We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Public Business. - Control of Prices Bill, 1932—Committee Stage.

Contributions 145–287 of 287. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Control of Prices Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 20 of 1932 ›

Senator Douglas has given the customer's view of these dockets. I look at the amendment from the point of view of the unfortunate shopkeeper in the country. There are innumerable small shops in country districts. How on earth could they work a provision such as this? It would be absolutely unworkable. Senator Johnson pays a very poor compliment to housekeepers in the country, because he seems to infer that they will not have the intelligence to inquire what is the price per lb. for meat. When a person goes in to buy 5 or 6 lbs. of meat, the very first thing any person of ordinary intelligence would do would be to inquire what the price per lb. the meat was. This seems to me to be an extraordinary amendment, and I hope it will not be accepted. It would add to the general vexatiousness, if I might use such a word, of the whole Bill. It would add enormously to shopkeepers' expenses. Even the smallest shop would have to get a special clerk to make out these dockets. My own practice is, as Senator Douglas states, to leave these dockets on the counter, or to throw them on the floor. I do not want to have my handbag crowded with them. The amendment is altogether unnecessary, and I hope it will not be accepted.

Comment on this

I think the opposition to this amendment is so general that it could not possibly be accepted by the Minister. In the very complicated state of affairs that obtains to-day, it takes much longer to obtain an article than it did heretofore. The shopkeeper has to consider very frequently whether he can afford to sell it at a certain price because he has not got it through the customs and he does not know what the price is going to be. All these complications add greatly to costs and if he has to supply a docket in respect of every article which he sells, the time and money which that entails will be added to the cost so that purchasers are going to lose much more than the problematical gain conferred on him by this provision. I think it would make business exceedingly complicated and would lead to a ridiculous situation.

Comment on this

My objection to the amendment is that if you make this provision law it will not be observed and one of the worst things you can have is a law that is not observed. Further, it may not work.

Comment on this

I think Senator Brown's argument against the amendment is one that has weighed most heavily with me. If the amendment were inserted in the Bill and became law, every shopkeeper would be immediately required to give receipts setting out the information suggested here on each occasion that a sale of the kind indicated took place. They would simply just not do that and you would have a very large percentage of shopkeepers liable to the suggested fine of £2. There is, however, a lot to be said for the proposal. There is undoubtedly a problem there. It is desirable that customers should know exactly for what they are paying. That is a problem we have been considering in relation to another Bill that is in contemplation, the nett Weights and Measures Bill. It seems to me that this is a matter that would apply more correctly to that Bill than this.

The amendment is not strictly relevant, in one sense to this Bill, although for the purpose of the Bill a customer might require to get a receipt in order to establish a charge of undue price-charging. In that case it is the practice for the shopkeeper to give such a receipt. I do not think it is possible to accept the amendment. I know there are occasions on which it would be completely impossible to carry it out even in shops not concerned with customs' regulations. There are some shops where the goods sold, although Senator Bagwell may not know it, do not pass through the customs at all. Even if Senator Bagwell went into a shop where goods were of Irish manufacture, and not subject to the test he mentioned, if that shop was doing a good trade as it would be, it would be possible to have that requirement carried out in all its accuracy. But the problem that Senator Johnson is trying to deal with and to which we have been giving consideration for a considerable time, will arise under another measure to be introduced and I hope by then we will have gone some distance towards finding a solution.

Comment on this

When drafting this amendment I confess I inserted the words "demand by the purchaser," and I thought it better to delete these words for the purpose of getting this matter discussed. I am not at all convinced that the thing is so impracticable as some Senators contend. As a matter of practice most shopkeepers do issue documents for the protection of their own accounts, and to have a check upon their assistants. The unfortunate part is that the document only gives the carried-out amount and no indication to the customer how the amount is made up. I can see very little chance of Part IV. of the Bill being effective without such provision as this. I do not know how any tribunal is going to take the word of the purchaser, or the word of the shopkeeper, on a mere cash transaction unless there is some evidence of the way that the charge is made up— the price per unit plus the number of articles. The mere statement that the price of a certain purchase is 25/- means nothing to the tribunal. I cannot see how we are to make any use at all of Part IV. of the Bill without some such evidence of a documentary character.

I must say Senator Miss Browne has had very fortunate experience. She often reminds the House that she is a farmer, and she seems perfectly content with the practice of the retail shopkeepers with whom she has come in contact. I have had a considerable amount of experience among the farming population in one way or another both by personal contact and by reading, and I find a considerable amount of evidence against her view. Senator Miss Browne has had a very fortunate experience among shopkeepers if she finds that they were always fair and generous in their treatment of her as a purchaser or as a seller to retail shopkeepers. I think the preponderance of opinion amongst the farming community is that it would be a good thing if they had some security that they, as purchasers, would not be subject to an excessive price charge, even in special cases. I do not know whether it would meet the objection if some such section as this were inserted in the Bill with an amendment that if the customer demands a docket it would be obligatory to issue one. I have had experience myself where shopkeepers refused to give a docket if there was an actual suspicion or doubt about the weight and the price charged, and they refused to compromise themselves by giving a document that would indicate how the price was made up. Without some such provision here showing how Part IV. of the Act is to be enforced there will be no valuable result. I think if I may be allowed to withdraw this amendment and to consider whether it could be amended so as not to have the appearance of being so formidable as it is now it might be introduced again on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment No. 16:—

Section 30, sub-section (3). After the word "respect" in line 46 to insert the words "or if any person makes a complaint which, in the opinion of the Controller, is frivolous."

As the section stands, it provides for the punishment of a person who makes a false or misleading statement in complaining of overcharges, but it does not deal with the case of a person who makes what is probably a frivolous complaint. Now, an utterly frivolous complaint may cause a great deal of damage and inconvenience to people and there is no redress. One of the dangers of this Bill is that if unfounded charges are made—and really that is what frivolous charges are—there is no real punishment although these may be brought for the purpose of damaging the trader. For these reasons and, also, for the reason that a trader ought not to be put to trouble and expense, and probable damage, due to frivolous complaints, I am strongly of opinion that those who make them ought to be punished. The way the amendment does that is that if any person makes a complaint which, in the opinion of the Controller, is frivolous and if the Controller is of opinion that it is frivolous he can certify and it can be dealt with as an offence under the Act.

Comment on this

It would seem in my opinion rather clear that a person who makes a complaint which in the opinion of the Controller is frivolous would be liable to a fine. The Act provides that the Controller need not act upon a complaint which he regards as frivolous, but it seems to me that that is a sufficient safeguard. If a person makes a frivolous charge for the purpose of damaging a trader and the Controller does not act nothing need happen, and that is the end of it.

Comment on this

But it should not be the end of it.

Comment on this

Undoubtedly, what I feel is that I would like to make it unprofitable for anyone who acts in that way. But it seems to me much severer, and a departure from the principle that the Senator advocated earlier, that a person should be liable to a fine of £10 in the judgment of the Controller. I think that is going further than we ought to go. I think so long as it is provided that if a person makes a misleading statement, based upon statements that are inaccurate, that he can be punished, we are going far enough. If a complaint is frivolous the Controller need not act upon it and that ends the matter. I do not think it is possible to devise a system that would prevent hardship while at the same time enabling punishment to be inflicted upon persons.

Comment on this

It is the experience of everyone who has had any dealings with this question of endeavouring to get evidence in regard to prices, that it is most difficult to get ordinary citizens to come and give evidence in connection with this question of overcharging. It is almost impossible to get them to come forward. If this amendment is inserted you may bid good-bye to any complaints. There is no poor man or woman who is going to take the risk of satisfying the Commission that the complaint is not frivolous. It is not frivolous in their opinion, but it may be another thing in the opinion of the Controller, and they are not going to take the risk of incurring a fine of £10. If this amendment is inserted you may bid good-bye to any effective control.

Comment on this

I think there is something in the Minister's criticism in regard to the words "in the opinion of the Controller." I do not at all agree that the fine should be £10; that is the maximum amount. It might mean that there would be no fine at all. I agree that the court may, without considering the Controller at all, have to convict. While there is reason for dealing with the word "frivolous," and the Minister considers it necessary, I think if you had the word "frivolous" with the words "false and misleading" it would meet the case. There is a genuine fear, and I share it, that in certain districts this Bill may be used to attack certain traders for reasons quite apart from the genuine reasons in the Bill. There need not be any fear that the court will decide the matter is frivolous unless it feels perfectly clear that the object of the complaint was to damage a particular person, and that the complaint could not be justified on proper grounds. Take a complaint arising really out of a mistake that has been made. We all know in practice where important mistakes have been made. I know a case where an assistant, in making out a bill, put the figure 1, which should have gone into the shilling column, into the pound column, and gave a receipt that if produced would prove that the sum of £1 was paid for an article which should only cost a shilling. Where it was pretty clear that it was a mistake a complaint based upon that would be frivolous. I do not give that as an ordinary case, but still one that would happen. If there are frivolous complaints we should provide a penalty against them. I do not suggest £10, but you might include it by having the penalty from a certain figure up to £10.

Comment on this

In small places where every little tittle-tattle is known, if it becomes known that a complaint is made against a trader that in itself would do him damage. There should be some special point for this complaint. I can see many cases where damage would be done to shopkeepers simply because certain people had malice against them—possibly political malice. I think this is a very reasonable amendment and that something ought to be done to meet it.

Comment on this

I recognise the weight of the Minister's objection to grounding this offence upon the opinion of the Controller. I agree that is not a wise thing to do, but I do suggest that the amendment suggested by Senator Douglas would get rid of a problem if you add after the word "frivolous" the other words and let the group decide it.

Comment on this

I am inclined to think that there is some misapprehension about the procedure. If the complaint is false or misleading, it is already provided for. If the complaint is true, can it be said to be frivolous? If it is of little account, and therefore held to be frivolous, what harm is there? The complaint is to be made to the Controller, and unless you are arguing that the Controller may be prejudiced against a particular shopkeeper, having received a complaint which may be frivolous and which he holds to be frivolous, the illustration given by Senator Miss Browne has no validity at all. The persons who are going to make complaints and create bad odour in a locality about a particular shopkeeper do not write to the Controller about it, and unless the Controller publishes it, no harm is done.

Comment on this

They publish it themselves.

Comment on this

Well, if they publish it themselves, this Bill does not come into operation at all. They may be liable to slander and libel and all the rest.

Comment on this

No, there is no liability for slander.

Comment on this

Well, whatever the consequences of lying may be. This Bill will not either help or prevent a malicious person making complaints of a frivolous character about a shopkeeper in a particular town. It has nothing to do with that—that is, as far as I can read it—where a complaint is made to the Controller in writing. If that complaint is frivolous, the Controller tears it up and throws it in the waste-paper basket and nobody else hears anything about it. Senator Douglas shakes his head as though that were a mis-statement.

Comment on this

I cannot believe that a person making a frivolous complaint is going to keep it secret.

Comment on this

Then the position is that the customer is going to make a complaint of a frivolous character regarding a certain transaction.

Comment on this

That is an unfounded complaint really—not necessarily supported by false statements.

Comment on this

An unfounded charge or complaint; and they are going to take advantage of this Bill to publish the fact that they have made a charge of this kind, and that because of this Act appointing a Controller to whom the complaint may be sent, it will give an occasion to publish the complaint broadcast. It seems to me that this provision is not needed. There is no need for penal clauses of this kind in the Bill because the Controller is going to squelch any frivolous complaint.

Comment on this

Then you ought to delete the whole section.

Comment on this

I think that Senator Johnson and I are looking at the matter from a totally different point of view. I stated—I think on the Second Stage—that I did not think this kind of complaint would have a serious effect in a large city such as Dublin but that in the case of a country shopkeeper, and I am quite convinced of this, a story running around that twenty or any number of people had sent in complaints against a shopkeeper would unfairly and definitely injure that shopkeeper, and would injure him very much more than any whisper such as that So-and-So had been overcharged. The fact that it gradually got out afterwards—and the fact that it got out gradually would make it all the worse—either that the Controller had done nothing or that he had eventually decided that the price was reasonable, would do a great deal of harm and it would take a great deal of time to catch up on that. As a matter of fact, there is nothing — hardly anything — more damaging to your business than to have one of your assistants inadvertently charge too much. If that gets round considerable damage is done.

I have no doubt at all in my own mind that there is in this Bill—I hope it will not be used—the possibility of material damage being done, particularly to a small shopkeeper, by the lodging of a complaint, and that it will take a long time to get it back. The fact that the Controller has done nothing will not be sufficient proof at all. In fact, the person concerned will have no way of proving that the complaint is frivolous or unfounded because it will be some time, naturally, before he will hear from the Controller. That is answering Senator Johnson's argument. I think that it does no harm at all to add that word "frivolous" to the two words provided here. You might have some mischief-maker going around doing this kind of thing, and I think that the court ought to have some method of dealing with that. The fine can be nominal. There is a possibility of a fine of £10, as it stands. In some cases, it would hardly be known, except by the Controller. I think that there is a weapon left out there and that it ought to be provided for.

Comment on this

I am not at all convinced by the illustration given by Senator Douglas. Suppose the assistant in a shop overcharges a customer, and suppose that customer makes a complaint. How can that complaint be regarded as frivolous? It would be absurd.

Comment on this

I never said anything of the kind.

Comment on this

I understood the Senator to say that. If not, what did he say in relation to an overcharge inadvertently by one of his assistants? Of course, the Senator did say it.

Comment on this

I am afraid I shall have to repeat what I said. I said that, even if there were no complaints, the very fact of an overcharge having been made, even inadvertently, was damaging to a man's business. The fact that a firm had overcharged was bad business and damaging, and it was a thing that they could not do without running the risk of damage, and the mere rumour that such a charge was made would injure them. I am perfectly convinced that it would injure them to have talk of their having overcharged being spread around.

Comment on this

The fact that his assistant has the misfortune to make a mistake gets around, but if the person who is overcharged makes a complaint to the Controller, I do not see how the Controller could regard such a complaint as frivolous. The object of the amendment is this: to hold a threat over small people who buy goods and who may be inclined to think that if they make a complaint they will be liable to a fine of £2 10s. because it is a frivolous complaint. "Frivolous" is a very dangerous word. It has no definite, specific meaning. I do commend the phraseology of this sub-section (3). I think it is a perfect sub-section: "If any person makes in any complaint any statement which is false or misleading in any material respect, such person shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding £10." If any person makes a statement which is true, he certainly should not be liable to any penalty, and the bringing in of the word "frivolous" here is to hold the lash over the unfortunate people in the small streets and the back lanes of the country towns.

Comment on this

I think that the amendment is unnecessary for the reason that the difficulty of getting people to make any complaints under this Bill will be very great. Householders—particularly women, who do most of the buying—will not be inclined to come in and make either frivolous or, unfortunately, any other kind of complaints. I base this statement entirely on the report issued by the recent Food Prices Commission, where they stated that they could not get evidence from the very people in whose interests they were working. That was the complaint of that particular Commission. Therefore I think that to get any complaints at all will be rather an effort, not to speak of these frivolous complaints. You will not get frivolous complaints. You will have very few complaints, if any. I therefore think that the amendment should be withdrawn.

Comment on this

The argument to which we have just listened amounts to this: that, if you want any complaint, you must permit frivolous ones.

Comment on this

I am perfectly willing to withdraw the amendment and put down an amendment of the kind suggested by Senator Douglas—that is, to add to the word "frivolous" the words "false and misleading."

Comment on this

Before the Senator puts in that amendment I suggest that he should read the section.

Comment on this

I should like to put in the suggested amendment, if the House allows me.

Comment on this

Or "frivolous in any respect." That would be a nice amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 17:—

Section 32, sub-section (2). To delete in lines 7-9 the words "or can be procured without unreasonable expense by such person."

If the House will look at sub-section (2) and the two sub-paragraphs of that, (a) and (b), they will see that in the last two or three lines of each of these there is some question of unreasonable expense coming in. The words are that "for the purposes of an investigation into a complaint an inspector may on production of his authority to act as an inspector require the person who made the complaint (or the seller mentioned in the complaint) the subject of such investigation to furnish him with such information relevant to the complaint as he may reasonably require and as is in the power or possession of such person." And then it goes on to say that he has the power in both cases, both as regards the complainant and the seller, to require that it be procured. The words are:—"or can be procured without unreasonable expense by such person" or "without unreasonable expense by such seller," as the case may be.

You can certainly see the seller there being put to what might be to him quite a lot of expense and I do not see why there should be any question of expense in the matter at all. Surely, the first part of what the inspector may require is quite sufficient: "to furnish him with such information relevant to the complaint as he may reasonably require and as is in the power or possession of such person."

The inspector asks the seller to give him everything in his power or possession to answer his inquiries, but, besides that, the inspector has the power to make him produce other things which he has to procure, it is said here, without unreasonable expense; but in both cases it seems to me to be going too far. Surely, the whole matter could be conducted on the first lines without putting either the complainant or the seller to any other expense. That is what the amendment really is. It seems unreasonable to put that in even though protected by the words "unreasonable expense"; because even reasonable expense involved in getting a thing which he has not got and which will give him at least a great deal of trouble to get, if he produces everything in his power or possession, will be considerably hard. Surely those words ought to be quite sufficient to meet the case.

Comment on this

I agree with this amendment principally because I do not know what the words "unreasonable expense" mean. In the case of the seller I have no doubt that if there is a case against him which is a serious one and which he thinks it worth his while to disprove, he will go to a considerable length to do so and there will be no difficulty at all. But to provide that in the event of procuring something not in his power or possession, which the inspector thinks he could get, and go to the cost of doing so, and then be subject to a fine at the end, seems to me unnecessary. If the seller thinks the charge unfounded and does not want to go to the expense, I think there is no need to provide legally, provided that you have said that he must give such information as the inspector "reasonably requires and as is in the power or possession of the seller." I think that is quite sufficient without the further provision. So far as the person who makes the complaint is concerned, of course it can be said that you are forcing the complainant to give all the information that he can without going to unreasonable expense. Possibly there is a stronger case for making the complainant spend money than the trader. Logically, I think it is better to leave them out in both cases.

Comment on this

Certainly this section as it stands puts a very heavy onus on merchants, and if the Minister is not actually wedded to it I think he ought to accept the modifications suggested by Senator Jameson. Whatever is in a man's possession or in his power he ought to produce, but I can imagine circumstances, especially in big business, where information might be required of a trader. It is in his power to get it certainly, but the getting of it might cost hundreds of pounds. I think there is a good deal of sense in what Senator Jameson has said.

Comment on this

These words were inserted in the Bill after the first draft had been prepared as an additional safeguard for the trader and the complainant. What Senator Comyn has said is quite correct and is an argument in favour of retaining these words. An inspector, for instance, might ask a shopkeeper to make out from his books the day to day prices of certain commodities over a period of five years, to show at the same time the margin of profit which he realised on each sale, and also to prepare a list of the purchase prices of the same commodities over the same period. The preparation of such a return might engage the labour of one man for a period of a month. If the words are deleted the shopkeeper must produce that information and he will be liable to a fine if he fails to do so. The words in the Bill are a safeguard. They were put in for that purpose and I think they should be retained.

Comment on this

I now see the point. It is the word "or" that has caused all the confusion. If the word "and" were in the paragraph instead of "or" it would be clear. The word "and" would safeguard the trader in a reasonable way. I did not understand what the Minister was driving at because of the insertion in the section of the word "or."

Comment on this

I can have an amendment introduced on Report to correct that.

Comment on this

I move amendment 19:—

Section 33, sub-section (1). After the word "founded" in line 23 to insert the words "and if the Controller is satisfied that the price charged by the seller was in excess of the price usually charged by sellers in the immediate neighbourhood."

This amendment is intended to deal with what seems to me to be rather an injustice under Section 4. Under that section, if there is a complaint against a specific trader and the Controller considers that the price is too high, he will then proceed with detailed proceedings which ultimately may lead to a price order in the case of that particular trader. A notice will be sent to him and he will be obliged to sell at the particular price set out. Ultimately, he has the right of appeal on the grounds that the price he is charging is the general price charged and that he wants to have the whole matter investigated by the Commission. It seems to me that if the Controller has satisfied himself that the price charged by a specific trader is the general price prevailing in that neighbourhood he ought not to be obliged to go ahead against that trader, to go through all the machinery provided, because obviously it is not a question of one individual overcharging—it is a question of general overcharging, and should be dealt with in the same way as any other complaint of general overcharging, if proved.

The section as amended would read that if the Controller is of opinion "that such complaint is well-founded and if the Controller is satisfied that the price charged by the seller was in excess of the price usually charged by sellers in the immediate neighbourhood," that then he shall proceed against the individual. What I want to avoid is that the Controller should go through all the machinery laid down in the case of one particular trader if there is general overcharging in that neighbourhood. If there is that general overcharging in the neighbourhood, then the Controller should tackle that, and not an individual.

Comment on this

I think this amendment should not be accepted. The principle on which it has been argued is wrong. Suppose one man commits a crime, is it any defence for him to say that the crime is very prevalent in the district? No. I think the acceptance of the amendment would nullify the whole purpose of the section. It is no answer for a man who has been overcharging for milk or for some other commodity, to say that all the people in his part of the town are charging the same price. They may be all committing the offence, but when one is caught, I think the law requires that he should be dealt with.

Comment on this

What the amendment aims at is this: that if dealers in a certain type of commodity agree to fix a price for it, and while that price may be altogether unreasonable from the point of view of the consumer, they are all to get off scot free simply because they are all in the swim and have been overcharging the public.

Comment on this

Emphatically no.

Comment on this

The Senator argued that the individual should not be attacked. For the sake of argument, let us suppose that dealers in a particular town decide that they are going to charge a certain price for an article of consumption, say bread, during the week beginning on a certain date. If the consumers in that area are of opinion that the price charged is unreasonable, are they to be prevented from lodging a complaint with the Controller against a certain shopkeeper simply because all the shopkeepers there are charging an unreasonable price? Are they to have to wait until the Controller gets information from some other source before he can deal with the whole situation?

Comment on this

I think the two Senators who have just spoken have not read the Bill or, if they have, I suggest that they have not read it carefully. Senator Comyn is horrified at the idea because one man commits a crime and the crime is prevalent in that area that he should not be punished. If he would read the Bill he would find that the Minister, unfortunately, if there be any analogy which I do not admit, has accepted the principle in the Bill, and the only difference is the exact point where it comes in. Under sub-section (2), paragraph (b) of Section 33, the Senator will find that in a case where the Controller makes and publishes a price certificate for an individual trader, that individual can appeal to the Commission to have the whole matter dealt with on the grounds that the price complained of is the general price in the neighbourhood. That is perfectly right and reasonable. It is not with the question of justice for the individual that I am so much concerned as that of ordinary commonsense in government. If there is general overcharging in a district, why go through all the machinery against one individual? If the Price Controller is satisfied that the price charged by an individual trader is the general price charged for a particular commodity in that area, then I suggest he should submit the matter to the Commission. In that case the procedure for general overcharging would be put into operation under the other sections of the Bill. I think it is silly—I use the word deliberately—to force the Controller——

Comment on this

Frivolous, in fact.

Comment on this

Frivolous is a dangerous word and I would not like to use it even though Senator Comyn has, but as I was saying I think it is silly to force the Controller to go against that individual if he knows that the price charged by him is the general price charged in that neighbourhood. I suggest that he should cut out all the machinery provided for proceeding against the individual and consult with the Commission as to whether the matter is one on which there should be a general investigation.

Comment on this

It is quite clear that this amendment introduces a new factor in the determination of what is an unreasonably high price, namely, the general level of prices in a neighbourhood.

Comment on this

If the price charged by the individual shopkeeper is determined to be an unreasonable price, in the sense that it is too high, then no action is to be taken against that shopkeeper on the ground that it is the normal price in that neighbourhood. That is what the amendment aims at. I think that while it is undoubtedly up to that shopkeeper to plead in his defence that he was charging the normal price charged in the neighbourhood it is at a later stage that he should do that. The introduction of the amendment in this part of the Bill would suggest that if that was established then, although it was clear that the price was an unreasonable one, the matter should drop there. That is a thing that I think should not happen. What the Bill provides for is that in such circumstances the section is put into operation against the individual shopkeeper, but before anything can be done to him which would be likely to damage him in any way he can appeal to the Commission on the one ground on which an appeal is open to him, namely, that his price, deemed to have been unreasonable, is, in fact, the normal price. The Commission will then be required to examine the matter. If they decide that what the shopkeeper alleges is correct, then they are required to carry out a normal price investigation, and come to the point ultimately whether they may have to consider recommending the fixing of a price for the commodity in the neighbourhood.

It should be quite clear that the individual shopkeeper is not exonerated from the charge of having made an unreasonable profit or fixed an unreasonable price for his goods merely because other people are doing the same thing. That, I suggest, is contained in the amendment. The amendment would introduce an entirely new factor into the Bill and would run contrary to it. It is true that the shopkeeper, if he has to meet a charge of having charged an unreasonable price, and if that is proved against him, should be entitled to plead that the general level of prices in the neighbourhood requires investigation; that an investigation into those prices should take place. Nevertheless, it should be clear that he is not exonerated from guilt on that account. It is clear that he has in fact committed an offence under the Bill, even though punishment for the offence may be deferred until it is going to be applied generally.

Comment on this

The Minister, in replying to me, has fallen into an error which I did not hear him commit previously, but it is one that is commonly used in connection with this Bill. He used the words "fault,""exoneration," and "unreasonable profit." I would like to call attention to the fact that there is nothing whatever in the amendment about unreasonable profit, or about an unreasonably high price. That is not necessarily a fault. There is no question of exoneration. A shopkeeper may be charging an unreasonably high price for a commodity because he cannot get it at a reasonable price. The suggestion of necessary guilt is, I think, a mistake, and explains to some extent why the Minister does not understand the point I am trying to make in connection with the amendment. He says that a man is not exonerated by the fact that he is charging a price which is being generally charged in the neighbourhood. I quite agree that he is in the same position as the other traders, but I will not agree that there is a question of exoneration. He is in the same position as the other traders, and I suggest that he should be. But under the section you single him out, with possible damage to him alone, on a certain charge. It will be some time before the inspector will have gone to his shop and held an investigation into the charge made against him. The trader may appeal, one of the grounds of his appeal being that the price he is charging is the general price charged in the immediate neighbourhood. The principal matter for investigation by the Commission will, in the first place, be that the general price charged in that area is too high. If such a charge is made, then it should be sent to the Commission for general investigation. But in the case of an individual, because of some haphazard complaint, he finds himself specifically attacked and damaged, and at least some months will elapse before the Commission will have sat and dealt with the whole commodity. Possibly my amendment is a little too strong, in so far as I provide that the Controller will only proceed if he is satisfied that the price charged by the seller was in excess of the price usually charged, but, if the Minister will agree to amend the Bill by giving the Controller some option whereby, if he has reason to believe or is satisfied that such is the case, he can immediately refer it to the Commission himself without waiting for the man to appeal, my point would be met.

It is difficult, in a detailed Bill of this kind, to make oneself quite clear. The Minister clearly has two opinions in his mind. He has it in his mind that if an individual alone is overcharging, that individual shall be dealt with alone, and he has it in his mind that, if a number of persons are overcharging they should be dealt with by the Commission and by a general price order. My point is that if the Controller finds that a number of people are involved, although the specific charge is against only one, he should have the option of putting the whole machinery into motion at once, and dealing with the whole matter instead of dealing with it, as he must do now, by first attacking the individual, waiting 14 days for the individual to appeal and then sending it to the Commission. It is unnecessary to make that obligatory if the Controller knows, and I suggest to the Minister that, if he does not like the exact wording of my amendment, he should give the Controller the option, where he is satisfied that it was a general price, of making a request to the Commission to investigate it before he attacks the individual. Otherwise, I would press my amendment because I think there is a definite blank there which might operate unfairly against the individual.

Comment on this

There is something to be said for providing that, if the Controller is satisfied that the particular price was not charged, shall I say, maliciously, but because of the general price prevailing in the neighbourhood, he should, instead of proceeding against the individual, carry out an investigation into the price in the neighbourhood. That is not what the amendment provides for. It merely provides that the matter ends if the Controller believes that the unreasonably high price charged by one individual was also being charged by other individuals.

Comment on this

That was not my intention, and I thought I had made it clear. A number of the amendments I have here were not followed out to their full logical conclusion because, until the principle had been adopted, I thought it useless to go on with the following amendment.

Comment on this

If the Senator will leave his amendment over for the next day, I will look into the matter.

Comment on this

This amendment will depend on the matter which the Minister has promised to look into before next stage. I move amendment No. 21:—

Section 33, sub-section (1). To delete in line 41 the words "twenty-one" and to substitute therefor the word "seven."

This is simply a matter of whether 21 days is too long a period to allow to elapse. Sub-section (1) says:—

(1) Where a report is made to the Controller by an inspector on a complaint referred to him for investigation and the Controller, after consideration of such report, is of opinion that such complaint is well founded, the following provisions shall have effect, that is to say:—

(a) the Controller shall serve on the seller mentioned in such complaint a notice in the prescribed form—

(i) stating the nature of such complaint, and

(ii) stating that in the opinion of the Controller such complaint is well founded, and

(iii) in case such complaint relates to a sale or offering for sale retail, specifying the price which in the opinion of the Controller is a reasonable retail price for the commodity the retail price of which was the subject of such complaint, and

(iv) in case such complaint relates to a sale or offering for sale wholesale, specifying the price which in the opinion of the Controller is a reasonable wholesale price for the commodity the wholesale price of which was the subject of such complaint, and

(v) requiring such seller within twenty-one days after the service of such notice to give to the Controller an undertaking in writing to charge in future a reasonable price.

To give a seller three weeks in which to continue an unreasonable price seems to me to be unnecessarily long. If it is a case of a man simply adjusting his price list, seven days, I suggest, is quite long enough, and to allow a seller to continue to charge unreasonably for three weeks would require more justification than I can see for it. I suggest that seven days is ample, if, indeed, you do not say "immediately on receipt of this notice."

Comment on this

I should like to say, before the discussion goes any further, that this section in the Bill, as originally introduced in the Dáil, did not contain sub-section (2) which was inserted by way of an official amendment later. In the original Bill, 21 days was the period fixed in paragraphs (v) and (vi) and, when sub-section (2) was introduced, it provided for another 14 days before a certificate could be issued. We moved to reduce the 21 days in the sub-section to ten days, but, through a printing error in the amendment sheet in the Dáil, the amendment was only accepted on Report Stage in relation to paragraph (vi) and we could not get agreement amongst the members of the Dáil to allow us to repair the printing error in relation to paragraph (v), so that the Bill came from the Dáil with 21 days in one paragraph and ten in the other. It is quite clear that the same period must be prescribed in both paragraphs, because the next paragraph says: "If such seller complies with the requirements of such notice." If he does not comply, the rest follows on. Of course, he has ceased to comply or has, in fact, complied with the requirements of the notice within ten days by the time paragraph (vi) comes into operation, so that there is no necessity for the Controller to wait for 21 days. It is obvious that a man will not give an undertaking, if he does not think he has overcharged, and will not agree to refund the amount overcharged, so I would ask that the 21 days in paragraph (vi) be reduced to ten days as in paragraph (v).

Comment on this

I think that ten days is somewhat short. In the case of a charge against an individual who admits it, if he has any sense and wants to look after his business, he will agree in one day. The time is only for a different purpose. I can assure the House that any trader, who has common sense and admits a charge, will get it put right as quickly as he possibly can in his own interest, but, if he has the feeling, as some traders have, that the price he is charging is high, but that he cannot help it, and if he wants to consult with others to see whether they should take the necessary steps to attack what they think is the source of the higher charge, he really must be given a reasonable time.

Comment on this

He has 24 days as the Bill stands.

Comment on this

Only when he is threatened with an order, and any individual is going to think a good deal before he refuses to carry out a request of the Controller. So far as I am concerned, I would prefer it if you gave him longer then, and, possibly, if necessary, a rather shorter time after, because the serious step will be when he refuses to carry out an order of the Controller. He will know, if he does so, that a price order will be fixed without any doubt, and there is, I admit, ample time then, but I think that it is in the earlier stage you want the 21 days, even if we have to shorten it afterwards. You will certainly want 14 days, because one trader will not fight this thing alone— a very big one might, but no small trader is going to fight it alone. He is only going to do it when he is satisfied that other traders agree that the price is right and ought to be fought, and a certain time must be allowed for consultation.

Comment on this

I am inclined to think that the seven days suggested by Senator Johnson is too short a period, particularly in this country, where there are only three postal deliveries a week in some parts of the country to which the Act might be applied. Ten days appears to be a reasonable period. The original proposal was 21 days when we introduced the section. That was cut down to ten, so that the total became 24, and it would be 48 days if the amendment were accepted. A period of 48 days might conceivably elapse before the Controller had decided, on the report of his inspector, that an act of profiteering had taken place. There is some misunderstanding about that, because the investigator's report would have to show that the price charged by a retailer was unreasonable having regard—and this would be taken into account—to the circumstances, including the price paid by him. If the Controller decided that such an act had taken place, 48 days, that is, well over a month, would elapse before the punishment would fall on the head of the offender if, in fact, any punishment fell on his head, because it seems to me that there would be very few traders who would not be able to bring themselves into line in some way and avoid the punishment—as they would be most anxious to do—and the punishment in that case is only the publication of a certificate. It seems to me that ten days, which provides for over three weeks elapsing, is a reasonable period.

Comment on this

May I be allowed to alter the period in my amendment to ten days?

Permission granted.

Comment on this

Might I also, on that section, ask the Minister what it means to give an undertaking to charge a reasonable price?

Comment on this

It means precisely what it says. It is, I am prepared to admit, a flaw in the Bill. It seems to me that you could contemplate an unscrupulous shopkeeper charging prices double what he should charge, having a complaint made against him, having that complaint investigated and getting out of the difficulty by promising never again to offend, and then going out and offending again and letting the machinery start all over again. The shopkeeper doing that, however, would, I think, be taking a risk, and what we hope to achieve by that is that by representation we will be able to prevent shopkeepers charging excessive prices, and that we will not have to resort to any punitive methods, until it has been shown that private representation is not going to achieve any good result. Consequently, although I will admit that that section is very wide as it stands, and gives a shopkeeper broad road by which he can escape the effects of his act, I think it is preferable to have it that way.

Amended amendment agreed to.

Comment on this

I move amendment 22:—

Section 33, sub-section (1). To delete all from and including the word "and" in line 45 down to and including the word "price" in line 51.

Paragraph (vi) of the sub-section provides for the repayment by the profiteer to the purchaser whom he had overcharged of the difference between what the purchaser paid and the reasonable price he ought to have paid. In my opinion, that will either work unfairly or it will not work at all. Cases of individual profiteering will be found, I think, to be extremely rare. Probably 90 per cent of the cases of overcharging are in respect of overcharging which is general in a particular neighbourhood, probably due to a multiplicity of shops. At any rate, they are not cases of individual overcharging but of overcharging which prevails in a particular neighbourhood. If a complaint is made against a trader in a neighbourhood in which everybody in that trade is overcharging, and if he is convicted, I do not think it is fair that he should be punished in the way of having to pay back his ill-gotten gains, and that all the other people should get off. That will be the general case. In the case of the individual profiteer who is the only one guilty in the neighbourhood, it might be all very well, but, even in that case, it would not, in my opinion, be possible to carry it into effect. The provision is:—

(vi) if such complaint relates to a sale, requiring such seller within ten days after the service of such notice to pay to the complainant the difference between the price the subject of such complaint and the price specified in such notice as the reasonable price;

That creates what is known to the law as a statutory debt. It is not a debt that arises from contract and if a single profiteer who ought to be hit declines to comply with the notice to pay back to the customer his ill-gotten gains, how are you going to enforce it? You cannot enforce it in the District Court, because a statutory debt is not permissible. There is no jurisdiction in the District Court to sue for a statutory debt. Prima facie it must be sued for in the High Court. Fancy an action in the High Court for a few pence, a few shillings or a few pounds. It is not worth it. I suggest that the section would be better with this amendment.

Comment on this

What Senator Brown has said is remarkable—that it is not fair to make a man who overcharges pay the amount of the overcharge back to the complainant. The reason why it is not fair is not because it is not just, but because it is not full justice, because all the other people who have overcharged are not required to pay back. That is a very curious argument. There must be some inducement to some person to come forward and to make a complaint. The most reasonable inducement is that the person who makes the complaint, if it is well-founded, gets back the amount of the overcharge. That is fair, that is justice. It is not full justice, because full justice would be to compel that person to pay back to every individual to whom he sold the commodity the amount of the overcharge. That would be full justice. This is a measure of justice. In regard to the other objection made by Senator Brown, with his great legal skill, I admit that this does create a statutory debt which, probably, cannot be sued for in the District Court but it can be sued for in other courts.

Comment on this

The poor man cannot go there.

Comment on this

In this case it is the rich man who will have to pay the costs.

Comment on this

Judgment for 5/- in the High Courts.

Comment on this

Judgment for 5/- and costs. The man who overcharges will have to pay the costs, and rather than pay the costs he will repay what he ought not to have charged, the amount that he wrongly got from the unfortunate man who went in to buy goods from him. Supposing there was to be an amendment on the lines suggested by Senator Brown, it ought to be: "And if not paid may be sued for as a debt in the District Court." These words could be put into the section. The arguments adduced by Senator Brown afford no reason whatever why the main provisions of the sub-section should not remain.

Comment on this

I think if this part of the Bill only dealt with small retail transactions there would be a good deal of force in what Senator Brown argued, but it might cover a whole transaction and might cover charges made by people who have a monopoly. For instance, it might deal with the price of manures sold to farmers—to Senator Miss Browne, for instance—and there might be a general charge all over the country by that particular firm which was unreasonable. If it could be shown that there was, in fact, an unreasonably high charge paid by farmers for the manures, surely there is some reason in asking that there should be a refund of the overcharge.

Comment on this

The discussion so far does not seem to have got to the real objection to paragraph (vi). I will not go into the legal points between Senator Comyn and Senator Brown because I do not understand them. Senator Comyn said the real object was to have an inducement to a person to make a complaint.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation I did not say that was the real object. The real object was to do justice between people. It might have the effect of inducing people to come forward.

Comment on this

I apologise to Senator Comyn if I misquoted him in any way. Quite conceivably this provision will work out unfairly, and I doubt if it will achieve the purpose that certain Senators require. If it was a simple matter of an individual overcharging in one case I should not very much quarrel with the provision. That is not the case. The Minister is to consider between now and the Report Stage certain representations that I made to him. As the Bill stands the Controller must put these provisions into effect and order that the amount be repaid, irrespective of the exact grounds. Let some Senators get the idea out of their heads that it is a question of profiteering. It is not. It is a question of the price being unreasonably high. If it were a question of profiteering I would have no objection whatever to having the money paid back. Senators seem to think that the Bill deals only with profiteering. It deals with prices.

Comment on this

The Senator is the only one who introduced the term "excessive profits" in his amendment.

Comment on this

I admit that high prices might be due to excessive profits. If this referred to an isolated case I would not have any great objection. The section is to be put into effect irrespective of the grounds of the high prices. There is an even greater objection, and that is that a trader against whom there is a clear case of overcharging might repay the difference. I think in certain cases that will be done—not necessarily because he is fair-minded, but because he will find that it is wise for him to do so. This power in the complainant to get his money back—and he must get it back if the case is made—will, I think, be unfair in certain districts. A man may go to a shopkeeper and say: "If you do not repay me so much out of what I paid you for an article last week I will make a complaint against you." A shopkeeper will go a considerable length rather than have a complaint made—even though it is an unfair complaint—because I am absolutely convinced it would injure him. I have no doubt whatever that it will injure a shopkeeper if a complaint is made against him. As Senator Comyn pointed out, this provision gives an inducement which is not necessary, and which might easily be abused. For that reason I am going to vote in favour of deleting it. I do not think you are going to have as much trouble in getting bona fide complaints, after the Bill is law, as some people believe. The work of the former Commission on Prices was different. It was a general inquiry into prices, and people were reluctant to come forward. It is quite unnecessary to have this provision for the purpose of giving an inducement. Although one does not like to suggest it, it might easily lead to blackmail as this particular power might be very easily mis-used.

Comment on this

I had not the privilege of hearing the earlier debate, but looking at the section it does not appear that the provisions of paragraph (vi) are mandatory. The seller can say "No, I refuse to refund," and then there is put into operation all the subsequent very elaborate procedure in the latter part of the sub-section. It states that if the seller does not comply with the requirements of such notice the Controller will proceed to issue a price certificate, which can only be done after very elaborate investigation and further inquiry. I may be wrong there. I do not think so. The obligation to refund can be evaded by refusal. Then follows the very elaborate procedure which is never going to work.

[The Cathaoirleach resumed the Chair.]

Comment on this

Senator Douglas said that if an individual case was affected he would not have objected. As I read the section it is only the complainant will get a refund. The fact that a customer complains to the Controller that he believes he was overcharged for a certain article, and that the Controller, on investigation, is satisfied that the complaint was justified, and that there was overcharging——

Comment on this

No, too high a price.

Comment on this

It means the same thing.

Comment on this

I make the Senator a present of the difference. After being satisfied that there was overcharging, the Controller informs the seller that the difference should be refunded. Is not that fair and reasonable? What hardship is inflicted on anyone? The only person who will be entitled to a refund will be the person who made the complaint. He will get the difference between what is considered to be a fair price and the price he was charged. I do not see where any difficulty will arise. It is only common justice that if a person proves a case before the Controller, having gone to all that trouble, he should get the difference between the fair price and the price he was charged for the article.

Comment on this

I am not going to argue the matter further. If a complaint is made under paragraph (iv), and if the Controller considered that the price charged was unreasonably high, and serves notice for repayment of the difference, what is to happen if 1,000 people go around to the shops and serve notices? Can they be delayed pending a full inquiry into prices? I do not think they can. It seems that the Controller must investigate each case separately and go ahead with the order. If it concerned a single case I would not object. It seems to me that when it is the general price is too high, and that you order one person to pay back, at a time when the whole matter should be investigated, you will have everyone claiming their money back and you will have chaos. It seems that the Controller cannot do for Seán what he will do for someone else, and that there is no limit.

Comment on this

If shopkeepers or firms sell certain articles at an unreasonably high price and if someone has the courage to come forward and challenge their action, by lodging a complaint, if the Controller considers that the complaint was justified and orders a refund of the difference, is it wrong if other members of the community who have been fleeced—perhaps because of the activities of a ring—make a complaint and get a refund of the overcharges? I do not think it is.

Comment on this

I think that the case against this paragraph, as it stands, is that regarded from one point of view it is retrospective legislation. At the same time I think it should stand. The only point which struck me, arising out of the discussion, in respect of which some amendment might be necessary is that we should ensure that where a complaint has been investigated against a particular shopkeeper in respect of a particular commodity, and the complaint is found to be justified when this procedure is adopted, the Controller should not investigate a complaint relating to a sale by the same shopkeeper of the same commodity at a date earlier than the date of the complaint investigated.

Comment on this

Or sale by any other shopkeeper.

Comment on this

Any other shopkeeper in the same vicinity perhaps. I mean that the only complaints that would arise for investigation must be complaints of a later date than that which is investigated. I think that is reasonable. Otherwise you might have people claiming refunds for a number of years and the Controller required to carry out a separate investigation in each case because, of course, it is clear that the only thing that the seller is required to do is to make a refund in the one single case which was brought to the notice of the Controller. He could not be required by the Controller to refund in other cases. The Controller could not act unless there was an investigation and an inspector had furnished a report. There is only the one case in respect of which the seller could be made to give a refund. I agree he should be protected against the possibility of other complaints arising immediately in respect of sales that took place prior to the date of the sale investigated. I think an amendment could be devised on these lines and I am prepared to consider the matter. I think, that subject to that, the paragraph should stand. The whole proceeding would be meaningless without it. The mere fact that an investigation is carried out and a report is made shows that the complaint is well founded. Paragraphs (i), (ii), (iv), and (v) inflict no hardship on anybody. The other part of the section only comes into operation in the event of these things being done.

Comment on this

I think the Minister will want to make a specific provision to cover what he says. In Section 23 you have an investigation into prices, and under another section a maximum price can be fixed. As far as I can see there is nothing to prevent any person applying to have a refund immediately from every shopkeeper if he can prove that he was overcharged.

Comment on this

The statement made by Senator Douglas and purported to be answered by Senator Farren raises a most alarming question. I shall tell you what it is. Suppose a merchant has overcharged and a man comes forward and makes a complaint, and the Controller finds that there has been an overcharge, let us say on the 1st of the month. He makes his finding, and that finding gets known. Is it possible that every person who bought commodities in that shop or any other shop before the 1st of the month, and made no complaint, as a result of the finding of the Controller can come and make claims against merchants?

Comment on this

They can ask for another investigation as the Bill stands.

Comment on this

That is a thing that should be provided against, we all think. It would lead to endless confusion and endless investigation. I think it is only fair that no man should be allowed to come forward with a complaint after he knows the decision.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

The Minister has left to take part in a Division in the other House, but if we agree on that point we shall bring it before him when he returns.

Comment on this

I think the Minister has already agreed to look into it.

Comment on this

I want to press on the Minister's notice and the notice of the House the importance of looking at this part of the Bill, not merely as a matter of retail trading—of purchases and complaints in regard to over-charging—but as a protection also of the shopkeeper on the one hand against the manufacturer or the importer, and the protection, shall I say, of the farmer buying considerable quantities of goods. Within my own experience I have known not infrequently of manufacturers, merchants and wholesalers taking particular advantage of both farmers and traders in specific areas, because there was no effective competition in those areas. As long as the trader or the farmer was in a tight difficulty, an excessive price was charged. This Bill, particularly this part of it, is a protection against that kind of overcharging. In my own view this paragraph (vi) is a distinct advantage if it is retained to ensure that perhaps £5, £10, £15 or £20 overcharged in a large bill would have to be refunded. It is distinctly to the advantage of the large purchaser. The shopkeeper, the farmer or even the creamery is put in a position of protection under this Bill. It is not proper to think of this part of the Bill as merely a matter of retail prices as between shopkeepers and consumers.

Amendment, by leave, deferred to Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 23:—

Section 33, sub-section (1). To delete lines 2-5 inclusive.

The question of publication is the matter which I wish to raise under this amendment. If a seller does not comply with the requirements of a notice, a certificate has to be made by the Controller stating what is a reasonable retail price and a copy of such certificate is to be served on the seller. There is then a further sub-section which states that the Controller shall "publish a copy of such certificate in a newspaper or newspapers circulating in the district where the commodity, the price of which was the subject of such complaint, was sold or offered for sale." The publication of such a matter in a newspaper in the district where a man resides is a very serious thing and might inflict a great deal of injury on the seller. I should like to ask the Minister what is the nature of the publication. Is it merely to be the publication of a certificate or are names to be mentioned? If it is merely a question of publishing a copy of the certificate, containing the price which the Controller thinks should be charged in that district, the sub-section might probably be defended. If it is going to give the details of the case and the man's name is mentioned, it does seem unnecessary and might inflict very great hardship. I should like to have some information as to the nature of the publication, but as the Minister is not here I desire to leave the amendment over to the Report Stage.

Comment on this

The Minister will probably be back before the amendment is disposed of. I think that if the Senator looks at the bottom of page ten he will find that it is quite clear that the Controller may make a certificate certifying a price which in the opinion of the Controller is a reasonable retail price to be charged by the seller. That is a certificate for one individual alone. Errors may arise even under the best Controllers and to publish a man's name in the local papers is an attempt to put him out of business or very little short of it. If the Controller's certificate is not carried out, the man should be prosecuted and fined, but to have his name published in a newspaper as an obligation under the Act is a sort of blackmail to my mind.

Comment on this

I submit that this amendment should be postponed until the Minister returns. I presume he is coming back again. My reason for saying so is that from my knowledge of legal forms, I cannot visualise a certificate under this section which would not contain the name of the seller. I think it would be almost essential that the name of the seller should appear in the certificate. I agree that that would be a tremendous penalty, far and away greater than any fine which could be inflicted upon him. We could provide that the certificate should contain merely a statement of the price and that the name of the seller should be excluded from any publication of the certificate. I think the Minister probably ought to look into that, to see whether he could have a form of certificate leaving out the name. If the name of the merchant who overcharged has to be published in the local paper, it would go a long way towards putting a merchant out of business. That might be as injurious to the poor man who is the purchaser as to the merchant himself.

Comment on this

Would not the reference "subject to the provisions of the next following sub-section" have something to say to this argument, because if no action is taken under the provisions of the following sub-section it is obvious that the seller is defying the Controller, and in these circumstances probably publication is necessary? That is how it strikes me without a very full examination of the matter.

Comment on this

It appears to me that this penal clause regarding publication in the newspapers does not come into operation if the person is reasonable and complies with the requirements laid down under the previous sub-sections. One of these sub-sections states:—

If such seller complies with the requirements of such notice the Controller shall take no further steps in relation to such complaint.

It is only in the event of his refusing to do these things that the penal clause can come into operation. If he defies the Controller, surely in the interests of the public he should be made pay for it. If a man persists in defying the Controller, after the Controller has fixed a fair price, he should be penalised, but if the man gives an undertaking to carry out the provisions of the fair price certificate there will be nothing further about it. There will be no publicity or anything else. And if a man persists, surely the law must provide some penal clause to deal with that man.

Comment on this

Surely a merchant has a right to go to the Commission and appeal and say the Controller is quite wrong. It is the assertion of a legal right, and, until it is found by the Commission to have been wrong, I think nothing injurious to him should be done by publication or otherwise. Paragraph (c) of sub-section (1) of Section 33 says "if such seller does not comply with the requirements of such notice," that is if he does not comply with certain duties set out in the Bill certain matters take place, including the publication of the certificate; but the certificate might be published before the appeal is heard.

Comment on this

Well, then the other question that arises is this. If the certificate is made there is provision here for publication; but what the Seanad wants to know is whether the certificate will contain the name of the seller as part of the certificate, or whether the certificate cannot be devised fixing prices without giving the names of the sellers.

Comment on this

Originally it was intended that the certificate would contain the name of the seller. It was intended as a definite punishment for a seller who charged an unreasonably high price, and who refused to give an undertaking not to do the same again, or who failed, in any of the ways open to him under the Act, to make amends, and, consequently, as it were, came up for punishment. The first punishment was publishing the fact that a certificate had been issued against him. Having gone into that with great care, and after representations upon that score, I am somewhat inclined to think, perhaps, that it would be an undue hardship that the name of the firm should be published. It is clear if you do not publish the name of the firm you may, perhaps, be letting somebody in for some very serious form of punishment upon this. The procedure is, a complaint is made, is investigated and found to be well-founded. The seller can then either refund the amount of the overcharge, and give an undertaking not to make any overcharges in the future and that matter ends. Alternatively, he could appeal to the Commission to investigate the general level of prices paid for those commodities in the neighbourhood in which he lives. If the Commission does investigate and finds against him there the matter ends. If he refuses to refund the amount of the overcharge after the Commission decides that there is an overcharge, then the certificate may be published. It is a question for determination whether, in view of that happening, the punishment of the individual shopkeeper, who overcharged and refused to refund and offended again, should not be to send him to prison, and whether his name should be published with the publication of the certificate. But if subsequent to the issue of the certificate he again overcharges then he becomes liable to a fine or imprisonment. We could contemplate leaving the name out of the certificate, and I am sure many shopkeepers would prefer imprisonment to the publication, and it might be a much greater deterrent. However, it is a matter upon which I have more or less an open mind, whether the certificate should contain the name of the seller or not. When you regard it from one point of view, and give consideration to the various means of escaping the punishment open to the seller, you will see at a later stage publication to be effective should take place. But having regard to the effect that that might have upon the business of the person concerned, possibly out of proportion altogether to the amount of the overcharge or the seriousness of the article concerned, I am inclined to think that after due notice is given in that particular neighbourhood of what is a reasonable price, then, that seller and all others would become liable to a period of imprisonment if they again overcharged for those commodities in that neighbourhood. I am inclined to think at present we should leave that out.

Comment on this

This particular amendment is to delete paragraph (iii), that is to delete the words "publish a copy of such certificate in a newspaper or newspapers circulating in the district where the commodity the price of which was the subject of such complaint was sold or offered for sale."

Comment on this

The whole case is altered now after what the Minister said. I put down an amendment to delete certain words because they might include the name. I take it from what the Minister now said that he will substitute another paragraph for paragraph (iii) in which he will give exact words that will meet my case.

Comment on this

I move amendment 25:—

Section 33, sub-section (5). After the word "section" in line 16 to insert the words "and shall do so if, on representation from the person on whom such certificate has been served, he is satisfied that the wholesale or manufacturers' prices, as the case may be, have been advanced since the order was made."

This deals with the question of revocation of the certificate. There is power to the Controller to revoke a certificate he himself has made. I want to provide that if he is satisfied from representations made to him that the cost that the trader has charged is not excessive he shall not revoke it.

Comment on this

I am prepared to consider that matter and to introduce an amendment on Report dealing with it.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 26:—

Section 33, sub-section (8). To delete in lines 28-30 the words "or by leaving it with a person over sixteen years of age at the premises where such first-mentioned person carries on business."

The documents, with which the certificate in this sub-section deals, are of vital importance to the trader. They involve the right of appeal to the Commission and the penal consequences for acting in contravention of the proposed certificate. Now the mode of service laid down in sub-section (8) is this: "Any notice or certificate required by this section to be served on any person may be served by delivering it to such person or by leaving it with a person over 16 years of age at the premises where such first-mentioned person carries on business...." The object of the amendment is to delete that portion of the mode of service. The third way the sub-section provides for service is "by sending it by registered post to such first-mentioned person at such premises." Now the service on a young person over 16 years of age in a shop is a most objectionable procedure. I do not think that any legal document of any kind ought to be served in a shop, and the service of every legal document, a summons under the Circuit Court or the District Court, has to be served either personally or on some relative of the person in the employment of the person to be served at his residence. I suggest to the Minister that it is only right that the service of these documents, which are just as important as any other legal documents, should not include service on anybody over 16 years of age or who looks to be over 16 years of age in a shop.

Comment on this

I would like to join with Senator Brown in that respect. Seeing that there is provision made for service by registered letter, I think the form of service to which he objects should not be included in the Bill.

Comment on this

I am prepared to agree.

Comment on this

I move amendment 27:

Section 36, sub-section (5). After the word "than" in line 42 to insert the words "ten days after."

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept that amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 28:—

Section 38, sub-section (1). After the word "manufacturing" in line 2 to insert the words "or producing."

I put this amendment down to raise the question: what exactly is a manufacture? This covers "food" and there are quite a number of protected commodities besides food. For my part I have something in the nature of a market garden. I do not know whether I would be held to manufacture cabbages or vegetables, which are protected, but if I overcharge, I would be subject to an investigation as if I were a manufacturer. I put down this amendment in order that the Minister might tell us what a manufacture means. Does it exclude something which may be food, but not manufactured in the ordinary sense of the word? I do not know how we stand with regard to every food which is protected but not in the strict sense manufactured.

Comment on this

I shall dodge the question by accepting the amendment.

Comment on this

In that case there are a number of consequential amendments.

Comment on this

Then I shall bring up an amendment on the Report Stage to deal with the whole matter.

Comment on this

I move amendment 29:—

Section 39. Before paragraph (e) to insert a new paragraph as follows:—

(e) the price at which the commodity could be obtained by purchase from manufacturers outside Saorstát Eireann if such commodity was not a protected commodity, and if such price is lower than the price charged by manufacturers in Saorstát Eireann the general reasons which are explanatory of the higher price in Saorstát Eireann, and in particular if the price at which such commodity could be obtained from outside Saorstát Eireann is due to lower wages being paid or to the commodity being offered at less than the cost of production.

I dealt with the principal argument in favour of this important section in the debate on the Second Reading. I will not go into details now except to say that after having full investigation into the manufacturers' prices and those published, it seems to me highly desirable that we should have a report on prices for commodities in protected groups. In order that there should be no misunderstanding I want to make it clear that I am not attacking Irish manufactures in this case at all. I think there are some cases where you would be satisfied that the price is the same or substantially the same. There are other cases where Irish manufacturers' prices will be of necessity very high. For that reason I have put in this amendment, partly on a hint gleaned from a speech of the Minister's that there were certain matters that should be considered. If there is to be a report of this kind from the Commission I want to put in a provision that the Commission will show, if they can, what are the reasons for the higher manufacturing prices here if the prices are higher. At any rate, I do think that if you are going to have an inquiry into prices of a protected commodity, the value of that inquiry would be of very little use unless you are prepared to ascertain what the price would be without protection. If that is so, you have also got to show if the prices were below the cost of production elsewhere or below the wages elsewhere; if the circumstances in Continental countries were such that they could be brought in here at a low cost because the whole standard in these countries is low, which we do not want here.

Comment on this

While Senator Douglas was speaking, I read through his proposed amendment, and it means that the Minister is to be constantly reminded of the consequences of protection in this country. Night, noon and morning he is to be told in words, figures and tables what protection costs. He is never to be allowed to forget that. It reminds me of what the old Roman used to say after every speech—"Delenda est Carthago"— Carthage must be destroyed! What Senator Douglas wants to say is that in every report that comes in there should be this information, the meaning of which is: "Protection should be destroyed." That is the meaning of such an amendment as this, and for that reason I am against it.

Comment on this

Following on the lines of what the last speaker said, I would say that "Nobody ought to be afraid of the truth."

Comment on this

I had intended to oppose this amendment, but I think there must be a case for it that had not occurred to me after hearing what Senator Comyn said. I have absolutely no objection to be continuously reminded night, noon and morning of the consequences of protection. Instead of that I intend to take steps to ensure that nobody will forget the consequences of a protectionist policy.

In the first place, I think it is unnecessary. Paragraph (c) of Section 39 provides that the Commission shall report "whether in the opinion of the Commission such prices are or are not unreasonably high, together with the reasons for such opinion." I think that the Commission, in setting out their reason for that opinion, would, in the majority of cases, have to have advertence to the prices prevailing for the same commodities elsewhere, or the prices at which these goods could be purchased if protective duties were not in force. In quite a number of cases it is not possible to say—it is not possible for anybody to say—at what price goods could be imported into the country if the protective duty did not apply, because prices fluctuate from day to day in accordance with the size of the order or the nature of the competition prevailing in a particular district for certain classes of goods. Senators can recall quite a number of classes of goods to which that applies. With respect to other classes of goods, the prices at which they can be purchased from different countries would vary considerably, depending on the style or cut or fashion of the goods. We can buy hats, for instance, but the people will only buy hats of a particular size or a particular shape or colour. The same applies to boots. People will only wear boots of a particular type. The same applies to clothing. Consequently, you would have to take into account not merely what the price would be with free competition, but whether the people of this country would purchase the goods even with a protective tariff.

Supposing that this amendment were carried, it would pre-suppose not only the carrying out of an investigation into prices, and the reason why these prices are or are not too high, but also the wages paid in the particular industries in other countries, the practice of those engaged in these industries in relation to the dumping of goods at or under the cost of production, and to take in other circumstances which would be altogether outside the scope of the Commission's enquiries and which could not be ascertained in a satisfactory manner without the setting up of complicated machinery and always having to face the possibility of the Commission depending on statements made to it, by witnesses appearing before it, and coming to wrong conclusions as a result of these statements, because it would have no means of checking up on these statements in the countries concerned. For example, the cheapest products come from Japan, and despite duties of 60 or 70 per cent., they are still coming in from that country. We all know that the conditions of labour and the wages paid there are such as would not be tolerated in this country and that that is the chief reason for the low price at which these goods from Japan can be sold. There are other reasons as well. Prices are not entirely due to wages being lower. They are due to a variety of causes, and the Commission would have no means of investigating these causes and would be required to do so by this amendment.

My objections to this amendment are that it proposes to impose upon the Commission a task which it could not perform. Secondly, it is not clear that the Commission should be asked to perform that task, even if it had the power to do so. Thirdly—and this sounds like a legal argument—the Commission will do it in any case. The Commission is certainly given power to carry out any investigation which it considers practicable and to report the result of this investigation.

Comment on this

The first portion of the Minister's statement sounded like my own statement. He gave all the different classes of goods and showed that it would be impossible to ascertain the price.

Comment on this

At which they are produced in other countries.

Comment on this

If it is possible to fix a maximum price for a defined article, as is stated here, it should be possible to do the same for goods obtained outside. It is not fair to bring in the point about the difference in the styles and shapes of boots and other articles of clothing. With regard to the statement that the Commission will do that in any case, with great respect to the Minister, I think he is wrong. Apart from the fact that it could not do it, I do not think that it would necessarily do it. I think that you are not going to get satisfaction unless you are going to have advertence to the price at which the article could be obtained from outside without protection, which might come in here in a reasonable explanation as between the two prices. The Minister has not been coming here very long, and he might realise that, while I do not believe in high protection. I am not, at the same time, a free trader. I am not at all afraid of an investigation of this kind, but I will admit, frankly, that I believe it will be healthy for the manufacturer here to know that when there was an investigation into his goods, there would be also a reasonably fair report as to the prices that could be obtained outside. There may be a fair argument with regard to the latter portion of my amendment, but that was only put in because of a certain sentence in the Minister's speech on the Second Stage in which he suggested that if I was making a suggestion for this inquiry, I should have advertence to these two things, of the conditions outside and the possibility of the commodity being dumped. As far as taking advantage of this Commission to have an inquiry to show what the prices were outside, not in any sense as to what they should charge here, but in relation to seeing that if prices were not reasonable the country should know it, that is a thing I think that nobody should be ashamed of, whether free trader or protectionist.

Comment on this

That they ought always to be reminded of the advantages of mass production.

Comment on this

We can have mass production here, too. I would be prepared to take the last portion of the amendment away, if that would meet the case.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

You mean the portion starting with "and in particular"?

Comment on this

Yes, that is the portion I mean, but otherwise I think that there is an opinion here on which I would like the opinion of the House.

Comment on this

I think the last few words of the Senator's speech amount to this—that he is seeking to have reinstated under this amendment the Tariff Commission, because practically all the inquiry that the amendment required was the work of the Tariff Commission. I am entirely in favour of the fullest examination and the fullest publication of the result of this class of investigation, and if this were going to be embodied in the Bill I should certainly like the last paragraph to remain in. But I think it is important for the people of this country, Ministers or others, to know that low prices do not necessarily follow from low wages, and that very often the lowest prices run with the highest wages. A good deal of talk about the product of sweated labour is at sea, because the goods in question are the product of highly-paid labour and highly-efficient organisation. I am prompted to rise because of the feeling that the moving of this amendment must have been consequent on the withdrawal of other amendments coming from the same quarter of the House. I cannot imagine, if the Commission is going to undertake this kind of inquiry, how it could be other than a body sitting continuously. The Tariff Commission had to be working constantly for very many months.

Comment on this

It is only asked to do this if it is inquiring into a specific commodity under the Bill.

Comment on this

This is additional to all the other work of the Commission, and if there is any justification for the allegation that no protective tariffs are needed, one has to be very careful of the prices which manufacturers charge and that there are always temptations to charge a higher price than is justified in free competition. I would imagine that this would be a whole-time job for this Commission. In the last case it proved to be so, and this Commission would have to be continuously sitting. It could not be by any means partially occupied and, in addition, I think it would have to be a highly-remunerated Commission. If these inquiries are going to be of any value at all, the Commission would have to be a much more highly-qualified and much more efficient body than the rest of the Bill would necessitate. While I would have no objection to a Commission of the kind that would have, in addition to its other duties, the duty of this inquiry, I would warn the House that this particular amendment will enlarge the functions of the Commission considerably, will add a good deal to the expense, and will call for continuous whole time operations.

Comment on this

Is it open to me to speak again on this matter?

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

Yes.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Johnson that if this amendment is to be put forward at all it ought certainly contain the three or four last lines of it. What is the meaning of it? The price at which a commodity can be obtained from manufacturers outside Saorstát Eireann, and the general reasons which are explanatory of the higher price in Saorstát Eireann. We can very well imagine what the general reasons would be. The first would be that these goods are produced on the Continent, or in Great Britain, on a large scale, and that being so they can be produced cheaper. That would be the main, general reason, and then the lower wages that are being paid, say, in England or in Czecho-Slovakia, if it came to the question of boots—lower wages and less costs of production. I repeat again that public servants would be employed, and a very efficient commission would be established for the purpose of saying, as a result of every investigation into prices, that our prices are high here because we have not mass production, because the labourers are overpaid, and because the conditions of employment are against the cheap production of commodities. This is an amendment that I certainly will not support.

Comment on this

I think it has been stated by the mover of the amendment that he would be prepared to move only the first part of it. I would like to know if I am correct in that?

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

He said that he was quite prepared to stop at the words "Saorstát Eireann."

Comment on this

The Minister objects to the latter part of it, and there are some Senators who do not like the first part. Therefore, there is no inducement to me to meet them. I am quite prepared to leave the matter to the House. On the whole, I prefer the amendment as it stands.

Comment on this

The section as it stands requires the Commission to examine into the matters set out in the amendment in so far as they affect its business. In so far as it would involve an investigation which the Commission might not otherwise undertake, it means a new investigation and the piling on of work to the Commission. It would lead to complications in certain cases in so far as the Commission was not able to carry out the functions proposed to be conferred on it by the amendment.

I think the amendment should not be inserted in the Bill. Its object is to try to get the Commission to do a kind of work different from that intended: that is, to carry out a sort of general investigation into tariffs and the effect of tariffs, and the difference between the efficiency of industry here and the efficiency of industry in other countries. The Commission has not been established to do that. The Commission should not necessarily have regard to the prices prevailing for similar commodities in other countries except in so far as it is necessary for it to do so to enable it to publish a valuable report on the single question whether or not the prices prevailing here are unreasonably high.

Comment on this

If the principle of the amendment is accepted we can consider the question of altering it later. I think it is quite possible that if the House does accept it, it might be made a little less mandatory on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

The first part of the amendment is the important part and the difficulties in connection with that have, I think, been very much exaggerated. Suppose that the amendment stopped at the word "commodity" in the third line. The remainder of the amendment, if adopted, might involve the Commission in a good deal of work, but the task of the Commission even in connection with that part of it would be much easier, I think, than some of the other things it will be obliged to deal with under the Bill.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 18
·
Níl 10
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?