PUBLIC SAFETY (EMERGENCY POWERS) BILL, 1923. - IN COMMITTEE.
Contributions 163–326 of 326. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 30 of 1923 ›
That is quite erroneous. The present discussion is not a discussion on the strict right at all, or on the interpretation of the Standing Order. There can be no doubt about that. The present discussion is the result of an appeal by a certain section of the Seanad to another section suggesting that they should be content as regards the amendments with a show of hands, and as regards the sections with a division. That is only a suggestion, and we will see whether it is going to be accepted when we come to the next amendment.
Comment on this
With your permission I would like to make another suggestion, and that would be that the main body of Senators should not make it a principle simply to vote against every amendment, because it comes from this side. It may not be done deliberately, but it is a remarkable coincidence. If they will give a little more consideration to reasonable suggestions from this side then we might be in a position to take a suggestion from them.
Comment on this
The difficulty remains of deciding what are reasonable suggestions.
Comment on this
Senator O'Farrell has said something with regard to the responsibility of the party that he represents. My responsibility, I feel, is to sit here and see the matter out to the end, no matter how long we sit.
Comment on this
Question: "That Section 1, as amended, stand part of the Bill," put.
Do you agree with this result?
I beg to move:—"Section 4, Sub-section (1): To delete in line 46 the words ‘a person certified by the Attorney-General to have legal knowledge and experience,' and to substitute therefor the words ‘a Judge of the High Court.'" I think there are a good many people in Ireland who might be certified as having a knowledge of the law and whom we would not have very much confidence in. I think, if it were left to a Judge, that people at all events will have a great deal of confidence in him. I know the Minister will say that the Attorney-General would not certify any improper person. I do not think myself that he would—I do not question for a moment. Still, it would give more confidence to the people generally if a man in the position of a High Court Judge or some such person were on this Commission, which will be a very important one.
Comment on this
I think this is a good amendment. There is a precedent for an arrangement of this kind in Commissions set up in another place for the purpose of dealing with this question of people who are in prison for political offences. This is a very peculiar Bill, and some of us who feel it our duty to vote for it do not like it any the more for that. It would have a very good effect on public opinion in the case of an incarcerated man if a Commission were appointed having as its chairman possibly, or one of its members, a person with the authority of one of our Judges. That would remove any legitimate objection that might be made to a revising tribunal in these cases. I hope the Government will consider this question with an open mind and see if they cannot agree to it.
Comment on this
The tendency seems to be to give this Advisory Council or Committee the complexion of a Court, and to make it obligatory that one of its three members shall be a Judge of the High Court would increase and emphasise that aspect. In point of fact, it is not a Court, and it is not proposed formally to charge persons detained. The idea is that detained persons should have an opportunity of going before three reasonable fellow-citizens and rebutting or attempting to rebut the suggestion that the public safety in any way requires their detention. It is considered advisable that one of three members should have some legal knowledge—some kind of training that would enable him to summarise facts and appreciate evidence accurately—but it is not a Court. Apart from everything else, I would ask Senators to dwell on the question of the advisability of putting a highly-salaried Judge of the High Court on to work of this kind. The persons detained will be persons against whom the Executive Council feel perfectly satisfied that there is reasonable suspicion of acts which endanger the foundations of the State and the foundations of Society. The proposal to set a gentleman with a salary of £2,000 or £3,000 a year on the work of hearing appeals from people of that class is doubtful wisdom and doubtful finance. Any barrister of four or five or six years' standing is capable of doing all that is required of members of that Advisory Council.
Comment on this
May I ask whether there would be any way, short of appointing a Judge of the High Court, to strengthen these Councils? This is the only Appeal Council that is being suggested for the prisoners, and I think it ought to be suggested to the Minister that he should consider the advisability of strengthening the Council, if it is at all possible to do so. A Judge of the High Court would undoubtedly be a very high official to bring into the matter, but there may be somebody not quite as high as that. Of course, this would entirely rely on the Attorney-General's opinion, and no doubt the Attorney-General would select some sound man of legal experience. I think the Ministry would not be wrong in suggesting so many years' experience, so that we would be sure of getting a qualified person.
Comment on this
Would you suggest a practising barrister of not less than ten years' standing?
Comment on this
Perhaps we could say a practising lawyer of not less than five years' standing, and leave it open to appoint a solicitor or barrister.
Comment on this
The amendment is now altered to read: "To substitute the words ‘a practising barrister or solicitor of not less than five years' standing."
Comment on this
Senator Moore asked me to move this amendment:—"Section 4, Sub-section (3): To insert after the word ‘Council,' in line 56, the words ‘and also the prisoner.'" This amendment simply provides that the certificate, by virtue of which the prisoner is detained, shall be supplied to the Appeal Council and also to the prisoner. If the members of the Council are supplied with the particulars of the circumstances under which the prisoner is detained, it is at least reasonable that the prisoner himself should have a similar copy of the stated reasons.
Comment on this
There would be no objection to giving the prisoner the certificate on which he was detained, and, generally, there would be no objection to giving him rather full information on the whole question of the matters of which he was suspected, but there is a very definite objection to laying before the prisoner the complete dossier of his case, which is what would be involved by acceptance of the amendment. It is not proposed to lay before the prisoner all the detailed information that is to hand.
Comment on this
It is not "reports and certificates." It is, in the alternative of that that it would be necessary to supply the certificate. It is "reports or certificates." which would apparently mean that the prisoner is to get one, but not both.
Comment on this
As a general thing it can be understood that the Appeal Council will be supplied with fuller information than would be supplied to the prisoners. There are obvious reasons for that. Prisoners may ask to appeal before the Council simply with a view to ascertaining the source of the evidence on which they were arrested. It would not be wise to put into the hands of such prisoner the dossier of his case. Prisoners appearing before the Council will be left under no illusions as to the general nature of the suspicions which rest on them, and the considerations which led to their arrest and detention. The important point is that this is not a tribunal in the ordinary sense of the word. A prisoner coming before that body takes on himself the onus of convincing three reasonable men that there was no reason for detaining him. These people will have at their disposal accurate information as to his arrest. They may put questions to the prisoner on that dossier, and will give him such information as it is considered wise and safe to impart to him. By safe, I mean proper protection for citizens who may have given information for their own protection and the protection of the community generally. It is not a matter where you can lay down a hard and fast rule, but you must be careful to preserve to yourself the right to withhold from the prisoner a certain amount of information you have with regard to him. Prisoners of a certain turn of mind may, with a view to vengeance in the future, come to find out where the information with regard to them came from.
Comment on this
Question put: "That Section 2 stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
I beg to move the following amendment:—Section 4, Sub-section (4). To delete the sub-section and to substitute the following new sub-section therefor:—
"(4) When such an Executive Minister shall receive a report from an Appeal Council that there are no reasonable grounds for suspecting him of having committed or being engaged or concerned in the commission of any of the offences mentioned in the Schedule to this Act, he shall, within one calendar month, order his release unless—
(a) he shall refer back the report to the Appeal Council for the consideration of further evidence, or:
(b) the person be charged with any offence punishable by imprisonment."
The object of my amendment is to try and make it clear that it is the intention, unless there are reasons, that when the Appeal Council recommends the prisoner to be released it puts the onus of his release on the Minister as soon as he receives a report to that effect unless he is prepared to refer it back on further points, or unless he is prepared to have the person charged before the Court.
The way the Section is worded does not seem to make it clear what the circumstances are, how, or what time the person may be released, if at all. I understand the Minister's point that this is not a Court, and I do not think it is desirable that it should be thought that it is a Court, because, if so, a person failing in his claim to be released would virtually be found guilty. I do not want to suggest that this is anything more than a claim to come before the Advisory Council, but to ease the public mind and make it clear that as soon as the Council has examined and reported, they should be released within one month. If the Minister considers the clause he will see that something should be inserted so as to make it clear that he should be released in a reasonable time.
The reason I am urging this is because I think it is wise and right, and because a number of persons have the impression, it may be genuine or it may not, that the Appeal Council is not a genuine body, and is not intended to function, and that no one will ever know whether a case is being heard by the Council or not. With abnormal legislation of this kind it is well that you should have the public with you, and that you should allay any uneasiness that may occur. On the Second Reading debate a suggestion was made in the Seanad that the Government had inserted certain of these internment clauses for the purpose of attacking their political opponents in a vindictive spirit. I should like to say that anyone who took any part in the so-called negotiations that took place would absolutely give the lie to that statement. There never was anything which could lend any colour whatsoever to the suggestion that there was a vindictive or personal element, or anything of that nature. I hope that by either accepting this amendment or, on the next Stage, bringing in another amendment, the position will be made quite clear.
Comment on this
I feel disposed to accept this amendment. It gets over one difficulty. Attempts were made in the Dáil, when they were dealing with the question of the Appeal Councils, to give to the Councils mandatory powers of release that were objectionable. Just as the arrest of persons is an Executive act, so ought their release to be an Executive act. It should not lie with an advisory body, set up the Government or a Minister, to order, the release of any person. I told the Dáil I did not conceive that in 100 cases there would be one in which the advice of that body would be set aside, and yet the principle was important that the power of release should lie with the Executive Council, and ought not to lie with this body. Senator Douglas' amendment is an improvement on that. If the Executive Council are to receive an order it is better that it should come from the Oireachtas than an Adsory Departmental Committee, and this amendment gives a month. Even after the Advisory Council has reported that there does not seem to be grounds for the detention of a particular individual, if the Executive Council is strongly of opinion that his release would be dangerous, then they have a month in which to produce any further evidence that may be at their disposal for the consideration of this Committee. If the Senators were to accept this amendment, and I see no reason why they should not, I would be prepared to recommend its acceptance to the Dáil.
Comment on this
A slight alteration would need to be made in the amendment in the following manner:—"No reasonable grounds for suspecting him," might be made to read "no reasonable grounds for suspecting a detained person."
Comment on this
This goes some little distance to improve the clause, and I suppose we must be thankful for small mercies. We have little hope of getting any of the amendments put down by us accepted, and I am going to support this amendment on this Stage in the hope that on the next Stage it may seem proper to eliminate the words "within one calendar month," or at all events reduce the time. It is a terrible hardship on a person, particularly one with a family, to be kept in a month after he has been declared innocent. It is no encouragement to hasten his release or investigate his case. Sub-section (a) is somewhat vague. I do not know exactly what it implies, or whether it means that some evidence already in possession of the Government had been held back, and ultimately given for the purpose of detaining the person still longer. I am prepared to vote for the amendment at this Stage.
Comment on this
In view of the amendment proposed by Senator Douglas and accepted, I think the following amendment of mine will fall through:—
"To insert after the word ‘or,' in line 65 the words ‘for regarding his detention as a matter of military necessity or desirable in the interest of public safety."
It covers what I want, but in different terms. The prisoner is arrested for three causes, first as a matter of military necessity, second as a matter of public safety, and thirdly, because he is guilty of offences set forth in the Schedules. Now, the Appeal Court has not power to deal with those offences. In the case of offences where prisoners have been arrested through military necessity, or for public safety, I understand that report would not be given to the Appeal Court. I think that is not correct. I think that is not as it should be.
Comment on this
What portion of Sub-section 4 are you dealing with now?
Comment on this
It must. If Sub-section 4 has gone, and there is a new Sub-section in its place, your amendment goes.
Comment on this
I want to be clear as regards those who will appeal; will their cases be reported upon no matter from what cause they are arrested?
Comment on this
But I take it the new sub-section deals with the question of offences. There are offences upon which the Court of Appeal would not be in a position to report.
Comment on this
The position with regard to this Appeal Council would be that it is free to hear the cases of all persons detained without trial, that is to say all persons arrested under the provisions of this Bill. The military, while a condition of war or armed revolt prevailed, would be free to hold any prisoner, and nothing that this council could do or recommend would alter that fact. But, if a state of war or armed revolt were declared at an end, then the provisions of this new Sub-section would apply to all prisoners, both to prisoners arrested if such were to happen that they were arrested under the provisions of this Bill, and the prisoners who were arrested under a state of war or armed revolt, and whose detention is prolonged by the Bill. But we could not in legislation interfere with the inherent common law right of the military to detain any prisoner whom they thought was a matter of military necessity to detain. The new sub-section has everything short of an over-riding power of the military in a time of war, and when the time of war would be at an end, would have complete power to deal with prisoners whose arrest was, in the first instance, made as a matter of military necessity.
Comment on this
I move:—In Section 4, Sub-section (6). To delete in lines 16-17, the words "as soon as may be," and to substitute therefor the words "before the dissolution of the present Oireachtas."
I propose this amendment, and the reason I do so is because the Oireachtas will not be sitting. The Ministry say that they will lay these matters before the Oireachtas, and if either of the Chambers object, that it may be withdrawn. That sounds very pretty on paper, but the Oireachtas will not be sitting. There will be a dissolution some time. I do not know when. Until after the elections these things cannot be put on the table at all. Therefore, I suggest that before the dissolution of the present Oireachtas these papers should be put on the table, so that the Seanad would have a right to give an opinion on the matter.
Comment on this
I think the amendment is scarcely reasonable. The preparation of these regulations will take some little time, and if the Senator's amendment were accepted the dissolution would need to be postponed in order that these regulations might be considered. "As soon as may be" in that context is, I submit sufficiently imperative, and the Senator may feel that no time will be unnecessarily lost in the preparation of these regulations. If when they are completed the Oireachtas is not sitting, it may be assumed that immediately after the elections the new Dáil will be summoned, and the regulations will be laid before them. In the meantime there is provision that anything done under the regulation will not be prejudiced by the fact that they did not receive sanction.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—Section 4. To insert after this section a new Section 5, as follows: "5. As soon as may be after the passing of this Act, there shall be established a Prisons' Inspection Committee of three persons of recognised status and independent position (to be appointed by the President of the Executive Council) who shall be empowered to visit and inspect any prisons or places of internment in Saorstát Eireann, to investivate any complaints that may be made by persons under detention other than those connected with the reasons for their detention, to examine the general conditions obtaining in such prisons or places of internment, and to report thereon to the Minister for Home Affairs."
In moving the amendment I hope it will receive the favourable consideration of the Minister. I express that hope because during the discussion of the measure in the Dáil a great many of the Deputies expressed a very strong feeling in favour of some suggestion, such as is indicated here. As a matter of fact on no less than four occasions amendments in this direction were introduced. One of these amendments dealt with the appointment of certain medical members of the Oireachtas, and was ruled out of order. The other three were rejected by the Minister mainly on the ground that to allow the Dáil or County Councils to appoint Committees of Inspection, as was proposed in these amendments, would be utterly out of order; that it would not be fair to submit or subject the actions of the people who are in charge of these prisons or detention camps to the criticism of outside bodies, and that it also would virtually mean the abdication by the Government of its own responsibilities and functions. In that contention I think the Minister was unquestionably right, but as this amendment does not err in that direction I hope he will be able to reconsider his attitude to it.
The amendment, I may say at once, is as much in the interest of the Government as it is of the internees and of their relatives and friends. It is brought forward in the hope that if the Minister can see his way to nominate a Committee of three persons, men or women, who fulfil the conditions of recognised status and independent position, that it will go a long way to dispel the cloud of mistrust and suspicion that, unfortunately, has grown up around the whole question of detention and the treatment accorded by the Government to its political opponents. To account for that suspicion and mistrust we have to carry our minds back a little way and to think of those drear months last winter when every day brought forth its tale of horror and outrage; when hundreds of persons were being arrested, both men and women; when party spirit ran high, and the passions of civil war were in the ascendancy. If we think of that, we can realise that the conditions under which many of these internees were placed must have been one of considerable hardship. What else could be expected. The existing prisons were full to overflowing, and the arrangements for the housing and feeding of hundreds of men and women drawn from all parts of the country, and between whom no distinction could be made, had to be hastily provided. Their medical supervision, the sanitation of their camps, their safe custody, and so on, had also to be provided for, and this had to be done largely by the officers and men of an Army that had only recently sprung forth, as it were, from the void, and which lacked training, had little idea of discipline in the ordinary sense of the word— I am not making any complaint about that, because it was inevitable—and who had no experience, at least no knowledge, of the duties which, under the new order of things, they would be expected to perform. Is it any wonder that in such circumstances discontent and disorder on the part of those under detention were rife?
Many of the internees very naturally resented their arrest. Others were unruly and insubordinate. Few of them would conform to any regulations or submit to any discipline, both of which, I need hardly say, were absolutely essential if any kind of decency or order was to be maintained. As we all know, in some cases the prisoners, with the possibility of getting out, broke up the furniture, burnt their beds, choked the latrines, and did other things which could not be defended, and which only aggravated the situation. Can we be surprised if under such circumstances and in face of such behaviour reprisals did take place, and that soldiers took the law into their own hands and adopted rough and ready methods for putting a stop to these irregularities? Can we be surprised if, in order to improve their position, the internees made the most of the situation, and wrote home to their relatives and friends gruesome details and exaggerated reports of their treatment? The familiar molehill became a mountain, and, to add to all this, the public protagonists of those who were opposed to the Government piled up the agony, issuing a weekly bulletin of what I can only say were mendacious reports respecting the sufferings of the internees? Under such circumstances can we be surprised that many of the relatives and friends of these unfortunate people were very much concerned for their safety and for their health? Happily those days have now passed away, I hope never to return.
With the discipline and efficiency of the Army very much increased, with the higher instincts of our human nature coming into play and reasserting themselves, with party passions dying down, may we not hope that such irregularities will not now be possible, and that if they are, we may be quite certain that the military authorities will put them down with great insistence. We may, I think, be satisfied that under present conditions the position of the internees is as satisfactory as, under the circumstances, is possible. Liberty is, as has been expressed by many Senators, a subject which is dearest to men's hearts, and I hope that some means may be found, as the Minister told us to-day, of releasing a considerable number of these men and women, who are now detained, before very long, and that in any case, long before the expiry of this Bill, the whole of these persons may be restored to their homes. In the meantime, I think that if the Minister can see his way to obtain the services of three men or women who will fulfil the conditions laid down, that their very presence and their association with the Government in the administration of the prison camps, and so on, will inspire confidence and allay any anxiety that may still be felt on behalf of the internees.
Comment on this
I trust it will meet the Senator when I say that I am prepared to accept Amendment 33 on the Orders of the Day in the name of Senator McPartlin to appoint honorary visitors to places of detention who will report to the Minister for Home Affairs for the time being. The need for the inspection of these places, an inspection that will not be official, is obvious. I am glad the Senator stressed the point that these prisoners themselves took good care to ensure that their conditions would be far from ideal. The mania for destruction did not desert them on their arrest, and they did damage on a large scale to the extent of thousands of pounds in places of detention. They did such foolish, wanton things as smashing the hot water system in their places of detention, and then complained of the cold; tearing the fibre out of mattresses; stuffing the lavatories, and then complaining of unsanitary conditions. There are complaints of congestion, and yet if they had succeeded in their attempt to burn Maryborough Prison there would be more congestion.
The Minister for Defence dealt at length with this aspect of the question recently when commenting on conditions in Wicklow Gaol. Every attempt has been made to ensure decent sanitary conditions in places of detention, and any failure has been due to the conduct of the prisoners themselves. It is humanly impossible to keep conditions properly in places of detention without a reasonable amount of co-operation on the part of the prisoners, and that co-operation has not been forthcoming. I am prepared under this Bill to appoint honorary inspectors, decent level-headed citizens here and there through the country on condition that their reports will be made to me in the first instance, and that only in the event of their finding the reports not investigated or proper action not taken, would there be publication to any other source. After all if the Executive is to have the real power and real responsibility delegated to it by the Dáil, then any matter which calls for comment by these inspectors should be reported in the first instance to the responsible Minister. Only in the event of clear failure to take action on any matter which requires action, should there be publication elsewhere.
Comment on this
The chief difference between the amendment that the Minister says he will accept and the amendment put forward by Senator Sir Hutcheson Poe, is that the latter's says the persons appointed shall be persons of recognised status and position. I think it is very desirable that they should be such persons. Otherwise you will find it difficult to get the country to believe that the Government has not somehow or other settled the matter beforehand with these people. I do not believe that the Government would do such a thing, but I also do not believe that they will carry the same weight with the people as if the Minister had accepted Senator Sir Hutcheson Poe's amendment, that they should be persons of independent position and recognised status. I would be glad if the Minister would let us know what kind of person he proposes to appoint.
Comment on this
This is a little out of order. The proposition is to insert a new section after Section 4. We cannot debate an amendment to Section 13 now. We have got to dispose of Senator Sir Hutcheson Poe's amendment first. It might be that, in view of the Minister's statement the Senator would withdraw the motion now before the Seanad in favour of Senator MacPartlin.
Comment on this
As to withdrawing my amendment, I feel bound to ask the Minister to appoint persons that Senator Yeats has alluded to as described in the amendment. I do so entirely in the interests of the internees and their friends, as the suggestion the Minister made about appointing certain medical officers throughout the country will not satisfy these people. I am not surprised. The conditions, I am sure, have led to hardship. I believe fully in the honesty and the good intentions of the Minister, but there are plenty of people who do not. It is suggested that the want would be met by appointing dispensary doctors, or whoever you like, very worthy and very good people, but they cannot command the confidence of these people. In view of the strong feeling expressed in the Dáil I believe the feeling I myself voice is the feeling of the Seanad. I wish, however, to leave the matter in the hands of the Minister.
Comment on this
Would not your purpose be accomplished if, when we come to Section 13 the Government accepted Senator MacPartlin's amendment with the addition of the words "detained therein, by persons of recognised status," and so on? If these words were put in they would meet your view, and probably the Government would not object.
Comment on this
I would like to support Senator Sir Hutcheson Poe's amendment. I think he has got much further than we did in improving the Bill when he has got the other amendment accepted.
Comment on this
It distinctly says in the amendment that there is to be no remuneration.
Comment on this
Would it not be possible that the amendment could be taken in connection with Colonel Poe's amendment in Section 13?
Comment on this
It would be just as simple if Colonel Poe's amendment were accepted. I fail to see any difference except that one specifies the qualification.
Comment on this
There is just this difference. In Section 13 it provides for regulations, and the regulations will provide, with the acceptance of Senator McPartlin's amendment, for inspection by honorary inspectors, and it will at the same time define conditions under which inspection could be carried out, and the persons to whom the reports or complaints are to be addressed. If we merely put in the Bill this new Section which Sir Hutcheson Poe proposes, the matter is left vague. It would be necessary, when inspectors are appointed, to have a clear understanding as to the quarters to which they should report any matters which they consider called for attention. I would ask that the persons to be appointed to inspect would be persons not in receipt of any salary or emolument from the Government. Senator MacPartlin's regulations come in under Section 13, and the regulations made with regard to inspection are set out.
Comment on this
Could not Colonel Poe and Mr. McPartlin settle the matter between themselves after consultation with the Minister?
Comment on this
It seems to me difficult to understand that the few words "recognised status" and "independent position" should be excluded.
Comment on this
It gives it much greater importance if this appears as an independent section rather than have it dragged into another.
Comment on this
I think the Minister would be extremely unwise not to accept this amendment. It is a notorious fact in the city of Dublin that there are a number of people who are worked up to a terrible pitch about stories told about their relatives in prison. They are being played upon by certain people, and these stories are doing a great deal of harm to the Government. I think in the interest of the Ministry that it would be wise to accept the amendment, that independent inspections and reports should be given and thus prevent certain people trading on the sufferings of others.
Comment on this
My preference for Mr. McPartlin's amendment is this. There will possibly be six or eight places of detention throughout the country, and to set up an inspection Committee of three, presumably resident in Dublin, would involve a certain amount of expense to these people by reason of their travelling to these places. My conception of the future was that near these places we would make a selection of sane, level-headed citizens, and ask them to act as honorary inspectors and define their duty.
Comment on this
As there is obviously a fundamental agreement, I suggest that this should be brought forward on the Report Stage after consultation with the Minister. I suggest that you should combine both ideas, and that power to make the regulations should be put in Section 13. By that means you give the Minister power to make regulations in Section 13.
Comment on this
I quite agree with Senator Douglas. I think it would be the most common-sense plan for the two Senators to come together and settle this amendment on the Report Stage. The Minister has stated that these Committees should be local, and I quite agree with him, because I foresee what might happen. Once you set these people up you cannot get rid of them when the Bill comes to an end. I think the Minister's remarks are very sensible and will lead to a saving of expense.
Comment on this
Might I suggest that the Minister himself might introduce the words on the Report Stage?
Comment on this
I would undertake to bring up on the Report Stage a section making it quite clear what my conception of the future is. I simply visualise near each place of detention three or four persons appointed, with a reputation for common-sense and straight dealing, and we ask them as a public duty to make occasional visits and inspections of the places of detention, and bring any matters under the notice of the responsible Executive Minister that may require attention.
Comment on this
The procedure should be for both Colonel Poe and Mr. McPartlin to withdraw their amendments and wait until they see the clause which the Minister will introduce.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would be willing that Mr. McPartlin and I should go into this matter with him? We are willing to accept any suggestion which will give effect to our view. We had no idea of appointing paid men in Dublin, but only men and women who would be willing to do that duty free.
Comment on this
Then this amendment and the amendment on Clause 13 are by leave withdrawn.
Comment on this
Would I be in order in moving an adjournment for tea? I have some knowledge of the provisions of the Factory Act, and they provide that work people shall not be allowed to remain at work for a period of five hours without a break. If we provide that in an Act of Parliament surely we should act up to it ourselves.
Comment on this
I suggest that it would be better to go on. I think we would gain far more respect if we went right through with our business as far as possible. Why should we adjourn, especially, if we are not going to get this Bill through this evening?
Comment on this
I think it is plain that if we adopt the suggestion of Senator Guinness we will not get through this Committee Stage this evening.
Comment on this
We do need some sustenance, and there may be some important Clauses in the Bill dealt with while we are away. It would be better for us all to be here rather than have us coming in in snatches and patches. It would be a great relief if we knew when we would be relieved to-night. Is it proposed that we should have an all-night sitting?
Comment on this
It is in the hands of the Seanad. I do not want an all-night sitting.
Comment on this
I think the Seanad might decide now whether it shall go through the whole night or whether we work until 10 o'clock and resume the business some other day. I do not think the business of the country calls for an all-night sitting.
Comment on this
You were not here when I had to announce that between the Bills we have already got and the Bills of this week there would be seventeen in all.
Comment on this
If we begin by sitting up all night we will never get through with seventeen Bills. I have had some experience of training people. I never found it was the wisest thing to begin with your utmost efforts at the start. I think we might begin by getting accustomed to things. Also we have not all got beds in town.
Comment on this
The President is here now. He may have some information to give.
Comment on this
I would not like to interfere with the dinner hour of the Senators. We have been considering for some time the question of dissolution, and in that connection we also had to consider the various Bills which we would like to see passed by both Houses before dissolution. I have had the advantage of having a preliminary consultation with the Dáil, and we have got general agreement upon a number of Bills that will be non-contentious. I have been in the Dáil all the evening, and three Bills are being sent up from it this evening. I do not think any of those three will provoke much opportunity for contention in the Seanad. But, in order that it would be possible to dissolve at the end of the week, I am afraid that we will have to ask the Seanad to give us some assistance with regard to the matter, and in that connection I would like to say that we have given an undertaking to what may be termed the opposition in the Dáil that they would not be called upon to sit next week. To some extent that limits our time, and if it would be possible for the Seanad to help us I think it would almost be necessary in the case of amended measures that we should have them back in the Dáil, by Friday. There may be a difficulty about that, but I would ask for the special consideration of the Seanad owing to the circumstances of the time. Apart from a small number of Bills those measures will be non-contentious. It was our hope to have the election by the 20th of August. That has not been possible, and I am sure it is unnecessary to say anything here in the Seanad about the advisability of having an Election at the earliest possible moment. Most of the business people and quite a number of other. sections are satisfied that the sooner we approach stabilised conditions the better. That is in essence what I have got to say, and it is to explain the reason for this big congestion of legislation. The Dáil has sat almost continuously for eleven months. It has been kept on the quick march the whole time. Apart from that time there has been a great deal of work in connection with the setting up of the Saorstát. I am sure when we ask for the indulgence of the Seanad in the circumstances a good deal of the objections urged towards such a list of measures will be restricted as we are so much pushed ourselves.
Comment on this
I desire to support the suggestion of Senator Douglas. We should try to get through the Committee Stage to-night.
Comment on this
I move that we sit until 8 o'clock and then adjourn until to-morrow. No matter how optimistic we may be, I do not think we could get through the Committee Stage to-night. The people most anxious to sit on are those who believe in going out and refreshing themselves. They tell those who have been watching the business here to sit on ad infinitum. It is a farce to call this legislation—to rush business of this kind, and tell us that we have to get through it in order that we may have an election. The only alternative to considering those Bills properly is to pass them without considering them at all. The overwhelming majority of the Senators can be in the smoke-room and elsewhere, and they merely come in here to record their votes. That is not legislation.
Comment on this
Nothing can be gained by coercion. Let us get through the business quietly and reasonably, and we will work much more quickly.
Comment on this
Whatever we may decide, let us not interfere with the arrangement by which the Committee Stage of the Land Bill is to be taken to-morrow. If we cannot complete the Committee Stage of this Bill to-night, it will stand over till Wednesday.
Comment on this
We should endeavour to finish the Committee Stage to-night. Senator O'Farrell referred to the rushing of business. There has been nothing more farcical than the attitude of the Labour Party and the calls for divisions.
Comment on this
I second the proposal of Senator O'Farrell that we adjourn at 8 to-night and resume to-morrow morning.
Amendment put. On a show of hands the amendment was declared negatived.
Comment on this
I am sorry, but as a protest against this treatment I shall have to ask for a division.
Comment on this
Under the Standing Orders I have power to reject any amendment if it seems to me to be put forward for the purposes of obstruction. I did not believe for a moment that your amendment was moved in that spirit. I am rather doubtful now that I should not have done so in view of the fact that you challenge a division despite the show of hands.
Comment on this
I regret you consider my amendment was moved for the purpose of obstruction. It was nothing of the kind. The same thing has been done in the Dáil under exactly similar circumstances, and it has not been questioned.
Comment on this
I challenge a division on the ground that we are not legislating but are simply rushing measures and are not given a shadow of a chance to consider them. Those who rush the business take no part in the discussions at all.
Comment on this
In view of the dignity of the Seanad and the excellent way in which we have carried on our debates until now, I think we ought to arrive at some conclusion that will prevent the Seanad being exposed to ridicule in the public mind. I appeal to every section of the Seanad to treasure the dignity of the House. I believe we are going to imperil our dignity and position by such discussions and dissensions as we are embarking on now. From one point of view everyone recognizes that the Labour Party in the Seanad are fighting for a principle. It is open to them to consider now whether they have not asserted it, or whether there would be any doubt in the public mind what is their position in the future as to the attitude they have taken up to-day, or whether it is consistent with the dignity of the Seanad whether they could maintain that any longer. That is for them and not for me to decide.
Comment on this
I entirely agree that the dignity of the Seanad should be kept in mind, and I am not anxious to fight out this thing at all, but——
Comment on this
I would rather, if possible, this should be discussed quietly amongst the Senators without debating it any further.
Comment on this
As a matter of general courtesy, when there is an agreed arrangement all sections should be consulted.
Comment on this
We are getting a little bit too touchy. I think we ought to be able to come to some solution about this. Shall we adjourn until 8.30?
Agreed.
The Seanad adjourned at 7.45 p.m., and resumed at 8.30 p.m.
SECTION 5.
(1) Any person found guilty on indictment of any of the offences mentioned in Part I. of the Schedule to this Act may be sentenced to suffer death or penal servitude for any term not less than three years.
(2) Every person convicted by a Court of summary jurisdiction of any of the offences mentioned in Part II. of the Schedule to this Act shall be sentenced to suffer imprisonment with or without hard labour for the term of twelve months, and may in addition be sentenced to pay a fine of fifty pounds and, in default of payment of such fine within one month after conviction, to suffer imprisonment without hard labour for a further term of six months to be added to and commence on the expiration of the said term of twelve months.
(3) Every person found guilty on indictment of any of the offences mentioned in Part II. of the Schedule to this Act shall be sentenced either—
(a) to suffer penal servitude for a term of three years and to pay a fine of not more than one hundred pounds nor less than fifty pounds and, in default of payment of such fine within one month after sentence, to suffer penal servitude for a further term of one year to be added to and commence on the expiration of the said term of three years; or
(b) to suffer imprisonment with hard labour for a term of not more than two years nor less than one year and to pay a fine of not more than one hundred pounds nor less than fifty pounds and, in default of payment of such fine within one month after sentence, to suffer imprisonment without hard labour for a further term of six months to be added to and commence on the expiration of the first mentioned term of imprisonment.
(4) Every male person who shall be found guilty on indictment of the offence of robbery under arms as defined at No. 6 in Part II. of the Schedule to this Act, or of the offence of arson as defined at No. 7 in Part II. of the said Schedule shall (unless the Court is satisfied that there are special circumstances in the case which constitute a mitigation of the offence, or is of opinion that, owing to the state of health or advanced age of such person, corporal punishment could not be inflicted on him without permanent injury to his health), in addition to the punishment prescribed in the foregoing sub-sections, be sentenced to be once privately whipped subject to the following provisions:—
(a) in the case of a person whose age does not exceed eighteen years, the number of strokes at such whipping shall not exceed twenty, and the instrument used shall be a birch rod;
(b) in the case of any other person, the number of strokes at such whipping shall not exceed twenty-five;
(c) in each case the court in its sentence shall specify the number of strokes to be inflicted and the instrument to be used;
(d) such whipping shall not take place after the expiration of six months from the passing of the sentence;
(e) such whipping to be inflicted on any person sentenced to penal servitude shall be inflicted on him before he is removed to a convict prison with a view to his undergoing his sentence of penal servitude.
(5) The jurisdiction of a court of summary jurisdiction in respect of any of the offences mentioned in Part II. of the Schedule to this Act shall not be ousted by reason of the title to any corporeal or incorporeal hereditaments or any lands or premises being drawn into question.
(6) This Section shall not apply to any offence committed before the passing of this Act.
Comment on this
I beg to move: Section 5, sub-section (1): "To delete in line 23 the words ‘death or.'" I put down this amendment for two reasons. In the first place I am one of those persons who is totally opposed to capital punishment. I recognise that this is not the time or place to go in any detail into the merits or demerits of capital punishment, except to say that I have always held and believed that to send a man to his Maker without any possibility of redress or rectifying an error is an enormous responsibility for the State to take. When a man takes up arms against the State he takes his risks, but when he has been caught and when, as it were, in cold blood he is tried, I think the State makes a serious mistake in executing him. I could go at great length into the reasons why I am opposed to capital punishment, but I do not propose to do so. In the main, my reasons are that I have a great belief in the possibility of the spiritual reclamation of any man.
My main reason for putting down the amendment is this: It has been suggested that it is the intention of the Authorities, if the Bill is passed, to try a number of persons at present held and to execute a number of them. I feel it would be a very good thing if the Minister could give an assurance, unless there is an actual state of warfare again in the country, that that is not the intention. Personally I feel that it is a mistake, except in very grave circumstances, even if one admits the right of capital punishment, to execute persons taken for political offences. We all must know that in many cases persons who have been sentenced to death for political offences and afterwards reprieved, have become some of the very best and noblest citizens in the country. Although we may not anticipate that at present with those whom we may be dealing with, at the same time there is always a possibility. In the main I put the amendment down not to press it, but in the hope that there might be some kind of assurance from the Government as to the suggestions made outside.
Comment on this
I have nothing but respect and sympathy for Senator Douglas's outlook on the question of capital punishment, and I feel that if the world, or even the country, were composed of citizens like Senator Douglas, that it might be possible to adopt that view. But the fact is that it is far from being the case, and I am not aware that any State has found itself able to dispense with capital punishment for treason. One could talk at length on the abstract side of the thing, taking the view that no man should be hurled into eternity without any chance of being reformed or reclaimed and so on.
It is simply a question, that those on whom responsibility lies of saving the State, and saving society within the State, are compelled to resort to the extreme penalty in certain cases. As to any retrospective intention in this Bill, I want to make this perfectly clear. There has been a good deal of ill-informed, loose criticism about this Bill, as about other Bills, and it has been mooted that we propose to turn round on men who have robbed or burned within the last year, and apply the penalties of this Bill to them. That is far from being the case, but every robber, every prospective robber, and prospective arsoneer in the country may expect the penalties of this Bill. The penalties under this Bill will not apply to any person except for an offence committed after the date of the passing of the Bill.
I do readily give the undertaking which Senator Douglas has asked for, that with regard to these penalties for offences mentioned in Part I. of the Schedule of this Bill it is not proposed to go back now and deal with anything that has passed up to date. There is no such intention. The whole outlook of the Bill is simply to meet a possible future situation, rather than deal with an actual past situation. We share the pious hopes expressed here and elsewhere that things will continue to improve, and that in a couple of months everything will be lovely in the Irish garden. There ought to be no one more pleased, and none more relieved, if that turns out to be the case, than we who are members of the Executive Council. At the same time it is our business as prudent, responsible men, with a duty to the people of the country, to face the fact that something quite different is possible. If it is even possible, it is our duty to provide against it, and to see that the Executive returned after the coming Election does not find itself hampered or fettered for want of full power to deal with such a situation. It is in that spirit this Bill is framed. We all hope that people will come to their senses and realise that no political creed, and no political formula justify them in garrotting the nation. If people do attempt to garrotte the Nation—and mind you it is the Nation rather than the fabric of the State, that this onslaught has been upon—then those on whom the primary responsibility rests for dealing with the situation ought to have very full and comprehensive powers, and ought not to be fettered in any detail, in dealing with that situation by any lack of powers delegated to them by representatives of the people.
Comment on this
I am very glad there seems to be general agreement on both sides of the Seanad on this question of the death penalty. I happen to have practically the same amendment down as Senator Douglas, and for that reason I have every hope that the Seanad will carry this amendment. Regarding executions in the past in this country, every one is aware that the country has been sickened with executions, and to my mind it is very doubtful if the death penalty is efficacious in preventing crime in any country. In this country we know that during the last seven centuries the people who tried to govern it always tried that punishment, and we know that is was not always successful. I think that every offence which this death penalty is intended to apply could be dealt with by the ordinary Courts with the ordinary law. That would have been preferable to passing a special Bill which is bound to be regarded by a number of people as a measure inspired by political animosity and a vindictive desire to get rid of obnoxious Republicans. If it were true that we could obtain or have obtained peace and order in this country the best way to attain it to my mind is by having a certain amount of clemency and good-will in our legislation rather than advocate the shedding of more blood in this unfortunate country.
Comment on this
May I quote to my fellow-citizens the answer given by an old French philosopher in the last century to people who asked him to support a Bill for the suppression of capital punishment? His answer was "let the gentlemen who commit the crimes set the example." There is nothing in this Bill to compel anyone to commit crimes which it wishes to punish; if the gentlemen who hold up banks, burn our houses, and commit other heinous crimes abstain from doing anything of this nature, not even the most hardhearted Executive can inflict any of the punishments here meted out to those who do so. If we agree that that class of crime is an unmitigated evil, what right have we to handicap the Government by vetoing the means which they consider to be the quickest in putting an end to that evil? Surely our common sense and our duty both suggest that we should give them the power they are asking for, as it is in the hands of the criminals themselves to make these penal clauses nugatory by not giving the Executive an excuse for putting them into action.
Comment on this
I should be glad to have leave to withdraw my amendment in view of the Minister's statement. I feel strongly about capital punishment. I recognise certain circumstances, and I will withdraw the motion rather than have it turned down. If I am spared, I hope when peace and order come to bring in a Bill to abolish capital punishment. In view of the last speech I should say that I have not opposed capital punishment on grounds that people do not deserve it. I think it is quite conceivable that in many cases they deserve much worse if they were to get their deserts. My desire is to find out some thing which will not be an eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth, but which shall give a person punished a chance of becoming a decent citizen and which shall protect the community. I am against capital punishment, because I believe it is not possible to make a man a decent citizen by sentencing him to death and hoping he will be alright in two or three weeks' time. It is because I believe that punishment should be in the direction of saving the man as well as saving the community that I am opposed to capital punishment on principle.
Comment on this
You have an amendment in the same terms, and if he withdraws his you are entitled to propose yours.
Comment on this
The motion is that Senator Douglas's amendment be withdrawn by leave.
Comment on this
Question put: "That Section 3 stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
I propose: To insert "not more" instead of "not less" in sub-section (1), line 24. I object in this case to give sentence not less than so and so. I think that is a very improper thing. I think these matters should be left to the discretion of the Judges. All sorts of exceptional circumstances arise which ought to be decided by the Judge and not by somebody else who knows nothing about it.
Comment on this
I would like to support this amendment. In all existing legislation I think the general practice has been to fix a maximum and not a minimum penalty. In this case we have the reverse. A person may be found guilty of any offences in the first part of the Schedule. Everyone will agree that there are varying degrees of guilt. The minimum penalty the Judge imposes in every case is three years' penal servitude. He must inflict that or discharge the man. Why it is considered necessary to tie down a man in that way is not apparent. Surely the Judge should be able to assess any penalty. Is it alleged that the Judges are supposed to be too lenient? I do not think that is our experience of the Judges of this country in the past. It is certainly showing a lack of confidence in their strength to punish crimes of this character, and whatever else they may be lacking in I think from past experience they are not disposed to treat people found guilty of crimes of this character very leniently. Apart from that the fact that it is a reversal of all previous law is another reason.
Comment on this
Precisely what I anticipated is happening in connection with the penalties of this Bill. When we were going over the Bill in the Executive Council the unanimous desire was to keep the penalties down to a minimum, and I felt at the time when the Bill came before the Dáil and Seanad that a very determined attempt would be made to convert that minimum into a maximum. Sub-section (1) of Section 5 deals with the offence "an armed revolt against the Government of Saorstát Eireann threatening, coercing, destroying, damaging or removing, or attempting to destroy, damage or remove any property in furtherance of such a revolt." Inside two months the Government of Saorstát Eireann will consist of persons elected by the Dáil, and that Dáil will be elected on an adult franchise of the population of this country. I ask any reasonable citizen who hopes for stability here, whether that penalty is excessive for that offence.
Men can go out to their fellow-countrymen and expound any mad or sane doctrine, and convince their fellow-citizens to that view, get the seal of the people's endorsement for whatever policy they wish to prosecute. But for men who abandon all attempts to settle the minds of their fellow-citizens, who set out to coerce their bodies or bring coercion to them by the destruction of what they hold most dear—their household gods— through intimidation of their wives and families, is three years an excessive penalty? Is it an excessive penalty for those who try to garrotte the nation and force their fellow-countrymen into their will? That penalty was a minimum penalty which men with a sense of their duty could attach to that crime. A comment was made that whereas it is usual in legislation to name the maximum that we named the minimum. We did that, not out of a desire to set down a harsh or vindictive penalty, but to set down the minimum penalty that would commend itself to a man with any proper conception of the insolence of the crime. I am surprised at the quarter this came from. Truly the essence of democracy is the fact that every man should have an equal voice in deciding the affairs of the community, and yet we are asked to say that in the case of men who go out with guns, torches or land mines to coerce their fellow citizens, three years' imprisonment is an excessive penalty. If the amendment were to be accepted here I would advise the other House to reject it.
Comment on this
It seems to me that where death may be the penalty for a particular crime, it is making light of an offence to say that the maximum penalty instead of death should be three years. It would be far better, if an amendment were required at all, that it should be the penalty of death or such less penalty as the court may decide. That I think would meet the case.
Comment on this
I entirely approve of what Sir Nugent Everard says. I would be prepared to accept that amendment. I think the Minister passes over what is really the objection to the clause that the Judge who may see the exceptional circumstances has no option whether he likes it or not, but to inflict the sentence. I do not at all question what the Minister says, that anybody going around and doing these things deserves three or five years penal servitude.
Comment on this
If I might intervene again it would be to say that Senators are losing sight of the fact that it is open to any Judge, having passed the particular sentence that is embodied in legislation, to make his recommendations afterwards. Judges do that as a matter of practice. In recent months Judges have passed sentence and have afterwards written to the Executive and stated they considered, that owing to the state of the country and for the sake of the effect upon the public mind, they should pass a particularly severe sentence. The Judge in such a case has said: "I want you to take a note of the fact that that sentence was passed more for its public effect than with the view that it should be served out to its last week or month as the case may be."
There is always that channel open to judges to make their recommendations. There is always room for the prerogative of mercy, and the prerogative of mercy is exercised constantly to a far greater extent than Deputies or Senators are aware of. Prisoners are brought before a Court. A judge, having regard to the general condition of the country and the general irresponsible outlook prevailing at the time, passes a particular sentence. Later on there is a petition for the prisoner and it is passed to the judge or magistrate for his comments. It is open to the judge, if such a particular case as Colonel Moore suggests comes before him, to pass his legal sentence and to make his recommendation to the Executive. That is done every day, and it will be done to the end of the chapter, and it is an aspect of affairs that the Senators ought not to lose sight of.
Comment on this
I submit that that is making the Minister the judge. Why should that principle be adopted here of fixing the minimum any more than in the case of any other offender? When the Minister talks of the enormity of the offences enumerated in the first part of the Schedule we are at a terrible disadvantage. When we make any opposition to this Bill we are accused of favouring this thing.
Comment on this
Such accusations have been made, and that is not conducive to getting all the good possible out of the Bill, at the finish. The position the judges will be in, will be that they must pass this sentence although they know that it would be unfair. There may be cases notwithstanding the enormity of the crime, that would make it an excessive sentence, but they must pass that sentence and constitute the Minister the judge. It is not fair to the Minister because, if he is to go into the decision he must have to review all the evidence himself, and that will be a duty that will lead to unnecessary labour. The suggestion of Sir Nugent Everard is an improvement undoubtedly upon it. It emphasises the enormity of the crime far more emphatically than this does, because it names death as a penalty, but leaves it to the judge to inflict a lesser penalty. For these reasons I do not know why the Minister would not accept it.
Comment on this
There are a number of amendments which it is almost inevitable should be discussed together and it would save time. I think the Minister's own speech to some extent shows the difficulty that is in our minds in this matter. The suggestion that a judge gives a severe sentence in order that it should be a deterrent has been made. That to some extent is an argument as to why there should be a discretionary power in the judge. I can conceive quite a number of cases in which the offences in the Schedule will be committed and in which the punishment is not by any means sufficient, and I can conceive of other cases in which the punishment might be decidedly one in which the judge or jury could not possibly approve of the sentence.
I think the mistake which the Government is making in this particular case is that they have decided on a long list of offences which are not at all equal, and which, according to different circumstances, might not be equal, yet they have a rule of thumb set of punishments which must be inflicted by the judge. I have consulted lawyers and some have spoken to me, and they all say that is an extremely unwise principle of legislation to introduce and one to which they are opposed. I know of several cases where the very speech of the judge gave an impression that he was prepared to deal leniently with the particular prisoner who was charged. I remember in one particular case where I felt on the evidence that a girl was not guilty; together with one or two other jurors I was extremely unwilling to find her guilty, but very reluctantly we brought in a verdict with a recommendation to mercy. The judge said that the impression we had formed was confirmed by the evidence as to character.
I recognise that if you insist on having an absolute rule of thumb you will have a certain reluctance to convict, if they feel that the judge has no option whatsoever in the sentence. Consequently I think it would have the effect of weakening the power of the judge in dealing effectively with the evidence. One or two cases mentioned in Part 2 of the Schedule provides a penalty for injury to property of any kind. That means that if a boy deliberately breaks a window he must if brought forward and if convicted be sentenced to one year or a year and a half. I have no doubt that in such cases there would be a reprieve.
It is not fair to the Minister himself nor is it a wise thing that offences of that kind should be included. In another portion of the Bill there is reference to a person aiding or abetting the escape of a prisoner. It does not say whether it is to be done knowingly or unknowingly. A person might come to my house and spend the night there. That kind of thing actually did happen during recent events in the country. That person might commit offences which I would know nothing of and yet the judge, even if he were satisfied that I knew nothing about it, would have no option.
The Minister to whom an appeal would be made for a reprieve would no doubt act as justly as he could, but I suggest it is the judge who has heard the whole of the case is the best judge, and it is not fair to the Minister who gets the recommendation to have to decide matters of this kind. I would urge the Minister carefully to consider between this and the Report Stage as to whether an alteration might not be made. I would be in favour of having the punishment heavier. I would not altogether favour the death penalty, but a very much stronger punishment ought to be possible. Some offences are exceptionally serious in view of the present condition of Ireland. The set of punishments indicated in the Bill are in some respects too moderate and in others too extreme. There should be no rule of thumb punishments. Circumstances would tend to make certain cases extremely serious and others not nearly so serious.
Comment on this
One would think we were discussing a Bill in normal times that was to settle the law for a long time. This is an emergency measure to deal with the aftermath of a revolution, and for abnormal punishments, abnormal powers are required.
Comment on this
I move: That after the word "death" the words "or such less penalty as the judge shall decide," be inserted. Those are words from the Army code of regulations.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Senator might agree to substitute the words "or such term of penal servitude as the judge may decide."
Comment on this
I beg to move: In Section 5, Sub-section (2) to delete the word "shall" in line 27, and substitute therefor the word "may." In the other amendment the main principle was argued but if it were at all possible, consistent with the amendment carried, for the Minister to make it "may" and increase the penalties very considerably, it would meet my point.
Comment on this
On the general principle underlying this Bill, I would like to say a few words. The Section we are dealing with introduces into the law two principles which were never known in it before. One is a mandatory principle, and the other is a flat rate punishment. If we are clear in our idea about this fundamental question, it will make all the later amendments more simple. Under the mandatory system the District Justice or the Judges are placed in a dependent position.
Comment on this
Yes, it is to Sub-Section 2. You are quite in order then.
Comment on this
The mandatory system is justified by the Government on the plea that in the dangerous state of the country the Executive Council should take the responsibility on themselves of assigning a definite penalty and not leave it simply to what the President described as such "accidental circumstances as the outlook of a Magistrate here and a Magistrate there to decide." There is something, according to the Minister, "haphazard and casual and fortuitous in that." If in any case the Judge or Magistrate under these definite orders, after having carried out the law by passing the sentence, should think it would be right to make representations to the Executive of mitigating circumstances, no doubt, Ministers think, he would do so. Is there nothing haphazard and casual and fortuitous in that? Is there nothing that implies a danger deeper to the country than a fortuitous error of a magistrate in open court, under public criticism? Are judges limited in authority under a severe State control likely to make many “representations” to their masters of cases where the rules imposed on them have failed in the execution of exact justice? For the next six months the mandatory system in fact appoints that it is with the Minister, not with the Judge, that lies the punishment of crime. I urge that so far as the nation consents to weaken the responsibility of Judges and Magistrates, it lowers their virtue. If it continues to throw on them the highest public duties, it gives to the weakest the strength of the strongest. The mandatory system is not only likely, but certain, to degrade the whole judicial order and ordinary law in the public mind—an evil that will last long beyond the six months of this Bill.
The further defence of the Minister does not help us. It is his sincere and courageous statement that the Executive in the present peril take on themselves the full responsibility for mandatory law. The fact, however, is that no such statement can relieve us of our duty. We have our own responsibility for giving Government such powers. The answer may be—"it is only for six months." But if the real protection of the citizen, the independence of the law as against the State, is once broken, who will repair it, and how? And if confidence of the people in Irish law is shattered at the outset, who will create that faith, and how? If the Minister feels and courageously uses his own responsibility, so we must consider our own problem. On the one side we may weave a net that shall catch every atrocious malefactor in the next six perilous months; for the enactment evidently contemplates the capture of a multitude of criminals and their swift condemnation. On the other side we can thus in this critical moment lower the non-political authority of law, and fashion it into a tool of this State, degrade its dignity, and once more make it the object of popular distrust, or even presently of contempt. Our responsibility is as great as that of the Minister. Where he sees danger ahead if we do not accept his mandate—we have on our part rightly to measure his demands and balance them against other dangers deeper and more persistent which might follow any lack in us of foresight and responsibility.
Besides the mandatory system, there is a second question of justice at issue in this question—the flat rate of punishments decreed. A schedule of crimes is set out, three in Part I, and other twelve in Part II., with a brief code of punishment for the lot. The debate in the Dáil shows how this scheme affects legal opinion. The Minister in fact undertook to consider carefully the possibility of discriminating between the last five and the first seven of these twelve offences thrown into the one bag. But no change has been made in the Bill as before us, and no may has been permitted as regards the last five offences instead of shall. Mandatory law, if we can call it law remains in possession.
The flat rate is defended by the Minister on the ground that it is not as high as it might be. It is not the question of high or low that is troubling some of us. It is rather the degradation of law. Till now law has had to laymen a dignity based on reason, on inherited learning and a great tradition. Instead of this we now find statesmen taking the maximum penalty of greater crimes, and "merging" it, as they say, with the minimum penalty for other offences, or in their words "whatever we believed was the minimum penalty that should be imposed by anyone with a proper sense of the gravity”—that is to say a sense of the present peril of the coutry. Maximum and minimum combined make up the flat rate. The fruitless discussion of this question in the Dáil shows at least how grave may be the reaction of public opinion to such a doctrine during the next six months. The flat rate is not a problem that requires a legal mind. It lies within the view of any plain believer in accustomed justice.
To sum up—these enactments of flat rates and mandatory sentences look as if the Executive could not trust the Judges by themselves to deal out justice. And if their own makers do not trust them, how shall the people have faith? Will any group here maintain that the calamity of temporary looters is so great as to drive us back on one final misfortune a remedy—the defiance of our whole legal system by flat rates and mandatory punishments. The amendments I have suggested in this Section have been entirely with regard to this desire to free the law from mandatory orders and from flat rates.
Comment on this
This is the usual discussion which always occurs wherever I have been before between the words "may" and "shall." I notice that further on in this Sub-section (2) the word "may" is used—"and may in addition be sentenced to pay a fine of fifty pounds." It also reads: "every person convicted by a court of summary jurisdiction of any offence mentioned"— we all know what the offences are—shall be sentenced to a certain imprisonment. "May be sentenced" is suggested. There is a "may" further on in the Section, and I cannot see from a commonsense point of view what this meticulous argument really means between the words "may" and "shall." Reading it as plain English, there is really no very great difference.
Comment on this
I have always understood that in Parliament phraseology "may" does mean "shall." Perhaps you can guide us in that respect.
Comment on this
I certainly never heard that startling proposition. There can be no doubt what the Section here means, because the whole policy of the Minister is made quite plain. It is perfectly plain that "shall" in the first part of the Sub-section (2) means that that is the penalty and no other penalty, and that it shall be and must be imposed by the Magistrate if he finds the person guilty. But he may, in addition—he is not bound —order a fine of £50. That is discretionary but the sentence of twelve months is mandatory, and he has no discretion over that.
Comment on this
I would like to put a position before the Seanad which might soften the heart of the Minister. In the Schedule there is an offence, number 12, "aiding, abetting and encouraging the commission of any of the offences mentioned in this Schedule, or helping in the concealment or escape of any person guilty of any such offence." A mother may have a son or a daughter who may be charged with an offence of this kind. Are you going to say to a magistrate that he shall send the mother of such a boy or a girl to jail for twelve months? Is there any mother that would not shield her son? You are going to compel a magistrate to send such a mother to jail for twelve months, and in addition she may be fined £50 for giving shelter to her son.
I remember in December, 1920, with two of my colleagues here, Senators MacPartlin and O'Farrell, being present at a Labour Party conference in London for the purpose of considering the awful conditions prevailing in this country at the time. We endeavoured to impress upon the representatives of the labour movement in England the horrible state of affairs existing here and the manner in which the people were being treated by the Government. We pointed out that an Irish mother could be sent to jail for harbouring her son. Sir Hamar Greenwood had passed a Bill known as the Restoration of Order Bill, in which a proviso was inserted that a mother could be sent to jail for harbouring her son. Surely we are not to follow the very bad example that was set us then. It is clear from this Bill that if a boy or a girl is concealed by a mother in her house, and if she is arrested for that the magistrate must send that mother to jail for twelve months. Surely we are not going to be guilty of such a crime as that at this stage of our history. I agree whole-heartedly with those who have spoken against making it mandatory for a magistrate to inflict this sentence. There must be a certain amount of discretion allowed to Judges, otherwise there is no necessity for having Judges at all. Judges are appointed because of their great knowledge of the law. They are placed in a most responsible position, and they are supposed to use discretion in making the punishment fit the crime. If in this Bill we lay down the penalties to be inflicted, then there is no necessity to bring them before a Magistrate at all.
Comment on this
I only want to say that Senator Farren knows well that under the law as it stands people may be sent to jail for compounding a felony, and that mothers are not excepted. Senator Farren also knows very well that the fixing of minimum penalties is not uncommon. This whole Bill must be taken in its setting, must be considered in perspective. Certain definite offences are menacing the life and the future of this country, are menacing stability here. Stability must come if we are to solve the problems that loom big and black ahead for us, and if we are to solve the social problems that confront us frowningly, such problems as unemployment and housing. If this State is to rest safe and solid on its foundations, the particular offences set out in the Schedule must be grappled with, and brought to a standstill. If we have taken certain offences and classified them in Part 2 of the Schedule, they are simply offences that reports from all over the country show are the ones that most menace peace, and most menace the future of this country. You cannot take one out of the context and analyse it and turn it over and say "Is that worth twelve months' imprisonment."
We have to take each item in the picture, and there is no use in Deputies or Senators talking about the harmless little bottle of poteen for which 12 months i to be given. You have to consider what part poteen is playing in the national life at the moment and what its re-actions are likely to be on the national life. I simply take that as one example of the fact that things must be considered in their setting and in their perspective. The six months to come are a vital six months for Ireland's future. I am not ashamed, despite Senator Mrs. Green's dissertation on the evils of a flat rate, of saying, after having considered reports from officials throughout the country, that there is no one of these offences more seriously menacing the life of the nation than another. So far as Ireland and her future goes it is equally necessary that each one of these offences in the Schedule of the Bill be stopped and stopped quickly. Senators will get into an atmosphere where they are inclined to consider this Bill and its provisions in a rather abstract and academic sense. Let us at any rate be realists, and let us face the fact that this country's books are unbalanced and must remain unbalanced when there is no atmosphere where men will indulge in that commercial enterprise which is necessary, if the country is to live and drain up unemployment.
Men will not sow here for fear they will not reap, and that is because the whole condition of the country is one of indiscipline, one of looseness, one of lawlessness, and these crimes set out in the Schedule must be stopped within the next six months, if there is to be a decent future for this country. Is it too much to say that we here, the Parliament, the highest Court in the land, should decide that the penalties for particular offences for six months to come shall be so and so? You say no role is left to the judge. It is left to the judge to decide the law; the question of guilt or no guilt on indictment, is left to the jury. We have a responsibility, more than the responsibility in each individual case. We have a responsibility to all the people, to society here, to the decent law-abiding people who live in the country, and we are entitled to say that particular offences must be stopped and particular offences in their present setting and perspective loom so large and so black that we are entitled to attach particular penalties to them.
Comment on this
I would like to point out that the Minister has in no way answered the point raised by Senator Douglas. When answering Senator Farren he stated that a mother may be convicted for compounding felony, thereby missing the whole point, because in the common law she "may" be, whereas the word we feel so strongly about now is the word "shall."
Comment on this
I agree with Senator MacLysaght that the Minister has not met the real point but has treated us to a dissertation on the enormity of these crimes. He is simply preaching to the converted. We all agree with his contention that there must be settled conditions of law and order. The only difference we have is as to the method. In this particular case the particular objection is that stated by Mrs. Green, making the judges and District Justices the creatures of the Ministers and taking away their independence and making them dependent on Ministers. Surely the Government must have confidence in their judges and District Justices to do justice in these cases as otherwise we could not carry on at all. To adopt this mandatory system is equivalent to passing a vote of non-confidence in the whole judicature of the country. That is calculated to create a lack of confidence.
The Judge is the person who gets the real atmosphere of the case. He has the whole case before him, and he should be allowed to decide for himself, up to a certain limit, if necessary, as to what the penalty shall be, otherwise the statements of the Minister are unnecessary. We know that a very bad state of affairs has existed and that all is not well in the garden as he pleases to put it; but that is no reason why we should stamp out all principles of justice which prevail in every civilised land. We are told that these are only temporary provisions. They will, however, have permanent effects. They are likely to be extended from one period to another. They destroy the whole essence of the administration of justice in the country. It is deplorable, because of what has happened in the past, that we should start on our career with a measure like this. The great difficulty in the past was that of catching the culprit. It was not because the punishment was not sufficiently severe, but because there was no way of bringing the culprit to justice. That has now come to an end. No matter what penalty you inflict, unless you are able to bring him to justice it is useless. It is on the basis that we have no police or courts functioning this Bill has been conceived.
Comment on this
With regard to the substitution of the word "may" for "shall" I consider that the word "shall" is the proper word.
Comment on this
I should like to say that the point between us is not a matter of the enormity of the offences nor the determination that these offences must be put down, but that the discretionary powers of the Judge would be far more effective than fixing a flat rate punishment.
Comment on this
I oppose the amendment as I cannot see why a mandate should not be given to the Executive for six months. You are not upsetting the judiciary system, or trial by jury.
Comment on this
In putting this amendment I want the Seanad to understand that it is confined to Sub-Section (2) Section 5, which deals with cases of summary jurisdiction and not with cases tried by juries on indictment.
Comment on this
As the decision has resulted in a tie, I give my casting vote in favour of the amendment.
Comment on this
I move "In Section 5, Sub-section 2 to delete the word "of" in line 29 and to substitute the words therefor "not exceeding."
Comment on this
I intended to propose in Section 5, Sub-section (2) to delete in line 33 the words "the said term of twelve months and to substitute therefor the first mentioned term of imprisonment." I propose to withdraw that amendment, and bring it up on report. There is some confusion owing to several members bringing in similar amendments.
Comment on this
I beg to propose to delete in line 27 the word "shall" and to substitute therefor the word "may." The amendment is similar to the one which has been carried, with this exception that the argument for it in the case of a jury is somewhat stronger. I would like to add to the amendment an increase in the term of penal servitude to which the person may be sentenced from three years to a period of five years. I think if it is "may" it will leave a power of discretion to the judge. Certainly they should have the power to give a sentence of more than three years, which would be too short a sentence for most of the offences set out.
Comment on this
I think we will deal with the question of extending the term when we have dealt with the question of "may" or "shall." I consider it right that the Executive Council, and the Parliament of the Nation in the existing conditions should attach particular penalties and leave to the court the question of deciding the guilt or innocence, leaving also to the judge or magistrate making his recommendation to the Executive Council in particular cases scope for the prerogative of mercy. On this "may" and "shall" question, Senator Douglas dangles his bait of an extension of the term. I am not anxious for an extension. What we wanted was not a long but a swift sentence, a sentence which a prospective criminal would have in his mind's eye when setting out to commit a crime. I would prefer if the Seanad would leave over the question of any extension of the term of imprisonment and deal simply with the question as to whether it is right or not that the Parliament should take into consideration the existing conditions to affix a penalty or leave to the Courts of the land simply the duty of deciding guilt or innocence. When that has been decided the question of the extension of the term, if "may" is inserted, can be raised and then we will consider it.
Comment on this
I desire to move, as a further amendment to substitute in Section 5, Sub-section 3, paragraph (a) instead of “for a term of three years,” the words “for a term not exceeding five years.”
Comment on this
I desire to withdraw the following amendment, "Section 5, Sub-section 3, to insert after the word "of" in line 37 the words "not more than."
Comment on this
The amendment in my name reads as follows: "Section 5, Sub-section 3 to delete in lines 38 and 39 the words ‘nor less than Fifty Pounds.'" I think the Minister ought to accept that amendment. I am sure he has seen by this time how harshly it is calculated to act on the man who has not £100. The man who has the £100 can buy off the punishment due to him simply because he has the money, although his crime is every bit as bad as the crime of the man who has not the £100. I move the amendment.
Comment on this
Question put:—"That Section 4 as amended stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
In view of what we have done already there is no sense now in the words "three years." We should have said "a term of imprisonment," so as not to have it making nonsense. I propose to substitute in line 42 for the words "at the expiration of the said term of three years" the words "expiration of the previous sentence."
Comment on this
I beg to move: "To delete in lines 38 and 39 the words ‘nor less than fifty pounds.'" The sense of the amendment has been pointed out already. It is not fair or just that a person who is in a position to pay a fine of £100 should be getting off with a sentence of six months less than the person who is not able to pay. It may be argued that the person who pays the fine will suffer financial loss. I respectfully suggest that there is no analogy as between a loss of £50 or £100 and suffering six months hard labour. It means that you are going to inflict the full penalty on the prisoner who will not be in a financial position to pay the money.
Comment on this
A fine of £10 on one man may be as severe as a fine of £100 on another. You have again the principle of fixing the absolute minimum. It is only reasonable that this amendment be carried. Take the case of two men committing a felony. One had previously held up a bank and has sufficient money in his pocket to pay the fine. He gets off the imprisonment. It is a case of again fixing the minimum instead of leaving it to the judge.
On a show of hands 11 voted for the amendment and 11 against. By the casting vote of An Cathaoirleach, the amendment was declared lost.
Comment on this
Will you accept a motion for the adjournment? It is obvious that we cannot get through the Bill to-night. We have been working for over 10 hours.
Comment on this
If we are not to adjourn now it is well that we ought all to know it. Therefore you ought to make up your minds to adjourn now or decide how long you are to go on. I will accept and put to the Seanad a motion if Seanator McLoughlin makes it.
Comment on this
I would like to make the point that this Bill is urgent. The president announced to-day an intention to prorogue on Friday next. I do not know whether Senators view with equanimity the prospect of 12,000 or 13,000 prisoners being released indiscriminately on the country. As one with some responsibility it is a thing that I contemplate with no equanimity, and I think that if we are to adjourn the Committee Stage of the Bill it should be adjourned with the definite understanding that the Bill would become law within the week.
Comment on this
I do not know what the delay would have to be between the Committee Stage and the Final Stage, but it seems to me that an adjournment until Wednesday——
Comment on this
If the Seanad would come to any sort of an agreement that the remaining stages will be taken to-morrow at 11 o'clock, finishing at 12, we might give that hour to it.
Comment on this
If the thing is to be fought out on the same lines as to-day, if we started it again to-morrow we probably would deprive Senators of any opportunity of debating the Land Bill.
Comment on this
I do not see why we should be pressed. No one can say there has been any obstruction in the last couple of hours. I think this sort of bullying is very objectionable.
Comment on this
It has been proposed that the Seanad do now adjourn and resume to-morrow at 11 o'clock.
Comment on this
I would like to propose that we go on for another hour in view of the statements of the Minister.
Comment on this
The difficulty about that is that those who have to catch trains would have to stay here all night. I have no objection to sitting at 10 in the morning if that is the wish of the Seanad, and take this Bill from 10 o'clock to 12 o'clock. We could take the Land Bill at 12 o'clock.
Comment on this
I was fishing for some such undertaking but I did not get it.
The Seanad adjourned at 10.35 p.m. until 10 o'clock on Tuesday morning.