We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

[SEANAD IN COMMITTEE.] - RAILWAYS BILL, 1924.—THIRD STAGE.

Contributions 1–142 of 294. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Railways Bill, 1924
Enacted

No. 12 of 1924 ›

AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I might mention that amendments are still coming in for the Committee Stage of the Railways Bill, and it has not been possible to have them printed. Accordingly, I shall read out each section of the Bill, and any Senator who has given notice of an amendment, or who wishes to move an amendment, will then have an opportunity of doing so. I hope Senators will be alive to that fact, and that if they wish to move amendments they will take the advantage of doing so when the section is called in its order.

Sections 1, 2 and 3 ordered to stand part of the Bill.

SECTION 4.

An amalgamation scheme under this Act—

(a) shall provide for the incorporation of the amalgamated company under an appropriate name with power to hold land for the purposes of the company, and make such provisions as appear necessary or expedient with regard to the share and loan capital of the amalgamated company and the vesting of the property, rights, powers, duties and liabilities, whether statutory or otherwise, of the amalgamating companies; and

(b) shall provide generally as to the terms and conditions of amalgamation and for the winding-up of the amalgamating companies, including the allocation to holders of securities of the amalgamating companies, in substitution therefor and in satisfaction of all claims arising thereunder, of such securities of the amalgamated company, and of such amounts, as may be specified in the scheme; and

(c) shall incorporate Part V. of the Railways Clauses Act, 1863, subject to the provisions of this Act; and may incorporate any of the provisions of the Companies Clauses Consolidation Act 1845, and the Acts amending that Act, subject to the modification that any committees appointed under Section 95 of the Companies Clauses Consolidation Act 1845, may comprise persons who, though not directors of the company, are proprietors and possess such other qualifications (if any) as may be provided by the scheme; and

(d) shall give effect to the provisions contained in the Second Schedule to this Act with respect to the direction of the amalgamated company, and may, with the consent of the proprietors, provide for the payment of compensation out of the assets of an amalgamating company to any director of such company who suffers loss by abolition of office; and

(e) shall contain such provisions with respect to the management of any superannuation, pension, provident, widows' and orphans' and other benefit fund or funds established by any amalgamating company as may be necessary in consequence of amalgamation, so, however, as to preserve in all other respects the management of such funds unaltered until other provision is made by the Oireachtas; and

(f) shall incorporate the provisions contained in the Third Schedule to this Act with respect to existing officers and servants; and

(g) may make such incidental and supplemental provisions as appear necessary or expedient in order to give full effect to the provisions of the scheme and the purposes of this Act.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

Section 4, immediately after the word "office" in line 46, to insert the words:

"Provided that any director of an amalgamating company who may be appointed to be a standing member of the railway tribunal or who shall resign office in consequence of being appointed a standing member of the railway tribunal shall upon such appointment be deemed to have suffered a loss as if his office as such director had been abolished and shall be entitled to be paid compensation out of the assets of the amalgamating company in respect of such loss of office."

The reason for this amendment is that I feel a person who may be in the employment of the railway companies at the present time, either as director or as an official, may suffer a loss in the event of being appointed a member of the railway tribunal. One member of the railway tribunal shall be a person of experience in railway business, and if a director or official were appointed his right under Section 4 would be lost, as the railway tribunal must be established before amalgamation. If an offer of an appointment on the railway tribunal is made the person might be tempted to refuse it because he would run the risk of losing his right. I am quite sure the Minister will see his way to accept the amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan MINISTER for INDUSTRY and COMMERCE (Mr. McGilligan)

The principle at the back of this amendment was very favourably considered, but in some way an amendment dealing with it, unknown to me, disappeared. It did not exactly run on these lines. I would point out to the Senator that if the amendment, in its present form, is accepted, it would mean that a director of an amalgamating company, who might be appointed a standing member of the railway tribunal, would come in for compensation, and also receive a salary or payment as a standing member of the tribunal. I am not clear that the Senator would think that desirable. I could accept the amendment if a proviso was inserted stating that on appointment a director of an amalgamating company would be entitled to compensation, but, that, in fixing the amount of compensation, the scheme would take into consideration the remuneration received by him as a standing member of the tribunal. Some proviso of that sort would be necessary in order to do away with the possibility, and the probability, under this amendment of a standing member of the tribunal receiving compensation and also a salary.

Comment on this

It will be observed that the compensation which is claimed by directors comes out of the assets of the company and not out of the pocket of the State. The last few lines of the amendment show that compensation is to be paid out of the assets of the amalgamated companies in respect of the loss of office, so that there is no charge on the State in regard to the payment of compensation.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I understand that the Minister points out, unless this is safeguarded by the proviso, it opens the possibility of there being double compensation. The Minister, I understand, is rather favourable to the principle of the amendment, but would like to have time to consider whether he should not be protected by some such proviso as he mentioned. Possibly the amendment could stand over.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied. I should not wish, by any means, that double compensation be paid.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Perhaps I might suggest a definite amendment which would be absolutely acceptable. If, for instance, we took the first four lines of the Senator's amendment down to "member of the railway tribunal shall"... "shall be entitled to compensation as if his office as such director had been abolished, but in fixing the amount of such compensation the scheme shall take into account the remuneration he is receiving as a standing member of the Railway Tribunal." If I got an intimation that the Senator would be favourably disposed towards that I would have it brought up at a later stage.

Comment on this

I will accept that amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The same would apply to the next amendment.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The two amendments can stand over for the Report Stage for the purpose of being amended in the sense indicated by the Minister.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

Section 8, immediately after the word "tribunal" in line 17 to insert the words "before approving or settling any amalgamation, absorption or preliminary scheme."

As it stands the Bill provides that preliminary amalgamation and absorption schemes may be submitted for approval to the Minister, prior to the 31st July, 1924, and at any subsequent period the tribunal must approve, not may approve, of the schemes, if the procedure preliminary to their submission has been complied with. Section 8 sets out the terms of amalgamation and absorption, but this only applies to schemes which may be settled by the tribunal in default of agreement. In my opinion it should also apply to preliminary schemes agreed to between the companies themselves. Otherwise the method of capitalisation agreed upon in any of these agreed schemes will be solely the work of the company and the tribunal will have no voice whatever, except in the procedure to be adopted. It will be seen, according to Section 10, that these preliminary schemes have merely to observe the procedure and that otherwise the provisions outlined for schemes enforced by the tribunal under Section 8 shall not apply to them at all. The effect of the amendment would be that, even in agreed preliminary schemes submitted by the railway company, the tribunal shall before approving or settling, examine, and shall have some voice in the determination as to capitalisation and so forth. The reply to a similar amendment in the Dáil was that it was no matter of concern of the public what terms of capitalisation, interest and so forth were agreed to between the various companies, as they agreed upon them themselves.

If the success of the amalgamated company could be assured—and I think its success ought to be desired by the companies, by the employees, and by the public generally—if the principle is right and if the working of the Bill is to be given a fair chance, the capitalisation should be decided on right lines. If the companies can present preliminary schemes, and if they are to be dealt with as set out in section 10, without any control at all by the tribunal, the result may be, that devices may be resorted to, to enable the present railway stock and shareholders to dispose of their holdings on favourable terms, and get out of the railway business, irrespective of results to unsuspecting purchasers of the stock. It is obvious that this scheme may, either by undue inflation of the capital of the amalgamated company, or otherwise, seriously prejudice the industrial and agricultural communities as well as railway passengers. If, for instance, the capitalisation is fixed too high it may lead to pressure by railway shareholders in the future for an increase in the net revenue. It will be impossible for shareholders buying railway stock in the next few years to appreciate fully the method of capitalisation agreed upon, or its influences and implications. The financial experts in the Seanad will, I am sure, be able to explain much better than I could, how future purchasers of stock might be, more or less, misled as to the value of railway shares. When they find out their mistake they will almost inevitably come forward and demand a higher net revenue than that allowed under the terms of the Bill.

I know that Sections 53 and 54 lay down the total amount that may be allowed in net revenue, but future developments may make a very good case for stock-holders to ask for an increase in that, because of the fact that the preliminary schemes which were submitted, and which will eventually become the approved schemes, have not treated them fairly and disclosed the full implications of the method of capitalisation. The desire of the Bill is to set the railway industry on its feet and to make it efficient. This can only be done if the capitalisation is carried out on sound financial lines. I do not know why there should be any particular objection to that, as all schemes which the tribunal itself shall enforce are subject to the provisions of Section 8. As the preliminary schemes have to be submitted by the 31st July, it is obvious that it is anticipated, and, indeed, well known, that these schemes are already prepared, ready for submission to the tribunal. The State is taking a big responsibility in respect of this Bill. It is guaranteeing a net revenue of the average of the three pre-war years, and it is pledging itself to support the companies against the travelling and trading community in order to ensure that this net revenue shall be secured

Because of these big responsibilities which the Oireachtas is putting on the State, I think it is eminently desirable that the railways should be placed on a sound financial basis. We have no guarantee that this is going to be the case, unless the tribunal examines on the merits these preliminary schemes. As I stated at the beginning, the only duty of the tribunal is to see that the procedure is complied with, that the schemes shall contain certain provisions, but the nature of these provisions is not a matter for them to examine or to alter in any way. That is a weakness in the Bill. As the State is accepting the responsibilities I have mentioned under Sections 53 and 54, it is, I think, the duty of the tribunal, which will be the protector of the interests of the trading and commercial community and of the community as a whole, if they are to satisfy public requirements, to examine these preliminary schemes and to see that they are placed on a fair, equitable and sound financial basis.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I do not think it is the business of the railway tribunal to inquire into the conditions of capitalisation or to protect innocent purchasers of railway stock against the alleged and most unlikely manipulations of railway financiers. I think the Stock Exchange and their advisers are well able to look after them. If the State once begins getting a tribunal to protect all investors it would open up an endless vista of complications and impossibilities. I do not think that the Senator who moved the amendment fully appreciates the distinction between revenue and capital. I do not see how in this relation they can have any bearing upon one another. The standard revenue is the net amount which arises after the payment of expenses and has nothing to do with the capital except in so far as it pays certain interest thereon. I do not see how any manipulation of capital is going to affect the amount of the standard revenue, which is a separate matter. One other point I should definitely like to challenge. The Senator said that the State is guaranteeing the pre-war revenue. I do not think that is a fair description. The State is practically taking over, through the tribunal, the fixing of rates and, to a great extent, limiting the revenue to that of these pre-war years. I do not think the term "guarantee" is correctly used in this connection.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

There is one preliminary minor objection to this amendment. It is an amendment to Section 8, but it proposes to deal with agreed schemes. Agreed and preliminary schemes are dealt with under other sections. The amendment to Section 8, which deals with the determination by the railway tribunal in case there is not agreement, would land the tribunal in a very awkward position, because they would find themselves faced with contradictory provisions. They would find themselves with a very clear indication of what had to be done in the case of preliminary and agreed schemes, and when they came to a later section, dealing not with preliminary or agreed schemes, but with a situation where there was no agreement, then they would find a section which appeared to have a repercussion on an agreed or preliminary scheme. So that the amendment, to my mind, is not moved to the proper section. To take it on its merits, apart from where it might come in, the answer is as stated by Senator Sir John Keane, that the basis of the Bill is that railway proprietors are to be secured a standard revenue, and whatever manipulations there may be between stockholders is no concern of ours. This Bill is, to a certain extent, interfering with private property rights, and that interference must be cut down to the absolute minimum. We are guaranteeing a standard revenue, and the method by which that is to be brought about is laid down very specifically. Persons interested and desirous of being heard may appear at any stage of the proceedings. The public interests are very well safeguarded, and the standard revenue, on which the standard rates will afterwards be built up, is the main thing. It is really no concern of the railway tribunal or the Government what manipulation there may be between stockholders.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

Section 8. To delete the word "amalgamated" in line 21 and immediately after the word "company" in the same line to insert the words "in which it is amalgamated or absorbed."

This is a more or less drafting amendment, and is necessary because the company formed by a preliminary scheme, or in which a company is absorbed, may not be the amalgamated company, and may precede the formation of the amalgamated company.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I did not advert to this as a drafting amendment. I had looked upon it rather as consequential to Senator O'Farrell's amendment, which has been defeated. In so far as it is described as a drafting amendment, if the Senator would be good enough to let it stand over for the Report Stage, we can see if any other formula can be agreed to.

Comment on this

I am satisfied.

Amendment, by leave, withdrawn. Section ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Section 9 ordered to stand part of the Bill.

SECTION 10.

(1) Any two or more amalgamating companies may, at any time after the passing of this Act and prior to the 31st day of July, 1924, submit to the Minister for reference to the railway tribunal a preliminary scheme for the amalgamation of those companies.

(2) An amalgamating company or any two or more amalgamating companies may, at any time after the passing of this Act, submit to the Minister for reference to the railway tribunal a preliminary scheme for the absorption by such amalgamating company or companies of any absorbed company or companies upon such terms as may be agreed between those companies.

(3) The railway tribunal shall approve any such preliminary scheme so referred to them unless it appears to them that the provisions of this Act relating to the procedure preliminary to the submission of a scheme have not been complied with, or unless after hearing such of the other amalgamating companies as desire to be heard, the railway tribunal consider the scheme to be inconsistent with or prejudicial to the amalgamation scheme to be made in accordance with the provisions of this Act.

(4) Every such preliminary scheme shall, subject to such provisions in that behalf as may be contained therein, come into operation forthwith after it is approved.

(5) Subject to the provisions of this section, all the provisions of this Part of the Act relating to amalgamation and absorption schemes shall, with the necessary adaptations, apply respectively to preliminary amalgamation and absorption schemes except that a preliminary amalgamation shall, instead of giving effect to the provisions contained in the Second Schedule to this Act with respect to the direction of the Company, make such alternative provision in that respect as may be agreed between the companies to be amalgamated.

(6) In the confirmation or preparation and settlement of the amalgation scheme the railway tribunal shall give effect to any preliminary scheme approved by them, but so that the interests of the other amalgamating companies shall not be prejudiced thereby.

(7) Any company formed by a preliminary amalgamation scheme shall be deemed to be an amalgamating company for the purposes of this Act in lieu of the companies amalgamated by the scheme, and shall not be deemed to be the amalgamated company within the meaning of this Act.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

Section 10, sub-section (2). Immediately after the word "Act" in line 26 to insert the words "and prior to the 31st day of July, 1924."

The effect of the amendment is to ensure that any preliminary scheme for the absorption of any company or companies shall be submitted as an agreed scheme by the 31st July, 1924, the same date as is set out in the previous sub-section. As it stands at present, there is no time limit in which such a scheme of absorption may be submitted, so that the companies to be absorbed could claim an indefinite period before an agreed scheme may be submitted on their behalf, and before which the railway tribunal could intervene. I think it is necessary that this should be inserted, and I hope the Minister will accept it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

This is on all fours with a similar amendment in the other House to the first section, and is quite acceptable.

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 12 sub-section (1). To delete in line 5 the words "with the modifications hereinafter mentioned."

Section 12. To delete all after the word "House" in line 7 down to and including the word "effect" in line 16.

These two amendments are really part and parcel of the one proposal. The section as it stands deals with the employees of the Irish Railway Clearing House. In all other respects, the employees of the Railway Clearing House are placed in the same position as those of the amalgamated company. In the case of the employees of the companies which will form the amalgamated company redundance arising out of the operations of the Bill will be compensated for. A man losing his position will get compensation under certain conditions, and there is no time limit fixed within which that redundancy carrying compensation may ensue, because it is obvious that in amalgamating a large number of companies of that kind a lot of clearing up work will have to be done before the new company can really say the number of staffs they will require. It would be unfair in these circumstances to fix any definite time limit so long as it can be shown that the redundancy occurred as a result of the operation of the Act. In the case of the Railway Clearing House the Bill lays down a period of three years. After that time any redundancy arising from any cause will not be compensated for. Clerks may find themselves unemployed, will be put on the labour market, and get no compensation, while clerks in a railway company, or any other employee, after 5 or 6 years will get compensation. That is placing the staff of the Railway Clearing House in a very inequitable position as compared with men doing railway work on the railways. It is true that the Clearing House is an institution which does the work of the whole of the railways, whether they are to be amalgamated or otherwise, and also of some of the shipping companies, and the Clearing House here is being placed on the same basis as the amalgamated company. The experience is that the tendency has been rather to increase the staff of the Railway Clearing House in recent years, and the inference will be that any redundancy that will take place within the next 5 or 6 years will in all probability be due to the operations of this Bill. If it is not due to the operation of the Bill, then it will be open to the amalgamated company or the Clearing House to take the matter to the arbitrator under Schedule 3 and say "This redundancy did not arise under the operation of the Act, and we should not be asked to pay compensation."

In the case of the British railways there was no such time limit at all. The grouping in England began operation on the 1st January, 1923, or eighteen months ago, and up to the present not a single clerk has become unemployed in the railway clearing house. In fact the position is that they had to increase the staff there to deal with the amount of clearing up work that has to be done. It is quite possible that three years will have elapsed before any serious redundancy will take place. After that three years it is possible redundancy will begin to show itself, and employees will be dismissed. If the Bill remains as it is they will have no compensation. I do not think that is a fair position to place these men in, seeing that they are part and parcel of the railway industry, and that they are doing railway work as genuinely as if employed by railway companies. They are employed by the railway companies in this clearing work, and if they become unemployed by the operation of this measure, say, after three and a half years, instead of three years, they would be told that the time limit has now elapsed and they had no claim to compensation. If the directors of the amalgamated company wanted to be unfair—and I do not say that they would—they could hold up the re-organisation until after three years had expired, and turn out the whole of the men without any compensation at all. I know that is a thing that is not likely to happen, but it is possible, and a possibility of that kind which happens so often in commercial and human affairs should not be rendered possible by the Bill. The two amendments in my name are really part of the same proposal, and one hinges on the other.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Would the result of the acceptance of your amendments be to leave no time limit?

Comment on this

Yes, to put them on the same basis as the other railway employees.

Comment on this

Is it a fact that there is no time limit to the right of the staff in the railways themselves to apply for this compensation under Schedule 3? I thought there was a time limit to the general staff as well as to the staff of the clearing house, but I quite agree with Senator O'Farrell that whatever terms are applied to the railways ought to be applied to the clearing house staff. I cannot see why they should be treated worse than the staff of the railways.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

In reply to Senator Jameson I wish to make it quite clear that there is no time limit with regard to any other railway employee. There is a definite time limit laid down with regard to the employees of the Irish Railway Clearing House, for a very definite reason. The main work of the Railway Clearing House is the division of the through rates on the traffic operating between the hitherto separate companies. These companies will become one immediately at the period after the passing of the Bill, the definite period set out, and the main bulk of the work done by the Irish Railway Clearing House will cease, and the redundancy, if there is going to be redundancy, will arise within the three years period. It ought to arise within twelve months. If this amendment is accepted it will mean that, say, ten, fifteen, or twenty years hereafter, on something not arising really out of the amalgamation scheme, a man may become redundant, and will then become entitled to a pension and allowance as a result of something not arising out of the amalgation scheme. The period of three years is put down definitely here, because it should be considered, and it ought to be clear from what I have said, that the immediate effect of the amalgamation scheme will be felt at once on the Irish Railway Clearing House. Three years is a long period—it could be limited to one—but three years put it beyond all doubt that if anyone suffers from the amalgamated scheme, his suffering will become evident within three years.

Comment on this
Earl of Mayo The EARL of MAYO Independent

May I ask the Minister with regard to the rates, that is to say overseas with the English companies, do the clerks in the Irish Railway Clearing House have to do with them?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes, a certain amount.

Comment on this
Earl of Mayo The EARL of MAYO Independent

But I imagine that is a rather serious amount, and if so I think Senator O'Farrell's contention should be attended to, because I do not see myself how the matter is going to close up in three years. I hope our trade will go on with the other side, and a very important trade it is, too.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It is quite correct that the Irish Railway Clearing House in Dublin deals with oversea and through rates across Channel, but the tendency has been in later years that the Dublin house should deal more and more with this, and not the London house. There has been a very definite effort on the part of the railway managers to have these things dealt with in the Railway Clearing House, and not across the water, but that is allowed for. That has almost reached its maximum point. The clearance, so far as the Irish Railway Clearing House is concerned, will not be lessened or increased by the amalgamation scheme. Certain things will be lessened, such as the division of certain receipts, and then there will be a redundancy, and that redundancy is bound to take place within three years.

Comment on this

It seems to me that there is a good deal to be said for the amendments. Perhaps if the Minister would explain how he would answer Senator O'Farrell's point about the fact that the English Clearing House now employs as many or more men, eighteen months after the English system began to operate we might vote otherwise, but unless he explains that I will vote for the amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

With regard to the Irish Railway Clearing House, there are 70 railway and shipping companies parties to that system. About one-third of that number is going to be affected by the Bill, and if the amendment is passed it means that any redundancy arising from any operations of the other two-thirds, will be put upon the shoulders of the amalgamated undertaking, and whatever payments have to be made will come out of that undertaking.

Comment on this

I would like to ask a question of the Minister. He says that the servants of the railway companies are given an unlimited time in which to make this application, if they are put out of service for any reason given in Schedule 3. He also tells us that the reason for not applying that to the Clearing House employees is that the Clearing House work will be greatly cut down in the amount of services which will be required. He also tells us that if we adopt the amendment, if at any time in the future there is re-organisation, or if anything happens in the Clearing House, which has nothing to do with the matter referred to in the Bill, and which we are now debating, it will give a right to the Clearing House employees to apply for the conditions contained in Schedule 3. I wonder does the Minister recognise that he is giving that right to every single employee of all the railway companies. If the amendment means that a re-organisation of the Clearing House system at any time will give the whole staff rights under Schedule 3 it does not seem a right thing to do, but that, however, from what the Minister says, is apparently what the Bill is giving to employees of all the railway companies as long as they do not belong to the Clearing House.

I wonder is that a wise thing to do. As I read the Bill I understood that because of the interference employees of the railway system were to be specially treated. That, of course, was quite clear, but if for ever and ever Schedule 3 can be applied as against the board of the amalgamated company, we undoubtedly seem to be giving away a great deal more than I dreamt of giving away in the Bill. Am I right in concluding from the Minister's remarks, that hereafter if at any time, for any reason, any member of the staff of the railway company becomes redundant he can appeal under the clauses of Schedule 3? That would extend the Bill altogether into regions which I did not know we were going into.

Comment on this

I would point out to Senator Jameson that no man can claim compensation unless he is rendered redundant because of the operations of the Bill. If his redundancy would have occurred, even if this Bill had not been passed, in these circumstances he could not claim compensation. Senator Jameson need have no fear that there is anything revolutionary in this Bill in that respect. It is a worse Bill in that respect than the British Railway Act. He will agree that a Bill passed by the British Parliament before Mr. Ramsay MacDonald's Government went into power would not be a revolutionary measure. The Bill provides that any man or woman who becomes redundant, because of the operations of this Bill, shall have the right of compensation. That is only right and it is the principle observed in every such measure. The railway companies themselves will bring about redundancy in the interests of economy as quickly as they can. If there is any question as to whether the redundancy did not arise because of the operations of the Bill, an appeal is given to the arbitrator who is to be appointed by the Chief Justice. That is my reply to the Minister. He mentioned 15 or 20 years' time, but that is too extravagant. Say, however, that in five years' time employees of the railway company may become redundant, they can claim that the redundancy was caused by the operations of the Act. If the railway companies say no, that it was due to another reason, they have the right to appeal to the arbitrator, and he in his judgment will be able to say whether it was or not.

The main work of the Railway Clearing House is taken up in the division of receipts, through or foreign, between the non-amalgamated companies, such as the Great Northern, but not so much as between the companies that are to form this combine. In England there was a far greater revolution, as 138 companies were amalgamated into four companies. One would imagine that there would be a huge redundancy at once, yet eighteen months after the passing of the British Railway Act, the staff of the Clearing House in London is greater than it was before grouping began to operate. It is safe to assume that five years will elapse before ordinary, permanent conditions will have been reached here. In view of the fact that the total staff of the Clearing House here is under 200, including lady clerks and temporary clerks, who have not the right to compensation, the amount of redundancy cannot be big, and the amount of compensation will be small. Because of that, should we run the chance of treating even two or three people with injustice and differentiate between those employees and others engaged on similar work elsewhere?

Comment on this

Would it meet the case, if instead of saying "three years" the words "five years" were substituted?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Do you move that as an amendment?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The amendment, inasmuch as it puts a definite limit on Senator O'Farrell's unlimited amendment, is, to that extent, an improvement, but as between three and five years it is a matter for the judgment of the Seanad. I put it again, however, that the portion of the work to be effected by the amalgamation is the division of the through rates as between the now separate undertakings. A certain number of these undertakings are going to be amalgamated. A number of them will disappear, redundancy will occur—it ought to occur within three years—and there is no ground for enlarging the period to five years. With regard to the other points raised, the argument has been used that the English Railway Clearing House is working with increased numbers, and we are asked to bear that in mind when considering this amendment. The English Railway Clearing House may be working with increased numbers, but that is not because of the ordinary Clearing House work. They have taken on to their shoulders an amount of extra work in consequence of grouping. There is no such thing here; there will be no extra work thrown upon the Clearing House here. There will be a reduction of the work, and there will be no increase as a result of the amalgamation scheme, and there is, in fact, bound to be a decrease. As to Senator Jameson's point with regard to the employees in Schedule 3, the matter is unlimited so far as time goes, but so far as personnel is concerned there is a definite limitation.

Take the employees of the separate railway concerns. Some of them are taken over by the amalgamated undertaking, only such as are necessary; therefore, the amalgamated undertaking starts, not with a swollen staff, but with a staff cut down to suit its requirements, and it is only right that if certain members of that staff become redundant they should be pensionable and have a right to compensation. That is allowed for in the Bill. It is limited so far as personnel goes. There is a definite segregation of employees required for the amalgamated work at the beginning, and some are rendered redundant by reason of amalgamation. May I repeat again that if the amendment be accepted in the form originally moved, it means, in the case of 70 railway and shipping companies concerned in the Clearing House system, that there is no time limit. Say, for instance, that employees of the Caledonian Railway, a party to the Irish Railway Clearing House, do something hereafter which rendered them liable to discharge under the section, if it were amended as proposed, they could come here and claim to be put on the shoulders of the amalgamated undertaking.

Comment on this

What about the arbitrator?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

They could make a claim. If the arbitrator is a safeguard, is there any reason urged yet why the three-year period should not be kept to? I think the facts are patent and that great redundancy will occur within the three years.

Comment on this

I think that members should realise that the work of the Irish Railway Clearing House will be effected very much more quickly by the operations of the Bill than that of the railway company. The effect on the latter will not work out for quite a long time. Different systems of working will be introduced and economies will take a long time to be effected, whereas the effect on the work of the Clearing House will be immediate. I do not think that there is any necessity for such amendment.

Comment on this

As regards Senator Bagwell's statement, I may say that it is in contravention of what happened elsewhere. As "five years" is better than "three," I would appeal to the Minister to accept it.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Would Senators Guinness and O'Farrell be satisfied if the amendment took the form of stating, "taking place within five years," and putting in, two lines above, the word "direct" before the word "result"?

Comment on this

That is assumed in all cases, and a similar word is not introduced in the case of railway employees.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I follow that, but the two conditions are different.

Comment on this

There may be a difference, but there is no difference here that would not operate in Great Britain. I do not think that there is any danger. I would suggest to the Minister that he would accept the five years. There is, moreover, always the arbitrator.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I think the suggestion of the Chairman is very valuable, that we should have the phrase, "direct result," and enlarge the time to five years.

Comment on this

The effect of that will be that every case will have to go forward and be proved. The company will not have the right to allow compensation without coming to the arbitrator.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I do not think that that is right. If the company are satisfied that it is a direct result, I do not think that there is any necessity for the arbitrator to intervene if they are agreed.

Comment on this

I quite agree that there is not much in that "direct result." I accept that.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The amendment is now altered so that the word "direct" is inserted before the word "result," and the word "three" is altered to "five."

Comment on this

I beg to move the amendment standing in my name:—"In section 13, sub-section (1), line 23, to delete the word "three," and to substitute therefor the word "five." Also in line 24 to delete the word "two" and to substitute therefor the word "four."

This amendment is not proposed in any way as hostile to the principles of the Bill. It is merely put forward as a safeguarding amendment. We have no objection to the fact that the head of the tribunal is to be a judge and that there is to be an expert railway man on the tribunal. Nevertheless, we think that on the whole this tribunal is too narrow. We think also that the chief supporters of the railways in the Free State, the agriculturists and the commercial men, are entitled to at least three representatives on the tribunal. Now, there is an old adage that "the man who pays the piper calls the tune." These sections, the agriculturists, the manufacturers and the wholesale distributors are really the principal supporters of the railways in the Free State and elsewhere. We do not want in any way to impair the principles of the Bill nor to injure it. We want to make the best we can of it. We want, if possible, to make it as popular as it can be made with the business people, the traders and the agriculturists of this country. Doubt has been expressed that one business man on this tribunal would have a very poor show with the learned judge and a railway representative who, no doubt, will safeguard the interests of the railway stockholders. That is a perfectly natural conclusion to arrive at.

Our object is to safeguard the interests of the agriculturists and particularly the interests of manufacturers and the businessmen in the Free State. I hope that the Minister will see his way to meet us in this amendment. We are determined to do all we can to help the railways out of the present condition in which they find themselves. They are, no doubt, suffering considerably. They have suffered in the past two years, and are threatened seriously by motor haulage. Motor haulage is a powerful factor in the transit system of the country. For one thing, motors are a good deal more satisfactory for the transit of goods than railways. One might say that goods are moved in motors from door to door, from the sender's door to the consumer's door. There is no delay, there are no goods missing, and there are no disputes, and it is a service that entirely appeals to us. If the railways wish to keep the business of the community, they will have to give a service that will at least be as satisfactory as that now offered by motor transit. The object of this amendment is, as I have said, to meet the desire of the business people and the agriculturists to have more representation on this tribunal.

Comment on this

I should like to support the amendment proposed by Senator O'Dea, not that I feel that a tribunal of three could not possibly do all that is asked of it, but I think a slight extension of its numbers would be better. There is no doubt that the agricultural community, and this is an agricultural community, will feel that they have been more or less left out of consideration unless this amendment is accepted. Whether that is wise or not I leave it for the Minister to decide in regard to the acceptance or not of this amendment. Other amendments to the Bill involve this particular claim. That the one great interest of the country, the agricultural interest, which pays for everything, so to speak—pays for three-fourths of the activity of the country—that that important industry should have no one capable of taking a useful part in a tribunal established for the purpose of increasing railway accommodation and increasing its usefulness is, I think, a slur on the industry. For that reason I support this amendment.

Comment on this

The amendment seems to me to be not an improvement. I think that any attempt to render a body of this kind representative of different trades is, in principle, entirely wrong. I agree with everything that has been said by Senator Bennett regarding the great importance to this country of its agricultural business, which is its biggest business, but I think the principle the Government had in mind in setting up this tribunal was the protection of the public; that is the inhabitants of the country as a whole. They are entitled to greater consideration than the particular people of any one industry, and I think it is a mistake that a tribunal of this kind should be confined to any particular trade or industry. I think the members of that tribunal are far more likely to take a broad view of the matters submitted to them if the tribunal is confined to three members, as set down in the Bill. It is impossible, after all, for any member of this tribunal to know everything, but surely it is possible to select a representative who will have sufficient ability to consider the various interests and the necessities which will arise in dealing with any particular set of rates or other matters which the tribunal will have to deal with. I think to make it representative of various trades and industries is a great mistake. It should be in itself a judicial body.

Comment on this

Senator Bagwell's statement implies that Senator O'Dea's amendment aims at having the tribunal representative of different trades. That is not so. The amendment aims at having a representative of the one trade that is the mainstay of the country, the one trade that creates 80 per cent, of the wealth of the country. One may reasonably assume that the commercial representative represents the other 20 per cent. of the trade of the community. Considering that the country's trade is mainly agricultural and that agricultural interests are so different in outlook from the interests that are commonly called commercial, it is advisable to have somebody on the tribunal that would have an agricultural knowledge.

Comment on this

I think the arguments used by Senator Bagwell are as much against the Section as it stands as against the amendment proposed by Senator O'Dea. If the tribunal is to be independent of all interests and all parties, why, then, are the terms used that one of the members shall be experienced in commercial affairs and another experienced in railway affairs? If it is right that none of the interests concerned in the future working of this Bill should be put on this railway tribunal, I think the proper method of carrying it out would be, not to mention qualifications at all of any of the members, but to leave it an open matter in the selection of these two people. As it has been put into the Bill that commercial and railway interests are to be represented on the tribunal and that agricultural and other interests are to be excluded, I think the amendment proposed by Senator O'Dea is one that should be accepted by the Seanad.

Comment on this

I think that some members of the Seanad who have spoken have forgotten that in addition to the railway tribunal, a standing tribunal of three members, there is also a panel, and that when any question comes up before the tribunal for decision possibly in connection with agricultural interests or any other interest, the tribunal, as such, will call from the panel experts or assessors to assist them in the particular point or question which is put before them and which it is possible they may not have personal experience of. For that reason I agree with Senator Bagwell that it is much better to have these three members as impartial and as unconnected with any particular trade as you can have them.

Comment on this

I think Senator O'Dea's amendment goes a long way further than the remarks that have been made about it would seem to indicate. What is established here really is a court of three members. It is a very high tribunal. It is practically given all the powers of a court, and it is to act as a court. It can summon witnesses and do everything that judges do. We can easily see that the chairman is to be a lawyer of the very highest class. He sits there with, on one side an individual advising him on the subject of railway matters, an individual with railway experience; and on the other side is an individual versed in commercial affairs. That means an ordinary man who has had a business training and who is in the habit of handling business affairs. Agriculturists are business men, according to their own lights.

Evidently this Section points at a man who has had experience in many other directions than in the particular trade with which he is connected. You then have a tribunal of three persons, one more or less independent, who will be guided in giving his decision by the case the other two put before him, and then you will have a majority of two settling the question, unless they all agree upon the decision. Senator O'Dea's amendment tends to destroy that balance entirely. He leaves in the man versed in railway affairs, and then instead of one individual of business capacity he puts in one man with commercial knowledge one manufacturer and one representative of agriculture, all of whom are appointed, not because of their personal qualifications, but as representatives to fight for the particular interests they represent. If Senator O'Dea's point is worth having, the agricultural man must battle for everything connected with agriculture, the manufacturer must battle for everything connected with manufactures, and the commercial man must try and battle for the interests of the business community. You will then have the poor lawyer at the head of affairs with four different individuals all battling for particular interests around him, individuals appointed to look after the section of the community they were elected to represent.

To call that a tribunal and to set it up as a court which is to decide all those matters seems to me to destroy all chance of any success coming out of the railway tribunal at all. There is no use in talking in the Seanad about the value of agriculture in the Free State. We all know that it is valuable. Senator Guinness has already stated that in Section 17 agriculture is undoubtedly dealt with on the Panel, and it seems to me that the particular interests involved are all very carefully dealt with. The railway tribunal is supposed to be above all those individual interests, and I think it would be unwise on the part of the Seanad to push into that tribunal men who would be appointed to represent special interests and to bring the number constituting the tribunal up to five, with a large proportion of that number appointed to represent special interests and not the general affairs of the community. Those appointed to the tribunal should not fight for particular interests, but rather should decide as between the community as a whole and the amalgamated company. By altering the constitution of the tribunal you would destroy the simplicity of the whole thing, and you would probably always have a minority report; and as far as the ordinary individual who would be connected with business affairs is concerned, you would destroy absolutely all chance of getting any really good work out of the railway tribunal. If there is one thing to which the community should look forward to in this Bill, and which is really the best thing in the measure, it is the railway tribunal. We ought to be extremely careful to see that no sectional representation is pushed into that tribunal. Such a thing would practically destroy it as far as its effective use for being a real Appeal Board for every interest in the country is concerned. It should be a real Appeal Board to which people could turn, knowing that they are going to get absolute justice and fair treatment.

Comment on this
Earl of Mayo The EARL of MAYO Independent

I notice that one member of the tribunal is to be experienced in commercial affairs. Considering that most of our commerce in the Irish Free State is the produce of agriculture, I should say that the gentleman who would be appointed ought to consider that fact. There is no doubt that cattle, sheep, pigs, horses, butter, eggs, etc., form the chief articles of our commerce. The amendment deals with the addition of two more members to the tribunal. Under Section 15, payment to the members of this tribunal is indicated; that is very clearly set forth in the Section. The railway companies have to pay one-half of the sum involved and the taxpayers have to pay the other half. I, as a taxpayer, very strongly object to having two more members put on. That point has not been raised at all, and as we have a right to deal with financial clauses in a Bill which is not a Money Bill, I think it is only fair that the Seanad and the Minister should know that the taxpayers will have to bear portion of the cost involved in paying those gentlemen. I do not wish to say anything more, but I shall certainly vote against the amendment.

Comment on this

The Irish Cattle Trade and the Live Stock Owners' Association, whom I represent, have decided objections to many clauses in this Bill, but they have instructed me to support it because they see in this railway tribunal the only redeeming feature of the measure. I think I have a right to support or to compromise on this amendment. Later on there is an amendment of my own which will come under consideration. I would like to point to the fact that the cattle trade is one of the most important branches of industry in the country, and I believe that we should have representation amongst the big three of the railway tribunal. I do not agree with what Senator Jameson says as regards putting men on the tribunal representing sections. The agriculturists do not desire that there should be any sectional representation, and they have no anxiety that their representative would give an unfair or biased decision.

The Senator points out that tribunal representatives would be more or less in a judicial capacity. When you are appointing a judge you do not select a man who has not a knowledge of law. It does not follow that any person on the tribunal with a knowledge of the live stock trade and of agriculture would not be sufficiently qualified to give a fair, reasonable and proper decision on questions which would come under consideration. The person who may be selected because of a knowledge of commercial affairs may be the manager of a haberdashery store, and he would understand nothing whatever about agriculture and live stock in the country. I suggest that Senator O'Dea would withdraw his amendment if the Minister would be satisfied to compromise. We are not particular whether the number on the tribunal is three, four or five, so long as one of the members would have a knowledge of agriculture and live stock. If the Minister would find a word that would suit our view-point we would be prepared to accept it.

Comment on this

There is no doubt Senator Jameson put up an excellent case, but I really think it was an excellent case for the amendment. He suggests forsooth that this tribunal is to be an absolutely judicial body. If it is, why not make it a tribunal of judges? Why were the words "commercial" and "railway" brought in in connection with the constitution of the tribunal if it were not expressly for the purpose of showing that commerce and railways were to get special consideration from the tribunal? That case was freely developed by Senator Bagwell, and it was stated that this was no sectional tribunal but was a tribunal for the country. Very properly in the first instance the Government got a judge, a man versed in law, versed in evidence and versed in the various necessities of a tribunal such as this. But, having got that far, their intentions were turned aside from their purpose and they were led to appoint representatives of commerce and railways. Because agriculture was not vocal enough, because it was not considered of sufficient importance, because, so to speak, it was the child of the community, to which everything is turned on, and that it must be taught and advanced in every way, it was not taken into consideration in this matter.

I, as an agriculturist, am prepared absolutely to accept a tribunal of three judges. This amendment may be passed, but I am not content with a tribunal representative of sectional interests such as this tribunal is. I think the Government should accept the amendment, because it is a reasonable one. The fear that there may be discord, as suggested by Senator Jameson, will never arise. If the Chairman, as he suggests, wants to be guided aright as regards commercial matters and as regards railway matters, surely all the more he requires to be guided right as regards agricultural matters? We are told that the agriculturist in this country needs all sorts of teaching. He is to be actually taught out of existence. He is to produce agricultural produce to a greater extent than he does now; but having produced it he has no guarantee, because of the sectional interests involved in this tribunal, that his interests will be considered properly. For that reason I think the farmer and the manufacturer should be represented on the tribunal and the amendment ought to get every consideration from the Minister.

Comment on this

I, too speak as an agriculturist, but I cannot say that I feel very excited or very hot about this matter. In my opinion, if we were to cut out sub-section 3 altogether, the whole case would be met. At first I was inclined to agree with what Senator O'Dea said, but certainly Senator Jameson put up a very good case. I think if we leave out sub-section 3 the whole matter will be remedied.

Comment on this

I entirely agree with the last speaker. There is no doubt that the definition of the qualifications of the two members of the tribunal has made the agricultural community somewhat suspicious. I saw it stated in the columns of the "Irish Farmer" the other day that Ireland has but one industry and that is agriculture, and incidentally she has but one customer. There is a most important point that has been missed altogether in connection with transit, and that is the facilities given for the importation of foreign foods. It would be open to this railway tribunal to sanction through rates from the Continent for foreign food. They could, say, grant a through rate from Copenhagen to Maryborough, or any inland town which might place Irish butter at a great disadvantage. There are several matters of this kind which, I think, would necessitate that at any rate there should be one member of the tribunal who would have a knowledge of agriculture. The transit of live stock is a matter of great importance in the country. Therefore, I think, by omitting the qualifications for two members of the tribunal, the case will be met, and I am quite certain the Government, being fully alive to the importance of the industry, will probably take care that one or both of the two members of the tribunal should be thoroughly qualified in respect to dealing with matters which concern both agriculture and ordinary commerce.

Comment on this

I presume I am not now in order in moving the deletion of sub-section (3)?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

We are now dealing with Section 13, which refers to the number that should constitute the permanent railway tribunal. If the amendment is rejected it would be quite open to you when we come to Section 14 to move the omission of sub-section (3).

Comment on this

I listened to the arguments which have been advanced, and I think they all tend towards the conclusion and point to the necessity of the tribunal being a purely judicial body. It is very hard for any member, a commercial man, or a railway man, on a tribunal of that sort — a judicial body carrying out judicial functions — who has been associated for the greater part of his life with one or with several commercial interests to be supposed to dissociate himself within three months from every financial interest he may possess with regard to commerce or railways in order to qualify him for such a tribunal. It is very hard for him to sever his mind and to keep it apart so that he may properly carry out his duties as a member of that tribunal. It is almost more than human that a man appointed to such a tribunal and having those interests with which he has been so intimately associated during his life, could have an impartial mind on matters that come before him. The commercial man will have the commercial instinct, and he will be biased in that direction. The railway man will be biased also. In theory, of course, a judge on the bench dissociates himself from all interests that come before him, and tries to bring an impartial mind to bear on the matters that he has to adjudicate upon. It is very well in theory — I daresay our judges try to do that conscientiously, as far as it is humanly possible to do it—but a man who has been steeped in commerce, or who has been a railway man all his life, gets a habit of mind that it is very hard to alter.

If the tribunal is to have a purely judicial function it must be composed of people who are qualified to act in that capacity. They must be legal men. You have your courts of law every day dealing with most diverse matters, agriculture, commerce, railways, mining interests, and the judges constituting these courts have no specific or detailed knowledge of the matters that come before them. But they have power to bring in expert evidence and extract from these experts whatever information they consider necessary for coming to a proper decision. If this tribunal is a tribunal to stand between the partisan interests and the community as a whole — and the community is to be the main consideration in the matter — and to elucidate evidence, I think it should be a purely judicial tribunal comprised of men qualified legally to sit and deal with such happenings. It has been suggested to eliminate sub-section (3) of section 14, where one of the two members must be a commercial man and the other a railway man. If you eliminate that section a tribunal would be appointed consisting of the chairman, who must, of necessity, be a practising barrister or judge, and two ordinary members. That leaves the Governor-General with a very wide discretion. There is no limitation at all, no direction to him as to who these two men may be, or what their experience or anything else may be.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I want again to point out that at present we are dealing solely with Section 13, and the question before the House, and the only question, is whether the tribunal is to consist of three or five. If the amendment enlarging it to five is lost, it will then be open to anyone to move the omission of sub-section (3) to Section 14 when we come to it.

Comment on this

There is another reason why there should certainly be no commercial man or railway man appointed to such a tribunal, and that is because it may so happen that a commercial man, where a question comes up in which the bacon industry is involved— and that is an industry that ought to be safeguarded in this country, and very closely safeguarded, in order that our industries may be built up — his particular bent of mind may be entirely opposed to it. A commercial man may be, right through his life, interested in imports——

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I really must ask the Senator not to pursue this, because we are not dealing with qualifications in this amendment at all. We are simply dealing with the number — is the number to be three or is it to be five. When that is settled the question of their qualification, if any, will arise.

Comment on this

All these matters that I am touching on now have been touched on by previous speakers.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Well, I thought it was time to stop it, and I am sorry, Senator, that I had to begin with you.

Comment on this

If you enlarge it to five, it is simply with the object of getting partisan interests represented on the tribunal, and I certainly would be opposed to that, because I hold the view that it should be a purely judicial body.

Comment on this
Earl of Kerry The EARL of KERRY Independent

I should like to ask the Minister if he would make it clear exactly how the gentlemen on the panel function. It seems to me that the answer to this amendment very largely depends upon how Section 17 operates. I am not going into that now, but I just mention it, that there are, as everyone can see, three commercial, two labour, two passenger, one fisheries, and four agricultural representatives on that panel. If those agricultural representatives are called in whenever agricultural questions arise, in my view the agricultural position is amply safeguarded, but I am not aware under what conditions these representatives would be called upon to function.

Comment on this

I think Senator O'Dea came to the conclusion that the tribunal was bad, and he decided that the best way to make it better was to make it worse.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I had thought that I had moved away from the chilly atmosphere of the Dáil, and that I was coming to a more genial atmosphere, but Senator Kenny's comments have warned me that my heavy wine is going to be diluted by copious draughts of criticism here. I could not gild the refined gold of Senator Jameson's arguments. I would like to say one or two things in supplement to the matters dealt with by him. There are to be separate panels, and for all purposes other than matters arising under Part I. of the Bill the tribunal, for practical purposes, will consist of five members. For all purposes under Part III. of the Bill the tribunal may be enlarged, and on representations being made the tribunal can always be enlarged to five. If we accept this amendment the effect would be that for determining the compulsory amalgamation schemes the tribunal will consist of five, and for all other purposes the panel will consist of seven. That would be overweighted. Arguments have been used in the Dáil, and have already been used here, drawn from the example of the English system. I put it to the House that if a panel of three members is sufficient to deal with all the volume of railway business arising out of the group system in England, surely a panel of three ought to be sufficient to deal with a portion of the lines of the Free State. The operations of the panel are set out in Section 17, and the Senator referred to the panel as definitely answering most of the arguments put forward with regard to the amendment.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Is it not plain, Mr. McGilligan, that the members of the other panel, not the permanent panel, but the outside panel, once they are invited to sit do not sit as assessors but as actual members of the court? They become actual members of the court, with the same powers as the permanent members, do they not?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes. Sub-section 6 of section 17 says: "Any person appointed under this section to be an additional number of the railway tribunal shall, for the purposes of any proceeding in respect of which he may be so appointed, be a member of the railway tribunal and shall, subject to the provisions of this Part of this Act, and to the general rules made thereunder, have and exercise all the powers and functions of a member of the railway tribunal." The panel is really going to be for all purposes except matters arising under Part I, a panel of five members, and the agricultural interests are very carefully protected. Sub-section 1 (a) shows the big proportion of members given to the agricultural interest, so that very definitely the question of agriculture has not been forgotten. It has been argued that the tribunal should be a judicial one and a certain comment has been made upon later sections. The question of the status of the tribunal, as to whether it should be a wholly judicial tribunal or not, may I think be alluded to here.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

It is wiser to keep that for Section 14. At present we are on the question as to whether the tribunal is to consist of three or five.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I shall leave that to a later stage. I shall simply refer to the one matter, the question of the appointments that would arise if the amendment were accepted. The method of appointment is described in a later section, and has been described by the Senator. It comes to this, that certain fees are to be chargeable and the excess of remuneration over that is to be paid one half by the State and one half by the amalgamating undertakings. Putting on two wholly unnecessary members on the tribunal would, of course, increase the charges. The cost of one of those members would go on the railway undertaking and the cost of the other would be borne by the taxpayer. I think, having regard to the provisions of section 17, dealing with the panel, there is no necessity for the enlargement of this tribunal.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I shall put the amendment now dealing with Section 13 alone, and I shall put the two amendments moved by Senator O'Dea, because the second one would be a necessary corollary to the first. That is to say there shall be established a court styled the railway tribunal court consisting of five standing members — that is to say a chairman and four ordinary members. The amendment is to change the word "three" to "five" and the word "two" to "four."

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

There is an amendment by Senator O'Dea, which reads:—

"One of the ordinary members of the railway tribunal shall be a person of experience in commercial affairs, one a person of experience as a manufacturer, a third a person of experience in agriculture, and a fourth a person with a knowledge of railway business."

That amendment is now out of order because the Seanad has confirmed the principle of three forming the permanent tribunal, but I will take an amendment from him if he wishes to exclude sub-section (3) of Section 14, if he moves it.

Comment on this

I move it.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I would support this amendment. This word "commercial" has a definite meaning in the affairs of life, whatever its meaning is in the dictionary. It undoubtedly typifies more a merchant or person connected in the distributing business, or banking perhaps, as against the manufacturer. I do not think it is at all desirable that this tribunal, which admittedly is going to be judicial, as far as the standing members are concerned, should in any way have indicated the qualifications of its component members. I suggest that you could not get the most competent person drawn from what you call the commercial classes alone. There may be an equally competent person who would not come under that definition. That being so, the best way is to say nothing about it but to leave the selection of the two members and the Chairman to the Governor-General on the advice of the Executive Council.

If you read Section 17 alongside of Section 14, you will find that the word "commercial" must have a limited meaning as distinct from agriculture, otherwise why, in constituting your panel, do you indicate this class separately? If they are all the same there should be no necessity for this distinction. We know that in the past there has been a considerable antagonism between organised agriculture and what has been called the commercial community. We, agriculturists, are looking for a great development of cooperative agriculture, and as farmers are doing more and more of their own business, we fear that these agricultural organisations will not come into the definition of commercial. I do not think they can. Therefore these organisations would have an undoubted right, if they possessed a qualified person amongst their number, to be nominated on the railway tribunal. It is much safer to drop sub-section (3) altogether and leave it to the Government to nominate whoever they think best fitted for the post.

Comment on this

It seems to me that a certain amount of confusion has arisen here from the proposer not stating the exact thing he wishes to do.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I am not very strongly opposed to this amendment to have this section deleted, and that for a reason which may not be entirely appreciated by the Seanad. The appointment is to be made by the Governor-General on the advice of the Executive Council. This is a Government Bill. If the Government have in their minds the appointment of a person of experience in commercial affairs, and the appointment of a person of experience in railway business, the mere deletion of this section is not going to change their mind. To that extent the omission of the section may not do any good. The proposition to omit the section is based on a misconception, I think. There has been raised here an antagonism between agricultural and commercial interests. It has appeared here and the statement has been made that the Government was unduly favouring commerce as against agriculture. There is no such intention. The President definitely stated in speaking of this section and on this section on the Second Reading and on the Committee Stage that the composition of the tribunal as foreseen by him would be that of a judge experienced in matters of law, a person acquainted with railway business who knew the ins and outs of the whole work of the railways, and a third person versed in accounts. I think he said an accountant. An accountant was really in his mind. If he could get a person who, in addition to being a commercial man, had a knowledge of costings and accounts, that would be the man to fill the office. If it is proposed to leave out this section, well and good. But you do not, by leaving out that section, change the intentions of the Government with regard to the appointments. Their intention has been made clear, and their intention is a good one.

Comment on this

The object is to remove a misconception that exists in the minds of certain persons here and of possibly persons outside, too.

Comment on this

I call attention to this amendment which stands in the Orders of the Day with regard to Section 14. As that has been deleted I do not see the necessity for moving it.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I had already struck out that amendment.

Comment on this

I beg to move:

To add at the end of the Section a new sub-section (5) as follows:—

The provisions of this Section shall not apply to the members of the two Panels constituted by Section 17 of this Act.

Our whole object in inserting amendments to this Bill is to try and secure the best people possible for the tribunal and panels, and we contend that the best and most suitable men for the railway panels would be excluded if that section is left in. People holding shares in any carrying or shipping company, according to the previous section, would be excluded from becoming members of the panel. We contend that in that case it would deprive the most suitable man from becoming a member. For instance, trustees holding shares or anybody holding shares in trust would be excluded. I think the necessity for inserting the additional sub-section is apparent to everybody.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If I might intervene, Section 16 has four sub-sections. The fourth sub-section is the definition sub-section. The other sub-sections refer to the standing members of the tribunal. This section would have no effect on members of the panel.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I was going to point that out. This section applies only to what are called standing members of the tribunal — that is to the three members. It has no application to the temporary panel.

Comment on this

Then I was under a misapprehension, and I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

On this section I desire to ask a question. It is provided under sub-section (3) (b) that in the event of a standing member of the railway tribunal being unable to act through prolonged illness or some other unavoidable cause power is given to appoint a member of the panel to act in his place, the person so appointed being selected from the general panel or the railway and canal panel. What I want to know is: Will a member so appointed become a standing member?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That is not quite clear from the wording in the Bill. I think it could be better provided for if it were clearly expressed that the provisions of Section 16 would not apply in the case of a member so appointed from the temporary panel.

Comment on this

Is this to be only a temporary appointment?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

It is only temporary and will only last until the other person recovers his health.

Comment on this

But the other person may have died.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Then a new appointment has got to be made.

Comment on this

There is no provision here to meet a situation of that kind.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The question now before the Seanad is that Section 17 stand part of the Bill.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I would like if the Minister would tell us how this section is going to work. The standing tribunal is given power to supplement itself for certain purposes on certain occasions, especially in this Part 3 of the Act by calling in two additional members from the panel. There are altogether on the two panels 16 members: 12 on the general panel and 4 on the railway and canal panel. I am puzzled as to how in practice the thing is going to work. When rates are being fixed will the rates concerning agriculture be taken separately, and will agriculture for that purpose be given a preponderance among the additional members? You cannot, of course, give much of a preponderance because there are only two additional members to be appointed. When other matters are taken more remote from agriculture, although all are based on agriculture will other members be called in? I really want to know how this section is going to work, because it seems to me rather puzzling at present. There are only two members out of the 16 going to be called in on the tribunal, and it looks rather as if agriculture is going to have a poor show under these conditions, because one of these members at least is coming from the railway and canal panel. I would be glad if the Minister would answer the point that I have made.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The actual working of the section, as I see it, will be this: That a particular question arises for discussion or for determination, and if that is an agricultural question then the standing tribunal will be strengthened by one member drawn from the general panel. Such a person, in that event, will naturally be representative of the agricultural interests. If, say, a question relating to fisheries arose, then the addition to the standing tribunal will be a person interested in fishery matters.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I wonder if the Minister is quite correct in stating that. Section 17 appears to contemplate an addition of two.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Only one of the additional members can come from the panel referred to as the general panel, and one from the other panel referred to as the railway and canal panel.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

There will be two additional members, one taken from the railway and canal panel, and another from the general panel who is to represent the particular interest involved.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I was answering more specifically Senator Sir John Keane's point. The tribunal will always be strengthened by the addition of two members. One of these members will have to come from the railway and canal panel, and the other will be the representative of the particular interest which seems to be involved in the matter that arises for discussion. I do not see that there is any great difficulty in the working of the tribunal and in having it strengthened by members drawn from the panel, because, of course, it will be quite easy for a new member to be selected when any new matter comes before it. The agricultural representative will be drawn from the four on the general panel when an agricultural question is in dispute, and when other questions are in dispute the tribunal will be strengthened by a member interested in the question under discussion.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Can that be quite right? There will be a concrete application before the tribunal. The question to be determined is whether it is to be strengthened or not.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It is to be strengthened on application being made.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Then you bring two additional members, one from the railway and canal panel and the second representing the particular interest involved. If that interest appears for the moment to be agricultural and that it subsequently turns out that agriculture only plays a small part in it, and that it is really a commercial question, surely there is no provision here for getting rid of the agricultural member and then bringing in a new member altogether to represent the commercial interests in the same case.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Provision has not been made for that, and the only way that I see that provision could be made to meet such a situation under sub-section (4) is that the particular application be withdrawn and another substituted which would allow for the appointment of another member representing the interest which has emerged in the course of the proceedings as the particular interest involved. What An Cathaoirleach has said is quite correct. If an application is made and because of the particular class of case proceeding, an agricultural member is appointed, and it then emerges that it is some other interest that is involved, I am afraid then that the consequences of the preliminary mistake would have to be suffered except that the application might be withdrawn. If a new application were then made it could be made quite clear that the interests involved were other than those originally stated. Then there would be a shuffling as between the members of the general tribunal, and the representative of the new interest could be brought in.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I am afraid that would be very unsatisfactory, and I suggest to the Government it would be very wise if they would look into this particular section and see if they could not do something to amend it on Report. At present it seems as if it would be very difficult to work.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The suggestion could certainly be considered. I am not quite clear, though that when regard is being had to the particular class of case to be heard that a mistake is likely to happen. It is a contingency that might have to be provided against, but I imagine it will be a very rare contingency. The matter could be looked into before the Report Stage is reached.

Comment on this
Earl of Kerry The EARL of KERRY Independent

Conceivably, cases could arise in which all the interests would be involved under Part 3, and what would happen then?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Then you would have to regard the twelve members on the general panel and see who best represents all the interests. You cannot. I am afraid, legislate for every conceivable contingency. We can strengthen the Bill as suggested by An Cathaoirleach by bringing in something under sub-section (4).

Comment on this

With regard to sub-section (4) there is no discretionary power given to the railway tribunal. They must appoint one man from the general panel and one from the railway and canal panel. I suggest it would be preferable to do away with that and give them power to appoint the two additional members from the general panel if the case before them so required. Supposing an agricultural question comes before them they can only appoint one representing agriculture, and another one representing railways or canals. This latter representative might be quite useless for the purpose of dealing with the question before the tribunal. Therefore, I think it would be better if the sub-section were amended so that the tribunal should have power, if they wish to use it, to appoint both members from the general panel or both from the smaller panel.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

My view is that once you constitute your tribunal by calling in these two extra men they remain as the tribunal and they must take part in deciding the entire case. You cannot shift them during the progress of the case. They become members of a court for the hearing of a particular application, and no development in the course of the hearing can oust them from their position as standing members of that court. The case for good or evil would have to be determined by that tribunal of three with the two new members added, and there is no provision in this Bill to avoid that. Therefore, I was pointing out to the Government that I think it would be absolutely necessary for them to reconsider this entire section.

Comment on this

Arising out of that, the words of sub-section (4) are rather vague; they convey that these additional members are brought in on the application of either of the parties. To whom is the application made? Is it the Minister will decide whether the panel is to be increased or not? Because otherwise either of the railway tribunals might say: "No, we do not require it to be increased." There is nothing I can see in this that makes it perfectly clear as to the condition and time and the persons who are to be appointed extra members of the panel.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The appointment under sub-section (4) must be made either by the railway tribunal on the application of either of the parties—

Comment on this

But they may refuse.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

They are not bound to yield to that application. They could refuse it, and if they do the matter appears to end. But then there is an alternative power given to the Minister, and whether he is to exercise it when the tribunal refuses to exercise it I do not know. It is left rather vague, and that is another reason why I say this whole Section 17 will in my opinion require very drastic alterations to make it work at all.

Comment on this

Carried to extremes the railway tribunal might veto every application.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Yes, but the section contemplates if they do the Minister can come forward then and over-rule it.

Comment on this

That is not clear in the section.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I rose a while ago in some doubt, and after the Minister's reply my doubt is not dispelled. Supposing a general application is made to revise and recast the whole railway classification, there would be, as far as I can see, a claim made to the railway tribunal, and there would be quite a field day deciding who are to be the additional members to deal with this question. Regardful as I am for agriculture, the most that could be got additional is one in the interests of agriculture and one in the interests of the railways and canals, and, especially after what An Cathaoirleach has said, it looks as if the people who will really thrive upon this are the lawyers, because I can see nothing more fruitful than the point that would be raised. I am rather confirmed in that view by the views of An Cathaoirleach, who is experienced in the tactics of the profession.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

As a disinterested party I would strongly recommend the Minister to exclude this matter altogether. I do not see what the additional panel is for; they have not got it in England.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

This section is largely scissors and paste. Surely it would be better in all these cases where you seem groping in the dark to make the thing as general as possible, of course without doing injustice, and to trust to these three members of the railway tribunal, and to call in an assessor when required for those various interests. You give these additional members voting power, and there, I think, the various sectional interests should be alert. That is why I am alert to see that agriculture is not overshadowed or overlapped by all these other interests represented.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

It is obvious that something will have to be put in, if these things remain, to provide that these gentlemen, when acting in the event of a vacancy amongst the standing members either from death or illness, shall not be liable to the provisions of Clause 16, which compels them to get rid of their shares before they begin to operate. There is no provision for that at all in this section.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

It is evident this matter will have to be gone into very carefully. If it was allowed to stand over now it could be taken on the Report Stage. The principle of bringing in assessors in preference to additional members would leave greater flexibility under the Act.

Comment on this

I would like to support the views expressed by many Senators on this matter, that as far as possible the partisan nature of this tribunal should be eliminated. I think the Minister himself has given us an assurance that that was in the mind of the Executive, that the members of the tribunal, though designated commercial and railwaymen, would not exactly be commercial and railwaymen in the ordinary sense, but men whose qualifications showed that they were competent to deal with matters involving abstruse questions of that sort. If that is in the mind of the Executive, and is endorsed by the House, why then go back to it here by reintroducing, by way of strengthening the tribunal, a sectional element of three? You have invested your tribunal with a judicial character, and given it judicial functions; why, then, introduce a clause here getting back to the old evil of bringing in members to the tribunal from a panel constituted and made up by members who represent distinctive organisations in the community, and who are there to give their views on their own particular interest and their own particular organisations? That is the very thing we are trying to eliminate from the tribunal, and now we seem to be introducing that again, or giving facilities for bringing back that very undesirable element to the tribunal.

Comment on this

I suggest to the House that they should go a little slow in the process of eliminating or else they may succeed in eliminating the tribunal altogether. We have already carried an amendment to give the Government carte blanche as to whom they shall appoint on the standing tribunal. In all probability the first tribunal will be in accordance with the principles outlined in this Bill. Have we any guarantee that future Governments will not make purely political appointments to the tribunal? Men may be appointed to it for their political organising powers and for their vote-catching propensities without any regard to the duties that they are called upon to perform. I do not know whether the House realises the meaning of the amendment. At all events, it is carried now. I think it would be very desirable if there was provision which might at all events ensure that there would be somebody on the tribunal who would be able to speak with expert knowledge of one or other branches of the functions that the tribunal is called upon to perform. I do not know that this is such a terribly complicated provision as is made out. It is possible, of course, that in the general consideration of the classification of rates and so forth that all interests will become more or less involved at one time, but in circumstances of that kind I think the proper procedure would be for the panel to meet. From its previous proceedings it will be able to say who might best be able to represent the whole panel, and it would agree to take representatives from the other panel and put them forward before the tribunal, while, of course, every section will have a right to come in and appear by counsel before the tribunal. But I would urge that those panels be not eliminated, particularly in view of what we have already done in regard to the standing tribunal.

Comment on this

I agree with what is said with regard to the rather complicated arrangement under sub-section (4), and for myself I think it would be much better if instead of application being made to the railway tribunal the Minister himself had power to deal with this matter. If you had that you would have the Minister, who is responsible to both Houses, and he is exposed if he deals improperly or unfairly with the matter to the criticism of the Press in this country and also to the Press at the other side. I think that would be more satisfactory. Perhaps it does not commend itself to members of the Seanad in the same way. I know there is a feeling that they do not wish to put too much power into the hands of the Minister, but it must be remembered that if the Minister has that power, and if you put him in that position, he has got a responsibility to the public, and to maintain the position which he holds. I myself would rather see that than that an application be made to the railway tribunal. I hope I have made myself clear. I am not merely thinking of the present time when we are reconstructing our affairs, but I am thinking of the future. I myself have had a little experience, and I would much rather see the responsibility put upon the Minister chosen by the people than the application being dealt with by the tribunal.

Comment on this

I agree with a great deal of what has been said by Senator O'Farrell. He was speaking as if to an amendment, but I have heard no amendment proposed on this section at all.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I was expecting that out of this discussion would evolve an amendment, but it has not appeared yet.

Comment on this

I think what has evolved is that everybody who has spoken expressed the view that they did not understand sub-section (4), and the gist of the discussion seems to me to ask the Minister to look into it and see if he could make it clear how this was going to operate.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

In the last two lines it provides that the gentleman is to be selected on account of his special knowledge of the subjects that may arise for which he is being selected.

Comment on this

There are quite a large number of points that one could pick out. They would make a great deal of difficulty, but I do not think we will solve them by discussing the question now. Taking one point that Senator O'Farrell referred to, I looked at the construction of the panel and the balancing of these twelve members — three are commercial men, two labour, two passengers, four agriculture, and one fisheries. I look at that as a sort of panel to arrive at a certain decision, but it now turns out that the tribunal are to pick out of those twelve one individual whenever the tribunal begins to act in the particular manner. The four agriculturalists will probably represent different sections of the industry. There may be one for live stock, one for tillage, and so on, and one will be chosen for one particular case. Therefore Senator O'Farrell's idea that this panel should act as a body and have some views in the selection of these individuals who represent them is the only way I can possibly see that the panel as a body could be of the slightest use at all. You have matters in regard to agriculture changing from questions connected with live stock to questions connected with tillage, and in commerce you may have matters connected with imports and matters connected with manufacture, and how are you to change them?

I do not know how the section works. I was hoping that the result of this discussion would be that the Minister would explain the matter and tell us how it would really work. I think we ought to be slow to cut things out, and I certainly agree we ought not be in a hurry to cut out all the panels. Our object is to see that at the proper time they should come to have the influence they ought to have.

We have cut out sub-section (3) of Section 14. If we left in sub-section (3) in the case of an agricultural matter the five who would have dealt with it would be one lawyer, one railway representative, one commercial man, one agricultural man and one railway or canal representative. That means that you would have two railway people. But we have taken out sub-section (3). Therefore, we cannot in the least argue that there are going to be two railway men. The Minister was quite right in saying we ought not to be in a hurry. Our action has entirely destroyed the argument which we could bring against sub-section (4) that there would be two railway people always and only one agriculturist. That cannot now be argued. I do not see that we will get any further with this discussion, but I had hoped that we might get some statement as to what the Minister thinks ought to be done in view of the discussion.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

In view of the hour, I suggest that we should adjourn for luncheon and some amendment may emerge in the meantime.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

During the interval I had an opportunity of looking into the British Act, and I find that these provisions in essence — the provisions as to the panel and the additional members—are in the British Acts. Even then I personally do not see how in practice the section, as it now stands, can work. To put the matter in order I move to delete sub-sections 4, 5 and 6 and substitute the following:—"The railway tribunal, on application by any of the parties or otherwise, may call in such members of the panels as they think fit who possess technical knowledge of the case, to act as assessors in any particular case or proceedings under Part III. of the Act." The form of words is probably imperfect, but if the principle is accepted the wording can be altered. I will require a definition of what an assessor is. I do not legally know what an assessor is. I contemplate in this case an assessor as some person with technical knowledge who will sit with the members of the tribunal while the proceedings are going on and have the right of asking questions subject to the ordinary conduct of debate. Then, when the court is closed, he will also continue to confer with the members of the tribunal, but will have no voting power in such decision as may ultimately be reached.

Comment on this

I have an amendment to propose to sub-section (3).

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You can take that now.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

Section 17, sub-section (3). To delete all after the words "general panel" in line 39.

The necessity for the amendment may not be as great as it was in the Bill as originally drafted, but my purpose in submitting the amendment was that the stereotyped addition of a railway man or a commercial man should not be allowed to persist under the new arrangement, whereby three members, so to speak, will have no label. I think the necessity for "according to the qualification of the ordinary member in question" is quite unnecessary, because apparently he will not be qualified on any particular basis. I think, then, that there is no reason why, in the case of the subsequent member appointed from the panel for a temporary vacancy, it should not be left to the Minister to decide as regards his qualification without setting it out in any particular fashion. Under the old arrangement, as the Bill was introduced, the man should either be a lawyer, a railwayman or a commercial man. It is to prevent that, that I wish to have this amendment accepted. I do not think that the ordinary member ought to have any particular qualifications except that he is a person qualified to sit upon a tribunal. What was at the back of the mind of the Minister, I take it, was that any new member to be appointed to the tribunal from the ordinary members should have a tag to his name, either as a commercial or as a railway man. This amendment is for the purpose of securing that any member of the community who, in the opinion of the Government or of the Minister, is entitled to sit on such tribunal, can be appointed a temporary member.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Is your amendment to omit the words after "general panel" or after the word "place"?

Comment on this

I think it would be better after the word "place."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That is what I think.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I would urge very strongly that this amendment should not be accepted. It is proceeding further on the lines already travelled in deleting sub-section 3 of Section 14. It may seem to be consequential upon the omission of that sub-section, but it is not really so. Although you have now decided that the two members, other than the chairman, of the tribunal shall not be selected by reason of certain qualifications set out in the sub-section omitted, still when any one of these persons is appointed he will be a person of experience in some of the many interests alluded to in the general panel or in the railway and canal panel. If a man of that sort has temporarily to vacate his position, through illness or being out of the country, it is quite natural to expect that the person appointed to replace him shall be a man of similar interests or qualifications. I would urge, as I had intended to urge previously on this point of omission, that the tribunal does not represent anybody. There is no question of representatives on the tribunal. The tribunal is to be, as far as possible, a judicial body. All that was said previously was, "Shall be a person of experience in commercial affairs," not a person representative of commercial interests. These are totally different things. I would urge strongly that the words should not be omitted, although the Seanad has omitted sub-section 3 of Section 14. The interests are so many as set out in (a) and (b) of sub-section 1 of Section 17 that there is a very wide choice. There is no tying the hands of the Governor-General or the Executive Council in asking them to make their choice from these people. As they stand, the words are very valuable, and I would urge very strongly that they should not be omitted.

Comment on this