Issues Affecting the Aviation Sector: Discussion (Resumed)
Contributions 208–409 of 409. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I do not know what the Chairman means by "coincidental". He should come in here and look at things. There are no bookings.
Comment on this
We are running an airline here and one needs bookings. There is nothing coincidental about it at all. If one has no bookings, one does not put flights on. It is not just Cork Airport; it is Shannon Airport.
Comment on this
With respect, let us look at this on a European basis. It is not just in Cork and Shannon airports. We have cut flights right across Europe as well. As it turns out, however, because Cork and Shannon airports are peripheral airports the demand for those has dried up completely.
Comment on this
I am sorry but I have answered the Chairman's question.
Comment on this
If a pre-departure rapid antigen type test was put in the orange countries, would that be-----
Comment on this
If orange antigen testing came in and that restored confidence among people to return to flying then, of course, we would look at it. I am in the business of trying to move passengers and make a profit on that. I am not in the realms of speculation here.
Comment on this
Will Mr. Wilson hold off on his decision to 4 November until he sees the details of the-----
Comment on this
The cancellations have already been processed. They were processed yesterday.
Comment on this
Why did Ryanair make that announcement? It looks to me like it is upping the ante on this with the Government.
Comment on this
It is a commercial decision and we have not just done it in Ireland. People can understand this. It does not give anyone any pleasure to do this. We are doing it throughout Europe as well but it is particularly required at Cork and Shannon airports because there are no bookings. It is as simple as that. I cannot fly aircraft which are empty.
Comment on this
I will let my colleague, Mr. Moriarty, answer too. Yes, we will have flights from 14 December in and out of Cork and Shannon airports because we believe people will start to travel again but maybe they will not. Perhaps they will listen to NPHET and not travel and, in that case, we may have further cancellations.
Comment on this
I will answer that question. Of course, as Mr. Moody outlined earlier, we will be operating out of Cork Airport throughout the winter and we will increase services in London Heathrow for a three-week period over Christmas. We will, obviously, be operating all our existing services out of Dublin and hope to bring people home for Christmas in that regard.
Comment on this
I will just add that we will put on extra flights if there is sufficient demand to bring people home for Christmas.
Comment on this
This has been a real blow to everyone with an interest in aviation. To follow up on the point made by our Chairman, in the week of the announcement of the traffic light system, Ryanair announced the winter closure of its Shannon and Cork bases. In the week the new regime begins, it will withdraw from flights. It is important it is said, and we heard it in the last comment, that this is based on a lack of bookings. Two things are at play here. There are the orange and red countries and the lack of uniformity. That message rings loud and clear as does the need for testing. The fact is that the same barriers make flying out of Dublin difficult. Ryanair will still fly out of Dublin Airport but not out of Shannon and Cork airports. That point needs to be made loud, clear and several times. The airlines are making this decision on a commercial basis, based on low booking rates for both of those airports.
In terms of flying at Christmas and putting on extra flights, I want to hear from both airlines about their short-term and medium-term commitments to getting planes flying out of Shannon Airport again. Under what circumstances will they revise their spring and summer schedule? I want to hear what both airlines can say to the staff they have based in Shannon Airport because I am aware they talk about good communications. I have seen staff getting videos and WhatsApp messages. They need to know, unequivocally, from both airlines what the coming months will be like for them as workers who work for those companies out of the Shannon base. Will the airlines use staff based in their Dublin base to supplement what they are doing or to replace them if there are flights? I am specifically talking about cabin crew. I want to hear from both witnesses on that, please.
Comment on this
That is probably a question for Mr. Moriarty.
Comment on this
It is a question for both, Chairman.
Comment on this
We demonstrated our commitment to Shannon Airport by announcing our summer schedule 2021 and that being an extensive schedule. That is what we want to do. I am aware I am reiterating what I said earlier but there are key things that must be done to enable that to happen successfully. They are the policy change and the appropriate implementation of the traffic light system and the rapid antigen testing regime I outlined.
We have been communicating extensively with our colleagues based in Shannon Airport. As the Deputy said, we are doing so by video message. I do not really apologise for that. It is entirely appropriate in the context of the Covid-19 pandemic. We have also made significant changes recently in terms of pay through the introduction of 40% pay for availability to be in a work pool or winter leave, and we have introduced voluntary severance programmes.
We are, therefore, engaging extensively with our staff about all the options open to them and about the future in terms of our ambition. As I said, our ambition is to maintain an employment relationship with as many of our employees as we possibly can and to do that we want to restore our operations to a sustainable level. We need, however, the support of the State at a policy level to enable that to happen.
Comment on this
We had the announcement that flights from other bases do not affect our staff in Shannon and Cork airports. We spoke to them about the closures of those bases in recent weeks in terms of the winter schedule. Our hope is that we will reopen those bases next summer, that is, from 1 April onwards. What we need, however, is some basis for doing that and as a start we must be able to, at least, have a fighting chance before we get demand to recover. Flights for Christmas will be there from 14 December onwards and we would hope that people will be back travelling by that time.
We are committed to Shannon and Cork Airports but the demand is just not there at the moment. November is typically one of the worst months to try to stimulate people to travel and pricing is not going to do that. It is the policy failures of this Government and it needs to rapidly do something about it before this situation gets worse. It does not affect our colleagues there at the moment because, unfortunately, they have already been laid off and we would hope to have them back next summer. I hope there is some action as a result of this meeting, in particular by the Minister, to adopt the aviation task force recommendations and put something in place for next summer to attract traffic back into Cork and Shannon airports.
Comment on this
I will be very quick as some of my questions have been answered. What refunds have been paid, in both percentage and monetary terms, and what refunds are still to be paid? What flights across Europe have been reduced and what other bases have been dropped?
Comment on this
We have had cutbacks in pretty much every base across Europe. We have seen the closure of our base in Toulouse in France. We have had a reduction in traffic and we ran a reduced schedule throughout the summer and this winter. We recently announced that, and it is part of the further cutbacks coming in Cork and Shannon. It is happening everywhere across Europe.
On refunds, anybody entitled to a cash refund can get that refund. This can be done directly on the website. The Deputy referred to the travel agents issue earlier and I have already answered that.
Comment on this
The witness has answered that. Does he know, in percentage or monetary terms, the refunds paid and those which are still to be paid?
Comment on this
The only people outstanding are those who made bookings through travel agents. Once we identify them, we will be more than happy to reimburse those people. There is process for them to do it. We do not break down that amount.
Comment on this
It is a similar approach and we have had over 2 million refund and voucher requests. I will not provide a precise number but suffice it to say that it is in the hundreds of millions of euro and we have processed over 90% of them. As I have said, the remaining 10% or so that remain to be processed are particularly complex but we are working through them and committed to our customers that we will process them.
Comment on this
Has the general number of flights reduced on the basis of the airline stopping operating in locations across Europe?
Comment on this
We base our aircraft in Dublin, Shannon and Cork. The same question does not apply to us as it does to Ryanair.
Comment on this
What about the reduction in flights?
Comment on this
We have reduced our capacity very significantly. Throughout the crisis we were down to below 20% and we are slightly above that at this point. Our capacity has dramatically reduced because of the crisis. That remains the case for the winter.
Comment on this
We will have Dr. Tony Holohan, the Chief Medical Officer and the chair of the National Public Health Emergency Team, NPHET, before us next Tuesday, along with the Minister for Transport, Deputy Eamon Ryan. I hope both of the witnesses will be tuning in as we will put questions to the Minister and Dr. Holohan. We ask that they bear with us until the new system for flights is introduced by the Government on 8 November. Ryanair and Aer Lingus are very important to us because of the number of people they employ. This is a national crisis and we hope the airlines, like everyone else, will play their part to ensure we can get flights back in the air in a safe way. I thank our witnesses, including Mr. Wilson, Mr. Moriarty and Mr. Moody, for today's engagement with the committee.
Comment on this
I welcome Ms Mary Considine, CEO of Shannon Group; Mr. Dalton Philips, CEO of the Dublin Airport Authority, DAA; Mr. Niall MacCarthy, managing director of Cork Airport; Mr. Ivan Bassato, executive vice president airport management, Aeroporti di Roma; and Ms Veronica Pamio, chief communication and public affairs officer, Aeroporti di Roma. Members should be aware that the representatives from Aeroporti di Roma have informed us that they will leave the meeting after one hour. I propose to reduce the time for questions from seven minutes to five minutes in that context. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Witnesses attending in the committee room are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the presentation they make to the committee. This means they will have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything said at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Chair to ensure that this privilege is not abused. If statements are potentially defamatory, therefore, regarding an identified person or entity, witnesses will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that the witnesses comply with any such direction. For witnesses attending the meeting remotely, there are some limitations to parliamentary privilege, and they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as witnesses who are physically present. Witnesses participating in this meeting from jurisdictions outside this State are also advised that they should be mindful of their domestic law and how that may apply to the evidence they give. All witnesses are again reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or an entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory regarding the identified person or entity, the witnesses will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official, either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Members are also reminded that committee meetings should conclude within two hours in any one day. This committee is scheduled to sit twice today, and this is the second sitting, for a cumulative time of just under four hours. Members, therefore, are asked to rotate in and out of the meeting when they have finished asking their questions. With the indulgence of the other witnesses, in the context of Mr. Bassato having to go within an hour, I ask him to be the first to make a presentation. Is that okay with Ms Considine?
Comment on this
We thank Mr. Bassato for taking time out of his busy schedule at Rome Fiumicino Airport, and I ask him to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for the invitation. We are very proud and happy to be part of this committee sitting. I thank the members of the committee for inviting me to contribute to this session. It is an honour for me to have the opportunity to share with the members of the committee the views of Aeroporti di Roma on the future of travel in the aviation sector.
The pandemic has posed an unprecedented challenge to airports, which have found themselves with a need to evolve their approach rapidly to comply with the paradigm shift in travel and tourism. Aeroporti di Roma's primary commitment today is to create the necessary conditions to relaunch traffic in maximum safety. We have been working relentlessly to implement effective protection measures and a strong prevention plan. We installed multiple screening tools, engaged in a series of sanitation activities and supported the Italian health authorities' testing operations by establishing a testing area in the arrivals hall and a large drive-through testing facility at the long-term stay parking facility of the airport. We are also, however, the first airport in Europe to have trialled a system of 100% Covid-tested flights, on the Rome-Milan route, in partnership with Alitalia and the health authorities of the Lazio region.
Our long-term goal in this respect is to use the expertise we developed to contribute to the creation and implementation of new global travel protocols, focusing on expanding the 100% Covid-tested flight system. Indeed, we regard the use of large-scale pre-departure rapid testing as one of the safest alternatives to current restrictions on non-EU travel flows, especially in respect of mandatory self-quarantine, as well as a protocol that would simultaneously increase passengers’ confidence. I am proud to say that the effectiveness of our health safety plan has been recognized by international bodies such as RINA, Airports Council International, ACI, and Skytrax, which rated Rome Fiumicino Airport with the highest score of five stars for its measures and protocols, as well as by primary international media that have endorsed the Covid-testing system available at Rome's airports.
To adapt to the new normal is a big challenge for all of us. I am confident that with efforts and international co-operation, we will succeed. I thank the committee for the time dedicated to me, and I remain available for any questions.
Comment on this
Mr. Bassato also sent the committee a presentation document. Is he going to comment on that document, or is that intended just for the information of the committee?
Comment on this
I submitted that for the information of the committee. If there is a possibility of going through it now, I will do so.
Comment on this
No, that is fine. There is no need for Mr. Bassato to do that. We have read that document and that is fine. We will proceed to the other witnesses. There will then be questions after that. I thank Mr. Bassato, and I call Ms Considine to make her presentation on behalf of Shannon Group.
Comment on this
I know it is said that a week is a long time in politics, but it is a very long time in aviation these days. The prospects for the global aviation sector have worsened as the virus continues its hold on our people, our way of life and our economy. The situation in which we now find ourselves as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic is a far cry from the positivity back in January, when we were anticipating growth across all our Shannon Group businesses, including the airport.
Since presenting to the joint committee on 7 October, the situation at Shannon Airport has deteriorated considerably, unfortunately. On 15 October, Ryanair announced its decision to temporarily close its bases at Shannon and Cork airports for the winter period. We have since moved into level 5 restrictions, and Ryanair has advised us that it has seen a total collapse in its forward bookings. The airline now plans to cancel its flights from Shannon Airport for a month, from 14 November to 12 December. This is really disappointing news for us and for the other airports affected. As a result, we now expect passenger numbers to be down by more than 80% by the end of the year.
This is also very disheartening for our airport employees, who have worked hard to keep the airport operational throughout the pandemic. There is genuine worry now among businesses in this region who rely on the connectivity that the airport provides and also for those involved in tourism who rely on inbound and outbound flights from Shannon Airport to make a living. There is great disappointment among our loyal customers as well, whose continued support we depend on. This latest announcement shows just how critical the situation has become, and how vulnerable the aviation sector is right now.
It copper-fastens the urgent need for targeted financial assistance to protect our airports, airlines and our air connectivity. To put the situation in context, we have had no transatlantic services operating from Shannon since March of this year. Two of our US carriers, Delta and United, have advised that they will not resume services into Shannon until 2022 at the earliest. Aer Lingus has also suspended its transatlantic and Heathrow services.
It is ironic that we have just marked the 75th anniversary of the first ever scheduled commercial transatlantic passenger plane which landed at Shannon Airport on 24 October 1945. As a result of that first transatlantic service, Shannon became the original airport gateway between the US and Europe, developing a strong transatlantic business and becoming the home to many global firsts for aviation.
All of this, unfortunately, is poles apart from where we find ourselves today. It creates a determination and resolve, however, to restore our lost connectivity. Since we last met, we welcomed the announcement in budget 2021 of €5 million capital funding for Shannon Airport. It will also provide for the extension of the employment wage subsidy scheme and the waiver on commercial rates. However, in light of the group’s revenues being down on average €1.3 million a week since the onset of the pandemic, we urgently require further supports.
The aviation sector is in free fall. As an island nation we need to connect to the rest of the world. Our economy is dependent on a thriving aviation industry. While recovery in the aviation sector is some time off, we must protect our nation’s air connectivity and our vital airport infrastructure. What we need now is a clear pathway to recovery for aviation, a robust system to allow us to get aviation moving. We welcome the decision by the Government to implement the EU traffic light system. There is still confusion, however, as to how it will be implemented which urgently needs to be addressed at EU level. There needs to be one streamlined, harmonised system that is applied throughout Europe for it to work in a meaningful way.
The continuation of current travel restrictions is heavily impacting passenger numbers. Testing instead of restriction on movements has to be the way forward.
Comment on this
-----and for further financial support for aviation as the Covid-19 shutdown of air transport continues.
To support the EU traffic light system, Shannon Group has called for the development and implementation of routine Covid-19 testing for passengers boarding flights out of the country, as this will help aviation to resume in a safe manner.
For our part, we are working closely with our peers in the industry and the Department of Transport. We are ready to roll out a pre-departure Covid-19 testing regime at the airport once agreed testing protocols are in place. Pre-departure testing is already proving effective in many other countries. A robust testing regime at airports can help to restore confidence and get aviation moving safely again.
Our economy is dependent on a thriving aviation industry and restoring air connectivity is now critical as we learn to coexist with the virus. In the meantime, we must protect our airports to ensure they can continue to do what they do best, namely, welcome passengers, play a crucial role in globalisation, connect cities and countries, foster economic activity and encourage international commerce and tourism, all of which generate employment in our regions.
While the latest news on the development of a vaccine is encouraging, we know recovery will take time. It is important we plan now for the safe restoration of air services. We urgently need to see the full implementation of the aviation recovery task force recommendations published on 7 July. These call for supports for aviation and, particularly in the case of Shannon, support for regional airports, as well as rebuilding and international connectivity. In the context of the devastating financial impact of this pandemic, there is an urgent need for Shannon Airport to be incorporated into the regional airports programme. This would see the airport receive vitally needed operational, as well as capital expenditure, supports.
As I have outlined to the committee previously, businesses on the western seaboard which rely on air connectivity to sustain their operations need critical air services from Shannon Airport to the UK, US, and, particularly in the context of Brexit, to a central European hub. None of these air services, however, will be viable until the markets recover which experts say could be as far out as 2024. In the context of the Covid-19 pandemic, which is ravaging the aviation sector across the globe, we are calling on the Government to provide financial supports for these vital air services until they can return to normal commercial levels of activity. We are asking the Government to support us to ensure these routes are not lost to the region.
We have taken many short-term difficult decisions in Shannon Group to deal with Covid-19 in order to preserve our businesses for the future. Shannon Airport is the hub which connects the region’s people and industry with the world. This will be needed more than ever as we recover from this crisis. Shannon Airport is a valuable State asset which needs to be protected and supported. We hope this will be provided for in the forthcoming national economic plan which we expect to be published next month.
Comment on this
Thank you, Ms Considine. I call on Mr. Philips, Dublin Airport Authority, to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for the opportunity to continue the discussion regarding the ongoing devastating impact of Covid-19 on the aviation sector. Since my last appearance before the committee on 7 October, we have lost a further 1.5 million passengers, the population of Dublin, Cork and Limerick cities combined.
The European Commission has also adopted the framework for a common approach to travel within the EU. The Government’s decision to adopt that framework is the first step on a long road to rebuilding our connectivity. Unfortunately, however, the final European framework did not go nearly as far as anticipated. While we have this traffic light system in place, the road ahead for safely reopening European aviation is still littered with obstacles. Of primary concern is the fact that EU member states will set their own testing and quarantine rules without harmonisation. What we need is a system that delivers effective EU-wide co-ordination.
The Government has yet to formally announce how it will apply the new traffic light system in Ireland. From comments made by the Minister of State at the Department of Transport, Deputy Hildegarde Naughton, when she addressed the committee last week, it appears that 14-day movement restrictions will continue to apply to passengers from red and amber countries. This may be waived for those arriving from amber areas if they have a negative pre-departure test. There is a suggestion that movement restrictions for those arriving from red areas may be reduced to five days if a person has a negative test five days after arrival in Ireland.
In contrast, the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control, ECDC, has noted that travel restrictions are of “questionable effectiveness” when community transmission is ongoing, which is currently the case in most of Europe. Accordingly, opportunities for any significant uplift in travel as a result of this system are likely to be extremely limited. Red and amber zones currently account for about 98% of our potential passengers. Travel restrictions will continue to apply to these passengers. Even when case levels decrease in other European countries, travel to Ireland will remain closed off if quarantines continue to apply. In our view, pre-departure testing for both orange and red zone locations would be a safer alternative as it would mean we could screen out a significant proportion of risk before a passenger arrives in Ireland. This view is shared by all of Europe’s airports and airlines.
A recent survey of consumers conducted for the International Air Transport Association, IATA, shows widespread support for testing rather than quarantines or movement restrictions.
Some 83% of consumers said they will not fly if they have to quarantine on arrival, but 88% said they are willing to be tested to facilitate travel. Two thirds of European countries now offer testing at their airports. As I noted previously, DAA had secured suppliers to deliver pre-departure testing facilities at our airports using PCR methodology as a first step. Unfortunately, thus far the State has not provided DAA with the planning exemption required to establish these facilities, which has been granted to others, and we cannot therefore offer on-site testing at our airports at this point. As there is market demand for pre-testing, we will share information on private sector providers via our websites and other channels, although our preference remains to offer pre-departure testing on site. We will continue to engage with the relevant authorities on this.
We have spent months working on potential pre-departure testing at our airports in the belief that there would be a harmonised European system and that the Government would unequivocally support a pre-departure testing approach. Unfortunately, this does not seem to be the emerging picture. An outbound testing facility is required to support reciprocal arrangements in other countries and to facilitate reinstating Ireland’s connectivity. Ultimately, the slow turnaround time and the cost of PCR means that it will not represent a viable, long-term testing option. To truly get people moving again we must look at rapid, affordable and scalable testing options such as loop-mediated isothermal amplification, LAMP, and antigen testing. In this respect, the Health Information and Quality Authority, HIQA, recently published a report which advised NPHET to consider implementing such tests. There is evidence to show that other countries are starting to embrace these technologies. We have just heard about it from Rome. Five airports are currently offering rapid testing, including Heathrow and Paris Charles De Gaulle. Ironically, it appears that under the Government’s planned application of the traffic light system, Ireland will accept a pre-departure antigen test if it is approved in another EU state, but will not endorse this system at home.
The view of the aviation industry is that without the traffic light model, EU member states should focus on pre-testing rather than other measures. However, if we fail to also improve the delivery and cost-effectiveness of the testing regime that underpins it, we will most certainly suffer further significant losses in services, as has been the unfortunate experience at Cork Airport recently and in what we have just heard from Ms Considine in Shannon. In closing, Christmas is just 58 days away. We want to welcome home our loved ones safely and to allow those living here who have not been able to see their families overseas to be reunited. We appeal for the committee's support for the adoption of a rapid, affordable, scalable approach to pre-departure testing that will facilitate reinstating travel in the long-term economic and social interests of our country.
Comment on this
Thank you. Before proceeding with questions from members, I have some questions. Mr. Bassato, with regard to the rapid testing that has been introduced in Rome airport, according to your presentation there is a 30-minute turnaround. What is the level of positive tests? Who pays for the test? Is it paid by the airport or through the ticket of the passenger? Who carries out the test? Are they employees of the airport or has the airport contracted it to a third party company? Furthermore, did the airport require planning permission from the state authorities to establish such a facility? How long did it take to establish it? I understand it is applied to 100% of passengers on the Rome to Milan flight. Perhaps, Mr. Bassato will give us an overall view. It is something we are seeking to promote here, but you are doing it in real time at Rome airport today so perhaps you will describe exactly how it works.
Comment on this
Currently there are two large screening operations going on in Fiumicino airport and one in Ciampino airport. We manage the two airports in Rome, Fiumicino, the biggest one, and the smallest, Ciampino. There are two operations in Fiumicino and one in Ciampino. The screening operation is directly managed by the health authorities of the region of Rome. Healthcare operations in Italy are under the exclusive authority of the 20 regions of Italy.
The operation started on 16 August following an order of the national government of Italy to test the passengers arriving from countries within the European Union who were considered tourists. The Italian rule now foresees that there are two different regimes. There were no restrictions on intra-EU travel up to that date, at least between the lockdown and 12 August. Then the government introduced restrictions, and I will discuss them in a few seconds. The second part of the regime is for passengers coming from non-EU destinations outside the external border of the European Union. In that case quarantine or self-isolation for 14 days and limitations and restrictions apply. The passengers were mandated to test when they came to Italy from 12 August and we implemented that requirement on 16 August, four days later. At that time the four countries within the Union that were considered highly at risk were Spain, Greece, Croatia and Malta. That list changed following the evolution of the pandemic on the Continent. Currently, there is a requirement for passengers to test before entering Italy - at the airport, where possible, or within 48 hours after entering Italy - if they are coming from the following European states: Spain, France, United Kingdom, Belgium, the Netherlands and Czech Republic. All the remaining European Union member states, including Ireland, are not subject to the limitations at present upon entry into Italy.
The passengers have two options. They are asked to test, negative or positive. If they test negative obviously there is a certain course of action. If they test positive there is another course of action. They can choose between the two options - molecular or antigen testing before leaving their country of origin within a time limit of 72 hours.
Comment on this
We will speak specifically about the system introduced at Rome airport for rapid antigen testing. There is 100% Covid antigen testing on a flight between Rome and Milan. Under the system that has been introduced, is the turnaround time 30 minutes?
Comment on this
What is the positive rate of tests among the people who have been tested? Who pays for the test - the passenger or the airport? Perhaps you will answer those questions on the rapid testing that has been introduced.
Comment on this
Okay. I confirm it is a rapid antigen test. It takes 30 minutes to provide a response once the nasal swab is taken. I cannot provide results about the positivity rate because that is not in our responsibility or ownership. They should be addressed to the regional health authorities in Rome.
It is provided for free to locals and foreigners.
Comment on this
How many passengers have been turned back and not allowed to fly because of a positive test?
Comment on this
In the case of Rome-Milan flights, it is in the range of 1% of the passengers. The exact figure should be requested from the health authorities.
Comment on this
Yes, it is in that range, as far as I know.
Comment on this
Will this be rolled out elsewhere in Italy? Does Mr. Bassato believe what has been produced has been a success to date?
Comment on this
The project has involved co-operation between the airport, the Alitalia airline and the regional health authorities. We think it is a success and Alitalia shares this view. We are discussing rolling out the project on other routes. Our main objective is to have partial testing on long-haul flights and partially reactivate connectivity between Italy and the rest of the world. We are in discussion with several parties in the industry and the authorities to achieve this.
Comment on this
I will speak first about the Covid infrastructure we may require in our airports if we are to facilitate rapid testing. This is a significant issue which was outlined to us by Mr. Philips. What is the issue around that? Will Mr. Philips expand on the issue that means they are not able to avail of a fast-tracked planning process for Covid infrastructure at airports?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. There are two routes to go in introducing pre-departure testing at the airports. In either case, permission is required. Statutory Instrument 93/2020 has been used, for example, in Croke Park. We have not been able to avail of that yet although we urgently need to set up a pre-departure testing regime. If we cannot get that, we would have to go the traditional planning route, which could take an inordinate period of time and is very costly. We are urgently waiting to see if we can use the statutory instrument at the moment but we have had no joy.
Comment on this
That issue is arising with the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage.
Comment on this
That is correct. It needs to be signed off by a Minister and at the moment there is a concern that we would be facilitating travel by having pre-departure testing but, as we know with the EU traffic light system, there will ultimately be reciprocity. If one wants to go to 11 of the major countries in the EU at the moment, one needs a pre-departure test. We are shutting ourselves off.
Comment on this
My next question is for Mr. Philips and Ms Considine. In terms of capital infrastructure projects ongoing at the airports or which had been planned in the next number of years, do the witnesses have any intentions to ask the Government for support with such projects, taking advantage of the quiet period with low levels of air traffic?
Comment on this
We need to do a material level of ongoing maintenance in Dublin and Cork each year. Ms Considine will speak for Shannon. It is €100 million plus in Dublin just to keep the lights on. Cork is in a very severe situation and needs about €70 million of capital over the next five years, which includes a total runway reconstruction. At the moment, when we are losing €1 million per day and running out of liquidity, we will have no option but to go back to the Government. That is part of the aviation task force.
Comment on this
With the review of the national development plan coming up in the next number of months, it is critical for the authorities of the airports represented here today to make their presentations to the Government on that. It is important that should happen. Does Ms Considine have something to say on that?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. As Mr. Philips said, we have critical maintenance work that needs to be done in the airport on an ongoing basis. Our airport averages €7 million to €8 million per annum for maintenance, safety, security and regulatory work. We included that in our budgets for next year and we welcomed the Government support of €5 million towards the completion of those projects for 2021. We have to put a level of matched funding against it and that is a challenge in the context of the significant losses we are incurring this year. That is why, in addition to capital support, we have asked to be included in the regional airports programme, which will provide a level of operational funding as well. Airports with fewer than 3 million passengers per year under EU state aid are entitled to get that support. However, the State-owned airports of Shannon and Cork do not currently get Exchequer support.
Comment on this
It is deeply worrying to hear that. There is a major requirement for the Department of Transport to act on that immediately in parallel with the Departments with responsibility for expenditure and capital investment. I am sure other representatives will follow up on that.
I will make a final point to Ms Considine and Mr. Philips. Transatlantic travel is important to the DAA and to Shannon Airport but it is also important we have political engagement with our respective colleagues in the US and Canada to get our transatlantic services resumed as quickly as possible. It is disappointing to hear it will be 2022 before transatlantic flights depart from Shannon Airport again. That needs to be expedited as much as possible if we see a recovery before then. I thank the witnesses.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. Mr. Bassato has come through an experience that Ireland is struggling with. I have a couple of questions which I hope he will be able to answer. In terms of rapid antigen testing, what is the sample? Is it a nasal swab, a throat swab or both? Who are the manufacturers and suppliers of the rapid antigen tests? What system is being used? Does Mr. Bassato know about the performance of the test? Does it meet the standard of clinical sensitivity of greater than 80%, which is a requirement set out in a recent report by our quality authority here?
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy. In answer to the first question, the rapid test is an antigen test made on a nasal swab sample. The name of the product chosen by the Italian health authorities is SD BIOSENSOR. This is in use in Rome but it may be that in other locations in Italy, other products will be used.
Information regarding the clinical performance of the test is not available to the airport authorities. I am sorry to say this again but it should be requested from the health authorities operating the testing.
Comment on this
That is no problem. Has the impact of the introduction of this system on the demand for flights and the number of people travelling been monitored or measured? If so, is the impact positive or negative?
Comment on this
We are proposing to the authorities the model of pre-departure testing after an improvement with the Rome-Milan route that is operationally feasible. The experience in Rome has been mainly of passengers arriving to Rome, following the regulations issued by the Italian Government. We observed that the number of passengers coming from those countries subject to an obligatory test upon arrival has been declining. On the Rome-Milan route, which we are testing only partially since 16 September, that is, almost a month and a half, there is stability in the number of passengers.
Comment on this
From the time of conception to the time of implementation, how long did it take to introduce this system? What sort of capital investment was required?
Comment on this
The level of capital investment required was limited. We had been planning with the authorities from early July until there was a mandatory requirement by the Government. With the authorities, we did some planning and prepared different scenarios for the evolution of the pandemic. When the order was introduced, it took four days. The level of capital expenditure was low because we began in an area that was available in the arrival hall, on the ground floor of the terminal. We dedicated about 1,000 sq. m to the operation. Of course, social distancing was required in the area.
The level of capital expenditure for the testing machinery and kits is not known accurately but I would say it is also low because the rapid antigen technology does not require a big investment.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Bassato for those responses. I echo a point made earlier by Mr. Philips. We are entering a scenario whereby we will accept people coming into this country on the back of a negative rapid antigen test but we seem to be indicating it is not satisfactory for people departing the country. There is an immediate contradiction in that position.
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy.
Is Mr. Bassato familiar with the EU traffic light system?
Comment on this
How would his system fit with the EU traffic light system itself? Does he recognise green, orange and red countries in the way the traffic light system is supposed to? Has he a view on that?
Comment on this
We are familiar with the system as members of Airports Council International Europe so we continue to listen to this discussion. The system itself has not been implemented yet in the country but we started with a similar regime. As I stated, the country experienced, in the first part of the summer of 2020, the importation of cases from abroad, in the first instance from countries far from the external border of the EU. In August, there was a surge of cases among passengers - many were Italian - coming back from holidays in Spain, Greece, Croatia and Malta. Some countries within the EU were identified as countries bearing a higher risk. They were not coded at the time as red or amber. I do not dispute that in the evolution of the legislation in Italy, the system based on the recommendations of the EU can be adopted by our Government. We have set out six groups of countries, three of which involve EU member states and three of which do not.
Comment on this
Mr. Bassato referred to two airports in Rome. Is the system he is talking about available in other airports in Italy?
Comment on this
It is available in national airports. Before entering the country, the requirement for testing applies to all means of transport, not only to air transport. It applies to passengers coming by train or automobile. Many airports, although not all of them, have screening operations on the way. Not all involve antigen screening. It is a question of which is most accessible to the passenger. The utilisation of antigen testing is growing, however, and the level is much higher by comparison with two months ago, for example.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Bassato. I have a brief question for Ms Considine on rebuilding confidence in the aviation sector and getting people to travel. It is obvious that we need a testing regime of our own. In her presentation, she confirmed that she has worked to apply such a system. Could she expand on that and explain the extent to which she can roll out testing at Shannon Airport and the numbers that can be catered for if the system is rolled out across Ireland? Does she envisage that it would be delivered by a private contractor?
Comment on this
On that query, we have engaged with a private commercial operator who is available to come on site to provide pre-departure Covid-19 testing. Initially, it would be PCR testing, which is more expensive and takes longer, but subject to approval regarding the LAMP testing, there would be capability to do as envisaged.
We have also engaged with our planning authority, who advises us that it does not consider planning to be required for this because it is ancillary to the airport's activity. In that regard, if there were agreed protocols on testing, we would be in a position to engage in implementation. Unfortunately, because of the ongoing travel restrictions, we will not have any scheduled airline services here for a month or so. That is very concerning. Everything we can do now to restore confidence and to get people back travelling will be really important. In the absence of that, however, the private operator would provide a service for other businesses in the region because we do not have enough volume at this stage to warrant an operator coming on site. It is important, therefore, that the service be made available to other businesses in the region, and there is willingness to do that. The service would be operated on site at the airport.
Comment on this
I welcome the presentations from all concerned. It is good to see representatives of Shannon, Cork and Dublin airports back before us. I compliment them on the work they have done in the intervening period. They have moved pretty fast in addressing the potential for testing. They have provided many answers in advance of the questions being posed today, which is welcome. We can rightly use a considerable amount of information from what we have heard about the situation in Rome. Bearing in mind the earlier session with the airlines, what is coming across to us today, and certainly to me, is that one of the main issues is that no matter what we do, we cannot do so in isolation in Ireland. We either move ahead or stall. Acting in isolation is effectively not going to be of any great benefit because we need to see the harmonised approach at European level. I suggest to the committee that we invite the Minister of State responsible for European affairs or the Minister for Foreign Affairs to our committee in due course to gain an understanding of the progress on achieving a harmonised approach before we conclude our work.
There has been talk of capital investment at Shannon Airport. Operational investment will be required. What is the current financial position? What assistance will be needed in the medium term? It is now quite clear, based on NPHET's advice, that there will not be a lot of activity between now and Christmas in the airports. Ms Considine has already painted a fairly dark picture as to what the early part of next year will be like. Can she outline the financial supports for the airport on which this committee might make recommendations?
Ms Considine has been working with the HSE on trying to find alternative employment for staff during this difficult period to help them to increase their incomes and pay their bills. It is really important. I thank her for the work she has done in this regard. Has she any update on that?
My next question is not relevant to my constituency but I am asking it because this is a transport committee.
Has the DAA looked at assisting staff who have had to take very significant drops in income? Have the witnesses looked at helping them to augment or supplement that through them acting as contact tracers with the HSE?
Comment on this
To address the Senator's question about funding, we have through the budget secured a contribution towards capital funding for next year, which is very welcome. The real challenge for us is the level of operational losses and in the context of that, our immediate ask of Government, which we hope will be included in the national economic plan, is inclusion in the regional airports programme, which would see us benefit from operational funding to cover essential costs like the cost of providing fire service and security cover at the airport. That would be an immediate ask of Government to help us survive this crisis so we can recover and rebuild.
The Senator referred to the ongoing dialogue with the HSE. We have engaged with our employees, a number of whom, particularly those on continuing temporary lay-off or on a reduced working week, would be interested in taking up additional work as contact tracers. We have passed that information to the HSE and are in ongoing discussions with it.
Comment on this
In the case of Dublin and Cork, we are in a very material downsizing at the moment. We are having to say goodbye to over a quarter of our workforce. Both Dublin and Cork have been heavily impacted. We do not see the recovery happening until 2023 to 2024 and, therefore, at the moment, we have to say goodbye to people permanently. We have a voluntary severance scheme in place. Having said that, Senator Dooley's suggestion about seeing whether we can connect people who are departing with the HSE if they have the requisite skills is a good one and I will follow up on it.
Comment on this
There is an element of see-saw because one would hope that when the aviation industry recovers, the necessity for testing and tracing will, hopefully, not be there by then.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses, particularly Mr. Bassato. I assume this probably gives us some element of solace of a possibility. I agree with Senator Dooley that we probably do need a discussion with either the Minister for Foreign Affairs or the Minister of State with responsibility for European affairs because we have had this discussion over the past two decades regarding harmonisation. What we can do is get our own ducks in a row. This committee will be discussing matters with NPHET and HIQA, particularly rapid testing, so we should build a conversation regarding the type of antigen testing that is being operated in Rome Airport. We need to reach some kind of conclusion and put some kind of framework together. I reiterate the point made by Deputy O'Rourke. We need some sort of pre-departure testing system that operates from here rather than just to here.
I accept that the airports are having significant difficulties, which means significant worries for workers. Could Mr. Philips address the proposal on new ways of working, which a number of craft workers have not accepted? They are now on 60% time. There is a belief among some of them that these are work practice changes and it is almost a case of "never waste an opportunity like this", namely, the Covid-19 pandemic.
As some workers working in terminal 2 are on contracts that are not as good as those of people working in terminal 1, they have an issue with pay parity while accepting the difficulties faced by the DAA at this point in time. We need an operating system across the board to get workers and management through this.
Comment on this
People make up 60% of our total cost base. The traffic is not coming back. We have lost 25 years of traffic and are back at 1995 levels. We are a commercial organisation that needs to fulfil a critical State role. If we do not lower our cost base, we will hit a wall and go bust. We are saying goodbye to about a quarter to a third of our workforce, somewhere between 750 and 850 people. For those who remain, we are saying that we can guarantee their wages at 80% with a plan to get them back to 100%, which is unprecedented in the sector because, as we know, many people are on significantly lower levels than that. We have balloted all our team members and 93% of the groups represented by ballots have voted in favour of the new work practices, which are very fair and in most cases, and I can use crafts as an example, have been in place for the past ten years. We are dealing with a group of craft workers who, unfortunately, are not in favour of these new work practices, which a number of their colleagues have been operating for the past ten years. I am talking about people in the same teams. We are working through that and will continue to engage. I am very closely involved here. We do not want to see anybody suffer and I wish it was not the case.
Regarding the Deputy's second question, we do have two people doing the same job in the same airport on different terms and conditions. This disparity between those who came in on new market-based contracts and those with slightly older contracts has existed for nearly ten years. It is something of which we are very aware. Where we can look to bridge that gap, we try to do so but we cannot do it in all cases. At the moment, it is particularly difficult.
Comment on this
I accept the difficulties but we need to reach whatever solution we can. I imagine that this is a wider conversation that the DAA must have with regard to Government and being able to ensure we deliver when we have operational aviation, as we, hopefully, will have if we go down the road of vaccines and antigen testing.
Comment on this
That is correct. Our North Star in this regard is to have market-based salaries so we do not want to see anybody below the market but we have situations where, with similar-type roles, some people are being paid the equivalent in the market but others are being paid above the market rate. This issue has been with us for a number of years.
Comment on this
I thank all the witnesses for returning so soon. We have two realities here. We have the reality of what has been happening in this committee over the past two days with all the witnesses increasingly frustrated and understandably angry at the lack of progress and we have the reality of the Minister for Transport cycling to a Cabinet meeting today saying that he would love to see airport testing take place. It is incredible. Based on everything we are hearing from witnesses, there is no urgency on the part of the Minister regarding this and he has not been taking the lead on this. This needs to be hammered home by this committee.
I thank our guest from Rome Airport for his wonderful presentation, which is a template for our Government. Our stakeholders are pushing this as hard this as possible. I have a few questions for Mr. Philips. There was a motion in 28 July 2020 in the Dáil regarding the proposed approval by Dáil Éireann of the Planning and Development Act 2000 (Exempted Development) (No. 3) Regulations 2020 concerning airport Covid temporary structures for passenger movement. That was brought in on 28 July. Can Mr. Philips speak to that? Does he have any visibility on that? I think he mentioned something to Deputy O'Connor.
There was no debate on it. It seems like there was some movement from the Department in terms of providing an exemption for temporary structures for Covid testing. That is the language used.
Comment on this
At the initial stages of this outbreak we thought we would to have to erect marquees outside to protect people because we assumed the traffic would come back at the beginning of July. Due to social distancing, we have reduced the overall capacity of the terminal by 70% and we would need to have people outside. We were aware of the planning exemption and were going to avail of it for things like temporary marquee structures.
Comment on this
Was that for testing or passengers?
Comment on this
We pressure tested it for external queueing areas. We have obviously followed up on SI 93 of 2020 to determine whether we could move forward with the planning exemption to introduce a testing facility. I was interested to hear Ms Considine from the Shannon Group say that through her planning authorities she thinks she will be able to get permission. We are not able to get it at the moment. Our only route at the moment is to go through the normal planning process which, as the Deputy knows, takes a huge amount of time.
On Deputy O'Rourke's point, we have to have pre-departure to get people out of the country. We cannot let all the other European countries do the work to get people in.
Comment on this
Cork Airport has been discussed. There is pressure on all our international and regional airports. We know Cork Airport is worth up to €1 billion a year to the economy of Cork and the south. What level of engagement has taken place between the Minister, Deputy Ryan, and the DAA on Cork Airport, in particular? I am very interested in the level of engagement with the Minister and senior officials on this. It is one of my lines of consistent questioning.
Comment on this
If it is okay with Deputy Smith, I am happy to bring in Mr. Niall MacCarthy, managing director of Cork. I am also happy to answer the question myself.
Comment on this
We are very active with all our Ministers, Deputies and Senators, including meeting the Taoiseach. We have engaged with the Minister of State with responsibility for aviation, Deputy Naughton, and the Minister, Deputy Ryan, through the DAA and directly. We are very pleased with the €5 million capital allocation, but our ask is united. The committee has heard that from every airline and airport. We have to get our act together on pre-departure testing.
Smaller airports will need financial, capital and regional supports. Airports and airlines traditionally spend their time disagreeing and in conflict, but the industry is united. It is on its knees and has had various announcements. Ms Considine adverted to Ryanair announcing further cuts in the past few days. If we do not get pre-departure testing soon, there will be very little aviation infrastructure available to return to.
We will need financial, capital and operational supports. We have €5 million in capital support and a substantial capital programme to get through in Cork, totalling €70 million over the next number of years. We built a new terminal in 2005 and have not really invested in capital since then because it was not needed, but the airport now needs a lot of airside infrastructure. This year we will lose in excess of €40 million in operating profits and €20 million after depreciation. We will need support. I hope that answered Deputy Smith's question.
Comment on this
I want to recognise the input of our witness from Rome, Mr. Bassato. He is a very good witness and I thank him from the bottom of our hearts here in Ireland for his input to the hearing. We will include his input in our report.
Comment on this
I thank the committee for the invitation. I remain available for the committee if required.
Comment on this
I just missed asking questions of our witness from Rome. Nonetheless, there are some very important questions I would like to ask. I would like to put a question to Ms Considine from Shannon Airport. As a Clare Deputy, I recognise that today's news is a huge blow to everyone in the airport. When did Ryanair and Aer Lingus communicate that they would not fly in and out of Shannon for a one month period and until April, respectively? How recently was that communicated to the Shannon Group?
Comment on this
Ryanair informed us only in recent days that there has been a total collapse in bookings, in particular since the imposition of the level 5 restrictions last Wednesday. This was very unfortunate and disappointing news. We were just coming to terms with the closure of the base and the fact that the number of Ryanair flights per week had been reduced to eight. To see those now being pulled for a month is disappointing.
We have been in ongoing dialogue with Aer Lingus. I do not think there is any surprise in what it has said today. It has constantly said that Heathrow would be the first route it would look to bring back. We originally understood the date would be 7 December, but obviously given the ongoing restrictions, the confusion that surrounds the adoption of the European traffic light system and the lack of pre-departure testing, it has advised us that it will not restore the flight until the introduction of the summer schedule next year, which is usually the end of March or the beginning of April. Transatlantic flights are on sale for the summer season next year.
Comment on this
It seemed to pull back on some of that as the discussions went on and said it would review things around Christmas time. I know the Shannon Group will play its part for the region, but it is very important that full clarity is brought to bear in that regard, in particular in the case of Aer Lingus whose departure from flying out of Shannon seems further off than its counterpart, Ryanair.
We sense the huge frustration from the airlines that there is not uniformity across the EU member states. Mr. Eddie Wilson from Ryanair said Germany, Italy, France and Spain had good regimes that are very workable in terms of dealing with orange and red regions. He felt that only those four member states out of 28 had good regimes in place. I understand the situation. In a vacuum of uniformity, there must be some departmental negotiation going on between the Department of Transport and the airports. What kind of run-in time is needed for a pre-departure testing regime from it being announced politically to having it operational?
Comment on this
As I said, we have commercial operators that are ready to come on site. We need agreement around the protocols, what type of testing is acceptable and when it will be effective. We hope that the Government announcement on 8 November will bring some clarity to that and we will be in a position to have the service available for passengers and other businesses in the region.
Comment on this
That is good. There is still huge uncertainty facing the sector. We have heard from the IAA yesterday and the airlines have come before the committee. They have all told us very honestly the flaws that they see in the traffic light system.
As someone who is heading Shannon Airport, is there anything Ms Considine feels can be done in terms of new policy or otherwise to instill public confidence in the sector? We all understand the need for a testing regime. Can anything else be done so that the committee could deliver a message to Government?
Comment on this
The clear adoption of the traffic light system is really important. We need to remove restrictions and replace them with testing. There have been significant discussions in the committee today. There is a unanimous call that there should not be restrictions for green-listed as well as amber and orange-listed countries and that there be pre-departure testing for passengers coming in. We would also need to reciprocate that from an Irish perspective. That is why the airports have done a lot of work to ensure they would be able to put testing in place. We also need an acceptance of the type of testing.
My understanding is that there is no acceptance of anything other than PCR testing, which obviously is the most expensive and takes the longest to deliver. There are certain things that the Irish Government could do today to improve this. For example, it could have clear communications, remove the ambiguity and try to restore some level of consumer confidence while we are living with this pandemic.
Comment on this
My last thing is more of a comment. Maybe Mr. Philips could respond briefly. He will not like what I have to say. I understand the north runway at Dublin Airport is scheduled for completion in early 2021. It is an awful lot of money to spend to increase Dublin Airport's dominance in the sector even further. I note that Mr. Philips, by his own figures, estimates that it will increase connectivity by 34%. It is retrograde, and I know that it was funded a number of years ago and is near completion. Where is the DAA at in terms of delivering the additional dominance project beyond the Covid-19 pandemic? I know that like every organisation, the DAA is facing an immediate crisis, but beyond the Covid pandemic, where is the project in terms of its delivery? I would like Mr. Philips to explain that to us. Coming from County Clare, I fear what it will bring. I would appreciate it if he could update us on the status of the project.
Comment on this
It is a very fair challenge. I would say that neither Dublin Airport nor Cork Airport sets the market; passengers set the market. Airlines choose where they will travel based on passenger demand. Dublin Airport competes for routes against Manchester, Copenhagen and Vienna airports, for example, rather than against Shannon or Cork airports. When a large airline has a new aircraft to deploy, it will deploy it between two points on a map. If it thinks there is a market, it will deploy its aircraft to that end. We will be competing against all these other airports to win that business. We have to demonstrate for Dublin, and also for Ireland. In many cases, we are represented with the Industrial Development Authority, Enterprise Ireland, Tourism Ireland and Fáilte Ireland. We go in as a bloc to say to Qatar Airways, for example, that it should put the aircraft on the Doha-Dublin route, rather than the Doha-Copenhagen route, because this is the size of the market. A route lost to Dublin is a route lost to Ireland. It is not an issue of whether it is Dublin Airport or Shannon Airport. The airlines will choose where they go based on the demand.
On the question of the runway, we are near completion. Dublin Airport has been operating at capacity for many years now. We have the greatest admiration for what Ms Considine and the team do in Shannon Airport. This is not about us winning a Doha flight from Qatar Airways in a competition between Dublin Airport and Shannon Airports - it is about us competing with airports like those in Copenhagen, Manchester or Vienna.
Comment on this
In the Fine Gael slot, I will bring in Deputy O'Donnell, who joins the committee via video link.
Comment on this
I have a few questions for the witnesses. Have they had any interaction with NPHET to put the case for pre-departure rapid antigen or other types of testing? I would like them each to provide a brief response to that question. Perhaps Ms Considine could start.
Comment on this
We have liaised with our own officials in the Department of Transport but we have not liaised directly with NPHET. However, I understand that other peers in the industry have done so.
Comment on this
We have had a lot of interaction with NPHET and its members, with the national viral research laboratory and with other key bodies.
Comment on this
What has been the feedback? I ask the witness to answer honestly.
Comment on this
The feedback is that there is a real reluctance to open up the borders. I am not a scientist, but I know that the data from the HSE's own website show that if one takes the incidence rates over 14 days, for any number of weeks, the average number of positive Covid cases attributed to foreign travel is less than 20, or less than 0.05%. We have been challenging around the need to get something that is rapid and scalable, and not just PCR, but LAMP or antigen testing.
Comment on this
Would that tie in with what Mr. Bassato told the committee, whereby roughly 1% to 2% of passengers who are getting tested on the Rome to Milan flight appear to be positive?
Comment on this
We have had over 120,000 people come into the country in the last 14 days, and less than 20 incidences of positive Covid cases have been attributed-----
Comment on this
Do those numbers relate to those travelling into Dublin Airport, Cork Airport, or overall in Ireland?
Comment on this
That is overall. There are three simple questions that the Government needs to answer here. First, do we do pre-departure or post-arrival tests? It is a simple answer - one or the other.
Comment on this
All the airlines and airports are saying that it should be pre-departure. The second question is whether antigen or PCR testing should be used. I am not a scientist, but it seems to me that the veracity of the testing of antigen is becoming so sophisticated that we can go with antigen testing, which is rapid and scalable. The last question is what we should do with the amber and red countries. Do we allow pre-departure for both, or just one? They are three simple questions. If we can do that, we can get the country open again.
Comment on this
We will put those questions to both Dr. Tony Holohan and Mr. Ryan next week when they appear before the committee. Has Mr. MacCarthy had contact with NPHET, or would that have been done through the DAA?
Comment on this
We are all working together on this because it makes no sense to be competing. We have a member of staff assigned to the overall DAA team on testing and we are sharing all of our data with Shannon Airport. We would be competing for airlines, but in terms of testing, we want everyone to have the best, so therefore all three organisations are unanimous on this issue. PCR is too slow and expensive.
Comment on this
It takes 24 to 48 hours. It would get us up and running with something, but it is too expensive and slow. LAMP testing is a really good alternative, as is antigen testing, which was mentioned by the witness appearing from Rome.
Comment on this
Does Mr. MacCarthy know roughly what the cost of the three types is? What is the cost of the antigen test per passenger?
Comment on this
The antigen test is the cheapest. The antigen test can cost from €10 to €30 per passenger, the LAMP test is more substantial, and the PCR test is the dearest.
Comment on this
If pre-departure antigen testing were required, who would the organisations want to pay for that? Would the airports themselves cover the cost, like the airport in Rome?
Comment on this
To be clear, the airport in Rome does not cover the cost. It is the health authority that is covering the cost in Rome.
Comment on this
What view do Mr. Philips and Ms Considine take on the particular cost issue?
Comment on this
The cost in antigen testing is going to drop dramatically. I met with a supplier this morning who thinks they can offer world-class antigen testing for €6 per test. When we are down at that level, it is really a debate about where the responsibility for paying the cost sits. I think it should be borne by the passenger, but we can debate that.
Comment on this
We would be looking at the passenger paying for it, because at the moment, what we would be proposing through this commercial operation would be PCR and LAMP testing, and they are expensive. That is why we are collectively saying today that we need to move to rapid and more cost-effective testing.
Comment on this
Are we looking at a turnaround of 30 minutes for rapid, antigen and LAMP testing?
Comment on this
If the Government was to come out tomorrow and say it was moving ahead with a traffic light system from 8 November 2020 - for green countries, no tests would be required; for amber countries, pre-departure tests would be required; and restrictions would be in place for red countries - how quickly could the individual airports have their pre-departure testing systems up and running?
Comment on this
I am happy to go with that. We could be up and running in a matter of days, but we need planning permission to put that structure in place. We have facilities ready to go, but we do not have planning permission.
Comment on this
Has the DAA found a way to get around the planning issue? Is there a technical point whereby a response is required from the Government or the planning authority? Can it be provided under existing legislation?
Comment on this
We could go for retention but we know many other facilities have been given planning exemptions and it was done overnight with the Minister's signature.
As to the traffic light system, there is a lot of confusion on red at the moment. We are saying that amber is pre-departure testing but red should be also pre-departure testing because we do not want to import the virus and then have to deal with it here.
Comment on this
On a question to Ms Considine, how quickly would Shannon be up and running with pre-departure testing and what would be the cost?
Comment on this
I do not have a cost for antigen because that is not an accredited testing regime at the moment. We could be up and running in a matter of days with PCR or lab testing but antigen is the most cost-effective.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses, in particular for their patience. I compliment the committee because what we have heard today from our colleague in Rome gives us all very strong food for thought in terms of the direction in which we need to go. I was particularly concerned about the presentation by the Ryanair CEO, Eddie Wilson, this morning, where he said that if something is to be done for Cork and Shannon, it must be done now. He also spoke about the lack of communication with the airlines by the Ministers. Would Ms Considine like to comment about the lack of communication the airlines say they have received from the Ministers? The Irish Times is telling us these cancellations could have been averted.
Comment on this
I cannot comment for the airlines. I heard Mr. Wilson's comments on the lack of dialogue with Ministers. For our part, we have been in ongoing discussions with the officials in the Department of Transport and with Oireachtas Members, and we have briefed both the Minister of State and the Minister for Transport, Deputy Ryan. They are all aware of the challenges we are facing in the business. We have heard the industry and the airports collectively saying we all need to work together. If we want to reopen aviation in a safe manner, we need to adopt the European traffic light system, it needs to be harmonised across Europe and we need to adopt pre-departure testing. The most effective test would be the most cost-effective, which is antigen. We have all flagged that if things are not done quickly, the risks are very severe for airports like ourselves. Ryanair had flagged for a good while that the market had collapsed and that if we did not reopen aviation, these services were at risk. Unfortunately, this has come to pass.
Comment on this
Yes. In fact, he went on to threaten next summer's business as well, which I found particular disconcerting in regard to Shannon. I want to broaden out the conversation to ask Ms Considine about leverage. What leverage does Shannon Airport have right now in this marketplace? We are all horrified that there are going to be no flights out of Shannon for over a month, in effect. However, while Aer Lingus has cut back services, it has kept a service from Cork and there are services from Dublin. Why has Shannon been singled out as the airport that has no services for the next three months at a minimum?
Comment on this
I cannot speak for Aer Lingus. We are in ongoing dialogue with it and it is a very important customer to us and services very important markets. Transatlantic services are key for us and, obviously the Heathrow service is our main hub into Europe at the moment, before Brexit. It is a really important customer and we have been in ongoing dialogue with it. The reality is that Covid has decimated aviation and decimated demand. The restrictions in place means people have been advised not to travel except for essential purposes, and we are not supposed to travel beyond 5 km from our home unless it is for essential work. That is the reality. The Government is advising people not to travel and, therefore, the demand has fallen through the floor and nobody is booking flights. As a consequence, the airlines have made the very difficult decision to pull services. This is devastating for us. It is devastating for our employees and for the people of this region, who rely on the services. That is why we all need to do everything we can to get aviation reopened in a safe manner.
We all know there will be a very slow recovery and that is why the measures we are calling for are so important until normal commercial activity resumes. All the analysts say it probably will be 2024 before the market resumes at normal activity levels. After that, they are talking about up to five or ten years before there is a full recovery in yield. That is a real concern and is why supports are needed in the near term and medium term as we recover from this crisis.
Comment on this
My final point is a key one. I am not convinced that Shannon as a stand-alone airport has the leverage to win back that business in the difficult next three or four years. It is striking to note that 96% of the airport growth prior to this crisis was all on the east coast. I cannot understand how people in the mid-west can benefit from a model which puts Shannon in direct competition with Cork and Dublin. Is it not time for a rethink?
Comment on this
Obviously, aviation policy is that we have two State airport authorities. For our part, we are very focused, as part of the Shannon Group, on driving not only passengers through the airport but growing the economy footprint of this region. That is why we have invested almost €130 million in the region. This has not only addressed historic underinvestment in the airport but it has also brought new property solutions to the market and new investment to the region, which in turn supports services. The committee will have heard others today say airlines need demand. They will not just fly to a place; there has to be a reason to do it, so there needs to be economic activity and tourism in the region. We are investing in driving our economic footprint and in tourism products and all of that in turn will support the airport.
It is a real chicken and egg situation. The air services to the airport are a real selling point in trying to attract new industry into the region. That is the starting point and we need to continue to invest in growing this region. Prior to Covid, we were on a growth trajectory and we expected growth in the airport, growth in the commercial property business and growth in Shannon heritage business, and our aviation custom has grown from over 40 companies in the group in 2014 to over 80 today. I cannot agree with the Senator that this has not worked. We were on a growth trajectory but Covid has just decimated everything. Our colleagues in Dublin and Cork say the same. Traffic into the country is down 90% so we are all on our knees at this stage.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for their contributions. We heard earlier from the airlines and we are hearing now from those working in the airports and the aviation sector on the ground. Something we heard a lot about today is demand, to which Ms Considine also referred. An issue of great concern to me, and I hope to the witnesses as well, is the toxic aspect that has developed around aviation in Ireland, which has not happened in other European countries. It is something we need to tackle. I am sure the public at large will read what has been said here today by the representatives of the aviation industry in Ireland, and see the extraordinary measures they have taken to ensure that aviation is safe again and to ensure we can get planes back in the air and passengers through our airports. That is the key message that needs to come out of today's meeting.
Another important message is that the Government must now realise, after hearing all the evidence given to this committee, that it has to take action to commence pre-departure testing and antigen testing. I certainly will be talking to the Taoiseach and to the Minister for Transport following the appearances at this committee. This is critical and we need to champion it, as a country.
Ireland is incredibly dependent on the aviation sector for its economy and society. As many as 140,000 jobs are supported by the aviation sector in Ireland, which means 140,000 incomes for families across the country. It is time that people started to look with some degree of perspective at how important the sector is to this country. We cannot afford to make any more mistakes. I thank the witnesses for the information given but it is time for the Government to act. I will allow in Deputy Crowe to conclude.
Comment on this
In light of today's devastating announcements by Ryanair and Aer Lingus, I ask Ms Considine what will one see flying in and out of Shannon Airport, apart from cargo flights, between now and Christmas?
Comment on this
While Ryanair has cancelled its flights for the month what we will be left with, for that duration, is cargo flights and cargo movements morning and evening. We will have a level of transit operations that goes through the airport. We will also have general aviation. We will facilitate the movement of aircraft in and out of our hangar facilities. We have a large cluster of maintenance, repair and overhaul or MRO operators based around the airport so it is important that we maintain services for those because they are significant employers in the region. We will have no scheduled traffic which is devastating for the airport and it is the first time that I can ever remember anything like this. It is very concerning and that is why we need urgent action now. We cannot afford to be back here in another month talking about the same stuff. We need action now.
Comment on this
Can Mr. MacCarthy say what is left at Cork Airport after today's announcement?
Comment on this
We were starting on a relatively good base. We had nine scheduled airlines and 51 scheduled routes in Cork. Aer Lingus is continuing to operate into Heathrow and, periodically, into Amsterdam and have just indicated that they will continue to do so through the depths of whatever the crisis unfolds.
A new airline that we launched last year is KLM. We have a very successful relationship with KLM into Amsterdam. The Dutch royal family came over to be associated with the inaugural flight and presented us with some stuff. KLM has agreed that it will continue to operate. So we will have two scheduled airlines. We also have search and rescue, transplants, general aviation, the Air Corps and so on.
In passenger terms, we will be down by 95% but we will be open with scheduled airlines and scheduled routes.
Comment on this
Everyone is digesting today's announcement. Can Ms Considine state whether it has implications for the level of staffing with the Shannon Group? So far, the Shannon Group have had to take measures as an airport authority. We also know what Ryanair and Aer Lingus have had to do and the resistance with which that has been met by workers. Has the Shannon Group, on foot of what we have heard today, considered altering the current staffing level at the airport? Is there added cause for concern people should be made aware of right now?
Comment on this
Obviously this is new news to digest. We are evaluating it now. As it will be very challenging for us to maintain 24-7 operations in light of the reduction in scheduled services, we are evaluating all of our options now. First and foremost, we will engage with our own employees and will discuss it with them over the coming week. That will be our priority. We will be communicating with the airlines that continue to operate through the airport.
We have already taken difficult decisions and a number of measures. We had to take them to manage our cost base and preserve liquidity since this crisis hit us. Those measures are continuing.
Comment on this
I wish to follow up with a line of questioning. Mr. Philips, if rapid testing is not introduced by the Government as part of the opening of the European traffic system on 8 November where will Irish aviation be over the next six months?
Comment on this
We are at 1995 levels now so we have lost 25 years of growth. The country has been shut down essentially because there is only a smattering of flights coming in and out. We are down 95% and will continue at that level. For the 140,000 people in the sector it is a hammer blow. I see it as much wider than that, as I am sure the committee does, as a stranglehold on the overall economy and our ability to rebound in a post-Covid, post-Brexit world.
Comment on this
What would Mr. Philips say to people who have the view that flying in and out of Ireland is unsafe on public health grounds? Safety concerns is the countercharge that has been put forward. I ask Ms Considine and Mr. MacCarthy the same question.
Comment on this
I would say one would have to look at the data. The Covid reaction has been driven on data, which is why this country is at level 5. The data show, categorically, that the level of imported cases in totality is less than 2% of all cases and in respect of the 14-day average, less than 0.5% of all positive cases in the country are attributed to foreign travel. The data do not support the stranglehold that is on the country today. There are testing technologies, be it the polymerase chain reaction, PCR, or antigen tests that can be scaled and not just open up the aviation sector, devastating as it is for Cork and Shannon, but open up the country.
Comment on this
As it stands at the moment, Mr. Phillips, is the level of cash the DAA is burning per week for it to continue to exist in the public domain?
Comment on this
We will lose well over €200 million this year. We are rapidly depleting our cash reserves. If we do not open this country up we are going to be in a very severe state. On a wider level, when Shannon or Cork loses a route, it will not come back next year when things get better because that asset is redeployed somewhere else in that airline's network or sold and bought by another airline but is used somewhere else. It can take between four and six years to develop a route for Shannon, Cork and Dublin.
Yesterday, 19 people flew in on a flight from Dallas-Fort Worth on an American Airlines aircraft that probably cost €150,000 just to fly the route that day. That airline is ceasing operations and we will not get them back into this country in a hurry, which is a hammer blow for this country's links to the southern states of the US.
Comment on this
The Government needs to make three decisions and it can make them based on the data. Do we carry out pre-departure or post-arrival testing? Everybody has said it should be pre-departure but the Government needs to make the decision.
Do we do antigen or PCR testing? Today, we have heard from Rome airport about a very credible example of where antigen testing is now at a level of accuracy that competes with PCR testing, and is scalable.
Comment on this
Yes, it costs €6. What do we do for the people coming from a red country in terms of pre-departure testing or post-arrival testing and making them quarantine for five days? These are three simple questions.
It is not beyond the wit of man to get around the table and answer these questions and start opening it up. As I said, this is not about the aviation sector, it is much bigger than that.
Comment on this
Is Ms Considine at liberty to give us an indication of the level of cash the Shannon Group is burning at the moment? How can it survive? Does she regard 8 November as D-Day?
Comment on this
To give a quick response to the question, we have indicated already that our group revenue is down more than €1.3 million on average per week since the pandemic hit us in March. The committee can imagine how significant that is for an entity of our size. We have put difficult measures in place to reduce the amount of cash burn and that has been hard. It has been very difficult for staff who have had to take pain. We initially reduced hours of operation and we need to look at that again, so it has been tough. We have taken a number of measures to try to ensure we can trade our way through this but the longer it goes on, the more difficult it is and that is why operational support would be very important to us. On reopening the country, as an industry we have stepped up to the plate. We very quickly implemented all the measures to try to rebuild consumer confidence. We have made the journey through the airport as contactless as possible. We are, as an entity, advocating for pre-departure testing to restore confidence and working with the European traffic light system, and the committee has heard Mr. Philips talking about the decisions the Government needs to take. We have stepped up to the plate, as an industry, we have done all we can. We want to reopen aviation in a safe manner, we are very conscious of our public health obligations and we do not believe aviation is contributing to the spike in virus rates across the country that we are currently experiencing. It is certainly not the cause of us moving to level 5 restrictions, so we need to have a grown-up conversation and decisions need to be taken quickly about reopening the country.
Comment on this
We are an island nation. We are pioneers of aviation. If one looks at Australia, Mr. Alan Joyce of Qantas, is from Tallaght. If one looks at British Airways, Mr. Seán Doyle is from County Cork. The first duty-free operation in the world was in Shannon Airport. Aer Rianta International is in duty-free. We have the leasing sector-----
Comment on this
-----so we cannot just consider this in terms of airports and airlines. We have a massive ecosystem here where we were, and are, pioneers but we are definitely falling behind with testing. We will destroy this great industry and that whole supply chain if we do not mobilise in terms of testing. We have the largest low-cost carrier in Europe headquartered in Swords, and we have a really prestigious transatlantic carrier headquartered in Dublin as well. Tourism is our biggest employer and aviation feeds tourism. It used to be agriculture but tourism is now the biggest indigenous employer in Ireland. This whole supply chain is being collapsed, and it is billions and billions of euro.
Rapid testing is the first piece on the road to recovery. On the second question of cash burn, we have spoken about capex before. We need to go into the regional airports capex scheme. At Cork Airport, in operational expenditures we have burned €14 million in cash before capex this year and probably a similar amount next year.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. MacCarthy. Dr. Holohan and the Minister, Deputy Eamon Ryan, will be before the committee next. We will address what can be done to bring in pre-departure rapid testing on 8 November.
Comment on this
I refer to something Mr. Philips said. It is something I believe would have been the case heretofore, that is, this idea of losing a route and being unable to have it returned for probably three to five years. Would Mr. Philips accept that this is a very untypical situation? It is not as if an asset is being moved to another location. The fact is there will be, as part of the recovery, more than an oversupply of aircraft dotted throughout the world, so as part of our recovery there will not be a shortage of aircraft, that is for sure. If we can get a framework in place that gives confidence to airlines that we, as part of the European Union as a bloc, are serious about living with the effects of Covid and perhaps the aftereffects of it, does Mr. Philips believe that will be enough for the airline industry to come back more quickly on routes, since the supply of aircraft will not be the issue? If anything, it will be the degree of confidence among the travelling public that will be the guiding light more so than the availability of aircraft.
Comment on this
I really hope the Senator is right. The reality is that airlines' balance sheets have been stretched to enormous levels, so airlines are having to massively restructure their own businesses and downsize them. What they are doing is getting rid of the aircraft. A new route can cost about €3 million per year to get up and running. That is the sort of cash burn one loses when starting a new route. When one starts a new route one does so with a long-term horizon and to be going back to airlines now and saying, "Invest €3 million in a route to Cork, to Shannon or to Dublin" is going to be a really hard ask. We are out of kilter with the rest of Europe because we are the most closed. There is absolutely a balance-----
Comment on this
I am sorry to interrupt Mr. Philips. Which country is closest to us in terms of that deeper level of restrictions being in place?
Comment on this
The UK is pretty close at the moment but we are an outlier there. There is an absolute balance-----
Comment on this
Of course, the US, from a European perspective, is closed.
Comment on this
There is an absolute balance here in terms of public health and I would not like for a moment to suggest that we, as an industry, are not putting public health first and foremost. It has to be. However, it feels that this is a sector that is being held to a different standard from the rest of the country.
Comment on this
I accept that and I believe I made the point at an earlier session that if representatives of the clothing retail sector were before us, I suspect they would feel they were carrying an undue burden too. I suspect they would make the point that some of the airlines made, namely, that there are no cases of transmission of the virus in a clothes shop, in the same way as Mr. Wilson sought to sort of portray the industry by saying that because it did not happen on a plane that it was not an issue. However, decisions have to take more into account.
Comment on this
We have had zero risk. This sector has been closed down for eight months whereas the clothing sector has been open, one could argue now it is-----
Comment on this
Could Mr. Phillips make the case that if rapid antigen testing came in at airports, it would improve public health in terms of risk where the virus is concerned?
Comment on this
I am really stretching beyond my area of expertise. I can only tell you what I am hearing-----
Comment on this
It is staggering. This morning I was talking to a supplier of very powerful antigen testing and the data are really very compelling. I said, "I am not a scientist but surely when you share these data with NPHET it seems robust". Antigen testing seems to be the way to open up the country safely.
Comment on this
We have to take everything into perspective. Ms Considine will be familiar with some of the geography I talk about but if one lives in Tulla, as I do, and somebody else is living in Lissycasey in west County Clare, there are more than 5 km between us. At the moment we are being told we cannot travel between those two locations so there is that difficulty with saying we should open up the air routes because that is what the sector wants. One must balance public opinion and public acceptance of the restrictions which they are being asked to undertake as well. I feel we should be at level 3 and not level 5 but that is a moot point now, and we have moved on from that. There would be very considerable resistance among the public if a person had an issue going from Tulla to Lissycasey because it is outside the 5 km radius but could toddle down to the airport and head off to Spain for a week's holidays. While Mr. Philips is putting forward a very good case for the next phase of recovery, and we should be doing the work now to understand what that framework should look like, in the current climate one could not run the two systems in parallel.
Comment on this
We were here on 7 July and we talked about pre-departure testing, when the country was not at level 2, 3, 4 or 5. I totally understand the sentiment now that we are in level 5 but once we come out of level 5, we need to be ready to go. We need to be pumped, primed and say "Let's go" but we are not.
Comment on this
That is the point I am making, lest those who are watching this committee think that somehow we are suggesting that all this should be taking place in the current restrictions. We are looking at the short to medium term to have our ducks in a row when the suppression rates improve and where NPHET is at a point where it is able to recommend to Government an easing of our domestic restrictions, so that there is some kind of parallel environment that says, "It is okay for me to visit Lizzie Casey again and it is okay to head to wherever in Europe has the same level of the virus as the broader region of Ireland". I just wanted to put it in context.
Comment on this
I believe there is agreement across the board that we need a framework. If we had this framework and rapid antigen testing or whatever types of testing tomorrow, we still would not have a huge number of flights. I accept that the aviation sector has an argument for what it terms the "lost period", but we are where we are at this point in time. I believe there is a worry about getting harmonisation across Europe. The witnesses have spoken on the difficulties the sector is having and about ensuring the sector has the capacity to operate afterwards. There needs to be a straight conversation on what the sector is asking for now. With the best will in the world, and even if all this was put in place, the sector will probably not experience significant travel until next summer. Hopefully, that will be in a period when vaccines will start to roll out, combined with having proper antigen testing.
Comment on this
We just need clarity on what the next steps are. The European Union framework was adopted two weeks ago.
Comment on this
We are hearing about 8 November. What is happening on 8 November so we can scale up for it and be ready? We are 58 days away from Christmas. That is the number one ask in the short term. For the medium term we need liquidity support for the sector. Cork Airport will just run out of cash and I am sure Ms Considine will be in the same situation at Shannon Airport, but I will let her speak on that.
Comment on this
Okay, a testing regime and money.
Comment on this
I am sorry to have to dip in and out of the meeting, such is the nature of Covid-19. Mr. Philips referred to the liquidity ask with regard to Dublin and Cork Airports. I ask the same question of Ms Considine.
I want to also ask about the risks associated with flying. Earlier we discussed the argument that the risk is minimal. I believe it is a question of managing the risk. There is far greater opportunity in having a frank conversation on it and saying there are risks associated with it. That is why we have quarantines. It is about managing those risks. It is far better to be tested negative getting onto the plane than a one in 27 million chance of getting Covid while on the plane. This stresses the need for testing. How quickly could we deliver testing at the airport if we decided today that it was going to happen and if we decided on a methodology, perhaps PCR now and then moving to rapid antigen testing when people are satisfied that this is sufficient? On the threshold of greater than 80% clinical sensitivity, I would make the point that there are many rapid antigen tests that meet this bar while sometimes PCR tests do not meet the bar. This is what we are dealing with. If these measures were to be implemented how quickly could testing be done at airports? Will Ms Considine also comment on the liquidity demands of Dublin, Cork and Shannon Airports?
Comment on this
On foot of that, have the airport groups had discussions with Government and the Departments on their liquidity requirements?
Comment on this
I am happy to take the question. Once we have clarity on the testing protocols we should be ready to go in a matter of days. It is critical that we get clarity on the type of testing. Ideally, we would all like the rapid antigen testing, but failing that we are ready to go with PCR testing. It needs to be clarified quickly. We have already talked at length on that today.
On the liquidity, our revenues are down on average €1.3 million per week since the onset of the pandemic. This is extremely significant for an entity of our size. While we have taken measures to reduce costs and reserve liquidity, it is now critical in light of the slow recovery envisaged for the industry and given the recent announcements by Ryanair on closing its bases through the winter and Aer Lingus not resuming its services from Shannon until the summer schedule of next year. At this stage we have only one confirmed US carrier for next year, which is American Airlines, but this is all dependent on how the virus evolves between now and then and where we are with the vaccine. There is a huge number of variables and that is why we need clarity on the supports we are going to get from Government. We hope that the national economic plan in November will address that. It is really urgent that we are included in the regional airports' programme, which will provide operational funding as well as capital funding. We need to continue to provide a level of operational facilities such as cargo movements, general aviation transits and a resumption of scheduled traffic, albeit we will not get back up to normal levels of activity. To do all that there is a significant cost to keeping the airport open. This is why operational funding will be very important to sustain us through this recovery.
Comment on this
We can get up and running in a matter of days, we just need the planning exemption. On liquidity, the Cork Airport situation is acute. Dublin Airport's situation is slightly different whereby we are using up all our capital reserves that we had put aside and apportioned for infrastructure development to help fuel Dublin's economy, and I would argue Ireland's economy. All the money that was reserved for infrastructure is now being depleted on operating costs because we are losing €1 million a day. The challenge there is that we will need new infrastructure to bounce back out from Covid and Brexit. That money is being wasted, or being used up, keeping the airport alive, so to speak. We have shared all this with the Government.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Philips, Ms Considine and Mr. MacCarthy for their engagement with the committee. We will have follow-on hearings next week with the Chief Medical Officer and chairman of NPHET, Dr. Holohan, and with the Minister for Transport, Deputy Eamon Ryan, around the whole area of testing and the HIQA report. I hope the witnesses will tune into it. The committee will then issue a report.