We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

County Management Bill, 1939—Committee Stage.

Contributions 138–294 of 294. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill County Management Bill, 1939
Enacted

No. 20 of 1939 ›

I do not like to say that anybody might die, but we cannot ignore these possibilities. That is all it safeguards.

Comment on this

That possibly explains it. I could not understand what it meant because one was already appointed and the other practically appointed, if suitable.

Comment on this

I am not very skilled in this kind of thing, but when you take these sections together, you find a manager and certain assistant managers to whom the manager, if he desires to delegate any functions, is obliged to delegate these functions. When this Bill is passed, will this section not be construed in this way, that the county manager will be unable to delegate functions to any person other than these mentioned persons?

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

That being so, surely, since the Bill is experimental, it would be better to leave the county manager a certain degree of elbow room and to enable him to delegate functions to, for example, certain chief executive officers to find out what the necessity for delegating powers would be when the thing is actually working, rather than to tie him to certain people now, and prevent him from delegating functions to any other person whatever. I know that the Minister is endeavouring to make the best arrangement he can, but, since the matter is experimental, would it not be better that the county manager, looking at the work as it arises, should have more elbow room to make arrangements from time to time to suit the circumstances, because I take it that, under the ordinary law, he will always be subject to inspection and to some degree of ministerial control?

Comment on this

What the Senator wants to get is the very thing which the Bill is aimed at not giving. It would never do to have these managerial functions given to somebody not definitely set out there as assistant manager. That is the object in appointing an assistant manager.

Comment on this

To my mind, Senator Hayes's point borders on what Senator Magennis has referred to already—the delegation of duties— when we were speaking of areas. It was suggested that certain public health matters be delegated to the county medical officer, and that engineering matters be delegated to the borough surveyor or chief engineer. A discussion on those lines has taken place already. It is a thing which raises great possibilities for some future time. A clerical officer may get promotion from year to year into a position in which he is chief over medical officers, and all professional and legal, medical, and other public health officials. In virtue of his office as county manager he is chief of all these. We have already discussed such a managerial system through the different callings, and I think that the Minister has already promised—so far as County Dublin is concerned—to look into that matter. Apparently that scheme of organisation is in the minds of some Senators.

Comment on this

There is some difference between the Minister and Senator O'Donovan. Senator O'Donovan tells us that the Minister is going to look into the point, but the Minister quite clearly tells us—and I understand him quite well—that he is not going to look into the point, and that the Bill is framed to prevent it.

Comment on this

I was referring to the amendments by Senator Magennis.

Comment on this

They were withdrawn.

Comment on this
Leas-Chathaoirleach

I do not think that the two things are connected.

Comment on this

We cannot have somebody going into an urban council office and saying that authority was delegated to him the night before: we must have somebody well known.

Comment on this

Would there not be chief executive officers in that position?

Comment on this

Those functions cannot be distributed amongst officers.

Comment on this

Surely this does not mean that the functions cannot be carried out by somebody under direction?

Comment on this

They can be.

Comment on this

I move amendments Nos. 16 and 17:—

16. In sub-section (2), line 42, to delete the words "the chairman of."

17. In sub-section (3), line 57, to delete the words, "the chairman of."

Sub-section (2) contains the words, "after consultation with the chairman of the county council." It says that where a county manager is on vacation, and also where he may be incapable "as aforesaid," the power of appointing a deputy county manager may be exercised by such county manager after consultation with the chairman of the county council.

My amendment seeks to impose on him an obligation to consult with the county council instead of with the chairman of the county council. I do not understand the principle of consultation with the chairman and the ignoring of the other people. I feel it is not right and that it places the chairman in a very invidious position in relation to his colleagues in the county council. I do not understand why one member of the council should be taken out and consulted while the council in general is not consulted, and do not know what it will mean in the future. When one knows how the chairman happens, frequently, to get into that position in the county council, one knows there are all kinds of reasons why it should not be the chairman alone. If you are going to consult the members of the county council, the whole county council should be consulted. I feel definitely that it is something the chairman would not like to have put upon him and, if he did have it put upon him, I think he would feel disposed to consult his council. If he were a wise man he would. Apparently this is something to be done only between the county manager and the chairman. I would urge the Minister to delete the words "with the chairman", and leave it to read "after consultation with the county council".

Comment on this

I am not very keen as to whether the words are taken out or not, but I would remind Senator Baxter that it is quite a usual practice, to-day or at any other time, for the secretary in a similar position to the county manager to consult with the chairman. It is not so easy to call a meeting of the council and bring members from all over the county. The practice has gone on in my county for years and, during all that time, I have never seen any objection to it and, as a result, I am quite satisfied.

Comment on this

I think the section is all right as it stands. The chairman is really the representative of the county council and, when the manager says he wants to appoint somebody during his absence or sickness, the chairman can always say he is going to consult his council before giving an answer. If, on the other hand, he does not consult him, and does some outrageous thing, he can be put out at the next election.

Comment on this

It may arise on some occasion, but it is the practice in the county boroughs to consult the mayor or lord mayor when the case is urgent. It may happen that the council may not be in session, and the matter may be urgent; then the easiest way is to get the chairman.

Comment on this

I am quite unconvinced. In reply to Senator Byrne, who says the secretary consults the council chairman, I would say that he is the chairman of his county council, and he knows what the practice is. He would consult with the secretary of the county council about urgent and not very important matters of administration which may arise between one meeting and another. Where one is going to make an appointment, however, which may be an appointment to a permanent post in the future—that is not at all impossible—I believe it is something which should not be done by the chairman only. It seems to be that the question of having the appointment made by the chairman only is not right.

Comment on this

On a point of order, it is almost impossible to hear many of the speakers. Three Senators here cannot hear Senator Byrne. The House is so arranged that speakers turn the other way.

Comment on this

It is a recognised fact that the county manager gets his holidays. He may take a week now, and a fortnight some other time. When he is on vacation, he tells the chairman he is appointing the accountant or somebody else like that to carry out his duties.

Comment on this

I can bear out Senator Byrne's remarks. The chairman may appreciate his position or not, but, if he does, he must be careful, as people are far more apt to displace him than to displace a Minister.

Comment on this

I take it that the responsibility in the case of the deputy manager applies exactly in the same way as that of the assistant manager. It seems rather contradictory that, whereas the Minister decides on the salary of the manager, when a deputy is appointed the county council do it. Is there any particular reason for that? It is only a small point.

Comment on this

I do not think so. There is not very much involved in it.

Comment on this

We thought the Minister would decide the salary in both cases.

Comment on this

He will have to approve of the remuneration fixed by the council.

Comment on this

Is there not something terribly contradictory about it all? When I was arguing a little while ago that the request for an assistant ought to come from the council, the House said "no" and the Minister is accordingly to arrange for the appointment of an assistant. The Minister will also fix the salary of the county manager but when it comes to a question of fixing salary of a deputy, the council are to be allowed to fix it.

Comment on this

It may be only a question of a week or two. They can fix whatever remuneration they wish but that is subject to sanction.

Comment on this

The council do not appoint a manager but when it is a question only of filling a trifling job, the council have the liberty to do it.

Comment on this

It may be urgent. It may have to be done quickly and they would not have time to consult the Minister.

Comment on this

The Minister apparently visualises that these deputies will be in office for a short time. Suppose the manager is ill for six months and that the county council said nothing until he came back. What would the Minister's attitude be to a deputy in that case?

Comment on this

The manager, I presume, would appoint his deputy in case of vacation or short illness.

Comment on this

I think provision ought to be made to deal with these matters if deputies are going to be appointed for more than a certain period.

Comment on this

These are very rare cases.

Comment on this

Yet, provision is being made for all sorts of things such as cases where people die and I think that this is a matter that ought to be provided for.

Comment on this

The system has been in operation for a long time in the boroughs and no such situation like that arose.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 18:—

To delete sub-section (7).

In spite of Section 19, which we shall come to presently, under which services, which is the one thing which matters, are to be controlled by the manager—and services cover appointment, duties and dismissal—we find the Minister reserving the function of the appointment of rate collector for the county council. This is a very important matter because the utilisation of rate collectors is the most expensive means you could possibly adopt in any county for the collection of rates. We had that system in operation for years in my county and then we suddenly decided to drop it. I take a little credit to myself and the county secretary for initiating a new departure. We evolved a system whereby all the rates were collected by post and they came in as well as rates have ever come in in County Kerry.

Comment on this

The system was practically an absolute failure.

Comment on this

No, it was just the opposite.

Comment on this

On the contrary.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Senator does not know as much about County Kerry as I do. Another point about rate collectors is, that from the point of view of national uplift it is a very unwise system to have a rate collector going around after a small farmer, watching him after the fair and collecting a bob or two out of his 12/- rates. Mark you, we are trying to produce an uplift in a hundred different ways in this country and we still stick to that sort of system. A third aspect is that rate collectors, if they are appointed by the county council, can give rise to a system of patronage which the whole of this Bill is an attempt to check. That patronage is often exercised in very undesirable ways, ways that are undesirable so far as the ratepayers' pockets are concerned. I certainly cannot see why this question of rate collectors is left alone, whereas all the remaining servants of the county council are put under the control or are appointed by and dismissed by the manager. Another point is that if you make the position of rate collector a permanent office the rate collector is pensionable. If he is elected as a temporary officer, there is always a further resolution passed by the county council, which finally the manager has got to honour, to make him a permanent officer. You get all this pushing up of the rates against which we are all trying to fight and which we hope this Bill will succeed in preventing. I do not think there is any reason why these appointments should be reserved for the council.

Comment on this

Rate collectors are not officers to whom the Officers and Employees Act of 1926 applies, and as a rule they are persons who are long past school-leaving age. They are, therefore, not persons who would be suitable for competitive examination. In addition to that, they are subject to certain regulations. They must provide solvent sureties and insurance. In addition, they are subject not only to the control of the manager, but to inspection by a rates inspector. I do not agree with Senator The McGillycuddy that in Kerry the system of collection by post was a success. I think it was a failure. The collection might have been bad before, but it is very much worse now.

Comment on this

It was worse before.

Comment on this

My information is that it is very much worse since. If a rate collector is inefficient in carrying out his duties, the manager can have him removed. I do not know that it can be considered a bad thing to have rate collectors going around to houses to collect rates. In some cases it is the only way to collect them. If income-tax collectors can go about to collect income-tax, I do not see why rate collectors cannot go around to collect local taxes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 19:—

To delete the section.

I put down this amendment to make a protest, if indeed there is any point in making a protest to the Minister. He is the most inexorable Minister I have come across.

Comment on this

You are taking away all functions from the council.

Comment on this

I have not achieved it. I have put down this amendment to make a protest against the section. Apparently, while the council will have the obligation put upon it to levy a rate, and to see that the rate is collected, it is not going to have anything to say in regard to the services, control, supervision, privileges, or anything of that sort.

I presume that you are going to have a certain number of the people back again who have been accustomed to contact with the existing officials. Staffs will continue to do their work, as they have been doing it, and they are going to be put in the position that their local councillors will have nothing whatever to say to the people in their employment or service regarding their remuneration, privileges, or anything else. I think that is a very undesirable condition of things. I know it has been argued that it is a much more effective way, and that you would get more effective work and have more efficient control by the manager over the staff. That argument presupposes to me that there has been no such thing as efficient control up to the present, and it is something with which I cannot at all agree.

On the whole, we have been getting good service from the staffs of local authorities. I do not say that there have been no black sheep. There are always a certain number of them in every walk of life, but I say that this is definitely not the way to get harmonious work done and to get that kind of understanding necessary if local administration is to be sympathetically carried on. It seems to me that you are going to cut away all the contact between members of the staff and members of the local body except through the county manager. The county manager is to handle the staffs himself, and while it is to be presumed he is going to be a broadminded individual in that matter, it is quite conceivable that he may be just the contrary, and it is also conceivable that you may get a county manager dealing rather unjustly or harshly with the staff. The county manager will not only have the ordinary clerical staffs under his control, but he will also control officials like the county surveyor and the secretary of the board of health. To cut those staffs away from the members of the county council is, in my opinion, an unwise step.

If they have any grievances about their privileges or salaries, they are to have no right to discuss them with members of the council that is levying the rate and seeing that it is collected. I think that is not right. You may argue on one hand that you are going to get more efficient work, but that, as I have suggested, presupposes that the work has not been efficiently done up to the present. I think that is something that we could hardly accept. I do not think that there is much room for greater efficiency in the way that local authorities' staffs will do their work in the future, but I feel that this change in the relationship between the staffs and the members of the council is unsound and will probably prove not to be workable.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister a question.

Comment on this
Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator can ask it on the section. We are now on Senator Baxter's amendment.

Comment on this

I can hardly agree with Senator Baxter in his line of argument. While I do agree with what he says that the services contributed by the staffs generally have been very satisfactory and highly efficient, I entirely approve of the idea that the control of the staffs should be left to the manager completely.

Comment on this
Leas-Chathaoirleach

I am afraid that there is a tendency to turn this into a Second Reading debate. We are on the section, and this is a matter which could be debated at a later stage of the Bill.

Comment on this

I want to say, with all due respect, Sir, that I have seen times when disciplinary action was entirely necessary to maintain a higher standard of efficiency, and there cannot be proper discipline if a certain member of the staff misconducts himself and the county secretary is unable to take action because of certain friends of this individual among the county councillors. I believe the manager can exercise better control over the entire staff, and that we would have a higher standard of efficiency and an improvement on the present conditions.

Comment on this
Leas-Chathaoirleach

That has nothing to do with this section.

Comment on this

I do not want to say anything on this amendment. It really goes to the root of the Bill, and we had all this out on the Second Reading.

Comment on this
Leas-Chathaoirleach

It can, if desired, be raised on a later stage. Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

I want to ask a question on this section. There is no mention in the Second Schedule of certain important powers exercised by the county council—for instance, the electoral college for the panel members of the Seanad, and the election of representatives of insured persons to the committee of management of the National Health Insurance Society. Am I right in assuming that that is covered by Section 21 of the Second Schedule?

Comment on this

These are covered by other Acts.

Comment on this

There is power in the Bill to elect through other bodies.

Comment on this

I think it is rather an important point.

Comment on this

Paragraph 12 of Second Schedule would cover parliamentary and local elections.

Comment on this

Would it cover elections to the National Health Insurance Society?

Comment on this

Section 34 also deals with appointments to other bodies.

Comment on this

I think that does not exactly cover it.

Comment on this

In any case, if Senator Mrs. Concannon makes that point, I will have it looked into and considered on the Report Stage. Perhaps she will give me a note about it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 20, standing in Senator Quirke's name:—

In sub-section (5), page 12, to delete lines 24 and 25 and the word "member" in line 26 and to substitute the words "the presence of a member or any of a number of members".

It is a purely drafting amendment.

Comment on this

Yes, this is just a drafting amendment, and is designed to make the matter more flexible in the case of documents, warrants, and so on.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 21:—

In sub-section (5), line 16, page 12, to delete the words "for the inspection of" and insert instead the words "and read to".

My point is that the manager should produce and read for the members of the council the orders which he makes. I think that, in this regard, it is not enough for the manager to make orders and just have them registered in a register or minute book, or whatever you like to call it, throw that book on the table, and let the councillors read it or not or take an interest in it or not. I think that the obligation should be imposed on the manager to let the members of the council know what is being done from one meeting to another. If, between meetings, a number of orders have been made by the manager, I think that at least it should be obligatory on him to produce and read out these orders, or at least the substance of these orders. Merely to produce the book and give no other indication of what has been done, in my opinion, is not sufficient, and I think that the more contact that you have between the manager, in his active and actual work, and the members of the council, the better it will be. It is very desirable that we should have harmony between the manager and the council, and I think that there will be greater harmony between the manager and the council if the manager keeps his council informed as to what he is doing. I suggest that my amendment would help towards that end.

Comment on this

Sometimes there might be long intervals between meetings of a council and numerous orders might be made in the meantime, and I think that to read out all these things would be a waste, not alone of the manager's time, but of the time of the council. The register will be there, and any member of the council can get a copy of these orders, and the manager is bound to supply them. As a matter of fact, in the case of some city or borough or county councils the managers have found it practicable to circulate these orders to the members of the council, although there is no obligation upon them to do so. We are not putting that obligation on the manager, since any member of the council can get the orders if he wishes to do so.

Comment on this

I think that it would be rather desirable to have something like this in the Bill, because very often, when you go into a council meeting, you may not have the time to look up the particulars of whatever orders may be on the table. I think that these orders should be circulated, and I do not see any reason why there should not be something to that effect in the Bill.

Comment on this

Well, perhaps that could be done.

Comment on this

Could it not be arranged under their own by-laws that the manager should be instructed to circulate these orders?

Comment on this

Perhaps they could, but I am not sure about that.

Comment on this

Would it not be covered by the by-laws?

Comment on this

I do not think they would have power to make a by-law in that connection.

Comment on this

Well, I think it is rather important that, if any order is made, it should be circulated.

Comment on this

In practice, it is done in the case of a number of councils.

Comment on this

I think that what generally happens is that most of the councillors do not turn up until after the order is read, and I rather thought that the circulating of these orders was the correct thing.

Comment on this

Perhaps my experience is different from that of other Senators, but I am trying to think of normal councils with normal people acting as councillors, where people pay rates and like to get service for the rates they pay and take an interest in the things that are done. There may be a question of a bridge to be repaired, or some such thing, and an order made about that by the county surveyor or the county manager, and I feel that it is not sufficient for the manager to come in and just leave his register there on the table for the chairman or councillors to look through. That might mean looking down through a whole series of orders dealing with the whole county in order that a councillor might find out what happened in his own district. Take the case of the Order Paper of the Seanad here. I have it here in my hand and there is quite a long list of Orders that are left on the Table. I wonder how many Senators take the trouble to go through these Orders, although I admit that it is our job to do so. However, I am quite certain that it is not fully done, and I think that, from the point of view of the county councils, it is very necessary that the members of these councils should be kept fully cognisant of the activities of the county manager. The county manager may make a particular order affecting a particular part of the county, and which may involve a lot of expenditure. That is put down in his book, but the county councillors in another district will not know anything about that. It may happen that some trouble will arise about that particular matter, perhaps some months later, and then there is a lot of to-do about the matter and a great deal of confusion arises that could have been avoided. I believe that the county councillors should be informed of what the manager is doing, that it should not be merely a matter of his leaving the orders on the table, and that there should be an obligation on him to inform the councillors of what he has been doing, and, in the second place, that there should be an obligation on the councillors themselves to listen to him and discover from him what is taking place. I think that the right way to deal with these orders is to have them read out at the council meetings, or at least to have their headings read out. I know that there is a certain difficulty with regard to the shortage of paper at the moment in connection with the circulation of these lengthy orders, but I am not speaking of Dublin now, I am speaking of the ordinary councils down through the country. I am not thinking of the manifold orders that will have to be made in the case of a city such as Dublin. That is another problem, and I am not seeking to deal with that.

Comment on this

Is not Senator Baxter's point covered by Section 26, where it says that "every county manager shall, whenever requested by the council of his county or by an elective body for which he is the manager or by the chairman of such council or of any such body so to do, afford to such council, body, or chairman, as the case may require, all such information as may be in the possession or procurement of such county manager in regard to any Act, matter, or thing appertaining to or concerning any business or transaction of such council or body, as the case may be, which is mentioned in such request"? That covers amply the principle of Equity, vigilantibus non dormientibus.

Comment on this

I would just like to say, in reply to Professor Magennis, that that betrays two completely different lines of approach. I do not want the county councillor going to the county manager asking: "What did you do about this? Where do we stand with regard to that?" I want the obligation put on the county manager to tell the people, amongst whom he is living and working, what he is doing, and I think that that is the least that can be expected of him. I think our county councillors will have to go to the manager at the meetings in a rather informal way, in a sort of confused way, that each county councillor will be putting the question: "What did you do about this and that?" I believe that you would have a much more orderly and better informed council if what I am urging were accepted. I definitely feel that it is not the way to get the work done that our county councillors would have to go to the manager and say: "Please, sir, will you tell me what did you do about this?"

Comment on this

On that point, in regard to Section 26, would it not be possible for the manager to circulate something to the councillors similar to the minutes which are already circulated in every properly run council? That could be done by means of the Gestetner machines, which would make the work much easier than it used to be.

Comment on this

If the council requests that, there is no difficulty. The difficulty I see about reading out all these things is that the councillors might not be there. Councillors, working against time, would know that it would take a certain time to read out all these matters. Take a quarterly meeting. Every little thing the manager did during the three months might have to be read at that meeting and would take considerable time. I do not think it would be practicable to do it in that way. But under that section the councillors can get copies. It is not a question of saying, "Please, sir, give me this." It is a question of asking for what they are entitled to get. They are entitled to get a copy of every order that has been made since the last meeting. There is nothing to prevent the councillors getting from the manager a copy of all the orders.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 22:—

In sub-section (2), line 62, after the word "shall" to insert the words "after consultation with the county council."

I am urging, and I have argued it already, with regard to the question of service, remuneration, privileges, and superannuation of officers, that that will be done after consultation with the county council. I am not going to argue any more about it.

Comment on this

I think that would not be an advance, because a weak manager might try to shift the responsibility on to the county council, which I do not want.

Comment on this

I am only suggesting consultation.

Comment on this

You know what that develops into very often.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 23:—

In sub-section (1), page 14, line 41, to delete the word "in" and to substitute the word "for".

This is purely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

It says "in each local financial year". That might mean that the estimate should be prepared in the year to which it related. As members of councils know, these estimates are prepared before that year begins.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 24:—

In sub-section (1), page 14, line 42, to delete the word "at" and substitute the word "during", and to delete the word "time" and substitute the words "period and in the prescribed form".

This is also a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I think there is a chance of improving the present procedure. In the second line of Section 21, sub-section (1), are the words "at the prescribed time". The prescribed time is laid down, first of all for the county board of health, which is done away with, but for which there will still have to be an estimate of some sort, and for the county council, in the Public Bodies Order—I think Sections 76 and 79. It is laid down that the county board of health puts in its estimate at a certain date early in the year, and, two months later, the county council produces its own estimate, and at another time the roads estimate is put in as well. We find the rates going up year by year. The councillors come in, and on the estimate day, when the manager, as he will be now, puts forward the estimate, nobody has any idea, or very little idea, of what they are spending. The Minister has power under Article 3 of the Public Bodies Order from time to time to assent to any departure from the rules and regulations contained in this order. I do not know whether that always gives him the power to fix certain dates, but what I am suggesting is that, instead of the prescribed time being laid down, at a definite time early in the year there should first of all be a preliminary estimate in which the manager would describe to the county council what I call the fixed charges which he had to meet, such as interest on overdrafts and so on, so as to give them some idea of what they had got to spend before they started doing any improvements or anything else, and of their influence in the shapes of shillings and pennies on the actual rate itself.

If this original estimate were to be reviewed periodically—and the order made by the Minister would be varied to insist on this—I think the council would be far better aware of the degree to which the rate grew from, we will say, February, which is the first date, to June, and so on. The manager could say, "If you do this, your rate will grow from 7/- to 11/- and you have still six months to go." I think there would be very many fewer resolutions for improvements and works. I admit that schemes would move a good deal more slowly but these schemes would move in far better relation to the ability of the ratepayers to pay. Just to go back to that story of Kerry and to what Senator Madden said and the Minister said. The fault lies not with the post office collection. In fact, but for the post office collection, you would have no rates in Kerry at all, but the fault lies with the fact that the councillors come in, each one primed for a particular scheme. All the schemes are voted and passed, and but for the Minister here at the top, it is incredible what would be the burden on the ratepayers. Finally, the unfortunate ratepayers simply cannot foot the bill, and that is why we have got arrears of £59,000, not because we are unwilling to pay, we are burning to pay, but we cannot and that is the whole thing. I do suggest that the Minister's staff should examine the wording——

Comment on this

Could not your point be met under the Public Bodies Order?

Comment on this

I think you use the words "the prescribed time".

Comment on this

We are changing that in the amendment.

Comment on this

You do not use the words "prescribed time" at all in the Public Bodies Order?

Comment on this

The prescribed period.

Comment on this

I think what is required from the Department is a circular letter indicating the general idea of what I propose, but there should be periodical reviews and a definite statement to the council of what they are spending.

Comment on this

There is no objection at all to that.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 25:—

In sub-section (1), page 15, line 14, to delete the word "in" and to substitute the word "for".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 26:—

In sub-section (1), page 15, line 15, to delete the word "at" and to substitute the word "during" and to delete the word "time" and to substitute the words "period and in the prescribed form".

Comment on this

I move amendments Nos. 27 and 28:—

27. In sub-section (1), page 16, to insert in line 41 before the word "consent" the words "for any local financial year", to delete all words from the word "in" in line 42 to the word "expenses" in line 46, to insert in line 46 before the word "specified" the words "for any particular purpose", and to delete in lines 46 and 47 the words "particular power, function, or duty" and to substitute the words "financial year".

28. In sub-section (2), page 16, to delete all words from the words "in respect" in line 52 to the word "year" in line 56 and to substitute the words "for any particular purpose specified in the estimate of expenses for such local financial year", to insert in line 56 before the word "amount" the word "total", and to delete in line 57 the words "power, function, or duty" and to substitute the word "purposes".

Comment on this

These amendments are inserted following representations by the secretaries of county councils. They say that it is quite easy for them to estimate under four principal heads, but that there are certain sub-divisions of these four heads in respect of which it is not so easy to estimate. They will, I hope, be satisfied with the provision that they shall keep within the estimate for any one of the four principal heads, but that in the case of the smaller things they may save on one and apply the saving to another. It is a matter of being able to keep within their estimate without tying themselves down in respect of the minor portions of the estimate. It gives more flexibility.

Comment on this

I am afraid I have not quite taken in these amendments. Do they make sure that large supplementary estimates, such as we have here, cannot be placed on a council by resolution, that is, estimates over and above those made at the prescribed times?

Comment on this

If a council wants to do more, they will have to put up the money.

Comment on this

I think it is a very dangerous practice to allow these supplementary estimates. I think there should be a definite limitation and that they should set down at the four prescribed dates, if you like, what they are going to spend, because the rates are going up, as the Minister knows, beyond the capacity of everybody to pay.

Comment on this

It will not be a question of supplementary estimates but of making a rate at the beginning of the year. If they want to get particular work done and provide the money, they can do it, but it is when they are making the rate that they must provide the money.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 29:—

Before Section 25 on page 16, to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) Each body to which this Act applies shall as soon as may be after the expiration of each half year (but not later than four months after the 30th September and 31st March) have its accounts for the period balanced and made ready for audit, and a notification to this effect sent to the Local Government Department.

(2) The Local Government Department shall within ten months after the close of each financial half year send an auditor to examine and certify the accounts.

(3) At least fourteen days prior to each audit a notice of intention to audit shall be inserted in a newspaper or newspapers circulating in the administrative area; and on completion of each audit a notice of completion shall be inserted in a newspaper or newspapers circulating in the administrative area.

(4) Within four weeks after the auditor has duly certified the accounts for each half year the Manager shall cause to be inserted in a newspaper or newspapers circulating in the administrative area a statement of Receipts and Expenditure under the various heads, a summary of balances in favour and/or against at the close of the half year, and a statement of assets and liabilities.

(5) As soon as may be after each half-yearly audit the complete abstract of accounts as certified by the auditor shall be printed, and copies of such abstract made available to ratepayers on payment of one shilling for each copy.

During the passage of the Bill through the Dáil, an amendment on somewhat similar lines was moved and, after discussion, was, by leave, withdrawn. That amendment called for an audit of the accounts of each body to which the Act applies not later than four months after the close of each financial year, by either a Local Government auditor or a chartered accountant appointed by the Minister for the purpose. It also called for the insertion in a newspaper or newspapers circulating in the administrative area of a statement of receipts and expenditure under the various heads, a summary of balances in favour or against each account, and the manager's or secretary's statements of assets and liabilities. It finally asked that as soon as might be after the completion of each half-yearly audit, a complete abstract of accounts duly certified by the auditors should be printed, and copies made available to ratepayers on payment of 1/- for each copy.

The Minister on that occasion, while agreeing that it was very undesirable that there should be delay in auditing the accounts of public bodies, contended, and reasonably in my opinion, that if the auditing of these accounts was to be completed within four months, it would entail the employment of a number of extra auditors, for whom no work would be available for the remaining eight months of the year. He also stated that in a few instances he had come across, the engagement of chartered accountants to do this work, owing to their lack of contact with public bodies, had imposed a big charge on the councils, due probably, he said, to the extra time necessary to perform the work. He finally said that he did not think it desirable to have too much rigidity in matters of this kind.

The amendment I submit is drafted so as, firstly, to remove the rigidity to which the Minister referred; secondly, to ensure that the Local Government auditors will have a somewhat even spread of work throughout the year; and, finally, to make available to the ratepayers through the medium of advertisements in the Press in the particular administrative area, the financial condition of such public bodies functioning in that area. I think it can very reasonably be argued that to whatever extent illegalities or irregularities have occurred from time to time under the present system, they may be attributed, to some extent at any rate, to the Local Government Department's remissness in this matter of regular audits. Such audits of public bodies' accounts have not hitherto been carried out with that regularity which one would wish.

A reply to a recent Question in the Dáil on this matter elicited the information that there are some county councils and boards of health seven half-years in arrears with audits, and the average for all county councils and boards of health is four half-years in arrears. That return, in my opinion, amply justifies the amendment with regard to regular audits of accounts of public bodies to which the Act will apply, and I do not think it would be unfair to say that no business concern could be properly controlled or managed if the same haphazard system of audits were permitted. I think that disaster would inevitably follow such a practice. It is unnecessary to stress this aspect beyond saying that the ratepayers individually are entitled to know within a reasonable period how their money is spent, and are also entitled to the safeguards which regular audits by competent auditors will, in my opinion, secure for them.

I do not make any allegation against the Local Government Department as such. The request for prior publication of notice of intention to audit and of the completion of the audit, and the publication of the audited accounts in the Press is certainly not unreasonable. In fact, I submit that when the Act comes into operation and responsibility for all expenditure will have become vested in virtually one man or woman —I presume that a woman may even become a county manager—it will be more imperative and desirable than ever before that full and effective publicity should be availed of so that the ratepayers will be in a position to know how their money is being spent. I want it to be clearly understood that I make no charge whatever against the efficiency of the Local Government auditing department. I have no doubt whatever that the auditors of the Department are as competent to discharge their duties and to render efficient and valuable service to the community as any other branch of the Civil Service, but I do suggest that it should be so organised and sufficiently staffed as to ensure the carrying out of the audits within the time prescribed in the amendment, or, at least, in a somewhat reasonable period.

I have heard it suggested—I must confess that I do not believe there is any truth in the suggestion—that instances have from time to time occurred where irregularities or illegalities have, for alleged political reasons, been passed over without comment or surcharge, and it is for the purpose of obviating such happenings, or suggestions that such things could happen, that I am advocating in the amendment that, under the new régime, the county management system should be made thoroughly watertight.

This, in my opinion, can be accomplished only by rigid adherence to the principle of regular audits and the publication of the necessary information in connection therewith. I am sure the Minister is getting ready to turn this amendment down, and I would just draw attention to a statement that he made in the Dáil when he said that he did not think it was desirable to have it, and that he thought it was covered in the Public Bodies Order. The Minister said that he would keep that in mind and see what could be done. I would ask him now, if he turns down this amendment, to see if the terms of the amendment can be given effect to by the Public Bodies Order. That would save time.

Comment on this

The provisions of the Public Bodies Order already in operation are, I think, sufficient. Article 37 of the Public Bodies Order, 1925, says:—

When the secretary or clerk has received from the Department of Local Government and Public Health a copy of the auditor's report and of the abstract, he shall lay the same before the council or board at their next meeting and shall forthwith after such meeting, in lieu of the publication of the abstract of accounts directed to be published by Section 18 of the Local Government (Ireland) Act, 1871, publish a notice (Form 15) in some one or more of the public newspapers circulating throughout the county and district; and shall furnish without charge to the proprietor or editor of any newspaper who may apply for the same, and to each member of the council or board, a copy of the auditor's report and a copy of the abstract; he shall also furnish a copy of the report and abstract to any person who applies for the same and pays therefor to the council or board the sum of sixpence.

If the Minister shall so direct, the council or board shall publish the auditor's report in a newspaper circulating throughout the county, borough, or district.

While I regret that there may have been delay in auditing accounts, and while I may try in some way to speed that up, I do not think it is wise to accept this, and cannot undertake to pin the auditors down to a certain period. We are trying to do the best we can with the staff we have. Some members of the staff were changed over to other Departments at one time, when the other Departments were interfered with also, but certainly we will try to speed matters up. Senator Campbell seems to be making a charge which I never heard of, and which I feel is without foundation—I did not gather whether he was making it against auditors or against the members of councils—that certain things were passed over for political reasons.

Comment on this

I am not making any charge, but I heard the suggestion.

Comment on this

That is quite all right, so. I have never heard it. That is sufficient regarding the first portion of the amendment. The time of the audit will have to depend on the time it takes and the volume of work to be done. Very often, for various reasons, the auditor has to postpone the audit from one time to another, and it may extend over a lengthy period. I do not think we could impose other duties on councils about printing. That is a matter for the councils themselves, and if they want to do it I do not suppose there would be any objection. Anybody interested can get a certified abstract of the accounts for sixpence. The members of the council get it for nothing, and I do not think there is any necessity to ask the council to incur more expense. Even when it is only sixpence, very little interest is taken in it, and very few people apply for it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 31:—

In sub-section (1), line 26, to insert after the word "things" the words "under the advice of the Council's legal adviser".

This section deals with legal proceedings. The section reads:

In every action or other legal proceeding, whether civil or criminal, instituted in any court of law or equity by or against the council of a county, the county manager for that county shall act for and on behalf of such council and may do all such acts, matters, and things as he may consider necessary....

I am seeking to insert there "under the advice of the Council's legal adviser." Some councils have had peculiar experience in this matter of legal action. There is a legal adviser attached to each council and it should not be within the power of the county manager to proceed to any sort of legal action, either as plaintiff or defendant, and go into any court and become involved in all sorts of costs, without seeking legal advice. Whatever is done should be done under the advice of the solicitor to the county council. Secretaries of county councils are going to be appointed as county managers, presumably; most of them are very efficient, I am sure, and will probably do the work as well as anybody else.

However, it is one thing to be a county manager and another thing to be a lawyer. I do not think so many of them are lawyers. If they are going to be given power to decide whether or not they are going to enter into all sorts of legal proceedings—and to do that without consultation with the solicitor—I fear the result will be unsatisfactory. I have some experience of that, and know that it is not the thing to do. The county managers should not get this power without there being an obligation on them to seek legal opinion.

Comment on this

It seems quite obvious, from the fact that a solicitor is appointed at all, that it is the business of the county manager to consult him. Otherwise he would not be there. If you were to follow that idea to its logical conclusion, you should say that in certain cases it would be the business of the county manager to consult senior counsel. I do not think there is any necessity to put that in. A person with sufficient commonsense and ability will be appointed as county manager. If he does not apply for the advice of a solicitor or other legal expert, and makes a mistake, causing a whole lot of expense, he can be hauled over the coals.

Comment on this

What is then going to happen to the manager? If he is very busy and hands a case over to somebody else to proceed with without having consulted the solicitor: supposing that he loses the case, is he surcharged?

Comment on this

The manager who would be so busy that he could not look after his own business should not be manager.

Comment on this

He would have five elected bodies to deal with.

Comment on this

He has a solicitor for each body. If he did not take proper precautions he would be surcharged.

Comment on this

While what the Minister says is quite all right, this section reads in a particular way. I am not talking without some experience and I suggest that this is essential. We are not legislating for to-day only: even to-day these things have happened, and county councils have been engaged in rather extravagant legal proceedings. The county manager is being put in the position that he shall act "for and on behalf of such council and may do all such acts, matters, and things as he may consider necessary for the preparation and prosecution or defence of such action...." He could embark on proceedings—indeed, they have been embarked on—without advice.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Senator Baxter should read on a little further in sub-section (1): "in the same manner in all respects as if he were the plaintiff or prosecutor or the defendant therein". That is, he shall use the same diligence in regard to the affairs of the council as if it were his own case; and, if he does not, he is guilty of culpable negligence.

Comment on this

There are times when it is rather difficult to argue your case.

Comment on this

This is one of the times.

Comment on this

It is not that there is not the justification. It is not because there is not a very good case. I think the Minister should be quite satisfied that there is a very good reason why I could argue it. You may have a manager who thinks that he would know as much about the law as any lawyer. With all respect to the lawyers, there are any number of laymen who think they know a good deal about law, and that sometimes the lawyers are not right in their opinions. If the county manager is put in the position that he can engage in legal proceedings, both in regard to taking the initiative in actions against contractors or acting on the defensive where contractors may take legal proceedings, you may have a council involved in considerable expense that would be avoided if proper methods were adopted and proper steps taken with regard to consultation with a legal adviser. I am not going to argue the matter any further than that.

Comment on this

I think the manager will have quite enough to do to look after his own business and to refer those matters involving legal proceedings to solicitors, just the same as he will have to be guided by the road engineers in respect to matters connected with roads. Even if you have a man inclined to be a meddler, he will have enough to do in looking after the duties of his own office.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 32:—

To delete the section.

I do not intend to delay the House very long on this amendment. My purpose is at the eleventh hour to suggest to the Minister that something more should be done in relation to medical charities, as applied to mental hospitals and other hospitals as well. In Section 33, amongst the matters which are set out as the duty of the visiting committee of a district mental hospital is the following:

"From time to time to visit such hospital and there to hear any complaints which may be made to them by any inmate of such hospital and, if so requested by such inmate, to hear such complaints in private."

Then, again, in sub-section (4), it is set out that the visiting committee of a district mental hospital shall not inquire into or receive any complaint or make any report in relation to the services, remuneration, privileges or superannuation of the officers and servants of such hospital or any of such officers or servants. I submit, Sir, that sub-section (a), which I quoted first, is somewhat loose in its drafting. I think the section takes away authority that might reasonably be left with the committee. I would suggest to the Minister that this Bill would be very much improved by leaving all hospitals in charge of the councils. I do not see that a visiting committee can be of much use if, after hearing complaints of a weakened mind in the hospital, they find that nothing must be done in regard to the staff. I think you must look to the staff of the mental hospital to give loyalty to the council and to the representatives of the people.

It has been stated that good government is no substitute for government by the people. I think that is a very sound principle. To take away all power from representatives of the patients, and to place it absolutely in the hands of a professional man, is to my mind wrong. How can these poor people who go into these hospitals voice any grievance that they may have when redress through the councils is barred to them? I should not like to tell the Minister how difficult I find it to get into his Department to make a complaint sometimes. I do not want to enter on a Second Reading speech, but I submit that there are in this country scores of people whose services could be utilised for medical charities. I would remind Senator Robinson that about two months ago he attended a meeting with me, a meeting loosely called at seven o'clock on a winter's night, and we had 120 or 130 people there who were anxious to give their services to the Red Cross when the war came along, and when these services were to be given outside Ireland. I think that the State here should do something to invite such people, who are willing to give their services, to do so through the medium of medical charities to hospitals. I think it is a mistake to take control from the people in regard to these hospitals.

It is quite possible to limit expense and at the same time to invite the sympathy and support of those who are prepared to contribute them. The Red Cross Society, the St. Vincent de Paul Society and the Fianna Fáil clubs should all be invited to contribute their services. A sense of citizenship and of duty to others could be legally and legitimately developed in that way without infringing on anybody. How can you expect such services to be rendered if you provide in this Bill that the visiting committee of a mental hospital shall not inquire into or receive any complaints, or make any reports in relation to the services of officers and servants of such hospitals? It is all very well for Senator Magennis to tell me that certain things are provided for in the Bill. That is the professional mind down to a "T"—it is in the Bill, and everything in the library is all right; but when it comes down to the bogs, to Biddy McGee, Jane Moran, and the rest of them, I should like to see these provisions implemented much more thoroughly than this Bill provides for. There is none of these powers that could not be exercised by the local board. If you limit the expense, you cannot possibly do any harm or injustice to anybody.

Comment on this

The Senator, I think, is criticising certain aspects of the question, but he is really seeking the deletion of the whole section. The position that will arise is that you would have mental hospital committees and the manager would have no control over them, or the staff, or anything else. Mental hospitals are costing £1,000,000 a year and they have about 3,000 officials. I notice that a further amendment put forward by the Senator proposes to maintain boards of health. If you maintain mental hospitals and boards of health and exclude them from the manager, it is just as well to withdraw the Bill.

Comment on this

I did not suggest any such thing. I had in mind the maintenance of cohesion, and these different committees could be appointed by the council, subject to the manager.

Comment on this

I have stated the effect of the amendment. Bodies would be appointed at the request of the manager to deal with various things in certain cases.

Comment on this

There is just one point on this section. Sub-section (5) seems to be a rather extraordinary one. It says:

"The visiting committee of a district mental hospital shall collectively, and every member of such committee shall individually, be entitled at all times to visit such hospital and to have free access to every part thereof."

That power given to an individual member might on occasion be dangerous and I suggest that something ought to be done to amend it.

Comment on this

We propose to regulate that on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Thanks. I was going to suggest that you could insert the words "subject to the consent of the resident medical superintendent".

Comment on this

"Subject to regulations being made," and the regulations will cover that point.

Comment on this

I do not think you will have any trouble about that.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister a question. Does the term "public body" apply to governing bodies?

Comment on this

That is a matter I will get cleared up some time before the Report Stage, but we think it does.

Comment on this

With regard to the question raised by Senator Mrs. Concannon, I would like to know if the nomination of electors for the Seanad is covered by Section 34.

Comment on this

That will be looked up.

Comment on this

It will be a serious occurrence if the Seanad fell through, through any neglect of ours.

Comment on this

I think it is covered by another Act.

Comment on this

I move:—

In line 21, page 24, to delete the words "conditions as to payment or".

I want to end on rather a high note. The whole way through this debate Senator Baxter has been whispering in my ear, complaining of the standard of my county council. He told me that they are not orderly, that they are a frightful body——

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

It is really magical in that sense that I have put in a proposal that those four words "conditions as to payment" should be cut out from the reserved functions of the county council. The reasons are my experience of a mental hospital committee. First of all the members arrive, generally on a Saturday, and they do what work the medical superintendent puts before them and apart from what Senator McGee is frightened of, I want to tell him that during the last three years I do not think that one single member of that hospital committee has ever visited one ward or any part of the hospital. But when suddenly somebody meets him and says "Mary So-and-so, or Paddy So-and-so is no longer able to pay," notwithstanding the fact that he has paid ever since the time of entry, a resolution is put forward that in these particular cases, the actual charges should be remitted.

The medical superintendent and the county secretary have told me again and again that there was no foundation for it whatever, and in one case a resolution was put down that the whole scale of charges should not be remitted but reduced. It seems to me that the manager and the medical superintendent in preparing their estimates in the beginning of the year should be able to decide, on their contracts and the normal maintenance of the hospital, what the contributions of the patients as a whole should be and I think that this is only opening a chance of patronage which the whole of this Bill is attempting to take away from people who are prone to use it for one end or the other. The amendment seeks to take away patronage in that particular case. I would like the Minister to take out those four little words.

Comment on this

Some references made by Senator The McGillycuddy are just what I was going to say. I wanted to refer to three items on this Schedule.

Comment on this

We must dispose of the amendment first.

Comment on this

One of them has been referred to by Senator The McGillycuddy. What struck me was the making of the regulations by the council.

Comment on this

I never raised that. I raised only the question of the conditions of payment.

Comment on this

We will deal with the amendment.

Comment on this

This is taken from Section 9 (6) of the Local Government Act, 1898. It has not been of any practical importance during those intervening years. Where the council sets apart a certain portion of a mental hospital to deal with private patients who are able to pay in full, it provides that the council will have power to fix what should be charged for maintenance. Where a person goes into a mental hospital in the ordinary way, it is a matter for the manager to recover if they are able to pay. If he ascertains that a certain patient in a mental hospital has relatives who are able to pay, he can proceed to collect himself, but up to the present in those mental hospitals no portion has been set aside for dealing with purely private patients. The matter is therefore of no importance, and I do not mind one way or the other, but we took it from the 1898 Act.

Comment on this

That is leaving the position as it is at present?

Comment on this

I want to raise a few points with regard to some things that I think could be done better and with more efficiency by the county manager. This is the Schedule defining reserved functions, and one of them is the sub-section that has been referred to in the amendment. It is the making of these regulations, however, which seems to me to be imposing work on the councils which they might not be able to do efficiently. I wish to put forward the point of view that the making of regulations in clause 8 might be better performed by the county manager and his staff. Then in clause 9 (d) there is mention of the making and submission of a planning scheme under Section 29 of the Town and Regional Planning Act, 1934. That is giving democracy a greater power, if you like, but I think that the functions under clause 9 (d) would be better performed by the manager and his officials. I put forward that suggestion to the Minister. I have another suggestion with regard to clause 12, which simply details parliamentary and local elections as being a reserved function for the council. I do not think that that definition is wide enough. Does it mean the entire supervision of parliamentary elections? That matter was not actually in the power of the county council but was under the returning officer who was a law unto himself. To simply put down under clause 12, parliamentary and local elections, seems to me to be not explanatory enough. What is meant by parliamentary and local elections being a reserved function? It does not mean anything to me.

Comment on this

Well, it means something to the Seanad. What I mean is that we thought that might cover the method of election to the Seanad.

Comment on this

Well, it should be put down in such a way as to embrace that. I think that the clause requires some clarification. Clause 21 describes as a reserved function: "the exercise of a power which is vested by law, including this Act, in the council of a county or an elective body and is by this Act expressly made exercisable by resolution of such council or body". I thought that Senators might come under that. I understood that an elective body was different. It says "the council of a county or an elective body". I think that, with a little clarification, the election of Senators would come in there. It says "the exercise of a power which is vested by law, including this Act, in the council of a county or an elective body" to do so-and-so, but subsequently it says here that by this Act it shall be expressly made exercisable by resolution of such council or body. That seems to rule out the nomination of the electoral college. In my opinion, clause 21 could be clarified to include the electoral college, and I also think that clause 12 should be clarified and that the making and submission of a planning scheme, mentioned in clause 9 (d) should not be considered as a reserved function, because it seems to me to be too deep a subject for the members of the council to be able to give the study and time that would be essential in the preparation of a town-planning scheme under the Town and Regional Planning Act. I do not mean that as any slur on or insult to councils, but I think that, in their own interests and in the interests of efficiency, it might be better to have these things performed by the county manager and his staff.

Comment on this

I think that is an abominable suggestion. I think it is ridiculous to think that all the initiative and intelligence of Ireland is wrapped up in the professional men. Clause 9 (d) reserves the making of a planning scheme to the council, and so far as the professional men are concerned it does not require much training for any man to be able to see the state of the market in Dublin on a Thursday, and the litter and dirt that is there, when all that should be out in some area such as the Clontarf area. What is the use in Senator O'Donovan, just because he is a professional man himself, telling us that the members of the councils have not enough initiative, when anyone can see in Dublin on a Thursday morning that there is a positive danger to life and limb to anyone passing by the market. I suggest that these professional people should be kept out of such matters, and that they should be left in the hands of the ordinary, natural people like myself, from the bogs and hills. The ordinary people have just as much initiative, and we do not want to be coming in here to be listening to a lot of windbag professors.

Comment on this

Clause 21 is intended merely to preserve the powers under this Act as well as other Acts, but if you did not put clause 21 there it would mean that the manager might be in the position of the council, and it is to preserve the reserved functions given to the council under the Act itself, and that they should be exercisable by the council, that that clause is there.

Second Schedule agreed to.

THIRD SCHEDULE.

Comment on this

I formally move amendment No. 35:—

In sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 10, page 27, line 32, to delete the word "expenditure" and to substitute the word "payments".

Comment on this

It is considered that "payments" is a better word than "expenditure".

Comment on this