We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Transport

Remit of Iarnród Éireann: Discussion

Summary

Iarnród Éireann forecast passenger journeys rising from a record 55 million to about 60 million this year, but acknowledged severe peak-time capacity pressures while outlining fleet and infrastructure projects intended to expand services over coming years. The Indra train-control contract has been terminated; the company says it believes it owes Indra nothing, intends to pursue damages and has commissioned a board-led review, while details of the project’s total costs remain subject to commercial and legal considerations. Members pressed for urgent relief from overcrowding and clearer, evidence-based plans for allocating new carriages; Iarnród Éireann cited fleet and infrastructure constraints, decades of underinvestment and dependence on NTA funding. The company also said level-crossing safety is a priority following a fatal incident in Mayo, which remains under investigation.

Contributions 176–352 of 352. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Mr. Barry Kenny

I absolutely will. As I said, in the context of our timetable review, we constantly look at the opportunities. The first real opportunity we will have is when carriages are freed following the introduction of the new DART trains.

Comment on this

I will ask specifically about that issue. When those new DART carriages come, it will free up the existing intercity stock to come out to the regional routes, such as in Galway. Are we still talking about quarter 2 of 2027 for those electric carriages? When will the intercity carriages be freed up? Will that also be in quarter 2 of 2027?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry Kenny

It will be by the end of next year, but the first ones will come in during quarter 2 of 2027. By the end of next year, we will have approximately 50 or 55 carriages in service. There will be a critical mass and we can look at that for the timetable in December next year. We will consider the issue as early as possible within that process. If we are adding carriages, that is not a timetable change. There is the PSO to consider. We want to get in additional capacity as quickly as possible and preferably to have some of it in play for the peak commuting season in September, October and November next year.

Comment on this

Will Irish Rail be looking to prioritise the train that arrives into Galway at 8.10 a.m. for additional carriages?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry Kenny

In terms of the load factor, that is about as busy a train as we have on the network. It is absolutely crucial.

Comment on this

On the western rail corridor, my understanding is that there is due to be a public consultation with landowners and also in relation to affected level crossings. Is that due to take place shortly?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

We are currently working through the option selection process for the western rail corridor and what land we may or may not need. Obviously, we own a lot of the land on that corridor. We will be reinstating the rail corridor. It depends on some of the detailed solutions we come up with at the level crossings. We may need some parcels of land. We are working to try to deliver the scheme in a way that has minimal need in that sense. We will consider the detail for each level crossing. Each option has to be considered. We will consider how to address the issues, given there are a large number of level crossings on the route. That is a part of the option selection process we are working through. When we come out of that process, we will be looking to progress any relevant consultation with anyone affected by the solution in 2027.

Comment on this

I raise the recent decision by Irish Rail to permit the development of a greenway on the Claremorris to Collooney section of that line. It is obviously welcome to see progress on the section from Athenry to Claremorris, but ultimately we need that full rail line developed. Irish Rail has said previously that the next section, from Claremorris to Collooney, is viable. What led to a U-turn on this decision to now allow permission for a greenway to be developed on that section of the line? There are significant concerns about how that will affect the integrity of the corridor. It will make it more difficult to get that rail line reopened down the line.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

We have had ongoing engagement with various stakeholders on that section of the railway. As I mentioned earlier, it is not included for development as a rail link in the current all-Ireland strategic rail review. However, we have been clear that our ambition is to have rail services on that line. It is a matter that will be reviewed when the strategy comes around again for review. In the meantime, there has been strong support for a greenway in that part of the country.

Comment on this

Was there an intervention from the Taoiseach?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

There have been ongoing discussions with the Government in that regard. At the moment, the direction from the Government is to license the lands to TII and Sligo County Council to develop a greenway. There is an understanding among all parties that the longer term ambition is to reinstate rail.

Comment on this

Does Ms Considine not accept that a greenway will create difficulties for the reinstatement of that rail line? There will be resistance when we are talking about ripping up a greenway to put in a railway line. Does Ms Considine not accept that?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

We will work with Sligo County Council and TII so that the greenway will be constructed in a way that would still protect the railway for the future. That is a critical point.

Comment on this

Will it be alongside the track? Is that something that could be considered?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

Insofar as possible, it will be considered.

Comment on this

I thank Irish Rail for the engagement it has had with me on so many different issues regarding rail in and around the Sligo region. I appreciate that.

I will also take this opportunity to ask about the U-turn that was taken around the western rail corridor. It was disappointing. Irish Rail gave me solid confirmation last year that it was going to be for rail use only. Hearing of the U-turn, which only happened in past couple of months, was, to be honest, astounding for everyone, not alone elected representatives like me. There is the community of West on Track behind it. Its representatives have been raising the issue for years. We have seen progression. There was confirmation this morning that by 2031, there are going to be trains on the track on the Athenry to Claremorris route. I would like a straight answer to this question. Was there intervention from the Department of An Taoiseach around the decision to do a U-turn?

Comment on this

I thank the Senator for her comments about our team and her engagement on a number of matters relating to Sligo.

On the greenway matter, there have been discussions with the Department of An Taoiseach and the Department of Transport on this issue. Everybody understands that our longer term ambition is to have rail on the line. The current direction to license a greenway would, first of all, protect the alignment in State ownership. It will not prevent us from returning it to a railway. We are conscious that our team, when engaging with Sligo County Council, will work with it to ensure we are protecting the rail corridor for the longer term.

Comment on this

I appreciate that. Was confirmation given because money was given to progress the greenway? I can see from the public's point of view that it is a waste of money to invest in a temporary greenway and then rip it up. That is what will happen. It will be removed to have a western rail corridor if it comes about. As Deputy O'Hara said, there is major confusion about what happened. Who were the stakeholders involved? Were lobby groups involved? I know greenway lobby groups are significant. As a matter of public perception, is it okay that money is going to be given over to develop a greenway when we know that decision is going to be reversed? We are trying to understand the decision.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

It is ultimately a decision for the Government. Our priority is that the land remain in State ownership so it is there to allow the reinstatement of the railway at a future point if the strategy is reviewed to include that. We hope that will be the case. We have seen growing demand for the first phase of the western rail corridor.

Comment on this

That is wonderful.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

The second phase should see very strong demand and then the natural progression will be there. However, that is still a long way off, so I think the Government made the decision based on the timing and in consideration of the intervening period. I am obviously not going to speak for anyone else.

Comment on this

I understand protecting the line by clearing it and making way. However, doing works for a greenway when the ultimate goal is to put a railway on the land seems like a complete waste of money. I would love to find out from the Government. The committee is meeting the Minister for Transport tomorrow. I would love to find out who intervened to change this decision. I appreciate it was not the witnesses. I appreciate the work they have done in engaging with people like me and the representatives of West on Track. Irish Rail has been willing to engage about the western rail corridor.

We can see how much progress has been made so far, and that has to be really commended, but questions have to be asked about how this decision was changed. We were given a solid commitment that the line was going to be for rail use only. What happened?

Ms Considine stated that a range of early interventions under the all-Ireland strategic rail review is planned and "will comprise ten interventions on six of the main lines." Is the Boyle looping system for the Sligo-Dublin line included in that?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

Yes.

Comment on this

That is brilliant. Besides the looping system, is there any talk about double tracking on the Sligo-Dublin line?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

Not in the current plan. I mentioned earlier that the first phase of that we are looking at is the double tracking of the congested parts of the Galway line. I do not believe the Sligo line is included.

Comment on this

Is there another looping system on that line? Are there other plans for a different-----

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

We are putting in another platform at Sligo. That will provide a short section of loop but the main passing loop is at Boyle. The all-island strategic rail review does not have double tracking on the Sligo line as far as Enfield. Obviously we will be double tracking between Maynooth and Kilcock as part of DART+, which is on the Sligo line as well. That is about 7 km.

Comment on this

Does Irish Rail have a timeline? When does it envisage that happening?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

We hope to have the passing loop at Boyle and the early inventions delivered by 2030.

Comment on this

My final question is about the early morning commuter train. I know Irish Rail has been supportive of having this early morning commuter train. We know the fleet is there. Could I get confirmation of how much it is going to cost so I can bring it back to the NTA and the Minister to say how much it costs to provide this service? We know the fleet is there and that it is not in conflict with any other route at the moment. Is there any way that Irish Rail could provide costings that I can present directly to the Minister to say how much it costs? That is low-hanging fruit as well. It is an easy win.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

As the Senator noted, the fleet is there. It is one of the rare places where we have the fleet available but it is subject to funding. We have shared those figures with the NTA but we would be happy to share them with the Senator.

Comment on this

It is just so that I can bring it up with the Minister.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for being here this morning and for all their work and engagement with us all. It is much appreciated. I, too, share my sympathies with the Doyle family. It was such a tragedy for Eoin to lose his life after such a brilliant summer in Mayo celebrating the all-Ireland success. I have been engaging with a local councillor, Alma Gallagher, on the issue. I appreciate that it is a very sensitive subject and I do not want to go into too much detail. I want to reflect the fact that the family are grieving a devastating loss but they are very keen to see works carried out to make that crossing safe. I ask that this be given urgent attention. I know some minor works were being done but the gates are still blowing in the wind and this is having a very negative impact. I ask that attention be paid to immediate safety improvements at that junction because it is causing ongoing grief and distress to the Doyle family. I offer my sympathies to them and encourage Irish Rail to do what it can in terms of safety improvements at that junction.

Regarding the western rail corridor, what has changed in terms of the strategic thinking? From what I am hearing today, Irish Rail wants to see that line reopened with rail connectivity. Would it be fair to say that?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

Our longer term ambition would be to see rail reinstated but I think I have explained before that this project is not included in the all-Ireland strategic rail review that runs up to 2050. What is included is the next phase of the western rail corridor, from Athenry to Claremorris. We are hopeful that once that phase is completed in 2031 and trains are running, the natural progression would be to do the next area but, as I mentioned earlier, that strategy is not up for review under 2034. That review will be the opportunity to revisit that strategy. In the meantime, the Government has taken the decision to support TII in funding a greenway and work with Sligo County Council on that.

Comment on this

It was through Government intervention. Was it the Taoiseach who engaged directly with Irish Rail to overturn Irish Rail's decision?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

We have had ongoing discussions with the Government and our Department in relation to-----

Comment on this

The decision is against Irish Rail's will.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

-----protecting the rail corridor for the longer term.

Comment on this

It was against Irish Rail's will, however.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

Irish Rail's ambition is to reinstate the rail line but our first and foremost priority today is protecting the rail line and making sure it stays in State ownership, that it is available-----

Comment on this

Does Irish Rail want to see a greenway on it in the short term?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

In the short term, the greenway is protecting the line. It is staying in State ownership and there is an investment in a greenway. That is the decision of the Government and we will work with it to implement that. The clear thing is that we want to work to implement it in a way that does not prevent it being reinstated as rail.

Comment on this

Did the Taoiseach intervene directly to overturn the strategic thinking of Irish Rail?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

We have had discussions with the Taoiseach's office and the Department.

Comment on this

That is a "Yes". Regarding the western rail corridor, the expansion of different platforms beginning next year was mentioned. Which platforms are they?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

They are on the section of the line between Limerick and Athenry. What we call the first phase of the western rail corridor was opened in 2010, so we are looking to extend the platforms on that line to assist with having longer train formations on that service.

Comment on this

Different platforms and a multitude of level crossings were mentioned. I have raised Ballindine as an example where there are three different crossings on the road network. What is latest thinking in terms of an underpass or bypass of Ballindine?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

Sorry, is this on the-----

Comment on this

It is between Athenry and Claremorris.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

We are still working through the options for all of the crossings through there, so I do not have the detail to hand. We will get to the end of that option selection process after Christmas. That then has to be agreed with the NTA and the Department as the scope for what would then be developed as a preliminary design and an estimate. I could not comment on any particular one at the moment but we will be coming back with further details on it in the new year.

Comment on this

How will the increased capacity be rolled out to benefit the Mayo line when the 50 extra carriages are delivered next year?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry Kenny

It is fair to say that next year, the focus will be pretty much on the commuter areas where we have very significant pressures. As we continue, intercity routes will start to benefit more, as they did when we brought in the 41 intercity rail car carriages. For next year, however, the focus will be very much on the type of capacity issues described in the commuter belt system.

Comment on this

Fifty carriages are going to be added-----

Comment on this
Mr. Barry Kenny

By the end of next year.

Comment on this

I just want to make sure that Mayo is included in that because something I am contacted about regularly is the lack of capacity on the line. It is a long commute. People commute from Mayo to Dublin for work, college and appointments, and it is the same on all lines. I know that some lines may be a bit more pressurised than others but it is a reality and I am asking that Mayo be included with increased capacity. Sometimes there are only three carriages on the line.

Comment on this
Mr. Barry Kenny

Weekend services would potentially be scoped there. Obviously, as the Senator will appreciate, particularly with regard to tourism, and indeed people travelling home for weekends, that is an area where we have pressure. The day-in day-out focus would be very much on the commuter belt initially.

Comment on this

Could Irish Rail provide an update on the pilot of onboard catering and the potential to expand that to other services?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

The pilot started in mid-August. It is going well. We have had the first review. We are looking at a six-month window to run this pilot. If it is commercially viable at the end of the six months, it will provide a basis to look at expanding services. We are also looking at whether we could run a pilot on the Sligo service. There are other parts of the network where there is no service. This is something that we are actively looking at.

Comment on this

I have three or four issues I wish to focus on. I am looking for updates and some information.

The first concerns what is called the Kerry curve near Carey's Road in Limerick on the Foynes-Limerick line. Has extra funding been sought from the Department for this because the Land Development Agency is possibly looking at increased housing in the area that may jeopardise the line in the future? Has Iarnród Éireann been in contact with the Department about extra funding in order to make sure future development of the line is secure?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

Our long-term ambition is to connect the Kerry curve back to Colbert Station so that the line is able to be used. Obviously, it is planned for freight initially but we could reinstate passenger services on the line in the longer term. We are supportive of the development of housing and the LDA's plans for Limerick.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

However, it is important the alignment is protected. In the first instance, the embankment will need to be reinstated to protect the rail corridor and rail connection back into Colbert Station. We have discussed this with the NTA, as the funder. People are aware that our ask is to reinstate that.

Comment on this

Brilliant. It is an important part of the line. This ties into my next question. I assume Iarnród Éireann does not have a date for that freight line turning into a passenger line.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

We do not. Initially, the works on the line will be finished this weekend. It will be commissioned on time and on budget, which is a great news story for the region. Following driver testing, training and certification of the line from a safety perspective, our plan is that we will see freight services on the line from mid-2027. Longer term, particularly with the Kerry curve reinstated, it would make sense to have passenger services. It is not in the immediate plan, however.

Comment on this

It is then an overall plan-----

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

It is part of the overall-----

Comment on this

It is the ambition-----

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

-----strategy.

Comment on this

That is good to know. It would be utilised, even from the Kerry side travelling north. It would definitely be utilised. Will the witnesses provide an update on Moyross station? What point are we at with it?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

We have planning permission for Moyross station. We are pretty much ready to go to tender, but we are still seeking to resolve the land access arrangement with the stakeholders in the area. That is the main thing. We need to get that agreed with the stakeholders.

Comment on this

Is there a cut-off time for that agreement or could it be ongoing?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

It is ongoing at the moment. We would like to see it resolved swiftly so that we can progress the station. We are ready to go but we just need to get that closed out and agreed. Our intention is to build out that station once we are empowered to do it.

Comment on this

That is great. It is good news. The last point I will make is along the lines of what Senator Duffy spoke about. I know Iarnród Éireann has a trolley service in place on the Galway line for six months, but I hope to see the Limerick-Dublin service next in line for such a service. It is nice to see the trolley going around. I know there are not a huge number of direct Limerick-Dublin services. A lot of the time, we get off at Limerick Junction to change over to the train coming from Cork. By the time people get onto the train from Cork, however, the trolley is practically empty. It would be nice to see a trolley service in place for the Limerick-Dublin service, particularly for those of us leaving early in the morning who would not mind having something to eat, rather than having to buy a packet of bacon fries because it sounds like it is close enough to rashers, or having to justify eating Tayto at 9 a.m.

Other than that, it is great. I will advocate, as Iarnród Éireann does, for a passenger service on the Limerick-Foynes line. It would take an awful lot of cars off the road. We need to be pushing that. I am delighted to see that it is in Iarnród Éireann's overall plan and that it is being kept at the top of the witnesses' minds. They need not worry because every time I meet them I will keep it at the top of their minds. I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this

I have some questions about the development of DART+ West. First, has Government approval for the funding been put in place? When will tendering for this project commence?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

I thank the Deputy for the question. When it comes to DART+ West, we have what is called a detailed business case to secure approval gate 2, AG2, from the Department. That is with the NTA and the Department at the moment. We are expecting a positive decision by the end of November. That will put us in a position to commence the procurement process for the DART+ West project. I should say as well that we have also made the ask for DART+ South West-----

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

------in that approval.

Comment on this

DART+ West and DART+ South West are going to the Government at the same time. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

That is correct. We are looking for approval for both projects. Obviously, DART+ West is ahead in the queue but we want to get the approval for both. We want to progress the procurement and delivery of both in parallel.

Comment on this

Iarnród Éireann is expecting that they will go to Cabinet before Christmas.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

We are expecting approval before Christmas. I am not sure whether they go to Cabinet but we expect approval from the Department. Then, from a procurement point of view, we will look to issue to tender the civil engineering contract, which applies to both routes, the overhead power lines contract and the signalling and telecommunications contract. We have those contract packs ready. They are with the NTA, and it is reviewing them. It must give us approval for each tender pack before it goes out.

We are looking to issue the tender pack for the new train station at Spencer Dock in the city. That will go out in March. We will be carrying out some works at Connolly Station to improve accessibility. That will go to tender in March as well. We are planning to launch the railway order to extend DART+ West from Maynooth to Kilcock, which will include double tracking. Obviously, the depot at Kilcock-----

Comment on this

When does Iarnród Éireann hope to have decisions on the tenders? When does it expect to be awarding those key tenders?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

We expect to award those tenders by the end of 2027. Our view is to have DART+ West in full commencement and construction - these are design and build contracts - from the end of 2027. Again, that will be another Government decision because we will have to return for a-----

Comment on this

Iarnród Éireann hopes to break ground for DART+ West by the end of 2027.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

We will have enabling works in 2027. We are allowed to progress some of the enabling works. They will be located pretty much on the route corridor as opposed to off the corridor.

Comment on this

I am supportive of this programme but it is going to involve significant disruption for existing commuters during the build. When will commuters start to see significant disruption on the route?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

It will be during the four-year period between summer 2028 and summer 2032. Typically, we will be protective of Monday to Friday commuting patterns.

Comment on this

That is great. Iarnród Éireann will focus works on the weekends.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

That is correct. We will focus on nights and weekends. On bank holiday weekends, we will look for the longer possession windows where we can-----

Comment on this

Is it likely that, at some point, works will have to go beyond those windows and weekdays will be disrupted?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

There are a few such points, but they are only a handful. They are very limited.

Comment on this

Okay. That is good to hear.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

Such instances will occur, particularly at the back end of the scheme when we get into the commissioning phases.

Comment on this

Will they be flagged to commuters well in advance?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

Yes. In December every year, we agree the timetable for the following year. We will have this called out for the following year very clearly.

Comment on this

We will know in December or January for the year.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

Yes, for each coming year.

Comment on this

Turning to the big question, when will I be able to get a DART service from Castleknock into Connolly or Pearse stations?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

We are targeting day one opening by the end of 2032. There will be a ten-minute DART service pattern from Kilcock and the M3 parkway in Dunboyne, County Meath, into town and back.

Comment on this

Is that ten-minute service pattern for rush hour?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

That is correct. It will be a ten-minute service.

Comment on this

That is very good.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

There is a huge volume of work to be done in this regard. We need a good headwind on all the funding approvals and decisions we need, but that is the timeframe what we are working towards.

Comment on this

One of the concerns in Dublin West is the issue of the closure of level crossings, particularly at Coolmine and Clonsilla. At what point in the process will level crossings be closed? I know changes to the road network are meant to be brought in to deal with traffic redistribution. Is there any sense of those being piloted or tested to determine whether they work or actually make a difference?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

That is a valid question. The sequence for how we will deliver DART+ West requires us to do the up-front civil engineering work to prepare for the signalling equipment that will be installed on the route, the overhead power lines and the substations that will power the overhead power lines for the electric DART trains. We will also have to build the relief infrastructure around the levelling crossings. We have to build relief infrastructure to address the closure of the level crossings. Obviously, until that relief infrastructure is in place, we will not be able to close the level crossings. The closure of the level crossings is crucial to commissioning this signalling system, which is crucial to commissioning the overhead power lines. If any of the sequence moves, it puts the end date at risk. All I can say is that it will be after 2030 before we get to that point where we are in a position to-----

Comment on this

On the current timeline, the level crossings will remain open until after 2030.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

That is correct.

Comment on this

I will jump separately to Broombridge Station. I know when Iarnród Éireann looked at demand and throughput at stations on the Sligo line, it had some of the highest footfall because it interlinks with the Luas and a number of bus services.

Yet, in terms of facilities for passengers, it is one of the most poorly served stations. It has had a lot of vandalism over the years. While there are shelters at the Luas stop, there are none at the rail platform, nor are there any real-time monitors. For the busiest train station on the line not to have those basic facilities for passengers is really frustrating. Obviously, there will be work done on the DART stations in the run up to the DART expansion in 2032. Can anything be done for passengers in the short term? Sometimes there is a long wait between a Luas arriving and the connecting train arriving. Standing in the wet on a cold winter night not knowing when the train is coming is not pleasant. Is there anything that can be done in the short term to provide a bit of comfort to commuters using the Maynooth line?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

That is something we can take away and look at. It is not within the scope of the DART+ West project or programme at the moment. Deputy O'Gorman is right about the line, which I use myself. It is very intensely used and there is huge footfall. I am sure that is something we can take away.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

We can take that away and talk to the NTA about it.

Comment on this

This might seem like a small issue, but the loudspeaker in Connolly Station cannot be heard in the main building if any of the trains are in. I and others have often been at the station when the platform has been changed or there has been a delay to a train and it is announced on the loudspeaker, but nobody is any wiser because nobody can hear it. That needs to be looked at. Improving the passenger experience is something we need to focus on. It really frustrates passengers who know there is a problem with their journey when they cannot actually hear what is happening. I ask that the witnesses take that point away with them. My time is up.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am now going to move to other members. As Deputy Lawlor and Deputy Kelly have been here since the start of the meeting, I will give them two and a half minutes each, after which members will have another two and a half minutes each. Deputy Whitmore, who has just arrived, will have a two-and-a-half-minute slot at the end of the meeting.

Comment on this

I will be brief with my questions. The 2024 all-Ireland strategic rail review proposed that the Waterford-Rosslare line would be one of three lines to be reinstated by 2030. However, in December 2025 the Department of Transport omitted any reference to the line when it published works for prioritisation by 2040. Why did that happen?

Will Irish Rail indicate whether it is pursuing one or two separate insurance claims against the insurers of craft that struck the Barrow Bridge? What can Irish Rail tell us about the status of these claims? Are the moneys that result from these claims, on settlement, still ring-,fenced for repairs for the bridge as promised in a meeting in October 2023 between the then CEO of Irish Rail, Jim Meade, and South East on Track?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry Kenny

Regarding the query on the Waterford-Rosslare line, the rail review discussed a study at that time in the context of freight. Obviously, Irish Rail is developing Rosslare Europort for offshore renewable energy, as Deputy Lawlor knows and supports. Our strategy is that when that process is over there will then be the opportunity for rail freight.

Comment on this

Given the massive expansion of Rosslare and the almost 400% increase in freight traffic-----

Comment on this
Mr. Barry Kenny

There is a misunderstanding of what the prioritisation programme said. It did not take away the rest of the all-Ireland strategic rail review. It was about projects to get into the planning pipeline straight away, but it is not saying that the Waterford-Rosslare line is not being reinstated. That remains the longer term plan for that route, but it was in the context of freight that it was to be examined. Rail freight is not going to go to Rosslare in that timeframe because the offshore renewable energy, which will facilitate freight when that phase is over, is something we are moving ahead with first. Mr. Mangan will address the question on the Barrow Bridge.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Mangan

As the Deputy referenced, there were a couple of vessel strikes on the Barrow Bridge, which caused extensive damage to the functioning of the bridge. They are subject to an ongoing insurance claim.

Comment on this

Why are they ongoing? The bridge did not hit the ships. The ships hit the bridge. It is fairly straightforward.

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Mangan

I think it is quite complex. We are talking about underwater structures and so forth, and the claim is being challenged. It is ongoing.

Comment on this

I am hoping there will be a new departure, with Ms Considine and Mr. Mangan coming in, regarding the famous Ballybrophy line, which I have had to fight for decades to even keep open. On 2 November, promotional fares on the line will be taken away. Commuters into Limerick from Nenagh and other areas on that line have been using these fares in record numbers. I have had people message me from the train this morning asking why these fares are being taken away, given that they have been so successful.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

I will hand that over to Mr. Kenny.

Comment on this
Mr. Barry Kenny

These were legacy promotional fares. As Deputy Kelly may know, the NTA strategy is to implement a more consistent, distance-based fare structure across all public transport. Within that, in this current determination, this is a promotional fare that is being removed. There are fare options within it, certainly for regular commuters. The tax-saver fare with tax relief will still have an extremely competitive rate. It will be around €3.63 that will apply for a day-return ticket, depending on the customer's tax relief, if they go the tax-saver route. The option remains for heavily discounted fares there.

Comment on this

I know, but I have to say it has been a great success. We fought for so long to promote this line. This is a line that has been disgracefully neglected. Nenagh per capita probably has the highest number of houses being built in Ireland. It is a commuter town for Dublin. I would not even contemplate taking the train to Dublin because it does not meet my timetable needs, either going or coming. I have done videos to promote the line. The fact that something that has been a success is being taken away is madness. It is not going to have a massive budgetary impact one way or the other. It is about promoting the line. Will Irish Rail ask the NTA to reconsider this decision? I will do so.

I went to a presentation a number of months ago. I was a bit depressed because we thought people coming in from north Tipperary and from Foynes would be delighted with all the work going on, and we are, but it does not get away from the fact that we have a rail line that is under-utilised and in which there has been underinvestment. It obviously needs issues with level crossings and speed to be dealt with. We need direct trains. We need the junction at Ballybrophy to be put in place again for direct trains to Dublin. What is the timeline for doing that? Is there any hope that this will actually happen in my political lifetime, so we can have the track upgraded, the crossings dealt with and a proper timetable for people who, like me, genuinely want to use the service?

Comment on this
Mr. Cathal Mangan

Deputy Kelly will be aware that there has been some investment in the track in particular, where very aged track has been removed and upgraded. One of the big challenges that remains on the line as regards speeds is the large number of level crossings. We are continually looking at opportunities for closing those level crossings. We will achieve a couple of closures this year through negotiations with landowners. Incrementally, things are happening. There has been an improvement on the base infrastructure on the track, but that the level crossings-----

Comment on this

In terms of kilometres per hour, I would cycle faster.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I will turn to matters related to my region, namely, the Waterford-Limerick Junction line. I hope the witnesses are going to reassure me today by telling me that line is now a priority for Iarnród Éireann, particularly as it applies to my home town of Clonmel. I am thinking of the many students and workers who want to commute from Clonmel to Waterford each morning. Unfortunately, the timetable is, in essence, useless for those cohorts. The only train service each day departs sometime after 10.30 a.m., which I presume does not get into Waterford until well after 11 a.m. What are the plans for the Waterford-Limerick Junction line? Can Irish Rail give a commitment that it will make the existing timetable more user-friendly? Clonmel is defined as a regional economic driver in the regional economic and spatial strategy, as the main town along that particular route. For students and workers who want to commute every day to Waterford and get there in time for work or college, can Irish Rail commit to revising the 10.39 a.m. departure time? Will it look at having greater frequency, with additional trains on the line?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

The Deputy is correct. We have only two services daily at the moment. We have seen an increase in demand, but it is very moderate because of the timing. We acknowledge that. Interventions are required on the infrastructure there. In my opening statement, I mentioned ten early interventions. One of those will be the passing loop east of Clonmel, which has been prioritised and should be delivered by 2030. That will enable better infrastructure. We will then examine where we can cascade fleet, because we need fleet as well as infrastructure to improve the services and timetable.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Irish Rail is telling me, students and workers in Clonmel that there will be no change to the timetable until 2030.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

Unfortunately, until we have the passing loop in place, we have infrastructure constraints there. At the moment, we have real fleet constraints around-----

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

There are two services a day. Why can the existing timetable not be adjusted to suit workers and students who want to get to Waterford for 9 a.m.?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

We have examined that. To be fair to the Deputy, he has made strong representations on this in the past. We do not have fleet presently. As fleet becomes available in 2027 and 2028, we will start to look at it.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

There is already fleet on the line. I ask for an adjustment of the existing timetable for the fleet that is on the line.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

That links to the intercity services. That is where the train serves. We will continue to keep it under review.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I ask Ms Considine to look at it again and come back to me.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

We will.

Comment on this

I have asked a few questions on national issues and I now want to get into some local issues. There is a large freight crane at Colbert Station in Limerick which has been there for many years and seems to be rusting away. I asked about the status of the crane two or three years ago and I understood it had been bought and would be repurposed or sold on. It remains in place. At a time when the line from Foynes is ready to operate and there is a huge future for the region, what will happen to Colbert Station? Will the crane be retained by Irish Rail or is it still owned by the company? What freight future can Colbert Station look forward to?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

I will come back to the Deputy on the crane. I know what he is talking about, but I am not familiar with the history or background.

Comment on this

I appreciate that. Thank you very much. There was a lot of chatter about increased services. I refer to the Ballycar section of the Limerick to Ennis line, which is notorious for flooding. I understand there is a yellow rain warning overnight and we are getting into the winter season. Can Irish Rail give any reassurances to people following this meeting online on what Irish Rail and Clare County Council are doing to mitigate that?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

I thank the Deputy. As he is aware, a group of stakeholders have met on this, including Clare County Council, the OPW, Geological Survey Ireland and the National Parks and Wildlife Service. We are a member of the group, which commissioned a study in 2020 that came up with the design to address the flooding issues in Ballycar. The area is away from the railway, but obviously the railway is impacted by it. We are not the lead agency on that. We are keen to make sure that we have no further disruptions to rail services. We reached out to the other members of the group during the summer to reconvene it and see whether a solution can be brought forward. We are keen to have a solution found. If Members of the House can provide support to help us to move that along, we would appreciate it. Ultimately, it needs a lead agency and funding to address it.

Comment on this

I propose to the committee that the Commission for Railway Regulation, CRR, be invited to come before us to discuss the issue of train overcrowding. Irish Rail has operational responsibility, but the CRR is the safety body. Several elected representatives have said today that we do not feel it is safe to have people standing on trains. We cannot level all of this on Irish Rail. I would like the CRR to be brought before the committee so we can speak to its representatives. Someone might second that.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I second that.

Comment on this

I welcome the constructive engagement earlier and look forward to January when we have line of sight of how congestion will be eased. I want to return to DART+ South West and the medium term. The lesson we have all heard here today is that there is a need for us to plan, especially in terms of housing developments. I welcome that a business case has gone to AG2 for DART+ South West to be approved to go to tender. Will Mr. Hendrick give me a line of sight of what the timeline looks like if the green light is given for approval to go to tender for DART+ South West across all six aspects of the contract package?

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

I thank the Deputy for his question. If we get approval, we will be in position to issue the main construction tender part for DART+ South West in early summer next year, with a view to contracting that. A few other packages are linked to DART+ West for summer 2028. Our ambition is to have the main contract signed by summer 2028.

The work on the line is particularly challenging given the four tracking nature. We need to keep the main corridor running and protect passenger services, but we need to do a significant level of heavy civil engineering works to widen it from two to four tracks. That is the driving factor of the programme. We are looking at day one opening in 2034. It is a long timeline because of the tricky construction regime we have to follow in the corridor. It is moving from a double track to a four track. DART+ West will be open in 2032 and DART+ South West will be open in 2034. That is totally dependent on getting the necessary approvals so that we can work to that programme. Obviously, that is subject to funding.

Comment on this

In the interim period, there will be a cascading of the new fleet from DART+ Coastal North. There will not be one big bang in late 2027. There will be ongoing review and monitoring of the capacity on those lines over the time as well.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

A lot of people probably think that when we talk about DART+ it is all in development, but the reality is that we are in delivery for 57 five-car train sets, which is part of the DART+ programme. Obviously, it provides a direct benefit to the coastal service between Drogheda and Wicklow and everything in between. It also provides fleet opportunities around the fleet cascade. In terms of DART+ West and DART+ South West, there are 260 carriages on top of the 285 we have ordered. That will also provide the direct EMU service for west and south west. It will also provide other opportunities.

Comment on this

New carriages will be ordered as part of the DART+ South West programme, and that is in train and has been accounted and planned for as part of the overall package.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

That is the plan. In conjunction with signing the main construction contract, we will sign a rolling stock contract as well because we need to deliver fleet and infrastructure.

Comment on this

That will mitigate congestion problems in the future.

Comment on this

A couple of Green Party colleagues in Limerick and Tipperary have asked me to raise a matter that has already been raised, namely, issues to do with the Limerick to Ballybrophy line. One particular issue is the lack of services during the midday period. There is an understanding that there is a spare unit held in Limerick. Is there any capacity to bring that online to provide more midday services for the Limerick to Ballybrophy line?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry Kenny

My understanding is that it would also require significant PSO funding because there are quite a number of manned level crossings on that route. It is a bit more complicated than simply a train-----

Comment on this

Simply having a train, yes. A national fare increase will kick in in January. Is Irish Rail aware of any additional income coming from that being able to be deployed to deal with the level crossing issues?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

We are in ongoing discussions with the NTA to see whether we could secure even a modest uplift in services. It is to be hoped that the fact there will be additional funding allocated to the PSO budget for next year means we may be able to secure some of that. Those discussions are ongoing. As of now, we have no confirmation of additional funding.

Comment on this

Okay. My understanding is that there are no services on the line on Sundays and very few on bank holiday Mondays. Are Sunday services on the Limerick to Ballybrophy line part of the ask from Irish Rail this year?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

I do not believe so. I will take that away.

Comment on this

The change to fare structures has particularly impacted people on those lines. I am sure Irish Rail can understand the frustration people are feeling in that they are paying more. The Government line is that services are getting better, but is clear that there will be no improvement on that particular line in the short term. That undermines what we are trying to do in terms of encouraging people to use public transport.

Comment on this

Overcrowding is a huge issue. Many of the Members here have raised it and I have raised it in relation to the Rosslare-to-Dublin line. Has Iarnród Éireann done any safety assessments, inspections or monitoring of the safety issues? I have had people, including visually impaired women, tell me they have felt very unsafe on the train. People have fainted or collapsed on the train. It is causing huge problems. From a safety perspective, has Iarnród Éireann conducted any assessments of that?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry Kenny

As mentioned earlier, we appreciate that very busy trains are an uncomfortable experience when there is full loading. The trains are certified to safely accommodate full loading. Longer distance services, like Rosslare and Wexford to Dublin, are ones where we want to ensure that people have a seat, obviously, once the commuter area is cleared, but the nature of peak commuting does involve full loading. That is why it is so crucial that we get the additional fleet capacity in to meet both the current demand and the latent demand that is obviously there.

Comment on this

I know that is uncomfortable and those journeys are very long, but I am actually talking about safety risks. My understanding is that the railway safety commission recommended that Iarnród Éireann carry out inspections on the service.

Comment on this
Mr. Barry Kenny

As regards our fleet and network, there is both our own safety monitoring and the CRR, which can inspect us at any time as well.

Comment on this

How many times does Iarnród Éireann carry out inspections of, say, the Rosslare-to-Dublin line?

Comment on this
Mr. Barry Kenny

We would have to revert to the Deputy on that.

Comment on this

If the witnesses could come back to me with those figures, that would be great.

I will also talk, in relation to that line, about a very basic matter, and that is cleanliness. It has been reported to me that the line from Rosslare to Dublin, particularly the early service leaving Gorey northbound, can often be very dirty. I have raised this with members of Iarnród Éireann's staff. I have been told there has been vomit and urine in the carriages. Where are Iarnród Éireann's cleaning crews located? Are there any cleaning crews located in the Wexford or Wicklow areas?

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Briefly.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

I will come back to the Deputy. We do monitor cleanliness. I hear the concern the Deputy raises, and it is something we are very focused on, but if there are particular issues on that line, I will take that away and come back to her on it.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I call Deputy Connolly.

Comment on this

I appreciate the opportunity to contribute. I have heard a lot of positivity about the Ceannt Station development in Galway and the doubling of the platform in Oranmore. These are very positive developments. There is also the positivity today about the additional carriages that can be deployed to Galway in the near future, particularly for early-morning commuter services.

I have one concern following all that development. I was on the 9 a.m. train leaving Galway yesterday morning. It pulled out of Ceannt Station and stopped on Lough Atalia bridge, which is just outside the station. It was there until 9.30 a.m. while trains that were on their way to Galway had to proceed because the track changes from double to single at that point, at Lough Atalia. I am conscious of the Galway line capacity enhancement project. My simple request is that the doubling of the line from Galway to Athenry be separate from that and that it proceed without the necessity of going through the entire capacity enhancement programme between Galway and Portarlington. I think that will be a longer term project. I refer to the project from Galway to Athenry, which is much heralded, and we know the significant benefit it will be, particularly when we open the western rail corridor, the Limerick line. I do not want to describe it as pointless, but having six platforms in Ceannt Station and having only a single line to Athenry defeats the purpose, almost. That is my request, that the doubling of the rail track to Athenry be a separate project.

Comment on this
Mr. Paul Hendrick

I thank the Deputy for his question and his remarks about the Galway Ceannt projects in Oranmore. We fully recognise where he is coming from. What he says makes total sense. We are looking at the programme on the line from Portarlington to Galway, but it is broken down into a number of sections. How and when they get delivered is the discussion we are having around the funding availability and doing it. The long-term goal is to have that line fully double tracked. The Deputy is right about Galway to Athenry. We are looking to try to prioritise that as a project under the umbrella of the double-tracking of the line, particularly with the relationship with the line from Galway to Athenry and with the western rail corridor coming in. As to what we have done in Oranmore and with Galway Ceannt, it is the infill section in the middle. We are trying to advocate for that to be pushed forward.

Comment on this

The concern is that the funding for the second platform in Oranmore was announced in 2020. The planning application was not lodged until 2024. Since then, the progress has been reasonably good and swift, but it would be terrible to think we would have to wait a similar period for the rail line to Athenry to be double-tracked.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Deputy Aird, you have one minute.

Comment on this

My God. Do you hear that? One minute the Cathaoirleach gives his colleague.

I am a frequent user - and I mean frequent - of the train from Portlaoise to Dublin. The 10.10 p.m. service is the last one that leaves Heuston Station for Portlaoise in the evening. When we have late voting in the Dáil, we get caught by that, but there is a train at 11.10 p.m. that goes as far as Kildare and I am told it sleeps in Portlaoise. Could the witnesses check that out? If it is running the whole way to Portlaoise, why does it just stop there? It would be of great benefit to a whole lot of people, including me when I am late here in the Dáil, but not just me. There are loads of people who come up for concerts, matches and so on and who could use that late train going down the track. Could the witnesses please come back to me with an answer to that in their own time?

Thank you, Chair, for accommodating me with one minute.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

You are welcome, Deputy Aird. I fully support your request.

It is just left for me now to bring the meeting to a conclusion. We had a really good engagement, at times robust. It is great to see the extent to which services are growing and the growth over the past two years, at more than 20%, with passenger journeys in 2025 the highest ever, at more than 55 million and on track to approach 60 million. It is great to see that, but we also must acknowledge that there are passengers who are frustrated and angry. We heard a lot of safety concerns today. There are a number of follow-up actions. The clerk will be in touch with Iarnród Éireann seeking the additional information we require.

I thank the witnesses on behalf of the members for their time today. I do not think we will have any further engagement before the end of this year, they will be glad to know, but I am sure we will see them in the first quarter of next year. There are a lot of follow-ups. Hopefully, at that stage the NTA will have approved the roll-out of the TMS beyond the greater Dublin area or is it the Dublin metropolitan area?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

It is the greater Dublin area.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I still cannot get my head around why the Department is in charge and has already approved that yet the NTA is responsible. Is the reason Irish Rail is responsible only for the rail network outside the Dublin metropolitan area historical? Why is that?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

Irish Rail is responsible for the whole network, but the NTA is the approving authority within the greater Dublin area. It is not-----

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Why is the Department the approval body for the greater Dublin area and for the TMS?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Considine

It was approved as a resilience measure under the infrastructure manager funding, which is separate funding just to maintain our current infrastructure. It is to do with the funding stream.

Comment on this
Michael Murphy An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I will come back to that later.

I thank the Deputies and the Senators for their engagement. We will now publish the opening statement on the committee's website. Is that agreed? Agreed. I thank the witnesses from Iarnród Éireann again for their attendance.

The meeting now stands adjourned only until tomorrow, when we will meet again in public session with the Minister at 12.05 p.m.

Comment on this