Public Business. - Control of Prices Bill, 1932—Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–144 of 287. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 20 of 1932 ›
I have not had any information on the matter.
Comment on this
Will you argue your amendment or not, Senator Johnson?
Comment on this
I suppose I shall have to argue it again. I move amendment No. 1:—
Section 2. To add at the end of the section the words:—"the word ‘food' means and includes every article used for food or drink by man and any article which ordinarily enters into or is used in the composition or preparation of human food; and also includes flavouring matters and condiments."
The amendment deals with the definition of the word "food," and I draw attention to the fact that the Schedule says "Every commodity which is used as food, clothing, material for clothing or fuel." That might seem to be inclusive enough but a doubt has arisen as to what is covered by the word "food." Without stretching it to say that linseed cake for cattle might be said to be food and would come within the scope of the Bill, the question does arise as to whether liquor of any kind, intoxicating or non-intoxicating, would be brought within the scope of the Bill under the terms of the Schedule. As I said before, the inquiry, which was conducted by the Committee under the chairmanship of Senator Brown, included food in common use and intoxicating liquor.
Comment on this
Articles of general consumption—and we took drink as one of those.
Comment on this
The fact is, I think, that it is fairly general as an article of consumption. The definition I have put down is taken from the Food and Drugs Act already in operation. I want to be satisfied that the term "food" in the Schedule is necessarily and legally taken to cover a very wide range, or that it should be specifically defined. The definition in the amendment is taken from existing legislation.
Comment on this
Would it be possible to postpone consideration of this measure until the Minister is present? Many of the amendments deal with questions of definition, which are, more or less, at the discretion of the Minister. I understand he is at present engaged on Questions in the Dáil, and that he will not be very long.
Comment on this
Is it Senator Johnson's concern that inquiry might be made into the question of whether there is profiteering in food for cattle? If you are going to have a Bill as wide as this one, it might be important to the community, and to farmers in particular, if that was the case. I do not feel strongly about the amendment, but there will be the greatest difficulty when you come to the definition. Senator Johnson has made his point clear. Naturally his desire is for accuracy and for detail. I can conceive cases where an inquiry into unfair prices for food for cattle would be as important as an inquiry into flavouring matter, or condiments, which come under the Bill.
Comment on this
At this stage I should like, if I might, to raise a point of order concerning certain amendments I sent in proposing to delete two Parts of this Bill, and which do not appear on the Order Paper. I understand that I am not allowed to debate this matter, but I see great difficulty in certain cases in framing amendments to a Bill if the whole of a Part which could stand apart cannot be deleted in Committee. I submit that a precedent was afforded in the Land Act of 1923—on which some members of the Seanad will remember I was rather active—when I was allowed to remove a complete Part of the Bill which could be taken out without affecting other Parts. Otherwise one is driven back on the alternative of removing the Parts piecemeal which surely would be a rather cumbersome process. I suggest that it should be possible where Part of a Bill can stand apart to remove it in toto.
Comment on this
The Senator was informed that the amendments were not in order.
Comment on this
The reason for that is that in Committee a Bill must be moved section by section. If I were to allow a Senator to move to delete a whole Part of a Bill, this would involve several sections, which could not therefore be put seriatim as required by the Standing Orders. The Senator is in no way inconvenienced by my ruling, as it is open to him to oppose each section of the Parts to which he objects and, if he wishes, to challenge a division on each.
As the Minister is now in the House perhaps Senator Johnson would like to explain his amendment again.
Comment on this
As I explained earlier, the object of the amendment is to have it made quite clear that the term "food" will include liquor refreshments and any other article which might be dealt with, for instance, salt or pepper. There might be a doubt in the law courts whether salt was "food." I want to make it clear in the Bill that there should be no doubt of that kind. Possibly it would be said that the word "food" in the Schedule would cover anything that could be taken into the mouth and eaten or drunk. I am not quite sure whether the lawyers would agree with that. I have taken the definition in the amendment from the Food and Drugs Act, 1899.
Comment on this
The term "food" would be interpreted to cover any article which could itself be used as food. I would be disinclined to extend the meaning of the term and to bring a much larger range of articles within its scope than is the case at present. The machinery which has been established by the Bill is machinery which has yet to be tried out in practice, and in the beginning it is desirable that the number of articles to which it would apply should be reduced to those regarded as necessities of life in the strict interpretation of that term. Under the Bill there is always power in the Executive Council, by order, to extend the Schedule to include other articles and to bring them within the purview of the Commission. My inclination at the present time is to keep the Schedule as it stands and to confine the interpretation of the term "food" to any article which can by itself be used as food.
Comment on this
That is the definition of "food" as it stands. I am told the amendment is not necessary.
Comment on this
The Minister answered "I think so" to Senator Wilson. I want to have the matter clear. If he can give me an assurance that the term "food" includes porter, stout, whiskey, lemonade and such like articles I am satisfied. I am afraid, as the Bill stands, that there is a grave doubt, unless the Minister can point to some decision of a court, or something of that kind, which would make it certain that "food" includes drink. The Food and Drugs Act of 1889 says that the expression "food":
"means and includes every article used for food or drink by man, and any article which ordinarily enters into or is used in the composition or preparation of human food; and also includes flavouring matters and condiments, but does not include articles sold or offered for sale as seed potatoes ..."
There you have a standing definition and, as a layman quite unversed in the way courts proceed, I would think that that might easily have an influence on the definition of what is "food." I would like to have the matter cleared up.
Comment on this
When I say that I think whiskey or stout or other drinks of that kind would be determined to be food, I want to safeguard myself against someone getting a declaration in court that they were not. The term "food," I am informed, covers these articles. Of course it is a term the interpretation of which might be altered by some judicial decision at some time. If the Senator is satisfied that the term should not be extended to include more than the articles which could by themselves be used as food, I will make it clear, between this and the next stage of the Bill, that all the articles are in fact covered by it in the definition clause if necessary.
Comment on this
If the Minister inserts, instead of what is there, "any articles that can be used as food," I most certainly agree. There are many forms of drink, and very many of these forms of drink have no food value. Whiskey is one, and brandy is another. They are all very useful as articles of common consumption, but they certainly will not come under the term "food." Milk, I think, has a food value. Why should the term be left for interpretation? I think we should extend the definition and include drink.
Comment on this
It is a matter of getting an interpretation of the word "food." I will undertake to examine the point to see if there is a necessity for having such a definition, and, if necessary, introduce such a definition.
Comment on this
I move amendment 2:—
Section 2. To add at the end of the section the words "the word ‘premises' includes any vehicle or stall from which articles are sold retail."
Having got a hint from Senator O'Doherty in the discussion that took place last week, I put down this amendment. I do not know whether the word "premises" would include a vehicle or a travelling shop. It is well that attention should be drawn to the word in order to have some decision as to whether premises should be deemed to include stores in a market place. I would like some satisfaction from the Minister on the point, or otherwise that he would accept the amendment.
Comment on this
My advice is that the amendment is not necessary. I have no objection to accepting it in principle. My information is that it is not necessary, as the term "premises" would include any place.
Comment on this
Is it clear that the term would include a vehicle, and that it is so as far as a stall is concerned?
Comment on this
We found when going around the country on the Food Prices Commission that travelling shops, particularly in Sligo, have become extremely numerous. They are hardly fair competitors with other shops. They bring everything except drink to farmers' houses, and they bring back from the farmers' wives eggs and fowl which they get at a cheaper rate than if these things were sold in a town. It is entirely unfair competition against other shops, and I hope that the Commission which is dealing with the licensing of shops, when it takes up the question of travelling shops, will see that they are put on some reasonable level with other shops.
Comment on this
I am agreeable to accepting the principle of the amendment and I will introduce one on the Report Stage.
Amendment deferred until Report Stage.
Comment on this
I have not put down an amendment to Section 2, but I would ask the Minister to give consideration to the desirability of having a definition of the words "retail" and "wholesale." I do not attempt to define them because I am not an expert in draftsmanship. At the same time, I believe that there is a good deal of confusion conceivable between retail and wholesale prices. Possibly if the Minister considered the matter he might decide to define "retail," and to make it clear that it was a sale direct to the user. As the matter is one of some difficulty I am raising it in order to ask the Minister or his advisers to deal with it. Otherwise I think there will be confusion when the Act is operating.
Comment on this
I move amendment 3:—
Section 8, sub-section (2). To insert before the sub-section a new sub-section as follows:—
(2) As soon as conveniently may be after the passing of this Act, the Minister shall choose a number of persons, not exceeding twenty-five, to form a panel from which the members of the Commission shall be selected by the Minister from time to time for the purposes of an investigation under this Act.
In considering that sub-section certainly I could not imagine five persons picked, I do not care from what part of the community, who could fill the bill, who could possibly be sufficiently intelligent, who would have enough leisure or who would work hard enough to carry out the duties which the Commission would have to perform under this Bill. One of the five is to represent agricultural interests presumably. He need not know a single thing about ordinary things sold in shops. Two shall be women. Women have a great facility for taking up anything and for working very hard. They are splendid at various things but even the best of women or even the best of men could hardly fill the bill in this case. I honestly believe it would be impossible to get five individuals who could usefully constitute this Commission. My amendment proposes that instead of picking five and leaving the job to them, the Minister should have a panel of twenty-five, that these should be selected in a varied way, and that for each inquiry he could pick five persons out of this twenty-five. I am not quarrelling with the idea of agricultural representations or the selection of two ladies but I suggest that he should at least have a panel of twenty-five people who would profess their willingness to act and then as each inquiry arose the Minister could pick his Commission.
The words of the amendment are:
"As soon as conveniently may be after the passing of this Act, the Minister shall choose a number of persons, not exceeding twenty-five, to form a panel from which the members of the Commission shall be selected by the Minister from time to time for the purposes of an investigation under this Act."
I really think that would be the more workable method. I have no doubt the Minister will tell us what he thinks about it presently but I do think it is nearly impossible to get five human beings to carry out this Act satisfactorily. Of course I know that if the idea of the panel were agreed to, there would have to be considerable verbal alteration in various parts of the Act. I have not put down any other amendment in connection with this proposal until we find whether it is to be accepted. One of the first changes would be in sub-section (2) of this section which states that subject to the provisions of this Act the Commission shall consist of five members. I do not think it needs many words to explain the meaning of my amendment. The idea is to get a body of twenty-five people from whom a Commission can be appointed to investigate each case, instead of trying to get five super-individuals who are able to investigate every case.
Comment on this
Senator Jameson seems to think that the Act as it stands will be unworkable. I suggest that his proposal would be altogether unworkable. I think that in framing his amendment he lost sight of Section 9 of the Bill. Under Section 9 the Minister has power, from time to time, where the necessity of the case demands it, to appoint an additional member of the Commission who shall, for the time being, have all the privileges and powers of a member of the Commission. I think that is a much better arrangement than the suggestion of Senator Jameson. Any one amongst us who has had experience of Commissions and of the duties which they are called upon to perform, knows that this panel business is all humbug. It never works in practice. What is everybody's job is nobody's job. The Minister's proposal is that five people shall be responsible for carrying out certain duties and he provides for meeting the point raised by Senator Jameson in a much more workmanlike way than Senator Jameson suggests. Senator Jameson says that no five people could be expected to know the details of every business. That is all right, but the five people who would constitute the Commission would have to decide certain lines of policy which would not be varied every time the Commission sat. The Minister wisely provides that where expert advice is required dealing with certain specialised industries, he can appoint a person who possesses this special knowledge. During the time such person is on the Commission he has all the powers and privileges of the other five members. I think the Minister's proposal is much more likely to prove effective than the amendment proposed by Senator Jameson.
Comment on this
I support in principle the amendment moved by Senator Jameson. Most of the reasons I gave last week. I do not think, in fact I am quite certain, that Senator Jameson in any way overlooked the provisions of Section 9. The Minister in Section 9 more or less admits that there will be many occasions on which his Commission of five will not be sufficiently satisfactory. It seems to me that if this Bill is going to function at all, the one thing you want is confidence; and if you have a Commission of five people, who can only have a very limited knowledge, dealing with every subject, you are not going to have that confidence in the prices they recommend or the views they put forward as to what is or is not an unreasonable price. If the Minister simply from time to time adds one or two individuals to the Commission, I think I am not wrong in stating that there will be considerable suspicion centred in the public mind, whereas if you had a representative panel of, say, twenty-five, or whatever number is chosen, from all sections of the community, and chosen because of their wide knowledge, it would be comparatively easy to get five to act as a Commission.
There is another reason why this proposal should be accepted. That is, that the Minister has made it quite clear that he does not want a paid Commission. He wants people who are prepared to act in an honorary capacity. I respectfully suggest to him that he will find it almost impossible to get five first-class persons to give practically all their time in an honorary capacity. He will not get people with a wide experience of business. He will not get people who have an actual knowledge of what is happening from year to year and who are able to serve on this Commission without remuneration. If, on the other hand, you have a panel of 25, I think you will find in all classes of community there are people who can give up some time to serve on the Commission in the interests of the community. They would not be willing to act, however, if they are required to act from year to year. For that reason I think you will get a better inquiry if you had a panel. However, I do not think the matter is one of absolute principle and if the Minister has made up his mind to adhere to the proposal in the Bill, we shall not contest it keenly. I cannot agree with Senator Farren that the panel system would prove unworkable. I agree that if five members were selected from the panel on the chance of their turning up to meetings, it might prove unworkable, but this amendment is taken on the assumption that, if necessary, further amendments will be made in the Bill.
Comment on this
I cannot see that this amendment raises any question of principle. In my judgment it is a very wise amendment and I would urge on the Minister to accept it. Senator Farren said that it is advisable to have five members because they will be able to carry out a certain definite policy, running, of course, in grooves. That is a thing which I think is not desirable. If there is one thing desirable in connection with the administration of this Bill it is that it should be subject to the ordinary commonsense of the people. I would urge on the Minister, unless it runs counter altogether to his plans, to accept this amendment allowing for a panel of twenty-five from which he himself can draw. In my opinion it is a workable amendment and it will, I think, contribute to make the measure a success.
Comment on this
When I saw this amendment in the name of Senator Jameson for the first time, I was not at all clear as to the idea behind it. It is quite clear that there are two possible interpretations of it. I gather from him now that the intention is that there should be a panel of twenty-five members from which persons could be drawn from time to time to constitute the Commission for the purpose of carrying out particular investigations. That plan is, of course, if I may say so, based on a misconception of the Bill. We do not contemplate a series of disconnected investigations proceeding for a period of time. The Commission to be set up under the Bill is a permanent Commission, and in fact, a large part of the Bill would be completely unworkable unless we had some permanent body in existence. I would refer Senators to the functions of the Commission under Section 23, sub-section (3), where the Commission has to determine whether it is in the public interest that the general price level in respect of some article should be investigated following the receipt of a complaint or an allegation that an unduly high price had been charged. Similarly, under Section 33, sub-section (2), where an investigation into some individual transaction has been made by an inspector and the Controller of Prices shall issue a certificate, there is an appeal to the Commission. The Commission must be clearly some body which is always in existence, to which an appeal can be made.
Again under Part VI. of the Bill, sub-section (3) of Section 38 requires that the Commission shall, from time to time, as the other business of the Commission permits, select from amongst protective commodities manufactured in Saorstát Eireann, one commodity, for the purpose of making an investigation in relation to the price charged for that commodity.
It seems to me, therefore, that, from that point of view, the idea of a panel of twenty-five members from which individuals would be selected from time to time, runs counter to the entire conception of the Bill. There was another interpretation of the Senator's amendment, and until he introduced it I was not clear that it was not the interpretation he had in mind, namely, that the Minister would nominate a panel of twenty-five members, and from that panel select five members to constitute the Commission. If that was the idea in the Senator's mind, I would have said it was much better to have the whole three million people of the country to select from without restriction. The idea is that five members shall constitute the permanent Commission, that they shall remain in continuous existence, that changes can be made from time to time as members retire, but that the Commission shall be a continuous body and that there shall be added to that Commission as occasion requires—the circumstances associated with a particular investigation or some other circumstance— additional members who will have particular qualifications for the purpose of facilitating the Commission in carrying out certain investigations.
That, in my opinion, is a better and more workable system, seeing that we contemplate not a disconnected but a continuous investigation and review of all the circumstances. The object is continuous investigation in regard to Part IV. of the Bill. I think a continuous, or permanent body, would be more effective in carrying out what I regard as one of the most important functions of the Commission. That function is keeping under observation prices charged for protected commodities, and reporting to the Commission, if necessary, where such is the case, that unduly high prices are being charged, and that steps should be taken to remedy the matter. That is why I am inclined to oppose this amendment. The question as to the terms on which members of the Commission would hold office arises on the next amendment of Senator Brown.
Comment on this
I had in mind that the Minister himself would state whether the complaint was worthy of inquiry. I thought that was one of the things that he was to use his Controller for. Anything sent to the Minister, as something worthy of investigation, would pass, first, through his Controller. The Minister now says it must go first to the Commission. He believes he can get five people properly to carry out these duties. I do not believe he can. I should have thought it easier to get some machinery established to bring the case before the Minister and to appoint a body of 25 persons from whom to draw people to investigate, in the first instance, than it would be to find five people to fill the part. If the Minister tells the House that he is convinced he can get five people to act satisfactorily, for a period of years, and to carry out the duties imposed on them under the Bill I bow to it. It is a matter of opinion but I still hold that he risks the action of this Bill in trying to find five people to carry out this part of it. I think that is taking a great risk and the Minister would be wiser to have a body of twenty-five people and separate inquiry. If, however, the Minister says that that would seriously upset the machinery of the Bill I am not going to press it. If he is able to get five people to discharge these duties, well, then, I shall be delighted.
Comment on this
Before the amendment is withdrawn I venture to point out that it is obviously one of a friendly character. My personal objection to this Bill is that I consider it a very bad piece of legislation. I put forward that view on the debate on Second Reading, but I support this amendment because I believe it is our duty, no matter how we might differ from the principle of the Bill, to do our best to try to improve it before it becomes law. I think that is what this amendment would do. As a rule I am in favour of small commissions, but the Commission of five under this Bill is one of such an extraordinary character that I earnestly believe you will not get people with sufficient knowledge on such a commission. I think it would make the Bill work if you had five times the number of people and thereby five times the amount of knowledge to draw from. I do not believe that such a number would, in any way, diminish the State's responsibility. On the contrary, I think five people, picked out from twenty-five, to deal with that subject would mean a greater sense of responsibility than a commission of a fixed number of five people. You would have greater knowledge among the members to choose from and you would have people acting with a greater sense of responsibility.
Comment on this
I have no very strong opinion on this matter, but I find it hard to reconcile——
Comment on this
No, the House has not yet given permission to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I find it hard to reconcile the views of those who support a panel of 25 for this board, and who supported three gentlemen who were civil servants on the Tariff Commission, and who were supposed to be omniscient in regard to every subject relating to trade and manufacture in the Free State.
Comment on this
I rather differ from my friend Senator Dowdall on this matter. I think the cases are somewhat different. In this particular instance you are dealing with the prices and the charges made in small villages, towns and cities. It seems to me that local knowledge of all these places would be very necessary. I am inclined to agree with Senator Jameson that any five men you select will not have the requisite knowledge. In addition, I believe that the sittings of this Commission should not be confined to the City of Dublin. I think it should hold its sittings in the various localities where complaints arise. To my mind the only merits in this Bill are that it will give people a sense that if they are overcharged for anything they have some means of redress. Personally I believe they never will get any redress, but they will have a sort of satisfaction in feeling that if they are overcharged they can make a complaint to some representative of a powerful body. From that point of view I think it would be very desirable that the sittings of the Commission should not be confined merely to the City of Dublin. I, also, consider it very desirable that the number should be 25 from which to select. I believe further that as far as possible the places where the Commission sits should have representatives of their district upon the Commission.
Comment on this
I am quite certain that Senator Dowdall would never make a remark of the kind he did for the purpose of trying to gain a Party point, or to utter a jibe. Therefore, I think we should take him seriously. I think his idea is that this Commission should act like the Tariff Commission: That, in the first place, there should be notice given in the papers to the effect that all persons interested should appear before the Commission, and give the facts; that there should be full inquiry and that when the report comes before the Minister he should see that it would come before each House of the Oireachtas, before any price is fixed. If the Minister is prepared to give effect to that I would say that three or five persons would be sufficient, because they would act in a judicial capacity. They would not be acting upon their own opinion, but reporting the case as a result of the evidence put forward before them and upon which the Minister could act. I do not think that we have had any notification, as yet at any rate, that the Minister is prepared to have that kind of machinery set up for the purpose of dealing with prices which would I think follow from Senator Dowdall's proposal for a commission consisting of three or five persons.
Comment on this
I made no such proposal, but, if I may say so, I presume that any three intelligent persons selected by the Minister would not altogether run in blinkers. In regard to anything they did not know they would make inquiries, of course, on the spot.
Comment on this
We could settle this argument by pointing out that the procedure under this Bill is not at all dissimilar from that of the Tariff Commission. It was undoubtedly practically a public commission; it reported, and action was taken upon that; but there was nothing in the Tariff Commission Act that required publication of the report.
Comment on this
They had to give notice before they came to make inquiry so that parties interested could put their case and could be represented before the commission by counsel if necessary.
Comment on this
And they reported under a certain number of heads to the Minister for Finance, and upon their report the Minister for Finance acted, and, under the late administration, acted automatically. But nothing required him to act automatically and to publish the report.
Comment on this
The procedure we contemplate here is the carrying on of investigation as to the general prices of some commodities. The commission can on its own behalf make representations to the interested party to redress what has been done, and point out that it is a matter that requires attention. Then it reports to the Minister, giving the results of its investigation, and its recommendation as to the steps that might have to be taken to secure a reduction of prices, if it considers that excessive prices have been charged, and, finally, it states the circumstances that it thinks would justify a price fixing order. The Minister could not act until the report of the commission in all its bearings was before him.
Comment on this
I am somewhat in a difficulty in this matter. There have been quite strong opinions given in favour of the amendment, yet I hesitate a great deal to divide the House upon it. If the Minister tells us, quite candidly, that he cannot accept this amendment, and, that if it were passed, he would have to go to the Dáil and get it reversed, we would only arrive at a state of affairs that would not help. If the Minister assures us that he cannot accept the amendment I would not divide the House, even though I got this amendment carried against the Minister.
Comment on this
I would have to ask that the amendment be not pressed. If it were carried it would upset the whole scheme of the Bill, which is, that there must be a small permanent body continuously in existence to which may be added additional members if necessary. I believe a good many parts of the Bill could not be carried out if this amendment was accepted.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 4:—
Section 8, sub-section (4). To delete in lines 34-35 the words "during the pleasure of the Minister" and to substitute therefor the words "for such period, not exceeding five years, as the Minister shall fix at the time the appointment is made."
The object of this amendment is to give to the settled number of members of the Commission a certain fixity of tenure. Under the Bill they are mere creatures of the Minister. They have not even the status of ordinary domestic servants who are entitled to a month's notice. The Minister's justification is that the necessity for this state of affairs is that the Commission is really only an advisory body which is to advise the Minister, and that the Minister is the person who has the ultimate decision and that it is not for that reason in any sense a judicial body. Now, with great respect, that is not so. Under Part III. of the Bill the Commission is to hold what is called price investigation. As a matter of fact they have to decide whether the prices all over the Saorstát or in any particular district are reasonable prices. That is a most important question of fact. They have also to deal with the complaint against particular individuals for charging unreasonably high prices. Whether an individual is charging unreasonably high prices or not is a question, not only of fact, but of absolutely material fact, so far as the person who is complained about is concerned. If the result of that enquiry is that the accused person is acquitted, then the matter ceases. No further action is taken and the decision is final. If the finding is that the price is unreasonable, then notice of reduction has to be served. If the price is reduced in accordance with that notice, again no further action is taken. But, under Part IV., the Commission is a court of appeal from the owner. If the appeal is bona fide and in the public interest, the Commission again holds an investigation, as it would have done under Part III., and with the same results. With all those circumstances, and with all those duties as to ascertaining the facts, with the power of having evidence taken on oath, and with the indirect power of imprisonment for contempt of court, it is really trifling with language to say that this is not a judicial body. If this is not a judicial body, as a matter of principle no member of that body ought to be at the mercy of any Minister. That is a matter of principle. It is a matter of pure democracy that if you set up a body with powers such as those, with the duty of deciding questions such as those, that body ought to be absolutely independent of the Government for the time being.
The second objection to this power of dismissal at the will of the Minister is this: As long as it is there, in my opinion, you will not get any independent-minded, qualified person to take the job. I do not think anybody, with the knowledge that he may be turned out at a minute's notice— that he may be turned out, even during the investigation of a particular case, without a moment's notice—I do not think that any man of independent mind, and that is the kind of man you want, will accept such a condition. I, therefore, beg to move the amendment.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the Minister will follow his predecessors in regard to this amendment. In this House, on a good many occasions, we have raised a very similar principle, and we were nearly always told by the Minister concerned that, of course, no Minister would do such a thing. I am inclined to think that the argument, as far as its being true is concerned, is probably correct, but it might, nevertheless, happen that a change of Government might take place. Another Minister might change the whole Commission, and while some people might think that excellent, frankly, I do not. I really believe also that it is a matter of principle. The amendment moved by Senator Brown is a really reasonable one. It gives the Minister power to fix any length of time. The Minister has power, under the amendment, to fix the period for six or eight months, or any period he likes up to five years, but for whatever period the Minister does fix it the person is reasonably independent. It is possible that further provision might be necessary to make the removal—possibly for such things as non-attendance or for some other serious cause. This could be done on the Report Stage if this amendment is passed. I think the Minister will realise that it does not add to the general confidence in the Minister if it can be said that the members of the Commission are the creatures of the Minister and that he may remove them at once if he likes. Things that they might do in perfectly good faith it may be said that they did because the Minister could immediately remove them. I think that it is better not to put a person on a Commission in this country who is simply at the mercy of the Minister. Let the Minister fix comparatively short periods in order to see how it works, and, at any rate, for whatever time the appointment is made, that a person cannot be removed except for non-attendance, malfeasance, or things of that kind. A definite period should be fixed so that the person concerned might know where he stood.
Comment on this
Senator Brown, I think, proved too much, or he made a very unwise charge against a very large and important body of the people in this country when he said that no man of independent mind would accept any position of responsibility on these terms. They happen to be the terms on which any civil servant acts to-day. They happen to be the terms on which the members even of bodies like the Income Tax or the Revenue Commissioners are appointed to-day and have the same functions. It might be said that the whole Service is recruited on such terms.
Comment on this
They are not appointed in the same way, and the terms of their appointment are fixed. Ministers are responsible for the actions of civil servants who have got to obey them.
Comment on this
I was very glad to hear from Senator Douglas that this is a cause which has been fought before. The Senator, no doubt, will also remember that each time he fought it he lost. The practice adopted in this Bill is one that has been adopted on a number of occasions in the past, such as the Mines and Minerals Board.
Comment on this
The members are removable at any time and they have wider and more important functions than those conferred on the Commissioners in this Act. The Commissioners cannot act without the concurrence of the Minister. The other Board can give one person's property to another under certain circumstances and are appointed on the same terms. However, the Senator says that it is a matter of principle, and I am not disposed to fight on the principle because I think that there is a lot to be said for it. What I am concerned with is that there are difficulties of a practical nature to be met with if that principle were embodied. Reference has been made to the difficulty of getting people to act on the Commission. That is an important consideration. If we appoint them for five years, and afterwards they find they have undertaken more than they thought they could do, or if they lose interest and merely take a casual interest in the proceedings, it might definitely impede the working of the Act for the term of their appointment. If any period were to be inserted, it would be necessary to have a consequential amendment providing for their removal for causes stated, such as that if it was found that the member did not do his work he could be substituted.
Comment on this
And power to resign. As I say, I am not disposed to fight on the amendment. I am prepared to accept it, but I would suggest that if the Senator would leave it over to the next stage I would have some such amendment embodied with the necessary consequential amendment inserted.
Comment on this
The amendment to be brought forward on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment 5:—
Section 11. To delete the section and to substitute therefor a new section as follows:—
11. Every member of the Commission shall, if the Minister for Finance so directs, be paid such out of pocket expenses as the said Minister shall determine.
Section 11, again, I think, raises a difficulty as to the working of the Commission; the Minister said that he hoped that he would get honorary members of the Commission, but Section 11 allows some of the members to be paid and some unpaid. I do not know whether any members of the House have ever tried to serve on commissions or bodies where they were sitting with some paid and some unpaid. I am afraid that the result will be that those who are paid will attend and do the business and that there will be a great temptation to the others not to come there. Anyhow, it is more or less a disqualification to the Commission at the very start. I remember that there was a debate here on the construction of this House and some people thought that we ought all to sit without any salaries. Again, there was a discussion as to whether some, who could afford it, should sit without salaries, and that those who could not afford it should have salaries. The whole thing was turned down because it was agreed at once that the two bodies could not get on together. That is past history, and well known. We had all to sit equally or we could not manage to make up a working body. I believe the same thing applies here. And my amendment presumes that the Minister will be able to get honorary members on his Commission who will not be paid, but that "every member of the Commission shall, if the Minister for Finance so directs, be paid such out-of-pocket expenses as the said Minister shall determine." If you put that section in instead of Section 11, it will be seen that it means that members of the Commission are not to be out of pocket in any way, but it does not allow of any of them being paid salaries. It is to raise that question that I put in the amendment, because I really believe that it will not be a good thing for the Commission to have paid members and unpaid members on it. That is what I wanted to bring before the House and before the Minister. The section as it stands, in my opinion, will make the Commission very unworkable.
Comment on this
I had the impression that this amendment was consequential on the Senator's previous amendment. As it stands, while it is undoubtedly true that we hope to get members to act on the Commission in return for their out of pocket expenses, it is conceivable that we will not succeed in getting them. It is conceivable that the Chairman or others in responsible positions would have to be remunerated or, alternatively, that the state of affairs for a period, such as, for instance, the first period which would require personal and more continuous attention, would be such as to require remuneration for that period. During that period it might be necessary to pay a salary which could be dispensed with at a later stage when the affair had become more or less a matter of routine. We hope to get people who will be suitable in every way and who can act without remuneration. Nevertheless, it is eminently desirable that we should be able to get a suitable Commission even if we have to pay some of the members.
Comment on this
I strongly agree with what Senator Jameson said when he stated that commissions, some members of which are paid and some unpaid, do not work satisfactorily. I am almost certain that if the Minister had experience of such bodies he would agree. It has been my experience—of course, one cannot very well give details—but it has been my experience that such bodies are not a success. I believe that, if the Minister has reasonable expectation of getting such people, he would be wise to put that in; but, if not, I should like to suggest that the word "any" should be changed to "every." That is, that, if the Minister for Finance so directs, he will pay every member. You will either give them out of pocket expenses, which they ought to get, or you will pay them all. I think that the Minister is extraordinarily optimistic if he thinks that he can start off with a paid Commission for a few months and that then they will become honorary members. I think that that is the height of optimism. I suggest that if the Commission starts at all, it should be honorary at the beginning, and paid afterwards if necessary. But if it starts paid, I think it is quite hopeless to expect that it will become afterwards an honorary Commission.
Comment on this
Could not this be worked on the principle that operates in the case of local bodies, namely, that anyone claiming expenses should be allowed them? In the case of public bodies, quite a number of members never claim expenses although expenses are allowed. I think that the same principle might work very well in the case of this Commission.
Comment on this
That is undoubtedly correct so far as out of pocket expenses are concerned. Every member of the Commission is entitled to get, and should get, his travelling expenses from his place of residence as well as a subsistence allowance, but it may be necessary to have a commission on which either all the members or, say, the chairman should definitely be remunerated. If, say, the chairman is definitely remunerated he would be required, in return for the remuneration given, to devote a specified part of his time to the work of the Commission. Any experience that I have had bears out the contention that commissions, some of the members of which are remunerated and others are not, do not work satisfactorily unless there is a clear division between the functions to be discharged by the members. It may be possible to do that here, but still I am of the opinion that the Bill is much better as it stands. If we were to adopt Senator Douglas's suggestion and put in the word "every", then, of course, a number of consequential amendments would be necessary to provide for, perhaps, differential rates of remuneration as between the chairman and other members.
As I have said, I think the Bill is more satisfactory as it stands, because if the necessity arises it enables us to pay remuneration to any member if it is agreed that a particular individual, possessing certain qualifications, is required on the Commission, and that such an individual could not reasonably be expected to give his time free. It is quite possible that you will get the other members of the Commission to agree in certain circumstances to the remuneration of one member who has special qualifications, or in respect of whom special circumstances arise. That is why I would prefer that the Bill should remain as it is.
I am not as pessimistic as Senator Douglas in that respect because I believe that we will get people to act without remuneration. It may be that the members may have to be remunerated for a year or two and that they will cease to be remunerated after that period. I may be unduly optimistic, but I think Senator Douglas is unduly pessimistic as regards the public spirit of our people. We cannot at the moment have any clear idea as to the difficulties that will arise in connection with this, and that is why some discretionary power must be allowed.
Comment on this
The Minister's optimism is certainly greater than my pessimism. If the Minister thinks that this is a vital part of the Bill and that it would upset things if the amendment were carried, then I am not going to press it. I hope the Minister will succeed in getting his honorary members.
Comment on this
My suggestion to insert the word "every" did not mean that they had all got to be paid alike. It meant that either all the members of the Commission were to get out of pocket expenses or that they were all to be paid, but it did not mean that the chairman would not get a higher rate than the other members if there was good reason for it.
Comment on this
I think that the Senator's amendment would require consequential amendments to permit of differential rates for the members.
Comment on this
I do not think it would require that, but of course that is only a detail.
Comment on this
Is Senator Douglas moving now to insert the word "every"?
Comment on this
I am reserving the right to put down an amendment to that effect for Report, if I think fit.
Comment on this
I move amendment 6:—
Section 12. To delete the section and to substitute therefor a new section as follows:—
12. Any member of the Commission who is personally interested in any industry, trade or business which is for the time being the subject of investigation by the Commission, shall inform the Minister of the nature and the extent of his interest, and the Minister may, if he thinks fit, appoint a person to act in the place of such member for the purpose of the particular investigation.
The object of the amendment is to substitute new wording for the present section. If I understand Section 12 aright it means that any person who in the opinion of the Minister is substantially interested in any industry cannot serve as a member of the Commission. It frequently arises on boards and committees that persons whose services are decidedly valuable have, nevertheless, some interest in them. In my opinion there is no reason why a person interested in an industry, a person who might prove extremely useful as a member, should not serve, provided the full amount of his interest is known and is disclosed at the time. I suggest to the Minister that persons should not be disqualified because they have some interest, but instead that they should be obliged to disclose to the Minister the full amount of their interest. The Minister, if he accepts the principle of my amendment, may be able to improve the wording of it. If the nature and extent of a person's interest is disclosed to the Minister, then I think no action should be taken unless the Minister is of opinion that that person's interest is so great that he should not act.
For instance, if you have a very important inquiry, it might very easily happen that you would have seven or eight members acting on that. If one of the members happens to be interested in the particular matter that is being inquired into, I think the inquiry would be likely to be far better by reason of the fact that you had that person on it. Unless he had a very big interest in that particular industry the Minister, I imagine, would probably see no reason against his acting on it. Obviously, the Minister will use his discretion as to the persons selected to make an inquiry into a particular trade. My amendment, I suggest, allows for greater elasticity than the section as it stands, and I think, if accepted, it would enable the Minister to get a better commission.
Comment on this
I think the amendment is likely to be an improvement on the Bill and I am quite willing to accept it.
Comment on this
The amendment speaks of "any member of the Commission who is personally interested in any industry, trade or business which is for the time being the subject of investigation." It is not the industry, trade or business that is necessarily the subject of investigation, but some particular article. Take the case of a grocer's shop in which a great variety of articles is sold. That business, which is of a very general character, is not the subject of inquiry but rather a particular article. It may be the sale of that article in that particular shop that is the subject of inquiry. It seems to me that the amendment does not cover that kind of inquiry.
Comment on this
I am quite prepared to meet that by putting down my amendment for Report Stage. If the Minister brings in an amendment on Report to meet my point, I will probably withdraw mine.
Comment on this
If the Minister were to introduce an amendment with such words as "subject matter of investigation" it would probably be better, because it is really what Senator Douglas wants, I think.
Comment on this
I move amendment 7:—
Section 16, sub-section (1). Before paragraph (g) to insert a new paragraph as follows:—
(g) the attendance of representatives of such trade associations as shall satisfy the Commission that they represent a reasonable number of persons who are directly affected by any particular investigation.
The object of the amendment is to provide that in the regulations which the Commission will make for its proceedings there should be definite provision made for the attendance of the representatives of trade associations. I have been careful in the amendment to provide that it is only such representatives as satisfy the Commission that they represent a reasonable number of persons, that shall have this right. I think there should be specific instructions to the Commission to allow the representatives of trade associations to attend. In most cases possibly that may not be necessary, but it is likely there will be quite a number of important inquiries in which it will be necessary. The matter has been mentioned to me by a number of people. I admit that the amendment is little more than a gesture to the Commission, but I think that if the amendment were inserted it would tend to allay a certain amount of apprehension.
Comment on this
The powers given to the Commission under sub-section (1), paragraph (f) of Section 16 as well as in Section 17 largely meet the point covered by the amendment. I have no objection to clarifying the position if the Senator thinks it is necessary to do so. As a matter of fact, I have a draft amendment before me that I am prepared to introduce on Report to meet the Senator's point.
Comment on this
I think there is objection to paragraph (f). There is a feeling, probably quite unjustified I admit, that the Commission may decide that they will hear no trade associations at all. I think there should be an instruction to the Commission that they should hear the representatives of trade associations if they are satisfied that these represent a sufficient number of people. Under paragraph (f) they can say that they will hear none at all.
Comment on this
The draft amendment that I would propose to introduce on Report would be lettered (d). It reads:
The making of submissions and the giving of evidence by any person on behalf of any association or body appearing to the Commission to be substantially interested in the particular investigation or matter to be made or determined by the Commission.
Comment on this
Before the amendment is accepted, I would like to know if the attendance and the evidence of the representatives of trade associations would preclude an individual who had a substantial interest in a trade from being heard. My reason for raising the point is this: that under the administration of Food Control in Belfast and in Dublin there were members of trades who had quite substantial trade interests but who were not members of any trade association. So far as the interests of these people in Belfast and Dublin were concerned they were considered. A certain injustice would be done to a minority in a trade who were not members of a trade association if they had not the right to be heard before this Commission.
Comment on this
There is no doubt whatever that an individual, as such, would have the right to have his interests considered. There was a doubt in my mind as to whether the representatives of trade associations would have that right, but there is no doubt at all as to the right of an individual.
Comment on this
I am very glad that the Minister has suggested an alternative that will carry out Senator Douglas's intention. I know that during our investigations in connection with the Prices Tribunal we got some very valuable evidence from trade associations. We tried, if possible, to get in touch with them but we were not always able to do it. One trade association, through its unfortunate secretary, refused to give evidence with the result that he was committed for contempt of court and stayed in jail for five months.
Comment on this
If the House allows me to substitute the wording suggested by the Minister I am quite satisfied to move the amendment, as amended, now, and have the matter disposed of.
Comment on this
I think it is better to allow it to remain over for Report.
Comment on this
I would like to have some information as to the character of the documents that the Commission, under this section, can enforce the production of. Is it not the intention that the private ledgers and all the more intimate information of a business be laid before a Commission of five? This section seems to me to be extraordinarily harsh. I do not think it is calculated to ensure the co-operation of business. It is one thing to take powers and do things by force and quite another to seek co-operation and use persuasion. Does the Minister contemplate that intimate documents and the private affairs of a business can be ransacked by this Commission?
Comment on this
Definitely, that is the intention. It is intended that the Commission shall have power to demand the production of all documents, where necessary, to enable it to carry out its investigations. The powers which the Commission will have are similar to the powers which were exercised by the Tribunal on Food Prices and which are frequently conferred on special commissions established by the Dáil, from time to time, for particular purposes, but I am definitely of the opinion that the Commission would be quite useless if it had not got that power of demanding the production of documents.
Comment on this
They must be quite relevant to the inquiry, and I think the farthest we ever went on the Food Prices Tribunal was the production of the balance sheet of a business. We never had to go to private books, ledgers, or anything like that. But we were entitled to get and we did get, sometimes with a little difficulty, all the documents which were relevant to the question as to whether an excessive or unreasonable profit was being taken. The Commission will be entitled, as a matter of ordinary law, to get only documents which are really relevant and they ought to get the whole of these.
Comment on this
Does the test of profiteering not depend on the price that the seller pays for the article he is selling and the price he charges then to his customer? What has his balance sheet got to do with such a transaction? If one man sells at a profiteering rate he may actually make less profit, because he will do less business than the man who sells at a fair price. Is not the proper attitude to take up one of seeing that the man who sells is selling only at a fair profit on what he is paying?
Comment on this
You get the percentage of profit he is selling at by means of his balance sheet.
Comment on this
I maintain that in order to do any good you have to ransack the affairs of the business. You cannot dissociate one transaction from another in business. A man may undoubtedly make what appears to be an undue profit on one transaction to cover losses on previous transactions. The whole thing is interwoven and, surely, anybody who has the most elementary knowledge of business knows that it is not conducted in watertight compartments. There is the question of reserves and of contingent liability, and I think it is just as well that it should go forth from this House now that the trade must be prepared to put all its cards on the table and allow every single detail of its business to be enquired into if the Commission is to be in the least effective. I think you are going to produce the effect of alarming the public, with due cause, by provisions of this kind, and the House knows, and I am sure Senator Johnson knows, what happens when you create a large amount of irritation in business. Traders are very well able to protect themselves, and no law is going to save the public or the consumer from the actions that business will take for its own protection.
Comment on this
I take it that the House, having passed the Second Reading, has decided that the machinery for carrying it out must be effective, and I can say that it is my very definite view that there is no value at all in the Bill unless it has the powers indicated—either those powers or such powers as are provided in the Tribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) Act, 1921, which were made applicable to the Tribunal over which Senator Brown presided. I do not know whether these powers are any wider than the powers under the other Act. I do not think they are, but, certainly, unless these powers are to be given to the Commission, we had better scrap the proposals in the Bill entirely.
Comment on this
The last words of Senator Johnson were the most sensible I have heard—that the best thing to do would be to scrap the whole thing. The Bill is entirely unworkable and will only result in a lot of hardship to business people.
Comment on this
We have decided not to scrap the Bill for the present, Senator. This is Committee Stage.
Comment on this
I compliment Senator Johnson on his suggestion. I believe that the Bill is unworkable and will do no good to the people——
Comment on this
It will confer no benefit on anybody and it does not matter what amendments we put in. It is an unwarrantable piece of interference with the people.
Comment on this
Senator Brown said that the documents produced must, of course, be relevant and there is one danger I see in this, although I do not know exactly how it is to be remedied. If you have, as your chairman, a lawyer or some person experienced in deciding matters of the kind, you will probably not cause injustice, but if you have a layman who has not had experience as chairman it might be decidedly dangerous to give exactly the same powers as a High Court would have, as it is suggested here. In the case of a High Court, these powers are exercised by persons of judicial training who are in the habit of judging a matter from a judicial point of view. I think that probably the words in line 12, on page 6, which provide that the High Court may hold such inquiry as it thinks proper, would be some protection—I am not sure—because we might more or less assume that, if the Commission demanded the production of documents which were in no way relevant to the inquiry, and if they reported to the Court that the documents had been refused, the High Court would probably refuse to commit a person for contempt on the ground that they were not relevant. If that "may" means "shall," after inquiry, I think it ought to be amended, because if that "may" has the ordinary common meaning, it means that the Court could inquire and would not commit a person for contempt if they thought that the demand was unreasonable. If it means "shall," as "may" in law sometimes means, it- means that although they inquire, they nevertheless would have to commit because there has been a refusal of the Tribunal's demand. I should like the Minister to look into it and to see what is the proper definition because, while I agree with Senator Sir John Keane and Senator Johnson that some such powers are necessary, it is our business to see that the powers cannot be abused.
Comment on this
Arising out of what Senator Douglas has said I cannot see any information that could not be held to be relevant to an inquiry into the profits that a person is making. You cannot arrive at what is a fair profit until you know the whole circumstances of the business—what the reserves are, what the turnover has been over a period or what the depreciation is. All these matters are relevant to an inquiry into profits and I think that, in face of that, everything must be laid on the table if the Commission is to be effective.
Comment on this
I think that "may" there means "may," in view of the qualifying words "after such inquiry as it may think proper to make." There would obviously be no necessity for the court to inquire if it was compelled to commit in any case.
Comment on this
Yes, but the discretion of a High Court is a judicial discretion and not the discretion of an ordinary man. The High Court must use discretion, in accordance with rules of law, one of which is that they cannot compel a man to produce a document which has no relevancy to the question at issue.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:—
Section 23. To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
(5) Where the Commission have made an investigation into the retail price of any commodity and are of the opinion that unreasonably high retail prices are being charged but that the retail profits are fair and reasonable, they may, without any specific request having been made under this or any other section, proceed to make an investigation into the wholesale prices, and, if the commodity is a protected commodity, may make an investigation into the prices charged for such commodity by manufacturers in Saorstát Eireann.
The remarks I am going to make in connection with this amendment will apply, to some extent, to amendments 9, 10, 11 and 12, all of which are designed to achieve the same purpose. As this Bill stands, unless I completely misread it, it provides that, if the Commission holds an inquiry into the price of a commodity, and forms the opinion that the price is too high, they must immediately set certain machinery in motion, which will be found in Section 24. I suggest to the Minister that that is really an absurd provision. The machinery provided in Section 24 is only equitable where it is the retail price that is too high because of retail profits. If the Commission find other reasons for the too high price—and we can think of many possible reasons—it is ridiculous to start to attack the retailer alone. You achieve no purpose and create only a certain amount of chaos by frightening the retailer out of selling the article at all. Where the Commission hold an inquiry, on the request of the Minister, or in any other way, into retail prices, and if they find that it is the wholesale price that is too high, or that it is the manufacturer's price that is too high, there is no use in going straight for the retailer by means of the elaborate machinery provided in Section 24.
If they find that the price is too high because there are too many distributors or too many middlemen, or because of high wages, or because of any other reason, they should report to the Minister and he should consider what steps he would take to deal with the commodity, but there is no need at all, I suggest, for putting machinery into motion whereby ever so many notices will be sent out to every person affected as a retailer, if the Commission should find the cause was not the retail profits. If they find that the cause is retail profits, then, of course, the provisions of Section 24 of the Bill could apply. This specific amendment provides that if the Commission make an inquiry into retail prices—the Bill does not define clearly the difference between wholesale and retail prices, but it defines the two types of inquiry —and are satisfied that retail profits are too high, instead of putting this machinery into operation they might, if they thought fit—I do not say that they must—proceed to make an investigation into wholesale or manufacturers' prices. If you are going to have a general inquiry into prices, there is not the slightest use in reporting that retail prices are too high. You may as well go to the bottom of it and find out what the reason is.
Comment on this
When we were drafting the Bill, we took the view that investigation into retail prices would necessitate an investigation into wholesale and manufacturers' prices for the commodity concerned. My view is that the amendment is not necessary and that, in fact, the Commission could not do its work without carrying out an investigation into wholesale and manufacturers' prices. There is nothing in the Bill to preclude them from doing so. In fact, the underlying assumption in the wording of the Bill is that they will do so without question, and, certainly, that was the intention when we were drafting the Bill in this form. There is, of course, always the risk that, if the amendment were carried, it would convey some limitation of the Commission's powers to investigate retail prices. It would convey the suggestion that, in the investigation of retail prices, they were precluded from investigating wholesale or manufacturers' prices, unless they announced their intention of doing so, and proceeded to start a new investigation on the new basis.
Comment on this
I am not at all certain that the Bill is as clear as the Minister thinks. I cannot just at the moment, in view of his remarks, read it through in detail, but the Bill has different subsections dealing with retail prices and wholesale prices. It certainly regards them as separate investigations, and there is the impression that an inquiry into retail prices would not necessarily mean an investigation of manufacturers' prices.
Comment on this
The necessity for having retail and wholesale prices specified in the Bill is that the Minister may desire merely to have wholesale prices investigated. He may feel that it is impracticable, or that there is no reason, to investigate the retail prices of commodities, but, on the other hand, he may feel that there is an urgent need for investigating wholesale prices. In that case, he can require the Commission to carry out an investigation into wholesale prices only, but I think it will be agreed that, if he requires it to carry out an investigation into retail prices of various commodities, the Commission, if it is to do the investigating properly, will have to have regard to wholesale prices and will have to investigate these as well as the manufacturer's price, behind the wholesale prices, if there is such a price. In other words the retail price may be taken to include the wholesale price for the purpose of investigation.
Comment on this
The Minister is arguing what I was arguing. Section 23 (1) says:—"Where the Minister sends a request to the Commission to investigate whether unreasonably high retail prices or unreasonably high wholesale prices are being charged." The requisition could specify both but clearly it should specify either one. There is nothing to say that a requisition on retail prices involved wholesale prices. There again inquiry might show that the real trouble was with the retail prices, in which case there would be no necessity to go any further. My amendment endeavours to make it clear that the Commission may go and investigate. The other amendments deal with Section 24 to which I referred. If the Minister is satisfied I do not care about the details. I only raised the point because I think there is a flaw.
Comment on this
Supposing there is an investigation as the result of a complaint against an individual trader as to the retail price being unreasonably high, would it follow then, in the opinion of the Minister, that retail and wholesale prices might be investigated, even if the requisition only takes the form of a complaint referring to the retail prices? If it was found on investigation that the retail price was not so much at fault, and that it was not the trader's fault, but the fault of either the middleman or the wholesaleman, would that follow?
Comment on this
We may get a requisition to investigate the wholesale prices of a commodity. One can imagine that coming from a retailer, in which case he would desire the Commission to investigate wholesale prices. But if we desired the retail prices to be investigated, and that the Commission had referred to it a complaint either by the Minister or by some other person in respect of whom a price certificate is about to be issued, and if he pleads the defence that the price is the general level, and that it is the general level should be investigated, in these circumstances it is clear that the Commission would have to investigate all the circumstances that led to the price, which would include all the other prices behind the retail price. The reason for the distinction between wholesale and retail is that it may be desirable, for the purposes of convenience, to narrow down the investigation to the manufacturers' or the wholesale prices and not to worry about retail prices. It was in our minds definitely when drafting the Bill that if the retail price was complained of, and if it was desired to have it investigated, all the other prices would be examined at the same time by the Commission. That is why I think the amendment is not necessary. It certainly was the intention that the Commission would function in that way.
Comment on this
I am perfectly clear about what is in the Minister's mind and what is in my own mind, but I am not convinced that what I want is in the Bill. I do not want to press the amendment, because I think what we discuss here will not be read when the Commission comes to interpret the Act. It would probably be better to put in some provision that an inquiry into the retail price involved the other ones.
Comment on this
I move amendment 9:—
Section 24, sub-section (1). To add at the end of the sub-section the words "and such report shall be laid upon the Table of each House of the Oireachtas."
While this amendment is not of very much importance it is only fair to the trade generally that if the Minister gets a report to the effect that the prices are not unreasonably high he should lay it on the Table of both Houses. If the full report is not laid the facts contained in it should be laid.
Comment on this
I think so too, but I do not want to bind myself to lay every report automatically on the Table of each House. It is possible that an investigation might take place into the price of articles sold by one or two firms or manufactured by them. Circumstances might arise in which an injustice would be done to a firm by automatically publishing a report of the prices charged by it. I feel that the Commission would write the report for publication and I think that would give all the information they considered desirable. There might be a case in which it would be undesirable that the report should be published. My view is that the report should be published unless there were some strong arguments against it. That is why the Bill remains much the same as the Tariff Commission Act, which does not require publication, although every report has been published because no circumstances to the contrary arose. I think we can devise an amendment to meet the point.
Comment on this
The Minister says that one or two firms might be concerned and that is the case I have in mind. If an investigation only concerned one or two firms and if the report was that their prices were not unreasonably high it is only fair that it should be published. I will withdraw the amendment as it has served the purpose.
Comment on this
In that case you could not imagine a report saying that the prices were investigated and were found not to be high, not because of the desire to profiteer but because of the competency and efficiency of the firms concerned.
Comment on this
We are only dealing with Section I, which refers to where the prices are not unreasonably high. The other is a separate matter.
Comment on this
I move amendment 10:—
Section 24, sub-section (2). To insert before the sub-section a new sub-section as follows:—
(2) Where after the completion of a price investigation the Commission are of the opinion that the prices the subject of such investigation are unreasonably high, but that the cause of the high prices is not excessive retail or wholesale profit, the Commission shall report accordingly, and such report shall be laid upon the Table of each House of the Oireachtas.
This amendment deals with a different point. I do not want to deal with the last words because we have dealt with the principle previously. If it is found that prices are unreasonably high the section says that the provision in paragraphs (a), (b) and (c) of sub-section (2) shall have effect. My case is that if the price is not unreasonably high for some other reason than the retail profits the Commission should simply report to the Minister and let him see what was the best way to deal with it. The sending of a notice to the retailers will not solve the problem. I would be glad if the Minister when replying would give some idea of what he visualises under sub-section (2). It says:—
the Commission shall give notice ... to the persons by whom such prices are being charged stating the opinion of the Commission and the price to which such prices should in the opinion of the Commission be reduced, and requiring such reduction to be made within a time specified in such notice.
We mentioned some cases where you might have eight or ten dozen shops, and we visualise vehicles and stalls. I do not see how the Commission could give notice to all the persons concerned. My main point is that you should not force all the provisions in the sub-section to come into effect except for the purpose of dealing with retail prices.
Comment on this
The intention behind the paragraph is that if the Commission as a result of investigation are satisfied that unreasonably high prices are being charged, before the question of the report involving action would arise, the Commission would endeavour, by representation to the people concerned, to secure a reduction of the prices. The paragraph was intended to provide power to the Commission on its own behalf, by private representation or otherwise to secure the readjustment of the position rather than that they should proceed immediately to report what action should be taken in pursuance of the Minister's power to secure redress.
Comment on this
They have no option. The sub-section says: "Where ... the Commission are of opinion that the prices the subject of such investigation are unreasonably high ... the Commission shall give notice ..." My point is that there should not be provision in every circumstance to adopt this method. There are circumstances where the provision would be useless. I am not questioning that if you are dealing with retail prices it is better that the Commission should try, by giving certain notice, to endeavour to get common agreement. The Minister says he thinks that will be achieved. I have my doubts that it will be. If they are satisfied that the cause is other than the high price charged by the retailer or the wholesaler or manufacturer, and if it is caused through other reasons they should report the other reasons to the Minister rather than put all this machinery into effect.
Comment on this
In view of what the Minister says, I will withdraw the amendment until the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment 13:—
Section 25, sub-section (6). To insert before the sub-section a new sub-section as follows:—
(6) Every price order in relation to an article sold by weight shall fix the maximum price of such article in terms of the net weight of such article at the time of sale.
The object of the amendment is to ensure that in the fixing of a price order it will not be an order relating to an article, perhaps a packed article, but should have reference to the net weight of the article. It may be argued that the matter of net weight should be the subject of separate legislation, but, when dealing with price, it seems to me we must have regard to the weight or measure of the article in question, and that the price order should be directed to the net weight. It should not be possible to deal with an article except by reference to the net content of any package that it might be packed in. I do not want to argue the case. It is so obvious that either it is accepted or it is not, but I do not think it desirable that we should pass this legislation without meeting the question of weights or measures in the hope that at some future time we shall have legislation to deal with the question of weights and measures. I think that we should insert some provision in this measure— even though there is further legislation dealing with the same subject on the stocks.
Comment on this
I am agreeable to accept the amendment in principle. The wording may require some attention.
Amendment deferred to Report Stage.
Sections 25 to 27, inclusive, ordered to stand part of the Bill.
SECTION 28.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:—
New section. Before Section 28 to insert a new section as follows:—
28.—(1) Whenever a price (retail) order is in force for any commodity and any person sends a representation in the prescribed form and containing the prescribed particulars representing that the wholesale or manufacturers' prices for that commodity have risen since the price order was made, the Controller shall, if he is satisfied with the accuracy of the facts set out in the representation, do either of the following things, that is to say—
(a) send a report to the Minister requesting him to revoke the said price order; or
(b) summon a meeting of the Commission to investigate further the price of the commodity.
(2) If after an investigation into the price of a commodity has taken place under the provisions of this section the Commission are of the opinion that the price order should be revoked or altered, they shall report to the Minister accordingly.
The object of the amendment is to try to make some provision for other people who may conceivably have a grievance under this Act other than the person who has been charged too high a price. It seems to me that if you are to be logical and fair, if you are going to provide for the fixing of a maximum price, when that maximum price is in force, it is only reasonable to provide some machinery so that persons who are selling goods and who may have to face a substantial increase in cost, should have a method of applying to have the maximum price altered or increased. As the Bill stands the Minister can do it if he keeps a sufficient watch on prices but I want to have machinery provided by which the people affected shall have the same right to have an inquiry made and to have the order revoked or altered as the case may be. My suggestion is that they should send in the facts as to the change in price to the Controller and if the Controller is satisfied as to the reasonable accuracy of the facts as stated by the persons who make the representations he can do either of two things—if the thing is quite obvious he can send a report to the Minister asking him to revoke the price order or, if he is satisfied that there is a fair case for investigation but that he is not absolutely convinced as to the facts, he can summon a meeting of the Commission and have the matter investigated. As the Bill stands the only method of providing for a revocation is by trusting to the Minister to watch prices or by having people lobbying him in the Dáil. I think that where you have a Price Order in force there should be machinery by which the retailer can move to have a revocation of that Order if he thinks such necessary.
Comment on this
I think the proposal is not unreasonable but if you accept it in respect of a Retail Price Order I think it should apply also in respect of a Wholesale Price Order. If the Senator would leave it over I shall look into the matter.
Comment on this
The intention was to have this machinery only in respect of the Retail Price Order but the Minister may also have to deal with the Manufacturers' Price Order as well.
Amendment deferred to Report Stage.
Section 28 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
SECTION 29.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:—
New section. Before Section 29, and in Part IV., to insert a new section as follows:—
29.—(1) Where a person sells a scheduled commodity the price of which exceeds two shillings and sixpence or a number of different scheduled commodities the prices of which when added together exceed five shillings, he shall issue to the purchaser at the time of sale a written statement of the weight, measure or number of the commodities sold, the price per unit of weight, measure or number, as the case may be, and the sum charged for the said commodity or commodities.
(2) If any person acts in contravention of this section he shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding two pounds for each such offence.
I said on the Second Stage of the Bill that I thought a good deal of importance should be attached to an individual complaint of overcharging, and it seems to me that the necessity exists for having some kind of documentary evidence. There is no doubt that the practice in many places in the case of the shopkeepers sending out an article or a number of articles, is to send them out without any reference to weight or the price per unit. The retailer simply states the total price on the invoice, or there may be no invoice at all, or no bill, as we call it. There is no chance in these circumstances of the buyer making any case at all if there has been an overcharge. I think it is a very desirable practice when articles are sold, principally when articles are sent away, that there should be a specific invoice or statement of the way the amount charged is arrived at, otherwise there is no chance at all of deciding what was the price charged for a particular article.
Take meat. One gets meat sent to a house and there is either no weight or no price indicated. Sometimes the weight and the total amount charged are given, but the price per lb. is not stated. That is a very common experience, one that I have watched for a considerable time. There is the difficulty then of convincing anybody that there has been an overcharge. There should be an obligation imposed on the shopkeeper when selling an article to state the price definitely. There should be an obligation on him to send out a check of some sort indicating how the price is made up. That is the object of this new section and I would ask the Minister to consider it and, if possible, to have it inserted in the Bill.
Comment on this
This is a theoretical amendment which, with great respect, I suggest is utterly unworkable. If an amendment of this kind were to be made in the Bill it would inevitably add to the price of a great many small commodities. I know in detail the retail portion of one particular trade and I have a knowledge of others in a different capacity. The usual practice where goods are sent out either on credit or as a delivery is that a docket is always enclosed. That creates no serious difficulty. I do not say it is always the practice. I am quite certain it is not, but it is the usual practice. When you come to cash sales, particularly at a busy time, across the counter, you are going to make it obligatory under this amendment that in respect of every sale which represents 2/6, 5/- or even 10/-, you must have full details, the exact quantities and so on written out. You are in that way going to add to the cost of the commodity. I should like to invite Senator Johnson to come to assist some of my shop assistants whom he finds trying to sell an article at 2/6 and a packet of pins, and to assist him in counting the pins in the packet, as he would have to count them in order to put the exact number on the docket if this amendment were inserted. Again, if you were buying a card of mending wool, I cannot guarantee that the length of the wool will always be the same. Does the Senator realise that the additional cost entailed in supplying all these details would have to be added to the price of the commodity? As far as one scheduled commodity here is concerned, the thing is not workable.
There is another reason why the amendment should not be accepted. In my own business I thought some time ago that there would be a great deal to be said for a system of stating the nett amount purchased on every bill, or giving a docket with the amount purchased set out in it, but we found that the customers simply would not have them. The floor was littered with them; the customers would not take them away. That is the usual thing in business. I cannot say, of course, that every trade is the same, but certainly, as far as I know of my own knowledge, there is a specific instruction in every case, no matter how small the purchase is, that where the customer asks for a docket he is to get it. If however, you insert a provision that the exact quantity sold and the price of each item have to be furnished, it will prove either unworkable or the cost of working it would be added to the purchase price, and it is in the case of the smaller commodities that the cost would be greatest. I hope that the Minister will not accept the amendment in the detail in which it stands, because I do not think it will work at all.