Capital Projects and Operations: Iarnród Éireann
Contributions 157–309 of 309. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
It is not A or B. It is both. In the context of the earlier question, that is why consideration of both is in the all-Ireland strategic review. It is certainly not an either-or. We have all moved to the understanding that we need both. The metro is needed and there is also an option to put heavy rail in, if so required.
There are two elements to the capacity issue. We have got connecting Europe facility, CEF, funding from the EU for a project we call FourNorth, which is about adding two more tracks going north because it is a very heavily congested line. We are also talking about more Belfast services. That corridor needs extension, as the project title indicates. We got 50% EU funding from the most recent CEF call. The Department has put its 50% in and we are now ahead with that project.
On the question around the new fleet, there are no toilets in the new fleet as ordered, but we have made provision for them on a modular basis. We can add them to further orders for the fleet and retrofit them to the first orders if we need to. It is a balance between what is best capacity and toilet provision. The option is there to do so.
Comment on this
The option is there. Brilliant. I will briefly focus on Portmarnock Station. A lot of work is going on there at present. It is great to see the development taking place as the population in the area has increased. I have made some requests, along with my council colleague, regarding the moving of validation poles, which has been done. I ask for an update on the work being done at the train station and how it is moving. Is it ahead of schedule? It includes the car park facilities. The second pin to that question is whether there is an update on bringing the old bridge linking the station to Drumnigh Manor into use again, as an active travel measure for a new growing area.
Many people in Portmarnock are finding it easier to get to Malahide to use the train station there as opposed to the one at Portmarnock, possibly due to the buses flowing that way more easily. Has Irish Rail done any analysis, maybe in conjunction with the bus providers, on whether we are maximising Portmarnock train station for residents? Are we pushing people to another train station because complementary public transport services are going that way?
Comment on this
The Portmarnock car park development is going well. I am happy to report it is on schedule and on programme. It will be a significant enhancement to that station. I am not familiar with the bridge and neither is Mr. Hendrick. We will take that away and look at it for the Deputy because it is not on my radar.
On the Malahide-Portmarnock piece, the new BusConnects route will connect them. We are looking at it from the integrated transport model perspective. In fairness to the NTA, it always has a weather eye on how the whole thing works, including Dublin Bus, ourselves, Bus Éireann and active travel, and all fits together.
The BusConnects route is what will decongest that more than anything.
Comment on this
There is a concern that the way BusConnects is set up it will not work. We might keep that under our watch with Dublin Bus because it would be better to see people who live in Portmarnock being able to get to their local station.
I have a few questions on the Barrow Bridge and Rosslare line. Does Mr. Meade have a timetable for the repair of the bridge? Does he have an update on the process of recovering repair costs from the owners of the two crafts which struck the bridge? The rail strategy review prioritised the restoration of the Rosslare-Waterford railway line before 2030. Has Irish Rail management discussed this recommendation? What is its view on how to action this? Will it be delivered in that timeframe?
Comment on this
The Barrow Bridge was struck not once but twice by two ships over a short period. We had CCTV on the bridge so were able to identify both ships and their insurers. We have put the insurers on notice and are working through that process with them. They are waiting for us to come back with the costings and the breakdown of them. There was a lot of work to be done. Working in the river and in a marine area, there were certain things we had to do. We had to procure specialist consultants and do topographical and barometric surveys. We needed to do some ground investigations. We had an archaeological survey to do, even though it is there a long time. We have some preliminary design works. All of that has been moving along as per plan. We detailed a plan before. The works and timelines we committed to originally to some of the Deputy's colleagues have been substantially completed. We are working up the designs and costings to go back to the insurers to get the costings out of them. As part of that, we will not be getting this from insurers but we want to automate it because it is a manual operation today. When we bring it back into service, it will probably be controlled from the NTCC, which will be a significant improvement.
There is a plan to bring back the south Wexford line, as we call it. We are looking at how to bring it back into service. There is a plan to bring it back in the all-Ireland strategic rail review. We will be working to the timeline in that. We do not have a date pegged in the ground yet as to when it goes back into service but it is intended the bridge will be ready for when the line goes back into service.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Meade, his senior management team and all his team for today and in general. They have been receptive to us on individual queries and that is appreciated. Generally, the story of Irish Rail is a good news one and is going in the right direction. It is nice to see that and support it where we can.
Comment on this
Agreed. It is all very positive, but there is clearly a demand for even more progress and services for people all over the country.
Comment on this
Mr. Meade and his team are welcome. They are always willing to engage and come into the committee, as well as at local authority level. I was at Wicklow County Council when his team came in. It was the first time I floated the idea of the DART extension to Wicklow town. I am glad to see it is making progress. At the start, the Leas-Chathaoirleach provided a litany of what some people might call complaints or concerns-----
Comment on this
I was going to qualify that by saying, in a way-----
Comment on this
-----it is listing out the expectation, ambition and desire people have across the country for better rail services. What we are hearing today from Irish Rail is a good story for the future of rail transport, including freight, and will assist us in our climate challenge. That is a primary focus, though it has not been mentioned today except in Mr. Meade's opening statement. The Cork commuter project that is ongoing is transformative for rail transport in Cork. That five- and ten-minute service from Midleton, Cobh and Mallow will massively benefit the people of Cork. There is also the Galway line upgrade and the work to be done in Limerick. No doubt my colleague, Deputy Leddin, as, hopefully, future mayor of Cork, will be leading that delivery.
Comment on this
They can shake hands at the Cork-Limerick border with that rail line. It is fantastic to hear every Deputy come in here and talk about Navan lines, Cork extensions, Galway extensions, late-night services, more trains, better services and cheaper fares. We must remember the context of decades of underinvestment in public transport, which turned in 2020 with the programme for Government commitment of a 2:1 expenditure on public transport over new roads. One of the most important things for rail projects is certainty of investment and budgets, as well as confidence. They are long projects which last decades or a century. An investment in rail is an asset that will serve us for decades but we need certainty to deliver, design, build and maintain those projects. For future governments, that 2:1 spend must be maintained. That has to be a priority. Companies like Irish Rail need that certainty in budgets and support from Government policy for those projects. Stop-start policy changes destroy those long-term ambitions.
I have three questions. One is on freight and another is on staff capacity. Our colleagues from bus services were in recently and talked about driver training and retention. At the other end, when a piece of machinery is in operation for 18 or 20 hours per day, a good maintenance programme is needed for reliability. I also want to talk about heritage on the railway, which is an aspect we do not often talk about.
On the freight study, freight has been in decline for 40 years. It was a big part of how we got goods around the country. What is Irish Rail's vision for freight? What can we bring to the delivery of freight in this country?
Comment on this
The Deputy is correct that freight was a major part. At one stage we were doing 13% of the freight in the country; we are now doing 1%. Our vision is to get into the mid-teens area of activity for freight. That is a big programme of work and will take time to deliver. When taking a piece of freight from A to B anywhere in the country by road or rail, rail has an 80% lower carbon footprint. We have detailed in our freight strategy where and how we connect with ports and how we can do the heavy trunking to ports.
We have done many detailed studies with industry to understand who now wants to use freight. Twenty years ago people would argue it cost 50c per tonne more by rail than by road, so they went by road. Now we see from our detailed research with several areas of industry that they need and want to decarbonise for their CSR. There is a large organisation in the mid-west which has asked us to please put its containers on our train. They are almost saying they do mind the cost because their global headquarters are saying they have the worst carbon footprint of any of their facilities. They want to put their products on rail to reduce their carbon footprint. We see that in the agrifood and farm industries, where people want to move to rail. Some commentators say Ireland is too short of a haul for rail. It is not. If you go into big aggregates, like when we used to carry coal or whatever, you need big trains. We used to carry barytes to Foynes, shale out to the cement factory and gypsum across the country but now there is an awful lot of container movement in the country and that can move by rail. Shannon Foynes Port is interested in container traffic and getting empty containers into Foynes to ship back out to wherever. There is a lot of traffic on offer, we believe. The studies we have done tell us that. There is a significant carbon reduction in moving by rail, a significant reduction in kilometres done on our roads and a contribution to the driver age profile of the HGV industry, which is quite high. There are benefits all round.
Comment on this
The western rail corridor connection from Claremorris to Athenry and the reconnection of Waterford to Wexford would appear to make sense from a freight perspective, so it is not all going through Kildare and Dublin.
Comment on this
Absolutely, because of the fact it is a less congested area.
Comment on this
Perhaps we could talk about the driver training programme. More fleet equipment can be ordered and built. There is a lead-in time, but it can be delivered over time. If the drivers are not in place, though, there is not much point in having extra trains. How is recruitment for drivers, as well as for maintenance staff and apprentices, progressing? We hear this is challenging.
Comment on this
It is challenging. Everybody is fishing in a small pool for staff. I am happy to report we are having reasonable success with our recruitment campaigns. The younger cohorts, in particular, see the green credentials of a company like ours and what we are doing. We do not have a major problem getting staff. It is probably becoming more onerous now to get specialist staff in Mr. Hendrick's area than front-line staff. We have embarked on a campaign for several years now to grow our own staff and to add to the driver cohorts, and we are getting them. We recognised we were going to be bringing a lot of new technology into play over the years to come, so we started an apprentice programme several years ago. We also initiated a women in leadership programme because the rail industry has been heavily male-dominated for generations. That was the way it was, but we are trying to grow that women in leadership programme. It has grown very successfully. Our intake for the last three or four years has hovered around 20%. We want to get it to at least 25% and 30% over the next several years.
The I Wish foundation will be running a showcase conference shortly and we are now one of the sponsors of that event. I will be speaking at it. Young women from all over the country will be coming on trains to the RDS to showcase promoting science, technology, engineering and mathematics, STEM, subjects. We will be running special STEM trains and showing them what we do and how we do it. We have our high potential people within the organisation as well. These are people who come in as drivers or customer service personnel, for example, but with high potential to move through the organisation. We have a programme for bringing them on. We also started a graduate programme. This is all about creating the workforce of the future, which is exactly what the Deputy is referring to, and having a supply chain of people coming through, not just at the front line but also at the junior and senior management levels as well, and even all the way up to my position, in respect of who the future CEOs will be.
Comment on this
That is very good to hear. It is forward-thinking. These people will be the staff of the future, including, perhaps, the future chief executive who will be sitting here at some point.
Turning to the heritage aspect of our railways, we talk about modernising the railway and the NTCC, for example. In this context, we have signal cabins around the country that are no longer in use but that are examples of fine architecture and beautifully decorative buildings. We have old stores along the lines as well as beautiful bridges and railway stations. There are some exquisite designs from Victorian times. I was speaking with my colleague, the Minister of State, Deputy Noonan, who has responsibility for heritage and local government, about the development of a heritage policy for old railway infrastructure that would still be within the ownership of Irish Rail. Is there an existing heritage policy or is this something we could engage further on to consider developing such a policy for protecting, restoring and respecting this heritage the railway has?
Comment on this
There absolutely is. We have a heritage policy. Even if we did not, we are obligated to act in this regard in the context of the local authorities. Many of our buildings are listed structures, even including some of the signal cabins mentioned by the Deputy, that we must maintain even if they go out of use. We are generally happy to do so. We look at repurposing buildings too. In Portarlington, we have just done a complete refurbishment of the old station house and some of our own people are going to use it so that infrastructure comes back to life. It is a beautiful, cut-stone building. In Galway, we repurposed the old engine shed from the Victorian era and it is now a staff facility for our drivers. We glazed the end of it looking out on Lough Atalia. There is a beautiful vista there now and we put the canteen in the upstairs level. We have, therefore, repurposed that old building and brought it back to life. There was a second area there as well. Bus Éireann saw what we were able to do, and now we are doing that for its staff too. We are investing significantly in Connolly Station, which is our headquarters, because again it is a national monument and we have responsibility to maintain it. In that context, we are repurposing some of the arches under station, as well as the interior of the building, to be able to get more densification and more bodies into the building. Indeed, we invested not an insignificant amount of money in the area under Connolly Station, where our group medical centre is now. The stone arches there are all beautiful. They exist because, as I referred to earlier, the railway is elevated right through the city centre. Our complete medical centre is now located in those arches. The building is probably going to win several awards this year for what we did with it, how we repurposed it into a medical centre and how we preserved all the architecture of that area.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Meade. I failed to mention my own constituency but I trust all is in order with the DART extension to Wicklow town-----
Comment on this
We will have more queries from various councillors in Arklow and other places later. I thank Deputy Matthews. We move to the non-members of the committee who indicated to me earlier they would like to speak. I ask them to try to be as brief as possible to try to give everyone a chance. I call Deputy Pádraig O'Sullivan.
Comment on this
I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach. I welcome Mr. Meade. Unlike Deputy Matthews, I am going to start with all the local parochial, constituency stuff.
Comment on this
To be fair, I must say at the start that massive investment has gone into Cork. It is great to see such ambition, especially on the eastern line and the Mallow line as well. We are very appreciative of all the progress made.
Starting with the electrification of the track in Cork, it is great to see this happening. It has started. When are we likely to see electric locomotives and trains on the lines? Work on installing double-tracking has begun again in Kent Station. When is that likely to conclude? Turning to accessibility, Irish Rail is working on a lift at Little Island train station. This is great because it has always been difficult for people there with disabilities, prams or whatever. There is an issue, though, with the lift in Glounthaune station. I think it might be related to a planning issue concerned with the station being in a special area of conservation, SAC. I ask Mr. Meade to clarify at what stage this project is at.
We got welcome news a few weeks ago too about Monard. It is an area outside of Blarney where we hope a few thousand houses are going to be built. The initial phase of this project at Monard has been announced. It has come through the planning process. The developer there is eager to commence. Down the track, pardon the pun, there is a plan to have a rail station there. Where does this appear on Irish Rail's timelines? I am not going to hold Mr. Meade to any of these time scales. It would be good, though, if he could share an indicative timeline with us. From speaking to people in Cork, the stations in Blackpool and Tivoli, especially, are probably ahead of the project at Monard. It would be good if Mr. Meade could give us an update on the new stations and their roll-out.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. We see Cork as almost a template for the other regional cities because it is moving so well. There are three work packages in Cork, as I mentioned earlier in my introduction. Regarding all three work packages, the target date when we set up this programme, which was several years ago, was 2026. We are on schedule to meet it. As the Deputy will probably know, the rail order came through before Christmas. It came through earlier but the procurement standstill period meant it was finalised just before Christmas. We are now concerned with building that double track out to Midleton. That rail order was the first in more than a decade for rail and many more are going to come. This is indicative of where we are heading. The resignalling work on the platform in the station in Cork gives us the infrastructure to be able to run a high-frequency service, a ten-minute service, between Mallow, Cobh and Midleton. On electrification, the final decision has not been made yet. We have work packages one, two and three now. What we are doing in this regard is in the second tranche of work package endeavours. We have flagged it, we know what it is going to cost and we have it out there, but the final decision in this regard has not been made. All things being equal, however, the line will be electrified by 2030.
Turning to the project at Monard, as the Deputy will probably know, we are working very closely with Cork City Council and Cork County Council on the allocation of stations, including where they will go and how they will fit in together. I am happy to say there is a very strong working relationship between the two local authorities, ourselves and the NTA. As the Deputy will know as well, the NTA has collocated its team in Cork so that everyone will be working together to deliver that programme of work to be undertaken by the Irish Rail, the two local authorities and the NTA. On the timing of the Monard project itself, I do not know what that will be. The local authority will be very heavily involved in that decision. We are, though, ready, willing and able to build the station there. These stations get built to a template, so it will be just another headache to add to the list for Mr. Hendrick when the time comes. The work at Tivoli is currently ahead of that at Monard, but again that will be a call for all involved. There is no reason we could not build three stations together, by the way.
Comment on this
Is the funding in place for those new stations already?
Comment on this
No. The funding is not in place for those new stations yet.
Comment on this
I refer to the accessibility issue on the line as well. Work was being undertaken at Ballynoe, in Cobh, as well.
Comment on this
I am sorry. Little Island is nearly finished and I think and we will be opening it soon.
Comment on this
Yes.
There is an issue with the Glounthaune project. I do not think it has gone for planning permission yet.
Comment on this
It is ready to go for planning but it has not been submitted yet.
Comment on this
If I may, I will ask one more supplementary on the light rail plan. This might be a bit more into the future, but is the intention to take the light rail in through Kent Station?
Comment on this
Our preferred option is that it would come into Kent Station. This would mean there would be a transport hub, in the true sense of the word, at the station. That debate is still ongoing among all the interested parties. Cork City Council is very supportive of the idea that it would come all the way into Kent Station because you have the buses, the heavy rail and the light rail all there together.
Comment on this
What might the misgivings, by whoever, be about integrating the light rail?
Comment on this
It is just a different opinion. Is it close enough with the other side of the river? Do we need to incur the costs of coming across the river or do we loop back around? It is things like that. It is just different opinions at this stage as to what is the best solution for it. We believe it should come into Kent Station. The CEO of Cork City Council thinks likewise.
Comment on this
I know the vast majority of people do. Hopefully we will see that.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair for allowing me to come in. I welcome yesterday's announcement that Irish Rail has commissioned a study that will look into the infrastructural improvements needed to increase capacity on the Ennis to Limerick line. Additional resources to strengthen the rail infrastructure in Clare is always welcome. I look forward to seeing the results of that study. Is there any indication of a timeline for its expected completion? I hope the study will address the issues that have been identified to me so far with the proposal for a rail spur out to Shannon Airport. As I understand the matter, when this spur is completed, it will not be possible for trains to travel on the Ennis-Limerick and Shannon-Limerick lines at the same time. Is that the case? If so, has Irish Rail considered either a passing loop, a dynamic overtaking loop or a dual line to solve the problem?
I recently raised the possibility of extending the spur line out beyond Shannon to west Clare and Moneypoint because of the connectivity issues relating to west Clare. The west Clare railway was hugely successful at one time.
Irish Rail’s second announcement yesterday about QR code tickets was of great interest to me as someone who uses the train to get from Ennis to Dublin and back every week. I meet many of my Clare constituents doing the same. When will Irish Rail roll out the digital ticket service to all regional routes? What tech and infrastructural upgrades may be required to do so?
This has been a very interesting discussion. I have learned quite a lot about how Irish Rail can help with the reduction of the carbon footprint in terms of freight and about the women in leadership programme. The desire to increase that is positive.
Irish Rail has been pretty good about coming back to me if I raise an issue. It has not been something that it has been able to resolve straight away, the Irish Rail people have kept an eye on it. For example, last year, I raised the Sunday train service from Galway to Limerick that passes through Ennis. I have used the service many times. Because of all the students travelling to their accommodation on Sunday evenings, it gets extremely busy with people standing and so on. The provision of 41 extra carriages was mentioned. Have any of those been made available for this service?
Comment on this
We expect to have the result of that study by about September-October. That will look at how best to increase the capacity on the line. To link in with the point about the Sunday trains, that capacity study will look at where we can best put in infrastructure that allows us to put in a higher frequency on the whole route to Galway, not just the Limerick-Ennis part. The Limerick-Ennis part unlocks it because it is the longest section. It is a 40-minute section. Once a train enters it at either end, it is 40 minutes before you can do anything else. If we can cut that in half, it would increase the frequency significantly.
On the last part of the Deputy’s question, there are two issues: that of the western rail corridor but also that of platform lengths. One of Mr. Hendrick’s team is looking at that. As part of the study in that regard, four platforms, Sixmilebridge, one of the platforms in Gort, Craughwell and Ardrahan, will have to be extended. When the line was put in originally in 2007 or 2008, we placed the platforms in a position where we could extend them quite easily in the future. The study will identify what we need to do there. Then we need to see if we can get the funding to extend those platforms. The trains that are on it today are the longest trains we can operate on those. As we roll out the 41 ICRs which the Deputy mentioned, we cannot put any extra on that route because we can only put four-piece trains, or four carriages, because of the platform length. As we extend the platforms, we can add to that. We are looking at that maybe as a shorter term solution. If we get platform extensions, we can get longer trains and in time, we can add more passing loops to get the higher frequency into the route as a whole.
On the airport, as a young fellow in west Clare watching Moneypoint being built, I would love to see a train going all the way back there. I am not sure if it will. The line to the airport certainly is an option. That is just how we do our planning. It is single track just beyond Limerick station out to Ennis. You would be taking a single track off that, possibly. That would be part of the study to establish if we should do a double track into Shannon and where exactly do we come off, is it Cratloe or Sixmilebridge; do we go off at Cratloe and go through Bunratty because there is a very big tourist attraction there, Shannon town, Shannon industrial estate, the airport? How do you do that? The study process will identify those routes and where best to put them. Then for us it is just how we pass trains. From where you would be coming off at Sixmilebridge is about 15 or 18 minutes from Limerick. You would probably get the frequency you would want by leaving that single track and doing something double beyond it.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. The fact that there cannot be two trains on the line at the same time has been raised with me. There has to be a 90-minute gap just to allow one train to complete its journey. Anyone travelling from Limerick to Ennis town cannot make it before 9 a.m. for work unless they get the 6.16 a.m. train. I just wanted to mention that on behalf of my constituents.
I am happy that Crusheen was mentioned. It is something I have raised with Irish Rail before. Is it the case that no funding has been provided as yet and Irish Rail is looking at it? Is it just a funding issue?
Comment on this
It is just a funding issue from the Department. The Department decides, like our earlier conversation, where best to allocate the available funding to get the best result. It certainly can be done. We know we can physically do it. All the drawings are in place so, it will be a funding issue. Going back to the Deputy’s final comment, once we do that study and put a passing loop wherever we put it, maybe Sixmilebridge, and break that section - in our jargon - and shorten it to 20 minutes, that will increase the frequency across the entire route.
Comment on this
I welcome our guests and join with colleagues in congratulating Irish Rail on all the work it is doing developing the pipeline of projects that have been explained in quite a lot of detail in the opening statement and the question and answer session we have had already.
The representatives from Irish Rail will probably agree with what I am about to say, but the matter to which it relates is not one on which the company can make a decision. When we talk about investment in infrastructure, we are talking about strategic planning for the future. We have a history in this country of deciding on infrastructure and accelerating plans in a very reactive way. We look at where the traffic is and where the population growth is happening and then we build infrastructure accordingly. We need to flip that. We need to decide the kind of country we want, where we want people living and what is best for the country as a whole. This discussion is very relevant to that. No other member has made that point. Infrastructure planning has to be strategic. It is important for me to say this and I am saying it to colleagues on the committee, to the civil servants in the Departments of housing, public expenditure and reform, transport and to the NTA.
There are critical infrastructure decisions to be made, particularly in transport, that will change how this country develops over the decades ahead. Rail has the power to fundamentally and positively change this country. I am very much speaking with respect to balanced regional development. At the risk of sounding parochial - and we can all be accused of that - the plan for Limerick, the mid-west and Clare, which is very much as important as Limerick in this conversation, presents an opportunity to invest in rail infrastructure in order that we see a shortening or a closing of the gap between the regions and the capital. That is the power we, as politicians, and the Government have. Rail is fundamental to that because it enables people to move around in an efficient manner. It is the way to go. It is the way we can facilitate the fastest and most effective growth among the regions.
Putting all local and parochial bias aside, given the current infrastructure, the potential for future infrastructure, the people we have, our natural resources and our geographical location, I would argue that the mid-west is strategically located and that the counterbalance to the east should be the mid-west. Rail infrastructure should be the key to making the mid-west the counterbalance.
It is in this context that the rail link to Shannon Airport is critically important. I do not want to hear talk about feasibility studies. We need to be talking about what kind of country we want to live in, where we want people to live, and what is best for the country as a whole. This includes what is best for Dublin as well. That is the power of investing in projects like the rail link to Shannon Airport and in the suburban network that is detailed in the Limerick-Shannon metropolitan area transport strategy. This is what we need to be talking about.
Going by the draft strategic rail review, the rail link to Shannon Airport is in there at €100 million to €200 million in 2021 prices. I acknowledge that those will perhaps have gone up. That is really not a lot of money for the kind of growth that it could deliver for the mid-west region and for its power to close the gap between the mid-west and the capital. The corridor largely is preserved. It could be done very quickly. It is for the Government, not Irish Rail, to make the decision. I know that Irish Rail would do it in the morning if the Government cleared the way. The Department of Public Expenditure, National Development Plan Delivery and Reform, the NTA and the Department of Transport have key roles to play.
Critically, the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage and his Department also have a key role to play. We have a housing challenge and our population is due to increase by 1 million by 2040. In the context of our national planning framework target, we must decide, from a strategic point of view, where those people are going to live. Do we do the reactive thing and build infrastructure because those people are naturally going to move to Dublin where the jobs are, or do we create the infrastructure to create the environment for job creation in our regions as well? This is what our Government should be doing. All politicians across the Oireachtas should recognise that this is not a parochial point. This is about developing our country in the right way for the decades to come.
I have very little time remaining and I want to list off a few really important points. I congratulate-----
Comment on this
I will certainly come back in. I want to mention the transport hub in Limerick that has only opened in the past few weeks. It is phenomenal in how it is changing our perception of public transport in the mid-west. I commend Irish Rail on its role in making that happen. I also commend it on putting in place the new early train service from Limerick to Cork. This issue has been raised with me on the doorsteps over many years. I thank Mr. Meade and his team for delivering. It really is changing how we think about intercity transport between the State's third and second cities.
I want to ask about the Ballysimon train project. There is potential there if we think about the big context whereby Limerick and the mid-west are growing at twice the rate of the capital. That is the national planning framework objective. We probably need to be talking about multiple stations on that line between Limerick and Limerick Junction, not just a park-and-ride facility. We need to look at where a lot of new developments are happening there. For example, there is the new Bon Secours Hospital, the new Educate Together school and the mixed-use development that was announced just last year. Northern Trust employs a few thousand people very near the train line. We should also be looking at where the Ennis branch meets Limerick Junction because it seems to make sense to look at development opportunities around there. This is not necessarily a matter for Irish Rail. Rather, it is for the Land Development Agency to look at how we can develop parcels of land around the locations at which we can build strategic train stations-----
Comment on this
I will come back in for a second round.
Comment on this
I agree with the earlier comments around infrastructure and the strategic importance of it. We have started with the study on Ballysimon, as we have in Moyross, but they are constituent parts of the overarching plan on what we can deliver under The Limerick-Shannon Metropolitan Area Transport Strategy 2040, or LSMATS. That strategy looks at all the rail infrastructure around Limerick and how that can contribute by giving connectivity to the hospital, to the shopping centres, to the Technical University Shannon and to Thomond Park, the spiritual home of rugby - I hope there are no Cork people here. We are absolutely about it. We have some funding already in place and we started the studies around Ballysimon Moyross. The LSMATS programme will enhance that further.
Comment on this
Can I ask about Ballycar and the flood challenge? I got the train up to Ennis lately and I could see the water levels rising before my eyes. This is a real risk that the line between Limerick and Galway could be knocked out because of increased rainfall due to climate change. It will be catastrophic if that line has to close because of flooding. I am aware that responsibility in this regard does not all lie with Irish Rail, but I would like Mr. Meade's view.
Comment on this
Ballycar is filling up. It is a big turlough and it has only one outlet, which is underground. The project to solve it is developed and agreed between ourselves, Clare County Council, the National Parks and Wildlife Service and the OPW. We know what it is. At this stage it is a funding issue for allocation of funding to the project.
Comment on this
So that would be the Department of Public Expenditure, National Development Plan Delivery and Reform.
Comment on this
I understand it is the Department of Transport initially.
Comment on this
The witnesses have great patience listening to this. I missed part of it because I was in another committee, so I hope I will not be repeating questions already asked. It is good to have Irish Rail officials back in to get an update. As my colleagues have said, it is mainly a good news story.
On a technical issue, is it the NTA that decides on the projects that get done or is it the Department of Transport?
Comment on this
They are not. The NTA is a totally independent agency of Government with its own board. The Department of Transport is answerable to the people through the Minister who is the sole corporation there. I want to know who gets to decide in reality where the money goes. Is it the NTA or the Government?
Comment on this
I am glad the marker is there but sometimes one gets the answer that this does not matter. Any time I ask the Minister anything he seems to refer the thing over to the NTA.
Comment on this
Yes, for any infrastructure development. For example, our funding comes from two streams. For the service delivery and for service operation, it is through the public service obligation and the NTA. When we are putting the timetable together for announcement, we go back to the NTA and say, for example, that it will be a later Cork area service, or a morning Cork service from Limerick and so on. We tell them the cost and they either say "Yes" or "No". That is for the PSO. For infrastructure, however, and the calls for funding for infrastructure, that comes from the multi-annual contract, MAC, into my director of infrastructure who looks after the day-to-day maintenance of the railway, or through capital into all the capital investment. This comes from the Department. Sometimes the Department will channel that through the NTA and asks them to manage it or supervise it for us.
Comment on this
So the NTA has the asset but the Department provides the asset.
Comment on this
We have talked this afternoon about expansion zones. Does Mr. Meade have any indication of how 2023 was compared with 2022 and how that figured out spatially across country?
In other words, if there was 10% growth or whatever, was that all on the east coast or was it spread across the country?
Comment on this
We grew by 22% year on year from 2022 to 2023. We were still in recovery mode and we still had approximately 20% growth. It was predominantly intercity routes, which was the regions coming from and going to Dublin. All the intercity routes, bar none, are at and more than 100% of where they were previously. We have three business units covering intercity, the commuter area and the DART. The commuter area within a radius of 60 km from Dublin to places such as Portlaoise and Longford was the next best. It is probably between 95% and 98% depending on which route. The DART, which is the electrified network on the east coast, is only just over 90% because we still see a lot of white-collar blended working that. The regional routes into Dublin have shown by far the biggest growth.
Comment on this
Does that include Galway and Limerick?
Comment on this
Yes, absolutely. Galway and Limerick in particular have grown quite well. I do not have the figures for Galway and Limerick in my head. The trains on those lines are very busy every day. There is a lot of student travel to the two universities. We mentioned Cork earlier. We also see it in Cork. Within three months of moving to a half-hourly service on the Cobh-Midleton route, it had grown by 40%. Where we have put in the service with the frequency, we are getting the growth.
Comment on this
Based on the Iarnród Éireann timetable, a number of lines still have two services a day each way. There are a number which have four or five services each way without enormous conglomerations, although if we take Waterford to Limerick, the biggest inland town, Clonmel, is on that route. There is also Carrick-on-Suir and a number of other towns. With the same population, when frequency is increased from, for example, three to five, is there inevitably a dramatic growth in passenger numbers? If the service goes from five to ten, with the same infrastructure but more frequent service, is the experience that the greater the frequency the more passengers, not only on the new services but also on the existing services because there is better choice?
Comment on this
That happens once we add frequency and reliability. There are only three criteria to the business: capacity and whether we can carry the people and whether they will get seats; whether the service is frequent enough that it makes their decision process easy; and whether it is reliable. We spoke about capacity and having more trains earlier. Frequency is exactly what the Deputy is referring to. I use the Cork-Cobh-Midleton route as an example. We doubled the service by going from an hourly service to a half-hourly service and our patronage grew by 40% year on year. With new fleets we get reliability. We have pretty good reliability. Maybe self-praise is no praise, but we would say we have pretty good reliability and pretty good punctuality and people are using the service.
Comment on this
Mr. Meade already spoke about increasing the frequency and mentioned the Limerick and Galway routes. Since it is on the outskirts of Limerick, would I be right in thinking about increased frequency on the Nenagh line to Ballybrophy and increased frequency to Limerick Junction? It is not really a practical proposition to take a train from Limerick to Waterford, two of the major cities in the country with many big towns on the way. If as an interim step there were five services each way a day, would that result in getting significant numbers of people on those services, which I understand are the least used services in the country?
Comment on this
Yes, an increased service will result in a relative increase in patronage, absolutely.
Comment on this
Are there any plans for those particular lines?
Comment on this
Not in the short term because we do not have the fleet to do that, but in the longer term, absolutely.
Comment on this
Would the longer term be four to five years or 45 years?
Comment on this
It would be three to five years as we roll out the fleet. If we want to make them really viable, we would need to be heading towards a two-hourly frequency.
Comment on this
Mr. Meade went into considerable detail about Limerick to Galway. As I understand, the menu of options is put in the passing loop at Sixmilebridge, the passing loop that is already in train at Oranmore and then in the meantime longer platforms. How long will it take for the longer platforms?
Comment on this
I would say we could deliver the platforms in two to three years.
Comment on this
How long will the two bigger projects, the passing loops, take? Would it be five years?
Comment on this
It may be a bit less, but it would be four to five years. Neither of those options is currently funded.
Comment on this
So, we have to go after funding. That is very useful. Obviously, I would like to know what the hold-up is.
Iarnród Éireann got money to clear the line between Athenry and Claremorris. That is very welcome because it preserves the right of way. I understand some work was done around Tubbercurry last year to clear the line. I presume Iarnród Éireann tries to keep parts of that line clear every year to give a strong indication that it is its line and that encroachment is not to be allowed. Am I right in thinking that all it got was a mandate to clear the line?
Comment on this
Currently, all we have is a mandate to devegetate the line.
Comment on this
Now that Iarnród Éireann has devegetated the line, how big a job would it be to carry out the surveys that would be required to start designing what would be required if the funding came? In other words, how much funding would it need to do a design of what the line would cost? We have had so many estimates on this one. What we need to see is a professional design done on this line not to put it back the way it was because that was a 19th century rail line but suitable for now. I am talking about it being for freight and for passengers, lengths of platforms and passing loops to allow for increased frequency as well. What kind of money would Iarnród Éireann need to develop this plan and how long would it take to develop it? If it takes two years to develop the plan and if it got the money, then it does not need more money for another two years and it can get on with that bit of it. What kind of timeframe are we talking about?
Comment on this
Certainly, we would get all that done within a two-year timeframe. We spoke earlier about the Navan line and it is a similar process of identifying to get to the point where we have identified all the costs because we would be reinstating similar to Foynes. We would put in four-barrier level crossings with CCTV and not manual crossings. We would put in modern signalling and modern track.
Comment on this
Would Iarnród Éireann reduce farmer crossings and that kind of thing?
Comment on this
We would try to eliminate as many of them as we can. We always do. We work that through with each farmer. If we have options to put in overbridges or underpasses on any project like that, we are looking at grade separation as much as we can and then automation if we cannot do that. It would cost somewhere between €7 million and €10 million to take us over the next two years.
Comment on this
Allowing for procurement and all the rest of it, it would be approximately two years, would it not?
Comment on this
This is my final question and I thank the Chair for his indulgence.
Comment on this
I am just watching the clock because I may have to go to vote and we will need to get somebody to chair. We will keep going for as long as we can. I also want to bring in Senator Garvey.
Comment on this
Were there any discussions with TII on reinstating Ballyglunin bridge?
Comment on this
Not yet, but we have all the paperwork in place. TII signed off on that with the Department and with Galway County Council, so there is no issue there. They know and they are committed to replacing that bridge whenever we need it replaced.
Comment on this
I absolutely welcome Mr. Meade's clear statement here today - I think he said it twice - that Collooney to Claremorris is part of Iarnród Éireann's long-term plans. The rail strategy refers to connecting Dublin Airport to rail. That is a fairly expensive project, although it would be great. If it was heavy rail, it could bring people all around the country. I am not against the metro. The metro is a different job, which is internal to Dublin. Cork would be difficult and Limerick is expensive. The cheapest by far is Knock Airport. Some 800,000 people arrive there. If 10% of them took the train, that is 80,000 people. It is only ten minutes of a commuter hop.
In other words, it takes less time to get from Knock Airport to Charlestown than it takes to get from a terminal in Dublin Airport to the red car park in Dublin Airport, by the time you have gone into Google Maps and figured out how long it takes. That is without even having to walk beyond the front door of Knock Airport because it is so small. It is a very quick airport to get out of. You would not be as far as the red car park in Dublin by the time you would be in Charlestown from Knock Airport.
Comment on this
The railway station is in Bellahy in reality, rather than Charlestown. It is important that we keep it. I support efforts to maintain ownership of that line. In ten or 15 years, people will say it was always a no-brainer because it connects the north west to the west coast. I would love to have a room with a free wall to plaster on it all the articles that said there was never going to be anybody on the Limerick-Galway rail line. The witnesses are telling us people are sitting on the floors of carriages and standing. We should extend it to the north. If we do so, we will get the same surprising result because people are willing to travel 5 or 10 miles to get a train to a place like Galway, in particular for patients going to cancer treatment, for example. It is a no-brainer.
Comment on this
The point is well made that if you build it, they will come. I live close to the Luas. When there was no Luas, people said no one would use it because no one was using it then. You put the thing in and it is like a magnet. It sucks people in and they are willing to walk because they know there is reliability. We generally hear a lot more about Shannon Airport in this committee than Knock Airport by virtue of the members we have but the idea of having a rail line that close to the airport, accessible to people using the airport, sounds like a good proposal, in my neutral place as Chair, of course. I call Senator Garvey. I have a few more points, if I get a chance between votes. Equally, if Deputies Leddin or Matthews want to come back in, they can. I thank the witnesses for their forbearance.
Comment on this
I am proud that Mr. Meade is a fellow Clare person.
Comment on this
I have noticed a lot of Clare connections today. I had a fair idea there was a Clare connection.
Comment on this
In Clare, we care. Cooraclare actually. I have seen a revolution in rail. I have used the train regularly for the past 15 years. It was a lonely place for the first 12 of those years. What has happened in the last three years nearly brings a tear to my eye. The changes Irish Rail has brought around are unbelievable, in no small way due to Mr. Meade having a vision and growing up in Irish Rail - I believe he was 15 when he started. Having a Minister willing to fund public transport and a man in charge of a State agency like Mr. Meade is the perfect combination for what can be done when a State agency and a Minister have the same vision. I congratulate the witnesses and the staff.
Comment on this
It is phenomenal. It used to be just a few people with a free pass and me. Irish Rail has given people confidence in trains again. Limerick station looks amazing. It finally has decent coffee, which is a big one for me with early trains. I wish to ask a few questions. The reopening of Cratloe train station is key. I drove to Limerick the other day. I would normally get the train from Ennis. The number of cars on the road was chock-a-block. I could not believe it. I had not driven that road in a while because I always get the train. So many people still go via car to Limerick. There is something missing there. Cratloe train station would be a massive solution. I think people do not value Crusheen train station as much because I hear a lot about Cratloe. I have a guy doing research for me to prove it will be as financially viable and important to get people out of cars. We have to give people choices that suit them better than the car. We have a total car addiction. It is no wonder because we had bad public transport for so long. If we look at climate targets, of which transport has the biggest at 50%, there has never been a more important time to invest in rail. I ask Irish Rail to seriously look at Crusheen as well as Cratloe. People think it is all one-off houses and that there are not many people there. A huge number of people would go to Crusheen to get the train. I would like to hear what is happening about that and Cratloe.
On a more local level in Ennis, I would love to see a link between walking and cycling and getting the train. For instance, the bike shelter there is from the sixties. We need to invest in proper secure bike parking for people in the town or within a distance of perhaps 10 km of the town so they feel they can cycle there safely. I would love to see e-bike charging points for longer distances for someone like me - I would have to do 17 km. I might leave the bike there for three days. I would like to know I can get on my e-bike when I come back instead of bringing it to Dublin. I do not need to bring a bike to Dublin. There is DublinBikes and I have a bike there anyway.
Proper signs for information on train times are needed. The huge challenge for Irish Rail is that no matter how many trains are put on, there is a lack of confidence in public transport. It is a legacy issue. Clear information on train times is important. The people who make train signs for the underground in London are in Clare - the company is in Ennistymon. That should be looked into as well. We have to make it as easy as possible for people to access information.
I raised the issue that if you do not have the parking app, which a lot of older people do not, they are afraid they cannot leave the car there. They do not realise they can go into the station and pay for parking with cash or their card on the machine where you buy train tickets. If there are no signs in the car park to let people know that, they will not do it. People ring me saying they could leave the car there, but they do not know how to use the app, so they could not get the train. It is a question of a few signs.
Personally, later trains are needed. The last train from Dublin to Ennis is at 6 p.m. There are later trains to Limerick at around 9 p.m. but there is no train from Limerick to Ennis. That is a missing piece. One onto Galway would be amazing. Trains are very popular now with students and we need more carriages. I will speak about that in a minute. There is one at 6.50 a.m. to Galway and another one at 1.30 p.m. but due to housing reasons and because trains are so cheap thanks to the half-price ticket, students want to get the train to college like never before. They are parking their cars. They have saved up their money since their confirmation to buy a car and now they realise it is mad. Cars cost a ridiculous amount to run so they get the train and give up on the car. We need more trains. Particularly for students with the current train times especially - one at 6.50 a.m. and not another one until 1.30 p.m. does not make for happy commuters.
I feel Irish Rail was left out of Connecting Ireland. I know local authorities in many places talked to Bus Éireann and other bus companies but they did not talk to Irish Rail. It was not in the room. As a result, there are still 16 times a day when the bus and train miss each other by a short five minutes. A train comes in at 7.30 p.m. and at exactly 7.30 p.m. the last bus to west Clare leaves the station. It is a killer. People have to drive their kids up from Kilkee because the bus leaves at the same time. There is a missing piece. It is not necessarily the fault of Irish Rail. Irish Rail was left out of the room when we were looking at Connecting Ireland, from talking to the people who made submissions. Unfortunately, Irish Rail will have to drive it with Bus Éireann and Local Link - we now have that amazing infrastructure that goes where no bus has ever gone before. I would love to see the NTA bring Bus Éireann, Irish Rail and Local Link into a room and ask them to shift the timetables so there really is a Connecting Ireland.
Is there any timeline for the 140 new carriages? As was said, people are sitting on the floors which means Irish Rail is a victim of its own success. I will take the heat on that from people who give out about not having a seat. It is because we have done so well on public transport and trains in particular that we do not have enough seats because of the demand. When will we see the roll-out of increased capacity in trains?
Comment on this
We have reasonably good news on carriages and trains - they are two different things. Over the next number of weeks, we will get final certification from the CRR to start putting all 41 new carriages into the fleet. That will make existing trains longer for more capacity and people will not have to sit on the floor. Some of the Senator's colleagues who spoke earlier were from the Galway-Sligo-Westport area, where we are quite busy on the inter-city routes. That fleet will start rolling out over the next number of weeks and months. All 41 will go in to add capacity. We will accept the first of our new battery-electric trains in June and July. There is quite an onerous testing and commissioning programme by our regulator so they will not go into revenue-earning service until the end of quarter 1 or early quarter 2 of 2025 probably. For subsequent trains, we have done what we call a "head of series" so we can roll out more of that type of train. Through the latter half of 2025 and through 2026, we will add the first order of trains, 19 new trains, and the second order, a further 18 battery-electric trains.
Those trains will allow us to cascade existing trains out of the greater Dublin area into the regions and routes, significantly adding to capacity.
The timetable issue was flagged with me before by the Senator in a one-to-one session. I flagged it with Bus Éireann afterwards. We are starting to examine it to determine how we can make things work. Local Link, which we had not spoken about before, could be added to the debate to determine whether there is anything we can do in that regard. We will certainly take it back to the NTA.
On car parking and later trains for Ennis, we have got funding to examine capacity on the Ennis-Limerick line. It links to the Shannon link, which the Senator has mentioned. On whether we should put a station at Cratloe, the process on capacity on the Ennis line is now under way, so we will be asking whether we should put a passing loop at Sixmilebridge and looking at what else we should do. We need to extend some platforms to put longer trains on the route. We are full all the time on the route. That is all happening.
While this does not really deal with the issue the Senator has raised, we have provided earlier and later trains to Cork and Limerick, so students can now get to Cork earlier and people can get out of Dublin earlier. Someone can now leave Dublin and be in Shannon for a meeting at 9 a.m., which was not the case before. That is starting to come good.
On the information aspect, Daktronics does a lot of work for us. It is under new ownership now. We are rolling the initiative out across the system. Therefore, what you see in Limerick station will eventually be in all the smaller stations. We are building a new facility here in Dublin, the national train control centre, which members will have seen coming in on the train. It will be able to send information to all the signs when the project comes to finality.
Comment on this
I mentioned Cratloe. Crusheen, as I mentioned earlier, is not currently in the plan. It was examined in 2007–08. We have designed what it could be but it is not currently funded through the Department.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Garvey. I may not get back in at the rate we are going because of voting, so I want to make again the point I made at the start by naming the councillors from right across the country who have raised issues. I am going to raise them with the witnesses so they can come back to me on them on an individual basis. I include an issue on which it would be great if Mr. Kenny answered in a second. Even councillors from Donegal contacted me, namely, councillors Patrick McGowan and Michael Cholm Mac Giolla Easbuig. They do not have any train services but would like them. I have also been contacted by the following councillors: from Mayo, Mark Duffy and Brendan Mulroy; from Leitrim, Felim Gurn; from Louth, John Sheridan and Sean Kelly; from Meath, Sean Drew, Stephen McKee, Paul McCabe and Aisling Dempsey; from Westmeath, Frankie Keena; from Longford, Uruemu Adejinmi; from Fingal County Council, Howard Mahony and Adrian Henchy; from Dublin City Council; Christy Burke and Mannix Flynn; from South Dublin County Council, Mick Duff; from Kildare, Seamie Moore; from Galway, indicating how popular Galway is, John Connolly, Joe Sheridan, Shelly Herterich Quinn, Martina Kinnane, Dr. Evelyn Francis Parsons and Donagh Killilea; from Clare, Rita McInerney and Tony O'Brien; from Tipperary, Ryan O'Meara and Siobhán Ambrose; from Kerry, John O'Donoghue, Michael Cahill and Jackie Healy-Rae; from Waterford, Joe Conway; from Wexford, Michael Whelan; and from Wicklow, Gerry Walsh and Pat Fitzgerald. Therefore, there is an enormous amount of interest in Iarnród Éireann's services. By and large, the issues are not complaints as such but queries about when services, including earlier, later and more frequent ones, will be provided. Occasionally, they are about stairs, a bridge or a lift that is not working. I say this as much to bring it to the witnesses' attention as anything else. There is a genuine appetite and the vast bulk of the correspondence is positive.
Deputy Leddin mentioned the strategic profile. Many probably think rail services in Ireland are run only by Irish Rail, that it can do what it likes and that it keeps all the money and makes profit, but this is not the case. Irish Rail is now the operator. Everything it does is now controlled by the rail safety people, on one side, but also by the NTA through the farebox and the provision of the operational budget and by the Department of Transport through the capital programme. Sometimes people think Irish Rail did not do this or that but in many cases it was not that Irish Rail did not want to; it is just that it has not yet the ability. If it had its own budget, it would probably open a rail link to the airport in the morning. It would probably be one of the most profitable lines if it were put in. It is all about the Government. It is important for people to get a handle on it. A point well made by Deputy Leddin was that Irish Rail is not totally the master of its own destiny. It has to keep providing the service, looking for money and making a case for why it needs more money for its day-to-day activity, whether this entails security on trains or an extra service in the morning. It is about making a case regarding demand for services. A long time ago, people said the western rail corridor would never work, but when the service was provided, it worked all of a sudden. In my area, people could have said there was no point in reopening the old Harcourt Street line, as it was – a heavy rail line. The minute it was opened, it was incredibly popular, although I will not say it was full on the first day. People who never thought of using these kinds of services were using them and would not go back to any other mode of transport. It is very much a positive news story.
I suggest that the committee bring the witnesses back again quite soon because there is clearly an appetite for all they are doing. I do not wish to distract from what Irish Rail does but it is important that the public realise all that is happening. The public make demands of us and we in turn make demands of Irish Rail, which can then go to the NTA and the Government to ask for more funding for capital projects and day-to-day business. I thank all the witnesses for everything they have done.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair. We certainly see ourselves as a public service provider. We provide the ability for this country to move. That is a direct contributor to the economy and its growth.
Comment on this
As it happens, several members of this committee, including me, were in Brussels and we got the train to the airport. Someone asked whether we should get a taxi and I said we should not because it would be slower. Even though the train happened to be delayed on the day, we were still at the airport much more quickly than we would have ever got there by taxi, particularly where there are large volumes of people.
I know it is a case of "If you build it, they will come"; however, a map of where passengers are currently concentrated would be useful. Obviously, it is on the DART, along the eastern seaboard, where the frequency and population are highest. I would be interested in seeing where Irish Rail's current revenue base is. I do not know how much variable pricing there is and how much opportunity there is to have it. With airlines, flying is more expensive at certain times and cheaper at others to incentivise people. Maybe the delegates do not have the information but I would be interested in knowing the age profile of customers. Historically, there were many passengers with free travel. Now there are many students and commuters, with different profiles at different times of the day. I seek this information to understand what we can do to lobby our parties, the Government and indeed the Opposition, with a view to lobbying the Government on what else we can do. With a population that has increased by 50% or thereabouts in the past 25 years, you cannot allow everyone to be a single-occupancy car, yet sometimes the mindset is based on this. The closing of the Harcourt Street line and others all over the country is in my parents' recollection. The year 1959 was significant in this regard. I believe this was before all the committee members were born, but not necessarily before many in the country were born. We have a total modal and mental shift. This is all very positive but I would welcome the re-engagement of Irish Rail soon. It is not that the delegates have not been excellent today but that there is a considerable appetite for more discussion. There is much more information we would like to get from them, including for all of us to sell how good the service is. Deputies Crowe and Leddin, and I am sure other members, are good advertisements for getting the train to Dublin. Thirty years ago, probably very few members did so. I thank the witnesses.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair for the opportunity because I am not an ordinary member of this committee. I have been very strict with myself in that I have restricted myself to only eight issues.
Comment on this
Mr. Kenny might contribute on the Waterford rail line. The answer might be of benefit to Deputy Ó Cathasaigh before he contributes – I do not know.
Comment on this
It was about a specific train. Carriage 22135 collided with an obstruction on the line, rupturing the tank. This involves a longer job than normal but there is actually a second accessible toilet for people with disabilities on the train.
Comment on this
Maybe a sign could be put up stating one is not operational that there is another down the carriage. The Mayor of Waterford made a comment on the service. We have got it cleared up. I thank Mr. Kenny for that.
Comment on this
It was not on my list. It is one of the items that did not make it. I will start with the North Quays. We have the integrated transport hub, which is due to move from the current location at Plunkett Station to a location further up the quay. It will be the linchpin of the development and where the new sustainable transport bridge crossing the River Suir will land. I have been talking to the contractors and the council. They believe everything is moving as anticipated according to their timeline. I want an indication from Irish Rail as to when it believes we will see trains going in and out of the new integrated transport hub.
The second issue is that of the Barrow Bridge, which I believe was mentioned earlier at this meeting.
There was a bridge strike there maybe two years ago. How is the insurance claim progressing and are we advancing with repairs in the interim?
The third issue depends on the Barrow Bridge, namely, the Rosslare-Waterford line. It is quite some time since a passenger service ran on that line. The rail strategy moots reopening that line. Will Mr. Meade tell me where we are in terms of planning for the reopening of the Rosslare line? In a related issue, does Irish Rail envisage the Killinick loop as being a future connection? It would not only make a connection between Rosslare and Waterford, it would connect to the Dublin line that travels through Gorey, Enniscorthy and Wexford. Can we loop it across on to the south Wexford line? It would be a great transport connection, particularly in light of what is now South East Technological University, SETU, to link up its campuses.
I am sure the Deputy beside me has an interest in the Waterford-Limerick line as much as I do and I want to ask about line speed in particular along that line. What investments do we need to make? While I know we need to upgrade signalling and to look at level crossings, what level of investment is needed to get to a good quality line speed along that route? Do we have a good plan in place to try to get there? I also wish to raise increased services on that route. At present, there are only two services in each direction each day on that line and nothing at all on a Sunday. Better services to get people into Waterford or into Limerick at a reasonable time would see a huge jump in the patronage on that line.
As for the Waterford-Dublin line, I want to raise capacity issues. It has been said to me that every platform along that line can accommodate eight carriages apart from Kilkenny, which can only accommodate six carriages. Is that true and are there plans to expand that capacity in Kilkenny for when we get that cascade of carriages? I travel on that line frequently and there is a need for more capacity, particularly from Dublin to Kilkenny, where a lot of people seem to get off.
Finally the last train to Waterford out of Heuston Station leaves at 6.35 p.m., which is very early for people. As the last train to Carlow leaves at 8.30 p.m., is there any chance of getting the Carlow train to head a little bit further down the road in order to get a later service to Waterford? It would be of huge benefit to people who work in Dublin for a number of days of the week.
Comment on this
I will start with the Waterford North Quays project. I am happy to say the Waterford North Quays project is going very well. We are led by Waterford City and County Council and we are supporting that, as opposed to leading it. We are pretty much still on target for quarter 2 of 2026 to do the transfer. The contractor is doing very well. There are no issues with the contractor. It is the new BAM in there and it is really getting stuck into delivering well and on time. From our perspective, the project is going well and is on time for quarter 2 of 2026 with no issues of significance. There will always be little bits and pieces in any project but there is nothing of any significance.
On the Barrow Bridge, we did discuss it here earlier but I am happy to say we outlined a whole series of works some time back that demonstrates what we need to do. It included the consultants and needing to do topographic and barometric surveys, the ground investigations, etc. We are broadly online with that plan. We have been working through it and it is substantially complete. We have some residual GI surveys to do but nothing major in the scheme of things. We identified both ships that were involved in the two strikes. We were able to get in contact with the insurance companies and there is no argument about liability as we have CCTV and it is clear. Both insurers are now just waiting for us to come back to say that is the cost for their level of damage. There may be a debate between the two of them regarding who did what damage but it will not be with us. At the end of the day, that is for them to sort out at the marine level. We are currently building up the plan of what we will need to do to repair it. We intend to do a bit more, as we have advised before, because we also want to automate it in the process and bring it back to our national train control centre, rather than having people up on top with it. That plan is still on target.
The line itself, or the south Wexford line as we would refer to it - the line from there to Waterford - is in reasonable nick. It is identified in the all-island strategic rail review as a line to be brought back into service because there are options there for it. It is not in any funding stream at the moment and there is no direct plan to reopen the line. There is a desire there, however, as part of the all-island strategic rail review, to reopen it. Once the review is published, which should happen in the next couple of months, that prospect of a loop at Killinick, which can and will work, will be built into that design process when we get to that stage of the project.
The Deputy then mentioned the other side, that is, from Waterford going towards Limerick Junction. To enhance that, we need to move towards a two-hourly service. If you have a two-hourly service all day, that is when you grow patronage and when you get use from the service. We will not be able to do that until we have the extra fleet to deploy on that route. That will be a domino effect. We are putting in the 41 ICR carriages, as I mentioned earlier to Senator Garvey, but the real step-change will start to come as we roll out the 185 new carriages we currently have on order. They are coming in five-car sets or 37 new train sets. They will go in to the greater Dublin area because they are battery-electric but they will cascade other fleet and train sets that we can then start to deploy on our intercity routes to move to hourly services. We want to go hourly to Waterford, Galway and Sligo and to go two-hourly to Westport. We want to increase the frequency on the main routes and on regional routes. It will give us capacity to do that as well. It will be late 2026 or 2027 before we get to the point where we have the fleet to cascade down on to that.
The Deputy's information on Kilkenny is correct and there is a limit of six cars. It is not just the platform as we also are up against the actual signal to start the train there. As the Deputy is aware, we have a loop in Kilkenny, so they are all interconnected. It is not simply as easy as adding capacity to that train. We sometimes run specials out of Waterford for major events or whatever - people down there might get into an all-Ireland the odd time. We know we cannot let them into Kilkenny if it is an all-Ireland, so when we do that, we come straight past Kilkenny. We have that flexibility.
Comment on this
Witnesses should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable. Mr. Meade should stop goading our visiting non-member.
Comment on this
The issue for us is to add more capacity, with a higher frequency service initially. We will be looking at what we can do with Kilkenny station but it is actually quite tricky to lengthen the platform much beyond what it is.
Comment on this
On late trains, albeit not on the Waterford route, we have made some changes where we could sweat the assets more in the latest timetable change, such as earlier Cork ones or later on some routes.
Comment on this
Irish Rail has a three-carriage set that sits in Waterford once the last Limerick train comes in. Could Irish Rail not run it up to Carlow and run it back down again for me?
Comment on this
I am aware of that one. We could. We are in the process of training a couple of drivers. We just need more flexibility to do it. That is a point the Deputy raised with us before. We are working towards creating the capacity, not within the fleet, but within the staff to do it.
Comment on this
Very good. I thank Mr. Meade.
Comment on this
Nobody here is going to die of shock when I ask about the Enterprise and when it will become an hourly service between Dublin and Belfast. There have been various timelines but while people have said this possibly could happen in 2024, there is also talk of the replacement of the entire stock. I also wonder about the changing of ticketing infrastructure. We spoke previously of the difficulty regarding people's changed routines post Covid. They might now be travelling only two or three days but want to be able to get the benefit of a Taxsaver ticket or whatever. There was always a specific issue that those who were working for two or three days might not be facilitated and it was a problem with the ticketing infrastructure.
While this is still going through a process that has been elongated by the absence of an Executive in the North, I refer to the all-island rail review and Irish Rail's interaction with it. I suppose it is a case of sooner, better and quicker in relation to all that.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. There is good news on the hourly service. As the Deputy will know, a couple of things are happening in conjunction. The old Great Victoria Street Station is being completely redeveloped in Belfast. A big parcel of work will be done in early summer. Our colleagues in Translink intend to shut down the station for approximately five or six weeks in July and early August to make the transfer to Grand Central Station. That is the timeframe they are looking at. We are working towards putting an hourly service back in place when they reopen it; it will be part of the reopening process. That will require both Translink and Irish Rail to dedicate an extra train, if not two trains, to that service. That is also linked to our 41 ICRs. We are working at this in the background but the intention is to move to an hourly service after that. It is more of an issue for Translink than it is for Irish Rail because we have a plan in place. Translink needs to create some capacity up there. That would enable an hourly service with a mixture of train sets. We are talking to-----
Comment on this
At the end of the year. There is no specific date yet. I think what-----
Comment on this
It will be in September of this year. Irish Rail has just submitted the business case to the Department of Transport and to the Department for Infrastructure in Northern Ireland to replace the fleet. That is a project we have running. We are looking for funding from the special EU programmes body, SEUPB. That business case has gone in. SEUPB will give us some funding and the two Departments will have to make up the rest. That is for an entirely new fleet, one fleet being eight trains, in order that the whole service will be uniform. We hope to go to tender this summer, depending on getting the various approvals from the Departments. If those two steps happen, we will go to contract towards the end of 2025 with a completely new fleet in service for 2029. That is an important date for us because the SEUPB funding runs out then, so it must get it done by then.
Comment on this
That is complete replacement by 2029.
Comment on this
It will, yes. It will happen stage by stage but over a relatively short period, probably about a year or less as the trains come into service. As we will be running a mix of trains until then, including our existing Enterprise sets, some of our ICR sets, and some of Translink's CAF sets, there will not be one standard of service. Our ICRs and the Enterprise are very close in standard but the CAFs are more of a commuter train. While it is something we are looking at, the new trains will be next-generation, beyond what is on the Enterprise or the Cork service at present.
Comment on this
Will this resolve some of the mechanical issues and so on that have happened?
Comment on this
Yes, absolutely. The fleet ultimately will be electrical. It will come with some sort of mechanical propulsion in the short term but in the long term it will have the capacity to go 25 kV AC. That is what we are working towards, namely, a fully electrified hourly service with a reduced journey time. It will take all these factors into being.
On the ticketing side, there are two different ticketing systems and I happen to know that Translink has just started to look at its ticketing system to see if it can bring it more in line with Irish Rail's ticketing system. Currently, it works but it must be manually worked at several levels across the business. The all-island review, which we mentioned earlier and which was published for public consultation last September, came back with quite positive commentary. Even those comments that appeared negative were actually comments looking for more services. They were not against the proposals; they were simply saying that we might not have considered this or that. All the feedback went to the Department for Transport and it is working through that at the moment. It hopes to publish in the near future. It has not set an exact timeline but publication by the Department of the all-island review should be reasonably imminent. This will identify all the key projects to be done over the next 20 to 25 years. From an Irish Rail perspective, we will identify the short-term wins and go through a process of identifying short-, medium- and long-term projects. Short-term projects are projects over the next five years. Some of these short-term wins are programmes Irish Rail already has in play. Others are programmes we have put forward that are not yet funded but once the strategic review supports them, it will then make sense to advance them.
Comment on this
On the ticketing scenario, is it still an issue?
Comment on this
There are two different technologies involved at present. Translink has its ticketing system in the North and Irish Rail has its own. For booking tickets, there are a couple of clashes in the system. We make it work behind the scenes but a customer from the North cannot book a ticket or reserve everything like one can from the South.
Comment on this
In the South, there was an issue in certain places across the infrastructure. There was not necessarily the correct ticketing system to record days and so on.
Comment on this
I imagine the ticketing infrastructure across Iarnród Éireann has been upgraded to a degree at this stage. Is it?
Comment on this
Yes, it is. There are a couple of things in that regard. There is the next generation ticketing that the NTA is looking at and which will allow all modes of transport to use the same ticketing. Ultimately, you will just tap or scan your phone. That ultimately is where we are trying to get to. Our ticketing system is working but it does not interact with Dublin Bus or Bus Éireann. However, the Leap card currently interacts in certain areas. People in the commuter belt who are coming into Dublin from Sallins or Naas, for example, can tag on at Sallins or Naas and then go onto a bus or Luas with the same Leap card. That is working but it is not countrywide. The NTA has extended this facility to the greater Cork area recently; there is now a Leap card system in Cork. However, you cannot tag on at Heuston Station and go to Thurles.
Comment on this
I thank an Leas-Chathaoirleach for allowing me to ask further questions. I spent most of my previous contribution talking about projects in County Clare. I can be very parochial. This time I am going to talk about projects in County Limerick, namely, the exciting Limerick to Foynes railway line, which ostensibly is for freight but obviously-----
Comment on this
I have just been called to a vote. I may ask Deputy Matthews to finish off the committee meeting. Is that agreed? Agreed. The Deputy should keep going.
Comment on this
The Limerick to Foynes railway line is such an exciting project and, as I said, is ostensibly for freight but in upgrading the line, it is going to produce opportunities for passenger services in the future. I know that Irish Rail would be ambitious in that regard. It is up to us as politicians to persuade our colleagues and the various State agencies involved in that decision-making.
We are very proud in Limerick to be hosting the Ryder Cup in 2027. This is such a fantastic opportunity to develop passenger services because more than 100,000 people are going to be coming in and out of Adare every day. The best way to get them in and out of Adare is by rail and I know Mr. Meade would be supportive of that ambition. I certainly wish to see that happen and it would be remiss if heaven and earth is not moved to make that happen in time for the event. There should be passenger services to Raheen, Patrickswell, Adare, Askeaton and Foynes built on top of this freight project in the years ahead.
At Dooradoyle and Raheen, people are broadly positive about the project. There are concerns about construction works, noise mitigation, drainage issues and so on. I ask Mr. Meade that his team liaise closely with those people and residents on the ground there and-----
Comment on this
I am going to interrupt Deputy Leddin briefly. I would like to leave and I ask Deputy Matthews to come in.
I thank Mr. Meade, Mr. Kenny and Mr. Hendrick for their full three-hour engagement with the committee. They can see the appetite is here from both committee members and non-committee members, who are all interested in all of what Irish Rail is doing, as are public representatives from all over the country and the public. I thank the witnesses and the committee looks forward to using their services more frequently into the future.
Comment on this
We will go for another three hours in the absence of an Leas-Chathaoirleach.
We have a Green Party chairman now. Order the pizzas.
Comment on this
I think the room might be needed by somebody else very shortly.
Comment on this
I will be brief. It is about this project, which is really very positive. There is huge potential long into the future with it. I just want to raise the concern that residents in Raheen have raised with me, and I think it needs special attention. There is a huge possibility for Dooradoyle and Raheen to have a train station there. We have 7,000 people working in the industrial estate. They are coming from the hinterland and from Nenagh. They are coming from west Limerick, mid-Clare and north Clare. These places are all within reach of the national rail network and it makes sense to build a train station very near to Raheen Business Park. We should be talking about that and we should be ambitious about that. It can happen and I would expect that Irish Rail would agree with me in that regard.
With respect to the development of train stations along that line, we need to be looking at the city and county development plan for Limerick. This is for political colleagues across Limerick city and county. That development plan does not speak to our rail ambition at the moment. It needs to be aligned. We need to be looking at sites near the nodes along that railway line to see how we can develop them for housing, industry and so on. We need to look at what other infrastructure is needed, such as water services infrastructure, water treatment infrastructure and power infrastructure. All of these things are critically important, and it is crucial that our local authority in Limerick grasps the opportunity that this rail infrastructure presents for our city and county. I know Irish Rail will be very ambitious with respect to the vision that we have. I want to offer Mr. Meade the opportunity to respond with his own thoughts on that project, and he might give us an update on progress to date.
Comment on this
The Deputy mentioned the Foynes line. It is progressing very well. We intend to have all of the track laid in by the end of this year. As late as yesterday afternoon, I met with the main contractor there, Sisk, to discuss that very point. I have been assured that the track work will be all laid in by the end of the year. We are getting great support from the Department of Transport on this, in fairness. We have basically got the green light to finish out and do the signalling and the level crossing, so we are on track to have that finalised by very late 2025 or quarter 1 of 2026.
It is a freight line that is going in, and we are currently only considering it for freight. We are looking to move freight trains on it. That said, a train line is a train line, so once we have it, it would mean we could do something about passengers or putting in stations.
The Deputy mentioned the Ryder Cup, and there is a focus on the Ryder Cup and obviously the road extension to deal with that. TII approached us to assist them with that project because we have the expertise in Mr. Hendrick's team and his colleague, the director of infrastructure's team as well. We are going to do the three main bridges on that route for TII because we can do it faster and better than TII can at the moment. Did I say better? It is to help TII to help us all in delivering that project on time. It is a critical project for Limerick, and it will be a big showcase for Ireland Inc. That is all very much in train. We can, at the time, build temporary platforms. Once the line is there, we can operate passenger trains, even in a temporary case for the Ryder Cup.
I would agree that the line offers the potential. It is part of the LSMATS strategy, from a transport perspective, of putting in passenger services on that line, be it at Patrickswell, Adare, Raheen, Dooradoyle, the hospital or Castlemungret, which is a big residential area. All of that possibility is there, and we would say that we should absolutely do it. At Raheen, it would be at the back of Regeneron and beside where Eli Lilly is about to build. Regeneron is about 4,000-strong at the moment, and Eli Lilly would be as big, so we would have big communities of people moving in and out of there for work. It certainly is an opportunity if we want to do something significant around Limerick as part of the LSMATS plan to grow the rail infrastructure. We can certainly do it, and we are happy to work with the chief executive of the local authority there, Dr. Pat Daly, to look at the city and county development plan to see how we can assist with anything on it.
Comment on this
I want to thank Mr. Meade, Mr. Kenny and Mr. Hendrick for their participation today and for answering all of those questions. They can see the level of interest and support there is among Oireachtas Members. I thank them for their contributions today, and I ask them to pass our thanks and acknowledgment to the staff throughout the network as well for the work they do.