COURTS OF JUSTICE BILL, 1923—REPORT.
Contributions 1–141 of 285. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 41 of 1923 ›
There were one or two amendments that stood over since last evening. First there was amendment No. 6.
Comment on this
That was an amendment that was discussed on a point you raised, and I now submit the following new amendment: In Section 23 to insert the following words: "That no judge shall sit upon the hearing of an appeal in an action tried before him, whether with or without a jury, or upon any appeal from a judgment or order made by him, or to which he was a party, whether concurring or dissenting."
Comment on this
Amendments No. 20 and 22 stood over. Senator Jameson was interested in those.
Comment on this
These were left over to enable me to ascertain from the Chamber of Commerce whether I should agree with them or not. I had a conversation with the Secretary of the Chamber of Commerce, and I believe that Senator O'Dea, on behalf of the Chamber, will deal with any matter concerning it. I do not propose to deal with them.
Comment on this
Are we to leave these amendments as they are?
Comment on this
The alternative is the Government amendment No. 22, which reads as follows:—
Section 50. To insert immediately after clause (iv.) and before clause (v.) a new clause (v.) as follows:—
"(v.) If the plaintiff so elects, in any action founded on contract, whether the claim be to enforce, rescind, dissolve, or annul the contract, or for damages or other relief for the breach thereof, by the judge for the time being assigned to the Circuits within which the contract was made."
That amendment approaches the matter from a different angle, and I understand it was accepted as an alternative by the mercantile gentlemen whom I received on the subject.
Comment on this
Do you wish to speak on amendment 20, Senator O'Dea?
Comment on this
Senator Jameson had an amendment down of an alternative kind.
Comment on this
I am concerned with this amendment which the Attorney-General has proposed. Of course, we only got this amendment yesterday, and there has not been time to call a meeting of the Council of the Chamber of Commerce. I have, however, spoken to several members of the deputation that waited on and had a consultation with the Attorney-General. In the first instance, I am instructed to thank him very much for the great courtesy and great pains he took with the matter which we are discussing. They feel perfectly satisfied that this amendment meets their case very fairly so far as Section 46 is concerned. What they instructed me to ask the Attorney-General was to apply the same procedure to the District Courts. I think the Section they mean it to apply to is Section 76. I think it would be very prudent, and it would save a lot of confusion and expense if the same procedure were applied to the other clause. In case the Attorney-General is willing to do that we would have no further opposition to the Bill.
Comment on this
The suggestion made is that a clause somewhat similar to this, so far as it is applicable, should be passed to deal with District Courts.
Comment on this
It is difficult to see how it will be framed. There will be always power to take the matter to the High Court, and ask the High Court to send it to the District Court. I do not see for the moment how we can frame one.
Comment on this
The objection was that in many cases where an action was founded on a book or a contract debt it would involve a man taking his book-keeper and accounts to the country, and the point you met is to provide that if in such a case as that the contract was made in Dublin the plaintiff could sue in the Circuit Court in Dublin. Senator O'Dea says his Association is anxious that a similar clause with reference to District Courts should be inserted.
Comment on this
Contracts to that amount could be brought up in the Dublin Circuit Courts if the contract was made in Dublin.
Comment on this
I think that in the District Court the jurisdiction is where the defendant resides.
Comment on this
But the jurisdiction is not exclusive, they could institute proceedings in the Circuit Court.
Comment on this
Shall we leave it over for a little while? Are you satisfied with that, Senator O'Dea? The Attorney-General says he is not quite sure that under the terms of the Bill you have not got that power already. You can raise the point again when we come to Section 76.
Comment on this
With the exception of No. 26, that disposes of the points held over.
Comment on this
No. 26 stood over in order that we might examine the form of words. There is no difference of opinion as regards the idea, which is that judgments should be executed in any part of Ireland which are judgments of the Circuit Court. I propose a new Section 58 in these words: "Rules to be made under this part of this Act shall provide for the service of all originating or other documents or notices both inside and outside the circuit of the judge before whom the matter is intended to be brought or is pending. Any judgment or order of the Circuit Court may be enforced in any part of Saorstát Eireann in any of the modes in which a like judgment or order of the High Court might be enforced."
Comment on this
The next is a Government amendment:—
Section 63. After the word "Ireland" in line 44 to insert the words "of whom one shall be a solicitor having his office and carrying on the practice of his profession outside the City and County of Dublin."
Comment on this
During the week I had a deputation from the provincial solicitors in Ireland with reference to the Bill. The only complaint they had was as regards representation under the rule-making authority, and I undertook that I would offer an amendment in which provision would be made that one of their body at least should be on the rule-making authority in both the Circuit Courts and the District Courts. They will be most interested in the procedure of both these Courts, and it is highly proper that they should have a voice in the making of the rules.
Comment on this
Section 64, Government amendment:—To insert immediately after the word "costs" in line 6 and within the bracket the words "and also the entering-up of judgment and granting of summary judgment in appropriate cases."
Comment on this
That amendment is in fulfillment of a promise that I made to Senator O'Dea's colleagues in the Chamber of Commerce and the Mercantile Association, that there would be in the Circuit and District Courts provision for entering up judgment where no defence is made to a claim, and also power to apply for summary judgment on affidavit. This amendment is for the purpose of enabling rules to be made carrying out these ideas.
Comment on this
Government amendment to Section 66:—To delete the word "Judges" and to substitute the word "Justices" therefor.
Comment on this
The Government asks the House not to press the amendment, which was carried in Committee. The position of the District Justices is undoubtedly that of Judges; there is no question of that, and there can be no question of it. But when it comes to putting the same designation on Judges of every grade in the hierarchy of Judges, it may lead to some confusion. We do not want the thing made ridiculous, as in the case of the colonels after the American Civil War. However, there is also another feature in this which makes one suggest that it should not be insisted upon. These District Justices were created something over a year ago, and they have become an established institution. They are known by this title of District Justice throughout the country. All their stationery, forms and rules are printed, and to make this change would lead to another upheaval. We had one upheaval when we got rid of the Resident Magistrates, and it would lead to another if the title of these Justices were to be altered now. I met Deputy Johnson on the matter half-way in the Dáil by accepting as the Irish term the term Breitheamh. This is the same term that is applied throughout to all the Judges, and I think that with that compromise perhaps Senator O'Farrell will not insist upon this amendment.
Comment on this
When I moved this amendment I pointed out that in my opinion it was not one of supreme importance, but that I thought it was desirable if they were looked upon as judges and thereby rendered independent of every power, except the Constitution and the law, that it should be so stated in plain English, that they should get their proper definition. The Attorney-General has made that definition in the Irish language, but he does not see fit to make it in the English language, which is an extraordinarily anomalous position. Of course, he follows the same line as the President did on the last occasion, that it is to prevent confusing of these judges with Circuit Judges, but I think on that occasion we also pointed out that there might be a similar danger of confusing Circuit Judges with High Court Judges, and that it was hardly a very legitimate objection to the change. There is also, of course, the position, as we pointed out on the last occasion, that the jurisdiction of these judges or justices, or whatever they may be called, will be considerably changed or widened as the result of the passing into law of this Bill, and that it might be desirable to mark that great change by calling these people judges instead of justices. It would be one other means of bringing home to the community as a whole the fundamental change that had been made in the matter of the administration of the law. Of course, as to whether they are called justices, from the point of view of convenience, as against judges, is a matter perhaps for consideration. There is nothing fundamental in that. But what makes me apprehensive of the whole position is this, that this amendment seems to be only paving the way for the amendment which the Attorney-General has down, providing for the salaries of these justices to be paid out of moneys voted by the Oireachtas, and consequently open for discussion every year. That is the dangerous part of it——
Comment on this
I wish to assure the Senator that there is no relation whatever between them, as he will see when I come to the other. It never occurred to my mind that there was any relation between them.
Comment on this
I accept the assurance of the Attorney-General, but these are the motives that inspired me to move the amendment, and I confidently left it to the House, which decided, after a pretty full discussion on the last occasion, to change the name. It is rather undesirable, in my opinion, that after we discuss a matter pretty fully, taking the views of both sides, and passing in Committee a certain amendment, we should, without any new cause being shown, come along on the Report Stage and reverse our decision. I am afraid that is putting us in the position of simply passing amendments to show that we can pass them, but when they come back, without any new argument adduced or any new reasons advanced, we are asked to alter our position right away. If the House agrees to adopt that procedure, I cannot accept any responsibility for it, and the House itself will be at liberty to adopt that attitude.
Comment on this
I was not here when the matter was discussed on the previous occasion, and I did not know I was covering the same ground as the President had covered. I should have tried to avoid it otherwise. But it has been impressed upon me that there would be a large amount of administrative inconvenience, and I merely put it as a request that the thing should not be pressed. I leave it entirely in the hands of the Seanad.
Comment on this
I take it that the gentlemen who preside in the High Court and the Circuit Court will be designated as Judges?
Comment on this
And that it is merely those who preside in the District Courts who are being defined as Justices.
Comment on this
The manner in which confusion has undoubtedly arisen is this, that in the old days one never thought of describing as Judges Resident Magistrates or the unpaid Justices. "Judge" was a name reserved for the County Court and High Court Judges, and I think it was this that the framers of the Constitution had in their minds. But, nevertheless, on the strict interpretation of the Constitution it would certainly include Judges of all Courts set up under the Constitution, and that being in the Constitution, therefore, covers District Justices. This was fully discussed before. The Seanad took the view that it would be better to call them Judges, and the question now before the House is whether the reasons put forward by the Attorney-General are persuasive enough to induce the House to go back upon their previous decision.
Comment on this
I would like to put this aspect of the case before the House. In the public mind the term "Justice," from the legal point of view, is largely associated with Justices of the Peace. Knowing that would tend to give the impression to the general public that these Justices were reduced, as it were, or not considered to be equally entitled to the appellation of "Judge," I think it would be rather unfortunate. I anticipate, owing to the increased jurisdiction that has been given to District Justices, there will be, at the outset, at least, a large number of appeals. We should raise the dignity of these Courts in very possible way, in the matter of title or otherwise. They will be largely used as lesser courts, by defendants and plaintiffs, for the purpose of testing the strength of the other side with the ultimate intention of appeal. They will be used just as a sort of going over the course to find out as much as they can of the case of the other side. That was the practice heretofore in the lesser courts; the idea always was to appeal.
Unless you give the impression to the public mind that those who preside over the courts are, as in fact they are, in every way capable of dealing with the matters that will come within their enlarged jurisdiction, I think that will increase the chances of appeal from these courts. That is not an end that is to be desired, and the fact of selecting out from a whole series of courts, those presiding over these courts, and describing them simply as justices, will have the effect of conveying an impression to the public that they are of a minor capacity, or for some reason or other are not entitled to the appellation of judge. That would be rather unfortunate. The Government has proposed to meet the case by calling them Breitheamh. I think Breitheamh would possibly mean more than the ordinary conception of a judge, and it is a higher title than judge, but if there is a change at all to be made why not change consistently, and call everyone presiding over any court a judge of that court? That is a very rational suggestion to make, and there can be no confusion arising. If you call one who is presiding over a district court a district judge, one presiding over a circuit court a circuit judge, and so on, you will have no ambiguity, and you will know what is meant. The point I wish to stress particularly is, that in making any distinction of this sort, which is a rather subtle one, it should be one that would satisfy the ordinary man. The ordinary man in the street will simply know and observe that there is that distinction made, and that it is derogatory, and that would be unfortunate.
Comment on this
It occurs to me that the inconvenience referred to by the Attorney-General is entirely temporary, whereas the name District Justice or District Judge, whichever is adopted, is going to be adopted permanently. Therefore I think temporary inconvenience ought to give way. I will have great pleasure in supporting the view of Senator O'Farrell.
Comment on this
I have been looking up the Standing Orders, and although I am satisfied the Attorney-General, with his legal knowledge, has got inside the Standing Order, I suggest he is sailing dangerously close to the wind. If Senator O'Farrell's amendment had been defeated on the Committee Stage he would have been out of order in reintroducing the amendment in the Report Stage.
Comment on this
No, not if I thought it of sufficient importance. Under the Standing Orders I would have been entitled to allow him to discuss it, I think. That is my recollection.
Comment on this
It would be in the hands of the Chairman; if the Chairman thought it was brought forward for obstructive purposes he has power to rule it out. I suggest that if a member of this House proposed an amendment on the Committee Stage, and it was defeated, and he put down the same amendment on the Report Stage, that it would be within the power of the Chairman to rule it out of order. I say the exact position is the reverse now. The amendment was passed in the Committee Stage, and the Government come along now and propose an amendment to change that amendment. I suggest that is sailing dangerously close to the wind. However, dealing with the merits of this case, we have to remember that the District Courts will approximate to what the County Courts were, and that the functions of the District Justices or Judges will be similar to those performed in the old days by the County Court Judges. If it was right that those who presided over the County Courts should be designated judges, there is no reason why those who preside over the District Courts should not have the designation of judges also. After all they are acting in the capacity of judges, and what is the reason the Government are not anxious to give them their proper title? The Attorney-General's argument does not hold water. A rubber stamp put over the present stationery will meet the inconvenience that would be caused regarding the stationery at present in stock, in which they are described as District Justices. If that is all the inconvenience, I think the House has not sufficient reason why they should alter the decision arrived at on the Committee Stage.
Comment on this
The Attorney-General has said that he has given these District Justices an Irish name. That is by way of compromise, I believe. What I want to know is, what is the difference between a Justice and a Judge? I have a dictionary here, Cassell's New English Dictionary, which is the latest, and I find there that the Lord Chief Justice is a Judge combining the former functions of President of the King's Bench. I take it that Justice and Judge are much the same, then. If so, why all this trouble and fuss about papers that have been printed? After all, that is not a very great matter, and, with all due respect to you, sir, after having consulted the latest dictionary and finding that Justice and Judge mean the same thing, and as a District Justice has been labelled with an Irish name, which seems to please people very much, why should we not let it remain as it is and allow the Government amendment to pass? We are discussing a matter in which there is really the difference between Tweedledum and Tweedledee.
Comment on this
I spoke on this amendment on the last day, and I think if Senator O'Farrell will look up his list of amendments he will find four, or possibly five, amendments disposed of on the last occasion, which again appear on the list. I do not complain of that. I simply point out that the Attorney-General has not secured any special treatment for the Government by introducing another amendment. I mentioned on the last day that these District Justices were set up by the Government during a time of great trial and stress. It was at a time when, I think we might reasonably confess now, the positions were not regarded as plums, and that there was considerable danger attached to the holding of these offices at that time. I think that during the 14 or 15 months not one single District Justice resigned his office. They performed their duties sometimes under great difficulties in a time of stress, and they honoured this particular distinction by which they are described in the Bill, by the Committee which advised the Government, and upon which the Bill is founded.
The term "District Justice" has become during a time of stress an honoured term, a new institution in the country under which the Justices were given much more jurisdiction than formerly attached to the elementary courts, which is probably the easiest way of describing them. They have come to be known as District Justices. I hope and believe they are respected and that the people have a considerable amount of confidence in them. Relabelling them "Judges" will not enhance or increase that confidence. It might, however, lead to some mixing up of terms if we had District Judges, Circuit Judges, and Judges of the High Court, as we would then have something like forty judges in all. The term "Justice" is not a term of reproach in the hierarchy of the judiciary, as the Attorney-General has stated. Practically all the Judges of the High Court, I think, are known by the term "Mr. Justice." There are also special distinctions with regard to particular Judges, such as the Lord Chief Justice or the Lord Justices who are Appeal Judges. In this case I urge that this has become an honoured and honourable method of describing this particular class of Judge through the country, and the present occupants retaining that office I think ought to be allowed to retain whatever credit they acquired during that period of trial and of stress when they did their duty fearlessly, and, I think, with great satisfaction generally.
Comment on this
The compromise suggested by the Attorney-General, I think, is rather a bad compliment to the Irish language. We have the three-star Judges, whom we might call the Judges of the High Court; and the two-star Judges of the Circuit Court. We are now going to give the District Judges an Irish title and put them on the lowest rung of the ladder, with one star.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact all the judges are to be called by the same Irish title, "Breitheamh."
Comment on this
The Attorney-General made it quite plain. That was the suggested compromise as Senator O'Farrell described it. He made it quite plain that he was trying to meet the position by giving them the Irish title of Judge.
Comment on this
That is the title of the judges when they are referred to in the Irish language.
Comment on this
Might I venture to suggest that this matter should be referred to Dr. Eoin MacNeill. He has definitely stated in his last work that "Breitheamh" is not a judge, but a jurist—one of the leading jurists.
Comment on this
I might point out that, as a member of the Executive, Dr. Eoin MacNeill was collectively responsible for that.
Comment on this
I think the remarks made by the President are really a good, sound reason why we should take his advice, and I think the whole Seanad should agree with him. Senator O'Farrell is trying to give a title of honour to the Justices, or Judges, and the President's argument is that the greatest honour is done them by leaving them with the title of Justice. We have two amendments dealing with these judges. If the same treatment in reference to their pay and the source of their emoluments is given to them, then probably the President is perfectly correct. But if we find that their pay is to be left to be chargeable on moneys provided by the Oireachtas, whereas all the other judges are charged on the Central Fund, then I hold that there is a great deal in what Senator O'Farrell said and that the title of Judge will probably carry with it the fact that they will have to be paid also out of the Central Fund. I think the two amendments are very much tied together. Refusing the title of Judge, because Justice is a higher title, and at the same time refusing to put their salaries on the Central Fund, because they are Justices and not Judges, seems to be the argument as far as I can make out. Therefore, I think Senator O'Farrell is absolutely consistent in his two amendments. I would like if it were possible to debate the second amendment of Senator O'Farrell before we come to a decision on this one, because the two hang together. If the District Justices are to be placed on a different and more uncertain Fund which renders them likely to be severely criticised in a way which the other judges are not liable to, then I think we ought to do the best we can to give them the title of Judges, whether we can carry the other amendment or not.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
Section 69. Immediately before Section 69 to insert a new Section as follows:—
"69. So far as may be practicable having regard to all relevant circumstances the Justice of the District Court assigned to a District which includes an area where the Irish language is in general use shall possess such a knowledge of the Irish language as would enable him to dispense with the assistance of an interpreter when evidence is given in that language."
That is the Government proposal in lieu of Senator Kenny's amendment, which has been withdrawn.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
Section 69. To delete the Section and to substitute the following new Section therefor:—
69.—The age of retirement of a Justice of the District Court for the time being assigned to the Police District of Dublin Metropolis or to a District comprising or including the City of Cork shall be 70 years, and the age of retirement of every other Justice of the District Court shall be 65 years.
As I said yesterday, the Government is prepared to fix the retiring age in every case, with the exception I mentioned, and to provide that the retiring age for the District Justices shall be 65, and for those who function in the City of Dublin and City of Cork, 70. This amendment gives effect to that.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
Section 71.—To delete, in lines 3-4, the words "The remuneration payable to every Judge of the District Court under this Act shall be charged upon and paid out of the Central Fund of Saorstát Eireann or the growing produce thereof" and to substitute therefor the words "The several salaries aforesaid shall be paid out of monies provided by the Oireachtas."
With reference to this amendment, unfortunately, sir, I think your attention was not called to the necessary preliminary to all matters of finance, namely, a message of the Governor-General upon which every piece of financial legislation must be based. If it had, I think you would probably have dealt with the amendment that was carried in a different way. I think really the resolution should accompany Bills when they come up here. The message under Article 37 of the Constitution provides for the charge upon the Central Fund of the remuneration and pensions of the judges of the High Court, the Supreme Court, and the Circuit Court, and for the payment out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas of the remuneration of temporary Assistant Circuit Judges, the remuneration and pensions of Justices, Deputy Justices, and temporary Assistant Justices of the District Court, and any other expenses incurred in carrying such Act into effect. The financial resolution of the Dáil was in the same terms as the message.
Comment on this
What exactly do you suggest? This point is quite new to me. I have only heard it now for the first time. There was no suggestion of it when it was going through Committee. I think you were present.
Comment on this
Certainly, unless I am very much mistaken, the President was here, and I do not think this point was raised. I think I ought to have got some notice if it was intended to raise it to-day. It is a very serious Constitutional point, and I do not profess to be capable of dealing with it straight away at a moment's notice. The position appears, from a copy of the Governor-General's message which has been sent up by the Attorney-General, to be quite clear.
"On the advice of the Executive Council and for the purpose of Article 37 of the Constitution I have to recommend that for carrying out the provisions of any Act of the present Session to provide for the establishment of courts of justice according to the Constitution and for the better administration of justice, authority be granted for (a) the charge upon the Central Fund of the remuneration and pensions of the Judges of the High Court, the Supreme Court, and the Circuit Court; (b) the payment out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas of the remuneration of Temporary Assistant Circuit Judges, the remuneration and pensions of Justices, Deputy Justices, and Temporary Assistant Justices of the District Court, and any other expenses incurred in carrying such Act into effect.”
We have never had a copy of this resolution before us.
Comment on this
This is a Message, I take it, in pursuance of Article 37 of the Constitution. "Money shall not be appropriated by vote, resolution or law, unless the purposes of the appropriation has in the same Session been recommended by a message from the representative of the Crown acting on the advice of the Executive Council." The first point that occurs to me is that that only deals with the purpose of the appropriation. It does not deal with the fund from which the money is to come. I am not at all satisfied even if this resolution is binding on the Seanad when it comes to discuss the financial clauses of a Bill like this, that this Article covers it. This Article only seems to make it a condition precedent that the purpose of the appropriation is to be specified. It does not make it mandatory to specify out of what fund it is to come. The question here is, inasmuch as the Message of the Governor-General limits the authority over the financial grant in the case of the District Justices to payment out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas, whether that is binding upon the Seanad here, and prevents them saying: "No, the payment for the District Justices is to come out of the Central Fund in the same way as the other Judges." That is the question. It is a very difficult question to spring here now after completely ignoring it in Committee. Certainly I am not prepared to pronounce an opinion on it.
Comment on this
Is not the net effect of that Message from the Governor-General to render nugatory and abortive our deliberations, as a part of the Oireachtas? Does it not mean, according to the Attorney-General, that we have no right to amend a Bill except in accordance with the Message? Does it not forestall the whole of our proceedings?
Comment on this
It raises a very grave and serious question which I anticipated must be raised some day, and dealt with. At the same time it has never been raised until now. It is this, whether in the case of a Bill not certified as a Money Bill, the hands of the Seanad are tied, so that it is incapable of making any change in any scale of salary or otherwise that is provided in the Bill as it comes up from the Dáil. There is no such limit in the Constitution that I can find. I am speaking now as I anticipated this and looked into it. There is of course a restriction on the powers of the Seanad in the case of Money Bills so certified with which you are all familiar. There is no actual restriction imposed by the Constitution upon the Seanad in regard to Bills that are not Money Bills in dealing with the finances of these Bills. That leaves untouched the question whether having regard to Article 37 of the Constitution, there being no Resolution in accordance with the Message of the Governor-General which sanctions this payment otherwise than out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas, the Seanad can go behind that. That, I think, is the Attorney-General's view.
Comment on this
May I ask the date of the Message and if it was brought to the notice of the Dáil that their proceedings are affected by it?
Comment on this
The procedure is, before the Committee Stage of the Bill begins the Message is presented to the Speaker and then in accordance with the Message a Resolution of the Dáil is passed. The whole object of that of course is to keep control of the finances in the Dáil, acting on the advice of the Executive Ministry responsible to the Dáil.
Comment on this
As this is a question that may form a very serious precedent, speaking for myself, and as it, in one way or another, must necessarily affect the powers and privileges of the Seanad, I am not prepared to give a decision now. If that important point is pressed, this particular amendment will have to stand over until we meet on some future occasion. I do not mean by that that I want the question to be put aside at all, as it is a very serious one that some time or other must be determined. In fairness to myself and in order to make my advice worth having to the Seanad, I shall have to look into it.
Comment on this
Might we know if the Attorney-General contends that the Seanad has no right to make this amendment?
Comment on this
That, I think, is the view. I take it that the view of the Attorney-General is that we cannot go outside the Resolution passed on the Message of the Governor-General. That confines payment in regard to District Justices to monies provided by the Oireachtas as distinguished from those charged on the Central Fund. Any amendment here transferring that charge from the monies provided by the Oireachtas to the Central Funds would be ultra vires.
Comment on this
Would it be possible if we were to ask you to report at a future date on the actual position? I think it is extremely important that whatever decision is made on this matter it should be clear that it applies equally to the Seanad and the Dáil.
Comment on this
On that particular point I should say that this question has already been raised in the Dáil, and there is no doubt about it that the Ceann Comhairle has no option but to keep within the terms of the resolution and of the Message.
Comment on this
That may have been the Ceann Comhairle's own view. He may have acquiesced in that.
Comment on this
That puts it in a very simple and, if I may say so, plausible way, but I do not think that it is as simple as that.
Comment on this
There is no question under the Constitution but that the appropriation of money must be recommended, and that applies to both Houses. We are not likely to go beyond that. It seems, however, to be a matter of interpretation of the word "purpose"—whether it includes the expenditure of money in a different way.
Comment on this
That was the point of difficulty that occurred to me. The Constitution only prescribes that the Governor-General is to prescribe the purpose for the appropriation and not the particular fund out of which the money is to come. In this particular Message he has gone further and has specified the funds out of which, in the case of District Justices, the money for their pensions and salary is to be derived. The question then arises—Does that cripple the action of the Dáil and of this House?
Comment on this
This particular motion was debated at great length in the Dáil and I heard it discussed, but I would like to know whether on that occasion this particular resolution was brought to the notice of the Dáil and objection made to the amendment brought forward.
Comment on this
I should like to know for how long the Governor-General's Message takes effect. Does it bind the Oireachtas for all time not to appropriate money except in the way he suggests?
Comment on this
As regards Senator Moore's point my recollection is that this question was not raised in the course of the debate in the Dáil. I have only read the official record. I am quite clear, however, that it was not raised here in the course of our debate in Committee. That, of course, does not do away with its effects if it is a good point now.
Comment on this
I think that as this question has come to us so very suddenly before we had any notice of it, or any opportunity of discussing what might be a very important question in all its bearings, the least the Seanad should do, having regard to its own dignity, is, in my opinion, to take steps to consider the matter at its leisure. I think that we should report progress and resume the consideration of this Bill next week.
Comment on this
Would it not be simpler to postpone the consideration of this particular amendment and go on with the rest of the business?
Comment on this
I second that proposal. I am anxious to know how long the recommendations of the Governor-General shall be binding upon us.
Comment on this
Might I suggest, if this is to stand over for consideration, it might be desirable to have a small Committee appointed to consider it. I should like to have the assistance of Senator Brown and Senator Douglas on this matter, and I think it would be a very desirable thing that they should be associated with me in the consideration of it. It does not merely affect this particular Bill, but it affects our procedure and raises a question of precedent for all time. It is the most important and far-reaching question that has been raised in my time here. Is it the wish of the Seanad that consideration of this particular amendment be postponed, and that in the meantime the Seanad refers it to a Committee consisting of the Chairman, the Vice-Chairman, and Senator Brown, to report.
Comment on this
Might I suggest that as Senator O'Farrell is interested in this matter that he should join the Committee.
Comment on this
Yes, that is a good suggestion. It is proposed that further consideration of this particular amendment be postponed, and meantime a Committee consisting of the Chairman, Vice-Chairman, Senator Brown, and Senator O'Farrell be appointed, whose duty it shall be to consider the matter and draw up a report for submission to the Seanad. Do Senators agree with that proposal?
Comment on this
The next amendment is No. 40, Section (74).
Comment on this
May I say that that amendment stood over to enable the Government to bring in a certain amendment. I merely want to state that we complied with our undertaking that was given with regard to the summary judgment in District Courts.
Comment on this
Yes, the Government undertook to give facilities for entering judgment in uncontested and plain cases, and they have done so.
Comment on this
I move:—
Section 74, page 16, lines 53-54. To delete the words "for a declaration of title or in ejectment in relation to such land" and to substitute therefor the words "except in any proceedings brought for the same cause of action."
This is really a drafting amendment. I explained it when the Bill was in Committee. The Attorney-General was not there and it stood over. The effect of my amendment is to widen the cases in which the decision of the District Court is not to be an estoppel. If you look at the Section in the Bill you will find it gives the District Court jurisdiction in cases where title is involved. My amendment confines the cases in which the decision of a justice is not to be an estoppel to those two particular cases. My amendment widens the possible cases in which the decision of a District Justice might be pleaded in an estoppel. I suggest it is a useful amendment, as there are several other cases where that might occur.
Comment on this
I am afraid I can hardly agree that that improves the Section. As a matter of clearness, the expression, "the same cause of action" is so wide and indefinite that I think it would defeat the object in view. The idea was this, that a District Justice might have a case of trespass brought before him. If the matter of title was raised he might dispose of it and the parties might go away, but it left it open, if they liked, as a matter of title, to come to the Circuit Court. The weakness I see in Senator Brown's amendment is this. As a matter of trespass you might have trespass on Monday, Tuesday, and so on, and if Senator Brown's amendment is substituted the decision on a matter of trespass would not be final at all, because a trespass on each day would be a separate cause of action.
Comment on this
Certainly, as a tort. It was not intended to encourage that sort of thing. It was intended that there should be an estoppel as regards suits for trespass. It left it open to the parties to go in for a declaration of title. I submit the expression "the same cause of action" is so dangerous and would give rise to such disputation that it is really opening up a field of litigation instead of closing it.
Comment on this
I should have thought that "the same cause of action" to a lawyer would have meant nothing but the same cause of action. I do not think there would be any danger whatever of confusion. It is to meet the case of one trespass on one day and one on the other that I put this in the amendment.
Comment on this
I could well imagine cases where the trespass could be repeated. That would make the measure of damages different from what it might be the previous day. A gentleman could walk across your ground the first day and commit a trespass. The next day he might cut up a pathway as he went along. Your cause of action the second day would be a much more serious one. I do not think there is much difference in effect between the two. If I may venture an opinion, I prefer the form which the Government have.
Comment on this
As a lay man who knows very little about the details that learned members of the Bar know, I cannot see exactly how the District Judges are to compass all the work laid on their shoulders.
Comment on this
Having regard to the very doubtful nature of this and the view you express, I am quite willing to withdraw.
Comment on this
The next Government amendment is:—
"In Section 74, page 17, line 4, to insert after the word ‘summarily' the words ‘and the accused does not object to being so tried.'"
Comment on this
There is only one difference between the Government amendment, which is drawn to meet the question I raised, and the amendment which I have brought forward. I had in my amendment the words "and the accused shall so consent." In the Government amendment the words are "and the accused does not object to being so tried." There is only one little thing left out. Is it certain that the accused will be asked whether he objects or not? He may not know. As long as you say that he shall be asked, your clause is right. But if you add the words "after having been asked if he does object" it would be clearer.
Comment on this
I can quite understand an argument lasting for weeks on the question whether his conduct amounted to election or not. I think if the Government could see their way to say: "And the accused, when questioned, does not object to being so tried."
Comment on this
If he were never questioned, he could set the whole thing aside, I think.
Comment on this
Perhaps this would do: "And the accused, inquiry being made of him, does not object."
Comment on this
There might be a grave doubt raised. Unless consent was given in a prescribed form it would be a difficult thing to prove. If you accept the suggestion "provided that the accused on being questioned" it would make it certain that he must be questioned.
Comment on this
That would impose the necessity of questioning him. "Provided that the accused upon being questioned does not object to being so tried."
Comment on this
"Provided that the accused shall be asked if he objects to being so tried and in the event of his objecting, etc."
Comment on this
As matters stand, the Justice can deal with any number of the cases mentioned under those sub-headings. If this is made very strong it may have the effect of altering the law and they could only be dealt with in a Circuit Court.
Comment on this
That, of course, raises another difficulty. Perhaps this thing requires to be thought out a little more, and as we are not concluding the Report Stage to-day by reasons of the difficulty that arose over that particular amendment that had to be adjourned, we might let this stand over, because, you see, the peculiarity about this whole clause is this. I think myself it is an excellent clause, particularly because it was I who recommended it. But the difficulty about it is this, for the purpose we are at now, that it excludes some things that a District Justice can already try without the consent of the accused. So that if you were to put these words in a very stringent form it might deprive the District Justice of jurisdiction that has already been conferred on him in certain cases. There are other offences enumerated which he could not try under the existing law, and which he is given power to try for the first time by this Bill. Therefore, I think it might be desirable to separate it and to put in one category—(a) those whom he can already try without consent, and (b) those for which he will require to see that the accused realises his position and is satisfied he should be tried. If it is the desire of the House that this particular matter should stand over to be dealt with until the Bill is finally considered, I think it would be much better.
Amendment left over for further consideration.
Comment on this
Government Amendment to Section 74, page 17, line 30. After the word "Circuit" to insert the words "or of one of the Circuits (to be determined by the Justice)."
Comment on this
Some of the districts of the District Justices encroach upon different Circuits, and it would not be sufficient to say, as it is in the Section, that he is to send to the Circuit Court within which his district lies, because his district may touch upon several Circuits and, therefore, he must send to one of them. The object of the amendment is to enable him to send to the appropriate Circuit Court.
Comment on this
Government amendment to Section 81:—
To insert after the word "District," in line 24, the words "or any part of the district."
Comment on this
Government amendment to Section 82:—
To insert after the word "District," in line 30, the words "or any part of the district."
This is the same as the previous amendment.
Comment on this
Government amendment to Section 85:—
(1) page 18, line 54. Immediately after the word "County," to insert the words "and (if so expressed in his warrant of appointment) within the Counties immediately adjoining such Counties."
(2) line 58. Immediately after the word "Peace" to insert the words "or in two or more Justices of the Peace acting together."
(3) line 63. Immediately after the word "informations" to insert the word "bonds."
Comment on this
This amendment deals with the position of Peace Commissioners, and I am told that it would be a great convenience if a Peace Commissioner were not limited to the precise area of the County for which he is appointed, but that he should be allowed to act in the immediately adjoining Counties, and that is the object of the first part of the amendment. The second paragraph I would not press on the House. It proposes to permit a single Peace Commissioner to act where two or more Justices of the Peace would have acted, for instance, in reference to the committal of lunatics, and I do not think I could recommend that. The third part of the amendment is to include bonds in the matters that can be sworn before a Peace Commissioner.
Part 2 of amendment withdrawn. Parts 1 and 3 put and agreed to.
Comment on this
Do you move your amendment, Senator Kenny? I think not, as there is a Government amendment dealing with the matter.
Comment on this
No. I wish to say in regard to that, that in Committee, in submitting that particular amendment I purposely left out the words "where practicable," because I was given to understand that there are very suitable citizens in these Irish-speaking districts who are sufficiently intelligent, and who have a thorough knowledge of the Irish language, to be appointed as Peace Commissioners. The President said at the time that he was in favour of it, but he would consult the Minister for Home Affairs, and the Minister for Home Affairs told him that his greatest difficulty was in finding Irish speakers in these Irish-speaking districts of sufficient intelligence and education to carry out the functions of Peace Commissioners. I was rather surprised at the statement, and since that time I put myself in communication with certain sources of information. There is a Committee of the General Council of County Councils, which has been formed for the purpose of developing Irish culture and the preservation of the Irish language, and if the Minister applies to that Committee he will get very full particulars and very extensive lists of names of men in prominent public positions in these Irish-speaking districts who are fluent Irish speakers and who are sufficiently well educated to carry out the functions of a Peace Commissioner. I throw that out——
Comment on this
I do not think the Government amendment hurts you, Senator, because you do not want to have them appointed where it is impracticable to do so.
Comment on this
No; but I give one instance, the Dingle peninsula, where four or five Peace Commissioners have been appointed, and not one of them understands the Irish language—in an Irish-speaking district. I have had names given to me of thirty eligible citizens in that peninsula who are well qualified in every respect to take these positions. These other men are practically useless. Nobody understands them, and they cannot understand anybody. I think the sources of information tapped by the Minister for Home Affairs must be very meagre. In the amendment the Government have introduced these words in reference to appointment of Peace Commissioners, "where practicable." I have information that it is practicable in every instance to find men in these districts who are fluent Irish speakers, well educated, and willing to take these appointments. However, I am satisfied to accept the Government amendment.
Comment on this
I am afraid there is a danger of running considerable risks on this question. We would all like to see the Irish language revived, and the younger generation well grounded in it, but the action of my friend, Senator Kenny, reminds me of an incident that occurred some years ago. A certain gentleman came down from Dublin to Cork, appeared before the Corporation there, and enlarged on the desirability of the Irish language being universally adopted, suggesting that the minutes of the Corporation should be in Irish, and that Irish should be, as far as possible, broadcasted in the Corporation. A friend of mine who was a member of the Corporation, now gone, I trust, to a better world, asked him a question in Irish, and he could not understand it. The question was repeated, and then he had to admit, with considerable shamefacedness, that he did not know a word of Irish. He was thereupon told by my friend that he should go back to Dublin by the next train and not be wasting the time of the Cork Corporation, that they knew how to conduct their own business without being dictated to from Dublin. I think in this age of broadcasting, when the countries of the world are drawing closer and closer together, and communicating with each other so marvellously—a friend of mine was listening to "The Blue Bells of Scotland" being played in New York the other day—my friend, Senator Kenny, and others wish to have a narrow wall drawn round us, and to have the law interfered with by persons who, if they happen to know a little Irish, are to be appointed to Judgeships and other positions in preference to a prominence of knowledge of the law. I do not wish anyone to think that I am not as earnest and as keen on the younger generation being taught Irish as any member of the Seanad, but I think there is a danger of going too far on this question.
Comment on this
I want to see what we are discussing. Your amendment is withdrawn. Senator Kenny?