We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Transport, Tourism and Sport

Governance Review Group Report for the FAI Board and Sport Ireland: Sport Ireland

Contributions 166–342 of 342. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I do not like asking this question, but I feel I must. Has this process caused any concern or public trust issue in respect of Sport Ireland and how it deals with grants to sporting authorities?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

I do not think it has caused public trust issues. This committee asked us to review our terms and conditions and strengthen them. I think we have done that substantially without going into the regulatory role. We work in collaboration with organisations. We have so much power over these organisations. At the same time, they are autonomous organisations. If we give funding to an organisation and auditors come back confirming that funding was expended for the purposes for which we gave it, I am not sure we can do much more.

We have taken more steps regarding our terms and conditions of funding. The last time we appeared before this committee, we heard about the complete audit of organisations. We have taken that on board and put it into our terms and conditions of funding. I think it is okay because if taxpayers' money is going into any organisation, it needs to stand over its financial procedures. We took that advice from this committee on board and the board implemented it straightaway. We have acted in the best interests of the taxpayer, the Minister and this committee in the recommendations. We take these committee hearings very seriously. We go away and think about how we will react. As we demonstrated today, we have come up with a clear action plan from the previous committee meeting we attended. We have been very proactive.

Comment on this

I recall asking Mr. Treacy if any lessons had been learned from that meeting. I felt I had to ask the question because people had mentioned it and it gives Mr. Treacy the opportunity to come back.

Comment on this

Forgetting everything else, the FAI is not a charity, it is a company. Many of the reforms are processes within committees and so on, which I fully support. What is happening in the context of making the association fully accountable under the Companies Acts? What would happen if there was an insolvency? What role would Sport Ireland have in that regard? This is a serious issue. There is the possibility of a hugely adverse event.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Mulvey

On fiscal responsibility and as Mr. Treacy noted, we have expanded our terms of reference in terms of the obligatory and extensive nature of grant reporting obligations. We have been informed, legally and corporately, that this is okay. It arises from the controversies that arose not only in the FAI but also in other sporting and charitable organisations. We are heavily reliant on other State agencies, particularly the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement, which has a regulatory function under the Companies Act. On my last appearance before the committee, I may have posed the question as to who audits the auditors, but we also rely on auditors to do absolute due diligence. It came as a surprise to everyone that Deloitte placed in a H4 notice on previous accounts of the FAI. We do not have the competence or skill to undertake those audits. We have our own audit unit but, ultimately, when it comes to the law, there are bodies in place for regulatory purposes.

Deputy Catherine Murphy and Senator Ó Céidigh asked about the risks into the future. In the terms of reference relating to its audit, we have asked KOSI to evaluate those risks. We are aware, as Mr. Treacy indicated, that the FAI received either a letter of comfort or forward grant funding from UEFA-FIFA in the context of other moneys that may be due to the association from broadcasting rights relating to our international team, which is such a big focus of its activity. We will have to wait and see what they come back with in the context of identifying the external risks. I expect they are: first, loans the FAI must repay; second, potential income over the next season that it may achieve from broadcasting, transmission and attendances; third, the FAI's commercial arrangements with its sponsors, including the period for which the latter will continue to sponsor the association; and, fifth, the grant funding available from Sport Ireland, which is €2.78 million annually, as well as capital funding from the Department's regional programme and that for the individual clubs under the sports capital programme. There are myriad risks to current and future funding in that regard. The Minister has made it clear, as has Sport Ireland in the context of the funding we provide, that unless the Augean stables are cleared, there will be no forward funding.

We are holding the last tranche of the Sport Ireland grant until we are reassured that the FAI is governed appropriately and properly, that these reforms are accepted in their entirety and that it is given a clean bill of health. We await Deloitte's finding on that, what comes out of the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement and the KOSI audit, which I would like to see go coterminous in the autumn because our funding round for 2020 begins once we know what we are getting in the budget. Then our board will meet, look at the applications from our NGBs, local sports partnerships and others and we will make decisions as a board in December for the payout of funds, if we can, before the end of December so that NGBs can forward fund their own programmes, or in January. Many things need to come together in the audits, some of which we have control over and some key issues we do not.

Comment on this

In the key amendments Sport Ireland has made to its revised conditions for grant approval - which basically relate to full audit and inspection - making it a condition to provide details of full remuneration packages of CEOs, etc. and independent verification of good practice both represent major improvements. Was it not all very simple in the end? At the first meeting Sport Ireland representatives attended in March or February, they informed us that their hands were tied. We were told that sporting NGOs have their own agency and that no level of compliance could be imposed by Sport Ireland. Today, it seems that conditions can be imposed on sporting bodies.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

We would have done a complete audit on any organisation that we had funded by over 50%. If we provided funding of less than 50%, the main organisations being the three main field sports, we just audited the money we gave them. We would have received some push back in the past from the field sports, one in particular, around audits and going in there. When we attended the committee last time, we listened carefully to what it said to us. We spoke to the Department and the Minister, to our auditors and to legal people, and we are now pushing out the boat in terms of our powers. We also made an assessment and spoke to some of the NGBs which would be impacted upon. The board reached a-----

Comment on this

Would Mr. Treacy agree that Sport Ireland could have pushed the boat out a bit earlier, meaning that the level of bad practice might not have continued for so long?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

We probably pushed out the boat more than many organisations which give money to bodies. In fact, we were way ahead of the posse in auditing these organisations. Other sectors do not carry out audits or go into that area. We review the financial statements of all the organisations on an ongoing basis. Not only do we do that, but we also go back to the organisations with feedback. We have a good regime. Of course, Sport Ireland is audited by the Comptroller and Auditor General. Our regime is robust. The committee asked us to take a step further. We listened carefully, consulted with the Department and NGBs and we have taken the extra step.

Comment on this

That is to be welcomed. However, at the first meeting, I recall asking whether Sport Ireland would withhold funding as a deterrent and Mr. Treacy was very reluctant to do so. Now there are very stringent conditions.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

We have been accused in the past of being a bit heavy-handed with some of these organisations. No one likes for us to be in a situation where we withdraw funding from any organisation. That is not great. We are always trying to balance this. The FAI has changed everything and has moved things on with audit and the impact will be felt by everyone in sport. Mr. Horan will verify that the systems in place, even prior to this, were fairly robust and we probably went further than many organisations.

As an example, remuneration packages for CEOs would have been a significant source of unhappiness throughout society, especially in the football community. I am glad that Mr. Mulvey has included it as a condition, but I wonder why it was not included before.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Mulvey

We anticipate that there may be a pushback from some sports organisations on the new terms and conditions we will apply in the provision of grant funding. I have heard noises in the wind, asking if Sport Ireland is now trying to run every sports organisation in the country. There is a little of that in the undergrowth. It was an issue in the past, too. As Mr. Treacy indicated, when we went in in a way some people may have said was heavy-handed, we were rebuked for it, including by Ministers. The second issue is balancing it with governing bodies. In the past there was a pushback on remuneration packages for CEOs, not just from the FAI. There was the issue of commercial sensitivity in the case of some contracts which was related to the ability of CEOs to realise commercial value of the sport for the organisation. They said the matter was entirely private and did not relate to the grant or remuneration, as the CEO's salary did not come out of any public funding provided. One had to watch that. We are trying to be as positive and adventurous as we can without incurring legal action against us such as judicial reviews in exerting an authority for which we do not have a foundation. As Mr. Treacy indicated, the FAI has changed that, as have the investigations of Oireachtas committees into charities and such. The remit of the State may extend further than people realised in the past.

Comment on this

How has the discrepancy arisen between the clean sweep of the board for which the Minister is arguing and which we all thought would happen and the insistence in the report on maintaining two board members? When we last discussed this issue at the committee, I asked why would we wait until July. I am not pointing at anyone personally, but it is a fact that it is now July and we have found out that Mr. Conway is being nominated for the position of president. He sat in this room when we tried to get answers from the former CEO and was happy to lead the FAI in a merry dance around the committee. He will be the president because there is no other competition. There is already a significant problem with the report.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

The group is independent. There were three external nominees who were nominated by Sport Ireland. From the point of view of a transition in governance and a hand-over, when we looked at this issue and put it in the report, given that we are talking about a new board, independent directors and an independent chair, we considered that it would be a more serious risk to allow everybody with knowledge, an insight, relationships, corporate memory, etc. to walk away, rather than allow more than one or a maximum of two of the 12 to hand on the baton in a reasonable way.

Comment on this

Fair enough. Did Mr. Horan not-----

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

We were not leaned on by any individual anywhere. The three external members of the review group were very strong that it needed to be a managed transition and a prudent, astute, hand-over and changeover.

Comment on this

Did Mr. Horan not see the potential for it to happen with that recommendation? The nominee for president is somebody who has a long track record of facilitating whatever went on in the FAI and allowing the former CEO to sit there gagged and not to answer questions from elected persons, journalists or anybody else. Considering how small and monocultural the board was, could Mr. Horan not have had a stipulation that that would happen? He is putting continuity above a clean sweep.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

We were not commissioned to do this work until after it had happened, but I take the Deputy's point. It was a suggestion, rather than a recommendation, that it could happen. We put the onus back on the board at that stage following the resignations of seven people to reflect on the hand-over and transition and make the decision. It was not to leave an avenue, but we considered that it should be a suggestion. However, I take the point the Deputy is making. We have held the line on the issue which has come up in a number of guises. The recommendation is robust, although it has facilitated the situation about which the Deputy is talking. Even allowing for the exceptional circumstances, having a transition and hand-over is a safer way to do it than not having one at all. If one goes for a full sweep, one relies completely on the executive of the organisation, on which there was commentary. We viewed having some transition as a better outcome.

Comment on this

I have read the report and many of the recommendations made in it are very good.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

I thank the Deputy.

Comment on this

There is a danger that an impression is being given that we are entering a new era of reform and that the problems of the past will never be investigated or uncovered. I do not think that is acceptable. That is something for the Chairman of the committee to consider. The last time we were all at this committee we were in a farcical situation, with the Kerins judgment hanging over our heads, which the former CEO of the FAI used to say nothing, except whatever he wanted to say. In the light of the clarity provided on the Kerins judgment, we should consider inviting the former CEO of the FAI back to the committee.

Comment on this

We received a letter earlier, although I appreciate that the Deputy may not have been here, in which FAI offered to come after its annual general meeting.

Comment on this

The letter is from the president, but I hear the Deputy. I will have no problem in making that request.

Comment on this

We all wanted to hear from the person who did not speak at the last meeting.

Comment on this

I understand.

Comment on this

We heard from the president but not from the person from whom we all wanted to hear. In the light of the clarity provided on sending an invitation with clear information in advance, we should re-invite the former CEO to answer these questions.

Comment on this

That is something we can discuss in the autumn. While there is a process ongoing, it is appropriate that any citizen involved in it should have his or her right to decide whether to come or not, as he or she so wishes.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

One of the biggest issues which bedevils governance is the lack of clarity on roles and responsibilities, about which there is confusion. Much of our report tries to nail down that there is not a cross-over or a hand-over between the executive and the non-executive. We tried to implement committee terms of reference, on which work is ongoing in order that nobody would be under any illusion about what his or her job was in terms of oversight or the accountability of the executive or the board. That is why there will be independent directors and an independent element on various committees. There is a process for holding people to account. Building in structures to allow that to happen is a recurring theme in the report. We are acutely conscious that it is a requirement in the roll-forward of governance in the FAI.

Comment on this

In the delegates' recommendations on the make-up of the new governance boards they draw attention to the gender imbalance in the FAI, but it would not be the only sinner in the country in that regard. It is not too much better in the Dáil. There are two women to represent women's football out of a council membership of 58.

One looks back and asks whether it is any wonder that the women's team received the treatment they did, not least in light of the Women's World Cup, which engaged people's attention, enjoyed a high viewership and included some very good football. That a chant that rang around the stadium was for equal pay cannot be lost on the people who will run the FAI. Nevertheless, I wonder how it will be achieved. Our guests recommend a 33% female-----

Comment on this

Before that question is answered, I note that it is Fine Gael's turn next. Two members are in attendance and I do not wish to fall out with either of them if they decide who wants to go first.

Comment on this

I will finish the sentence, if the Chairman does not mind.

Comment on this

For the record, we have been fair with everybody-----

Comment on this

I know. I was almost finished.

Comment on this

-----and the Deputy has been asking questions for 16 minutes. While I acknowledge that it may upset her, I am trying to be fair to everybody.

Comment on this

If the Chairman lets me finish the sentence, I will be finished.

Comment on this

I have no problem with the Deputy finishing the sentence but I am trying to say her time is almost up.

Comment on this

It seems difficult to go from 3.5% to 33% in 24 months.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

The group acknowledged the challenge and hill to be climbed to achieve a gender balance. FIFA and UEFA talk about representative democracy in society, gender balance on state boards and so on. In a way, we are saying that within one year, we will attempt to achieve 33.3% on the board and that within three years, there will be a gender balance on the councils and at AGMs. There is much effort being done throughout the structures of UEFA and FIFA to build female leadership capacity and to get people to step into the roles. A programme of work will be required to get people to come forward for the roles. Throughout the country, the governance roadshows are predominantly male, which is not surprising.

The timeline is a target, although it is probably more than that because change is required. In view of the success of the women's team, the Women's World Cup and so on, it is clear that for representative democracy in the sport, it has to move towards a greater gender balance. While I concede that, currently, only two of the 58 members are female, the addition to the council of eight representatives of the women's league team, as per the recommendations, should give an injection to the council membership above the two who are in place. The target has to be supported by initiatives at FAI level to grow people and embrace a greater gender balance.

Comment on this

I thank our guests for their presentations and for their ongoing work on the issue. I return to a point made by Mr. Treacy about Sport Ireland's meeting with the FAI last Friday, at which Sport Ireland outlined its concerns about a completely new board. Did I read that correctly?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

We met the FAI and Mr. Donal Conway. We were aware that two members of the existing board intended to run for election. One was going to be opposed, whereas the other was not. We had previously articulated the view that the entire board should stand down, and at the meeting, we articulated that, at a minimum, there should be an election.

Comment on this

What response did the FAI give Sport Ireland at the meeting?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

The response was that Mr. Conway had led many meetings throughout the country. He is seen as having a reform agenda and had done a great deal to drive that agenda forward in recent months, with which I believe everyone would concur. As I said previously, he stepped in, calmed the waters within the FAI headquarters and added some value. We are firmly of the view, however, that everyone should resign and a new broom should be brought in. New faces are needed.

Comment on this

I agree and I am glad those points of clarification were made. I prepared questions based on our guests' opening statements, which suggested they all were happy with the progress, but then the Minister's letter was published yesterday evening. I was surprised that the clarifications were much stronger than what they was contained in their opening statements.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

We do not enter that area. It is up to every organisation to choose its president; it is not up to us. We do not have a say. While it is in our power to make a suggestion, the members elect the president. The Minister wrote a letter yesterday that changed an awful lot in respect of the issue. We endorsed it-----

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that. When Sport Ireland previously appeared before the committee, I made a comparison with the Olympic Council of Ireland and our guests very much agreed on the way that process was started. In that case, although the president who was appointed, Sarah Keane, had been on the board for a couple of years, she had been an open critic of what had been going on. She has done a wonderful job and she was elected.

The optics of this issue, however, are in contrast to that. As has been noted, at Mr. Conway's appearance before the committee, he was given an unfair job by his own CEO to protect him. From that point of view, Mr. Conway did the job quite well. This is a start, as Mr. Treacy indicated, but it is not a good start as a straw in the wind of what might happen down the road. That is the danger. The impression I get is that the reforms have a 50:50 chance of being voted down. It appears that the crisis thus far might look like a tea party compared with the crisis that is to come.

While I can see the argument for some continuity, the continuity in this case will be provided by someone who has been a member of the board for 14 years. While he may have steadied the waters, he was in place throughout the period when incorrect and questionable decisions were made. The Institute of Public Administration's report is independent but I detect a difference of opinion from that of Sport Ireland. The latter wanted a clear-out whereas the former's report made a different point.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

I might make an independent observation. The report was issued on 21 June. We had briefed the board of the FAI with the draft report on 13 June. The board received the final report late on 20 June and it was published on the website on 21 June. At the first press conference, which was the first briefing, the president acknowledged that the culpability for what was identified in the report, namely, the trouble that had been visited on the association, rested with the board. I have been invited to explain the report at the governance roadshow workshops that are taking place. The president takes the lead on them and acknowledges, in a public and open way, where the board was wrong and the deficiencies that existed. He has been challenged in respect of that and has indicated strongly that this reform package needs to be delivered for the FAI. Throughout the country, the members understand the challenge but it appears that they have vested trust in the man in question to lead the reform package.

He has stated publicly that this is an interim board, which will sit for one year. I do not think he envisages being there for more than a year. I will let him speak to that but that is definitely my understanding. The report and the package represent a recognition that this is the organisation's plan A. This must be the way forward. The question is who can lead that. I wish to emphasise that we were not leaned upon by anybody. No influence whatsoever was used to induce the committee to create an opportunity for someone to sit. That did not happen. We saw it as an important and prudent way to manage transition and renewal. I wish to underline that to people. The outcome is what we have at the moment.

Comment on this

I find this difficult. With all the issues, it beggars belief that there is an unopposed election.

Comment on this

I wish to go back to the point about the Companies Act. I accept the issues concerning the committees and clubs, but this is a commercial operation. That is the question. Its governance is completely and absolutely inadequate. The question of continuity does not arise in my view. They should all go. I understand the emphasis on Mr. Horan's work, which I respect and acknowledge. I do not think there is enough work in the report regarding obligations under the Companies Acts, the duties of the board of directors and how those directors will be monitored in future. If that is a respectful and fair point to make I would be delighted if the witnesses would come back to us with more work on the issues in the organisation which are absent from the report at the moment, even if that will take until the autumn.

Comment on this

This seems to be the issue that us bugging all of us. Is this just a fait accompli? Can this be altered?

Comment on this

It is of concern to everybody. In fairness to the committee, that is what it has recommended. It was accepted by other parties. That is the compromise as I see it, though obviously I do not agree with it and neither does anybody here. We have to listen. If that is what the committee recommended we cannot change it. However, the organisation can change to make sure that the changes happen. One way of not doing that is electing the president. That is the problem. That is why there has been no change.

Comment on this

The witnesses were asked if they anticipated that this could happen. The person who asked no questions at all about financial goings-on in the FAI, including the extravagant expenses and the so-called loan, is now going to lead the reform movement in the FAI. It just does not stand up.

Comment on this

In fairness, other members here have not spoken-----

Comment on this

Mr. Horan seem to be arguing a stronger case for Mr. Conway.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

I am simply making an observation, that is all. It is a member association.

Comment on this

The last point I want to make is that this organisation could in theory be heading into insolvency, as we were saying. How can a body rescue that when it is just an outsider, in one sense, with some legal or statutory duty of care for a certain amount of the organisation's budget? It is a very serious question. Has additional professional help been offered or asked for by the FAI to deal with these very serious issues? In other words, is the capacity to deal with them available?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

The association is dealing with them. Grant Thornton is providing support in the various investigations. That firm has brought in its own people to help.

Comment on this

Grant Thornton is also managing day-to-day affairs, is that right? I am not trying to put words in Mr. Treacy's mouth.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

My understanding is that Grant Thornton is supporting the financial people within the FAI in providing all the information for the various investigations ongoing at the moment.

Chairman: Regarding the running of the organisation-----

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

Grant Thornton is helping the financial people within the FAI to put some of those systems in place.

Comment on this

What are those systems?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

They are financial procedures, processes and that type of thing.

Comment on this

Mr. Treacy raised questions about managing the different activities. He mentioned quite a number of them. Who is managing those? What is going on?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

The football side is being managed by the general manager, Mr. Noel Mooney.

Comment on this

What about the financial issues?

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

We recommended the development of a governance manual of policies, procedures and protocols. I understand Grant Thornton is helping with a lot of these procedures and the documents that need to be prepared. That is our understanding. It is a recommendation in the report.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Treacy enumerate the resources Grant Thornton is providing? How many people have been assigned?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

That is a matter for the FAI.

Comment on this

Is that not a part of the due diligence Sport Ireland has to undertake?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

If the FAI is paying some people to come in and work with it, that is its business.

Comment on this

I am not being rude but Sport Ireland has a hugely important role here. It has brought about huge change, thankfully. However, Sport Ireland's management should be fully acquainted with what is actually going on now, given the additional duties it has imposed on the FAI in its new regulation. Is that right? In other words, Sport Ireland should be-----

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

We are already doing that through our KOSI audit. In fairness to the FAI, before we had changed our terms and conditions we asked if we could carry out a full audit. We met with the people in the FAI. Mr. Donal Conway was one of those people. They said "Yes".

Comment on this

There is one last point. It is implicit in the letter from the Minister, in the third last paragraph on the second page. He states that the query concerns the supply of information that has been requested.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

I am hearing that the information is forthcoming from the KOSI audit. It was a bit slow at the start but the information is now flowing. It may take time, but Sport Ireland will definitely get all the information we have requested. Otherwise we will not be able to complete the audit, and that is a very major step to restoring the funding. It is as simple as that.

Comment on this

The Minister writes that he is anxious to know if the FAI is responding in a full and timely manner to requests from Sport Ireland. Was Sport Ireland kept up to date with the details of the internal election for president and vice president? That is the nature of the second point. Is Mr. Treacy happy that Sport Ireland was kept up to date? That letter was written yesterday.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

A lot of that happened very quickly. Sending out a notice about an extraordinary general meeting, EGM, on a Sunday night is not a great idea. Asking for nominations on a Friday is not a great idea either. That was a very short timeframe. We met the FAI and we raised those issues. Its officials' argument was that if people had put forward names for elections, there would be a longer time for people to campaign. We thought that was too tight. We articulated that view to them.

Comment on this

I welcome Sport Ireland and Mr. Aidan Horan here today. Reading this report initially when it was first published, my first fear was that it would have a knock-on impact on other associations in regard to getting their house in order. Mr. Treacy has already acknowledged that there will be repercussions. I welcome the report and I am delighted that the response from everyone was positive. However, we have returned to a personality clash issue. I wish to put on the record that on 9 July the Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport, Deputy Ross, on foot of a parliamentary question from my colleague, Deputy MacSharry, stated:

I welcome the recent publication of the Report of the Governance Review Group... The Review Group has presented a detailed set of proposals covering a wide range of issues including the association's Board, commercial partnerships as well as audit and risk management.

Had the Minister, Deputy Ross, not read the report by 9 July? It has been referred to umpteen times at this committee, but everybody seems to be passing over this point. I refer to page 74 of Mr. Horan's report.

Its deliberations should be included the record:

In acknowledging the exceptional circumstances that exist, and the many calls for a complete change at the top, the Group considers that, for handover and transition purposes and to manage the serious risks where everyone leaves at once, at least one or possibly a maximum of two members might consider putting themselves forward for positions on the interim Board. This will require the current Board, as a collective, to consider their individual and personal interests but more importantly at this stage consider the interests of the Association and decide what they, as a collective, consider is the best course of action.

I was led to believe that this was all to cover the board on an interim basis for 12 months to 2020. I assume that everyone found that acceptable. In fairness, Mr. Horan acknowledges at the top of the page that the board offered its resignation in full, but the proviso was put into the report that it should reconsider one or two of the members. Do my committee colleagues have the other names that should have been put forward? Two names have been put forward for the position of vice president, one uncontested and the second contested. Is this not going well? In fairness, it is only for an interim board for 12 months. A lot is hanging on this decision and this deliberation because it will create more uncertainty.

My big concern as a member of the public, and in the context of accountability for taxpayers' money, is that the spin is that it is down to the clubs, which were not getting it, although we were led to believe they were. I refer to the development clubs, the sports partnerships and so on. Is this just a last-minute intervention on the part of the Minister, Deputy Ross? This report outlines matters clearly. Had they some other name in mind? I cited at a previous committee meeting the case of a company in my own back yard, namely Dairygold, where changes were made. However, one does not just make a clean sweep of management; one keeps some of the old guard and then moves forward. Many Governments have resigned but then sought re-election, have they not?

Comment on this

The Taoiseach never-----

Comment on this

I will try to keep outside of this jurisdiction. The point is that there seems to be a feeling now that we should just clean the board. I understand where people are coming from-----

Comment on this

-----but we need a transition period.

Comment on this

In fairness, Deputy Coppinger-----

Comment on this

I support Deputy Coppinger's comment that not all boardrooms need to comprise top-class lawyers and so on. Tradespeople can be put in place for directors to become board members. I am concerned that we are going off track as far as the report is concerned. Is the report worth the paper it is written on? I assume that when it comes before the AGM or whatever it will be written into the articles and memorandums of the FAI. Am I correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

Yes. The new rulebook, which is out now, incorporates the changes to the structures and the committees which are envisaged.

Comment on this

Will it be possible to amend that rulebook in future to deal with the issue of the quorum, which is a big topic at present?

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

Yes. The rulebook will be amended as the association sees fit. That is my understanding.

Comment on this

That is what I am saying. The proposal that the quorum be reduced to two members can be reversed at a proper AGM in-----

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

We had this discussion a little earlier. The rulebook that has been sent out states that the quorum is six members.

Comment on this

Mr. Horan said Sport Ireland had deliberations with FIFA and UEFA. Did it have any proposals that created a red line for them and made them tell it to pull back? Did Sport Ireland have issues with them?

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

No, they provided us with information that they thought would be helpful to the review. We gave them an overview of the terms of reference and the background we were using, we talked about the codes and the guidance and we looked at their statutes and the regulations. They were very happy to take on board our independent recommendations as to what the future should be. That is the context within which we worked with them. We got back comments on the draft report from both Sport Ireland and the FAI, both reflecting generally broad acceptance of the draft report, which ultimately became the final report issued on 21 June. This is very much based on UEFA and FIFA regulations, principles and practices, but they took no excess influence on us regarding any of the material here.

Comment on this

Were there not any reversals, though? In the draft report, for example, there were no recommendations or-----

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

No. This final report changed very little. These were just some editorial changes and other small modifications and adjustments. The draft report was substantively the final report the committee has.

Comment on this

Were staff structures discussed at all?

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

No, we took presentations and received submissions from staff. Our acknowledgement concerned the staff forum initiative, which is now happening; the presence of human resource management, HRM, skills on the board; and a new executive performance and remuneration committee with a staff role. Ultimately, with the new structures, there will have to be an alignment within the FAI into those committees from the staff. If the committees are working, the work programmes will have to feed into the work of the day-to-day staff. That has been presented back to the staff as well. FAI staff were presented with a report on the morning of 21 June at 9 a.m. The first people to get the report were the staff. We met them again last week to talk through any issues they wanted to explore. That has been part of the process with them. It is not an organisational review, but we flagged the alignment of the organisations, executive staff and management with the future structures of the FAI.

Comment on this

Did they come back with any further requests or suggested changes to staff?

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

No, we just commented on and put some detail around the recommendation, explaining what it would mean, but it was very much back to their leadership and their own executive to take that forward.

Comment on this

It is on the record that Sport Ireland was to come on board this year and that it was the turn of the FAI to be audited this year. If Sport Ireland only had its pre-March account audit skills in all this, do the witnesses think it would still be in a position to unearth what has now arisen? The officials say they have upped the ante regarding the auditing and the forensic accounting techniques for the audit going forward, unlike perhaps some other organisations. If they were still using the same pre-March audit techniques, do they think that if they went into the FAI headquarters tomorrow morning those techniques would be good enough to discover those discrepancies?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

As I said, up to March of this year we were, for the three main fields of funding, relying on the organisation's auditors to give us a letter stating that the funding we gave them was expended for the purposes for which it was given. The Sunday Times through Mark Tighe changed an awful lot in a very short period. It was a string that probably needed to be pulled, and things unravelled very quickly. Since then, we have highlighted how we have changed our terms and conditions of funding and how in future we will do in-depth audits of all the organisations we have funded. As I have said previously, this has changed things for a lot of sporting organisations. It has moved the goalposts significantly, to use a sporting term. All this work continues, but I said previously that we were well ahead of a lot of organisations that are giving State funding to the community, charitable and sporting sectors, so we are well ahead of the posse in terms of the audits we do.

Comment on this

To clarify, I acknowledge that Sport Ireland has not visited the FAI headquarters in the past three years because it cannot get around to every organisation every year. The witnesses themselves acknowledge that every few years Sport Ireland does visit the organisations' headquarters. It will visit the FAI headquarters this year. That was agreed, and we have been aware of that. If Sport Ireland had come in with the previous audit methodology, pre-March, do the witnesses think that would be good enough to unearth all these difficulties or problems?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

That is up to the auditors when they go in, if they find something. It is, again, a matter of looking for a trail or something unusual.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Mulvey

Its own auditors did not uncover any of it. That is why they put in their notice; they said it did not have proper books of account.

Comment on this

Why did they wait two years to run to the ODCE?

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Mulvey

I think there was a bit of retrospective coverage of one's rear.

Comment on this
Frankie Feighan Senator Frank Feighan Fine Gael

It is nice to be here after four months. I was also put on the ticket today to contest the next general election. I hope to be back here as a Deputy but if I am not elected, I hope I will get a Taoiseach's nomination to the Seanad.

Comment on this

We will be delighted to have the Senator back as a Deputy.

Comment on this
Frankie Feighan Senator Frank Feighan Fine Gael

I thank Mr. Horan and the review group for their report. I thank Sport Ireland, which has been in a difficult situation for the past few years. It has dealt with this quite well, so far so good. It is a situation it does not like to find itself in. We are very fortunate to have such a competent organisation to deal with a situation none of us wants to deal with. The FAI has form here, going back 17 or 18 years. When the Genesis report was done, it was dragged kicking and screaming. We hear nothing about the Olympic Council of Ireland, OCI, now. It has got its house in order, fair play to it. People must be falling over themselves at FAI headquarters because I have never heard of so many different investigations going on.

Mr. Treacy said Donal Conway calmed the waters. There was talk at the previous meeting of an appetite for change but how can we be sure about that? I understand that Donal Conway has been president of the FAI for the past 14 years and has been nominated unopposed for the presidency again. That is not exactly the appetite for change we were told about. I am trying to be a devil's advocate here. We have asked that all the board members step down unconditionally. Am I right in saying that if Donal Conway was the president he would be there only for an interim term of a year? Nobody has asked me about this but Deputy O'Keeffe referred to continuity. Is there anything in place to ensure that he would be gone after a year? It seems reasonable, not from a political point of view but from a business point of view, to have continuity for a year with somebody who has the knowledge and who, as Mr. Treacy rightly said, has calmed the waters for 14 years?

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

He has been on the board for 14 years but he has been president for only one year. The board of the FAI will have an independent chairperson. We have written in the report that we are advocating a more detailed job description for the president and vice president and we are asking them to support the chairperson who is to be independent. The future president of the FAI, after these reforms, will not be the current president in terms of position and status surrounding the governance of the FAI because of the independent chair. The president will chair the football management committee but not the board. It is important for us to remember that.

This is an interim board; it is like a reform board, task and finish, get involved, take forward the implementation recommendations and come to the July 2020 AGM having read the 78 recommendations and focused on the areas we have mentioned for future work. This will be a very busy programme of work for whoever takes on this key governance role or those who are entrusted with the role. I view this as putting people in a position of trust. It is important to recognise that there will be an independent chair of the board and there will be three other independents on the board.

Comment on this
Frankie Feighan Senator Frank Feighan Fine Gael

We know the 78 recommendations will be put to the FAI members. What happens if they do not all go through?

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

These are presented as a package. If we say there are governance principles for the FAI, these are the governance arrangements it requires. We have tried to fashion a structure, board, business committees, a football management committee and new committees that will help the arrangements to embed and to work. The 78 recommendations are not a menu. I gather what is coming from the EGMs and AGMs is that this is a package of reform. Of course it can be tweaked as the organisation goes forward but as of now this is what the membership has to vote on to change. The rule changes are there to take those parts of the report that require rule change. Many of the recommendations are not rule changes; they are behavioural and cultural and how it does its work.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

Sport Ireland supports the Minister's letter to the effect that the board should step down. The Senator mentioned the role Donal Conway has played over the past three or four months. He is the one who filled the vacuum and calmed the waters within FAI headquarters, and led the reform agenda, which was very important. If there was a vacuum we would have made no progress on the report or on any of these audits. I acknowledge his work and his commitment on a voluntary basis over the past three months. That said, we in Sport Ireland believe it is time for everyone to stand down.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Mulvey

That was the statement made by Sport Ireland to this committee, and then to the Minister who conveyed it to the committee. We expected that would happen. Something has happened in the past ten days that has changed that narrative. We have not had a sufficient explanation as to why that occurred.

The time period for nominations is dramatically short - one week. I do not think there is an organisation in the country, trade union, political party or company that would have that truncated period of reflection on who would be nominated for a post.

We want to separate the personality and the individual from the office. We want a new start, a new era for the FAI. That means new people at leadership level and the report reflects that. This is unfortunate. Nobody desired this.

Comment on this
Frankie Feighan Senator Frank Feighan Fine Gael

I am interested in the international recognition of Irish athletes. The Friends of Irish Athletics appeared before the committee. The Chairman made a statement. What happened? Why did they come in here?

Comment on this

They came at the request of a member of the committee.

Comment on this
Frankie Feighan Senator Frank Feighan Fine Gael

Why would somebody say that somebody in Armagh could not compete for Ireland?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

They can and do regularly compete. One of our top athletes is from Portaferry. The athletes who come from Northern Ireland have a choice between competing for Ireland or Great Britain. That is in keeping with the Good Friday Agreement.

It works well for everyone. There is real harmony among the various bodies and they all work together. It is also in keeping with the IAAF constitution. This is something that does work. The athletes have choice and this is what is important. They can wear the green and white shirt or the Union Jack. It works for everyone and it is in keeping with the traditions of both communities in Northern Ireland.

Comment on this

We will try to finish if we can.

Comment on this

To return to a point made by Senator Feighan, the presentation made to us by the athletes made it sound as if there is a loophole. I agree with what Mr. Treacy stated. Perhaps it is a technicality. One can argue that it is not a sporting issue, but it is a big issue for those involved. In the Olympics, there is no issue with people opting for the UK or Ireland. In the case of the IAAF, however, if people choose to represent Ireland, they are representing the 26 counties. We could have somebody from Armagh who technically would not be representing all of Ireland and that is the issue.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

Yes, I understand that.

Comment on this

It is an issue of minutiae but not for the very genuine people it affects. The report states that there has been no correspondence on this. Would it be possible for Sport Ireland to meet the athletes at some stage?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

Absolutely.

Comment on this

This was one of the requests they made to the committee. Sport Ireland could meet them and tease out the issue and perhaps find a solution.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

I read the transcript of their appearance before the committee. I made an inquiry of Athletics Ireland on whether any athlete has complained about representing Ireland or if it had heard about any issue regarding an athlete from Northern Ireland representing Ireland or the UK. It replied that it had not. I read the transcript, I understood what was being asked and I posed the question.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Treacy meet them?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

I will be happy to meet them.

Comment on this

There are two issues.

Comment on this

-----that has not been clarified.

Comment on this

I just want to get this right. We have had an excellent meeting and we are discussing the matter properly before us. The problem is we must finish by 2.15 p.m. We can come back to it afterwards if people want. We will be coming back at 3 p.m. or 3.15 p.m. because representatives from Transport Infrastructure Ireland will be coming before us. I do not want to curtail anybody but I am conscious of our time.

Comment on this

While Mr. Treacy is here, I want to make this point. I do perceive one problem for a Protestant living in Northern Ireland-----

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

I see that as well.

Comment on this

-----who may identify as being from Northern Ireland but may not want to compete for the Republic of Ireland. Potentially, this excludes us from having a wider pool of people who are probably very talented. The athletes have raised an issue and it is something that should be looked at.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

I understand the issue raised by the Deputy and what the athletes put to the committee. This is why I asked whether any athlete who has competed for Ireland has raised it as an issue but no one has done so. I would be very happy to meet them.

Comment on this

With regard to the forthcoming AGM, no FAI rule underpins the election of the president and vice president. A lot will be decided at the EGM. Given this is all about governance, have the candidates for president and vice president been validly nominated? Does Sport Ireland have a function in this? The FAI's constitution specifies what should be transacted at an AGM. It specifies financial statements and the nomination of auditors. How can any of this be complied with? How can Sport Ireland possibly stand over an AGM that does not even comply with its own rules? I accept it will take a very long time to get the association properly constituted but this is its first opportunity to have an AGM and it will be in breach of its own rules. The tight timeframe seems to exclude deliberately other people. This is not the type of voter confidence that will stand up publicly. Does Mr. Treacy accept this is how it will be read?

Comment on this

The short timeline means we do not know whether it is in order. I do not mean to be rude but I ask Deputy MacSharry to be brief.

Comment on this

I will be quick. I do not mind coming back but I do not want to disenfranchise others. It is a matter for the Chairman.

Comment on this

I do not know about other people.

Comment on this

Somebody mentioned we will have new council members but they must be approved at the AGM.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

The nominees will go forward.

Comment on this

That is grand. They will be approved at the AGM. Is it correct that none of them will be eligible to be on the new board because nominations close on 24 July?

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

They are looking to get nominations through so people can go on to the council, whether at the EGM or AGM. My understanding is they will be in a position to go forward to be nominated for the board of the FAI, if that is the question the Deputy is asking.

Comment on this

At the next AGM.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

No, at this AGM.

Comment on this

Given that nominations close on 24 July, how can they be nominated three days before they are eligible?

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

I do not have the rule book in front of me. My understanding, for what it is worth, is that new nominees will be brought forward to the council and those nominees, as a group of 79, can decide to put forward people to go onto the board of the FAI on 27 July or after it.

Comment on this

The nominations close on 24 July.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

I do not have the detail.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

Deputy MacSharry is asking a very fair question.

Comment on this

I have no doubt about that.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

We will ask the FAI to clarify this for everyone.

Comment on this

It is a very good point.

Comment on this

It is another example. We established that we do not know whether it is solvent. We established that in an ideal world we would like all of the report's results before we move forward with substantive change. Now we have confusion over the new people. Theoretically, from my reading of the rules, they will not even be eligible to be on the board until the next AGM so it is a bit on the never-never.

Another point is that the corporate governance report clearly provides for a list to be drawn up by an external recruitment firm but this is not reflected in the rules. This is what the report says but it is not reflected in the rules. Instead, a nominations committee, comprising mainly of members of the board, will select the independent directors, including the chairperson. In effect, this gives complete control to the board for the selection of the independent directors. It is a derivative of Einstein's comment that to keep doing the same thing expecting a different outcome is insanity.

Comment on this

Before our guests-----

Comment on this

I would like the answers to my questions. Will they be put to the FAI?

Comment on this

I am trying to get everybody to ask their questions.

Comment on this

I have one more point to make.

Comment on this

We will take all of the answers together.

Comment on this

For what it is worth at this late stage, and bear in mind that I am new to this but I have read and considered the information that is available to us, I urge Sport Ireland to appeal to the FAI - to the extent that it has influence over the association, which is one of its member organisations - to postpone its EGM and AGM until November. Let us get all of these reports, including that of the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement if it is available. We will then have a much more holistic view to be able to use Mr. Horan's template, with adjustments as may be required, so we can put in place a bespoke system that best suits it.

Comment on this

I thank our guests for coming before us and I thank Mr. Horan for a very good report. I am very appreciative of the work our guests are doing and the due diligence they are carrying out. Well done. They have explained matters very well.

I return to a question I asked earlier, which was followed up by Deputy MacSharry. It is critically important for our guests to use their influence to ensure that the EGM and the AGM are postponed. In light of what Mr. Treacy stated in response to my question about the potential for the FAI to go into liquidation - not in theory but in practical terms - I suggest that consideration could be given to Grant Thornton, which has a great deal of experience in this area, taking over the management of the FAI in the short term. I do not doubt that Donal Conway has the best of intentions for football. I do not know the man, although I met him once. I have no doubts about his passion. At this time, the FAI needs people with strong professional experience at this level. I am asking our guests to support what I am asking them to consider and to give the committee some feedback on it.

Comment on this

The Senator has made an important point. If the people from Grant Thornton have such a significant knowledge base, the first thing they should do is produce a draft set of accounts.

Comment on this

Grant Thornton has done this in the past. Its managing partner, Mick McAteer, is a first cousin of the soccer player Jason McAteer. Grant Thornton has vast experience in this space.

Comment on this

We will leave it at that. Do our guests have anything else they would like to say in response to the questions that have been asked?

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

I would like to say in response to Deputy Catherine Murphy that I understand the FAI intends to convene the AGM and try to operate in accordance with and in advocacy of the rules, before adjourning to take the accounts at a subsequent stage. That is my understanding. I did not give any advice on that. I understand that is what the FAI wants to do.

Comment on this

What about the election of the president and vice president? Is that in accordance with the rules?

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

The only recommendation in the report was that the president and vice president should be elected by the AGM rather than by the council. That is a departure from previous practice.

Comment on this

Are they validly nominated according to their own rules? Are those rules going to be decided on at the EGM? Has this approach excluded people from running validly? These matters are critical to good corporate governance.

Comment on this
Mr. Aidan Horan

My understanding is that they are validly nominated under the FAI's rules and processes. We recommended that the president and vice president should be elected by the AGM rather than by the council. That was the only departure from previous practice that we recommended.

Comment on this

I will bring in Deputy Troy - a great former member of the committee - for a couple of minutes before we suspend.

Comment on this

I thank the Chair. I thought the meeting was starting at 1.30 p.m. I got my times wrong. When the board of the FAI originally came before the committee, I posed a question that remains unanswered. From my perspective, this was an indication that more than one person was at fault for the corporate governance problems in the FAI. A press release was issued when it was originally identified that there was-----

Comment on this

They were to respond to us on that.

Comment on this

They were to respond to us on that, but they have not done so. The person who gave the guarantee that he would respond is now the sole nominee for the position of president of the FAI. When I asked him what actions he would take if it were deemed appropriate that all members of the board should stand down as a means of instilling confidence in the board, he replied by saying that whatever actions were deemed to be appropriate would be taken. At the time, there was unanimity across members of the committee of all political parties and none on the need for the existing board to step down in full. We now realise that is no longer the case. Given that the person in question is not giving positive replies to the Minister, who is the funding master, I do not expect him to give positive replies to this committee. I would be interested to hear the views of Sport Ireland on this matter. Quite frankly, I am gravely concerned that despite the need for continuity on any board, there is no need for continuity when bad practices have been put in place by people in the past.

Comment on this

It might be better if the Deputy could be given a reply in writing.

Comment on this

I would rather a verbal reply.

Comment on this

The problem is that I have a meeting with a Minister.

Comment on this

The Vice Chairman is here.

Comment on this
Mr. Kieran Mulvey

As I stated earlier, in anticipation of similar questions from members of the committee, Sport Ireland is in full concurrence with the Minister's statement regarding the presidency of the FAI. We took at face value and on trust the statement made on behalf of the FAI by Donal Conway to the effect that the board of the FAI would step down at the AGM. Our view was that this would transpire. As also stated, there was no suggestion that some of them would step up again. That is not acceptable to us.

Comment on this

The problem is being created by this recommendation.

Comment on this

We have been going since 11 a.m. I thank our guests for attending. Representatives from Transport Infrastructure Ireland will be in attendance when we resume.

Comment on this