Institute for Advanced Studies Bill, 1939—Committee.
Contributions 177–368 of 368. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 24 of 1939 ›
I can only have it examined from that point of view. Saying "shall determine from time to time" will do more than it was originally intended to do. Asking people to come into an existing position in which they would have security of tenure is different from asking them to come into a position from which they might be arbitrarily removed. I will have to postpone consideration of this question.
Comment on this
In business circles— though not actually in my own business —I have come across the case of a person who was not obtained for a certain position, but who would have been obtained were it not that a solicitor advised him that the terms of the contract could be overridden by an Act of Parliament. I should like the Taoiseach to consider something such as is contained in amendment No. 14.
Comment on this
The machinery for appointment or removal should be the same, and the question is to express that in such a way that it will not be regarded as giving arbitrary power to override a contract. I shall have to get legal advice about that.
Comment on this
Regarding the point "from time to time", which is not really in relation to removal, but with regard to salaries and conditions of service, I suggest my amendment, No. 14, would make it possible to leave "from time to time" there, and that it would safeguard the individual.
Comment on this
The consideration which I gave to this matter before this meeting was from a particular point of view, and it does not seem to be the same point of view as that taken by the Senator.
Comment on this
Has the individual senior professor a right of appeal to the Minister? The governing body of a school has the right, but supposing that the governing body tried to interfere with the terms of service of a professor, what redress has he got?
Comment on this
I do not think that any redress is provided for in the Bill. There are certain difficulties which can be referred to the Minister.
Comment on this
He might have redress in case of a breach of contract.
Comment on this
Regarding amendment No. 14, I do not like the idea of non-alteration of the office. There again there is the question of the contract. Sometimes it is necessary that there should be economies and it would not be well to have too many people paid out of public funds exempted. There was a time when general cuts were under consideration, and one of the difficulties in that matter was that certain people were specially excluded and that a special class was not asked to bear burdens which others had to bear. I know that there are difficulties when bringing in people from outside— probably from another country—but I do not like this question of non-alteration. If there is a time of special stringency of one kind or another regarding funds, I do not like that we should be precluded absolutely from interfering by having to get the person's consent.
Comment on this
In business, that is overcome, not infrequently, by providing for a salary for a limited period with a revision at the end—after, say, three years.
Comment on this
That would scarcely do. If certain work were being done by the School of Theoretical Physics, it might begin to branch off into a particular line of research. A particular person—say, in Australia—might have made remarkable discoveries in that particular direction, and bringing him to this school might mean that the value of the work done by the school would be tremendously enhanced. In order to bring him it would be necessary to guarantee him a certain salary and so on. I would not like to think that you could bring a person like that on conditions under which the salary could be changed after four or five years. If there is a contract, the contract ought to be kept, but I do not care to put in something which would prevent alterations being made.
Comment on this
The real danger is that one may not be able to get the man, as the Bill would prevent him from making a special case. In referring to business a few moments ago, I was dealing with the case of persons whom you can get under those conditions. In the case of persons who could not be got, there would have to be contracts for a definite time.
Comment on this
It would be better to secure that by making sure that there is nothing in the Bill to prevent the making of any kind of contract we want to make.
Comment on this
I suggest that senior professors be appointed for a time, and that the appointment be renewed after five or seven years if they have been found good and efficient and if their services are necessary.
Comment on this
That depends on the man you want. A young man would sometimes be of the greatest value to a school. First of all, he would probably be just entering on that line of research, and would be full of the energy of youth. Such a person who has just come out, and who has recognised ability, may not be willing to accept a short period of four or five years. Even though coming to a strange country, he may feel confident that his abilities would warrant his retention. The less we bind the better.
Comment on this
That is why I am anxious, on the point made by Senator Douglas, that there should be nothing to prevent the governing board of the school making a contract with a person they want to get.
Comment on this
I move amendments Nos. 10 and 13:—
10. In sub-section (1), to delete all words after the words "removed by" in line 32, and substitute the words "the Governing Board of the School".
13. In sub-section (2), to delete all words after the words "such as" in line 35 to the end of the sub-section and substitute the words "the Governing Board of the School shall determine".
In view of the turn which the discussion has taken, I scarcely suppose it worth while discussing these amendments at all. The Taoiseach has made it quite clear that he regards these professors as civil servants, and that their salaries—except in regard to certain people who may come in from abroad—will be more or less at the discretion of the Government, and that their appointment or removal will be in the hands of the Government. I put down these amendments after reading the provisions in Section 8: "The senior professors of a constituent school shall be appointed and removed by the President, on the advice of the Government." In that bare form the section constitutes something unique in the history of higher education, and I do not think an example will be found anywhere in the world where such complete power is taken by a Government. If you examine the method of appointment to the College de France, you will find a most intricate system under which the existing professors have an enormous amount to say in the appointment of new professors. There is no such provision in this Bill. The whole matter is left simply and solely in the hands of the Government. Without wishing to give offence to any university professor here, I must say that it is something which should not be in the Bill. I cannot conceive of a Government undertaking that function and carrying it out successfully. The Taoiseach may say that the Government is well able to make appointments. The fact is that it is not the function of a Government to make appointments in this matter, and I protest against the section.
Comment on this
But the Government appoints judges, and they are not lawyers and it might be said that the members of the Government should have no functions in the appointment of judges, but that they should be selected and appointed only by lawyers.
Comment on this
There is an ancient British tradition that the appointment of judges is made on a political basis. Is not that a fact?
Comment on this
The point here is that no matter who does it, the people who are to be appointed should inspire confidence. Their duties are of tremendous importance to the community as a whole, and naturally what will happen in making these appointments is this: First of all, I certainly would not dream of starting if I did not know that the Institute is to start with the people who will be appointed to begin the scheme with these two schools. The moment these schools are started you will have a competent body to advise. I could not imagine a Government making any further appointments without consulting with such an expert body as would be at their disposal. If a new school is started the same thing as happened in the present case will happen again. There will be some of these people who will be required to act as senior professors of that school, and you will have again a consultative advisory body, but all that is stated in the section is that the machinery of appointment shall be the Government, and that it is the Government who shall take the responsibility. It does not mean again that the Government would appoint anybody they pleased, because he happened to be a political friend. I think it is the old question of "who will guard the guardians?" In my view, it is a nice little check if people are put forward or suggested for appointments that they will have to be people of such outstanding ability that the Government will be justified in taking the responsibility for making those appointments. There is a certain check in that, and I think that it will be found of value.
Comment on this
I am strongly of the same opinion as Senator Tierney, and I would urge the Taoiseach to consider it. Young men will work better if they know that they will win the approval of the directors of their school, and if they know that their names can be put forward to the Government. By all means let the President act on the advice of the governing body, but bring in the school or the council to it. In its present form it looks too blank and too autocratic.
Comment on this
I propose to bring in a couple of amendments on the Report Stage. I am beginning to wonder whether if I had thought this Bill was going to take up so much time, I would ever have brought it before the House.
Comment on this
It is taking a tremendous amount of time, and I think that the difficulties put up are largely imaginary. In practice, they will not occur at all. An attempt has been made to go into detail on some of them and, as a result everybody wants to go into greater detail. I propose to bring in a couple of amendments that if proposals are put up by the schools they will be considered by the Government, but this is the machinery, and I think the machinery ought to remain, and that the responsibility for the appointments ought to be on the Government. It may not be a usual thing, but I think it can work well, because, again, I would like to point out that it is a case of specialised qualifications. The Government will not take it upon itself to appoint a specialist without having that specialist recommended either by clearly obvious qualifications, or by the school. It is not as if you were appointing, for instance, a clerical officer or something of that sort. I really believe that we can go on using our imagination, perhaps that is the reason why we can go on using our imagination——
Comment on this
——conjuring up every possible type of difficulty and friction. However, with regard to the amendments, I am wondering if the point of view of some of the Senators can be met to a certain extent, but we are not dropping the machinery of the section.
Comment on this
Are amendments Nos. 10 and 13 being pressed?
Comment on this
That is the intention. Will a quarter past seven suit Senators?
Comment on this
I have to do a piece of work that will take me about half an hour, and that is why I am anxious that we should adjourn.
Comment on this
Is it intended to finish the Bill to-night?
Comment on this
No. Will it suit Senators if we adjourn until 7.30?
Agreed.
Comment on this
I do not propose to move amendment No. 11. I leave the Taoiseach in possession of the field. I have done my best and I am exhausted in this combat. The Seanad seems thoroughly apathetic about everything, so I shall leave the future to judge who is right.
Comment on this
I do not propose to move amendment No. 15. I put it down merely to try to secure that some of the restrictions on the school should be removed, and that the question as to who should be members of the council should be left as far as possible to the discretion of the school itself. I do not see that there is any use in pressing the point.
Comment on this
Tairgim leasú a 16:—
Na focail "ach amháin go mbeidh a ndóthain Gaedhilge aca leis an obair do stiúradh as Gaedhilg" do chur isteach i ndiaidh na bhfocal "shall be ex-officio members of the council” i mír (c).
Tá mé ag tairgsint an leasú seo leis an riaghal atá i bhfeidhm cheana sa tseirbhís phoiblí agus i mórán áit eile ins an tír, go mbeidh Gaedhilg ag na daoinibh seo sul a n-ainmnighthear mar oificéil iad. B'fhearr liom féin gan aon bhaint a bheith ag na h-Iolscoltaibh leis an Institiúid nua. Níl aon mhuinighin agam as na h-Iolscoltaibh maidir le Gaedhealachas. Má gheibh siad mórán chumhachta san Institúid, déanfaidh siad cumang í, ag fiosruchán fá'n tsean-Gaedhilg gan áird aice ar an Ghaedhilg bheo. Tuigim go mbeadh sé deacair, b'éidir, deighilt iomlán a dhéanamh eadar na h-Iolscolta agus an Institiúid, agus mholfainn an tseift seo: má tá aon duine luaidhte nach bhfuil Gaedhilg aige, cead a thabhairt dó fear-ionaid d'ainmniú. Tá roinnt ollamhan ins na h-Iolscoltaibh go bhfuil Gaedhilg aca, d'fheudfaidhe duine aca seo d'ainmniú in ionad an Uachdaráin.
Comment on this
Tá brón orm nach féidir liom glacadh leis an leasú so. Ní haon mhaith daoine a chur isteach in ionad na ndaoine atá sna hoifigí sin. B'fhearr liom gan daoine a chur ina n-ionad. Mar adubhairt mé cheana, beidh leasuithe agam féin agus sílim gur féidir feidhm a bhaint asta, ach ní dóigh liom gur ceart é seo a dhéanamh. B'fhearr liom nach mbeidís ann chor ar bith ná daoine a chur ina n-ionad. Ní dóigh liom gur féidir, fá lathair, an Ghaedhilg a dhéanamh riachtanach dóibh. Ba mhaith liom a rádh nach n-aontuím le n-a lán rudaí adubhradh indiu nuair a bhí an leasú eile ar siúl. Bhí díospóireacht annseo. Sílim gur ceart an Ghaedhilg a thabhairt isteach más féidir. Ach nuair nach féidir, ní haon mhaith bheith ag iarraidh caisleán a thógáil in aon lá amháin. I ndiaidh a chéile a tógtar na caisleáin, agus i ndiaidh a chéile is féidir linn an Ghaedhilg a thabhairt isteach i ngach uile áit. Sin é mo thuairim-se, ar chuma ar bith.
Comment on this
Tá mé ag tarraint siar an leasú seo tar éis an méid atá ráidhte ag an Taoiseach. Agus tarraingim siar leasú eile atá ar an gclár mar tá leasuithe eile curtha isteach ag an Riaghaltas a bhfuil mise sásta leo.
Comment on this
is there any provision made for a vacancy in these cases? What would happen if there was a vacancy in the presidency?
Comment on this
I wanted to say something on that amendment, as far as I could understand what had happened. I want to know what has happened. Is it being accepted?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:—
To add to the section the following new sub-section:—
(2) Each ex-officio member of the council shall be entitled, with the consent of the Minister, to nominate a substitute who shall hold office on the same terms as the other members of the council.
The object of this amendment is to try to make provision for cases that may arise when holders of these offices, the President of University College, Dublin, the Provost of Trinity College, Dublin, or such persons, cannot find it possible to attend meetings of the council of the institute or take up that work at all. It may happen in certain cases—I do not suppose it would often happen—that one or other of these three persons who are named here as ex-officio members of the council would find that he had not time or that he was prevented in some other way from taking up that work. What I suggest is that if that should arise, he should be entitled, with the consent of the Minister, to nominate a substitute who would hold office for the duration of any particular council. I just put that down in case the Taoiseach thought that it might be possible to make better provision than actually is made in the section for the filling of these offices.
Comment on this
This question of a substitute occurred to me in another connection, namely, in regard to the chairman, but, on the whole, it seemed to me that it was much better, even in the case of the chairman, to have one person designated and if he were not able to attend, to allow the body to choose their own chairman. The purpose of the section is partly to associate the universities and the academy with the work of the institute and, by having the presidents on the body, to raise the prestige, if you like, of the institute. But I think if any substitutes were appointed that object would be defeated. If the presidents are not able to come, so much the worse. I think they will endeavour to do it. If they are not on occasions able to do it, it cannot be helped.
Comment on this
I was thinking of this amendment of Professor Tierney's, but rather in a different connection. For example, the Taoiseach will think of certain people who held or who hold the offices mentioned. The last Provost of Trinity College, for example, was an Irish scholar who, in the circumstances of there being only two schools in this institute, would have been anxious to have been on this body. The present President of University College, Dublin, is a very distinguished mathematical physicist, and would be obviously suitable in the circumstances where there was a school of theoretical physics. But you can easily imagine a person holding one of these three offices who would not be enthusiastic about acting himself, but would have at his disposal on the staff of the university or the academy, a person who would be quite admirable and helpful for the institute. I think that case might easily arise, and that it would be better to make provision for it. I am not pressing that point.
Comment on this
I think what would happen in a case like that is that the person who would be appointed would certainly, as a rule, be of academic standing and, therefore, would be generally acquainted with the type of work being done in the schools. Suppose a medical doctor happened to be either Provost of Trinity College, or President of University College, Dublin, or President of the Academy, in these particular bodies he would be associated with people who would have a special interest in any technical matter that might arise. I take it that there would be an agenda issued before these meetings, and he would know in advance generally the type of work that was to be done at any meeting, and he could consult. In any case, the work of the council in this connection is not so much directed towards the technical side as the general administration. I do not think it is necessary to arrange for substitutes, or that it would be worth bothering at this stage trying to provide for them.
Comment on this
I wish to ask the Taoiseach a question. The Provost of Trinity College has got an official substitute, a Vice-Provost. The President of the Academy has got an official substitute, a Vice-President, or Vice-Presidents. I suppose they will automatically act for them?
Comment on this
No, I imagine not, unless he can be called by that name. Unless he had the title, a President of the Academy, Provost of Trinity, or President of the University, I do not think he could act.
Comment on this
It is possible that, let us say, in the case of the Taoiseach or the Tánaiste, one man could act for the other, but that would be where the matter would be provided for by law. I do not know whether, in every case where the Taoiseach is absent, the Tanáiste can act for him. I think that there would have to be some special necessity there. However, I am not sure about that particular matter.
Comment on this
I think it is quite clear here that, if you mention the Provost of Trinity College, Dublin, the President of University College, Dublin, and the President of the Royal Irish Academy, the person who is, let us say, Vice-Provost, by virtue of some other function, could not be a member of the council in this particular matter.
Comment on this
The Vice-Provost of Trinity College or the Vice-President of the Royal Irish Academy, I understand, cannot act with regard to certain matters.
Comment on this
I think I can agree with Senator Hayes in this matter, to the effect that such a person would not be entitled to act.
Comment on this
I should like to know what would happen in the case of a vacancy. What I have in mind is the question of whether or not people could be elected validly by the council, even if the council were not at full strength.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:—
In sub-section (3), to delete line 61.
I do not suppose there is any use in pressing this amendment.
Comment on this
Yes. For instance, there was considerable difficulty experienced in connection with the Folklore Commission in this regard, and I do not think it was ever satisfactorily settled.
Comment on this
Well, again, I suppose it is a question of expense. I have no doubt that, at the beginning, there may be some people who will want to have a big establishment. Now, I do not want to prejudice anything that might be in people's minds, but my own view is that it is better to begin in a modest way in regard to these things. I think that there is nothing so terrible as to see a big establishment with nothing doing in it, so to speak. I believe that it is much better to begin in a modest way, and I am perfectly certain that any demands with regard to housing or accommodation, in this connection, will be met reasonably. For instance, in connection with the theoretical physics side of this matter, I was assured—I think I mentioned this matter already—that one of the houses in Merrion Square, if some slight alterations were made, would be quite suitable.
Comment on this
I agree with what has just been said. I think it will be admitted on all sides that it would be quite impossible, and against all ordinary rulings, that State expenditure should be taken out of the control of the Minister for Finance. As he is the Minister who is responsible for State expenditure, I do not see how the Minister for Finance could be eliminated from control in a matter of the expenditure of State moneys.
Comment on this
Yes, but my point is that, when you speak of the Minister for Finance, you generally mean the Board of Works, and everybody knows what that means. We all know the delays that occur in such cases.
Comment on this
Yes, but the Board of Works also has to get the sanction of the Minister for Finance for expenditure in connection with any of their schemes.
Comment on this
Well, at any rate, all I can say is that I have spent a lot of time thinking over this matter, and I shall certainly try to act as an intermediary in this connection in order to get these people provided with proper accommodation and properly housed as quickly as possible. Again, however, I do not know whether we shall be able to get a cage to fit the bird, so to speak, and it all depends on how this matter may develop later on. As I have said, I think it would be better to start in a modest way.
Comment on this
I think that everybody approves of the idea of starting modestly.
Comment on this
I would suggest that, if there is any question of adapting these houses, such as the Taoiseach has suggested, a good architect should be consulted.
Comment on this
Well, of course, as I have said, we have not got the bird yet for the cage, and do not know what kind of cage would be required.
Comment on this
At any rate, I think we can feel sure that the Minister for Finance will be a champion of modesty in that regard.
Comment on this
Since the same argument would apply to amendment No. 19, I wish to withdraw that amendment, with the leave of the House.
Comment on this
In this connection I should like to draw attention to the number of buildings that we have here in the city available for such purposes, many of which are unused or comparatively unused. Take the case of the Royal Hibernian School. I understand that portion of that institution has been given over as a preparatory training college for about 100 Protestant student-teachers, who are being trained to teach through the medium of Irish. Now, I understand that the heating installation that has been provided there for the accommodation of these students is such as would be more than sufficient for the biggest hospital or asylum in Ireland, while the rest of that institution is practically derelict, and left with broken windows and so on. I think it looks very bad to have these buildings in such a condition, and perhaps I might be permitted to suggest that, on the face of it, the ordinary business man, if he were a shareholder in such an institution, would have very good reason to object. I understand also that quite a large portion of the Castle is now of practically no value, and we also now have a new building in Stephen's Green.
I suggest, therefore, that you do not want a new building at all. We are told very frequently that it is the intention of the Government to house the various Departments in one building, and in that connection I should rather welcome an announcement from the Taoiseach that, instead of erecting a new building it was his intention to make use of some of the old buildings, such as Kilmainham. Really, when you consider that there is such a number of buildings available, it seems to be a waste of money to go about putting up other buildings, with all this talk of getting a special architect and having wonderful frontages, and so on. I think that we should seriously consider the matter of consolidating and tightening up on the buildings that are already in our possession instead of erecting new buildings. For instance, we have another one being erected now in Kildare Street. I wonder what is going to happen to that. I suppose it is only being put up in order to house more officials, or if there are not enough officials to fill that building, we will probably have to provide more officials in order to fill it.
Comment on this
Well, I do not know what kind of an argument I am going to be brought into now, but I should like to get a list of such buildings as have been suggested. The Senator mentioned the Hibernian School. I am not aware of the conditions there, but I do know that so far as the Board of Works is concerned, whenever there is need for office accommodation you are always being asked to locate the office in some place that is already full up. Now, if I had my way, and if I were a dictator in the matter, I would start out on a scheme of Government buildings or offices that would be specially designed for the purposes of these offices. It seems to me that there is a tremendous amount of waste as a result of the lack of centralisation, and I would endeavour to have all these offices and Departments in one central building, instead of having them scattered around through various parts of the city.
Comment on this
What about the Hibernian School, to which I have referred?
Comment on this
Well, in a good portion of that building there is nothing but broken windows.
Comment on this
I think that that would be good news to the Department of Defence. I was there on one occasion and I did not know that the entire buildings were not occupied.
Comment on this
I am very glad to have been told that, and I shall look into it. I really do believe that what we are doing at present is bad economy. Whenever a piece of work has to be done, we have to go round looking for buildings suitable for Government offices. I think the whole thing is wrong. I believe that you would ultimately have very much more economy if you had properly designed Government buildings, with large rooms where people could work together and where there could be general supervision. I do not believe in these little separate cells at all, but I wonder whether, if I brought in some such proposal, I would get the support of the Senator for it.
Comment on this
I am certain that it represents the best possible economy. At the moment, however, there is no intention of starting out with new buildings, though, there again, a case could probably be made that ultimately it might be better to have a separate building especially designed for it, but we have no intention of doing that at the moment. As a matter of fact, I have been making inquiries as to whether some of the rooms in Iveagh House would be suitable for housing the Department of External Affairs and some other Departments, but I have to have consultation with the Board of Works on the matter. There is no intention, as I say, of starting off elaborately in this matter. We want a suitable place, and if the house ultimately taken is worth preserving, care will be taken to preserve it. Deputy Dillon, I think, mentioned in the Dáil that if one of the old Georgian houses were being secured for a purpose of this kind, care should be taken to keep it as a kind of museum, as a sort of record of the time, with appropriate furniture and so on, but I do not know whether that could be done or whether such a house would be available.
Comment on this
As against what Senator Sir John Keane has said, I hope the Taoiseach will see that this institute is centrally situated. It is essential that, to be effective, it should be in immediate proximity to libraries and universities, and, for that reason, it could not be in the Park. If we want to find a use for Kilmainham or for the Royal Hibernian School, we might send the Seanad out there.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Phonix Park would be an excellent place. It is quiet and secluded, and is just the place for higher thought and contemplation.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the Taoiseach is open to a suggestion, but one of our corporation inspectors brought to my notice some time ago an excellent old mansion, not very many yards from where we are now. I went to the trouble of suggesting to certain parties that it might be a useful place for some Government purpose. I inspected it and found it an excellent old mansion. I do not know whether it would be suitable for the purpose we have in mind here, but I suggest to the Taoiseach that it might be worth inspecting. I do not know whether the place is still vacant or not, as it is some months since it was brought to my notice and since I brought it to the notice of people who, I thought, might interest themselves in it.
Comment on this
I hope that will not happen. The Army, police and Government Departments are like nature in that they abhor a vacuum. If we had inherited half the buildings when we took over, we would have had ample room, and, if we had got four times as much, every Department would say that it wanted to overflow into other places. So long as you have space, Government Departments will expand and fill it. I have had experience, and I know that if you put them in smaller places, they will do the work better, but if you have Dublin Castle and Kilmainham available, the police will say that they need the extra space. You have plenty of room and do not need any dilapidated or unused mansions. The Government has more room than it wants.
Comment on this
I should be very happy. I know with regard to the Army that it would have swollen and filled every barracks in the country. Unfortunately, the trouble was that when I was restraining the Army, the police really took advantage of the situation, and filled the places which the Army did not fill.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Senator's experience has been, but I can speak only from my own experience, and I do not think there is much room wasted. There certainly is not any in Government Buildings, and, in any other places I have been to, such as the Education Offices, I have not seen any waste. The room I have down there myself, as I am not always in it, is used as a council room for conferences, and so on. There really is a genuine shortage of space, and I assure the Senator, lest anybody should get a wrong impression, that one of the hardest things to get from Finance is extra room. The Board of Works naturally take their instructions from the Department of Finance.
Comment on this
On a question of fact, I should like to refute the statement of Senator Sir John Keane as to the condition of the Hibernian School.
Comment on this
As it is irrelevant, I will sit down and content myself with saying that I refute the statement made by Senator Sir John Keane. I was in the grounds on Monday last, and I saw no broken windows.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20.
In sub-section (4), to delete all words from the words "council shall", in line 26, to the word "Finance" in line 28.
This is the same point as before—the registrar bursar is tied down hand and foot to an appointment on such tenure and conditions as the council shall, with the approval of the Minister given with the concurrence of the Minister for Finance, determine. There, again, I think the procedure is bad. It would be much better to leave this body to employ its own officials and to establish their own terms, remuneration and conditions, with the ordinary control which the Minister for Finance is bound to have over these bodies. I can see no reason at all why the approval of the Minister and the concurrence of the Minister for Finance should be called for in all these cases and I think that, as in the case of professors, it sets up a most unfortunate and very strange precedent.
Comment on this
I wonder if I might ask the Taoiseach what he has in mind with regard to the registrar-bursar. He does not commit himself to giving an opinion. Is this bursar thought of in terms of being a civil servant? Can we have an idea as to whether he will be selected for his academic distinction or a vague suggestion as to what emoluments will attach to the office? My own judgment of the amendment would depend on information as to what his standing in the institute is going to be. If we had some information in this respect, my position would be made somewhat easier.
Comment on this
Naturally, the procedure would be that, first of all, the council would meet and consider what duties the man would have and would ask themselves what qualifications he would need. Then they would consider the position of a similar person elsewhere. The Civil Service might be taken as a good example for comparison, as in the Civil Service a man doing a certain sort of work would have certain emoluments and certain conditions of service. If I were asked to choose a person for this post, I should try to get one with administrative ability and scholarly attainments. He would need a good knowledge of Irish: it would be wrong to have him in that position without it. It is not like a professor of theoretical physics: one might not get a man like that with a knowledge of Irish. In this case, however, I think it is possible to get a man with a knowledge of Irish. It would be a good thing, of course, if he had a knowledge of theoretical physics as well to start with. In addition to having a good knowledge of Irish, he should also understand the type of work being done in the school, so that he could understand the general meaning of any discussions and, if it meant executive work afterwards, translate into actions the directions given to him. At the moment, I should not say what salary would be fair.
Comment on this
Yes; the council would decide on the man. He should have executive ability, a good knowledge of organisation and of the keeping of statistics and records, and he should also have accountancy experience. If one knew a suitable man with a certain salary and a certain future, one could consider what salary it would be necessary to pay to secure him.
Comment on this
It is almost inevitable that there will be certain tension between the council and the Department of Finance.
Comment on this
Probably there will, but that only happens once in a lifetime. Most of the criticism levelled here against financial control and control by the Government really means that at the start there will have to be an adjustment of ideas between the governing body of the schools and the Government, where expenditure is concerned. We are undertaking this on the understanding that we are not going to be committed to unnecessarily large expenditure and, as long as things are done in a reasonable way, there will not be very great difficulty. I can quite imagine that, at the start, there will be differences of opinion which will have to be adjusted with commonsense.
Comment on this
I am sorry that this section has been framed in such a cast-iron manner and that it includes the term "registrar-bursar". That fills me with surprise and doubt. I must admit to Senators that I am a registrar and know what a registrar has to do. When the task of accountant to two bodies is added to that of registrar, it makes the work more onerous. I admit it is essential that the person appointed should have a knowledge of Irish. Would it not be better to get an efficient registrar and attach to him a secretary as an accountant? The registrar will have to correspond with different corners of the world and arrange matters at different ends of it, so he must be up to date and very alert. The term "registrar-bursar" is awkward and, while I do not wish to give the Taoiseach more trouble, perhaps he would be able to find a solution.
Comment on this
Some consideration might be given to the unfortunates who will have to translate "registrar-bursar" into Irish.
Comment on this
They can get another name for him if they wish. When one has the idea, there is no need to translate the actual words into Irish. The purpose is to make it clear that he has control over all the records, and I do not mind if the word "bursar" is left out.
Comment on this
If we are not careful we will be building up a large administrative staff, which is the last thing we want to do. Any money available for this institute ought to be used for the academic work and we should grudge every penny spent on the administrative side. Senator Alton may be thinking of an institute like Trinity College with a very large number of students. This is going to be a relatively small school with small numbers, and the registrar's work will not be great. Even if there were five schools, I think he could be responsible for them all. He would, of course, need some clerical assistance, but the accountancy would not be very intricate.
Comment on this
Senators must realise that before a Minister brings a Bill into Parliament, the Departments concerned have considered it from many points of view. First of all, the principle is accepted by the Government, then it is elaborated on, then it is sent to the draftsman, then it is discussed by the Departments concerned to make sure that there is nothing inadvisable or undesirable in it. That means that, when it comes to Parliament, the Minister has the consent of many people to what is in the Bill; and, no matter how sound certain arguments may appear at the time, it is very difficult for a Minister to accept them. He may say that they are put forward only on the spur of the moment, while everything already in the Bill has been given consideration from different angles. There is not much in this question of title: the intention is that the man be responsible for finance. If it helps to make the title less cumbersome, he could be called the "Registrar."
Comment on this
Would it not be better to cut out the words "shall be known"? That would make the sentence read: "The council shall appoint an officer of the institute who is in this Act referred to as the registrar-bursar." That would enable a change to be made later without making a change in the Act. The simplest way would be to say that he would be known as the registrar. We will call it that—I am quite prepared to do it.
Comment on this
If you do not appoint a registrar-bursar I am afraid that in view of the amount of work that he would have to do in connection with the finances of the institute, you will have to appoint a bursar. There is really nothing against calling him a registrar-bursar except that you may object to the title. You will have to have a man in charge of finance.
Comment on this
Various things will have to be implemented by means of an order and the duties of the registrar will be set out in the order.
Comment on this
A large part of the work of the institute will centre around correspondence with schools in other parts of the world. Will the registrar be responsible for that?
Comment on this
I know it will be difficult to get anything like the ideal person and I hope that a great deal of care will be given to the selection of the proper person for the post. The difficulty is to get a combination of what you might call the scholarly type with the executive type. However, such people do exist.
Comment on this
I take it that amendment No. 20 is withdrawn, subject to the tabling of a Government amendment on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:—
In sub-sections (1) and (2), to delete all words after the word "proper", in sub-section (1), line 36, and all words from the word "council" in sub-section (2), line 41, to the word "Finance" in the same sub-section, line 43.
It is the same amendment in relation to the less important officials and I do not suppose there is any point in debating it at any further length. The Taoiseach has already sufficiently indicated his view on the question.
Comment on this
I need only say that the consideration which will affect the Government in regard to the Ministers for Education and Finance is: "Do you want two officers or do you want one?" If I were the Minister for Education, I would say: "Let us get a picture of the work this man has got to do. Will he be capable of looking after the Bursar's side as well?" I would say we are not going to create two high offices of that kind. If we want to get the work done, he may have a financial clerk who will do the work subject to his supervision and to his satisfying himself that everything is all right.
The same consideration will arise in connection with the entrances to the schools. I would have only one door, entering into the three schools because, assuming that it was easy to pass from one to the other, I think it would save expense by having all entry through the centre or administrative door. There are a lot of things like that. The question is, would you want three janitors or would one do? In matters of that sort, it is advisable to have some check against their saying: "We have a certain amount for administration. We will appoint three door porters," and so on, and although there may be differences of opinion—I could imagine, for instance, differences of opinion on the question of the registrar-bursar—as to whether two persons are not in fact wanted. My own belief is that, with two schools, one person would do, but, in questions of that sort, I think Senator Keane, if he only began to think in ordinary terms, would see that economies are much more likely to come when the Department of Finance, or the Department of Education, even, comes into it.
Comment on this
I think the Minister for Finance has the right to say a word as to the number of employees. He might also save the council from a lot of canvassing and looking for jobs if it was known that there could be an unlimited number.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23:—
In sub-section (1), to delete all words from the word "council" in line 50, to the word "Finance" in line 51.
There is no necessity to argue this all over again. It is the same story. The Taoiseach is quite convinced that the final word must be with the Minister for Finance and nothing can be done about it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:—
In sub-section (1) to delete the words and brackets "(with the approval of the Minister)", lines 15-16, page 9.
This is slightly more important—in fact it is considerably more important than the other matter. It is the same principle that runs all through the Bill:—
"Every appointment to a position (other than the position of senior professor on the academic staff of a constituent school) shall be made by the council on the request (with the approval of the Minister) of the governing board of such constituent school, and no such appointment shall be made by the council otherwise than in accordance with such request."
The Minister has the final word again in all these matters and the governing board of the schools has nothing to do except to register the decision of the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
Is it a fair representation to use the expression "register the decision of the Minister for Finance" when in fact what will happen is that the Minister will register their decision? Suppose that the governing board decided on a certain piece of work. They planned that work and they said that they wanted three people and three people were available to do the work. As a rule, everybody will have a general idea of whether it is, if I might put it that way, genuine. There will be no difficulty in this case. There would be a difficulty if, suppose instead of asking for three people, they started with 23. Then you might begin to say: "Are they acting properly here? Is this a natural development or is it going to be successful?" You might say that these people were starting altogether in a way that was not intended. This Bill has been brought in and this institute is being founded with the idea that there is a certain piece of work that can be begun modestly and that it will develop. Nobody is going to check its development but, if there is an attempt to do something like that in the first year it might be asked if they could not do with a smaller number.
Suppose there was something outrageous like that, the Minister for Education, as a go-between, would say: "Look here, I am afraid I can hardly go to the Minister for Finance with a proposal like that. You will have to convince me that this is a reasonable way to start." I would like to say this: that experts are splendid for certain things, but there is no reason why a man of ordinary commonsense cannot judge whether the expert's opinion is likely to be right or not. I have great dependence on the ordinary man's commonsense, and if an expert has a good case, he will be able to convince a man of commonsense, assuming goodwill and a desire to be convinced. The only thing here is to assure the Minister for Finance that nothing ridiculous is going to be proposed. I am assuming that nothing ridiculous will be proposed and, therefore, I am assuming generally that work will be carried on without restriction.
Comment on this
If the Taoiseach were always Minister for Education I would have confidence because he has experience and has seen the light, but I share Senator Tierney's doubts to some extent. I am convinced that the giving of a lot of authority and, consequently, responsibility to the governing bodies of these schools is of importance. Does not the Taoiseach think that they would be checked enough in the schools, in making appointments and in encroaching on the funds? Their grant is limited?
Comment on this
No, it is not limited. At the beginning we do not limit it. What I mean is this: I would hate to see this thing begun and for the sake of £1,000 abandoned if the real fruit of its work was going to depend on £1,000. I would hate to think that because it did not get that extra £1,000 it could not do its work properly I think that if we proceed for four or five years and let this institute develop a tradition, afterwards a more enlightened Minister for Finance and a more enlightened Minister for Education might come along and say: "All right; you have proved it is valuable national work and we want to free you from any fetters which you have found galling up to the present." The trouble is that we do not want to limit it. We have no idea of what is the sum that will be required. I believe myself that it will be a modest sum.
Comment on this
I take it that applies also to amendments Nos. 26 and 27?
Comment on this
I do not propose to move amendment No. 28 which stands in my name. If any of these things do happen, this side of the House cannot be blamed.
Comment on this
That is so. I shall have to carry all these sins on my shoulders if any of them are committed.
Comment on this
I do hope that this section will not preclude the Minister for Finance from making grants to the academy for the publication of Irish records. Their efforts in the past in that connection have been heroic under very difficult circumstances and I should be sorry to see the Minister for Finance cutting down the grants to the academy.
Comment on this
All I can say is that, on general principles, there is no intention to rob Peter to pay Paul.
Comment on this
I am rather surprised to find that the council is entitled, without the consent of the Minister for Finance, to give scholarships. I think the same difficulty arises there which was so eloquently pleaded by the Taoiseach in other cases.
Comment on this
The council could start off by providing 500 scholarships and the Minister, in his wisdom, might decide that that would involve too much expense.
Comment on this
It is suggested to me that there would be some administrative understanding between the school and the Minister for Education. However, if I had noticed that, it might read differently. At the same time, one does not need to go into it unnecessarily. I do not believe there will be the danger which the Senator mentions.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:—
To delete sub-section (2):—
This section reads:—
It shall be the duty of the council to make regulations providing... for the good government of the institute and... for the good government of every constituent school. No regulation made under this section shall have effect unless and until it is approved of by the Minister.
In other words, the Minister must decide whether smoking is to be allowed on the premises of the school.
Comment on this
That would be a matter which would be governed by rules apart from regulations. The matter has to be considered in that light.
Comment on this
I must break my promise to remain silent when I see that the Taoiseach suggests that Government control is not over the whole Bill. Regulations connected with such matters as even the care of a lavatory cannot be made without the approval of the Minister.
Comment on this
Regulations do not cover all these things. In every university, there are regulations and there are statutes. There are some things less formal than statutes that are called regulations, but I do not think they would include the control of smoking or matters of that kind. The trouble is that it would be impossible to find words to define exactly what these regulations should cover. You would have to spend an age to see how far you should go with regulations. There is no way in which you could define absolutely in an Act of Parliament every type of thing to prevent abuse. If people are going to abuse these things, I do not think that any Act you could possibly frame will prevent abuse. You must assume that these matters will be governed by common-sense and good-will.
Comment on this
If there was a distinction, I could understand the attitude of the Taoiseach, but every regulation has got to be approved by the Minister. The Taoiseach says that there are regulations and regulations and that the term "regulations" has not been defined. I take it that every rule governing the conduct of the schools is a regulation. Otherwise, where are we? We are talking in different languages. Conceivably some question arising out of this section might go to the courts, and how are the courts going to interpret "regulation?"
Comment on this
I would not call anything concerned with minor questions a regulation. I would call it a rule. If I were the person acting as registrar-bursar I would say: "We will call formal arrangements which have to be submitted to the Minister regulations and we will call these other things rules" and I would not bother submitting these smaller matters to the Minister. I am perfectly certain these things will not go to the Minister.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 31:—
To delete the section.
I have only to repeat on this that the decision of the Minister, with the concurrence of the Minister for Finance, is final. The governing board is entirely in the hands of the Minister in any matter that comes under the section, as it is in practically every other matter.
Comment on this
We have to eliminate the council in matters of this kind where a dispute is likely to arise. Suppose the council, for example, received a sum of money and the donor had not defined how it was to be divided. There might be a dispute between the council and one of the schools in that matter and you would require to have some arbitration. In a case of that sort, I am assuming that the Minister for Education would make certain recommendations and you may be perfectly certain that the recommendations of the Minister for Education would be accepted nine times out of ten. Where, of course, Government decisions have to be obtained he will have to make a case to the Government but generally the best thing that could happen, where there is a question of finance, is that one of the Ministers should be an intermediary because it prevents any Departmental entanglement, delay or want of appreciation of the points involved.
Comment on this
I think, of course, there must be an appeal in such cases to somebody. Does Professor Tierney suggest that there should be an appeal to somebody other than the Minister for Education or the Minister for Finance?
Comment on this
It is not possible under this scheme. You cannot have two schemes. This is a scheme which contemplates the Minister for Education and the Minister for Finance with a yearly grant and with the Minister being responsible for appointing or removing staffs. You cannot have two schemes. I do not say that I like this particular scheme, but at any rate you cannot have two schemes.
Comment on this
He is, of course. The only limitation here is on the Minister for Education and, of course, he gets limitless sums of money, subject to the sanction of the Minister for Finance. It is quite simple.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:—
Before Section 25 to insert the following new section:—
(1) In the financial year current at the passing of this Act and in each of the subsequent five financial years, there shall be paid to the institute out of the Central Fund—
(a) a grant towards the administration and expenses of the institute not exceeding £2,000;
(b) a grant in respect of the school of Celtic studies not exceeding £15,000;
(c) a grant in respect of the school of theoretical physics not exceeding £3,000.
(2) Any part of these grants not expended during any financial year shall be returned to the Central Fund.
(3) At the end of the period specified in sub-section (1) of this section, the said grants may be continued for a further period of five years on the passage, by both Houses of the Oireachtas, of a resolution to that effect.
(4) The further continuance, after ten years from the end of the current financial years of such grants, may be authorised by the passage of similar resolutions.
(5) Moneys paid under paragraphs (b) and (c) of sub-section (1) of this section to the institute in respect of each constituent school shall be applied by the council for the purpose of that school only.
Comment on this
The adoption of this amendment would involve the deletion of Section 25 of the Bill.
Comment on this
On the section, Sir, may I put this point? The moneys to be paid for this institute are to be provided by the Oireachtas. Now, I take it that there will be a new Estimate in this connection, for which the Minister for Education will be responsible, which will be presented to the Dáil and in which will be set out the expenses of the institute, including the salaries of the senior professors and other members—without mentioning their names, of course. Now, in Section 29 of the Bill there is provision for the submission to the Government by the council of an annual report of the work of the institute and the constituent schools. I take it that, since all these expenses are payable out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas, that means that there will be an Estimate for that particular matter. That is my belief, unless I am mistaken.
Comment on this
No, I think this is a different point. In the case of the university, the Minister for Finance has consistently refused to answer any questions in that regard.
Comment on this
No. In the case of the university, the moneys are provided by statute, and the Minister cannot be asked any questions about, for example, the behaviour of any professor of any university college. In this case, however, unless I am mistaken, under this particular scheme and section you will have, let us say, three senior professors appointed at £1,000 a year each, or whatever the amount may be, and these people will have been appointed by the Minister, and, as the Bill stands now, the Minister can appoint or remove them. It appears to me, therefore, that it will be possible for anyone in the Dáil to ask the Minister questions as to what these professors are doing. I would not mind making a prophecy that nobody in the Dáil is going to worry very much as to what these people are doing in a matter such as theoretical physics, but my point is that such questions may be asked in the Dáil, under the Bill as it stands, and I should like to know whether or not the Minister is putting himself in the position of having to answer such questions, because it seems to me that, under the Bill as it stands, there is responsibility on the Minister in the Dáil to answer such questions.
Comment on this
I should like to make the same point that Senator Hayes has made, and that is that you cannot have two schemes in this connection. I think it is fundamental to the whole scheme. The Minister will make certain orders as an administrative act, and he can be challenged publicly in connection with his administrative acts, but you cannot have it both ways. Of course, I do hope that what the Taoiseach has in mind will come to pass in two or three years' time, and that every effort will be made to get this matter on to the Central Fund.
Comment on this
It was with a view to what Senator Hayes has just said that I put down this amendment, to insert a new section before Section 25. That was in order to carry out the idea of giving these schools a fixed grant and remove them, as far as possible, from the control of the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Education. I realise, of course, that it is very doubtful if that sort of amendment would be in order in the Seanad. I only put down the figures that are given there in the amendment as a sort of token, because I take it that the proper course would be to come to some arrangement, before the Bill becomes an Act, as to what amount is to be expended on this scheme over a number of years, and then incorporate that in the Bill. I was hoping that the Taoiseach might be able to do that before the Report Stage of the Bill, but it has been pointed out now that that would cut across the whole intention of the Bill.
Comment on this
I do not know to what extent one would have to go into details in this connection. After all, in connection with the ordinary Estimates you have not to go into every item. You will have different headings, I dare say, dealing with salaries and so on, but I do not know whether you would have to indicate all of them. I think that the usual idea is just to make the details as clear as possible for the ordinary member of the Dáil or Seanad, so that he can appreciate how the money is being spent. I admit, of course, that in this case we are starting out to build up I presume that you when it is built up I presume that you will get to something like a stable position, and then, the moment we have reached that point, we will know where we are. If there are objections to the present system, then the sooner any of these difficulties, frictions, or inconveniences are pointed out in the working of the scheme, the more quickly will they be taken out of the present framework. For instance, if I were to go to the present Minister for Finance and ask him to give me so much money for such a scheme as this, I would probably be told: "We cannot do that unless you can give us some idea as to what is required for the administration of this scheme."
Therefore, since one cannot give a definite estimate at the start, the only way to proceed is by a process of trial. This is only a start, and after a few years, we may be able to go to the Minister for Finance and say that, if there is too much interference by Departments or Ministers in the working of the scheme, we think it would be very much better to put this matter on the Central Fund and provide an annual sum for it. I may say that it did not occur to me that there would be required more detailed estimates in this case than in the cases of universities. I believe, however, that it is true that there is a statutory sum mentioned in the case of universities, and I must confess that I had not appreciated that difference. My intention was that there would be an annual sum, such as is the case in the university, but we have not reached the position in which we can do that yet. All you want is to have a natural check against possible abuse. I do not expect that abuses will occur but, at the same time, when money is being asked for, one would like to make sure that certain possible abuses would not occur.
Comment on this
I do not propose to move any of the further amendments in my name because they all deal with the same question and, from the last remarks of the Taoiseach, it is perfectly plain that, fundamentally, we are all in complete agreement and that we completely disagree as to the way in which it will be achieved.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 34:—
In sub-section (2), to delete the words "in such form as shall be approved of by the Minister with the concurrence of the Minister for Finance," in lines 8-9.
All I have to say on this amendment is that, not only will the discussion of this Estimate come before the Dáil, but I take it it will also come before the Committee of Public Accounts, and some official in the Department of Education, who is responsible for this expenditure, is liable to be called before that committee and examined in the most detailed fashion in every single item of this expenditure. We all know that examination by the Committee of Public Accounts can go very far indeed. That is another aspect of the finances of this Bill which induced me to put in the amendment that I have now withdrawn—amendment No. 32.
Comment on this
I do not see how the Senator can expect to have it both ways. If it is a fully fledged Government Department it has got to submit to all the machinery of debate and examination by the Committee of Public Accounts. Incidentally, there will be strong objection to putting expenditure of this kind on the Central Fund. They have put judges on the Central Fund; they have put interest on debt on the Central Fund, and they have put pensions on the Central Fund. If these ordinary appointments which the Government make are put on the Central Fund there might be great objection to it.
Comment on this
That is a matter that arose in the Dáil. A doubt has been put into my mind by what Senator Hayes has said, but my information in the Dáil was that the procedure would be the same as in the case of the funds of the National University, which means that they would not be brought before the Committee of Public Accounts. My information was that they could, by a resolution of the Dáil, be referred to the Committee of Public Accounts. In practice, that is not done in the case of the National University, and the information given to me was that there would be the same position here, that it would not be discussed by the Committee of Public Accounts. A certain doubt has arisen in my mind now on account of the difference between the two positions, one being a statutory provision of a fixed sum. I would have to get further advice as to that.
Comment on this
There is really no doubt about it. Let us take an example that probably would never arise. A Deputy in the Dáil wants to know something about what is done in the department of chemistry in University College, Dublin. The Minister for Finance has an immediate answer—"I have nothing at all to do with the professor of chemistry. I do not know who he is. I did not appoint him. I cannot remove him. I have no control over him. I have nothing to do with the professor of chemistry in University College, Dublin, or University College, Cork. Do not ask me about him. I am completely ignorant about him." In this particular case the Minister for Finance cannot say that.
Comment on this
I am sure he would. If I had any influence in the Dáil I would prevent anybody in the Dáil from asking any question. Of course, that is not the position. The Minister for Finance cannot ignore the responsibility. There will be no use in his saying to the Chair in the Dáil: "I do not know anything about this" because it is provided that the Government appoints, the Government removes and, once that is so, the particular professor is in the same position as a civil servant. While personalities cannot be introduced, anything for which he is responsible, the Minister is responsible for too. It opens out a completely new field. I want to ask the Taoiseach, whoever he takes advice from, not to believe that anyone has any doubt. There is no doubt at all.
Comment on this
The former Ceann Comhairle is well aware of the practice but even his word I am not prepared at the moment to take without further examination. I know that if I were Minister and somebody asked me, "What is professor So-and-So doing," I would say,"I do not know. I know in general that the work is going on. I have got a report and I am satisfied that the work is being done. When I say ‘satisfied' I mean that I have no reason to think otherwise, that any indications I have seen satisfy me that the work is going on." If, for instance, I found that there was no work of any kind being done and I satisfied myself as to that then I would feel I had the responsibility. That is the type of responsibility I would have and no other.
In the Dáil, as the Senator knows, a Minister may be theoretically responsible and may be able to convince any of the Deputies in the Dáil that it is all nonsense to say he would be more responsible except in a general way. I would take up the attitude, as Minister for Education: "We made these appointments in a general way. You do not expect me to go in and examine how certain work is going to be done. There is certain evidence that this work is being done. Such and such books have been published and such and such work has been done. If anyone wants to satisfy himself in the matter he can examine those books. All I can say to the House is that I am generally satisfied that the purpose for which this institute was set up is being effected."
Comment on this
The Taoiseach does not get my point. He could, as Minister for Education, do a much more drastic thing than he has just suggested. He could say: "I will not answer about this at all." But this is the important point: the Minister for Education in the Dáil for the time being, no matter who he is, could not prevent a member of the Dáil from making a speech about it under the privilege of the House and saying what he liked about an unfortunate individual who had no redress. That is the point. It is not the Ministerial answer that matters.
Comment on this
That is the point I wanted to make. It is really going back to the old reasons why we have been opposed to this particular system. We know, for instance, the view taken, very sincerely, by Senator Counihan, and I think there are many people in the country who may continue to take that view, and perhaps in a more extreme form after the institute is set up. If the Minister declined to give further information, I can easily see a Deputy from some Party moving the reduction of the Vote in order to debate the whole matter and making statements so that the Minister would feel, in the interests of the institute, he would have to go and get more information and try to defend it. It is too late to hope that it will be changed now, but I would ask the Taoiseach to see whether it would not be possible to change it in a year or two.
Comment on this
I promise that if I have anything to do with it, and if a development such as has been suggested here takes place, we will get a better way of doing it. In the meantime we live in hope that no such instances will occur.
Comment on this
I notice that under Section 28—and also Section 29—that there is no date or period specified within which these accounts must be rendered. I hope, perhaps as a consolation to me for all the trouble I have been taking, that the Minister might agree to consider this matter on the Report Stage because a very undesirable practice has arisen in some Departments now. Some Departments' reports are three years late. I think one of the Revenue Commissioners' reports was four years late and in one case we got three reports together. There is a period prescribed for the report. Apparently the report has got to be rendered within the next financial year after the year covered by the report. In practice, what reason is there for separating the report and the accounts? In every business institution—and I suggest that this has some analogy to business, certainly not much, if you look at the Bill—the reports and the accounts are issued together. Why should not the reports and the accounts be issued in one single document and why should there not be a period within which these must be rendered? That appears to be a very harmless and simple request and I hope the Minister will consider it before Report Stage.
Comment on this
I think Senator Sir John Keane's remarks represent the first good argument in favour of the scheme in the Bill because if it is definitely under the Department of Finance, it will have to be provided for in the Estimates, and if they do not send in accounts, there will be no Estimate.
Comment on this
I think it is clearly indicated that the accounts must be rendered for the financial year. With regard to the report, you can sometimes try to get consistency of that sort which may not be desirable. For instance, the end of the financial year may be a proper time for the accounts, but it might not be the best time to fix in respect of the report on the work being done. It might, perhaps, be better to have it in July, or some time like that. It is left open so that the most convenient arrangement can be made, and my regret now is that we did not leave more to be done in that fashion, because I think that, looking at it now in the light of the discussions we have had, one of the mistakes made is an attempt to work out too much in detail.
Comment on this
Do I understand the Taoiseach to say that there is a period within which the accounts must be rendered?
Comment on this
I think so; I think it is set out in the next section that the accounts have to be rendered for the financial year.
Comment on this
Yes, but it does not say when. You could render the accounts for this financial year in 1947.
Comment on this
Surely Senator Sir John Keane knows the infallibility of the 5th April from the point of view of the Department of Finance?
Comment on this
It is never done. Many Departments do not render their report for quite a considerable time, but I see the Minister's point. It is as he says.