We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

SEANAD IN COMMITTEE. - LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924—THIRD STAGE (RESUMED).

Contributions 155–315 of 315. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Local Government Bill 1924
Withdrawn

No. 18 of 1924 ›

I am in favour of the principle of the amendment and am willing to accept it. It might require some re-drafting and perhaps we could have it for the Report Stage.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

At present the amendment would only give the right of appeal where both parties took it. The Senator means to give the right of appeal to either party.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

So that it would read "with a right of appeal by either party to the Circuit Court."

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 27, sub-section (6), page 14, line 25. After the word "ground" to insert the words "including demesne land, golf links, tennis grounds, football or hurling grounds," and at the end of the sub-section to add the words "this sub-section shall only apply where there is no existing quarry or gravel-pit."

I submit that the section is not sufficiently comprehensive, and, I think, if the words I have suggested were included there would be no mistake. The section should include golf links, tennis courts, and football and hurling grounds.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Would not your object be met by substituting the words "recreation" for "pleasure"? I think that that would cover it.

Comment on this

I am glad to believe that sport is making strides in popularity and is doing more than is, perhaps, generally realised to bring the different sections of the people together by international matches in different games in the British Isles and elsewhere. Such events as the test matches that took place in the Antipodes commanded tremendous interest amongst the public generally. I believe that games will do much more in bringing about what we all so earnestly desire, good feeling among the people in the country, than any amount of platform oratory.

Comment on this

The serious part of the amendment is "demesne land." I am afraid that as the sub-section stands the words might imply the demesne, but I do not think that that is meant. I do not know whether the Minister recognises that, if the section stands as it is, he could go into a demesne. I do not know whether he wishes to take that power. I think it is a very useful power, as the place might be far enough away from the mansion house to do no harm to the amenities. If Senator Haughton wishes to confine himself to recreation grounds he should strike out "demesne land."

Comment on this

In my county people have to go five or six miles to get proper material. There may be material in demesne land where there are tennis courts or something of that sort. In the past we know that it was a common thing for those who did not wish to have material taken from their lands to plant a few apple trees to create an orchard, or have a tennis court, or an imitation tennis court, in order to evade the law.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

An imitation tennis court would not do, as it has to be bona fide used.

Comment on this

What I mean by a tennis court is one that would prevent stones being taken from the lands, or such interference.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

If it was imitation it would not be bona fide used and would not come within the section.

Comment on this

What troubles me is that if demesne land is allowed to remain in the amendment, I would have to vote against it. If these words are taken out I am entirely in favour of recreation grounds.

Comment on this

I think Senator Brown has raised a very good point. When drafting this section I gave particular attention to this point about the amenity and convenience of a dwelling-house. I think it would be a very serious thing if a person was allowed to open a sandpit or bring objectionable machinery near a mansion, in such a way as to injure the prospect, or anything of that kind. I think these words, "amenity" and "convenience," would protect that interest if they were included. If we include the word "demesne" it will protect interests of a much wider kind. I think when the holding of the small farmer, and of the man with a small bit of ground, or a tillage plot, can be encroached upon, we should not draw the line at "demesne land," which might include a very large tract of land around a house. I think the section would be helped by the addition of the words "for recreation purposes."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

If the Senator accepts that I think it would carry it far enough. Perhaps you could leave the section as it stands and make no change except substitute the word "recreation" for "pleasure."

Comment on this

I agree to that.

Comment on this

It might be well to add "recreation" and leave "pleasure ground" in.

Comment on this

"Pleasure ground" would apply to a house.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Insert after the word "orchard""pleasure or recreation ground."

Comment on this

The second part of the amendment was inserted in order that, if there was such a place in existence in the neighbourhood, attention should be drawn to that first.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

If that is the purpose, that part of the amendment would defeat it. I do not think that part is required at all.

Comment on this

I agree to the deletion of the latter part of the amendment.

Comment on this

I beg to move:

Section 28, sub-section (1). Line 32. To delete the word "yards" and to substitute therefor the word "feet."

My amendment aims at making the distance from the road thirty feet instead of thirty yards. It is advisable to make some change in that respect. Roads may go through urban districts, and in those districts no lands may be available on which to erect a house. It might be possible to erect a house thirty feet from the road. A house erected thirty feet off the road would not in any way, I believe, interfere with the speed of motor vehicles, if the persons using them adopt ordinary precautions, keep their own side of the road, and look out for vehicles coming in the opposite direction. As the section stands, it will to some extent obstruct the proposed building of houses. It will not be always possible to provide sites at such a long distance as thirty yards from the road. Take, for instance, the case of the plots provided for labourers' cottages. The fact that the houses would have to be erected thirty yards back would, to a very considerable extent, destroy the utility of the whole scheme. There would have to be a passage thirty yards in length from the road to the cottage. It is not desirable that any obstacle should be placed in the way of any people who intend to build houses. If the section in its present form is adopted it will prevent people who may be so inclined from erecting houses.

Comment on this

I do not think it would be advisable to accept the amendment. In most cases these powers will be used only where dangerous corners exist at cross-roads. It is not proposed to insist on using those powers on long, level stretches of straight road. A great deal will depend on the angle and the contour of the road in order to decide whether a distance of twenty or thirty feet, or thirty yards, will be sufficient. The section leaves a certain amount of discretion with the Minister. It will not be necessary to insist on thirty yards if thirty feet will meet the requirements of the situation. Having regard to the speed of modern traffic, and to the difficulty experienced in negotiating dangerous corners at the present time, a distance of thirty yards is not by any means too much. I am afraid that a distance of thirty feet would not be adequate in order to make those corners safe for the motoring public and for the people who are more or less at the mercy of the motoring community.

Comment on this

If the section were confined to houses at cross-roads or adjacent to dangerous corners, possibly that might meet with agreement.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The section reads very like that. If the Minister is satisfied that the erection of the proposed building would obstruct the view of persons using the road, so as to render the road dangerous to such a person, he can refuse permission. He can always refuse unless he is satisfied that anything less than the thirty yards would be adequate.

Comment on this

I will, with permission, withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I beg to move the following amendment:—

Section 28. To delete sub-sections (2), (3), (4), (5), (6), (7) and (8).

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You had better move the deletion of sub-section (2) first. If that proposal is not carried the others would be purely consequential upon it, and need not be touched.

Comment on this

This sub-section deals with the removal of an existing house which happens to be less than 30 yards from the public road. It is very undesirable that any power should be given either to the county council or to the Minister to interfere with the residence of any person whose house happened to be within that limit of the road. I dare say that the object of the amendment is to enable motors to travel at a greater speed than they have hitherto been travelling at. That object is not as important as the preservation of the right of occupants to regard their houses as their castles. They should not, under any circumstances be compelled to leave. There is, of course, the provision that an alternative house shall be provided.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

And the occupant is also to get compensation.

Comment on this

The people in this country are so very fond of their old homes that no alternative accommodation would satisfy them for the house that, perhaps, they were born in.

Comment on this

I cannot agree with this amendment. I do not believe it is intended that motorists should travel at any greater speed now than they have been travelling at. I believe the section is intended for the safety of the people who live in those houses. I have in mind a house on the border of the Counties Cork and Kerry at which, to my own knowledge, three people were killed. Two were visitors who were riding a motor cycle and side car, which dashed against the house, and they lost their lives. Such an obstacle as that should not be permitted on a public highway. Perhaps it might be easier and cheaper to remove the road away from the house? At any rate the road should be quite clear for motorists and all other users.

Comment on this

I hope I will not be out of order in calling attention to the words made use of some generations ago by William Pitt, afterwards Earl of Chatham, touching on the sanctity of the home. The words were to this effect: "The poorest man may in his cottage bid defiance to all the forces of the Crown. It may be frail; its roof may shake; the winds may blow through it and the storm may enter; but the King of England with all his forces dare not cross the threshold of this ruined tenement."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Are you sure William Pitt used those words?

Comment on this

I think so.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think I heard something like them before.

Comment on this

I was going to suggest that we should have those words copied out and handed to the genial Minister for Local Government and Public Health, who turned me down so graciously with regard to lodging houses the other day. They will be useful when it comes to the question of ruthlessly interfering with dwelling-houses.

Comment on this

The intention of this section is to apply it principally to walls. The mere fact that compensation will have to be granted when a house is removed, and that alternative accommodation will have to be found for the people who have been deprived of their dwellings will constitute, in itself, a sufficient safeguard against the arbitrary use of this section. It certainly would render the provision of this Bill with regard to roads very unsatisfactory if this section were to be deleted. The object of this section is more to protect pedestrians and the persons living in or near a dwelling-house than to protect the motorists. Senator Linehan seems to imagine that my whole object in framing this Bill was to enable motorists to go at a greater speed than they can at the present time. I can assure him that that was not my object at all. It was more to protect pedestrians and the persons using other means of conveyance than in the interests of motorists and motor-car owners that this section has been drafted.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That disposes of the amendment as affecting the remaining sub-sections.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

In Section 28, sub-section (2), page 14, line 36, after the word "structure" to insert the words "not used for religious purposes."

This section gives power to remove any obstruction. That would include a church. I want to know if churches or houses intended for religious purposes could be removed. I do not suppose it was intended that churches should be removed.

Comment on this

I am afraid if this amendment were passed that its power would be a very wide one. Its purpose is very widely framed. A person selling rosary beads in a little shop in a country town might seek to have it construed that his house was performing or serving a religious purpose. Or, perhaps, it might be argued that the wall around the graveyard which might constitute a menace to the public might come within the definition and that it could not be touched if this amendment were accepted. I do not think that in this country there is any danger of a structure used for religious purposes being interfered with. The Senator seeks to impose a very wide limitation by this amendment. I do not think the Senator should insist upon pressing it.

Comment on this

Would the Minister be satisfied to insert in the Bill that he would exclude churches?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think such a phrase as "churches not used for public worship" might meet the case. As it stands at present the Bill would include schoolhouses, meeting houses, church halls, and things of that kind. It is very wide, but if you put in the words "not used for purposes of public worship" that might meet the situation.

Comment on this

I think the section should be allowed stand as it is. Surely, in the name of goodness, no Government in Ireland elected by the people of Ireland are going to pull down churches.

Comment on this

I withdraw the amendment with the permission of the Seanad.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

In Section 28, sub-section (6), page 15, to add at the end of the sub-section the words "and the District Court shall have full jurisdiction to deal with the same, notwithstanding that the amount thereof exceeds £25."

I beg to call attention to the fact that the jurisdiction at present of the District Justice does not reach beyond this figure of £25. It is in order to cover that I am moving this amendment.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Of course it really is not necessary, because this Act of the Oireachtas will just have the same effect as the Courts of Justice Act. This Act of the Oireachtas gives jurisdiction, and therefore the District Justice has jurisdiction under the statute. It is not really necessary to press this amendment. This is subsequent to the Courts of Justice Act, and it provides in this particular case that the District Justice is to have jurisdiction.

Comment on this

On sub-section (6) I meant to have an amendment moved which is not on the amendment paper. I had other amendments practically the same as this. As my amendments were based on the same principle I ask the permission of the Seanad to be allowed to move an amendment on this section. Sub-clause 6 gives the Government power to remove houses within 30 yards from the road and have them put back. To enable them to do that they have to go through certain forms. One is that there must be a certain amount of compensation. I think the clause dealing with compensation is rather vague. I will be guided by you on the matter. If you assure me that the compensation is to be paid I am quite satisfied. But if compensation is to be paid you will find that there will be an amount of litigation. The person whose house is to be removed will have to go to the District Court, and there go through a complicated system of law. After the court has made an order that the house is to be removed, if the person fails to carry out that order, the duty will devolve upon the council to do the work themselves. They would then have to do the work themselves, which they would have done in the first instance if there had been no objection. I would ask that sub-section (6) be amended in this direction. Some people may object that the county council should enter into a man's land willy nilly. That would not be the case, because before making the application to the Minister he would have to be notified, and he would have the ordinary recourse to law.

If a house has got to be removed, if the public interest makes it necessary that it should be removed, I think it is a great hardship to ask a man, if he is a poor man, to go to the trouble of hiring servants and possibly of going to the bank to get some money to enable him to remove this house or structure. There is a great chance that he will fail to do that, because he is not conversant with all the necessary details. Local authorities have at their disposal a great number of trades people of every description, and they would be in a position to remove it in the most expeditious and economical manner. I think it would be reasonable that the council should remove such obstruction, giving at the same time a person interested an opportunity of appealing to the District Justice if he thinks that the removal is unjust. The Minister very courteously spoke to me on the matter, and he was of opinion, I think, that under this particular section no compensation is to be paid. He said to me that he would go as far as possible to enable compensation to be paid. I ask you, sir, to help me. I think, as the section stands, it would fail unless the Acquisition of Land clause at the end makes it clear.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

As regards your first point, I do not see in this section any provision in sub-section (4) giving compensation to the occupier where he holds under contract of tenancy, and yet he will be the person, of course, who will be inconvenienced by having to clear out. There is no provision for compensation for him. The occupier is only to get compensation where he is not holding under lease or contract of tenancy but is himself the owner of the place.

Comment on this

Would not that be met by inserting the words, in line 52, sub-section (4): "shall pay to every person having an interest in the land on which such building or structure is situated or in such building or structure...?"

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That is what I was going to suggest—or in the building or structure itself.

Comment on this

That, of course, would make it much plainer and simpler, but it would not relieve a man who is in the position of having his house shifted of doing it himself. After all it would be a great convenience if you were told to pull down a stable or anything else if the people requiring that to be done did it themselves. Nobody would be inconvenienced. I think that is much simpler than asking a man to go into court, asking that compensation should be awarded to him, and then seeking compulsory powers for a local body to do work which could be done in the first instance by a much simpler process.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That is on the second point.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

As regards the first point, the position is more peculiar than I thought it was, because while the occupier of the building or structure is to get no compensation if he is in possession as a tenant he is nevertheless to be liable to recoup the council for all expenses that they have been put to in the removal of the structure in the event of the order to remove it being disobeyed. I think there is some omission there. I think subclause (4) should include compensation to the occupier as well as to the owner of the land.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Bennett on this point. I think the county council should be made to remove these structures. When a railway company has to remove a house in the construction of a railway, they have to build another house instead, and I think the authorities should be compelled to do the same thing here. The building of a wall may cost £5, but the legal procedure involved in getting compensation would probably cost about £10. I think that we should make it compulsory on the county council to build the wall or house, as the case may be.

Comment on this

It might be better to leave this amendment over to the Report Stage. I have discussed the matter with Senator Bennett and we agreed the draft was defective as regards compensation. Of course, the point as to whether the county council should rebuild the wall or not, is a moot point, and people will have different opinions on it. In a great many cases a man whose wall is taken down would prefer to rebuild the wall himself if he got compensation from the county council. It would not be necessary except in exceptional cases for him to go into court. However, that is a matter in which I am in the hands of the Seanad and I do not think it matters very much.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied to leave it over to the Report Stage if the Minister so wishes, and if he will bring in an amendment which will meet the case equitably. I do impress upon him, however, that my amendment would meet the case in a much simpler and more economic way than any that could be devised.

Comment on this

There is also the question of compensating a person whose house has been taken down. I take it that it is intended that sub-section (3) should cover that, but I do not think it refers to it. It simply says: "No order shall be made by the Minister under the next preceding sub-section in respect of any occupied dwelling-house at the passing of this Act unless and until the Minister is satisfied that alternative accommodation, reasonably equivalent as regards rent and suitability in all respects is available for the occupants." Alternative accommodation may be available but it does not necessarily follow that the people whose houses had been pulled down had not suffered considerable loss as a result of that, and I think there should be some compensation if the owner of the land is to be compensated.

Comment on this

It may cost them £20 to move.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That is what I have in mind. That is what we have to look into, and the Minister, I am sure, will consider that in connection with your other point and deal with with it on Report.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied if it is dealt with on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (7), line 19, after the word "notice" to insert the words "shall be served by personal service or by registered letter."

Sub-section (7) provides that one month's notice must be served by the council on the owner of the dwelling, and it goes on to state: "and such notice may be served by posting a copy thereof in a conspicuous place on such building or structure or on such site, as the case may be." I propose to delete these words and to insert those in the amendment. If the owner of the building is available, I do not see why he should not be served personally. The notice could be stuck on the building and torn down a few hours afterwards, and the owner might not know anything about it.

Comment on this

I would like to support this amendment. I think it is very reasonable. In these days notices are pulled down by innocent schoolboys, or offending schoolboys, half an hour after they are put up.

Comment on this

The only trouble is the difficulty in finding out who the owner is in many cases.

Comment on this

Generally speaking there is no trouble in finding the owner.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

It could be amended: "and such notice may, in cases where the owner and occupier cannot be ascertained."

Comment on this

Where the owner can be found he can be served personally.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

"Where the owner or occupier cannot be found." Will that do?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

After the word "notice," in line 19, you amend the section in this way: "and such notice may, in any case in which the owner or occupier cannot be found, be served by posting a copy thereof."

Comment on this

Does that mean that where the owner can be found he must be served personally?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

He will be served by notice in writing. The first part of that clause says: "a council shall give not less than one month's notice in writing to the owner and to the occupier."

Comment on this

I move the deletion of sub-section (2). I admit that in certain cases it may be necessary to cut down a few trees, but it seems to me that sub-section (2) might refer to plantations along the roads. I think we will all agree that too many trees have been cut down in this country. There is another matter which perhaps the Minister would take into consideration. Most of the land in the Free State is held by tenant purchasers. Supposing one of these were to get a notice from the county surveyor to cut down a tree, and an order is made against him to do so, under one of the Land Acts he is prohibited from doing so without the consent of the Minister for Lands and Agriculture. If the Minister refuses to give his consent, whom is he to obey? If he refuses to cut down the tree he is prosecuted by the county surveyor; if he obeys he will probably be prosecuted by the Minister for Lands and Agriculture.

Comment on this

The Senator has put up a conundrum that I do not think I am in a position to solve. Perhaps you, Sir, with your great legal experience, will be able to find the solution. But I think it would be a mistake to delete this sub-section. At present these overgrown hedges and trees constitute a very grave danger to users of the roads, not merely motorists, but all people travelling on them. They constitute a source of inconvenience in three ways. To begin with, tall trees overhanging the roads in many cases keep the surface soft, and make it very difficult to keep the roads in repair. Secondly, they obstruct the view of people coming round corners; and, thirdly, there is the danger of having one's eyes torn out by brambles. It is very necessary that this power should be given. Of course we cannot make omelettes without breaking eggs, and in some cases individual rights may be infringed a very little, but if we balance the amount of good that will accrue from putting this section into operation against the loss that may occur to individuals, I think that everybody will agree that the benefits greatly outweigh the losses. If this clause is deleted it would scarcely be worth while continuing the rest of the section.

Comment on this

At present the county surveyor or the county council has power to make an order for the trimming of hedges, but not for cutting them down. I do not see that they need any more power.

Comment on this

That is only for the purpose of preventing injury to the road itself.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

This sub-clause (2), Senator Brown, appears to be aimed solely at the injury to the roads. The owner gets "within twenty-one days after the service of the notice to trim or cut such hedge or tree so that it will no longer be prejudicial to the road."

Comment on this

He certainly has that power already, there is no doubt about that. But I think this was intended to do more than that.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think instead of "trim" the words should be "cut down."

Comment on this

The present power, I think, is only to compel trimming.

Comment on this

Prejudicial in that sense is governed by sub-clause (c) of sub-section (1): "obstructs the view of persons using the road so that the road thereby becomes dangerous to persons using it."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I would like to hear that discussed. I think it would be very difficult to maintain that contention.

Comment on this

"A hedge or tree shall be deemed to be prejudicial to a road within the meaning of this section"——

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That covers it. This sub-section (2) appears to apply only to trimming.

Comment on this

Does it take away from the county surveyor the power to cut down these hedges? I do not think you could carry out county council work at all if the council do not have that authority.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think the only change made here is this: There is already power to cut down hedges or trees where they are prejudicial to the road. But prejudicial to the road in the existing legislation would have a very narrow view. It has not been extended to cover the cases (a), (b) and (c), so that in the future there would be jurisdiction which did not exist before to compel the trimming of a hedge where it causes an obstruction to the road, obstructs the view of persons, and so on. It enlarges the reasons for which the county surveyor may cause any hedge to be trimmed or tree to be cut.

Comment on this

It gives power to remove also, which is most important.

Comment on this

If this amendment were passed it would put us in the position in which we were before the previous Act was passed. Does Senator Butler want to give the county surveyor no authority to act?

Comment on this

He wants to strike the sub-section out of the Bill.

Comment on this

I think it is a very necessary sub-section.

Comment on this

The real difficulty seems to be (a). Nobody who owns trees will object to them being cut down, because they are an obstruction to the view, but there are many places where there are new or old plantations along the side of a road, and this power may be used by some arbitrarily-minded county surveyor to cut down rows of trees. Trees are scarce enough, and any power that could be used for that purpose I would oppose. Consequently I think the amendment ought to be passed.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think that disposes of the next, to delete sub-clause (3).

Comment on this

Might I move that sub-clause (a) be deleted, for the reasons which I gave?

Comment on this

This is the existing power that the Senator proposes to remove, the power that has been in existence for I cannot say how many years, and I might say that the view of our head Roads Engineer is that all the roads should be planted with trees, but that they should be planted in suitable positions. I think it would be a very serious thing to interfere with this existing right of cutting down timber where it prejudices the road-users' point of view.

Comment on this

In view of that, as I only suggested the amendment on the spur of the moment, I had better withdraw it.

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 29, sub-section (5). To delete all after the word "necessary" in line 41 down to and including the word "days" in line 44, and to substitute therefor the words "may order that the necessary work be carried out by the county surveyor or urban district council by whom the request was made."

This provision is not quite as innocuous as it appears. The hedge and all that appertains to it will have to be removed. That will be a very big job. It will be more difficult than the erecting of a house. The Minister may not realise that, but to take a fence back twenty yards is a very serious operation. The same principle should apply in this case as in the other case, and the work should be done by the local authority. That would be only reasonable. The uprooting of a fence and the replanting of it in another place is too big a task to impose upon a man without proper compensation. I think this matter should be considered on Report.

Comment on this

This work is not in the same category as the removal of a wall. After all, if we place the onus on the local authority of cutting down all those hedges that obstruct the view on roads, the county council will have to hire a special staff for the purpose. In one of his recent reports, our chief engineer said it would be a good thing for the country if those responsible for the maintenance of roads would stop gardening. I think that if we accepted the Senator's amendment it would lead to a great deal more of this abuse. Ample compensation can be given under the section to the owner to compensate for the removal of those hedges and I think that that should be quite adequate to safeguard the interests of the private owner.

Comment on this

Are you quite satisfied that he will be compensated.

Comment on this

Sub-section (7) deals with that.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied. I ask leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 29, sub-section (6), page 16, line 51, after the word "within" to delete the word "fourteen" and to substitute therefor the word "twenty-eight."

Fourteen days is not sufficient time to give to have the work carried out.

Comment on this

I think the notice provided under the Bill is ample. First of all there is notice of twenty-one days. Then there is a hearing in the District Court. After that, there is notice of fourteen days more. In all, the notice amounts to nearly two months. I think that should be ample. This is one of the matters which we have to pay attention to, because you cannot cut a hedge except at certain times of the year without endangering its subsequent growth. If we allow too long a time to elapse it will be impossible to put the section into operation at all.

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 29, sub-section (6). Page 16, line 58. After the word "expenses" to insert the words "which the District Justice shall consider-reasonable," and to delete line 59.

Under the Bill, an urban district council or a county council would be able to spend any money they liked in carrying out the work. I propose to restrict that by inserting the words "which the District Justice shall consider reasonable."

Comment on this

I have no objection to the amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 29, sub-section (8). Page 17, line 9. After the word "hedge" to insert the words "or tree."

Comment on this

We can accept that amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 30. Immediately before section 30 to insert a new section as follows:—

30.—(1) In this section the word "animal" means all cattle and swine and also any horse, ass, mule, sheep or goat, and the young of any such animal.

(2) Every person who permits any animal belonging to him or in his charge to wander or stray on a road shall be guilty of an offence under this section, and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to the following penalties, that is to say:

(a) in the case of a first offence a fine not exceeding one pound for every animal in respect of which the offence is committed more than one hour after sunset and more than one hour before sunrise a fine not exceeding two pounds for every such animal, and

(b) in the case of a second or any subsequent offence to a fine not exceeding five pounds for every animal in respect of which the offence is committed, or where the offence is committed more than one hour after sunset and more than one hour before sunrise a fine not exceeding ten pounds for every such animal.

The reason for this amendment is the growing evil of straying cattle on the roads. In many parts of the country the cattle practically live on the roads. That is the case in regard to one of the counties that I know best in the west of Ireland. With the increase in motor traffic, that is a very real and growing danger. The present law is altogether insufficient for the purpose of suppressing this evil. The maximum fine under the old Petty Sessions Act is 2s., and the procedure is very technical. The section which it is proposed to add defines "animal" in such a way as to include all animals except dogs and cats. Sub-section (2) provides a maximum penalty of £1 where the animal strays in the daylight, and £2 where the animal is straying at night. That is for the first offence, and Clause (b) for the second offence brings the maximum penalty in the day time up to £5, and at night time up to £10.

Comment on this

Should not the word "jennet" be added. I do not think under the wording that it would come under the section. In my district there is a jennet which is continuously living on the roads.

Comment on this

It is quite clear that this amendment is put down in order to allow motorists further to increase their speed. There is an extraordinary penalty put on here for allowing a goat to stray on a road. It is a fine of £5. It is not meant to be recovered as a civil debt, and the unfortunate owner of the goat would have to go to prison if he could not procure £5.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

He might disown the goat.

Comment on this

It seems to me that the common people are to be ignored altogether and that nothing must stop the motors. I am surprised that the extreme penalty of the law was not put on to keep those animals off the road. In very many cases goats are useful for the purpose of supplying milk to the occupiers of cottages adjoining the roads. I daresay sometimes the goats are fed on the roads. In that way they supply milk to the family. I think that is a more important thing than even the extra miles per hour of a motor car. This amendment would make the Bill repugnant to all the cottiers in the country.

Comment on this

I have another objection to this amendment. As it stands, if a beast strayed out on the road—we all know that will happen— and was taken by Civic Guard, the owner is subject to a penalty of a pound. If we are to accept the amendment I think there should be some clause protecting such a man. The goat is a little harmless animal. If you tried to ride over a goat on a bicycle you hardly could. I have done a lot of work on bicycles and I know that a goat can hardly be ridden over. Senator Linehan's plea for the cottiers' goat ought to be considered. Every cottier has a little goat which grazes on the hedge. Those poor persons get their grazing and always will from the outside of the hedges.

Comment on this

I agree with what Senator Linehan and Senator Bennett said about the goat. If you were going in a motor at about 55 miles an hour you could hardly run over him.

Comment on this

I cannot find any reasonable cause for this amendment, nor can I understand the attitude taken up on the question by Senators. It seems strange to me that the fact that a goat, belonging to a very poor person, strays on the road is classified as a serious crime according to the penalties here. Some people have large demesnes with roads through them and have cattle and sheep feeding on those demesnes and straying on these roads. No remarks about those are passed. If you go out to the Phoenix Park you will see hundreds of cattle and deer grazing there. They are not considered an obstruction, but when a poor man has a goat which gets on the road, although he runs the risk of losing his goat through an accident, he also will be almost hanged for having his goat at all there.

Comment on this

Under the old Brehon laws of this country, which were founded on equity and justice, the fine for the trespass of a goat was 3/- and for the trespass of a hen 3d. If you can confine a goat to the road it is all right, but I do not think there is a more harmful or destructive beast than a goat. It will graze a hedge out of existence and it will ring a tree in one night. If goats were spancelled properly, so that they would not go into adjoining plantations, I would be in favour of exempting them from the scope of the amendment.

Comment on this

I cannot agree with the sentiments of Senators Bennett and MacLysaght. I think a goat is a desperate animal on a road. Have these Senators ever seen two goats tethered on the road and both pulling in opposite directions? I have often had to stop my car owing to such an event. That is my experience of the Kerry goats at least. I think goats are the most objectionable animals in creation.

Comment on this

My objection is not altogether to their being on the road, but I find that they come into people's gardens. The goat is a most wonderful animal. She can produce milk from ivy and the bark of holly trees. I live in a place called Terenure. We have several goats there owned by people living in cottages. The goats are let loose on the roads to stray into people's gardens and to destroy all their plants and shrubs.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think they sometimes come down to Miltown.

Comment on this

I see they stray down the road to Rathgar. I feel strongly in favour of this amendment.

Comment on this

I consider the penalties imposed by this amendment are too heavy. If we reverted to the old penalties of something like 1/- or 2/- for the first offence, and then a scale going up it would be reasonable. As Senator Bennett pointed out, this can be made a terrible hardship, because in several cases someone might leave a gate open and cattle might stray out on to the roads. The Civic Guard comes along then and the owner is prosecuted under this law and fined to the extent of £20.

Comment on this

I have a great deal of sympathy with Senator Linehan's contention. I believe a large number of cottiers almost depend for their subsistence on goats, and they have no other place to graze on but the country roads.

Comment on this

I do not see any particular hardship in this amendment any more than in the amendment which provides for the removal of trees and even houses which obstruct the view. If you pull down a man's house to give a good view of the road there seems very little to be said in favour of the goat. The whole argument in favour of the goat seems to me to centre on her agility in getting out of the way. One might calculate wrongly the way the goat intended to go and then a serious accident might happen. I think the amendment is a desirable one. The penalties are maximum ones, and they can be made small. I think straying animals are a terrible pest and should be removed. Not only are they a danger to traffic but they are a nuisance. They are continually straying into gardens and destroying trees.

Comment on this

I have been pestered by flocks of twenty or thirty goats coming in and barking every tree, holly especially. There has always been a law against trespass on roads but no one carried it out. Around my place flocks of cattle, sheep, and all sorts of animals trespass about the road, but no one ever turns them off and no one is likely to turn them off. I think that these rules and regulations are perfectly futile, because the goats will live on the roads no matter what regulations are made.

Comment on this

I do not know whether or not Senator Colonel Moore's contention is right. I have gone to the police barracks myself and complained about the trespass of goats. The police told me they had no power to do anything unless the goats were actually caught in my garden. I know another inhabitant in my neighbourhood—a lady —who also complained. She became very indignant when she discovered that there were nine policemen in the barrack and that there were nine goats straying on the road. Surely the nine policemen should have been able to deal with the nine goats, but as a matter of fact nothing was done.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Of course it would be necessary, Senator, to catch them in the act.

Comment on this

It seems to me that the penalties proposed to be imposed under this section are enormous for such a trivial offence. The goat, after all, is the poor man's cow. In cases such as these, much lighter penalties should, I think, be provided.

Comment on this

I think the amendment is a reasonable one. I think, too, it is a very good amendment. Proof of that is to be found in the fact that all the argument has centred around the goat. Senator Kenny made reference to the jennet, but that animal does not appear on the list at all. A jennet, I understand, comes under the definition of a mule, so that it is not necessary to include jennet here at all. Anyone aware of the conditions that prevail in the country at the present time must realise the terrible nuisance that these animals are on the public roads. The present laws are very inadequate for dealing with them. As Senator O'Farrell pointed out, the penalties mentioned here are maximum, and it is to be assumed that the District Justice will use his discretion in fining people who are brought before him and found guilty of the offence of allowing animals to stray along the public roads. I think it is high time that drastic measures should be taken to prevent this terrible nuisance. Goats, whether they are agile or not, are undoubtedly a great danger to the public. In the majority of cases, as Senator O'Sullivan pointed out, two goats are spancelled together, and in these cases you usually find one goat trying to go one way, and the second goat the other way. Incidents of that kind constitute a great public nuisance. We all know, too, that the goat is a very poisonous animal. The branches of a tree or anything like that on which it lays its tongue dies or gets badly injured. On the whole, I think there is a great deal to be said in favour of the amendment, and I am willing to accept it.

Comment on this

Would I be in order in moving that the penalties be reduced by half?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

If the amendment is carried, you can then move your amendment.

Comment on this

Senator Brown suggests to me that I ought to add to the amendment the word "permits." We all know that at times it is impossible to prevent cattle and horses from breaking away from the lands on which they are grazing. They may get on to the roads and wander for miles. In such cases it would be a great hardship on the owners to be prosecuted and fined heavily, and hence I think the safeguard suggested by the addition of the word "permits" ought to be adopted.

Comment on this

I think the word "permits" implies knowledge. It is a word that has been used in the Petty Sessions Act, and I do not know any other word that you could substitute for it. Before the amendment is put it might be well to add to the definition in Clause 1 of the proposed new section the word "jennet."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I would suggest, Senator Brown, that on the Report Stage, you would introduce an amendment making it plain that this applies to actual knowledge on the part of the owner of the animal. I think many Senators found difficulty in regard to that.

Comment on this

I will try to do that.

Comment on this

With regard to my amendment to Section 30, I think it could be dealt with better under Section 31.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think so, too. I will take it as soon as we come to Section 31.

Section 30 was agreed to and added to the Bill.

SECTION 31.

(1) The Minister may make regulations prescribing:—

(a) the nature and quality of the materials which may be used in the maintenance and construction of roads:

(b) the size, shape, colour, and character of the signs to be erected on roads for the purpose of—

(i.) indicating the places to which the road leads, and the distances to such places,

(ii.) indicating the distances on the road,

(iii.) warning persons using the road of dangerous portions thereof,

(iv.) guiding traffic on the road with a view to minimising the risk of accidents;

(c) the places at which the several signs hereinbefore mentioned are to be erected;

(d) the conditions upon which such signs as aforesaid may be erected or retained on land adjoining any road by the owner or occupier thereof;

(e) the signals by which persons using roads can indicate their intentions to other persons.

(2) Every regulation made under this section shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as may be after it is made, and if a resolution is passed by either House of the Oireachtas within the next subsequent twenty-one days on which such House has sat after the regulation is laid before it annulling the regulation, the regulation shall be annulled accordingly but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done under such regulation.

(3) The council entrusted by this Act with the maintenance of any road—

(a) shall not use in the maintenance of such road any material of a nature or quality contrary to regulations made under this section, and

(b) shall erect and maintain on such road such and so many of the signs prescribed by the regulations made under this section and in such places as shall be necessary to comply with such regulations, and

(c) shall not erect on such road any sign in contravention of such regulations.

(4) The expenses of a council in erecting any sign in accordance with such regulations as aforesaid on any road and of maintaining such sign shall be part of the expenses of the maintenance of that road.

(5) If it appears to a Justice of the District Court that any sign such as is referred to in this section is erected or retained on land adjoining any road contrary to any regulation made under this section, he may on the application of any police officer or of any officer of the council to whom the maintenance of such road is entrusted by this Act, order the removal of such sign, and, if he thinks it advisable, by such order authorise such officer to enter on such land for the purpose of removing such sign.

(6) If any person, without lawful authority, removes, defaces, or otherwise injures any such sign as is mentioned in this section, he shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding ten pounds or, at the discretion of the court, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding one month.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—In Section 31, sub-section (1), to delete paragraph (a).

I do not think it is desirable to take away from the discretion of the county councils, especially in the case of minor county roads and bye-roads, what material they should use on them. The traffic on some of these roads is not very great and it is really of very little importance what class of material is put on them. I therefore move the deletion of this paragraph so that it may be left to the discretion of the county council to select the material they shall use, particularly on the roads I have referred to.

Comment on this

I cannot agree with Senator Linehan on this question. I think the Minister should have full power to prescribe the kind of material to be used on the roads. In my own town soft material out of a quarry, that was condemned twenty-five years ago is being put on a road there. The material is not suitable for the traffic on that road, and I think it is an outrageous waste of public money to be putting material of that description on a road. This is a matter on which the Minister should have absolute control and it certainly should not be left to the discretion of the county council.

Comment on this

I desire to support the statement made by Senator O'Sullivan. I know a case in which stones, locally known as clay slate, were put out on a road. Owing to the action of the sun they became a kind of gravel and soon after you had nothing but a heap of mud. I have known councils to go to the expense of steam-rolling with that class of material. I think it is absolutely essential that this matter should be left in the hands of the Minister.

Comment on this

I would like to know from the Minister what exactly he means by the words "nature of the materials." That is an expression that I think, would need to be explained. It might mean that nothing would be used on the roads except stones; on the other hand it might be contended that the expression meant that nothing could be used on the roads except cement. I would be prepared to give him the power as far as the quality of the material is concerned, but without some explanation the term "nature of the materials" may have very far-reaching effects and should be explained.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I thought we were going to get some assistance from those who favour government on democratic principles. During the weekends we hear democracy lauded to the skies, and the principle preached that the people should be trusted, yet when we come to a matter of legislation here we see all sorts of attempts made to impose unreasonable conditions. I do not stand for any absolute doctrine of democracy; perhaps if Senators heard my private opinions upon that matter they would be horrified. But in a matter of this kind, where there is no real sin and no real extravagance being committed, they must be allowed to use their own discretion. How can you expect to get any education or self-consciousness developed, if the Minister thinks there is a certain danger being perpetrated, comes in and nips the tendency in the bud, not realising that instruction only comes through a process of making mistakes. Apart from that altogether, people who pay money should be allowed to call the tune, and that is the ground on which I challenge the wisdom and the right of this power on the part of the Minister to interfere. These rural districts are very badly off, and they cannot afford these things, and a centralised government has no right to impose upon them expenses which they cannot afford, being, as they are, self-governing and autonomous institutions. If, in their discretion, they consider that a limit should be imposed upon expenditure on roads, they should have full control as to how that expenditure should take place, and for that reason I support the amendment.

Comment on this

Possibly the Minister had in view a road scheme of a general character which undoubtedly must be arrived at. In order to make for uniformity of standard for main roads or trunk roads under any such scheme it is necessary the Minister should have control. At the moment every county surveyor has his own particular fad both as to repair of roads and the sort of materials to be used, and when it comes to improving and strengthening the foundations he also has his particular fads. The result is that if you go through the counties of Ireland you can always tell where one county boundary crosses another, because of the different methods of road construction. It is, therefore, very essential that in any scheme that is ahead of us uniformity should be observed as to method of construction and method of surfacing, because otherwise the overhead charges will be the same, even if you use bad material.

Under the new scheme if a standard is not set to secure that uniformity which should prevail along trunk roads they will be found to vary between one county and another. You will find the road has held up well in one county, while it has gone down in another, because in the one county the surveyor, whether for the purposes of economy or otherwise, used local inferior material, whether in the foundation of the road or in the surfacing, whereas if he had gone three or four miles further at a little expense he would have as good a road as that in the neighbouring county. That is what is in the Minister's mind when he seeks this power and I suggest that he should take further power than that in paragraphs (a) and (b). Paragraph (a) speaks as to the nature and quality of the materials which may be used in the maintenance and construction of roads, and (b) of the size, shape, colour and character of the signs to be erected on the road. I say there should be another paragraph (c) as to the methods of maintenance and construction of the road——

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

We have not come to that; we are dealing with an amendment to delete paragraph (a).

Comment on this

I am in favour of giving the Minister powers under this sub-section. The reason for giving these powers is that some councils have very indifferent county surveyors and assistant surveyors. I have seen in a county close to me, 20 or 30 men and a steamroller rolling material, and they might as well have been rolling turf. Where there is an efficient county surveyor it will not be necessary to interfere, but in other counties it is very necessary to have powers such as contained in a section like this.

Comment on this

I want to ask for information. I want to know whether this sub-section gives the Minister power to say what class of road shall be made. There is an important question: whether or not the use of concrete roads would be an advantage. I want to know whether, if this section is passed, the sub-section will give the Minister power to insist upon a county council laying down concrete roads in certain areas. As I read it I think it gives that power and I am asking for information.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think it is quite plain it would.

Comment on this

I may say it was not my intention in drafting this section to look for that power. It was impressed upon me at one time that I should use a method which would enable me to have roads maintained or constructed of concrete and I refused to have it. The main motive in introducing this section is to enable me to prevent the use of soft limestone and that kind of material of which Senator O'Sullivan spoke.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Leave out the word "any" and leave in the words "quality of the materials." If the word "any" is added it would be open to the objection of Senator Farren.

Comment on this

While I am not opposed to giving the Minister power to insist on people in the country carrying out the necessary work, I am opposed to giving the Minister power to override the elected representatives of the people in the spending of money provided for maintaining the roads in a proper state. A difference of opinion may arise between two surveyors—between the surveyor of a county council and the surveyor from a Government Department—as to the class of road most suitable in a certain area. I am of the opinion that, in certain circumstances, there should be a serious attempt made to try whether these concrete roads would be a success. In certain areas I believe that they would be a success, and would prove to be less expensive to repair than macadam roads, but there are certain areas, and particularly rural areas, where you could not possibly adopt concrete roads. They would be all right in cities, where there would be a tremendous amount of motor traffic, but in rural districts, where farmers' carts are the principal traffic, concrete roads would not be suitable in winter months. There would be very great danger of slipping in frosty weather, and for that reason I do not think it would be well to give the Minister power to override the decisions of county councils as to the class of roads. I do not object to give him power to specify the proper material but I object to giving him power to say "this shall be a concrete road instead of a macadam road."

I have heard Senators referring to the use of material, and, from my experience, it is not always the class of material used that is responsible for bad roads. If a road is not properly made, no matter what material it is made from it will crack up. I am prepared, as I said, to give the Minister the necessary power to see that proper material will be used in the roads. I will not go so far as to give him power to say what class the road shall be.

Comment on this

I object to the word "nature."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Would it be sufficient if you had in the words "standard and quality."

Comment on this

I agree to that.

Comment on this

Would it not be desirable to say that trunk roads should be made from certain materials.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That is the question at issue.

Comment on this

The different county councils might dispute about that, and the Minister would not be able to settle the question unless he had power to say what material should be used on trunk roads. I think it is generally recognised that in future all trunk roads should be made of concrete.

Comment on this

As we are discussing main roads and trunk roads I should like to say that I would give the Minister every power. I am strongly in favour of what are called national roads being regulated by a central authority, and local roads by the local authorities. If there is any idea that this may devolve into a system of main, trunk, or national roads, I would be in favour of giving the Ministry every possible power. Therefore I shall vote for the words as they are.

Comment on this

I wish to point out to the last speaker that this clause covers every road. After the discussion, I will be satisfied if the power given to the Minister be confined to main and trunk roads and let the bye-roads be dealt with by the county council.

Comment on this

I do not think that bad material should be allowed on any road. I think that the quality of the materials ought in all cases to be regulated by the Minister. I do not think it should be optional with the Minister to dictate the use of, say, cement instead of stone. I think it would be well to delete the word suggested.

Comment on this

I agree to the words "standard and quality."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The clause would then be amended by deleting the word "nature" and inserting the word "standard."

Comment on this