PUBLIC SAFETY (EMERGENCY POWERS) BILL, 1923. - IN COMMITTEE.
Contributions 1–162 of 326. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 30 of 1923 ›
I put down an amendment:—"Before the word ‘It' in line 38 to insert the words ‘subject to the provisions of the Constitution.'" My reason for that is that the Constitution lays down in Sections 6, 7, 70 and 72 some important rules which cannot, as far as I see, be broken through. Any Bill that controverts the Constitution is in itself illegal. When a Bill is passed by the Oireachtas it is always to be considered in collaboration with the Constitution, and when the two clash the Constitution rules. I am not sure, but I think that is the Constitutional state of affairs. Section 6 of the Constitution states, "the liberty of the person is inviolable, and so on, and in Sections 7, 70 and 72, you will find similar provisions.
It seems to me that a good many of these Articles laid down here in this Bill now before us are clearly contrary to the Constitution. That would not matter if it was in time of war. Then, of course, the Constitution states very clearly and definitely that these Rules do not apply in time of war. So that, if this Bill referred merely to a time of war there would be no such objection to be raised. But it is clearly not that, because it is meant to continue after the war is over. For instance, any of those days the judges may decide, and it is for them to decide, that a state of war no longer exists. As long as they do not say that, the state of war is presumed to continue. But once the judges state that war has ceased, that in their opinion war has ceased, then, and therefore, they must grant a habeas corpus. Then we will have to go by the Constitution. It is not for me to say whether these do constitute breaches of the Constitution. I merely put this down subject to the provision in the Constitution. There are two things that might occur, if it is contrary to the Constitution. First it is contrary to the Constitution, and therefore is not law; or, as an alternative, it might be possible to amend the Constitution. If it is a law amending the Constitution I think the Minister ought tell us that. There ought be a preamble that this law amends the Constitution. The Constitution can be amended, but I do not see any such provision in this Bill. If the Bill is in accordance with the Constitution there is nothing more to be said about it.
Comment on this
This is not a Bill to amend the Constitution. The Constitution is the touchstone of every Bill and will be the touchstone of this. The Constitution provides that persons shall not be detained save in accordance with law. I do not know whether Senator Colonel Moore is suggesting that persons detained under this Act will not be detained in accordance with law. I am opposing the amendment moved by him on the grounds that it is not an improvement of the Bill, that it is superfluous and that it is a bad precedent to set in our legislation that a particular Bill which we are considering is to be read subject to the Constitution. Every Bill passing through the Dáil and Seanad will be read subject to the Constitution, and the words which the Senator proposes to insert are quite superfluous.
Comment on this
I agree with every word the Minister has uttered. It would be a great mistake to suggest that any Bill which did not specifically amend the Constitution could be read otherwise than in accordance with its provisions. I hope the amendment will be withdrawn.
Comment on this
It might be helpful if Senator Moore referred to any portion of the Bill that he considers provides for trial for criminal offences without a jury.
Comment on this
That is very easily done. There is not a jury mentioned from end to end. Section 1 is a good example.
Comment on this
That does not affect in any way a person's right to have a jury when he is tried. Whenever he is tried it does not affect his right to have a jury.
Comment on this
That is a different question. Your suggestion is that the Bill was ultra vires with the Constitution inasmuch as it deprived a person of his right to be tried by a jury. The clause does not do anything of the sort. I do not think you will find any provision in the Bill which deprives a person of the right to be tried by jury.
Comment on this
The Constitution indicates that the liberty of the person is inviolable. That liberty is not inviolable if the Minister can take a man and shove him into prison whenever he likes.
Comment on this
But the law, I maintain, would be contrary to the provisions of the Constitution.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
I beg to move: —Section 1: to delete in line 38 the words "an Executive Minister," and to substitute therefor the words "the Executive Council or any Minister thereof authorised by them." This is very small beer compared with the vital amendments which are coming on later. The object of it is to fix the responsibility for these very wide powers as far as possible and to leave it as little vague as possible.
Comment on this
In the definition which we have of the words "Executive Minister" it is stated that the Executive Minister mentioned in the Bill shall be a Minister who is a member of the Executive Council. That absolutely secures what the Senator's amendment wishes to secure—the collective responsibility of the Executive Council for acts performed under the provisions of the Bill. The Executive Council are, collectively, responsible for all matters concerning the Departments of State that are administered by any one member of the Executive Council, and that collective responsibility is observed throughout the Bill. That is why no one member or two members of the Executive Council were mentioned specifically. There is no specific mention in the Bill of the Minister for Home Affairs or of the Minister for Defence, because the things done under the Bill will be matters for which the Council will be responsible as a whole—collectively responsible.
Comment on this
I think what the Minister has stated is correct, but I should like to urge him to consider that, from the point of view of the public, it would be wise to insert words such as are proposed. The substance, I admit, is the same. Where you have an Executive Council there is, of course, collective responsibility, and the whole Council would be, under the present words, collectively responsible for the act of any one Minister. But the way in which the amendment appeals to me is, that it is desirable that this Bill should be carried out by one, or at most two,—possibly the Minister for Defence and the Minister for Home Affairs, or either or both. It seems to me as it stands now that the public will say that the Minister for Education is interning somebody or the Minister for something else. I admit collective responsibility is there, but I think it would be better if the Council themselves delegated their powers to one or two of the Ministers named so as to make it clear. I would not be in favour of pressing the amendment, but I hope the Minister will consider the matter and see whether it would not, from the public point of view, make it clear.
Comment on this
I am of opinion, and I am confirmed in that opinion by the Attorney-General, that in fact the acceptance of the amendment would be rather to weaken the position and restrict, to some extent, responsibility. The words "Executive Minister" were used throughout the Bill to emphasise the collective responsibility aspect. If we substitute for that, that a particular Minister authorised by the rest may do these things, then that tends to limit, and will in the public mind, tend to limit the responsibility for acts done under the Bill.
Comment on this
In view of what has been said and as there are other amendments far more important, which I really believe in, I ask leave to with draw the amendment.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—Section 1—"To delete all after the word ‘shall' in line 42 to the word ‘officer' in line 43, and to substitute therefor the words ‘certify in writing that he is satisfied.'" The object of the amendment is to endeavour, to some extent, to meet a point to which I referred on the Second Reading. The Minister in reply, possibly not to remarks of mine, but to some points made in the discussion, said that some Senators had objected to portion of Section 2, which gave a responsible officer of the Civic Guard power to arrest. As far as I am concerned I certainly did not object to anything of the kind, because I do not see what the Civic Guard are there for except to arrest persons whom they suspect. But the feeling, I think, is this, that the object of the Government will be met every bit as well by the words I have suggested, which would put the whole responsibility on the Minister concerned without his having to state exactly, or even state at the tribunal, the exact source from which he received his information.
If you are going to have power of interning given a Minister, then I think it is much better that he himself should be satisfied that the reasons put forward for suspicion are good. As it stands in the Bill, you bring in your responsible officer, who may be either a Superintendent of the Civic Guard or a Commandant of the Army. What I want to avoid, if possible, is bringing in these new forces, particularly the Civic Guard, and mixing them up with this Bill in the eyes of the public. I should like it to be made quite clear that if an officer of the Civic Guard arrests a man he brings him forward in the ordinary Courts for trial, but if in the meantime, under the Bill, the Minister interferes and interns him, the public cannot blame the Civic Guard officer who is responsible. This and another amendment further down would have the effect, in Section 1, of placing the full responsibility on the Minister. Exactly where he gets his information he is not bound to disclose, and it would not bring in the Civic Guard to the same extent in the public mind. I hope the Minister will consider this, and see whether it is not possible definitely to remove the advice of this officer of the Civic Guard in regard to interning.
Comment on this
I wonder whether the Senator has considered this aspect: that it might well be a weakening of the section to leave out any reference to a definite report from a responsible officer, and that the amendment that he proposes to substitute would, in fact, enable the Minister to act without such report, simply on the ground that he personally was satisfied, possibly by something that he heard from some reliable person who had been in to see him on other business, or possibly in some other way, that there were reasonable grounds for suspecting a particular person of being engaged in the commission of the offences mentioned in Part I. Whether it is really strengthening the Bill to substitute a mere certificate from a Minister for a definite Order based on a definite report from a responsible officer of the rank named in the Bill is simply a matter to consider. If the Senators generally consider that there is virtue in the amendment I would not oppose it, and I would be prepared to move in the Dáil that it be accepted.
Comment on this
No. If the amendment is accepted it will read "in respect of whom such Minister shall certify in writing that he is satisfied that such a person." I do not know how the section then would read. I suppose it will read "is satisfied that there is reasonable ground"—the word "officer" would go.
Comment on this
In reply to the Minister, I might say that I have carefully considered the point he made, and my feeling is that this is abnormal legislation for a period of six months. The ordinary carrying out of the law by the Civic Guard is a thing which we want to establish definitely in the country by means of the ordinary law. It will be permanent; it is becoming permanent; and it is essential that the respect and complete confidence of the country and of the people of all sections should be gained by the Civic Guard in the exercise of their duty. I think, even if it were weakening them—I do not think, for reasons which I will state, that it is —that it would really be what the Government require, and would help, in any case, to prevent the danger of our mixing the new things which we are setting up—which we are proud of and hope to be permanent—with this temporary legislation, however necessary it may be.
Personally I do not think that, if a man is a Minister, and fit to be a Minister, he will do as Mr. O'Higgins suggests— which I know he does not mean—simply take something said to him by someone who was in on other business. I would rather, if we are going to have internment, to have a statement signed by a Minister or his responsible official, to the effect that he is satisfied that the grounds are reasonable without stating that he has a report from a Superintendent of the Civic Guard. I suggest, therefore, that, instead of weakening, it would rather strengthen the section. What I want to particularly avoid is that a person in a town should feel that a certain superintendent in the Civic Guard was the man who reported him or his cousin, whoever it is who happens to be interned under this Bill. It is an endeavour to try and keep the Civic Guard out of such a position. I thank the Minister for the way he met this amendment, and in stating that he is willing to leave it to the Seanad. On this occasion I hope the Seanad will agree to the amendment.
Comment on this
As it is going to be left to the Seanad, I think, on looking forward a little into the Bill, that Senator Douglas is fighting for a principle that underlies Clause 2, where the Executive Minister takes the whole responsibility on himself, and where the officer of the Civic Guard makes the arrest and only carries out the ordinary law. If there is anything to be done beyond the ordinary law to carry out this Bill, then the Minister takes full responsibility. I think what Senator Douglas is asking for is that much of the same principle should apply to Clause 1. As it strikes one on looking at the section, if the Minister does not think the amendment injures the Bill, it seems reasonable.
Comment on this
I think the principle is that the Minister can be changed if he does an unpopular act. He can go away, taking the bitterness he has raised with him, but the Civic Guard cannot be changed.
Comment on this
The whole point at issue in this section is not whether the Minister shall certify that a person is to be detained, but whether it shall be on the report of a responsible officer. The fundamental issue is giving anybody the right to arrest and detain any citizen in this country without trial.
Comment on this
That does not arise on this amendment. That would arise on an amendment to leave out the section.
Comment on this
With all respect, the manner in which it is to be done is under consideration. If I understand Senator Douglas's amendment aright, it is to amend the section in so far as it is provided that on the recommendation of an officer the Minister shall have power to do so and so.
Comment on this
Quite right But what you said was that the cardinal mistake was in giving power to arrest at all. That is an argument in favour of an amendment to omit the section.
Comment on this
Am I not in order in discussing whether it is on the advice of the police officer or the Minister himself that power shall be given to order detention?
Comment on this
Certainly, you are entitled to discuss the alternatives, but it is not relevant to say that you want to have the whole section removed.
Comment on this
I quite follow, but the way to raise that is to move the omission of the section.
Comment on this
You are rather late. If such an amendment had been down I would have had to take it first.
Comment on this
I think, as it stands, the section is perfectly reasonable. The Executive Minister, it seems to me, according to the section, is the only person given power to order arrest. He gets the report and orders arrest. I do not think by adding the amendment to the Bill that it will make him any less responsible. The following section gives powers to a subordinate officer, and there I should like some safeguards introduced. I do not think the present amendment will take any power from or give any power to the officer without an order from the Executive Minister. I do not think the Bill would be improved by such amendment.
Comment on this
I have no special regard for the amendment, as I fail to see how the section can be satisfactorily amended. The only point in the amendment that appeals to me was the one emphasised by Senator Douglas, that the acceptance of the amendment would tend to save the Civic Guard from becoming a new R.I.C. or Black and Tan organisation. It is unfortunate at the very inception of their career that they should be called upon to discharge duties of this particular character, and definitely made responsible in this subsection for the internment of people without trial. After all, the law is successful or otherwise according to the respect in which those who administer it are held, and if we proceed right away by making the Civic Guard, which is the principal police force in the country, discharge duties of this obnoxious nature and make them directly responsible for the detention of people without trial— possibly large numbers of people—we are going to strike at the very fundamentals of justice in the beginning. That is the only point of view from which I would support the amendment. For that reason I hope the Seanad will adopt it in order to try, as far as possible, to make the Civic Guard respected a little more than the R.I.C. was, and to render the force more liable to discharge its duties in a more satisfactory manner, and with more public confidence, than will be the case if these duties are imposed upon them.
Comment on this
I do not think the object is to make the clause perfect, but simply to place the responsibility on the Minister. As the clause stands he can act without any responsibility on receipt of some report.
Comment on this
I propose the following amendment:—Section 1: To delete in lines 43-45 the words "reasonable ground for suspecting such person of," and to substitute therefor the words "prima facie evidence of such person.” The object of this amendment is shown on the face of it, and I do not think it requires much argument. I can only give you an instance of what I know was done in the past by people across the water, who, I regret to say, are now being copied very much on this side of the water. They kept a man in prison in the belief that he was reasonably suspected. The matter was later brought before a Commission which they had set up, and the evidence was that a certain policeman admitted that the prisoner had not been keeping company with any suspicious person. Then he was asked why he reasonably suspected him, and he explained that this man had paid a visit to the priest. It was admitted that the priest was not a rebel nor suspected of being a rebel. It was also stated that another man had been on a visit with the priest, and that he was reasonably suspected. Although it could not be shown that the first prisoner came in contact with the other prisoner, he was suspected. These are the sorts of suspicions that will take place when you want to arrest a man. When you want to arrest a man in the country there are suspicions on all kinds of extraordinary grounds. I want to see some prima facie evidence showing that there is some cause for arresting a man.
Comment on this
I would not be open to accept that amendment, and if the Seanad were to accept it I would have no alternative but to ask the Dáil not to accept it. It would render the Executive absolutely powerless in dealing with the situation in the country. Senators must know that there are scores of men engaged in criminal activities throughout the country against whom it would be impossible to produce even that prima facie evidence which the amendment demands. Personally I am aware that there are men in charge of columns in various parts of the country still in hiding who could not be placed on trial, and against whom no prima facie evidence could be produced. The term “suspicion” throughout this Bill means something more than suspicion. It means common knowledge prevailing through a locality, but inasmuch as everything short of legal proof has to be covered, the word suspicion has to be used in the Bill. I could not agree to an amendment which would impose on the Executive the necessity of producing prima facie evidence.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
I propose the following amendment:—Section 1: To insert after the word "is," in line 50, the words "for reasons stated in the report." This amendment was moved in the Dáil, and was rejected on the grounds that the inclusion of the words might leave it open to a civil court to enquire into the sufficiency of the reasons stated. The words at the end of the clause were added as a kind of safeguard to insure that the powers given by this clause would be utilised only on account of the state of war. The argument that the words to be added would bring the case before the Courts is of doubtful validity. In any case, the words about the state of war have been added. The intention of the amendment is simply that the military authorities should not be able to secure the internment of any person on the general statement that it is a matter of military necessity.
Something more definite should be required. Presumably a military officer always makes a report of some sort as to why he makes an internment. The amendment would mean that the information in that report, or at least the substance of it, should be passed on to the Minister who orders the internment. I cannot see why this amendment cannot be accepted. We all know from experience, with human nature as it is, that it would be humanly impossible to get any body of men, whether members of the Civic Guard or of the Army, who are all desirable. We all know it is quite possible that men may get into the Army who are undesirable. I am not suggesting that the general body of the Army are undesirable. I suggest that it is quite possible for undesirables to get into the Civic Guard and become officers. I suggest that men may have petty spleen, and if they are empowered, without making a definite specific report as to why a person is reasonably suspected, they should not be allowed to deprive a man of his liberty. It should not be within the power of any officer, military or police, to deprive a citizen of his or her liberty without making a definite specific report as to the reasons for so doing. I leave it to the good sense and honour of the Seanad to see justice done to the rights of the citizen.
Comment on this
The Senator seems to proceed on the assumption that it is not possible to limit by statute the ordinary powers of the military in times of armed rebellion. That is contrary to my advice on the matter, which is expert and technical. I am informed that if in a Bill you state reasons for what courses are to be taken, and set out in writing the reasons, thereupon you place it in the competence of the Court to inquire into the sufficiency of those reasons. Both in the Dáil and in the Seanad I have been strongly advised by the Attorney-General not to agree to the insertion of those words or any similar words, and that if they were to be inserted it brings it within the competence of the Courts to ask for the reasons and to inquire into their sufficiency. That would be an impossible position to place the military in when confronted with a military situation.
Comment on this
I suggest that the military necessity is passed, and my desire is, for God's sake let us not think of the past, but of the present, and let us see that the rights and liberties of the citizens of this country shall be protected.
Comment on this
This is a letter, dated 27th June, 1923, from Mr. Frank Aiken to Mr. Ernest O'Malley, a prisoner in Mountjoy:—
General Headquarters, Dublin,
27th June, 1923.
Dept. C/s.
To E. O'M.
Yours of 20th June received on 26/6/23.
1. I am sorry to hear that you are still confined to bed. If you were able to move round a little at all you would soon get your strength.
2. It is a splendid idea to start classes. I was never in jail very long myself, but while I was there I was absolutely fed up with the way men used to lounge around.
3. Military Organisation. Our time is pretty much taken up with our present difficulties, so that I have not made a very deep analysis of the real reasons for our failure. I believe your three reasons and the fact that it was a defensive war, and that we always thought the enemy would not go so far, were the principal ones.
4. That question of staff work. There was too much of it done by Division O/C.'s through the country instead of by Adjutants, and there wouldn't be call for half as much if the junior officers were impressed with the necessity of sending short reports regularly.
With regard to the future, I believe the rifle and revolver is out of date as an offensive weapon, and that riflemen should only be on protection for special Corps of Engineers. The use of explosives, gas, and fire may be concentrated on, also small trench mortars.
Organisation. Our organisation in the past made for a lot of unnecessary duplication and staff work. You should raise a discussion on this matter, and see if it would be better to have county organisation and batts., and the present divisional officers merely an operation and inspecting staff. If we have to fight another war with the Staters, it will have to be short and sweet, and our units will need to be trained in taking the offensive in large bodies.
Non-fighting men. I am continually impressing on Divs. the fact that the lack of civilian organisation to back us up was chiefly responsible for our present position, and that it is their duty to see that our civilian supporters are organised, also that the Fianna are reorganised and trained at once.
Hoping to have an answer from you soon to my circular to members of original Executive of the 23rd instant, and that you will be soon strong again.
Comment on this
The letter read by the Minister is very impressive if not taken in connection with other facts. We know arrests have practically ceased throughout the whole country, and there is a very shrewd suspicion abroad that the writer of that letter and other people more prominent than he are available both in Dublin and outside, but are still left at large. It is inconceivable to think of the number of prominent men that have been left at large and the general belief is that they can be arrested. I do not like to suggest that they are left at large as an excuse for a measure of this kind, which proposes to trample on the elementary freedom of the citizen. The amendment is of a character that one can hardly imagine the Minister should refuse assent to. It merely suggests that whatever Minister is responsible for the detention of the arrested person shall know from the military authority the reason why he is being interned. Otherwise there is no use whatever for having the Minister in Parliament, alleged to be responsible for the internment of those people, when he can say he has not the slightest idea why they are interned. All he can say is that some military captain, perhaps one with a limited experience, says that those people should be interned, and "consequently because of this Act which you yourselves have passed I have no right to inquire into it." I do not know how this would meet him. All those reasons could be inquired into by the Civic Guard.
That may be; but I hope, and all the indications go to show that we are approaching a period when there will be no great danger to the State involved in having matters of this kind brought into the Court, and the sooner the Executive Council show they have the confidence that that time is approaching, the more likely is the restoration of normal conditions to come about. It is this panicky legislation, such as the refusal to accept simple amendments of this kind, which keeps people on tenter-hooks, and which is injurious here and disastrous abroad. I hope notwithstanding what he has already said, that the Minister will see his way to reconsider the matter, and that the Seanad will accept the amendment, looking at the country as they know it, and record their own convictions. There must be a tremendous censorship of the Press if the country is as bad as the Minister would lead us to believe. We hear of terrible happenings, but very little appears in the Press. We hear of very little violence, and we are informed no censorship is in operation. Consequently it is only in the minds of certain people that those things may come to pass. I believe there is no justification for passing this section, and, consequently, that the amendment moved by Senator Farren should be accepted
Comment on this
I must say I am not much impressed by this letter, which was read already in the Dáil. It is a custom of the Minister, when he wants to get something out of the way, to shake gory locks in our faces, and say "This is what you may expect; we know what those people were and what they did; we know that they did make use of the petrol can and revolver." The reading of that letter does not tell us anything more than what we know. But we also know that those things do not happen now. This is bringing the past into the future as a kind of horoscope that what has been done in the past is to be done in the future. Until we make some effort to get some friendship into this country we will never get further, and if we pass this measure we are only pushing things further away from us.
Comment on this
I move as an amendment to delete Clause (c). Senators will notice that Clauses (a) and (b) cover certain cases that powers are needed to deal with, and Part II. of the Schedule contains a whole litany of crimes that powers are sought to deal with. This clause is intended to meet some particular cases which the Executive appears to be somewhat afraid to mention. I assume that it is intended to deal probably with politicians or Labour leaders or social reformers, or other people of that type, who, in the opinion of the Executive Council, would be much better removed, and the Executive Council, apparently consider it desirable to prevent them from creating difficulties. There is no case that could not be dealt with under the ordinary law, with the exception of the cases mentioned here, and why the Executive Council should be seeking such wide powers as are contained in Clause (c) I fail to understand. If the clause is aimed at getting political opponents put out of the way, it is an unfair thing. If it is intended to deal with social reformers, it is likewise unfair; it is unfair to leave them at the mercy of any man in the crowd, either officer or anybody else. Whatever class he sprang from, he would be paid to do a certain duty, and he would be directly bound to be opposed to the feelings of the people he is listening to. He has the power to get them interned simply because he might not agree with their system of propaganda. In my opinion, the powers sought here are too wide.
Comment on this
I would like to support this amendment, for the reason that I believe the section as it stands is a further encroachment on one of the few privileges that a citizen enjoys. It seems to me that it is handing into the hands of any Minister or the Executive the power to arrest without charge any civilian. I hold, and I think the Seanad will agree with me, that that is not a state of affairs that should exist in this country. There ought to be some charter of liberty for the individual. Sub-sections (a) and (b) have already provided sufficient powers to deal with any individuals with whom it may be necessary to deal.
Comment on this
Paragraph (a) of this sub-section deals strictly with offences mentioned in Part I. of the Schedule, and paragraph (b) deals with arrests made during a state of war or armed revolt. Paragraph (c) deals, and is intended to deal, particularly with the question of public safety. It deals with situations that will arise the day after the Courts decide that a condition of war or armed revolt does not exist in the country. I do not know when the Courts may decide that; I do not know when the Courts may refuse to accept the affidavit of the Adjutant-General that you have an organisation opposed to the State, that that organisation has arms and explosives at its disposal, and has refused to surrender them to the accredited representatives of the people and to those who alone have the right to control lethal weapons in the country.
I do not know that the Courts may decide that that state of affairs does not constitute a state of war or armed revolt. On the day after they so decide you will have a situation where people who have been in hiding for a long time may come out and work more or less openly, and unless covered by (a) or (b) it would not be within the power of the Executive to arrest such persons. Senators Duffy and MacPartlin suggest that paragraph (a) is sufficiently broad. It does not give power to deal with people preparing for the commission of such offences or people advocating the commission of such offences. It confines itself to people who have been committing or concerned in committing offences in Part I. of the Schedule, and people who are abusing their liberty to the detriment of the public safety. It is really for the Senators, in a responsible spirit, as it was for the Dáil, to ask themselves whether it is right, in a situation like the present, and with the potentialities that there are for future trouble in the country, to hamper the Executive—an Executive that will be from day to day responsible to the people's representatives in the Dáil and inside two months will be responsible to the people's representatives in the Dáil, elected on the broadest possible franchise basis. That Executive cannot remain a day in office if it has lost the confidence of the people's representatives. It is to a body of that kind that it is proposed to entrust those powers.
I have said again and again, with regard to this Bill, that theoretically it can be used as a vehicle of tyranny and a vehicle of oppression, or, as some of the Senators have called it, a coercion Bill, but I submit that is not probable, and in fact and in practice that is not possible, because the Executive that would attempt to so use it would not retain the confidence of the majority of the people's representatives.
You have got to distinguish between the letter of the Bill and the spirit of the Bill in which these powers will, in fact, be exercised. If you hamper and fetter and restrict the Executive, then you would not be entitled to complain of the results. If no one would be arrested except people concerned in committing offences mentioned in Part I. of the Schedule, except where you have the situation of war or armed revolt, then you are hampering the Executive, and you are hampering it in dealing with people going around the country sowing the seeds of future war or armed revolt; in dealing with persons the most dangerous of all—the person who keeps clear from any firing line himself, but is active in stirring up revolt and stirring up conditions that will react disastrously on the country.
Comment on this
I see tremendous danger in this portion, which leaves room for the secret letter being sent by the opponents of certain people to the responsible military authority, and it then being acted upon. Now, the liberty of the subject is all-important. We should endeavour to provide that no subject of this nation might possibly be arrested and detained on anything but what was a fair charge. We cannot punish people for their opinions. We cannot imprison a man or woman for having certain opinions. Everybody is entitled to have opinions, and I suggest that it is possible, with partisanship running so high as it is in this country at the moment, that a person who would be guilty of no crime—persons who would conscientiously and honestly have their convictions and work for them in a constitutional way, would be arrested.
I would suggest that, if you go to the utmost of the terms that are proposed in this Bill, it is quite possible that such people might be deprived of their liberty. I do not suggest for a moment that the Executive would use these powers harshly, but the Minister has admitted that it could be used as a measure of coercion. The Minister admits that. I have been trying in my own way to put that before this Seanad and it is quite possible, if this Bill is passed, that it can be used as a measure of tyranny to deprive the subjects of this nation of their liberty. Now, that is a very serious thing. To take away the liberty of a subject is a very serious thing, and I respectfully suggest that the Minister is not taking the proper view of the position. The Minister seems to think that there is quite a possibility that there may be a recurrence of trouble in this country. I suppose it is quite natural that the Minister, having been, as he has been, a member of the Executive during the past twelve months, would not be taking the same view as a person outside, moving amongst the people, would take. As one who travels about the country, I think the danger of a recurrence of war is over. I think that our people have got such a sickener and horror of war, and horror and a distaste against everything appertaining to war and the gun, that it will be a long time before the people of this country will go into war again, whether it be war amongst themselves or war against any other nation. Therefore, I do not see the necessity for taking these powers. For the good name of the country I sincerely hope that this clause will not be passed. I think it would be a blot on our civilisation to pass this Bill.
Comment on this
Looking at the schedule of crimes in Parts I. and II., one would imagine that these embody every possible crime that could be committed against the State, and that there should be no necessity for giving further scope and opportunity to the Executive.
Comment on this
Then, I suggest that instead of including that, Clause 3, the schedule of crimes, should be amended, and that if there are special crimes in the Minister's mind to which the paragraph 3 refers, these crimes should be specified in the schedules.
Comment on this
I think it would be a good thing if the Minister would give us some idea as to the distinction between (a) and (c) in regard to the powers which are claimed. I think it would be well if he would consider whether, if this clause is retained, there might not be words inserted which might meet one, at any rate, of the points which some of the Labour Senators have raised. They want to make it clear that constitutional action, even in a direction which some of us might think would not be for the public good, would not be interfered with. “Public safety” is a pretty wide term— much wider than in most of the other sections in the Bill. Therefore, I think that the Minister might consider between this and the next stage whether some other words might not be introduced which would be somewhat more limiting than the words “public safety.” Most of the other powers are given either for definitely endangering the State, as in Part 1, or for the offences mentioned in Part 2 of the schedule, which you have in Section 2. In this case you have the vague powers simply of “public safety,” and I think these are words which would cause some uneasiness. I can quite understand the desire of the Minister to be able to use the powers in Sub-section (a) in reference to persons who might not actually have formed military units, or might not technically come under Part 1. At the same time, I see the point of the Labour Senators that “public safety” might be taken by some Minister—and we cannot be sure of the Minister we may have—to include offences which it is not desirable should be dealt with except by means of a Court. Personally, I can conceive of persons making speeches which, in my opinion, do not help the public safety; but unless they advocate armed violence, or violence of some kind, I am not prepared to intern them for the speeches.
Comment on this
There is one point which I think some of those present, including the Minister, seem to be overlooking. As has already been pointed out, Sub-section (a) deals with armed revolt and Sub-section (b) deals with a state of war. In addition to that, Part 2 of the Schedule contains a litany of all the possible crimes that could be committed against the public safety. Section 2 of this Bill reads: “It shall be lawful for a responsible officer to arrest and to detain in custody for any period not exceeding one week, any person found committing or attempting to commit, or whom such officer suspects of having committed, any of the offences mentioned in Part 2 of the Schedule to this Act.” It goes on to state that at the expiration of one week the Minister shall have power to intern that man without trial for any of the crimes mentioned in Part 2 of the Schedule. What other crime is there that a person could commit against the public safety in addition to these that cannot be dealt with under the ordinary law, unless the Executive are to have the power to intern everybody whom they may wish and keep them there without trial?
I do not know what state of mind the draftsmen of the Bill were in when they put in Sub-section 3. It seems utterly unnecessary, and sweeps away the last vestige of protection remaining to the individual citizen. It leaves it open to any evil-minded individual to lock up a large section of the community. It leaves it open to Ministers deeply imbued with political ideas and vigorously opposed to their opponents, to lock up at crucial periods some of their opponents merely on the strength of a report under this sub-section. It is too dangerously wide altogether as it stands, and it does not seem necessary. It seems a gross abuse of private liberty altogether. I do not believe that the suggestion of Senator Douglas is practicable, and I hope the mover of the amendment will not accept any amendment, such as to put in other words for "public safety," because, I believe, the only way to amend this is to delete the sub-section altogether.
Comment on this
Principles of liberty are easily stated, and Senators have been stating absolute principles of liberty with a certain glibness, forgetting that people enjoy the maximum of liberty by agreeing between themselves to surrender a certain amount; forgetting that men live together in society by each making certain concessions to all; Senator Farren agreeing not to exercise his liberty of throwing stones through my window, and I making a reciprocal concession, and so on. There are times when, in order to enjoy liberty and security, it is necessary to give up more than in normal times; to surrender to the Committee of the people, which is called the Executive Council, greater rights and powers than would be surrendered in normal, hum-drum, routine times. That is the principle underlying the whole of this Bill, that the decent, law-abiding people of the country, in order that security may be restored for them, in order that they may sleep of nights, in order that we may get back to the day when a man can leave his door on the latch, entrust to their Committee or Executive Council larger powers than it is usual normally to entrust to such an Executive.
These are broad powers that are asked for in this Bill. They are not considered excessive, having regard to the circumstances of the times and of the possibilities of the future. I am asked what kind of case would come under Sub-section (c) as distinct from (a) and (b), and I am reminded that “public safety” is a vague word. It is a vague word. But the body in the country that has the duty of interpreting where public safety lies in any particular case is the Executive Council. If its interpretation is wise, if it is an interpretation that appeals to the common-sense of the majority of the people's representatives, that Executive Council will remain in office. If its interpretation is unwise, if it is harsh, if it is tyrannical, if it is oppressive, presumably that Executive Council will not retain the confidence of the majority of the people's representatives. I do base the whole case for this Bill on that—that its powers are to be exercised by an Executive responsible from day to day, and from week to week, to the people through their representatives. That is democracy; that is representative government.
I could not state offhand the exact cases that might, in a given set of circumstances, come under (c) as distinct from (a) and (b). Let us take a purely hypothetical case. Sub-section (a) gives power to arrest and detain without trial people on reasonable suspicion of participation in the offences mentioned in Part 1 of the Schedule. Sub-section (b) deals with arrests made during a state of war or armed revolt. My attention was drawn by Senator Cummins to Part 2 of the Schedule, with which Section 2 of the Bill deals. What about the people advocating the offences mentioned in Part 2 of the Schedule, or, for that matter, advocating the offences mentioned in Part 1 of the Schedule? The arrests mentioned in (a) are for participation in the acts mentioned in Part 1 of the Schedule. The arrests mentioned in (b) are for active participation in the offences mentioned in Part 2. What about the man who goes around the country advocating both one and the other, or advocating either for that matter? Let us take one item in Part 5: Wrongful entry and retention of possession of land without colour or pretence to title or authority. A man who does that may be arrested under Section 2 of the Bill. The only provision you have for the man who goes around inciting to these offences is paragraph (c) of Section 1. Public safety is a broad term. The interpretation of it would not be the same in one set of circumstances as it would in altered circumstances. The body that must interpret it from day to day and decide where public safety lies is the Executive Council, and that body holds office from the representatives of the people. It cannot hold office one day or one hour longer than it succeeds in retaining the confidence of the majority of the people's representatives.
Comment on this
I think I can assist the Minister if I draw his attention to Section 12 of Part 2 of the Schedule. He has mentioned that the only thing which occurs to him at the moment as left out of this Schedule is the encouraging or advocating the commission of any of the crimes mentioned in Parts 1 and 2 of the Schedule. Section 12 reads: "Aiding, abetting, assisting in or encouraging the commission of any of the offences mentioned in this Schedule, or helping in the concealment or escape of any person guilty of any such offence." That certainly covers the cases mentioned by the Minister but he might have overlooked it for the moment. Seeing that he has made a special point about it, I hope he will now see his way to accept it.
Comment on this
After listening to a good many of the speeches that we have heard, one would think that all danger has passed in this country, and that we are living in a state of perfect peace. Unfortunately, I must say that is not my experience. I know that peace does not exist yet in spite of the efforts of the Government and of the forces that are working for peace in the country. Houses are being visited and raided still. We are urged to reject the advice of our present Government, who have succeeded in giving us the amount of peace we now have. I really cannot understand how the Seanad could be asked to accept an amendment which predicts a state of peace which most of us know does not exist. We hope it will exist; but for the Seanad to say to the Government, "We will not take your advice as to the essential requirements of the present state of the country, but will take away from you the weapon that you say from your experience is necessary for the public safety," would be acting against the best interest of public safety. I, for one, cannot see how we can take the advice of those who have not got the experience and do not know what the country requires, in preference to the advice of the Ministers who have charge of the country and know the dangers with which we are confronted.
Comment on this
Senator Jameson's information is quite different from what I have heard, and is quite different from what the Ministers themselves state. Ministers themselves state the country is quiet. The Postmaster-General stated the other day at Athlone that there was less crime in Ireland than in any country in Europe. These things may or may not be true. I have not been all over the country, and I do not know, but, judging from the newspapers and from what people tell you, my information does not agree with Senator Jameson. He might be right. I do not know where he gets his information. With regard to the Minister's statement about the representatives of the nation turning out the Government if they do not do what is right, I do not think that is our experience of party government at all. Party Government, I am afraid, is not better than any other form of government. If a party intends to back a Minister, it does so through thick and thin, whether he is right or wrong, not only here, but in England and everywhere else. The party backs him, and the Minister sails along until the election comes, and that Government is turned out of office.
Comment on this
I only rise to express an opinion in agreement with Senator Jameson's. Within the last week there have been two cases of incendiarism within ten miles of where I live, and one murder. They are all the more serious because we have not found the people coming forward to give evidence as to the commission of these crimes. As to the amendment before the Seanad, I cannot see the particular and cowardly crime of inciting others to commit offences mentioned in the list. Sub-section (c) appears to have been drawn up for the purpose of meeting that omission.
Comment on this
I only want to say a word about what Senator Jameson has put before the Seanad. He suggests that we are not supposed to reject or criticise anything put forward by the Government. That has not been the attitude that Senator Jameson took on other Bills in which his own party were interested. I think I remember him putting forward certain amendments to certain Bills. In connection with the Land Bill I have also seen people putting forward amendments. We have the same right, especially if the object is to make the Government more popular than it is. I believe this section is encroaching too much on the liberty of the people. I believe there is plenty of power in the Bill to cover all the crimes that the Government wishes to cover. If we are to take the line suggested by Senator Jameson, the best thing we could do is to dissolve the Seanad and the Dáil and let the Government manage the show.
Comment on this
The Seanad divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I beg to move: To delete in line 2, the words "from a responsible officer, or." This follows naturally on Amendment 2, which was passed by the Seanad. I take out responsible officers, and leave in paragraph (c)—namely, that the Minister receives reports from the military authorities as distinct from a military officer. It is entirely in consonance with the argument adopted in regard to (a), which was passed.
Comment on this
I think this amendment scarcely follows on the amendment which was accepted, and which was an agreement to leave out any reference to a report, and place the responsibility on the Minister to act on his own initiative. Paragraph (c) retains mention of a report, and provides that people may during this middle period be interned without trial if a report is received that they are abusing their liberty and that it is a danger to the public that they should remain at liberty. If that is right, if we decide to put in this Bill the powers of internment of persons who are abusing their liberty, then I see no reason why the police should be excluded, and that a report to that effect should be strictly confined to military sources. The police will shortly be established in 807 stations throughout the country. One may assume, if the improvement in affairs be progressive, that the military will be gradually withdrawn from the country, and concentrated in larger centres here and there. It is simply a case that if we decide to intern at all, if we think this transitional period demands internment without trial, that internment should be possible on a police report. I share to a certain extent the reluctance of Senator Douglas to bring the police into what some might consider a temporary Act arising out of the political situation, but surely the police are the guardians of the people, and, even more than the military, they are concerned with the question of the public peace and safety, and if a Minister is to intern on report that an individual citizen is abusing his liberty there is no case for excluding a police report, and saying that it must emanate from a military source.
Comment on this
I think the Minister is right to this extent to bring it into conformity with (a), and that the words “military authority” should go out. That would leave it open to the Minister as in (a) to use the source he thinks best. I agree that the public safety is the business of the police, but I want the Civic Guards, so far as their responsibility is concerned to carry out the ordinary law which, in the future, they will be expected to carry out. I do not know whether I would be allowed to alter my amendment, and substitute different words so as to conform with (a).
Comment on this
If you withdraw the present amendment I will accept it.
Comment on this
I now propose: "In respect of whom such Minister shall certify in writing that he is satisfied that the public safety is endangered by such person being allowed to remain at liberty."
Comment on this
Your amendment is not in order, because the words you want to omit are now gone.
Comment on this
Before you rule out that, I think there is some misunderstanding. By that amendment the section is considerably disimproved.
Comment on this
Whether it is improved or disimproved, the Seanad has passed it, and if you think there is anything wrong you can deal with it on the Report Stage. I put the amendment and it was carried unanimously.
Comment on this
You are now going to put the section as a whole, and because of the inclusion of Sub-section (c) I am going to divide the Seanad. I desire to oppose the section as a whole, but particularly because of the inclusion of Sub-section (c).
Comment on this
The motion is: "That Clause 1 Section 1, as amended, stand part of the Bill."
Comment on this
I am sorry to find that people who continuously remind us that they do not belong to any one party —that they are simply national representatives with a broad and national aspect— again remind us that they are going to do nothing but take the word of the Minister, who, of course, represents a party. It is deplorable that in an Assembly of this kind people do not exercise a little more liberty of conscience. It is extraordinary that this body could not be convinced of the necessity of accepting the amendment I have referred to. The Minister was not very strongly opposed to it, and if he could only have got a little encouragement from the people who mistakenly supported him he would have accepted it. For that reason I am going to vote against the section, and I hope that the panic displayed in other places will not be displayed here, and that Senator Jameson's dictum that the Government must be the best-informed body, and that they are the people who know best, is not to be followed out in this Seanad. It is ludicrous to bring us here at all if we are simply to carry out what the Minister says. I know Senator Jameson does not always do it when it does not suit him. Yet he queries the right of us to inquire into the merits of the Bill, and advises us to let it go by the board. The Government said it was necessary, and consequently we must do it.
Comment on this
I do not think that Senator O'Farrell is quite justified in his remarks. It is not for me to interpret for Senator Jameson, but I do not think the attitude taken here is one of stating that whatever the Government proposes is what should be accepted. I only make the remark simply because Senator O'Farrell's statement was received in silence and no one refuted it. But in other discussions it has been frequently stated and repudiated. There are a great many amendments to this Bill, which proves that a great many of us are not satisfied with this Bill. At the same time, I think a Senator has the right to follow the Government if he likes. When he says so, I do not think there is any right to say that he is not following his conscience. I deprecate that statement.
Comment on this
I oppose the whole section, and I think I will have the opportuniy of saying now what I wanted to say before. I am opposed to the whole section because it gives the right to the Minister or his responsible officers to take away from the subject liberty without trial. I am sorry the Government have taken the view-point they have, because I think they are alarmed needlessly. I do not think there is such cause for alarm. I do not suggest that an ordinary person going through the country can see a wonderful change. Notwithstanding the letter read to-day, I believe there will be no further necessity for having such a Bill. I am not looking forward to the immediate present. A precedent will be set if we pass this Bill that will give responsible Government the power to deprive a citizen of his liberty without charge or trial. For that reason I am opposed to this section of the Bill. I will not say anything further, except that I hope, when Senator O'Farrell is in the position now occupied by Deputy O'Higgins, he will get the same amount of support, when there is a Labour Government in power. All those suggestions were made on a previous occasion here—that it was quite possible under the Bill that it could be used for the advantage of the present Executive. The present Government might not be likely to take advantage of the powers, and the suggestion was made that they felt sure that if a Farmers' Government were in power they would not take advantage of the powers, but in the case of the Labour Party there was some doubt. I think there is just as great a sense of justice among labour people as any other section of the community, and they would not abuse any power. I would make a last despairing appeal to the Minister on this point, because I believe in future, when we have got over the present little trouble, we would not like to have inserted on the Statute Book of the First Oireachtas a measure of this kind. For that reason, and for the good of the country, I would press upon him carefully to consider the points we have brought under his notice. When all the trouble if over, let us be in a position to look back on this thing with satisfaction, and not be sorry for what we have done.
Comment on this
I voted against the amendment proposed by Senator Douglas on the grounds that I thought it was restricting or placing greater power on the initiative of the Minister. In this case I feel the powers are necessary, and it is advisable that the Minister should have such powers.
Comment on this
Amendment to delete the words in line 23, Section 5, Sub-section (1) "death or," put.
Do you agree with this result?
You did not say that; I could not follow that.
Comment on this
I am afraid I cannot correct the matter now. The Debates will record that you voted by mistake, but I cannot alter the vote.
Comment on this
We cannot discuss that now; I have already ruled.
SECTION 2.
(1) It shall be lawful for a responsible officer to arrest and to detain in custody for any period not exceeding one week any person found committing or attempting to commit or whom such officer suspects of having committed any of the offences mentioned in Part II. of the Schedule to this Act.
(2) It shall be lawful for an Executive Minister, subject to the provisions of this Act, to order the detention in custody in any place in Saorstát Eireann of any person arrested under this section in respect of whom such Minister certifies in writing that for stated reasons he is of opinion that the public safety would be endangered by such person being set at liberty.
(3) Whenever any person is arrested under this section, such person shall, not later than one week after his arrest, unless an order for his detention is made by an Executive Minister under this section, either be released or be charged with one or more of the offences mentioned in the Schedule to this Act, or with any other offence or offences, and dealt with according to law, and shall for that purpose, if in military custody, be delivered into civil custody.
Comment on this
The following amendment is in my name:—
To delete in line 11 the words "an Executive Minister," and to substitute therefor the words "the Executive Council or any Minister thereof authorised by them."
The same reasons underline this amendment as the one I proposed earlier. I desire to withdraw it.
Comment on this
I beg to move the following amendment:—
Section 2, Sub-section (2): To insert after the word "custody," in line 12, the words "for a period not extending beyond the limit of the duration of this Act."
My reason for moving this amendment is the fact that this Bill is temporary. It might happen that a person would be sentenced to nine or twelve months' imprisonment. I do not think it was the intention of the Minister that at any time such a thing would happen, but to make it clear that it would not be possible for such a thing to happen I move the insertion of those words.
Comment on this
The Senator's namesake in the Dáil moved an amendment to this effect, and it was not accepted, simply because it is not in reason that the powers of detention without trial which spring from this Bill could survive the Bill. Those powers would not exist but for the Bill, and when the Bill expires the powers conferred by it will expire also. No one could imagine the State Counsel coming into Court and pleading as justification for the detention of a person without trial the Public Safety (Emergency Powers) Bill, if that Bill had expired. If it has meantime expired, such a defence to a habeas corpus action would be simply scoffed out of Court, and the words “subject to the provisions of this Act” which appear in that sub-section are considered ample. My reasons, therefore, for not accepting the Senator's amendment are identical with the reasons given for not accepting a similar amendment in the Dáil. I believe the amendment is absolutely unnecessary, and the words suggested would be a blot on the draftsmanship of the Bill. The words are not necessary; they are superfluous. The Attorney-General has advised in this matter, and has stated that an amendment of that kind could not be accepted, because it would seem to imply a belief or opinion that the powers conferred by the Bill could last beyond the lifetime of the Bill itself.
Comment on this
The objection of the Minister does not seem convincing to me. If the powers do not last beyond the lifetime of the Bill, what harm can there be in those words? Is there any legal point involved?
Comment on this
Apart from the fact that the amendment will do no harm, it will relieve a great deal of doubt in the public mind. People interned under this Bill, when it becomes an Act, may be, in the words of a Minister, left in until they rot. That is one of the reasons why this amendment should be accepted, apart altogether from that which will be the position quite definitely, and avoiding a good deal of litigation and legal proceedings afterwards. That will be the effect of having this amendment accepted. I do not know why the Minister should stand so strong against it. Even if he states it is the intention of the Government, it may not add to the artistic side of the draftsmanship, but that drawback will be counterbalanced and the drawbacks will be balanced by the amount of doubts which it will remove.
Comment on this
The view simply is that under this Bill a person could not be kept interned without trial for a single day longer than the lifetime of the Bill. The objection to putting in any reference such as the Senator suggests to a period is that internment is not for a period. It is simply a business from day to day, under the powers of the Bill, and to suggest that a man could be interned with reference to some fixed period is wrong. It is wrong in principle. The whole idea of the Bill is a deterrent detention as distinct from a punitive imprisonment. Men interned to-day might, if the situation appreciably altered, be released in three or four weeks' time. There is no suggestion that people interned will be kept in for the six months. They may be released sooner than six months. The reference to a fixed period in connection with internment is wrong, because it suggests the same as a fixed sentence. Now, the Law Advisers of the Government are absolutely of opinion, and the Senators may make their minds easy about it, that there would be no power in the Government to hold people detained without trial for a single day beyond the lifetime of the Bill. The reasons for refusing the amendment are simply the reasons I have stated—that to insert it would be a blot on the draftsmanship of the Bill. The words are utterly superfluous.
Comment on this
The Minister is rather conflicting in his statement. He stated that no person arrested under this can be kept a day after the Bill expires, or a day longer than the Bill is in operation. In rising to speak on the last occasion he stated that, if he accepted it, this would mean that every person interned would have to be released. Do I take it that the Minister gives it as his opinion, according to his legal advisers, that any person arrested and interned or imprisoned under this Act will, on the expiration of this Act, have to be charged and tried, or released?
Comment on this
In view of the guarantee the Minister has given us, I would ask the permission of the Seanad to withdraw my amendment.
Comment on this
I suppose this is Sub-section (2), and I wish to move: "To insert after the word ‘writing,' in line 14, the words ‘to a Judge of the High Court.'"
Comment on this
Would you pardon me for a moment? The next amendment we are dealing with is an earlier amendment of yours.
Comment on this
Very well, I withdraw the following amendment:—"Section 1: To add at the end of line 5 the words ‘the reasons stated to be in writing and a copy given to the prisoner at the time of arrest.'"
Comment on this
I beg to move: "To insert after the word ‘writing,' in line 14, the words ‘to a Judge of the High Court.'" I see it constantly stated in this Bill, "shall certify in writing," but I have not seen to whom. Does he certify in writing to himself? Does he go into one room and write a report, and go into another room and accept the report? Perhaps the Minister would be able to explain that. As it was not clearly shown, I put down this amendment. I do not know would the Judge be the proper person to certify to. Perhaps the Minister would explain. Is he going to sit down to his desk and certify, and stick that certificate into a drawer? If that is so, I do not see much object in the certificate. I should like to be allowed to add now to this amendment what I was cut out from in the previous amendment: "For stated reasons to be shown to the prisoner."
Comment on this
You must keep to one amendment at a time. You have another amendment down in which you ask that a copy should be handed to the prisoner. At present you are on a different one, and I must ask you to confine yourself to it.
Comment on this
I must call your attention to the fact that you are neither treating the Seanad nor the Chair with proper respect. You come in and do not appear to know your own amendments. You take them in a different order, and do not know the contents and forms of them. At least, Senators who put down amendments ought to take the trouble to see that they themselves understand them before they submit them to the Seanad.
Comment on this
I think it is a misunderstanding. I perfectly understood where I was, but as my previous amendment on the same subject had been cut out by Senator Douglas's amendment, I was not able to bring it forward, and I did not notice I had a second one down.
Comment on this
I am anxious to help you and every other Senator to the best of my ability, but they must help me, too. They must understand what amendments they are moving and the order in which they are taken.
Comment on this
Yes, a great deal, if Senators would take a little more trouble to study their own amendments.
Comment on this
And other things. Who is the certificate to be sent to? I would like the Minister to say if it is to be sent to anyone in particular or to himself? If it is to himself, I do not think it is any good. If it is to some proper person, my amendment will be withdrawn.
Comment on this
The Senator's amendment is unacceptable. As to the point in the certificate at all, that question was raised in the Dáil, and the mover of an amendment which called for a definite record simply stated that he wanted, at least, to ensure that there would be that much trouble taken about the thing that a Minister would set his hand to a statement that "A B" was considered to be abusing his liberty to the detriment of the public peace and safety. It is the merest formal check on irresponsible action by any subordinate of the Ministry. To drag the Courts into it, to suggest that a certificate should be sent to the Judge of the High Court, is not in keeping with the spirit of the Bill—a temporary Emergency Bill, which legalises deterrent detention, which legalises detention without trial for a period of six months, during a difficult transition period from conditions of anarchy to what we hope may develop to be normal peaceful conditions. The exact value of the certificate might be difficult to say. It will at least be a Departmental record of the fact that the Minister assented to detention and concurred with the propriety of the detention of the individual concerned.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—"Section 2, Sub-section (2): To insert at the end of the sub-section the words ‘a copy to be handed to the prisoner.'" The Minister the other day animadverted on a statement of mine that it was the Bastille, and said I was apparently very badly acquainted with the history of France. That, in his opinion, may be so or not. As far as I know, subject to the Minister's contradiction, it is the very essence of the Bastille, and why it was called that, is that a person could be put into the Bastille without any definite charge being made against him, simply on the work of the King. That is exactly what is happening here. That is the essence of the thing being called a Bastille, and the essence of it here as well as in France. I want to get out of that to a certain extent by prescribing that the prisoner himself should be given a copy of the charge, so that when the case comes before the Appeal Committee he will be able to say: "These things are quite incorrect; such and such charge is not correct, and I can prove it." If he comes before the Committee and does not know what he is charged with, how can he argue against it?
Comment on this
I support the amendment. I think it is the very essence of justice to state that a man shall at least know what he has been deprived of his liberty for. Many things have happened in this country during the last few years that some time ago we thought would have been impossible, but there are things proposed in this Bill which we thought no Irish Government would ever think of proposing. It is a repetition of the old kidnapping by the Czar's police of politicians and others, hiding them away in the cellars of Moscow, and not allowing them even to know why they were kidnapped. It may be said that this is exaggerating the position, but there are all the powers to do acts of that kind here—filch prisoners away, pitch them into internment camps or prisons, and not even tell them why they are being kept there. It is certainly not asking too much that persons taken away in these circumstances shall have a statement of the reasons why they are being interned. The Minister is to certify in writing that the man is being detained for certain reasons. Where is the object or the justice in withholding these reasons from the persons interned. I hope that this will receive more consideration than other amendments of an equally reasonable character. The desire is to make the Bill as reasonable or mild as can be expected in the circumstances, and amendments of this kind should not be treated as hostile and turned down by a dead-weight vote without giving them serious consideration. It may be a display of force, but it is not a display of strength or statesmanship.
Comment on this
I support this amendment, which seems to be an eminently reasonable one. If a certificate has been given by the Minister, it has been given for some purpose, and I cannot see any more reasonable purpose than that it should be given to the prisoner.
Comment on this
It was contemplated that in practice, under this Bill, an Order would be served on the persons to be detained and the Order would set out in general terms the reasons for the detention. But words have been used which seem to suggest a confusion of thought One Senator used the word "charge"—that it is unheard of that a man should be arrested without charge, particularly as he will be coming up later before this Court of Appeal. Both the words "charge" and "Court of Appeal" show misconception of the provisions and of the purpose of the Bill.
There will be no charge, there will be no trial, and no Court of Appeal. There will be an Advisory Council or Committee before which detained persons will be at liberty to appear, if they feel that a mistake has been made, and that the public safety does not, in effect, require their detention. They will have an opportunity of showing and endeavouring to convince reasonable men of that. Any suggestion that this Council is to be in the nature of a Court, or that there is to be a trial, is out of harmony with the entire object of the Bill.
Senators know, or ought to know, that against some of the most dangerous people within our jurisdiction at the moment it would be utterly impossible to formulate a charge, or to sustain that charge with evidence. Senators know that it requires a rather higher degree of both moral and physical courage than, in fact, prevails to enable evidence to be brought forward against the people who are of most danger to the State. The reference to the Czarist police and all that is on a par with the reference to penal provisions against clergymen in the past that was used when discussing the flogging section of this Bill. In fact, we were dealing with penalties for people who were found guilty on indictment of the crimes of arson and robbery under arms. There is no analogy; but if you are going to make seven or eight men responsible for order and peace and stability and decency of life in this country, then you must give these seven or eight men very wide powers for dealing with the situation that exists and that may develop. No men will face the task, no men will accept the primary responsibility to the people for restoring order and stability here, and solving the social problems that exist, unless they are given wide powers, answering for the use of these powers to the Dáil. No detailed charge will be served on persons arrested under the provision of this Bill but they will be served with an order for detention, stating in general terms the reasons that prompted the Executive to secure their arrest and detain them temporarily.
Comment on this
Do I understand from the Minister in charge of the Bill that an order will be served on everybody arrested or detained something like Form 48B, I think it was called previously?
Comment on this
I suggest that is not fair. A person may be guilty of any or none of these crimes or misdemeanours mentioned. It will be a general order, and the whole community or an individual cannot be held up on a general order of that kind. With all respect to the Minister, I say that it is not a question of giving power to the Executive Council to carry on the government of the country, but it is a question of protecting the rights of the citizens.
Comment on this
I was going to suggest that the Executive Council could not possibly be in touch with the conduct of all people likely to be interned under this Bill. They will only be acting on the advice of certain people, and I suggest that it is not right to give such power. If people do wrong, it is not right to do wrong to other people. Because certain sections of the community do wrong, it is not right to pass a law that will leave it in the power of anyone to deprive others of their liberty without just and sufficient reason being given. The more we get into this Bill the more we see that it certainly denies the right of the citizen. It is all very well to serve a printed document informing a citizen that he is being detained because of so and so. That is not fair treatment. There ought to be some evidence as to the reason why people are going to be detained. I think that is the least they are entitled to get. It is quite possible that an innocent man or woman may be arrested and detained under this Bill. If only for the sake of one or two persons that might be illegally imprisoned we ought not to pass this Bill. I think the Minister should accept the amendment.
Amendment declared lost on a show of hands.
Comment on this
The next amendment stands in my name, but as a similar one has already been turned down, I do not intend to move it. The amendment reads: "Section 2, Sub-section (3): To delete in line 11 the words ‘an Executive Minister,' and to substitute therefor the words ‘the Executive Council or any Minister thereof authorised by them.'"
Comment on this
I think there is hardly any necessity in moving the next amendment, because it is practically the same as a previous one.
Comment on this
I think it is in accordance with the Standing Orders that each clause should be put separately.
Comment on this
I know. It causes unnecessary delay; and if the clause is not amended, I think the inference is that the Seanad is in favour of the section as it stands.
Comment on this
Amendment put. On a show of hands the Chairman declared the Amendment carried.
Do you agree with this result?
I move the following in Section 3, Sub-section 1: "To insert after the words ‘those authorities,' in line 30, the words ‘certify in writing that for stated reasons they.'"
Is doigh liom nach gadh moran cainnt ar an run so mar bhí an cheist ceadna againn cheana. The same arguments apply to that as to some of the previous clauses, where we ask that the matter should be put down in writing. The arguments that those words would bring the case before the Courts are of very doubtful validity. The intention of the amendment would be that the military authorities would state something definite for the Minister to go upon. This amendment, I understand, was accepted in the Committee Stage in the Dáil, and was taken out on the Report Stage. A very distinguished legal authority there did not, I understand, agree with the Minister's advisers that the amendment would leave it open to the Courts to enquire into the reasons. It is a matter for this Seanad to judge for themselves. I think if they come with an impartial and open mind to the matter they will be in favour of not having this matter so vague. I think it is a very dangerous thing that the unqualified statement of the Minister should be accepted. It should be remembered, of course, that this deals with prisoners in custody, and that their position can hardly be affected very much by any sporadic outbreaks of war in any particular locality. That seems to be the fear of the Minister. The amendment, I think, is a very moderate one. It simply asks why they are keeping a particular individual in custody. We have been told that great numbers have been already released. I have no doubt whatever that many more could be released without any danger to the State. I believe in times of excitement it is known that many a fellow who was absolutely harmless in himself, except perhaps that he had a loose tongue and talked flippantly of the Government, was arrested on the unsupported statement of young and inexperienced military officers.
Fellows went on the run, and remained on the run for a few weeks, and came back with an enlarged beard and an extra growth of whiskers from their sojourn in the wilds. They were regarded as popular heroes, and were stuck into prison. I have no doubt many of those could be released with advantage to the State. Men and women are detained without trial for very long periods. The case of those men may not have been sufficiently investigated by the officers responsible for their arrest. Other officers got into control, and mistakes are liable to occur, and great injustice as a consequence results to some of those people. We have no appreciation for the fellow up against the State, and it would be suggested that every attempt to amend this Bill is a direct act of opposition against the Government in their efforts to maintain peace in the State. I repudiate all such insinuations as that. It is an effort on our part to popularise the present form of government and to make people feel that while due protection is being extended to them, at the same time none of the rights extended to citizens in all parts of the world shall be filched from them by that Act. Executives come into power and perpetrate grave acts of injustice in the name of justice before they can be removed. It is our object not to leave it in the power of anyone to do this without being immediately brought to book in the matter. To justify such detention a statement should be made in writing that for reasons set forth the detention of the prisoner is a matter of military necessity. This would ensure that prisoners may not be detained without reasonable cause. The amendment cannot in any way affect the utility of the Bill or curtail the powers the Executive have taken.
Comment on this
I should like to urge the Minister to accept this amendment. We have heard statements to the effect that large numbers of prisoners have been released every week. If that is the case, there must be some specific reason for detaining the others. Is it too much to ask that those reasons should be stated in writing by the military officers who detain them? It is reported that, because of the confusion that existed for some considerable time during the conflict, and because of transfers of responsible officers from one district to another, there are large numbers of prisoners interned, and that no one has the slightest idea why they are interned. The mere fact is that they were arrested, and the people responsible for their arrest having left the Army or been transferred, nobody can say on what suspicion they were arrested or for what cause they are being detained. It is time that that position was investigated to some extent, and that some enquiries should be made into the detention of people who did not play a prominent part in the recent struggle. Those people did not play a prominent part at all, and their neighbours are well aware that they were never connected with any movement. That is causing a great amount of discontent, and it is the case of those people that this amendment would apply. It is a reasonable proposition, and in normal times to refuse it would be looked upon as tyrannical to the last degree.
Comment on this
I would accept this amendment if the words "for stated reasons" were left out. I have already explained the objection to those words. Senator Cummins has stated that one eminent lawyer disagreed with the opinion of the Government's advisers. Lawyers are apt to disagree, but it is not a matter that we could leave in doubt. If we are to set down in the Bill in that way that reasons for the detention of a prisoner should be stated, the principle is that the claims could be put forward that the Courts have power to examine into the sufficiency or otherwise of those reasons.
Senators who have talked about persons detained in recent months should know, or ought to know, that 75 per cent. of the persons detained were taken in arms, and they know that the only condition precedent to the sympathetic consideration of a prisoner's release was an undertaking from that prisoner that he would not take up arms against the lawfully elected Government of the people, and that he would respect the rights of his fellow-citizens and not injure the property or person of his neighbour. That was the only condition we insisted on before we were prepared to give very careful and sympathetic consideration to the question of releasing prisoners. The vast majority of the prisoners have refused to give any such undertaking, and it is substantially true to say that they hold the keys of their own cells. No one wants to keep those men living parasitically on their country, costing roughly £1 per head per week, for a single day longer than is necessary. The lists of prisoners are being scrutinised with a view to releasing as many as it is considered possible in a responsible spirit to release. It will depend on whether the improvement that is taking place for the last couple of months goes on progressively, and it will depend on the powers it is thought fit to give the Executive. If the powers are narrow, we will be forced into a conscientious discharge of our stewardship to the to take up a conservative attitude on the release of prisoners. It is true that there is a good deal of information at our disposal that we have not thought fit to communicate either to the Dáil, Seanad, or the people generally.
We would be glad that an improved commercial atmosphere in the country would continue to improve. We would be glad that the kind of faith cure that is taking place in the country would continue to take place. At the same time there is information at our disposal showing a very delicate and highly explosive position, and we have to keep at least one eye on that. It is proposed to release in the near future as many prisoners as it is thought proper, with due regard to the public safety. Before the elections we will try to release every man whom it is considered safe to release, and it is not fair to suggest that we are out to lock up anti-Government votes, as was suggested here the other day. There are two sides to the shield, and we have to watch those two sides. If the Senator who moved the amendment would leave out the words "for stated reasons," I would be prepared to accept it. But there is a technicality there, and it is at least doubtful that if these were inserted the Court would not claim that they had full power to call for those reasons and to examine them.
Comment on this
Does Senator Cummins accept the suggestion of the Minister?
Comment on this
The Minister stated rather cautiously and guardedly that if people signed a certain document their positions would be considered. I think it is pretty well and generally known that numbers of people have signed that document and have not been let out. That is to say, the Minister claims the right, even where they sign a document, to keep them interned. That is one of the main reasons why others have not signed documents. When they see that those who have signed documents are not let out, they say: "Well, there is no reason why we should sign a thing like that and put ourselves in the way of doing a thing we dislike. Those who have signed have not been let out after all." I do not think it is quite fair to let the public believe that if people sign they will be let out. They are left under that impression, though I do not think the Minister stated that.
Comment on this
I move:—
To insert after the words "such Minister," in lines 35-36, the words "certifies in writing that for stated reasons he."
This amendment is somewhat similar to the last one, only the Executive Minister is the authority. I see no reason at all why my amendment could not be accepted. Probably legal phrases are very tricky, and so peculiar that maybe, while the Minister refused to accept it in the last case, he would accept it in this. I would like to emphasise the fact that this is dealing with people already interned, and the Minister has stated both in the Dáil and here that great numbers of men are being released. Now, if there is no reason for keeping those men in gaol, there must be some reason for keeping the others; and if there is some reason, I do not see why it should not be stated. I do not see why these men should not be told why they are kept in.
I do not think it would do the Government any harm, and, in so far as blaming them for not signing the documents is concerned, the Minister knows as well as any other Irishman that there has been an objection to signing any documents in this country for some years back. The very same feeling prevails with the men now interned as prevailed two or three years ago. I do not say they are the same class of men, or that the fight is of the same character, but they are Irishmen all the same, and they feel that signing any documents means some class of humiliation. Senator Colonel Moore has said many signed, and it did not do them much good. It does not appear that signing the document is any particular advantage to the men interned. The other night I met one of the members of the Dáil who was looking after the interests of a Government supporter who was interned. He was trying to find out why the man was interned. There was no one who could give particulars of the man's arrest. I do not know whether anything has been found out yet. If there was some reason stated as to why the man was arrested and interned, he might be able to make some move for his release. Perhaps the Minister could see his way to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I make the same offer as I made to the Senator who moved the last amendment. I will accept the amendment minus the words "for stated reasons." I said no more with regard to the form of undertaking than that it was a consideration precedent to the consideration of a prisoner's release. In any case where that form had been signed a careful and sympathetic consideration is given to the prisoner's case. We released men who signed those forms, and they took up arms again. As soon as our faith in human nature got a few little shocks of that kind we were a little more careful. Some men signed the form with a view to getting out and renewing their activities, but they were disappointed to find that the signing of the form was not the master key to their cell doors. All cases in which documents are signed are carefully considered. We look at every case from the angle that a man wants to get out to lead a decent life.
Comment on this
What is the objection to accepting those words in Section 3 when they are already accepted in Section 2 Sub-section (2)? The words "for stated reasons" are in that section.
Comment on this
The Minister now informs us that he is going to get those words taken out of the Bill. They were evidently not inserted without full consideration in Committee in the Dáil, and the terrible things that he points out to us are just as likely to happen under Section 2 as under Section 3.
Comment on this
I believe it was through a mistake those words have been left in. They should have been taken out as a result of the Report Stage in the Dáil.
Comment on this
I think no harm will be done by the acceptance of the amendment. When the Minister stated that 75 per cent of those who were taken were taken under arms, he made a very alarming statement. The general impression is that only a small number had arms, and that fully three-fourths of them were taken without arms. The people who were taken without arms are the people we are anxious about. We do not want to turn adrift people who will turn their hands against the State. No prisoners should be kept longer than is humanly necessary, and they should be told why they are being kept, so that they will be able to make an effort to clear themselves of any charges made against them, and to prove that those charges are false.
Comment on this
I rise to oppose Section 3 on general principles.
The Section was declared carried, and a division was challenged.
Comment on this
You mean Senators? Better so describe them.
Comment on this
Would it not be possible that these Senators who are forcing these unnecessary divisions, and wasting the time of business people would be satisfied with a show of hands? They may not be business people, but people here do not like to be giving their time unnecessarily.
Comment on this
It is not in order, but it is in order for every Senator to ask whether he might not make an appeal. He cannot ask me to do so, because I am not going to do it. He can himself suggest it, and I do not want to prevent any Senator suggesting that this matter of challenging divisions might be going too far.
Comment on this
I want a ruling on the point I made, that when a division is called for, there can be no speeches. If a Senator wishes to make an appeal he can do so, but there can be no further discussion when a division is called.
Comment on this
If he has an opportunity of making an appeal, and when a division has been called for, as in this case, I think now is the proper time as it does not stop the taking of a division.
Comment on this
It was only while we were waiting for the division that I made the suggestion, and I did not want to irritate the Senators who called for it. I only wish to point out that it is really wasting valuable time.
Comment on this
The Seanad notices your suggestion, but whether it will be acted upon or not I do not know.
Comment on this
As one who has challenged divisions I accept the statement that this suggestion is offered in a proper spirit, but I would point out that we also have a sense of responsibility. Some Senators may view their sense of responsibility as coming here and simply passing as rapidly as possible, particular measures. We have another sense of responsibility which is equally important from our point of view. To say that we are simply obstructing or holding up the public business is altogether beside the mark. We claim the right to discuss every measure, however necessary, and to challenge divisions. We have challenged divisions because of the statement made by the Cathaoirleach that when a clause is not amended it is taken for granted there is general agreement upon it. Because of the very serious nature of the Bill, and of the serious in-roads it makes on the liberty of the subject and the citizen generally, we think it our duty to record our votes properly on every section.
Comment on this
I said that a show of hands might be equally satisfactory.
Comment on this
I think the Senator may be quite right if divisions were taken to Sections. A show of hands could be taken on the amendments, and we could get ahead faster. I cannot see how the principles of the Party Senator O'Farrell represents are in any way called into account by reserving divisions for the Sections. I merely throw out the suggestion as the question has not arisen in the Seanad before. I think we might cooperate with each other, and debate to the full, but when it comes to a division on an amendment a show of hands might meet the case.