Sustainable Travel Operations Update: National Transport Authority
Contributions 1–158 of 316. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
The purpose of the meeting today is for the joint committee to seek an update on the National Transport Authority's sustainable travel operations. I am very pleased to welcome on behalf of the committee from the National Transport Authority: Ms Anne Graham, chief executive officer; Mr. Hugh Creegan deputy CEO and director of transport, planning and investment; and Mr. Jeremy Ryan, director of public transport services.
I will now read a quick note on privilege. Witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against a person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. If witnesses' statements are potentially defamatory in respect of an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative they comply with any such direction.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.
I remind members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex in order to participate in public meetings. I will not permit a member to participate where they are not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, any member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I ask any members participating via Microsoft Teams, prior to making a contribution, that they confirm they are on the grounds of the Leinster House campus.
I now invite Ms Graham to make her opening statement, please.
Comment on this
I thank the Chairperson and members of the committee for the invitation to attend. I understand that the committee wishes to receive an update on the National Transport Authority’s sustainable travel operations. To assist me in dealing with the committee's subsequent questions, I am joined by Hugh Creegan, deputy CEO, and Jeremy Ryan, director of public transport services with the authority.
The authority is responsible for the provision of an integrated, accessible public transport system. BusConnects and Connecting Ireland are key public transport programmes where the authority, in association with transport operators and local authorities, has planned new and improved networks to allow the continued economic and social development of our cities, towns and rural areas. The services are planned by the authority to allow residents and visitors the choice of sustainable, low carbon emission transport for some or all of their journeys.
Once again, I am happy to report that public transport numbers continue to grow on all our subsidised services. The total passenger numbers in 2023 at 311 million represented a 24% growth on the previous year’s figures and a 5% increase on pre-Covid passenger journeys.
In 2024 to date, we have seen a 9% growth on bus services in Dublin and a 10% growth in Luas services. Bus services operated outside Dublin by Bus Éireann grew substantially last year at 20% higher than 2022 passenger journey numbers but this growth has tempered to 6% this year so far. Rail services grew to 46.1 million passenger journeys in 2023, which was just back at pre-Covid levels, and the growth in volume this year so far exceeds 2023 levels by 9%. Our passenger numbers on regular rural services delivered under the Connecting Ireland programme continue to grow exponentially. This phenomenal growth brings about its own challenges where demand exceeds capacity at times. We are working with operators to provide additional capacity where necessary and where driver and fleet resources allow.
Some key service improvements that have been introduced in recent times include the southern orbital bus services in Dublin, which have seen 40% growth in passenger numbers compared to background network growth, since they were introduced. Some 41 inter-city rail cars, ICR, are being introduced to the rail fleet, which will allow additional services to be introduced in the new rail timetable from August this year. Some 16 new or enhanced Connecting Ireland rural bus services have been introduced in the first half of 2024. Our ambition is to continue to improve services across our cities, towns and rural Ireland through our BusConnects and Connecting Ireland programmes in partnership with operators and local authorities. Phase 6 of BusConnects, which includes spine E, will be introduced later this year.
Along with a number of customer service metrics, the key performance metrics for all bus operators include lost kilometres, which is a measure of the contracted service kilometres that were not operated. It also includes punctuality, which is measured for each stop along the route and is measured differently for low frequency routes compared to high frequency routes. These metrics, along with other customer-focused metrics are used by the authority to measure operator performance. The reports on transport operator performances are published regularly on our website and an annual performance report is produced. The latest that is available is for 2023. The NTA does not pay for any services that failed to operate where the failure was in the control of the operator. There are also penalties imposed on operators for the punctuality target for the service or contract not being met. Similarly, failure to meet the fare collection targets can result in a financial penalty. In contrast, if the operator exceeds any targets, a bonus is paid.
In recent times, the performance of the bus operators has been impacted by the loss of drivers and mechanics and this has resulted in the loss of services and an increase in lost kilometres. In terms of driver recruitment, Dublin Bus and Go-Ahead are in a stable position, but Bus Éireann has shortages in Cork in particular which is impacting its performance in this city. Recruitment of additional drivers and mechanics for BusConnects in Dublin is steady but it is not at the pace that we would like to see, which is delaying the next phases of BusConnects Dublin.
The next challenge that is facing the operation of bus services and, to some extent, Luas services is the growing level of car congestion in our towns and cities. We urgently need to address the lack of priority for the bus services because their end-to-end journeys are increasing because of car congestion. For example, route 208 in Cork has seen its journey time increase by 25% in the last five years. To ensure the same frequency of service, the authority must add in additional fleet and drivers.. In the case of route 220 in Cork we have added four additional vehicles and up to 16 additional drivers to this route in recent years at a cost of €500,000. In the face of congestion continually worsening and a lack of bus priority, further expenditure of approximately €1 million will need to be expended on this route in the coming months, just to stand still. This situation is replicated right across the system, such that I estimate that tens of millions of euro are being added to the cost of operation of bus services just to maintain the same level of services. The provision of bus priority through BusConnects schemes allows us to reverse that trend and start building in efficiencies into the service that can be re-invested back into improved frequency and coverage of services. It makes economic sense.
In Dublin, we have six of the 12 corridors that have received planning approval from An Bord Pleanála with no substantial amendments to the schemes. Two of those schemes are the subject of judicial reviews and cannot be progressed until those judicial review processes conclude. The NTA is now planning to bring two schemes forward to commence construction in the first quarter of next year, namely, Liffey Valley to city centre and Ballymun-Finglas to city centre. The remaining schemes will be scheduled sequentially such that a maximum of four schemes will be undertaken at any one time. While there will inevitably be some disruption during the works, the customers of the bus services operating on those routes will be the first to benefit from end-to-end bus priority, shorter journey times and much greater levels of reliability and punctuality. The authority will have in place a comprehensive programme of local engagement to ensure that residents and business owners are informed of any impending work that will impact their local area. In terms of the other cities, BusConnects Cork sustainable transport corridors are being finalised for planning by the NTA.
In summary, the key priorities for the NTA to achieve improvements in public transport services are: adequate capital funding in the current and future NDPs to deliver improved transport infrastructure to support the growing sustainable transport demand and sustainable multi-annual funding for the operation of public transport services. That concludes my introductory statement and I trust that we can answer any queries that arise.
Comment on this
First, I thank Ms Graham and her team very much for being here. It is clear from her opening remarks that participation in public transport is back to pre-Covid levels and is higher than pre-Covid levels. All that success brings its own challenges. Occasionally on Twitter or X, one will see people queuing at bus stops, but their buses are going past them because they are already full. We all understand that there are occasional days on which this can happen, such as during an all-Ireland final, if a big concert is on, etc. Yet, how bad is the congestion, generally speaking? Are there capacity constraints every Monday morning and every Friday? That may not be the case on Mondays and Fridays because people are working from home then, but when are the problems? How is the NTA moving to resolve those problems?
Touching on that, we know that airlines charge different prices at different times. Have we looked into the idea of peak fares? I am not saying that the peak fares should be higher, but maybe the off-peak fare should be lower. Maybe the €2 fare could become €1.80 or €1.70, etc., at one time of the day rather than another. This could get people to consider getting the Luas at 7.45 a.m. rather than 8.15 a.m. It might spread things out a bit better. I do not know if this is feasible. This is a matter of making sure that the capacity that is in place is used better. Equally, there are times of the day and week when people will want to travel and this is about how we handle those challenges.
Comment on this
I will respond to the question about fares and then I will ask Mr. Ryan to respond about the capacity.
On the fares side, our whole drive has been to simplify the fares system and offer a simplified fare structure. If we start to introduce a layer of off-peak fares, that would introduce a complexity to the system when we have been trying to reduce that. We introduced off-peak fares on Luas services a number of years ago but we have now removed them because they did not actually cause any change in behaviour. If people are travelling at a particular time, they are travelling at that time for a particular reason. The fare change, even when it is a substantial change, does not really make much difference to their travelling patterns. For that reason, we do not-----
Comment on this
Yes, I did remember the off-peak Luas fares. There was definitely a capacity constraint on the Dundrum line in pre-Covid times. People were actually getting the Luas from Dundrum to Kilmacud so they could cross the track to come back into town, because they could not get on the Luas in Dundrum. I do not think it is that bad now, but it was. This was before the carriages were linked, etc. I understand why the NTA does not do it. If the difference is small, it is not enough to incentivise the move.
Comment on this
Yes. Our drive is to simplify fares, rather than introducing-----
Comment on this
Yes. There are times of the week and day when there will be a problem with capacity. Clearly, we want to try to get people to want to use public transport and we want to remove all the barriers to that. If a person is not able to get on a bus, that will be a huge disincentive in their trying to do so the next day.
Comment on this
We have capacity issues at peak times, but we also have them at off-peak and inter-peak times. We have particular issues in the evening, between the times at which students come out of schools and the time at which work closes. That is between 3.30 p.m. and 6 p.m. We also have issues on weekends on occasion, such as on Saturday afternoons when people are travelling out of Dublin. We have capacity issues then. This is a little bit different to pre-Covid times when services were quite peaked in terms of demand and when there was less demand for inter-peak times. The growth in demand has primarily been outside the peak, at weekends, evenings, and between the morning and evening peaks. That is where we have seen a growth and that is partly to do with changes in travel behaviours. It is also to do with the fact that services now run at those times. People have got used to being able to avail of those services outside of the traditional peak times as network redesign in Dublin in particular has been rolled out.
Changing fares to deal with that probably is not the answer.
Comment on this
We are putting on more capacity this autumn. We are in a reasonably good place at the moment. Summertime is always a bit quieter. However, at the end of August, we are putting on additional capacity in the cities and particularly in Dublin and Cork to get ready for the additional demand. We expect to see-----
Comment on this
Additional buses are being operated. We have the buses. It is just more buses out more often.
Comment on this
Okay, so there was a level of downtime on the buses and now there will be less downtime.
Comment on this
There will be less downtime. As the Chair knows, a peak bus fleet is required to service that demand, but the times we are looking at are the evenings where there is a bit more capacity and also inter-peak in the morning. That will require additional expenditure and additional drivers. We think we have the drivers to cater for that in Dublin. In Cork, it is still a challenge at the moment. We are being told by Bus Éireann that we can get that in August or early September, but we will have to confirm that with it at a later date when we hear more about driver numbers.
Comment on this
In terms of recruitment of both engineers to service the buses and drivers, how is that going? There was a big problem there.
Comment on this
In the case of Dublin, we expect the mechanic issue to be largely resolved this autumn. Forty mechanics have been recruited from the Philippines and we expect they are coming over to work in Dublin between now and September. That should alleviate the issues that were in Dublin, which were really preventing us from growing the network in Dublin as we had planned.
In Cork, there are ongoing driver issues. There are less than there were, but there is still a shortfall of 30 or 35 drivers. That is down from around 45 or 50 earlier in the year. Again, there is an intensive recruitment campaign going on by Bus Éireann in Cork now. At the moment, it is anticipating that it will be successful, and we can do what we need to do in September. As I said, we will have to watch this space.
Comment on this
In terms of the total number of BusConnects, is it 12 routes in total that were being proposed? Where are we in terms of how many have been delivered?
Comment on this
Is the Chair referring to phases of network redesign in BusConnects?
Comment on this
There are eight spines, but we have broken the delivery down to 11 different phases to allow for their introduction.
Comment on this
We are coming on to phase 6 now. Phases 1 to 5 have been completed. Phase 6 was delayed-----
Comment on this
Of the eight spines that are supposed to be in operation, how many are in operation?
Comment on this
In terms of how they are operating and delivering, has Mr. Ryan seen measurable improvements in numbers and delivery times and so on?
Comment on this
We have. We have seen significant growth. We are looking at around 25% up compared to background network growth. Overall-----
Comment on this
I am getting slightly confused because there are 11 phases and eight spines and now 12 corridors have been referenced.
Comment on this
The 12 corridors are the bus sustainable transport corridors. That is the infrastructure side.
Comment on this
We have 12 corridors that need bus priority that will serve the eight spines as well as the other part of the network.
Comment on this
On the 12 corridors, six have received planning approval with no substantial amendments, but two of those are subject to judicial review.
Comment on this
We do have bus priority at different sections across the network.
Comment on this
Yes. It represents approximately 30% of the core network that is covered by bus priority.
Comment on this
In terms of the 12 corridors, six have received approval and two are subject to judicial review. Therefore, four of them could in theory start physical development.
Comment on this
Two have only just received planning approval, so they still could be subject to a judicial review.
Comment on this
They will be commencing in quarter 1 of next year.
Comment on this
They are the Liffey Valley-city centre and Ballymun-Finglas corridors.
Comment on this
Clongriffin to city centre and Blackrock to city centre.
Comment on this
Does Ms Graham have any idea how long the judicial reviews are going to take? There is probably an element of asking how long is a piece of string, but it is-----
Comment on this
Not at this time. Obviously, this new court must be available in order to try to progress these as quickly as possible when they are planning decisions. We have no indication at this stage how long that will take.
Comment on this
I will want to get back in at some stage because my time has almost elapsed. There is an issue about the fairer fares, which Senator O'Loughlin will raise later so we will leave that for her to discuss. We got plenty of emails about it this morning, however.
Where are we in terms of disability proofing the entire network in respect of access to Luas and buses, better bus stop design and so on?
Comment on this
We have obviously progressed a number of issues with the transport operators. If we break it down into our city fleet, all our bus fleet is accessible with low-floor access ramps at the front, and the bus stops will be capable of receiving those ramps as well. Internally in the bus, we have moved to provide a separate wheelchair space and a buggy space. Approximately 80% of our city fleet would have---
Comment on this
Are they kind of interchangeable whereby a bus could hold two buggies or two people using wheelchairs?
Comment on this
We could certainly have two buggies. It might be a little bit tight for two wheelchairs. It depends on the size of the wheelchair. We have also introduced a secondary ramp on the middle door as a back-up if the mechanical ramp at the front is not operating. We are introducing hearing loops in the buses and next-stop announcement improvements. We are doing a lot to try to improve that with the operators.
Comment on this
What about the Luas? The Luas trams are accessible but sometimes it is the platforms or there are or have been lift issues in various stations. Are they getting resolved? Are there permanent or almost semi-permanent problems in some places?
Comment on this
I do not know whether Mr. Ryan has that information.
Comment on this
I am not aware of any particular long-duration problems on Luas with regard to lifts. They do break down, as all lifts do from time to time, but I am not aware of any chronic ongoing issues.
Comment on this
However, there have been issues with railway station lifts. A programme of work has now been undertaken to replace lifts and put in CCTV call at lifts to try to protect them from antisocial behaviour and vandalism, which has unfortunately been affecting the availability of lifts on our rail services in particular. Then, we are working through a programme of putting in lifts where there may not be access to the second platform. Those works are ongoing as well.
Comment on this
Okay. I thank the witnesses for all that. I will come back in for a second round, and other members also want to come in. I thank the witnesses for all they are doing.
Deputy Crowe may go ahead if he is ready.
Comment on this
I welcome the representatives from the National Transport Authority. I thank them for their engagement. I have quite a few bits to put to them so I will go fairly quickly if that is okay. First, I wish to raise the whole issue of Local Link services, which I raised in the committee last week with the Minister, Deputy Eamon Ryan.
Over the past 18 months, many new accommodation centres have been set up for international protection applicants and also Ukrainian war refugees. Typically, when one of these centres opens, sometimes they are in towns and cities but sometimes they are in far-flung, remote parts of rural Ireland. Typically, a bus service follows, with Local Link fulfilling it.
I discovered an issue last week. This happens to be in my county, but it could be anywhere in Ireland because this will replicate itself unless someone screams for it to stop and intervenes. The famous Loop Head Lighthouse is in a beautiful remote part of County Clare. The contract for Loop Head Lodge is now up and will not be renewed. Therefore, the Ukrainian war refugees there will be moved elsewhere in the country. That is a whole different debate. We have now discovered that the Local Link service was tied into that accommodation centre, and it will now be pulled.
I made this point to the Minister, Deputy Ryan, and he agreed in this committee. This has been tough on people who have left. This will be extremely tough on people who have fled war. It has been extremely tough for international protection applicants, but it has also been tough on local communities. It has been a rough and tumultuous 18 months. Whatever we have gained in terms of public transport, we should not be losing. Whatever strings were tied into these initial contracts should now be retied so that these services stay embedded in the community.
I would like to hear Ms Graham’s response to that and if she would generally or maybe specifically intervene on this.
Comment on this
I am not aware of the particular service that Deputy Crowe has raised, but when these services were being initiated a separate funding stream was put in place to facilitate us to provide those services. It may be the case that there is a funding issue around that, but that is something I can check. If we have established a service, it is not necessarily in our interest to remove it and if we can retain it at all, we will do so. It may be the case that there is a funding issue around that, but we will check that out and get back to Deputy Crowe with more detail.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Graham very much. I appreciate that. Next, I want to raise the issue of capacity on some services at certain times, which was mentioned in the NTA’s opening statement. That is true. When you go to the Google Maps app, it will tell you when the next bus is busy and the information there is quite accurate. What is becoming a huge trend is that the early morning trains coming into Dublin are very much congested. This morning, I travelled on the 7.40 a.m. train. The earlier train, which was at 7.25 a.m., would have been about half full by the time it left Cork and collected passengers in Limerick Junction. It would increase as it went through Thurles and Portlaoise. Beyond Portlaoise, as you get to areas such as Newbridge, Sallins, Naas, etc., you will start seeing that the train becomes too full to the point that the passengers are not only standing between carriages, but they are also standing up and down the aisles of carriages and they are holding onto seats and are rocking over and back. I do not think it is safe. I do not think it is right. It is morally wrong that there are not more carriages when they are paying a lot of money to travel on those trains. I know the issue corrects itself as the day goes on, but surely there needs to be better oversight of the number of the carriages on those morning trains. Is it safe? I will ask that question. I know it is safe on the Luas and buses, but is it safe for someone when a train is travelling at 120 km/h, or whatever the speed is, that they should be standing in the aisle for the entire duration of the journey?
Comment on this
The issue of safety of the passengers and the volume of passengers is assessed by Irish Rail. The trains are designed for standing passengers. Generally, it is considered that there would be some standing passengers on some of those services. It is not ideal, and it is our preference to reduce the number of standing passengers on those services. A number of commuter services also serve those inner parts of the city. It might just be a timing issue. Those services are probably followed fairly quickly by a commuter service that can cover much of that capacity. As the Deputy knows, 41 ICRs are being introduced to the fleet and more fleet is being manufactured as part of the DART+ programme, in particular to try to build the capacity on the commuter services. This will allow other fleet to be introduced to the intercity services as well.
Comment on this
I might just add that Irish Rail does annual surveys in November of each year and crowding of carriages is assessed as part of that survey. If those surveys show that there is an unacceptable level of crowding, it will come to us with a revised plan where they have rolling stock to increase the length of trains. Also, in our contract, there is a contracted length of train for each service that Irish Rail operates. On occasion, for whatever reason, carriages are not included when they should be. We keep an eye on that through the contract.
Comment on this
I am no expert on this, but I use this service five or six times per week. The morning train and the early service to which I refer has three carriages, but as the day goes on, it will have seven carriages. Surely, the last trains at night that are going out of Dublin and are going to the other parts of Ireland should be bringing extra carriages to Cork, Limerick and Galway, etc., so that when they are going up through areas such as Thurles, Portlaoise, Newbridge, Naas, and Sallins, etc., they have the capacity-----
Comment on this
The carriages should be going west and south in the night-time. That is certainly how the airline industry works. The capacity goes a certain way in the morning.
Next, I want to ask about an issue that I raised as a parliamentary question. It was responded to yesterday evening, and I thank the NTA for that. Licences are granted by the NTA for day trip coach tour operators. I will not name them, but I think we can all guess which ones they are. There are a few of them operating in the country and they go to the NTA for licences. They seek licences on certain routes to iconic tourism sites in the west and south of Ireland. Increasingly, they are relegating the status of some of these, in their own words, to “photo stops”. These are photo stops along the roads. The coach will pull in, 50 passengers will get off, and this is dangerous. They will take a photo, they will get back on the bus and they will go again. This has totally hollowed out tourism in the west of Ireland. These iconic sites were once the magnet to bring people to the west. They get out and take a photo and they are gone again. It is Instagram tourism. Whether we like it or not, through the NTA’s licensing deals, it has become almost complicit in this, although maybe unwittingly so.
We are asking for more sustainable tourism, which would happen if we did not have these express services, which is what they have become. They shuttle around these narrow roads in Dingle and west Clare and drop these passengers off. They have breakfast in the morning in Dublin, they have dinner in the evening in Dublin and they stop in one place for lunch. It is hollowing out tourism, it is not safe, and it is not sustainable. I know that the NTA will say that this is not fully a function for it, but surely there needs to be some additional criteria in this licensing. We are not speaking about A to B services here, but tourism. There needs to be some stopping along the way. There has to be some value for the west of Ireland. I do not think this would happen in other countries where there is coach tourism that they would allow the shuttle service to go in and out, take a photo and go again. I would love if the NTA could put its eyes on that situation.
Comment on this
As I said to the Deputy, that is not our role. Our role is to ensure that they are licensed under the Public Transport Regulation Act. This is really about establishing and looking at the demand for those services and the proper stopping locations. Tourism policy is the responsibility of Fáilte Ireland, which is another authority. If that authority were to engage with us, the licensing authority, about what public transport can do, that would be something different. When we get an application for a licence, it is from a commercial business that has made a decision on what kind of service it wants to offer. We are not in a position to encourage it to do anything else with its commercial business. Like a normal licence for public transport service that is just for commuters or other passengers, if it decides to stop at a particular location, we will examine the demand, but we will not be requiring an operator to stay at a particular location for any particular time. That is not something that we-----
Comment on this
I think at a minimum they should elongate their schedules because they drive around like shuttles. They go around Doolin, the Cliffs of Moher and west Kerry where there are no roads that can take these vehicles. They are under this insane pressure to make it to the location where they get to the ferry to the Aran Islands, which I think is at Ros a Mhíl. They are under this insane pressure to get from Dublin all the way to that point of departure for the ferry. It is a matter of them taking a photo and going, so I just-----
Comment on this
That is their business, and it is obviously what their customers are looking for, because they would not be providing the service-----
Comment on this
The NTA should reject some of the licence applications on the basis that the timings are not working. They are-----
Comment on this
We just have to ensure that they can operate the distance they travel. We do not regulate their stopping times. That is not the role of the authority.
Comment on this
Okay. Next, I want to ask a question about school transport. Do not worry because this has an NTA angle to it-----
Comment on this
Yes, I am just wrapping up with my final question. There is a whole different debate about school transport, but the point I wish to make is that much of the Bus Éireann fleet in rural areas throughout the country is tied up in the mornings and afternoons with bringing children to and from school. My home village of Parteen is an example because there is no bus service that goes in and out from there to Limerick city. A Bus Éireann coach goes out in the morning, collects children and brings them to the school gate. This fulfils a contract for the Department of Education. It then leaves the school gate, entirely empty of passengers, and returns to the Bus Éireann depot in Limerick. I have brought up this issue many times with the Minister, Deputy Foley. I have mentioned it to the Minister, Deputy Eamon Ryan. If there was a little bit of smart thinking, surely we could analyse how that bus goes out on a contract with the Department of Education, turns around, and returns to the depot as a Bus Éireann vehicle. Surely, with a little imaginative thinking, that could provide at a minimum a morning and afternoon service. Perhaps the NTA could advise on that situation. That is just one village, but it is happening all over the country. Many contracts are of course being fulfilled by private operators, but I think the NTA needs to have a chat with Bus Éireann in particular. How many of its vehicles are on the road each morning? This is not so relevant to the city area but let us take a village in the west of Ireland that may not have a bus service, or which may have a skeletal one. It is devastating, particularly for the older people in the village, to see an empty coach, which is a fabulous 241-registration vehicle, returning to the depot in the morning when it is empty. We are only 5 km from Limerick city but we do not have a service to bring us into it.
Comment on this
I am interested to hear about that particular situation, because a number of years ago we sought information on instances like that where we could do pilots to trial situations where a return journey of school transport could serve a Local Link-type service.
We found it difficult to find locations. We did several pilots. One in Waterford was particularly successful and it is now a fully established Local Link service. This is certainly something we can look at because we found it difficult to find locations where the return journey would be beneficial. The local school is usually not located where people would be returning from. If the Deputy will give me that information, we will certainly look at it in terms of planning.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Graham for the opening statement. It is clear from it that the number of passengers is growing across all the services. This is very welcome news. I see we have increased numbers on the buses, the Luas services and everywhere. We have increased the use of public transport and this is all very welcome. What springs to mind immediately in this context is capacity in this regard. On several occasions, we have had the Minister in here and he has, of course, made a great case for BusConnects and the removal of cars from the road to make space for the buses. Yet when I talk to people, most tell me that is not the issue. Instead, they tell me the issue is that buses are always full when they arrive and not that the cars are blocking the passage of the buses. I welcome the commitment that more services will be put in place and additional buses will be put on many of these routes.
The major issue we need to be looking at is expanding this network in future. The Luas to Lucan is one of the services we want to see moving along. I would like to get an update on these projects, including DART+. A whole range of issues exists here concerning where these projects are at and how soon we are going to see the resulting new capacity getting to the stage where we will have people travelling on them. MetroLink is the one project that springs to mind immediately. At this stage, the project has almost taken generations. We need to see movement on expanding this capacity.
Comment on this
To explain how road congestion can impact on capacity, where a bus is travelling with general car traffic, the speed of the car traffic impacts the speed of the bus. The impact is that it slows down the bus, which means there is a need to introduce additional time into the journey and this, in turn, means introducing additional fleet and drivers. You are not actually increasing overall capacity in that case; you are just providing the capacity because the journeys are longer. This is why we are finding we are pumping in many resources into dealing with road congestion rather than building capacity. Unfortunately, this is the position we are in.
This is why we need the reallocation of road space. It will not be needed everywhere. There will be pinch points, especially in towns and villages around the country, that may only need a short bit of bus priority to get the buses through. In the cities, however, we definitely need end-to-end bus priority just to make the services much more efficient. It will mean we will not be spending money to deal with increased journey times but putting it into providing actual capacity. We are at the point where bus priority really is a priority for us now. I hand over to Mr. Creegan to give an update on where the major projects stand.
Comment on this
To start with the BusConnects infrastructure, as mentioned in the opening statement, we have sought planning consent for 12 corridors to build bus priority and cycle lanes along. We have now got consent from An Bord Pleanála for six of those. We are, hopefully, going to go to tender for the first two at the end of this month and get them into the construction phase at the start of next year. As soon as we get another two corridors that are clean and there is no judicial review of them, we will get those into construction quickly too.
In terms of the other projects, MetroLink is with An Bord Pleanála, as the Deputy is aware.
Comment on this
The application was lodged in September 2022 and an oral hearing concluded in March this year. An Bord Pleanála has now written to Transport Infrastructure Ireland seeking that all additional information made available during the oral hearing now be published to allow people to review it and make submissions. I think that publication will occur in the coming weeks. We are, then, waiting for An Bord Pleanála to make its decision on the MetroLink project.
Regarding the rail side of things, several DART expansion schemes are with An Bord Pleanála now. The application for DART+ West was submitted in July 2022, I think, while that for DART+ South West was submitted in March 2023. This month, we have given Irish Rail the okay to submit a third railway order for what we call DART+ Coastal North, which consists of improvements as far as Drogheda. The application will go into An Bord Pleanála this month. We are hopeful one of these applications will come through pretty soon and Irish Rail is geared up to move the project into the construction phase as fast as possible.
A lot of work is going on in Cork too on the major project there, namely, the Cork area commuter rail project. Works are going on at Kent Station and shortly a contract will be awarded for the double-tracking of the line between Glounthaune and Midleton. In terms of the Luas projects, Luas Finglas will be the next line that will go to construction, in my view. A railway order application is ready to go into An Bord Pleanála. Government approval is required for that, which I believe will come through in the coming weeks. If this is the case, then that application will be submitted around September.
There is, then, a portfolio of projects coming up. In fairness, when we look back, there have been delays in the planning system. We think this situation has much improved now. We can see that decisions are coming out now, and well-reasoned ones. We are now moving from a planning phase for all these projects into, hopefully, a construction phase for all of them.
Comment on this
Regarding capacity for the construction of those projects, are there any issues there?
Comment on this
With things like MetroLink, for example, much of the required skill sets must come from international contractors.
Comment on this
At what stage will that project go to tender?
Comment on this
It is all linked to when we get approval for the railway order. As soon as that approval comes through, there will be an ability to go to tender. We will have to do a sequence of construction activities on it but there will be an ability to start that tendering process almost immediately.
Comment on this
Have any pre-tender documents been prepared or anything like that?
Comment on this
There have and there will be. We hope to have certain parts of this undertaking where we will have tenders short-listed in advance and ready to go. This is all in train to have it all ready.
Comment on this
Regarding extending the Luas to Finglas and similar projects, are there timescales for how long it is expected construction will take?
Comment on this
The funding for the Luas-to-Finglas project is not contained in the current national development plan.
Comment on this
That aspect would have to be addressed. If the project is funded and does get approval, I would say construction would take about three and a half years to complete. Let us say it will take 18 months to go through the An Bord Pleanála process and then three and a half years to build, a five-year horizon would then be the earliest possible date for completion.
Comment on this
Okay. To move to the rural issues, Local Link has provided a great service in many areas and has been revolutionary for some areas. Many areas are still left behind, though, and do not have required frequency and so on. I know some projects that have been put in are awaiting funding. Is this a case of waiting for the budget and hoping it is a giveaway one on the eve of an election or what is the situation here?
Comment on this
Obviously, we have a specific level here. As the Deputy will be aware, we have the Connecting Ireland programme and that was going to be a multiyear programme anyway. It was never going to be a case of us being able to deliver everywhere at once and was always going to have to be a phased programme of delivery. We have gone through several phases and they have been very successfully delivered, but it does take funding and resources to do it. We have a specific budget for this year and we are working to this budget. We will deliver as much as we can within these budgetary amounts.
Comment on this
When Ms Graham says multi-annual funding is required to be able to achieve the existing target, will there be a need to see this funding increased year on year and, if so, by what value?
Comment on this
Of course, we would always seek additional funding. If you are delivering services and you know there are gaps in them, there is always a requirement for additional funding. We can use additional funding across service delivery and infrastructure, but what would assist us greatly, and it is not something that is in place, because we go through an annual cycle of PSO funding and it goes through the budget every year, this means we have to stop-start in terms of planning. By the time we know what our budget is going to be and plan for delivery, it can be the second quarter of the following year before we are beginning to deliver. What would be helpful for us, therefore, as an authority would be some foresight of what the funding could be over a horizon of a few years because this would allow for much more efficient planning and delivery.
However, that is challenging with the current budgetary structure.
Comment on this
With regard to the delivery of projects in rural areas as well as urban areas, is the same problem of finding drivers the biggest obstacle or is it actually finding the buses?
Comment on this
It is not as big a problem as in the cities but it has been a problem in certain areas. Driver availability in the industry generally was a problem for the past couple of years. It is pretty much confined to a small number of areas now - Cork and, to some extent, Limerick cities. We are not hearing of many issues regarding drivers in rural areas at the moment but it was an issue earlier in the year.
Comment on this
Mechanics were also another issue that was spoken of. Is that still a problem?
Comment on this
That is a sporadic problem and, again, it was a problem in Dublin primarily but, to some extent, in Cork city. Outside, I have not heard of too many issues regarding mechanics in rural areas but I am not sure.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming before us and I want to compliment the secretariat on the briefing note that was provided to us. I am sure the NTA contributed to it but it is really thorough. I thank the secretariat for that.
On behalf of the Minister of State, Deputy Heydon, who obviously cannot be at this committee, and on the basis of the glut of emails we received from Kildare this morning and this afternoon, I wanted to raise a query with the witnesses regarding the timeline for the implementation of the reduced fares for the commuter belt areas, including Kildare, Newbridge, my own area of Fingal, Louth and Meath, and along the introduction of the new commuter belt. I understand Oireachtas Members were told recently that it would be quarter 3. It now looks like January. Will the witnesses clarify, please?
Comment on this
That is the unfortunate case. Unfortunately, we have to announce that the Irish Rail contractor that manages its ticketing system, particularly the ticket-vending machines is not in a position to deliver to the timeline we would have liked and has given a timeline of quarter 1 of next year. We are obviously trying to see how we can mitigate that and if there are any changes we can make. The other thing we are also considering is whether there are other elements of fares we need to bring forward now so we package up even more with regard to that delivery. Unfortunately, we are very disappointed to say this introduction is now delayed from quarter 3 to quarter 1 next year.
Comment on this
Will Ms Graham give us a commitment that, if the NTA is in a position to introduce it sooner than quarter 1, it will do so?
Comment on this
Absolutely, yes. It is our ambition to deliver it as quickly as possible. We knew there was infrastructure required with respect to validators. They are being put in place but, unfortunately, it is the back office works that need to be done which are taking the time. We cannot commit to doing it any faster until we have engaged with the contractor to see if there are any other ways of delivering it faster.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Graham for that reply. I have six items I wanted to touch on. I hope to have enough time to do so. I will start with the DART+. The witnesses have gone through that and Coastal North is in process, having been approved by Cabinet. There is an interim roll-out planned, I understand. Are there any impediments to choosing the implementation date for the roll-out of DART+ Coastal North while the railway order is in place? I assume the NTA is waiting for the rolling stock. Obviously, that is needed before it does anything. Are there any perceived or real-time delays in the delivery of that rolling stock?
Comment on this
No, it is all within the expected territory. In fact, the first trial train will come in later this year but it will go through a whole series of tests over the next 12 to 15 months. In early 2026, we would expect to see a DART running to Drogheda, effectively. To go back to an earlier question, that allows some of the other diesel fleet to be taken off that line and cascaded onto other lines, which also deals with capacity issues.
Comment on this
Could I ask for clarity? On Irish Rail's website there is a very helpful document, which is literally a PDF on the website. It details that there will be diminution of service for existing services at existing stations. What Mr. Creegan has inferred will be that some services will be removed to provide services elsewhere. I wonder are these communities and train stations that will be served by DART+ Coastal North going to see a reduction in the number of what I call diesels, or will they remain the same and have the additional DARTs?
Comment on this
I may have got my verb wrong but what I should have said is we replaced the diesel services with electrified DART services so there is no diminution in the service to all those communities.
Comment on this
It is an increase in frequency and capacity.
Comment on this
It is certainly an increase in capacity and much more modern rolling stock. The frequency may take a while to build up so we are not committing to increased frequency on day 1. We are committing to transitioning the existing fleet over to the new fleet and then we will see afterwards what additional increases we can do beyond that.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Creegan for that. With regard to any research the NTA has carried out on fare incentivisation - in other words, usage incentivisation - the Luas was mentioned with regard to there not being a change in demand for the use of that service when there were changes in the pricing structure. The Luas is a little bit like the railway lines. It is a fixed service in a fixed location and it does not move. Therefore there is a fixed demand. Buses, on the other hand, are everywhere and they are a different thing. Has any research been done in any other jurisdictions that have used fare structures to incentivise passenger usage?
Comment on this
Various cities and countries have various fare structures, and some have off-peak fares for weekends and outside of peak travel, while some do not. The point we were making was that, regarding travel patterns we have seen since Covid, the growth has primarily been outside of peak. We are getting that growth without off-peak fares. Do we need more of that growth? We would need the capacity to deal with it in first place if we were to get more of that growth. At the moment, there is not a strong case for having higher peak fares compared with off-peak fares that we can see based on our experience.
Comment on this
I might add to that. We were monitoring to see what happened with the 20% fare reduction. While it is difficult to identify whether that drove additional passenger numbers, given everything else that was happening and that we were recovering from Covid, and whether passenger numbers would have been recovering anyway, there is no doubt the 20% reduction did result in increased passenger numbers but it is probably difficult to put an actual figure on that.
We have also done some research because there has certainly been a push for free fares across the public transport network. The research that has been done elsewhere has shown that while it may increase passenger numbers by a certain amount, what you find is that people are doing less walking and cycling as a result of free fares. They are just transferring from the more sustainable modes like walking and cycling - the active modes - to public transport. That is the kind of behaviour-----
Comment on this
I ask the Leas-Chathaoirleach that we might consider a session just on that area of fare incentivisation with the NTA and perhaps with other actual transport service providers in the autumn.
Comment on this
We might even get a briefing on it or something, or maybe an online briefing, not using a session.
Comment on this
It might be something worth exploring.
Comment on this
On the metro, it is a little bit of a pet project of mine in my own constituency. I very much welcome the appointment of Dr. Sean Sweeney and the advances that are being made. I note the remarks that have been made thus far. We are all waiting on tenterhooks for An Bord Pleanála to get us a decision, and I certainly hope the right decision is made. I very much hope that once that decision is made and the matter is concluded, we can have the NTA in and have a lengthy debate about how we might assist it in getting that project up and running. That is not a question but more of a remark.
With regard to fleet optimisation, Irish Rail has obviously published plans. We know about the electric buses that have been delivered or are in the process of being delivered under the theme of sustainable transport operations, which is what this meeting is about. Perhaps the witnesses could write to the committee and inform us or identify for us the timeline for the electrification of the Dublin Bus fleet and those in other cities and large urban centres.
Could they also include remarks on the operators' capacity to provide those buses? I am sure every urban TD and Senator in this building would be aware of ghost buses that are not showing up because real time is not real time; it is timetable time. We have buses that do not show up, not to be confused with the tourist offering, which is a ghost bus. I want to make sure that we have a good grip as to precisely what has been ordered, by whom and what plans are there. As I said, the Irish Rail timetable is very well known. It is published. It is up on its website. With other operators, it is not so much the case. I wonder whether the NTA might be able to provide us with additional information.
My other point for a reply is in relation to the BusConnects projects. The Chairman quite helpfully ran through it at the beginning. The NTA is on phase 6, I understand, which, by extrapolation, is spine E. Can the witnesses provide us with a full list of their expectations as to when the next number of services, right down to No. 12, are rolled out, with a quarter or half-year associated with it, in order that the committee can be fully briefed on precisely what their expectations are in terms of the actual buses? Separately, it would be extremely helpful if they could provide us with information in regards to their plans for planning applications for the infrastructure side of the BusConnects projects.
Finally, I compliment the NTA for the foresight in the additional funding that is being provided to the rural link services. Local Link is the only service provider in the State that I have not received a complaint about in many years.
Comment on this
I have had no reliability issues and no state-of-bus service or interaction-with-the-driver issues - nothing like that. I am delighted with the service that has been provided. It has been relatively responsive, too, from the NTA's perspective, at granting additional extensions for parts of my rural constituency. I am very pleased with that.
I would be grateful if they would not mind commenting on the BusConnects question.
Comment on this
Mr. Creegan might address the fleet on BusConnects.
Comment on this
The decision was made three or four years ago, to transition our urban bus fleet all to a fully-electric fleet. We have approximately 100 buses in operation here in Dublin, 34 in Limerick and more coming on stream. We have a pathway to fully replace all the fleet on a staged basis and we are happy to provide that to the committee.
Comment on this
I should have said that. Athlone is fully electric. It is the first fully-electric town service in Ireland.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Creegan for that and thank Deputy Alan Farrell. I call Deputy Duncan Smith.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for always being so available to the committee and being so frank and honest in their answers. I appreciate that.
I will following up on the point in relation to the Dublin commuter zone. Obviously, this impacts my own constituency. However, in relation to Newbridge, while the committee received many emails this morning, this campaign has been going on for six years. It was started by the Newbridge Labour Party, with Mark Wall, now a Senator, and it has gathered momentum. We have had the community development campaign, led by Jennifer Caffrey, down there for the past three years. It is greatly needed. People have made decisions or life choices based, in terms of living and moving to Newbridge, on the commuting capabilities and the costs. I could sense Ms Graham's frustration with Irish Rail. I impress upon her that anything she could do to bring this back closer to the September timetable would be greatly appreciated. As I say, there were 8,000 signatures handed over at one stage to the NTA by the group and Ms Graham knows how deeply felt it is in that community.
On MetroLink, we are way behind the intended schedule of 2027. Could the witnesses provide any further details of what has been pre-prepared in advance of what, we hope, will be a favourable decision from An Bord Pleanála? They mentioned lining up pre-tenders, etc. Is there any other detail they could provide in terms of what the NTA has done and can do in its capacity to ensure MetroLink is not delayed any further? We recently had a ministerial intervention in relation to the Dublin city traffic plan which has the capacity to delay that much-needed project in Dublin. Does the NTA have any concerns as a body about that level of ministerial or governmental interference in relation to MetroLink?
Comment on this
Mr. Creegan can talk about the preparations. As for the Government, MetroLink is part of the national development plan. It is an important strategic project for the region and for the country. We do not have any concerns that there is no political will to deliver that. We believe that there is a will, across party and across Government, to deliver MetroLink for the State.
Comment on this
In terms of getting MetroLink ready for construction, assuming a positive decision, a major body of work has been ongoing for a while and is still continuing to make sure that tender documents for all the various contracts that are needed are in place and that planned enabling works are organised. All of that is being set up so that as soon as a railway order comes out, assuming the funding in place, we have got a clear pathway to deliver it on the ground. Tender documents, pre-qualification procedures, planning of advanced works, etc., all are well in hand.
Comment on this
That is the kind of stuff that we could hear being delaying factors on other projects, rightly or wrongly. In terms of MetroLink, if we get a favourable decision and there is funding in place, insofar as it can, the NTA is ahead of the game on its side.
Comment on this
It is our intention to be good to go when, hopefully, planning consent comes through.
Comment on this
Brilliant. I thank Mr. Creegan.
In relation to accessibility, a few weeks ago I met a constituent who is blind and is a regular bus user but who has had buses drive pass him at bus stops and has had to rely on the kindness of strangers at bus stops to make him aware of when buses arrive. Is any work being done, such as app technology, that can aid visually-impaired people in using the bus services, be it Dublin Bus or others?
In terms of wheelchair accessibility, in particular, on the bus fleet, there is limited capacity. Even the most modern buses may only have capacity for one wheelchair. If there are buggies or prams, that can cause difficulty. Is there any further work being done to improve accessibility to the buses and in terms of the new fleet coming on stream?
Comment on this
I can answer the first bit in relation to accessibility for visually-impaired people boarding buses. We have tested apps on this. Something we are also looking at doing in our new contracts that are coming up for renewal with Dublin Bus and Bus Éireann, and we might role out to other contracts as well for bus, is that if there is somebody who is visually impaired at a stop or obviously visually impaired waiting at a stop, a bus pulls up regardless of whether the person signals for the bus to stop to ask the person if he or she wishes to board the service and to tell the person what service it is to make sure that he or she can board if he or she needs to.
Comment on this
That would require every bus that passes that stop to stop and ask every individual.
Comment on this
Every bus that is scheduled to stop at that service if somebody wants it to stop, would stop and ask the person if they wish to board the service, tell them the route number that it is and give them the opportunity to board.
Comment on this
Would there be practical implications of that given the timetabling constrains on the bus services or anything like that? Obviously, there would be multiple bus services that could be coming from multiple areas. Particularly where they are converging on somewhere such as the Ballymun Road or the Swords Road, one could have buses coming from Coolock, Swords or the Glasnevin direction. Are there difficulties there?
Comment on this
Given the number of people who are likely to be waiting at a stop who are visually impaired and who the driver can obviously see are visually impaired-----
Comment on this
Sorry, is this once a driver sees someone is visually impaired?
Comment on this
That the person has an aid or a dog.
Comment on this
-----they have an aid, a guide dog or what have you.