Capital Projects and Operations: Iarnród Éireann
Contributions 1–156 of 309. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
The purpose of today's meeting is to engage with Iarnród Éireann-Irish Rail and be provided with an update on its capital projects and operational activities. I am very pleased to welcome Mr. Jim Meade, chief executive, Mr. Paul Hendrick, director of capital investments, and Mr. Barry Kenny, corporate communications manager.
Witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. If their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks and it is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official, either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. I also remind members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit a member to participate where he or she is not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Any member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting and in this regard, I ask any member partaking via Microsoft Teams to confirm that he or she is on the grounds of the Leinster House campus prior to making a contribution.
Mr. Meade, I now invite you to make your opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for the invitation to attend to provide it with an update on Iarnród Éireann’s activities, including our capital projects and operations. We are at a time of great ambition and optimism for our rail services and network, and for Rosslare Europort, for which Iarnród Éireann is the port authority. Projects for all our cities and for the national network will ensure rail is the backbone of Ireland’s sustainable transport network. The decade of delivery that we are working through will be genuinely transformative for the network.
Passenger demand for 2023 saw 46.1 million journeys made across the network, an increase of 29% on the 2022 total of 35.8 million. The pre-Covid record of over 50 million is in sight for this coming year. The intercity service is seeing a particularly strong recovery. We introduced new services on routes including Cork, Limerick, Westport-Ballina and Carlow in our recent December 2023 timetable change, as well as enhanced Portlaoise and Drogheda commuter services. In the short term, we will begin the introduction of 41 new intercity railcar carriages, which could not be more timely. We envisage further timetable improvements during 2024, particularly on the Galway and Belfast routes. As well as building our service capacity, we continue to build the customer experience. Our restructured train operations division brings a determined focus to ensuring we become a leader in Europe for customer care.
Our major rail investment programme, funded by the National Transport Authority, NTA, under Project Ireland 2040, will see significant, tangible progress in a range of projects during the year ahead. Our current planned fleet and network investment programme will exceed €1 billion during the life of the national development plan, NDP, and will bring us to a new era for rail transport in Ireland. As well as the intercity railcar carriages mentioned previously, the first of 185 DART+ carriages on order from Alstom will arrive in summer of 2024 to begin testing and commissioning ahead of entering service in 2025. These are battery-electric and so are a very sustainable fleet. This transformative fleet is central to the DART+ programme. The investment will allow more trains to operate on all routes on the rail network, provide greater standards of accessibility, and allow for the decarbonising of all greater Dublin area rail services. DART+ will double the capacity and treble the electrification of the greater Dublin rail network.
In our submission, we have included a table outlining the various programmes under DART+, with DART+ West being the first element. We are awaiting a railway order on that and believe it is imminent, with DART+ South West coming hot on its heels. We are just awaiting the railway order oral hearing, which is to be scheduled by An Bord Pleanála, and the others will follow suit.
At the bottom of the table, there is the DART+ Fleet, which, as I said, the first carriages of which will arrive at the end of quarter 2.
We are also progressing, with our partners Translink and Northern Ireland Railways, a tender for a new Enterprise fleet to ensure a sustainably powered hourly service on the Dublin to Belfast route. We are liaising with the Department of Transport and the Special EU Programmes Body, SEUPB, on funding and timelines for this project.
Turning to our regional cities, I will start with Cork. All projects in the Cork area commuter rail programme are under way under the EU-funded recovery and resilience plan, allowing Iarnród Éireann to treble the Cork commuter rail network’s capacity through three enabling projects on the infrastructure side. First is double-tracking Glounthaune to Midleton. The railway order was granted before Christmas and works have commenced. Second, we are developing a new platform at Kent Station that would allow through-running for Mallow to Cobh-Midleton. Third, we are resignalling the Cork commuter network, for which the contract has been signed and work commenced. That whole project is on target for delivery in 2026.
In Galway, funding under the urban regeneration development fund, URDF, includes investment of just under €10 million for a second platform and passing loop at the existing Oranmore train station. This will allow the busy commuter link between Athenry and Galway to grow. A planning application is currently in the pipeline for early this year. In addition, Ceannt Station will be regenerated as part of a major Galway City Council transport connectivity project. We recently awarded the contract. Physical works began earlier this month, which will deliver a transformative five-platform station at the heart of an integrated transport hub, catering for all future service growth.
In Limerick, the completion of the city’s own transport hub centred at Colbert Station will boost services, and the Limerick Shannon metropolitan area transport strategy has detailed the opportunities provided by the network of rail lines around Limerick city. Station studies are under way for both Moyross and Ballysimon stations, and a capacity enhancement study for Limerick to Limerick Junction and Limerick to Ennis is also under way.
Waterford’s Plunkett Station is being relocated to be part of an integrated transport hub under the Waterford North Quays, and these works are also under way.
As one arrives and departs Heuston Station, one will see our new national train control centre, NTCC. Its construction was completed in late 2022 and is co-located with An Garda Síochána facilities opened in 2023. The Garda moved from the Harcourt Street site. It will control the entire national network, incorporating a new rail traffic management system called TMS and enhance train performance, punctuality and customer information across the network. It will be fully operational by autumn 2025. We had targeted the end of 2024 for completion but the impacts of Covid-19 and the Ukraine conflict affected construction and TMS development timelines. However, we are working with the NTA as the approving authority and applying rigorous project oversight to ensure that we can, as planned, migrate from our existing central traffic control, CTC, facility at Connolly Station on a phased basis to mid-2025, gradually transferring all our railway controls operations from Connolly to Heuston for full operation.
We are ambitious for our rail freight services to become a key part of Ireland’s freight sector. Our Rail Freight 2040 Strategy sets out a clear path to make this happen. The strategy aims to achieve a fivefold increase in the number of freight services, to include more than 100 new weekly services across the network; a resulting reduction of 25,000 tonnes of CO2 emissions annually, with rail freight emissions per unit as little as 16% of HGV emissions; and avoiding the requirement for 140,000 HGV journeys on our roads annually, as well as helping the supply chain, which is facing a shortage of HGV drivers.
The strategy outlines 25 initiatives and a cumulative investment of approximately €500 million within the five strategic pillars of the freight strategy, which are: enhancing connections with sea ports; developing a network of inland intermodal terminals; investing in new wagon fleets and bimodal locomotives to allow for further decarbonisation of freight flows; network developments including the connectivity of industrial sites directly to the network; and working with national, regional and European agencies to ensure a policy framework is in place to support a more favourable environment for rail freight, in line with European norms.
Works to reinstate the Limerick to Foynes rail line for freight services are under way following funding from the Department of Transport. It is clear commitment to the goals of the Rail Freight 2040 Strategy, with an early 2026 opening still planned.
Under climate action, as well as providing sustainable transport alternatives for people and freight, this investment is part of our climate action to reduce emissions by 51% by 2030. This will be achieved from reduced reliance on diesel through alternative fuels on existing fleets with biofuels, hydrotreated vegetable oil, HVO, and green hydrogen programmes being pursued. Track maintenance vehicle and road fleet transition programmes are under way. We will also be transitioning to electric-powered fleet. The DART+ fleet mentioned are the first order from a framework contract of 750 carriages, which can also serve the Cork area, Wicklow and elsewhere, subject to infrastructure investment. We will also achieve reduced emissions through: green energy generation, including photovoltaic, PV, solar panels and corporate purchasing power agreements; a fleet and building works to reduce energy consumption, with our existing intercity railcar and commuter fleets seeing hybrid power and other upgrades to reduce consumption; and building upgrades to improve energy efficiency while protecting the heritage of our buildings.
The next subject I will speak about is the all-island strategic rail review. Railways and other transport infrastructure are long-term national assets, and the publication by the Department of Transport in Ireland and Department of Infrastructure in Northern Ireland of the draft of the first all-island strategic rail review was extremely welcome in establishing the future strategic agenda for our sector. It recommends improved speeds and frequency, electrification, new and enhanced routes and greater regional balance by developing a rail network that will sustainably serve a growing population, significantly benefitting people, communities, businesses, the environment and economies across the island of Ireland, both North and South. Iarnród Éireann strongly supports all recommendations in the draft review and appreciates having had the opportunity to input into its preparation. We look forward to collaborating with all stakeholders on next steps and see it as part of the real momentum towards rail playing a stronger role in our transport and mobility solutions over the years and decades ahead. It is critical that we ensure a steady pipeline of projects to maintain our infrastructure development and move away from stop-start patterns of the past.
There are two final matters that I wish to raise, the first of which is Rosslare Europort. Iarnród Éireann is port authority for Rosslare Europort and its status as Ireland’s gateway to Europe has been confirmed with 36 services operating directly between the port and Europe each week. As well as investment in the port master plan, an ambitious €200 million plan to become one of Ireland’s renewable energy hubs to service the offshore renewable energy, ORE, sector is progressing, with the port uniquely placed to support the development of the industry in the Celtic and Irish Seas. The planning process for this key national and regional strategic investment will be progressed through 2024. We are also supporting the Office of Public Works, OPW, in its significant T7 investment programme in the port, incorporating permanent border control facilities within our site at Rosslare Europort.
Last but not least is our people. We are building a workplace to firmly establish Iarnród Eireann as an employer of choice. Ensuring the railway has the talent and skills across all roles needed to deliver on its ambitions is critical. The company offers not just employment but full career opportunities across the company. In 2023, for the third year in a row, Iarnród Eireann was ranked as one of Ireland’s five leading employers in the best employers research. It was third overall and the leading Irish employer in the study in 2023. Additionally, we have been awarded apprenticeship employer of the year, with a commitment not only to excellent apprenticeships but continued career opportunities. It is a busy time but an exciting one. Our team of more than 4,500 colleagues across all business areas are working as one team to deliver on our ambitions.
I thank the committee for its continued support. We would be happy to answer any questions members may have.
Comment on this
Mr. Meade was supposed to have five minutes but his presentation took 11. However, it was important that he took the time to outline the position in full. It is clear that there is a great deal of activity going on. The numbers relating to public transport generally and the rail service in particular are very positive. Where the facilities are offered, we see people are able to make the change.
As a Senator, you get the opportunity to have a constituency that encompasses the entire country. You can be parochial everywhere because it is all your parish. I sent out an email only yesterday evening and since then I have heard from 34 different councillors right across the country, from areas with huge amounts of rail services to areas, including Donegal, that do not have any services but want them. I will not be able to cover all the points raised by those councillors but I will try to mention them. I spoke to Mr. Meade in advance about how he might be able to respond with answers in writing. We will have his company's chair designate in shortly, no doubt with some others as well, and we might go back and clarify those that do not get resolved.
I know some are definitely being looked at. For example, the dining service is not back everywhere yet. Is it on the way back? That has been kind of a constant of our engagement since I have been on this committee.
It is back on some services. It is not back on others. There was a difficulty tendering. Airlines seem to make an awful lot of money out of catering on planes but they may have a different cost model because they have cabin crew there providing security already who are then doing it additionally. Certainly, that is one of the points.
I will touch on other points but I want to mention a flavour of the queries I got. Iarnród Éireann can respond. I do not expect a response to all of these, but only wish to touch on them to let people know that we are in touch and listening to their issues and their challenges, and equally, that they are being considered and that Iarnród Éireann will come back to them.
Councillor Mark Duffy in Ballina says the additional trains for Mayo are most welcome but the late train service to Ballina on a Saturday is not available, and asks if that can be rectified.
On staffing resources, there is a query for Bus Éireann which we will deal with on another day. I do not expect Mr. Meade to answer those ones.
On an update on DART+ West for Councillor Howard Mahony in Fingal, does Iarnród Éireann intend to close all the railway crossings west of Ashtown? Apparently, they can be open on the DART line from Bray to Howth but not on DART West. They have not been able to get an answer to that for three years.
Councillor Adrian Henchy asks for an update, including timelines, on the delivery of the DART extension north of Malahide to Drogheda. Are their potential opportunities for Irish Rail to connect in any line out of Dublin Airport? That is separate to the MetroLink. Obviously, there was talk previously of a connection from the DART.
Councillor Mick Duff, in Tallaght, states that areas such as Ballyfermot and Inchicore have experienced high population increases and asks if Iarnród Éireann could open a station at the Inchicore engineering works with access via the so-called Khyber Pass at Sarsfield Road in order to serve this high-demand area.
Councillor Christy Burke, in Dublin, wants to know why Iarnród Éireann cut down trees along the canal at Charleville Mall, on the North Strand. They have been asking for three years about that.
In Meath, we have issues about the Navan rail line, if Mr. Meade can touch on that. It is topical.
The NTA came out with its new fare structure today. Mr. Meade might mention the impact of that on Iarnród Éireann's services.
There is more about the Navan rail line from Councillor Paul McCabe and Councillor Aisling Dempsey, and, in Kildare, from Councillor Seamus Moore. It is a case of there being an absolute appetite here. We see extra members here today. There are other members who want to contribute who are not members of this committee. Deputy Ó Cuív is here. Deputies Leddin, Wynne and Pádraig O'Sullivan are all interested. We might be having Mr. Meade back sooner than he thinks or sooner than he might have liked to be here. To touch on those points, is it a resourcing issue? Is it a financing issue? The dining car is one that we have been asking about a lot since Covid.
Comment on this
I took a note on them. I will deal with all those. The fare structure-----
Comment on this
Would the Leas-Chathaoirleach take a vote in the Seanad?
Comment on this
As we committed already, I am pleased to forward on all the various queries and we will respond to them. We will have those responses in before our-----
Comment on this
I have Sligo-Longford queries. I have Galway queries. I have Limerick-Ennis queries. I have Kerry queries. I have Cork queries. It is almost like Iarnród Éireann's arterial network. I have got queries from people about all those lines, and then from some people who do not have lines but want lines.
Comment on this
The Leas-Chathaoirleach might get through it all.
The NTA has announced a new fare structure. Like all fare structures, it is mostly improvements but, from our perspective, it does not really impact us. We are now on what is called a gross-cost contract.
Comment on this
We collect the fare box but it goes straight to the NTA.
Comment on this
We do not keep it. It goes straight to the NTA. That is since the start of the year.
The changes to fares are done by the NTA. They collect the farebox. We submit our budget every year and they approve it or not, which they did last year for the current year. Then we have to provide our services against that budget and not go over it. In that context, it does not really impact on us.
It will impact on us in certain areas. I commute in and out from Newbridge when I stay up and the short-hop zone will be extending out as part of this. That will draw a lot more people onto that network and it will become a capacity issue for us quite quickly, particularly in the greater Dublin area, as we extend the short-hop zone. What we will be looking at increasingly is how this can be done. As we go through this afternoon, the committee will hear more from us on where we are going with the fleet and when we expect to see new trains on the system. There will be a pinch point with capacity because we are already seeing it with the rate of recovery we have had. The fare structure is looked after by the NTA. The benefit, or not as the case may be, will be to its account and not to ours.
The Navan rail line is in plan already. That is something that will happen. Part of Mr. Hendrick's team is looking after it. They have just put the team in place and they are starting with the planning phase of that.
Dublin Airport is not in the current NDP. It is called out in the all-island strategic rail review. It is a line item in that review for consideration. The all-island strategic rail review, as I stated in my note, was out for public consultation. Consultation has gone back. The Department is collating that. I believe they hope to publish it as soon as they can. We inputted into that. It is the Department's document. It details all three airports, Belfast, Dublin and Shannon, to be considered for connection to the heavy-rail network. Arising out of that review, the next steps for post-final publication will be to identify the projects we want to move forward with and start the plan on those.
Later trains is always an issue for everybody. It is something we have looked at. We have added some in the current timetable. By sweating the assets, we have more. We are constantly looking at that. There is a trade-off between maintaining the railway, which we can only do at night, and how late we operate and how early we start so that we create a window for the infrastructure people to get in, maintain the railway and keep it at the level we want to keep it at. That will always be a trade-off but we are considering the possibilities on all routes. As we roll out our new fleets, including the new Alstom fleet and the battery-electrics, we will be able to start cascading fleet, particularly onto the regional routes that are currently there because, of the first two orders, we will be adding these fleets and we will not be taking anything out. That will allow us to cascade, to provide for hourly services to the major cities, and to put on later trains once we have that fleet.
The dining service was mentioned as well by the Leas-Chathaoirleach. When we came back after the pandemic, we went to put back the full service. Costs had increased, in some cases fourfold or fivefold. We pay for somebody to provide that service. We had a limited budget from the NTA to do it.
Comment on this
Is it not considered a profitable service in that an operator can go on a train, deliver a product and collect what they can get paid for it?
Comment on this
No. Even in the boom times, we were paying for that service. We were paying an annual contribution and the operator was making what it could from it. Post Covid, people wanted to shift all the risk onto the rail company. The kind of numbers that were being suggested were just not tenable with us. However, we used the budget we had to put on the Cork service because that, for us, was the premier route. It is the longest route. It catches Kerry. It catches Limerick. We were getting a decent benefit from it. While using that budget for that, we have also gone back to the market. That allows suppliers to understand what the market is now like, how many people would use it and what the footfall would be, etc. We are currently in the market for a full service but it will come down to a cost factor as to what kind of costs come back. We are all seeing cost inflation in every aspect of life now - it is just what it is - but we hope to be able to put services back on all routes post that procurement process.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Meade. I will not keep listing all the issues. Some of the members here will be touching on points. I have issues about the Ballybrophy line in north Tipperary. I have issues about the lack of a bridge in Killarney between the bus station and the train station. If there was one, it would save people, particularly the elderly and those with mobility issues, an eight- or nine-minute walk. It seems a no-brainer but it has never happened. Mr. Meade might touch on that.
I will submit all these queries. Mr. Meade might come back to me with them and then we can resolve them if they need further investigation. There is an appetite for public transport. If it is there and it is reliable, clean, frequent and priced well, people really want to use it, but if it is not there, they cannot. If it is not reliable, they cannot. If it is too full, they cannot. I was genuinely amazed by the amount and volume of queries I got, and the detailed nature of some of the queries I have. I may come back in at a later stage. Some of them may be covered by other members anyway.
I do not want to hog the time but to allow other members in. I will bring in, first of all, members of the committee and then non-members of the committee. Then we will go back to members of the committee for a second round, if we have time. The next contributor, a member of the committee, is Deputy Martin Kenny, who has ten minutes.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Meade for his contribution and the work he and all the staff across the whole network do.
Starting locally, on 10 December Iarnród Éireann announced increases to services across the country. Unfortunately, living in the north west, we did not seem to get any such increases. The Sligo-Dublin line did not get any additional services or investment. I would like an explanation. What plans are there to set that particular discrepancy right?
I would also like to get some more information on the plans for the development of the western rail corridor.
It is welcome that the Athenry to Claremorris part of it is in progress. The next part of that is up to Collooney. People in my constituency and, indeed, the entire north west are determined for that to happen as quickly as possible. I hope Iarnród Éireann shares that determination, not as something that is pie in the sky but to ensure that infrastructure will be sterilised, cannot be used for anything else and is put in place to put rail on it as fast as we can.
Mr. Meade mentioned a lot of the investment that is happening. He stated that in some cases there is double-tracking and pointed out where issues are to be resolved. I hope there are other areas where that can be expanded, with more work done in respect of that.
We really need to look at the issue in Dublin Airport. It is the main international airport in the country, and while metro is something we absolutely need and should be happening as quickly as possible, I am interested to know whether there are any plans or any possibility for a DART line that would go there, which would happen much faster than metro. Even if we started metro tomorrow, it would probably be seven, eight or ten years before it would happen. Is there an alternative whereby we could put a rail out there-----
Comment on this
Yes, but when we get into government, it will be much faster than that.
Comment on this
You can try your best but it will be hard for you. We want to see something that is progressing and can happen soon. What is Mr. Meade’s view on delivering something in that area?
Comment on this
As the Deputy outlined, we made several changes in December relating to sweating the assets we have as best we can. We intend to significantly improve the services to the full arc of the country, including Sligo, Westport, Galway, Limerick, Kerry, which is at the maximum, Waterford and so on, as we roll out the fleet. We also intend to move to an hourly service and reduce journey times. Those are our two big ticket items on those routes. It is about sweating the assets we have at the moment on the route in question. We have ambition and plans to add other services to the route and we will be doing that.
The Deputy mentioned the airport. It is, as I outlined, a line item in the all-island strategic rail review, where all three major airports are called out. It is not currently in either the regional NDP up to 2027 or the revised NDP from 2021 to 2030. It is not in our plans at the moment, but the draft TEN-T proposal from the European Commission targets all major city airports with passenger traffic of more than 12 million passengers to be connected to the heavy rail network by 2040. That is going to align with the ambition in the all-island rail review. The TEN-T proposal is still a draft and may change, but right now that is what the draft says.
Yes, it can be done, but it is up to the Government at a given point to decide whether it wants to do it. We can deliver it if we are asked to do it, but that will come from the Government, through the Department, and probably through the NTA to us.
Comment on this
Does Iarnród Éireann have a timeline as to how fast that could happen?
Comment on this
In reality, if we had approval for it to happen today, we would first start into a design and planning phase. It would require a railway order. If we had a fair wind, it would be two or two and a half years at a minimum, probably a little more, and we would build it out in a further two or two and a half years.
Comment on this
It is dangerous to say numbers because numbers get bandied about and quoted back. I will not put a number on it, but it would be reasonable for what we would be doing, although I would say that, given I am a railway person.
Comment on this
Is there a track, or does Iarnród Éireann have something in mind, for the route it would take to do that?
Comment on this
It was looked at previously. The alignment would be that we would go beyond Clongriffin Station, turn left and go in under the flight path. We would elevate and go over the M1 rather than underground, just as the railway through the centre of Dublin is elevated and has been for 190 years. As we approached the motorway, we would elevate, stay up and go into the departure areas of T2 and T1.
On the western rail corridor, again, that is a line item and we know it is the ambition of the Minister for Transport to reinstate it if he can. It is called out in the strategic review. We recently started doing some de-vegetation works on it to keep the line clean and open. The Department's view is that it is very viable for a freight corridor, in particular. We would probably do it in stages from Athenry to Claremorris. Beyond Claremorris, we would certainly support the ambition to keep it for rail traffic rather than anything else, and in time, if a decision is made to connect to Collooney, so be it.
Comment on this
Mr. Meade mentioned freight and, in his opening statement, pointed out the ambition Iarnród Éireann has around that. Are there issues with regard to yards and so on? A lot of them were closed and the facilities taken away. Would a lot of investment be required to get back into freight to make it profitable in future?
Comment on this
We carried out an overarching freight strategy a year and a half ago, which called out €500 million over a ten- or 15-year period or maybe longer. It looked at inland ports and intermodal hubs. Those would be new facilities where we would connect in. There are some yards we could use. We are talking to some of the local authorities. One local authority in the middle of the country is very interested in an intermodal hub because it would have connectivity to ports. We would put in the facilities where they would be best suited to allow the heavy goods industry to do the short hauls to and from the ports. Traditionally, such as in the case of my home station in Limerick, the freight yard was located in what is now almost the middle of the city, but we would not put it there now. It would be somewhere outside the city and we would let the road transport do the short legs.
For us, it is about reconnecting with the ports. A good example is Foynes Port, which we are reconnecting with. I know the Shannon Foynes Port Company is anxious to get it finished and believes it will get a lot of traffic for it if we can start moving traffic to that port. A supplier in the west is anxious to move two trains a week, as soon as we get it open, from the west to Foynes Port. It has specified Foynes Port, but it could really go to any port. We intend to reconnect with Cork Port and we are currently connecting with Waterford Port and Dublin Port. It is about growing business. We currently carry in or around 1% of the traffic, and the ambition is to grow that into the mid-teens over a ten- or 15-year period.
Comment on this
The frequency of trains is one of the main issues people have a difficulty with, not least in the case of late-night or late-evening trains. Are there ambitions to do that throughout the State and when will that happen? What happened in early December was clearly welcome but an awful lot of the trains, even from the west, which has a poor enough service some of the time, are very overcrowded and do not have the frequency people require. Will double-tracking be needed on some of those tracks to bring them up to the standard we need?
Comment on this
The short answer on the final part of that question is "Yes", and we have identified in our own strategies where we believe those sections will be. While we spoke about the Sligo road earlier, in the case of Westport and Galway, we would look at double-tracking between Portarlington and Athlone. We definitely want to double-track from Athenry into Galway, given that if and when Athenry to Claremorris is completed, we would then be at a crossroads of the railway and there are inherent traffic difficulties in Galway. Oranmore into Galway by rail takes eight minutes, whereas by road at the morning peak it takes closer to an hour, so it is a no-brainer and we have the desire to do that. We have started a study looking at double-tracking from Limerick to Limerick Junction. We have identified areas throughout the network where we need to add double-tracking, which will add capacity to the network and frequency.
We absolutely have an ambition to put later trains to all our major cities and to go to an hourly service to all our major cities throughout the network. It does give us a headache, and we have to figure out how we are going to maintain the railway. When TII wants to do major work on a motorway, it will shut it and switch to an alternative route, but we do not have that flexibility, so we have to plan how we can carry out our maintenance cleverly and in shorter timeframes or blitz it in different ways. The network has been upgraded and continues to be upgraded, and once we get it to the condition it should be in, given it was let run down over a couple of decades, it will be easier to keep that maintenance level.
The spend over time is smaller if you do it that way. We will always have that trade-off and, not so much early trains, because we probably have enough early trains in most directions, but later trains are being looked at to all the cities.
Comment on this
Will there be a problem providing security on later trains?
Comment on this
There is always a security risk in everything we do. It is slightly different but the model is the same. We ran a lot of late-night trains over the Christmas period in the greater Dublin area and we put security on all of those. We got very good numbers on them this year and numbers are growing every year. As we put on those Christmas and new year late-night trains, they get support and the use of them is growing.
On all of our intercity services over the past three years, we have put onboard customer service people back on board. We do not have an intercity train that moves around now with nobody on board. We did for a number of years but we have corrected that, and anywhere we have issues, we will put in security, be it in stations or on board. There are no right or wrong answers. Antisocial behaviour is a societal issue. We see it. Dublin Bus, Bus Éireann and the Luas see it, and we see it off the public transport system as well. It will be constant monitoring, reviewing and seeing where we need security. We have more than doubled our security presence across the network in recent years and we keep responding to the need.
On security, there is an onus on me to say for the record of the committee that An Garda Síochána has been very co-operative with us in this area. We have done an awful lot of very good work with it. It has put in transport hubs for us and it does the twin-track days. There is great co-operation between ourselves and An Garda Síochána and there is a great response to the whole antisocial area.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Kenny and if he wants I will try to bring him back in later. Senator Craughwell is next.
Comment on this
I am delighted to see that the Leas-Chathaoirleach has covered most of our electorate but he missed out on one or two.
Comment on this
Councillor Leonard from Wicklow talks about the Rosslare line. I understand now that the train is so overcrowded that people stand all of the time. She has made the request for at least two more carriages to be added. She also mentions people carrying bicycles on the train, and this is becoming a problem. I use the Luas and have seen people bringing their bicycles into seated and standing areas on the Luas, which is a problem and, indeed, is a problem on any sort of rail.
Comment on this
People cannot actually bring bicycles on the Luas, so if the Senator saw them, he should not have seen them.
Comment on this
People do, and especially these scooters we are still waiting to regulate.
Comment on this
That is a problem. Councillor Joe Conway - I got another one of my councillors in, thank God - has highlighted the fact that the disabled toilet on the Waterford train has been out of service since 2 December. Of all the people to let down, and I know because my son-in-law is in a wheelchair, any time wheelchair users want to travel, it is particularly difficult to have access and find where they get access. Has Irish Rail plans to provide better access for disabled people on the rail system?
Another issue is the dining service my colleague mentioned. The Enterprise service from Dublin to Belfast has excellent dining services, as does the Cork train service. An auld fella like myself travelling by rail likes to sit down and have my breakfast in comfort as I travel back to the west or wherever. From that point of view, I would hope that Irish Rail is successful in getting a new contractor to come in and that the business would be viable for it, but not for six times the price. If there is anything we can do to assist in that, that would be really important.
The other issue that bothers me is the number of railway lines we closed down in the sixties. I am mindful, for example, of the line to Clifden. My grandfather, God be good to him, drove a Bianconi coach out to Clifden before there was a train going out there, and then we had the train. A lot of the infrastructure is still there. Has anybody looked at that infrastructure and seen how we might expand the rail system? I realise we are talking about a lot of money. If we want a truly green country, the best thing we could do is have a rail service going out to places like Clifden and Donegal. The western rail corridor needs to be reopened fully.
I am really impressed to hear the witnesses talk about freight. I reckon we could reduce to a fraction the number of 40-foot trucks I see on the roads every single day if we had proper depots. I am very familiar with Limerick railway station. You could not do freight there, but you could probably do freight somewhere out around Mungret. There is a railway line going out as far as Mungret, so it could possibly be done. Is Irish Rail getting the support it would need to start setting up these freight depots around the country? I can see us reducing from 40-foot trailers to delivery vans in local and regional areas.
Those are my key issues. The Rosslare issue seems to be a huge problem now. With the growth of towns like Gorey, Arklow, etc., and the people are all commuting into this godforsaken town, that is a serious problem. Has Irish Rail the money to buy extra carriages if it needs them?
Comment on this
I remind the Senator not to find fault or criticise things, or make them identifiable. Be careful what you say about our capital city.
Comment on this
There is support from the Department, absolutely. I give credit to the Department and the NTA, which some of the funding comes through. They are supportive of the programmes we have and have listed. They are supportive of the capital programmes. We have just made a submission for Rosslare. The business case has gone in to the Department. We are just about finishing the procurement process for a new fleet for freight. The Department awaits that from us to go through the funding models to see if it has the capital to fund. Everything must go through a business case process and comply with the public spending code. Is the Department's door open to us and can we put plans on the table? Absolutely, I would say that aspect has shifted considerably over recent years. There is a willingness to discuss. We still have to make the case stand up but there is a willingness to cost.
As a west Clare man who grew up on the old west Clare line and now lives in east Clare, which is near Deputy Crowe's constituency, I also lament what we could have if we had the west Clare line right now. Like the Clifden line, in the 1960s, when these railway lines were closed, they were abandoned. Local farmers took them over and people built houses on the permanent way, etc., so it would be a considerable cost to bring some of those back into use. Can it be done? Of course it can but it is all about how many. To be honest, you start talking billions if you are going to CPO land.
Where we have existing alignments, they are from the seventies on and the eighties. We learned from the mistakes of the past. That was our forefathers and none of us were involved. We did not abandon lines anymore but put them under care and maintenance, which is why we have the Foynes line to reopen. I have the unusual distinction that, as a very young manager, one of the first jobs I got when I went into operations was to close the Foynes line, so I am happy to be still here to reopen it. We retained the western rail corridor and the Cork-Midleton line, so we were able to put railways back on for a relatively cheap price. You have to look at all of these assets. There are big numbers involved. Mr. Hendrick will not talk unless you are talking about a hundred million or a billion. Those are the numbers he likes to talk in now because-----
Comment on this
-----it is major capital. You are putting in infrastructure for 100 years. When you stand back and look at the life cycle cost of these investments, of new trains, which now come at a very reasonable price, and new infrastructure, it is actually cheap infrastructure. In fairness to the Government, and the Department was mentioned, they now see that and that the long-term investment, especially in all modes of transport infrastructure, is a good investment long term.
The Senator mentioned two things, one of which was the Rosslare line. Maybe afterwards he would give us details about the Waterford train because there should not be a disability toilet out of service. We do need to follow up on the matter.
Comment on this
I have the same query and there is a photo, but it is about the accessible toilet at Heuston Station. It has not been operational since 2 December, and it was still not operational on 15 and 22 January, which is about seven weeks. People use the toilet on their train journey between Waterford and wherever, but I think this is a query about the station's accessible toilet.
Comment on this
No, it was the train here and I have the photographs.
Comment on this
The Senator has the photograph but I think is the accessible toilet at the station rather than on the train.
Comment on this
The Senator might pass on what he has to us later and we will have a look. I do want to follow up.
Our toilets on our trains should be operational full stop. Yes, one can go out of service but it should not be out of service for that length of time. We are after spending a considerable amount of money in Heuston Station so I am surprised to hear that is out of service. There is a call system on it, is there not?
Comment on this
There is a call system, so we just need to check the detail on that for the Senator because-----
Comment on this
On the Heuston to Waterford train, the disabled toilet has been defunct since 2 December, which is at least seven weeks. Mr. Meade might just check that.
Comment on this
We will follow up. It would not be the same train. There is no way we have several trains out there with it not working. There is something misaligned there, but we will have a look. We will absolutely have a look and come back to both the Leas-Chathaoirleach and the Senator on it.
On the Rosslare line issue raised by the Senator's constituent, yes, we would like to add two more carriages. Sometimes, I say to myself tongue-in-cheek when someone suggests it that I wish we had thought of it. We have every wheel turning. We do not have two spare carriages to put on. However, the really good news is that we will. We have a fleet coming. The first order of our new fleet, the Alstom battery-electric trains, is coming. The very first train will arrive in Q2 of this year. That goes into a very rigorous testing process with our regulator, the Commission for Railway Regulation. It is a very slow, onerous process because it is under the jurisdiction of the European Union Agency for Railways, ERA. It can take approximately nine months to commission that train and prove it is safe on our network and all the things that go with it. It will be at least that time. Once that is done, that is the head of the series and we start rolling out after that.
Comment on this
Those new trains are going to create capacity to have more trains across the network and that allows us to add services. The other thing we are doing this year is that we have 41 new carriages for our existing trains coming in - what we call our intercity railcars, ICRs. We have ordered 41 of them. That will add capacity. They were originally for the greater Dublin area for commuter capacity. We will be spreading them across the network. We have a plan for where they will go. That may add some capacity to the Rosslare line, but the real relief will not come until we start adding more trains. Today, we have a live fleet of 629 vehicles across the network. We are adding 41 carriages to that. Then, we will start with the first new trains coming this year and they will be rolling out through 2025. We will, therefore, have 19 trains coming through in 2025. We will have a further 18 coming in 2026, all of which are five-car trains. All those trains will be added capacity. That will allow us then to cascade and put in bigger trains. It will allow us to take some of the trains that are on commuter routes now and put them on the likes of the Rosslare line and Waterford, Limerick, Sligo, Westport, etc. That is when the step change will come in late 2025-early 2026.
Comment on this
Okay. I thank Mr. Meade very much. Senator Craughwell said he would be brief and he would not use his time. He is actually on 12 minutes instead of ten.
Comment on this
I will finish up by saying that Mr. Meade did respond very quickly to the call for early morning trains from Ballina and he is to be complimented on that. I thank him.
Comment on this
We are looking for late-night trains to Ballina as well now at this stage. I thank Senator Craughwell for that. Substituting for Senator Boylan is her party colleague, Deputy O'Rourke.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. First of all, I am interested in the Navan rail line because I am Meath based. Mr. Meade touched on it earlier. Is it the case that consultants have been appointed or that they are to be appointed in early 2024? Can Mr. Meade outline what those consultants will do step by step? Will they deal with route selection, for example? How far are they funded? How far can we take this project until we need to go back for more funding?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. The Navan rail line is a new 40 km line from the M3 parkway north to Navan. The project development has commenced. We will be bringing it for approval right out to delivery in 2029 or 2030 with the line open. Mr. Hendrick might take the Deputy through the first three steps in that process because I do not have them clear in my head.
Comment on this
That is no problem. We are appointing a design team. We are in a procurement process at the moment.
Comment on this
Iarnród Éireann does not have them appointed yet.
Comment on this
That is correct. We are in a tendering process at the moment. We should expect to have them appointed in the summer.
Comment on this
Right. I thought we heard it was early 2024 but we are now saying the summer.
Comment on this
In the summer, yes, we are going to tap in with the money. We are mobilising a team ourselves dedicated to work on it, so it is not just a technical design consultancy.
Comment on this
We are deploying our own staff as part of that project team. To explain the initial development process for the project, obviously, the Deputy is right. We will go through an optioneering process where we will look at the concept and feasibility and the different possibilities in terms of the routes. We will look at selecting the preferred most viable option. That will involve extensive public consultation and a lot of public consultation sessions with all of the constituents and stakeholders.
Comment on this
There are questions about east of Dunshaughlin and west of Dunshaughlin.
Comment on this
That is correct. I grew up in Dunshaughlin so I probably have a conflict of interest in one sense in that I would prefer it in Dunshaughlin.
Comment on this
Fair play. Mr. Hendrick really wants to put a stop there.
Comment on this
That is it. It is certainly a project about which I am going to be very passionate. I have been involved in rail projects all my career over the past 20 years, so I would love to see this delivered all the way, suffice to say. The development process will take us through from the summer out to the end of 2025 when we get to the point of looking at what that preferred solution is. At that point in time, we will put together a business case. We will have to put the business case forward to the Department to get the approval to continue through that development process to take it all the way up to a planning submission, which will most likely be a railway order application to An Bord Pleanála.
Comment on this
What is the timeline on a business case at the end of 2025 to 2026 and then a railway order?
Comment on this
We would be hoping to be able to submit and, if we can get the approval from the Government to proceed with the submission, proceed with the railway order into 2026.
Comment on this
Does that require a financial commitment on behalf of the NTA or the Department?
Comment on this
It gives us a commitment to go to that next stage in order that we can go through the process with An Bord Pleanála like we are doing with the DART+ programme at the moment and similar to what MetroLink is doing as well.
Comment on this
The railway order might take one year or 18 months.
Comment on this
Yes, potentially. Obviously, there have been some challenges there in terms of having the flow of work.
Comment on this
Hopefully, by 2026 or 2027 we will be in a better place in that regard. Is that then the green light for construction if Iarnród Éireann gets it through?
Comment on this
That gives us the green light, so we will be able then to go to tender to the market for the works contractors to deliver the scheme.
Comment on this
What sort of timeline to build would Mr. Hendrick see for a project like this 40 km?
Comment on this
We would see it in the order of three to four years from starting to getting it finished.
Comment on this
Really, what I would always say to people is that it is all about framing the timeline to build it. When we have the planning permission and a full Government investment decision to actually appoint the contractors, then we are into a secure timeline because it is now being delivered
Comment on this
In terms of where this sits, a couple of things are related. I thank Mr. Hendrick for that answer. As this sits at the minute in the greater Dublin area transport strategy, it is post 2031 and medium-term 2031 to 2036. Then, coupled with that, we have news reports about significant inflation. Iarnród Éireann knows all about that in terms of the budgetary envelope in the national development plan out to 2030. The Minister, Deputy Eamon Ryan, reported just before Christmas that it could be a €30 billion shortfall across all transport projects. That is before we include Navan rail and the western rail corridor. Mr. Meade might give me sense of what he needs to see in financial terms. Is it survival of the fittest on these projects in that whichever ones come through planning are dealt with and then become the ones that Iarnród Éireann brings to the Government with a business case? At the same time, I presume Iarnród Éireann needs the financials to be in place from the Government. None of these projects will get delivered if there is not Government support. Is that generally the picture?
Comment on this
Broadly, it is. However, it is not so much the survival of the fittest. What does "correctly planned" mean? For us, it is about having that pipeline correct. In the past, we did not have that pipeline correct and it was stop-start. Now, however, by setting up the capital investment team within Iarnród Éireann, we have a whole suite of projects. We have a constant iterative process with the NTA and the Department on costs. We know what has happened in the past couple of years and we are steadying those down again now. Mr. Hendrick's team would, on an ongoing basis, do programme costs for the NTA and Department of Transport to say this is what we know and this is the vista we have in front of us. There is a constant re-evaluation of cash flows and what needs to go next.
What the Government decides to fund is the Government's call. What we do is keep it well informed of where we are with the project and what the next steps are. There are certain gateways we have to go through as part of the public spending code. Therefore, we go through those gateways and there are no surprises. One thing we do quite well, if I say so myself, is that we do not give the Department or the Government surprises. We give them schedules and show them what is coming. We agree with them what the projects are and then we agree the funding streams.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Meade very much for that. Picking up on a point he made earlier, Mr. Meade said there is an appreciation within the Department that if the lifecycle costs are factored in, this is actually a good investment. I think he used the word "cheap", but I appreciate the point.
I raised with the NTA, as I do a regular basis, the option of heavy rail. The thing I keep hearing back from the NTA is that this stuff is breathtakingly expensive. Is Irish Rail appropriately assessing this stuff in terms of the carbon impact and the lifecycle impact of it? Does Mr. Meade have a sense that there is a step change in thinking in the Department and, more importantly for me, in the NTA, on the role of heavy rail?
Comment on this
I think there is. In fairness to all parties, the challenge we have is what value we can get now. Some of the heavy rail projects have a long timeline, as we have outlined. One of the things the Department and the NTA also look at is whether we can get more value out of doing something slightly differently upfront. The numbers can look large, but I would not have said breathtakingly expensive
Comment on this
Yes, people have their opinions, that is for sure. We do know that anywhere heavier infrastructure is put in, it gets used and indeed overused. I give the example of the Crossrail project in London. That was going to do them for ten years. In due course, the committee will have our chair designate, who was heavily involved in the project. Some 18 months in, they are at capacity. It has outstripped what they planned for.
To the substantive part of the Deputy's question, we are getting a fair hearing. There are other competing projects. That is where the debate comes in, as to whether we should spend it on heavy rail, light rail, bus or active travel. We would say that as a country we need to do all of these things. Then that comes down to a cash flow and we also have to be realistic. We cannot just keep shovelling money over the fence at everything. It is a matter of getting the balance right and identifying the projects that will deliver. I think the Navan line is one of those that will deliver. It will be heavily used and it will justify its investment.
Comment on this
It is positive to hear from Mr. Meade that he is ambitious for that project and that he is planning to deliver it as quickly as possible. There are a number of junctures at which Irish Rail will go to Government in 2026 and, in my opinion, the Government of the day needs to be ready to support the project and deliver it as quickly as possible. There is an indication it could be delivered by 2029 or 2030, which is significantly in advance of what is referenced in the greater Dublin area transport strategy. That is positive news for me and I am sure for the commuters in County Meath, Dunshaughlin included.
Comment on this
I welcome Mr. Meade, Mr. Hendrick and Mr Kenny. Mr. Meade began his presentation by mentioning his staff. I find them to be outstanding. I take the train regularly and they are the friendly face of the organisation. I left Colbert Station in Limerick at 6.40 this morning. There were a lot of bleary-eyed people who are not used to getting up too early, but staff are always there with a smile and a professional air. They focus on getting everything out of the station on time, safely and in a very orderly fashion.
On the HR angle, maybe some of the members do or do not know that Jim Meade started his career in Irish Rail as an apprentice mechanic. I just want to say that I think that is a fantastic journey in any organisation to go from apprentice level. As politicians we are always saying that there are many routes into an organisation. To start at apprentice level and work the whole way up to chief executive is a fabulous passage and a journey that other organisations should try to replicate
Comment on this
I do want to cut you off, but I think his CIE group has a history of that. Others in Dublin Bus and CIE group started at the coalface, if you like, and worked their way up to the very top.
Comment on this
It allows the management to resonate with staff within the organisation, so well done.
I have quite a number of points and I want to go through them nice and quickly if that is possible. On that 6.40 a.m. train there were three carriages, A, B and C. It was lovely and quiet until we got beyond Thurles. Then we picked up in Ballybrophy. There were stops in Portlaoise and Portarlington. It becomes chaotic every morning the farther up the line one goes because people are using the train to get in to Dublin for the 9 o'clock work start. It is lovely and quiet leaving Limerick and into Tipperary and then it turns to mayhem. It is devastating then when one pulls into Heuston station and sees carriages parked up around the yard. I am wondering why that train cannot have five or six carriages. There were people standing, not just at the end of carriages, but holding onto chairs and tables for an hour or an hour and a half as they made their way to Dublin. All I am asking is that Irish Rail please consider putting additional carriages on those early morning services.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for his kind words of introduction. They are appreciated. "Yes" is the short answer. I mentioned earlier that we have 41 ICR carriages on which we are expecting approval from the CRR by the middle of next month. Those are the services on which they will be put. They are ICR carriages like the Deputy travelled on this morning. We do have that issue with commuters using those services and I use them regularly myself, so I fully appreciate what the Deputy is saying. As we roll out the 41 ICRs, we will add capacity. However, I think we will still have the issue. We will still have people standing from the likes of Ballybrophy, Portlaoise and Portarlington in to Dublin. It is just the nature of things. It is a good commute and a fast one, so people will do it. It will be two to three years before we really get to the point where people will not have to stand.
Comment on this
I just think that if the last trains out of Heuston Station at night time brought an extra carriage to Ceannt Station or Colbert Station, it would mean that the morning trains could bring them back up to headquarters. I think it could work. I have quite a number of other small points I want to mention.
There is fabulous work going on in Colbert Station in Limerick. The old cargo crane has been there for years. I do not think it was a very old piece of equipment when it became redundant but I would love to know what is happening with this. Surely it could be repurposed. Perhaps it could be used again or perhaps it could be scrapped. There is surely value to it but at the very least, it is an eyesore.
The other issue in Colbert Station is the car parking. The new car park is fabulous, but already it gets filled up. Is anything going to happen in this regard?
We are all green. We all might not be politically green, but we are all living kind of green lifestyles these days. When I get off the train at Colbert Station, there is a dry waste recycling facility, but there is not the same thing at Heuston Station, where there is just a bin. I mentioned this the last time Irish Rail was before the committee. It would be lovely to have rubbish segregation at the other end as well.
Comment on this
That is something I am sure we can do so. We will take that away and have a look at it. Regarding the old freight crane, we are talking with the Land Development Agency, LDA, about developing the site further, which is one of the things that they have to discuss as well. The structure of the crane is very safe. There were even talks of making it a viewing platform, giving a vista over Limerick. Some years ago there was consideration of whether it could be used elsewhere. The cost of taking it down and rebuilding it somewhere else is as much as a new crane, so the companies that looked did not want to use it for that purpose.
We recognise the issues with the car park. The Deputy has probably seen that where the old bus station was is now being redeveloped. The car park is going to come all the way down to the old front gate, so that capacity will be added to the car park.
Comment on this
The early birds like the Deputy on the earlier trains, the 5.25 a.m. or the 6.15 a.m., which I tend to get myself, will be parking close to the station and then others will move up through it.
To the Deputy's earlier comment on the spare carriages and Heuston, they are just the trains that arrive before the Deputy. They get lifted from the platform to allow other trains to come in, so they are not sitting there overnight. They have already carried loads of people in that morning
Comment on this
Regarding the Shannon rail spur, there is really positive news happening in the suburban Limerick area and that Foynes line is very good. However, many people in Clare are wondering about this rail spur, not just to Shannon Airport, but also to Shannon town and the industrial zone. How realistic does Mr. Meade think that is and what kind of safeguarding is being done in terms of keeping the route line there so that it is available in the future?
Comment on this
As I mentioned earlier in my opening comments, the Shannon rail link is part of the Limerick-Shannon metropolitan area transport strategy. It is called out in that as a line item. That whole strategy is to look at the feasibility of whether the link to the airport is viable or not. It is also in the all-island strategic rail review as a link to the airport. A study was done back in the early 2000s that identified the ideal route and preserved it, so Clare County Council has that on its records .
Comment on this
Is it five years or ten years away, or is it in dreamland at the moment?
Comment on this
It depends on what we as a nation, or what the Government decides, post the all-island rail review. If the Government decides that it wants it and it is going to do it, then it is a five- to six-year timeline.
Comment on this
Could I next ask about Crusheen Station? I was a councillor at the time, but I remember TDs scrambling to announce money, funding and a station to be built that would be a stop going up to Galway. Where exactly is that at?
We have one in Clare, Councillor Pat Hayes, who constantly advocates this, as do I. There is a real lobby group. Crusheen is one of those communities that would be viable to live in. The census identified that it has the youngest population in the mid-west.
Comment on this
If I can finish, living in that community is viable if you are going to college in UL. You can nip into Limerick and up to Galway. You can live there and work or study elsewhere. I would love to hear where that stands.
Comment on this
Deputy Crowe's colleagues, newly co-opted Councillor Rita McInerney and Councillor Tony O'Brien, both contacted me about the Limerick-Ennis rail resilience. They mentioned the Crusheen-Ennis spur link to Shannon and so on. Clearly the people and councillors in Clare are very interested in rail services. It is not only Deputy Crowe.
Comment on this
The Leas-Chathaoirleach might add some time because I have more to get through.
Comment on this
Crusheen is not currently in the plan. It has been well flagged by the Deputy and some of his colleagues, but it is not currently in the funded plan we have from the Department. It is part of the all-island review. If the decision is taken to add a station there, it could be one of the quick wins of the review. Before the financial crash, a station design was drawn up for it, so it is with Mr. Hendrick's section. It can be done, but it is a Government decision as to whether it will be funded.
Comment on this
I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach for extending me some latitude. I understand there has been a budgetary overrun on the national train control centre. Where is it at and who is picking up the tab? All of us here have a rudimentary knowledge of what is going on. The old points levers are well and truly gone. We have an automated system. For the laypeople, and we are laypeople - I certainly do not have an engineering background - what efficiencies will the facility bring when it opens and at what cost? Are there safety issues? Will providing this infrastructure get us to the point we have all been talking about, with perhaps more night trains and the passing lines? Will it co-ordinate all of that? We would love to know a little more about it.
Comment on this
Anyone who uses Heuston Station, like Deputy Crowe does, will see the lovely building on the left as they approach with our name up in lights, namely, the NTCC. It is a piece of national infrastructure that was built during the Covid-19 pandemic. What will it be? All the signalling of all trains across the network will come into one centre. It is a state-of-the-art centre. When it opens in quarter 3 of 2025, it will be the most modern in Europe. We are taking a massive leap in technology. It is cloud based. I probably should have put this into my opening statement. It would be good for the committee to come and have a look. We talk a lot about investment and what we can and cannot deliver, but it would bring the documents to life. I extend an invitation to the committee to come and see the national train control centre if it suited some time. All that happens, anyone who comes in there------
Comment on this
We would be more than willing to take up the invitation. I certainly would be. Whether we all go or we go individually, we would very happy to do it.
Comment on this
Whatever works for the committee will work for us. We will make it happen. All anyone who has been to see it has said when they came out was "Wow, we did not realise what you were doing".
To go back to the Deputy's substantive question, it will be one source of the truth for everything to do with the railway. Customer services is there, as is all the activity of managing and manoeuvring trains. All the signalling locations around the country will come back in there. All train activities will be managed from there. The contract for it was signed a few weeks before Covid-19 hit us. We had to stand back and re-design how we would deliver it. We delivered the building a few weeks late. We added a floor for An Garda Síochána because it needed to get out of Harcourt Street. An Garda Síochána is now on the third floor. Its call centre for Dublin is there, which is another state-of-the-art centre. It is a demonstration of great collaboration between the OPW, the NTA, ourselves and An Garda Síochána and shows how State agencies can work together. That facility is a multigenerational facility.
Comment on this
Has it cost more than was intended?
Comment on this
We are within the broad parameters. If the Deputy is referring to the report at the weekend, it was misleading. It is not two years late. We expected to get it up and running last November and to start migrating the various routes into it. The latest date is March. By then, we will have all the technology in it and then we will start migrating route by route. It will take, as Mr. Hendrick said, up to quarter 3 of 2025 to get them all in.
Comment on this
Yes, it is my final question. I find trains to be a safe, efficient and fabulous way to travel. More people should be on them. On a very rare occasion - once - I had to make a 999 call from the train because of the actions of another passenger. Occasionally, you see someone losing the rag or someone who is possibly under the influence of drugs, but it is tricky to go down to the bathroom or to the other end of the carriage to make a call. It would be great if there was a text facility to be able to text - there is a new name for the person who travels on the train.
Comment on this
Yes. It would be great if there was a text facility on board so you could say there was trouble in carriage D or if An Garda Síochána need to intervene at the next station, that there would be a more discreet way of doing it. It is pretty difficult to make a call or to get a message out of a train when you are shuttling along down the track.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for all their work.
Comment on this
Like previous speakers, I acknowledge all the work Irish Rail is undertaking. It is much appreciated.
My first question relates to providing further insight into passenger journeys per route. Has Irish Rail seen an increase in demand in certain services compared with pre-Covid-19 pandemic times, specifically on the intercity routes in the west of Ireland? How has that impacted on planning for increased capacity?
Comment on this
The short answer is "Yes". On our intercity routes we are now carrying numbers in excess of those we were carrying before the Covid-19 pandemic. We are particularly seeing that in the west of Ireland on the Galway, Sligo and Westport routes. We are seeing it across all routes. Some of the early morning Cork services, as Deputy Crowe alluded to, are full and passengers are standing by the time they get to Heuston Station.
We have 41 new carriages coming on stream. When we ordered those carriages in 2019, we were planning to put them on commuter trains around Dublin. We are now working with the NTA, which we meet on a regular basis, on the best allocation of those carriages. The majority of them will go onto the regional and intercity routes as that is where the demand is now. Intercity is beyond where it was. The demand on the commuter belt is now back to just under where we were before the Covid-19 pandemic because of blended working. The DART system has a little less demand. There are a lot of white-collar workers on the DART who do blended working, so it is at a little more than 90% of where it was. Certainly, the demand is on the intercity routes and that is where we will try to concentrate the new carriages.
Comment on this
Does Irish Rail have any plans to add to the 41 intercity carriages that have already been purchased?
Comment on this
They are diesel traction, so "No" is the short answer, because we want to move into the battery-electric arena and to continue to electrify.
Comment on this
Has Irish Rail ordered battery-electric carriages?
Comment on this
We have ordered 185 of those vehicles. They will go into the greater Dublin area and that will allow us to cascade other fleet. We will increase the frequency on all those routes, especially Sligo, Westport and Galway. We will concentrate on those first.
Comment on this
As other colleagues said, there are real capacity challenges at peak times. I am specifically talking about the Westport and Ballina routes from Heuston Station. While we had the positive news of an extra late service from Athlone to Westport and Ballina, it does not negate the challenges in Heuston Station for an additional late evening service. What is the timeline? Mr. Meade spoke previously about the intention of Irish Rail to increase the delivery of a late evening service. Can he give us an estimated timeline for when we will see this being implemented?
Comment on this
It will be in 2026, because we will roll out the new fleet in 2025 and 2026 and that will allow us to cascade. It will be 2026 before you see us moving to hourly services and a real enhancement. It will be incremental. It will not be a big bang. As we start to bring in the additional trains, we can start cascading. It will be a process that builds up.
Comment on this
Mr. Meade talked previously about sweating the assets. Will he expand on how that is done? There is still commentary that Irish Rail could continue to do more in that regard. People need clarity on why no additional services are being put in place.
Comment on this
How do we sweat the assets? We just try to run them more. What catches people out sometimes is that there is a return leg on everything. If we run a train to Cork, we have to get it back in order to have it somewhere else. For example, we are running an extra service to Cork, but that means we have taken a train, we are running it down earlier and running it back, and we are taking out some of our resilience. If we have a failure now in Cork, where anything happens to any of the early morning trains, we have to start back-pedalling straight away. We do not have any capacity to drop in another train to rescue that service. It is about running the existing fleet so we have more, while recognising that it has to work into a linking system. If we have a spare train at Heuston, we can run it to Galway, but then where is its next leg? Where was it supposed to go? Can it get to Galway and back before it does the journey we want it to do? That is what we do when we sweat the asset.
Comment on this
Mr. Meade also talked about frequency of services. The expectation is to increase the frequency of services to a two-hourly service for services such as the Westport line, and an hourly service for cities. When will we see that being implemented?
Comment on this
There are two parts to getting all that done. We need the fleet to be able to do it but on certain routes, of which Westport is one-----
Comment on this
We are not an outlier but we need extra pieces of infrastructure at certain points just so trains can pass each other out. As the Deputy knows, west of Portarlington it is all single line to Galway and Westport. We are in the process of designing that timetable, which will tell us where those conflicts are. That will be part of the early-----
Comment on this
Can Mr. Meade give an indication-----
Comment on this
Can Mr. Meade give us an indication of when these key pieces of infrastructure will be introduced? When will a two-hourly service, such as that to Sligo and other areas, be implemented?
Comment on this
We are working towards 2027 to have the extra infrastructure and extra fleet in place.
Comment on this
Another issue that comes up on the doorsteps is the resumption of catering services. Mr. Meade talked about the Cork line. Will he expand on lessons learned on the Cork line when the service was reintroduced? The Westport to Dublin line takes three hours and 22 minutes. That is a long time without any hospitality services. When does Mr. Meade expect the procurement process to end? When will we see the resumption of catering services?
Comment on this
We expect to be in a position by early summer, maybe mid-June, to have that tendering process back in. That will indicate the costs. We would like to then go live on every route, but we will start looking at a hierarchy of routes if we do not have enough money to do everything. We would then start looking at the longer haul routes, absolutely. The ideal scenario for us is to get catering on all the regional routes together. That is our ambition and what we are trying to do. That is what we briefed the NTA on. The NTA knows the range of costs that came in previously. Those were not in the most recent budget and the NTA knows we will try to budget for more. We do not expect the cost to come back down just because people realise they can get the service again. It will be more expensive. We just have to accept that.
Comment on this
Is Irish Rail just delaying the inevitable that there will be a budgetary line item in relation to this?
Comment on this
No, because it is part of the offering people want, just as they want customer service on board and just as we have to get security right. Those are added costs we have taken on board. We recognise that we need to do it because it is part of the offering of an intercity rail service.
Comment on this
The western rail corridor is a big issue in the west of Ireland. Many Deputies and Senators are very supportive of it. How is progress on line clearance of that line going? We previously met Mr. Meade regarding protection of the line north of Claremorris in February last year. What is Irish Rail's position on it? Does it want to protect the line?
Comment on this
Yes, absolutely. We want and intend to protect the line for rail use first and foremost. We started clearing and de-vegetation of the line before Christmas. We will do a certain amount of it within the current season. I think we have to have it done by March. Beyond that, we do not have any funding from the Department at present to start rehabilitating the line. That decision still needs to be made.
Comment on this
To go back to a previous comment, I was a little disappointed to hear Sinn Féin float a hard rail solution for Dublin Airport, or the spur out to Clongriffin as it was known. While that solution might meet the needs of airport users, it would not meet those of towns such as Swords and Ballymun, or DCU. That is why MetroLink is on the table. It has been tested against all the other options. Hard rail would not fix the congestion on the M1 corridor either.
We also have congestion on the northern line as it exists at present. That is another impact. What are the plans to remove congestion on the northern line as it exists? New carriages are on order. There has been a massive population increase along the coast as far as Drogheda and electrification of the line, but we still just have those two tracks linking Dublin and Belfast. What are Irish Rail's plans as regards congestion?
One of the questions I get regarding the new carriages on order is whether there will be toilet facilities on them. Some of the commuter line commuters are concerned that the service might diminish in that regard. If Mr. Meade will answer that, I have two more issues to raise after that.
Comment on this
I will start with the Deputy's comment on the metro. We need to be clear; we say that we absolutely need the metro. There is no question.