We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

County Management Bill, 1939—Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–137 of 294. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill County Management Bill, 1939
Enacted

No. 20 of 1939 ›

In the absence of Senator Lynch, I have agreed to move the following amendment standing in his name:—

1. To insert the following new subsections:—

(2) If within one month after the passing of this Act an elective body, by resolution, declares that the provisions of this Act should not apply or have effect in relation to such elective body, the adoption of such resolution shall operate to exclude from the operation of this Act such elective body and the provisions of this Act shall thereupon cease to apply to such excluded body.

(3) A resolution adopted for the purpose of the next preceding sub-section of this section may be rescinded by an excluded body at any time.

The expression "excluded body" means an elective body which has adopted the resolution referred to in sub-section (2) of this section.

I think the advocates of this Bill claim for it that it will be effective in bringing about a more efficient administration of local government. We believe that the right to opt out of the Bill should be a cardinal feature of the Bill, and the amendment seeks to establish that right. I am sure there are many elective bodies discharging their duties in an efficient manner who resent the effort made to deprive them of that right. The amendment endeavours to establish the right of such bodies to opt out, if, by resolution, they declare that the provisions of the Act shall not apply, have effect or have relation to such elective bodies.

Sub-section (3) provides that if at any time an elective body wishes to rescind a resolution to opt out it can do so. We think that in view of the efficient and loyal service given by these people to local government, they ought to have that right. Many councils resent the effort to deprive them of the power to give useful social service to the community. If the intention in the Bill is to remove from people the right of local administration, then I am sure the Minister will object to any body opting out, but I think it good that we should establish that right, in view of the efforts being made to lessen the right of the people to take an efficient and intelligent part in the administration of our affairs.

Comment on this

I second the amendment.

Comment on this

I oppose the amendment, and I believe that if it were accepted it would nullify the whole purpose of the Bill. It has been said, and I agree, that there are many county councils very efficient and doing their work in such a way that nobody could take exception to them, but the fact that these councils will have a county manager will not make them less efficient. I think the majority of the councils who are efficient are the councils which would welcome the appointment of a county manager so that some of the responsibility might be taken off their shoulders, and, for that reason, I think the Minister should not accept the amendment.

Comment on this

This amendment, if passed, would cut across the whole principle of the Bill which was accepted on Second Reading. Elective bodies include borough councils, urban councils, town commissioners, boards of assistance, mental hospitals and port sanitary authorities, and if the Bill is not to apply to these, I do not know to whom it might apply. The proposal would not be workable for one thing. Suppose a council did not opt out and some of the bodies under it did, you would have the whole thing divided up in the most extraordinary way, with the manager not responsible for the main portion of the duties that should be assigned to him. I cannot accept the amendment.

Comment on this

What is the case for making the Dublin City Manager identical with the Dublin County Manager? I should like to hear some case being made for that. Quite a number of points arise in connection with it. There is Dublin City; there is the coastal Borough of Dun Laoghaire; and there is Dublin County. At present, these three places are separate, and have three separate staffs. The intention of the Bill is to put one individual manager in charge of the whole of that area. That is a very large job, and it is being done before these places are themselves formally amalgamated at all. Are they going to retain, for example, the three separate staffs, and what are the functions of the assistants going to be? I do not know if I am quite in order, but this whole matter arises again on Section 9. For the moment, I should like to know what the case is for making the Dublin City Manager manager also for the county and the coastal borough.

Comment on this

As the Senator knows, there are a number of services common to Dublin County and City, such as mental hospitals and so on. A recommendation was made in the Greater Dublin Commission Report as to an amalgamation of Dublin City and County, but we do not think the present time opportune to submit proposals to the Oireachtas for that amalgamation. What we have in mind, however, is—and it does not in any way prejudice the Oireachtas dealing with the matter later—that we should have the machinery set up, so that if it were decided afterwards to go ahead with the Greater Dublin scheme, the machinery would be available for operation. It might be considered that the Dublin City Manager's position is pretty big, but I do not think it would be any bigger than that of the manager in County Cork when you take into account the number of elective bodies in that county.

Difficulties arise from time to time, which, if we have the same manager for Dublin City and County, there might be means of avoiding. The most recent case brought to my notice is this difficulty about school meals for children at Crumlin. The position which has arisen there is that the school is built in County Dublin, a few yards outside the city boundary, while, of course, the children are from inside the city area. You have some conflict of interest between bodies in cases such as that, but, if you had the same manager, he could appreciate the difficulties and devise ways of getting over them much more easily than would be the case if you had different managers for different areas.

When the county manager takes up his position as manager for Dublin City and County, he will, in the first instance, be manager for both. He will be in control of the assistant managers for County Dublin who may be dealing with affairs of County Dublin. As to how he is going to assign duties to these people, I have not any clear picture, and I do not know whether he will bring the present manager of Dun Laoghaire into the City Hall and assist him in operating from there, or whether he will assign a certain number of institutions to one of the assistant managers. He might, for example, assign an assistant manager to Grangegorman and the Dublin Board of Public Assistance, or he might assign another assistant manager to deal with such institutions as Rathdown Union and Balrothery. It will be a matter of working it out. I do not think it will do any harm, and if it is ever decided by the Oireachtas to go ahead with the unification of the city and county, the administrative machinery will be available.

Comment on this

Will the staff remain intact in the two places?

Comment on this

They will. There will be a secretary to the Dublin County Council, in addition. The present secretary will remain as secretary, if he is not selected by the Appointments Commissioners as assistant manager, and there will be a town clerk also in Dun Laoghaire. The staffs will remain as they are.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Then there will be the same manager for three separate staffs.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:—

To insert after sub-section (2), in page 4, the following new sub-sections:—

(3) The Minister may, by order, whenever he so thinks proper, prescribe rules and regulations, in regard to the educational or other qualifications of candidates, who may offer themselves for consideration by the Local Appointments Commission, for recommendation to the offices of county manager, assistant county manager, city manager and assistant city manager.

(4) The Minister may whenever he so thinks proper, revoke or amend any such rules and regulations made by him under the preceding sub-section.

(5) Every rule or regulation made, revoked or amended by the Minister under this section shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as conveniently may be after it is made and if either such House shall, within the next 21 days on which it sits after the order is laid before it, pass a resolution annulling such order, rule or regulation, such order, rule or regulation shall be annulled accordingly, but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done thereunder.

This amendment arises out of the fact that I thought the complexity of local government had now become such that serious consideration must be given to the necessity for special education of the servants of local authorities and particularly of the more superior officials. Under the present Bill, the method of appointing the first officers is probably the best which can be found at the moment, and does not contemplate the uniformity of knowledge and education which my amendment allows the Minister to lay down, as and when the correct time arrives.

As I have said before, this complexity does call—in the interest of the public—for some scheme of general education in the various subjects which managers—and, in later years, the subordinate officials of local authorities—will definitely require. Even though it may be fully realised by Senators, I feel it is not realised by the general public, that both managers and assistant managers in these days must know a great deal more than a little about a whole lot of things. They need to know about road construction and maintenance, as they will now have to superintend the county surveyor, who will be completely under their control. They will have to know something about the building of hospitals and sanatoria, about the picking of the right kind of sites and giving the right ideas to experts. Then there is the question of housing and the complicated one of town planning, and also the questions of home assistance, the provision of water and sewerage, education and scholarships and a host of other things. A man brought up as an apprentice to a carpenter by rule of thumb—as a great many people have been in years past—must know what that position has become since, and that he is not going to be so well qualified to cover all the ground as a man who has been educated on definite lines. I think common sense and experience go an immense way and the educated fellow cannot possibly do without them, yet the trained man will definitely use his brains to better advantage.

Would any Senator in this House commit his affairs to a lawyer not inscribed on the Law Society Register or to a doctor whom the medical profession did not approve of or who was not on their register? In the same way it seems to me to be most important that the public should be given the advantages of some form of training of their officials. I feel that the Minister misunderstood me when I mentioned university training or training in the same way as civil servants. What I visualised was really some form of diploma, not necessarily a long course at a university, which the young man could not afford, but study in his own time. He would know that when he has passed a certain examination he is going to be qualified.

I am not really dealing with the first appointment of managers, but with the qualifications of managers in future years as they arise, and I suggest that the Minister may lay down some course which would lead to a diploma, to be issued either by him or by a board appointed by him, which would cover generally the following subjects which I have in mind: a general knowledge of the Irish language and Irish history; a knowledge of public administration, a great deal of which will have to be learned from experience on county councils or elected bodies; a knowledge of economics and public finance; some idea of modern political institutions, so that he may be able to apply his mind to advising Ministers as they come along, in regard to local institutions; a knowledge of business administration, not only the rule of thumb method as laid down for civil service and local authorities examinations, but also statistics; and a general knowledge of law and engineering. These are many and varied things, but the manager who is going to carry out the laws laid down by the Department of Local Government and Public Health in these days must have an all-round knowledge of these things.

Looking forward again, I would suggest the principle that—taking for granted that the applicants have the character and other characteristics required in a manager—only those should be considered who can achieve the highest form of diploma or standard which the Minister may lay down. Later on, other officials would get Certificate A or B and work their way up to the top. People may say that a diploma of this kind only provides us with a "Jack-of-all-trades." I would rather look at the matter otherwise. The man who is definitely striving for a high standard in the elements of his profession would be very much better able to estimate the value of the various proposals which come before managers of local bodies for housing and other things and he would be able to check up on what the experts put forward. He would be able to do that much better than he would with only a bare smattering of the subject. When he has checked up, he will be a wise man and will not meddle with the expert once he has approved of the plan but will let him carry the thing out according to the financial rules which his council have laid down.

Naturally, I do not specify any time for this to be introduced, and I say: "The Minister may, by order, whenever he so thinks proper...". I want to try to establish the principle that, in years to come, when there has been time to consider this thing and to consult with the universities and other authorities, the Minister may be able to say: "Now, for the next batch of managers which I am going to put into place as vacancies occur, I am going to require the following qualifications." Such officials as are at present serving in local government in the counties or under elected bodies and who propose to put themselves forward as candidates for these higher appointments will be warned to study on certain lines. I hope the result of this will be that in future years the public will get a very much finer service than we have at the present moment.

Comment on this

I would like to give my strong personal support to the object of this amendment. Unlike one of the other amendments with which we have just dealt, so far from being a wrecking one it seems to develop the main purpose of the Bill and to be one which the Minister should receive with the utmost sympathy. As I conceive it, the main purpose of the Bill is to ensure that those who administer our local affairs shall be expert in the art and science of administration.

Public administration is both an art and a science. It requires for its successful conduct not only skill— which may be largely a personal quality and a matter of practical training—but a knowledge of a number of difficult and complicated sciences which form the background of all successful local administration. Therefore, it is not enough to rely, as we seem to be doing in the present phraseology of this Bill, on the acquired skill of existing county secretaries, and so on. No doubt, those men in many cases are very able and valuable public servants. We ought to do something on the lines suggested by Senator The McGillycuddy to encourage these men to acquire, in addition to their practical training, a knowledge of those theoretical sciences which are at the foundation of all successful public administration. This is a matter which has attained to considerable development in other countries. There exists—in England, I think—a body known as the Institute of Public Administration, which provides courses and examinations in the various sciences which form the background of public administration. Such subjects as law, economics, finance and others important in that connection, are included.

Now the Institute of Public Administration has much the same function in relation to the practical work of local government and administrators in England, as the Bankers' Institute has in relation to the practical work of bank clerks. The banks for a very good reason encourage their clerks to acquire the additional theoretical knowledge that they obtain under the auspices of the Bankers Institute. For exactly the same reason and in exactly the same way, we can provide encouragement for administrators under local bodies to acquire this additional theoretical knowledge which they could acquire under a suitable institute of public administration. I do not know whether any such body functions in Ireland but if it does not, the sooner it is organised the better. I think I can say on behalf of the university with which I am associated that the organisation of such an institute would be received most favourably and we would do everything possible to further the work of such a valuable public institution.

Comment on this

If this amendment were to come into force immediately, or if it meant that the Minister was going to make such regulations immediately, I think I would be opposed to it. It is quite clear that its object is to provide for the future. I agree very largely with what Senator Johnston has said. I certainly think that if this whole system, which is extended under the Bill, is going to be a success, we shall have to look to the provision, and the regular supply in future, of suitable persons. For that reason, I think that the creation of some kind of institute of public administration would be of great value. It would be very much easier to establish such an institute or course of study if the Minister had power at some future date to insist on certain qualifications. To that extent, I entirely agree with the amendment. I think it is most important that the men who are going to hold these posts should be able to reach a professional standard of their own, that it should be a question of honours generally, and that the standard should be reasonably high. While I agree to that extent with the amendment, I am not quite sure that I could agree with some of the remarks made by Senator The McGillycuddy. I am not at all sure that some of the subjects which he mentioned are subjects of which it is desirable that candidates for these posts should know a little. I think in many cases a little knowledge is a dangerous thing, and that a man who knows a little about building for instance—just enough to lead him to interfere with somebody who knows 100 times more than he does—may be an actual danger. I think the real advantage of education is that it enables a person to understand certain problems as they are presented to him by experts. I do think that if you could get an institute for public administration it would provide the necessary course of studies. I do not place as much importance on the diploma as on the actual course of study itself. I would support this amendment or some similar provision which would give the Minister power to prescribe a standard at some future date for candidates for these posts.

Comment on this

There is no doubt that in the course of time a county managership will be regarded as a profession and the ambition of capable men will be attracted towards such posts. That is so in other countries. In fact, as it originally developed, the eyes of all important cities in America were directed towards managers in other cities and the usual competition resulted. Offers were made to highly successful men who had made their mark, and the city that could offer the highest attraction in the way of salary and the assistance of competent subordinate officials, got the best men. I was greatly struck by what Senator Douglas said because, to my mind, it burst up the whole amendment that is proposed. We cannot make a man of ability by teaching him a smattering of a diversity of subjects. The first appointments will be filled by men who already have had actual experience in their own selected profession that fits them for these positions. It is absurd to think that the Oireachtas—if the Minister were capable of such a folly as to propose it— would accept the proposition that the first appointments should be made by filling the positions with A, B and C, not because A, B and C had acquired competence, but because they happened to be in certain positions and out of kindliness of heart and good feeling we would not like to dismiss them. There seems to be something of that mentality in the case of those who are willing to tolerate the filling of positions in the first instance by this method and who desire to have these educational standards provided for some future period.

The late Viscount Haldane, who was both a very capable lawyer and a great statesman, addressing a meeting of Scottish teachers many years ago, said:

"Other things being equal, I would rather have an educated man to dig my garden than an uneducated man."

That is the principle that is working in the mind of The McGillycuddy in his proposal. He wants educated men. So do we all. We want men who, as Senator Douglas put it so aptly, have got that flexibility, that aptitude to see and understand what an expert in a particular subject puts forward and who will have the humility at the same time to regard the expert for what he is. In the case of a competent county manager, what we ought to look for is not the possession of a certain kind of knowledge that can be easily acquired by a young student by diligent application to the Encyclopædia Britannica or some similar work of that kind. We want men who are able to work with men and who are able to control subordinates. The subordinates are subordinate only in a very technical sense, because they are frequently men filling high positions and men with very long experience. I can easily conceive—I am sure Senator Johnston has had the same experience as a university examiner—of a youth who could, with a good grinding, secure full marks in an examination for a diploma such as has been outlined and who would be utterly inefficient in the office over which he is supposed to preside. He must have had the actual training, he must go through all the hard apprenticeship and, by personal achievement, he must acquire capacity. That is the only way. No doubt if he is a highly educated man it is all the better. He would be more competent to meet others in conference.

I hope the Minister will remember also, in dealing with this proposition, that ample provision is made to serve the purposes the amendment intends by the candidates presenting themselves to the Local Appointments Commission. Presumably, the Local Appointments Commissioners will know the candidate for assistant managership or county managership and they will, of course, as wise men, take practical means of ascertaining whether he is acquainted with the duties that are attached to the position. They will know what to look for and I hope that they will be able to take a glance at what, in this connection, is barbarously called "personality." They will be able to look at the man for his qualities and not merely as a storehouse of information.

I suggest that it would give the public a great deal more confidence in the appointments if they knew that this practical form of test followed the line that the candidates, unless they were very foolish, would be asked what experience they had in this line of activity, how many years they had been county surveyors, engineers, architects, planners of roads and building estates, and so on. Satisfactory answers to questions of that kind would be more consoling to the ratepayers of a county than answers that would be scientifically accurate or statistically correct, in other words, general information.

Comment on this

I see certain dangers in this amendment, and those that strike me are that it may happen some day that we may have a corrupt Minister. God forbid that that should happen in such an important Department, but if the situation arose he could manipulate the qualifications on a certain occasion to suit certain candidates and to exclude others.

Comment on this

If you read Section 5 of the Bill you will see that you will have to get a corrupt Dáil and Seanad also.

Comment on this

The amendment says that the Minister would have the power to prescribe rules and regulations, but it does not say that they are to be submitted to the Seanad.

Comment on this

That is covered by No. 5.

Comment on this

At a later period, yes, but for the purposes of a particular appointment the Minister is to be empowered to make rules and regulations and if he wants to revoke them at a later period he will have to come before the Seanad. I see a great danger in the position. A Minister might have a particular candidate in mind whom he wanted to place.

I am speaking only of what is possible under that amendment, but the position is that the Minister could frame the regulations to exclude candidates other than the one he wants. He might prescribe a knowledge of Greek or Latin which only one candidate might possess, and once the appointment is made the Minister would have no further use for the regulations and he could then come before the House with them. I admit that the danger is present only in certain conditions, but nevertheless it exists. I agree also with the last speaker that experience and general knowledge and the capability to handle men and the power to administer and to govern, do not come by mere inspiration; they come from experience. I believe in time to come there will not be any great difficulty in selecting from assistant secretaries, county surveyors and such people, men who have the necessary training and the ability to handle men. I object to the Bill as a whole, but since we have it here, I think we should try to make the best of it, and for that reason I object to the amendment on two grounds, the first being that no educational qualifications or passing of examinations will secure the best men and the second, that it may lead to corrupt administration.

Mr. M. Hayes rose.

Comment on this

Perhaps I could shorten this debate.

Comment on this

I was about to say that surely the Minister has power to do this already.

Comment on this

Yes, that is the position. Section 7 of the Local Authorities (Officers and Employees) Act, 1926, sets out:

(1) Whenever a local authority or the Minister requests the commissioners to recommend a person for appointment to an office to which this Act applies the commissioner shall, with the consent of the Minister, prescribe the qualifications as to age, health, character, education, training, experience and (where, in the opinion of the commissioners the duties of the office so require) sex for such office.

That is as wide as it can possibly be. It is true that in this Bill we are making special provisions with regard to the first appointments in order to effect a smooth change-over. We are giving a preference to secretaries of county councils and of boards of health. Another Bill will be introduced in the Dáil very shortly— I hope in this Session. I mentioned it when I was dealing with this Bill in the Dáil. It is rather a long Bill, but this Act will be dependent on it coming into operation on its passage. It deals with the number of members of county councils and so on, and among other things, with the taking over of the setting out of the qualifications from the Appointments Commissioners to the Minister. It is the Minister who will declare what the qualifications of the office are to be. When that measure comes up, I think that Senator The McGillycuddy will find that he will be met, so far as that goes, because even as it stands the Appointments Commissioners can prescribe any particular qualifications they like, at least whatever they think necessary or desirable. I must say from my experience that in appointments made to high offices there has been plenty of competition and there has been no difficulty about getting people with experience and with the necessary qualifications. These are positions that will be very much sought after in the future. They will be very responsible, and, I expect, fairly well paid, and I believe that there will be plenty of competition and that a very high standard will be reached.

With regard to the suggestion of setting up something in the universities, I am quite sure that the people who are interested in public administration and who are convenient to universities or who may be able to find an opportunity during their holidays to visit them, would not find much difficulty if they organised themselves and asked for certain lectures to be arranged. I think, in fact, that there are certain lectures on civics already.

Comment on this

There are lectures in public administration available in the university already.

Comment on this

That is a matter that would have to be gone into with the co-operation of the Minister but, of course, depending entirely on the universities to do it, and I am sure the universities would do everything they could to assist in a matter of that kind. It would be for the people to show that they were interested. So far as this amendment is concerned, it is not necessary. The position is set out in the section I read from the Act of 1926, and when the new Bill is brought in it will transfer from the commissioners to the Minister the specifying of the conditions and qualifications, and he will prescribe what he considers necessary for the post.

Comment on this

I gather from what the Minister has said that I have rather wasted the time of the House, but I do not think I have really wasted it, because the discussion has brought up a principle that is not generally known. I am afraid I did not know of it myself.

I only want to deal with one or two points raised by Senator Magennis. I gather that the whole ground of his objections, on the Second Reading of the Bill, was concerned with the fact that a county manager must be an individual who is not only an efficient businessman, trained in details of local government administration, but that he must also be sympathetic and tactful with his equals, inferiors and superiors. As regards the subjects which I thought the Minister might lay down they were not meant to be anything but a general idea to cover the various functions which the manager and the officials would have to know about. Finally, I have never visualised—and I want this to be quite clear—a fellow coming in from outside with a university textbook education, going before the Appointments Commissioners, and being appointed just because he had that type of university textbook education. What I do want, however, is to give an incentive to the younger members of the clerical staff who go into the local government service to fit themselves for the higher positions and to give them better opportunities in that regard than seem to be provided at the moment. However, in view of what the Minister has said, I ask leave to withdraw my amendment.

Comment on this

Before we come to the next amendment, Sir, might I ask a question in regard to a point on sub-section (2) that I raised on the Second Reading? I do not quite understand why, according to sub-section (2) of Section 4, the Local Appointments Commissioners shall select, otherwise than by competitive examination, and recommend to the Minister a person for such appointment. What does that mean? My understanding was that the board took, let us say, six people, in order of merit, and therefore was carrying out the idea of competitive examination; and, unless I am greatly mistaken, an Attorney-General once gave that ruling.

Comment on this

I think that that is set out in Section 8 of the Local Authorities (Officers and Employees) Act, 1926, which deals with selection by competitive examination. Section 8 of that Act set out what constitutes a competitive examination, and then Section 9 of the same Act goes on to deal with the matter of selection for appointments. Section 9 says:—

"Whenever a local authority or the Minister requests the commissioners to recommend a person for appointment to an office to which this Act applies and the commissioners with the concurrence of the Minister are of opinion, having regard to the nature of the duties of that office, the knowledge and experience necessary for the efficient performance of those duties, and the qualification prescribed under this Act for that office, the person or persons to be recommended for appointment to that office cannot be satisfactorily selected by competitive examination, the commissioners may dispense with the competitive examination required by this Act and may select the person or persons to be recommended by them to the local authority by such means and in such manner as they think proper."

These are the two sections dealing with this matter. One deals with what are called competitive examinations and the other with selection boards. However, it is a matter that I should like to be more sure of.

Comment on this

I wonder what is the selection board, if it is not competitive examination.

Comment on this

Well, there is a distinction drawn there.

Comment on this

Yes, I see that.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:—

To delete sub-section (5).

Briefly, my reason for bringing forward this amendment is that the Minister has taken power to appoint a person to be county manager temporarily and, I take it, that sometime later the permanent appointment will be made by the Appointments Commissioners. In the first place, my view is that we ought to get the best available person for the position of county manager, and I would not restrict it in the fashion in which the Minister has restricted it at all. I think that if you are going to do this you ought to do it in the best way and that you should try to get the best material available.

I am not very optimistic about the value of the measure and, as I have stated already, if you want to get a fair trial, I do not think you can get it unless you have the very best people as managers. The Minister, however, has imposed restrictions here with regard to the people who can go forward, and I think that it is definitely a mistake in policy on the part of the Minister to select somebody for the post of county manager merely to act in a temporary capacity. If you want to put a certain person in for a certain reason, of course you can do so. I am not suggesting that the Minister is going to do that, but I do urge upon the Minister that if you put somebody into such a position temporarily, when that person comes before the Local Appointments Commissioners, they are not likely to turn down the individual whom the Minister has nominated. I think that you are prejudicing the case. If, say, you put a person into the position of secretary or manager, even though that person might not turn out to be as competent as you would like him to be, the Local Appointments Commissioners might not like to turn down that person. Then, just imagine the position you would have where, actually, a county secretary has been in control, but is turned down by the Local Appointments Commissioners and somebody else put over him. I think that there should be a fair field, and if the responsibility is to be put on the Local Appointments Commissioners to make the permanent appointment, then that should not be prejudiced by any act of the Minister.

I think that it is wrong for the Minister to do that, and that, tactically, even from the Minister's own point of view, it is not the right way to approach this matter. I do not know how long the Minister anticipates the temporary appointment may last— whether for a month, three months or six months. I am trying to look at this matter from the point of view of my experience of local government, and I am trying to find out why exactly it is necessary to make a temporary appointment at all. I cannot see the reason. I cannot see any disaster coming upon local administration, because of the lack of a manager for two, three, or even six months, which has not come upon it already, and I should much prefer to have a situation where, as I say, the stand was not taken by the Minister that he had actually handed over to the Local Appointments Commissioners a county manager who was nominally temporary, but who, in fact, was going to be permanent. I cannot follow the line of reasoning that would make the Minister decide to put a person into such a position, whom the Local Appointments Commissioners would afterwards regard as unsuitable, and I think that the turning down of such a person would be bad, not alone from the Minister's point of view, but bad from the point of view of local administration, and equally bad from the point of view of the person concerned. I think the Minister should adopt some sort of scheme whereby every individual, who is available to go up for the post of county manager, should be free to go up for it. Let them all go up together, be graded, according to merit, put in the order of their ability, and so on, one after the other. I think that would be a much better plan, and I can see all sorts of difficulties arising from the policy the Minister has adopted. I believe that the Minister would be very well advised, from the point of view of administration, not to continue with this section as it is.

Comment on this

I think the Senator is under a misapprehension with regard to this matter. This is what is intended here: By the time this Act is brought into operation, you will have all your managers appointed by the Appointments Commissioners with, of course, the first preference, in the matter of selection, given to the county secretaries, as provided in the Bill. I believe that that is what will occur, but what the section is intended to deal with is this: That, if a person should die after being selected, somebody must be put in his place during the intervening period until a permanent appointment is made. That is all is, intended. I suppose you could take a chance, and not fill the appointment in the intervening period, but the only intention is that, if a person dies or became incapable for some reason or other, you should appoint somebody to act while you are waiting for the permanent appointment. Perhaps that is a rather farfetched possibility, but you have to provide against it.

Comment on this

I was going to support Senator Baxter until the Minister gave us his explanation. The point that still strikes me is that if this person were to die the county council is still operating with his staff and surely the county council could go on operating, instead of making a second change, until such time as the Appointments Commissioners found somebody else, because I do see one danger, and it is my experience that temporary appointments create a certain amount of unrest and they also create a vested interest. It may be a very slight one, but it is a fact that people start canvassing to get that temporary appointment made permanent. I hardly see, as long as the county council remains in being, why there is any real need for this, even if the prospective manager does die.

Comment on this

The point is this, that it cannot be done in the way Senator The McGillycuddy has in mind, that is, that the county council should carry on. When this Bill becomes an Act the functions are there set out for a manager to perform. If a manager dies somebody must be appointed there and then to carry out the duties that the manager has to perform. That is what is in mind—probably the secretary of the county council or somebody else or, perhaps, whoever is recommended by the county council. It is for the Minister to decide which of these people may be put in for the period we would be waiting for the Appointments Commissioners. The reason is that you must always have a manager there.

Comment on this

It is very hard to see that in the sub-section. The intention is that the Minister will fix a day under Section 2 for the commencement of the Act and the intention is that before that date is fixed the Local Appointments Commissioners shall have recommended a county manager for each county.

Comment on this

The strange part of it is that no obligation is imposed upon the Minister to set the Local Appointments Commission in motion so as to have the appointments made before the Act comes into operation, but at the same time the Minister is given power before the Act comes into operation to himself make a temporary appointment. I am not looking for the hidden hand, but it does seem an extraordinary provision. The Minister's explanation, I am sure, is quite bona fide but it is extraordinary that the Local Appointments Commissioners are not bound to act before the commencement of the Act, nor is the Minister bound to fix a date subsequent to the date after which the manager shall have been nominated to him, but, at the same time, he has power to make temporary appointments. Of course, the whole case of Senator Baxter's amendment falls to the ground if the Minister has no power to make temporary appointments and thus prejudice the permanent one except in the case of a particular vacancy.

Comment on this

The Minister has certain obligations and they are not set down in any Bill in that particular way. We hope to have all these appointments made before the commencement of the Act. Particulars have already been given to the Local Appointments Commission with a view to getting that done, or they have been consulted about it. There is nothing in the Bill to say that the Minister must make the appointment at a certain time. It is like all other obligations that the Minister has to discharge. We are putting this Bill through for the purpose of certain things being done, one of which is to set up a county manager.

Comment on this

You can only get information by asking for it and the Minister has put an entirely different construction on what the situation is going to be from that of those of us who are ignorant of what was intended in local government. I think my amendment is obvious. The Minister tells us that he has no intention of making these appointments except under certain peculiar circumstances, such as the event of a selected candidate for a particular post of county manager not being available, through death or other reason. I may have appeared guilty of various indiscretions in some of my speech here on the last day, but if you were down the country at the present and if you were asked is So-and-So going to be county manager in such and such a county and is So-and-So going to be county manager in such another county you would know the position. That question has been put to me repeatedly. I found very great difficulty in trying to convince quite a number of people that the first person who could go up for a post in the county was the secretary of the county council and not a particular politician. I found further difficulty in convincing people that, after the secretary of the county council, if he were turned down, then the secretary of the board of health could apply. I do not want to continue that line but I think the section ought to be drafted in such a way as to indicate that it is going to be operated under certain specific conditions which the Minister has indicated might likely arise. I have no desire whatever to tie the Minister's hands in that way but I think the power which he has taken is altogether too wide for the purpose for which he intends to use it. This section is going to be here for goodness knows how long and you could very well have a situation developing here where some Minister could go off and do all sorts of things with regard to those appointments and do it quite legitimately under this Act.

I think the Minister could amend this sub-section in such a way as to provide that where under certain circumstances, if a certain candidate selected by the Local Appointments Commission was not available, the Minister would make the temporary appointment, and I think it would be much fairer to the administration. I am quite convinced of the truth of this. Speaking now as a representative from the country, knowing the atmosphere that this is going to create, I think it would be much fairer to the administration and would give the whole plan a fairer chance of being worked rather than being tied hand and foot, when the Minister can make an appointment in any county to the position of county manager, as he has power to do under this. I am not going to press the amendment any further than that, but I put it to the Minister—I am speaking with conviction—that there is a case behind what I am advancing.

Comment on this

I believe you could get the co-operation of the Appointments Commission to fill these positions before the appointed day. You might get 25 and the other one might be left over by the Appointments Commission. But once that appointed day is here it comes in for all these councils at the same time, and if a person dies after being appointed or selected by the Appointments Commissioners, I have to appoint somebody to act temporarily until they make a new appointment or if for some reason or other—though I do not anticipate it—you did not get their selections for one county or two counties or more, I have to make an appointment once the date is fixed.

Comment on this

Has the secretary of the county council to remain secretary until his successor is appointed?

Comment on this

I think he would carry on both duties. I do not know how it will work out. I think he would get someone to deputise for him as secretary.

Comment on this

What is the legal position of a secretary? Would he have to resign?

Comment on this

Manager and secretary are two different posts to be held by different persons.

Comment on this

I have an amendment down to delete the section and I am sure that the House understands that that only means, in my mind, the reconstruction of the scheme of appointment of managers. The chief matter I have in view is the transfer of appointed managers from one county to another, from the county in which they have served as secretary of a county council or board of health to another county. I think the House will appreciate what I have in mind— that the secretary of a county council or board of health is elected to his position and that all his friends, relatives and possibly his political affiliations are in a particular county. I am of opinion, and I think other good judges are also of opinion, that no matter how they will endeavour to serve the State to the best of their ability, in respect of any appointment they make or any works they order to be carried out, there will be somebody to say that it was done through friendship, through prejudice or for some other reason. My idea is that such a manager will be able to act in a more independent and competent manner by removing him from these affiliations and transferring him to another county.

For the purpose of implementing that proposal on the Report Stage, I have roughly drafted a proposal to the effect that a panel of managers be selected by the Appointments Commissioners from existing county council secretaries and other qualified applicants who will make themselves available to the Minister for allocation to such counties as he may decide, other than the counties in which such persons have served as county secretary, county board of health secretary, or in other public positions. I also propose that this regulation may not apply to county council secretaries who have been appointed by the Appointments Commissioners. The reason I add that qualification is that I am aware of one county secretary—and there may be others—appointed by the Appointments Commission and taken from another county, so that it would not be necessary that my proposal should apply in that case. I think it would be in the interest of the manager and of the county which he manages that he should be perfectly independent by being transferred from his own county to another county.

Comment on this

I support the principle put forward. I said on the Second Reading—and this is possibly the shortest way of putting my views to the House—that I thought it was a regrettable decision that a golden opportunity of creating a general list of county council officials has been missed in the Bill and that changing them from one county to another would be a gradual gain in experience and incentive to energy which staying in one's own county would not produce. The Minister was somewhat short with us and I thought he was a little hidebound by the Department outlook when he said that to him it looked very much like putting them in the same position as officials who are paid out of the Central Fund, a position almost like that of a superintendent of the Civic Guards whom you can change from one area to another. Surely, you can enact any type of legislation to move people, if you think that, as a result of that moving, there will be an advantage in the long run to the public through greater experience, knowledge and energy on the part of these people. You move Civic Guards possibly for that reason, and who also move other people. I do think that, although I do not know that it could be put into this Bill, it is a matter which should certainly be considered in the future.

Comment on this

I support generally the view expressed by Senator Honan and I have given expression to the point of view in another form. It seems to be that the Local Appointments Commissioners have a certain procedure in the matter of the appointment of doctors to dispensaries. There may be three or four dispensaries to be filled and they have a number of applicants going up who can take their choice of the vacancies, and I think it would have been a better method to adopt in this case than the method adopted. I think it true that a great many of the county officials would do the work of county managers in another county better than in the counties in which they are at present operating. There are all sorts of reasons for that, and it is quite possible that the administration of a county manager would be more impartial in a county other than his own than that it very well might be in a county in which he has operated for years.

I see certain difficulties here, particularly with regard to sub-paragraph (a) of sub-section (3) in respect of the grouped counties. The county manager is going to be one or other of two county secretaries, and if you are going to have one of the county secretaries as the manager and the defeated county secretary having to remain at his post under the county manager who has defeated him, I think you are going to have anything but harmony or a happy condition of things. I do not know what you are going to do about it, but there it is.

Comment on this

Financially, he may be better off.

Comment on this

I was coming to that point. I think the Minister could clear up a great deal of doubt and certain misunderstandings in the minds of some of us, if he would give an indication as to what the salaries of county managers are likely to be. I do not know if there are many of them to-day, but I know some county secretaries who have very respectable salaries indeed. I do not know if any of the county managers will get any such salaries, but I think there are quite a number of secretaries who have not got as large salaries as probably the county manager will have.

I wish to come back to this point about the counties which are joined. I may completely misunderstand human nature, but it seems to me that you are not going to arrive at the sort of "pulling in harness" which is absolutely essential in local administration, if you take one of two county secretaries in one of the grouped counties and put him over the other, leaving the other gentleman to continue as he is. I do not know what the local circumstances may be; it may very well be that in all these grouped counties, there may be a county secretary going out on pension, or something like that. If, however, you have two tolerably young men, nearly equal in competence, and one is put over the other, and one happens to be a native and is going to be county manager in that county— with all its local ramifications—I prophesy that the local administration in that county will be something closely approximating to disorder, instead of prospering and being satisfactory as everybody—including the local officials and the Department—would like. That is something which the Minister ought to take into account at once, as it is going to create a problem for him. I could call to mind counties around my own where, if we were going to join two particular counties, I know I should not like to have the job of sorting things out.

Comment on this

I should like to hear what the Minister has to say in this matter. If he has a doubt in his mind, I may have an amendment for the Report Stage.

Comment on this

On the point mentioned by Senator Baxter regarding grouped counties, I suppose we can only go on the experience that we have. Managers have been appointed in certain urban areas already. Members of the staffs of those corporations have been up as candidates for the same position, yet somebody outside with more experience has got the job and has come in over those people. That has happened in Limerick and Dublin, I believe. We have had no indication, however, of any lack of harmony in the relations between the officials and the managers in those particular cases. Town clerks, too, have been appointed from time to time—the secretary of a county council was appointed the other day from Dun Laoghaire, I think, and got a position in Westmeath. That is happening every day before the Appointments Commissioners. Although there may be candidates up from the staff of the county council or local body, when the appointment is made there has been no lack of harmony. Where two secretaries of county councils are candidates, the more suitable one is appointed.

In the case of many counties, I have no idea as to what the salary should be. Taking the urban areas, in Dublin, it is £1,700, in Cork, £1,200, and in Limerick I think it is £800 to £1,000, and in Dun Laoghaire, £1,000. In small counties the manager might not have a big number of institutions; while in other counties there may be bigger responsibilities. There are a number of county secretaries in receipt of fees. They get much higher salaries than they could hope to get as county managers; but the position will be that, if a secretary is appointed a manager he will not get less. That is, where he gets the preference here in the Bill. It would be a joke if we said we would give a preference to the secretary which would mean that he would lose on taking over the managership. That is not the intention at all, I am talking about cases where there are fees which bring the total remuneration up to a very high figure. When a vacancy arises, whatever is the general policy with regard to the fixing of salaries will apply as in the present cases under the Appointments Commission where there is no preference given to county secretaries or to secretaries of boards of health. I think there will be a differentiation between certain counties. Where he has greater responsibilities and more duties, he will have to be paid higher than in smaller counties where there are fewer institutions and less responsibilities.

With regard to the question of transferring, that is a matter which I do not care for. If one takes the right to transfer, then one can transfer from time to time. When a man is put in as a manager, probably he has got a house in the county, and has got to know the county, and it would be wrong, I think, if some Minister could come along and transfer him to another county. Only a few officials who are paid through the Central Fund are transferable. Where they are paid out of county rates, it more or less gives the people there the right to keep the man they have got.

Comment on this

He would be transferred on promotion, with better emoluments?

Comment on this

If a vacancy arises in another county, there is nothing to prevent the manager of one county being a candidate, if there is a bigger salary attached to the position. Probably it would work out all right and there will continue to be competition in that way. Medical officers of health are not transferrable, nor are county surveyors, and I think it would be very unfair to permit the transfer of managers.

Regarding the question of association with people, we know perfectly well that the county manager, after a few years in an area, will become as associated with the people there as if he had been there all his life. If he is foolish enough to get his prejudices, his likes and dislikes, he will get them whether he is there for ten years or five. I hope that will not be the position. When you give the manager powers under this Bill to control staff, he will be in a different position from that of the secretary of a county council, who is liable to be pulled up by the county council for everything he does. I think he will exercise his duties properly and without fear or favour. I do not think it would be a solution to transfer people from one county to another. This is being done for the first managers only, to try and effect a smooth change over. These people happen to be in the counties and to have done well there or they have a substantial association with local administration.

Comment on this

Would it be necessary to make it explicit that, if the county secretary is appointed manager of a county, he automatically resigns the secretaryship?

Comment on this

It would be unnecessary to state that.

Comment on this

I am prepared to withdraw the amendment, although I am not at all convinced by the argument.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 5:—

Before Section 6 to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) The county manager for a county, being as set out in Section 3, sub-section (4), an officer of the council of that county, shall be liable to (a) suspension or (b) removal at the instance of the council of that county.

(2) The county manager for a county shall not, however, be suspended or removed by the council of that county save by special resolution passed at a meeting of the council convened expressly for the consideration of such special resolution; and the procedure to be followed in respect of this special meeting and the passing thereat of a special resolution of suspension, or removal as the case may be, shall be regulated in accordance with the next following sub-section of this section.

(3) (a) A notice in writing of the intention to propose any such resolution of suspension or removal of a county manager signed by at least three members of the council shall be lodged with the chairman at an ordinary meeting of the council, and the chairman shall thereupon fix a date not later than 14 days subsequent there to for a special meeting to consider the proposition; and due notice of the date and business of this meeting shall be sent to the county manager as well as to every person who is a member of the council at the time of issue of such notice.

(b) No other business shall be transacted at the special meeting thus convened. The proposition shall be declared to have failed to pass unless two-thirds of the total members of the council shall have voted thereon at the meeting and the majority of council's votes cast in its favour has a clear majority.

(4) No decision to suspend, or to remove, a county manager shall take effect unless and until it receives the sanction of the Minister.

(5) A county manager shall have a right to appeal, if he so desires, to the Minister against such suspension or removal by the council of the county.

The purpose is to substitute a different form of words for that which has been used in the existing Section 6. Section 6, sub-section 1 reads:—

The county manager for a county shall not be removed by the council of that county without the sanction of the Minister.

I think that that hits the public—as the phrase runs—in the eye, as nondemocratic, as the assertion of a superior claim on the part of the central bureaucracy, asserted over the rights of the council, notwithstanding that an earlier section has declared that the county manager is an officer of the county council. The Minister as a lawyer will readily remember that in the working of the law of libel, the court takes into account, not what the author of the writing complained of as a libel meant but what the ordinary normal man in the street who has read the publication reasonably takes it to mean. Unfortunately a great deal of colour is lent to the arguments of those who attack this managerial scheme for the counties on the ground that it takes away powers from county councillors who are the elected representatives of the people and that it substitutes an arbitrary professional authority for an elective authority. They find some sort of foundation for their allegations in the sentence: "The county manager for a county shall not be removed by the council of that county." Interpreted freely, that becomes, in ordinary conversation, that the council are absolutely forbidden to remove the manager, so I propose to word it differently and to set it out frankly for what it is, in terms more democratic.

I do not question in the least—and I hope nobody else would—that the relation between national Governments and local government must be preserved, that where a local authority has got administration of its own local affairs, there is over and above that the paramount interests of the nation and that the Minister is the paramount authority, as representing the people at large, rather than the local authority which represents the people in some particular district. I know that the Minister will reply to me that most of what is in my Section 6 is already set out. I agree, of course, that that is so. For example, the amendment states at the outset:—

"The county manager for a county, being as set out in Section 3, sub-section (4), an officer of that council, shall be liable to (a) suspension, or (b) removal at the instance of the council of that county."

That is contained virtually in Section 19 of the Second Schedule. It sets out the reserved powers, that is to say, the powers vested in the county council as distinct from the executive powers allotted to the county manager. Therefore, sub-section (1) of the amendment is identical in spirit, and almost in form, with the provisions of the Bill as it already stands. The only difference I can claim for it is that no one can quote sub-section (1) of Section 6 in support of the allegation that this removes the power from the county council. On the contrary, it distinctly declares that the manager is an officer of the county council and, as an officer, is amenable to all these operations of the council—suspension or removal.

There is a slight difference in doctrine, or rather in practice, in the next sub-section, which states:—

"The county manager shall not, however, be suspended or removed by the council of that county save by special resolution passed at a meeting of the council convened expressly for the consideration of such special resolution."

That is to say, the sole business to be transacted on that occasion is the inquisition into what is complained of in regard to the operations of the county manager. The procedure to be followed shall be as set out in the next sub-section:—

"A notice in writing of the intention to propose any such resolution of suspension or removal of a county manager, signed by at least three members of the council shall be lodged with the chairman at an ordinary meeting of the council."

That is the practice in regard to normal resolutions to be proposed. It is the ordinary normal way of giving notice of motion.

The amendment goes on—

—and the chairman shall thereupon fix a date not later than 14 days subsequent thereto for a special meeting to consider the proposition.

Now, in the next clause there is something introduced that is not in the original measure—

—and due notice of the date and business of this meeting shall be sent to the county manager as well as to every person who is a member of the council at the time of issue of such notice.

The purpose of that is to acquaint the county manager of the fact that he is to be charged, that some complaint is to be made against him for the purpose of having him suspended or, as the case may be, for having him removed. I think that ordinary common justice requires that. It is only just that an officer should get due notice of the fact that a complaint is to be made against him, so that he can defend himself against any cabal which may be worked up against him. The fact that the complaint will be investigated at the meeting has to be communicated to him specifically at the same time and in the same manner as it is to the members of the council. This provision to acquaint the manager is a new clause. Of course there is a section in a later part of the Bill which authorises the manager, if he so pleases, to attend ordinary meetings but I regard this, because it is summoned in a special way, as an extraordinary meeting and this clause is there to provide against his being excluded from the hearing of the charge that he has to answer or of his being shut out on a technicality.

The next portion is sub-section (3) which reads:—

"No other business shall be transacted at the special meeting thus convened. The proposition shall be declared to have failed to pass unless two-thirds of the total members of the council shall have voted thereon at the meeting——"

That, again, obviously is directed against the working up of feeling and the working of promises to vote in a particular way—

"unless two-thirds of the total members of the council shall have voted thereon at the meeting"

There is an unfortunate misprint in the next passage—

"and the majority of the council's votes cast in its favour is a clear majority".

This has been elaborated with the express purpose of allaying anxiety. The whole effort is directed to making it clear that a manager shall be loyally dealt with by the county council which expects loyal service from him. The Bill provides that no decision to suspend or remove a county manager shall take effect unless and until it receives the sanction of the Minister—at least, if not in those words, just as explicitly. The next sub-section of the proposed new section provides:

A county manager shall have a right to appeal, if he so desires, to the Minister against such suspension or removal by the council of the county.

It seems to me that those who are anxious that this measure should pass as a step for the betterment and improvement of local government feel that there should be no room for suspicion and no ground for making charges of unfairness or injustice, but that, on the contrary, if there be any fault to be found, the Bill should, if anything, be obviously bent on observing justice, preserving rights and doing no wrong. Therefore, the county manager is allowed to have a right of appeal, if he so desires, to the Minister. That will, of course, in accordance with the preceding sub-sections, presuppose that the vote to suspend or remove the county manager has been duly carried, and that in the period of submitting that vote to the Minister and the Minister giving his decision, the opportunity will be allowed to the manager to state his case to the Minister. In other words, it makes it very clear that the Minister does not become a rubber stamp in the matter, but that he exercises something of a judicial capacity, that he weighs carefully, by virtue of his office, and his high responsibility, all that has been alleged against the manager, so that the proper relations between the local government and national government will be observed.

Comment on this

Before we conclude the debate on that section, I would like to ask the Minister to accept an amendment on the Report Stage making provision for the men who now hold the position of commissioners. There are only two of them, so far as I know personally, but I believe there may be one or two more, and I think anybody considering this Bill, especially those who approve of it, must take into consideration the successful operations carried out by those commissioners during their term of office. I am thinking particularly of Tipperary and Waterford, and I would suggest that some provision might be made by way of amendment to allow those men to apply for the positions at least. I think as a result of their work that they have proved themselves very capable men.

Comment on this

That matter would have been more appropriate on Section 4.

Comment on this

I understand that the commissioners in those cases are civil servants and that they go back to their departments.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

I think that it would be a right principle to have civil servants going back to their own authority. In connection with the amendment proposed by Senator Magennis, I would like to point out that the substance of the amendment is practically the same as the original clause, but it seems to me to clarify definitely what the majority is. The voting strength will be the same. The amendment prescribes that two-thirds of the members should vote, whereas the original Section 6 mentioned that it would be "passed by such council." The amendment definitely defines how the passage is to be executed—that there must be a clear majority of the council. That probably would mean that there would be no such thing as a casting vote.

Comment on this

That is the idea.

Comment on this

That is certainly more definite in the amendment than in the original section. Much of the other sub-sections seem to be on the same lines as the original section. I would like to point out in reading Section 6, it seems to me that the county manager must know beforehand of such a motion. It cannot be sprung on him because in the original section it is provided that seven days' notice is to be given. The notice is sent out from the managerial office and the manager would certainly know that such a motion was coming. Therefore, I think that nothing in the nature of taking him unawares occurs even in the original Section 6. It seems to me that beyond these alterations of phrases the amendment contains the same substance as the original section, but that the question of the majority is very definitely defined.

Comment on this

I quite accept those criticisms, but what I would remind Senator O'Donovan about is this: the Bill contains Section 26 and when it becomes an Act it will be a statutory duty of the manager to provide information on certain of his functions at the demand of the council. In Section 28 there is complete control, in any reasonable sense of complete control, given to the council over the manager. In Section 28, sub-section (1), and the following sub-sections, we provide for the framing of estimates for the expenditure of the county council. It is very obvious to an unprejudiced mind that the financial control in regard to budgeting is really with the county council. Yet, in spite of the obviousness and clarity of the section, we have speeches in this House declaring that all the powers are being taken from the representatives of the people. It was that experience which prompted me to reword this. That is all the claim I make for it. It shuts the door, to some extent, at least, against the operation of sincere ignorance, but you cannot close the door completely against prejudice and malice.

Comment on this

I think that the whole point is whether it is sufficiently clear in the Bill itself or not. I must confess that I have been trying to compare them and I do not see that the amendment is very much different from the provisions of the Bill. Sub-section (2) of the amendment provides for a special resolution adopted at a special meeting.

Now, I cannot imagine a council treating such a thing as the suspension or removal of a manager as a matter of routine at the end of a meeting. I do not know whether their standing orders would cover that or not, but I imagine that they would.

Comment on this

I hope that the Minister will not regard my remarks now as an interruption. Since the discussion on this Bill began, I have heard several times from my friend and colleague, Senator Baxter, about the clouds of suspicion and mistrust existing in the county councils with regard to this measure. What I am thinking of in this connection is really the psychology of the whole business. I suggest, with all respect, that it is not sufficient that there should be just this provision in the Bill, and I suggest, again with all respect, that there should not be anything in the Bill that would lend itself to, what I might call, clever misquotation. That is all I venture to say in connection with this matter or in connection with the wording of the Bill. I quite admit that, in substance, it is 90 per cent., or even 99 per cent., the same as the original section.

Comment on this

I think it is made perfectly clear in the Bill itself that you must have two-thirds of the council, whether present or not, in order to suspend or remove a man from such a position. I think it is made perfectly clear in Section 6 of this Bill, which says:—

(1) The county manager for a county shall not be removed by the council of that county without the sanction of the Minister.

(2) The county manager for a county shall not be suspended or removed by the council of that county save by a resolution passed by such council for the purpose of such suspension or such removal and for the passing of which not less than two-thirds of the members of such council voted and of the intention to propose which not less than seven days' notice was given to every person who was a member of such council when such notice was given.

That does not mean that two-thirds of those members were present, but the point I want to make is that, under Section 4, the office of county manager is an office to which the Local Authorities (Officers and Employees) Act applies, with certain exceptions. Section 4 says that

"... the said Act shall not apply to the said office and that Sections 6, 8, and 9 of the said Act shall apply to the said office subject to the subsequent provisions of this section."

Now, Section 11 of the Local Authorties (Officers and Employees) Act, 1926, says:—

(1) Whenever there is in the opinion of any local authority or of the Minister reason to believe that an officer or servant of such local authority has failed to perform satisfactorily the duties of his position or has misconducted himself in relation thereto or is otherwise unfit to hold such position, such local authority or the Minister, as the case may be, may suspend such officer or servant from the performance of his duties while such alleged failure, misconduct or unfitness is being inquired into and the disciplinary action, if any, to be taken in regard thereto is being determined.

(2) The suspension of an officer or servant who is suspended under this section by a local authority or the Minister shall continue until terminated by the Minister.

I think that is sufficiently clear.

Comment on this

No doubt, that is in the Local Authorities (Officers and Employees) Act of 1926, or, possibly, in subsequent Acts of other years, but does every man who hears about this Bill, or who reads the summaries about it or the criticisms of it, know anything about Section 11 of the Act of 1926? That is another thing which, I think, we ought to remove from our code of laws—legislation by reference. However, that is a matter which, I think, I am not entitled to raise in this connection. In any case, if the Minister thinks that my amendment will not serve a useful purpose, I do not wish to press it and will, by leave, withdraw it.

Comment on this

I know that the Senator's object is to try to make the position perfectly clear, but I think that, as the section stands, it should not be liable either to misconstruction or misconception.

Comment on this

There is another point that I see in this connection. Section 6 of the Bill says that "the county manager for a county shall not be removed by the council of that county without the sanction of the Minister." That would imply that he could be suspended without the sanction of the Minister, since sub-section (2) of the same section says that "the county manager for a county shall not be suspended or removed by the council of that county save by a resolution passed by such council for the purpose of such suspension or such removal," and so on. The effect of Senator Magennis's amendment is that no decision to suspend, or to remove, a county manager shall take effect unless and until it receives the sanction of the Minister. Now, the word "suspension" is omitted in the opening phrases of Section 6 in the Bill, and I should like to know what is the meaning of that.

Comment on this

Has not Senator Magennis withdrawn his amendment?

Comment on this

No, Senator, the amendment is not withdrawn yet.

Comment on this

Whether or not the Senator has withdrawn his amendment, I am only asking for a clarification of the clause.

Comment on this

It is the deliberate intention that the council should be able to suspend in the first instance. For example, you might come across a case where the council discovered that a man had embezzled money, and therefore they should be empowered to act at once in such a case; or there might be a case—I hope it would not occur very often—where a man might go off his head, and in such a case also it would be necessary to act at once. Of course, the Minister could terminate any such appointment, if he were not satisfied.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:—

In sub-section (2), line 45, after the word "members" to insert the word "present".

I take a somewhat different view from the view held, apparently, by a number of members of the House, to the effect that a county council would be a collection of very ruthless people who can be always relied upon to treat their officials in a most cruel and heartless fashion. I do not think they are anything of the kind, and I should like to have some information from anybody who is experienced in these matters as to the number of officials of local authorities who, in the past 20 or 30 years, have been either suspended or dismissed by local authorities. I think that the last thing the local authorities do is to suspend or dismiss an official, even when they have every justification for doing so. The fact is that they just do not do it. My opinion, with regard to this section, is that a local authority will never either remove or suspend a county manager and that it is practically impossible, under this section as it stands, to effect such removal or suspension. The Minister has told us that he is going to reduce the number of members of county councils, by four or five in some cases, and even more in other cases; but the position here is that you must have two-thirds of the members of the council determining the suspension or removal of a county manager before that suspension or removal can be brought about. Now, I do not think you would ever get two-thirds of a council to suspend a man. We all know what would happen. You just manage to keep two or three of them away and, in any case, if they did not want to come, they would not come to the meeting anyway. A great many of us when it comes to a question of doing an unpleasant job, are inclined to take the line of least resistance, and just stay away. It is not a pleasant task to come in and pass judgment either for incapacity, inefficiency, dishonesty, or some other failing, on a very responsible man. People do not like to do it, and what I fear is that, even when the responsibility is on the people to do such a thing and when, perhaps, they should do it, not alone in the interests of the person concerned, but also in their own interests as ratepayers and the guardians of ratepayers, and representing the authority of the Local Government Department also, still you will not get them to face up to their job in such a case as that, because it is a rather unpleasant and even cruel job to suspend or remove an official holding a prominent position. I am asking the Minister to accept an amendment that two-thirds of the members present and voting, will be sufficient to suspend or remove an official. I have been watching local government for a fairly long time and I have seen sufficient officials—as, I am sure, other Senators have seen—but I have always observed that the local authorities take the part, even of people who are not efficient, and I suggest to the Minister that he can be quite convinced that the very last thing a local authority will want to do will be to take any such unpleasant action as the suspension or removal of a county manager.

They will not do it even when they ought to do it. They will put it on to the last second of the last minute of the last hour, and when it comes to the day to make the decision some of the people who ought to be there to do their job will not be there. I urge that the men who go there and take the responsibility of facing up to it, either saying for or against it, should make the decision, that what should be in the Bill is not two-thirds of the members of the council but two-thirds of the members of the council who are present. If you get two-thirds of the members of the council who are present to take the decision, that should be a decision and should be recognised as such. After all, a county manager is not going to be suspended unless he has gone off the rails very far indeed, but the peculiar thing about it in this country is that the man who runs off the rails can almost have as many people behind him as the fellow who keeps straight on all the time. We are inclined to give a considerable backing to the poor devil and every type of official like that. They are not so many indeed, but the strange thing is that they always have their supporters and they always will have. There are ways of getting support for these people. A certain amount of good nature in the Irish character is, I suppose, in part, responsible but, whatever the cause may be, I am quite convinced that you never will get two-thirds of the members of the council to take that decision. You could get two-thirds of the members present to take it, but the men who do not want to take this responsibility will stay away and leave it to the other people to do it and it just will not be done, and the man will be able to stay on even when he should be treated differently. It may be that eventually the Minister will have to take very strong action, sometimes very unpleasant, and sometimes having political reactions not a bit favourable to the Minister. I believe that is a wise amendment. I believe that the manager will have ample protection. I believe that he would have ample protection even in a bare majority of the council, because when he gets into harness and goes on with his work, the fundamental attitude of our people locally is to keep him and treat him well on the whole. They rarely turn out a man until he is long past his time for giving valuable service. I urge the Minister very strongly to accept that amendment.

Comment on this

I can scarcely believe that this is the same Senator Baxter we had here last week speaking on the Second Stage of this Bill, and if the Bill had not been drafted before he made his speech on the Second Reading I would say that it was as a result of that speech that this section was put into the Bill. It is quite obvious that the section is merely providing against what might possibly happen, and it is also quite obvious that there was no suggestion at all that the county councils as a whole were 1 per cent. as bad as they were represented by Senator Baxter on the Second Reading.

Comment on this

I did not make any such suggestion about the county councils on the Second Reading. I referred to a certain particular county.

Comment on this

Even if that happened in only one particular county it would be well to provide against it. While I do not believe that even in Senator Baxter's own county or his neighbouring county conditions are anything like what he represented them to be I see no reason why we should not provide against a possibility of such a condition of affairs cropping up.

Comment on this

There is one point about this, that you might have one abortive meeting after another. If you had a council of 60 you would require 40 in order to get two-thirds of a majority. Through the operation of what, Senator Baxter quite rightly says, is the feeling of all of us who serve on local boards to do the best we possibly can for our officials and ensure that in the end they get the biggest pensions they can, you might some day find after the seven days that there were only two people in the chamber. Those two people would take on themselves to suspend or remove the manager, but I think the manager still has the Minister's protection and unless the case put up by those two people was a very, very serious one, which would probably necessitate an inquiry on the part of the Minister, the man is protected. I am inclined to think that this amendment might help quick decisions and get over the very kind-hearted outlook we all have in regard to officials.

Comment on this

Is it not within the province of a Minister, if the council should evade its responsibility, to dismiss the manager and, equally, if a prejudiced council seeks to dismiss the manager, is it not within the province of the Minister to protect him?

Comment on this

The point strikes me in regard to Senator Baxter's amendment that you could possibly have a decision by a minority, not by a quorum even of the meeting. The wording of it would not be too happy. His amendment suggests putting in the word "present" after the word "members"—"not less than two-thirds of the members present of such council voted". If there were just a quorum present and if two-thirds of that quorum voted you would have a decision by, possibly, a small minority of the whole council, and I think that that would not be very advisable at all. A council could have no standing orders if such an amendment were inserted.

Comment on this

That is the whole point. I know a county council, for example, of 36. The quorum is usually one-fourth. That would be nine members. If those nine people met, six people out of 36 could suspend the manager. I think there are two sides of approach to this. There is the side who want—not saying that it is expressed in this House—to approach it from the way to make it easy to suspend a manager and the other side that want to make it difficult to suspend a manager. You have to get some sort of medium, and I think in a matter of this sort the Minister has the power in any case, under Section 11 of the Act of 1926 in certain circumstances to suspend. I think that in a matter of such importance as suspending or removing a manager there should be at least two-thirds of the council in favour of it.

Special circumstances might arise suddenly, but I do not think a council would have any difficulty whatever in getting that two-thirds majority. If it were a case of embezzlement or of a person, as I mentioned already, becoming insane, I do not think there would be any difficulty in getting the necessary majority. The point that Senator O'Donovan has made, however, is the kernel of the whole thing that is, that you might get a small minority in a position to suspend the manager.

Comment on this

The comment I make on Senator O'Donovan's remarks and the Minister's reply is that it may be that there are councils the attendance at which is so low that a quorum of only nine members out of 36 represents the attendance. I do not think the Minister said that was the case because I do not think it is a fact.

Comment on this

But it could happen.

Comment on this

I am trying to deal with the facts as we know them. I do not know that there are any local authorities whose attendance would be anything as low, and I think that Senator O'Donovan drew a picture which is unreal and which is not related to the facts. I am not arguing that it could not happen; what I am arguing is that it does not happen. That is not the way the local authorities transact their business, at least down the country. You will find generally that two-thirds of the members are very regular attenders in the case of most of the councils, with a higher percentage in the case of quite a number of them.

Comment on this

Ninety-five or 99 per cent.

Comment on this

Perhaps some would be as high as 90 per cent., and sometimes 100 per cent.

Comment on this

I never suggested they would not.

Comment on this

The Senator did not suggest it, but he did suggest that a very small proportion of the total members were likely to suspend the manager. I do not think that is a situation that would be likely to arise at all and I did not anticipate that because, as I say, it is not related to the facts. I am not going to argue any further about it. I still have the view I had when I put down the amendment, and I am satisfied that it is closer to reality than anything I have heard against the amendment.

I make this concession to Senator O'Donovan, that the wording might be better and might have to be altered, but that is a trifle. I believe that you are building up certain trouble and, as Senator McGee says, if local authorities will not do their duty, the Minister will. My view is that local authorities ought to have power given to them in a workable kind of way, and I believe that when you give this power to two-thirds of a council, it may very well be a power which they will never be able to use. I want to give it to them in a workable way, and I do not believe that they are ever going to use that power in an unjust way. If they use it at all, it will be used more in favour of the individual concerned than otherwise. With regard to Senator Quirke, if he would like to come down to Monaghan, I will bring him, but I do not know whether he would be pleased with his visit or not.

Comment on this

There is one matter which is not quite clear to me. What is the position of an elective body if it wants to show its displeasure with the administration? Can one of the five elective bodies in the county remove the manager? I am not quite clear as to whether that is covered in the Bill.

Comment on this

I am afraid the only thing they can do is to complain to the county council or the Minister.

Comment on this

Would it not be wise to insert some section to that effect on Report Stage?

Comment on this

I wonder how we could manage to provide that they could bring it to the council's notice. They could not have the power themselves of removal, and I do not know in what other way you could make the suggestion effective.

Comment on this

I have searched the Bill and I thought it was covered elsewhere.

Comment on this

There is no provision made for bringing complaints of that kind.

Comment on this

When I spoke of two or three commissioners or more, I did not mean that it should necessarily be made possible for them to apply in the counties in which they have been operating in the past, but that it should be made possible for them to apply in other counties where perhaps suitable men may not be available.

I can see the possibility of various counties not being able to provide suitable men, or men who would be as suitable as men who have acted in this capacity in the past.

Comment on this

I do not see how it can possibly be arranged at this stage. I might consider it but I do not see how it can be met. The only concession we are giving is in respect of secretaries of boards of health and county councils, and, if we extend it any further, it would be better to leave it open altogether.

Comment on this

There are two distinct services—the central service and the local authorities service. I should not like to see the Civil Service butting in on the local authorities. They can control them in every way but the local authority service up to the present has been a disjointed service. Every county is more or less on its own and this Bill seems to establish a definite service of local government. I think it was Senator The McGillycuddy who referred to it as a calling in the future to which students could aspire, and I should like to see them worked separately. I would entirely disagree with the suggestion of Senator Quirke that the Civil Service should be taken into the local service.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:—

In sub-section (1), line 5, to delete the word "two" and insert instead the word "four".

Comment on this

Would the Senator agree to consider this as governing amendments Nos. 8, 11, 12, 13, 14 and 15?

Comment on this

Yes. I am afraid it is useless to move this at all, on account of the complexity of the situation. The Minister proposes a city and county manager, that is to say, the city manager shall be the county manager, and he is to have two assistant managers, but later on we find that one of the assistant manager positions is to be filled by express nomination. That is under Section 10, if I may be permitted to refer to it:

"If, immediately before the commencement of this Act, Timothy O'Mahony holds the office of Dun Laoghaire borough manager and town clerk, he shall, by virtue of this sub-section, be and he is hereby appointed to be a Dublin assistant city manager."

There is, therefore, only one city assistant manager position to be filled. I have studied carefully the answers made in the debate in Committee on March 14th in the Dáil, and I gather —maybe wrongly— that, broadly, the Minister's intention is that the city and county manager, who is the official bearing the ultimate responsibility, will be locally assisted. He does not say definitely that this will be so, but I take it from the remarks here and there in the debate, that the present manager of the borough council will be continued in that office, on account of his acquaintance with the work there and because he has already been initiated into the duties of managership. It would look as if the remaining city and county sub-manager would be relegated to do the work of the county. At first I was under the impression that that was the Minister's intention, but since the debate began to-day, I had an opportunity of reading again what the Minister said in that regard in reply to Deputy Cosgrave. He said:

"There is an amendment that these others will be appointed as assistant managers. Some of them may know more about the work of the county than perhaps a city manager would, and the city manager will have to be guided a good deal by the advice he will get. I do admit that the ultimate responsibility must rest on the city and county manager."

At first I was under the impression that that indicated the intention of the Minister to sub-divide the work in the way I have now indicated—the city and county manager for the entire county, including the borough and then the work of the Dún Laoghaire Borough Council relegated to the existing occupant of the office and the county dealt with by the other. It is not so definitely fixed as I had at first surmised. What I did gather from it is this, that in the present Bill, while the manager is the chief executive officer on whom the ultimate responsibility rests, the delegation would be delegation in regard to local areas. The amendments I have put down here are directed in quite a different direction. I am thinking of the Greater Dublin which will eventually come out of all this reorganisation and improvement of local government.

The Minister and some of my colleagues will perhaps recollect that there was, previous to the Greater Dublin Tribunal investigation under Mr. Justice Gavan Duffy, a Greater Dublin Commission which sat and took evidence for something like two years. On the report of that Commission was based the legislation in 1930 which created the present Greater Dublin and introduced the present managerial system. In that report, the organisation of functions amongst the chief officers which would be the most salutary was suggested and the delegation which was contemplated in that report was of the same type that was contemplated in the Report of the Gavan Duffy Commission, namely, that the delegation should be of services and not a distribution of local areas. I brought the Tribunal's Report with me and I shall read out the relative passage. It is as follows:

"It is essential that men of outstanding attainments with appropriate salaries should be obtained for these key positions".

What it designates key positions, are the positions occupied by the chief officials who are at the head of the essential services in the municipality.

Mr. Justice Gavan Duffy does not take the same categories as I have taken in the Greater Dublin Report, but they are approximately the same. The first and most important official, according to the Greater Dublin Commission, is to have charge of finance. He regarded the City Corporation officials or the manager as being in the relation of a Prime Minister to his Ministers, or as directors to a county council. We had in contemplation management by conference, no doubt, the responsibility in the last resort to be laid at the door of the manager, but the decision and the work in practice to be the outcome of conferences between these key position holders—the city treasurer, having very responsible duties to perform, then the officer in charge of constructive work—the construction of roads, highways, the opening up of streets, the provision of water services, sewerage, etc.—and then the officer in charge of medical services. Now, I thought that was the leading idea in the Minister's conception of the managerial system for the whole city, but in this particular instance what I fear is that the territorial working out of the system may block the further and, what to my conception, was the better arrangement for the city and the county in the years to come.

This is the passage I wanted particularly to quote from the report of the tribunal. It is paragraph 479:—

"We advocate a system whereby delegation shall be effected by way of services in lieu of the managerial authority being delegated in respect of different areas. If the former system were not adopted (that is, if the delegation in respect of areas were the system to be followed as it is followed in this Bill) it would be necessary to appoint local managers in the different sub-divisions of the metropolitan borough, and we feel that such a procedure would cut across the principle of unification of authority and control which we postulate as essential."

It is to bring these views once again under the notice of the Minister that I put down these amendments.

If we look at the basis of population, you will notice that there follows immediately after the first sub-section to which the amendment is moved, the following provision:—

There shall be three assistant county managers for the county of Cork.

The population as far as I could discover is about 170,000, and the population of the present Greater Dublin is well over 400,000. It is nearer to-day, I think, to 500,000. On that basis alone there is some justification for asking for more than two assistant managers for the work of the combined city and county. With regard to these elements of complexity—the enormous amount of public work to be done, to be designed, to be provided for in the municipalities—there is also the further fact that the type of services in the non-urbanised regions of the county is completely different. In our Greater Dublin Report, we had to take into account, semi-prophetically, how much of the area in the proximity of the city and the townships of that time was likely to undergo speedy organisation. That meant naturally going over the ground day after day, inspecting plans for the development of estates, and work of that sort. In the report we were very careful not to include the area that would remain, we believed, an agricultural area. I take it that was a commonsense procedure. Between the passing of the Act and the carrying out of the scheme formulated in the Gavan Duffy Tribunal Report there will be quite an interval of years. In that period there will be most valuable time and opportunity for any adjustment, not merely to services as between the two regions, the agricultural or county region and the urbanised region, but there will be an opportunity also for dealing with the existing officials and readjusting them to the altered conditions.

It seems to me to be useless to press these arguments in favour of the realisation of the ideal of the Greater Dublin tribunal of one manager, one responsible unified authority and control, and delegation, according to the necessities of the situation and the wisdom and experience of the manager. I think it is very important to remember that the manager could never shoulder the entire work. It would be impossible for him to be so busy. He must really be director-in-chief. With all respect, I submit to the Minister that what I gather from a careful study of his replies in the debate in Committee in the Dáil, is that he wishes to leave the county manager with an absolutely free hand and that applies equally to the city manager. He replies, for instance, on one occasion: "I cannot answer that", and again: "The manager will determine that", and so on. With great respect, I submit that we are to be dependent on the ability, devoted service and high character of the county manager, but it is not good policy to leave everything exclusively to his discretion.

I think that just as in other Acts of Parliament if the whole course is mapped out and an outline clearly manifested of the policy desired by the Government to be followed by those to whose lot it falls to carry out the work, there should be a specification of services and of the mode of providing for the direction of these services given by the Oireachtas itself, or by the Minister, in any case, so that it is still possible if the Minister so desires— that is to say if he favoured it—to have the idea of the Greater Dublin tribunal of unification of control with subdivision of local managerial functions. If he had any view that ultimately there would be this delegation of services, the easy way over from what is contemplated in the present Bill to that new and better arrangement—I submit it would be a new and better arrangement—is by the provision here and now of four managers.

I do not care whether they are called assistant managers, or directors of the different services, so long as it is clearly and specifically indicated to the manager that this is the organisation over which he is to take control and that the policy of the national Government in regard to local government is that those are the key services and they are to be organised in this fashion. Keeping my mind not so much on the policy of the managerial system in the present Bill applied to conditions that are now regnant, but to the policy of keeping the door open, or, to put it in another way, to have no door closed against the realisation eventually of the idea of Greater Dublin, it is in that interest that I am inflicting myself on the House in such detail and at such length.

If you keep to the scheme of a manager, plus two assistants, giving one of them the control of a determinate area and the other of the remaining area, then you cannot avoid having non-unification. You have plurality, you have multiplication, and, no matter how much you desire it otherwise, you will have multiplication of officials. That is inevitable, and it means that there is the simulacrum in the City and County of Dublin of the managerial system, because they will really be three managers, each with the centre from which he radiates control, marked out for him legally. I would appeal to the Minister to abandon what I see only as a tendency towards this in his speeches in the Dáil, to abandon the local area ideal and keep rather to that of delegation of services. The first step to that is secured in making a clear plan for the differentiation of functions a part of this legislation.

It is obvious to everyone that for the right government of the municipality there must be someone who is professionally capable and therefore professionally to be made responsible for the care of public health and public assistance, and, as we who have eyes to see are all aware, for the great local development of the city in all directions and all places through the really marvellous expansion in the north, south, east and west. For that, the work of the city architect, and of planning and engineering, becomes of very vital importance, and the right handling of it is of outstanding importance, not merely for the benefit of the capital of the State, but for the benefit of the State itself. Suppose the scheme, as I perhaps misinterpret it, is a scheme of one manager called the city and county manager and two assistants, no matter what they are called, one in the borough and one in the city. With that plan there is bound to be friction. It is already alleged that there is bound to be overlapping, multiplication of offices. Any increase of rates on a population incensed by the policy of the thing will be put down to the managerial idea, and not to the wrong method of using it. The result will be a set-back, and therefore I put it to the Minister that he should guard against prejudicing the success of this great scheme by a flaw of this kind which might militate against it just because a certain part of the scheme might be in the blaze of the searchlight or the limelight.

Comment on this

Undoubtedly, the manager here will be the manager for the city and county, but it does not follow that the person who is now manager in Dún Laoghaire will become the assistant manager for that area. The assistant manager may have certain duties assigned to him from time to time, and even if whoever is the present secretary of the Dublin County Council is selected as assistant manager, it does not follow that he will be assistant manager for the county. These offices will be, from time to time, interchangeable, and it will be up to the city manager to assign these people to different duties. It is not a question of drawing up hard-and-fast rules, and leaving the city manager to look after the city. As the Bill is drafted, there is a certain flexibility about it in that regard. On the other hand, it can be said that there is not any more fusion in this than there is in other cases where two counties are grouped. There is a certain number of counties that are grouped, one with another, and in these cases the manager of one county is also the manager of another. I appreciate very much Senator Magennis's point of view, to the effect that we should bear in mind what will be ultimately Greater Dublin, and the organisation that would be there, but I do not feel that this is closing the door, or even putting up any barrier, to whatever might be done when the time should be suitable. As a matter of fact, we do not regard this as a suitable time to go ahead with the Greater Dublin plan, but I do not think there is anything in the Bill to close the door or to put up any barrier against any developments when times might be more suitable. The Bill, however, is not an attempt at a solution of the Greater Dublin problem, but it may bring the County and the City of Dublin into closer contact, and I think it will mean that there will be closer contact between the county and city than if you were to appoint one county manager and a city manager as well. However, I should like to consider this matter between now and the Report Stage, with a view to seeing whether or not there could be another assistant manager or something on the lines Senator Magennis suggested. I want to say at once, however, that this is not an attempt to solve the problem of Greater Dublin, but, at the same time, there is nothing in this Bill to close the door or to raise any barrier, as I have said, against the solving of that problem when the time comes for it to be put into operation.

Comment on this

In view of what the Minister has said, perhaps I might be permitted to withdraw these amendments.

Comment on this
Leas-Chathaoirleach

I take it that that would include amendments Nos. 11, 12, 13, 14 and 15.

Comment on this

There are two amendments in my name, amendments Nos. 9 and 10. Let us take amendment No. 9 first. I move amendment No. 9.

To delete sub-section (4).

I do not understand the Minister's point here. He has set out in the Bill the various areas to which managers and assistant managers are to be assigned and he is taking power to himself to decide that an assistant manager must be appointed by any local authority to any area in which, in his judgment, he thinks there ought to be an assistant manager. Now, the judgment of the Minister and his advisers may be absolutely sound from their point of view, but there are always two points of view, and I fail to understand what the Minister has in mind in taking this power in the Bill at this stage. First of all, I object to any legislation of this nature. You are going to have a certain number of managers and assistant managers, and we know that, but, according to this section, the Minister takes power to appoint one or two or perhaps more assistant managers in all these areas. As I say, I do not like this business of legislating by order, and that is what this really amounts to. I do not believe that the Minister feels that there is any necessity for this sub-section at all. As a matter of fact, I think that we could do quite well without managers in a number of counties, and I do not believe that there is going to be very much improvement as a result of having these managers appointed, but if, in addition to the manager, we are going to have assistant managers directed to be appointed by the Minister, where are we going to be? Undoubtedly, the people who are bearing the burden of the local rates have got certain benefits; we have built up a tremendous amount of local organisation, but we are paying for it, and, mind you, eventually we shall reach the point where we shall have to stop. I do not believe in this sub-section. I should much prefer if the Minister would say that he was going to appoint a certain number of managers or assistant managers in Cavan, Monaghan, Meath, or the various other counties, but this business of sending down an official to appoint an assistant manager, in my opinion, is all wrong.

Comment on this

If the Senator's amendment were to be accepted, it would mean that you could not appoint an assistant manager except in Dublin, Cork and Dun Laoghaire. The Senator's next amendment proposes to insert the words "after consultation with the council". If the Senator will look at sub-section (9) of this section he will see that, before making an order under this section in respect of a county, the Minister must consult with the council of such county.

When it is brought to the Minister's notice that the manager is not able to perform the duties, the Minister then consults with the council as to the appointment of an assistant manager.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the amendment to delete the sub-section.

Comment on this

You can take it that the council will have to satisfy that it is necessary before the appointment is made. In the Dáil I was trying to indicate, so far as I could, the places where assistant managers would be appointed, but that you could not tie yourself down, that some time in the future it might be necessary to appoint an assistant manager in some other county. That is all.

Comment on this

Would the council have the authority to make the appointment?

Comment on this

While I can see the Minister's point of view, I see what is taking place in my own county. We were one of the first three or four in the country to appoint a county medical officer of health, and there was a certain organisation built around that office. Now I see, as some of us anticipated at the beginning, that the board of health are beginning to realise that the expenditure on this scheme is very considerable indeed, and what is actually taking place now is discussion about cutting down the scheme. That is what you get by going too far and, naturally, in view of the dimensions to which local expenditure has swollen to-day, a great many people are very fearful of all this. They cannot help being fearful. You could go on all down the country employing new officials every day, but unless they were to get more money to spend, there is nothing for them to do. Somebody has to pay. The people in the backwoods, working to get the money, are afraid of this sort of thing.

Comment on this

That may be the Senator's experience of one county, but in a county I happen to know the difficulty is to try to hold them from appointing additional officers.

Comment on this

They have got to be held; that is the point. May I say just one word? Taking these two sub-sections (4) and (9), together, I think (4) would read more happily to the public mind if the Minister put in a phrase like—the wording is not correct—"on the recommendation of a council or a member of an elective body." If he re-drafted it in that way, I think it would be better. Then I come to No. (9). What does the word "consult" mean?

Comment on this

It means "consult"—nothing beyond that.

Comment on this

You consult with me, and I tell you exactly what I think, but finally the Minister can go back to his office and, no matter what the county council says, if he thinks an assistant manager is desirable there, quite regardless of funds, he will appoint him. I am not attempting to wreck in any way, but "consult" is a very vague word as to the result which the consultation produces afterwards. I have got an open mind about this, and that is my contribution towards the debate.

Comment on this

It is used a lot in Acts—consultation between Ministers

Comment on this

It does not mean a lot.

Comment on this

Consultation with the Minister for Finance, for example, is not the same thing as consultation with a county council.

Comment on this

I agree that where you have responsibility there must be power. There is going to be a responsibility on the Minister. The responsibility is imposed upon the Minister to consult. If he is going to have responsibility, then, after he has consulted, he ought to make up his mind and face any criticism on it. I think if you do not have it as it is, you must merely put all the powers in the hands of the council.

Comment on this

Supposing the council, as frequently happens, disagree with the Minister, it would subsequently be within the power of that council to refuse to finance the scheme should the Minister go ahead with it.

Comment on this

I think there is still the word "mandamus." That has not gone out of commission. That is still there.

Comment on this

They must strike a proper rate.

Comment on this

Would there be any point in putting it to the Minister to consider an amendment whereby the request would come from the local authority for the appointment of an assistant county manager? I understand that you are making only a county manager for Galway. I realise that there is a problem there. I realise, too, that there would be no difficulty in a county like Galway making such a request, but I think there is more sense and wisdom about that. After all, when people are paying they like to have some choice. If the Minister is paying he likes to have a word in the choice, he likes to have something to say about it. The Minister decides whether or not an assistant manager is necessary, and he is going to have him selected in Dublin and sent down, and the local people are just to pay. It is not right. That is my feeling. The principle is unsound. We are either sensible and practical down the country, and we are entitled to some trust, or we are incompetent and, if so, there is no hope for the future of the country. I think that it would be a far wiser course, and that the whole working would be harmonious if the local people had the power to request the appointment of an assistant manager. I say again that some county councils may have faults, and that some individual members of the councils are not up to the level of others, but there is no question about it that there is a great number of our county councillors whom you would be proud to know. That is true in every county. You cannot treat such people as if they were children. I am not a member of a county council, but I have had close contact with them for a great many years, and I believe that if the Minister were ready to approach it like that, it would be the right method.

Comment on this

The Senators do not realise that there is a statutory duty being imposed by this on the Minister. He shall consult. Suppose the word "consult" were replaced by "shall invite representations from the county council" I daresay they would be delighted with the clause, but because the ordinary, normal word "consult" is used, they are up in arms. It is an unfortunate oversight in some of these criticisms that they forget the Dáil, they forget the Oireachtas. Suppose the Minister did not consult with the local county council in the matter, the allegation would properly be made that he acted in a high-handed, autocratic fashion. If he is obliged by this sub-section to get the mind of the county council on the matter, suppose he wantonly ignored it—let us make that insulting supposition—questions might be asked about it in the Dáil. All sorts of censures could be moved on the Minister for his action in the matter. So it is not then so bad a situation as we are asked to believe.

Comment on this
Mr. Johnston

A suggestion has been made here that the invitation should come from the council to the Minister to make an additional appointment. From my own experience in my own county, and my experience of other counties, I know that any project, any scheme, any suggestion made by a Minister, a member of a council or anyone else that involves any additional expenditure, anything on the rates or on the people, is opposed and opposed by a number who, while they may not be numerically very strong, are very voluble, and appeal very forcibly to whatever ratepayers may have to foot the bill, with the result that, in some cases, schemes that would be for the benefit of the people of the country are held up for years. Senator Baxter mentioned his own county and the case of a public health scheme, the appointment of a county medical officer of health, which was held up. There was delay also in the case of other counties, and the scheme in my own county was also held up for the reason that I have given, that a number of elected representatives in the county raised the question of the cost on the rates. Some members took the view that the appointment of a county medical officer of health was a form of insurance, and it was urged that it was better to provide for the health and the improvement of the conditions of the youth than to have to pay for them in institutions such as county hospitals, mental hospitals and sanatoria. So long as there is consultation with the councils, my view is met.

Comment on this

When this Bill was going through the Dáil, some Deputies, who were opposed to the managerial system altogether, spoke of it as being another way of flooding the country with officials, and they said that we would have assistant managers all over the country. I had the thing examined as best I could at the time to see if I could indicate where assistant managers would be required and, as a result, we have decided on Cork, Tipperary, amalgamating the two ridings, and Dublin. At the moment, we do not foresee that assistant managers will be required anywhere else, but I can foresee urgings by councils themselves in this respect. From the experience I have at the moment, particularly with regard to hospitals, I can say that the inclination is to have more officials. That is my experience at the moment —pressure from below—and we have to try to stop it. I believe that in the case of many councils that pressure will be forthcoming.

On the other hand, I heard a Deputy say, as I thought, rather recklessly, that they could wreck the Bill. That is the sort of thing that one has to look out for, too. The county which that Deputy represents is very small, and it is unlikely that an assistant manager will be required there, but in the case of a large county, where the manager wanted assistance, if you had a council composed of people of that type, or of that viewpoint, lest anybody should misunderstand my use of the word "type", they might withhold from the manager the assistance to which he was entitled.

I think that what Senator Baxter forgets altogether is that this money which is spent in a county is not all a local charge. Half the amount in every county is contributed by the Central Fund and the Minister is answerable to the Oireachtas for the expenditure of that money and for seeing that the expenditure is kept as low as possible. If an assistant manager is appointed, surely we are going to have questions in the Dáil as to the grounds for such an appointment. When the Bill was passing through the Dáil, as I say, I tried to find out where it would be necessary to appoint assistant managers. Those places are now indicated in the Bill and, at the moment, we do not visualise that any other assistant managers will be required, but we cannot cut out altogether all power to appoint assistant managers, if it becomes necessary.

Comment on this

There are some points which I should like to have clarified. Sub-section (2) sets out that every office of assistant county manager shall be an office to which the Local Authorities (Officers and Employees) Act, 1926, applies. For the first appointments, does that mean that the appointment shall be made by the Local Appointments Commissioners and that there are no restrictions in relation to the appointment of secretaries of boards of health or county councils who have not already been appointed? Otherwise, this will be open to all comers, under the 1926 Act.

Comment on this

The preceding section governs that.

Comment on this

It deals with Dublin and one official is named. It is the other appointments which are not definitely restricted?

Comment on this

Does the Senator mean outside Dublin?

Comment on this

They will be appointed in the ordinary way by the Local Appointments Commissioners. There is preference given to managers if they are secretaries and are suitable, but that does not apply in the case of assistant managers.

Comment on this

Sub-section (2) then means that, outside County Dublin, these assistant county managerial positions are open to all comers?

Comment on this

Yes; there is no preference in anyone's favour.

Comment on this

I should like further to get some clarification of sub-section (4), because one of the assistants is nominated by a section already passed, and it seems to me that there is only one other vacancy. I should like an explanation of sub-section (4).

Comment on this

All that it refers to is temporary appointments.

Comment on this

It does not seem to me to be necessary to have any temporary appointments there because, under a section already passed, one of the assistant managers is nominated, while the other——

Comment on this