REPORT ON THE NATIONAL MUSEUM. - RAILWAYS BILL, 1924—(THIRD STAGE RESUMED).
Contributions 1–119 of 243. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 12 of 1924 ›
Am I to understand that Amendment 19 "to delete in lines 30 and 31 the words `live stock' " has to do with the same matter as the last? I was not able to understand the drift of it.
Comment on this
Perhaps, Senator Counihan, you had better explain to the Minister what your object was, that is to say, if you are withdrawing it.
Comment on this
The effect would be that if the previous amendment were inserted these words would naturally go out.
Comment on this
The preceding amendment is left over for the Senator's consideration, not mine.
Comment on this
On Sub-section 3 I would like to ask a question, I would like to know whether any corporate body might make arrangements. There are a certain number of co-operative societies in the country, and I think it is unjust that they should be precluded. Would "trader" include any corporate body? I think if it does not the section should be made to include it.
Comment on this
I do not think "trader" has been specifically defined. There are certain definitions relative to parts of the Act. There is a definition later on in Section 52, but I do not think it brings in "traders."
Comment on this
I should think trader would include a corporation or a company carrying on business.
Comment on this
In addition to the definition clause of Section 52 there is contained in a particular section a further definition, but I do not think it applies to this word. It defines corporations as being included in another general word. I will bear the Senator's question in mind and see whether any further definition can be brought in.
Comment on this
Senator O'Rourke asked me to move the following amendment, and I therefore move it:
Section 46, sub-section (1). To delete lines 16 and 17 and to substitute therefor the following:—
"46.—(1) On and after the appointed day the amalgamated company shall collect and deliver in all towns of a population of more than 1,500 all merchandise in classes 1 to 5 which is."
It is a simple amendment, and it asks for facilities that we have been looking for for years. I believe I would be correct in saying that these facilities have been in operation on the three Northern railways for the last thirty years, but the Free State railways have not given the facilities for some reasons. They give carting and delivery facilities to English traffic, but we have not been able to get such facilities from them so far as Irish traffic is concerned. It does not mean that it will impair the revenue of the railway companies in any shape or form, nor can it cause any extra inconvenience for the reason that they have already carters employed in the principal stations in the Free State areas for English and foreign traffic. We find that station rates are particularly penalising on small traders. Traders and manufacturers have not got a carting staff, and they should be helped as much as possible. These facilities would be of great assistance to small manufacturers and producers. I do not think that the railways made any great profit out of the carting. In the olden days before the war, the cost was 2s. 6d. per ton. The Great Northern Railway have always fused the cost of carting into the rates, so that the customer got his goods delivered at once. I have supervision over the cost of carting here in Dublin, because I can do it myself or get a carter, but I have no supervision at the other end. I can only allow my customers the cartage at the end of the transit. If the railway company make a good contract with carters like Messrs. Wallis, they ought to make a profit out of the transaction, and it would be an enormous advantage, particularly to the small traders and manufacturers all over the country. I think it is a facility that the Minister may give. They do give it in this clause, but it is not definite. They say "may," but I shall be satisfied if they say "shall."
Comment on this
This seems to be the old contest between "may" and "shall," as to whether a section is to be permissive or mandatory. The section ought not to be taken by itself. It ought to be read in conjunction with another section which has a definite bearing on the point. The amendment is to make it compulsory on the amalgamated company to collect and deliver in all towns of a population of more than 1,500 all merchandise in classes 1 to 5. Classes 1 to 5 would include the type of traffic known as "bag stuffs," meal, grain, etc. It is almost exceptional to find a trader who wishes to have these things carted and delivered.
Comment on this
I have to speak on the amendment as it is before me. Supposing we leave out this type of traffic which is not desired to be carted and delivered by the ordinary trader, it means you set up a system of charges which will include these "C" and "D" additions. That will mean, in cases where the facility is not availed of, that there will have to be rebates. It is not a mere "may" in this connection. As far as Section 46 (1) is concerned, it says:—
On and after the appointed day the amalgamated company may collect and deliver by road any merchandise which is to be or has been carried by railway and may make reasonable charges therefor in addition to the charges for carriage by railway, and shall publish in the rate book kept at the station where it undertakes the services of collection and delivery the charges in force for the collection and delivery of merchandise ordinarily collected and delivered.
Section 58 again has "may" in it, but when the two are added together, I think you get almost compulsory cartage and delivery. Section 58 (1) states:—
With a view to securing and promoting the public safety, or the interests of the public, or of trade, or of any particular locality, the railway tribunal may, on the application of any body of persons representing any such interests, by order require the amalgamated company or any other railway company in respect to that portion of its undertaking situate in Saorstát Eireann to afford such reasonable railway services, facilities, and conveniences upon and in connection with its undertaking (including the provision of such minor alterations and extensions and improvements of existing works as will not involve in any one case an expenditure exceeding ten thousand pounds) as may be specified in the order.
There is room between the two sections for any body of traders interested in the matter to press the tribunal to make an order requiring the railway company to quote "C" and "D" rates, where they are desired in towns. This amendment would make it mandatory on the company to cart and deliver, even though traders in these towns might not desire it. Then you will have the further costly inconvenience of rebates.
Comment on this
My experience is that the traders in these towns require this. It is the railway companies do not want to do it. When goods are lost or damaged in transit it is quite common for the railway companies to try and shift the responsibility on to the carters. We want these services placed in the one hands. Supposing the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs were to send out notice that owing to trouble with the postmen he could no longer deliver letters or packets, and that people would have to call at the Post Office and collect them for themselves, what would the public think of that? The principle here is identically the same, only that you would have to apply to another body instead of the Post Office. I think that is absurd. We want to make a contract with the railway companies, and to have these services performed by them, so as not to bring three sets of people into it, one throwing the liability on to the others for damages for loss and injury to goods in transit. We never can get paid for any damages in transit except by the Great Northern Railway Company, who settle at once, because they are responsible from one door to another. I think the Minister would be well advised, in the interests of the railway themselves, to make this mandatory. We should appreciate the conditions under which small, struggling manufacturers are working, and give them the best services we can. Even if a man with a horse and cart says he will do his own carting, I do not think he ought to be allowed to do it. There are times at which you must protect men from themselves.
Comment on this
I wish to support the amendment. It seems absurd that a small shopkeeper in the West should have to keep a horse and cart specially to fetch goods, perhaps once a week only, from the railway station. It would be much cheaper for the railway companies to distribute the goods to a great number of people as they could employ their horses and carts for six days of the week. It would be a great help, especially to people in a small way of business in the towns.
Comment on this
The Minister's argument is that the "may" in this section and the "may" in Section 58 in cumulative effect almost amount to a mandate, but I notice that in sub-section (1) of Section 58, there is a very wide loop-hole, namely, that if the company can make out that there is not capital sufficient for the purpose of doing cartage business, they are absolved from that responsibility. That seems to me to be such a wide opening that it fully justifies the fears which the mover of the amendment has expressed, that the "may" may amount to nothing, and that nothing will be done.
Comment on this
Might I ask the mover of the amendment how many towns are there in the Free State with a population of more than 1,500?
Comment on this
We are not adamant in regard to the 1,500; we are prepared to accept a reasonable limit.
Comment on this
The mover of the amendment has offered to leave out the cartage of bag stuffs. I do not know what the Minister has to say to that. My knowledge of towns in the Free State is confined to the town of Naas where the railway company deliver into the town. These matters ought to be cleared up, so that our minds may be clear on this. What Senator the Earl of Kerry stated is perfectly true, that Section 58 gives an opening to the railway company to refuse to do this cartage if they find it would not pay. I do not agree with the argument of the Minister that the two sections taken together would meet the views of the mover of the amendment.
Comment on this
Does not this seem as if the Seanad was again trying to take up the duties of the tribunal? We have no evidence before us that either of the Senators concerned in this amendment have gone into the matter so thoroughly as to know what effect it was going to have, and what the cost would be. Senator the Earl of Kerry says that under Section 58 it is doubtful whether the inhabitants of a town with a population of 1,500 could get what they wanted. That section enables a claim to have this privilege of delivery applied to a town, brought before the tribunal, who will examine both the case for the railway companies and the case put forward for the town. The Seanad ought not to take it for granted that these towns are incapable of looking after their own affairs. We are asked to make it compulsory for every town with a population of 1,500 to have these rates whether they want them or not. I believe the Seanad would be better advised to allow the inhabitants of these towns to take advantage of Section 58 and allow the applications for these special rates to come before the tribunal, which is to be established to deal with all these matters, rather than that the Seanad should deal with a matter about which they practically know nothing. We do not know the length that this amendment will carry us, or the cost that it will entail. We do not know how it will effect the railways, or whether there is any great demand from these towns for it. It would, I think, be rather premature for the Seanad to rush in and do what is the plain duty of the tribunal.
Comment on this
I think what Senator Jameson has said is not quite correct, because throughout this Bill we are laying down certain general propositions for the guidance of the tribunal. This is what I might call a general proposition, that carting could be done by the company more economically than by individuals. A population of 1,500 is only laid down because it would be unreasonable to ask it to be done in villages and at small stations. I do not think it can be maintained that with a town, the population of which is 1,500, it would not pay the railway to employ carters. As to the number of towns covered by the amendment, I do not see that that has much to do with the matter. If there were only three towns concerned it, would be equally necessary for the railways to do the carting. I am sure-there are at least eighty towns concerned and, therefore, it is all the more necessary.
Comment on this
It is true that this amendment proceeds in advance to lay down rules that properly fall to the railway tribunal. As Senator the Earl of Kerry has pointed out, Section 58 gives power to the railway company to go before the railway tribunal, and prove by a host of expert witnesses, that any facility asked for, such as carting, would be a financial loss, and consequently should not be granted. Local traders and others have as much chance of winning against the expert witnesses of the company, with all their experience, as the proverbial camel has of getting through the eye of an needle. That is one of the reasons I think which suggests the necessity for this amendment. We have heard numerous complaints from time to time about the high cost of living in Ireland. One of the reasons of that is the large number of distributors. Their turnover is small, and consequently their profit has to be unusually large in proportion, if they are to exist at all. In every town with a population of 1,500 or 2,000 there are numerous small traders, every one of whom must have his own carting arrangements. The result is that the carting arrangements are uneconomic. The extent to which they are uneconomic has to be borne by the cost of the commodity carried. That is one of the reasons the cost of living is so high. It is obvious to anyone that, if the railway companies could muster up sufficient enterprise and do the carting and the delivery, it could be done far more-economically and on a more businesslike basis. I agree that there is a difficulty with regard to the amendment where it seeks to interfere with the work of the tribunal, but it is certainly one that merits serious consideration. If the company seeks to resist it, and do not desire to go to the trouble or to run any risk, in my opinion no body of traders will be able to establish a case against expert railway witnesses. As a result, Section 58 will be absolutely useless, for practical purposes, in respect to any single proposal that the railway company seek to oppose. We have experience of the railway expert witnesses on other boards, and we know how the truth can be told in different ways. Unless you are an expert you will be misled. There will really be no one to meet these expert witnesses except, perhaps, one member of the tribunal. Of course, he has to deal with the evidence put before him. I feel compelled to vote for the amendment, but I will ask the Minister if he could not consider a compromise in regard to the populations of the towns involved. I think it would be a reasonable proposition to have it in operation in any town of sufficient size where it would have reasonable chance of being made a financial success, leaving the railway tribunal to deal with the smaller towns. In the past, railway companies have not displayed that enterprise which would lead us to hope that they are going to make any advance in this direction. It is desirable, if for no other reason, in order that the cost of living will be brought down.
Comment on this
I think there would be a good deal in what Senator O'Farrell has said about the difficulty of fighting a case against expert railway witnesses, were it not that the Government has taken care to provide against that, by establishing a special railway tribunal. It includes one railway expert and two others of business capacity. That is with a view to protecting the interests of the public in every direction. Accordingly, I think it is going too far to say that the traders will be fighting the railway experts when you have a special tribunal, composed of the best men the Government can find, to protect the interests of the public. I think they are going a long way to lay down directions. I would be prepared to support the suggestion made by Senator Jameson that we should not go out of our way by taking on work which would be much better discharged by the tribunal.
Comment on this
What strikes me is that the railway company will find it easy to prove that there is not sufficient capital to undertake this work. We all know that there will not be a great deal of capital floating about, and it is easy to say there is not sufficient for this purpose, unless the Bill is strengthened in some way in favour of the traders. As to the possibility of a compromise suggested by Senator O'Farrell, my feeling is that the Minister, if he does not like this particular amendment, might bring up one on the Report Stage that will strengthen the power of the trader to secure this generally desired concession.
Comment on this
It occurs to me that the views of the Seanad would be met if the proviso in Section 58 were slightly altered. At present it reads: "Without prejudicially affecting the interests of the then existing stockholders." If it could be shown that a transaction would result in one penny of loss it would prejudicially affect the interest of the shareholders. I would suggest that the Minister might consider whether the difficulty could not be got over by altering the words "prejudicially affecting" to "materially prejudicing," the interests of the shareholders. In other words, I think as the proviso stands, if the company could show that there was one penny lost on the transaction, they could defeat it, whereas if the words were "materially prejudicing," they would have to show that it would result in a substantial loss. I think that might meet the position. I am only throwing out that suggestion for consideration on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
The point is this: Section 46 is under discussion, and it gives power to the amalgamated company to undertake the collection and delivery of goods. That is carting. Senator O'Dea wants to make this obligatory on the company, in all cases where a town has a population of 1,500. The Minister has pointed out that the effect of Section 58, taken in conjunction with this section, is practically to make it obligatory, as the railway tribunal on a proper application being made to them, have power to compel the amalgamated company to put Section 46 into force. He is met then by the suggestion that that is all right until you come to the proviso in Section 58, which says the company is not to be compelled to do this, if the cost would prejudicially affect their shareholders.
Comment on this
At the risk of repeating what other Senators have said, it seems to me that this is essentially one of the matters that should be calmly deliberated by the body it is proposed to set up—the railway tribunal. I suggest that it is a more fitting body to discuss this matter than the Seanad. I know enough about railway rates to know how little I know. I suggest to the Seanad that it would be a great mistake to take upon itself to discharge functions that really concern the railway tribunal. It is impossible to consider here all the various issues that depend on an amendment of this kind. It might involve the amalgamated company in an expenditure which is not only serious from their point of view, but possibly not in the public interest. That is a matter which it would be impossible to bring out before the Seanad, but which could be brought out before the railway tribunal. It seems to me that the Seanad is making a great mistake in taking upon itself to settle very important points like this when the Bill sets up a properly-qualified body to deal with such questions.
Comment on this
If it is merely a question of expense I suggest that the figure 1,500 might be changed to 5,000. Then you would know where you are. There are 20 or 25 towns of that size covered in the area that the amalgamated company will serve. The amount of capital that would be required for this purpose would not be very large. I am not expressing any opinion on the general question.
Comment on this
Following on what Senator O'Farrell has stated, I hardly like to assert that truth has been urged under various guises during the course of this discussion. Certainly inaccuracy has been put forward with varying degrees of completeness. May I put this point to the Senator. There has been no authoritative statement made here as to the number of towns with a population of 1,500 or 5,000 where on examination being made it has been ascertained that they desire this. It is a matter for the tribunal to go into all the facts and get all the figures and decide. I suggest that we have no amendment before us. We had an amendment previously dealing with classes from one to five in towns with a population over 1,500. We had classes one to five withdrawn immediately, and we were told that the mover was not adamant on the question of the population of towns. The amendment has really disappeared. We are discussing generally a vague idea, whether we should make it compulsory on the amalgamated company to provide cartage and delivery rates. I have a little experience of trade.
In my native town in the North of Ireland, where I had business connections, there was a cartage agency with the railway companies there. That cartage agent was generally unemployed. So far as my business was concerned, we did not employ him. We had a contract with certain other carriers, and they conveyed our goods, and we had no trouble, and our stuff was always safe in the hands of these cartage people. If this amendment is carried every trader in these towns, whatever the population may turn out to be, will have to have his goods carted by the railway company, whether he desires it or not. The majority in a town may desire it, but the minority may not. But you are going to insist that they must all be ruled in the same rigid way. From the railway company's point of view such a service may not prove remunerative; it is bound not to be remunerative if not availed of. Here we go blindly and say to the traders that a town with a population must have its goods carted by the agency of the railway company. Having done that, we insist that it shall be done without consideration. The service may turn out to be unremunerative. How is the deficiency to be made up? The only way is by extra charges on the rates. The taxpayer will have to pay for that concession which has not been pressed for, and about which no real examination is made, and no real case put up. With regard to Section 58 (1), I would not go so far as to say that the word "may" there added to "may" in another section equals "shall." But I say you have permission in a further clause for further coercion, if I may put it that way, on the railway tribunal to impose an order upon the amalgamated company. That "may" in 58 (1) will of course be open to the backing of public opinion and to the newspapers, and everything possible is being done to insist that when a case is made out, and the traders in a particular town wish for this concession, that it shall be granted to them. What I described previously as an inaccuracy in regard to this amendment is this: It is argued as if the Bill prevented the concession which Senator O'Dea said is desired, and no doubt will be desired in many places. But it does not prevent this being done if a case is made out. The tendency of the Bill is the other way. It tends towards the setting up of C. and D. rates. The only thing is that we hesitate to say simply on a basis of population that there shall be compulsion to have C. and D. rates. Let it not be thought that there is anything in Part I. which precludes or hampers these rates being established. The tendency of the Bill is the other way completely. It tends towards them, and allows them after pressure by the railway tribunal, which in itself will be affected by public opinion, and which will be subject to pressure by traders coming before it and making their case.
There is one point urged against Section 58 (1), namely, that there is a proviso which seems to take away the value of the section itself. I think if 58 (1) and the first proviso be read together it is quite clear that the proviso has reference mainly—I am not going so far as to say reference only—but mainly to the portion in brackets in Section 58: "(including the provision of such minor alterations and extensions and improvements of existing works as will not involve in any one case an expenditure exceeding £10,000)." And it was because it had been put on behalf of the railway companies that that limit of £10,000 was rather much for minor alterations, extensions, etc., that the proviso was inserted to guard against the necessity of the existing stockholders being prejudiced. Now, if in order to effect the particular point in regard to this amendment we are now considering, we changed the proviso, it may throw out of gear Section 58, which has been constructed mainly from the point of view of the portion in brackets, with regard to undertakings limiting the expenditure to £10,000. I think the section and the proviso should be read together, and if they are, it becomes quite clear that the limitation with regard to prejudicially affecting the interests of the existing stockholders has reference mainly to the "extension and improvements, etc.," involving expenditure not exceeding £10,000.
Comment on this
Would it be possible to alter the proviso so as to confine it to that?
Comment on this
As it stands at present the railway tribunal would hold it referred to every service in the previous section.
Comment on this
They are at liberty to urge that, but we think the decision would lie with the tribunal. I think the main point in 58 (1) is bound up to a certain extent with the amendment we are now discussing, and the only warning I give is, that we should not for the sake of effecting a small improvement in an earlier section tamper with a section which has been very carefully drafted with the main points of Section 58 before us. I do urge it is a matter for the tribunal. The amendment now has practically disappeared. We are discussing the general principle; that principle is not defeated by this Bill, and the tendency of the Bill is to help to carry out that principle.
Comment on this
As regards cost, I do not think there will be any costs at all, because the railway company can employ outside carters without any capital, so that so far as cost is concerned there is really no case. With regard to the loss, I cannot see how possibly any loss can arise when the tribunal has power to measure the cost of the carting to the parties themselves. Surely a great railway corporation can get cartage service performed cheaper than a small, struggling trader. My difficulty is this, and I am speaking now for my class: We feel it as a grievance that goods are not delivered from door to door no matter how many towns there may be requiring these facilities. It is very simple to find out how many towns there are in Ireland with a population of over 1,500. We could find that out in ten minutes. But I am not insisting that you give this service to every town of 1,500 of a population. If you agree to the principle then you say the rest ought to be left to the tribunal, and in a way I agree. But what in the name of goodness have we being doing here for the last three days if the tribunal is to deal with every subject? If that be so we have no business proposing amendments, and trying to improve the Bill. The whole thing in that case is merely an adaptation of a Bill passed in England in 1921. I have great respect for English institutions, and great respect for the whole of the railway system in Great Britain, and I think that if we could apply that system to Ireland it would be an enormous advantage to our country. But I cannot understand the arguments of Senator Jameson and of Senator Bagwell saying that all these things should be thrown on to the tribunal, and that we should have no say in the matter whatever. I said yesterday, and I repeat it to-day, that the up-keep of the railways and the revenue they get is borne by the agriculturist and traders in this country, and I say that they should get every facility that does not in any way injure the revenue of the railway company. I do not want the railway companies to lose one penny in giving these facilities. No man in this assembly knows half as much about this subject as Senator Bagwell, and no man could speak with more authority upon it than he could. His predecessor also was an authority upon this subject, and I could repeat declarations made by him upon it, but I do not want to.
Senator Sir Hutcheson Poë is in a peculiar position in this matter. He was a very distinguished member of the Railway Commission—a Royal Commission, I think—of 1910, which recommended these facilities. I cannot understand his attitude on the subject now. He was in favour of it as a member of that Commission, but now he comes in here and says he does not want it. I do not want to put the railway companies to one penny extra of expense. They will possibly get a profit out of it, and I believe if we could get Senator Bagwell's real opinion he would admit to us that his company make a profit out of this system. His predecessor, Colonel Plews, admitted they did not get much profit out of it but at that time only 2/6 was charged. Now it is something like 7/6, and any man can tell that a small, struggling manufacturer could not possibly get his cartage done as cheaply as the railway companies could get it done for him. Business with the traders is in a bad way. The railways themselves, we are told, are in a bad way, and this is a real effort to try and make railway transit more popular than it is. No one wants to see it worse. Even the Post Office, which is maligned by everybody, is more popular than the railways to-day, and my object in this matter is really to help them.
Comment on this
A new point has been raised in this discussion, that no expense would be involved if this amendment was carried. That is completely illusory. This amendment lays down that cartage facilities shall be provided in case of every town of 1,500 inhabitants, which involves many small places. It may be that in some places people do not receive goods by rail at all and do not require cartage and delivery rates. There may be others who prefer to take delivery themselves. It costs less to have the goods consigned at station to station rates. The railway companies would be forced to set up machinery for delivery if this amendment were accepted, and few people might avail themselves of it, and consequently the thing would be worked at a loss, and the fact that the railway company can contract with somebody else to do it on their behalf does not make it any better, because in such a case as I describe the contract figures would have to be paid. If this were embodied in legislation, whether there are any goods to go by this special delivery service or not, it has got to be provided, which I submit, would be unreasonable.
Comment on this
I have three amendments on the paper, and they really all hang together, though some of them deal with clause 54. The first is amendment number 20, Section 53, sub-section (1), page 25, line 4. To delete the words "thirty-three and one-third" and to substitute therefor the word "fifty." Amendment 22, in Section 54, sub-section (3), page 25, line 65, to delete the word "eighty" and to substitute therefor the words "sixty-six and two-thirds," and amendment 24, Section 54, sub-section (5), line 23, to delete the word "twenty" and to substitute therefor the words "thirty-three and one-third."
There are certain proportions laid down in the Bill as to what amount of the savings and economies effected are to be left in the hands of the company, and what amounts are to be used in the reduction of rates and giving protection for the public benefit. Sub-section (1) of Clause 53 of the Bill states that such amount shall not exceed thirty-three and one-third per cent. of such economies, and my amendment is that that figure of thirty-three and one-third should be raised to fifty. In Section 54 the same point is raised in sub-section (3), and only 20 per cent. of the saving is left to the company, and 80 per cent is taken for the general cheapening of charges. I propose that there ought to be thirty-three and one-third per cent. left to the company instead of twenty per cent. Again, in sub-section (5) of clause 54, I propose that the twenty per cent. there should be altered to thirty-three and one-third. With the permission of An Cathaoirleach, I am going ahead, as will be seen, with this amendment to Section 54, because the alteration is for one and the same purpose.
Comment on this
All these amendments have the same object. When we look at this Bill there are various interests to be considered. We hear a great deal about the interests of the trader, and the necessity for the reduction of charges. We heard that exceedingly well put by many Senators. But we have also to consider that which is of vital importance to the State, namely, that these railways should not be in an impoverished condition, and that they should not be short of capital to carry out the various alterations and improvements which are necessary from time to time to meet the demands of the public. The companies do not make these extensions entirely for themselves. If they make any extensions not demanded by the public they are pretty sure to be failures. But for demands made upon them by the public they need capital. We hear a good deal here about the iniquities of the various capitalists, but I think we will admit that in a huge railway system, such as we are now dealing with, and which covers the whole of the State, if we are to close the whole of the capital account we close every avenue of improvement, every demand made upon the railway companies which requires expenditure of new capital, and we veto at once the steady advance and improvement of the railways to meet the demands of the public. Now, my view is that this Bill, as I read it, does not leave the railway companies sufficient means to receive fresh capital through their earning revenue to put before the ordinary investor to induce him to put money into the railway companies which will enable them to make these improvements. I think if Senators will look through the Bill they will see a fixed revenue is allowed upon the existing capital, and as far as I can read it there is no other source of revenue open to the amalgamated company than is dealt with in these two clauses—the amount to be gained by savings which had been effected and which are to be effected. According to the Bill, in one case, taking the first, page 25, sub-section (1) they are only to get thirty-three and one-third per cent. of such economies. When we come to think how capital is to be raised, nowadays to raise capital needs a far better effort of the capitalist than formerly, just as to get a labourer to work for you now you must give him a far higher wage to-day than before the war. Nowadays to get anybody to put money in investments you have to offer him far better terms now than pre-war. If you look at the railway companies that are dealt with in this way you ask yourself what are they earning at the present. As far as I can see, it is about four per cent. I think that is the total rate on all the money invested in these railways, taking debenture, preference and ordinary stock. It is a condition of the issue of capital by railway companies that they have to issue stock in certain proportions, and if they cannot issue their ordinary stock they cannot issue debentures and preference, and there is a limit put upon them.
Therefore, if you are going to limit the amount of the savings which the railway companies can put on one side to offer to future investors of fresh capital in their undertakings at four per cent. they will get no more money at all. As far as we can judge, the best of the English railway companies at present pay seven or eight per cent. If this Bill, with the amount it enables the companies to hold back out of the savings effected, does not allow the companies sufficient further revenue to offer to future investors and to people who would supply fresh capital, then I say we are putting an end to the prosperity of our railways in this country, or, at least, to the advancement of these railways. Those of us who have been living in this country for a long time know the one thing we have seen is the steady advance of the railways to meet the demands of the public, every one of which has needed fresh capital. If this Bill is passed in its present form, and if I am right that these proposals in these two clauses allow too small a sum to the companies, then we are undoubtedly doing a thing that we ought not to do. How can the railways meet the demands put forward by Senator O'Dea and meet the wants of the ports for further extension if we stop the chances which the railways have of doing these things? This Bill also proposes that the amalgamated company is to carry on, and take over by absorption a lot of the little baronially guaranteed railways which we know are in a very bad state. It is one of the best things in this Bill that these railways, which we know, if the Bill is not passed will have to stop, are being taken over. It is essential they should be kept on, but, as far as we can judge, they will not be a paying proposition at all for the amalgamated company. Of course, what we do hope for is that with better management, more centralised management, and more modern ideas, savings will be effected on a huge system instead of having a number of small one-horsed things. The savings may not be as great as one might have thought at one time, still, they will, at the same time, be very considerable. I do seriously hope that the Seanad will consider the amendments I have put down and that the amounts that the Bill allows the railway companies to get out of the savings effected will be sufficient to enable them to bring in fresh capital and make the necessary improvements which, if this country is to go ahead, are necessary to be made in the railways. If there have been feelings expressed against the railway companies as to their popularity, still, that they are a vital part in the progress of this country there can be no doubt. We are now going to give them probably as good a set of men as can be got in the Free State to manage them. The management will be the pick of all our railway boards, and I think even Senator O'Dea will admit that there are some brains amongst our railway managers. I think that we may certainly expect to get excellent management in this amalgamated company.
I think that it is not right that this Bill should so cripple the Board in their chances of putting up enough money out of the savings which they could effect to enable the appeal to the public to get the capital which they must get if they are to go on extending their railways in the way which will be absolutely necessary if the Free State is to go ahead at all. Therefore, I would ask the Seanad to make that thirty-three and one-third per cent. fifty per cent. Probably it would be better not to go beyond the paragraph in the amendment now——
Comment on this
Yes, it is better to confine yourself to it.
Comment on this
Very well. What I am asking the Seanad to do now is to make that fifty per cent. instead of thirty-three and a third per cent, and that is the amount the tribunal will allow the railways to hold out of the savings which are effected. I think that this is a matter with which the Seanad is peculiarly well qualified to deal. Because we are balancing now the demands of the different parts of the community; that is, the demands made on the amalgamated company. On the one hand there is one matter that all of us traders are intimately concerned in, that is to say, the reduction of freights on goods and passengers. Everyone of us here in the Seanad who has anything to do with trade knows how vital that is. We have also to consider the demands that will be made on the railway company for facilities. There are others that come in, and if we give the savings, or the main portion of the savings merely to bring down freight charges and passenger fares, and things of that sort, we may absolutely neglect the demands of different parts or different districts, and we may be starving the services in a way that we do not know. I believe we will be far safer if we adopt the fifty per cent. to be left to the railway company for the improvement and advancement of the country. I think we are, many of us, inclined to look upon a railway board as if they were a set of avaricious people requiring huge amounts of money for themselves and for their company. Now, in this amalgamated company every penny, after a few years, and every matter will be examined by the tribunal, and the whole public will know every single thing about it. Therefore, there is no question of the directors damaging the public interests for their own gain or for the gain of the amalgamated company. If we have done anything good at all in this Bill it is that nothing of that sort, let us hope, can take place in the future; that the tribunal watching the whole of the savings of the company and everything of that sort, nothing can be done, as far as I can see, that will militate against the interests of the public. But it will militate against the interests of the whole State if by this Bill we render it impossible for the railway company from time to time to get investors to put fresh capital into the company to meet the increasing demands of the public for facilities and advantages. Therefore I would ask the Seanad to raise the thirty-three and a third to fifty per cent.
Comment on this
I have a number of amendments running parallel to this amendment in the name of Senator Jameson which deal with this very important question—that is this question of the inducement of private enterprise to supply the capital necessary for railway development. I do not think I need press the point that development of the railway service will entail fresh capital, at any rate nominal capital. I feel bound to say that if capital were available experts might recommend the electrification of the suburban lines. That certainly cannot be done at present, I imagine, owing to the shortage of capital. Now in this question we are up against economic verity. You cannot get capital to come from motives of patriotism or through anything of that kind. You will get capital only because there is an inducement to capital. I would, therefore, very much like to know what is really in the recesses of the Government's mind. Are they genuinely anxious that the railways should continue under private enterprise, or have they any lurking desire for nationalisation? If there is any ulterior desire for nationalisation they will certainly get it, if this Bill is allowed to remain as at present, because I venture to say that fresh capital will not come in, and the alternative is clear. I know that there is a very responsible and prominent section of the community who want nationalisation. Others of us say that way disaster lies, and there we are at the parting of the ways.
Now I charge the Government with a lack of imagination in this matter, and with not having really looked at the financial question from the standpoint of our newly-gained political status. I do not want to say anything that is going to embarrass the Government from the point of view of their public finance. But it is common knowledge that they cannot borrow. The Government cannot borrow. Capital is not attracted as readily at the present moment to the Free State as it is to Britain, and there is no use blinking facts. The facts are there. Any Stock Exchange list will demonstrate that. Yet the Government, when free and unfettered in their financial arrangements, have gone with scissors and paste and taken the ipsissima verba practically of the English Act. That seems to be an inconsistency, if the fundamentals, as indicated by me, are true, that we cannot borrow as easily or our private enterprises cannot attract capital in the Free State as easily as it is attracted in England. I do not like to say it; but we are here as responsible men, and we have got to face facts. The time may come when we can do better.
Well, then, the question arises whether we are offering sufficient inducement in this Bill to fresh capital, and I boldly say we are not. In some matters we are only allowing the company twenty per cent., in some thirty-three and a third. I state it in general terms that we are allowing them an inadequate percentage of the economies they will effect; and moreover, the power of effecting any economies at all and any savings is largely in the hands of the railway tribunal. The railway tribunal by the fixation of rates may prevent any excess in savings, and even assuming that the rates are such that the amalgamated companies do effect savings, which is a big assumption, even then the percentage allowed to stockholders as an increase of the standard revenue is inadequate. I do hope that the Seanad realises the great importance of this question, because it really is an issue between private enterprise and nationalisation; and believing as I do that nationalisation is disastrous, and is stagnation, as has been proved in every country in the world that has tried it, that it is lacking in resourcefulness, in imagination, in fertility of invention and in every one of those qualities——
Comment on this
Is this a Second Reading Debate or are we sitting now in Committee? Is the Senator speaking to the amendment?
Comment on this
I understand that the Senator has stated that this question now debated raises an issue whether the railways are to be conducted as private enterprise or whether they are to be State managed.
Comment on this
Yes, but he is discussing the merits of nationalisation, and we have a right to traverse the same ground with him, and if we do start arguing that question we will never get finished.
Comment on this
I will simply finish by saying that if this section is allowed to stand as drafted, and if the amendment is rejected—it will involve other amendments that come on later on—then nationalisation seems clear.
Comment on this
In supporting the amendment that has been moved by Senator Jameson, I should just like to mention one small matter for the information of the Seanad. It is this: the whole of this clause has been taken, I will not say word for word, but very largely, from the English Act. That being the case, in reference to this particular point that we have been discussing, or rather the point in the amendment, if the railways in Ireland were put in the same position as the railways in England, then it has been worked out that the percentage which the railways would be entitled to get back from their economies, the revenue derived from these consequent economies, would be fifty per cent. So that in asking that fifty per cent. should now be granted, we are really not going beyond the model on which the clause was framed. So much for that connection. If you would allow me a moment, I would just like to mention one small matter, and it is this: I do not know whether it is considered by the members of the Seanad, but I know that outside it is very widely thought that the return to the investor guarantees a profit of four per cent. That is to say, this Bill guarantees four per cent. to the investor. That is not so. He may get four per cent. if the revenue will allow it. But there is no clause in this Bill which states that the investors or holders of railway stock in the amalgamated company will get four per cent. That is entirely dependent on the words in line 30 of page 24. That reads: "the revenue will.... as far as practicable yield." That is a matter, if I am correct, which puts the case very differently from what is generally believed to be the fact. I would like the Minister to refer to it.
Comment on this
I would like something to be said by people who have a somewhat different view from the Senators who have spoken on this amendment. I look forward to the time when all the railways in Ireland will be electrified. That is, as far as I understand, the general tendency throughout the world. It has become so in America to a very great extent, and it has shown there that very great economies can be effected by it. If the time does come when the railways will be electrified, large quantities of capital will be necessary. The railway company cannot raise capital unless there is money behind it to do it. Therefore, though I am in general tendency somewhat of a socialist and nationaliser, as far as these things are practicable—but I do not think they are practicable in railways—as long as things are as they are, I advocate what Senators Jameson and Sir John Keane say, giving more liberty to the railways to retain fifty per cent. of the savings so as to have the money when these improvements become necessary.
Comment on this
The main point raised by the mover of the amendment is one that I can deal with very briefly. Senator Jameson has a fear that the provision of additional capital will not be easy unless an addition is made to the sum which the amalgamated company can retain out of any excess profits over the standard revenue for a particular year. That fear is groundless. Section 54 (4) has a proviso which deals very definitely with this point. It deals with revenue and says "if on any such review the railway tribunal finds that the net revenue or the average annual net revenue obtained by the company during the period on the experience of which the review is based is less than the standard revenue of the company, with such allowance (if any) as appears to the railway tribunal necessary to remunerate adequately any additional capital which may have been raised or provided in respect of expenditure on capital account incurred since the date upon which the standard charges were fixed in the first instance"—I think that meets Senator Jameson's point. I see that he dissents. There is to be an allowance made, such allowance as will remunerate adequately additional capital which may have been raised or provided.
Comment on this
Might I say a word in a conversational way. I have underlined the words "have been." I am dealing with the future. The company will not be able to be in that position if it has not had money enough, and has not got money enough to go to the public and ask them for further capital. This clause deals with the guaranteed capital that has been raised. I am not dealing with that at all. My objection is to the words "have been." I am dealing with the future.
Comment on this
It is dealing with the immediate past. It does mean that there can be no provision made ahead for the raising of capital in any year. There is to be an allowance made to remunerate any additional capital. Remember, this does not mean capital raised or provided in respect of expenditure prior to the amalgamation, because that is already dealt with in Sections 53 (I), (a), (b), and (c).
Comment on this
There is the past, prior to amalgamation, and it is even brought forward a little into the period of post amalgamation, because Section 53 (1), (a), (b) and (c) has reference to that point. We come to this phrase: "may have been raised." It is quite right to say that the Bill makes no allowance for the remuneration of capital ahead, that the expenditure must have been incurred, and then afterwards, a year afterwards, on review you allow it.
Comment on this
It may be allowed. It is put in in a very definite way, that "such allowance (if any) as appears to the railway tribunal necessary." Of course the railway tribunal is to be the judge of the necessity. If they say that there is no necessity for this remuneration there is no allowance required. Senator Jameson's point boils down to this, that there will have to be an expenditure of capital, and no allowance will be made by fixation of rates until a year afterwards. That is what it comes down to. Let us look at the danger from the other point of view. It is sought to increase the amount of excess which would go to the amalgamated company from 20 per cent to 33? per cent. There is no obligation; that is to say, year after year, if there is a surplus, the railway company shall collect 33? per cent. of the excess, instead of 20 per cent., and that is necessary, we are told, in case they may have to incur fresh capital expenditure for certain purposes. But there is no obligation on them to expend or to modify in any way. There is a certain obligation in Section 58, to which I have already referred. They may have to provide minor alterations, extensions and improvements, but there is a limitation that it will not involve in any one case an expenditure exceeding £10,000. And there is a further proviso which has already been discussed here, that if it cannot be provided or expended without prejudicially affecting the interests of the stockholders the order shall not be made, and we have Senator O'Farrell's fears that a body of railway experts might roll up to the tribunal and be able to prove anything to it, certainly that this expenditure ought not be incurred. There are all these limitations, and in a case where the modification is necessary under Section 54 an allowance can be made under sub-section (4). Where the expenditure is voluntarily incurred an allowance may be made under sub-section (4). The danger, on the other hand, is that you allow the railway company to increase their takings of the excess from 20 to 33? per cent. in the hope that they will voluntarily expend. We know that sum of money was paid over to the companies at the end of the war control, sum amounting to £3,000,000. That money was supposed to be a payment to make up for arrears of maintenance. It was not expended in that way. It was expended mainly in dividends, and there is no obligation, and there is no power in the railway tribunal to compel extensions except under Section 58, and under Section 54 the remuneration of the capital drawn upon for the purpose of Section 58 is allowed. Now, I simply make this as a statement that is not made at all as a threat, or anything of that sort.
We are asked if the Government had any lurking idea with regard to nationalisation. The Government, as far as the Dáil is concerned, has already rejected a Bill brought forward for nationalisation, but it has rejected it while saying very definitely that this is the last trial before nationalisation, and if this amendment is carried this Bill certainly will not go through, because seeing the struggle I have had in the Dáil to get this section carried as it stands, allowing the railway company to retain 20 per cent. of any surplus in a year, I have no hope whatever of getting through the section as it is proposed to be amended by Senator Jameson. It would mean that the Bill would be held up; the Bill would not become law before the Recess, and it would mean that the Government would have to approach the matter from the point of view of the Labour Party Bill, which is nationalisation.
Comment on this
Does the Minister refute the statement regarding the English railways, that the proportion should be 50 per cent. instead of 33? per cent.?
Comment on this
I simply have the Senator's statement. I know that this clause is taken pretty well from the English Railways Act, and I would like to hear, at least, what the Senator's calculations are.
Comment on this
I would like the Seanad not to take any vote on the 50 per cent. without having such information before them. My advice is that it is not so; it is exactly the percentage that is allowed here. There may be a more abstruse calculation, and I would like to refute it in detail, but I cannot go into it when it is made in such a vague way.
Comment on this
In view of the Minister's statement I am half-inclined to vote for the amendment. I originally intended to vote against it, but in view of his statement that this is the last trial before nationalisation, I would be inclined to support it. Senator Sir John Keane stated that the Bill was largely scissors and paste, and that this portion was exactly similar to the English Act of 1921. He gave us a reason why we should not follow that Act in this particular respect, because of the fact that this country could not get capital as easily as it could be got in England. I want to say that we never could get money in this country as easily as they could in England. The banks, in accommodating either a trader or a private individual, always charge at least one per cent. more for money than they would have to pay in England. Therefore it is no new phase in the situation to say that we cannot get money as easily in this country as it can be got in England.
Senator Sir John Keane has an awful terror of what nationalisation would mean—that it would bring about disaster. I want to say that in other countries where nationalisation of the railways has been tried it has not brought about disaster. On the contrary, one of the greatest railways in the world, the Grand Trunk Railway of Canada, under private management got into a very deplorable state, and they had to ask the Government to take it over, with the result that a great deal of the big deficit that had accumulated under private management is now being wiped out under a nationalisation system. Further, in Queensland, Australia, where the railways are nationalised, the percentage of increase over pre-war charges for freight and passenger traffic is only 12½ per cent. and I do not think that in any privately owned railway in any part of the world you could show the same result as is shown there.
Comment on this
I wish to point out with regard to Senator Jameson's statement that the Bill in respect of these savings as it stands now is exactly the same as the British Railways Act. The same percentage is allowed.
Comment on this
I should like to say a few words on this point. I was very much struck by what the Minister said—that it did not follow that these savings, which Senator Jameson's amendment would increase from 33? per cent. to fifty per cent, will be used for improving and ameliorating the position of passengers, etc. Senator Jameson said that he was not a shareholder. I am a shareholder in two big railways in this country, not of Ordinary shares, but of what are called Trustee shares, but after the Minister's statement I shall vote against the amendment, because if they are going to spend that money in dividends they are not going to improve the railways. That is perfectly certain. We had an example of it when the money that was paid by the English Government for the use of the railways during the war was spent on dividends.
Comment on this
I would like to say a word in reference to what Senator Farren has said. In connection with the Grand Trunk Railway the way they paid off all the expenses and all the capital was to confiscate it, not only the ordinary but the preference shares.
Comment on this
I know it because I have had experience of it. The shareholders were wiped out, and they got nothing for their money. The railway was taken over practically free of all charges.
Comment on this
Perhaps I might be allowed one more word in order to bind more closely to my side Senator the Earl of Mayo, who is beginning to show signs of coming towards me. On Senator Jameson's hypothesis the money would be almost necessarily spent on dividends, because it is by giving bigger dividends that Senator Jameson would hope to get further capital more easily.
Comment on this
As regards the point the Minister has mentioned, they seem to be going on the principle in this Bill that a 4 per cent. dividend is quite sufficient to attract capital. Capital is a very shy bird, and I think it was Henry George who said that if there was anything more timorous than one million dollars it was two million dollars. If capital is going to get a better return elsewhere it is not going to come to the railway companies. Senator the Earl of Mayo seems to think that it is a bad thing to increase dividends.
Comment on this
I regret if I have misrepresented his lordship. If the railway companies want to get capital they will have to pay considerably more than 4 per cent., and unless dividends are increased they will not get people to come forward and stump up their money. A great deal has been said about the virtues of nationalisation. I think that an ounce of fact is worth a ton of theory. Perhaps I may give an instance which has come within my own experience during the last few months. The railways in Italy have been nationalised, and one morning I went to catch a train due at seven minutes to ten o'clock. About ten minutes to ten a train came in, and as the trains are usually hours late I said to a porter: "How are you so early?" and he replied: "Oh, this is yesterday's train."
Comment on this
No, it was the Italian State Railway. That is an instance of some of the disadvantages that arise from nationalisation. They could be recited ad lib.
Comment on this
I may say that the same experience occurred to me on the Canadian Pacific Railway, which happens to be a private concern.
Comment on this
In the course of this discussion the Minister has only done what is perfectly right. He has placed before the Seanad what state of affairs would be created if we pass this amendment. The Minister seems to think that it is easy for the amalgamated company to go away and get money during a year for which they have no revenue to show that they can pay interest on it. I suppose he thinks it will be easy for the company to go to their bankers and borrow on the prospect that they may possibly get permission from the tribunal to pay back the bank. What chance have they got of getting it from the public? They can only get it from such a source as a bank. If the railway company came before a bank and could only offer a problematical security I do not think that they would get the money. The Minister said that the money would be spent on dividends. Of course it would be spent, but it would be on dividends on fresh capital which had been spent on extensions for the good of the country. The tribunal has a right to fix what they consider would be a proper proportion. All I am dealing with is that the railway companies should have the right to put before the tribunal their case for fifty per cent. instead of thirty-three per cent. The Minister seems to take it for granted that because I am asking for fifty per cent. that the tribunal must necessarily give fifty per cent. I hold that if the railway company cannot show that it is absolutely necessary for them to get this further portion and they cannot raise the capital to carry out extensions demanded by the public, and which are necessary, the tribunal will not give it to them. All I am asking is that the railway company should have the right to appear before the tribunal and ask for fifty per cent. instead of thirty-three per cent. The Minister says that if the amendment passes we will be wrecking the Bill, because it will be impossible to get the Dáil to agree to the amendment, and the Bill will be hung up.
Comment on this
I said I did not intend my remarks as a threat. I simply pointed to this fact, that I was not dealing so much with Clause 53, but with all the amendments together. There is an enlargement from twenty per cent. in another section to thirty-three and one-third per cent. This is a different matter.
Comment on this
At my request the Minister confined his case entirely to this first matter, the question of thirty-three one-third per cent. and fifty per cent.
Comment on this
Yes. My remarks about the difficulty with the Dáil would apply rather to coming amendments and not so much to this. With regard to coming amendments, it will not be possible to get the Bill through on them. I do not want members to think that they have to give in to the other House, but if they think it wise to have the Bill through so that the small lines will be saved to the community this year there is a necessity for speed in the matter.
Comment on this
I am very glad that the Minister has given us this information, as it is extremely valuable and must weigh with us in coming to a decision on this matter. I am also glad to hear the information that if the Government would be unable to get clause 54 through we will have to look at that matter from that point of view. We are told that this case is not governed by that consideration, and, therefore, it is quite open for the Seanad to express its opinion as to whether they will not give the railway company the right to appear before the tribunal for a maximum of fifty per cent. instead of thirty-three and one-third per cent. It is quite clear that the Bill deals only with capital which has been raised. I am trying in all I have said to make a case for capital which must be raised in the future, and I hoped that the railway company should be given a chance of making a case that they need further capital, and that they must get fifty instead of thirty-three and one-third per cent. and leave it to the tribunal to decide what they ought to get.
Amendment put and declared carried on a show of hands.
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I am sorry to see that the Seanad is equally divided in this matter, and in view of the fact that the amendment only authorises the amalgamated company to apply to the railway tribunal, and only seeks to enlarge the maximum the railway tribunal may fix, I think this amendment ought to be carried, and I vote in favour of it.
Comment on this
I move:—
Section 53. Immediately before sub-section (3) to insert a new sub-section (3) as follows:—
"(3) When fixing charges for the carriage by railway of merchandise, the railway tribunal shall, so far as is practicable, make such charges proportionate to the distance carried."
Now I would just like to say that this is quite a general statement of policy. It does not tie the tribunal down too much, but it is a general statement of policy which affects the people of Ireland very much now. It has hitherto been the very natural policy of the railways for their own benefit to force traffic as far as possible along their own line, and to make the goods travel the whole of the line, if possible, instead of a short distance. For instance, some time ago I investigated the rates between Dublin and Ballyhaunis. The rates were the same from Dublin to Ballyhaunis as from Westport to Ballyhaunis. The distance in the one case is 130 miles, and in the other about 30 miles. When the distance to be travelled was, say, the whole length to Westport, then the railway cut down their prices to meet the competition of the seaborne trade. In every town outside the radius they piled up the rates as high as they could. To meet the ocean carriage, when they came to the western ports then they cut down their rates. The result of a policy of that kind is to penalise very heavily all the western ports. It gives to Dublin as a port, a hinterland of 130 or 140 miles. The railway only gave the western ports a hinterland of some 10, 12 or 15 miles. That was more important certainly in former times than it is at present since motor transport has come in. The western ports cannot compete fairly with Dublin and other eastern ports in this matter, and the result is that the port districts in the West are the poorest districts in Ireland. The land is not so good.
There are various other reasons. They are handicapped to a greater extent by the crushing dues. They are not given the advantage of their position on the sea to compete with the eastern ports. In Section 30 there is a statement that the rates must be fixed without placing any one port in Saorstát Eireann at an undue advantage as compared with any other port in Saorstát Eireann. It may be remembered that I had an amendment to change the word "undue," but the Chairman said that "undue" is the ordinary word in railway legislation, so I withdrew my amendment in that case. I think it is very necessary for the population of Ireland generally that we should be quite sure that the rating is, as far as possible according to mileage. I am not laying it down as a hard and fast rule that it is to be so much a mile. It is quite clear that railways cannot carry goods for one mile at the same rate as they can carry goods for one hundred miles. It would be for the railways to have the rates say 10 miles for one charge, twenty miles for the next, and so on, just as is found reasonable by the people.
Comment on this
I think we are entitled to a little more information as to what exactly is meant. There is the fixing of charges, what is known as a tapering principle, whereby the rate decreases as the mileage increases. If the Senator approves of that principle and his amendment establishes that principle, it is a good amendment. It is peculiarly worded. I interpreted the Senator's desire to be, when I read the amendment first, that the charge for one hundred miles should be one hundred times the carriage for one mile.
Comment on this
The Minister's comment was that now it appears that you wish that "as far as possible" the system he suggested should be carried out.
Comment on this
I ask the Senator whether he meant A or B, and he said "as far as possible." I cannot understand his answer.
Comment on this
What I want is that the western and other ports would be given the same advantage as is given to Dublin and the eastern ports. If you transport material one hundred miles from Dublin you should be able to transport it from any western port for the same price. At present you can only transport say from Westport for fifteen miles at the same price.
Comment on this
I do not know if it will have any bearing if I refer to the Fifth Schedule in which certain divisions are made. The blanks in the forms are to be filled in, after consultation with the parties interested, by the railway tribunal. The filling in of the blanks is left to the railway tribunal.
Comment on this
If the Minister means that my system is to be carried out by mileage I am in agreement.
Comment on this
It means that the railway tribunal in filling up those blanks will naturally follow the principles you have laid down.
Comment on this
Some of the Senators are in the same position as I am. This may mean the abolition or the retaining of the tapering system. If the amendment seeks to maintain that system it ought to be differently worded.
Comment on this
I have no desire to abolish it. If the Minister wishes I will withdraw it and bring in a better form of words later.
Comment on this
I have a public engagement which will prevent my being back before 3.30. I suggest that the House should meet at 2.30. I have asked Senator Bennett to take my place.
Agreed.
Comment on this
Senators will remember what the Minister told us when we were debating Section 53. What we were debating then was only mandatory in so far as the maximum was concerned. On Section 54 it is mandatory so far as the allowances to be given to the company are concerned. We can see, therefore, that there is a very distinct difference between the two sections. The Seanád, I believe, and especially the Chairman, when he gave his casting vote, was influenced by the fact that in Section 53 all we did was to give the company liberty to fight for 50 per cent. before the tribunal instead of 33? per cent. The amendments which I have down to Section 54, if passed by the Seanád and the Dáil, will be mandatory on the tribunal. Therefore there is a distinct difference between the two classes. The Minister has warned us quite rightly that the Government had found in bringing these sections before the Dáil that the most they could get was this 20 per cent., and that if the Seanád put in 33? per cent. the Dáil would not agree to that amendment. Therefore we will be face to face with the situation that our amendment will be rejected and that the Bill will be held up. In this matter I am only expressing my own views, as I have not consulted anybody. Even if I could carry this amendment, and everyone was agreed upon it, with that statement of the Minister before us I am very doubtful whether I should advise the Seanad to adopt the amendment, knowing it would hold up the Bill for a very considerable time. The Minister has told us it would have a great deal to do with the existence of many of these lines that are to be absorbed, and it might really cause a great deal of trouble. I doubt, therefore, if it would be worth while to run that risk, however strongly I may feel that the Bill in these sections does not give the railway companies a fair proportion of the savings which they will effect to enable them to raise the fresh capital which must be required. In the circumstances, the wisest thing for me to do is to withdraw this and the other amendments to the section in my name.
Comment on this
After what the Senator has said, I am rather in a dilemma. I am sorry he has done what he has done, but he has acted on his own judgment. Most unfortunately, I think, the position now faces us clearly that we will have either stagnation or nationalisation. I do not know which is the worst. To all intents and purposes they are the same, except that you can get a sort of spurious progress under nationalisation at the expense of the taxpayer, and under stagnation you will get what the word implies. I feel it is one's duty to say these things, even if they may not lead to much practical result. Under private enterprise, to secure which some amendments of the kind indicated are necessary, you get admittedly speculative development. The capitalist system is largely speculative. People take risks with the prospect of getting profit. You do not invest money unless you think you are going to make a profit. You may lose all, but you take the risk for the purpose of a speculation for profit. To refer to the Grand Trunk system, as Senator O'Farrell did, as an argument against private enterprise, is looking at the wrong end of the matter. You have got to recognise that if it were not for private enterprise there would not have been the enormous development that there was under the Grand Trunk system. It is true it was not remunerative and that in the end the State had to come in and take it over. But look at what the public got. They had all that railway development out of private capital instead of out of the pockets of the taxpayer. I consider it is an enormous advantage to get railways built even at the loss of private capital. However, as the opinion of the Seanad, in the circumstances, seems to be against us, I must fall into line and withdraw this and the other amendments to this section.
Comment on this
I beg to move:
Section 54, sub-section (6). Immediately after the word "instance," in line 37, to insert the words "Provided always that such modifications shall have regard to providing any extra capital for any extensions of or improvements in the railway system which the tribunal may consider necessary or desirable for the development of the trade or industries of the Saorstát."
On the occasion on which this Bill received what the President described as conditional baptism, Senator the Earl of Kerry pointed out what is, in the opinion of many of us, a very serious blot on the face of the Bill. It contains no provisions whatsoever and no machinery by which extensions, which it is obvious must be made one time or another, can be carried out. This section, which I propose to amend, provides that where a surplus exists, and only where a surplus exists, the tribunal can take power to dispose of that surplus, and that they may make modifying charges. This amendment proposes that before making these modifications they shall have regard to any extensions or developments which it is proved to them are necessary or desirable; that instead of giving away entirely any surplus in the shape of reduction of rates and fares they shall have power, if they so think fit, to reserve a certain portion of it for the raising of capital that may be necessary for further extensions. That further extensions are absolutely necessary in many cases is, I think, undeniable. In Limerick, for instance, the railway stops about one and a half miles from the docks. That penalises the port to a very great extent. Without railway communication to the docks I do not see how the port of Limerick is ever going to develop. I do not see where the money is going to come from for such work except in the way I propose. If it were proved to the satisfaction of the railway tribunal that it was necessary and desirable to link up the docks and the railway, in the event of this amendment passing and a surplus at any time arising, then a certain proportion of that surplus could be earmarked for the raising of capital for such a purpose. I cannot see any objection to such a proposal, and I hope the Minister will see his way to accept it.
Comment on this
I have just one objection to the amendment, and I must refer to other sections in order to state it. The tribunal has no power to order any extensions except under Section 58. For any extensions which may be ordered under Section 58 the remuneration of the capital required is provided for under this section in sub-section (4). The tribunal has no power to compel expenditure for extensions which it may consider necessary or desirable. If it did consider an extension necessary or desirable and earmarked money for it, it has no power to compel that extension. Why should the tribunal be given power to earmark money, indicating its opinion as to the necessity or desirability of certain extensions, when it cannot order them? Anything which the Senator has spoken of can be provided under Section 58 (1). If not, that section might possibly be enlarged to include what he is speaking of. The rooted objection to the amendment as it stands is that the matter is approached from the wrong angle. It says that the modifications shall have regard to providing the extra capital for any extensions which the tribunal might consider necessary. All that is effected then is that the tribunal marks its approval of the necessity or desirability of certain extensions by setting aside a certain amount of capital for them, which capital may not be used for the said extensions.
Comment on this
May I explain that the Minister has omitted to point out the limiting provision in Section 58, which I will read:
"Including the provision of such minor alterations and extensions and improvements of existing works as will not involve in any one case an expenditure exceeding £10,000."
Obviously that only refers to minor matters that might be done, and which would be entirely inadequate to provide for such a case as I have mentioned. I think everybody will agree that the Bill ought to contain some elastic provision by which some machinery would be provided for meeting cases like the one mentioned. As it is, the Bill does not contain such a provision. It is only where there is consent that the thing is desirable and necessary, that portion of the money can be found in the way I indicate. I think it would be most desirable to have such a provision put into the Bill.
Comment on this
I am sure the Senator will not accuse me of having deliberately avoided reading that part of the sub-section.
Comment on this
I thought it would be present to the mind of everyone. With regard to this sub-section, there are two amendments coming on, in which Senators Jameson and Sir John Keane seek to lessen that sum from £10,000 to £5,000 in one case, and in the other from £10,000 to £3,000. It shows that the Senator's argument, if it was considered at all, has not met with the approval of the two Senators.
Comment on this
Sub-section (4) allows generally for that with the limitation I have adverted to, and to which Senator Jameson has called attention. There is an allowance for such sums:—
As appear to the railway tribunal necessary to remunerate adequately any additional capital which may have been raised or provided in respect of expenditure on capital account incurred since the date,....
Surely that would cover what Senator Barrington has in view.
Comment on this
It would not cover them at all. A case of this sort, and there are many such cases, would involve very much larger expenditure. It will be absolutely necessary, and there will be an outcry to have such works carried out. If the Bill is passed in its present form there will be no means of carrying out such works.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister is there any provision in the Bill for further extensions or for the construction of new railways?
Comment on this
There is one section that deals with the compelling of extensions. There is nothing in the Bill precluding extensions. Sub-section (4) allows for the remuneration of capital already raised to provide extensions, and there is no limit on that second point whatsoever. The £10,000 limit does not apply to sub-section (4).
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister is not as familiar as I am with the difficulties that one encounters in trying to carry out such schemes. You must prepare a scheme in advance which will show the people from whom you propose to get the money that financial arrangements have been made. If it is only going to be an arrangement to meet expenditure already incurred you will never get the money.
Comment on this
I think Senator Barrington's argument rests on the fact that there will be no incentive whatever to carry out necessary extensions. It may not be to the obvious advantage of the amalgamated company to carry out such extensions. I fear without some incentive these extensions will not be carried out.
Comment on this
I consider this is an instruction to the tribunal and not a mandate. The words of the amendment are: "Provided always that such modifications shall have regard." I cannot see why the Minister should have such a strong objection to the amendment, seeing that it is only an instruction. The Minister has not argued that he objects to an instruction being given to the tribunal.