Issues Affecting the Aviation Sector: Discussion (Resumed)
Contributions 1–207 of 409. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
We are dealing with issues affecting the aviation sector. I welcome our witnesses. We are joined by Mr. Eddie Wilson, chief executive officer, of Ryanair. I thank him for coming back before the committee a second time. This is an extremely important issue. We are also joined by Mr. Donal Moriarty, interim chief executive officer, and Mr. Reid Moody, chief strategy and planning officer, of Aer Lingus. I thank them for being with us virtually today.
Before commencing, I wish to explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the Houses as regards reference the witnesses may make to other persons in their evidence. The evidence of witnesses physically present who give evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected pursuant to both the Constitution and the statute by absolute privilege. However, today's witnesses are giving their evidence remotely from a place outside the parliamentary precincts and as such may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as a witness physically present does. Witnesses are again reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or an entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to the identified person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction. Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official, either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.
Members are also reminded that committee meetings should conclude within two hours in any one day. The committee is scheduled to sit twice today for a cumulative time of just under four hours. Therefore, members are asked to rotate in and out of the meeting when they have finished asking their questions. With this in mind, I propose Deputy Joe Carey to act as temporary Chair, as he did previously, for the part of today's meeting where I will be rotating out of the meeting to abide by the two-hour rule. Is that agreed? Agreed.
I call Mr. Wilson to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the Chairman for having me back today. Unfortunately since we here on the last occasion on 7 October nothing has changed regarding aviation policy and the strangulation of this industry. The green list system has been a complete and utter disaster for this economy and despite the promises that we are going to adopt a new system, nothing has happened. We have cut ourselves off from Europe. Before anyone comes back and talks about the traffic light system in terms of what other EU countries are doing, this morning in Germany, France, Sweden, Belgium and Spain, one can travel anywhere within the European Union. There is no restriction on flights whatsoever. A direct consequence of this strangulation of our industry is that the Ryanair bases in Cork and Shannon, which we had flagged explicitly based on this because we had no bookings, have now closed and the question is whether they will reopen next summer. That could have been averted. I find it extraordinary that after coming to this committee on the last occasion we did not get one call from either the Minister, Deputy Eamon Ryan, or the Minister of State, Deputy Naughton. The closure of our bases in Cork and Shannon could have been averted or minimised in some way. We did not even get a telephone call from them.
The aviation task force has been reported on since 7 July, more than four months ago, and nothing has been done about it.
People from Ryanair, Aer Lingus, the airports and the leasing companies put in their good time last June and July to put together a report, and it is inexplicable that this Minister has done nothing about it whatsoever.
The market update that I gave the committee the last time I attended has deteriorated. Airlines across Europe are in a bad place. The two airlines that are represented at the committee today are well capitalised, but what is happening is that there will be smaller fleets within Europe next year. Ireland is bottom of the list at the moment, because we are closed for business. Having lost this summer, for summer 2021, nothing has been done to attract business, on which 140,000 people in aviation and 325,000 people in tourism depend for their jobs.
We are calling on the Minister today to do some very simple things, and we have been doing so for months now. The EU traffic light system must be implemented today. We must stop waiting around. There are already countries that are green and amber, and they should be opened straight away. For example, the Greek Islands, the Canary Islands, Germany, Sweden, and parts of Italy could be open today. We do not know what the delay is. As it stands, Government policy is to say that nobody should fly anywhere in and off this small island economy. A key part of this EU traffic light system is that there should be regionalisation, and unless the Government adopts it, it will be useless. Countries should not be cut off in full, so that one can still fly to some places, for example, the Canary Islands, when one may not fly to Madrid, as it is part of Spain.
The aviation task force must be implemented. Why is it still sitting there and why have the Minister for Transport and the Minister of State, Deputy Naughton, not done anything about it?
We want consultation. There are many things happening at the moment on which none of the airlines and stakeholders are being consulted. When has one ever heard of Ryanair, Aer Lingus and the Dublin Airport Authority, DAA, all saying exactly the same thing?
This industry is in decline, and we lost this summer due to Government policy failures and advice not to travel. I note that this morning that the National Public Health Emergency Team, NPHET, stated that Christmas travel should be suspended. I am sorry, but being worried is not good enough for us. We need data, and there are no data that state that air travel is not safe. It is the safest place where people can congregate, due to a combination of 100% compliance in the wearing of face masks, high efficiency particulate air filters being used, and policies and procedures from the European Centre of Disease Prevention and Control, ECDC, being followed.
We need to get the balance right in this economy, which means that we need to be able to preserve jobs and protect those who are most vulnerable, and we should be able to do this. NPHET got it wrong on care homes, meat factories, face masks, and on travel throughout this summer when it should have been concentrating on increasing capacity and getting a properly functioning track and trace system.
The two points I wish to make to the Minister are as follows. The EU traffic light system must be implemented with regionalisation, and it must be done today. We are closed when all the other economies within Europe are open. Second, the Minister must implement the aviation task force, which has not been done to date. This includes in particular the incentives to get airlines to return to Ireland, especially for summer 2021, including the specific recommendation for the rebate of airport charges for a period of three years, which would apply to all airlines within the industry.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Wilson. Dr. Tony Holohan and NPHET will be appearing before the committee next week, and we will put the points raised by the witness to them. I now call on Mr. Moriarty to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for having the opportunity to speak before it again. Aer Lingus has previously outlined, both in July at the Oireachtas Special Committee on Covid-19 Response and again at our appearance before this committee on 7 October, the catastrophic effects that the Covid-19 pandemic continues to have on the global aviation sector.
The committee is aware of how important aviation is for the Irish economy and its prospects for future recovery. The members all know that the international businesses that headquarter in Ireland, that manufacture in Ireland, that carry out critical research and development in Ireland, and that secure investment from their boards for Ireland do so because Ireland is a connected, progressive, business-friendly country. Connectivity is key. We are an island nation, and that connectivity can never be taken for granted. It is a key element of foreign inward investment and in helping our domestic businesses to grow and develop.
Now is the time to put a framework in place so that all businesses can plan for 2021. Fortunately, there are elements of that framework already in existence. Crucially, we know that air travel is safe. Aer Lingus and other airlines have put in place measures in line with European Union Aviation Safety Agency, EASA, and ECDC guidelines that very effectively mitigate the risk of transmission during travel. Indeed, a recent study by the International Air Transport Association, IATA, indicated that risk of transmission on board an aircraft is as low as one in 27 million. Second, the traffic light system introduced by the European Council recently is an important step towards ensuring greater harmonisation for safer travel across Europe, and I will address that in more detail later. Third, new and more effective means of testing are being used globally, and their introduction into this country can increase the level of safe international travel.
I now turn to the decision of the European Council on the traffic light system. The decision at the European Council on 13 October aims to co-ordinate the approach to free movement in response to the Covid-19 pandemic. The wider aviation sector has been somewhat critical of the ultimate decision that emerged from the European Council. The Council recommended a co-ordinated approach to free movement and set out some guidance for member states, but it falls considerably short of what was originally proposed by the European Commission on 4 September, which was to encourage a restart of travel through effective co-ordination and proportionate, predictable and non-discriminatory measures.
Despite this assessment of the European Council decision, Aer Lingus has constructively shared an implementation approach with the Department of Transport that could support safely increasing international travel. Although it has not yet been published, Aer Lingus understands that the Government approach to implementing the European traffic light system will involve a number of elements. First, persons arriving from green list locations can enter the State without the requirement to restrict movement or undergo testing. Second, people arriving from orange-listed locations should have the option to disapply the requirement to restrict movements if they have negative test result of an appropriate standard done pre-departure. Third, people coming from red-listed countries should have the option to disapply the requirement to restrict movements following a negative test result taken five days after arrival. We understand that that is the Government's proposal, although it has not been published yet.
We would describe the proposed approach as a fairly tentative and moderately positive step forward, but it urgently needs to evolve and move to something quite different. Aer Lingus is actively engaging with the Government and will seek to influence the implementation of an appropriate solution before 8 November 2020, which I understand is the date the Government has in mind.
Aer Lingus notes that the intention is to allow travel from orange-coded countries and areas without a requirement to restrict movements on arrival if a pre-departure test is taken. In our view, it is critical that if pre-departure tests are required for passengers travelling from orange-coded countries, it has to be based on a rapid, affordable antigen testing solution. Only a rapid antigen testing solution will facilitate a meaningful increase in safe international travel. For passengers coming from high-risk or red countries, the European Council decision specifically enables the replacement of quarantine and movement restrictions by the introduction of a testing regime.
Aer Lingus also welcomes the exemption in the European Council decision for passengers with an essential function from the requirement to undertake restricted movement or testing while exercising this essential function, and this includes those in critical occupations, students and persons travelling for imperative family or business reasons. This exemption will allow passengers with an essential function to travel without restriction, be that a test or a movement restriction.
Aer Lingus believes that following the initial implementation of the measures, the fortnightly review process, which we understand the Government intends to apply, should quickly lead to a streamlining of the processes to allow a meaningful increase in safe international travel. This streamlining should look like a limited form of random rapid testing for passengers arriving from higher risk orange-coded countries, and a pre-departure testing for countries classified as red.
Aer Lingus believes that through the adoption of a co-ordinated and multilayered risk mitigation approach the level of safe international travel can be increased. The multiple layers involve pre-travel health declarations; mandatory use of face masks; enhanced cleaning on aircraft and in the airport environment; the use of state-of-the-art air filtration technology on board the aircraft; the use of the e-passenger locator forms, ePLF; the use of the Covid tracker app and its integration with similar apps in other countries; and agreed international travel protocols such as the European traffic light system. It is based on this range of risk mitigation measures, which are already in place, that we believe aviation requires a screening standard of testing, not a diagnostic standard of testing. In summary, Ireland must implement the European Council’s decision in such a way that the traffic light system delivers a meaningful contribution to increasing safe international travel.
I will turn briefly to testing and rapid testing. First, I draw the committee's attention to the International Air Transport Association, IATA, study which indicates that the risk of on-board transmission is one in 27 million. So far in 2020, 1.2 billion passengers have travelled by air and IATA says there are only 44 cases of Covid-19 being transmitted on board an aircraft in that period of time. Second, the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control, ECDC, notes that in the current epidemiological situation it does not recommend that passengers should be systematically tested when crossing internal or external administrative borders. I also point to the recent data released by the Health Protection Surveillance Centre, HPSC, on 21 October, which highlighted that four cases were reported in the previous 14 days that were travel related. There were 80,000 passengers in that period of time, which represents 0.05% of cases in that period. The evidence, therefore, is that international travel is simply not a vector of transmission for Covid-19. Interestingly, the HPSC report published on 21 October has not been published since. We believe the continued publication of the report would be a helpful statistic and it should continue. I do not understand why it has been discontinued.
All this highlights the effectiveness of the measures introduced by the-----
Comment on this
Excuse me, Mr. Moriarty. Do you have much more of your presentation to make in terms of the time?
Comment on this
All that I have said highlights the effectiveness of the measures introduced by the European Aviation Safety Agency, EASA, and the ECDC.
I will turn now to some specifics on antigen testing and why we believe it is the route forward. Italy has recently introduced a testing requirement for arrivals from high-risk or red-coded countries that includes antigen testing as an appropriate standard. On 18 October last, the French minister for transport announced plans to introduce rapid antigen testing at airports on departure to countries such as the US and on arrival from red-zone countries. On 13 October, Germany's Robert Koch Institute, RKI, recommended antigen testing to complement existing molecular PCR tests. Several European airports, including Milan, Rome, Frankfurt, Heathrow and Paris, are in the process of equipping themselves for antigen testing in the future. Alitalia is already using it and Lufthansa has announced plans to do so. Similarly, Austrian Airlines has recently announced a trial programme for antigen testing. It is clear that antigen testing, at a screening standard, is becoming prevalent, and the solution in terms of facilitating international travel.
I will briefly mention regional operations, in Cork and Shannon airports in particular. Aer Lingus has published its 2021 summer schedule, and there are extensive operations planned from both Cork and Shannon airports. However, the easing of international travel restrictions is assumed in the publication of that summer schedule for 2021. Urgent progress along the lines I have just outlined must be made in the appropriate introduction of a traffic light system and testing regime. We have highlighted these issues repeatedly to this committee and to the Special Committee on Covid-19 Response since July. We have referred to the recommendations of the aviation recovery task force, published on 7 July, which have not been implemented. In our view, all these changes must be implemented now.
I will conclude by referring to the Government's resilience and recovery plan. It says that there is a need to keep airports and travel routes open and that Ireland depends on airports for supply chains and economic activity. It says there is a need for travel for essential reasons, and that significant employment and other direct economic impacts result from aviation. It also states that aviation’s strategic importance underpins tourism and business generally, and that rebuilding the national economy has a critical dependence on aviation. That is what the resilience and recovery plan says, but we do not have any evidence of policy decisions and actions being taken in pursuit of that plan.
Our economy needs certainty about connectivity. This must be prioritised urgently for 2021. Businesses and the economy in general are critically dependent on it. I thank the committee for the opportunity to make these remarks.
Comment on this
Thank you, Mr. Moriarty. You are probably aware that representatives of Aeroporti di Roma will be appearing before the committee this afternoon to discuss rapid testing at the airports. That should shed some light on the matter.
I now move to questions from the members. Deputy Darren O'Rourke has seven minutes and he must abide by that.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. I will start with a question for both Ryanair and Aer Lingus. Since we last met there has been some progress on the traffic light system and some commitment regarding pre-departure testing, but not much movement. However, there has been significant backward movement in the spread of Covid-19 across the Continent. In a best case scenario and if everything Mr. Wilson and Mr. Moriarty prescribed this morning happened tomorrow, what will the aviation landscape resemble in the next six and 12 months in Ireland and across Europe, and further if they wish, and what are the implications for their operations in terms of staff and commitment to the sector in Ireland?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. There are two distinct phases in this. One must have a basis for travelling, and in Ireland we do not have that at present. The Deputy is correct that the situation has got progressively worse in Europe. However, at least most of those countries are well positioned for when confidence may return. We have not even got to the starting blocks in Ireland because we are prevaricating all the time as to what we are going to do. We must not forget that official Government policy for the citizens of this nation, since March, has been not to fly. What it has done is put an anchor around the neck of airlines in and out of this country and this has resulted, unfortunately, in Cork and Shannon closing as Ryanair bases. If there is going to be an upturn here, the real work starts in convincing people to travel. It will be easier to convince people to travel on short haul rather than on long haul. However, when that comes about, we will have to start that hard work, but there will be fewer aircraft and less capacity.
Comment on this
Let me finish. This country is saying that we are not open for business, so it is not even going to be considered. We have-----
Comment on this
My question relates to the best-case scenario.
Comment on this
The best-case scenario is to give us a fighting chance to come back and start selling tickets again, but one cannot sell tickets if the organs of this State say people should not be flying.
Comment on this
Has Mr. Wilson a sense of pent-up demand?
Comment on this
Whether it is visiting friends and relatives, business or tourism and hospitality, there is obviously restricted opportunity to do anything if one is travelling abroad or coming to Ireland.
Is there any sense of a pent-up demand and, if so, where is it relative to other years?
Comment on this
There is. We can see this in other countries. During the week, for example, the UK lifted its restrictions on the Canary Islands, Crete and Denmark, and bookings went up tenfold overnight. People want to do the right thing and we have scared the life out of people to comply with stuff on an unscientific basis when it comes to air travel. I believe if that were to change, then people will travel. The difficulty for Ireland is that we are currently at the bottom of the queue because other countries are already encouraging airlines like Ryanair to put capacity in place for next summer, and we are still faffing around here.
Comment on this
Okay. I put the same question to Mr. Moriarty about a best-case scenario and the opportunities for 2021.
Comment on this
It is entirely premature to talk about best-case scenarios. We need to get to the first step, which is the implementation of the traffic light system in an appropriate way that facilitates international travel. I agree with Mr. Wilson's comments. The willingness of people to travel will be there but the toxicity in respect of travel has to be removed. That toxicity and that narrative have been largely delivered by policy over the past seven or eight months. That has to change fundamentally. Second, the implementation of practical steps to facilitate travel has to happen. The demand will follow, but it is entirely too premature for me to be talking about a best-case scenario when we have not got to that stage.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Moriarty believe that his case his helped by coming here this morning and saying that there is a one in 27 million chance of transmission of the virus onboard an aircraft? That is completely not credible. I have looked at the IATA evidence, which indicates that it is not possible to give an exact estimation and that the figure is only based on published reports. Is it credible for Mr. Moriarty to come and make statements of that nature? Does it not do a disservice to the role that aviation plays in the transmission of the virus?
Comment on this
I refer to a report published by IATA. I can send on the report to the committee separately, but that is what is says.
Comment on this
I have it. The report also says that there is no way to establish an exact tally of possible flight-associated cases. Does it not say this also?
Comment on this
It does. I can tell Mr. Moriarty that it does.
Comment on this
I believe I have accurately reflected what the report says. I would also refer the committee to the HSBC data about the low level of travel-related cases of transmission on board flights. The Deputy may be distrustful of what IATA says, but it is an agency of the State and it is producing the data.
Comment on this
My point is that it is important to recognise the role played by aviation in the spread of the virus. We cannot be in denial of the role it plays and it is important to have an honest conversation about it. To suggest that there is a one in 27 million chance of transmission is completely incredible and is not based on any sound science. It does a disservice to the quality of the conversation we are having. I think it should be recognised as such.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy O'Rourke. I shall now turn to my own questions, which I put to both witnesses. Mr. Moriarty made reference earlier to what he believes the Government will implement under the new traffic light system from 8 November, namely, that persons arriving from green list countries could go unrestricted without undergoing any test, that arrivals from orange list locations should have the option to apply to have unrestricted movement if they have tested negative prior to departure and that passengers from red list countries could be restricted for five days but would have free movement on receiving a negative test result thereafter. Do the witnesses believe that if that system is implemented by the Government, with a rapid antigen test, it would be the panacea to ensure that the aviation sector can recover? I put this question to Mr. Wilson first.
Comment on this
I do not think it will be a panacea. In our comments on the original drafting of the traffic light system, our preference was to see people from orange and green countries being allowed to travel unrestricted. Anything is better than quarantine. The logistics of testing, particularly at airports, mean that it is a non-starter. People are not going to travel to airports for tests, especially if they have already paid their fares, on the basis that they may not be able to get on an aircraft. People must look at the human behaviours. Anything is better than the blanket ban we have at the moment. While the traffic light system is really about not having the free movement of people in the European Union for work, visiting friends and relatives, etc., it is important to remember - sometimes we forget this - that regardless of the traffic light system and the testing scenarios, people in Germany, Italy, France and Spain will continue to travel because they have land borders. It will not be a panacea. Anything is better than a quarantine.
Comment on this
If this particular procedure is implemented by the Government on 8 November, will Ryanair have extra flights in the air flying in and out of Ireland?
Comment on this
If there is no regionalisation, and currently there are very few green regions left-----
Comment on this
-----it should be green and orange, it is not going to turbo start air travel. It would be a start, but it must have regionalisation and in preference it must have green and amber countries for unrestricted travel.
Comment on this
It is not a panacea. We have described it as an initial step, which is positive in that it provides a roadmap for the removal of the 14-day restriction on movements. Our view is that it needs to evolve and that there is a need to establish rapid, affordable antigen testing as both the testing standard and the testing solution on a screening basis. There is a further need to evolve to a limited form of random, rapid testing for passengers from higher-risk orange Covid countries and regions, and a pre-departure rapid test for those from red countries. We believe that is the solution. That testing standard needs to be on the basis of an antigen test.
Comment on this
Aer Lingus announced its summer schedule, which includes flights from Shannon and Cork airports. The Shannon-Heathrow route was to be restored. Will Mr. Moriarty tell the committee when that route will be restored? There are to be transatlantic routes to Boston and John F. Kennedy International Airport. Will Mr Moriarty give the committee an update as to where Aer Lingus is on that? Is the Aer Lingus base in Shannon Airport secure with regard to cabin crew and so on? In the context of these two measures being introduced, where does Mr. Moriarty see the landscape of Shannon and Cork airports over the next year?
Comment on this
With Shannon Airport, we had ambition to recommence our Shannon-Heathrow service in December. We cannot now do that. It was on the basis of what movement had taken place some time ago with the easing of travel restrictions. Our plan is to recommence operations in April on the Shannon-Heathrow, Shannon-Boston and Shannon-JFK routes. That is our plan but, as I said in my remarks, it is dependent on the significant easing of restrictions contemplated by the traffic light system, which have to be appropriately implemented. We are very keen to restore those services and we plan to do so.
Comment on this
What would encourage Aer Lingus to bring the Shannon-Heathrow route back as quickly as possible?
Comment on this
It would be exactly what I have said. We are assuming that what I have said about easing of restrictions is going to happen. We make that assumption in the publication of our summer 2021 schedule. That is what has to happen. We plan to operate-----
Comment on this
What would Aer Lingus require in order to restore the Shannon-Heathrow route in December?
Comment on this
There is nothing that can be done at this point to make that happen. It is too late, unfortunately. That is something we had asked for in terms of revisions to green lists a number of months ago. The aviation recovery task force has been asking for that since July. As Mr. Wilson said earlier, those recommendations have not been implemented four months later so, unfortunately, in terms of an earlier resumption of the Shannon-Heathrow service, that is now not possible.
Comment on this
That is very disappointing. This question is for Mr. Wilson. In terms of restoring the Ryanair bases at Shannon and Cork, do the new measures that will come in on 8 November give him confidence in that area? What is required to ensure that Ryanair can restore its permanent bases and proper complement of flights at both Shannon and Cork?
Comment on this
Before answering that question directly, we will have, and not just in terms of the based activity, zero flights from Cork and Shannon Airports from 4 November until 12 December at least. Can the Chairman imagine that the second city in Ireland will have no Ryanair flights in or out, not just the based activity? It is that bad. As Mr. Moriarty said, if we have not got a basis to fly then nobody will book and if nobody is going to book, we cannot fly. What I really worry about is that the Government will fudge this and try to implement some traffic light system that will put us at a disadvantage in terms of what other European countries are doing, and I do not have a lot of faith in that.
Comment on this
While we have some flights on sale for next summer at the moment, there is a reasonable chance that these two bases may not open.
Comment on this
In terms of what is due to come in on 8 November, is Mr. Wilson saying, even with that, Ryanair will have no flights out of either Shannon or Cork? What date did he mention?
Comment on this
From 4 November until 12 December there will not be a single-----
Comment on this
We do not know what is in it. We do not know whether it will involve regions. We do not know whether it will include amber countries. We do not know what testing it will put in place.
Comment on this
What would Mr. Wilson need to see from the Government by 8 November to keep the flights at both Cork and Shannon?
Comment on this
We have the same difficulties as Aer Lingus on this in that we have to have a plan. We have to have time to sell the flights. We cannot simply put them back on sale. The aircraft plans have been made. If the Minister, Deputy Eamon Ryan, was to come back today and say that he will allow unrestricted travel for green and amber countries and regionalisation, we would have a look at that but he would have to do that.
Comment on this
How would Ryanair regionalise in an Irish context when ours is such a small country?
Comment on this
I am talking about flying out. One could fly to the Canaries but perhaps not to Madrid. The ECDC map comes out every Tuesday and it shows the regions-----
Comment on this
It is regionalisation in terms of flights out to other countries, not here in Ireland.
Comment on this
Yes. Ireland, for ECDC map purposes, is classified as one region.
Comment on this
I hope those measures will be in the Government's plan on 8 November because it would be hugely disappointing if Ryanair were to cease flights out of Shannon or Cork because they are vital for connectivity.
Comment on this
We want to fly out of Shannon and Cork. If the Government implemented its own aviation recovery task force reports and put in green and amber lists, we would certainly re-examine at what we could do for Shannon and Cork.
Comment on this
It was a devastating blow to County Clare and Shannon that in the same week the traffic light system was announced, the Ryanair base at Shannon closed. I would largely agree with Mr. Wilson regarding the regionalisation argument. The Covid-19 figures are released around teatime every evening. When the ECDC talks about regionalising risk, it seems, and I made this point yesterday, that it is looking at countries more than regions. As far as I can see, there is only one region, which is Calabria, in the south of Italy, to which one can fly and Ryanair is certainly not flying from Shannon to Calabria. If we were to look at the figures provided last night and if Tipperary and Wicklow had airports, their incidence rates have dropped below 150. There is another metric where a region has to have a positivity rate of 4% or lower, but on that metric alone, if we looked at better regionalisation for collecting data, parts of Ireland would be creeping back to levels which would be deemed orange. We need the European Commission and the Department of Transport to urgently clarify the regions Europe is using to designate those regions.
I ask Mr. Moriarty to take up the point on which the Chairman concluded. I hear what he is saying about the uncertainty relating to orange and red routes. Both witnesses were very clear about that but how much of their decision to not fly from Shannon is based on the traffic light system and how much is based on a commercial decision? Could they apportion that out? There has been rigorous questioning from various members. If we get to 8 November and other measures are brought in or we see commonality across members states, they are still saying that they will not be flying until next April. How much of their decision on that would they apportion to corporate and commercial reasoning?
Comment on this
The commercial is absolutely linked to the ability to fly and having the environment in terms of easing of restrictions to allow us to fly. I will ask my colleague, Mr. Moody, to comment on that more specifically.
Comment on this
Everything that we do at the minute is based on economic and commercial viability. They are completely linked to the traffic light system and therefore the demand picture and, ultimately, the capacity that we will put on the network. For the sequence to happen consumer confidence needs to be restored. For that to happen, there needs to be adoption of the traffic light system in addition to full adoption of the aviation recovery task force recommendations. If, as a result of that, confidence in the market starts to build, as Mr. Wilson said, we will look at the demand and adjust capacity in accordance with that demand but the sequence has to start and at the minute the sequence is not starting.
Comment on this
If Aer Lingus is not committed to flying from Shannon between now and April, under what circumstances would it review that? I believe one can book flights from Shannon to Heathrow from 7 December onwards on the website. First, what does Aer Lingus need to happen? Second, what is Aer Lingus's intentions for its aircraft based in Shannon between now and the time they will be airborne again?
Comment on this
In the next couple of days, we will be finalising our winter schedule. That will see the removal of Shannon-Heathrow flights from aerlingus.com. We will be revising the full schedule for the rest of the network. That will be updated in the coming days and it will show the removal of the Heathrow flight rights through to the end of February. Unless there is a significant sea change in that demand picture I do not see the flying from Shannon situation changing before the end of February. We are starting to put aircraft into longer-term storage. Most of that is moving to Spain because of the arid conditions there versus the more-----
Comment on this
Can Mr. Moody give commitments as to what will happen those aircraft? Are they to come back to Shannon, particularly transatlantic aircraft? Also, what can Mr. Moody say to the Shannon-based staff of his airline today in light of the April date he is now flagging?
Comment on this
I will address that. We communicate with our staff on a more than weekly basis. We have local sessions with them also so they are well aware of the constraints and challenges we have in terms of our winter operation and our plans for the summer schedule.
In terms of the aircraft, we are planning to resume operations on the Boston and JFK routes for summer 2021. There will be no change in terms of deployment of aircraft. That is our planned schedule and it is built in but as I said, it is critically dependent upon the environment being right for us to-----
Comment on this
Would Mr. Moriarty consider a stopover facility in these months to ensure that he is satisfying the needs of a customer base in the mid-west and-or in Cork?
Comment on this
The Shannon stopover concept is something we are not inclined to revive.
Comment on this
My next question is for Mr. Wilson. We have heard his traffic light system argument. We have heard him talk about Ireland being an outlier. There are 28 European Union countries, four of which have a policy Ryanair likes, so 24 of them, including Ireland, have a policy Ryanair does not like.
What circumstances does Mr. Wilson need to see a normal return and the reopening of Ryanair's Shannon base?
Comment on this
Will the Deputy clarify the 24 countries we do not like? I am not quite clear on that.
Comment on this
There are 24 regimes relating to orange and red countries. Mr. Wilson referenced four countries, namely, Spain, Italy, France and Germany. He likes the regime they have in treating red and orange countries but he does not agree with the other regimes, including Ireland.
Comment on this
There is no traffic light system at the moment.
Comment on this
What would bring Ryanair back to Shannon? What circumstances does Mr. Wilson need to change?
Comment on this
I have already made that clear. It is when the official Government policy of this country is not to demonise air travel and open it again in a responsible way. We had a wasted summer here. We have seen the casualties already in Cork and Shannon and in reduced traffic out of Dublin, which means people are not willing to travel when their Governments tell them not to do so. We accept that where there are red countries, particularly within the EU, there will have to be some testing regime. We will have to restore travel to green and amber countries, however, and then we would be of a mind to look at restoring those where there may well be some demand. In the meantime, however, the tide is going out further all the time because other countries are looking for those aircraft and we are making decisions already for next summer.
Comment on this
Most people in this room accept and have worked individually and collectively from the point of view that there is a requirement for a framework. Everyone accepts that. We have all asked individual and collective questions on when we can get antigen testing in operation if that is up to specification so we do not take away from community testing. Most people are in that scenario. We accept how difficult it has been for the aviation sector and the absolute necessity to ensure we have an aviation sector when we get beyond this.
When we talk about the likes of Germany, Italy, France, Spain and Ireland at the minute, we are dealing with places that are either introducing new restrictions or have already done so on the basis that we have a huge amount of community transmission. That will obviously impact flying now. I accept we need the framework up and running. The European Commission and the Irish Aviation Authority, IAA, appeared before the committee yesterday. There is talk, obviously, of these European Union Aviation Safety Agency, EASA, and ECDC protocols which will be in operation and that would relate to testing. There is no surety, however, that we have any level of agreement across Europe that we will have anything close to harmonisation. That is before we talk about the difficulties here as regards Brexit and the fact we obviously must get an all-Ireland response but there also needs to be some element of a deal or harmonisation with the British Government, which is very difficult at the minute. We all accept the Irish Government needs to move as soon as possible. That is accepted.
When we talk about Aer Lingus and Ryanair we are dealing with two major airlines which have already spoken from the point of view of seeking to have this framework up and running. They are not necessarily looking for State money at this point. They are talking about rebates with regard to the future. We hope that when we talk about travel next summer, we are also talking about a period when we will probably have the outworking of a vaccine. None of this, however, is absolutely sure.
I want to put this question to Mr. Wilson. We also had travel agents before the committee, particularly travel agents who have block booked and who stated they were having incredible difficulty in getting moneys back from Ryanair. There is all this talk about dealing directly with customers but in some cases these were block bookings for school groups and such. Could we get that sort of problem resolved? I have a further question after that.
Comment on this
Sorry, I do not know which question the Deputy wants answered. Which one does he want answered first?
Comment on this
Mr. Wilson has stated what he wants. We all know there is a need for a framework. Mr. Wilson has been incredibly clear that he needs the Government to move. The first question is on the difficulty regarding harmonisation across Europe.
My second question concerns the travel agents we had in before the committee who spoke about the fact they and individual consumers have had incredible difficulty in getting money back for flights that did not fly at an earlier stage in the pandemic.
Comment on this
I keep saying with regard to harmonisation at the moment, and I do not know how many times I have to say it, that regardless of the traffic light system, outside of this jurisdiction at the moment a person can fly to any country in Europe, even those that are affected now, because they have land borders, not unlike Northern Ireland with the Republic. We are cutting ourselves off from the rest of Europe. I do not think people here get it and it is going to get worse because there will be fewer airline seats in Europe when this comes back. There are going to be fewer airline seats throughout the world. Our policy at the moment is to wander around in the darkness and say we might be doing something and we are having an expert group and all sorts of things rather than doing something.
We need connectivity on this island for this economy and if we are not going to have it, we had better be honest with the 325,000 people in tourism for next summer. They are going to lose next summer over complete inaction from this Minister. This Minister has had a report. He has all the answers in 12 recommendations and I do not know why he is not here today to say when he is going to implement them. Is he going to be honest with the 140,000 people in this industry or the 325,000 people in the tourism industry who are likely to lose their jobs next year? We will be able to put our aircraft elsewhere. It is the most moveable of assets. We do not want to do that.
Comment on this
I accept that. It is what Mr. Wilson said earlier. We need movement as quickly as possible at State level even if we cannot be absolutely sure of getting harmonisation across Europe. That is okay. Could Mr. Wilson give me the answer with regard to travel agents?
Comment on this
One does not need to worry about harmonisation. One can fly today. It just takes the will of this Government to do something. The will of this Government is that we have to control our own destiny in this.
Comment on this
I accept we need movement. Can Mr. Wilson give me the answer on the travel agents?
Comment on this
Ryanair has no commercial relationship with travel agents. When all the cancellations came through as a result of Covid-19, we put in a procedure because under law we have the liability to the passenger. Passengers who bought their flights through travel agents, and in many cases have been ripped off by travel agents because they add on to our fares and the charges for seats and bags, can get their money back directly. If the travel agents have a group of people, they can sign a waiver to say the travel agents can get it. Many travel agents have availed of this but we have no commercial relationship with them. The people who want their money back are getting their money back. There is a process there and the travel agents need to engage with it and people will get their money back. We have a responsibility to the passenger and not to the travel agent whom we have no commercial relationship with.
Comment on this
There are still difficulties but I accept Mr. Wilson's answer with regard to the waiver.
I will quickly move to Mr. Moriarty. What information did Aer Lingus get with regard to the initial period when it would not sign the X and O forms for those people who were on the temporary wage subsidy scheme, TWSS? Did it get instruction from the Department of Social Protection? What exactly was it?
Comment on this
I take it the Deputy's question relates to the temporary wage subsidy scheme rather than the employment wage subsidy scheme, EWSS. In the period since the TWSS was brought in and up to the point of its expiry on 31 August, we complied with the direction we got from the Department and from the Revenue Commissioners. That included the way in which we were to complete the forms to which the Deputy refers. We completed them in exactly the way we were directed to do so by the Department.
Comment on this
Moving on to my questions, I wish to direct my first set of questions to Mr. Wilson of Ryanair. Today's news from Ryanair that it will not fly any flights from Shannon or Cork airports from 4 November until 12 December is extremely disappointing. When Ryanair made this decision, had it communicated this decision to the Shannon Airport Authority and to Ryanair's workers? Are there any circumstances under which Ryanair could review this position?
It is my understanding that last weekend there were more than 100 people on the Shannon to Stansted flight. What makes it sustainable for Ryanair to fly that route? That represents a significant improvement on the number of passengers travelling from Shannon to Stansted. At what point does Ryanair say this is economical and it can fly? This is going to have a major, devastating impact on the economy of the mid-west, from a business point of view in particular.
Comment on this
Just to make one thing clear, when we made the decision about the based aircraft, that affects the pilots and cabin crew who are based in Shannon and in Cork. These additional cutbacks clearly do not affect those staff because these are flights that originate from London or other bases elsewhere. It is entirely due to demand, however. The reason there is no demand is that the Government is saying, "Don't fly". The Government has not opened up the green list. That is the only option. Today it says all of Europe and the UK is closed. One cannot operate an airline without passengers. While there may well be some flights that are better booked than others, I can tell the Acting Chairman that the bookings out of Cork and Shannon are absolutely shocking. If something is to be done for those airports, it needs to be done now by the Minister. We put a lot of time into this. We went down and met all of the politicians in Cork. We met airport management and our staff. We telegraphed this very clearly for more than six weeks and we did not get one phone call from the Government about what it could do to avert it. We are still flailing around in the darkness as to what we are going to do. One cannot run an airline without demand. At its most basic, we are an island nation and we must be able to say to people that they will not be demonised for travelling. We are responsible in this industry, we do everything that is risk-based and we are not going to make money-----
Comment on this
From 12 December on, what traffic volume does Mr. Wilson foresee through Shannon Airport?
Comment on this
Some of that traffic may come back from other non-based activity because there may well be traffic for Christmas. However, reading this morning's newspapers and NPHET's comments, which have no scientific basis, they are now saying people should not travel for that because they are very worried. As I said earlier, being worried is not good enough; we want to see the data. The data are there that airline travel itself is safe and we need a framework as to what countries and regions to balance the risk. Life has to go on. We have got to look after the most vulnerable and we have got to be able to have a functioning economy. As an island economy without any connectivity, we do not have a lot of hope on that so I hope the Government will do something about this today.
Comment on this
Turning to Mr. Moriarty and Aer Lingus, the Heathrow route is of strategic importance to our region and we have been missing it since last March. There was conflicting evidence given between him and Mr. Moody. He gave February as a possible return date for that particular route whereas Mr. Moriarty said April.
Comment on this
Can they clarify that? Are there any circumstances under which they can see an earlier return of that vital connectivity?
Comment on this
I do not think that there was a contradiction. What I said was we plan to operate it as part of our summer schedule and our summer schedule is planned from April. That is the normal date from the airline industry perspective. Mr. Moody may wish to address the specific point.
Comment on this
The reason I mentioned February was purely that it is the next planning horizon that I have based the most recent schedule on, so there is no difference there in any of the information between myself and Mr. Moriarty.
I would like to update the committee as well. As of last night we have communicated to Cork Airport that we will reduce frequency on Cork to Heathrow as well. Again, to echo Mr. Wilson's comments, the demand outlook is so weak that we have no other choice but to reduce frequencies.
Comment on this
I offer sincere congratulations to Mr. Seán Doyle on his appointment as head of British Airways. He is working with Aer Lingus's parent group AIG at the moment and is a very proud son of Youghal. I wish the new acting CEO the best of luck.
Mr. Wilson is probably aware that I gave a significant presentation at Cork Airport when he visited us about my concerns. A reference we have heard a lot today from the representatives of the aviation sector is the toxicity around flying and people's attitude to it, particularly around short-haul flights. I am incredibly concerned about the attitude people have towards aviation because 120,000 jobs were fully supported by this industry prior to the onset of Covid-19. The witnesses have said a great deal about demand and that is obviously king when it comes to providing flights out of Cork Airport, which is absolutely critical to the entire province of Munster. Shannon Airport is very important as well.
I am very concerned to hear some of the statements made by Mr. Wilson regarding engagement by senior representatives from Government. The representatives of the Government parties will feed that back. It is not good enough because if what he is saying is true, it has cost jobs and flights out of Cork Airport, which I am incredibly concerned about. I am also very concerned to hear that Aer Lingus will reduce its Cork to Heathrow capacity, which is the major link Cork has to airports internationally. We are fighting hard to hold on to the flights we have left and it is important that the public understands just how serious this is.
My first question is for Aer Lingus. When do Mr. Moriarty and Mr. Moody foresee some degree of normality returning to its transatlantic passenger traffic? It is important. There is a very problematic geopolitical situation there now but when do they see normality coming back to transatlantic travel, which is important to tourism in Ireland.
Comment on this
Clearly, transatlantic travel will not be restored by the adoption of the traffic light system but the approach of a pre-departure test as a standard for facilitating traffic within the EU is a model that could be applied to traffic to and from North America. We would very much advocate that engagement happen with the US and Canadian authorities-----
Comment on this
I apologise for interrupting Mr. Moriarty but is any engagement ongoing between the European Commission and representatives from the US and Canada, to his knowledge?
Comment on this
I am aware that there is some contact. We need to remember that Ireland is not in the Schengen area, so we have a slightly different regime with respect to traffic between Ireland and the US. There needs to be bilateral engagement, therefore, between the Irish Government and the US authorities to establish a safe travel corridor. The basis for doing so is similar to the one I outlined earlier, based upon a pre-departure test regime that facilitates traffic. Ireland is somewhat uniquely positioned to benefit from the relationships we have with the US. We have customs and border protection, CBP, facilities in Dublin and Shannon airports and that gives us a significant advantage in being able to have these safety and health technical conversations with the US authorities.
Comment on this
The Chairman has put a lot of work into trying to get a representative from NPHET to come before the committee and I understand the chief medical officer, CMO, may appear before us very soon. As the two key airlines in the State, it is important I ask the representatives what message would they like this committee to convey to the CMO when he appears before us. Perhaps Mr. Wilson might like to answer that one first.
Comment on this
What we have is this drip-drip on airline travel. We always hear about the data but travel has been demonised. We were told throughout the summer that if people did not travel abroad, everything would be fine and, as we now know, it was driven by domestic factors and Government policy failures on track and trace and increasing capacity. I would say to NPHET that if it is going to have an opinion on aviation, maybe it should look at what the experts outside this country say.
NPHET could look to what is being said by the US Department of Defense, the Boeing Company, the World Health Organization and the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control, ECDC. For some reason, however, it is ignoring all that. We saw that on 1 July when people were advised not to travel, which was not in line with what the ECDC, which we are supposedly following, was saying. As soon as the new traffic light system, or whatever derivative we have, was announced, people were already being told that they might not be able to come home for Christmas. It is not clear why people would not be able to return from green countries or orange countries or whatever, but it seems to be to do with testing. NPHET is dealing a death blow to the industry in Ireland while the rest of Europe looks to move on. People sometimes forget that no airline in this country is State-owned. Airlines are being bailed out throughout Europe and we will have to go to where we will get a return. At the moment, Ireland is bottom of the list because aviation has been demonised, particularly by NPHET. That body should stick to what it knows best.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Wilson. In the minute that is remaining to me, will the representatives from Aer Lingus comment on the same issue?
Comment on this
The key message from our perspective is that there is a range of measures in place that significantly de-risk aviation as a vector of transmission of Covid-19. These include health questionnaires, mandatory use of face masks, aircraft and airport cleaning, technology and so on. The act of travel itself is safe. We are suggesting, therefore, that a standard of testing needs to be introduced that is a screening standard, not a diagnostic standard. That standard of testing should be applied on a pre-departure basis from orange-list and red-list countries. By doing so, we believe that aviation can resume contributing to the Irish economy, which is urgently required, and it can be done safely.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses. There is a sense of déjà vu about this discussion because we had more or less the same conversation this day three weeks ago at a previous meeting of the committee. Unfortunately, that meeting was followed by three further weeks of inaction on the part of the Government. I am very interested in what the level of communication is between senior management at each of the two airlines represented today and the Minister or Minister of State. Will the witnesses indicate how many conversations or meetings they have had in the past three weeks with the Minister, Minister of State or a senior official on their behalf?
Comment on this
I do not believe we have spoken to the Minister or Minister of State in that period of time. As I recall, we spoke to the Minister, Deputy Eamon Ryan, shortly prior to our last appearance before the committee. However, we are engaging with the Department of Transport at a senior level on a regular basis. To be clear, we are proactively engaging with and making submissions to the Department as things develop.
Comment on this
Would it be fair to say that Aer Lingus is leading that engagement? In other words, is it the case that the company is proactively making representations to the Department and the latter is not leading that engagement?
Comment on this
I think it would be slightly unfair to say that. We are being proactive but the Department is engaging with us on the range of issues.
Comment on this
My sense is that since the report of the Commission for Aviation Regulation in the summer, the sittings of the Special Committee on Covid-19 Response and through to today, we have not seen the level of urgency that is required in terms of implementing a plan for the sector. We know that even if a plan were implemented next week that included rapid testing, locator forms and everything else, it would still require a number of months, if not longer, for the aviation industry to recover. It is not a question of the aeroplanes going straight back up in the sky. None of us is operating under that assumption. However, I do not get a sense that there is any urgency from the Minister in tackling the issues or at least putting us on a path to recovery. I am very concerned about that.
The witnesses mentioned the importance of planning and scheduling of flights. However, there has been no progress in this regard in the period from the meetings of the Covid committee in July, the meeting of this committee on 7 October, through to this meeting today. If the Government continues to make no progress through November, December and into the start of next year, what plans are the witnesses putting in place in terms of their workforces? I am not trying to create any extra fear because the workers are already very scared and uncertain about their future. What kinds of implications will continuing Government inaction have for the airlines' ability to sustain their workforce at current levels?
Comment on this
Before answering that question, I would like to correct something I said in response to the Deputy's previous question. We spoke to the Minister, Deputy Eamon Ryan, on the evening after we last appeared before the committee, rather than just before it, as I stated.
To answer the question the Deputy just asked, we are communicating very regularly with our workforce. We continue to emphasise the importance of the adoption by the State at a policy level of the traffic light system and a meaningful and appropriate implementation of that system. We are planning our business and resources on that basis. We have not engaged or communicated a detailed plan as to what would happen if that policy step and that implementation is not done. We are emphasising today the critical importance of ensuring those steps are taken urgently. Doing so will facilitate a recovery over time, a restoration of demand and, indeed, a restoration of confidence that it is, in fact, okay to travel. That is the important first step. As both Mr. Wilson and I have said, that first step has to be taken and then we can get into the phase of planning for what the future is going to look like.
Comment on this
Looking at Cork and Shannon, I would say that the mood among our staff is utterly despondent as to what is going on and how it was allowed to happen without any intervention. We have more than 80 locations throughout Europe where our aircraft are based, similar to Cork and Shannon, and we must make commercial decisions about all of them. This limping along is not going to do anything for anybody. Life will be difficult enough as Europe works its ways through the current spike of infections and until confidence returns at some point with the introduction of a vaccine. It is hard to get across how truly extraordinary it is that this country - an island nation that needs air connectivity more than most - instead of leading the pack in seeking to bring aviation back in a more expedited way, is actually at the bottom of the class in this regard. I really do not understand it, especially when the answer is on the Minister's desk. That solution would give us a fighting chance. In its absence, things are going to get a lot worse before they get better and I really fear for our tourism sector next summer. If there are no aircraft coming into the country, there will be nobody coming here to fill the hotel rooms and visit the attractions. We are making our decisions with that prospect in view and the Government needs to get to grips with it. No other airlines are coming in. Operators throughout Europe are getting much smaller and airports already realise they need to attract people for next summer. Other countries are working on that but nothing is being done here in Ireland. It is a shame.
Comment on this
If we get this first step wrong or do not take it, are we going to see extensive job losses in the two airlines next year?
Comment on this
I really do not want to be thinking about that. Aviation is one of those industries where people can be more transferable. They might not want to do it but pilots and cabin crew in Cork and Shannon may well move with their aircraft in the hope that things will come back. The thing about aviation is that we have relatively small numbers of people for the movement of the aircraft. Of course, there are significant implications for the wider economy, including people working at the airports, taxi drivers operating out of them, hotels, attractions and all of that. I do not want to be thinking about job losses because we will continue to work with our people. We have implemented agreements whereby we have not made anyone redundant among our crews in Cork, Shannon and Dublin. We want to be able to bring them back. If that means that those aircraft go elsewhere, then it may be an unpalatable solution for some of our people but they will be doing so in the hope that we would come back at some other stage. In the short term, this is going to be disastrous for Ireland and I do not think people realise what is coming next summer.
We are going to miss the boat or the plane.
Comment on this
I can feel the frustration. Indeed, that is felt here at committee level as well on the basis that we seem to have made no progress since our last discussion. The scenario that has been pointed out today is frank and forthright but very bleak. We started this process in the past few days and the whole aviation scenario tends to look catastrophic. We have a situation where the prospects for airlines are bleak and where Cork, Shannon and Knock airports are effectively wastelands and deserted as we speak. Plus tourism is non-existent. Both Aer Lingus and Ryanair bring many people to Ireland through the commercial and business sector so they have a good idea of their profile. We all talk about tourism and the impact on the economy, which is correct. Will the witnesses outline their assessment of the damage that has been, and is being, done to our business and corporate sector due to a lack of connectivity?
Have both airlines requested state aid from the Government? Yesterday, we heard from a representative of the European Commission that he was not aware of any application for state aid being made on Ireland's behalf. Aer Lingus and Ryanair mentioned on several occasions in the recent past that they must compete with other airlines in other countries that have the assistance and support of state aid within their jurisdiction. Has the Government made an application? Yesterday, I was gobsmacked to hear the representative of the European Commission say that there were a number of funds available to be accessed but he was not aware as to whether the Irish Department, Ministry or Government had made an application.
Yesterday, a refund issue arose. What is the refund position with both airlines? We have had many complaints from consumers who are entitled and eligible for a refund. The process seems extremely slow and the Irish Travel Agents Association has taken a huge amount of criticism as a result. Will the witnesses update us? What is their attitude to refunds? How have the airlines approached that?
Do the witnesses agree we have no possibility of opening the airports and bringing people on to aircrafts unless we put a rapid testing system in place? This is all about people having the confidence to board an aircraft and fly. Obviously, the movement of people generates movement within the economy but, as things stand, we are at a complete standstill. What is the view on rapid testing? What is the level of communication between the airlines and the Dublin Airport Authority and the Department on rapid testing? How do the witnesses see that progressing?
In terms of Christmas, I understood from the way we were moving yesterday and from the statements emanating from Government previously that we hoped for some happy reunions at Christmas. Therefore, I hoped that we would have a co-ordinated policy, and that guidelines would be set out so people could understand the basis on which they could return home for Christmas. However, yesterday, the Chief Medical Officer, CMO, and NPHET poured cold water on that. There does not seem to be a co-ordinated approach of one voice and one action. The policy is all over the shop and we seem to be making it up as we go along. There is no place more impacted than the aviation industry because of a lack of direction and policy.
Comment on this
I am happy to give Aer Lingus's response to those questions, if I may?
Comment on this
With respect to the first question from Deputy Lowry that related to the business community and the impact a lack of connectivity is having on it, increasingly, we are hearing voices from the business community expressing concern about the lack of connectivity. I have heard it expressed best by some executives with significant investments in Ireland who expressed a wish to walk the land and review their investment in Ireland but that is not something they can do. That not only impacts on the existing foreign direct investment in Ireland but also future investments that may or may not be made. It is quite clear that Ireland is putting itself at a significant disadvantage by the policies it has adopted in preventing business traffic.
With respect to state aid and the appearance by Mr. Cornelis at the committee yesterday, I confirm that the aviation recovery task force made a number of recommendations but none of them has been implemented. First, two of the recommendations related to the application of waivers or rebates with respect to airport and air navigation charges. Second, the task force spoke about a stimulus package with respect to regional airports. It is not clear to me whether they would constitute state aid or not but the State should consider implementing the recommendations, and if that requires an application to be lodged with the European Commission, then it should make it. To be clear, Aer Lingus has not made any application to the State for state aid, on a direct basis.
With respect to the refund issue, Aer Lingus has received in excess of 2 million refund or voucher requests since the start of the crisis and that is driven by the unprecedented level of flight cancellations. To date, we have processed 1.8 million refunds and vouchers, which is more than 90% of the requests we have received. Of the remaining 10%, we are working through them. Some of them are very challenging in terms of the complexity of the bookings. We are working through them and are committed to getting those refunds to our customers.
With respect to rapid testing, and I am not sure whether the Acting Chairman heard my remarks earlier, Aer Lingus believes that a rapid, affordable testing solution, based on antigen testing, is critical in order to meaningfully increase the level of international travel, and safely do so. It is our view that that testing needs to be at a screening standard, not at a diagnostic standard. The reason for that is that there are many other risk mitigations that make travel safe.
With respect to the comments on Christmas, I would agree that a lack of co-ordination and lack of a consistent and clear voice as to what the policy is has bedevilled aviation since March. I am aware of the comments that have been referred to but the lack of consistency has been a feature of the crisis since the start.
Comment on this
Does the Acting Chairman want me to continue?
Comment on this
Unfortunately, we do not have the time to hear the response of Mr. Wilson. I must move on to the next lot and call Senator McCallion who has seven minutes.
Comment on this
It is clearly very evident from the representatives of both airlines that they are frustrated by how the Government has handled the entire aviation situation. Mr. Wilson, in his opening statement, referred to the decisions taken on the Cork and Shannon bases. He said he was really disappointed that he had not heard from either the Minister for Transport, Deputy Eamon Ryan, or the Minister of State, Deputy Naughton, at the time. He said the decision could have been averted had he had a conversation with either the Minister or Minister of State. I ask him to quickly elaborate on that point.
Comment on this
It could, potentially, have been averted if they had come to us before the decision. We had that well signalled, in that if they had adopted the traffic light system, as initially put forward by the European Council of Ministers, which was the freedom of movement for green and amber countries. We made our stance absolutely clear to this committee and the Special Committee on Covid-19 Response. We wrote to the Minister on that basis on several occasions and yet we had no engagement whatsoever.
Honestly, I find it extraordinary to this day. Imagine that a factory of that size owned by Pfizer or Johnson & Johnson in Cork closed down and the Minister for Health or the Minister with responsibility for industry and commerce did not contact the company. We could have at least explored the options but we did not get that opportunity.
Comment on this
I will turn to a slightly different issue which faces all of aviation at present. I raised the matter yesterday with representatives of the Irish Aviation Authority, IAA, but I would not mind hearing what it would mean for our guests' airlines. We are fewer than 70 days away from the end of the transition period and we do not seem to have a proper legal framework to address what is next for the open skies agreement. I have heard soundings from Ministers in London who have said they believe there will be an agreement. I have concerns that at this stage we cannot see the agreement in its entirety and I am sure that the Government is looking to address those issues in the omnibus legislation. It is a real concern that we are in the mouth of the end of the transition and still do not have a legal framework for the open skies agreement. How will that have an impact our guests and their airlines?
Comment on this
We hope a trade deal which facilitates aviation is done. The Senator may recall the last occasion when there was a hard stop in terms of imminent Brexit effects. At that point, a contingency arrangement was put in place. We would expect that in the event of the failure of trade discussions, such a contingency arrangement would also be put in place on this occasion. That happened in preparation for the last expected hard stop to emerge from Brexit.
Comment on this
I concur with that. There is still the possibility that there will be no traffic between the European Union and the UK. That threat still exists but we are hopeful that there will be a trade deal and that eventuality will not come to pass.
Comment on this
The witnesses' understanding is that the position that applied to last year's no-deal scenario would be likely to apply again if a similar scenario arises presently. Have they been engaged by the Irish and UK Governments on the matter?
Comment on this
Both Aer Lingus and Ryanair participate in the national civil aviation development forum where the Brexit issue is discussed in significant detail. We are absolutely engaged with Government on the subject.
Comment on this
Ryanair today announced a reduction in the frequency of flights between Cork and Heathrow. That was obviously disappointing to hear. What was suggested to Cork? Which flights will take place? Will they match the needs of commuters who work, for example, in London or elsewhere or will flights occur at a random frequency? Has that decision been taken yet?
Comment on this
That decision has been taken. We will be reducing flights from Cork to Heathrow to three a week. We will increase that frequency over the peak Christmas season, the three weeks from the second half of December through the first week of January. The flights will be in alignment with the busiest Cork frequencies, which are mainly commuter driven.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Moody. Those are all the questions I have for now.
Comment on this
I thank our guests for the comprehensive presentations they set out, on behalf of their sector, in a strong way. I expect that if we had people from the hospitality or retail sectors before us, we would hear similar passion about the reopening of their sectors. It is a fact at the moment that Ireland is, under the traffic light system, considered to be in a red zone. Can our guests identify what other countries on a green or orange traffic light would allow travel into their countries without any restrictions?
Comment on this
That would apply to pretty much every European country at the moment. One can fly in and out of Germany with some restrictions. One can board flights out of France, Sweden or Italy. There is no testing between most of those countries.
Comment on this
The Senator should not forget that the traffic light system was only brought in-----
Comment on this
I am asking in terms of quarantine.
Comment on this
There are exceptions to the traffic light system. We, in Ireland, have the idea that every other country in Europe is closed down and waiting for a "Go" from the traffic light system. That is not the case at all.
Comment on this
Spain has one of the highest rates of Covid-19 in Europe and there are no restrictions to flying in and out of Spain at the moment.
Comment on this
I get from where Mr. Wilson is coming in terms of protecting his industry. If he looks at the issue from our perspective-----
Comment on this
I am not protecting my industry. The Senator asked me a question-----
Comment on this
-----and I gave him the facts in my answer. He asked the question and seemed to be under the illusion that other countries have restrictions like we have. We need to get this message across to Oireachtas Members because this is like Groundhog Dáil. We are the only country that is restricting travel in the way that we are at the moment. The British are doing so to a lesser extent.
Comment on this
At the moment, the green list means we are closed to each of the 27 EU countries and the UK. We are unique in the European Union in that regard.
Comment on this
Public health officials have guided us.
Comment on this
Public health officials have guided us to being a red zone. I live in Tulla, County Clare, and except in exceptional circumstances, I am restricted from going 5 km from home. Is Mr. Wilson suggesting that if I want to travel to Spain, I should be allowed go as I wish? That is the dilemma.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting any such thing. The Senator asked me which countries in the European Union are restricting movement and I am telling him the factual position that Ireland is unique. We can argue about whether that is a good or a bad thing but the factual position is that, for example, there is no restriction on travel in and out of Spain. The reason is it has land borders and other ways of transporting. One could argue over the value judgment of that. When this pandemic passes, or gets better, we in Ireland are going to be left on the sidelines and nobody seems to be getting that.
Comment on this
We do get it and I was coming to that. It seems to me that because we are in a red zone at the moment, there are restrictions and limited access. It is hardly the fault of this Government or the Minister who Mr. Wilson identified that only about 42% of the flights that took place this time last year happened last week. Load factors are down at 38% but that is not necessarily the fault of the Government.
Comment on this
What the Minister did was to sit on his hands-----
Comment on this
-----since 1 June, when this country was in a green zone. He did nothing.
Comment on this
The red zone classification then caught up with the Minister in his inactivity.
Comment on this
Mr. Wilson has helped me by identifying the other countries that had no restrictions and yet, right across Europe, activity is down by 58% in terms of the amount of flights.
Comment on this
That is absolutely the case. Activity is down. We all agree about that.
Comment on this
Load factors are down to 38%. Mr. Wilson made the threat that he has many other locations to which he can take his aircraft. With the best of goodwill, I wonder where he will find locations for them. We will move on.
Comment on this
Is that a wish of the Senator or does he actually think that? I can tell him the countries at which we are looking at the moment. For example, there are two countries, Croatia and Slovenia-----
Comment on this
Mr. Wilson should keep that information for the stock market.
Comment on this
Croatia and Slovenia have no national airlines at the moment and realise the precarious situations they will be in when the pandemic lifts.
Comment on this
What is the population of Slovenia?
Comment on this
They have no national airline and have a tender out at the moment. Ireland may well find itself in that position in the not-too-distant future. If it keeps on pushing airlines out of this country, that is what will happen.
Comment on this
When Mr. Wilson considers the significant reduction in activity around Europe, there are not too many opportunities.
Comment on this
Why does the Senator not come in here and run the business? He seems to know all about it. I am here today to try to help.
Comment on this
With the greatest of respect, Mr. Wilson is lecturing us a little bit so maybe he would accept the offer and come on.
Comment on this
I am not lecturing the committee, I am trying to give the facts. It seems that people are trying to make excuses for the Minister, who did nothing when Ireland's cases of Covid-19 were down in June and July and is now saying he was right all along in doing nothing since we have become a red-light country.
Comment on this
I will let the Minister answer for that.
Comment on this
I agree that we should have testing but I do not think the Senator's argument for the inaction of this Minister holds up at all.
Comment on this
I will address the next question to Mr. Moriarty. Some of the staff at our airports are on reduced pay, temporarily laid off or both. Has Mr. Moriarty looked to engage with the HSE about having some of those staff members available to do contact tracing?
Aer Lingus will not see much activity in those areas over the next number of months. Have Mr. Moriarty and his colleagues given any consideration to the redeployment of staff to assist with contact tracing?
Comment on this
We have not. I assume the Senator is referring to staff in Shannon Airport. Throughout the crisis, we have tried to align working hours and pay with the amount of work that needs to be done. We made some recent changes in respect of our staff at Shannon Airport by giving them an option to return to a work pool at 40% pay in preparation for a resumption of operations or a winter lay-off. We put a similar arrangement in place for our cabin crew at Shannon. We have also launched voluntary severance schemes and incentivised career break schemes for our cabin crew. We have not taken the step of offering our staff to the HSE for the purpose of contact tracing. To be honest, it is our assumption that there is sufficient availability within the public sector to provide that facility.
Comment on this
I wish to follow up on the issue of workforce planning. Will Mr. Moriarty indicate where Aer Lingus expects to be in that regard in the months ahead? For example, it has a voluntary redundancy package. By what number is it looking to reduce its head count?
Comment on this
Our approach throughout the crisis has been to maintain the employment relationship with as many of our employees as possible. That has been our approach across our business regardless of location. Employees in the form of fixed-term contractors have left our business and contractors who were due to join our business over the busy summer period ultimately did not do so. We have engaged in consultation with our staff and their representatives on redundancies. When we wrote to the Minister in that regard, we told him that we were looking at up to 500 redundancies. Consultation and the deployment of schemes are ongoing, but we now anticipate that the number of redundancies will be approximately 250. That figure is based on our assumptions about the recovery. Our plan is to run a significant operation in summer 2021 from all of our bases. In order to facilitate that, certain changes in policy and the implementation of the traffic light system have to take place.
Comment on this
We heard Mr. Moriarty loud and clear as regards those requests. I thank him.
Comment on this
I will give Mr. Wilson an opportunity to reply to the questions on reuniting families at Christmas and mixed messages, to set out Ryanair's position on those who are eligible for refunds and the lack of rapid testing, and to outline his views on the fact that competitors have access to state aid, which puts our airlines at a disadvantage.
Comment on this
Our view is that most of the state aid in Europe is illegal. In extraordinary times, however, it is possible to have state aid that is legal. As set out in the task force's recommendations, Aer Lingus, Ryanair and any other airline that flies in and out of Ireland could access reduced rates of airport charges or rebates on same. That would be fundamental in decisions to base aircraft in Ireland from next summer. We urge the Minister to do something on that.
Regarding businesses that are involved, we carry a large number of people to and from the UK. Many of them work in the National Health Service, NHS, and so on. They have been discommoded by travel bans. One can only imagine what is going on in Pfizer and Johnson & Johnson in Cork where they are battling to develop a vaccine but it looks like access out of Cork Airport is slowly being strangled.
Anyone who wanted a cash refund has got a cash refund. It is accessible on the website. One will find people who are noisy about this but who were not entitled to refunds. If someone is entitled to a valid refund, he or she will get it.
Regarding travel agents, there is a process on our website. We must be sure that the person is getting his or her money back because that is what we are obliged to do under EU Regulation 261/2004. The Commission for Aviation Regulation understands that.
As to the question on Christmas, the Chief Medical Officer's decisions must be based on science. Saying at this stage that we should not have travel, regardless of where people come from, is to take the same route we followed in the summer when we trashed the tourism industry and policy failures saw the rates of Covid-19 spiral due to domestic factors. We must learn to live with this virus, restore our economy and protect the most vulnerable. There must be a way of doing that as opposed to this continuous cycle of lockdown, which will get us nowhere. We are very vulnerable as an economy.
I hope I answered all of the questions.
Comment on this
Ryanair is considering discontinuing flights out of Shannon Airport and Cork Airport from 4 November.
Comment on this
I have a question for Mr. Wilson. The Government is introducing the new traffic light system. I want to drill down into the details. The proposal we are hearing about in respect of orange countries has to do with people undergoing rapid pre-departure testing and effectively getting negative results. Would that not work?
Comment on this
I can only deal with the demand we have. The policy must allow demand to resume in some sort of predictable fashion so that we can put on flights. One must work backwards from that. We have made it clear that if we can get green and amber, it would be very beneficial for us.
Comment on this
-----and I am trying to answer as best I can. I cannot tell what effect a certain amount of testing will have on demand. We will make our decisions based on demand. I can only give the Chairman my best opinion as to what circumstances would release that demand. It is clear-----
Comment on this
I am sorry. We have seen that there has been pent-up demand in other markets following the lifting of restrictions.
Comment on this
The point I am making is that Ryanair is taking a decision to pull flights in their entirety from Shannon Airport and Cork Airport four days prior to the Irish Government's implementation of the new European traffic light system, which will obviously involve some form of pre-departure testing. Is this just about upping the ante for the Government? Why did Ryanair not wait until the new system had been announced before making its decision? Why is it pre-empting the Government's announcement by announcing here publicly that, from 4 November, there will be no flights out of Shannon Airport or Cork Airport?
Comment on this
I am sorry, but the question should be put to the Minister. What has he been doing since 1 July?
Comment on this
I have no confidence. Maybe if the Minister was in here and picked up the phone to us. I have no idea what the Government is going to put into the traffic light system because it has not said exactly what it will-----
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, the latest news is that the Government will ask an expert group to report back some time in late November.
Comment on this
Why did Ryanair do that? Second, would it work for Ryanair if a rapid pre-testing system was implemented in orange countries?
Comment on this
In the airline industry we need to know whether people are going to travel. If we were going to sort out the bookings for November, then we should have had a new system in last August or September at the latest, so we would know what bookings would be. I can only deal with what I have and the simple answer is we are not flying because there is nobody booking. It is as simple as that. It is up to the Minister to talk to us and to say what things might work and the reasons for doing X,Y and Z.
I do not know whether testing in orange zones will work. Perhaps they will prove us wrong but we need a track record as to whether it is going to work. I keep coming back to this. In other European countries at the moment, a person can fly without that. We are an outlier and have been since the start of this. We are now reaping that in places like Cork and Shannon airports which really depend on high load factors. There is nobody booking, so there is nothing I can do about it.