REPORT ON THE NATIONAL MUSEUM. - RAILWAYS BILL, 1924—(THIRD STAGE RESUMED).
Contributions 120–243 of 243. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 12 of 1924 ›
It puzzles the ordinary non-financier to know why these provisions should be so necessary in the case of this Bill, seeing that they were not necessary in the case of the British Railways Act. Amendments in various forms, but pointing in one direction, are brought forward under different specious pleas. I think we should have some sound reason to show why these amendments are necessary here. They were not found necessary in another Parliament, which certainly protects financiers to a greater extent than one might hope a Parliament such as this would. A certain long-eared animal once got leave to advise a saintly prophet, and, if I might be permitted to tender a word of advice to the financiers in this Assembly it would be, not to be too voracious. It is a dangerous thing to be too greedy like the boy who tried to get a fistful of nuts out of a jar with a narrow neck. They might have to let go all they have got by their attempt to grab too much. We have been treated to lectures and admonitions on more than one occasion to the effect that this is not as prosperous a country as Great Britain, and that we cannot expect as good conditions here as they have on the other side of the Channel. But some people who give these lectures come along and tell us in another connection "we must get something better than the British." The ordinary man in the street is unable to follow these two lines of argument. In my opinion it is trying to get more than they could possibly hope to get if this Bill had not been introduced.
The shareholders are amply protected, and in addition to getting the net revenue for the best three pre-war years they are guaranteed a sure 20 per cent. of anything above that which the rates fixed will bring in, and that then becomes the new standard revenue. To that extent they are going to be better off than they could hope to be if the Bill was not brought in. Now they want to accumulate a reserve in order to be able to float new capital. Is it really necessary to accumulate such reserves in a guaranteed and protected industry like the railways will be after this Bill is passed? I certainly think it will not tend towards getting the Bill through if these amendments are passed, and if the Bill is held up for a year those people who are now looking for more than the Bill provides will find that they will not get as much as it presently provides.
Comment on this
From Senator O'Farrell's remarks one would think that we were fighting for something that we were going to get for ourselves instead of for other people. What we are fighting for is a method by which capital will be raised for the extension of railways, out of which the Party that the Senator represents will get more benefit than any other section of the community. It astonishes me to hear the statement that has just been made, that shareholders of the amalgamated company are guaranteed their dividend. They are guaranteed the right to try and earn that dividend. They are not in any way guaranteed their dividend. I do not think this is the place for any of us to talk about the future of these dividends, as by doing so we may be affecting interests in a way that might be harmful. When a statement is made, that a guarantee is given to the shareholders of the railways that the dividend will be what it was during these three years, I must contradict that statement, as it is not consistent with the facts. I believe the Minister will support me in that. I want the Seanad to understand that what we want is a method to enable railways to raise money from capital to carry out extensions. It is not meant to increase the dividends, as Senator O'Farrell says, of existing shareholders in any shape or form. After what has been said, the Senator should know, that what we aim at is to see that the Bill will give the Board of the amalgamated company a chance of raising fresh capital, on which they will have to pay dividends, to carry out such extensions as the advancement of the Free State will require. That is all we want. We are not trying to make money for anyone.
I think that the Government have not got it into their heads clearly what Senator Barrington refers to—the extreme difficulty which people who have to do with money know that the amalgamated company will have in raising this capital to take advantage of the clauses of the Bill as they exist. All that Senator Barrington is asking for is that these words be altered, and that some other words be put in. One of the things which the tribunal will have to take into consideration when settling this question as to the disposal of the surplus gained by savings is whether the dividends on capital are necessarily to be spent. I believe the views of all of us would be met if you give an instruction to the tribunal to give a decision on that point. Representations would probably be made by the public just as much as by the companies that certain extensions were necessary, and dividends would have to be provided on that capital, because, however much you may take away from dividends on shares at present, you certainly are not going to be able to take away dividends from people who have not yet subscribed their capital, and you will not get capital unless you show that it will provide dividends. We are really arguing this from the point of view of those who are looking on the railways of the Free State as a most necessary industry, and without whose success it will be impossible to meet the demands upon them by the advancing needs of the community, and they will be a handicap to us instead of a help. I would ask the Minister in regard to this proposed amendment of Senator Barrington to try and get the Government to look at it from the point of view which I am putting forward, and to give us a chance of looking to the future instead of to the past. Unless you can put up a proposition in the first instance to bankers and to the owners of capital which will show them that the amount of money which the amalgamated company needs can be earned and applied in the payment of dividends from capital, you will not be able to get that money.
That is the whole point of our argument. I do not know what is the best way to do it. I cannot see how it will hurt the Government very much to accept an amendment on the lines of that of Senator Barrington. It merely gives an instruction to the tribunal that in disposing of this surplus they are to take into account the possibilities of raising capital to carry out extensions for which the company is satisfied there is a crying need by the community. I should have thought that the introduction of such an instruction to the tribunal would have been of the greatest advantage. Unless these matters are mentioned in the Bill I do not think that the tribunal are likely to take them into account. I think the Government should meet us to that extent and direct the attention of the tribunal to the necessity of providing fresh capital in the future as in the past. To that extent I strongly recommend the Seanad to approve of Senator Barrington's amendment.
Comment on this
The Earl of Kerry has called attention to an inaccuracy of mine when I was speaking on Section 58. I referred to it as mandatory. It is not wholly so. It is not mandatory on the railway tribunal to make such an order, but it is mandatory after the case has been made before the tribunal. It does not say that the tribunal shall consider this scheme and make up its mind in a certain way. This section has its repercussion on what we are dealing with, and when I am told, as I have been told, by the Earl of Mayo, that this is merely an instruction and should be accepted——
Comment on this
It is an instruction of course, but to my mind the Bill would be better without it. It does not say that the proposed extension or improvement shall be carried out. You may set aside money for a particular purpose, but there is no power in the Bill to compel the expenditure of that money.
Comment on this
That would be a different amendment. I say that a certain amount of leave has been given. Senator Jameson said that it is for past expenditure, and has no reference to the future. That, however, does not, I think, fairly express sub-section (4), Section 54. It deals with the future to this extent, that it may happen any time within the next ten or fifteen years. It is not allowed for until you look at it. The expenditure is not limited to the pre-amalgamation period. If I am asked why there should be insistence on payment after, instead of before, I say that it is those who have to deal with railway matters who are to blame. A sum of three millions was handed over by the British to the railway companies for a certain purpose, but it was not used for that purpose. This sets out that the remuneration shall be provided only after the expenditure has taken place. If it is necessary to borrow money from the bank it can be met on the review. All that this does is to hold up the payment of whatever remuneration is considered right for a yearly period. You are seeking in this to take away relief from the rates which would come about, but we are told that there will be a great disadvantage from the point of view of the trading community unless rates are cut down speedily.
Comment on this
I move:—
In Section 55, sub-section (1). To delete the sub-section and to substitute the following two new sub-sections therefor:—
"(1) From and after the passing of this Act all questions relating to the rates of pay, hours of duty and other conditions of service of railway employees shall be regulated in accordance with agreements made or to be made from time to time between the representatives of the railway companies and the Irish Railway Clearing House of the one part and the trade unions representative of such employees of the other part, and in default of such agreements shall be referred to the Central Wages Board, and on appeal to the Irish Railways Wages Board which have been established by agreement between the parties named.
"(2) Any necessary modifications with respect to the Central Wages Board and the Irish Railways Wages Board and Railway Councils to meet the altered situation arising from the passing of this Act shall be made by agreement between the amalgamated company and the other parties concerned."
This amendment is an antidote to industrial anarchy on the railways. The sub-section as it stands allows any set of employees to demand separate negotiations with the railway company. In other words, it means that when the trades unions functioning for those men make an agreement or award that any disgruntled section of the employees can repudiate that award and demand separate negotiations. Under the section all sorts and conditions of persons employed in the railways can come forward separately and demand separate negotiations. The amendment confines the negotiations to the recognised trade unions, and also asks that the new Wages Boards which have been set up as a result of agreements between both sides shall be recognised. We do not very much mind if those are not recognised in the Bill, but we think that that is a gesture towards the solution and settlement by reason rather than by force, and should be embodied in the Bill. During the past year new negotiating machinery has been set up for the regulation of rates of pay and conditions of service in the railways. The two important boards in connection with that are, first, the Central Wages Board, composed of an equal number of representatives of the companies, and the three railway trade unions, and in the event of their failing to agree, there is an appeal to an Irish Wages Board which is representative of companies, railway trade unions and users of the railways, both in the Free State and Northern Ireland. It is presided over by an eminent Judge of the High Court.
As an example of the necessity for this amendment, this Board had before it recently important proposals from both sides, and after a good deal of public hearing it failed to arrive at an agreement, leaving both sides free to take what action they liked. One union decided to go forward in support of certain claims they had, and at one time it looked as if there would be no compromise of any kind in view of the fact that the companies would not advance an inch until the Minister for Industry and Commerce intervened, and very wisely, in my opinion, asked the Minister for Northern Ireland also to take part in the negotiations. I would like here to pay a tribute to the way in which the Minister acted in a dangerous crisis. I know he said hard things to us, but I hope he said equally hard things to the other side in another room. The net result was that it was decided to refer the matter to the Chairman of the Wages Board. The workers could not, in fact—they were against compulsory arbitration—do that, were it not for the fact that they knew the judge would give a reasonable show to both sides, and the result of his award, while not pleasing either side, gave a certain amount of satisfaction, and both sides pledged themselves to it. If the Bill remains as it is, a certain section could repudiate that award, and they could show that under the Bill they had a right to separate negotiations.
I know the Minister in the other House said that there was something in the nature of a constitutional question involved here, as the Board represented all Ireland. To that extent I think the railway company and their employees are to be commended because they have refused to recognise partition. They have decided that the whole country shall be represented and that the same conditions will apply throughout. I do not think it would detract from the dignity of the Oireachtas to recognise those Boards, seeing that a judge of the High Court presides over them, that a member of the Dáil is representing on the Board the users of the railways, and a great number are residents in the Saorstát. All we ask is that the trades unions shall be made the medium of negotiation. We hope that the machinery already set up shall be recognised as it is in the British Railways Act. In the British Act the Government had nothing to do at all with the machinery, but they decided they would recognise it as such. It makes no matter in the long run, except to give it a mandate. We ask that this section shall be amended to take cognisance of the machinery set up which, I think, is the first serious advance on the part of the employers and employees to arrive at some method by which reason shall apply in negotiations regarding wages and conditions of service.
Comment on this
Senator O'Farrell foreshadowed this amendment in his Second Reading speech, which I read with the greatest interest. To my mind this is one of the most important amendments that have been brought before us, for this reason, that I consider he is perfectly right in saying that all people working on the railways who have any grievance whatsoever, shall refer them to these Boards. I, therefore, think that the amendment is absolutely necessary. I put down an amendment which only deals with just three words in the section.
If the Seanad is agreeable. I think it would be as well to take the two together. I wish to say to Senator O'Farrell that I consider if an employee wishes to deal with his managing directors with regard to a domestic matter that, as an individual, he should be allowed to approach them. It is a matter for the Seanad to decide whether Senator O'Farrell's amendment or mine is the better one. On the other side of the Channel there have been very serious and dangerous projects carried out by men who are called shop stewards, as well as by other men who, during the lunch hour, take an opportunity of making speeches to railway employees urging them to all sort of mischief. The railway systems over there contain many men holding all sorts of different opinions, and all with a different way of living. These men who wish to create mischief take great care that they go to those parts where they will find people ready to agree to the mischievous doctrines that they preach. We wish to avoid that as much as possible in this country. I welcome what Senator O'Farrell has said with regard to the Wages Board that has been set up and as to the way employers and employees have agreed to go before this Board. It is quite true, perhaps, that you cannot satisfy everybody, but the Wages Board has done its duty in a proper and correct manner. I support Senator O'Farrell's amendment because I know the very serious mischief that is being created in other places. It is people outside the workers who come amongst them and who have no right to be in their midst that create the mischief. That is done in England, and if they get the chance they will come to this country and do the same thing here. That is one of the principal reasons why I welcome Senator O'Farrell's amendment and why I intend to vote for it.
Comment on this
I hesitate to venture into the region of trade union organisation, because I am not very familiar with it. I seem to see a difficulty, however, in this, and I feel it my duty to state it. Personally I am opposed to the ruling out of all methods of private or individual negotiations be tween employers and employees, but for the moment I will leave that aside. I will argue my case on the proposition that it is desirable to have corporate bargaining, and corporate bargaining solely. I may be wrong, but I felt when listening to Senator O'Farrell's speech, and in view of the doubts in my own mind, that he was on rather delicate ground. He talked about recognised trade unions. In this amendment there is nothing at all about recognised trades unions. I should like to ask him what a recognised trades union is. I define a trades union as any body that has statutory status. There is nothing, so far as I can see, to prevent any body of railway employees, if they think fit, from starting a trades union of their own and getting it duly registered. That would then become a recognised trades union, and I think it is most undesirable to pass any amendment that would prevent action of that kind. I gather that what Senator O'Farrell requires is that this Bill should give statutory recognition to the existing trades unions so that no other railway trades unions are to come into being. If any further railway trades unions do come into being, further legislation will be necessary to give them statutory status. I may be wrong, but that is what I gather from his speech. Passing from that, I just wish to say that I think a verbal alteration is needed in the amendment. The wording is trades union `representative." I imagine it should be "representatives" and not "representative." What I desire to know from Senator O'Farrell is if he contemplates the creation of further trades unions and if he will be prepared to allow additional unions. Perhaps it may be that disgruntled members of a trades union will break away from their union and form another union separately and legally register it. Would he be prepared to admit them in under this Bill. and give them the power and the status necessary for the purpose of negotiating? If it is the intention to stereotype by legislation the existing trades unions, and these only, I think the amendment is a most undesirable one.
Comment on this
I do not want to stereotype by legislation any trades union. The idea that is behind this amendment is that at least there shall be trades unions which will negotiate and not sections of trades unions, revolting sections which may be called outlaws or malcontents. Senator Sir John Keane knows that the phrase "trades union representative of the employees" is that union which can claim to represent the majority, or at all events a very substantial portion of the employees. It does not follow that because one man can start a union of say 20 members and get it registered that an employer should be asked to recognise that as a trades union. That really is a matter between the workers and the employers. Trades unions generally have to force recognition from employers, and they generally have to force that recognition by industrial action. They first of all show the numerical strength of the people they represent, and if the employers insist that the numerical strength is not sufficient in order to give recognition to the union, then industrial action is resorted to. It is obvious that a union of 100 or 200 members could not do that, and I do not think that any difficulty would be experienced by the adoption of this amendment. What we want to provide against is that there shall not be 20 different negotiating committees with the amalgamated company which could be the case if the Bill is left in its present form. I know that the Minister did not intend that that should be the case at all, but taking the Bill in the way it is drafted it is left open in such a way that a party of men could come forward and say that they had formed a union and represented 20 members. Such a union could demand certain conditions of service under the national agreement. They could go before the Board of the amalgamated company or the general manager of the company and put forward their case. With regard to the Earl of Mayo's remarks in the beginning of his speech, no one who has a personal grievance or any body of men with a grievance can interfere with a national agreement. In the first instance they would have to approach the company, and until they had approached the company and endeavoured to come to a settlement no trades union would take up their case. That is the procedure that all trades unions insist on. Trades unions refuse definitely to take up any case until the men in the first instance approach their employer and endeavour to secure an adjustment of their grievance, if it is a genuine one. It is only when they fail in that that the trades unions interfere and take up the case.
Comment on this
I think I have followed Senator O'Farrell, but yet I do not see how his argument is going to be satisfactorily embodied in any legislative measure. The basis of my argument is that a body duly registered appears before the tribunal with all the statutory equipment of a trades union, and that then somebody, presumably the parent union or a body representing a majority of workers also comes forward and objects. It says: Although you are a registered union we do not consider that you represent a sufficiently substantial proportion of employees to find a status here. Is it, I ask, then left to the tribunal to rule that these bodies, although properly registered and so on, are not to be heard. I see a great difficulty about this amendment, and, in fact, a good deal of litigation. For instance, I should like to hear the views of a distinguished lawyer like Senator Brown on this matter, which seems to me to be largely a legal matter. As far as I can understand, you are going to give power to the tribunal to refuse recognition to a Trades Union which has been duly registered, merely because it is not large enough or sufficiently representative in the opinion of the tribunal. I do not know where that is going to land us.
Comment on this
I should like to say that I intend to support Senator O'Farrell's amendment on grounds which I think are sufficient from long experience. As a young man I was deadly opposed to Trades Unions. Years passed, and I found that I changed my opinion, and that men could not do without their unions. For many years I carried out my work with very pleasant relations with the Trades Unions that we recognise in this City of Dublin. Unfortunately a time came towards the end of my professional life in which the men began to break away from their Trades Unions, and from that moment we faced some of the most difficult labour problems that I have met with. As soon as the men broke away from their Trades Unions we seem to have the foundation of all peace knocked on the head. Anything that would strengthen legitimate Trades Unions and our dealings with them shall have my most hearty support, and for that reason I intend to vote for Senator O'Farrell's amendment.
Comment on this
We seem to be speaking to two amendments, the main amendment proposed by Senator O'Farrell and the subsidiary one which is the proposition of Senator the Earl of Mayo. If I may leave over for the moment any remarks which I may think it necessary to make relative to the question of omitting the words "or other representative," I will proceed now to deal with the earlier matter. It is suggested here that we should not merely omit the words "or other representatives," but that we should confine the representative of the employees to a trades union. It is also suggested that there should be a reference in any additional agreement to the Central Wages Board and to the Irish Railway Wages Board. What are these two bodies? When were they called into being? Have they any statutory right, have they any security or tenure, or have they any permanency? Were they created by the Oireachtas or by any Act of the Oireachtas? Might they not disappear to-morrow, and why, therefore, legislate for bodies which have no statutory status? They have no statutory status whatever. As a matter of fact, the incident to which Senator O'Farrell so generously referred to a moment ago seemed to me to mark the scrapping of the conciliation machinery. I do not know, after the arguments that have been put forward by Senator Sir John Keane, why we should seek here solemnly, in an Act of the Oireachtas, to make a reference necessary to two bodies which may not live beyond next week. There is no permanency about them. A further point was raised in the Dáil about this matter. If you take over these two bodies, the difficulty is that you do not know what you are taking over with them. What are the conditions under which they operate? I understand there is one thing not definitely settled, but looked upon as approaching settlement, and that is that these two bodies should not report except the report be unanimous. There, again, is a further blot, but it is the present position. You may think that these bodies should not report unless there be unanimity, but you are not arriving at anything permanent in voting for a reference to these two bodies by means of this amendment.
That is with regard to the main portion of the amendment. The second portion of it has been more specifically treated by Senator the Earl of Mayo in a later amendment. His amendment proposes to leave out the words "or other representatives." On that I have an open mind, but I wish to point out one danger, and it is: Is it the intention of this House, however desirable they may think trades unions are, to penalise an employee who is not in a trades union? If this amendment is carried, what is going to be the result? That any agreement to be entered into will have to be signed by the trades union that represents the men and by every single individual employee who is not in a trades union, because you prohibit those employees not in trades unions from electing representatives to act or sign for them. That is a danger that will have to be guarded against. With regard to the main point, if it is considered desirable afterwards to have a reference in the Bill to the Central Wages Board and to the Irish Railway Wages Board, if and when these bodies are made statutory, the section does not preclude that because Section 55, as it stands, states that the rates of pay, hours of duty, etc., shall be regulated in accordance with agreements made from time to time between the employees or their trades union or other representatives of the one part and the railway companies.
There may be other agreements entered into to refer matters in dispute to these two bodies if and when they become statutory bodies. I wish to stress the point that at present these bodies are not statutory, and, as I have said, they may disappear next week. You are now making essential a reference to them, and they may not exist a week hence.
Comment on this
I do not know how the Minister suggests that these two bodies should be made statutory. In Great Britain what happened was that the very same procedure was adopted there that we propose to adopt here. The railway companies and the trade unions met and agreed upon the constitution of these two bodies. The Bill, when introduced in England, took cognizance of these two bodies and made reference to them in the manner suggested here. That is all we ask the Government to do here. If the Government agree to the insertion of this amendment they will have no further responsibility in the matter. Each party will be obliged to give three months notice before they can terminate their agreements. The Boards in England have done very useful work, and they have saved more than one conflict. Their findings are not compulsory, but I need hardly point out that there is a big difficulty in repudiating any findings they may bring in if a person has any regard at all for public opinion. With regard to the Minister's statement that the findings of these Boards must be unanimous, that was merely a ruling of the judge at the first meeting of the Board. He stated that he felt it would be useless to have a majority finding, and he suggested that any findings brought in should be unanimous. That suggestion was more or less reluctantly agreed to. That decision was come to in respect of only one meeting of the Board. I do not give a brass farthing whether this is carried or not, except to this extent, that I have an interest in industrial peace. The Minister says that any small section of employees, say a body composed of 10 or 20 employees, can demand the right of negotiating under the national agreement, and that another party composed of a similar number of workers can come forward and make a similar demand. He said that they could put forward the case that they were not in any trades union and that their demand was for separate agreements. My answer to that is, let them come on that assumption, because we are not going to be the sufferers. It is the amalgamated company and the community generally that will be the sufferers if such a course of action is pursued. We are well able to look after our own members. They will represent at least 90 per cent. of the lay community and we will be able to deal with the others. Of course, we may be lectured again in the Press and elsewhere regarding the desirability of having some method or some machinery to which industrial disputes should be referred. In that event we can only reluctantly and sadly point to the fate of this amendment here to-day. I leave the amendment to the Seanad to do with it what it pleases, but if the amendment is defeated the Seanad can take on itself the consequences of any industrial strife that may develop afterwards.
Comment on this
I do not want to use unparliamentary language, but I was rather astonished to hear the Minister throw cold water, or, rather, sneer at trades unions. He said they may not live beyond next week.
Comment on this
No; I was referring then to the Central Wages Board and the Railway Wages Board.
Comment on this
I think it is my duty, and the duty of the Seanad, to refute that statement. We have heard that the Wages Board has done very good work, and I am at one with Senator O'Farrell when he says he desires industrial peace.
Comment on this
I think it is only fair to the Minister to point out that what he did say was that these two boards may not exist beyond next week.
Comment on this
Coming from the Minister, that is a very important statement. I have great respect for what a Minister says. I do not care if he is a Minister of the Free State or a Minister on the other side, because I always listen with the greatest attention to what he says. I repeat what I have already said on the amendment, and I hope Senator O'Farrell will press it to a division, because I intend to vote for it.
Comment on this
I desire to answer one point raised by Senator O'Farrell in his last speech. He made a comparison between this country and England. This is really an attempt to legislate by a sort of side wind for these two bodies here. The conditions in England are altogether different from the conditions that obtain here. In England the Central Wages Board and the Railway Wages Board represent the whole country, but here we are legislating in a Twenty-Six County Assembly for the whole country. These two Boards include the representatives of people who are outside the Saorstát, and in taking up the attitude that has been taken with regard to them, you are liable to run a great risk. First of all, this might be regarded as very unconstitutional, legislating in this way for people outside the Saorstát. I am not pressing that point at the moment, but I am pointing out the danger that these two bodies are all-Ireland bodies. It is likely that they may be broken up at any time on some question arising out of the continuance of Partition. I do not think Senator O'Farrell really holds that we are going to do away with Partition simply because we legislate for two bodies which are representative of the whole country. I am not speaking now on the amendment moved by the Earl of Mayo. That amendment is being held in reserve, but I do say that if Senator O'Farrell has any great fears with regard to any weakening of trades unions which might be brought about through the phrase referred to being kept in, then the amendment can be put to the Seanad and voted on.
Comment on this
I am now putting Senator O'Farrell's amendment to the Seanad.
Comment on this
I now move my amendment to Section 55 sub-section (1). "To delete in line 55 the words "or other representatives."
Although this amendment does not go so far as Senator O'Farrell's amendment, I would like to draw the attention of the Seanad to what he said on the Second Reading of this Bill. He said that under this section it was possible for sectional movements to take place amongst railway trades unions, and that this enabled any section of employees to go out on strike on their own at any time. I may say that I consulted no Labour member on this matter. In fact I consulted no one about it, but it appears to me that this is a simple way of dealing with what are called lightning strikes. The amendment does not preclude employees from bringing the private grievances alluded to by Senator O'Farrell before their directors.
Comment on this
I have already stated that I have no objection whatever to this. The only thing is that it precludes individual employees who are not members of a trades union from being dealt with except by a separate agreement with each. If that is considered desirable, well and good. I agree with the points raised by Senator the Earl of Mayo and by Senator O'Farrell, that anything which would tend to weaken the trades union movement is undesirable, but this, I think, goes rather the opposite way. If any other form of words could be found to meet the point I have raised, the amendment would be very acceptable to me. I do not urge any very strong objection against it, but I simply point out that there is a danger to be faced.
Comment on this
Before the division is taken I make the suggestion that perhaps the amendment ought to be withdrawn so as to give an opportunity for an agreement being reached before the Report Stage of the Bill comes to the Seanad. I submit that as a point of order.
Comment on this
That is not a point of order, but a point of wisdom. I do not know whether the Senator who moved the amendment would be satisfied with that. The Minister said that if a suitable form of words could be found that he would be prepared to accept the amendment. Possibly it might be desirable to let it stand over for the Report Stage.
Comment on this
Would I be in order in moving that the amendment be allowed to stand over for the Report Stage?
Comment on this
I am afraid you are late now. If the Seanad will give permission I will not stop it, but a division has been challenged.
Comment on this
The Minister has made a statement with regard to the amendment, to the effect that he has an open mind on it, but I would like to have something more definite from him than that. A division has been challenged on the amendment, and to put it off to the Report stage would be a very serious matter.
Comment on this
It will be equally serious if the amendment is lost on the division.
Comment on this
One must take one's chance of that. If the Minister would say that he would consider it on Report and substantially put the substance of the amendment, as perhaps it does not fall in properly with the wording of the section, I would agree, but as for committing myself entirely into his hands without some indication as to what he intends to do, I would prefer rather, with Senator O'Farrell, that it should go to a division.
Comment on this
I should like, at this stage, to consult the wishes of the House as to what day they will meet next week. It would be possible, of course, to meet on Tuesday. The business, apart from the concluding stages of the Committee on the Railways Bill, would be comparatively light. We have the Second Stage of the National Health Insurance Bill, the Second Stage of the Agricultural Produce Bill, the Second Stage of the Local Government (Rates on Agricultural Land) Bill, the Second Stage of the Unemployment Insurance Bill, and the Second Stage of the Finance Bill. Then we have the Committee Stage of the Pilotage Orders Confirmation Bill, a non-controversial measure, the Dublin Police Bill, which I do not think will arouse much opposition, the Dáil Eireann Courts (Winding-Up) Bill, which, I think, is more or less formal. I am entirely in the hands of the Seanad as to whether they prefer to adhere to the existing arrangement, and sit on Wednesday, or whether they would like to sit on Tuesday, and if so, at what hour.
Comment on this
Of course, we are not all situated alike in this Assembly. It is very difficult for some of us to be here almost continuously. Between now and Tuesday, for example, there is practically only a day and a morning.
Comment on this
But do you think, guessing, that we will be able to get through our business in these three days?
Comment on this
I have great hope that we will get through it easily by Thursday.
Comment on this
As a good many Senators are presumably already compelled to stay in Dublin to-night, if we were to sit late would it not be possible to finish to-morrow morning? I think, from the point of view of those who live in the country, that that would be preferable to being called up again.
Comment on this
That would be convenient enough for Senators living in the city, but I understand that a good many Senators have made arrangements for returning to their homes this evening. It would be very inconvenient for them.
Comment on this
It has been represented to me that in all probability there may not be a great deal of difference between the Minister and what is meant by the amendment. It might be desirable to withdraw it until the Report Stage, and I would appeal to Senator the Earl of Mayo to do so. I take it that the Minister, as a general principle, is in favour of having negotiations through the trade unions and not through sections of employees, and if that is the general principle that he has in mind I hope that it will be within the bounds of possibility to draft a suitable amendment for the Report Stage.
Comment on this
Of course, in fairness to the Minister, it must be borne in mind in doing that, that he has pointed out, from his point of view, that it will be necessary to make some provision not to exclude the possibility of representation by men not belonging to a union. It is quite possible that between this and the Report Stage some form of words that will meet the situation will be found, and therefore it cannot do any harm to let the amendment stand over for the Report Stage.
Consideration of the amendment postponed.
SECTION 56.
(1) Save as hereinafter in this section provided, all appointments to any office or situation in the clerical grades of the service of the amalgamated company shall be made by means of open competitive examination in accordance with regulations made by the amalgamated company.
(2) Every such open competitive examination shall be open to all persons desiring to attend the same who are ordinarily resident in Ireland and pay fees and possess the qualifications as to age, health and character prescribed by the regulations relating to the examination.
(3) The amalgamated company may by special regulation provide that such proportion as may be approved by the Minister of the vacancies in the clerical grades of its service shall be filled by means of limited competitive examinations, and where an examination is so limited only persons in the employment of the amalgamated company or the children of such persons shall be admitted thereto.
Comment on this
I move: To add at the end of the sub-section (1) the words "fifteen per cent. of the marks at such an examination to be for a knowledge of Irish." The time is coming, I hope, when we will be bilingual, and to lay the foundation of that the majority of the people should have a knowledge of the national language, and it will be essential, I believe, that all officials should have such a knowledge ten years from now.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Minister is Irish a subject in examinations for the railways? It holds good for Civil Service and other examinations. If Irish is to be a subject, I think it could be left to the examining body to fix the marks, as long as Irish is a subject.
Comment on this
So far as I understand, Irish has been an optional subject. It is not compulsory, and while there is a great deal to be said for Senator O'Rourke's point of view that a knowledge of Irish should now be made compulsory for entrance to the clerical grades of the railway undertaking, I would like to have this amendment worded in a more definite way: "fifteen per cent. of the marks at such an examination to be for a knowledge of Irish"—does that mean that a man gets 15 per cent. of whatever hundreds of marks is allotted to the whole examination because he knows some Irish? The thing is very vague. What the Senator is driving at is simply to make Irish a compulsory subject at the examinations.
Comment on this
That is so. I am not committed to 15 per cent. I think 15 per cent. would be reasonable, but if the Minister wants a different form of words it could be held over for the Report Stage.
Comment on this
What I mean is that as it is worded, if a candidate came forward for examination and was asked if he could say, as is said here, tá and níl, he would then get 15 per cent. It could be so interpreted. If the Seanad wishes to vote on the principle it is possible that Senator O'Rourke could make up his mind as to a more definite amendment.
Comment on this
Unpopular as it may seem to say so, sir, I think that this amendment is undesirable. It is quite time, I think——
Comment on this
We are discussing the amendment as it is on the Paper, of course.
Comment on this
I cannot do that. I cannot have a vote in the air, but if you will draft anything you like I will submit it.
Comment on this
I was going to move an amendment that the Irish language be a subject of the examination.
Comment on this
I move that as an amendment, and that the proportion of marks for Irish be left to the examining body.
Comment on this
The amendment proposed is that Irish be one of the subjects at this examination, and that the question of marks to be allotted be left to the examining body.
Comment on this
A compulsory subject. I think that amendment is undesirable. It is quite time enough when the railways are nationalised, as they will be before long, to do that, when they will have become a purely Government concern. There are a large number of people for whom this compulsory Irish will be of no use whatsoever. There is a great deal to be done in the world, and a great deal to be learned, and you should place as small a handicap as possible on people who want to get on. You want to concentrate on what I call the "bread and butter" studies.
Comment on this
I am not satisfied that Senator Mrs. Costello has proposed that it must be compulsory.
Comment on this
That must appear on the amendment, because your amendment is that Irish should be one of the subjects set for competition at these examinations, but now I understand that you wish to propose that Irish be a compulsory subject?
Comment on this
I say that in a concern of this kind which is still contemplated by this Bill to be independent of the Government, and still controlled, or mainly controlled, under private enterprise, and which is a proprietary concern in the general sense of the term, that you should not place what I say is a handicap, in the bread and butter sense, on the employees. It is quite evident that if they want to learn Irish they can do so, but to compel them to learn Irish, while crowding out subjects which it is very necessary they should know in order to earn their living, is a great mistake.
Comment on this
I quite understand the motives of Senator Sir John Keane in opposing the amendment, but at the same time perhaps he does not take into account that the clerical grades in the railways will have to deal with Irish. Irish is being taught almost universally. I do not mean to say that the people who speak and read Irish cannot speak and read English, but people can write in Irish if they choose, and it is for these that the clerical staff ought to be able to understand Irish.
Comment on this
I am perfectly satisfied that this is merely to state in general terms that Irish shall become a compulsory subject, and it is not going to work in practice.
Comment on this
I think that Senator Sir John Keane accentuates the difficulty of this matter very much, indeed. I spent some years in South Africa, and I found Kaffirs and Hottentots, and people of that sort were able to speak three or four languages. I have had Hottentots interpreting Dutch, Kaffir, and their own language to me, one after the other, without any difficulty.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation. Might I ask had the Kaffirs and Hottentots to learn these languages compulsorily in schools, or had they to pass compulsory examinations in them?
Comment on this
Of course it was compulsory, because they learned them in their childhood, and they had to learn them because everybody spoke these languages. Irish will be compulsory in most things, and I think that people like Sir John Keane had better open their eyes to that fact, and that he himself before long should be able to make a speech in the Seanad in Irish. I think the sooner he buys an O'Growney grammar the better. I can make him a present of one. Seriously, it is of great importance that Irish should be learned, that people should recognise the necessities of the case. This matter has been preached for twenty years and we all felt twenty years ago that those who did not learn Irish would be handicapped. The time is now coming when it will be a handicap not to know it.
Comment on this
Senator Mrs. Costello, would it suit your purpose if the amendment were inserted at the end of the first sub-clause of Clause 56?
Comment on this
This amendment has come on me pretty suddenly, but as far as I am concerned I may say that is is quite acceptable. I see the point made by Senator Sir John Keane, that to state that Irish shall be a compulsory subject for examination does not effect very much, and if the Senator cares to bring up any further amendment to say that a knowledge of the spoken language, and literary grace in written composition should be included, I would also be prepared to accept it.
Comment on this
I should like to consult the convenience of the House further as to whether they would like to take up the Committee Stage again on Wednesday, or to allocate Thursday to it, and in that connection we would, of course, like to consult the convenience of the Minister as far as possible. I do not know if the Minister would prefer, and the House would agree, to have this taken up at once on Wednesday, or to leave it over for Thursday.
Comment on this
I certainly should like to have the Committee Stage resumed as early as possible. Two amendments have been carried to day, and I see no great possibility of having them accepted by the Dáil. I see a necessity for having to come back here again to try to prevail on the Seanad to change its point of view, and if the resumption of the Committee Stage be left until Thursday, and we go on for a day, and if I then have to give notice to the Dáil, allow the Dáil to make its comments, and return here, I am afraid it would mean that we would be very close to the end of the Session. So that if it would not be to the serious inconvenience of the Seanad I would press for an early resumption, the earlier the better.
Comment on this
Would it be possible to continue the discussion of the Committee Stage this evening?
Comment on this
I am in the hands of the Seanad, but a number of Senators have made arrangements to leave by train this evening on the assumption that we would rise by 5 o'clock. I do not think it is possible for us, no matter how late we sit, to finish to-day.
Comment on this
Would the Minister tell us when the session in the Dáil is to end, and when ours is to end?
Comment on this
I am afraid you will have to ask an easier one than that, or at least give the Minister some notice.
Comment on this
He has been threatening us so often with the end of the session that we would rather like to know when it will happen.
Comment on this
I think the date now contemplated is the 15th July.
Comment on this
The date contemplated was the 15th or the 16th, but there was, of course, an understanding that the Dáil would have to be called together later, somewhere about the end of the month, in order to receive back bills that had meanwhile been passing through the Seanad.
Comment on this
I move to delete sub-section (3) of Section 56. I think it is very undesirable to confine competitive examinations in any public service to any special class, and if we adopt this sub-section, in order to be consistent we should apply the same principle to the Civil Service, that no persons shall be eligible for competitive examinations except the children of persons who are already connected with the service. I think that every citizen of the Saorstát should be eligible for employment through competitive examination in any of those services, and for that reason I move the deletion of this clause so that the competition may be an entirely open one.
Comment on this
There is an objection to this amendment, sir, which, perhaps, would not occur to the mind of the mover of the amendment. It is a very ordinary practice on railways generally occasionally to promote from what may be described as the wages section of the staff to the salaried section. The cases which I have in mind are men who may begin, perhaps quite young as messenger boys or porters, but who show special aptitude for the work, and whom it is obviously desirable to promote to positions of greater responsibility than they could obtain if they remained in the wages grade. If these men had to enter through a competitive examination and had to compete against men from a school or college, who have, in some cases undoubtedly, crammed the whole thing up, they would be at a great disadvantage, and I think it would be very undesirable and a very unfair thing that they should be excluded from getting into the salaried grade by qualifying examination.
Comment on this
I have very little to say on this. The system advocated is the system, I suppose, at present in operation in most of the railways, that a certain number of posts are reserved for those who make their way up by promotion, and I understand that the system holds to a certain extent in the Post Office. It is not entirely unknown to the Civil Service. It has been regarded as quite accepted and a good thing, and I think it was moved in the Dáil by a Labour Deputy, and met with the general approval of the Dáil. The Deputy pointed out these things to us and impressed this point of view upon the Dáil, that it was a system already in existence with some of the companies.
Amendment put and negatived.
Amendment by Senator Jackson, Section 56, sub-section (3). To delete in line 22 the words "limited competitive" and to substitute therefor the word "qualifying."
Comment on this
With the permission of the House, I should like to move this amendment for Senator Jackson, for very much the same reasons as those which have been advanced by Senator Bagwell, that some of these men have been in the service of the railways and are suitable for promotion though they have lost the art of competitive examination, if I might so call it, and it would be foreign to them. But a qualifying examination in railway work would be eminently suitable for their promotion.
Comment on this
I do not know exactly what the result of this amendment would be. At present the 25 per cent. of clerical vacancies on lines where open competition is the rule are reserved for the sons or daughters of employees. That has worked pretty satisfactorily to a certain extent. There is this objection to it at times, that one man may be able to get into the service by that means three or four of his sons or daughters, simply because he may happen to have more influence than another, while another man equally deserving, may not be able to get any in. The meaning of the section as it stands would be that, say, this 25 per cent., or whatever number the Minister might approve, would be reserved for fair competition between the children of railway employees, so that no railway employee would get a preference as against another. These promotions are not confined to the promotion of operative grade employees to the clerical grade at all. I have known cases of men getting in two or three children who have simply passed a qualifying clerical examination, and others get in brothers and sisters. Perhaps there is a danger that some employees, through influence or through being connected with headquarters, may get an undue preference in a case of this kind. The subjects for examination may be reduced in their case, and the number of marks in order to qualify may be much lower than would be the case in open competition. But I think it would be only fair that all railway employees should have a fair field, and that there should be no favour in so far as this open competition is concerned.
Comment on this
I am in favour of the amendment, which I think is desirable for the reasons which I mentioned when I last spoke. If a man who has been working as a weekly paid servant doing practical railway work, is it to compete at a competitive examination with the children of employees fresh from school, he will be at a disadvantage. Yet he may be a very useful man, because he has had experience of a certain number of years practical work. You cannot expect him to have had that experience of practical work and, at the same time, be as apt a competitor as the others.
Comment on this
It is easy to have an examination which will take into account all these considerations. When the amendment was proposed in the Dáil it was pointed out that the examination might be a qualifying one afterwards and not a competitive one. The case of the banks was brought up very definitely. It was pointed out that there had been great dissatisfaction and all sorts of allegations of favouritism on account of there not being a competitive examination where the places were so limited. A competitive examination for the employees or the children of employees is very necessary. Without that limitation of competition, I do not see that the amendment will be very satisfactory.
Comment on this
I beg to move the following amendment standing in the name of Senator Jackson:—
Section 56, sub-section (3). Immediately after the word "in" in line 23 to insert the words "or have been in."
The object of the amendment is to include the children of old servants of the company.
Comment on this
The principle of the amendment is acceptable, but there has been a change made in it, and I think it will have to be considered from the point of view of drafting.
Comment on this
On this section I want to ask the Minister is there any provision in the Bill which will prevent the amalgamated company from ceasing to work an uneconomic section of line. I will give an instance just to make it clear. Take the Dublin and South Eastern line between Waterford, Wexford and Bray. If you eliminate the traffic which may be picked up from Waterford and Wexford, which might possibly be diverted by the G.S. and W.R. to Dublin, it is probable that the passenger trains from Waterford and Wexford would not pick up on their way sufficient traffic to make the line pay. According to Section 58 the railway tribunal is to be satisfied that the shareholders in the amalgamated company are not going to lose by what they may be called upon to do. Supposing the inhabitants of the counties of Wicklow and Wexford were to appeal to the railway tribunal to order the amalgamated company to provide a satisfactory service, it might be contended by the company that inasmuch as the shareholders would lose by the working of that section of the line they should not legally be compelled to maintain the service. I only mention the Dublin and South Eastern as an instance, because I know it perfectly myself, and not because I think what I am suggesting may happen on that line. I have no doubt that in many parts of Ireland there are many sections of line which do not pay to work and on which what I fear is more likely to happen. If we could get an assurance that it is not intended that any existing part of the lines to be amalgamated or absorbed shall cease to be worked, that is all I want.
Comment on this
There is a section in this Bill which has reference to the baronially guaranteed railways, and which provides for the continuance of facilities at present afforded. But with regard to railways generally, or any portion, which may not come under the heading of "baronially guaranteed." there is no definite provision except in so far as Section 58 (1) would secure it. That sub-section says that the railway tribunal may on the application of any body of persons representing any such interests, by order, require the amalgamated company of any other railway company in respect to that portion of its undertakings situate in Saorstát Eireann to afford such reasonable railway services, facilities and conveniences as may be specified in the order. There is a proviso which does seem to affect the particular point, that if the interests of the stockholders are prejudiced, then the order shall not be made. That may be a matter to be amended and the Senator who is interested may bring forward an amendment later. I do not say that this will meet his point, but it has to be borne in mind when considering any amendment that the tribunal would have to take into consideration the existing facilities afforded at the time. This had reference rather to new facilities. We did go on the basis of continuing the present arrangement. If that is not specifically guaranteed, and if it is thought necessary to have that guarantee in a special way, we can take it on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
Would the Minister undertake to put in something to that effect, or does he expect us to do it?
Comment on this
I think the Minister has gone pretty far to meet the Senator. He says that the matter can be brought up and considered on the Report Stage. If the Senator draw attention to it on the Report Stage I will give him every facility for drafting an amendment if one becomes necessary. In the meantime, the Minister says he will consider and see if it is possible to frame a provision that will meet the Senator's case.
Comment on this
What appears to be in the mind of the Senator is that it should be rendered unlawful for the amalgamated company to close any line or section of a line at any time in future. I think a hard and fast rule of that kind would be absolutely disastrous. Supposing that there is a section of line which is absolutely unremunerative—it is quite possible that sections of line may become unremunerative which are not now so, or not so to any excessive extent—to keep a service on a line like that is directly contrary to the public interest. It is simply a waste of money. If you have a waste of money on a big scale it falls not only on the shareholders but on the community as a whole. It means that there is so much less money remaining to do what is required to be done, and what is desirable to be done where there really is business and where the life of the country is affected in an important manner. I think it would be most disastrous to lay down a hard and fast rule that no section of line should be closed.
Comment on this
Would it meet the case if there was a provision that no part of any existing line should be closed without the consent of the tribunal?
Comment on this
That would probably satisfy Senator the Earl of Wicklow.
Comment on this
I should have thought it would have meant "discontinued to be used."
Comment on this
It might be said that a line was not closed if one passenger train a week was run. That would not be any comfort to the people I am speaking for.
Comment on this
The Senator will have to exercise his ingenuity between this and the Report Stage and bring up a provision, or suggest it to the Minister, who says he is quite willing to consider it.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
Section 58, sub-section (1). To delete in line 49 the word "ten" and to substitute therefor the word "three."
The words in the sub-section that I wish to draw attention to are, that on the application of any body of persons the tribunal may by order require the amalgamated company to spend up to a sum not exceeding £10,000. £10,000 is the figure that is also mentioned in the British Act. When we consider the enormous capital of the English railways, £10,000 is quite a small amount, but when we consider the capital of the amalgamated company here, £10,000 is quite an excessive amount. To spend £10,000 here and £10,000 there, would probably place the company in an extremely difficult position and, if carried out to any extent, might bankrupt the undertaking. All through in my previous amendments I have been trying to secure that the amalgamated company shall be able to maintain a dividend which will tempt people to supply capital for the concern. This section would have the opposite effect. It gives the tribunal power, on representation being made to it, to order the spending of money to supply facilities and railway services up to an amount which the English railway companies, with their enormous capital, are only called upon to spend. The burden on the amalgamated company would be out of all proportion to the burden which is being placed on the British companies. It may be contended that the tribunal is to be the judge in this matter. But we ought to view very seriously the effect on the amalgamated company if this bait is held out to various districts in the country to get the tribunal to make orders compelling the company to spend sums up to £10,000. It is not very easy at present in the Free State for any company to raise £10,000, and many of the things we were fighting for, in order to give the amalgamated company the revenue which would enable them to provide for capital expenditure, have had to be dropped.
We have only secured one concession in the way of an amendment by which they can fight a case before the tribunal for 50 per cent. instead of 33? per cent. of the savings they are able to effect in certain classes of cases. We should not put on top of that a burden equal to that placed on the English railways. There may be extensions which the needs of the community will force on the company, and which the company will try to do themselves. To make it compulsory to make extensions, when they may not have the money to pay interest on the capital required, seems to me to be quite wrong. We should cut our cloth according to our measure. There is a certain amount of capital in the amalgamated company. It will not be as easy for the company to raise £10,000 capital here and there, as it would be for the English railways. The section, I hold, might inflict serious damage on the company. That and other restrictions in the Bill will make it extremely hard for the amalgamated company to raise the capital which they will have to spend to meet improvements.
Comment on this
This amendment has been argued on a simple basis. In order to be quite clear I wonder would the Senator mind informing me what proportion he would think right and desirable, as between the amount to be expended in England under a similar section, and the amount to be expended here? Is there any proportion he would consider suitable?
Comment on this
It is not. It is £100,000 for each of the four groups, £400,000, lately increased from £100,000 to £500,000. The entire sum for the whole country is £2,000,000.
Comment on this
In Part 2 of Section 15 of the Act. I am speaking of the main Act, and there is a subsequent Act which has increased the sum from £100,000 to £500,000 for each of the four groups, or £2,000,000 altogether.
Comment on this
What is the capital of the railways there as compared with the capital of the Irish railways?
Comment on this
That is putting a question to me after refusing my definite application for an answer to one I raised previously.
Comment on this
I am creditably informed the proportionate amount is £3,000 in Ireland as compared with £100,000 in England.
Comment on this
I was faced earlier to-day with another calculation from the same Senator, who wisely declined to give any details.
Comment on this
If £3,000 here represents the same proportion as £100,000 in Great Britain, then would not the £10,000 in this Bill be quite a fair figure as contrasted with £400,000 in the British Act? If anything it would be somewhat short.
Comment on this
And in addition no attention is being paid to the proviso.
Comment on this
I think you ought to leave very well alone, Senator Jameson.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the point of view of the railway company in having to spend £10,000 on an order of the tribunal to supply certain railway facilities. I honestly believe that if we pass a section making such a demand on the amalgamated company —and it may be made in various cases under a section of this kind—and also provisions which give the company a very small chance of securing the necessary surplus of profits to pay interest on the capital, we are absolutely stultifying ourselves. It is a case of making bricks without straw. You are stopping the companies from making the profits which will enable them on the one hand to get in capital, and, on the other hand, giving the tribunal power to call upon them to spend money which they have no means of getting. I think it would be far better to reduce the amount, and make it a figure that the railway company would be able to meet in accordance with the requirements of the district. Sums of £10,000 are far too large to be dealt under this section of the Bill.
Comment on this
I put it to the Minister that this method of imposing capital expenditure, following the method in England, is really not the right method of approach. I can quite conceive a very necessary local work costing more than £10,000, that the tribunal might with equity impose. But in my opinion the railway company should be protected not with regard to the expenditure on any one service but with regard to the total amount of capital they are called on to spend in any given year. I do not imagine that would be altogether impracticable. Various demands for works of this kind would have to be sent in by a certain time. The amount involved would then be known and the railway company could contest the totals, with no limit on any one individual work. Placing this limit might lead to a lot of regional or sectional demands, some of which are not really necessary, costing individually not very much, but to the prejudice of one good work that would cost more than £10,000. I would ask the Minister to consider that matter, and not to have a slavish adherence— I do not say that in an opprobrious sense—to the British Act, not that I wish to decry British goods. We should take advantage of our independence and look at this thing de novo. If the Minister would consider it, something might be done to safeguard the company as to the total amount of capital that they shall be asked to spend on these works within a year, instead of limiting the actual amount on any individual work. I do not think it is good business to do it in the way contemplated. I think that is a line of thought worth exploring.
Comment on this
Up to recently there was a game known as "put and take," which became very popular for a time. It is quite evident the interests that briefed Senators Jameson and Sir John Keane are determined "to take" all and to "put" nothing. Let them take care that they do not kill the goose that might lay the golden egg. In Section 54, Senator Jameson got 33? per cent. raised to 50 per cent. Senator Barrington, with the able assistance of Senator Jameson, also got in a very valuable amendment, to enable the companies to amass reserves in anticipation of something that might happen, but without any proviso which would prevent them from paying what were supposed to be reserves as increased dividends. Now they come along and suggest that £10,000, the maximum amount of expenditure which the tribunal can ask the railway company to expend in the way of necessary facilities, shall be cut down to £3,000. They really want to have it both ways. It is a case of "heads I win" and "tails you lose" every time.
Senator Sir John Keane speaks almost with a sense of nausea of anything Irish when it does not suit him. Now he asks us to realise our independence and to assert it. Why should financiers here be given privileges which the non-progressive British Empire refuses to give to its inhabitants? I only wish he would assert that independence generally and in a more consistent manner. I hope the Seanad is not going to be led away on this matter. There is no use indulging in histrionics and mutilating this Bill. This was an exceedingly good Bill for the shareholders when first introduced. It was considerably improved during its progress through the Dáil. The Seanad should not countenance an attempt to make railway shareholders an octopus on an impoverished country— parasites trying to suck out the last drop of industrial blood from the community—in the way that has been attempted. Already they are more than protected and have amply entrenched themselves as a result of the two amendments passed to-day. This is another amendment to entrench them still further. The revolt will be in proportion to the amount of havoc played with the Bill here. Reasonable amendments will receive reasonable consideration elsewhere, but are not going to be taken seriously if we make wholesale inroads in the Bill.
Comment on this
Might I point out that the all-embracing proviso here is a complete answer to anything that has been said. The limit of £10,000 might very well be increased to £100,000, which is, I believe, what Senator Sir John Keane is aiming at, but as long as that proviso is there, the £10,000 does not matter. A limitation is put on it by the actual sum, but to cut that down to £3,000 or £5,000 with this very definite provision in it is to make a farce of this part of the Bill.