at is more what the Deputy talked about there - about making contact at the right level to make sure the platforms are aware of certain incidents to allow them to get ahead of that. From the meetings I had with TikTok, it seems to have very significant processes in place around moderating content. What we talked about was more about us being aware of certain content and how we formally do that. We are looking to update the procedures we have around that so that we have the appropriate escalation as well.

Comment on this

We established at this committee and at the media committee last week that about 11% of dangerous activity does not get taken down and is in the ether for about 24 hours. As I said, that is a lifetime in the social media space. It can be seen by tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of people. The Garda is looking to put in place protocols with the social media companies so that if a road safety issue arises with a video, the Garda can escalate that appropriately. Am I correct in that?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

That is what I would like to see in place and I think the platforms are very much open to that. It is about making sure that we have the balance there around what has happened and what we are looking to inform them of. The recent incidents obviously highlight that sort of issue around when the platforms become aware, when we are aware, etc., and what flows from that type of incident. We are trying to improve those processes so that we have-----

Comment on this

The recent incidents show that the processes failed, or certainly that the videos were available online.

It is important that there is clarity and, whether it is at the assistant commissioner's level or whether it is a front-line garda who sees something, that there is a rapid escalation pathway.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

What we are looking to do there is make sure we have procedures in place that can work 24-7. That is where we will probably look to something like our control rooms.

Comment on this

Does the assistant commissioner have a sense of when those procedures will be agreed with the different platforms?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

It should be done fairly quickly. There are processes in place and with TikTok in particular, which we met recently, there are clear points of contact that we can escalate to. It is about putting in place something that is more robust on a 24-7 basis, where possible, so that we can do that.

Comment on this

Is the assistant commissioner aware of, or have gardaí ever raised, a road safety issue with a video on a platform and the platform has said it will not moderate it and will not take it down?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

In my time, which has been a short period, I cannot-----

Comment on this

That is fine; I understand. The assistant commissioner mentioned TikTok. Has he engaged with Meta or YouTube? Is the Garda engaging with all the key platforms?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I think a date has been proposed to meet with Meta next. We have written to all the platforms. It is an introductory piece for me, as much as anything else, and I think it is timely to meet with them to make sure there is a consistency of approach.

Comment on this

Is the engagement with Meta to tie down a specific protocol on escalation?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

It is more an introductory meeting with the platform to see how it operates, what it does and what the lessons learned are. We are all trying to find more efficient ways of making sure that we can communicate issues that arise. There is a very clear pathway there in the process around the removal of content. What we are looking at here is more around incidents of concern that we need to make the platforms aware of that they may not have picked up, or they may have picked up and we are not aware of, so vice versa. It is a good opportunity to make sure there are processes is in place.

Comment on this

I thank Assistant Commissioner Ferry and Chief Superintendent Sugrue for being here this morning to discuss this very important topic, which we have spent a lot of time discussing.

Does the Garda have international best practice or is there a gold standard that it, as a force, would aspire to achieve in addressing the more recent threats to safety on our roads and on motorways because of wrong-way driving? I know it is a new-found threat that has increased more recently but is there a gold standard, from the Garda's viewpoint, in other countries that have best dealt with it?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I thank the Senator. I know that with any event, we always use that opportunity to look at what other countries are doing. I would not want to single out any individual countries but there are lessons learned across the board when you look at what they are doing. We work very closely with our colleagues in the UK and what Chief Superintendent Sugrue has talked about around training and access to trainers and information. We have also looked at other jurisdictions and what they have done in this area from a policing perspective. All of them are probably consistent on how high the risk is and some of them completely prohibit pursuits that involve contraflow on motorways. Others have other policy decisions that they make.

The other big thing that came from looking at other organisations was in relation to the protection of their members and how they would classify and refer cases involving instances where, if they take that driver training, they would look then at the standard. There are different ways they do it from a legislation perspective but also looking at expert groups, who would look at an incident and whether the driver followed procedure, policy and training. If they did, then that would probably discount any follow-up action against the member. That issue of protecting our members has really focused on what other jurisdictions and police forces are doing in that area. This is not just down to police forces; it is down to the other agencies that look at road design and infrastructure, etc.

Comment on this

I thank the assistant commissioner. In relation to road design, we have spoken with Transport Infrastructure Ireland previously about that. The number of off-ramps and on-ramps onto motorways is obviously an issue. One of the things that was mentioned was that, regardless of those off-ramps, there is a tendency at times for certain motorists to drive on the correct side of the road and then do a U-turn and start heading back in the opposite direction, which is something that cannot be detected at any of the off-ramps, etc. Does the Garda have a regular, nightly interaction with the TII's control centre for the motorways? Is that a regular interaction?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

If issues arise, we look to all our agencies and what they can assist with. Questions were previously asked about this. We have access to some of the cameras but would not have full access to everything that maybe TII would have. It is fair to say we probably would not require it either. The important thing is that we meet quite regularly with the other agencies - TII and the RSA - on road safety. The importance is making sure if there is anything we can do to assist in respect of our information, that we are sharing it. We do that on a regular basis with both agencies.

Comment on this

In the instance of a case arising, and the Garda gets a call from, say, an emergency number where a road user has detected wrong-way driving at night-time, how long does it take for warnings to go out to other road users, for example, on the TII notifications? Is the assistant commissioner satisfied with the speed of the response using current capabilities? Are there issues from when the call and the report is made, to the notification getting out as quickly as possible to as many people as possible to protect vulnerable road users?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

We always need to keep looking at how we interact and communicate that. It is something that we do in regard to any incident. We will look to see if there are ways to improve that notification. At some of the meetings I have been at, there were conversations about what technical options are there. There are a lot of very advanced ideas but maybe technically they are not possible yet.

From a policing perspective, with our control rooms, as members of the public ring in an incident, it is then for us to react as quickly as we can. What we try to do there is look at closing access to the motorway at that point and then deploying our members. If someone has made a mistake, it is easier to bring them to a safe place to get off the motorway. If it is somebody trying to avoid detection, it is back again to how we use our control rooms and resources to best place members to bring an end to the incident.

Comment on this

Is it an immediate response to close off all of the junctions on the approach to the road?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

That is one of the simplest options that we have.

Comment on this

Is that a protocol?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

One of the things that we use from a control room perspective is to try to deploy our cars to prevent access. That involves simply somebody blocking the ramp. That option is obviously limited, as the Senator said, by the number of ramps and it is then down to the number of vehicles that are available. That is one of the first things we try to do in order to protect. It is not just the people on the road but also, if we were to try to go onto the motorways, it is about trying to protect our own members as well.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank Senator Duffy. Deputy Currie would like to ask one final question.

Comment on this

I wanted to ask about the mobility devices. The national vehicle and driver file Bill, which is going through the Houses of the Oireachtas, addresses some of the information-sharing between agencies in relation to road safety. However, it is missing that aspect where someone's photograph will be available on the mobility devices through the national vehicle and driver file.

I have done a lot of work with Susan Gray of the PARC Road Safety Group in tightening up the process of catching driver numbers and making sure that people are fully identifiable whenever they commit a road offence. This has now been going on for seven years. How does the assistant commissioner feel about the importance of having that information for the gardaí to do their job? What happens when that information is not available?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I spoke to Ms Gray before the committee meeting today.

It is very important that all available information is available to the Garda. Now we have mobility devices, it is critically important that all the information the Garda can have regarding a driver and a vehicle is available at the scene. That is a significant improvement in terms of the availability of technology. I would be hopeful that we can probably get to that point in the near future, so that the photograph is also available. Technically, there is no issue. It is a matter of clarifying the issues around that.

Comment on this

Is it a worry for gardaí on the ground when they stop somebody who does not have his or her licence and they are trying to figure out who he or she is?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

To reassure the committee, there are also a lot of other tools available to gardaí to identify the car and make sure there is proper investigation at the scene to ensure they identify who is driving the car. The vehicle information will tell us a lot. It is not wholly dependent on the photograph. A photograph would make it a lot easier. It is very simple if the photograph is available but even before we had mobility devices, we stopped people on the side of the road, asked the obvious questions and if there was something with which we were not satisfied, there were other options available to us to make sure we clarified the person's identity.

Comment on this

It has been stated that there have been mismatches over the years. This is something we have to ensure does not happen anymore. This committee is identifying any gaps because all of those gaps make our roads a more dangerous place to be.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I agree. It is important that no matter what the information available is, we satisfy ourselves about people's identity and what their purpose is when we stop them on the roads and talk to them. I may have stated that roads policing gardaí were four on and four off. I think it is six on and four off. I might clarify that in writing. I think I used the term "four on, four off".

Comment on this

Mr. Ferry did. I thank him for the clarification.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Has Mr. Ferry seen this before?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I have and I was-----

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is good to see it on the Garda website. I want to acknowledge Susan Gray and Fiona Clancy from PARC as well. At the outset, I spoke about victims, families and communities left devastated. Does Mr. Ferry wish to speak about policies and procedures around engaging with families following a fatal or near-fatal accident?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I met Ms Gray before and I had a copy of PARC's booklet and that of the other victim groups as well. The role they play for families, particularly in the aftermath of incidents, is critically important. Our members provide copies of the booklets to families who are, unfortunately, affected by fatalities. There is also the dedicated family liaison officer, who plays a big part in engaging with families following serious incidents. That is a critical additional resource we have available, with people trained as family liaison officers. They provide a very professional conduit with families, investigators and investigation teams. It is about trying to provide as much information to the families as we can. That is a critical aspect that has been raised with me, not just by Ms Gray but also the rural victims group as well. It involves that understanding and having that information available to the families. Where somebody is involved in a serious collision or worse - where there is a fatality or a likely fatality - it is very important that the information we provide to families is as clear and helpful as it can be.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Notwithstanding that I had brought the meeting to a conclusion, because I have a few minutes left and Deputy Carrigy, who chairs our housing committee, has asked to intervene, I will, with the permission of members, give a few more minutes.

Comment on this

I am also a member of the Oireachtas Committee on Arts, Media, Communications, Culture and Sport, which had discussions last week with social media companies relating to the topic we are speaking about today. There is an issue with content being uploaded that promotes illegal activity. My view is that content should be moderated before it is uploaded on to a platform but we were informed by Department officials that under EU regulations, we cannot do that. We have asked that this be looked into. We should be able to put these rules in place. We would not have the issue of taking down content if it was not put up in the first place. A lot of content that is illegal has been put on the various social media platforms. On how many occasions have social media platforms forwarded these videos to An Garda Síochána showing illegal activity that were uploaded to their sites? Does Mr. Ferry have any figures about the number of times they have forwarded these videos to An Garda Síochána?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I do not. I can inquire and we can come back to the Cathaoirleach if we can provide those figures. Quite often, our members receive calls from people who see content online or perhaps as part of an investigation, they know there is content online. That process of looking to remove, identify or have access to content is well proven and there is good co-operation with the platforms. What we are trying to work on now with those platforms is possibly notification and how, when we become aware of content, we make sure the platforms are also aware and, to address the Deputy's point, that when they are aware of certain content that should be removed, they inform us of same. That is something we have already started with some of the platforms. I have met with TikTok and will, hopefully, met Meta and the others in due course around those protocols and processes.

Comment on this

It would be interesting to get those figures from An Garda Síochána. We asked the platforms for their figures to see whether they match up because they gave anecdotal evidence that the figure would be a number of thousands. Have they all been-----

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I will come back to the Deputy. We will make that request, see what is available and follow up on that.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I want to bring the meeting to a conclusion. This discussion also concludes the committee's wider work around road safety. I am looking at my emails. I wrote to members in late January and we began this series of focused meetings on road safety in February. We met with many stakeholders. From a vulnerable road users perspective, I mention the various cycling bodies, pedestrian and walking representative groups, representative groups from motorcycling and victim impact groups. I again acknowledge PARC. We met with academics, medical personnel, technology experts, other road users like the Irish Road Haulage Association and the AA. We met the RSA, TII and the NTA. We also met Mr. Ferry's predecessor and the Garda Commissioner. We met the Department. We met so many different stakeholders. We discussed issues around roads policing capacity, learner permit reform, issues around disqualified drivers, licence surrender, compliance and enforcement. Garda access to real-time data was mentioned today. We discussed legislative priorities, particularly around stiffer sentences, and infrastructure. I could go on.

We hope to have a draft report towards the end of next week. What we really want is a practical report that is not lengthy and has clear recommendations to the Government and relevant agencies.

I really appreciate Mr. Ferry's and Mr. Sugrue's participation today. I am always conscious that members of An Garda Síochána are first on the scene. I met the GRA informally in recent weeks and we spoke about the impact of that and the supports that are available to members of An Garda Síochána. There is a lot of trauma involved in those occurrences of being first on the scene.

I also want to mention the victims and their families. They are at the heart of everything we do. I am conscious that Deputy Cathal Crowe wants to come in with one question. We have a small bit of time.

I had concluded the meeting but I will give him two minutes.

Comment on this

I will be very quick. I apologise. So many committees overlap on Wednesday mornings. I followed about half of the meeting. Please accept my apologies. I will be very brief. I will not cover ground others have covered here. At the outset, I put on record my huge support for the Garda rank and file members. What they are doing is incredible. It is a very tough job that gets tougher by the week and month.

I have a specific question I raised in the past with the Garda Commissioner relating to e-bikes, particularly where they are used for food delivery. In urban environments they are using fully electric bikes, not pedelecs or electric-assisted bikes. They use cycle lanes. They interface with cyclists but travel at the speed of cars, in many instances, and motorcycles. It is not safe. The Commissioner said he would follow up directly with the companies. I am not going to name them because this is quite a niche area. We are talking about probably a few hundred of these cyclists and food couriers around the country. They have to be compliant and most of them are not. The fact that they wear motorbike helmets says a lot. They are not bicycles and we would really love to see enforcement. Is there any update the witnesses can give us on this? It is not all e-scooters; e-bikes are very dangerous as well.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I thank the Deputy. We do intend to. I am not sure what the Commissioner personally has done but I think it would fall to me to meet those companies. We are trying to arrange that. I stress that there have been a number of operations that have focused on enforcement in those areas, which would include people on e-bikes, looking at their speed and using equipment to test what speeds they are actually doing. There have been a number of targeted operations, which we talked about earlier, around making sure we have that targeted, co-ordinated piece centrally and then we have inspectors in each of the divisions who are focusing on that. As well as the operations that are in place generally, we are looking at those sorts of targeted operations that can focus on mainly urban areas where there are different types of e-bikes, scooters, etc., and obviously having a-----

Comment on this

An Garda Síochána might come back to the committee when that body of work has concluded. There are not many of these companies or riders but it is dangerous and I have flagged it here a few times. We would love to know where that has led to. I ask that they do that in due course. I thank the Cathaoirleach and the witnesses.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank Deputy Crowe. There is so much more we could have discussed today. On e-scooters, I think it is really important that an outright ban is kept on the table. We could have talked about so much more, such as alcohol ignition interlock systems as well as how we investigate accidents. However, we are out of time. I really appreciate this engagement. We will continue to engage but it will be a matter for the members to decide whether we meet again before the end of the year or maybe early next year. On behalf of the committee, I thank the witnesses for their attendance here today. I thank the members as well.

Comment on this