Remit of Iarnród Éireann: Discussion
Iarnród Éireann forecast passenger journeys rising from a record 55 million to about 60 million this year, but acknowledged severe peak-time capacity pressures while outlining fleet and infrastructure projects intended to expand services over coming years. The Indra train-control contract has been terminated; the company says it believes it owes Indra nothing, intends to pursue damages and has commissioned a board-led review, while details of the project’s total costs remain subject to commercial and legal considerations. Members pressed for urgent relief from overcrowding and clearer, evidence-based plans for allocating new carriages; Iarnród Éireann cited fleet and infrastructure constraints, decades of underinvestment and dependence on NTA funding. The company also said level-crossing safety is a priority following a fatal incident in Mayo, which remains under investigation.
Contributions 1–175 of 352. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Good morning all. Our engagement today is with Iarnród Éireann to discuss all matters under its remit. On behalf of the committee, I am delighted to welcome from Iarnród Éireann, Ms Mary Considine, chief executive officer, Mr. Paul Hendrick, director of capital investments, Mr. Barry Kenny, head of corporate communications, and Mr. Cathal Mangan, director of infrastructure. The format of the meeting is that we will hear an opening statement, followed by a question-and-answer session with members. I ask members to be concise in their questions to allow witnesses the opportunity to participate.
Witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of that person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside of the House or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Members will have an initial seven minutes for questions and answers.
I now invite Ms Considine to make her opening statement on behalf of Iarnród Éireann.
Comment on this
I thank the Chairperson for the invitation to address the committee and discuss all matters within Iarnród Éireann’s remit.
As the committee will know, the record demand for Iarnród Éireann's services continues to grow. Last year's highest ever passenger journey figure of 55 million will be surpassed again this year. We forecast that there will be approximately 60 million passengers by the end of the year. This represents a near 20% growth in just two years. While the demand for our services is welcome, it brings with it pressure on capacity, particularly at peak times. However, over the coming 12 months, our customers will begin to see benefits from a range of projects.
Our DART fleet will begin entering service from the middle of next year. The first trains will be battery-electric trains, operating on the Drogheda commuter line, with charging facilities already having been installed in Drogheda station. As the trains are rolled out through 2027 and beyond, this will ensure high-capacity trains on a number of Drogheda services. Importantly, they will also free up intercity and commuter trains used on that line today for other routes. We will have a particular focus, working with the National Transport Authority, on how we can address demand in our key commuter areas, including Dublin, Galway and Cork.
Such is the level of current and future demand, it is important to understand that the first order alone will not address every need. However, as more trains and supporting infrastructure continue to be delivered, we will be able to increase services to allow people to live, work, study and travel more sustainably.
Other projects which are nearing completion include the new Ceannt Station in Galway, which will be completed by the end of this year; the second platform and passing loop at Oranmore, which will be completed next year; the 42 km Foynes line, which will be commissioned this weekend; following driver training and testing, we are working to commence freight services next year; and the new Plunkett Station in Waterford is also due to open next year as part of a wider Waterford north quays development.
We also have a significant pipeline of projects under way or in development, including the Cork area commuter rail. As members will know, this was designated as one of the three critical transport projects by the Government earlier this year. We have already completed the twin-tracking on Midleton and the new platform at Kent Station as part of that project. Resignalling will be delivered in 2028. We are also working to achieve the approval to enable us to apply to An Coimisiún Pleanála in early 2027 for a railway order for the Cork area electrification, a new fleet depot and a range of new stations.
There is a project to remove six of the existing level crossings on the Cork line between Limerick Junction and Mallow. Again, we hope to have that work complete by the summer of 2028.
On the DART+ programme, enabling works for DART+ West will begin next year. We will continue to work to progress other elements of the programme, with a railway order application for the new depot in Kilcock, including an extension of the line from Maynooth to Kilcock, before the end of the year.
Early infrastructure works for DART+ Coastal North are also being progressed. The tender process for the charging facilities and other infrastructure for Wicklow DART is under way, with the project scheduled to be completed in 2029. That will allow an hourly service to and from Wicklow.
We operate the Enterprise fleet jointly with Translink, supported by both Governments and EU special PEACE funding. We have placed an order for a new flagship fleet for the Dublin-Belfast route, with delivery beginning in 2029, and we hope to have those trains in service in 2031. On the Navan line, we plan to conduct a second round of public consultation before the end of this year to confirm the preferred route, allowing us to move forward with preparing the railway order application for that. On the western rail corridor, next year we will undertake works to lengthen platforms on the existing route. We are also developing plans to reinstate the 52 km line between Athenry and Claremorris. That is funded under the NDP transport sectoral plan.
In addition, we are progressing a range of projects which will help build towards the longer term ambitions of the all-Ireland strategic rail review. Among those is FourNorth. This critical project will deal with the most congested part of our network, between Connolly Station and Malahide, along that corridor. The project provides for additional tracks along that line. We hope to move to public consultation in early next year. A range of early interventions under the all-Ireland strategic rail review is planned and will comprise ten interventions on six of the main lines. That will enable, by the end of this decade, more trains to operate on a range of intercity and regional routes. We will see public consultation take place next year on the Galway capacity study. That is to identify measures to increase the capacity and frequency on this busy intercity route.
I spoke of the demand we see now and the urgency of new capacity to meet that demand. The projects I have just outlined and the wider ambitions under the Rail2050 strategy are critical to delivering the rail infrastructure and services we need to meet growing demand. Our country needs strong public transport links to facilitate and sustainably support the type of housing and other development we envisage as a nation and the population and employment growth predicted, particularly along those high-capacity rail lines. The committee's continued support for these projects is really appreciated.
We have, in writing, updated the committee on the train management system, but I will summarise. Following receipt of NTA consent, we terminated the TMS contract with Indra on 17 July in accordance with the provisions of the contract. We propose to replace the train control system for our network. The first phase of this will deliver a solution for the greater Dublin area to improve operational resilience and help mitigate the obsolescence risks for this part of our network. This has already been approved and is being funded by the Department of Transport. We hope that the project will be substantially complete by the end of 2028.
Subject to the relevant approvals from the NTA, as approving authority for the overall national train control centre project, we plan to deploy this system across the remaining areas of our network to complete the project. While overall completion is envisaged by 2031, the majority of the project will be substantially complete and operational by the end of 2030.
Before I finish, I want to mention the very tragic incident that took place at the Kiltybo level crossing in Mayo in early September, which resulted in the loss of the life of a young boy, Eoin Doyle. I again express our deepest condolences to the grieving family and the community there. This accident is under live investigation by our internal team as well as the independent railway accident investigation unit, RAIU, to which we are providing all the information needed to support its work.
I assure the committee that level crossing safety is a primary focus of our infrastructure department, from elimination of crossings, where possible, which is the ideal situation, to detailed risk analysis and mitigation at all our 853 level crossings. That number is down significantly, from over 2,000 at the beginning of this century. Our level crossing strategy will continue to accelerate that programme and adopt further initiatives and new technology to ensure we significantly reduce risk on the level crossing network.
I am joined by a number of my colleagues, as the Cathaoirleach outlined, and we are happy to take questions from the committee.
Comment on this
Thank you, Ms Considine. We now move to members' questions. These are seven-minute slots. I ask Deputy Boland to open.
Comment on this
The witnesses are all very welcome. I will try to move quickly. As the witnesses know, there have been a number of issues with the rail network. Over the past six months in particular, we have seen issues as a result of signalling. Today and on Monday and Tuesday of this week, there were delays on the northern commuter line. The train carriages, as the witnesses know, just cannot come soon enough. How many carriages will be delivered by June 2027?
Comment on this
I will pass over to my colleague to give the Deputy the exact number.
Comment on this
In the first fleet order we have 95 carriages. We already have nine train sets delivered. That is nine times five. They are in five-car formation. We therefore have 45 of the 95 carriages, and by the summer we expect that delivery to be up to around 65 carriages. Effectively, that means we will have 13 of the 19 five-car sets by June. The important point is that we have to get a safety approval from the European regulator. We hope to issue the safety case submission to the regulator at the end of next week. There is a six-month review period for the regulator to grant the safety certificate, which will allow us to put the first train set and the other train sets into service in the summer of 2027. That is the most important activity in the programme at the moment.
Comment on this
It is hoped to have 95 carriages next year and 285 have been ordered. When do we expect the remainder? I just want the date.
Comment on this
All those carriages will be in service by 2030. We are targeting to get them all in by the end of-----
Comment on this
Have any been ordered since the 285 were ordered?
Comment on this
No, but as part of the DART+ West and DART+ South West projects, which are under review by the-----
Comment on this
There are 260 additional carriages to come in under those. We can-----
Comment on this
Once we get the new carriages, if funding is not an issue, how many times an hour could we have a service on the northern commuter line?
Comment on this
It is not necessarily extending. In the meantime, while we are extending DART+ Coastal North, when we get the new battery electric carriages, how many times per hour could we have a service?
Comment on this
We expect to put those DART sets into service throughout 2027 to get to three ten-car sets running per hour between Drogheda and the city centre and vice versa.
Comment on this
It is very good to see works under way on FourNorth and Rush and Lusk train station. One thing I need to mention to the witnesses about Rush and Lusk train station is that, as they know, it is in the middle of nowhere. It is in the countryside. I continually raise this issue with the NTA. The car park on both sides is at capacity. One of the entrances, as we know, is dangerous. There is work that will resolve the issue with the entrance but there is no commuter transport to get to the train station, so people have to drive. We are doing nothing to encourage people to get to the station. This is an issue I continually raise with the NTA. In the interim, Iarnród Éireann will need to expand the car park on both sides.
I will quickly move on to the train control centre. It was reported in The Irish Times today that Indra has issued Iarnród Éireann an invoice for €30 million. I assume this invoice has been disputed.
Comment on this
We do not believe we owe anything to Indra. The Deputy will appreciate that we are in commercial and legal considerations, so we are limited in what we can say. However, we do not believe there is anything owing.
Comment on this
Good. That needs to be resolved as quickly as it can be.
On the signalling programme, I noted from Ms Considine's opening statement that phase 1 works have been funded by the Department of Transport and, subject to any relevant approval from the NTA, Iarnród Éireann will go further. What is the timeline for those NTA approvals?
Comment on this
We expect to have that fully resolved by the end of the year. We expect to have all the approvals we need by the end of this year, which will allow us then to conclude the contract arrangements to build that system out for the entire network, with a view to having it substantially done by 2030. As we understand it, the NTA is working in line with that timeline, so we are reasonably confident that we will have a resolution.
However, it is subject to the review and approval of the Department, so I do not want to cut across that.
Comment on this
I appreciate that, but it is important that the committee emphasise the urgency of this being addressed and the appropriate approvals being obtained. The impact can be seen on the rail network of not having the TMS. It, and the delay of the train carriages, are having a detrimental impact across the rail network and they need to be resolved.
The NTA commissioned an external report on the train control centre debacle, which has been delayed. We are still waiting for it. Did Irish Rail do an internal lessons learned report?
Comment on this
Our board will conduct an internal review of the governance around the project. It is a matter for the Irish Rail board. It took the decision to write down the asset in the first place so it and we, the executive team, will be keen to understand whether things could have been done differently and whether there are lessons to be learned from it.
Comment on this
It is being undertaken by the a third party on behalf of the board, but managed directly by the board.
Comment on this
I do not have that information, but it is ongoing. I expect the board would like to have the outcome of it as quickly as possible.
Comment on this
It is important, Chair, that we write to the board of Irish Rail to ask it when the review is to conclude and to look for a copy of it. It is essential lessons be learned from this project and that anyone who has any reports on the debacle share them, because the lessons need to be learned right across the various transport bodies and, more broadly, across the public service and Civil Service. We cannot continue to have these issues on our big transport projects. The impact is being lived by all our constituents every day in overcrowded buses and trains. We need to get much better at delivering our capital projects.
Finally, when are the works on DART+ Coastal North expected to commence?
Comment on this
We will be doing works. We will start a project next year at Malahide and Clongriffin to add additional track capacity. We will put in additional track at Malahide and Clongriffin. We will also be doing work at Mosney and Skerries to assist with the capacity challenges of the intercity service, combined with the commuter fleet.
Comment on this
Any impact on the commuter line must be carefully managed.
Comment on this
Since this hearing was announced, I have received many emails from passengers of Irish Rail. There is huge frustration and anger in them. They are from individuals who are clearly standing in overcrowded trains on a daily basis, in many cases five days per week. In the context of the Indra contract, which had an original value back in 2020 of €19.5 million and has since resulted in an impairment of more than €50 million, the national control centre, which had an original budget of €148 million and now has a potential overrun of €57 million, and a new battery electric fleet, which was initially to be delivered in 2025 and now will not be delivered until the second quarter of 2027, what does Iarnród Éireann say to those passengers? How can it restore public confidence?
Comment on this
What I would say, as I outlined in my opening statement, is that we have seen record levels of passenger demand. There has been 20% growth in two years and our team is working hard to try to improve the customer experience for every one of our passengers. However, we acknowledge and recognise that we are under severe pressure at peak times. As Deputy Boland mentioned, if any minor thing goes wrong and takes a train out of service, it has serious knock-on implications. Even if we have a technical fault and have to short-form a train, that results in increased congestion on the train.
Delivering our capital programme as quickly as possible is an absolute priority for us. We are focused on trying to execute and deliver. We need more infrastructure and more fleet. We have plans in place for them. We have been working with the Government to secure the funding for them through our funder, the NTA, but we are playing catch-up. That is the problem. We have had decades of underinvestment and, as a result, we do not have the capacity or fleet to deal with the demand for our services today.
Comment on this
In the context of what is going on with Indra, the malaise around the Alstom contract and the overruns in the national control centre, does Ms Considine think the passengers, including commuter passengers and passengers from my constituency getting on at Thurles today and standing on trains all the way to Dublin, deserve an apology?
Comment on this
We would love to be providing a better service and we acknowledge the challenges with the Indra contract, but the overall portfolio of projects is being managed very well. I have listed all the projects that are nearing completion and will be coming on stream next year. We have a pipeline of projects that will deliver the capacity for commuters, but we are in a challenging space and ask for the committee's support and for people to bear with us, because there will be continual disruptions as we continue to build out the network and introduce new fleet. We are working closely with Alstom to ensure it delivers next summer, that it gets through the certification process and the new trains come into service next year.
Comment on this
I will move on as time is limited. The Indra contract has now been terminated. Was that contract default or termination by convenience?
Comment on this
It was terminated under the provisions of the contract, which allows for termination by convenience.
Comment on this
Why was it termination of convenience and not contractual default? Are there not implications for Indra's entitlement to compensation or Irish Rail's ability to recover damages?
Comment on this
I need to be careful what we say while we are working through it. We have issued the final account to Indra. We are taking every measure possible to recover as much as we can on behalf of the Exchequer because, at the end of the day, when we go right back to this we are very sorry about the delay of the project.
Comment on this
However, Indra did not deliver a product that was fit for purpose.
Comment on this
Has Indra sought damages from Irish Rail, as per The Irish Times report this morning?
Comment on this
Indra has issued a claim but, as the Cathaoirleach will appreciate, we are working through all these matters. We do not believe anything is owed to Indra.
Comment on this
At this stage, can Ms Considine provide any consolidated assessment of the total financial consequences of the Indra project, including the €50 million impairment, potential claims, legal expenditure, any interim system costs and the estimated cost of replacement? Can she provide any consolidated assessment of what the final cost might be?
Comment on this
At this point, because of legal and commercial considerations, we are not in a position to furnish the details. We will, when we have approval for the business case to replace the system and have worked through the close-out of the account with the supplier, be happy to brief the committee, but we do not want to prejudice the outcome now. We want to be successful.
Comment on this
There should not be further impairment. We have incurred some costs to date, but they have already been accounted for.
Comment on this
Three contracts with Alstom were entered into under the framework for additional carriages. Are any claims being lodged with Alstom that are currently before Irish Rail?
Comment on this
There is the normal contract negotiation. I might bring Mr. Hendrick in to add to that.
Comment on this
On the three projects - fleet orders one, two and three - the total estimated investment value is a budget of €700 million to deliver 57 trains. We are on course to deliver the project within budget. On every contract we have with every supplier, not just in the capital business, there are always variations to be managed under the process. We are managing them within the budget.
Comment on this
A number of variations have been made based on the development design process we have been through.
Comment on this
I am asking about the first order that has been significantly delayed until the first half of next year. Is there a change order request in the context of that particular order?
Comment on this
The change orders we were talking about actually apply to the whole of the fleet because they are to do with the design and development process.
Comment on this
They are in the order of €10 million, but that is inside the budget. It is all inside the budget that we have approval for.
Comment on this
I want to ask the witnesses about Maynooth line capacity, which serves Dublin West. In replies to parliamentary questions, it has been stated that the number of weekday services has remained at 74 since September 2019. At one stage, it went to 75 per week, but it is back at 74. I acknowledge that there has been an increase in the number of longer trains, eight-carriage trains, since 2025, but there are still a lot of reports of overcrowding. How is overcrowding on trains measured during the morning and afternoon school commutes? Does Irish Rail measure the numbers of passengers unable to board as well as those already on the train or is it the level of discomfort?
Comment on this
I will address that issue. At peak times, and this is not unique to Irish Rail but an international phenomenon, the trains are designed to accommodate full loading. I appreciate that it is not comfortable at all times. We want to be able to carry everybody on every service. Effectively, if we are leaving people behind on a service, that is the problem. That is not physically counted as such, but obviously we have direct driver and station reports on that, and those help inform our planning.
We are very limited until we get the new trains in terms of any additional capacity we can bring into play, but we know where the issues are. Typically, we are not leaving people behind. Where we have done so, it tends to happen, as the chief executive described, because of incidents where we have a mechanical issue, a shorter train or a delay that causes congestion. The Deputy is absolutely right about the increase in demand since the pre-Covid peak of 2019. Apart from the 41 extra intercity carriages, we are still working with the same capacity.
Comment on this
In this day and age, I do not think it is enough that we are relying on driver reports and the feedback Irish Rail is getting. I question what the company knows about what is happening and if enough is being done about it. Last year, the National Transport Authority worked on a business intelligence tool using Leap cards to identify capacity pressures on bus routes and to prioritise intervention. What equivalent evidence will Irish Rail and the NTA use when deciding where the carriages released from the Drogheda line next year will go? What evidence-based approach will Irish Rail take to the chronic capacity issues which my constituents and people in other areas have been experiencing since 2019 at this stage?
Comment on this
We can see the load factors, as I said, on our services. That is from the day-to-day footfall. We also have the passenger census, which gives a bit more detail. That will show us where we are dealing with the greatest capacity pressures. As we stated, this is not going to be addressed in one fell swoop. We are not going to solve all of this with the first carriages, but the impact will begin to build out.
There is also the physical infrastructure capacity. Where we have a full eight-car train on a service, that service is at its maximum capacity. That will be the case until we get to a point where, speaking in terms of the Maynooth line, the DART+ West project has the electrification in place and we can move DART trains.
In terms of the cascade, we have some intercity trains, for example, on the M3 Parkway services, which pass through Clonsilla. They are doing a job at the moment but, in a perfect world, we would not be using them on commuter services because the commuter trains that will be displaced have higher capacity and much quicker boarding and disembarking through their wider doors. It will be about looking, with the NTA, at where we have all those capacity pressures around the network, looking at the load factors we have and where within the infrastructure we can put on-----
Comment on this
I am hearing that Irish Rail is looking at daily averages and not at the specifics, such as individual departures, school commuting times, housing growth and passengers left behind. At this stage, surely there should be a model that reflects the commuter experience in a more in-depth way. I am also not hearing about Irish Rail's plans to make the allocation of those carriages evidence-based at this point. Should Irish Rail and the NTA not be working on that now if we are going to see 95 new carriages entering service on the Drogheda line? The second order of 90 carriages is due to enter service from 2028. I am here to speak up for the people of Dublin West, but I am quite sure that every other TD and Senator here will speak for his or her area. We need a plan.
Comment on this
We are working on that now, very much so, because the pressures, as the Deputy just said, are not confined to one route. For example, one of the considerations we would look at in terms of the cascade of the fleet is whether we will move more of the intercity trains onto the Phoenix Park tunnel service to have longer trains or will we try to get the commuter trains across, which would involve some driver training on that side to allocate it. All these factors are being put in together, recognising that pressures are multiple, and to reallocate resources as fairly as we possibly can.
Comment on this
I ask the witnesses to come back to the committee and share that modelling with us. We should have that information by now. People need to have an end in sight to the commuter experience they are having.
Before I finish, are the level crossings going to be retained on the Howth branch under the DART+ Coastal North project, or will they be closed on that project as well?
Comment on this
One of the level crossings is at Howth. We will be changing the signalling layout at that crossing. I would like to come back on this question if I can, just to make sure I have not misspoken. I think it is being retained, but it is a different arrangement and there is a much different frequency.
Comment on this
I thank everyone for coming in. I join others in sympathising with the Doyle family from Ballyhaunis on the awful tragedy that happened a few weeks back.
In July, representatives of the NTA were before the Committee of Public Accounts. It became very apparent in their answers that there will be paralysis in route expansion and service delivery. Yet, the NTA has recently been telling us that fare hikes, which the public do not like, will fund route expansion and more services. Some service improvements are mentioned in the opening statement for 2027, but it appears most will come on stream in 2029. We are hearing today that there is litigation and Irish Rail is trying to get some money back from the failed Indra contract. Where are we at regarding the paralysis in route expansion? Is that still the case or has Irish Rail surmounted it? What is the timeline for the litigation and, hopefully, compensation for Irish Rail?
Comment on this
The Deputy will be aware from the briefings he has had from us and the NTA previously that all our services are subject to funding on an annual basis from the NTA. We are in ongoing dialogue as to where we could expand services, dependent on funding. We are very constrained at the moment, as I set out, because of the infrastructure and fleet constraints. There are minor modifications and some uplifts in the timetable that we would like to introduce but they are all subject to funding. In our dialogue with the NTA, it will speak to the constraints on public service obligation funding. One of the ways it could increase the pot was through the fares determination. A decision was taken, with the Government, to increase fares. I understand the fares were previously reduced post the Covid period.
It is about reinstating them and trying to have more funding available for services. We are in dialogue and we are hoping we will get some uplift in services for the summer 2027 timetable when we see the new fleet starting to come into service. We are very constrained at the moment. We hear from passengers all over the country, and we get representations from Oireachtas Members from all over the country, looking for more and more services. We absolutely understand the point Deputy Crowe is making. We hear it day in, day out.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Considine. A point I have made repeatedly at committee meetings is that I know special services are run out of Dublin on the evening of a match or a large concert but far too many people in the west of Ireland are confined to staying in Dublin overnight when they do not need to do so. Dublin is one of the few European capitals that does not have late-night services going west. There is a service at 7 p.m. from Heuston Station to Cork, with a connection to Limerick and then on to Ennis, and there is something similar to Galway. There is also a service at 9 p.m. but nothing thereafter. Services to the north have improved but, again, I am pitching that people coming from western counties to Dublin should have the possibility of returning home late into the night, as per other European capitals. I want to put that on record.
The opening statement deals with the plans and projects that are under way but it does not deal so much with overcrowding. This is still a major feature of morning services, particularly in and out of Dublin. I did some research and there does not seem to be any standardised European safety regulation on standing on trains. I am no safety expert but I can say, as someone who uses trains, that it cannot be safe to be moving at 85 mph or 90 mph along a train line with all of these people standing and blocking the exits. People are unable to get into toilets in many instances. The carriages are not configured for standing and there are no handle loops. I have often seen when a train shudders over a piece of track that people stumble onto those sitting at a table. Will anything happen in the area of safety? Certainly when those trains originating in the west come into the commuter belt areas, if a carriage is full then it should be considered full. I know this would discommode people who would not be able to get on the train but something is going to happen. If we have a major train crash, and there have been plenty of them on the Continent, the lens of scrutiny will be put on how many people were standing and whether the train carriages were configured for it. Irish Rail simply does not have carriages that are configured for standing. Are the witnesses concerned about the level of standing and the lack of provision in carriages for people who are standing?
Comment on this
It is primarily a comfort issue rather than a safety issue. The trains can accommodate standing. We are not an outlier internationally in this regard at busier times. On longer distance journeys and intercity journeys, we want everybody to have a seat. Again, there will be the cascade of benefits from the new DART trains coming into the commuter area, which will free up intercity trains so we can have more of them. It is uncomfortable. We appreciate that and apologise to customers for it but the trains are designed to safely accommodate standing. The Commission for Railway Regulation, our safety regulator, has confirmed that is its view also. We are working to put in the capacity to make it a better customer experience and to address the points Deputy Crowe has raised.
Comment on this
I have to bow to Mr. Kenny's expertise. I am not a rail safety expert so I have to accept what he has said. I am just saying that, in my humble opinion, it is not safe when a train going at speed gets a little shudder and an elderly person starts tumbling around the carriage. If we were to have a major incident in Ireland, I do not think standing on trains that are going fast, with exit doors fully blocked, would be safe.
In terms of safety, following the awful incident in Ballyhaunis, two carriages were taken off the fleet for examination. This has discommoded users of the services at Ennis, Sixmilebridge and Limerick. On some mornings, the service is two carriages short because of the ongoing investigation. Is that the case and, if so, when will these carriages rejoin the train for normal service?
Comment on this
Deputy Crowe will remember there was a separate level crossing incident on the same day involving a tractor elsewhere in the country. That is the incident that caused damage to a train, which has caused-----
Comment on this
Did it put two carriages out of action?
Comment on this
It is a three-car set that is out of action.
Comment on this
That has disadvantaged more than one service, including an early morning service originating in the mid-west. Perhaps the carriages can be reconfigured a bit to balance it.
Comment on this
I suppose there is some pain arising from this on a number of different routes.
Comment on this
From reading a story in the newspaper this morning, I know that a request was made by Indra. Have any proceedings been lodged or served on Irish Rail?
Comment on this
No, where we are at the moment is that we have closed out the final account. Indra has put in its final account and we have put in ours. As Deputy Daly will appreciate, we have to go through that.
Comment on this
When did Irish Rail close its account? Was it on 17 July?
Comment on this
We were closed out by 15 October. We served notice of termination on 17 July and the final account was closed out by 15 October.
Comment on this
Is there a threat of proceedings in any correspondence that has come from Indra?
Comment on this
Deputy Daly will understand that we have just worked through closing the final account with Indra. Obviously, we will deal with whatever will arise out of this and we will endeavour, as we have said here before, to recover as much as we can on behalf of the taxpayer.
Comment on this
There are no proceedings served on Irish Rail to date. Arising out of some of the previous questions, there was mention of the battery electric fleet and the possibility of more routes. For example, there is still no 8 p.m. service to Cork. This issue has already been raised. I met someone coming into one of the committees this morning who had come up from Kerry and there is no train early enough in the morning to come from Tralee all the way up to Dublin and be here in time for a committee meeting. Are there plans for services like these? There is low-hanging fruit, such as an 8 p.m. service to Cork, a guaranteed late service to Cork after a concert or an international football match, and an earlier morning train from Kerry.
Comment on this
I will start with the Cork service. An 8 p.m. service to Cork from Heuston Station is feasible because we have fleet but we do not have the funding for it. That is on the list of potential uplifts in service if more funding was to become available. That would be doable. Later services after 9 p.m. would be a challenge. Deputy Crowe also raised this matter. We need the time at night to maintain the track. If we did not do that, we would have more disruption over a longer weekend period. It is a balancing act.
Comment on this
It is not necessarily subject to funding; it is more that we need the time.
Comment on this
Some of the other routes are subject to funding.
Comment on this
An 8 p.m. service is subject to funding. Regarding an early morning service, at the moment we do not have fleet for it but there will be hope as we start to see the cascade. I do not want to mislead the committee as the first train sets that will come in next year and free up some commuter and intercity rail fleet from the Drogheda line will be used in the most congested part of the network. It is not going to solve issues all over the country. As the second fleet comes in, and then the subsequent fleets, hopefully we will have more fleet available to move around the country.
Comment on this
Is this proposed additional service and the lack of delivery in the last year or so a result of the decades of underinvestment that were mentioned earlier?
Comment on this
We are suffering from decades of underinvestment. There has been a significant uplift in investment in rail in recent years but it takes time to catch up. We cannot order fleet overnight and we cannot deliver infrastructure in a short period of time. These are all projects that need to be planned, approved and procured and then go through a certification process. We are now trying to play catch-up.
Comment on this
If there had not been such underinvestment by Governments over recent years, Irish Rail would have been able to put these services in place.
Comment on this
There was a shortfall in funding during the economic crash in particular. There was a period when there was a reduction in services and we are playing catch-up.
Comment on this
There was a slowdown over the last two or three years in particular, was there not?
Comment on this
There has been additional funding over the last-----
Comment on this
There was an expansion of services initially but that has dried up somewhat in the last-----
Comment on this
Yes, we do not have the fleet or the infrastructure to deliver more.
Comment on this
My colleague will mention something about the Foynes line later.
We met recently with Cork Airport. Does Iarnród Éireann have any plans to secure a line from the proposed new Cork Luas up to the airport for the future so that it will happen in the decades to come?
Comment on this
I am not familiar with the Luas, which is under Transport Infrastructure Ireland, TII. I am not sure if Mr. Hendrick is aware of it but it is not our project.
Comment on this
The goal of the Cork area commuter rail programme is to bring in more fleet, a new depot and electrification and to get it to a DART-style commuter service on the 62 km between Mallow, Cork and Midleton.
Comment on this
What about securing land to get from the line up to the airport?
Comment on this
That is not currently in the all-island strategic rail review, which is the investment framework for heavy rail. Obviously, there is light rail. TII is doing Luas Cork. It is taking that through the planning process. I am not sure whether it is looking at that option.
Comment on this
What about Letterkenny to Derry? Does Iarnród Éireann own the track from Letterkenny to Derry? Do the witnesses have any idea of when that could be progressed?
Comment on this
I might just jump in there. I do not believe the all-Ireland strategic rail review for Cork included any heavy rail option to the airport, so we are not in a position to confirm what the Luas may be doing. The other route the Deputy mentioned is in the all-Ireland strategic rail review, but it is not currently funded.
Comment on this
Again, if there was more funding, Iarnród Éireann would maybe be looking at that one.
Comment on this
Could I just say "Yes", but it would also depend on Translink - that is also in the all-island rail review - with which we work very closely. It has a project that it needs to deliver as a line, because that is obviously a spur off its line.
Comment on this
I am running slightly out of time. There has been a lot of talk about the western rail corridor, including in the committees, over the last couple of years. When are we likely to see a train running on the tracks there?
Comment on this
We are working on that project with a view to having it complete and in service by the end of 2031. We are looking to appoint a main contractor for the works by the end of next year. I should also say, on the existing western rail corridor between Limerick and Athenry, that we are working on a project to lengthen the platforms on that line to allow for longer trains.
Comment on this
When will there be a train running on the tracks?
Comment on this
It will be the end of 2031 for the Athenry to Claremorris section.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas leis na finnéithe ar fad as teacht os chomhair an chomhchoiste ar maidin. I am here to speak for the commuters in my constituency who use stations like Adamstown, Kishoge, Clondalkin, Fonthill and Hazelhatch. I hope the witnesses are of the same view as me that DART+ South West needs to be brought forward and funded as a matter of urgency. I hope that is the message that is going from Iarnród Éireann to the NTA and the Department of Transport, as it is the message coming to me.
Overcrowding is particularly acute in my constituency. We have had incidents of people fainting on the train over the last few weeks and people being left behind. It is also fair to say that my constituency is one of those in the country that is now taking the brunt of the new housing that is being built, in this case in Clonburris and Adamstown. There is a need to provide high-capacity transport links for those people, especially given the pressure on car parking spaces.
My first question relates to capacity on the overall line. Is Iarnród Éireann confident that it is sweating every asset entirely to make sure all of them are being brought into use at optimal times, including peak times? I ask this because customers who use the Phoenix Park tunnel line, while standing on the Kishoge and Adamstown platforms, see half-empty intercity trains pass them in the morning. Are the witnesses satisfied that every single carriage is being optimised in terms of its usage and is being brought into service at peak times? Has that exercise been done and is it being monitored on an ongoing basis?
Comment on this
Yes. We do everything we can to ensure service resilience. There is a maintenance cycle that happens with the fleet. Outside of that, everything that we have is in service.
Comment on this
How often does Iarnród Éireann monitor that?
Comment on this
How is it monitored? What evidence is being used?
Comment on this
We literally track fleet kilometres from day to day in terms of what is in service. Obviously, if we have a mechanical issue, as mentioned earlier, there can be occasions when that means we have to put out a shorter train. It is something we work to avoid but we report to the NTA in terms of the fleet kilometres because that is within our PSO contract.
Comment on this
Do the fleet kilometres measure spare capacity on existing lines and routes? Would Mr. Kenny be able to say that a train is running at full capacity between certain parts of the line and is that a metric that is monitored over time?
Comment on this
We manage and monitor that over time in terms of passenger demand. Deputy Moynihan mentioned people being left behind. I said to Deputy Currie earlier that it is a circumstance we want to avoid. The trains can take full loading but leaving people behind is where we are into real problems and it shows real pressure. I appreciate that is difficult if a commuter has an issue.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Kenny have a measure of spare capacity? How is that measured?
Comment on this
Ultimately, it is load factors. We are dealing with different types of trains. For example, the Deputy mentioned intercity trains. I would argue that trains passing through in the morning peak time in that area, the express services, are not half empty.
Comment on this
Those trains are all extremely busy. They would have some capacity. An intercity train that is seven carriages long, for example, is a three-carriage and a four-carriage train coupled together. It could be said that seven carriages are not needed, but we cannot take three carriages off those trains as we would otherwise be creating another problem, if the Deputy understands. It is virtually a case of loaves and fishes at the moment in terms of trying to meet all of the demand and balance it all at the same time. The challenge Deputy Moynihan describes in his constituency is one that we are seeing elsewhere as well.
Comment on this
In terms of the carriages that are coming on stream next year, that is a loaves and fishes exercise from what I can make out because I hear a number but I do not hear of any work being done on how areas are being prioritised, how we are going to ensure timetable changes and how we are thinking about the longer trains. Another concern, which is on the Government, is around the PSO funding for those additional carriages. That is something I will raise with the Minister. When are we going to have the results of that prioritisation? At this stage, I cannot keep telling constituents there are new carriages coming and they might come here, fingers crossed. That is what it feels like at the moment. For someone getting the train every day, having bought a house in Adamstown or Clonburris, who is seeing people faint in the train, that is not good enough. When will we have the results of that prioritisation exercise? When will we be able to give some certainty to people about when things are going to change? Telling them there are new carriages coming in 2027 to relieve congestion is not where we need to be.
Comment on this
We will agree the timetable and that allocation with the NTA. The infrastructure can take longer trains than we provide at the moment on that route and that is a priority for us, particularly the Phoenix Park tunnel route. There is certainly scope to deliver there, either through longer intercity trains or through putting the commuter trains onto that route.
We welcome Deputy Moynihan's support for DART+ South West. There is more housing coming there. We know that the benefits DART+ South West, with the four-tracking into Heuston, will bring to that area and nationally are critical. I do not know if Mr. Hendrick wants to add to that. With the NTA, we want to confirm that as quickly as possible for customers. It is important to see what the latest trends are before we allocate carriages, but I can assure the Deputy that in that first wave, we want-----
Comment on this
When does Mr. Kenny think Irish Rail will be able to do that?
Comment on this
As early as possible in the new year, I think, is realistic.
Comment on this
We will have to engage with the NTA, but we will have circa 50 of the carriages in service by the end of next year. We want the Heuston commuter routes to benefit from those.
Comment on this
Is Irish Rail getting the support it needs from the NTA on this?
Comment on this
Does the NTA understand the urgency of what is happening?
Comment on this
It is hearing what we are hearing and seeing what we are seeing in terms of the interaction with customers.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Hendrick want to come in there too?
Comment on this
I am sorry. No. I was only going to speak about DART+ South West, but that is more the delivery of the project and additional capacity, if that is of benefit. The Deputy is quite right about the short-term pressures he is flagging but I will give people the vision of what we are trying to do with Dart+ South West. There is the four-tracking section that Mr. Kenny mentioned. We have a restriction coming into Heuston on an arterial route. We have got to get that to four tracks. That is one of the most important aspects of DART+ South West but also it is to deliver a ten-minute DART commuter product on that line to Hazelhatch, just like we see on the coastal line today between Howth Junction and Greystones. It is critical that we progress that project. We have a business case with the NTA and the Department for approval by the end of this year. We hope to get approval to be able to progress the procurement process for DART+ South West from next year onwards.
Comment on this
I raised this directly with the Taoiseach in the Dáil yesterday and I have been raising it with the Minister. As the witnesses know, I have been hugely supportive of this project and trying to get it prioritised as a matter of urgency.
I will turn quickly to accessibility, if I may. Does Iarnród Éireann proactively, at the start of every day, check if lifts are operational in train stations for wheelchair users? How is that monitored?
Comment on this
We have a lift call system which transmits information on the availability of our lifts, and that is essentially the central means of monitoring them.
Comment on this
It gives information on the lifts as being operational, but if a lift is deemed not to be operational, is a repair organised immediately for that day? How long can it take for a lift to be repaired?
Comment on this
There is a service level agreement with our lift maintainers that require them essentially to come out within a number of hours and effect repairs.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Mangan know what the success rate is and how long the delay is?
Comment on this
The success rate is generally good because we monitor it. It is a key performance indicator for us in how we manage that contract.
Comment on this
It is generally good. Is it more than 95%?
Comment on this
Absolutely, yes. It is very rare that we would not meet the requirements.
Comment on this
I will squeeze in one final question related to the lived experience of James Casserly, who people are probably familiar with, and his mother Vicki. It relates to a scheme that would make it easier for wheelchair users on trains to have a designated alighting and landing bay on the platform, like the blue space that is being made available at bus stops by Dublin Bus at the moment. Is that something Iarnród Éireann is exploring in terms of its overall accessibility offering for wheelchair users, whereby there will be a point on the platform where someone can get on and the driver knows that is where wheelchair users will alight?
Comment on this
The vision, particularly in the commuter areas, is that the new DART trains will have a retractable step and that they will be fully accessible trains, with independent access for the vast majority of mobility impaired customers. That is where we need to get to.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses. I will start with the western rail corridor. I was with Councillor Michael Clarke from Independent Ireland recently and we looked at one of the closed railway stations that served the old rail line. There is a huge need to open the line from Claremorris to Sligo and Tobercurry. Is Iarnród Éireann looking at that? Is it interested? Is it pushing towards delivering in that area? There is a huge catchment of people there. Obviously, we are trying to get people out of cars and rail is the way to go. There is an organisation in Tobercurry that hopes to give evidence before the committee at some stage. The line at Tobercurry needs to be reopened. There is a strong need there. That is the message coming from the community. The population is there. Does Iarnród Éireann have an update on that?
Comment on this
We spoke about the western rail corridor just a few moments ago. Our initial plans are to extend from Athenry to Claremorris. We are hoping to appoint a contractor for that project by the end of next year and have it operational by 2031. The section the Deputy mentioned, from Claremorris on to Sligo, was not provided for in the all-island strategic rail review. That strategy is up for review every ten years. We are hoping that once the next phase is done as far as Claremorris, people will see the demand for and the benefits of rail and that that could be included in the next review of the all-island strategic rail review. As of now, there is no live project to develop the railway beyond Claremorris.
Comment on this
When is the next all-island strategic rail review starting?
Comment on this
Is there a scenario in which Tobercurry could fit in, even if it was not in the initial plan? If demand exceeds all expectations, which it looks like it might, could that project be included, even if it is not in the initial all-island strategic rail review?
Comment on this
Obviously, that is a matter for Government when the review of the strategy is undertaken. From an Irish Rail perspective, our ambition is to deliver more rail infrastructure all around the country. Anywhere we can expand the network, we would be keen to do so. At the end of the day, however, we are working to an overall strategy.
Comment on this
That moves me on nicely to my next question. I thank Ms Considine very much for her answer. Irish Rail's plan is to have an all-Ireland rail service. That sounds lovely. A gentleman present spoke about loaves and fishes. Somebody else spoke about standing room. However, people are living in a situation where they have no train. From Ardgroom to Cork train station is 138 km. Cork train station is 123 km from Goleen, where I live, and 120 km from the Sheep's Head. There is no rail in Bantry, Castletownbere, Drimoleague, Dunmanway, Ballineen, Enniskean, Bandon, Clonakilty or Skibbereen. It is an astonishing situation in which we find ourselves. Do not tell me I have to wait seven years to even get a dream put into a plan. Where is the thought and connectivity? Is there any connectivity? I have brought this up with the witnesses before. Irish Rail falls under the NTA umbrella, so if it cannot deliver this, who can?
I invite the witnesses to come down to Schull this weekend where there will be a re-enactment of the return of rail. It is being put on for Hallowe'en weekend on Sunday evening, and it will be quite interesting. The bottom line is that in 1850, rail came within 3 km of my door. In 2026, I have to travel the guts of 130 km to find a train, which is pointless, so I keep going in the car. The point I am trying to make is that is how it looks to me. There is no point in dreaming because the focus is completely against rural rail lines returning. There certainly should be a bus link, however. West Cork Connect has put forward suggestions that could connect the Mizen, the Beara and the Sheep's Head peninsulas all the way to the train station in Cork. The person in question delivers a massive service to west Cork. It is second to none. Bus Éireann provides a service but it is not in the same league. It looks like the NTA is blocking that.
Are the various organisations sitting around a table? Irish Rail cannot come in here and talk about Connecting Ireland if I can identify hundreds of kilometres that are not covered by rail. The witnesses know I am not having a go at any of them personally. It has nothing to do with them personally. The point is that they should be sitting around the table with Bus Éireann and private operators to see how they can deliver, once or twice every day, a connection to rail services from areas where a rail line cannot be delivered. They can tell me that light rail is coming to Bandon. That is fantastic. It is a step in the right direction. However, it is astonishing that in 1850, light rail could come to Bantry and Schull and in 2026, it cannot go west of Cork city. There is something wrong somewhere. What is the answer?
Comment on this
We have spoken about this before in this committee. We have reached out to our colleagues in Bus Éireann to see if we can get a better integration of bus services to train timetables at Kent Station. That is something Bus Éireann is very open to and on which I think the NTA would work with us.
In relation to the overall transport strategy, I am not abdicating our responsibility but that really is a role for the NTA to have those conversations. From a rail perspective, we are keen to see better integration of the timetables so that people would be able to avail of bus services and connect with rail. We spoke about this previously as well. In some of our stations in Cork, particularly at Blackpool station, we are providing for significant park-and-ride facilities to encourage people to park and avail of our rail services from the major station there, Kent Station. I appreciate the point the Deputy is making. I have heard similar representations from other parts of the country that were not covered initially in the all-island strategic rail review. I would say there will be a review. I know it is seven or eight years away-----
Comment on this
I would like to see it before I retire. The bottom line is that we must connect, and that it for the NTA, Irish Rail and Bus Éireann to do. The private operator who is operating a service and offering to deliver the service I described has been blocked from delivering it. That is an astonishing situation.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, I cannot comment on that. I do not know the details; I am sorry.
Comment on this
I know Ms Considine cannot comment but I certainly can. I have to advocate for those people in west Cork who have no service. Connecting Ireland will continue to disconnect them until that is sorted.
Comment on this
I thank everyone for their time today. I have raised with Iarnród Éireann many times the overcrowding on early morning trains into Galway, particularly the service that arrives into Galway at 8.10 a.m. I have been contacted by a huge number of people about this. I am going to read out three messages I have received recently because I have seen Irish Rail, in response to commuters who have made complaints about this service, continue to insist that the service is safe for passengers when it clearly is not, in my view.
One person told me that:
A young lady passed out on Wednesday morning on the train due to the heat and overcrowding. I have two colleagues who are pregnant and no longer take the train to work due to feeling unsafe.
Another person who contacted me this week said:
I took the train from Ardrahan this morning. I stood all the way to Galway. The train stopped at all stops and packed everyone in. This is so dangerous. People were lying against one another. In Oranmore, I felt a panic attack coming on but I calmly talked myself down.
A mother whose child uses the service said:
My child relies on the commuter train to Athenry to attend school on Galway. On a daily basis, I am paying for the privilege of worry, thinking of the bodies pressed into two carriages on the 7:49 a.m. train from Athenry to Galway. More train carriages must be added to that line on weekday mornings before there is a tragedy for which Irish Rail will be responsible.
I have had many more accounts of people falling ill on this service because of the conditions. I have raised all of this with Iarnród Éireann before. Does Irish Rail stand over the claim that this service is safe for passengers?
Comment on this
We know that the train needs more capacity. As we get the new trains in, we will ensure that we bring new capacity to that route. It absolutely is uncomfortable. It is a feature of commuting at peak times, not just into Galway but in Dublin and other cities in Ireland and, indeed, internationally. We need more capacity on that service. That is absolutely the case.
Comment on this
Of course we do. Telling people in response to complaints that it is safe and there is nothing to worry about is insulting.
Comment on this
I appreciate that if people have taken ill-----
Comment on this
Irish Rail might reconsider its use of language when responding to people. I understand that we do not have additional carriages on the service. The lack of forward planning that has left us in that situation is disappointing. All carriages are in use across the rail network. I ask Irish Rail to raise these concerns with the Department and the NTA and to stress that this is an emergency. I know there are restrictions with the single track but some kind of solution could be found to allow for more regular services in the morning time or for alternative arrangements to be provided for passengers. I ask Mr. Kenny to commit to doing that.