We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

[SEANAD IN COMMITTEE.] - RAILWAYS BILL, 1924.—THIRD STAGE.

Contributions 143–294 of 294. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Railways Bill, 1924
Enacted

No. 12 of 1924 ›

In addition to the objections mentioned by the Minister there is also the fact that this Amendment would mean the setting up of a third panel, from which the chairman would be selected. Already there is objection to the two panels. This means the setting up of a third. For that reason I suggest that the amendment should not be pressed. It is really making the amendment that we have already carried more serious, because it again gives power to the Executive Council to appoint a person as chairman without any particular qualifications, with the possibility that the position of chairman may be the reward of political services rendered.

Comment on this

The principle that we are contending against all the time is the baneful one of having any member of this tribunal biassed in a partisan or sectional way. Members of the panel are distinctly selected because of their expert knowledge of some particular branch of industry or commerce, and when you confine the Governor-General, under the advice of the Executive Council, to selecting from the panel to fill a vacancy on the tribunal, you at once get back to this baneful principle again. The Governor-General and the Executive Council are limited in their choice to this panel. Anyone from this panel would be a man representing a distinctive industry or branch of commerce and will not be the sort of man that ought to be selected — a man of wide general experience. All the men on the panels cannot claim to have that. They are not selected and put on the panels because they have that, but because they have a special distinctive knowledge of some particular branch. Outside of that, there is no guarantee that they have any particular knowledge at all. I think this is the easiest way out of the difficulty, although it may not meet the objections of every Senator. In the selection of a member to fill a vacancy, the Governor-General and the Government should be allowed just the same choice as they are allowed in the first instance, and not be confined to the panel. I would suggest that the sub-section should read: "in the case of either of the ordinary members the Governor-General on the advice of the Executive Council may appoint a person to act in his place." He need not necessarily be from the panel, and we have the assurance given through the Minister that such a person will be a person of wide general experience.

Comment on this

I am sorry I do not find myself in agreement with Senator Bennett on this point. We generally do find ourselves in agreement. The Seanad, I think, would be better advised to allow the section to remain as it stands. They have already amended Section 14, and have taken out a very important sub-section, sub-section 3. I am only giving my own view, but it seems to me that it would have been very advisable to have persons of commercial or railway experience upon this panel. However, the Seanad, in the exercise of its discretion, has thrown that out. I do not think it would be wise to leave out the words which it is proposed to omit and which gives the Ministry certain directions in the matter. I do not think it would be any improvement to leave them out. On the contrary, by retaining them, we give the Ministry certain directions and, on the whole, those directions are useful ones. We ought to give them a certain line to follow. This panel, I think, should be constituted from people who know something about what they are entrusted to decide. On the whole, in view of the great care with which this Bill has been drafted in all its details, I think the Seanad would be better advised to allow the words to stand.

Comment on this

I think Senator Bennett has not looked at the first part of this sub-section. It would have been clearer if the word "temporary" had been put in front of the word "vacancy." Later on it says "pending the filling up of such vacancies." That shows that it is only a temporary matter that is being dealt with. The moment it becomes permanent what the Seanad has already decided comes into operation. A permanent member will be appointed the moment the vacancy becomes permanent. Therefore the Executive Council must appoint somebody under Section 14 without any restriction. It would seem the wise thing, and I think in view of what the Minister has said, it would be wrong to reject his advice.

There is a panel of sixteen persons selected from various lines of life, and undoubtedly they will be selected as being good men. To go outside that panel in the filling of a temporary vacancy would be wrong. In dealing with a temporary matter of this sort I cannot see why the Executive should be forced to put on a man who had nothing whatever to do with the general panels. I would be inclined to take the Minister's advice and leave the section as it is and let the temporary vacancies be filled by men specially selected.

Comment on this

I must have been misinterpreted. My suggestion was that the men for temporary vacancies would be selected from the panels and not from outside. What I would like is that the Governor-General could appoint a member from the panels. Senator O'Farrell suggested that the appointment of the chairman would create a difficulty. The chairman is not mentioned in the amendment at all. He is appointed under another category. I want to ensure that in the selection of men from the panel what we objected to this morning should not be continued. We objected to a man being labelled a lawyer, a railway man or a commercial man. I want to present a condition of things that to my mind is stereotyped by the section. This amendment proposes to delete the words "according to the qualification of the ordinary member in question." Ordinary members are to be selected, I take it, because of their wide knowledge and because of their capacity for sifting evidence, and acting in a judicial capacity. After all, I take it that those selected by the Ministry will be men of wide knowledge. It is not because a man is a commercial man, a railway man, a farmer or a labourer that he is not a man of diversified views. If not, he has no reason to be on the panel at all. When one of the members of the panel is ill, what I suggest is that a member selected may be a person outside the panel. It may be that when the railways are electrified he will be an electrician, and I want to secure freedom for the Government to select a man in his place from the panel, if necessary. I do not think anything that has been urged would make me change my views or withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I may be wrong, but as far as I can see as this section stands there is no qualification for the person to be appointed as temporary chairman.

Comment on this

I am not alluding to him. I am only dealing with ordinary panel members and I want to have them taken from the panel. In the first instance it is objectionable that the chairman can be brought from anywhere.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not know if I quite understood the Senator to say that it is objectionable that the chairman might be brought from anywhere. In order to meet that object he proposes that the additional members might be brought from anywhere.

Comment on this

I am not alluding to the chairman; I am dealing with sub-section (b), dealing with the filling of ordinary vacancies.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I am quite clear as to the purpose of the amendment, but it was while the Senator was moving the amendment I though I caught some words used by the Senator.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think that I am responsible.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I thought I caught the phrase that it was objectionable that the temporary chairman should be drawn from anywhere.

Comment on this

I never said anything of the kind.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I withdraw. I misinterpreted the Senator's remark. The purpose of the amendment is to leave out all the words after "general panel" in line 39, and that the Executive Council are left to advise the Governor-General with regard to the man who is to be a member of the panel. Am I to take it that that means he is a member of either panel referred to in Section 17 of the general panel or of the railway and canal panel? I am speaking now rather in answer to Senator O'Farrell's objection, as he seemed to think a third panel as distinct from panels (a) and (b) would have to be appointed. The Senator himself told us that he meant a member of either panel and simply to omit that the selection is to be according to the qualification of the ordinary member in question. I urge the Seanad not to omit these words as I previously urged against the omission of sub-section 3 of Section 14. I thought I had detected signs of repentance amongst Senators for omitting sub-section 3. I thought it well to stress that so that I might now get Senators' minds into a proper state to accept an amendment later on and reinstate sub-section 3 of Section 14. I think it would be very desirable to do so. My remarks are really consequential upon that amendment and I would like to think that I would be able to get the Seanad to accept that view. I think it is advisable that definite instructions to the Executive Council should be laid down in the Bill with regard to the qualifications of the two members of the tribunal and with regard to temporary appointments to temporary vacancies.

Comment on this

Are we to understand the amendment moved by Senator Bennett will leave the section as it was except that the man to be appointed need have no qualifications? In other words, he may be the most unsuitable man on either panel. He says the effect of this amendment would be that the appointment would be made from a general panel or from the railway and canal panel. He objects to the last words of the sub-section "according to the qualification of the ordinary member in question," which has for its object to see that the man shall have some qualification for the job. I do not think we should accept the amendment on that ground. I think the ordinary man will understand it to mean that he is to be selected from a panel. There is nothing following to state that that panel shall be the general panel or the railway and canal panel. I think a consequential amendment would be required to explain that.

Comment on this

My original amendment was to delete all words after the word "general panel" in line 39, and the Cathaoirleach suggested that I should have deleted all words after "place." If that is accepted I am satisfied.

Comment on this

Is this an amended amendment?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

This is suggested now.

Comment on this

The area of choice for the Government is confined to two panels, and on these panels you have men appointed for their specific knowledge of commerce, industry, labour, railway passengers, agriculture, fisheries, railways and canals. Obviously when the Government come to fill a vacancy, confined as they are to members of the panel, they are up against this, that all those interests represented on the panel feel that their particular interest is dominant. The Government will find themselves in this position, that no matter how well disposed they may be when they make a selection there will be a feeling that one particular interest is primarily represented to the exclusion of the others. The Government will be in the position that the other interests will have more or less of a grievance, and they will want to know why a representative of a particular interest was selected. As was stated, it may be that by eliminating the panel altogether you eliminate the best men. It may be that it will be recognised that on these panels there are one or two men of outstanding general experience, apart from the particular interest they represent. It would be a difficult thing to exclude the Governor-General's choice of such a man. Nobody, I think, suggests doing away with the panels entirely. My suggestion is that the Governor-General, on the advice of the Executive Council, should be at liberty to appoint a person to fill the vacancy. Such a person might or might not be on the panel.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

And leave out all about a person so appointed.

Comment on this

He may or he may not be on the panel.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Are you proposing that as an amendment?

Comment on this

I am, if I am in order.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce is the first Minister to come to this House and ask that the Seanad should apply some rules to his conduct. Unlike other Ministers, he thinks it important that he should have some instructions from the Seanad as to what he is to do, and I agree with that.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Of course my remarks apply equally to my successor. I am not so confident that I require all these checks upon myself. With regard to Senator Guinness's proposal, I remember reading somewhere, I believe it was in "Alice in Wonderland," where certain intricate machinery in a watch was being lubricated; I think butter was put into the works, and when it was pointed out that it was not suitable, the answer was given. "Yes, but it is the best butter." Senator Guinness's amendment would be to the same effect — let us have something that might be a lubricant, but do not insist on qualifications, and that is proposed as a serious amendment.

Comment on this

Make it the second panel then.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The proposal, then, is to omit the words "according to the qualification of the ordinary member in question."

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Before I come to Sir John Keane's amendment I wish again to ask Senators when going through these sections to follow their own amendments, and to rise when they realise that the time is reached for them. I have passed over quite unintentionally an amendment by Senator Counihan to the earlier part of this section. I do not know whether he wishes to move it or not.

Comment on this

Yes. Senator Keane rose to get an explanation from the Minister at the time, and the discussion has been carried on since. I move:—

Section 17, sub-section (1), page 11, line 6, to insert after the word "interests" the words "(of whom two shall be representatives of live stock interests)."

My proposal is that two members of the live stock trade should be nominated on this panel. This panel is to be nominated by the Minister for Lands and Agriculture. It is supposed to consist of agriculturists, and as the live stock trade is a most important branch of agriculture I am sure it is not unreasonable to ask for two representatives. We pay the greatest amount of freights to the railway companies, the most remunerative portion of their receipts, but there are other considerations which make us anxious to have these two representatives on this panel. Applications would come before the railway tribunal to get facilities for loading stocks at several of the loading banks. In a good many of the stations the facilities are very bad, indeed, and an ordinary agriculturist would not understand so well about the working of the live stock trade. No matter how well intentioned he would be, he would not be able to have the same interest in the trade, or the same knowledge, as a member who had practical experience of the work. I am sure the Minister will accept that. In discussing it with the Minister for Lands and Agriculture he said: "Why should we ask for two representatives of the live stock industry, as there would be a representation of four agriculturists on the panel, and we might possibly have four." I said I am satisfied to have two, and to have that inserted in the Bill.

Comment on this

Might I ask whether the four persons in this section who are to be appointed after consultation with the Minister for Lands and Agriculture would not represent agricultural interests? The section says: "being representative of agricultural interests"; would that not cover the case of the cattle trade?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You do not quite follow, Senator Esmonde, what the proposal is. It is quite plain that the four persons are to be persons identified with agriculture and the Senator's amendment is to provide that at least two of them should be identified with that particular branch of agriculture, the cattle trade.

Comment on this

That is a point the Senator did not explain. I was not quite sure whether he meant to delete the two members of the fishery industry in favour of agriculture.

Comment on this

It has nothing to do with the fishing industry at all.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I have two objections to this amendment. The first is that live stock is included in agricultural interests, the second is that the representation claimed seems to be out of proportion to the importance of the live stock trade. The Minister for Lands and Agriculture might think otherwise; if so, he will have the controlling voice.

Comment on this

In point of fact there is no farmer who could not claim that he might be described as a person who could look after the live stock interests, even though he is not engaged in the cattle trade. I think the term means very little.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I move: "To delete sub-sections (4), (5), and (6), and substitute:—"The railway tribunal on application by any parties or otherwise may call in such members of the panels as they think fit, who possess technical knowledge of the case, to act as assessors in any particular case or proceedings under Part III. of this Act." I put forward that amendment first of all on the principle that we want to preserve the judicial aspect of the tribunal. I can conceive no arrangement better calculated to serve that end than this Box and Cox arrangement of determining a case. You bring two people in one case, and in another case you bring in perhaps two other people, and give them practically judicial powers, the power to vote and the other ordinary powers of the tribunal. I do not see how you will get a judicial detachment of mind by an arrangement of that kind. The object of the panel surely would be to give leave to the members of the tribunal to have such technical opinion given them in a difficult case. Of course they will get the technical arguments from counsel and others appearing, and when they are consulting in private the technical knowledge should be provided by the interest affected. That to my mind would be the best way of associating with the tribunal the gentlemen from the panel in the capacity of assessors. Furthermore, how is the tribunal going to meet the case satisfactorily if it is limited to two additional members. If you have a question relating to classification, that cannot be satisfactorily met by bringing in two additional members only. I do not know that that covers the whole range of the public interest on a matter of that kind. If you are going to admit agriculture you are not going to do justice to commerce, and other interests, and in any general question more than one interest could and must always be affected, and only one interest is allowed representation in the capacity of additional members. I submit it would be more business-like, and would generally lead to a more efficient working of the Act, if the tribunal were allowed to call in any number of people from the panel qualified to advise them in the capacity of assessors, and who would be associated with them all the time, except that they will not have the right of voting.

Comment on this

On a point of procedure, may I suggest that this is a very important amendment, and radically affecting the tribunal, and as no previous notice has been given of it, that it should be held over for the Report Stage. This is a technical matter, and as many members of the Seanad have not themselves the advantage of technical knowledge some little time is necessary to enable them to make up their minds.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I am quite satisfied, especially as the House knows my views.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I suggest to the Minister, and to all parties concerned, that we would get on quicker if this whole section would be allowed to stand over for the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Does the amendment proposed by Senator Sir John Keane take the place of the whole section?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Not at all; only sub-sections (4) and (6) of Section 17. It does not necessarily interfere with sub-section (5).

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

Sub-section (6) makes provision for additional members.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

It would not get rid of sub-section (6) if you only alter it to "any person appointed under this section to be an assessor." You would have to define the functions of the assessor in a new clause. However, that is a matter for the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I think you would have to define what is meant by an assessor. It may have many meanings according to the thing contemplated.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The word "assessor" has a legal meaning. It is quite a common thing in practice. The Court of Admiralty, for example, have assessors, and under the Lands Clauses Act an assessor may be called in. The position of the assessor is well recognised, I mean in legal phraseology.

Comment on this

May I point out that this matter may have to be handled with some care, for I take it these assessors will be paid, and, therefore, it may mean we will have to have a new Money Resolution on which to pass an amendment.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I do not think a new Money Resolution would be required, because the panel members are to be paid.

Comment on this

As I understand, these assessors are not to be panel members.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If I might say a word on the general proposition, even if this amendment were left over for Report, I am very glad that this discussion has taken place, for I find a section subjected to a certain amount of criticism, and that it requires drastic revision, but the revision now proposed would make confusion worse confounded. This proposal is to take the place of sub-sections (4), (5) and (6).

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

No, only sub-sections (4) and (6).

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I had (5) in, but as advised by you (5) stands.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes, (5) has reference only to the temporary chairman, or temporary member of the railway tribunal. These will require remuneration. That remuneration would disappear if sub-section (5) were omitted. That removes one objection I had. The whole proposal leaves the matter very vague and very loose—that the railway tribunal may call in additional members without limit. You may have a panel, or additional assessors to the number of 5 or 500. It is not likely you will have them all.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

You cannot exceed the number of the panel. The panel is limited to 16 in all.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I did not know we were confined to the panel.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The amendment says "may call on such members of the panel."

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

You would then have a number limited to sixteen. In a House which has apparently made up its mind that a conflict of interests is to be avoided, you are going to have all the different interests brought in— agriculture, fisheries, etc. All may be brought in as assessors, and it is urged in favour of the assessors, as opposed to making them definitely members of the tribunal, that they will be in a better position to give information from within than they might as expert witnesses attending the tribunal. It has been thought that men who have interests and who are desirous of attending, might give expert evidence, and it was thought better to bring in two men, one representing the railway users, if not a particular interest, and the other representing the railway, not the user, but having some advertence to those interests. There would be that balance and that would give these men responsibility and increase the value of this advice by putting upon them the onus of voting to help to decide the question. A lot of objections have been raised; one raised by An Cathaoirleach would mean, if it were possible to suggest that it could come from such a source, that it has been raised for difficulty's sake; that a technical matter may arise, and it was suggested you may appoint a man without knowing what the technical matter is likely to be. That, of course, will not arise. An application will be made, some application involving a technical difficulty. That difficulty will be considered, and having considered the difficulty, the appointment will be made. It was represented that this was a clumsy and amateurish piece of work coming from the Dáil. This section has been taken from the British Railway Act of 1921, and in England no difficulty has been found in carrying out the provisions. It is taken line for line, and almost word for word, with a few necessary changes.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Can the Minister say that it has ever been enforced? I am informed it has not, that it has never been found possible to enforce it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I understood it was operative.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

It is operative, but has it been ever put into practice?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I understood it was. Certain difficulties may arise, but I do not want to have it represented that this is a provision springing from the brain of any official in my Department or any Government Department, and that it is an entirely new and novel procedure. It is entirely taken from this Act, and, as I understood, it had worked. Sub-section 4 is perfectly simple. Either on application made by any of the parties or otherwise, or if the Minister thinks it expedient, there shall be appointed in a very definite way by the Governor-General on the advice of the Executive Council from the panel two additional members of the tribunal for a particular purpose. I do not think anything could be more simple. The Executive Council, or rather the Governor-General appoints, on the advice of the Executive Council. That advice can be given if the Minister thinks it expedient or if the Railway Company request it or on application made or without application made. The question has been raised that the Minister may think it expedient in defiance of the railway tribunal. There is nothing here to hold the Minister from thinking it expedient. I take it he has that power. The Minister may advert to the fact that the application has been made and has been refused. and may override the refusal and request the Executive Council to advise the Governor-General to appoint members. I consider the section a very clear one. It has worked, so far, in practice in England. It is taken definitely from a serious piece of legislation in another House by people who have greater railway interests than we have. It is urged that it should be left open until the Report Stage, but unless some indication is given to me of what is desired I do not think it can be accepted. The question has been raised as to whether or not Section 16 requires members of the railway tribunal not to hold shares in any transit company and whether that is an obligation on temporary members. We have been advised that a standing member could not be held to be a temporary appointee. That is a point that can be made quite clear on Report Stage.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I am very anxious that this should be made as clear as possible, and as your draft stands at present, I am quite satisfied that the words, "subject to the provisions of this part of this Act," would make Section 16 apply to these temporary members, and they would have to get rid of their shares.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is a very definite objection, and that can be removed by a definite amendment on the Report Stage. The other point is more vague and more indefinite, and as far as I am concerned I could not make any move towards amending sub-section (4) in the way suggested, because I think it would not improve the section.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I had better put the amendment.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

Are you not leaving it over to the Report Stage?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If the Seanad prefers, I would leave it to a decision of the Seanad, or defer it to the Report Stage.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I would rather leave it over till the Report Stage, but I am afraid I cannot do so without the permission of the House.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I had better put the amendment, and you can renew it on the Report Stage if you wish.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

As the amendment is being put, I wish again to emphasise it is a negation of the proper functions of a judicial tribunal to have members going in and out in a particular case and having the full powers of voting. I say that these members who have the power of voting should not be allowed to have any shares in any undertaking of the kind or to have any financial interest in a matter on which they vote. I understand that is what is contemplated when you say you shall not force additional members to get rid of any interest they may hold in the company. For all these reasons I think it is eminently reasonable that the tribunal should be a strictly judicial one and that no additional members should be appointed.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

In answer to that it may be a slight negation from the point of view of the ordinary judicial tribunal that members may go in and out on separate points, but there is a bigger negation that seems to be implied by Senator Sir John Keane's interpretation of the functions of the additional members of the tribunal. The Senator seems to regard them, irrespective of anything put before them, voting on their sectional interests only. We intend to get much more responsible men than people who will act in that way.

Comment on this

Are you going to take a vote on the amendment now, sir? The Minister has said we are throwing aspersions on the Dáil, but really all that has happened here is to show that we are not big enough to swallow this and see how it is going to act. I am still in that stage, and I do see a great difficulty in the working of this section. You select a man because he is representing a certain interest and you make him judge of cases concerned with that particular interest and put him on the bench, and yet he is to forget all about that interest and to act as if he had nothing to do with it. Personally I believe we would be far better off in the hands of the tribunal of three. The only value of the technical knowledge of an additional member would be to bring the whole of his technical knowledge before the tribunal, and how he could do that and sit on the bench I am at a loss to understand. If we could get a little more time to think it over we would be in a much better position to deal with it.

Comment on this

The section as it stands says that the person selected shall be conversant with and have knowledge of the technical matter that may arise. I think you will find it almost impossible to segregate the interests involved in certain questions that will come before this tribunal. It will be very hard to discover and define a dividing line between the commercial and the industrial aspects of the question and the agricultural aspects, between the manufacturing aspect and the labour aspect, and it will be a matter then of giving some predominant advantage to one particular party on a question of that sort where it is very hard to discover which interest is most deeply involved. Whereas at the outset one interest may seem to be more deeply involved than another, in the ultimate unravelling of it, we may find that another will entirely dominate the situation. Still you have one man appointed, and he must sit there when the question has largely got out of his hands from his point of view. Another thing is that you have no manufacturing interest represented on the panel at all. You have a commercial and industrial interest, which is nearest to the manufacturing interest, but I think the manufacturing interest is worthy of consideration by itself. On the panel I find that all interests representing commerce, industry, labour and agriculture are provided for, and manufacturers in this country have no representation at all.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Would you not think they came within the category of "industrial"?

Comment on this

That is the nearest to it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The point regarding shares might stand over for report.

Comment on this

I move to delete the sub-section. In my opinion this sub-section is inconsistent with Section 22 of the Bill. The proposal as it now stands is that the railway tribunal shall have full powers above the law, and that there shall be no appeal either on question of law or fact from its decision. Section 22 seems to say something to the contrary. I do not know whether legal men will adopt that way of reading these two sections, but to the ordinary laymen it seems that they are contrary to one another.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

There is no contradiction between them. This Section 18 gives the railway tribunal power and jurisdiction to hear and determine all cases. It does not say they would not be subject to appeal, but it goes on to say that in exercising the powers conferred upon them they cannot be restrained by another court nor their proceedings removed by certiorari. But later on you will see that the section says that their decisions on questions of law are capable of being reviewed by the court of appeal. That is not inconsistent—it is a little complicated, but there is no inconsistency.

Comment on this

So long as I have the assurance that there is an appeal on a question of law I am quite satisfied.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I would like to call the attention on this matter to Section 22, which says: "No appeal shall lie from any order made by the railway tribunal in exercise of any jurisdiction conferred on them by Part I of this Act."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I was dealing with their decisions under Part 3, on questions of law. Senator O'Farrell was right in saying there is no appeal under Part I, but under Part III there is an appeal provided on questions of law.

Comment on this

My contention is that in questions of law, whether with regard to Part 3 or Part I, there should be an appeal.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That is not required, because Section 22 excludes an appeal in cases under Part I.

Comment on this

After all, the right of appeal is one of the great safeguards of judicial efficiency. It ensures respect for judicial decisions, and the confidence of the ordinary citizen in the administration of the law. If we set aside this appeal and this safeguard I am afraid we will be setting a very dangerous precedent. I think it is only right that nobody except the highest court in the land should be exempt from appeal. The orders of every court should be restrained by that of the highest court in the land. This railway tribunal, prior to the deletion of sub-section (3) of Section 14, which might be reinstated, was to be composed of one legal gentleman, the Chairman and two non-legal gentlemen. The decision of the court was to be by a majority, and the minority is not to express a reason for dissenting. It is possible that the non-legal representatives on that tribunal might overrule the legal representative upon any of the matters in Part I of this Bill. Nevertheless, on the question of law there is to be no appeal from that decision. I quite admit there should be no appeal on a question of fact, but on a question of law, I certainly think, they should not be turned into a supreme court as they are in respect of this Bill. After all, their work in respect of amalgamation is really private Bill legislation work. It is extremely important work, and has the effect of legislation, and I suggest it is a very serious proposition to make that the Supreme Court, even in a question of law, are to be deprived of reviewing their judgment. There should be an appeal to the Supreme Court in order to remedy any abuse or the use of excessive powers or branch of the law which might be permitted by these non-legal representatives on this tribunal.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Senator has made a very eloquent speech on Section 22, but he was supposed to be speaking on sub-section (1) of Section 18. That sub-section says that the railway tribunal shall have full power and jurisdiction to hear and determine all matters, whether of law or fact, etc., and it is proposed seriously by the Senator to delete that sub-section, that is to say, to delete the railway tribunal. That is the full effect of it.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think the Minister is right. Senator O'Farrell's amendment would be quite in order on Section 22, but if he moves it now it would deprive the tribunal of any legal status whatever.

Comment on this

I had an amendment to Section 22, and it is quite possible that they may have got mixed up.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You will be quite safe in waiting until we have come to Section 22. I take it that you are not now proposing any amendment to Section 18.

Comment on this

I beg to move, immediately before Sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(2) The railway tribunal or person holding an inquiry for the purposes of Part I. of this Act shall take into consideration all objections to an amalgamation, absorption or preliminary scheme, or in respect of the subject matter of the inquiry, which may have been lodged by any person or class or body of persons within the prescribed time and in the prescribed manner and, where any objections have been so lodged, shall hear any objectors."

The powers to be given to the tribunal in respect of the amalgamation and absorption schemes will be very great. They constitute a considerable interference with private interests, and therefore every person concerned—share-holders whose financial interests are directly affected by the Bill, railway employees who are directly mentioned in the Bill (Sections 4 (d) and (e) and 6 (e) and (f)—should have a right to come to the tribunal to protect their position. Moreover, Section 9 (3) of the Bill provides that the schemes, when confirmed and settled by the tribunal, should have the effect of an Act of the Oireachtas, and therefore it is of the utmost importance that everything should be done correctly, and that every interest concerned should be entitled to appear before the tribunal, before the rights it now owns, or which are given to it or preserved by the Bill, are precluded. The freest access to the railways amalgamation tribunal was afforded under the British Railways Act, and this proposed new sub-section is a reproduction of Section 9 (6) of the British Railways Act. The sub-section in the British Railways Act worked very well in practice, and gave great satisfaction to all parties. It will be observed that Section 65 (2) limits the classes of persons who may appear before the tribunal, and although Section 65 is undoubtedly meant to refer to appearances in relation to questions affecting rates and charges, its terms do in fact apply to matters coming within the scope of Part I. of the Act.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

Is the Senator allowed to read from a brief, as I respectfully suggest Senator Farren is doing?

Comment on this

With all respect I submit the same objection has not been made to other members of the House when they read their speeches.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

It is an objection that is capable of being raised, but the Chairman has always some difficulty in seeing it.

Comment on this

I did not object, and I did not see objection taken in other cases. I have a distinct recollection that other members of this House have repeatedly done the same thing, and I have never seen objection raised. It all depends upon the class of member who reads his speech. This is a very technical matter that we are dealing with here, and people without technical knowledge on the subject have to be very careful of what they are going to say. I think it is unfair to take objection to a person reading what he has committed to paper on these matters. However, I will read no more, but I will take very good care no other Senator will, either. The substance of my amendment is that under Part I of the Bill when the tribunal is considering questions arising out of amalgamation or absorption persons who are concerned shall get the opportunity of appearing and stating their case, and I hope the Minister will accept my amendment to that effect.

Comment on this

I do not know whether the Senator has read sub-section (d) of Section 19, because I think that meets the purpose of the amendment: "the right of audience before the tribunal provided that any party shall be entitled to be heard in person or by a representative in the regular employment of the party duly authorised in writing, or by counsel or solicitor." I do not think the amendment is necessary.

Comment on this

Sub-section (d) seems to me to be somewhat vague. There is a provision providing that anybody is entitled to be present. Who is to decide as to the wording of the provision?

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

If this amendment was passed would it not be tantamount to restoring an amendment which the Seanad rejected earlier in the day? Would not the question of the arrangement between stockholders be liable to review, and to that extent I ask is the amendment in order if it would have the effect of restoring an amendment which the Seanad previously rejected?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

As it stands at present I think it is open to that objection.

Comment on this

Might we have an expression of opinion as to whether the point made by Senator Sir T. Esmonde is not right? Does not Section 19 (d) cover the point made by the mover of the amendment?

Comment on this

The section says: "The railway tribunal may, with the approval of the Minister and the Chief Justice, make general rules governing their procedure and practice." and so on. You will observe it says "may make rules."

Comment on this

They cannot make any rule which would prevent a party from being heard in person. That is what I take sub-section (d) to mean.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The obligation is cast upon the tribunal to make rules. In that case the word "may" means "shall." The obligation is there. They must make the rules. I think that would be the effect of the section as it stands. Where it says that they are to make rules it gives in (d) "the right of audience before the tribunal" provided always that any party shall be entitled to be heard in person. There is to be a right of audience. That is to say, whether they make rules or not the right of audience is there.

Comment on this

If you would take sub-section (1) and read the last two lines, and read it in connection with the sub-clause (d), does it not show that it is not compulsory upon the tribunal to make rules providing for the right of audience, but they may make them?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Neither is it necessary or compulsory that they should make rules providing for the number to form a quorum, but they are all absolutely necessary rules, and they are things which must be provided for. It has been put up to me that the word "may" in this connection has the effect of "shall."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

This, I take it, is a case where "may" means "shall." If you look up the sub-section (d), which reads "the right of audience before the tribunal, provided that any party shall be entitled to be heard in person or by a representative in the regular employment of the party duly authorised in writing or by counsel or by solicitor" you will find the meaning of that is that they may make rules. That is not a matter of what they put in their rules. They can put nothing in their rules that will deprive a party of their rights to be heard in person. That is limited in respect to the things they are entitled to go into. But it does not extend the powers of jurisdiction of the tribunal to any of the matters over which they have not jurisdiction. This section confers the absolute right of the objector to be heard in person.

Comment on this

Would not "providing" be better than "provided"?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

No, that would spoil the effect of the whole thing. The object of sub-section (d) is that, amongst the other things which they are to provide, are rules regulating the right of audience, but no rules regulating the right of audience can deprive a party of the right to be heard in person.

Comment on this

In view of your interpretation, which gives all I want to get, I am satisfied to withdraw it.

Comment on this

I beg to move:

Immediately before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section (4) as follows:—

"(4) The proceedings before the railway tribunal shall be officially reported and verbatim reports thereof shall be printed, numbered, published and sold, and may be cited in the like manner as statutory rules are for the time being by law required to be printed, numbered, published and sold, and permitted to be cited.”

A similar amendment to this was moved in the Dáil, and there was a considerable amount of discussion over it. Some concession was given on the part of the Minister that some particular cases, very important cases, would be reported and the evidence printed. I wish to point out that there is a necessity for the business coming before the tribunal to be printed, so as to give the people of the country an opportunity of understanding the manner in which the railway administration in this country is carried out, and to educate and assist the public throughout the country, who are absolutely ignorant of how railway matters are managed.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The amendment does not say who is to pay for this.

Comment on this

I take it, it was the people who would pay for the special cases who would also pay for the complete report.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

But that might run into an enormous sum of money. Investigations before these tribunals very often run into a week or two.

Comment on this

I take it that some record has to be taken and kept, and surely the publication of a few extra documents would not cost such an enormous lot. In any case the document has to be printed and a record kept of the proceedings. It would only mean possibly a few hundred copies being printed, and I take it that that would not give a great deal of extra labour or expense.

Comment on this

I am afraid that this would add very considerably to the expense. The Senator thinks 200 copies would be sufficient. I doubt very much if he could state the number interested in the proceedings, but I think the edition would run into a thousand. Now, if it is a case in which public interest is taken, or if there is sufficiently large public interest taken in it, you may be quite certain that the daily papers would report it fully enough. It would be hard to saddle the railway companies with what may amount to a very considerable cost, and for no real purpose.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

This amendment, if accepted, would amount to the publication of not merely pivotal decisions, that is, decisions which are of interest, but every decision which is merely a repeat decision of previous cases. All these would have to be reported verbatim, and the tribunal reports printed and sold. There would be no return to the public adequate to the cost. It is noted that this goes far beyond the procedure in the ordinary courts of law. There, decisions are not compulsorily published. I think that matter was taken up by a Committee of the Benchers in the Law Society. The future of law reporting in the country is still undecided. When this amendment was introduced into the Dáil we did meet it by inserting in Section 19 (4) the words, "including reports of such of the cases heard and decided by them as appear to be of permanent or special importance." That was put in to meet this amendment, and I think it goes as far as necessary. There are some reasons why expense should be incurred for the publication of these special cases of importance, but there is no reason why expense should be incurred in publishing reports of all cases.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

To delete all after the word "tribunal" in line 26, to the end of the sub-section."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You wish to put it rather in the affirmative way —an appeal on questions of law shall exist under this Act, and is not limited to Part 3.

Comment on this

I am afraid that I bungled my amendment in this respect, and with the permission of the Seanad, I will withdraw it until the Report Stage.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If I might get an indication from Senator O'Farrell as to what he intends to move on Report, it might help—is it that there shall be an appeal in Part I. in matters of law?

Comment on this

I wish to propose:

To delete the section and to substitute the following new section therefor:—

"24.—(1) The charges of the amalgamating and absorbed companies shall be those in force on the first day of January, 1915, plus seventy-five per cent., which charges shall remain in force as maximum charges unless and until altered in accordance with this part of this Act.

(2) In all cases in which through rates are in force between stations in the Saorstát and stations outside the Saorstát, the rate from the frontier station to the inland station shall not be greater than what the company gets as its proportion of the through rate."

I do that for the purpose of putting the onus on the company instead of putting the onus on the trader. The charges as compared with pre-war have increased very much. The onus is put on the trader in this Bill, and the process of ascertaining the standard will be a very expensive proceeding. I submit that that expense should be put on the companies. The charges in a good many cases where the mileage is less than fifty are not very much greater than 75 per cent. or 100 per cent. over pre-war, because of the competition by motor lorries, which has induced the companies to reduce their charges for short distances. Long distance charges are not reduced. One would think in some cases that rates are being put up to prevent any stuff being sent by train. The rates from Dundalk to Cork in 1914 were 20s. a ton. Now they are 52s. 6d. The rate from Dundalk to Skibbereen in 1914 was 32s. 11d.; now it is 92s. 1d. The rates from Dundalk to Enniscorthy in 1914 were 16s. 8d. per ton; now they are 57s. 11d. That is an increase of over 250 per cent. The effect of that is that there is no traffic moved long distances by train. What happens is that the traffic will be sent from Belfast to the nearest place by water and then taken by motor lorry to the purchaser. I think the effect of my amendment is not so much to reduce the revenues of the railways but to put the onus on them to show that they are charging reasonable rates.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The first part of the amendment deals with the question of the charges for rates, and the Senator has fortified his amendments by a statement that the onus is, by the Bill, thrown on the trader to make a case for the reduction. That is not quite accurate. Section 25 deals definitely with that. That means this: There was a general percentage increase in 1920. That increase was based on certain conditions which are no longer operative. The railway tribunal is here given an instruction that it shall, within three months after the passing of the Act, review the present charges with a view to their modification on the basis of that general percentage increase of 1920. Under Section 25 the Government will look to get a considerable decrease in the rates and charges at present operative. So that the onus is not on the trader. This amendment, if accepted, would cut right across the main principle of the Bill, at least one of the main principles, that with reference to the standard revenue. The standard revenue is secured to the proprietors of the undertakings to be amalgamated. This would mean that, whether or not the standard revenue can be guaranteed to them, the rates must come down to a certain point, namely, 75 per cent. on the charges in force on the 1st January, 1915. That is to say, an allowance of 75 per cent. above the pre-control rate, whether or not that would prejudice the standard revenue. The effect would be that it would cut across one of the main principles of the Bill. The onus is not entirely on the traders. The onus is first on the railway tribunal. It is mandatory on the tribunal to revise the rates, taking into consideration the way in which the rates were increased in 1920.

Comment on this

I believe the onus is still on the traders. The tribunal is supposed to revise the rates, but I do not think they will go over every rate at present in existence unless they are induced to do that by the traders. I consider that 75 per cent. over the pre-war rate is a reasonable rate, considering that 75 per cent. is the standard rate in Northern Ireland, and 50 per cent. is the standard rate in England. At present our rate from Dundalk to Hull, which means rail from Dundalk to Greenore, a sea passage from Greenore to Holyhead, and rail from Holyhead to Hull, is 24s. 6d. as against 77s. 6d. from Dundalk to Cork. The thing is absurd, and I will have to take the feelings of the Seanad on the matter.

Comment on this

I think it would be well for the Seanad to reflect on the seriousness of the effect of the amendment. I suggest that it is farcical to be legislating for the setting up of a very important tribunal to deal with very important, difficult and technical questions, and for the Seanad to say that one of the principal pieces of work which that tribunal should do should be done for them by the Seanad, without considering the very serious issues which ought to be considered before a step of that kind is taken. This amendment suggests that the Seanad should do the work of the tribunal, and I suggest that the Seanad is not properly qualified to do it.

Comment on this

I wish to support the amendment. It is quite impossible for manufacturers and traders to continue paying indefinitely railway rates 150 per cent. over pre-war. It is out of the question. Our chief competitors are principally North of Ireland people. How does the Government expect manufacturers and traders to pay a penalty of 75 per cent. over and above the charges in the Six County area? There may be some way of doing it, but I am a long time trying to find it out. Freight is a very large item in the cost of production. I have yet to learn how these freights can be paid and how manufacturers and traders can pay their way. We are quite prepared to give the Minister reasonable time. If he wants three or six months we are willing to give him that time, but we want some definite promise that the railway rates will come down. They are nearly altogether responsible for the high cost of living to-day. They are also responsible for unemployment. Manufacturers could do a great deal more business and increase their output and turn-over if they had any reasonable means of distributing their manufactures, which they have not at present. We do not want to press this amendment unduly if we get some definite promise from the Minister that the whole subject will be looked into immediately. Things cannot go on as they are going. If the Minister tells us that he cannot do anything for the next six months, we will have to put motor traction into operation. We will have to increase and expand motor services, which will mean that business will be taken from the railway companies. At present we are in a very peculiar position. We have to live and we must defend ourselves as best we can. If there is not some definite promise made by the Minister the only way we can defend ourselves is by organising motor services, and that we certainly will do.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I remember when I was in London being asked one day by a harassed tradesman if I could guarantee the stability of the Irish Free State to the extent of £200,000. As my monthly salary at that time was about £30, and I had half of it expended, I felt I could give him the guarantee without feeling that I was giving away much. I am asked now to give an assurance about a reduction of rates. An assurance from me is no good. I have inserted a section in this Bill providing that on a date not later than three months after its passing the railway tribunal shall review the existing charges with a view to the modification of such charges, having regard to the circumstances in which the increased charges were authorised as from the 1st September, 1920. The circumstances were these. A deficit was accruing and had accrued. To make up for that deficit, accruing over a period of 16 months, charges were allowed which in 11 months would make up for these arrears. The basis of the 1920 Percentage Order was that by charges operating for a period of 11 months there should be made up and wiped out arrears accumulating over a period of 15 or 16 months. That is the basis of the present charges. Obviously that is a wrong basis. These charges can no longer continue, and we have given the tribunal in this Bill an order to review the charges, having regard to the circumstances under which the increased charges were authorised on the 1st September, 1920. I think that is considerably better than any assurance I might light-heartedly give here that the rates are going to come down. We put it to the tribunal to see that they do come down. I join with Senator Bagwell in appealing to the Seanad not, in a light-hearted way, to put a limit to the efforts of the tribunal and decide beforehand what should be left to the expert tribunal to decide.

Comment on this

In view of the discussion which has taken place, I desire to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I beg to move:

(2) In all cases in which through rates are in force between stations in the Saorstát and stations outside the Saorstát, the rate from the frontier station to the inland station shall not be greater than what the company gets as its proportion of the through rate.

This question of through rates is a grievance that the manufacturers have had to contend with for a number of years, as the railways in Ireland carry foreign manufactured goods cheaper than Irish manufactured ones. The object of the amendment is to give a direction to the tribunal that that will be put a stop to. I will give an illustration of it. There is a through rate from Liverpool to Ballinamore for bread stuffs coming through Dundalk of 26s. The Great Northern Railway charge 20s. 8d. from Dundalk to Ballinamore. I do not know what the proportion of the rate is from Liverpool to Dundalk. I take it that it is half. That means that they get 13s. for carrying bread stuffs from Dundalk to Ballinamore, but for bread stuffs manufactured in Dundalk they want 20s. 8d. There are dozens of such rates operating all over the country. They are designed to facilitate traders and manufacturers outside the Saorstát and prevent trade by merchants and manufacturers inside the Saorstát. We hear a great deal about protection. I am a protectionist myself, but this is the very opposite to protection. It is protecting foreign trade as against the home trade. I hope the tribunal will not allow these through rates to operate in that manner. We do not object to through rates, no matter how low they are, provided the railway company will carry the home produce at the same rate as they carry the foreign produce. If the Minister will assure me that the tribunal will give an early decision in this matter of through rates, I am willing to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not know if the Seanad, after listening to the mover of the amendment, feels competent to go into this very intricate matter of through rates. I spent some three weeks getting a very intensive education in the Dáil with regard to it, and I do not feel at all competent to have anything to say to it. I feel it is a matter for the expert members of the railway tribunal. I would direct attention to Section 29 (2), which reads:—

The railway tribunal shall have power on any representations made to them, whether by the amalgamated company when submitting the schedules of standard charges proposed to be made, or by any party interested, or by the Minister at any time, to determine the amount which the amalgamated company shall contribute to and receive out of any through rate or fare.

The Senator will have a right to attend as well as anyone else to make his representations.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister if there will be any expense connected with persons making representations under the section referred to.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think the Minister could hardly answer because that is left to the tribunal. They are to fix the scale of fees and so forth, but in the case of an individual appearing in person the expenses would be practically nil. I do not think the Minister can give an assurance on that, because it is left by the Bill to the tribunal.

Comment on this

This question of through rates is a very old and a very contentious one. These through rates, particularly those operating from across the Channel, are made in England and are sent to the Irish railway companies for acceptance without option. I do not think that is so in the case of the Midland Great Western Railway, but it applies to the others, and the cost of the service from the port to the interior was invariably one-third less than the same service would be to Dublin, Cork or Limerick. We could never find out exactly how these rates were divided, but whatever they were, the Irish manufacturer or merchant was penalised. If there is any preference to be given, citizens of the Saorstát deserve to get it. It should not be given to goods that are imported into the country. Anything that can be given should not be given to the foreigner. It is exceedingly unjust and unfair to perform certain services for the foreigner to the disadvantage of the home trader. There will never be any development of industry in this country as long as goods are imported cheaper than similar goods manufactured here can be sent to the interior of the country.

Amendment declared lost on a show of hands, 13 voting for, and 17 against.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

Immediately before Section 26 to insert a new Section 26 as follows:—

26.—From and after the passing of this Act every station in the Saorstát where through rates do not now operate shall enjoy the through rates operating from the nearest station to it from which through rates do operate or may subsequently operate, at an addition to such rates not greater than the local rate between the outlying station and the station nearest to it from which through rates operate.

There are many stations in Ireland to which through rates do not operate. If you go to the railway people and ask them for a through rate they will always say, "I will allow you to go into the water when you are able to swim." or, in other words, "when you are able to provide traffic." What happens in that case is that someone finds himself being mulcted by people coming around and buying his goods at half their value. He decides to try other markets. The moment he does so the railway companies set up a regular schedule of rates against him. If he sends goods away he finds that it costs twice as much to market them as it would cost a man who sent them from a station further on, on a through rate. It takes him some time to find out that what he ought to do is to pay the local rate to the other station and rebook from there. It may be inconvenient to do that, and my object is to prevent the railway companies mulcting such people. I believe that if the proposal in this amendment were passed it would be to the advantage of everyone, and would encourage thrift and industry. It would provide an opportunity to producers for having several markets at their service. From long experience I am convinced that this would be a step in the right direction, and I hope it will appeal to the Ministry.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

This is a very desirable amendment, if it were possible to carry out. The only objection I have to it is that it is not possible to carry it out. Through rates are not matters for fixation merely by the Irish railway tribunal. Through rates are a matter of agreement. Another party is interested in a through rate. A through rate does not operate within the territory of the Saorstát. It operates from that territory to some other territory. The whole thing depends upon agreement. We cannot compel the other parties to the agreement to establish through rates.

Comment on this

What I suggest is that the through rates shall be enjoyed from the nearest station plus the local rate to that station.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You propose that the customer shall have the privilege of enjoying the through rate by paying the rate from his own station to the nearest one to which there is a through rate.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If there is an arrangement with an English railway or shipping company for a through rate between Sheffield and Mullingar, and if there is no through rate between Sheffield and Athlone, the Senator's proposal would mean that we should compel the other parties to the agreement with Mullingar to give a similar through rate to Athlone. We cannot do that. We have given the railway tribunal all the powers we think possible under Section 50 (b): "The institution, variation or cancellation of through rates." I do not see what else can be done.

Comment on this

With great respect I am not speaking about a through rate from England to Mullingar. At Dun Laoghaire, if you ask for a through rate to Leicester, they will tell you that they do not possess a through rate, but that they will take the goods in the ordinary way. If you go to Amiens Street they will take the goods at a through rate. The man who takes his goods from Dun Laoghaire to Amiens Street at the local rate and books through from there to Leicester will get them carried at about half the rate charged the man who booked in the ordinary way from Dun Laoghaire. I am satisfied that a man taking goods from Dun Laoghaire to Westland Row or Amiens Street should pay the ordinary fare, but I do not think he should pay twice as much if he booked his goods at Dun Laoghaire as he would pay if he booked them from Amiens Street where there is a through rate.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It may be irritating to the Senator that there is a through rate from Amiens Street and none from Westland Row, but there has been an agreement with other parties, who are necessary parties with regard to the through rate from Amiens Street. There has not been an agreement in the other case, and you cannot compel agreement.

Comment on this

That does not affect the case, as all the man had to do was book his goods by the local rate from Dun Laoghaire to Amiens Street, and rebook them through by the through rate to Leicester.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

As I have said, we cannot compel agreement. We have given the railway tribunal the power and the direction to proceed to enquire into "the institution, variation or cancellation of through rates" and where there are no through rates to see if they can institute them.

A show of hands was taken on the amendment, 16 Senators voting each way.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I confess that I would like to have this amendment examined. I do not see any difficulty about carrying out the proposal of the Senator, and in order to enable the matter to be considered I give my casting vote in favour of the amendment.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

On a point of order, does a casting vote lie where there is a show of hands?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Yes; no division was asked for. I have to do the best I can. No division was challenged and the matter was left in such a way that there was nothing left but to give a casting vote. I do that with the knowledge that the whole matter can be gone into again on the Report Stage.

Sections 26, 27, 28 and 29 ordered to stand part of the Bill.

SECTION 30.

(1) All the terms, conditions and provisions of any statutory enactment or any agreement confirmed by or scheduled to a statutory enactment which, at the passing of this Act, are in force and binding on any amalgamating or absorbed company, by which the forwarding of traffic is affected, or for any other purpose, shall continue in full force and effect, save in so far as the same are rescinded or varied by this Act; but no such statutory enactment or agreement shall be construed as affecting or extending to any part of the railway of the amalgamated company or the traffic thereon which was not at the passing of this Act subject to or affected by such statutory enactment or agreement.

(2) Subject to the provisions of this Act the amalgamated company shall not by the rates or fares charged, whether through or local, the facilities provided or the accommodation afforded by it, or otherwise, place any one port in Saorstát Eireann at an undue disadvantage as compared with any other port in Saorstát Eireann to, from, or through which traffic is or may be carried.

(3) The amalgamated company shall if required by any person interested use all proper endeavours to provide a reasonable system of through booking with through rates, fares and facilities by all reasonable routes.

(4) No rebates, commissions, or agency, or other allowances shall be given by the amalgamated company to traders at or using any port in Saorstát Eireann which are not given by the company in similar circumstances to traders at or using any other port in Saorstát Eireann, and the word "traders" shall include any incorporated railway or steamship company.

(5) If any dispute shall at any time arise under the provisions of this section or as to any matter or thing under this section, or as to whether the amalgamated company are fulfilling their obligations hereunder or taking all reasonable or necessary steps for that purpose, the same shall from time to time be referred to and determined by the railway tribunal.

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 30, sub-section (2), line 25. Immediately after the word "local" to insert the words "or by." Line 26. Immediately after the word "otherwise" to insert the words "having regard to the nature and extent of the traffic."

The sub-section gives any port in Saorstát Eireann a right to call for fares and rates, facilities and accommodation, not to place it "at an undue advantage." As it stands I take it the sub-section means that ports in the State can call on the amalgamated company to provide them with rates and fares. That is reasonable enough, but when you come to the words "facilities and accommodation" I do not understand what they mean. Apparently, the section means as it stands, that the port is not to be at a disadvantage. If a small port claims that there is a siding and all sorts of expensive things supplied to a large port which has a lot of traffic, and it has a right as the section stands to call on the amalgamated company to give it the same facilities I think it ought to be a direction in deciding this matter that regard should be had to the nature and extent of the traffic. We all know in the old days the small ports in Ireland used to make great efforts to get money out of the British Exchequer. As long as it came out of the British Exchequer it was all right; we all approved of the effort. But when we are trying to cut down the railway rates and the railway fares, to have the money of the railways spent on boosting small ports, quite irrespective of whether it will lead to much traffic or not seems to me to be quite wrong. A section may be drawn with words in it which may prevent such a thing being done, but I think it may be better to put in the words "having regard to the nature and the extent of the traffic," so that when the question comes up for decision any small port would not get an allowance which would be quite outside anything it could show justice for in the way of traffic. Only reasonable requirements should be satisfied, and the railways should not be subject to demands on them which could not be justified by the results.

Comment on this

I have an amendment on the same section, which depends a good deal on the word "undue." Senator Jameson has called attention to the word "undue." I agree with him. No one can possibly tell what "undue" means. It means not due. How can anyone say what "undue disadvantage compared with any other port in the Saorstát" means? I propose to leave out the word "undue." Senator Jameson's suggestion as far as it goes seems quite sound and reasonable.

Comment on this

I would suggest in agreeing with Senator Jameson that the words he proposes should come at the end of the section, and not at the beginning. I think it would be better and clearer. It emphasises traffic.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The first or verbal amendment does not seem to me to be very necessary, but it is acceptable as moved—I am speaking of Senator Jameson's amendment—that we should insert the words "having regard to the nature and extent of the traffic." I do not see that it improves the section. "Undue disadvantage" must mean unfair, having regard to all the circumstances. The two things singled out here would be included. I think there is danger in singling out certain things. There may be other points to come into consideration, as to whether or not undue disadvantage has been brought about; but I think from that point of view the general phrase covers all circumstances, and all circumstances will certainly embrace the two points called attention to here.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

"Undue" is a well-recognised term in Railway Acts, and it means having regard to all considerations, of which the most obvious would be the two you want to specify.

Comment on this

Then, I understand from what the Minister has said, and your explanation of what undue disadvantage means, that there would be, as the section stands, no temptation in it for small ports to make what we might call outrageous claims for expenditure.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Nothing will stop that and the railway tribunal, if they interpret this Act and these words as they have been interpreted, will have regard to the considerations which you want to have specially mentioned.

Comment on this

With that knowledge of the meaning that is attached to these words, I ask leave to withdraw the amendment.

Amendment withdrawn, by leave.

Comment on this

I am not bringing up my own amendment now. What I approve of in this Bill mostly is that it seems to deal fairly between one port and another. Hitherto, ports on the western seaboard have always been handicapped because the rates from Dublin to 100 or 150 miles from Dublin are less than they are from the West Coast to only 30 miles off. If that is prevented by this section, of course I am quite satisfied, but I do not really know.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It has been mentioned that all sorts of claims are to be looked for, from small ports, sometimes exorbitant and outrageous claims, and it has been said the railway tribunal need not consider them, but they would be bound to consider them, and to act on them if Senator Moore's amendment was accepted. You would have to take the Port of Dublin and standardise that as regards advantages, and give the same facilities to every other port in the country, irrespective of whether the traffic could be said to come conveniently through that port or not. Of course, the amendment does not confine itself to rates and fares.

Comment on this