We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Transport, Tourism and Sport

Cycling Policy: Discussion

Contributions 160–343 of 343. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The office will cost €1.5 million and have seven staff. Are these staff exclusively dedicated to Dublin, as anecdotal evidence suggests?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

No. They are not staff. They are not-----

Comment on this

Are they on the agency side?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

It is an outsourced design consultancy that is delivering designs. It is a consultancy service we are taking on but the staff are placed in our offices and are working alongside our staff.

Comment on this

Are these staff on the agency side? Ms Graham will know this issue came up last week at a meeting of the Committee of Public Accounts.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

They are outsourced but they are placed within our organisation. It is a consultancy for design services.

Comment on this

In real terms, would it be accurate to say the workers in the national cycling office in the NTA are not public servants? They are contracted in.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Yes, they are contracted in.

Comment on this

In that case, we do not really have a national cycling office.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

It is a cycle design office. It works on and will continue to work on cycle designs outside of Dublin.

Comment on this

It does not have a policy function.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We work to our own-----

Comment on this

It is a technical service.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Yes.

Comment on this

Is it fair to say that we had design people before this announcement?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Does the Deputy mean in-house?

Comment on this

No, I am referring to contractors for the schemes that have managed to get through.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Yes, usually they would be designed by an external consultant.

Comment on this

It is, therefore, a case of smoke and mirrors. It is a superficial announcement that we have a national cycling office when all we have done is given a name to something that already existed.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We have a cycle design office. It is additional resources to be able to bring forward and increase our delivery rate of cycling infrastructure.

Comment on this

The cost this year is €1.5 million. What was the cost last year before we announced the office?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

There was no expenditure because there was no office.

Comment on this

An office is like a room. There were, however, people dedicated to schemes and we were paying them to do designs and so forth. The announcement of a national cycling office within the National Transport Authority seems to me to be a little superficial. It is smoke and mirrors because there are seven people in the office who do not really work for us. They are contracted in to do a particular job.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

They work for the NTA. They are working to a programme that the NTA-----

Comment on this

Yes, but they are subcontractors for want of a better word.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

They are working to a programme the NTA has set for them in association with the Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport. They are additional to what is already being done within the local authorities. In earlier years, the funding that was available for active travel would have been assigned to the different local authorities. The local authorities would either do the design in-house or go out to external consultants for assistance with their designs. It is a mixture, depending on what resources are available within the local authorities.

Comment on this

I know the NTA is depending on the resources that are available and all of that kind of stuff. I suggest, however, that what it says on the tin and the public perception of that is not what we are getting.

Comment on this

I hear what the Deputy is saying but I also hear the NTA and I have great respect for the work it does.

Comment on this

I want to make this point in a fair way. I have the greatest respect for the work the NTA does. The issue is not so much with the design because we accept that this has to be done by professionals and qualified persons who are able to do the job. The issue for the cycling representatives we met today is one of policy and who drives policy nationally. It should not be the function of the NTA. While it is appropriate and proper that the office reside within the NTA, the key point being made this morning was that it must push the boundaries. It must determine where to get more money and where to spend it and identify what people want. Operating that agenda is entirely separate from what the NTA is doing.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

I will expand on that and assist Deputy MacSharry in the discussion on this point. The policy is driven and made at Department level. The NTA is an important player in this and it works at the level of strategy, technical design and interaction with the local authorities around delivery. At the policy level in the Department, the Minister has looked for us to put an increasing focus on this in the past couple of years. The funding he has secured for it has stepped up in recent years. We are looking at how to align the funding available now and in the future, which is unlike the levels of funding available five or ten years ago, with getting projects delivered. The delivery of infrastructure has been identified by everybody, including the cycling groups the committee and the Department have met, as a key and critical feature that needs to be delivered, alongside some other features which I will address in a moment. Our emphasis at policy level has been on ensuring the NTA is in contact with the local authorities to get them to develop the plans they need to develop. That has been done and now it is about getting the projects through, having them technically designed and providing the assistance the local authorities need to do that. It is also about getting the projects through the planning process. There has been difficulty in some local authorities with achieving progress in the planning process for cycling schemes. Decisions have to be made on the allocation of road space between cycling and other forms of transport. Some local authorities have experienced difficulty with elected members coming to a view on what is the appropriate way forward and on what they can agree to. We have place much emphasis on that thus far.

The Department also has a strong understanding that road safety policy and legislation, which are areas on which the Department leads and works closely with the Road Safety Authority, are critically important to cyclists and other people using the roads and footpaths. A number of measures have been progressed in the past while, including some by the Department and Minister, for example, the regulations we are discussing today. Others have been progressed with agencies such as the Road Safety Authority, which is doing the advertising campaign that is needed on the soft side to complement the hard legislative measure and get the message and understanding across.

Deputy Eamon Ryan briefly mentioned the normalisation of cycling. That is one of the critical things we are trying to achieve in the Department. We have a policy around behavioural measures. We have brought in a scheme of training in cycling that is being developed and rolled out in conjunction with cycling groups. Predominantly funded by the Department, it teaches children at an appropriate age about cycling and moving safely on the roads and about the things they need to be aware of. That has just started. We have been able to do that in the past couple of years and we are expanding and rolling it out further. We now want to evaluate it and look at rolling it out further for training older children and adults.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Hanlon for what was to some extent a second opening statement on what is going on. The crux of this is that the national cycling is not what I thought it would be.

Comment on this

It is not a policy office.

Comment on this

Maybe we need a policy office in the Department. We basically have a structured design team within the NTA. That is not what I understood the office to be. It is specific to infrastructure. Ms Hanlon mentioned all the good things taking place in education, challenging stigma and normalising cycling, to which Deputy Eamon Ryan referred. That is all great but people are interested in the delivery of infrastructure. I will move on because other members want to contribute.

On the money that is available, Ms Hanlon mentioned a sum of €100 million for active travel. Senator Lombard, in a press release after the budget, stated €114 million had been made available for cycling through funding for greenways. As we heard earlier, Cycling.ie has done an analysis showing that in 2018 the budget for cycling would be about 3% of the transport budget.

If we note the percentages from the total land transport budget for 2020, the amount is €1.82 billion. In the past, subheading B8 was for sustainable transport, and approximately 32.26% of that budget in previous years was allocated to it. That would put the figure at approximately €587 million, which would mean approximately €17.62 million would come towards this area. If we add to that the €23 million for greenways, that adds up to approximately €41 million. Other figures have been given that would bring it closer to €50 million, which is less than 3% and closer to 2.25% or 2.5% of the budget. How does Ms Hanlon categorise expenditure on cycling and what are the real figures? We have Senator Lombard's figure of €114 million and Ms. Hanlon's figure of €100 million in terms of active travel. However, taking account of the figure from Cycling.ie, from what we heard from our guests earlier this morning and my calculations, the figure is somewhere between €40 million and €50 million, including greenways, which are as much to do with tourism as transport.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

Cycling is funded under a number of headings and there are a number of headings under which we provide Exchequer support to benefit cycling. Two programmes within the Department are principally targeted at supporting active travel. One is the cycling and walking programme. It alone will have funding of €70 million next year

Comment on this

What programme will have €70 million in funding?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

The cycling and walking programme.

Comment on this

Can we separate those out? Presumably the walking programme involves funding for footpaths for local authorities. Is that the case?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

Perhaps I could explain a few figures first.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

There is a sequence to this and then I will be happy to disaggregate as best I can. If we consider 2018, the spend the Department supported under the two principal programmes was approximately €37 million. The allocation under those programmes for 2019 is €48 million. The allocation for them for 2020 is €100 million, which is a considerable step up. We need to ensure when spending taxpayers' money that the projects are in place, ready to absorb it and that we can get them done. That does not include the money being spent on greenways. Money is allocated for greenways in addition to that. The allocation for greenways next year is €23 million.

Comment on this

Does that come under rural affairs funding?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

No. It is comes under our Department. We examined the greenways programme a few years ago, which is on the travel and transport side. While it comprises cycling and walking infrastructure, its focus is not on transport as such. It is not about getting somebody from one place to another. People are not travelling on them with that type of purpose, as if they were commuting. It is about having a local amenity for communities and a good strong tourism product for certain rural areas. It is led on the tourism side but that does not mean it is divorced from what we are doing with respect to cycling. We have a connection with them. We deal with issues of common and mutual interest and topicality and we keep in touch with what is happening.

Comment on this

Can I interject? There is a benefit from greenways for walkers and cyclists. The allocation for it is €23 million and nobody is arguing with that. I am still confused how we get to a funding figure of €100 million or €114 million for cycling. Let us take €23 million off the €114 million-----

Comment on this

I am sure Ms Hanlon is coming to that point.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

Can I explain that very directly? Regarding the €100 million figure I spoke about for cycling, about €70 million of that is for the cycling and walking programme that the Department funds and the remainder of it is for the sustainable urban travel programme that it also funds. Both of those are delivered through the National Transport Authority.

Comment on this

In terms of that €70 million funding, can Ms Hanlon strip out walking from cycling?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

At the moment, no, because----

Comment on this

I apologise for interrupting. Coming at this issue from being a member of this committee, perhaps I am a bit more aggressive than I should be and I apologise if I am. Does the walking infrastructure include footpaths?

Comment on this

People can walk on the cycling paths-----

Comment on this

I am trying to strip out waking from cycling.

Comment on this

Is funding for walking areas separate from cycling or does it cover both?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

On the implementation side, the NTA might be closer to the action.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

In terms of the projects funded through the Department's grants, they can be for specific cycle paths and for joint cycle ways and pathways, which are shared pathways. There can be schemes addressing junctions to improve pedestrian facilities as well as the cycle facilities. It is very hard to strip out what funding is for cycling alone. That is why we also refer to active travel, which is walking and cycling, and our funds go through to all types of projects.

Comment on this

I know I am being incredibly annoying but how much of the €70 million is for infrastructure that is exclusively for walkers, that is, where bicycles cannot be used?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

It is very difficult - almost impossible - to do that because most cycle schemes cannot be built without interfering with the footpath or making some changes.

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

Effectively, we get the benefit of a footpath change as well as the cycle lane.

Comment on this

I suggest all public commentary on this should indicate it is for cycling and walking.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

We do. We call it active travel.

Comment on this

Mr. O'Leary wishes to add a comment.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray O'Leary

On a point of clarification, regular footpaths in most local authorities come under roads expenditure.

Comment on this

Yes, I know that.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray O'Leary

As I have responsibility for roads and road safety, sometimes I can get annoyed when people talk about roads versus pedestrians versus cyclists versus public transport because roads expenditure serves all users. I wanted to clarify that is distinct from the specific investment through the NTA to support bicycle movement or pedestrian movement through difficult junctions.

Comment on this

I thank everybody for their efforts and they are doing a great job, but this is a matter of policy and resources, which is not necessarily in their domain. It is down to Ministers and the Government. We have established that the national cycling office is not that, rather it comprises a design team that has been subcontracted.

Comment on this

It has been stated it is a dedicated cycle office to bring a number of projects forward for planning and construction.

Comment on this

We are glad to have the opportunity-----

Comment on this

There is no problem. It is separate from what we want.

Comment on this

-----because we represent members of the public and it is important they know we are not getting what we assumed or thought we were getting. The €100 million in funding is not exclusively for cycling and it is wrong to say it is. We need to build towards that 10% figure and I might contribute further later, but I want to allow my colleagues to contribute.

Comment on this

I would add one further point to be helpful. If the Deputy were to submit a parliamentary question to the Department, it might be able to provide him with a list of where the money has been or will be spent.

Comment on this

I do not want to create additional expense for people who are working hard to answer parliamentary questions when I can get them answered here.

Comment on this

Of course, but the Deputy would have to give them due notice of such a list. That is what I would like to see. The point they have made is that cycling and walking are joined up in the space they occupy. It is hard to be specific unless the route is only a path on which nobody could cycle such as a narrow path near a cliff surface or somewhere like that. Cycling and walking go together. They are compatible. They are not mutually exclusive. Is that not it?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

In policy terms, we are trying to progress both because the benefits we get from them, in terms of impact on reducing congestion and on the deliverability of cities and urban areas and health and safety benefits, all work together. That is the policy, and what we have discussed in terms of funding is in the area of active travel.

Comment on this

I call Deputy Catherine Murphy.

Comment on this

I welcome our guests.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

On another point of clarification, we publish an annual report that covers where the grants have gone, the sustainable transport measures and all the projects that have been funded every year. The 2018 annual report is the most recent one. It would give members an example of the types of schemes we are discussing, such as shared schemes, full cycling schemes, or other facilities. It will show how they work together.

Comment on this

The transfer in respect of funding.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

They are available online.

Comment on this

I have asked several parliamentary questions to try to get a sense of where the money is spent because I find it difficult to track what is spent on cycling. I take issue with the idea that footpaths and cycleways are more or less the same piece of infrastructure. While in some cases they are, in others they certainly are not. As I noted earlier, where new housing estates are developed, they will typically include cycling infrastructure, but there will be permeability and the route will pass through a housing estate that does not have it. That causes an immediate conflict because it has not been provided for. We are not building a network but rather increments that might lead to a network over time. There is great frustration when someone intends to cycle somewhere but experiences a range of obstacles. The public, in many ways, are leading from the front, given the growing number of people who cycle. Nevertheless, we will never normalise it unless a safe environment and network are provided for them to cycle, and we will not encourage people to take up cycling. I refer in particular to certain groups who have been highlighted, such as women.

The question is how to develop the network. The issue of institutional arrangements was raised, and there is a question as to whether they are an inhibitor, which is why the views of the cycling office at the Department, in particular, are being sought. There are some matters I do not understand and would like to clear up. Ms Graham spoke about the statutory basis in the greater Dublin area. What does that include? My notion of the greater Dublin area might be wider. Does she mean the city and county of Dublin?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Yes, and the counties of-----

Comment on this

It includes the River Boyne but not Drogheda.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Yes, the counties of Meath, Wicklow and Kildare.

Comment on this

That area is on a statutory basis.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Yes.

Comment on this

What is the advantage of it being on a statutory basis?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

We have a statutory transport plan that includes a network of cycle routes. It is part of our statutory delivery of transport infrastructure. We progressed the others on a non-statutory basis because we do not have a statutory function to carry out a transport strategy in the regional cities, although we have developed a network of cycle plans for them.

Comment on this

Is a change in the area for which the NTA has direct responsibility on the cards?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Part of the national planning framework seeks to determine whether we could have additional powers in respect of transport strategies for the regional cities.

Comment on this

One criticism relates to the institutional arrangements and the fragmentation, of which there is a great deal. Some of that will be inevitable because there are various local authorities and approaches, but is an attempt to reach a logical institutional arrangement, where there is one point of engagement on both policy and delivery, likely to rest with the NTA or will it be combined with the Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

Our focus is on the design and delivery of the networks. That the NTA is in place means it breaks down some of the barriers, not least in respect of cycle routes that cross local authority boundaries. One of the strengths in the cycle design office we have put in place is that it can work across those boundaries, which should ease the bringing forward of plans for construction.

Comment on this

The primary organisations that will deliver will be the local authorities, and some will be better than others. I understand the kinds of conflict there may be, such as where shops may lose parking space in the street because it will be turned into a cycleway. Such conflict will remain until demand increases and people see the success and change, which will be beneficial for other areas. Is there an exemplar network anywhere in the country? If so, where is it and has Ms Graham seen it?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Graham

It will take a number of years to build the network. We agree that a number of cycle projects have been initiated throughout the region but they have not been joined up, which is why we wanted to put in place a plan - a network - to show we needed to join up all the bits of infrastructure in the region and to provide those connections. The Sutton-Sandycove route is a prime example of where we are trying to build one major route but it is being delivered in sections. A number of exemplars, in respect of the infrastructure put in place in recent years, are segregated cycle infrastructure. Braemor Road in Churchtown is one example. The design manual is in place to be able to have consistency in designs and to ensure there will be the best cycling infrastructure in our cities and towns.

Comment on this

Improvements to the design manual happen all the time. Will it be updated and when might we see it?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

As we are working on many cycling designs as part of the BusConnects project, we will take advantage of what we learn from the project to update the manual and add further guidance, probably next year.

Comment on this

Will it be towards the end of next year?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

Yes, I think so.

Comment on this

The NTA's remit is wider than the local authorities' remit, given that it includes public transport infrastructure as well as that of roads. I recall seeing at a train station in another country a ramp at the side of steps to allow people to wheel up and down bicycles. There are other basic measures such as facilities for storing baggage. What engagement has there been? Is there dedicated money for such infrastructure? I acknowledge there is a capacity issue on trains and buses but that will sort itself out over time. Is the design of such infrastructure automatically a central feature when dealing, for example, with the procurement of new carriages or where a train station is to be upgraded?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

In the design of new train stations, the issue of its location, cycle parking facilities and accessibility to the platforms for bicycles is a consideration. As for the carriage of bicycles on the fleet, there will be space provision to allow for it but there are definitely policy issues to be sorted out.

Comment on this

I return to the issue of cycleway projects. In my area, I am familiar with those on the two canals. I accept that it is not a straight route all the way and that there are pinch points but it is taking an incredible length of time. What are the impediments in that regard? For example, is it a matter of finance or design?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

Up to the past few years, finance was a big issue because such schemes are expensive. For one of the schemes on which we are working, at the Royal Canal, the budget is in the multiple millions of euro. It is not a small-scale scheme. The funding is now available but we have to catch up on the planning aspect. There are also challenges to have the scheme approved, for all the reasons the Deputy mentioned.

There are others in respect of which there are environmental issues to be addressed, in particular on the Royal Canal. These are not unusual impediments. Rather, they are the usual impediments but it takes time for the issues to be dealt with.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Creegan for his responses but I would like to continue my line of questioning on this issue because people are interested in it and they are putting pressure on me to get answers. This demonstrates that there is a desire for this mode of travel. When one factors in the number of people that could travel that route and take pressure off city streets it makes complete sense to get that done quickly.

Mr. Creegan mentioned that a percentage of the NTA's budget is spent on active travel. What is that percentage and how does it relate to other spend?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

I do not have the exact percentage but it is in excess of 10%. Between 10% and 12% of our capital budget will be spent on cycling and walking schemes. The percentage will increase next year to approximately 15%.

Comment on this

Is the increase related to BusConnects?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

No. It will increase because additional funding has been provided and because we are starting to catch up and develop a pipeline of projects that can be delivered.

Comment on this

Returning to the NTA's engagement with the local authorities and some of them being better in this area than others, are those who are good at this better because they have staff that are committed to cycling and walking, they have more advanced plans or they are better at drawing down funding or are there common denominators in that regard? Where there are people who are more proactive this is reflected in drawdown. What are the stand-out issues?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

It is fair to say that there are differences between local authorities' approach to cycling and walking projects and sustainable projects. Some are better than others. We cannot put our finger on why that is the case. In some cases, it may be down to resources and the fact that the people involved have multiple projects to deal with such that these projects may be low on their priority list. I would not be capable of identifying the causes, but it is fair to say that there is a different approach in some local authorities.

Comment on this

If there was a staff member dedicated to active travel would that make a difference?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

It would not do any harm but I do not know what difference it would make. Fundamentally, it is an issue of resources and priorities within the local authorities. They have multiple tasks to perform. The key question is whether they have the resources to bring this work far enough up the pecking order.

Comment on this

Is this work being driven by the local authorities or the NTA?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

It is a mix of both. Where progress is not happening, the cycle design office which I mentioned earlier can intervene and take on the design and move it ahead. In that sense, the NTA is driving it. When it comes to bringing the project through the council chamber and getting approval for it, that has to be the remit of the local authorities.

Comment on this

The NTA does not have a statutory remit in regard to the local authorities and so, therefore, its voice does not have to be recognised.

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

That is true.

Comment on this

It was mentioned by the witness for I BIKE Dublin that in regard to cycling policy and infrastructure requests it has to deal with up to 30 organisations. Is there a role for the NTA in co-ordinating and streamlining those requests?

My second question is to the witness from the Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport and relates to enforcement of the road traffic legislation. Is the legislation open to legal challenge in respect of the interpretation of dangerous overtaking? In many cases, dangerous overtaking occurs on a 50:50 basis. I travel to Dublin via the Long Mile Road. I have noted that on parts of that road the cycle lane is 1.5 m wide and on other parts of it the cycle lane is 1 m wide. In that situation, how would a garda make a judgment in regard to dangerous overtaking? Will an assessment be made on the basis of a collision and so on? Is it possible that we could be facing many legal challenges in the Four Courts in regard to this legislation?

Comment on this
Mr. Ray O'Leary

I will respond to the second part of the Deputy's question. Enforcement will be a matter for An Garda Síochána. The legislation that was introduced took account of views in regard to enforceability. My recollection is that the Deputy raised questions in a previous discussion about the enforceability of a minimum passing distance of either 1 m or 1.5 m. The legislation takes account of those views. It is important to stress that there always has been a general offence of dangerous overtaking. The question of dangerous overtaking is long established in Irish road traffic law. In the current legislation we have separated out dangerous overtaking of cyclists because they are particularly vulnerable road users who are sharing the road space with mechanically propelled vehicles, unlike pedestrians in normal circumstances, and therefore they are particularly vulnerable and there is an increased penalty in terms of the fix charged notice.

On the question of legal challenge, legislative provisions are always open to challenge by a citizen. I cannot say whether this legislation specifically will be open to challenge. In bringing forward this specific legislation, we decided that it was best to build on a long established offence in Irish road traffic law that had been tested through the courts and had been the basis of previous action by the various parties. These issues were borne in mind in bringing forward and distinguishing dangerous overtaking of a cyclist from dangerous overtaking generally.

Comment on this

In regard to enforcement of the legislation, some years ago when the sugar beet factory in Carlow closed and the company moved its operations to Mallow, concerns were raised in regard to the ability of the infrastructure in place in north Cork to accommodate the heavy goods vehicles. At that time a motion was tabled to the local authority requesting that on the N73, which was the road from Mitchelstown to Mallow, these heavy goods vehicles be required to pull in at designated areas to allow other traffic to pass. We need a gentleman-type agreement on country roads in regard to cyclists. I have spoken to various people about this issue. In bygone days there was a gentleman's agreement among road-users in that slow moving vehicles would pull over to allow other vehicles to pass. Nowadays, our roads are increasingly busy with cyclists. The N73 is a national secondary road. As one approaches that road there is a sign advising motorists to be aware that owing to the width of the road oncoming traffic may be in the middle of the road.

Lately, while stuck in traffic congestion I assumed there was a slow car in front of me. When I eventually got to this section of road, one cyclist had held up 40 cars. I know there were 40 cars because the person in the car in front of me asked. It causes confusion and frustration. It can lead to road rage, which we are trying to avoid. I enjoy riding a bicycle as well but road users must share the road and care about each other. Much of the focus is on what happens in Dublin but we must not forget rural Ireland. We welcome the greenways but as previous speakers have said, they are for recreational purposes. Something more must be done to get more money to rural Ireland, as Deputy MacSharry noted, not just for footpaths but for cycle lanes. We need proper legislation as well.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray O'Leary

To be honest, the answer to those kinds of issues do not necessarily lie in legislation. To some extent this is always an issue and we cannot legislate for or against what might be called "road courtesy". It can be encouraged through education. The State cannot do everything to change behaviour but we can encourage it through education, enforcement and, in some cases, engineering or investment. For example, greenway investment provides an alternative. One of the biggest issues, whether it is in rural or urban areas, is the limited amount of road space. We are trying to manage a limited amount of road space with a limited amount of funding to maintain and invest it and make the best use of it for the many different people who want to use it. This takes in the tourist, the tractor and the cyclist. One of the advantages of greenways, for example, is to create space for more vulnerable road users and reduce the chances of them being in "conflict", to use the word in the engineering sense and where it refers to different kinds of users on the same stretch of road.

The Deputy might be aware that on the national secondary route from Tralee to Dingle, a cycle track was built into the side of the road despite environmental objections being made. The track required some extra width and an environmental organisation objected to the inclusion of a cycle track being added to the improved road. That has been delivered but such a project is subject to environmental capacity and resources available for investment. There will always be a mix of different solutions. We might work with local authorities where investment in an alternative route or in enhancing the existing route is feasible. Engagement with stakeholders can be useful in trying to encourage people to respect each other, whether that is a driver respecting a cyclist or the cyclist respecting the driver.

From the road safety perspective, we do not like using terms like cycling safety. We talk about road safety for everybody because people do not live in boxes. The same people who use bicycles use buses, footpaths and cars. Therefore, it is about trying to create the conditions where people using public infrastructure can do so in an optimal way.

Comment on this

Between 2009 and 2013, road fatalities of cyclists averaged seven per year. Between 2014 and 2018 the figure was 11 per year, so the trend for cyclist deaths is up while it is significantly down for road users as a whole. The number of road fatalities in 2009 was 238, compared with 142 last year. That includes pedestrians. The point by the witness is very well made but cyclists are undoubtedly at a particular risk.

I referred earlier to the cyclist injury report and collision data from 2008 to 2016 that is due early next month. It would be important to have representatives of the Road Safety Authority before us to discuss that. We will learn much from that as I understand it goes into every reported injury and fatality and we can get a really clear picture of what more we need to do.

Comment on this

There are organisations that can help in this respect.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

The Deputy is talking about structures for engagement with stakeholders, which was mentioned by the Chairman earlier. I spoke about the public consultation we are doing and one of the questions being put in the public consultation is the question of engagement with various stakeholders both in this and other areas. It is about seeing whether we should or how we can widen existing processes, or whether they should be formalised. We are very open to ideas around that and to progressing it in future. The Deputy speaks about the proliferation of parties involved in this, and we are looking at institutional structures under the public consultation. We are inviting views on this and are open to hearing them. It is about asking what is the best way of having that interaction at the policy, strategy, implementation and user levels, which is really important. It is about ensuring that the views of users, when they come in, are not just targeted at one of the parties but that they influence and inform what is happening at the policy and strategy levels, as well as at the delivery and implementation levels.

Comment on this

We must leave by 1.15 p.m.

Comment on this

I have some questions that will require a bit of back and forth.

Comment on this

I have seven rapid-fire buzzer questions. The Senator can go ahead.

Comment on this

When we speak about road conflict and frustration, there are different consequences for different users and cyclists have a higher risk of death. Cyclists are also more likely to get off a bike and not cycle again. There are not many drivers who have a frustrating driving experience and never drive again but this happens with cyclists. It is not just about individuals and there is a negative social consequence if the collective social policy goal we have identified nationally is that we want people to cycle. It makes it everybody's business and not just the business of those involved if people are deterred from cycling. We have heard about the work on design but what about the work on cycling promotion and encouraging people to do it? That is what is different about potentially having a cycling office in the Department as opposed to having people who can offer expertise on the detail of cycling design. The Department or a local authority could have a cycling officer who is not just looking at how to accommodate the needs of cyclists but how we can create new cyclists in future. It is a stated collective public goal.

There was mention of a figure of approximately 12% or 14% of budget for active travel from the National Transport Authority. What part of that relates to cycling? The Department mentioned an increase of €385 million in the budget, with over €354 million relating to capital increases. I am on the climate action committee and I know there is a 10% target so does the Department envisage that 10% of the new capital infrastructure might move to cycling? How can this be accelerated?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

Under the Government's climate action plan published in the summer, there is a commitment to increase the amount of funding to facilitate cycling infrastructure. The figure of approximately €354 million mentioned by the Deputy is the increase in the Department's budget from 2019 to 2020.

Comment on this

It relates to capital expenditure.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

I replied earlier to Deputy MacSharry about the level of capital funding.

For simplicity, we are just looking at the two main programmes we run that have a beneficial impact in this area. The 2019 allocation for those is €48 million and the 2020 allocation is €100 million.

Comment on this

There are five minutes left.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

An enormous slice of the step up next year is-----

Comment on this

It is going to address the imbalance in the overall percentage lag.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

Yes. Over time we want to build that up. That is the budget for active travel, as I said earlier.

Comment on this

What about cycling promotion?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

The Department has been involved in two main areas in cycling promotion. One of them is National Bike Week, which is very well known. That is an initiative run by the Department. We have ramped up what we have been doing in that for the last ten years. We are also engaged with European Mobility Week. One that is really interesting and encouraging because it gets in at an earlier stage is the initiative we have developed with cycling groups on cycle training.

Comment on this

I must call Deputy MacSharry. He is a member of the committee and I want to give him a fair amount of time.

Comment on this

I want to look after members of the committee first and other Members thereafter.

Comment on this

To be helpful rather than rude, Ms Hanlon gives great detail in her answers but perhaps I could get a "yes" or "no" to the questions I have. This will inform parliamentary questions in which I can tease the matter out further. I want to use the time as best I can. If the reply is neither "yes" nor "no" the witnesses can tell me it is not that simple or that they do not know.

Comment on this

In fairness to our witnesses, they have been as brief as they can be.

Comment on this

It is just that I do not have much time. Is there still a cross-departmental team on infrastructure at assistant secretary level that meets regularly?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

It is at Secretary General level.

Comment on this

How often does that meet?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

It will meet on Friday and it last met about six weeks ago.

Comment on this

Would it be fair to say it meets about six times a year?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

It meets more regularly than that.

Comment on this

Do the same representatives attend? Is it always the Secretaries General?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

It is the Secretaries General of the Departments that deal with infrastructure. They bring supplementary officials with them depending on the subjects on the agenda.

Comment on this

Are there plans to fund a cycling officer in each local authority?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

Is that local authorities?

Comment on this

Yes. Will the Department give the local authorities funding to fund an officer?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

We have not developed that piece of work yet.

Comment on this

Okay. Fingal County Council has €100 million on deposit on any given day while Sligo and Leitrim can barely fund a librarian, so that is an issue. Has the Department considered full segregation on a pilot basis in certain towns or certain parts of urban centres, that is, to make a street one way with one side for traffic and the other for micro mobility?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

Yes, some of our schemes do things like that.

Comment on this

It that being actively considered?

Comment on this
Mr. Hugh Creegan

Yes.

Comment on this

Okay. I will tease that out further in parliamentary questions. Regarding more financial incentives, there is the bike to work scheme but what about pensioners, retired people, non-workers and children? Are financial incentives being considered for them?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

It is a tax arrangement and it is done by the Minister for Finance-----

Comment on this

I know, but if I am a child I do not pay tax and if I am a pensioner I possibly do not pay tax either.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

It applies to workers and that is the tax arrangement.

Comment on this

There is no other scheme under consideration at present.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

No.

Comment on this

Okay. I will tease that out further as well. Regarding the new laws that came into force last week, have additional resources been provided to An Garda Síochána for enforcement?

Comment on this
Mr. Ray O'Leary

We are not in a position to answer questions about Garda resources.

Comment on this

I understand that.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray O'Leary

They are a matter for the Garda Commissioner.

Comment on this

Mr. O'Leary does not know.

Comment on this
Mr. Ray O'Leary

I do not know.

Comment on this

Put a parliamentary question to the Minister for Justice and Equality.

Comment on this

I will tease that out as well.

Comment on this

It could be referred to the Garda as well. There is one minute left.

Comment on this

This is my second last question. Are there any current plans for a cycling division in the Department?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

There is an active travel section in the Department and that is where we lead and progress this.

Comment on this

We established earlier that it is walking and greenways.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

No, it is not greenways. We have moved greenways to tourism. We still have links, but it is led by the tourism side.

Comment on this

How many staff are there?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

Walking and cycling are within the sustainable transport area of the Department.

Comment on this

That is the broad sustainable transport area.

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

No. Sustainable transport is my brief. Within it there is a group of people who deal with active travel.

Comment on this

How many are in the group?

Comment on this
Ms Deirdre Hanlon

Approximately five.

Comment on this

We are near closing time.

Comment on this

I know. This question has a "yes" or "no" answer and is for Ms Graham. When we discussed the disability issue in public transport previously I asked Ms Graham how long it would take, at current resource levels, to have saturation coverage in terms of vehicles that are accessible for disabled people. She answered that it would be at least ten years with current funding. I will apply the same question to cycling. At current resource levels, how many centuries will it be before we have saturation in terms of cycling infrastructure?

Comment on this

I do not know about centuries but our time is up and I must conclude the meeting. I thank Deputy Catherine Murphy for organising this meeting and advising all the people who participated. Minutes and correspondence have to be deferred to the next meeting. Senator Higgins can take up the issues with the witnesses as they leave.

Comment on this

I have a supplementary question.

Comment on this

I must adjourn the meeting.

Comment on this