We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Private Business. - Land Bill, 1933—Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–220 of 430. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1933
Enacted

No. 33 of 1933 ›

I move amendment No. 1:—

Section 2. Between lines 32 and 33 to insert the following:—

the expression "tenanted land" means land held in fee simple or land held under any contract of tenancy other than a letting for the purpose of temporary depasturage, agistment or conacre, or for temporary convenience, or to meet a temporary necessity, provided that such land is used by the owner or tenant thereof (as the case may be) as an ordinary farm in accordance with proper methods of husbandary.

The expression "tenanted land" is defined by Section 73, sub-section 2, of the 1923 Land Act as follows:—

The expression "tenanted land" means land held under any contract of tenancy other than a fee farm grant, or lease renewable for ever or lives or years or lease for a term of years of which 60 or more are unexpired at the date of the passing of this Act, or a letting for the purpose of temporary depasturage, agistment, or conacre, or for temporary convenience, or to meet a temporary necessity, and the expression "untenanted land" shall be construed accordingly.

In that definition, the expression "tenanted land" would not include land held in fee simple, and my main object in putting forward this amendment is to include such land in the expression "tenanted land." I cannot conceive any greater title to land by anybody than the title of land held in fee simple. What better title could a man have to his land? As the Bill stands at present a tenant farmer with seven acres, 15 acres, 40 acres or any quantity of land in fee simple might only have a complement of land which would be an economic holding. If that land is acquired by the Land Commission the owner will not be entitled to any of the privileges or considerations given to a tenant paying an annuity. I think that is grossly unfair. Furthermore, if such a holding is acquired by the Land Commission, even although it may be only just an economic holding, the Land Commission need not give the man who owns it anything except the market value of the land, whereas if they take the land of his neighbour, land that is being worked in precisely the same way as the land held in fee simple, under this or previous Acts for the relief of congestion or for any of the other purposes set out in the Bill, the Land Commission must give him—in fact he can demand it—a farm in return of not less value than the one that he holds. The Land Commission must do that simply because such a man is paying an annuity. I think there should be no objection to having my amendment inserted in the Bill.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Acting Minister for Lands and Fisheries (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

Senator Counihan's amendment is much more far-reaching than the Senator has stated. His amendment, if accepted, would completely change the definition of tenanted and untenanted land. It would mean that persons who hold their land in fee simple would have their farms purchased by the Land Commission and resold to them. The Land Purchase Acts were designed for the purchase of tenanted land and to facilitate tenants by reselling to them. If this amendment were passed the Land Commission would be compelled to purchase farms from ordinary farmers and resell them. That would involve the utilisation of State funds and State resources for making very large capital advances to people who are already well-off. I do not think there is any reason for the amendment.

Comment on this

The point that the Minister has made is that if a man holds his land in fee simple he is not entitled to any consideration. I know hundreds of farms in several parts of the country that were purchased under the 1923 Act and previous Acts and they are very much larger than many fee simple holdings. I contend that, where the Land Commission buy fee simple land, so long as it is worked as an ordinary farm in accordance with the ordinary methods of husbandry, the owner of it is entitled to the same consideration as the man with 300, 400 or 500 acres that he has purchased under the Land Acts and that a man should not be penalised simply because he has bought his land and owns it in fee.

Comment on this

I have some sympathy with the point of view that has been expressed by Senator Counihan that what is proposed here is putting, so to speak, an embargo on one particular class of land holder. I suggest that somewhere in the Bill there should be a maximum of, say, 200 acres which cannot be taken from anybody for any purpose except in a most extreme case. I would also like to see a provision in the Bill protecting homestead land: that where a man had a certain small quantity of land with his home on it he could not be evicted from it under any circumstances except, perhaps, for the payment of rates. I think that even in the case of shop and other debts a man should not be liable to disturbance in the case of homestead land. There are Homestead Acts in operation in America and in other countries. Their provisions vary sometimes in the case of different States. Under these Acts a man cannot be sold out completely so as to beggar him forever.

Comment on this

The Minister's objection to the inclusion of fee-simple land is because the State would have to purchase it from the owner. Senator Counihan's amendment is not designed to meet the case of the fee-simple owner of grass lands. The Senator has in mind the fee-simple owner of land that is tilled and worked in accordance with the ordinary methods of husbandry. He contends that the owner of such fee-simple land should have the same rights as his neighbour who is paying an annuity. The distinction about these two classes of land is really a paper one. Tenanted land is any land held under a contract of tenancy, and all other land is described as untenanted land. That distinction was made for certain reasons. There is no such thing now as tenanted land in the sense that that expression was understood when earlier Land Acts were being passed. If the owner of a particular parcel of land had the good fortune to buy the fee-simple of his holding out of his earnings, well, that is nothing to the State and why should he be penalised for it. I think it is unfair to penalise a man who invested his savings in that particular class of holding, who paid off the debts due on it and became the owner-in-fee: that he should be considered in the same way as the man who is paying an annuity and is a tenant of the State. I am not pleading for those who have very large holdings of untenanted land. This amendment deals with those who are working their farms according to the ordinary methods of husbandry in the same way as any tenant farmer works his holding. Perhaps the Minister would be willing to accept the principle of the amendment and introduce on Report Stage an amendment that would carry out the idea Senator Counihan has in mind.

Comment on this

I do not think this amendment goes the right way to do what Senator Counihan wants. Without saying anything on the merits of the matter, I merely want to make a suggestion as to how this could be carried out, not by way of definition, in which it certainly could not be carried out, but rather, I think, by way of amendment to sub-section (1) of Section 29. That is the section and sub-section which give protection to tenant purchasers. They give protection to those people who hold land which is defined in one of the sections of the Act of 1923, and which, for practical purposes, means lands purchased under the Land Purchase Acts. If you extend that to include holdings in fee-simple under a certain acreage, the land being used in the ordinary and proper manner, that would be the only way of achieving what is desired, consistently with the rest of the Bill. If Senator Counihan wants to pursue this he should withdraw the present amendment and put down an amendment to Section 29, sub-section 1.

Comment on this

The criterion of acreage would not be a proper criterion. You must go on either valuation or value.

Comment on this

The better procedure would be to have this amendment carried now, when we would probably have a better opportunity of getting an amendment from the Minister on Report Stage. This amendment could then be withdrawn.

Comment on this

That would not be a proper way of dealing with the matter.

Comment on this

Before this amendment is put, I suggest to the Minister that he should consider the position of those who have redeemed their purchase annuities and who now hold in fee simple. These people have, in fact, been through the Land Purchase Acts and now hold in fee. They have a very strong case and I find it hard to believe that the Minister will not consider it very sympathetically.

Comment on this

With regard to what Senator Sir John Keane has said, all purchased lands, whether the annuity has been redeemed or not, are covered by Section 29. If Senator Counihan wants to give land held in fee the same terms as purchased land by means of this amendment, it would mean that the Land Commission would have to purchase land held in fee so that it would become "purchased land."

Comment on this

Not if you amend Section 29 (1).

Comment on this

If the Senator wants to achieve his purpose by means of this amendment, it would mean that the land would have to be purchased so that it would become "purchased land."

Comment on this

I agree. That is the objection to this amendment.

Comment on this

I ask leave to withdraw the amendment. I shall put in another amendment for Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment 2:—

Section 2. Between the lines 32 and 33 to insert the following:—

"the expression ‘market value' means the price which a willing purchaser would pay for a holding in the open market in normal times."

In putting down this amendment, I am quite conscious that "market value" is very difficult to define. The Attorney-General gave a definition of "market value" in the Dáil. This amendment is practically on the same lines as the Attorney-General's definition, with the exception that I have added the words "normal times." If the Attorney-General's definition could be construed as meaning that market value would be the value which land was worth in the open market at the present time, or at the time of acquisition by the Land Commission, I do not think it would be quite fair, because at present there is no such thing as market value for land. If I were asked to define "normal times," my definition would be: "When prices for commodities operate in the ordinary way on the recognised principles of supply and demand which are not influenced by economic wars or other wars of any class or any abnormal happenings." If I were asked to name a period which would represent normal times, I should say any date ten years previous to 1914. From 1904 to 1914 I should describe as normal times. If the Minister is prepared to make a reasonable suggestion as to market value and as to what "normal times" should represent, I shall also withdraw this amendment. We are not in normal times now and there is no market value for land. However, we hope to get back to normal times some time and, for that reason, I think the Minister should accept this or some similar amendment.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Counihan that these are not normal times and that there is considerable difficulty at present in ascertaining what the market value of land is. I suggest to the House that this amendment, as phrased, does not carry out the idea expressed by Senator Counihan (Amendment quoted). So far as I know, the purchaser is always a "willing purchaser." I think that there must be some mistake there.

Comment on this

The Attorney-General gave that definition.

Comment on this

Perhaps you misunderstood him. The expression "market value" means the price which a purchaser would pay for a holding on a free sale by a willing vendor in the open market. It is the vendor who has the goodwill, not the purchaser. Probably Senator Counihan misapprehended what was said in the Dáil. So far as my experience goes, the purchaser is always a willing purchaser but the vendor need not always be a willing vendor. There is probably some oversight there.

Comment on this

So far as I remember, I have taken the Attorney-General's definition.

Comment on this

You have mistaken the word "purchaser" for the word "vendor." That is, at all events, what the Attorney-General meant because the goodwill is the vendor's goodwill. I have often heard of a willing vendor and of an unwilling vendor where there was a forced sale, but I never heard of any distinction between purchasers as to willingness and unwillingness. An unwilling purchaser is not known except he be the man who makes a bargain and wants to get out of it, in which case there is a suit for specific performance and he is compelled to perform. I think that this amendment ought to be altered if there is a vote to be taken upon it.

Comment on this

I followed the Attorney-General's statement.

Comment on this

I suggest that the amendment ought to be changed to say "which a purchaser would pay for a holding on a free sale by a willing vendor in the open market in normal times."

Comment on this

I am agreeable, and I ask the House to agree to the alteration suggested.

Comment on this

I do not think Senator Counihan or Senator Comyn defined what "normal times" are. The expression "market value" has been used in the Land Purchase Acts before. It is not a new expression. The Land Commission have been dealing with it for many years. As far as I remember the definition given by the Attorney-General in the Dáil of "market value" was the price which the purchaser would give in a free sale by a willing vendor.

Comment on this

In normal times?

Comment on this

I do not know what normal times are.

Comment on this

That is the crux.

Comment on this

They will never be normal again!

Comment on this

If normal times are what the world has been up to now, I hope the world will be normally abnormal in a few years; that there will be a state of affairs reached when the people who produce things for the community will be able to get what covers costs, and that the purchaser will be able to give them their costs. I do not know how you are going to describe in legal language what normal times are.

Comment on this

Will the Minister accept the dates I gave?

Comment on this

I will not. I do not believe the world was very rosy then. Between 1904 and 1914 there was a lot of starvation in this and in other countries.

Comment on this

It is the price of land we are talking about.

Comment on this

If it is left to the Land Commission they will do their work as well as they did it before. They have interpreted market value more or less on the lines of the definition I have given.

Comment on this

What has fallen from Senator Comyn and the Minister shows the enormous difficulty of this definition. I am not sure that it would be a wise thing to define market value in this Bill. The Minister told us that the Land Commission had already adopted a method for arriving at the market value under previous Acts. Whether that will be a satisfactory solution of the working of market value under this Bill or not I do not know. I understand by market value that it implies certain things; it implies a willing vendor and a willing purchaser. It implies a real market; that is, an open market, and that there is competition in that open market. If the Land Commission do their work honestly in ascertaining the market value of farms they take under the Bill, and we cannot assume that they are going to do anything else but honestly administer this Bill, they will have to fix the market value in relation to matters which that implies. If that interpretation of market value is put into the Bill I will certainly be absolutely satisfied. I should be very glad if the Minister could give an undertaking that that is his view.

Comment on this

I would accept Senator Brown's definition absolutely.

Comment on this

This is one of the sections that involve the greatest hardship under the Bill. The market value at present is what it is owing to the depressed state of agriculture, as a result of the direct action of the Government. That is why I stated on the Second Reading that this was not a proper time to bring in a Land Bill at all, because times are wholly abnormal. Take the case of a man who could have sold a farm five years ago. The market value would be entirely different from what it is now. We can judge market value when we see valuable farms put up for sale every day, for which there is no offer, or else an offer which nobody in his senses could accept. I have seen farms put up for sale which three years ago would be worth £2,000 in the open market, but £500 could not be got for them to-day. No one would take a present of them because there is no market for land. How could the market value be fixed when there is no market there? This is one of the most important matters in the Bill, one which will make for the greatest hardship on farmers whose lands will be taken. Take the case of a person, of whom there are many in the country, who bought land which was in a bad state, undrained, without proper fences, which was a wilderness and which was made into good land. Will that be taken into consideration when the market value is being fixed? We have no assurance that the market value will be anything except what the place if put up for sale at present would fetch and that is no value.

Something will have to be done, or great injustice will be perpetrated on unfortunate people under this Section. I leave it to some one else to find a way out. This is one of the most iniquitous things ever proposed by any Government, to take land at present, and, if you like to use the word, to confiscate it, or to take it by force, from the present owners. The value might be fixed five years ago, or at the period suggested by Senator Counihan. I do not think this Bill should pass from this House until this matter is settled.

Comment on this

I am ready to admit that the Land Commission has long experience, and will probably deal as justly as circumstances permit with cases of this sort. I want to know if there will be advertence by the Land Commission to the amount of money due to the State by tenant owners in the way of land purchase annuities? That may work out very harshly in connection with the 1903 Act, because the capital sum was very high then and there will always be a large sum due by the tenants. Will that be taken from the market value when the owner is being paid?

Comment on this

That is future annuities.

Comment on this

The rate of interest is higher now.

Comment on this

A great many of the tenants purchased under the 1903 Act. Money was very cheap at that time and as there was a reduction in the rent the capital sum which the landlord got was exceedingly high, compared with what he would get to-day. Under the 1903 Act he got 15 times his rent and there was a 12 per cent. contribution by the State. Under the 1903 Act money could be had at £2 15s. per cent. and, as a result, there is a considerable amount due to the State for farms bought under that Act. When assessing the market value will the Land Commission have advertence to that when paying compensation?

Comment on this

I hope that this is not a Party question, because it is a very serious one for a great number of farmers. During the war period people went land-mad and purchased at very high prices. Money was easily obtained from the banks on the security of the purchasers and their neighbours. When the price of land went down it was impossible for these people to meet their liabilities to the banks. They were hoping against hope for better times. Things have not improved but have gone from bad to worse. Numbers of people are in the position to-day that they purchased land at a high figure, that it is partly paid for, and the balance is owing to the banks. If that land was taken at to-day's market value it would simply mean that the owners and their families were ruined for all time. I hope the Minister will look into this matter on broad lines and will try to do justice to everyone. It is a question of honest dealing with people who are in a very bad way.

Comment on this

I could understand certain members of the Opposition having sympathy for people whose land will be taken and who are worrying whether they will get enough for it or not, but I cannot understand two sensible men bringing in such an amendment. I have a fair idea of what Senator Counihan means by "normal times," and I am optimistic enough to think that Senator Wilson will hardly agree with him. Is it suggested that we should go back to war times?

Comment on this

I suggested 1904-1914 which were not war times.

Comment on this

That is a long time ago. I fail to see the necessity to go back to that time. If we were to go back to the ten years period of "prosperity" that we heard so much about, when land values were steadily falling, it would be just as ridiculous. What we should consider under this Bill is, what effect such an amendment would have on the future of this country. Without dragging in Party politics we know that the action of the Government here had absolutely nothing whatever to do with the position of the farmers in England. We know that the farmers in England to-day are in just as bad a position as the farmers here. I will read an extract from the Farmer and Stock Breeder.

Comment on this

Are we going to have a discussion now on the economic war?

Comment on this

The Senator does not want that.

Comment on this

If we are going to have a discussion on the economic war I am quite willing.

Comment on this

It is a great thing to see Senator Counihan objecting to a discussion on the economic war, a thing that he has argued out on all occasions. The reason he is objecting now is because he knows the discussion would be against himself.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

I must ask Senators to keep to the amendment.

Comment on this

We only want to get out the truth. I do not object to any discussion on the economic war.

Comment on this

You got enough of it already and I think it is an outrage to have you objecting to bringing in the economic war in this discussion. The cutting I have to read is from the Farmer and Stock Breeder. It is under the heading of “Decline in Fat Stock Prices. N.F.U. to Continue to Impress on Minister the Need for Fresh Action,” and reads:

"A number of County branches wrote to the Livestock Committee of the N.F.U. Council complaining of the unsatisfactory position of fat stock prices and of the failure of the import restrictions to bring about an improvement."

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

I do not think, Senator, that has anything to do with the value of land in Ireland.

Comment on this

I am sorry if I am out of order, but I am trying to explain that the prices of cattle in England have fallen considerably and that the action of the Government in this country, as alleged, has no connection with the fall in prices at all.

Comment on this

They are getting over £4 a head more than we are getting here for our cattle. There is no question about that.

Comment on this

We must consider this Bill and the amendment before us in regard to what effect it would have on this country if the land of this country is to be purchased for division amongst uneconomic holders and landless men. If the price of land is based on the price paid a number of years back we would put the people of this country who are being given this land into an impossible position. A farm must be an economic proposition and if farms are to be an economic proposition for the uneconomic holders and the landless men they must be purchased on the present value. We have been told that the present value of this land is nothing. I hope some of the Senators here will talk their neighbours into that line and, if so, the farms that will be taken over under this Bill will be very desirable propositions, and we will have a very prosperous country in a few years' time.

Comment on this

It is quite easy to understand and appreciate now what the meaning of the economic war was. That war was started for one specific purpose and that specific purpose is standing out a mile and a quarter. It was for the purpose of freezing down the land to an absolute nullity, to bring it to a state where it would be of no value and then our new Government will go in and take over that land on the Cromwellian principle of paying no price for it.

Comment on this

That is quite true.

Comment on this

I did not intend to intervene on this question as to what is the "market value" of land until Senator Fanning got up to tell us what this "market value" is. The Senator has one idea and, like everyone of his mentality, he has followed that idea. He has followed that idea like every member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party has done. He is filled up with materialism, pure, unadulterated materialism—their own personal gain.

Comment on this

Just listen to that from the man who is speaking.

Comment on this

We have that demonstrated now from Senator Fanning, who is so full of it himself that he thinks everyone else is full of it too.

Comment on this

Except the Senator who is speaking.

Comment on this

I have as much land as any member of this House has. I am a member of the Government Party and I stand for the Government in their internal and external policy. As a member of the Government Party I say that it was never the intention of the present Government to confiscate land, or to injure the financial position of any landowner, big or small. If lands are being taken up in the near or distant future under the régime of the present Government, fair compensation will be paid. I think that was explained time after time and day after day in the long drawn-out debates in the Dáil recently. Surely to goodness Senator Fanning's outburst that the economic war was purely and solely for the purpose of pushing down the price of land is a thing that everybody——

Comment on this

There can be no question about it. That was the specific reason for the economic war.

Comment on this

You have no land to lose anything by and you need not talk about it.

Comment on this

People belonging to me have more land than you ever had.

Comment on this

The publicans put you in here, but you did not stick to them; you let them down.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

The Senator must not use that sort of language. Personal abuse is no argument.

Comment on this

I can answer anything he has to say.

Comment on this

The publicans will tell you what they think of you when you go back to them. In any case, the "market value" is a very elusive term as such and people would not be well advised to take on themselves to explain what "market value" means, because "market value" in one part of the country is not "market value" in another part of the country. Some members here have been telling us where a 500 acre farm cost £7,000 a few years ago.

Comment on this

Only five years ago I said.

Comment on this

Well, supposing that farm was bought for any specified number of pounds, will people explain to me why a 50-acre farm in the West of Ireland will go four times more at the present time than a 200-acre farm in Meath? Why is that so? What is the meaning of "market value" then? Does not a thing like that demonstrate the fallacy of going on with such an amendment? Does it not demonstrate that the Land Commission, knowing all those facts, are the best judges? They know the business thoroughly because they have had years of experience. Surely the duty devolves upon them to act as judges in this matter and the public must abide by their decisions.

Comment on this

Senator Brown seemed to advance a very clear definition of market value, and it was accepted by the Minister. I presume that meant an undertaking that that basis would be acceptable by the Land Commission in the working of this measure. In the circumstances, is there any use in going on with this discussion, and introducing personal abuse, when the matter is virtually agreed?

Comment on this

I have endeavoured to debate the amendments in a commonsense manner from the point of view of the effect on farmers, and not from the point of view of Party politics, like some of the Senators who have spoken. I do not want to touch on the economic war or to comment upon the Government's object in bringing forward this Bill. I am anxious to get as many reasonable concessions as I can from the Minister. I do not think I would get anything if I adopted the attitude which is adopted by Senators on the other side. Apparently they are anxious for an acrimonious debate such as took place in the Dáil. I am certain the Seanad does not want to conduct its proceedings in the manner desired at least by some Senators. Senators Quirke and MacEllin are desirous of referring to political matters, to their political side of the question. They seem to have no consideration at all for anybody else. Judging by Senator Quirke's remarks, if a man owns more than an economic holding he should get no consideration at all; the land should be taken from him at the present market price. I think the Senator mentioned that the present market price might be too much.

Comment on this

The Senator is absolutely wrong. I hold more land than would be considered an economic holding, and I never made the statement the Senator has attributed to me.

Comment on this

The fact is there is no market value at the present moment, and if the economic war continues there will be no market value. I want to safeguard people during the period when there will be no market value. I am satisfied to withdraw the amendment and to bring forward an amendment on the Report Stage, on the lines suggested by Senator Comyn.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

I am sure the Senator heard what the Minister said.

Comment on this

Yes, but it is not in the Bill.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

It will be in the records.

Comment on this

I do not think the Commissioners will mind what is in the records; they just take what is in the Bill.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 3:—

Section 6, sub-section (1). To add at the end of the sub-section a new paragraph as follows:—

(g) the determination whether or not a holding has been used by the tenant thereof as an ordinary farm in accordance with proper methods of husbandry.

By inserting this amendment you will take from the Minister the power of interfering with the decision of the Land Commissioners in regard to the report of an inspector as to whether or not a farmer is working his land in accordance with proper methods of husbandry. An inspector may visit a farm and tell the farmer he is not working the land in accordance with ordinary methods of husbandry. He may tell him he should have grown more wheat, beet, cabbage or tobacco, or some other crop in respect of which he might not have a fad. That report might be submitted to the Minister. Although the Land Commissioners may disagree with the report the Minister, who may also be a faddist about some particular crop, may say "You are not working your land in accordance with proper methods of husbandry and, consequently, I will rule against you." I do not want to say anything against any of the officers of the Land Commission. The majority of them are honest, straight-forward men, but there are some of them who know absolutely nothing about farming. Those men may contend that a farm is not being properly worked, and they will endeavour to show the commonsense, practical farmer how best to cultivate his holding.

Comment on this

In my opinion there is really no necessity for the amendment, because in Section 6 (1) (a) the whole thing is clearly set out. The determination of the persons from whom land is to be resumed or acquired is an excepted matter, as is also the determination of the actual lands to be acquired or resumed. If the Senator wants to press the amendment I am prepared to accept it, but I believe its object is already covered. I accepted (b) in the Dáil, although I believe that the subject-matter was already covered. However, if the Senator wants to press his amendment I am prepared to accept it, although I believe it is so much verbiage and there is no necessity for it.

Comment on this

I do not think it would do any harm to put it in, but, on the other hand, I am quite prepared to accept the Minister's assurance.

Comment on this

If Senator Counihan thinks this amendment will do no harm, I may say I am of a different opinion. I think the effect of the amendment would be to make this a question to be answered in all cases. Where a holding has been used by the tenant as an ordinary farm in accordance with proper methods of husbandry, the commissioner will have to answer that as a specific question. Under the Bill what he has to do is to determine the actual land to be acquired or resumed without giving any of the various reasons which have actuated him in coming to that conclusion. Of course, if the Minister is prepared to accept the amendment, I think Senator Counihan ought to reconsider whether he will press it.

Comment on this

In one of the clauses is it not specifically set out that land can be acquired if it is not worked in an ordinary manner and in accordance with ordinary methods of husbandry? Who is going to decide whether the land has been worked in accordance with ordinary methods of husbandry if we do not get the inspector or the Land Commissioner?

Comment on this

And he decides it under Section 6 (1) (a). He is more free there than he would be if this amendment were to be inserted in the Bill.

Comment on this

I ask leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 4:—

Section 6, sub-section (3). To delete paragraph (a) and to substitute therefor a new paragraph as follows:—

(a) an appeal shall lie both on the question of law and on the question of fact from the determination of an excepted matter to the appeal tribunal, and

I consider this amendment, if accepted, will make a very important difference in the Bill. The amendment would prove to be one of the most important for the safeguarding of the tenant's rights and independence. In my speech on the Second Reading I said that the excepted matters were mere eyewash. Unless this amendment is accepted I still contend that the excepted matters are all eyewash, and that we are setting up, in the person of the Minister for Lands and Fisheries for the time being under this Bill, a dictator over the farmers throughout the Free State. I still hold to that statement. Many sections of this Bill make the Minister a complete dictator. He has absolute and complete powers under Sections 5 and 6, and, also, under other sections, including Section 31. I need not read these sections. Let us consider what is the meaning of having an appeal on excepted matters to the appeal tribunal. Take the first one, the determination of the person from whom land is to be acquired or resumed. That is an excepted matter. The Minister cannot interfere as to the person from whom the land is to be acquired or resumed; the Land Commissioners are to have complete jurisdiction there. But the Minister takes, under the Bill, complete power over the Land Commissioners and other officers of his Department. We all know that political influence will compel the Minister to exercise his powers. No matter how determined they may be to stand upon their own judgment he will occasionally get round the Land Commissioners in another way. Under the old system there was an appeal, on all matters, to the judicial commissioner. In this Bill that is all swept away and we have only now an appeal on questions of law or on questions of price to the appeal tribunal. The procedure under this Bill will possibly be that the inspector will make a report on certain farms that are to be acquired. The Land Commissioners will examine that report. If they agree with the report that the land is to be acquired, they will notify the farmer that certain portions of his land are to be acquired. The only redress he will have in stopping the acquisition of this land would be to send a memorial to the Land Commissioners asking them to reconsider their decision; to pray that they would take into account that he is a man working his land in the ordinary way, and that he wants it for his own purposes. If, on reconsideration of that memorial, the Land Commissioners decide that this man has still to lose his land, he is finished so far as having any effect in stopping the acquirement of his land is concerned; and the only thing left is an appeal to the appeal tribunal on a question of price or of law. I do not think I am asking too much in trying to secure that in connection with any decision in a case of this kind, the farmer should have the right of appeal from the decision of the Land Commissioners to the appeal tribunal.

The usual practice heretofore was that the farmer had a right to go before the judicial commissioner who examined him, on oath, as to what use he was making of his land. He examined him as to the employment he gave, as to the number of his family, and as to all the circumstances pertaining to the acquisition of that holding before he gave a decision that it was to be acquired. All that is swept away by this Bill. The complete independence of the farmer is swept away, and he has no redress except what the Minister will instruct the Land Commissioners to do. I do not want to make political capital out of the influence that may be brought to bear upon the Minister, but I would very earnestly appeal to the Minister to accept my amendment. If that amendment is accepted and another further down on the Paper, it will alter my attitude towards the Bill and the attitude of those who may support me in this House. These two amendments are I think vital, if the farmer is to retain any independence or security in his holding.

Comment on this

Senator Counihan seems to have led himself astray, and has led the House astray as to the effect of his amendment. He said that heretofore there has been an appeal to the judicial commissioner on all matters. That is not so.

Comment on this

On all matters of acquisition.

Comment on this

The Senator said definitely that there was an appeal to the judicial commissioner on all matters.

Comment on this

On the acquisition of land.

Comment on this

What we are doing under this paragraph 3 (a) is we are giving the same appeal to the appeal tribunal which lay to the judicial commissioner. Any appeal which lay to the judicial commissioner can now go to the appeal tribunal. That is all there is in this clause which the Senator proposes to delete. Any appeal that might be made by law from determination on excepted matter shall now go to the appeal tribunal. The appeal before was to the judicial commissioner. As there are now to be two lay commissioners with the judicial commissioner forming the tribunal we have to change the law from what it was and say that the appeal now lies to the appeal tribunal.

Comment on this

What is the objection to accepting my amendment?

Comment on this

The objections are various and many. I shall explain a couple of them. Usually when land is to be allotted about ten people apply where only one can get it eventually. If the amendment went through, there would be an appeal to the appeal tribunal in the case of every person who got land on the ground that he was not the right person to get it. Then every rejected person would have an appeal to the tribunal and it would be absolutely impossible to work the Land Purchase Acts. What we are trying to do is to remove some of the insuperable snags that we found in practice arising out of the previous Land Purchase Acts. The amendment would completely upset land purchase and we do not propose to accept it.

Comment on this

Some of us are not as familiar with the Land Acts as the Minister. Would he tell us specifically on what matters an appeal does lie? I think that would be more satisfactory to the House than to be told of cases where an appeal would obviously be undesirable. Surely an appeal should lie under (a) the determination of the persons from whom the land is to be acquired or resumed. Will he say whether an appeal lies under that? Does an appeal lie under (b) the determination of the actual lands to be acquired? I know an appeal lies under (c) the determination of the price. Perhaps it is undesirable that an appeal should lie under (d) the determination of the persons to be selected as allottees of untenanted land, or under (e) the determination of the price at which land is to be sold to any such allottee. I certainly think that an appeal should be allowed under (f) the determination of the new holding which is to be provided for a tenant or proprietor whose holding has been acquired by the Land Commission.

I would ask the Minister to appreciate that this Bill breaks fresh ground. The landlords in the past were men of substance whose livelihood was not in the land and it was not so great a personal injustice to take the land from them as it would be to take land from a man whose sole livelihood is in the land. I think men whose sole livelihood is in their land are entitled to very full legal protection. I wish the Minister would deal with that point of view. I am sure he does appreciate that this Bill is in a different category to previous Land Acts and I think he ought to be able to say specifically what are the matters on which an appeal lies to the appeal tribunal after the Bill becomes law.

Comment on this

I have a list of about six pages of typescript of the matters on which an appeal does lie. I will read some of them and the Senator can stop me if he gets tired. I—The inclusion or non-inclusion of land in a provisional list of lands situated in a congested districts county or lands situated in a non-congested districts county which the Land Commission declare are required for the relief of congestion; (b) application by an owner of lands subject to land purchase annuity and which the Land Commission declare to be required for the relief of congestion who is dissatisfied with the Land Commission offer of an alternative holding which the Land Commission consider equally suitable and of not less value than the declared lands (Section 24 (4) (b), L.A. 1923), or an appeal on the grounds that there are other unacquired lands in the same locality suitable for relieving congestion which do not come within the exceptions mentioned in Section 24 (2); (c) price of untenanted land. II— Application under Section 44 that lands held under fee farm grants or long leases shall vest in the Land Commission as tenanted land. III— Tenanted Land—(a) Amendment of a list of vested holdings published under the provisions of Section 9 of the Land Act, 1931 (Section 10, L.A. 1931); (b) dismissal of proceedings where lands have been included in a list of vested holdings (Section 13, L.A. 1931); (c) omission of a holding from list of vested holdings (Section 14, L.A. 1931); (d) objection to vesting order published under Section 12, L.A. 1931; (e) declaration that a sub-tenancy be treated as a separate tenancy and apportioning rent or that a sub-tenancy is not suitable to be dealt with as a separate holding (Section 15, L.L.C. 1903, Section 26, L.A. 1923, Section 15, L.A. 1931); (f) division and apportionment of rent in the case of a holding held by joint tenants or tenants in common or which is sub-divided between two or more persons and so forth.

Comment on this

That is sufficient.

Comment on this

In every matter on which appeals to the judicial commissioner have been provided for under the Land Acts, we are providing that these appeals will be heard by the appeal tribunal instead of by the judicial commissioner. There are certain matters which were always finally determined by the Land Commission, and it would completely obstruct the work of the Land Commission if these matters were not to be determined by the Land Commission in future and if an appeal were to lie on every fiddle-faddle that comes before them.

Comment on this

Is there to be an appeal under Section 6 paragraph (a) —the determination of the persons from whom the land is to be acquired or resumed?

Comment on this

There is.

Comment on this

It appears from what the Minister has said that there is an appeal under paragraph (b), which is the same thing—the determination of the actual lands to be acquired. If that is so, then ipso facto there is an appeal under paragraph (a)—the determination of the persons from whom the land is to be acquired.

Comment on this

I am asking the Minister to answer, not the Senator.

Comment on this

Paragraphs (d) and (e) are not subject to an appeal to the tribunal, but (a), (b) and (c) are covered by appeals of one sort or another to the judicial commissioner heretofore and now to the appeal tribunal.

Comment on this

The four questions covered by (a), (b), (c) and (f) are subject to appeal?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I shall withdraw my amendment and shall prepare other amendments to put that definitely in the Bill.

Comment on this

I was out of the Chamber when the Minister spoke and I want to be quite clear as to the construction of sub-section (3). It is rather loosely worded but I think on the whole it is clear that any appeal which may lie on the determination of an excepted matter, would be to the appeal tribunal. There are a number of matters which were the subject of appeal under previous Acts to the judicial commissioner. They will now go to the appeal tribunal which is the judicial commissioner plus two lay colleagues. Will there be included amongst the matters on which the right of appeal is given, any matter on which the right of appeal is now given to the judicial commissioner? The only question of fact on which there is an appeal, as far as I can make out, are questions of value. I may be wrong in that and if so I would like to be corrected by the Minister.

Comment on this

The Bill does not repeal a right of appeal which is given under previous Acts.

Comment on this

We are setting up under this Bill a new tribunal and substituting it for the judicial commissioner. Any appeals that lay heretofore to the judicial commissioner will now lie to this new appeal tribunal. There are certain appeals under these excepted matters which instead of going before the judicial commissioner will go before the appeal tribunal. If there is a question of law to be decided by the appeal tribunal, it will be determined by the judicial commissioner. If there are questions of fact or of value to be determined they will be determined by the majority of the tribunal.

Comment on this

Then there are questions of fact, questions under the excepted matters besides the question of value, which will go to the appeal tribunal?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied.

Comment on this

(a), (b), (c), and (f) all go before the appeal tribunal, if there is an appeal.

Comment on this

I move amendment 5:

Section 7, sub-section (2). To add at the end of the sub-section the words "and the first lay commissioners so appointed shall both have been officers of the Land Commission prior to the 1st day of June, 1933."

The feeling amongst the public with regard to the lay commissioners is that some persons may be appointed who would be, as they have been termed, "Party hacks." This amendment, if accepted, will save the Minister from a lot of wire-pulling and give him an opportunity of appointing the best and most suitable men to these positions which are very important ones. I do not say that if the Minister was left to himself he would not appoint proper and correct persons. We all know, however, how appointments are made, particularly political appointments— that every political element in the country will be pulling for its own particular candidates. For that reason, the Minister should accept the amendment and thus create confidence that the men appointed will not be appointed for political reasons but as being the best men for the positions within the Land Commission. I think the Minister said in the Dáil that he did intend to appoint to these positions men of experience in the Land Commission—with experience of Land Commission work, at all events. If that is so, I think he will accept the amendment. It is not restricting his power very much. It is only confining him to officers of the Land Commission—a class from which the commissioners ought to be appointed.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister has shown any disposition to yield to political pressure in the appointments which he has made or which he proposes to make in the Land Commission. I saw the other day, not in the Land Commission offices, but in the hands of a prospective candidate for a position, the rules and regulations provided for the appointment of commissioners, inspectors and engineers under the Land Commission. I was glad to see in these regulations that special consideration will be given to persons who have qualifications in respect of engineering, in respect of the constituents of soil and of the character of land. Special regard is to be had to any degrees which people have obtained in the science of agriculture. That is an innovation. It shows that the Minister is not disposed to yield to political pressure. This amendment means that you cannot trust the Minister who has shown himself to be impartial. I do not know whether the Minister intends to appoint men who are already in the Land Commission to this appeal tribunal, or whether he intends to go outside the Land Commission for one or both of the lay commissioners. I think, however, that he should be free. I think that in his conduct of the Land Commission and by his impartiality he has shown that he deserves to get a free hand in this matter and that he deserves to have the confidence of this House in the administration of it.

Comment on this

Considering the terrible amount of apprehension there is over the country about this Land Bill, why can there be any objection to an amendment like this? I am not saying that the Minister is, by any means, not to be trusted, but why not allay people's fears and apprehensions which are terribly disturbing? What is the objection? We have not all the same outlook as Senator Comyn.

Comment on this

I do not say the others were wrong but they were appointed by the other side. I think they are very good men.

Comment on this

That may be. Why object to something which will allay people's fears to a certain extent? It will be some consolation, at any rate, for the people to know that some men who are not Communists, at any rate, will be appointed. We all know that the people would regard an earthquake with less fear than they would the appointment as lay commissioners of some members of this House.

Comment on this

And quite a number on the other side.

Comment on this

There are quite a number on the other side I would trust and there are quite a number I would not trust with anything.

Comment on this

The appointment of these lay commissioners is a very important matter in the question of appeals. It is obvious that it is of importance to the person going before the appeal tribunal. It probably will affect his property and what means he will have of living after he is finished with the Land Commission. Men who are qualified for the position of land commissioner, I take it, must have some expert knowledge. The fact that they have been appointed as Land Commissioners previous to the passing of this Bill and before their services could be required on the appeal tribunal shows that they are people who must be, to a very large extent, fitted for the position. It would, as Senator Miss Browne said, allay the fears of those people who will be affected by the Bill with regard to the final determination of what is their rights. In the first instance, it is possible that a mistake may be made and the personnel of the appeal tribunal will be very important in that respect, so that if a mistake has been made in the determination in the first instance it can be set right. If this amendment is accepted a certain definition will be laid down as to the two lay commissioners to be appointed. I myself, without having inside knowledge of the Bill as drafted, cannot see why there should be any objection to accepting the amendment. I am sure that if the Minister does not see any great objection to it he will accept it. It will certainly make for a certain amount of confidence amongst the people who are going to be affected. For that reason I support the amendment and I ask the Minister to accept it.

Comment on this

Quite obviously, the fount of this amendment is distrust of the Minister. I would ask those responsible for it to realise what it means. It is confining the choice to officers of the Land Commission prior to 1st June, 1933. On the assumption that the Minister is not only a fool but a rogue, the choice of officers of the Land Commission is a very wide one. I have heard all kinds of criticism of the Land Commission because of the enormous number of subordinate officers of all kinds that they have. Within this amendment it will be quite possible for the Minister to choose some of the Communist friends that Senator Miss Browne speaks of and do the thing that Senator Miss Browne desires to prevent him from doing, so that the amendment is not going to be effective. If the Minister wants to do this evil thing, I have no doubt that he can find the evil-doers in the Land Commission if he seeks them out, because there is a large staff there and in seeking them amongst the officers of the Land Commission he is not confining the choice to those versed in the technicalities of the higher range of Land Commission work. I suggest to the Minister that he should not allow himself to be bound by this rather foolish kind of amendment which merely means that we have no confidence in the Minister's judgment, in the Minister's honesty, or in the Minister's reasonable interpretation of the Act.

Comment on this

I refused an amendment similar to this in the Dáil and, on that occasion, I pointed out that I believed that this Executive Council is just as competent to appoint land commissioners as any other Executive Council in the past.

Comment on this

Agreed.

Comment on this

The Executive Council, at the moment, have the appointment of judges, and, up to now, they have had the appointment of land commissioners. I do not see, for the life of me, why anybody might reasonably fear that the Executive Council in the future will not appoint men to the post of land commissioners or officers of the Land Commission or members of the appeal tribunal whom they can stand over in public. This amendment seeks to confine the choice to officers of the Land Commission. It has been found, however, from time to time, that officers of other Departments could be moved into the Land Commission. Three of the most senior men of the Land Commission at the moment are men of long experience in other Departments of the Government. They were put into the Land Commission because of their experience and they have done good work there. In practice from the point of view of carrying out the purpose of that amendment, I would have no objection to it, but there is a principle involved which I am not going to accept, and that is that the Executive Council is not to be entrusted with the appointment of the members of the appeal tribunal.

Comment on this

I am assuming that the Executive Council will act with commonsense and that they will not, as Senator Johnson suggests they can, appoint Bolshevists in the Land Commission. My point, however, is that the members should be taken from the Land Commission. The Minister says that the Executive Council have the authority to appoint judges, but have they the authority to go outside the legal profession and appoint anybody they like as judges? They must draw the judges from a special section of the community, and that is the legal profession. That is one of the reasons which justifies this amendment and it cannot be taken as being any slur on the Executive Council. From the Minister's own statement, they have the power to appoint judges but they cannot go outside their particular class in these appointments. All I am doing in this amendment is to say that they must draw the members of their appeal tribunal from the Land Commission and I think the Minister need not think that we have any doubt as to their ability to appoint members of the Tribunal merely because we say that they should be appointed in the same way as the judges are appointed and must be drawn from a special class.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 25
·
Níl 14
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 6:—

Section 7, sub-section (5). To delete in lines 63-64 the words "with the concurrence of one or both of the other members of the tribunal."

The object of this amendment is to reduce the appeals to the Supreme Court as to whether a question is or is not a question of law and by that means to save not only time but money and time is really the more important of the two. As the section stands, the two lay members of the appeal tribunal can over-rule the judicial member of the appeal tribunal on the question as to whether a particular matter is or is not a matter of law. It is a case of two lay men against a highly trained expert, because nobody gets to the position of judge in the High Court in this or, indeed, in any other civilised country, without being an expert on the question as to whether a question is or is not a matter of law. If the two lay members disagree with the judicial member I suggest that in the large majority of cases—I was going to say nine out of ten—they would be wrong and the judicial commissioner would be right and you would have an appeal practically in every one of those cases in which the two lay men differed from the judge, whereas if you leave it to the judicial commissioner alone to decide whether a particular question is or is not a question of law, he will be right in nine cases out of ten—I am giving those figures rather against him than in his favour—and you would have an appeal in only one case. In that way, not only money would be saved, but what is far more important in the administration of these land Acts you would save time. The appeal is to the Supreme Court.

My friend, Senator Comyn knows better than I do, because I have been so long away from the Bar, that the lists in the Supreme Court, in my recollection and I think they are pretty much the same now, are very congested, and, in fact, an Act like this would be required to relieve the congestion. That being so, if you had this large number of appeals, as you certainly would if you leave the section as it is, you would have a very long wait before you got a decision from the Supreme Court, and you would block that particular case in the Land Commission for a very long time. I suggest to the Minister that this is a reasonable amendment which he ought to accept.

Comment on this

This Appeal Tribunal is, I think, a well balanced tribunal. It has to do not ordinary legal work, and a man who might have vast experience in the ordinary body of law might know very little about the Land Purchase Acts. We propose to associate with the judicial commissioner for the time being two lay men who have a thorough knowledge of the operation of the Land Purchase Acts throughout the country and of the practical problems that face the Land Commission. I do not believe that there will be any big number of appeals against the decision of a majority of the appeal tribunal, as to whether or not a question is a matter of law. This appeal tribunal is an exact replica of the tribunal that was set up under the Railways and Canals Act in the British Parliament somewhere in the 'eighties, and there, the majority decide whether or not a question is a question of law. I think that both the two lay commissioners and the judicial commissioner will have to be very sure of their ground before they give a decision as to whether a question is or is not a question of law. It will make the judicial commissioner careful in arriving at his decision on such a point because there will be an appeal against his decision sitting in the Land Commission just as there would be an appeal against his decision if he were sitting in the High Court.

Legal gentlemen are themselves subject to the same disabilities as other men. Men might be very practical and reasonable men going on the bench, but after a number of years—I think Senator Brown will agree with me in this—some of them get very cranky. I think it is a wise safeguard to provide that in the future the members of the appeal tribunal cannot take the bit in their teeth and, without reason, decide that a question is a question of law when it is not. There will not be a great number of appeals, because both the judicial commissioner and the lay commissioners will have in mind that they are not the final authority on this: that there is an appeal to a higher court against their decision. I think they will be very careful to see that there will be general agreement between them as to what are questions of law and what are questions of fact.

Comment on this

I do not agree with the Minister, with great respect, that the fact that the two lay commissioners are two sensible men with large experience of matters arising in the Land Commission under the Land Acts will help them at all in deciding whether a question is or is not a question of law. That is a question of law itself, and their experience will not help them in the least. My whole object in putting down the amendment was to try and prevent a multiplicity of appeals, with loss of time and loss of money. If the amendment had been accepted by the Minister that would have been achieved. The Minister said that the number of appeals will be few. I daresay they will, but the number would have been still fewer if my amendment had been accepted.

Comment on this

I move amendment 7:—

Section 12, sub-section (2). To delete in line 24 the figures and letters "15th" and to substitute therefor the figures and letters "31st."

Comment on this

The change in the date that has been proposed will make for greater administrative convenience: the 31st July instead of the 15th July.

Comment on this

I move amendment 8:—

Section 12, sub-section (4). To delete in line 61 the figures said letters "15th" and to substitute therefor the figures and letters "31st."

This amendment is consequential.

Comment on this

I move:

Section 13, sub-section (2). To delete in line 51 the figures and letters "15th" and to substitute therefor the figures and letters "31st."

This and the following amendments are consequential.

Comment on this

I move.

Section 14, sub-section (2). To delete in line 35 the figures and letters "15th" and to substitute therefor the figures and letters "31st."

Comment on this

I move:

Section 15, sub-section (2). To delete in line 40 the figures and letters "15th" and to substitute therefor the figures and letters "31st."

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 15, sub-section (4). To delete in line 15 the figures and letters "15th" and to substitute therefor the figures and letters "31st."

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 16, sub-section (2). To delete in line 36 the figures and letters "15th" and to substitute therefor the figures and letters "31st."

Comment on this

I move amendment 14:—

New section. Before Section 17 to insert a new section as follows:—

17. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in Sections 12, 13, 14 and 15 of this Act, in every case in which the total aggregate amount of a purchase annuity, an annual sum equivalent to a purchase annuity, an additional sum, payment in lieu of rent or interest on purchase money, payable by any proprietor during the three years ending on the first gale day of the year 1933 has been paid, the amount payable by such proprietor for any instalment in respect of any of the above-mentioned liabilities after the first gale day in 1933 up to and including the first gale day in 1939 shall not be payable by or recoverable from such proprietor, but such instalments of liability shall be payable by means of a funding annuity in like manner in all respects as if there had been an amount of arrears of liability due by such proprietor equal to the aggregate amount of liability payable by him during the three years ending on the first gale day in 1933.

I do not think this amendment really requires very much explanation. So far as I can see the whole policy which is developed in Sections 12 to 16 is one which will encourage very materially people not to pay their annuities. Very few of the defaulters will be any better off by reason of the funding of their arrears. They have got used to them. Take the case of a man who had a yearly sum of £10 to pay to the Land Commission. He got bad advice in 1922. He stopped paying in January, 1922, and has never paid since. He now owes £100. By this Bill he is to be forgiven £70, £30 is to be funded and added to his annuity, which is reduced to £5. This is supposed to give him a fresh start. I admit that there are a great number of people who have fallen into arrears through misfortune of various kinds, but I think, taking the defaulters as a whole, they are greatly in the minority. Numbers of other people have kept paying on their annuities, and it is these who have kept the State going. They continued to pay while other people fell into arrears. They had the same circumstances and the same difficulties to contend with, and yet they have managed to keep on paying. Over and above paying their own annuities, they have paid for all those men who have fallen into arrears, and now they are to be asked again to pay a very considerable sum.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I do not think this amendment is in order because, if accepted, it would entail a charge on the Central Fund.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

We have always held in this House that we are entitled to make amendments of this kind to a Bill.

Comment on this

These people have paid for the defaulters through the rates, and now they will pay indirectly for the speeding up of land purchase which this Bill involves. In many ways that is going to be a considerable sum. The men who have been bearing those charges of various kinds are the men who may at any time be compulsorily removed from their holdings to make room for other people, because the practice of the Land Commission always has been, and naturally will continue to be, to pick out the most solvent people to establish in new places. They will go on bearing the whole burden of land migration. I think these are really the best type of Irishmen. They have kept to their contract under difficult circumstances. They got bad advice but, by their hard work and intelligence, they have kept going. Where one class of men has failed this class has succeeded, and it is simple justice that they should be treated on exactly the same basis as the men who have fallen into arrears and whose arrears are forgiven. I do not ask any more for them than that. The Minister may argue that the cost is greater than the State can bear. But when people branch out on new economic adventures and try to get things going more quickly, they should very carefully consider what the cost of these adventures will be.

Comment on this

I wonder whether Senator The McGillycuddy is quite sure that the tenant purchasers who have been paying their annuities up to the first gale day of 1933 desire this amendment. Men who are in the habit of paying their annuities may desire still to pay half the annuities, which is the amount to be demanded from them henceforward.

Comment on this

If they can afford it.

Comment on this

They have afforded it up to the present. As Senator Counihan has put his name to this amendment, perhaps he will say whether he is satisfied that in this amendment he represents the view of any considerable number of the tenant purchasers who have paid their annuities continuously up to the last gale day. I am not sure that he does. I know many men throughout the country who say: "We wish to pay our land annuities; we regard the payment of our land annuities as a matter of ordinary honesty." I refer to payment to the State, which is entitled to it.

Comment on this

The State?

Comment on this

When they have paid their annuity their responsibility ceases. They have nothing whatever to say to the ultimate destination of that annuity. The ultimate destination of the annuity payable in respect of Irish land is the Exchequer of Ireland and not the Exchequer of Great Britain. But there are a number of tenants who say: "We entered into an agreement to purchase our land. We are anxious to perform that agreement. We are anxious to make these annual payments." The State now says: "For the future we will require you to pay only half of the annuities you have been paying heretofore." Now Senator The McGillycuddy comes along and says that these men who have paid up to the last gale day and who have been in the habit of paying should get out of the habit of paying for the next six years and then pay again.

Comment on this

That the annuities should be funded.

Comment on this

May I say, if it will relieve the Senator's mind, that I am willing to add the words to the amendment: "if they so desire."

Comment on this

The question I asked the Senator was whether he considers he represents in this amendment the opinion of any considerable number of tenant purchasers who have been paying their annuities.

Comment on this

I am sure he does.

Comment on this

I do not know that he does. A number of tenant purchasers would prefer to pay their annuity rather than have it funded and "in front of them," to use an expression common in the country. I suggest to Senators that they should not vote for this amendment.

Comment on this
Raphael P. Keyes Mr. Kennedy

Senator Comyn has alluded to the man who has always paid and who, he says, should continue to pay. In my opinion, the vast majority of farmers are not able to pay. I speak from experience of that part of the country to which I belong. I am a farmer myself. I know a case in which a young man had five cattle at the fair of Newtownmountkennedy the other day. They were over a year old. What did he get for them? £16 5s. 0d. for the five. Is it in accord with common sense or reason that that man should be expected to pay his annuities? He is a farmer in a small way and reared, I suppose, about ten of these cattle in the year. He would have got very much more out of these beasts if, in ordinary circumstances, he had sold them as dropped calves. I could give his name and address. For the five he got £16 5s. 0d. out of which he had to give a luck-penny. The position is that the people are not able to pay. How could they pay in circumstances of that kind? They go to fairs but they cannot sell a single beast. In the days gone by, the Minister for Agriculture used to go over and see how the sales were going in the Dublin market. I was over there recently and there were a large number of salesmasters but no sales at all. There is, of course, the market in the morning, as we all know, but there is a sale by auction in the evening. Although it was stated in the newspapers that cattle were sold at from 16/- to 20/- per cwt., I saw only six beasts there and I was in one of the biggest places in it. I was there a fortnight before that and there were only three beasts offered, not one of which was sold.

When people say that the farmer should pay as usual, may I ask where the money is to come from? It is very easy for Senator Comyn to go into the courts and make money. I am sure he can make as good a case there as he makes here, but he makes a very strange case here sometimes. Surely Senator Comyn could not argue that you can make a man pay if he has not got the money. I think that until this economic war is over the Government should not expect payment. Whether they expect it or not, they cannot get it, because the people have not got the money. That is a very good reason.

Comment on this

This amendment is, in my opinion, necessary on account of the inability of farmers to pay their annuities at the present time. It only applies to those who have paid during the whole time, and, as far as I can see, does not make provision for those who have paid half the time.

Comment on this

It does.

Comment on this

If that is so, it is more in keeping with the circumstances of the case. Something has been said about the reduction of land annuities in the future. I got my demand for rates this morning, and I think it is 80 per cent. greater than the amount I paid last year.

Comment on this

8 per cent. or 80 per cent.?

Comment on this

80 per cent.

Comment on this

Think it out again.

Comment on this

The great reduction that we are told we are getting by the remission of annuities is offset by something like £1 a statute acre in County Dublin for rates alone. That is in consequence of the number of people who are getting able-bodied relief. This is a disguise motion. Owing to the state of affairs that exists it really means that people who have paid annuities should not be asked to pay until 1939. That means that the six half-years should be funded. Farmers are not asking to be let off paying annuities, because they will pay in the future, but they are not able to pay now. When it is not a question of letting them off, but of funding three years annuities, I do not see where the great loss will be. If the amendment were passed it would be a great boon to the farmers.

Comment on this

When I put my name to this amendment I understood it was going much further than it does. I contend that no class of farmer can pay while the economic war lasts. I stated that I was not going to discuss the economic war, and consequently I cannot discuss the amendment. It is impossible to discuss it without referring to the economic war. As Senator Wilson stated, this Bill is supposed to confer great concessions on the farmers. The Senator was not correct, I think, about the 80 per cent. increase in rates. I got the demand note for rates this morning, and the increase is something like 50 per cent. over last year's demand.

Comment on this

About 50 per cent.

Comment on this

The principal reason the House should support the amendment is the inability of farmers to pay. If they are pressed for the annuities they will be able to pay only by using whatever little capital they have for working their farms and for stocking them. Under present circumstances they will get no money from the banks or from moneylenders.

Comment on this

I would like to get back to the amendment, because it appears to me that the discussion has got clean away from it. Annuitants who owe three years arrears, or more, have been dealt with in the Bill. Annuitants who partly paid their annuities but did not pay the rest, have been dealt with, and have got a relief. The only persons who have not got any relief under the Bill are the people who paid their annuities in full, whether from innate honesty, or because they thought it was the best thing to do. Where these other people have been helped, surely in common honesty, and, as a matter of fair play, they are entitled to get the same kind of relief as if they had not paid. These people have been honest and all that the amendment asks is that the three years' arrears which they have paid should be set off against the next three years; that these three years should be funded. That is only mere fair play and for that reason I ask the Minister to consider the position of these honest people. They need not take advantage of it if they do not like to do so. Give them the chance. They can refuse to take the money or to accept the funding.

Comment on this

They are compelled to fund under the section.

Comment on this

I admit that the Land Commission is bound to fund but, if they make representations to the Land Commission that they do not want the amount funded, but wish to go on paying half the annuities for the next three years, the Land Commission will be willing to let them do so.

Comment on this

Senator Counihan says that he put his name to this amendment and I think from his speech he did not read the amendment before he signed it. This amendment proposes to give relief to the farmers who have proved, one way or another, that of all the farmers in the country they are the farmers who least require relief. If this amendment were passed 40,000 out of the 436,000 annuitants would get their next six years' annuities funded. Up to the present time 40,000 annuitants have paid and thereby these have proved that they were able to pay.

Comment on this

That they paid.

Comment on this

They proved that they were best able to pay.

Comment on this

That does not at all follow.

Comment on this

Senator Brown said that those people who have paid up to the present are entitled to get some kind of relief. They are going to get it.

Comment on this

The same as the others?

Comment on this

People who have paid up at the present time have a half-year's less annuity to pay at the other end. The people who have not paid up will have to pay their annuity until the funded debt is wiped out in 50 years' time. Viewing the necessities of the farmer, there is no need for this amendment and certainly it would put a burden on the State Exchequer that could not be justified. I think that the annuities payable by these people during the next three years would be better in the State Exchequer and can be used in a better manner than in funding them. This proposal is really a proposal to give credit to people who, up to the present time, have not signified that they want credit. This amendment is funding their annuities over 50 years at 4½ per cent. Now these people may not want to pay 4½ per cent. interest on the money. But if the annuities are funded they will have to pay 4½ per cent. in the future. If these people have the money and they are able to pay they will find that if the annuities are funded and they put the money in the bank that they will certainly get nothing like 4½ per cent. on that money.

Comment on this

Arising out of this amendment are we to understand from some of the comments that have fallen from the Minister that in relation to 436,000 annuitants none of these men are to be forgiven any portion of the annuities that they have paid and that some time one and all of them will have to refund part of the annuities now forgiven? Is that the position?

Comment on this

With the exception of those over three years in arrears.

Comment on this

It is a matter of £150,000. The others will have to pay.

Comment on this

To how many annuitants does that apply?

Comment on this

About 436,000 payers altogether. Of these 40,000 have paid up-to-date.

Comment on this

These men would in some form or another be forgiven portion of their annuities?

Comment on this

No, their annuities will not be forgiven. The annuity would be funded and payable for 50 years at 4½ per cent.

Comment on this

Nobody will be forgiven?

Comment on this

Nobody will be forgiven but the half year's annuity which will be forgiven to all.

Comment on this

The only man who is to be forgiven under the Bill is the lazy, incompetent man who did not pay. That is the man who is to get off scot free. On that point I wish to answer Senator Comyn—that the annuities are due to the State. I will not let that pass. That is a thing that is not generally known and I take the opportunity of saying it now that that argument and that principle were first enunciated by an avowed Communist, Peadar O'Donnell. One man, a member of this House, Senator Moore, was first credited with that, but he was only the loud speaker. Peadar O'Donnell was the first to enunciate that principle.

Comment on this

I may say that Peadar O'Donnell publicly announced that he was not a Communist.

Comment on this

I think Senator Colonel Moore was given the honour of claiming to be the first.

Comment on this

Am I to understand that there are actually 130,000 defaulters in this island of saints?

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

It is 400,000 out of 436,000.

Comment on this

I do not understand the Minister's plea that this is going to cost the State so much money. This is a mere question of funding. Surely one thing should pay off the other. The rate that is to be charged on the bonds is to meet the cost of this funding. The annuitants who will pay what they will be called on to pay will free the State from any loss. This amendment is only giving the 40,000 what the others are getting. I do not suppose that the State is incurring a great deal of liability in funding these three years' arrears. Are we really incurring a great deal of expense in funding this and paying the rates that are to be paid by the annuitants or the people who are paying the annuities—is the State really incurring a very great liability in that part of the matter? I thought that the ultimate repayment of the moneys now to be funded would free the State from all liability in this matter and that there would be no loss to the State.

I did not know that the State in regard to the annuitants who were going to get their annuities funded for three years was going really to lose anything. But now we have the Minister saying that this transaction is going to cost quite a lot of money to the State. Is it true that the same argument applies to the funded annuities in the case of those for whom the whole arrangement about funding the annuities has been made? I ask that because if it is we are in for a much greater expense than that which we had calculated up to now. I never thought this was really going to cost the State anything. I understood that the future annuities were calculated on the basis that there would be no loss caused to the State by the funding. Those who are in possession of land and are not paying the annuities will of course cause loss to the State. In such cases the State will lose. There is no question about that. But as long as honesty prevails I do not think we are going to put any bigger burden on the State by giving those annuitants who have paid their annuities what this amendment seeks to give them. If that is going to cost the State money I think we should be told how much it is to cost. There is the same reason in each case. Both Senator Comyn and the Minister in calculating this matter said that the good payers of annuities will be in the same position to pay their annuities in the future as in the past. That is rather assuming a thing that is not so at all. There are many people who have paid their annuities quite well in the past who will not be able to pay them in the future.

Comment on this

There is only 50 per cent. payable in the future.

Comment on this

Even so. I believe the people who have paid up their annuities will find that this amendment, giving the power to fund, will give them great relief in the next few years. I do not believe it is going to cost the State anything, especially in the case of those people who have been honest payers up to the present. Therefore, I do not believe that it is true to say that this amendment is going to be a financial burden on the State. I do think that the Seanad ought, seriously, to consider whether it would not be right to state their opinion that the people who have paid up honestly in the past should be treated in the same way as those who did not pay up. I do not say that those who did not pay up failed through their own fault, but let us say they failed for reasons which they could not have avoided. At all events, we ought to treat both these sections on the same lines, at least, those who have paid should be treated equally with those who have not. Preferential treatment should surely not be given to those who did not pay their annuities in the past.

Comment on this

Senators will remember that the Minister for Finance, in his Budget speech, said he was going to borrow £1,000,000 on the strength of the deferred annuities. These deferred annuities are funded annuities. If this amendment is carried in the case of the 40,000 good payers of annuities it will be necessary for the State to provide moneys by loan or otherwise to foot the bill until 1939. That is not an expense to the State.

Comment on this

It comes to this, that there are 40,000 men who have shown, up to the present, that they were able to pay their annuities regularly. What this amendment means is that the State should borrow money for the purpose of forcing a loan at 4½ per cent. on these people.

Comment on this

Yes, forcing a loan at 4½ per cent., because that is the meaning of this amendment. Now, some of those people may have money in the bank at one per cent. Many of them may be people who do not desire to have this loan, people who may wish to continue to pay in the future. If this amendment is passed, half their annuities will be funded at 4½ per cent.

Comment on this
Raphael P. Keyes Mr. Kennedy

My argument is that these people are not able to pay now in the changed conditions.

Comment on this

Some of them may. I would put this as a submission now to Senator Jameson: You have men who have been in the habit of paying their annuities even in difficult times. You are now going to say to these men: "You shall not pay anything for the next six years. We will fund it and charge you 4½ per cent. for it, even though you may have the money in your pockets or in the bank." These men who have been in the habit of paying are to get out of that habit.

Comment on this

I was born on a farm, but I do not want to say very much about land; I got off it as soon as I could.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

The Senator was wise.

Comment on this

This is a case of 40,000 farmers who have paid their annuities regularly but who find themselves in this position to-day, that in order to pay the wages of their workers they have to bring over-fed cattle into the Dublin and other markets. I attend the Dublin cattle market practically every Thursday, and I have observed these men bringing in a few cattle in order to help to pay their wages. They are leaving overgrown and over-fed cattle, cattle that are too big, on the land. They do not want to sell them at 50 per cent. of their value. They are waiting like the rest of the Irish people for something to turn up. Nothing has turned up, and I think these people, who so far have paid their way, would be very glad to-day to accept this funding arrangement at 4 or 4½ per cent. They are still hoping that something will turn up and that this economic war will be settled. I know it is not going to be settled; it is going to be just like a corkscrew, coming to a point where there will be nothing left for anybody.

Comment on this

The Communists will get their share.

Comment on this

I am prepared to vote for the amendment.

Comment on this

The thing that surprises me in connection with this amendment is that the Minister does not accept it. I cannot understand why he does not. I do not think this amendment goes any distance. If the purpose of the amendment is to afford relief to farmers, I submit it does not afford very much in the nature of relief. Two reasons have been advanced in connection with this amendment. We are told the position of agriculturists is that they cannot pay and will not be in a position during the economic war to meet their land purchase liabilities. The other argument is that it will give relief to a certain section of farmers. What relief does it give? It merely postpones the day when these men will have to pay their land purchase annuities. Section 16 (2) (a) says:—

"such arrears and the amount so ascertained of the said costs and expenses together with interest at the rate of 4½ per cent. per annum on the said arrears, costs and expenses from the first gale day in the year 1933 shall ... be added."

There are farmers who met their land purchase annuities, paid them in good time. These farmers are now going to be absolved for a certain number of years. At the end of a six years period they have to meet the land purchase annuities for which they would be ordinarily liable, together with the arrears which have accrued, together with costs and interest at 4½ per cent.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

That is not so.

Comment on this

That is what it means.

Comment on this

They will have to pay 4½ per cent. over a period of six years. That money surely is not going to be allowed to stay out without interest? Why should it apply in the case of outstanding arrears at the present time and not in the case of arrears for the next six years? Where is the relief to the farmer in that? I fail to see any relief. If the farmers were absolved from paying any portion, if any portion of it was forgiven them, then I would say there would be some relief. Here we have 40,000 farmers, only one-tenth of the defaulters, and you are going to give them a reward or premium in some form for doing something which, I take it, every farmer might have done. There is no specific form of relief offered in this instance. As regards the general position, the farmers cannot pay and the 40,000 will be in the same position as the 400,000. If the farmers are in the position that they cannot pay, arrears will accrue and the Government will have to face the situation which has arisen owing to their manipulation of the whole land purchase question.

Comment on this

When I put my name to this proposal I thought it specified 1932 instead of 1933. The economic war started in July, 1932. I know there are perfectly honest men who were unable to pay their annuities in 1932 and I will ask Senator The McGillycuddy to substitute 1932 for 1933, and also add the provision that where any annuitants want to pay half the annuity they should be given an opportunity to do so, instead of having the money funded.

Comment on this
Cathaoirleach

I could not agree to such a change.

Comment on this

We will table an amendment in that connection on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I have listened to this discussion with some interest and amusement. I have been listening for the purpose of finding out the rights or wrongs, the justice or injustice of the claim. I cannot but remind myself of the discussions on the Moneylenders Bill. I had occasion to read the evidence given before the Commissions here and in England on the Moneylenders Bill. I find one great complaint was that the moneylenders were forcing their clients to keep on borrowing, never to let them get out of debt. That seems to be the case that is put forward in favour of this amendment. Further, I am amused in this way, that the arguments that have been adduced, while I have a good deal of sympathy with them, seem to me to be equally applicable to any trader's debt, any debt for house purchase, rental, milk—a trader's debt of any kind.

Let us say a man is in business and has 100 customers. A majority of them or a minority of them pay up-to-date. The remainder are not able to pay and the debts are wiped off as bad. Therefore, as a consequence, because he has wiped off the debt of a number of customers as bad, the merchant must be bound to say to the remainder "Because we wiped off the debts of these other people, we must reduce liabilities, or at least, we must ask you to borrow money from us to reduce your payment on account of your future purchases". I think it is very good to have that doctrine preached by merchants, manufacturers, bankers, house owners and farmers. Let us apply that to ordinary trading operations in a town. I think on these grounds we ought perhaps to support this amendment having in mind the debt case that Senator Miss Browne is so anxious about, so that the purpose of this amendment and the advocacy of those in favour of it should be borne in mind. It is a very useful argument that because we allow those who were unable to pay to have their debts cancelled, we are bound to follow that up, and say those who are able to pay must be treated equally. The unfortunate or the dishonest, whichever case you like to take, has to have his debt remitted, but the remainder must be treated equally well. That is a very good doctrine and I hope merchants, manufacturers and traders will bear that in mind in future.

Comment on this

The comparison made by Senator Johnson does not work. The traders, because of debts due to them, do not take away a man's livelihood from him.

Comment on this

It is not a question of shopkeepers in towns. The question here is one of national liability, national responsibility and national honour. Senator Johnson can compromise if he likes on these matters. I am not prepared to compromise on them.

Comment on this

There are two things which came out in this debate, and one is the special knowledge Senator Comyn seems to have of the Irish farmers. I only know those in Waterford, and I do not know any of them who would not accept a remission of his debt. There are many in Clare, I suppose, who are only too anxious to pay up in the fullest terms in cash. I am rather puzzled at Senator O'Hanlon's argument. I do not gather from it whether he quite understands the position. Surely, actuarially, it is the same thing to fund a debt or to pay it, but in practice it is very different in having your liability extended over 50 years or paying it right away. I suggest it is a relief to a man to be able to pass on a debt to his children and his grandchildren.

Comment on this

There is a terrible lot of potter about this amendment. It really means nothing. Senators who put it down hardly knew what they were putting down; that is clear from the retractions and the additions that have been made during the debate. The fact of the matter is, this applies to about 40,000 people who want to pay in order to get rid of their debt to the Land Commission. They will have to pay whether in 20 or 30 years, in order to get their land free from annuities. One Senator talked a lot about ten bullocks that were bought in the market. These 40,000 people only mean about £90,000. The annual rents run from about 5/- to £3 or £4, and the average is £2 annuity which will be reduced to half. It would be going too far taking a loan of a half-crown at 4½ per cent. for 50 years. That is really what the amendment means.

Comment on this

I would like to inform Senator Sir John Keane that I knew perfectly well what I was saying. I ask Senator The McGillycuddy, now, to say what genuine relief will come to the 40,000 farmers. The Minister says it means nothing. If that is so, I am surprised he does not accept this amendment.

Comment on this

The debate has not altered the position I took up. I knew perfectly well what I was doing when I put down the amendment. Some other Senators did not read the amendment as carefully as I did during the three weeks which I took to prepare it. Senator Comyn made one point about the farmers and their position. He questions whether I represented the farming community. I am a farmer, living amongst farmers, and I have a very good idea of the farmer's mentality in my own county. I can say that the farmers welcome something in the shape of relief of any kind. You will find numbers of farmers now, who, in the past, had taken decadal reductions so as to allow their sons and their grandsons to bear some of the costs of land purchase. In the same way, rather than take their money out of the banks, they would prefer to go to the Board of Works and borrow for the purpose of building their houses. Why? Because they want their sons and grandsons to bear some of the cost while they are building up a home. I believe they will have the same view about the proposal in this amendment. The men I pick out are those who have partially paid, and I pick them out as impeccables. They are small men paying, perhaps, about £2 per annum, and I think they are, perhaps, more worthy of relief than any other citizen. It certainly will be a very great relief in these very serious times. Reading the Bill quite dispassionately I would say that the economic war does not enter into consideration at all. This is a question where the State takes a certain number of citizens and limits portion of their contracts. Others they allow to go on. I suggest that six years will put them on equal terms, and in the end the State pays nothing.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 24
·
Níl 16
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

On behalf of Senator Seamus Robinson I move amendment No. 15:—

Section 17. To delete in line 62 the figures and letters "15th" and to substitute therefor the figures and letters "31st".

This is a consequential amendment.

Comment on this

If I am right in assuming that amendment No. 19 in the name of Senators Wilson and Garahan seeks to abolish the Guarantee Fund or seeks to deprive the Government of the powers they at present possess to deduct arrears of annuities from the Grants-in-Aid to local authorities, I would prefer to withdraw amendments Nos. 16 and 17 to Section 26 which stand in my name and let the case be argued on amendment No. 19.

Comment on this

I suggest that amendment 18 is consequential to amendment 19, and if amendment 19 is carried that can be cleared up on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Could we not argue the matter on amendment 18?

Comment on this