Private Business. - Land Bill, 1933—Committee Stage.
Contributions 221–430 of 430. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 33 of 1933 ›
I think it would be better to argue the matter on amendment 19, which is the important one. Amendment 18 can be brought forward again on the Report Stage if the other is passed.
Comment on this
I move amendment 19.
Section 27, sub-section (2). To insert before the sub-section a new sub-section as follows:—
(2) The charge on the Guarantee Fund in respect of deficiencies in the Purchase Annuities Fund arising from the provisions of this Part of this Act in relation to the payment of arrears of purchase annuities by means of funding annuities shall cease on the passing of this Act.
The object of this is to do away with the Guarantee Fund altogether with regard to empowering the Government to take from the Agricultural Grant the amount of annuities unpaid. As the House is aware, the practice is to deduct the amount of the annuities which are unpaid from the grants to local authorities. The money is then paid into the Guarantee Fund, and is taken out of the Guarantee Fund to make up the deficiency which occurs by reason of the default in the payment of annuities. My object is to do away with the Guarantee Fund altogether, because the State is the collector of these annuities, and the State ought to be responsible rather than the local ratepayers if it fails to collect the annuities. A ratepayer may have paid his annuity and still be made liable for those who were in default. Under this Bill that arrangement will result in a loss of £250,000 to the ratepayers, which is being given in the shape of a gratuity by the Government. I do not see any reason for this Guarantee Fund. There might have been a necessity for it when the British were getting the annuities. At the present time the collecting authority is the State, which has a department for the collection of the money. If the money is short, it is the duty of the State to find the money; it is not the duty of the ratepayers. In arguing this case before the Minister for Finance, he said that we should by persuasion induce our neighbours and friends to pay the annuities. That kind of talk is all very well for a Minister for Finance, but it will not go very far in the collection of money from neighbours when they will not pay their annuities. My amendment will have the effect of preventing the amount of the unpaid annuities being taken from the Agricultural Grant and paid into the Guarantee Fund.
Comment on this
I am in agreement with Senator Wilson in what he said about this money which was collected from the ratepayers because of the default of certain annuitants before now and which is being written off by the Government. They are really having it both ways in my opinion with regard to the arrears of annuities which are now proposed to be funded. As far as I can see, some of these arrears, if not all, have been charged against the county councils and collected by the Government by deducting them from the grants to these councils. The Government are collecting from the county councils the arrears which annuitants had not paid. It is proposed now to collect them again by means of funding them. If I am right in my belief that that is the case, it seems an extraordinary state of affairs that the Government when they succeed in funding these arrears will have for the second time collected the same moneys, so far as the funding is collection, and, directly, so far as deduction from grants to county councils is a collection. That being so, and because of the other reasons Senator Wilson has given, I am in favour of this Guarantee Fund ceasing so far as the liability of county councils is concerned. I think the county councils are the only local bodies which are liable as guarantors. So far as the county councils are concerned, I think they should not be included any longer. There is nothing to be gained so far as one can see in present circumstances, by the continuance of this Guarantee Fund, and I am strongly of opinion that the amendment can be accepted by the Minister without any qualms whatever.
Comment on this
Ever since I have taken part in Land Bill discussions I have tried to effect the object of this amendment. Senator Wilson referred to the possible justification in the past. There was justification in the early days of land legislation, when the British Government, not sure that these annuities would be honestly met, and naturally wishing to avoid the odium of collection and all that it involved in matters of high politics, said: "We will make sure of the fund to discharge the obligation to the bond holders by deducting it from the grants-in-aid." The position, however, is now utterly and entirely different. The Government have the power to collect the annuities and nobody else. If these annuities are not paid, under the present system, as Senator Wilson pointed out, they are collected from the whole body of ratepayers in the district. Is it justice that because A.B. does not pay his annuity his neighbours shall have to pay? Yet you deprive them of the power to collect. We know what peaceful persuasion means. You even deprive them of the power of blacklisting these people. I believe that some local authorities took advice as to posting the names of defaulters on the county council buildings, and they were told that if they posted one single wrong name they would be liable for an action for defamation of credit and all the rest. I want to point out one effect that this has in practice. In practice the Government, by getting this money easily by deduction, are undoubtedly lax in the collection of annuities. As a banker, I have come across these cases.
When people are allowed to run into arrears for seven or eight years and no steps have been taken, beyond sending them a notice, to enforce the payment of the annuities, look at the effect of that. These annuities are the prior charge on that farm. When that farm is put up for sale, all the other debts secured on that land disappear, and I say that it is most unjust to other creditors, who have mortgages on that land, to let those annuities mount up to such an extent that they swallow up the whole of the purchase price of the sale of that land and leave other creditors out in the cold and deprive them of their legal security. That is the effect. There is another effect also. I do not wish to impute dishonesty in any general terms, but everybody knows that there are individuals who take advantage of this accumulation of arrears to effect a deal in their land. Senator Comyn knows, from his legal experience, that there are dishonest men as well as honest men, and he knows that a frame-up sometimes takes place where the buyer and the seller know that there will not be an open market. A friend comes along and says: "I will put in a bid for that land; there will be no competition and we will share the proceeds." As a result of that dishonest deal, all the other creditors are wiped out and the security, even for shop-debts, is gone. The delinquent will have evaded all his liabilities and he gets a fresh lease of life.
The whole thing is wrong, and it is aggravated by the action of this Guarantee Fund which gives the Government an inducement to be lax in the collection of those annuities. Where the Government has been lax in the past—and for very good reasons, because it is not pleasant to go to these people to collect their arrears of annuities when you can get them in another way-they could always collect their arrears from the Grants-in-Aid. The whole thing is wrong, inequitable and most unjust, and has long outlived its purpose.
Comment on this
I suggest that if the purpose of the amendment is to abolish the Guarantee Fund entirely, I do not think it would be accomplished by this amendment. However, I would raise another matter of more importance. One has learned, in the course of inquiry into local government accounts and State finances generally, how intimately bound up this Guarantee Fund is with all kinds of local and national finances, and to accomplish the abolition of the fund by means of an amendment in the Seanad in this way is going to do, probably, too much without due consideration. It seems to me that it is a matter that would have to be brought forward inevitably in connection with other financial adjustments in other circumstances and ought to be brought forward by a Ministry. I think the case that Senator Sir John Keane has made is a good one, but I do not think it should be accomplished in this rather casual way. This Guarantee Fund, as I said, is very closely associated with all kinds of local government and national finance, and I think it is very unlikely that the Dáil would agree with it in this form. I suggest that the line the Seanad should take is to indicate favourable reaction to this proposal, but not to attempt to make this very big change in the financial arrangements of the country by almost a casual amendment to a Land Bill.
Comment on this
I agree with what has been said that this is a great grievance, and it is the opinion of practically every county council in the country that this should be removed. I think we shall do something to remove it.
Comment on this
Senator Johnson objects that this is complicated. I know it is complicated, but it seems perfectly clear that this money has got to be paid. If it is not paid, it is deducted from the grants. If it is no longer deducted, it has to come into the Budget. The purpose of the Guarantee Fund is not working now. Let Senator Johnson be clear on the point. There is no distinct association between the annuities and the bondholders. The bondholders are a general debt secured by the Consolidated Fund. The annuities were absolutely associated with the Guarantee Fund in the past. That has all gone now. It is all pooled and melted and in the future the Minister for Finance says: "I shall budget for a certain amount of annuities, and if I do not get that amount it will have to be put on the general taxpayer." There is no complication whatever about it. I agree that there may be some difficulty as to the proper draftsmanship of the amendment but, if the principle is acceptable to the Seanad, I am sure the Government would at least give us the assistance of its advisers in the Parliamentary draftsman's office to put it into shape.
Comment on this
This is a long-standing grievance with county councils, and I hope the amendment will be accepted. We do feel that it is a great injustice to the honest ratepayers of the country that they must pay for the defaulters, and I must say that the Government or the Land Commission have been very lax up to the present. They have made no effort, in a great many cases, to enforce payments. They allowed them to drift on for years and years, and then in the end, when the sale of the land came about, they put in their claim with the result that honest traders were deprived of their debts. People know that they can get off in this way and they take advantage of it. The county councils have been protesting for years, and I hope the Minister will see his way to readjust this long-standing grievance.
Comment on this
This particular amendment does not do what the Senators say they want to have done: that is, to abolish the Guarantee Fund. It only refers to arrears arising out of this Part of this Act, and it refers to the deficiencies in the Land Bond Fund and not the deficiencies in the Guarantee Fund. The Land Bond Fund is a fund out of which comes the interest on the bonds issued in respect of land purchased since 1923, and the Government has already made that Fund good in respect of arrears that have been forgiven since 1932. There were two Estimates passed; one was for £1,400,000 which was introduced into the Dáil a few months ago, and the other was for £1,616,000. However, it is quite clear that what the Senators want is the abolition of the Guarantee Fund, and I am not prepared to agree to it. It does, undoubtedly, help the Government to collect the land annuities, and it will have to be kept on until there is a change of policy in the matter.
Comment on this
I think what the Minister has just said was an utterly unconvincing defence of the position. The Minister says it helps the Government to collect. Of course, it helps the Government to collect, but by passing it on to the whole body of the ratepayers who have had nothing approaching the relief to which they are entitled. Of course, it helps the Government to collect, but is it just? The Minister makes no attempt to justify it, and I consider he has adopted a most unaccommodating attitude, and I hope the House will support the amendment.
Comment on this
I am not surprised that my friend Senator Garahan did not understand all the intricacies of the Guarantee Fund and the Land Bond Fund. I tried many and many a time to understand them with their accounts and cross accounts and their debits and credits. It comes to this— let us know what it is—that in 1891, I think, when stock was issued, it was the policy of the British Government to treat all holders of agricultural land as one class, and to make them, in a sense, stand as security for each other. In 1888, the British Local Government Act was introduced, and there were various sums collected in respect of licences for public-houses and other local matters. These were collected by the Imperial Parliament and put into the Imperial Treasury and paid back again to the English counties by means of grants. In 1898, the Local Government Act was introduced into this country, and the system of grants-in-aid applied also to this country. The British Parliament said: "We will make the holders of all agricultural land security for each other in respect of the payment of these annuities, and we will do that by means of deductions from various grants made to them."
The Guarantee Fund was established and that fund was to be the fund out of which the default of the annuitants was paid in the first instance. That Guarantee Fund was replenished in various ways. In the first place, it was replenished by means of these Grants-in-Aid, and if these Grants-in-Aid were insufficient, there was power to raid the fund even for industrial schools, lunatic asylums and other things. In the last resort, the Guarantee Fund was to be replenished by means of a rate to be struck on the county by the grand jury, in the first instance, and if they failed, by the judge of assizes. In that way, the British Government at the time sought to make all holders of agricultural land security for each other in respect of the payment of these annuities. That is how the matter stands. It is a complicated matter and it is a matter of profound policy.
Comment on this
The British had nothing to do with land bonds and the Minister pointed out very properly——
Comment on this
——that there are two funds—the Land Bond Fund and the other fund. The Guarantee Fund applies to one, and, therefore, this amendment does not deal with the entire matter. It is only partial in its operation. I do not know what view the Government may take of it, but if you want to substitute for the liability of the agricultural class the liability of the entire country——
Comment on this
This amendment does not do that. It does not solve the question. It only, as it were, solves part of the question and, in fact, it leaves the matter as complicated as it was when the Guarantee Fund was first established under the Act of 1891 because in respect of some of the defaults, this section makes provision that they shall be made good by the general taxpayer but in respect of other defaults the old system by which the remainder of the agricultural community in each county shall be the guarantors for defaults will obtain. I think that is about the position and the question is whether this House ought to deal with the matter piece-meal—whether it ought to be dealt with on an amendment without full debate and due consideration as to where the money is to be found and how the money is to be found or whether the matter having been raised now should be agitated until such time as you get a complete settlement.
Comment on this
I think that my friend who has just spoken is not quite accurate in his description of what underlies this. He says that the object of this Guarantee Fund and the charges on it was to make the agricultural community security for each other but, unfortunately, that is not what it does. It makes the agricultural community plus every other ratepayer in the country security for them.
Comment on this
I think my friend will find that the urban areas were not responsible.
Comment on this
There are many other people who are not holders of agricultural farms, and who are ratepayers in a county, and who are not in any urban district at all.
Comment on this
There are some people certainly who are not owners of agricultural land and who were in a rural area, but the urban areas were exempted from liability under this Act of 1891.
Comment on this
Senator Comyn is pleading that because the matter is so intricate we should let it go by default, having agitated it. Senator Comyn must think we are very childish because we would never have an opportunity of raising this question again if we let it go through in the Land Bill. If the Minister is not prepared to agree to this, we ourselves would bring in an amendment properly drafted on Report Stage to effect what we desire, because it is plain that sub-section (3) of Section 26 is another payment that is not touched by this but, at the same time, we want to test the mind of the House on the whole question of the Guarantee Fund by means of this amendment, and if we get an expression from the House in support of it, I promise the Minister that a well-considered and well-drafted amendment will be brought forward on Report and the Guarantee Fund will be very easily dealt with.
Comment on this
This is a matter which I feel we cannot allow to pass. Time after time, protests have come up from every county council, I might say, in Ireland against the injustice of this. We have no remedy. If we had the power to collect this money ourselves we would not have the same justification, but we have no power whatever. As I say, the county councils have protested time and time again, and now, when the Land Bill is before the House, is the time to have the injustice remedied. I hope that the Senators will insist on their amendment.
Comment on this
I want to say just one word to make our position clear. We know that this amendment does not carry our wishes into full legal effect but it is testing the House on the simple issue as to whether arrears of annuities should be paid by ratepayers or taxpayers. When we have the feeling of the House on that matter, we will get counsel to draft an amendment which will effect our purpose and bring it forward on Report. Let there be no doubt about what we intend to do.
Comment on this
On the wording of the amendment, there is certainly grave doubt as to what the Senators intend to do but, of course, they have explained their intention in their speeches. As the amendment stands, it relieves the Guarantee Fund or the Land Bond Fund from a liability which has already been met by the Minister for Finance in the estimates that were passed by the Dáil.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment 20:—
Section 28, sub-section (3). To delete the sub-section and to substitute therefor three new sub-sections as follows:—
(3) Immediately upon receipt from the Land Commission of a warrant under this section the county registrar shall serve such notices and do such acts as shall be prescribed by regulations to be made by the Minister for Justice, including a notice by the county registrar of his intention, after the expiration of 15 days from the service of such notice, to levy the amount mentioned in such warrant as due by the defaulter to the Land Commission.
(4) Within 14 days after the service by the county registrar of the said notice of his intention to levy the amount mentioned in the last preceding sub-section, the defaulter may make and file with the county registrar a declaration in the prescribed form, stating either that he does not owe the amount claimed to be due by him to the Land Commission or that he is not the person liable to pay the same, and thereafter it shall be lawful for the Land Commission, if and when the Land Commission thinks proper, to take any remedy which the Land Commission may have by law for the recovery of such amount other than the remedies given by this section to the Land Commission.
(5) Immediately after the expiration of the period of 14 days mentioned in the last preceding sub-section, if the defaulter has not prior thereto made and filed such declaration in the prescribed form as is mentioned in such sub-section, the county registrar shall proceed to levy the amount certified to be due by the defaulter in the warrant issued by the Land Commission under sub-section (1) of this section in the same manner as Execution Orders at the suit of the Land Commission are by law leviable, and such county registrar shall for that purpose have all the rights, powers and duties for the time being vested in or imposed on him by law in relation to the execution of an Execution Order, including such rights, powers and duties as are for the time being vested in or imposed on him by Section 31 of the Land Act, 1927 (No. 19 of 1927).
This is the section which gives the Land Commission the right to issue a warrant to the county registrar which is to be executed by the sheriff in the case of anybody who is a defaulter in the payment of his annuities. The object of the section is to save the cost both to the State and to the defaulter of proceedings at law in the District Court or the Circuit Court, as the case may be, to recover the arrears due. There is no doubt that the amount of the cost to the State and, sometimes, to the defaulter is very considerable. Although I am of opinion that no Department of State should be judge and executioner in its own cause, I am not seeking by this amendment to interfere with the power of the Land Commission to do this in any case in which there is no doubt as to the amount that is due or as to the person by whom it is due. The amendment is directed entirely to the case where there has been or is a mistake either in the amount due by the alleged defaulter or as to the person by whom it is due. I want only to protect the honest defaulter and to give him a chance, where there has been a mistake, of having the mistake rectified.
The amendment is somewhat technical but I can explain it in a few words. Under my proposal, sub-sections (1) and (2) of the section in the Bill will stand but sub-section (3) will be deleted and will be substituted by the three sub-sections in the amendment. Under the first of these sub-sections, upon receipt from the Land Commission by the county registrar of a warrant, he is to serve such notices and do such acts as shall be prescribed by regulations to be made by the Minister for Justice, including a notice by the county registrar of his intention, after the expiration of 15 days from the service of such notice, to levy the amount mentioned in the warrant. That is to say, he is to give the defaulter 15 days' notice of his intention to levy. The next sub-section provides that within the next fourteen days—that is, fourteen days after the service of that notice by the county registrar—the defaulter may make and file with the county registrar a declaration in the prescribed form stating either that he does not owe the amount claimed to be due by him or that he is not the person liable to pay the same. That notice will be in the prescribed form and the prescribed form should oblige him, if he is quarrelling with the amount claimed, to state how much he does owe, so that the amount of the alleged mistake will be known as soon as he makes the declaration. In case he alleges that he is not the person liable to pay the amount, he should explain why he is not the person and, so far as his knowledge goes, who is the person liable.
Once that declaration is made under this sub-section, the county registrar has no longer the power of making a levy and the Land Commission are then put to their other remedies at law, whatever they are. In case there is no declaration made by the defaulter on one or other of these matters, then the sheriff is to go on and levy. That provides a perfect remedy in the case of mistake. It is admitted there are mistakes. They will be very few and the cases in which the defaulter will have to make this declaration and to stop the warrant will be very few. If the prescribed form is in the form I have indicated, it will have to state whether the question is as regards amount or as regards the defaulter's personal liability. This procedure cannot result in any subsequent litigation. The question at issue will then be fixed up between the defaulter and probably the county solicitor.
Comment on this
I have every sympathy with what Senator Brown proposes to effect by means of this amendment, but I think that it would be much wiser for the Seanad to leave the drawing up of the regulations to the Department of Justice, in consultation with the Land Commission. It is a very intricate matter and I do not think that anyone outside these two Departments, without intimate knowledge of the day to day work, could really do what Senator Brown proposes to do—that is, draft regulations for the carrying out of the operative part of the section. Senator Brown proposes to give, in the first place, 15 days' notice. I can promise that in the regulations to be drafted there will be adequate notice given by the sheriff to all persons concerned, in addition to the ordinary notice given by the Land Commission. First of all, the receivable order is sent back to the tenant purchaser a couple of months before the annuities are due. After the gale day, it is a month or sometimes six weeks before the six-day notice is sent out, so that the tenant purchaser will have at least 2½ months or thereabouts to make up his mind whether or not he will give the Land Commission notice that he disputes the payment upon which he is assessed. I can promise that, in addition to that time and these notices, a reasonable time—say 15 days or so—will be given by the sheriff that he has in hands a warrant from the Land Commission and that if the defaulter does not pay up he will proceed against him. I can further promise that the regulations will provide that where the defaulter establishes a prima facie case that he is not the person liable, the Land Commission will not proceed by means of the powers conferred in this section but will proceed in the ordinary way through the courts.
That is as far as we can reasonably go here. One or two snags have appeared already in the amendment put down by Senator Brown. In a large number of cases through the country there are occupiers of land who are not legally the owners, because they have not taken out administration. That goes on for years and for generations on many farms, and the user or occupier who derives the profit from the land has no real grievance if he is proceeded against. The amendment would inhibit the Land Commission from proceeding against an occupier who is deriving profits therefrom. I think the Senator should be content with a definite promise, which I have no hesitation in giving, that in the regulations to be made by the Department of Justice, in consultation with the Land Commission, provision will be made to give the annuitant adequate notice of the fact that the sheriff has a warrant in his possession against him, and further, where there is a prima facie case made out that the assessment is wrong, either in the amount or because the person says he is not the correct person, in such cases the Land Commission will not use the powers conferred by this section, but will proceed through the courts to recover the debt.
Comment on this
The Minister has really pointed out a difficulty which would be of rather frequent occurrence in regard to the amendment proposed by Senator Brown. I am sure Senator Brown would be satisfied with the assurance given by the Minister that he intends to see, in the regulations that are to be made, that every precaution is taken. I would like to point out a difficulty that is likely to arise in sub-section (3) in a case where the amount claimed by the Land Commission exceeds the actual amount due by the tenant, or by the person in occupation. There are numbers of cases where persons in occupation are not really the registered tenants. The difficulty may arise under sub-section (3) which reads:—
"Immediately upon receipt from the Land Commission of a warrant under this section the county registrar shall, after serving such notices and doing such acts as may be prescribed in that behalf by regulations to be made by the Minister for Justice, proceed to levy the amount therein certified."
That is, the money certified in the original certificate of the Land Commission. That sum may be £25 but, as a result of representations made by the tenant, the amount may be found to be inaccurate, and the Land Commission may agree that the amount is only £21. I think the words "therein" certified" or the word "therein" would require consideration. I do not know how much consideration is required or whether my observations have any real foundation or not.
Comment on this
I do not think there would be any difficulty in withdrawing the original certificate in a case like that.
Comment on this
I consider the amendment a very reasonable one. I ask the House to remember that the whole system of collection of arrears of annuities has been changed in this Bill. Instead of the ordinary process of going through the courts, judicial powers are being given to the Land Commission. As I am not a legal man Senator Comyn can correct me if I am wrong there. The Minister proposes that the Department of Justice, in consultation with the Land Commission, should draw up rules. Before we agree to that we should consider the matter very carefully, and should know what the respective costs were under the old system and what they will be under the new system, in order to see what protection the farmers get. Senator Comyn made a good point when he referred to the taking out of administration by farmers. Small farmers are very careless in these matters. If they get a notice from the county registrar or from the under-sheriff they may be careless and the first thing they will know is when they see the sheriff or the county registrar on their land. In some counties these duties are carried out by the county registrar but in other counties where the sub-sheriff who held office still occupies the position he will carry them out. The sheriff and the bailiffs will be on the land before a man knows where he is. People of that class must be given some protection. That is the reason I ask the House to consider the matter carefully before agreeing to the Minister's suggestion.
Comment on this
I only want to protect the alleged defaulter in whose case there has been a mistake as to the amount. The real trouble is generally about the amount. What happens in these cases is that a receivable order is sent down at which the tenant does not look. He puts it on the shelf and forgets about it. It is only when legal proceedings are commenced that he really thinks about the matter. I am quite willing to accept the Minister's suggestion as to what he will do. The Minister has promised now to prescribe a notice which will contain a statement, not only of the amount which is alleged to be due, but, if the alleged defaulter claims that a less amount is due, will point out what steps he ought to take. I am not so much bothered about those liable, because I recognise that very often persons not legally liable have not taken out administration. I think, however, that might be included, and, if so, I am perfectly willing to accept the Minister's suggestion and to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would kindly lay them on the Table of the House or say if we could see them.
Comment on this
I think all rules and regulations of the Land Commission are available in the Library.
Comment on this
On Section 29, I wonder if the Minister could give us a definition of what he means by the relief of congestion. It is rather an important point in the context of this Bill. Secondly, could he tell us the number of congests immediately to be dealt with under the Bill?
Comment on this
I have not the exact figures of the number of uneconomic holders in the country. As to the relief of congestion, I would put it this way. The Land Act of 1923 defines what a congest is. Section 73 (4) says:—
"The expression ‘relieving congestion' means the provision of land for the relief of a person or persons having an uneconomic holding or uneconomic holdings or for a person or persons whose holding or holdings has or have been acquired for the relief of persons having uneconomic holdings."
Comment on this
Could the Minister give us the approximate number of congests?
Comment on this
Before we go further in the discussion on Section 29 I should like to ask the Minister if he would tell us if there is anything in the section that will in any way interfere with the right of the people who have stud farms. These rights were protected under the Land Act of 1927. Section 9 of that Act protected people who have these stud farms. These people are now very greatly alarmed for fear anything in the Bill might interfere with their rights to run these stud farms. The stud farm is, of course, mainly in grass, and it has to be, if the stud farm is of any consequence. The Minister will see that Section 9 of the Land Act of 1927 gave protection, subject to the Minister's sanction, to these stud farms.
Comment on this
There is nothing in this Bill which takes away from the protection given in Section 9 of the Land Act of 1927 to stud farms. Apart altogether from the legal protection given in that Act, I do not think anybody would interfere with the stud farm. Usually in a stud farm you have very much more employment given for the number of acres than you would have even in a tillage farm.
Comment on this
I am very much surprised that any question should have been raised in regard to this matter. This Bill does not at all interfere with the fixity of tenure in regard to stud farms. They are sufficiently protected by the Act which was passed some years ago. Nobody need have any doubt that as long as stud farms are kept going there will be no interference with them.
Comment on this
I am very much obliged to the Minister for his statement, and I am also obliged to Senator Comyn for his help in the matter. This is a question which has a bigger effect outside than inside the country, because there has been a lot of misrepresentation about what this Bill will and will not do. What the Minister has said will give a good deal of confidence to people who are frightened about what might happen.
Comment on this
I move amendment 21:—
Section 29, sub-section (1). After the word "exceeds" in line 53 to insert the words and figures "where the land in question is situated within a radius of 15 miles from any of the cities of Dublin, Cork, Limerick and Waterford the sum of £4,000, and where such land is situated within a radius of ten miles from any town having a population of 10,000 according to the census of 1926 the sum of 3,000, and where such land is situate elsewhere".
The object of this amendment is to provide that where land is situated in the vicinity of a city or where there is what is known as proximity value, the amount of land which the owner would be entitled to hold would be increased from the £2,000 value in the Bill to £4,000 value. If one were to judge of the value of land by the annuities which are paid now under purchase conditions, that is in the case of vested land, there would be a huge discrepancy between different areas. In the case of vested land seven miles from the City of Dublin the rentals now being paid are mostly about £2 per Irish acre, and of course it is the rentals or the annuities that will fix the price that the farmer is to get for the land that is taken from him.
It has been frequently stated that the average rental for land is somewhere about 6/- or 7/- an acre. Where the rental would be so low, the £2,000 would give a holder of land a considerable area; but where the rental is high, £2,000 worth of land would give a very small area. The amendment is so arranged that in the vicinity of the four cities of the Free State, and in towns of 10,000 of a population, a greater value might be allowed in order that the area would be sufficient to attract a farmer's children to remain on the land. Farmers' children living beside a city naturally have ambitions away from the land. If you confine a farmer to a small area, his boys, instead of taking to the land, will prefer some other mode of living. They have ample facilities for education by reason of their proximity to the cities. If the area which is allowed the farmer is too small, you will have a situation arising where the learned professions, which at the moment are overcrowded, will be considerably overcrowded. In order to balance a situation of that sort, you ought to allow an increase in value to the holder of land in areas such as I have designated.
Comment on this
Section 29, in effect, says to the farmers: "Thus far shalt thou go and no further." If a farmer's son who has ambitions realises that he has no means of extending his property and that the possibilities of development are curtailed, largely through the action of the Land Commission under this measure, he will not remain on the farm. I would very much prefer the conditions that obtained under the Act which has been described as a Bolshevik measure, the 1923 Act. It appears that every Act tends to reduce the farmer's possibilities. Senator Johnson has forecasted that next year, or in two years' time, we probably will have a Land Bill curtailing the farmers very much more than does this measure.
The whole policy of this Government is to split up the land. Is that a wise policy? Do the Government realise the result of splitting up holdings all over the country? Do they realise the effect it will have on dairy farming? Do they realise that the splitting up policy tends in the direction of lessening rather than increasing production? Every farmer knows perfectly well that to till certain portions of his farm would be a great mistake. It would be very hard to induce a practical farmer to till certain divisions of his land. He knows from practical experience that the best way to utilise that land is to keep it in grass, and for that reason he will never allow a plough to go into it. If we take the Free State as a unit, the same thing will apply.
Comment on this
My argument bears upon the cutting-down of holdings to the value of £2,000. I am dealing with the section also. I maintain that it would be a great mistake to till all the good land of this country or break it up. If you make it into very small farms it will not even then be economical as a grazing proposition. Senator Johnson spoke about a man and his dog. Does the Senator realise that it is the people who own the large grazing farms who are most useful to the residents of the congested districts in the South and West of Ireland? Those men pay a good price for the stock raised by the small farmers, and if they were not in a position to take the stock the small farmers would have to go out of stock raising. If the big farmers are going to become tillage farmers there will not be much use for the small dairy farmers. The people who will suffer most by a splitting up of the land will be the small farmers in the congested districts.
Comment on this
I desire to support this amendment. I would like to mention that in many parts of the County Dublin there are holdings which could not be worked economically if they were broken up. There are holdings within three miles of Dublin, and of necessity they must be allowed to remain under grass. To convert them into tillage land would be almost like committing suicide. It is land that can only be used for dairying purposes, and its value is enhanced by reason of its close proximity to the city. To insist on having that land converted into tillage land would be a very grave mistake. I have known holdings near the city that have been under grass for the last 50 or 60 years. Any grain crops that would be grown in such land would turn out to be a rank failure, and would be a definite loss to the owner. It would be a mistake for the Land Commission to interfere with such holdings. The views of the people who own that land should be considered. They are in a position to know how the land can be profitably worked and they should not be subjected to any compulsion or direction.
One Senator used a satirical remark about a man and his dog. That sort of clap-trap is used by people who do not understand farming, or how land should be utilised so as to make it an asset to the State. I think the less interference there is with the farmers the better; in fact interference should be out of the question. There should be no such thing as compelling a man to till his land. The policy rather should be to increase the materials for food and for the country's benefit generally. We have foreign competition increasing every day, and every year the value of what the land can produce is becoming less. It would amaze many people if they took into account the weekly arrivals of foreign cattle. Further efforts to try to get people to change their methods of farming would be the greatest mistake in the world.
Comment on this
Senator Wilson has spoken to his amendment and I do not know what view the Minister will take of the Senator's observations. I do not propose to say anything upon the one side or the other. But Senator Counihan and Senator O'Connor have stated in the clearest and simplest manner the views of the grazier—the man with large tracts of land. They have stated those views more clearly and concisely than ever I heard them put before. What does it all amount to? It amounts to this: that for the owner of these large tracts of land it is easier, and might be more profitable for him, to have it in grass. That may be so; and in many cases it is so. But is it more profitable for the nation that that land should be kept in grass? I submit that Senators who take up the extreme view as stated by Senator Counihan will very seriously embarrass people who, generally speaking, are good supporters of fixity of tenure in land. After all, the ordinary people of the country have an interest in these matters as well as the individual proprietor, and the individual proprietor cannot consider his own interest to the exclusion of the interests of the country. I would advise the Senators who take that view to reconsider the position. Here is an amendment spoken to by Senator Wilson with a considerable amount, if I may say so with great respect, of good sense and ability. There is no doubt about it that land near towns, on a basis of acreage and fertility, is of considerably more value than land remote from a town. As I understand it that is the argument of Senator Wilson. A boy growing up on a farm near a town has greater inducement to leave that farm than one in a remote district. It might be more difficult on a farm near a town for a farmer to get his sons to remain on the land and become farmers themselves, but I would never subscribe to the proposition so well stated by Senator Counihan that it is better for a man with a great area of land to keep it in grass because it is easier and more profitable for him.
Comment on this
And that, therefore, it ought to remain in grass. We are coming to rather critical times, and we ought to consider the interests of the country at large.
Comment on this
The Senator has deliberately left out of account the important part of Senator Counihan's statement, that is that these grass farms fill a most necessary part in our national economy. Take them away and you take away the whole market for the small farmer who has young cattle to sell.
Comment on this
I am glad to see that Miss Browne is coming to see that the future of agriculture depends so much on the home market. I fail to see how the other arguments used are justified at all. The question of the big ranch has been so often discussed that there is hardly any need to pursue it further. Those in favour of the large landowner confine themselves to one branch of the cattle trade—the three-year-old bullock. Everyone knows that the small farms under 100 acres support more cows, pigs, poultry, and more human beings proportionately than the big farms. The farms under 100 acres support a greater human population proportionately than farms of over 100 acres. The next argument put forward was that land round Dublin was not suitable for the growing of wheat.
Comment on this
It was definitely stated, so far as I understand it. It was suggested that it would be ridiculous to turn that land into wheat-growing land.
Comment on this
The Senator spoke of everything except the economic war, and he would have brought that in if he thought he could have got away with it. It was definitely stated that no farmer round Dublin would allow his good land to be turned into tillage. I do not know Dublin as well as Senator Counihan, but I know good crops when I see them, and I have seen as good crops grown outside the boundary of the City of Dublin as I have seen in any part of Ireland. To talk of not growing good crops in the neighbourhood of cities and towns is all nonsense.
Comment on this
I think the real argument is not the question of a particular man holding a large amount of land, but that the land in the zones outside towns is of essential interest for the market here and for the raising of cattle. The people who hold this land in the neighbourhood of the towns are really a great service to the towns. For the service of these towns it is essential that large tracts of land should be retained in their vicinity. It is not a question, as Senator Quirke said, of big ranches. That does not arise here at all. I suggest that for the service of the towns, special consideration should be made in this Bill. I must say there is one great difficulty, and that is that if you make a zone ten miles round a town you may do as much injustice to some people as you would do benefit to others. I think the Minister should consider this matter from the point of view of the service of the towns and from that point of view you would want to retain the bigger tracts of land.
Comment on this
The whole argument for this amendment is based on the hypothesis that land near towns is more fertile and valuable than land outside a certain zone. That is the hypothesis, but that is not true. It was supported, to my surprise, by Senator Comyn.
Comment on this
I did not say it was more fertile but I said that it was more valuable by reason of its proximity to a town.
Comment on this
I know land within 15 miles of Waterford City which is of less value than land outside the 15 miles radius. There is really no basis on which to support the argument advanced in favour of the amendment. If the hypothesis is all wrong—that land near a city, land within a 15-mile radius of Dublin, Cork, Limerick or Waterford, is necessarily more valuable than land outside that 15-mile radius—if that hypothesis is not true, there can be no basis for the argument put forward in support of the amendment. It is not true. There is land within 15 miles of Dublin City which is not as valuable as some land outside the 15-mile radius. That is quite true.
Comment on this
I do not say it is the rule, but I say that the hypothesis on which the argument for this amendment is based is all wrong. It might be justifiable to raise the figure from £2,000 to £3,000 all round, but I suggest that the amendment ought to be withdrawn in its present form and that it can be moved at a later stage in another form to cover what Senator Counihan has stated.
Comment on this
I am afraid that Senator O'Hanlon does not understand all about the value of land within a 15-mile radius of Dublin, Waterford, Cork or Limerick. Lands within a 10-mile radius of these cities are very valuable by reason of the fact, if for nothing else, that they are near a shipping port. That fact in itself makes them valuable. I cannot see how Senator O'Hanlon could argue that land which is within 15 miles of a shipping port is less valuable than land which is 60 miles away.
Comment on this
You said you knew of cases in Waterford where land further away was more valuable than land within a 15-mile radius of the city.
Comment on this
All I said was that land within 15 miles from Waterford City was not necessarily more valuable than land outside a 15-mile radius of the city.
Comment on this
If the Senator wants to make out that land 15¼ miles outside the city is as valuable as land within the 15-mile radius, I will concede him the point.
Comment on this
Senators should try to discuss the amendment more calmly.
Comment on this
I think that some Senators are supporting the amendment on the supposition that Senator Counihan put forward, that we are going to cut down every holding to one of £2,000 value.
Comment on this
The Bill does not say that every holding is going to be cut down to a holding value £2,000. That is the definite statement the Senator made. I made a note of it at the time. If Senators will open their ears and allow the reasoning of the Bill to get into their heads, I think they will not be so alarmed as they have expressed themselves to be. Section 29 has to be read in relation to the rest of the Bill. Because of a lot of similar statements made in the Dáil, we introduced an amendment to Section 32, which put down in black and white the policy of the Land Commission and the policy of the Government in relation to all lands, no matter how held, no matter under what lease or what tenure it is held. Senator Counihan said that he wished we would revert to the 1923 Act. What was the effect of the 1923 Act? It left 80,000 holdings in this country that were subject to judicial tenancies without any protection whatever. No matter how the lands were worked the Land Commission could resume them, not leaving the occupier a portion value £2,000, £1,000 or £500, but taking all his land and giving him land bonds in return. Notwithstanding the fact that the Land Commission had these powers, they have been very rarely exercised.
The owners of land do not belong to one political party in this country. Fianna Fáil supporters are as much interested in the tenure and the ownership of land as the followers of any other Party. The idea we have tried to get into this Bill is that a man who is working his land in the interests of the community shall not be touched. The Bill does not propose to cut down all farms to £2,000 market value, and I do not believe that any Fianna Fáil supporter ever advocated such a policy. You have in Section 32 more protection given to judicial tenants and to certain lands held in fee-simple than was given in any section of the 1923 Act or subsequent Acts. Under these Acts, lands held either in fee-simple or held under a judicial tenancy could be acquired and resumed and the owner got nothing in exchange except land bonds. Here it is clearly set out that any farmer who works his land, gives adequate employment and produces an adequate amount of foodstuffs, considered in relation to the amount of unemployment and the amount of food that the country requires, shall be secured in his holding.
Comment on this
The whole of the section. That is definitely giving more protection to judicial tenants and to owners of fee-simple land than was given under the 1923 Act. What the Bill, however, does is this. It says that the extent of land that can be misused by anybody is £2,000 worth. The extent of vested land that can be misused by a vested owner is £2,000 worth. There is sufficient land in the country and the circumstances are such that we believe there is no necessity to go further. But any Government here in this country or in any other country will always have to take cognisance of the way in which land is being utilised. The area is limited and the needs of the population must be met from that limited area of land. No Government could stand idly by and see land being misused or not used for the benefit of the community, not giving the employment that is required and not producing the foodstuffs required by the community.
Senator O'Connor adverted to one fact and if the significance of that were fully appreciated, I think we would have the unanimous support of the country for the policy we are trying to follow. I do not want to debate the general agricultural, political or economic policy of the Government on this Bill, but Senator O'Connor adverted to the fact that more competition is being met with in England for cattle; that the weekly arrivals of cattle in the British market from Canada and other countries are growing. Let that fact bear its full weight and significance and we must realise that we cannot in future depend upon selling cattle in the British market at a price that would cover the cost of production here. The tendency for cattle to fall below the cost of production began many years ago. We would be foolish if we said that our people in this fertile land must starve because people in some other part of the world will not buy our cattle at a price which will pay us to sell to them. We have land here and the use we should make of that land is to provide the highest standard of comfort for our people. The reason we have to sell cattle is to pay for our imports.
If we had not to import all the coal and wheat and feeding stuffs we have been importing there would have been no necessity for us to export and we would have been as well off without exporting any cattle. We know that until our policy of self-sufficiency has had full effect we have to export, but we must all see that the race for economic national self-sufficiency is going to be one which means life or death to every nation in the world. There are more economic wars going on than the one between Ireland and England. Every country in the world has economic wars with all its neighbours. We have to take cognisance of the fact and to realise that every country is finding it more difficult day by day to export sufficient to pay for its imports. It is with that end in view that we want to secure that our unemployed are absorbed on the land and if the present owners of the land are not going to absorb them they will have to get out and make way for somebody who will work the land. We will not interfere at present with the owner of vested land to the extent of £2,000 market value. Over £2,000 market value we are going to insist that that man shall use his land in the interests of the community, shall give the employment and produce the foodstuffs that the community require from him.
Take Senator Wilson's amendment relating to the proximity value of land near cities. The Senator is very much out in his percentage of the increased value due to proximity to populous centres. Everyone must realise that there is proximity value and that land near the cities in some cases must be used for the feeding of dairy cattle during the summer. We have not tightened up the Bill so much that we are compelling the Land Commission to exclude that fact from their minds. You have again in Section 32 a clause which says that the Land Commission shall take cognisance of the desirability of increasing the production of food supplies and such land as is producing an adequate amount of agricultural products and is providing an adequate amount of employment, etc. So that the Land Commission can take cognisance of the fact that certain lands are near towns and cities and if they are producing food in the form of milk it will always be found that there is more employment given per 100 acres on a dairy farm than there is on any other farm. There is nothing in this Bill which says that unless a man tills 15, 20, 25 or 50 per cent. of his land he should be turned out. There are two factors: one is the employment factor and the other is the production factor. The production of milk is the production of food and it gives more employment than any other form of food production. So that from that point of view I do not think Senator Wilson need have any alarm. As I say, all that we are doing in the Bill is to state in legal form that the area of vested land which an owner can misuse is £2,000 worth.
Comment on this
The Minister in the latter portion of his speech referred to the amendment; the rest of his speech dealt with the section proper. Coming to the amendment, the Minister said that if the land was producing a sufficient amount of foodstuffs that would absolve that land from any interference, whereas the section which he quotes distinctly says that for the relief of congestion in the locality, unemployment and so on, it does not absolve it. It is there in black and white. No matter where you are situated in North County Dublin you are next to a village where there is any amount of unemployed people. No matter what way you work the land they are there. You will see them lined up along the wall. Unless for the relief of congestion in the locality, if you produce a certain amount of foodstuffs and engage a certain number of men then your land will not be touched. The Minister in the Dáil said something about the number of men that ought to be employed on a farm. I think he mentioned one man to 40 acres. Did he mean 40 statute or 40 Irish acres? I am not quarrelling with the Minister's estimate of the number that should be employed, but I know that there is a great deal of agitation in the minds of the people over this question of how many men ought to be employed. I want to ask would the householder and his wife and children and domestic servants be counted as being employed on a farm when reckoning the number of people to the acre, because there is a great deal of disturbance over this matter.
I am not arguing my own case at all. I am satisfied for him to take my land or not to take it because I am getting old and am willing to let the people who come after me fight their own battle. I am sure, if it were for the relief of congestion, I would be satisfied. But yesterday we had people coming here who were very much agitated about this. What I want to know from the Minister is this: Would the man and his wife and his children and his domestic servants count when reckoning the number of people on the land? That is a question that has to do entirely with the amount of land. I think the Minister should make a statement on that point. No attention at all has been directed to the factor that the rents are high, which means that the value is high; and that means that the area is relatively low and the amount of land that can be held in the vicinity of a city is limited. There is what is called accommodation land.
Comment on this
I would ask the Minister to redraft the whole of this section, No. 29. As it stands at present, I defy any man to understand it. A lawyer might be able to understand it but no ordinary lay man could possibly understand it. There are so many clauses and sub-clauses and insertions and parentheses of all kinds that at the end one does not know where one is. I think the Minister should consider writing the whole section out again and leaving out all these parentheses. As I have said already, nobody but a lawyer could understand it. Perhaps the difficulty could be met by making two or three sections out of it.
Comment on this
Senator Wilson asked for certain information and that is what I wanted to know also. There is another thing that is causing a great deal of disturbance in people's minds, and that is the question of the local committees which are to be set up to judge as to whose land is to be divided and to advise the Government accordingly. In my opinion, that is a most frightfully dangerous thing. Will the Minister define exactly from what class of people these committees are to be selected? Is it to be left to the Fianna Fáil clubs? If so, it will not be a matter of equity. It will mean that the local Fianna Fáil club will gather and say: "This person was against us at such-and-such a time and now is our time for revenge." That is what is disturbing the minds of the people very much. What are these committees to do? From what class are they to be drawn and what qualifications will they have?
Comment on this
Has this section anything to do with the question of the selection committees?
Comment on this
It was spoken about in the Dáil. Apart from the question of these committees, Senators ought to remember that when half the rest of the world were trying to get their cattle and farm produce into the British market we were able to beat them. The policy of the ex-Minister for Agriculture—the proper and reasonable and sensible policy—was to beat the commerce of other countries in cattle and every kind of farm produce in the British market, and we succeeded in doing that. No matter how many cattle or how much other farm produce came from other countries we could do that. In my opinion, in that respect, the Minister's argument is no good. His reply to Senator Wilson as to how many people are to be employed on a farm does not answer that question.
Comment on this
I am not going to follow the Minister or the other speakers with regard to the references to cattle, but the Minister made a statement to the effect that the land must be used to produce food for the people. What food, with the exception of wheat, does the Minister want us to produce that we are not producing already to the saturation point and at less than the cost of production— such as potatoes at less than 2/- a cwt., or oats, as Senator Miss Browne stated the other day, at 4/6 a cwt.? What sort of food, with the exception of wheat, is the Minister going to produce by splitting up the land?
Comment on this
I hesitate to intervene in this debate, because I have been through all this already. I take a certain savage delight in what I may call the economic tom-foolery that is going on, but I suppose it has got to go on and that we have to argue such matters in this unreal atmosphere.
Comment on this
Despite this, the Minister realises, of course, that the element of profit must come in, and yet he has not said a word as to whether or not a man makes a profit. He pictures a man tilling the land under some academic standard which his advisers tell him is the correct standard, and whether the man is making any profit or not out of the land does not matter. But everybody knows, of course, that you cannot sustain a system of that kind. Nobody wants to till land if it will not yield a profit. Senator Johnson and all these other pundits who talk about service cannot square a circle or make people farm land except with the purpose of making the land yield a profit. Evidently, however, this has got to go on until these people learn their lesson and until they bite the dust. In the papers to-day you have a case of land in the possession of the Land Commission for 20 years, and because a scheme was put forward in which the herd would get 20 years, the other claimants objected and rendered the scheme abortive and there is going to be bloody murder. However, I leave it to those lower down in the scale of those who hold land, like Senator Counihan.
Comment on this
Do not say "lower." We are as good a class as you are.
Comment on this
I was referring to the old landlords. Most of the old landlords have gone out of the State and they are only too glad to let their land. They would be better off if they no longer had the land. They are the people who were doing a public service, employing people on the land and providing the largest amount of employment in the country. It has come to this now, that if the Government want the land, let them have it, because the owners would be better off without it. I suggest to Senator Counihan that it would be more practicable to try to raise the standard of value and not to try to differentiate between towns. I think the people are in for a bad time anyhow.
Comment on this
Before putting the amendment, Sir, I should like to know if the Minister is going to reply to my question about the number of people employed on a farm.
Comment on this
There is no hard and fast rule laid down in this Bill. All that the Land Commission are compelled to do is, when they are examining land for acquisition or resumption, to take cognisance of the amount of employment that is being given and the amount of food which it is necessary to produce for the country. Senator Wilson referred to a speech which I made in the Dáil, and he seemed rather to believe that I had laid down some rule that a man must employ such and such a number of men per 100 acres or so. What I said was merely this, and it is subject to the fact that an acre of land is no standard of value, that taking good land and bad land lumped together, on farms over 100 acres in extent if there was one man extra employed per each 40 acres, there would be 100,000 extra men put on the land.
Comment on this
What is the calculation in respect of farms under 100 acres?
Comment on this
I forget. I was simply putting it that if we took it that farms under 100 acres were doing their bit in the matter of employment, and if lands over 100 acres in extent employed one man per each 40 acres, there would be 100,000 additional men placed on the soil.
Comment on this
Would the Minister accept an amendment on those lines?
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister if he could see his way to confirm a statement that he has made. I think it would relieve a good deal of anxiety in the part of the country I come from where we have not very many big ranches. The Minister said that no land under a valuation of £2,000 would be interfered with.
Comment on this
If that were so, it would be very encouraging, because the Minister knows as well as I do the struggle that we in the Northern counties had to get land at all, and I know that there would be a very great struggle before we gave up the land for which we had fought so strenuously and so long. I think it would be very unfair if farms of land were taken from people who put up such a long fight for them. There may be families in possession of lands who may not be in a position to till the land up to the required standard, but if the statement the Minister made to the effect that it was not intended to interfere with farms under £2,000 valuation were confirmed it would be very satisfactory.
Comment on this
I should like to draw the attention of the Minister to this phrase—
"... and the tenant or proprietor of the declared land or the wife or the husband of such tenant or proprietor resides on or in the immediate neighbourhood of the declared land and uses it in the same manner as an ordinary farmer in accordance with the proper methods of husbandry...."
This is a thing that occurs in my part of the country to a very great extent. A farmer with a number of children dies and leaves his wife and children on the land. They are unable to carry out the tilling of the land owing to the heavy burden constituted by the young children and, whether they like it or not, they have to sub-let the land to some other person, perhaps for several years. That is a case that has come under my own notice. I have known families in that position—good working people, but too busy rearing young children to be able to work the land. Those people do not fulfil the conditions. They are not working the land as proper farmers should, and they would be liable to have their land taken away under the wording of the section.
Comment on this
I think you have spoken three times already, Senator.
Comment on this
I merely want to withdraw the amendment. I tried three times to get up, but was not allowed.
Comment on this
I move amendment 22:—
Section 29, sub-section (1). After the word "Commissioners" in line 57 to insert the words "consider to be suitable for such tenant or proprietor and also consider".
Comment on this
This amendment, with No. 23, is introduced to give effect to a promise I made on the Fourth Stage in the Dáil to the effect that the alternative holding given to the tenant would be suitable to him.
Comment on this
I move amendment 23:—
Section 29, sub-section (1). To delete in line 59 the word "consider".
This is consequential on the previous amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:—
Section 29, sub-section (2). To insert before the sub-section a new sub-section as follows:—
(2) Where a tenant or proprietor is the owner of two holdings the market value of each of which exceeds £2,000 and on one of which such tenant or proprietor or the wife or husband of such tenant or proprietor resides and one of which, or portion of one of which, holdings is declared land, the Land Commission shall at the request of such tenant or proprietor withdraw the declaration that the declared land is required for the relief of congestion, and may declare the other of such holdings, or such portion thereof as the Land Commission think proper to be required for the relief of congestion.
That amendment more or less explains itself. Its object is to prevent cases of what may be very real hardship. It applies to the case where a tenant or proprietor is the owner of two holdings, both of them over £2,000 in value and on one of which he resides, and the Land Commission make up their minds to take from him the holding on which he does not reside or portion of it, for the purpose of the Act. That holding may be the one which gives the value to the two holdings and it may be the holding on which he really depends for his livelihood and his profit as a farmer of the two holdings. The object of the amendment is to give a man in that position the right to request the Land Commission to go to the other farm and take it for the purpose of relieving congestion. In this case, what is left to him must always be over £2,000, because both his holdings are over £2,000 and, therefore, he has not got the remedy given to the man with less than £2,000 land of claiming an alternative farm. He is left possibly with an absolutely uneconomic holding if the Land Commission cannot take the second holding, on which he does not live and on which he does not depend for his existence, from him. That is not right, and all that the amendment asks is that in such cases it should be within the power of the tenant or the proprietor to request the Land Commission to take the same amount of any land they require from him on the other holding. I should state that there are very few cases of this, but there are a number. They are not, however, very many, so it will not make very much difference in the administration of the Act.
Comment on this
The amendment is really very far-reaching. It annuls altogether the powers which the Land Commission were given under the 1923 Act. For the relief of urgent congestion in a district they were permitted and directed to acquire any land, whether vested land or fee-simple land. It is absolutely necessary that, in the last resort, the Land Commission should have that power.
Comment on this
That is, for the relief of congestion they should have the power, in the last extremity, to take even a vested holding in that locality. It might happen that a man had two holdings, one in one county and another 20 miles away. If the second holding is in a non-congested county the Land Commission are not interested in it, but they are really interested in the relief of congestion in a congested districts county, and if the other holding is in that county that is the farm they want to get. The other farm would be no good to them. Under the 1923 Act, all land in any part of the country could be taken for the relief of congestion. In the case of land that is giving adequate employment and providing an adequate amount of foodstuffs, we are restricting the taking of that land for the relief of congestion in the same locality. I think we have gone as far as we could go without upsetting things too much. If Senator Brown's amendment were carried, it would upset the Land Commission in a most vital part of their work.
Comment on this
I agree with the Minister that, if the second holding was 20 miles away, or even less, this would interfere with the powers of the Land Commission in relieving congestion. Therefore, I think the amendment might be amended by putting into it the words "in the same locality" or, "in the neighbourhood." With such an insertion, I think the objection that the Minister has made to the amendment would be removed, because he could get one of the two holdings in the immediate vicinity. I propose, with the leave of the House, to withdraw the amendment and put in an amendment for Report Stage with the addition that I have mentioned.
Comment on this
Before the amendment is withdrawn, I would like to call attention to the phraseology of the section proposed by Senator Brown with a view to his probably meeting the objection made when he is drawing up the new section. Presumably, the Commissioners will fix upon the holding which is suitable, but according to Senator Brown's amendment they must take at the request of the tenant another holding.
Comment on this
The amendment reads: "The Land Commission shall, at the request of such tenant or proprietor, withdraw the declaration that the declared land is required for the relief of congestion, and may declare the other of such holdings," etc.
Comment on this
My point is this: that the other holding may be a holding which is not suitable for the purposes of the Land Commission in respect of the relief of congestion or otherwise. Therefore, the Land Commission is deprived of the right of taking the suitable holding simply because the tenant or proprietor has two holdings, one of which may be suitable for the relief of congestion and the other may not.
Comment on this
Would Senator Brown be willing to have the amendment modified so as to secure that the holding which is offered by the tenant is a holding suitable for the purposes of the Land Commission?
Comment on this
Would the Minister say if there is any period in which a man must be in residence?
Comment on this
This Bill, when it becomes an Act, will depend for its success more than anything else on its administration. If the Land Commission were composed of celestial beings, I daresay it would work all right, but the Land Commission, being human, will be pressed from various places and by different people to do certain things. I know, for instance, a case that occurred in Leix, where land was taken from an old woman of over 70 years of age. She had not over much land, while a lot of land owned by other people suitable for the purpose was left to them. Therefore, I can only conclude that there must have been certain pressure put on the Land Commission to take this old lady's land. I do not know how that is going to be prevented. If we were all celestial beings it might be prevented, but we are not. I have had a certain amount of experience myself of these things, and I know that in many cases great hardships may be imposed. I do not see why the owner of one of these farms should be left with a barren piece of land and the good land that he has taken and handed over to a number of individuals. I think that in such a case the man himself ought to have a preference as to the land that he is to continue to live on. He has another farm vacant and why not take that? If the Land Commission want it for any purpose, they can use it. I do not think they should take away the good farm that the man himself has been living on.
Comment on this
My answer to Senator Comyn is this: that the Land Commission will not be left with the choice of taking the holding that would not be suitable for the relief of congestion. I cannot imagine any holding of the value of over £2,000 not being fit for the relief of congestion. I have asked the House to give me leave to withdraw the amendment, with the intention of putting in an amendment for Report Stage, which will confine this right to two holdings that are in the same locality.
Comment on this
I move amendment 26:—
Section 29. To add at the end of the section two new sub-sections as follows:—
(8) In any case in which the Land Commission provides the tenant or proprietor of a holding with a new holding under the provisions of this Act, the Land Commission shall pay such full compensation to such tenant or proprietor for all loss as is the direct result of his transfer to the new holding and shall also pay to such tenant or proprietor the actual cost of the removal by such tenant or proprietor of himself and his family and household and also of his stock, farm implements and furniture to the new holding.
(9) In the absence of agreement, the amount of the compensation payable under the next preceding sub-section shall be determined by the appeal tribunal.
The principle of compensation for disturbance was accepted in Section 23 of the Land Act of 1931, in connection with resumed holdings. Now I suggest, in connection with this Bill, that the House should consider the case of a man who is uprooted from his holding and sent elsewhere at the will of the Land Commission. I imagine there will not be many such cases. But I do not think the provision of a new holding, even if it is of equal market value, is sufficient to recoup a man for being moved from the place where he has been all his life, and in which generations of his family have lived. There are various objections to such removals. The first is the translation from the old home. That entails, first of all, the movement of his family, his goods, chattels and implements, and sometimes the removal of his stock, etc.
The practice has been in the past for free grants of amounts entirely at the will of the Land Commission and coming under the head of "removal expenses" to be given. That covered the case of the man who had to remove his family, but do not let us forget that these were all small men and that the grants have been small as well. I do not think that all the members of the House know that a member of the family of the migrant has been retained in the old holding until the new holding has been put in working order. Sometimes this occupation of the old holding and of the new holding has gone on for two years. A great deal of that is going to happen in the future—I mention it by the way now—however much the Minister speeds up migration. All the surrender agreements of the holdings have been conditional on this. The grants which have been made were satisfactory to the men to whom they were made, who were all willing migrants. In view of the proposed speeding up, I think that some type of acknowledgment of this liability should appear in the Bill, and that is why I put down this amendment.
One type of loss is not provided for under any of the powers of the Land Commission or its subsidiaries—that is, the incoming loss in the new holding. Removal very often means the purchase of a different type of stock. The migrant may have to buy his hay and corn at market prices for a certain time, instead of growing his own. He is entirely at the mercy of his neighbours. He may have as satisfactory turbary as he had before but it may be more difficult of access and he may not be able to reach it in the same time. Although I admit that the Land Commission and the Congested Districts Board always did their best to cause as little loss as possible to migrants, it is not always possible to synchronise their movement with the different operations of farming. All the matters I have mentioned are to a great extent a drain on the migrant's resources.
The question of labour is, I think, as important as any, as a definite, direct loss by reason of migration. In a congested district, labour is cheap. There is mutual assistance amongst the small holders who live close together and labour is sometimes given in return for the service of a bull. A man is removed to a ranch country. Labour is very scarce there and is, consequently, more expensive. I put down that as a very definite loss. The migrant has then to learn to work his new holding. He has got to learn the soil and this can only be learned by working it and gaining acquaintance with the conditions of the new country. I do not mind how long a man has been on the land, if he has remained in one townland all his life, he has got into a groove as regards the method of working that particular type of land. He is, no doubt, ready to take advice but he has got to adjust his ideas to the new conditions and it will be a very considerable time before he can get the best out of his new holding.
Another important point was touched upon by Senator Wilson this afternoon. That is that the man who will be compulsorily removed under this Act will, normally and usually, have purchased under earlier Acts than the 1923 Act. If he is under the 1903 Act, he has been paying 3½ per cent. He is removed to a 1923 holding, where he pays 4¾ per cent. That is a direct loss of 1¼ per cent. Because the State wants it, the old holding becomes accommodation land. By the compulsory removal of a farmer from a congested district, the State avoids all the expense of removing and housing a number of small holders. In exchange for the acquired holding, they provide one of equal face value, but not of equal value. If the holding given in exchange were to be developed by the Land Commission for the accommodation of migrants, it would entail very large expenditure of capital, whereas they take an old holding in a congested district which can be divided up amongst the neighbouring small holders at practically no cost at all or just the cost of fencing. I think that that item should, in all fairness, be added to the market value of the new holding which the man gets for his compulsory removal under this Bill. That may be for the good of the State but there is the fact. I do not know why such a man should suffer any loss. The migrants have been what I may call willing adventurers. The compensation has satisfied them and they have been prepared to suffer the other losses which I have mentioned—the incoming loss and the reduction of assets.
The situation is quite different now. In the speeding up of distribution most of the safeguards of any value are being swept away and the farmer car be compulsorily evicted from his farm and sent elsewhere. The Minister will say that sub-section (3) of Section 32 covers that. As a matter of fact, there are so many exceptions to that section that you can read it almost in any way. You can acquire land for any purpose but you shall not acquire it except for the relief of congestion. Again, you shall not acquire it except for the relief of congestion in the same locality. That seems to fine it down somewhat. Then it is not to be acquired if it is providing adequate labour and producing adequate food. That, apparently, is another safeguard but then we are told that the Land Commission must have regard to the area, to the situation, to the character of the land, the amount of congestion, to unemployment locally and generally through the country and finally, to the desirability of increasing production.
The Minister may say: "I require another ¼ per cent. tillage on every farm in the country." The land immediately comes under the Bill and it may be used not only for the relief of congestion but for all the excepted persons mentioned in another section, who include unemployed and landless men. With all these exceptions, the section may be read in any way. It is not as protective as the Minister so fluently told us in a speech just now. I think that the situation has entirely changed, and that "market value" does not compensate for this arbitrary disturbance in the course of speeding up. The incoming man into the old holding gets everything. He is at a definite advantage. The amendment which I put down is framed not to give a similar advantage to the man who is going into the new holding but to ensure that he will be at no loss.
It may be argued by the Minister that this is more than the State can afford. I think it is the same as in the case of arrears. Men who initiate reforms must count on the cost and must see that justice is done to all. As I stated on the Second Reading, some other means should be examined by which congestion could be catered for instead of relying so much on moving people. Some means should be examined which will not damage one citizen for the benefit of others, simply because the State is trying to do the thing on the cheap, or will not bear a proportion of the cost of what it has initiated. That is my case as regards compensation for removal. In this debate, as I predicted, I found the Minister extremely reasonable about most things that we suggested. He has evidently left a very considerable margin, and I trust this amendment will be included in it.
Comment on this
Senator The McGillycuddy of the Reeks' bill of costs for removal sounded like a lawyer's bill of costs, and, as far as I can see, it was so well stuffed that we will have to get someone else to tax them. The people that we propose should do so are the Land Commissioners. The Land Commission have already power under Section 48 of the Land Act of 1931 to grant such sums for or towards the expense of transferring migrants to new homes as the Land Commission may think fit. I was not quite sure what the Senator had in mind when he put down the amendment. I thought what was operating mostly with him was the actual removal expenses. If that is so, certainly, under the present scheme of administration, the removed person would be better off than he would be under the amendment. If the Land Commission compelled a removed person to supply them with a detailed vouched bill of costs that person would have got much less for removal than he got.
Comment on this
I think I admitted that the actual cost of removal from the old holding was already provided for.
Comment on this
That case was provided for, and was provided for much more liberally than would be the case if the removed person had to submit a vouched bill of costs. I asked the Land Commissioners to give me some idea of the amounts they gave. They gave lump sums of £50 or £100 or £150 in respect of removal expenses. That is part of the offer made and the man can transfer in his own way and in his own time. If that person had to produce vouchers for train fares, cattle fares and for his costs of removal perhaps he would get less money after all the trouble. Then the actual cost could only be ascertained after the exchange was completed. Where it is done without an estimate of what the cost will be, the Land Commission will give what they consider will be a fair lump sum to cover the cost of removal. If any of the men who were moved were consulted I think it would be found that they had been dealt with pretty liberally.
One of the things Senators are trying to do is to cover every possible action of the Land Commissioners by some section in the Bill. That cannot be done. If we sat here until Tibb's Eve we could not get down in black and white sections covering all the activities, and the shades of difference in the activities, of the Land Commission inspectors. This procedure has worked out for a number of years, and, notwithstanding the fact that the Land Commission had powers far in excess of what Senators seem to imagine, they operated them in a fair way. When a man was removed he got more than the equal market value. One of the reasons for cutting down the amount of land a man has a legal right to get, as an alternative to the holding from which he is disturbed, is the fact that the Land Commission have been compelled in some cases to give almost twice the area and value of land to migrants from the West. That resulted in migrants going into a district in the East in which there was some local congestion, where landless men were accustomed to take land on the 11 months' system. These migrants came in and got what appeared to have been another ranch and that caused a lot of local disturbance. It is for that reason we have cut down the alternative holding to £2,000. That is one of the principal reasons, I believe, why it can be safely left to the Land Commission to give a fair exchange and to give fair removal expenses. Senators should remember that owners of land do not belong to one political party, but to all political parties, and that each section is as much interested in seeing that the land is divided in a fair and reasonable way as the other. If the Land Commission acted in any other way, I do not think Senators or Deputies would be any more tongue-tied in the future than in the past. They would certainly kick up a row if the Land Commission acted unfairly towards anyone in such circumstances.
Comment on this
What is to happen to the person whose land is taken away but who remains on in the house? If he objects to his land being taken, he goes to law, and spends money on attorneys or barristers in advocating his case against the land being taken. Up to now the judge allots what he considers the proper price to cover the law expenses but the price he allots is not a quarter or a half of what the individual ought to get and what he has really expended. That may be provided all right in this Bill but that was not the case in the past. Is there anything in the Bill which would make the Land Commission which has taken away a man's land pay for the cost of any objection a man might make to the Land Commission?
Comment on this
If there is no change it is very unfair that the land should be taken away from him and when he objects he will find that he will have to pay the whole of the legal expenses. That is very unfair and I know cases where it happened.
Comment on this
There would be a good deal to be said for what the Minister has urged—that up to the present the Land Commission has been giving lump sums—what he calls reasonably fair— and that that has satisfied the people. That would be all right or it might be all right if those estimated costs of removal and damage owing to removal were based on some facts supplied by the migrant himself or on bills that he had paid and facts that he had brought to the notice of the Land Commission. But if it is to be a mere guess by the Land Commission as to what they ought to give, then this might create a very great hardship. I do not know how they estimated this in the past. If it is done on information there is a good deal to be said for it. Taxing bills of this kind would be a troublesome and prolonged operation.
Comment on this
The Land Commission would have more definite information than the migrant himself because they have done it already several times before.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned that the Land Act of 1931 has apparently given some statutory justification for these payments to the Land Commission. Where is it?
Comment on this
That is at present the sole justification for these payments?
Comment on this
These are the words of Section 48 of the Land Act of 1931:
"The powers of the Land Commission to expend money for the benefit or improvement of land purchased or agreed to be purchased under the Land Purchase Acts shall extend to and include the grant, where the Land Commission think it expedient, of such sums for or towards the expenses of transferring migrants to their new holdings as the Land Commission may think fit."
That is exactly what Senator Brown was referring to. If we had some knowledge of what the Land Commission think fit then it would be different. This was in respect of the class of individual that had been migrated in the past, but when it is a case of the passing of a measure into which compulsion has been brought we ought to put in something which would say that these sums were based on information given to the Land Commission by the individual who has been migrated or that it was being the subject of agreement, or as in the last part of Senator The McGillycuddy's amendment, failing agreement there was some chance of the individual migrated having his claim considered. It hardly seems right to make that the sole clause under the new arrangement. There should be added to it that in the absence of agreement the amount of compensation to be paid should be determined by the appeal tribunal. If we put in some section of that kind in addition to Section 48 of the Land Act of 1931 we would be carrying some certainty that the judge would have the right to say that the man should be paid his own costs. But to presume that because the Land Commission have acted rightly with people willing to migrate in the past, they will act rightly in the case of people being compelled to migrate under this Bill is presuming too much. It would be only fair to put something into the Bill or to adopt something of Section 48 of the Act of 1931 so that the man who is being migrated would have some chance of stating his case.
Comment on this
It should also be remembered that migrants who were compensated under the 1931 Act had little to remove and there were people who were willing to go. They had little to remove except themselves and their families, but here you are removing people who have a farm worth £2,000 properly worked and stocked. You are removing these with their family and their farming implements.
Comment on this
Senator Brown is wrong in saying that the men who were removed heretofore had little to move. I think, as a matter of fact, it was the very large farmers who were removed. The last man who was removed got £200 for his expenses. I think that if Senator The McGillycuddy knew the Governmental accounting system he would recognise that in pressing this amendment he would be doing the migrants a disservice. If he is going to put down that the migrant is going to get his removal expenses then vouchers will have to be produced, and the Land Commission cannot act as generously in most cases as they have done up to now. I again say that instead of helping the migrant it will be doing him a disservice, in my opinion.
Comment on this
There is a good deal to be said for the Minister's statement in regard to sub-section (8) in the amendment. I would suggest to Senator The McGillycuddy to withdraw the amendment and we might have something inserted on Report Stage which would ensure removal expenses to the migrant.
Comment on this
I take it that the Senator will not press his amendment even in a modified form. Let us just take his own amendment. It says: "...the Land Commission shall pay such full compensation to such tenant or proprietor for all loss as is the direct result of his transfer to the new holding ..." If that passes it will mean not merely an appeal to the appeal tribunal but to the Supreme Court. It would mean that in every case, if we take Senator The McGillycuddy's speech as an indication, there should be included in the loss various items. He would go so far as to include the loss of cattle, resulting from want of knowledge of the new holding and loss arising from the fact that the tenant in the new holding would lose money because he did not understand the nature of the soil. I think if the Senator confined himself to the second part of the amendment it would be better.
Comment on this
I am only taking the words of the amendment. There is loss in it the moment you put in direct loss. It would mean that this would be a case not merely for the appeal tribunal, but for the Supreme Court.
Comment on this
I agree with Senator Comyn that the idea of a multiplicity of appeals is to be deprecated. I would point out to the House and to the Minister that this shifting of men from one place to another is a thing which is associated in the minds of citizens of civilised countries with nothing less than conditions of a state of war. I know of no precedent for this sort of thing, but as a result of a state of war. This removal of people from one place to another is such a frightfully drastic thing when it is done under compulsion. I think the question of compensation should be looked upon very liberally, because it is a terrible thing compulsorily to remove people. We associate this kind of thing as arising out of a situation of a state of war and nothing less.
Comment on this
I think I must correct Senator Comyn on one point which has reference to the second part of my amendment regarding a transfer to a new holding. I admitted already that there is provision made by the Land Commission. The main part of the whole thing is that a person who is transferred should be compensated for all losses directly resulting from the transfer. That was the main point of my remarks. The Minister assured us that generous provision is made in the case of a transfer. I agree with that, but they are not over-generous. I come from a very congested district and I am aware that when a man is being moved they inquire down to the last penny before they recommend a grant. They certainly are very careful. There is no very generous grant and no throwing out of money. The Minister stops short at the point of what I call translation from the old holding expenses. He did not deal with the point I made about the incoming expenses, the loss during establishment and, finally, the loss of asset which I suggest exists. Those remain the major points of the whole argument.
Comment on this
What would come under this "full compensation for all loss which is the direct result of the transfer"? Will the Senator give an example? For instance, if a man's children were in a good school in one part of the country could he claim compensation because another school was not as good?
Comment on this
There are several things that would come under the heading of losses directly due to the transfer. I think I have made my points quite clear.
Comment on this
Can the Senator give us any example of the full compensation for all loss arising as a direct result of the transfer?
Comment on this
I have already instanced two points. There also arises the question of a deficiency of labour in one place as against a plentiful supply of labour in another district.
Comment on this
And all that is to come before the appeal tribunal and, if there is an appeal, before the Supreme Court.
Comment on this
It could not go to the Supreme Court under this Bill.
Comment on this
I hope the Senator will not press this amendment, because I can see very serious results if it were accepted. I believe the situation will be such—that is, if we are to believe any of the statements made in this House recently—that people will be more than anxious to sell their land to the Land Commission. If the idea the Senator has in mind were put into effect I believe it would create a spirit of unrest in the country and we would soon have a nation on wheels. It would develop into a sort of joy-ride, people would be so anxious to get compensation with all the facilities that have been mentioned. Senator Bagwell said he was not aware of any other occasion in this country when people were moved about in the manner suggested here. I will refer the Senator who has, I am sure, a knowledge of Irish history, to 1847. If he will look up that period he will find that the people were moved very quickly then and they were not compensated to any such extent as it is proposed to compensate them under this measure.
Comment on this
May I be allowed to intervene in order to add to war, famine?
Comment on this
I will appeal to Senator The McGillycuddy to withdraw this amendment. I could quote him cases where direct loss would ensue. A good deal would depend on the type of farm. If it were the case of a dairy farmer going into a new place he might have no food for his cattle and a whole lot of things like that. I think the Senator would be advised, having regard to the way these migrants have been dealt with up to the present, to withdraw this amendment and perhaps we might get something more agreeable to the Minister on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
We might, on Report, get an amendment which would make more definite the concessions that have been given by the Land Commission and give some claim to the people who are to be migrated. There is a great deal of good in what Senator Wilson said.
Comment on this
If the Minister will consider the points I made in regard to losses outside the actual losses of transfer and removal I will not press the amendment.
Comment on this
I move the adjournment of the House until 3 o'clock to-morrow.
Comment on this
I think it would be better if we sit until 10.30.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 27:—
Section 29. To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
(8) Nothing in this section shall empower the Land Commission to declare that any land which is held by a religious community and which is being utilised in connection with a branch of such community shall be required for the purposes of sub-section (1) of this section.
The land which is attached to religious communities is, in my opinion, essential and makes for the convenience, comfort, and prosperity of such community. By no stretch of imagination can even the most easily convinced of our Senator friends call the land attached to such a community a ranch. That is one reason why it should be accepted. The fact that it is such an asset to these communities is one strong reason which justifies the acceptance of this amendment. I do not visualise for one moment that this Government would think of taking the land from such communities.
Governments come and Governments go, but none go on for ever. We do not know, to-day, what Government may be in power in the near future. A Government might come into power that would have no scruple in taking lands from religious communities. They might defend their action by saying, what might be said, not for the first time: "We are only using the machinery we found in order to justify our taking this action." That argument would be made use of by people who would take such action. I am not very much afraid such will happen; but it is no harm to take precautions. I am myself opposed to any Government taking powers they do not require, and giving as a reason for doing so that they would never use them. I do not see the necessity or advantage of taking such powers if they are not to be made use of. It may be an oversight that exemption was not made in regard to religious communities in this Bill. I was, in fact, surprised when putting this amendment down, that others did not put in an amendment to the same effect. Anyhow, this is not an amendment that requires very much justification in asking for its acceptance. I think it would be a very good and sensible thing for the Government to accept it.
Comment on this
If we are to have an amendment of this kind at all it ought not to be confined to land in the possession of religious communities. There are a large number of other bodies who ought not to be interfered with. There are lands in connection with schools which are very necessary for those institutions. There are lands in connection with asylums, public and private, which are very necessary for them. I would suggest, in matters of this kind, that it might well be left to the good sense of the Land Commission not to interfere with such lands.
Comment on this
If ever such a party came into power and was prepared to do what the amendment seeks to prevent, they would make very little opposition to any argument, logical or otherwise, that might be used to prevent them. They would put an end to all such argument. If so, what is the good of having this safeguard? As Senator Brown said, these things would be much better left to the good sense of the Land Commission instead of making a speciality of one class of people.
Comment on this
There is no reason why the Land Commission would want to do anything of this kind. If the lands were under £2,000 value they would have to provide these people with suitable alternative holdings. Where would they get them? To where would they move a religious community, an asylum, or a school?
Comment on this
I did not move this amendment for a joke. I am very serious about it. Even if there is no danger that such action will be taken by this Government, and I know well there is no such danger, there is still the possibility, remote though it may be, of a Government coming into power in the future that might possibly move in that direction. Even though some Senators say that if a Government got into power of a type that would take these lands they would make no bones about taking such steps whether this machinery was there or not. But when the machinery is there it would be an excuse for them, and things could be so evenly balanced between scrupulousness and covetousness, that the fact of the power being there might be the turning point in their taking such action. I am very serious and very anxious that this amendment should be introduced into the Bill. I did not for a moment imagine that there would be all this talk about it.
Comment on this
Before the discussion goes further, I would like to know, from the mover of the amendment, whether he has the consent of the religious houses in Ireland or, more important still, whether he has the consent of the Hierarchy, because all these houses are under the Bishops in their dioceses. I think an amendment of this kind should not be put forward unless the Senator has secured the consent I have indicated. I would like to know whether he has that consent.
Comment on this
I do not see why the mover of this amendment should be asked whether he has this consent that Senator Mrs. Wyse Power talks of. I think Senator Garahan's amendment is a just one, a common-sense one and a necessary one. We know the history of our country. Such things happened in the past and I think it is necessary to have such provision as this amendment seeks. We know the necessity that prevails for colleges to have land. It is necessary to feed the community and the pupils and to provide proper facilities for such institutions. I am surprised that in an assembly like this, objection should be raised to this amendment.
Comment on this
We do not believe for one moment that the present Government would make any such change. Senator Johnson laughs. From an Englishman's point of view this may be an extravagant motion, but, from the point of view of the history of this country, we know what we suffered in the past, and I hope Senator Johnson will control himself.
Comment on this
I deny absolutely that I laughed, or smiled or made any indication in regard to this proposition.
Comment on this
I am not blind, and I could see Senator Johnson smile very plainly before me.
Comment on this
The Senator should accept the denial made by Senator Johnson.
Comment on this
I accept the denial at your suggestion, but I am surprised that there should be any objection to this, and I hope the Minister will realise the necessity for accepting it. The Minister should know as well as Senators here know that it is a necessary amendment. I hope Senator Garahan will press his amendment.
Comment on this
In reply to Senator Mrs. Wyse Power I may say that I know these communities are very much concerned about this. There is growing in this country, whether you like it or not, a spirit of avarice and cupidity. I know several large farms which are especially the envy of certain people included amongst landless men. They would not think anything about grabbing from these religious communities. I think this amendment is most necessary and I hope the Senator who moved it will go to a division in order to have it inserted in the Bill.
Comment on this
I am at a terrible disadvantage in this House. My hearing is very good, but the acoustic properties of this Chamber are very bad. I blame that alcove over your head, a Chathaoirligh. I cannot hear people in front of me although my hearing is good and some Senators tell me that when I get up to speak I speak too loudly. I do not want to speak loudly, but I tell Senators in front of me that when they speak I cannot hear them. With reference to this amendment we have people running educational establishments, hospitals, convalescent homes and monasteries, and I say they are all doing good work. I do not care who says that they have too much land. I say that any land they have I would leave to them. I am surprised at Senator Mrs. Wyse Power getting up and asking the proposer of the amendment had he the consent of the Hierarchy. We know something about the history of Ireland, and that the people who defended the monasteries in the olden days had not the consent of the inhabitants of the monasteries to defend them. They did, however, defend them and I hope it will be always so in Ireland.
We heard quite a lot of jeers from the opposite benches since I came here about Senator Sir John Keane. You had the celebrations in Mount Melleray the other day. I do not want to pay any compliments to Senator Sir John Keane and I am sure that he does not wish that I should pay them to him either, but it is always well to state the truth. When the Cistercians came to Ireland they got a place in Ireland from Senator Sir John Keane's ancestors. I know something about my ancestry, and I know that in towns in the West of Ireland some of the landlords would not give the parishioners a site for a Catholic church or, as they called them at the time, Catholic chapels. That shows, at any rate, that Senator Sir John Keane's ancestors were something better than the ancestors of other landlords. To go further, I remember meeting Senator Sir John Keane in the real troubled times when he was doing good work for Ireland in the economic line. I met him in the Metropole Hotel in Waterford. I think that Mrs. Power, the proprietress, was a sister of one of our Senators. If I am wrong, Senator Mrs. Wyse Power can correct me.
Comment on this
Right. I was present in Power's Hotel one day in Waterford. I was there on ordinary business which had no connection with the meeting that was being held there that day.
Comment on this
I dare say the Senator will show the connection with the amendment.
Comment on this
I will bring it to the amendment in a moment. As I have referred to Mount Melleray, I want to show that Senator Sir John Keane was following in the footsteps of his ancestors. Possibly other Senators do not think so. I frequently get letters asking me not to vote the same way as Senator Sir John Keane. I make no apology for voting the same way because, when we wanted help, Senator Sir John Keane helped us economically; I do not say politically. He helped us economically. I was having luncheon in that hotel after doing my ordinary business. I was watched by the R.I.C. all the time. Senator Sir John Keane and certain members of the co-operative factory in Waterford, which was really sponsored by Sinn Féin, came in to have their luncheon at the same hotel, and for the first time in my life I was introduced to Senator Sir John Keane. I was glad to meet him because he was doing Ireland's work, although it might be said that it was only economically. Other people do Ireland's work but they do it in a destructive way. He was doing it in a constructive way, and I agreed with that. It was a pure accident that the whole lot of us were not lodged in Ballybricken jail that evening. Instead of sneers at Senator Sir John Keane, a descendant of the men who handed over Mount Melleray to the Cistercians, the man who was doing his work for Ireland on that day, if he were shoved into Ballybricken that evening, everybody on the opposite benches to-day would be calling him Seán O Cathain and he would be a hero because he was put into jail. I think the real hero is the man who does his work for Ireland. I think that it is very bad policy for this House to agree with any interference with the lands that are held by religious orders in this country. I could say much more about it if I wished but I ask the House to agree with Senator Garahan's amendment.
Comment on this
I hope that in forming our opinion as to how to vote on this amendment, if there is any vote, we will not be in any way swayed by any consideration of religious persecution in the past or have any particular advertence to the history of religious institutions. This is a matter of cold legislation. I am impressed by what Senator Brown said. This amendment seeks to exclude certain lands from the provisions of this Act provided they are held by religious bodies. I certainly say that the arguments which could be put forward in support of this amendment could apply equally to the lands which he mentioned, lands held by asylums, by educational bodies——
Comment on this
——boarding schools and so on. The very same arguments apply. If we are going to differentiate in one category, why not differentiate in respect of other categories? I submit to Senator Garahan, with great respect, that he should make his amendment more comprehensive, that we should not select one section and say that they shall be immune from the application of the Bill, whereas there are other sections which are just as worthy which are left open to the operations of the Act. I am certainly of Senator Brown's opinion that the amendment should be made more comprehensive or withdrawn.
Comment on this
I wish to repeat that there is a spirit of Bolshevism growing up in almost every village. It is directed against religion and against religious institutions. I have heard it myself. It is not directed against the other institutions to which Senator O'Hanlon referred.
Comment on this
I would also like to point out that the religious communities referred to in this amendment are not defined very clearly. As Senator Brown has stated, there are other communities which are equally entitled to protection from the Land Commission and from any interference with their lands or with their institutions. They are doing good work educationally and otherwise, and they should not be interfered with. I think it would be a very unusual suggestion to make, that the Land Commission have any desire or will take upon themselves the responsibility, to interfere with any such institution. I have faith in the integrity, the wisdom and intelligence of the Land Commission, and I know that such a thing will never arise. I appeal to Senator Garahan to amend the amendment in the sense suggested and not allow any distinction to be made between religious and educational bodies.
Comment on this
Some Senator has suggested I should withdraw the amendment and bring in an amendment of a more comprehensive nature on the Report Stage. I do not know in what respect it could be made more comprehensive except by including educational establishments. I am satisfied to withdraw my amendment and to express my intention of moving a further amendment on the Report Stage, although I must say that I protest against the fact that I have to do so.
Comment on this
I do not think the Senator ought to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
Does the House give permission to have the amendment withdrawn?
Comment on this
The Senator is not the whole House. The amendment is, by leave, withdrawn.
Comment on this
I protest against the withdrawal of the amendment also. I do not think it is fair. I think it is a necessary amendment and that the mover should insist upon it.
Comment on this
Senators Toal and Miss Browne can be taken as protesting.
Comment on this
Sub-section (4) states: "Sub-section (5) of Section 24 of the Land Act, 1923, is hereby repealed." I want to ask the Minister why that particular sub-section is being repealed. In the course of the debate on one of the amendments the Minister dealing with food production said the farmer should take cognisance of the food required and produced. I want him to explain that further and tell us how the farmer is to do that. Is it proposed that the Land Commission or the Department of Agriculture will issue a statement as to the amount of food required for the year and the amount the farmer will be expected to contribute to that total? If so, will that amount be for the home market or will it be for the export trade? If for the export trade, will it be for an alternative market to the market we have lost?
Comment on this
If the Minister promises to explain his views on Section 32 I will not ask him to explain them now. I would ask him to give the reason for the repeal of this sub-section of the Land Act of 1923.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, I must try to confine the discussion on the amendments to the matter in the amendments and to the section. We cannot rove any further.
Comment on this
Slightly. The question is that Section 29 stand part of the Bill.
Comment on this
On a point of procedure, I asked for a definite reply on a certain matter and I think I am entitled to it. I asked the Minister to state the reason why that sub-section of the Land Act of 1923 is being repealed, and I am surely entitled to an answer.
Comment on this
The Senator is quite right then. Perhaps the Minister will answer the question.
Comment on this
Sub-section (5) of the Land Act of 1923 reads:—
(5) The Land Commission shall not without the consent of the owner acquire land from him under the powers conferred on them by sub-section (3) of this section so long as there is other unacquired land in the same locality suitable for relieving congestion which does not come within the exceptions mentioned in sub-section (2) of this section and which the Land Commission can acquire without exercising the special powers given by the said sub-section.
It was found in operation that owners of land appealed against the acquisition on the ground that there was other unacquired land in the same locality. In a great number of cases that held up the acquisition of lands which were really suitable for the relief of congestion, and that is the reason it is being repealed.
Comment on this
I move amendment 28:—
Section 32, sub-section (3). After the word "land" in line 64 to insert the words "and the farm buildings thereon."
This amendment asks that the Land Commission in considering the acquisition of land should have regard to this in addition to the other matters mentioned in the section. In the case of a holding having a large number of farm buildings it would be uneconomic to leave such a holding without land proportionate to the buildings thereon. The amendment asks that the Land Commission should have regard to the buildings on the holding when deciding to take portion of a farm compulsorily. The amendment merely asks the Land Commission to see what buildings there are on the land and does not compel them to desist from taking the land on account of that. It merely asks that this should be one of the matters they would consider. I see no harm in the section if the Minister accepts the amendment.