SEANAD IN COMMITTEE. - LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924—THIRD STAGE (RESUMED).
Contributions 1–154 of 315. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 18 of 1924 ›
The Seanad will recollect that we were discussing, at the time of the adjournment last evening, an amendment standing in the name of Senator Sir John Keane. It is No. 42 on the Order Paper, and is to sub-section (1) of Section 23. The question arose as to how far this amendment was in order. If it is an appropriation of money, it is clearly out of order, because I find that the Message from the Governor-General, in connection with this Bill, reads as follows:—
That it is expedient to authorise the payment out of moneys to be provided by the Oireachtas of any expenses incurred in connection with allowances and remuneration payable to members of consultative councils and to committees established under any Act of the present Session to amend the law relating to Local Government in Saorstát Eireann.
Therefore, the Message plainly covers only appropriation for the purpose of paying allowances and remuneration to consultative councils, and does not go beyond that. Under the Constitution, no money can be voted, in either House, unless the object has been already approved of by a Message from the Governor-General, and as this Message only approves of appropriation in respect of a defined and limited subject, it does not cover the proposal in Senator Sir John Keane's amendment. It would, if it is an
Senator O'Farrell made an ingenious suggestion to the effect that this amendment is not an appropriation of money, but is simply a declaration that when the appropriation of the Road Fund comes to be made it should be made in certain proportions. That is a very ingenious suggestion, and there may be something in it. It is certainly a suggestion that I am not prepared to yield to without having it further argued and developed, and I have only had a very brief time to look into it since yesterday. So far as I can see, under the Road Improvement Act of 1910, which was an amendment to a previous Act, the Act of 1909, there is a limit upon the power of the Minister in making grants out of the Road Fund for the construction of new roads. He is expressly limited by statute to one-third of the total amount. It might well be that Senator Sir John Keane's amendment would involve the appropriation or the application of the entire balance. That I cannot tell. It would depend, of course, on the amounts that would be involved in the construction of new roads, but what I am leading up to is this, that I am not prepared to give any definite ruling now upon the point raised by Senator O'Farrell.
In view of the importance of this whole subject matter, I suggest that the wisest course is for Senator Sir John Keane to withdraw this amendment now. I will give him leave to bring it up again, if he wishes, on Report. Meanwhile, he and others interested can look into the matter for themselves and assist me then by their views on the Constitutional question.
Comment on this
I am perfectly satisfied to adopt the suggestion you have made. In examining the question further I would ask you to bear in mind this submission: That the proportion you have stated, one-third, has been exceeded in past years, and that a far larger proportion of the Road Fund is expended on the purposes you state——
Comment on this
Perhaps there may be ambiguity about what you are saying, Senator. What that Act does say is this: It provides that certain charges and expenses in connection with the collection of motor tax duties and other things by county councils are to be paid out of the Road Fund. Then it goes on to say that after these charges have been paid, the Minister may allocate from the Road Fund for two purposes: maintenance and construction. There is a proviso in regard to construction as distinct from maintenance. In regard to construction, the amount to be expended out of the balance is not to exceed one-third of the total amount. When you say that more than one-third of the Road Fund has been exhausted, that would probably include maintenance as well as construction, because the Act seems to be specific in limiting the amount for construction to one-third of the balance.
Comment on this
The only authority I have for stating that none of the Road Fund is applied to maintenance is that of Senator Kenny.
Comment on this
There is power to apply it. All these questions show how difficult the matter is, and how dangerous it would be for us to legislate without sufficient information. There is another matter that I think may help you if you could get hold of it. As far as I can understand, there has to be in each year a published account by the responsible Minister showing the way in which the Road Fund has been applied during that particular year. That has to appear as a Parliamentary paper, and probably such a paper was issued last year. If you could get a hold of that it would, perhaps, give you some indication as to how the Act has been construed in fact in this country. You see we are in the dark as to all these important particulars, and I certainly do not think it would be reasonable or right that I should commit the Seanad to definite action in an important matter of this kind, which might involve Constitutional issues, without having the fullest information. I would suggest—Senator Kenny probably will give us the benefit of his information when we come to discuss it—that those interested would look into the law and the Parliamentary returns on the subject. Then, perhaps, we would be able to arrive at a decision on it. Meanwhile, I think the wisest course is for Senator Sir John Keane to withdraw his amendment for the moment. I shall give him permission to bring it up later on Report.
Comment on this
On the understanding that it be brought up again on Report. I take it that the Seanad agrees to that.
Comment on this
As the two following amendments, also in my name, are consequential on the one we have been discussing, I ask leave to withdraw them.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
Sub-section (1). Line 36. To delete all from and including the words "shall be" to the end of the paragraph, and to substitute therefor the words "a district charge."
This amendment emanates from the General Council of the County Councils. As Senators are already aware, under existing conditions these roads under this Bill now called county roads, but more popularly known as district roads, are district charges. Rural councils and councillors could initiate expenditure on these roads, subject, of course, to the sanction of the county councils, and in that way they had a sort of security that these district roads would not be neglected, inasmuch as the charges were to be borne by the ratepayers of the districts, and they had it thus in their own power to expend as much or as little as they thought fit on these roads. Now that the district councils are abolished, the fear is that these roads will be neglected, and I find in view of the amendment passed yesterday that this amendment of mine becomes more important, because it would appear now that when that amendment of yesterday is incorporated in the Bill, county councils will be almost compelled to maintain roads of a width of 11 feet. Yesterday, when the amendment came on, I asserted that in measuring a road you measure from fence to fence, and that a 16-foot road which can only now be characterised as a public road or accepted as a public road under the existing definition, should be 16 feet, but that so far as the actual roadway over which cars travel is concerned, it is only 10 feet, because they allow on both sides for the water table.
Comment on this
With regard to that amendment accepted yesterday, and which is to be inserted in the Bill, I think it will require to be very carefully considered on the Report Stage, and certainly a definition of the 11-foot road will have to be put in, because there is no law which regulates what the width actually of a road is, or where you take the measurements from. Supposing there is no water table, but a ditch on one side and a grass bank on the other, does the width run from hedge to hedge or where? I think it will be necessary for Senator O'Rourke, on Report Stage, to define where the measurement of 11 feet is to be taken from, because at present it is absolutely ambiguous. As the amendment stands, it is absolutely uncertain where you are to get the 11 feet from. Does it mean 11 feet clear or 11 feet from one side of the hedge to the other, or does it mean 11 feet from the water table? That will have to be made clear.
Comment on this
I thought it likely that there might be some misapprehension on the part of the Seanad, and I rang up the Road Board this morning and got in touch with the Chief Engineer. He said he had no doubt about the matter; that it has been the practice to measure a road from one ditch to the other, and that in effect a 16-foot road would be 10 feet. I asked him what then would be the width of an 11-foot road, and he said it would be only about 5 feet. I will leave that for the moment. The point here is that the maintenance of these roads, formerly known as district roads, and now known as county roads, was a matter of local charge and should still continue to be a local charge. Under the Bill the maintenance of all roads by the county council will be a county-at-large charge, and that is where the difference comes in. Members of district councils and of the General Council of County Councils, are of opinion that if that old practice of levying the charge for maintenance of district roads formerly under the control of the rural district councils is still leviable on districts, then in those districts, inasmuch as the ratepayers pay their own expenses for upkeep and have a certain amount of control, the maintenance of the roads will not be neglected, as they think they are apt to be when they are losing their local representatives, and that the county councils will pay more attention to the main roads and trunk roads to the disadvantage of the minor roads and by-roads.
Comment on this
With all due respect to the opinion of Senator Kenny, I am not at all satisfied that this matter will work out the way he suggests. I feel that if you make all those district charges for district roads, you will get indifference on the part of the county councillors who do not come from the particular districts affected, and the tendency will be to place greater burdens upon ratepayers; whereas if this be made a county-at-large charge every presentment will affect every councillor, and the tendency will be to examine the matter more closely. Of course I know it is a difficult question to decide, and from my own experience of public bodies I think that the county-at-large charge would, on the whole, work for economy, which is so badly needed by local ratepayers.
Comment on this
I do not think it is necessary for me to say much after what Sir John Keane has just stated. There was a great amount of argument in favour of a district charge when we had the district councils, because it was a great check on extravagance when these rural district councils knew that they were spending their own money. Now that the district councils will be wiped out, that argument no longer holds good. On the contrary, it will go in the opposite direction, because county councillors, drawn from other parts of the county, will have no particular interest in keeping down the expenditure if it is raised upon one particular area, and for that reason I think it would only lead to much greater extravagance, and, as everyone realises, it is of the greatest importance to try to keep our rates down to the lowest possible figure, for the present at all events.
Comment on this
I think there is a good deal in the amendment proposed by Senator Kenny. It is a matter that ought to be discussed by the Seanad before this section is passed. In counties where there are several rural districts the cost of the maintenance of the district roads varies considerably. In some districts there is a very low rate levied for the maintenance of the roads, and in others the rate is very high. By amalgamation of the expenditure and rating, as is proposed by this Bill, the result will be that districts which hitherto had a low rate for the upkeep of their roads will have to contribute for the upkeep of more expensive roads in other districts, and, thereby, their rates will be considerably increased. On the other hand, the abolition of the district councils will do away with the authority of the body that had the maintenance of, and expenditure on, the district roads. The county councils will, of course, be composed of some members representing these districts, and I think it will be their duty to see that the districts they represent will not incur expenditure which the ratepayers would be unable to pay. I have had experience of tendencies such as this on boards from time to time.
We have the case of the amalgamation of poor law unions. Formerly each electoral division had its own rate. That rate was based on the cost of maintenance of the poor from that district. When the Local Government Act came into force it made the rates a union charge, and the result was that districts which had previously a very low rate were obliged to share the high rates of other districts. In that way expenditure was considerably increased. I am inclined to support the amendment. I do not want to make any change in the rating of districts, for the maintenance of roads, where the rates are at present low. I fear that the section in the Bill, as it stands, will tend to increase the rates in places that have hitherto been worked economically.
Comment on this
I think there is a great deal to be said for the area of charge. The ratepayers of a district are very much interested in the area of charge. Where roads are maintained as a general charge the ratepayers of some districts feel that there is extravagance and complain that under direct labour the men are not doing the work properly. If the charge was coming off their own districts the ratepayers would soon send complaints to the county surveyor or to the county council. As the Bill does away with district councils, and as area of charge varies, I think the charge should be a district charge, or be on the county electoral area, or the district of a particular surveyor. On small roads, 11 feet in width, there is no reason to fear that there will be a water table of more than one foot or nine inches. My point is to allow a county council to repair a road 11 feet wide.
Comment on this
I take the same view as Senator Sir John Keane, and I think the amendment should be passed. From my experience of county council work I found that when the road question came on, the surveyor made a declaration, and the council had before them information as to which were main and which were district roads. In fact, when it came to a question of district roads, whatever the cost, the councillors closed their portfolios and did not bother further. Where everyone in the county is interested in expenditure I think it will make for economy.
Comment on this
May I point out that if the amendment is carried in its present form it will read badly. The sub-section will then read:—
The expenses of maintaining and constructing county and main roads and abandoning county roads a district charge.
Comment on this
Of course that is a clerical error. The intention is to exclude all words after "shall be."
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
I move:—Section 23, sub-section (1), line 43, to insert after the word "but" the words "such expenses."
Comment on this
Before we pass from this Section I want to direct the attention of the Seanad and the Minister to a matter that will be very relevant to the amendment a Senator proposes to bring up on the Report Stage. I may be entirely wrong, but what troubles me about this Section is that it seems altogether to ignore the existence of the Road Fund. Section 1 expressly provides that the expenses are to be defrayed out of the poor rate.
The expenses of maintaining and constructing county and main roads and abandoning county roads shall be raised and defrayed out of the poor rate.
If that stands alone, it means that the entire cost of maintenance and the construction of new and main roads is to be borne by the poor rate. There is a proviso at the end of that Section which says that where there is any provision in a local Act, or in any Provisional Order for a contribution, this provision is to stand good. It says nothing about the public Act which provides this Road Improvement Fund. It ignores that altogether. I think it must be a mistake or an oversight in some way. It seems to me that under the Section, as it now stands, every shilling of the cost of maintaining and constructing every new road or main road is to be borne by the poor rate.
Comment on this
I understand—I may be wrong—that the contribution from the Road Fund is in ease of the other, or a recoupment, and that you must put the liability on the poor rate to start with.
Comment on this
Why not say, "subject to repayment as prescribed by the Road Fund Act," or something of that kind?
Comment on this
With all respect, I think I can suggest a reason, because the Local Government Department use this grant from the Road Fund as a whip with which to lash county councils and urban councils to carry out their orders. In fact, they make it a charitable donation, when, in reality, it is money that should be distributed for a certain purpose.
Comment on this
I think this requires to be looked into. As I understand the Road Fund Acts—I do not know if they have been modified by legislation here or not—I do not think they have—the Minister in charge of the Road Fund is only a trustee and has to apply it as directed by the Act of Parliament. Under the Act of Parliament it has to be applied for two purposes; the charges and expenses incurred by the county council in raising the motor duties, and for the maintenance and expenses of roads, or the construction of new roads. It is not left to discretion; it is mandatory.
Comment on this
Certainly he will not be inclined to give any grant to any council if this section is passed as it stands. The section puts the absolute liability for defraying any of the cost of constructing and maintaining county roads on the rates.
Comment on this
I think it will require to be very carefully considered by the House, and looked into before it is passed on the Report Stage. I am sure that the matter has not been overlooked by the Minister or by others, but it will require some attention.
Section 23, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Sections 24 and 25 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
SECTION 26.
(1) Money borrowed by the council of a county, county or other borough, or urban district, for the purpose of the repair of any damage (including total destruction) done to any road at any time prior to the 20th day of March, 1923, shall not be reckoned as part of the total debt of such council for the purpose of any limitation on borrowing imposed by any enactment relating to borrowing by such council.
(2) The repayment of so much as is on the appointed day outstanding of any loan borrowed before the passing of this Act by the council of any county for the purpose of the construction or maintenance of any road, shall, from and after the passing of this Act, be charged on the area upon which the expense of such construction and maintenance would be charged under the provisions of this Act.
Comment on this
I move:
In sub-section (2), line 16, to delete the words "appointed day" and to substitute therefor the words and figures "first day of April, 1925."
This is consequential on a previous amendment, No. 36, in Section 23.
Comment on this
I move:
In sub-section (2), page 13, line 18, after the word "county" to insert the words "county or other borough or urban district."
Section 23 and sub-section (2) of Section 26 make main road maintenance a county-at-large charge. This sub-section (2) extends that principle, and outstanding loans for main road maintenance now become a county-at-large charge. What I want to secure by the amendment is that outstanding loans due by urban districts should also become a county-at-large charge. I think that is only mere justice. Outstanding loans heretofore levied on a smaller area become a county-at-large charge and urban districts pay their charge in proportion.
Comment on this
You want to bring sub-section (2) into harmony with sub-section (1)?
Comment on this
I move to add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
"(3) Notwithstanding anything in Section 23 of this Act or in the last preceding sub-section contained, any expenses incurred after the passing of this Act under the authority of the Bridges (Ireland) Acts, 1834 and 1867, in respect of the construction and repair of any bridge (being part of the maintenance, as hereinbefore in this Act defined, of the road of which such bridge forms part), and so much as is on the appointed day outstanding of any loan borrowed before the passing of this Act under the authority of the said Acts for any expenses in respect of any such purpose as aforesaid, shall continue to be chargeable and payable in like manner as if this Act had not passed, but for the purposes of this sub-section, the borough of Kilkenny, notwithstanding the Local Government (Ireland) Act, 1898. Amendment Act, 1906, and anything in that Act contained, shall, as well for the purpose of the Bridges (Ireland) Acts, 1834 and 1867, aforesaid, as for other purposes, be deemed to be part of the County of Kilkenny, and not to be a separate county borough or county of a city, and the said Local Government (Ireland) Act, 1898, Amendment Act, 1906, is hereby repealed."
This deals with loans under the Bridges Acts, and they are in a different category. They are levied over more than one county and in some places three, four or five counties contribute to those loans. The whole tendency of the Bill is to widen the area of charge for main road maintenance, but if this section applied to loans under the Bridges Acts it would have the reverse effect, as it would narrow it to one county charge. I do not think it is clear from the Bill whether these sections operate on loans obtained under the Bridges Acts and I think it is necessary to set it down clearly. It is better to do that than to leave it a moot point whether the sections operate or not. That is what I hope to achieve by the first part of the amendment— that loans now contributed to by more than one county should not be affected by these sections and should remain as formerly. In Kilkenny the principal bridge was built on an agreed basis. The borough agreed to pay one-third and the county agreed to pay two-thirds. As Kilkenny is not a county borough that seemed a feasible arrangement. For some reason for which I cannot account, Kilkenny, under a special Act of 1906, was created a county borough for the purposes of the Bridges Acts, and the loans for John's Bridge were obtained under the Bridges Acts as if two or more counties participated in the loans, although there was never a suggestion that the loans would come from anywhere but from the County Kilkenny, of which Kilkenny City is part. In future the urban district of Kilkenny will have to bear its rateable portion of all outstanding loans in the county. I think it is right that the loans for this bridge, which are a main road charge, should be spread over the whole county.
Comment on this
I do not think that the Seanad should agree to this amendment without further consideration. I must confess that I have been negligent in not studying this amendment more closely. Those of us who are solicitous for rural districts cannot possibly consent to placing these urban charges, which are of a character peculiar to themselves, dealing as they do with congested areas, or with more dense areas of population, upon the whole agricultural district. I would ask the Senator not to press the amendment now, but to give us time to consider it. I think we might ask leave to have the matter reconsidered on the Report Stage. I presume it will not be out of order to bring up amendments dealing with the matter on the Report Stage whatever the result will be now.
Comment on this
That would depend on the amount of discussion that amendments receive here, and whether they were withdrawn on the understanding that they were to be resumed on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I feel that we rather allowed the previous amendment to go by default. This amendment is seeking still further to enlarge that principle, and we would like to have the matter brought up again on the Report Stage. We do not know the amount of these loans.
Comment on this
This is a very far-reaching amendment, because it provides that the borough of Kilkenny is to be treated as part of the whole county, not merely for charges under the Bridges Acts but for all other purposes. As to the amount of loans that may be let loose on the county, we have no information.
Comment on this
It is for that reason that we ask leave to allow the matter remain open for discussion in order to ascertain what the figures mean, not only for Kilkenny but elsewhere. This is a comprehensive amendment and it may be very dangerous.
Comment on this
Kilkenny is not alone in being liable to contribute for bridges. There are several other places besides Kilkenny, such, for instance, as the City of Limerick, which is liable to contribute to a bridge at Portumna, many miles away. I think that there is also a bridge in Waterford for which a number of other places are brought in to contribute. I think it would be unwise to pass legislation dealing with Kilkenny alone, as there are other places in a similar position.
Comment on this
I might mention that the levy extends over about seven counties, and it ranges from 25 per cent. each for the city and county of Waterford to about 4 per cent. for County Carlow.
Comment on this
I think it would be advisable, if possible, to let this matter stand over. I am not in a position now to say whether or not I could accept it. It is a far-reaching amendment and involves a great many issues that do not appear on the surface. It would be more satisfactory if this amendment were left over.
Comment on this
It is not sought merely to have the Borough of Kilkenny extended over the entire county for the purpose of liability under the Bridges Act, but for the purposes of loans. It might be well if the Seanad were informed as to the nature and amount of the loans. That really would be a tremendous proposition.
Comment on this
I quite realise this is a complex matter, but I think there is some misconception. As far as the Waterford bridge and the bridge in Limerick are concerned, I propose to leave them as they are. I want to impress upon the Seanad that since the Local Government Act was passed, the city of Kilkenny is made part of the county for the purpose of the maintenance of main roads.
Comment on this
A bridge was built at Kilkenny, and a special Act of Parliament was carried through for that purpose. You have given Kilkenny the temporary status of a county borough, which it is not; but for the purpose of building this bridge it was given that status.
Comment on this
You want to deprive it of that status now?
Comment on this
Does it not come to this: that instead of the Borough of Kilkenny being made liable for the maintenance of the bridge, you want the cost of the bridge to be treated as a county charge?
Comment on this
It is a bridge on the main road, and it should come under the maintenance charge of main roads. We have been made liable for all main road maintenance, and we have to pay our rates, in proportion, for all main roads. Why should not our main roads, including the bridge, be paid for by the county as well?
Comment on this
I do not think there are. I would not bind myself to that, but I believe there is no other charge. I will make sure about the matter before the Report Stage.
Comment on this
It would be a great advantage to the Seanad if you would circulate amongst the members a short memorandum setting out the position. It is not easy for any Senator, in the time at his disposal, to make the thing plain.
Comment on this
Before Section 26 is adopted. I would like to ask for further information as to what is meant by moneys borrowed for the purpose of construction or maintenance of any road. To those not intimate with the subject, sewers and all kinds of work incidental to roads might come under that heading. In that case the cost of sewers and other incidentals to roads would come on the rural district. I would ask to have the matter further considered on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
There is no danger of sewers being included. Sanitary matters do not come under the heading of road maintenance at all.
Comment on this
That is right. In the Public Health Act of 1898, the Irish as well as the English Act, the question of sewers and drains is treated as part of the duty of the sanitary authority, and it is quite different from the maintenance and construction of roads.
Comment on this
Pavements would come under the heading of maintenance of roads.
Comment on this
It is essentially an urban service, and I would like some reference to the matter on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I beg to move the following amendment, which is purely a drafting amendment:—
Section 27, sub-section (1), line 40, after the word "in" to insert the words "on to."
Comment on this
I would like to touch upon the question of raising and carrying away from land gravel, stone, sand or other material. I think there is some law to that effect in being, and under it the distance over which material may be carried is limited. I do not think it is reasonable to go on to a man's land and take away from it gravel for a road two or five miles away. They could in reason be entitled, by permission, to take sand or gravel from land adjacent to the road requiring repair.
Comment on this
You have not apparently read sub-section (2), where all that is provided for.
Comment on this
I read that sub-section, but it appears to me the District Justice may do what he likes in that matter.
Comment on this
He has to be satisfied that the exercise of the powers proposed is reasonable, having regard to the convenience and the cost of any alternative method, or the facilities sought, the character of the land and all the circumstances of the case.
Comment on this
I recognise all that, but I believe the District Justice has still power to do what he likes. It is a matter of opinion as to what he will do. There should be some limit of distance. I am not sure what the old law was, but there was a limit.
Comment on this
In the Grand Jury days the same things had to be proved as have to be proved under this section.
Comment on this
But suppose they cannot get decent gravel near where the road needs repair? I am not in favour of any restriction.
Comment on this
If you are not in favour of any restriction you should move to strike out sub-section (2). It is quite evident that they have to satisfy the District Justice that their application is reasonable. If they wanted to go 30 or 40 miles, and he thought it was unreasonable, he could refuse any application. The law is left practically where it was.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
Section 27, sub-section (2), page 14, line 4. To add at the end of the sub-section the words "and in the event of any unreasonable objection shall have power to award legal costs not exceeding three guineas against such objector and to give costs to a similar amount against the council or contractor whose application shall be deemed unreasonable."
That amendment is moved in the interests of the Minister's own profession. I think that in the interests of the legal profession it ought to be accepted. The profession is not sufficiently safeguarded there at all.
Comment on this
I would be agreeable to accept that in principle, but I think it would be well to look into the drafting of the amendment before the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I object to the amendment in the interests of the ratepayers. The legal profession can very well look after itself.
Comment on this
Surely Senator Linehan does not suggest that the legal profession is to do the work for nothing.
Comment on this
It is obvious, and, of course, Senator Linehan will see, if the District Justice thinks that the action of the council was very unreasonable, that the District Justice should have power to indemnify the owner of the land for costs incurred in coming up to object. It is not a very large sum. He is giving him three ; that would not break the ratepayers. If a council proceeded to take sand or gravel out of Senator Linehan's land, and if the Senator objected, and this objection was upheld by the District Justice, would it not be unjust if the Senator had to do that at his own expense?
Comment on this
The amendment does that. It does now allow him to award more than three guineas.
Comment on this
Should not the word "unreasonable" be changed in the amendment? Should it not be "reasonable objection"?
Comment on this
No. The first portion of the clause you are reading deals with costs against the objector. Of course, you cannot give costs against an objector unless his objection is unreasonable. It should really be redrafted, because the proper way to do it is, in the event of the objection not being over-ruled, the District Justice should have power to award costs against the objector not exceeding three guineas. On the other hand, in the event of his acceding to the objection, it is the other way round. It would require to be revised. The principle is accepted subject to the revising of the phraseology.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
Section 27, sub-section (4), page 14, line 12. After the word "through" to insert the words "or drain on to."
Comment on this
I understand the Minister accepts this amendment.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment in Section 27, sub-section (4), "to delete all after the word ‘powers' in line 13 to the end of the sub-section."
My amendment is to give the county surveyor free access to all sorts of road material on every land. The practice hitherto, and it is maintained in this Bill, was that where any gravel pit had been worked the owner claimed a certain amount out of the gravel. I do not think that is justice. If it is continued under this Bill and with new power the tendency will be to encroach on land on which hitherto quarries or gravel pits had not been opened. These people who owned these gravel pits had a property which brought enormous revenue to them. The men who opened these quarries opened them for the distinct purpose of supplying these materials. If it is sufficient under this Bill that a man should give whatever he had in the way of road metalling on his land for the purpose of road maintenance and construction, I think this consideration in favour of people who own existing quarries should not be continued. The effect of that will be that the county surveyor will pass these gravel pits and quarries by and he will be tempted to go into lands which hitherto have not been opened up for the purposes of quarrying for gravel pits.
We all know that many people who happen to have gravel pits and quarries on their lands do not open them. In the interests of the proper working of their farm they object to allowing men and horses go through their land. Now we are going to authorise the county surveyor to go into these lands and open them up and pay no compensation. But where pits are already opened he is to give them the go-by, or if he uses the material he will have to pay, while in the other case he will not pay. In the cases of men making an enormous revenue out of supplying what is sometimes very bad road material I do not think it ought be continued, and these men should not be allowed to make an enormous revenue out of it. Where the county surveyor takes gravel out of an existing pit, or where he takes stones out of a quarry, the matter would be treated in just the some way as where he goes into lands and opens up a new quarry.
As the Bill stands it provides that if a man has an existing quarry he is to be paid compensation per load for the material taken out of it. I do not think that is fair. It is an undesirable consideration given to men who hitherto have made large sums of money out of the public, and it is a thing which this Bill should not continue. It is not just to the ratepayers at large.
Comment on this
Would not your object be met if you include in the first part the words "compensation should include the value of the material taken"?
Comment on this
I do not want anything to be paid for the material. I think if a man has this stuff on his land it should be given for the public use. But I think it unreasonable that one man should be paid and that another man should not.
Comment on this
I should like to support the principle that Senator Bennett makes very clear. I know quite a number of scandals which have arisen in this way. I knew a man who, when there was some talk of the county requiring a gravel pit for road metalling, opened a pit and sold to his neighbours two or three shovelfuls of sand to prevent the county coming in and taking the material themselves without paying him compensation. I have known that man get large sums from the county in the way of compensation. If a man who does not open a quarry or gravel pit on his land is not entitled to compensation, I do not see why a man who has opened a quarry or gravel pit and who has carried on a lucrative business there should be treated differently. I think it is very unreason able in the case of one man to give no compensation and in the case of another man to give compensation.
Comment on this
I do not think the omission of these words will have the effect that the Senator wishes. I do not know much about the law, but I understand in common law it has been ruled, in judgments given to me, that the owner has a right of payment for stones as soon as they are severed from the freehold, and, unless you expressly take that right away by Statute, it remains.
I only put that out for consideration from the drafting point of view, and I strongly resist the whole principle of taking away a ratepayer's property without compensation. You must look at this thing in broad outline. Where the quarries are equally distributed and the quality of the stone is more or less the same all over the country, it might not be inequitable, but it is quite conceivable that one district, or even one individual, might possess very desirable stone for the repair of roads. It is well-known that in England some counties have no suitable stone in their areas at all. They have to go some distance to procure stone by rail or barge. If this proposal is passed and you wanted to get better roads and get away from limestone, which everybody knows is unsuitable for our roads, you might have to bring stone some distance. Under this Bill it will be possible for whole counties to be preying on an owner in one district for all the stone they require. There will be enormous quantities, perhaps thousands and thousands of tons, removed from that district without payment. It has been said by a very distinguished judge "What you take, take openly, and pay for what you take." It is a fundamental right of the citizen to be paid for what is taken. If you apply that crude principle to one article what is to prevent the extension of that principle? You may require timber for road-making. Why not go into the woods, then, and cut down that timber, and remove it without compensation? I ask the House to resist that amendment and to protect the elementary rights of the citizen to adequate compensation.
Comment on this
I think if there was no express legislation on this point in the section your submission would have been right. If there was no restriction on the compensation, and any county council entered a man's land and took away material from it, the compensation would include the value of the material. If the section is passed in its present form I think the courts would probably hold that that common law right to compensation for the value of the materials, is excluded by the words of the section, because the words of the section are: "shall pay to the owner or occupier of such land compensation for the damage done by breaking the surface of, or making a passage through the land, or for the loss of the use of such land." You see there is no provision for compensation for the material abstracted.
Comment on this
The object of the amendment is this: There is an exception made in favour of a person who is already working an open quarry because he is to get compensation for any materials taken from his open quarry. Where no quarry has been opened, material found there and taken is not to be paid for.
Comment on this
That is exactly the old Grand Jury law. Under the Grand Jury Acts you had to get an order from the magistrates, and you did not compensate for anything except surface damage and that kind of thing, when you took the materials. But if the person was actually working for his own profit a sand pit or quarry on his land, then compensation had to be paid. I have no sympathy with Senator Barrington's and Senator Bennett's idea that because there happened to be scandals in opening bogus sandpits, and because men made a profit, they should not have made, you should not pay compensation to the ordinary man. When you go in on a man's land to take his sand, why should he not be compensated?
Comment on this
Senator Brown has no conception of the position in the country. What really has occurred is, as Senator Barrington has told us, that a man had a worthless little bit of a pit. He gave a shovel of sand to a neighbour and he has some pal on the county council to whom he said: "Will you take this worthless stuff from me." The Minister has recognised that in his Bill. He is to have control of the quality of the material to be taken, and all I want to secure in the Bill is that if the interests of the county council require it, they shall get that material without paying any compensation. Senator Sir John Keane has taken me up wrongly. He says I wish to take away all this property without compensation. I do not wish to do so. If it is his intention that every bit of material that is taken should be paid for, I shall support him in that, but I wish to protect the principle of the Bill that material should be free to the maker of the road except for such damage as surface breaking or injury to the land by carting. That seems to be reasonable.
In the section as it stands you not only pay that compensation but you pay a man who has a pit on the roadside, compensation per load for that stuff. What will the effect be? The effect will be, if this section passes as it stands, that a county surveyor interested in the upkeep of roads will pass that pit by and he will make for another pit, breaking new ground for material, which he should get for nothing. I think the whole principle of compensation is unjust and for that reason I strongly urge on the Seanad to accept this amendment. It will make for economy, efficiency and justice.
Comment on this
I think we should give road authorities every facility in the circumstances confronting us for getting our roads into fair order as economically and expeditiously as possible. I think that we should give authorities under this Bill every facility for getting the best stone they can get for the maintenance and reconstruction of our roads. It would perhaps surprise Senators to know that there are shires in England which are importing stones from Ireland for road maintenance. It pays them, seemingly, to come overland get whinstone out of our quarries and pay for shipping, rail and cartage. It is an extraordinary thing, but it shows they find it economical to do so, and how very essential it is to get the best material for any work in the way of reconstruction or maintenance, no matter where we have to go for it. It is economical to do it in the long run.
We certainly have not as far to go as they have. That is all right, but you have the wording of the Bill: "sandpit in existence and being bona fide worked at the time of the exercise of such powers.” Supposing, according to Senator Bennett, that at a time when building or other local necessity demanded it, a man opened and worked a quarry, and that for the past three years it had not been worked, the local need being exhausted, would you say under that wording that he had a quarry that was being bona fide worked at the time of the exercise of these powers?
Comment on this
I think clearly not, Senator, if he had abandoned the quarry three years before.
Comment on this
Take the other man referred to by Senator Barrington, who, in anticipation of a demand such as would arise under this Bill, finds that he has some stone available and employs a few men to work it in view of the county surveyor coming to him. That would be clearly dishonest, but I would suggest that both of these abuses could be covered by the wording of the Bill. I certainly would put a limit of time, that a man who had not bona fide worked his quarry for six months, twelve months, two years or three years, whatever period you like, when clearly it is no longer a paying concern to that man, should be excluded. Stone for public utility and public need has the character of a mineral. In many cases mineral rights were reserved to the State. Such stone is required for public utility and need, and only when it ceases to be worked by that man and there is no local demand for it is the State entitled to step in and get the material without compensation. The Bill says “at the time.” A man may have ceased working a month before, and while at the time of the exercise of these powers the quarry may be idle, he may intend to work it again in a month's time. He may say, “I am not working bona fide at the moment, but I intend working again shortly.” It would be very hard on such a man if in the meantime the county surveyor were to take it. But if a quarry has not been open within a certain time of the exercise of the power, say twelve months or two years, it should be within the right of the county surveyor to go in to get stones. I suggest to the Minister that by re-drafting he could meet these abuses.
Comment on this
That would be met by some such words as these: "and which has been bona fide opened and worked as such for at least six months before the time of the exercise of such powers.” Is that what you suggest?
Comment on this
I agree with Senator Sir John Keane in this matter. I really do not understand Senator Barrington's argument. It is the first part of this clause that I object to, that power should be taken to enter on a man's land, dig it up in a search for gravel and stone and take these away because the place has not been used as a quarry hitherto. Senator Brown says that this has been the law, but the conditions formerly were quite different from what they are now. At that time there were large landowners with thousands and thousands of acres, and it was more or less a matter of indifference to them if stone was taken from land occupied by a tenant of theirs. They did not care very much whether this land was taken or not. Now the state of affairs is quite different. The owner will now have perhaps only a few acres and he will be vitally concerned. The authorities could open all his land, practically throw him out and use his gravel and stone for public purposes. If the public want it they should pay for it. Why should the public have a right to take away a small farmer's gravel and stone, and not only that, but ruin his land? If a man has thousands of acres of land it does not matter, but in such a case as this it is a very serious matter and I object to it. I believe a man who has a gravel pit is entitled to compensation if his gravel is taken, but I should also give him compensation if he had not previously opened the quarry, not only on account of the damage done to the land but on account of the stuff that is taken away. I think he is entitled to it as much as any other man.
Comment on this
Might I emphasise the point that was alluded to by Senator Kenny and which, apparently, Senator Colonel Moore is forgetting? I think that under the provisions of the Constitution all royalties that have not hitherto been exercised are vested in the State. I do not think that trees, that Senator Sir John Keane mentioned, are royalties, but such a thing as stone which has never been worked is a royalty and therefore belongs to the State and can be taken by the State. As far as the justice of the thing goes it is obviously unfair to pay one man and not to pay another.
Comment on this
The principle underlying my amendment is this: This Bill seeks powers to get material anywhere, to raise it and to use it for the upkeep of the roads. I have accepted that as a just principle. Criticism against my amendment has been that that is unfair. It may be unfair, but my amendment does not change the Bill in that respect. All it seeks to do is to insure that no man shall be paid for material. If it is just to pay, let every man be paid. But this Bill discriminates in favour of a man who already has a pit, and I do not think that that is fair discrimination. Senator Colonel Moore agrees that it is not; he would pay every man. If so, let him move an amendment to that effect and I will support it. I want to have the roads kept better. I know that at present, where direct labour schemes are concerned, men are deprived of labour on the roads owing to excessive cost of material in many of these cases where land is taken. It is said that England was importing stones. I was on the Road Board for two or three years and I know that material was imported from France for Kent, where the best roads in England are. The innuendo was that if a suitable quarry was on a man's land people can come from Timbuctoo, Kerry, or anywhere else, and take material from it. They cannot. All they can do under this particular section is "to dig for, raise and carry away, in or out of any land to which this section applies any gravel, stone, sand, or other material which may be required for the construction or maintenance of such roads." They cannot export it, they can only take material for the purpose of these roads. I am prepared to admit that if the material is required by the Minister, he ought to have it, but what I have tried to explain, unavailingly apparently, is that under the Bill he may take it from Peter but may not take it from Paul. He may take it from the man on whom he will inflict an enormous injury by breaking up his land and knocking down his fences. That man is to have no compensation, but the man who has a pit at the roadside and to whom it will be no disadvantage at all is to get compensation. I do not think that is just, and I do not think it ought to be allowed.
Comment on this
I am rather puzzled by Senator Bennett. I do not think he really means to go quite as far as it strikes me this amendment will go. As we all know, there are quarries in existence employing large numbers of men and trading for profit. They have been exporting macadam and setts across Channel and sending them to Dublin. Does Senator Bennett really propose to go to the proprietors of the quarries and say: "Look here, you have got a fine quarry and a lot of fine machinery. We are going to take macadam from you and not compensate you?" I can hardly believe that that is his intention. Yet if this amendment is carried it will undoubtedly have that effect.
Comment on this
My desire is to make the upkeep of roads cheaper, and I think that imaginary case of the Earl of Wicklow does not exist. I know the finest granite stones at Foynes belong to Lord Monteagle, and in the last ten years not one stone has been exported.
Comment on this
This is not confined to stone. It extends to sand, gravel, and any material at all suitable to road maintenance and construction. This would be a far-reaching amendment, because I have at present in my mind a number of persons in the vicinity of Dublin who are now making a substantial income by selling sand of a superior quality to golf clubs, tennis clubs, and places like that. They are getting big prices for that sand, and that is the way in which they are utilising their land. Under this provision powers have been given to a borough or county council to go in and take any quantity they like.
Comment on this
I recognise the logic of your position. You say if you are going to compensate one, compensate the other; and if you are not compensating one, do not compensate the other.
Comment on this
I wish to say that the Senator is wrong in accusing me of trotting out an imaginary case. There are quarries in this country which were engaged in manufacturing and exporting up to quite recently.
Comment on this
At the outset I would like to point out, as Senator Brown has said, that this is not a revolutionary measure. It has been sanctioned by usage for a long period. There are good grounds for the distinction between quarries bona fide worked and quarries only opened for the specific purpose of maintaining roads. To begin with, I am not sure if the Senator's amendment would effect what he has in mind. His purpose would be better served if he suggested the deletion of the section from the word “whatever.” Otherwise it does not specifically exclude payment of compensation for other things besides breaking the surface. Apart from that, I think there are good grounds for the distinction between quarries bona fide worked and places that will not be quarries unless the county council makes them quarries. The value of a quarry depends on the demand. If the demand is there for stone it causes the stone to be valuable, and, in consequence, the quarry has a value. The quarry, has no value before the existence of the demand. Stone lying out in the Sahara desert is of no value, because it is in a place where no demand exists for it. A person owning property where stone is being worked, if the stone is valuable, is entitled to compensation for it. On the other hand, you may have a large tract of country under which there is some valuable stone or sand. There may be 100 farms under which you have the same strata of stone and sand. The county council comes to one man, picks out his gravel or sand, and says: “We will take this for the maintenance of the road.” He gets compensation for any surface damage, but the material is of no value, because there is no shortage of the material in the district. It would be inequitable to the farmers who have material of equal value to make them pay any rates for this particular material, which would have no value but for the fact that the county council is taking it. I think there is a clear distinction there, and as it is recognised by law at present I think there is no reason why we should depart from it at the present stage.
Comment on this
I move: Section 27, sub-section (4). To delete all after the word "powers" in line 13 to the end of the sub-section, and to substitute therefor the words "together with the value of any gravel, sand, stone or other material taken."
This is another amendment, approaching the same subject from a different angle. It is to ensure that compensation should be given in all cases. I am afraid I have not got that absolute veneration for what has been that would preclude me from ever amending an existing practice. I concede there has been an existing practice not to pay for material taken where the quarry has not been worked.
Comment on this
It was a matter of doubt for many years, and there were conflicting decisions on the subject. Some of the judges held that the owner was entitled in his compensation to include the value of the material taken. Finally, in 1913, it was settled that it was not. Since 1913 the law has been uniform and has refused to give compensation for the value of the material.
Comment on this
I wish first to ask the House to recognise what new conditions may produce, how it may become increasingly necessary to search for better stone, and it may necessitate counties proceeding to other counties to procure this stone, and quarries being opened which were never opened before. Is it suggested that if some owner is fortunate enough to possess this improved quality of stone, which modern conditions require, that the whole of the councils of the Free State or a number of county councils should be allowed to enter his land and remove his stone without compensation? It may be said that under the Bill this power to take is limited to one county alone. That is a matter on which I am not clear. I suggest that the Minister has power, by regulation, to authorise any county to go in and get stone in any other county. That is a point that should be safeguarded. If the stone is to be taken without compensation this power should be confined to the county in which the stone is used. Then, I think it is unjust that one end of a county should be maintaining its roads out of stone which is got gratis at another end. There would not be much injustice if those quarries were distributed equally and if everyone was sharing in the giving of this gift. Some Senators do not appreciate quality. Quality is an essential feature in the demand. Where good stuff exists everyone will want it. Look at the question of ferro-concrete roads. There you will require large quantities not alone of stone but of sand and gravel. Those materials will have to be of the best quality and can only be procured at certain places. You might have the whole of the County Dublin getting the material free from one place merely because the owner did not work his quarry at the time. If Senator Barrington's theory is right—that is, that the Constitution overrides everything—the State has power to take possession everywhere and anywhere.
I now approach the more narrow aspect of this question which arises from the words "bona fide worked.” Senator Kenny's attitude is that of a Rip Van Winkle, who has just wakened up and who does not realise what has happened during the past ten years in Ireland. It would be impossible to expect owners to have worked their quarries in Ireland during the past three or four years. It was impossible to get explosives. That alone would preclude the universal working of already-opened quarries. We know, too, that the state of the country upset any demand. Go back, then, to a date previous to our internal troubles, and we had the European War. There, again, everything was upset. All these internal development services were abandoned. All concentration was on outside issues, and it was very difficult, I think, even to get explosives in those days. The consequence was that maintenance of the roads was allowed to run down. If you are going to do justice, you will have to ante-date this question of bona fide practice to a period prior to 1914. To leave it six months or a year from now would be monstrously unjust. You will have to ante-date it to normal conditions, and I ask the House to take that view of the matter.
Comment on this
Your amendment, Senator, will delete the whole sub-section after the word "powers," because the remaining sub-section would become unnecessary if you inserted a provision that in all cases the material is to be paid for.
Comment on this
That would be the effect. I do not mind by what method it is achieved, so long as it is achieved.
Comment on this
I agree with the views of Sir John Keane on this question. We have handed over the land to the present occupiers. They are paying for it, and I think it is a scandal that their property should be taken from them in this fashion. As to the rights of the State under the Constitution to these underlying things, that is a question for the lawyers. I am not sure how lawyers in the future may interpret it, but I do say it is grossly unfair to take a man's property in this way. In the old days, the roads were made largely from broken stones and sand, taken from the landlord's quarry. The people came and took the stone away and the loss was not felt. But in the case of these small tenant owners, I hold that the county should pay for what it takes from them. Otherwise rich people in the towns may enjoy the advantage of this stuff, which is taken without payment from some poor farmer.
Comment on this
Before debating the question any further, I should like to have a ruling from you, A Chathaoirligh, on the constitutional point as to whether these things really belong to the people who have acquired their farms under the Land Acts or whether they belong to the State. It seems to me that we are beating the air until we have that very important question settled.
Comment on this
I have no doubt whatever that the sand and stone underneath the surface of a holding owned by a tenant farmer belongs to him and not to the State. A question might arise in the case of a vein of coal or a mineral of that kind. But in the case of agricultural land, I am quite satisfied that stone or gravel is the property of the owner.
Comment on this
It has been held in the case of railways, with which I have some familiarity, that gravel, which is ballast, is a royalty and that royalties are reserved to the State. It seems to me then that gravel and such things for ballast which have not been hitherto worked, would be the property of the State.
Comment on this
Have you present to your mind what the Constitution says on the subject? I do not recollect at the moment. When a question of this sort is raised and I am asked to give an opinion about it, you might at least let me know the provision of the Constitution upon which you rely.
Comment on this
Article 11 states:—
All the lands and waters, mines and minerals within the territory of the Irish Free State (Saorstát Eireann) hitherto vested in the State or any department thereof, or held for the public use or benefit and also all the natural resources of the same territory (including the air and all forms of potential energy) and also all royalties and franchises within that territory shall ... belong to the Irish Free State (Saorstát Eireann) subject to any trusts, grants, leases or concessions then existing in respect thereof or any valid private interests therein ...
I think a tenant who purchased under the Land Act would be rather surprised if he were told that the stuff under the surface of his farm did not belong to him but belonged to the State.
Comment on this
I quite agree with your view, A Chathaoirligh, on this question. It is absurd to imagine a farmer who bought out his farm being told that because there is gravel a few inches below the surface it is the property of the State. I would not envy the State in endeavouring to assert its rights to that particular form of property. I am in agreement with Sir John Keane. Heretofore in constructing roads, stone was the chief material used. There was good stone and bad stone, and the roads in the different districts indicate the nature of the stone that was used. We are entering on a new era now, and it is certain that other methods will be used in the construction of our roads. It is quite conceivable that the old-fashioned methods may no longer be resorted to. If the public wish to take possession of something belonging to a citizen, it is only fair that he should be compensated therefor. I do not suggest that he should get an extravagant value. After all you have the district justice, or whoever the official is, to fix what is a fair value, and I think the Seanad should support Senator Sir John Keane. His amendment is quite a simple and an honest one.
Comment on this
I would suggest to Senator Sir John Keane that he should introduce the words "market value," because "value" is, after all, a very difficult thing to determine in the case of a thing that has no saleable value.
Comment on this
I am quite prepared to accept that, but I would go further and suggest that the Minister should bring in some form of words, having regard to the expense which the opening of a quarry or gravel pit involves. There is considerable expense involved in going into a new area and opening a quarry. If the State opens a quarry it should be allowed, as a setoff against the cost of doing that, any material it takes from the quarry.
Comment on this
If you leave it in this way: "Such compensation as the district justice, taking all the circumstances into account, should consider just." That, I think, would cover everything.
Comment on this
I have a good deal of sympathy with the amendment, particularly with the saving clause that you, A Chathaoirligh, have suggested. At the same time I would like to stress the point that we arc up against a very serious problem in trying to maintain our roads at all. Of course the big problem is the question of finance. That is a point on which we have had a considerable amount of discussion here as well as in the Dáil. Everyone is anxious to remove the burden from their own shoulders and to try to get it on to somebody else's, but in the long run it is the one people who will have to shoulder the burden, whether you call them ratepayers or taxpayers. The problem of road-making is becoming a tremendous difficulty. I am not in a position to find a solution for it now. The Roads Advisory Committee are trying to find a solution of it. It all turns on the question of money. This amendment would undoubtedly increase the cost of maintenance considerably. I think that at a later period it might be considered just to bring forward a provision of this kind, but at the present moment, when we do not know exactly where we stand in regard to financing these road undertakings, I think it would be very inadvisable to rush it at this particular moment.
Comment on this
The Minister wants to impose a plan of his own, because he does not think this is advisable. If he left the matter open it would be different. He is trying to impose a plan of his own because he says he cannot settle the matter now.
Comment on this
I am opposed to this amendment. The land owners, referred to by Senator Colonel Moore and others, are supposed to be suffering great hardships under the system at present in force, and which this Bill intends to carry on. In my opinion, there is no hardship on land owners when compensation is paid to them for material that is taken. I have some experience of going in on land for the purpose of getting road material. The magistrates always took into account the value of the damage done to the land. The compensation given amounted to, roughly, about £250 per Irish acre, or £1 per English perch. Surely anyone getting rid of his land at that price was not suffering much hardships.
Now, in addition to giving him £250 an acre for the land, it is proposed to pay him for every load of material taken out of the quarry or sandpit. If that is to be agreed to, it will mean that he will probably get a figure running into thousands for his acre of land. I do not think a case can be made for compensating a man for material taken out of his quarry unless, as some Senators have stated, he is working the quarry bona fide himself at the present time. In such a case as that a grave hardship would be inflicted on a man if he was not paid for the material taken out of his quarry. In the case of a man working a quarry himself and selling the material out of it for building purposes, it would break up his business, of course, if a public authority were to take over that quarry and then not give him any compensation for the material they removed. I have in mind a number of cases where quarries are being worked for the production of cut stone. It is proposed by some people that material should be taken away from a man, and no compensation given to him. It is proposed by the same people to run about and pay everyone for material, whether they use it themselves or not. I think the position as it is at present is a just and a fair one; that there should be no compensation for material taken unless in the case of quarries worked bona fide by the owners.
Comment on this
Perhaps I ought to explain the legal position a little more fully to the Seanad, because what Senator Duffy states is quite true. At least it was true up to the year 1913, and the reason for that was this. The compensation, under the old Grand Jury system, where the parties could not agree, was assessed by three neighbours. The law, as I stated, was viewed differently by different judges. Some of them held that it should include the value of materials, and others held that it should not, but in practice the three neighbouring householders, when they came to measure the compensation, included the value of the material taken. But now the matter is no longer left to the three neighbouring householders. The compensation is to be assessed by the District Justice. He will have regard to the law, as settled in 1913, and he will hold that he is not entitled to give any sum whatever for the materials taken away. That will be the position under this Bill.
Comment on this
The compensation is to be no longer assessed by his neighbours but by the district justice.
Comment on this
I was going to ask whether that custom still obtains. I understood it does up to the present. Otherwise one would like to know whether there has been any grievance arising out of this arrangement that has been the law up to the present. Notwithstanding the fact that the cost of the upkeep of the roads is more than the counties can keep pace with, instead of doing anything to relieve the position here is a fresh impost imposed by the men who complain that it is absolutely impossible to keep pace with the wear and tear of the roads under modern traffic conditions. After all, these quarry lands that may be broken into are of comparatively little use for grazing or agricultural purposes, and one may take it that the district justice will assess reasonable compensation for such land. If you buy land from another there is no reason why you should buy it down to a depth of five hundred feet. You buy a piece of land for building on its face value, and afterwards you have a right if you like, instead of building on it, to open it as a quarry or sand-pit. I do not think the person that sold it has a right to come back and claim compensation for the minerals he would never work. If compensation is paid for this, there is going to be all sorts of obstruction put in the way, and extravagant claims will be made, and the cost of the roads will be greater than they are. What the other House will do is hard to say, but if it has been the law so far there is no demand for a change, and unless it is suggested that where three householders acted justly the district justice will act unjustly, there is no case for this change.
Comment on this
Senator O'Farrell seeks to impale me on the horns of a dilemma; but if you ask me whether I prefer that the roads should cost a little more or that a little should be saved by injustice, amounting almost to dishonesty, I prefer the slightly increased cost of the roads. The Minister said it would be a considerable increase I would like him to justify that assertion, because I refuse to accept it. The cost paid for the material is but a fractional cost of the expenses of the road; to anybody who knows anything about road-making it is a truism that that cost is only a small decimal of the total cost. The Minister, while expressing sympathy with the amendment, seeks to get out of the position, and I suggest, with all due respect, in a somewhat slovenly manner. He says there is difficulty about the finance and then he left the matter. But there is difficulty about finance for all public work, and it is largely due to the feeling of insecurity as to the rights of property, and if you do anything further, as I submit the present practice does, to weaken the rights of property, you will only aggravate the difficulty. Any measure that seeks to deprive owners of fair and just compensation for what you take will get us no further at all and will only put us back. I do hope the Minister will stand by what I believe are his innermost sympathies, and accept this amendment. If he does not I hope the House will assert its authority in the matter.
Comment on this
Before voting on this question may I point out that from all the discussion that took place here both yesterday and to-day, it is abundantly clear that by the methods hitherto adopted it is, as Senator O'Farrell says, absolutely impossible to meet the demands for the reconstruction of the roads by direct application of that fund. But "absolutely impossible" might be hitherto more of a relative term. What is absolutely impossible when trying a thing in one way may not be absolutely impossible by trying it in another way. Would it not be possible in some way to turn this money which is derived from the taxation of motor vehicles, which certainly is not likely to be reduced, and to hypothecate portion of that to a loan and raise a capital sum?
Comment on this
The Senator is wandering from the amendment. At present we are dealing with the question whether gravel or sand taken away from an unopened quarry is to be included in the compensation.
Comment on this
My reason for mentioning the other suggestion is that we have been told that it is absolutely impossible to pay the extra costs that would be imposed upon the construction of the roads by the present methods. I was pointing out that although it may be absolutely impossible to do it under the system hitherto adopted, it may not be absolutely impossible if another system was adopted.
Comment on this
There are 15 in favour of the amendment and 15 against. It is consequently my duty to give a casting vote. Having regard to my experience, the practice hitherto, and the change that will be involved in legislation in this Bill, if it stands as at present, I am in favour of the amendment and I declare it carried.
The Committee adjourned at 1.40 p.m. and resumed at 2.30, An Cathaoirleach in the Chair.
Comment on this
I move:—
Section 27, sub-section (5), line 23. After the word "Court" to delete the words "whose determination shall be final" and to substitute therefor the words "with a right of appeal by both parties to the Circuit Court."
During the discussion that took place on this section we learned that this question is a very involved one, and that the damage dono where there are large quarries might be very great. The amount involved might be greater than the jurisdiction given to a District Justice. I think it would be only fair to both parties that there should be a right of appeal to the Circuit Court.