We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

COURTS OF JUSTICE BILL, 1923—REPORT.

Contributions 142–285 of 285. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Courts of Justice Bill 1923
Lapsed

No. 41 of 1923 ›

AN CATHAOIRLEACH

We are therefore discussing the Government amendment to Section 85. To add a new sub-section (2) as follows:—

"(2).—So far as may be practicable, having regard to all relevant circumstances, every person appointed to be a Peace Commissioner in a County which includes an area in which the Irish language is in general use shall have a knowledge of the Irish language adequate for the transaction of the business of his office in that language."

Comment on this

The amendment of the Government is, to my mind, the smallest concession that can possibly be made to the Irish language, Irish sentiment, and Irish thought. Senator Haughton made some very attractive remarks, and he told a pleasing story at the expense of the Irish language, but he has altogether overlooked the fact that, I am glad to say, the Government has not overlooked, that in a great many districts Irish is the only language really understood. Senator Haughton speaks from a knowledge of a particular part of the country. I have been in many parts of the country, and my Irish may be bad, and my English worse, but they understood my Irish and did not understand my English. For any Senator to suggest now that it is an injustice to allow Irish to be spoken is hardly a fair attitude to adopt. I think in a country like Ireland where, I might say, the position we have attained is largely due to the great interest which was taken in the Irish revival, such an expression from any member of the Seanad at this stage is very retrograde. I think, and I hope, that the attempt that is being made to revive the language will make each and every one of us feel more keenly the pride of race which we ought to have. Let us be Anglo-Saxons, Anglo-Irish, or whatever we wish to be, we can all have a pride in the past of Ireland and a pride in the ideals transmitted to us through the vehicle of Irish. That being so, anyone who suggests that Irish should not be fostered in these days of broadcasting ought not to get sympathy from anyone who desires to make Ireland what we all hope she will be eventually, a real Irish-Ireland, thinking through the culture inspired by Irish thought and the ideals transmitted to us, kindling in our veins a responsive chord struck through the ages, through the medium of the Irish tongue. All these things affect our national existence. I, for my part, thank the Government for having made the only concession possible to assist in the method of administration of justice at the moment. I think the Government will find in a short time from the interest taken in the language that it will be practicable and possible to secure in every Irish district every administrator of justice from the District Court to the Superior Court who will be able to expound the language for the benefit of the people.

Comment on this

As I supported the various motions by Senator Kenny before, I should say that I am very grateful to the Government for the generous concessions they have made in this matter. It is only what we have expected from men who themselves were nurtured in the language movement, to which fact I think it is not too much to say it is due that we are sitting here making our own laws to-day. I think they met us in every way possible, and I do not think any advantage will be taken of the words "where practicable." I think if, as has been suggested by Senator Kenny, men have been appointed who are not suitable, that is a matter if brought to the attention of the Minister for Home Affairs could be rectified.

Comment on this

Senator Haughton's speech reminds me of a good deal of the talk and statements made outside by people who profess a great Platonic affection for the Irish language, but at the same time hold that on no account is it to be used in the Courts or taught to anybody, and that if you give Irish its proper place then the person who does not know English is not to have any fair play in the law or anything else. That is the effect of what Senator Haughton stated. Senator Bennett pointed out, very correctly, that it is due practically to the efforts made by the Gaelic Leaguers for the past twenty years that we have gained all we have since then. That is due to the Irish language, and Senator Haughton would not be sitting in this room at present were it not for the movement on behalf of the language. There is no doubt whatever of it, but Senator Haughton perhaps is not as well acquainted with these matters as some of us. There are people who do not know the history of the past twenty years so well. Senator Haughton, I think, ought to be a little more careful before he attacks the national language of Ireland in the way he has done. People who have hitherto felt with him have adopted quite a different attitude. I congratulate the Government on making some effort, and I hope they will make stronger effort in bringing forward the Irish language.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

This is a Government amendment:

Section 85, page 19, line 3. To add at the end of sub-paragraph (d) the words "and providing for the remuneration of the medical officer and the examiner of lunatics under Section 14 of the Lunatic Asylums (Ireland) Act, 1875."

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

This amendment is for the purpose of enabling a Peace Commissioner who acts under Section 10 of the Act, 1867, mentioned in paragraph 3, to provide for the remuneration of the examining medical officer in the way which a Justice of the Peace formerly did by a certificate that he has examined.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Pardon me. Is this covered by the Governor-General's Message, and does this require a resolution, because I want to understand it, and I confess frankly I do not at present understand it?

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

It is not necessary for this reason, that the remuneration of the medical men under this provision is paid by the local authority, and not out of monies provided by Parliament.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

The object of the amendment is this. Under the existing law a Justice of the Peace could condemn on report of the Food Inspectors material that was displayed for sale for consumption as human food if it happened to be unsound, and order its destruction. This amendment enables a Peace Commissioner, on having similar certificates produced to him, to make an order condemning and ordering the destruction of unsound food. If it were to wait for the arrival of the District Justice it might have become more unsound.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

This is to guarantee that one of the Dublin Justices should be one of the Justices on the Rule-making Authority because it may be that very special rules in certain cases will be required. There are special Police Acts in Dublin and I thought it right when providing for the country solicitors to provide also for one of the Dublin Justice.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir J. KEANE Independent

I want to ask why under Section 87 the number of Justices on the Rule-making Authority is not stated. Apparently, as it reads now, the Committee could consist of only two Justices. I would also like to know, although I do not usually champion it, why a knowledge of the Irish language is not necessary in the case of the District Justices as it is in the case of a certain number of the Circuit Court Rule-making Authority. There seems to be a totally different procedure adopted in the case of the Rule-making Authority for the District Courts and there has been no explanation why a different procedure is required.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

As regards the language, the great majority of the District Justices have the language. The range of selection for the other Courts does not afford the same opportunity. It would be almost impossible to constitute a rule-making authority of District Justices without having men who know the language amongst them. A great number of them are fluent speakers of the language, and it is probable for that reason that it did not occur to anyone as necessary to stipulate it. As regards the number, a large number of District Justices are actually engaged at work, and the difficulty always will be that these Courts, being actually constituted, it will be a matter of trying to recall a certain number of the most efficient for this particular class of work and forming them into a Committee. We thought it better to leave the number at large.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Might you not then put in a minimum? If you inserted at line 30 the words "being not less than five," it would cover it.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

I am quite content.

Suggested amendment put and agreed to.

Original amendment put and agreed to.

Government amendment:—

Line 30. To delete the word "one" and to substitute the word "two" therefor and to delete the word "solicitor" and to substitute the word "solicitors" therefor.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

This amendment is intended to give representation to the provincial solicitors.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

That completes the provisions for giving effect to the undertaking that facilities would be given in all the Courts for entering-up summary judgments.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

Section 90. Immediately after the foregoing Section to insert a new Section (91) as follows:—

"91.—Nothing in this Act or in any rules to be made by virtue thereof shall affect the mode of giving evidence by the oral examination of witnesses in trial by jury, or the rules of evidence."

This is a Section which is practically taken from Section (66) of the present Judicature Act in Ireland. Its objects are, first, to ensure that evidence will be given vivâ voce in open court and be subject to cross-examination and, secondly, that the established laws of evidence shall not be altered by any Rules of Court. I think it is a necessary limitation of the power of a Rule-making authority that they should not have any power by rules made under the Bill to alter the established rules of evidence. It is a Section which was thought necessary when the Judicature Act was being framed, and I submit it is a Section which ought to be introduced into this Bill.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

I am rather afraid of this amendment. There was a reason, of course, in the Judicature Act why it was necessary, but in this Bill, as it stands, there is absolutely nothing that purports to touch the rules of evidence or the method of giving evidence. I am rather afraid that if a qualification of that kind is put in, it might suggest that other things are affected. The Bill does not purport to touch the Rules of Evidence and I do not see myself, if we were to change the laws as regards evidence, how we could do it otherwise than by a subsequent enactment.

Comment on this

If the Attorney-General assures me that no Rules of Court can alter the existing established rules of evidence, I will be perfectly willing to withdraw this.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

That is my view.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That would depend upon the ultimate decision as to whether the Rules of Court are to be made ultimately by Parliament or not.

Comment on this

I am assuming for the moment that the Rules of Court are to be made in accordance with the provisions already in the Bill, and not as I tried to amend them. If so, it would be quite impossible, I think, not to have a Section like this.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

I may say that I have never contemplated these rules as making alterations in substantive law. As a matter of fact, at an early stage when we were working out the scheme of this Bill, I foresaw that we would necessarily have to introduce some kind of consequential Bill dealing with a number of matters that would become evident, and that would involve alterations in the law. It has always been my view that at a later stage when we have worked out the draft rules, we will see a number of matters in which amendments of existing laws will be necessary. As an instance, we can take the Petty Sessions Act procedure. I feel sure that we will require a kind of Omnibus Bill dealing with a variety of repeals and amendments of Sections which at the moment it would be impossible completely to visualise, but which will become apparent when the Rule-making Committees get to work. We do contemplate one alteration as regards evidence, by a Bill which shall be submitted to the Oireachtas, enabling accused persons to give evidence in criminal cases.

Comment on this

I am not entirely satisfied with what the learned Attorney-General has said. I am greatly afraid that they might, by rules of court made under this Bill, provide that the mode of giving evidence in cases tried with witnesses before a jury might be altered. I think that is a very serious thing. It was thought absolutely necessary in the Judicature Act to put in these limitations as to what could possibly be done by Rules of Court. I ask the Attorney-General to consider seriously whether he ought not to have some provision of this kind limiting the power of the rule-making authority in these two matters.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Do you not think it would be very desirable that this amendment should stand over until we see what becomes of your other amendment? If that was carried what you are proposing now would be quite wrong. You are proposing that the rules of court shall be given effect to by Parliament. If they are given effect to by Parliament they are law. Therefore, I think you had better let this amendment stand over.

Comment on this

I agree.

Consideration of amendment postponed.

SECTION 91.

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 91, line 2. To insert after the words "the High Court or" the words "(save as hereinafter provided)."

lines 3-5. To delete all the words in brackets.

line 8. To delete the words "the High Court or"

The object of the amendment is to retain in the High Court the right to a jury in all cases. As the Section stands it deprives a body of the right to a jury in the High Court as well as in the Circuit Court, in actions for liquidating sums or for the enforcement of damages for breach of contract. I submit that this is too great an invasion on the old-established practice of having a question of fact tried by a jury. It is right, I think, in a Circuit Court where the amounts sued for will be comparatively small, and where the juries are not likely to be quite as satisfactory as they are in Dublin. I, therefore, think that the Section should be altered so as to preserve in the High Court the right to a jury in all cases. I quite agree that in the Circuit Court the Section should stand as it is.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

I anticipate that Senator O'Farrell will say that what is sauce for the Circuit Court goose should be sauce for the High Court gander. In this Section we have dealt only with matters of contract. We have made it necessary to apply to the court for a jury, and I really cannot see in principle why there should be a distinction between the Circuit Court and the High Court. Moreover, I am having appeals from all directions to enable some kind of commercial court to be set up in Dublin, and in my judgment this really is the first step towards that end. I submit that the Section should be allowed to stand.

Comment on this

If you want to go to the Commercial Court naturally you would not want a jury.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

There is no Commercial Court established by this.

Comment on this

Not yet. That is a matter for Rules. In England, where they have this very useful Commercial Court, it was established, not by Act of Parliament but by one of the Rules. It merely means that a certain court will be listed for certain kind of cases which will be tried by a jury and by short cuts in the way of pleadings. If you want to go to that kind of Court you do not want to have a jury.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Why do they deprive the parties of that right in that case in England?

Comment on this

They did not deprive them of their right, but both sides decided to go to that Court and waive their right to have a jury.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

Under this, application might be made to the Court by either party, and the Judge might say that it was not a case for a jury and that it was largely a matter for commercial consideration, and he might send it to a commercial court.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

And he might of his motion dispense with the jury.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

Yes, if he really thinks that the matter in dispute is not one of fact but one of the consideration of documents.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think, Senator Brown, you might safely accept this. Your interests are guarded.

Comment on this

Very well.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

What about the amendment in line 10, to insert the words "in any action for the recovery of land."

Comment on this

I do not think that that is necessary. I think that was intended to exclude in the Circuit Court, where you might not have a very good jury.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

I am content to have the same rules apply to both contract and the other.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think it is a good amendment, and should be accepted.

Amendment—"In line 10, after the word ‘contract,' to insert the words ‘or in an action for the recovery of land'"—put, and agreed to.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The next amendment is to Clause 92, which stands in the name of Senator Brown.

Comment on this

I do not move that.

Comment on this

My next amendment is No. 61, which reads as follows:—In Section 93, line 30 to 31: To delete the words "or the Circuit Court." Line 32: To delete the words "or the Circuit Court." Line 34: To delete all after the words "new trial" to the end of the Section and to substitute therefor the words "or to set aside the verdict, findings and judgment, and to enter the proper judgment upon such grounds as were heretofore recognised as proper grounds for similar applications in the High Court of Justice in Ireland." I have seen an alternative amendment by the Government. It is not on the Order Paper.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You have the advantage over me.

Comment on this

I think the Attorney-General will explain. I think it provides for the matter better than my amendment.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

It has only been drafted a short while ago. When I studied Senator Brown's amendment I ventured upon an alternative proposal "to add at the end of Section 93, after the full stop, the following ‘In any appeal to which this Section applies, the Appellate Tribunal may, in lieu of an Order for a new trial, set aside the verdict, findings and judgment appealed against and enter such judgment as the Appellate Tribunal considers proper."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Would that saisfy the point raised in Senator Sir John Keane's next amendment?

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

Senator Brown is going to argue that.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Are you satisfied with this new amendment, Senator Brown?

Comment on this

I want to be certain that it applies to a case like this. Under Section 93 as it stands, the application by way of appeal from a Circuit Court, where the case was tried by a judge and jury, is for a new trial, and the only order they could make would be either to refuse the appeal or direct a new trial. The amendment of Senator Sir John Keane provides that instead of doing that they might, on the evidence before them, enter a verdict.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

This amendment expressly does that.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

It was intended to cover Senator Sir John Keane's amendment as well.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

May I suggest a slight change. I think that the repetition of the words "Appellate Tribunal" is a little tautological. I suggest that you use the word "Court."

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

Very well.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The next is a Government amendment to Clause 94.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

The amendment is: Immediately after Section 94 to insert a new Section, as follows:—"Report of stenographer to be certified." 94.—"Whenever under this Act an appeal is required to be grounded or heard on the report of an official stenographer, such report shall not be accepted by the Appellate Tribunal unless it is certified by the Judge of the Court of first instance." I think it would be right that the notes of the stenographer should be vouched by the signature of the Judge in order that there may be no question of their identity. I desire to alter the amendment now on the Order Paper by making it end after the words "in Court of first instance."

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

Does the Judge certify that the notes are accurate? Without qualification this might mean anything?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think it is intended to certify that it is the work of a stenographer—that these are the notes.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

Should not the wording be qualified?

Comment on this

Why should you not use the words "true and accurate report?"

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think there is great danger in that. First of all it would impose upon the judge the necessity of reading from start to finish these notes. Supposing an appeal is taken from the Judge's own judgment, human nature being what it is, there is always a temptation to read the evidence in a particular way. It is irresistible. You would really be making the Judge the arbiter of what is said and not the stenographer. I think what you really require is to certify that these are the notes taken by the stenographer in a particular case.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

Yes, certified as such.

Comment on this

I thought that the Judge's certificate meant that they were a true description of what took place.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That would be so if you put in the last two lines, That transfers to the Judge who has not taken the notes the responsibility of supplying a correct copy although he has not taken the notes. Furthermore these notes will be used for the purpose of endeavouring to upset his judgment. It would be putting the judge in a false position if he were compelled to certify in the way you suggest. What is wanted is some guarantee that the stenographer's notes were those taken by the stenographer in that particular case.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

Is he going to certify the actual shorthand record or the transcript? The transcript would be satisfactory. What we want to ensure is that the actual notes taken in shorthand, are the notes taken in the Court.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Then you would require every judge to be an expert shorthand writer.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

No, what I want is simply to certify the document. What happens to those documents? Are they impounded after the trial and kept free from access? What is to prevent some other document being substituted in an important action?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

In England —I am only speaking from the experience of having watched the operations —there are responsible officials attached to the Court and when they make their transcript they lodge it and keep the original notes.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I take it that this matter is to be provided for in the Rules. It shows how important those Rules are and how dangerous it is to allow any laxity.

Comment on this

I thought that the object of this amendment was to be quite certain that a transcript was a transcript?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

How can a judge do that?

Comment on this

If you put in a proviso that it is true in substance and in fact.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Then the responsibility for the notes is shifted to the judge?

Comment on this

I thought that was the object of the Attorney-General. I think we can trust to the judge rather more than to the stenographer.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

That is hard on Civil Servants.

Comment on this

There seems to be some difficulty in understanding what this Section is going to carry out. The word "certify" is hard to explain.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think that the matter requires careful consideration and revision, and that it should stand over. As the amendment was originally framed it threw the responsibility for the correctness of the notes on to the judge who did not take them.

Comment on this

As originally framed it was all right. The difficulty was caused by striking out the last two lines.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

There can be no objection to having the shorthand notes passed on to the Appeal Court as part of the documents of appeal. I will amend that wording so as to have the original notes and transcripts certified as such.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

How can a judge certify a transcript to be a transcript of the notes if he does not understand shorthand?

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

He certifies it to be a report.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That does not carry us much further.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

It might.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You will want to think it over.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

Very well.

Amendment deferred for further consideration.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The next is a Government amendment to Clause 96:—

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

This Section was referred to by you, Sir, yesterday, as perhaps going a little further than was contemplated. I have reconsidered the Section, and have had it re-drafted. I propose to move it in the following form:—

Section 96.—To delete the Section and insert in lieu thereof the following Section:—

Age of retirement for existing judges appointed under this Act.— 96. Where any person who is at the passing of this Act a judge of the Supreme Court of Judicature in Ireland, a Recorder, County Court Judge, Divisional Justice of the Police District of Dublin Metropolis, or District Justice, is appointed to be a judge or justice under this Act, the age of retirement prescribed by this Act may in his case be extended by the Executive Council, after consultation with the Chief Justice and the Attorney-General, to any age not exceeding the lesser of the two following ages, that is to say, the age of 75 years, or the age of five years beyond the said prescribed age of retirement.

A person who has been a judge of the Supreme Court of Judicature in Ireland, a Recorder or County Court Judge in Ireland shall not be disqualified from being appointed a judge of the Supreme Court, the High Court or the Circuit Court by reason of his having at the date of such appointment already attained the age prescribed by this Act as the age of retirement of the judges of such Court, and where such person as aforesaid is appointed to be a judge of any of the Courts aforesaid after he has attained the age of retirement aforesaid, the age of retirement shall in his case be deemed to be extended to the maximum age to which it could be extended by the Executive Council under this Section.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Might I make this suggestion in all seriousness? Would it not be far better to say that where any person is appointed to be a judge or a justice that the age of retirement prescribed by this Bill shall be extended for three years? The way that will work out is this. In the case of a judge newly appointed he would retire at 72. In the case of an existing judge kept on he would retire at 75. That is the case of the High Court. In the case of a Circuit Court any newly-appointed judge would retire at 70. Any existing judge re-appointed would retire at 73. In the case of a District Court any new appointment would retire at 65, but any re-appointment would have until 68. In other words, make an automatic addition of three years to the period prescribed in the Bill in the case of men re-appointed.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

There are two cases to be considered. There is the case of a man who has not attained the full age limit, where the Government might be willing to recommend his appointment for the balance of that period. Then there is the case of a man where they would like to extend that particular case or the case of a man who has attained the age of 72. It is proposed in that case to give automatic extension.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You do not want to extend it in any case beyond 75?

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

No.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Would it not be met by what I suggest, that for the newly-appointed judge he should automatically retire at 72, but in the case of re-appointment he should have three years automatically added, whether he be a Circuit, District, or High Court Judge, that the particular period mentioned in the Bill should be automatically increased by three years in the case of every re-appointment? That would leave the maximum in the High Court at 75, Circuit Court at 73, and a District Court at 68, except in the case of the Dublin Justices, in whose case it would run to 73.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

The difficulty is in looking at people just on the border line of the age limit. A person might be appointed under 50 whom it might not be desirable to continue until 75.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Under the Constitution you still have control over them, and can remove them if they are inefficient.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

That is an unpleasant expedient.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The last amendment you read out strikes me as being very complicated.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

The position the Government take is this, that a man whose age would be the retiring age, they would wish to treat him as automatically having an extension. But if you take a man under the retiring age, either they will give him a fixed limit in the Bill or, if the House assents, they will take power to extend his period, but they are not prepared to give an automatic extension in that case.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

No, but why should they, if they take a man who is below the age and give him an automatic extension? But if at the time of re-appointing he has reached 72 years of age, then I would give it to him.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

If he has actually reached the age of retirement he gets an automatic three years to 75 years, and that would apply to all courts. But if he has not reached that age, they reserve that right.

Comment on this

There is no differentiation between the age of the Dublin Justices and the Recorder of Cork.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The Dublin Justices have nothing to do with the Recorder of Cork, but the extension that is given to the Dublin Justices is also extended to the Recorder of Cork.

Comment on this

Might I call the attention of the Attorney-General to an objection to the second part of his proposal, that is, in the case of an existing Judge who has not yet reached the retiring age and is re-appointed. In the amendment, as it stands, the extension of the age of retirement in a case of that kind is on the recommendation of—I forget if it is the Minister for Home Affairs—and the Attorney-General.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

The Chief Justice.

Comment on this

The Chief Justice and the Attorney-General. As was pointed out when the Bill was in Committee, that puts a Judge in a rather unpleasant position, just as he is reaching the age of retirement.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Does it not put the Attorney-General in a worse position, because he might be expecting succession?

Comment on this

What I was going to suggest to the Attorney-General is this: in the case of a Judge who is an existing Judge, and has not yet reached that critical age, that in his case an extension should be made on his appointment, so that he will know how far the age of retirement is to be extended. It would take away that invidious position in which you put him, that his case is to be considered when he reaches the age of retirement. You have done it in all the other cases.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

Of course, the option of extension has been given up. It was originally a concession. In all the cases of the ordinary appointments this power of extension was suggested as a thing that it might be desirable to have with reference to some of the re-appointments. If it is thought well of, then the age limit could remain.

Comment on this

I doubt very much if you could persuade any existing judge who has not reached the age to take advantage of that. I think he would rather go out at 72.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Would it not be far simpler and better in the case of any judge, whether re-appointed or not, who was below the prescribed limit, that he should go at the prescribed limit, but that in the case of all judges of any court who are re-appointed, when they reach the prescribed limit, they should have the automatic extension of three years?

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

I accept that.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I am glad the Government make that concession. I really think it simplifies it. The Seanad understands what is proposed. In the case of all existing judges, including in these words District Justices, Circuit Judges and Judges of the High Court, if in the case of any of these Courts an existing Judge is re-appointed who has reached the age prescribed in the Bill for retirement, he gets an automatic and further term of three years added to his term. If, however, at the date of his re-appointment he has not reached the prescribed period, he has to go at the prescribed period and he gets another three years automatically added. That is the proposal, that a new section to this effect be inserted in lieu of the existing section.

Amendment postponed.

Comment on this

There is an amendment on the Order Paper which I now withdraw, because it is merely to delete Section 97, and would have been necessary if I carried my amendment yesterday.

Comment on this

The amendment which I now propose is as follows: To delete Section 97 and to substitute therefor the following new Section: "All Rules of Court made under this Act shall be laid on the Tables of both Houses of the Oireachtas but shall have no force or effect unless within six months from the date of their being so laid they shall have been passed into law by the Oireachtas." I think I may say that this is my last effort to keep the Rule-making provisions of the Bill within the Constitution, and the amendment is one which I hope will meet the views of some Senators who voted against my amendment yesterday and may even capture the support of the Government. The effect of the amendment is this, that it leaves the Rule-making Authority untouched; that is, the Rule-making Authority as provided originally in the Bill.

Rules are to be made by the Minister for Home Affairs in the manner provided by the Bill, but instead of laying on the Tables of the two Houses and coming into force automatically if not objected to, as they would under Section 97 as it stands, I propose that the Rules of Court shall be enacted as laws by the Oireachtas. Under that amendment the Government will have obtained all the objects which they desire, and which they told us they desired yesterday. The Rules of Court will be prepared in the way they are proposed in the Bill. They will be able to provide by these Rules for the cheap litigation, for arrangements for vacations, and all other matters they have at heart and the only disadvantage to them will be that they will have to put a Bill, scheduling these Rules through the two Houses, and in a matter of such importance as this, I suggest that that is a small thing. It certainly is a small price to pay for the certainty that these Rules will be within the Constitution and that they will be understood by the Houses, and that the Houses will have an opportunity of understanding them. We all know what papers laid on the Table of the House means. Personally, I never physically saw the papers on the Table of the House until yesterday, and I very much doubt whether any member has ever read any of the papers.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I had them put there for the occasion.

Comment on this

I am very much obliged to you. Therefore, if these Rules are to be approved of by the House— and that is what Section 97 means— and if this laying of them on the Table is to have any real effect the only way that can be carried out is to have them passed as Acts through both Houses.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I should like to second the amendment, and in doing so I desire to call the attention of the House to the fact that fresh evidence in this matter has been revealed to-day in certain statements of the Attorney-General which must convince us that this Rule-making power is very closely allied to legislation. He has told us that when they come to consider these Rules there will then arise a necessity for further legislation. If they are so intimately bound up as that, I do think that it is very important to this House to have a close and positive scrutiny of the rules. Further, I think he gave us to understand that some question of the rules of evidence was to be considered under the new Rules. I am sure the House will realise how important the procedure of evidence is, and how very necessary it is that any change of that kind should be fully reviewed by the sovereign power which is the Houses of the Oireachtas. Then, there is a small but important matter that came up to-day, as to the method in which these shorthand notes are to be taken, and what happens to these notes after they are made, what happens to the transcript, and so on. These are only a few of many other matters which will concern the Rule-making Authority, and I make the point that it is not sufficient that the House should be satisfied by tabling papers. They should take definite cognisance of these rules whether in the form of an actual Bill or by Resolution, or by some method to ensure that they receive full and careful scrutiny.

Comment on this

I have tried, to the best of my ability, to understand the position in regard to the discussion on the Rule-making Authority, and I should be prepared to support some definite sanction by the Houses of the Oireachtas, and if Senator Brown had brought that in in a form which seemed to me both constitutional and workable, I, for one, would be prepared to support it. As brought in, in this amendment, I doubt if it is strictly constitutional, and I doubt if it is workable. In the first place, I do not think that one Act can say that another Act must be passed within six months, because it seems to me that once these Rules are brought in as an Act they would then stand as an Act by themselves, and will have to pass under the Constitution subject to such delays and amendments as would take place. From that point of view I doubt the workability of the statement that they shall have no force or effect unless within six months of being so laid they shall be passed into law. Passed into law presumably means the introduction of the Rules by someone in the form of an Act and that might mean a delay of nine months. I doubt, as I have said, six months is possible, or that it would be correct under the Constitution. Sir John Keane suggested that a simple Resolution might meet the case. I rather question the statement of Senator Brown, with great respect, that we all know what papers laid on the Table means. I should like to point out to members of the Seanad that the papers laid on the Table differ according to the Regulations and Acts under which they are laid. Certain papers are laid for the information of the Seanad, and other papers the Seanad have power to prevent coming into force by Resolution, but all these papers are not only to be laid on the Table, but they are actually quoted in the Orders of the Day which every member receives. Apart from that question, I have not much sympathy with members of the Seanad who feel because they do not read these Papers, and are not interested in them, that therefore they have no powers. At the same time, I would rather hope, as this matter has been debated so far, and as Senator Brown has said that the main thing he wants is effective control by the Oireachtas, it might be possible to alter the form and substitute a simple Resolution approving without amendment by both Houses. I have no idea of the view the Government will take in that matter, but if that were done it would be more acceptable than the form proposed by Senator Brown.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

With regard to what Senator Sir John Keane has said, what I said earlier in the day was that we contemplated a change in the law of evidence by a Bill for that purpose, enabling prisoners to give evidence on their own behalf, and I never suggested that we contemplated a change in the rules of evidence.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I am sorry I misunderstood the Attorney-General.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

Further, I said at an earlier stage, if in course of preparation of these rules we find, as I believe we will, that there will be substantive laws here and there that require amendment, adaptation or alteration, we will bring in a sort of omnibus Bill, to cover these points. It appears both Senator Brown and myself have spent some of our midnight oil on this, and I only wish it was the same oil we had spent, because I have here a proposal alternative to Section 97, which is exactly on the lines of Senator Douglas's suggestion, and which, I submit, meets the situation. The desire that was evinced here yesterday was that a responsible Minister should come in and definitely propound the body of rules, and that there should be an opportunity of discussing the body of rules, having them first laid before the House by him, and expounded by him. In order to give effect to that I propose this alternative to Section 97—"No Rules of Court made under this Act shall come into operation unless and until they have been laid before each House of the Oireachtas and have been approved by a Resolution of each House." I do not know if Senator Brown will say that that is a workable alternative to his, which I agree with Senator Douglas in thinking is neither constitutional nor workable, and with the leave of the House, and your permission, Sir, I would offer that as a Government amendment.

Comment on this

May I say this, that the alternative which he now proposes is in exact form the amendment I proposed in Committee. It was then ruled out as practically unconstitutional by my friend, the President, who said that this was not legislation, and I am afraid, that if I accept this I would be giving up the constitutional point which I have insisted upon ever since.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think I would take it.

Comment on this

As it is more or less a triumph to accomplish, I will take it.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

This will always be known as Brown's clause. I think you may be proud of yourself. This will be always known as Senator Brown's Section.

Comment on this

When the Resolution suggested by the Attorney-General comes before the Seanad, will the Seanad be offered an opportunity for discussing it?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Seeing that they will have to approve of it, they will certainly have the power of discussing it. This means, of course, that they can disapprove of any one of them.

Comment on this

That is what I wanted to get at.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think, Senator Brown, you had better look in to the wording of this. You and the Attorney-General are on the same lines, I think, but it should be made plain that the resolution should be capable of approving of some and disapproving of others. This says "No Rules of Court made under this Act shall come into operation unless and until they have been laid before each House of the Oireachtas and have been approved by a resolution of each House."

Comment on this

If the word "rule" was used instead of "rules"? That was my original amendment.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

Unfortunately you might have a separate resolution for each rule.

Comment on this

No, I provided for that.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Could you not add this "any such resolution or resolutions may approve or disapprove of the said rules in whole or in part"?

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

It will be observed that that was the object of the original Section 97 because that provided that the same or any of them might be annulled.

Comment on this

As there are some other matters left over we might be allowed to have a little further time to consider this. I will confer with the Attorney-General.

Consideration of amendment postponed.

SECTION 98.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

"Section 98, line 32. After the word "tenure" to insert the words "and upon the same terms and conditions, and receive the same salaries; and if entitled to pensions, be entitled to the same pensions."

This is a small matter which I raised in Committee and the Government said they would look into it. It deals with certain officials connected with the various Courts who are to carry on their work under the new regime. The idea is that they should be confirmed in their pensions and emoluments as they would have been if this Bill had not been passed. The Government agreed to the question of principle some time ago. When the Bill was first introduced it had a Section which was drawn up to the satisfaction of the persons concerned. In Committee in the Dáil that Section was amended and certain words were taken out. The taking out of these words these persons think means their case is not as water-tight as it was before. I propose therefore to insert the words that were in the Bill when originally introduced, unless the Attorney-General can assure me that the word "tenure" means that they will get the same treatment and receive the same pensions, etc., as they would if the Bill had not been passed.

Comment on this

I beg to second. Those who have remained faithful to the State under its new aspect certainly deserve much consideration because it was open to them to adopt a different mode of action. They have shown their faith in the Free State, and the Free State should consider their case.

Comment on this
Hugh Kennedy ATTORNEY-GENERAL Independent

When the words were taken out there was added at the end, nothing in the Section shall prejudice their rights under the Treaty. Of course the position of any civil servant who had his salary reduced or his position in any way affected is that he can retire with 17 added years, and so on, under the Treaty. I am advised by the people concerned in the establishments that the Section, as it stands, preserves the position of these persons, which is the intention.

Comment on this

If the Attorney-General can assure me that their position is secure I will not press this. I take it that it is perfectly safe?

Comment on this

I am informed by the Ministry of Finance that their positions are safeguarded by Article 10 of the Treaty and by Article 77, I think it is, of the Constitution. I do not know that there are any cases which have a right to be considered which are not covered by these two Articles. There was, however, one particular instance, which I think I mentioned here before, that there were certain people employed in the Courts, for a very considerable sum of money, at work which could easily be done for something like half the sum. In that case there was no position analogous to that of the civil servant. If there be such a case I would undertake to look into it. To accept the amendment in this form might prejudice the Chief Justice when he would have to decide whether the terms were analogous to those they had already. Let us take the instance of the Courts opening at 11 o'clock. Should it be decided that they should open at 10.30 some person employed there might say that it was unreasonable to expect him to attend at 10.30. Only in such a case as that would there be a likelihood, so far as I can learn, of anything in the nature of a dispute. I am informed that the Section, as it stands, safeguards the rights and privileges and pensions, so far as they are consistent with Article 10 of the Treaty and Article 77 of the Constitution. I am advised that it would be scarcely within our power to go outside of those Articles, as they are above the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

If the President and the Attorney-General assure me that every reasonable and proper case will be properly attended to I will not press the amendment.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That disposes of the amendments, subject to the three matters which stand over for further consideration.

Comment on this