We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Transport and Communications

Sustainable Travel Operations Update: National Transport Authority

Contributions 159–316 of 316. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Okay. That would be most welcome but not everyone has a visual impairment that-----

Comment on this
Gerry Horkan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Is obvious.

Comment on this

-----is obvious.

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

That is true.

Comment on this

Okay. It is good to hear that there is work being done in that area anyway.

Comment on this
Gerry Horkan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Maybe there is some kind of mechanism with a card or one could have something that would indicate to the driver that one has a visual impairment.

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

On the fleet, for all our bus fleet we put a lot of effort into designing the layout that it works for everyone, and particularly for people with disabilities.

There is no use having a spacious wheelchair space if the gangway to it is very restrictive. That gets a lot of attention during the design stage. As soon as the first buses get built of each model, we arrange a consultation through the IWA with wheelchair users. If there is feedback from that suggesting modifications are required, we address it. We put a lot of effort into optimising it.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We run a "Please Don't Buggy in the Wheelchair Zone" campaign to encourage those who use the wheelchair space for buggies to move to an available buggy space, where there is one, if a wheelchair user wants to access the wheelchair space. There can be challenges if the bus is full but the priority is that the space be available for wheelchair users.

Comment on this

Will the witnesses provide an update on the status of the 2019 order for 41 rail carriages, which were designed to increase capacity by up to 10% on the northern commuter line? In addition, we are in public consultation on the plans there. There is massive population growth along the northern commuter line in my and Deputy Farrell's constituency and right up to Louth. Huge political pressure is being applied regarding the rail line between Howth Junction and Howth, which could become a shuttle service in order to allow the northern commuter line to meet the demand that is there and will grow in years to come. Given the massive population growth along the coast up the northern line, is it clear we will need a shuttle service of some kind on the spur out to Howth? If we do not and we continue a full schedule out to Howth - and this is the key bit - will that impact the ability of the northern commuter line to meet demand in the coming years?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

There are lots of parts to that question. The short answer is not yet, but at some point in the future it will prove very difficult to run a direct service to Howth at regular frequency because of the overall needs of the northern line. The line can handle 12 to 16 train paths per hour. At some point, that will get used up and at that stage, we think the right thing to do will be to run a shuttle service from Howth Junction to Howth. Part of the DART+ railway order is to revamp the Howth Junction station to make that easier. It is important to say, because I know there is a lot of concern out there, that in the early days we do not need to make that change but we are setting up the project because in the future it will be required and it will be done at that stage.

The positive for people in Howth would be that currently they have a 20-minute DART service and when the change is made there can be much higher frequency from Howth to Howth Junction, every ten minutes or even more frequently. If we get the station reconfigured well to make the interchange easier, overall journeys, if you count walking and waiting time, should get shorter. They can leave when they want to and get to where they want to. As of now, we do not need to make those changes but we are future-proofing, as you should do when planning something.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Of the 41 ICRs, there are currently 17 in service, which is behind Irish Rail's original roll-out plan. There has been a delay of about three weeks but the roll-out has now been ramped up to about three sets per week. I believe some are being used as part of the timetable change in August.

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

That is right. A lot of those will be used for the timetable change in August and then in October, when the additional Dublin-Belfast service comes on stream and that goes to an hourly service.

Comment on this

When will all 41 be delivered?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

They are all in place. They are delivered.

Comment on this

I will revisit the delay in the roll-out of the new fare structure. What are the practical implications of that? Does it only apply to rail services? Is the issue unique to Irish Rail? Is the phased roll-out still on course for other areas, such as bus services in Navan and elsewhere in County Meath?

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

We would like to introduce them at the same time because multimodal tickets will be introduced on the same date to be used on bus and rail. It would be difficult to separate them, unfortunately. The bus element will be delayed by the rail element.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We did phase 1 introduction earlier this summer but that was mostly to do with town and city services change to the town fares.

Comment on this

My colleague, Deputy Patricia Ryan, and others asked me to raise the issue with Newbridge and Kildare but it affects my county equally. I have raised repeatedly the anomaly of Laytown, Gormanston and Drogheda versus Balbriggan. I have a student in Leinster House today from Stamullen who should be getting the train from Gormanston but when asked from where did he get the train, he of course replied from Balbriggan, because that is where people go in that area or else they stay in the car.

This has been raised for a long time. When the NTA was before the committee previously, we asked these questions and got the answer that there is a review. We welcomed that review but it took an extended period. At the start of the year, we had announcements. What does it say about the NTA's preparation for the roll-out of the strategy that we are in the position we are in? In January, a phased roll-out was announced but in July, the NTA is saying it will not happen in September and will be delayed. Effectively, the delay is in the region of 100%.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We are not happy to be making that announcement. The delay is not in our interest or that of customers. However, we are not the client for a number of contracts that deliver the fare structures across our operations so we rely on our operators and their contractors to deliver our fare structure. This will be different with next-generation ticketing, where we take much more direct control of ticketing equipment and fares as a result of the issues that have arisen with delivery.

Comment on this

Spell out exactly what has gone wrong to cause this delay. Ms Graham stated it relates to IT and back-office technology.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

The fare structure is completely restructured. Mr. Ryan will provide more detail.

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

The delay is to do with the back office, as Ms Graham said, as well as the need to reconfigure the gating equipment to enable the new fare structure. In relation to timelines, when we announced quarter 3, that was the indication we got from the operator, so that was doable. When the operator engaged in more detail with its contractor, the contractor informed it that it was not able to meet the timescale expected by Irish Rail.

Comment on this

What did the NTA initially engage with Irish Rail on this?

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

In 2023.

Comment on this

The review has been ongoing for how long?

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

The announcement of the fares was earlier this year.

Comment on this

My point concerns whether the NTA engaged earlier with Irish Rail on the practical implications of it.

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

We spoke to Irish Rail before we put those dates in our plan.

Comment on this

My question is whether the NTA should have spoken to Irish Rail earlier on the practical implications of it. It is not much good standing on a podium announcing fare reductions and a scheduled timeframe if it is now clear it was undeliverable.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We do not like being in that position. We are usually careful around announcing dates. We find it difficult to give dates for certain things because we are circumspect. However, based on our experience up to then, we were able to deliver dates around changes to fares and infrastructure. This is a significant change because it changes boundaries. It is more significant than what we have done up to now. We probably should not have indicated a date until we were more clear about what the works involved.

It is unfortunate it has happened. We do not like to be in a position where we are saying it is delayed, but we will work with the contractor and Irish Rail to try to bring that timeline down to a more reasonable one.

Comment on this

Could the NTA have engaged with Irish Rail earlier?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We engage with Irish Rail all the time. We are constantly-----

Comment on this

I mean on this issue.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We are constantly engaged with Irish Rail on every aspect of the delivery of services, including fares infrastructure. It was involved with us when we were examining the fares. It is just unfortunate that its contractor is not currently in a position to be able to deliver in the expected timeframe, but we continue to engage with it------

Comment on this

I suggest the NTA could and should have engaged with Irish Rail earlier. It should have let people know earlier and should have had a clearer timeline for the roll-out of this.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Based on our experience, we believed we were putting together the right estimated timeframe for what would be in place. Irish Rail also put its best estimate on it at the time we made the announcement. It is only as more details emerged from the operator's contractor that unfortunately, we got this timeline.

Comment on this

Tens of thousands of public transport users will say time and again that they are the ones who have to suffer because of this.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Some of the customers------

Comment on this

I have not finished. Mr. Ryan stated the NTA would like to roll them out together. I am sure it would. I am sure the customers who use public transport every day would like to see them rolled out separately, because they will benefit from them. That benefit has now been delayed and will not be delivered in the timeframe that was committed to.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

The Deputy has forgotten that the various changes include some increases in fares as well as reductions-----

Comment on this

I have not forgotten that at all.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

-----and some customers will probably be quite happy that it has been delayed. That is not in anyone's interest either. There is a mixture of increases and reductions in fares and it is quite a significant change. As I have said consistently, we are disappointed that we are not able to deliver it earlier for customers, because they are also our customers. We want to get the best and fairest structure for them. That is why we have been working on this structure for a period to introduce a fairer structure across the country.

Comment on this

It looks like we will be working on it for longer now, given this further delay. It is hugely frustrating for the communities I represent. That is exactly what will be reflected.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

It is also frustrating for us. We are not happy to be announcing a delay. It is frustrating for us and we understand that customers are frustrated.

Comment on this

Let us be clear. The customers have a different role in this regard than do Ms Graham and her organisation. Let us not claim there is some kind of equality or comparison to be made. The NTA has a responsibility for designing and delivering the scheme. The customers do not have that responsibility.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

I never said they had responsibility. We work to improve the infrastructure of public transport for our customers. This delay is not in our or the customers' interest. We are apologetic and frustrated that delay is happening. I cannot say more than to apologise to customers.

Comment on this

The NTA apologises for it.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Of course we do, because it is not what we want to deliver. We wanted to deliver it in the timeframe we had indicated, but we are not in control of all the systems in place across the system.

Comment on this

On the point that has been made about delivering it as quickly as possible, I urge the NTA to do everything it can - quarter 1 runs to the end of March - and bring March delivery back to January, or bring January back to December, November or October.

A point was made earlier about school transport services and the opportunity for scheduled services to complement or substitute for them. I raise the case of Stamullen in east Meath again, which I raised with the Minister, Deputy Ryan, a few weeks ago. Some students there have been left behind because of the strict eligibility criteria for the school transport service. There is a scheduled service in the area, but they do not marry up as well as they might. Will there be an opportunity to look at that again for September 2024? Will the NTA look at it?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

The Deputy probably raised that with us before and we probably responded that it can sometimes be difficult to serve a school when there are other demands on a service. However, we will look at that particular service again.

Comment on this

I welcome the NTA to the transport committee. I concur with Deputy Duncan Smith's comment that the NTA is always willing to engage and that is appreciated by all members of the committee.

I saw the Environmental Protection Agency, EPA, report this week, which is positive about emissions reductions. We are here to discuss sustainability in transport. We have seen good work being done in agriculture and results being achieved. We know farmers want to and will do more and will get better results. We have seen a significant reduction in emissions from energy and we will also do a lot more in that space with further offshore development that is awaiting planning permission at the moment.

Transport is still a challenge. Its emissions rose slightly, but there is some comfort in the fact that we are slowing down the rise. We have not halted it and we need to go in the opposite direction. Everything we do to make public transport easier, more frequent, secure, affordable and attractive across the board, whether that applies to cycling, walking, buses, trains and so forth, is important. I encourage the NTA to continue to do what it is doing and we will do the same. I do not want the NTA to comment on Government policy. The programme for Government sets out a commitment for a 2:1 ratio of spend on public transport to new roads. Will the NTA comment on that principle? Transport projects are quite long and surety and financial certainty are needed to plan, design and build them. How important is it going forward that the 2:1 spend is retained for public transport to give the NTA and transport companies confidence that they will get the investment that is needed?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We will not comment on the split in the spend. All we can comment on is that we need surety of commitment to financing the sustainable transport aspect of the national development plan, because as we are building and planning for those systems - especially for such large infrastructure as MetroLink - we need to see commitment to those projects continue through national development plans to ensure, for the construction and design communities, the people who will build these systems, that the Government remains committed to investment in the infrastructure. That builds confidence for delivery in the industry and allows - as the Deputy will be aware, we have multiple projects of different sizes - the construction industry to have a supply of a range of projects, including smaller active travel projects up to the largest projects, such as MetroLink.

Comment on this

It is absolutely critical for the reasons Ms Graham outlined. I urge any future Government to adopt that type of policy. The transport budget will always be there, but knowing what the ratio of the spend will be gives confidence.

We spoke about driver recruitment earlier. How does train driver recruitment stand at the moment? I engaged with the NTA about improving the weekend service to Greystones. It is every half hour Monday to Friday, but it is an hourly service at the weekend at the moment. I would like to see that improved. We are waiting for train drivers and I expect to see an improvement in the service. Will the NTA tell me about the progress on rail recruitment?

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

Unfortunately, that still has not been possible because Irish Rail is making up for the Covid-19 pandemic. This year, its driving school trained drivers to replace those who have retired. It did not manage to recruit or train drivers during the Covid-19 pandemic. That additional service to Greystones at the weekends has not been possible. We anticipate that it will be possible in 2025, subject to funding.

Comment on this

In the first year, we saw active travel budgets.

In the second year, we saw the recruitment of staff by local authorities to design and implement those projects. It did not really bed in until the third year of this Government, when everything started to work well together. What is the process when a local authority district engineer and members identify potential active travel projects within their districts? They then feed that into the active travel teams within the local authorities. It then goes up to the NTA to decide which projects should be prioritised and which are deliverable.

There are small projects within areas, however. I reference in particular those relating to the tightening of the radius on some roads, where the radius is quite wide and encourages cars to sweep around at quite some speed. In every town and village in Ireland, there are areas where the radius of the curve could be tightened. This does not prevent cars going through. It does not stop cars at all; rather, it slows down cars as they approach a junction and makes it safer for people cycling and walking, and for all road users. Those projects tend to be small. My concern is that because there are many small projects like that, they do not make it through the filter system. I do not know how local authority district engineers can then do that tightening of the radius of curves out of the budgets they have. Can they approach with, say, ten or 15 projects and bundle those together?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

The short answer is "Yes". To elaborate on that a little further, a couple of years ago we were in the position where we had more funding available than projects that were ready. As the Deputy knows, it has now changed. We now find we are unable to fund all the requests local authorities have, which is a good sign. That is a good place to be by comparison with the alternative. We are also conscious that we want to build up the cycling networks in particular. We have a lot of disparate pieces of cycling infrastructure. Until a network is put together, it does not become usable to people. The number one priority for us in respect of local authorities is to fill in the gaps to try to get a clearer network. At this stage, we have developed a plan for each local authority for what the core network will be. That is not to say there are not measures such as pedestrian crossings, junction tightening and so on, which the Deputy mentioned, that we also want to do. There will be limits to what we can accommodate, however, if we want to achieve that overall network ambition.

We are not against small projects at all. We have many small projects around the place. Sometimes, it is easier and looks more coherent and thought through if a bundle is put together. We are happy to consider that in particular cases. As I said, it is a challenge because that local authority will probably have twice as many projects that it wants us to fund than we have funding for. It becomes a discussion with the local authority in trying to prioritise what makes sense out of the package.

Comment on this

Is each individual project assigned its own code? Could a district engineer come along and say, "I have a bundle of ten radius-tightening projects", and then submit that up through the chain?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

Yes. We have loads of bundles. I am not sure whether too many concern junction tightening. It is the same with footpath schemes. In many cases, local authority engineers have bundled up together five, six, seven or ten particular pieces of footpath renewal projects. We are happy to take that as a singular project, which is then funded with singular paperwork running for that. The same can occur for junction-tightening schemes.

Comment on this

That is important because it is often small interventions that can make the link between two bigger ones. On the 23 km zone, how did the NTA arrive at 23 km? I appreciate a line will always have to be drawn and there will always be people outside it-----

Comment on this
Gerry Horkan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

The Deputy only has a minute and a half, not an hour and a half.

Comment on this

How did the NTA come to 23 km, when the other zone is 50 km?

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

It is a very good question. The answer relates to how far Maynooth goes out on the rail network. We wanted to capture Maynooth and Hazelhatch on the Kildare suburban line. That largely dictated how far out we would go. I remind people that the Dublin Bus network extends beyond 23 km. That is, exceptionally, also within that city zone.

Comment on this

I had not intended to ask this question but Mr. Ryan has set it up very nicely for me. Maynooth was the north star. The Maynooth service commences at Pearse Station. The service is from Pearse Station, or possibly Grand Canal Dock, to Maynooth. Pearse to Greystones and Pearse to Maynooth is the exact same number of kilometres, yet Pearse to Maynooth passengers can avail of the cheaper fares while Pearse to Greystones passengers cannot. Greystones is the only DART station on the line that does not avail of that service. That is unfair. I made a very good case to Mr. Ryan previously. I know he responded to me on it, but he raised the matter of Maynooth so I just want to-----

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

I will go back to the answer I gave at that time, which is that we had to pick a centre for the circle somewhere. The centre was O'Connell Bridge, which meant Greystones was outside that circle. I remind everyone that is where the DART ends now. In future, the DART will end in Drogheda. Looking ahead, we could not possibly use the extent of the DART network as the basis of the fares.

Comment on this

The other end of that DART line will end in Wicklow town.

Comment on this
Gerry Horkan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

A work in progress.

Comment on this

I thank Senator Dooley who has given me his time. In its statement, the NTA referenced its responsibility "for the provision of an integrated, accessible public transport system." I always say that affordability has to come into that. Public transport should be integrated, affordable and accessible. I will come back to the integrated piece. The issue of affordability has been raised. I will not say the statement regarding the delay in implementation of the fairer fares strategy was an announcement because, to be fair, it was not an announcement but something we learned of rather casually, which is extremely regrettable. I live in Newbridge, which is in the constituency most impacted, and use the train quite regularly. In fact, I used it this morning. It was a bombshell that was dropped yesterday, when this news spread on social media. There were a number of phone calls, emails, etc., looking for clarity on it from public representatives, who were integrally involved in trying to deliver this. I am sure the NTA will acknowledge all the many meetings we had.

Technical issues that have arisen were referred to. Why were these not factored into the NTA's original timeframes?

Comment on this
Gerry Horkan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I need to step out for a minute. Can we get members' agreement for Deputy Matthews to take the Chair for a few minutes? Agreed.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

As I explained to Deputy O'Rourke, engagement had taken place with Irish Rail, which had engaged with its contractor at that time. That was the timeframe that was considered reasonable at the time. We were happy to then put that in the announcement we made at the time of the fares determination. Since then, there have been further engagements with Irish Rail and its contractor. They have informed us that they are not in a position to meet the timeline we had set out and publicised. Unfortunately, we were in a position where we had to give the timeline that has now been given to us, which is quarter 1 of next year.

That is not a situation we want to be in. We did not introduce the information casually yesterday. It was in response to a parliamentary question. We are obliged, if we are asked a parliamentary question, to respond with the most up-to-date information we have. We could have chosen not to respond to the request for information yesterday so that it would not feature in the discussion we had today, but that is not a position we normally take. We are happy to be here to explain the situation to Deputies. We are not happy to be in this position, but we are happy to give as much information as we currently have regarding the unfortunate timeline that has now been introduced.

Comment on this

It would have been very bad practice not to respond in an open and honest way regarding this. Where is the internal accountability within the NTA to deliver on targets and implement change? Surely, it has to be somewhere.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We are an authority that makes the decisions on fares based on the funding available to us. We are responsible for the structure of those fares but we do not have the contracts in place for the ticketing equipment used and managed directly by the operators, which has been the case for many years. We put a structure on top of that.

The Leap card integrates the fares system but we do not own the ticketing equipment that the operators use. We are changing that as part of next-generation ticketing in that we will own the ticketing equipment on the bus and will have a much more centralised structure so that we can be held to account much more closely in terms of the delivery of that infrastructure and anything associated with that. When we are at a remove and the only mechanism we have is to encourage our operators to get their contractors to deliver on our behalf, that is not the easiest position to be in when delivering on behalf of the State.

Comment on this

The roll-out of the fairer fares strategy, which is a key element of Government strategy to encourage more people to use public transport, is essentially being stalled. That was a very poor justification for it in my view. Ms Graham mentioned the budget. Was a specific budget allocated to the NTA under budget 2024 to cover the cost of implementing the fairer fares strategy in quarter 3 of this year?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

If there was any infrastructure, and there is new infrastructure that must be put in place, that has been covered by the budget. It is not a budgetary issue. It is a resource availability issue with the contractor so that it is in a position to prioritise this work as part of its overall work.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Graham for her response. The planned fares would result in a fare drop of 48% in Newbridge and 35% in Kildare town. If it is not a budgetary issue, what cost reduction can be offered to the commuters I represent who are being failed by the implementation of this plan? I put it to Ms Graham that from 1 September, an equivalent fare reduction should be put in place in those areas that would have been positively affected by this implementation?

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

We would have to increase fares elsewhere. Bear in mind that this is a revenue-neutral strategy for the Dublin commuter area. The other complication is that many of the fare reductions are dependent on Leap. We come back again to the ticketing equipment and the systems that Irish Rail and Luas contractors need to upgrade and reconfigure. It would not really be possible because the scheme depends on Leap and Leap depends on the ticketing system contractors to reconfigure it in order to implement the changes.

Comment on this

I hear what Mr. Ryan is saying but I genuinely do not accept it. There must be a better way to support the cost of commuting for commuters. We all know that very many commuters bypass the stations in Newbridge and Kildare to go to Sallins where there is a much cheaper fare. The car parks there are beyond capacity so we need this to be put in place.

My next question goes back to integrated public transport. Many people live quite a distance from the stations in Newbridge and Kildare. I am very fortunate to live beside the train station so I find it quite easy to get there but there are many people living in the town who live 3 km away from the train station. There was an expectation that a town bus would be rolled out in both Kildare and Newbridge to enable people to get the train stations so they would not need to have a second car. What progress has been made on this?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

I am not sure where that expectation came from because we have indicated to the committee and publicly our programme of town services, which is based on towns with no service. We have a programme we need to deliver. It starts with Portlaoise, Mullingar, Ennis and Letterkenny and we have to work through those service deliveries, subject to the funding and resources being available, before we are in a position to move to any other towns. We never gave any commitment as regards delivery of a town service. Some planning work may have been commenced with the local authority but, at this stage, we could not give any commitments to a town service for Newbridge or Kildare.

Comment on this

I understand that planning work has taken place but I take it that this is a budgetary issue and that if significant budgetary provision were made for this service, it could be put in place.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

A number of towns are ahead of all other towns. We are delighted to be in a position where there is demand for services across the country but we have always wanted to deliver a town service for towns with a population of 10,000 or more. We have a list of those we need to get through before we can consider any others for delivery.

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

The towns on which we are working have populations of more than 20,000. If funding is available, and depending on the order of priority, we would be looking at towns with a population of more than 10,000 at that point.

Comment on this

Newbridge has a population of almost 30,000 so it certainly fits the criteria.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

It is served by commuter services. We are talking about towns that are of a size such that they need a town service of their own. We are not saying that Newbridge or Kildare do not need such a service but in terms of our priorities, the other towns I mentioned are the ones that have been identified at this stage. We will work towards delivering, and considering for delivery in the future, any other town services because there are demands across the country for these services but we can only operate, plan for and have the resources to be able to plan for a number of services at any particular time.

Comment on this

I agree with the comments about Irish Rural Link. It is an excellent service that provides a lifeline for many. Could I get an update on the No. 888 service from Athy to Monasterevin to Rathangan and on to Allenwood? I understand it has gone to tender. We are very anxious to see it delivered as soon as possible. Could I get an update on the roll-out of the No. 821 service, which would include Suncroft, which also needs to keep part of the No. 126 service that links into Kildare town?

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

We will come back to the Senator on some of those. We are waiting to award the tender for the No. 888 service. We just need to get confirmation from the Department and we can then proceed with that award.

Comment on this

My next question concerns the fare capping for Dublin commuter zones. It is based on 2.5 journeys. How does this work within outer zones, for example, for people from Newbridge who are travelling to Sallins, Naas or Kildare? It seems to be Dublin-centric rather than looking at the wider commuter area.

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

What does the 2.5 relate to?

Comment on this

The 2.5 journeys.

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

There is no fare capping outside Dublin. Within the 90-minute area, or the city zone, as we are now going to call it, we have effectively a flat fare. That really only works in cities. We cannot have a flat fare throughout the country because to have a cap and a flat fare around that cap is just not practical unfortunately.

Comment on this

I thank the Chair for his indulgence. I appreciate it and the work being done on Irish Rural Link in particular. I wish to express the very deep frustration of all the commuters I represent and those in parts of north County Dublin, Meath, Drogheda and Wicklow.

Comment on this

Mr. Ryan mentioned the number of mechanics who had been or are to be hired in the Dublin area. I was not sure whether it was 40 or 14.

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

That was Cork and the number was 40.

Comment on this

Has Mr. Ryan anything to say about Dublin? The reason I am asking is that an issue was raised relating to Broadstone.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

I think there has been a bit of confusion. Was the Deputy referring to mechanics or drivers?

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

I do not think we mentioned a number for mechanics.

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

Sorry, we did. In relation to Dublin-----

Comment on this

It was the Philippines in September. I may have been mixed up.

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

No, sorry. The Deputy is right. It is mechanics in Dublin Bus and the number was 40.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Ryan know how many of those are going to Broadstone, for example? Are they just for Dublin Bus?

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

Yes, they are just for Dublin Bus.

Comment on this

The figure does not include Bus Éireann in Dublin.

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

No.

Comment on this

Broadstone would not be covered.

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

The Phibsboro depot which is beside Broadstone, the Dublin Bus depot, would be covered by that.

Comment on this

I ask Mr. Ryan get some clarification on that. I am particularly interested because the Meath bus services are largely covered by the Broadstone depot and we know that part of the challenge with those relates to mechanics in Broadstone. If they are not covered, I would make the case that Bus Éireann should be doing something similar to try to address the shortage.

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

Bus Éireann is indeed doing something similar. It is also trying to bring in contractors to help it out with the shortage at the moment.

Comment on this

I received a written response on the rail service from Navan. The tender for contractors will issue towards the end of the year. Is that the case?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

It is not for contractors; it is for the design team.

Comment on this

Yes, it is for consultants who will be contracted to-----

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

The Deputy is ahead of himself. Tender requests have gone out to a number of consultants to offer their services. Someone will be appointed in September. That is the target.

Comment on this

Members have been saying very positive things about Connecting Ireland, and I echo those. My understanding is that this is a €56 million multi-annual programme and the NTA is working its way through it. I have always been critical that there has been funding of €8 million followed by €8 million, rather than €15 million or €20 million followed by €20 million. What is the timeframe for the full roll-out of the initial Connecting Plan now? Are there plans to go beyond that? Is the NTA in the early stages of looking beyond it to Connecting Ireland 2.0 or something similar?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We had originally planned that it would take about five years to roll out but that was dependent on getting a consistent level of funding. We commenced Connecting Ireland just at the end of Covid, which also had its challenges. Initially, we would have liked to have delivered in a five-year programme. Based on our current run rate, it is probably going to take about six years to roll out the ambition we set out in Connecting Ireland. I do not think it will ever meet all the demands we will see in rural Ireland so there will be a need for a Connecting Ireland part 2.

Comment on this

The NTA has not-----

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We have not commenced that, no. Our focus is on delivering the ambition in the Connecting Ireland programme as well as doing a lot of advancements around the place. It is not that we constrain ourselves to exactly what is in the plan. We may discover links that we were not even aware of and we will try to include those in our Connecting Ireland programme. We are delighted with how it has gone. We would like to deliver it a lot quicker, of course. We are ambitious for Connecting Ireland and for additional service in rural Ireland but it is subject to funding.

Comment on this

I will finish on that point. I have only ever been complimentary about Connecting Ireland. It is transformative.

Comment on this
Steven Matthews An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Green Party

To continue on that point before I bring in Deputy O'Connor, I fully concur with Deputy O'Rourke. People in villages and towns tell me they never had a bus before and now they do. In terms of meeting demand, there is also induced demand there as well. As people become more aware, they find there is a bus service in place and it works. The NTA may look at static demand first but then there is induced demand too. Is the NTA able to factor that into the Connecting Ireland 2.0-type longer term planning?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We factored it into phase 1 because we always believed, and knew, that there would be demand that would develop over time. That is why when we put in the services we usually leave them for a year or 18 months before making changes because that is when we really truly see how people are responding. We build in as much of what we think is induced demand but we would probably say we have been surprised at the level of response and how quickly the response has occurred. We would be delighted to do more of that right across Ireland.

Comment on this
Steven Matthews An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Green Party

I think we all would. I will bring in Deputy O'Connor next.

Comment on this

It is always good to see NTA representatives at the committee. I thank them for being here. There are a couple of issues that are very important to me. Patrick Mulcahy, who works in my office and is now a councillor, and I have held a lot of meetings and, to be fair, they have been fruitful in trying to deliver additional capacity in certain areas. Ms Graham will know the route 260 service has been a very big issue in east Cork. It is very important to Youghal and to some of the rural villages along the N25. Youghal is looking for further morning services. People are using the bus service because it is an affordable way to get to work. It is well used. Youghal is within a 45-minute commute of Cork city when traffic is favourable. We are seeking further assistance around the morning services. I acknowledge the NTA has provided an additional double-decker service but we want to see what more can be done. I am talking about the morning services at 7 a.m., 7.10 a.m. and 7.20 a.m. which terminate in Midleton and the 8.10 a.m. and 10 a.m. services from Youghal. All those services need additional capacity. My constituency office in the town, which is a short walk up from the bus stop, gets many calls from people complaining about not being able to access services at appropriate times in the morning. There is demand on that route. Can the NTA help me and my office to deliver for our constituency and the town of Youghal with extra services?

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

We will go back to Bus Éireann to check on those numbers. I am aware of those particular times, for which the Deputy has reported capacity issues. If there are capacity issues, we will do what we can to provide additional services to deal with that demand.

Comment on this

I appreciate that. There is an issue of a PSO service and also the commercial route 40 service provided by Expressway. The more the merrier is my view of the matter.

I wish to raise something that is important to me. Looking at east Cork commuters, whether they live in Youghal, Midleton or any of the dozens rural villages in my constituency - I will not name them all - much of that traffic goes from east Cork under the Jack Lynch tunnel and on down to Mahon and Ringaskiddy where Pfizer and various pharmaceutical companies are located. Employees of these companies and of Cork University Hospital and Munster Technological University travel through the Jack Lynch tunnel from east Cork to their destinations without going into Cork city centre. It might be to Douglas where there are lots of industrial parks. Will the NTA do a demand analysis on providing increased bus services for people living in Midleton, Youghal, Carrigtwohill, Glantane and other places to see if we can do a proper job and provide bus services through the Jack Lynch tunnel connecting to Mahon, Ringaskiddy, Douglas and other employment hubs in that area? There are huge numbers travelling to and from those places daily. The pressure point is the famous Dunkettle interchange. That is where the biggest issue has been. Could the NTA look at trying to deliver that?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

I will check with Mr. Creegan whether that was done as part of the Cork metropolitan area transport strategy, CMATS. It is something we would have to look at. Obviously, as the Deputy knows, we cannot deliver bus services from every place to every place, as it were. Often we look at centres so we bring people to centres. It may be the case that this could be done as a park and ride with additional services. It is something we can look at because we do want to serve commuters, whether by rail or bus. Another option is an integrated rail and bus service, certainly for Midleton. We can look at that in more detail.

Comment on this

That would be very welcome. This would take tens of thousands of cars off the road. The journeys are very significant.

If we look at the traffic numbers in Dunkettle or on the southbound or northbound lanes in the Jack Lynch tunnel in the evening and morning, we will very quickly see precisely what I am getting at. I appreciate the point about designing the demand around centres but Cork bucks the trend. Historically, the population of the urban core of Cork decreased, but it rose significantly in the commuter towns around the city, such as Midleton and Carrigtwohill, which was the fastest growing village, now town, in Ireland. New towns are planned in Water-rock and major housing developments are going on there. That route is getting busier and busier and the traffic is getting worse and worse but nothing is servicing that connection under the tunnel from east Cork, even though a huge proportion of that commuter traffic is using it.

If I might be critical of one thing, I acknowledge it is hard to serve everybody but Bus Éireann held an information night in the Metropole on Tuesday night and, as part of that, representation from my office attended. None of the presentation related to Cork county. It was all focused on the city. I am anxious to get cars off the road where it is possible and where we can put in a proactive service that people will use. As I said earlier, the witnesses are all an example of this. If a bus service is put on in the morning, people will use it and it will be full. We want to try to get that addressed.

We need to see a better Local Link service as well. The villages I am thinking of in particular are Lady's Bridge, Ballymacoda and Cloyne, which have very limited bus services. Lady's Bridge village has one bus that leaves at 10.15 a.m. but there is no return bus unless you come back on the 260 coming into Castlemartyr. I would appreciate if those villages could be looked at in the context of Local Link service. The report I have is good. When the services are introduced in east Cork, we use them. They are a little pricey but we use them. We do need to get the additional capacity in Youghal.

My other ask is that we would please look at putting in a proper service that will connect Ringaskiddy, with all its pharmaceutical plants and the Port of Cork, to Mahon and the Carrigtwohill, Midleton and Youghal urban core. If we do that, we will remove thousands of car journeys from those roads every day. If a morning and evening service leaves early enough, that will help a lot of the people who work shifts in pharmaceuticals. Cork has one of the largest pharmaceutical hubs not only in Ireland but in the world and there is huge demand. Tens of thousands of people work in pharmaceuticals in Cork alone, between that Little Island down to the Ringaskiddy belt, but bus services are just non-existent going out of the tunnel. The consequences of that are congestion, increased numbers of cars and having to spend €260 million on the Dunkettle interchange. I think the public would appreciate an option in that regard. Younger people, in particular, who are moving into the new houses we are building in east Cork, where thousands of new homes are being built, would like to be able to live without the expense of a car. A car is a necessity in Cork, however, because if you are travelling to Ringaskiddy or to the tech employers in the south ring road, there is no proper bus connection unless you go into the city and out again, which would add an unnecessary 20 or 30 minutes to your commute. I would appreciate it if the witnesses could look into that.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We can certainly look at that.

Comment on this
Steven Matthews An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Green Party

We have spoken about the Local Link service. Is there potentially any option to have some sort of GPS on a bus such that somebody could use an app to know where the service is? The 183, for example, is a fantastic service but it is on a very long route and can fall behind. Is that something the NTA would look at?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We have a contract now to provide what we are calling next-generation AVL, or the automatic vehicle location system on the bus. We will start with our main bus services, as in those provided by those Dublin Bus, Go-Ahead and Bus Éireann, but we have a module in there of what we are calling AVL light, which can be attached to the ticketing system on the Local Link bus services. That will give a signal and enable us to track where the bus is and to then give real-time information. It is definitely something we want to deliver. We have it included within that contract that we can deliver it, but it will just take some time and will be later in that contract delivery.

Comment on this
Steven Matthews An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Green Party

That is positive. We spoke briefly earlier about circulating buses in towns. Two buses have been proposed under BusConnects, namely, route L14 for Bray and L2 and L3 for Greystones, although those numbers might be incorrect. Is there a commencement date for any of those services?

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

The commencement date will be in either September or November and we are still in discussions with Dublin Bus and Go-Ahead because we need to speak to both of them about what that date might be. We are hoping it will be September and that we can go early with those ones for Bray, in particular, and Greystones for phase 6A, with the spine element of phase 6A turning up later, but we are not yet 100% sure whether we can do that. We are still in discussions with Go-Ahead on that.

Comment on this
Steven Matthews An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Green Party

I think we have had about five or six Local Link services into Wicklow over recent years, which is very positive, but there is one missing link, which relates to Laragh and Annamoe, through Roundwood, into Bray train station. A private operator operates on that route. It is a well-established service that has served people well, but a Local Link service would suit that commuting type of growth we are seeing in places such as Roundwood. Is this something that is on the NTA's horizon to deliver? I understand the challenges relating to budgets, drivers, fleet availability and so on but is it something the authority is considering for introduction?

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

The difficulty probably relates to the private operator operating in that space as well, which always makes things complicated. I will take this back to the service planning team to examine but I imagine that will be a complication.

Comment on this
Steven Matthews An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Green Party

It would be a complication that there is a private operator there.

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

Yes. We have to be careful not to run the same route.

Comment on this
Steven Matthews An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Green Party

The private operator has been operating there for a long time. It does not, in my view, provide a commuting option. It is very much a St. Stephen's Green to Glendalough-type service, so it was intended more to serve perhaps visitors or tourists. As the witnesses well know, however, Local Link services can provide that link into Bray train station for people working in the city or who need to pick up a rail or bus connection. That private operator service runs only twice a day and I do not think the fares are in any way comparable with what is available on a Local Link service, so I do not think it is right to compare the two. It is a bus service but it is not comparable.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Yes, it is not that it is comparable, but when we introduce PSO services on top of a commercial service, even if it is at a different time, that could have an impact on that commercial service. It is something we need to be mindful of as we plan those services. I am aware the service planning team know about the issues and are looking to see how they can best serve that corridor without undermining the existing commercial service too much.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their engagement. I have previously raised an issue with some bus services in Meath, which I will again put on record. There is a regular call in Ratoath for a more regular direct service into the city - the 105X is the example – and for a direct service via the M3 parkway for people who might want to use the train. I will continue to make the case for those.

In respect of the 103 route, a number of people have been affected by the decision of Bus Éireann to terminate not on the south side of the city in Townsend Street, although it used to go all the way to St. Stephen’s Green, but rather in O'Connell Street. Why did that happen? We hear from Bus Éireann that it was a time-saving measure but I think that needs to be reviewed because a number of people have been affected, especially students and workers.

More broadly, on bus services in Meath, a number of high-frequency public bus services are very well used and people who rely on the services tend to be frustrated with them because they organise their lives around them and are impacted by the issues we have.

That particularly includes the shortage of mechanics at Broadstone. Hopefully that is resolved soon and we can get back to full capacity, because Bus Éireann has outsourced some of its services, so we end up with coaches where double deckers are needed and that has an impact. Eventually, my question on the matter of ensuring punctuality is this. These services are largely on the N2 or old N2 route or the M3 or old N3 route. Are there quality bus corridors? Are they part of BusConnects? You can get caught at Phibsborough or the Halfway House on the N3. Will they be resolved? What is the timeline for those? Are they factored into the Dublin BusConnects programme?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

The answer is "Yes". There is a scheme under BusConnects. One of the 12 corridors we mention is Blanchardstown to the city centre. That commences at Blanchardstown Shopping Centre and provides bus lanes in both directions right into the city centre. We also have planning consent for the Finglas corridor. That would have more or less continuous bus corridors from Finglas village, through Hart's Corner and to the quays. Both of those are part of the BusConnects programme.

Comment on this

Do they both have planning consent? I know Mr. Creegan touched on the headlines of those.

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

The Finglas scheme has planning consent and we will start tendering it for construction later this month. There are no legal challenges against it. The Blanchardstown scheme just received approval about one week ago. After receiving approval, there are two months in which people could challenge it.

Comment on this

For a judicial review or such.

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

We are in that space. We are not sure where in it. It has planning, subject to that legal issue.

Comment on this

How long does Mr. Creegan expect the Finglas works to take?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

Our target is to get contractors on the ground at the beginning of next year. It would be two to three years to build the whole corridor. Bits of it would obviously get done far earlier than that, so it is not a case of waiting until the end for something. It will come incrementally.

Comment on this

I know I have contributed already but there are a few matters I would like to put to the witnesses before they depart. The M20 motorway was perhaps already discussed. It is not clear based on the announcements last week if it will be tolled or untolled. Can the witnesses shed any light on that?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Thankfully, that is not our project. It is a project of Transport Infrastructure Ireland. Anything related to tolling is its responsibility, not ours.

Comment on this

That is grand. The next question is definitely within the NTA's remit. It relates to bus transport. Dublin Airport is in discourse because of the passenger cap, all the constraints it has trying to get people in and out of Ireland, and the cap on flights. There was an announcement yesterday about trying to incentivise airlines to move flights to Cork. We feel disadvantaged in Clare because the public bus services to Cork Airport and Dublin Airport are far superior to those that serve Shannon. The 51 route starts from Cork, stops at Mallow, Ballyhay, Charleville, Limerick, Clarecastle, Ennis, Crusheen, and others. There are about 14 stops on that route and then Shannon Airport. If you are in Cork, the current format is a very unattractive service to Shannon Airport. There is no express. This is very much the stagecoach that stops at every village on the way.

In contrast, the 51X service is a service from Limerick city, stopping in Shannon Airport and then to Galway. The service from Limerick to Shannon and Galway is far superior. We are lacking Cork connectivity. If we are to have a counterbalance in aviation in Ireland, we certainly need an improved bus service. At the moment, the Dublin Airport position of dominance is close to 90% of the market. Aviation is a whole different realm, of course, but certainly the transport links could be improved, and Shannon is the poor relation. It galls me when I see an express service to Dublin Airport parked in Bunratty, which is only 4 km from Shannon Airport. It seems incongruent with where services should be.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Many of the services that serve airports across the country are commercial services that are licensed by the authority. There is probably a view that the subsidised services which serve the airport are not sufficient in Dublin as well as Cork and Shannon. There is a requirement from our side to improve the services to all the airports. Generally, the airport-type traffic from city centres to the airport are provided by commercial services because they can see business in doing that.

Comment on this
Mr. Jeremy Ryan

Commercial services to the airport are generally intercity, longer distance, limited stop or express services. The services that we deal with for airports tend to be city services that stop at many locations along the way to their destination. They are a different creature. We do not tend to subsidise longer-distance express-type services, generally.

Comment on this

My next question relates to multimodal transport. Our rail and bus stations are quite well configured for transport at the moment but there are still certain inadequacies relating to car parking, e-bikes and short-term rental bikes. Much more could be done. For example, when you arrive at Heuston Station in Dublin city, there is not always a fleet of bikes at the nearby station. I came on the 7.40 a.m. train this morning and cycled to the Dáil. I drive from home to Limerick station, take the train and then the bike at the other end. I see many people do that each day. It does not all fall into place seamlessly if there are not bikes. The e-bikes were withdrawn around two years ago. There was some malfunction with the e-device. If it is to be truly multimodal and easy for the passenger or commuter, all the cogs of that have to work. Parking is also lacking at some stations. The new rail and bus station in Limerick is fabulous and things are really improved, but parking has been reduced. I know in the sustainable eyes of the NTA, maybe the car is the enemy to some degree, but if someone is going to make the effort to drive to a station then take the train, that should be encouraged. There should be plenty of car parking there.

I recently met Ms Graham's officials regarding the prospects of an increased bus service to Meelick, my home village in County Clare. That meeting happened with Councillor Rachel Hartigan and me. We want to see some action on that. There will be a report coming back to us in August. To explain our situation, we are a County Clare village about 4 km from Limerick city. All around us are incredible bus services, including the 303 service to Moyross every 15 minutes, the Caherdavin bus service every 20 minutes, and the Westbury service every 30 minutes. We have one bus in and one bus out each day. It is not good enough for a village that is just beside a city. I am raising a localised issue. Ms Graham's officials have looked at it. We have given them maps. I would love if she could, in her leadership role, drive this on a little and maybe give the people of Meelick a favourable response next month. I thank Ms Graham. I sense she is going to announce something. She was smiling there.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We will obviously consider it, taking into account everything that we need to consider as part of delivery as a service. If we said August, we will respond in August.

Comment on this

Ms Graham might write it on her hand going out.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Do not worry. It is on our list.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for all their engagement today.

Comment on this
Steven Matthews An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Green Party

I call Senator Murphy.

Comment on this

I thank the Chair. It is kind of him to give me a few minutes. I say hi to the witnesses. It is my first time to be at a meeting with them. I am not a member of the committee but as an Oireachtas Member, I can be here. It is important to say that we are making real progress on transport throughout the country. I welcome the commitment, work, and ongoing discussions and negotiations the NTA has with Oireachtas Members and communities in general, but as the witnesses all know, we have a long way to go. Being a little parochial, the NTA introduced a good link between Roscommon and Longford, which I am glad to report is being widely used.

Of course it stops in the village of Ballyleague-Lanesborough where the Shannon divides Longford and Roscommon. The service is outstanding. Just off that road there is a village which was developed by Bord na Móna called Cloontuskert. There were 76 houses and there are now about 100. It is less than a kilometre from the village of Ballyleague. It would be lovely, and again we cannot take in every corner of an area and I understand this, to be able to establish a link with a village such as this. Perhaps asking that buses go off the main route to go down there is not on but perhaps we could have a support link to the village. We are dealing with some elderly people and younger families who do not have transport. It would be something to look at if we could have a model for it. Perhaps I will write to the NTA with some ideas I have.

The creation and expansion of Local Link is very important to rural areas. I live in the Strokestown area of Roscommon. It is a well-known town and Scramogue is in its rural area. The Local Link bus there is very important to bring people from A, B, C and D. The problem, and I appreciate it is not easy to solve, is that it is not able to reach some people. Some of these are people with disabilities, elderly people and people with no car transport. The problem is difficult to solve and I wonder whether it is something the NTA looks at and discusses. I know the NTA is well aware of it but I cannot stress enough the importance of Irish Rural Link to people in rural areas. If we want to reduce the amount of time people spend in cars, and we are all doing this from an environmental perspective as the witnesses are aware, we have to have the back-up services such as buses.

Some of the buses providing the service need to be upgraded in terms of carrying people with disabilities. I am involved in social services in my area. Sometimes when elderly people are going out for a day we have to try to accommodate three wheelchairs. There is no proper facility on some of the buses to put the wheelchairs to one side. This means that not everyone can go and this is a pity when everyone is enthusiastic about going on a day out. I understand the cost of the modern buses but we have to introduce them and make sure they are people friendly. I accept there is an enormous cost involved but I would like to see it being improved. There is a company in Dublin that specialises in this. The buses are available but they are quite expensive.

I commend the work of the NTA. We all come to it with a list. I would also like to speak about train services but I will not do so today.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We are very much aware that even with all we propose in the Connecting Ireland programme, we estimate there is a population of almost 750,000 people in Ireland who will not be served by the regular rural services we offer. It would be very inefficient to try to serve them with the type of service we are speaking about. It is challenging to deliver a service to the likes of the village mentioned by Senator Murphy, which is less than 1 km away from the main service. Diverting off the main road will discommode other passengers. Sometimes it is very challenging to get the balance between serving smaller villages that are off the main run.

We have a number of demand-responsive services, which operate through the Local Link offices throughout the country. We have not seen growth in these services. Earlier we spoke about phase 2 of Connecting Ireland and what we do afterwards. Part of the phase 2 delivery will be looking to see how we can improve the demand-responsive side of the service, where there is a more dispersed population that can be served by a bus that will collect from the door. This would serve those with mobility issues, and either bring people to a local town from where they can travel onwards on the regular service or bring them close to the regular service at a good stopping location. This is something for the future development of Connecting Ireland. We are very much aware we are not able to reach everybody through the programme under way at present and that more work has to be done.

Accessibility of these services is very challenging. I am very much aware that it is challenging enough to get the type of accessibility we want for one wheelchair user but removing seats to be able to provide for three wheelchairs is challenging. Ensuring they have the statutory restraints can also be challenging. When these spaces are not being used we want to have as many seats available as possible for those who may not be wheelchair users but might have mobility issues and need to be seated. It is a challenge and one that we will always look at so that at least maybe a type of bus that facilitates multiple wheelchair users is available in a particular locality, not necessarily for every service but which can be provided by an operator when we are aware such a service is needed. It will be a refinement of the services we operate at present.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Graham.

Comment on this
Steven Matthews An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach Green Party

I thank Ms Graham, Mr. Creegan and Mr. Ryan for their attendance today. The investment in transport in recent years creates further difficulties and expectations and puts further strain on the system. For me these are positive problems rather than negative problems. We have all been around long enough to have seen major cutbacks in public transport. We are now going the other way. I pass on our appreciation of the work done by the staff of the NTA as well as all of the public transport service providers day in, day out, at weekends and through night work. I thank the witnesses for their time.

Comment on this