We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1942—Committee Stage.

Contributions 129–267 of 267. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1942
Enacted

No. 17 of 1942 ›

I am a member of a golf club and see very little drinking between 1 and 2. I do not think that the particular golf club to which I belong would be at any loss if there were no drinking before 2 o'clock, unless you were taking a meal. The abuse takes place in a different type of club, and I do not see why a club member should have an advantage over an ordinary citizen.

Comment on this

Why not apply that to the Kildare Street Club?

Comment on this

My sympathies in regard to the Kildare Street Club are identical with those of Senator Foran. Such a change would involve no extension in the hours of drinking. I know it would cause inconvenience to some people, but I do not see how that can be remedied.

Comment on this

All these arguments are so good and so sensible that it is extremely hard to know with which to agree. I would like to reinforce Senator Cummins' remarks about the single hour. I never liked it and I think in the end it will mean, as it meant in England when it was tried there, that you have to close down and refuse to serve people a quarter of an hour before closing time. You have two types of people to deal with—the man who rushes and drinks quickly and the other who is always a little late and is often difficult to get out. The latter type may be the cause of scenes, which would not occur if there were two periods of two hours each, as the Minister suggested originally.

Comment on this

As there are various amendments, I am not quite sure how the question will be put on which we are to vote. I stand for the split hour, and preferably for a split two hours. It is not desirable that an advantage should be given to clubs as against public houses. Further, there should not be sufficient time to make it worth a man's while to rush out to the bona fide area after the public houses close in town. I would like to vote for the hours 1 to 3 and 5 to 7. As far as opening is concerned, that would put the public houses in the same position as the clubs.

Comment on this

Yes, as far as opening is concerned.

Comment on this

Again, I would vote against any proposal that has no break. These hours would give a four hours run—two periods of two hours each, with a two-hour break. If a man is settled down in a public house and then is put out at 7 o'clock, he will not find it worth his while trying to get to, say, Lucan, where they would close at 8 o'clock. I would like to vote for the hours 1 to 3 and 5 to 7.

Comment on this

Those are the hours for Cork, Limerick and Waterford.

Comment on this
Leas-Chathaoirleach

Those are the hours in Senator Conlon's amendment, and it is open to Senator Fitzgerald to vote for it. A question to test the opening hour of 1 o'clock will be put first on that amendment.

Comment on this

I would suggest that all amendments relating to Sunday closing be withdrawn and that time be given, before they are withdrawn, for all the members of the House to express their preferences. Then we should endeavour to put down one or two amendments on the Report Stage which would give a clear view of what is proposed. That would save any waste of time. I think there is enough agreement amongst us to do that.

I do not think there is need for any increase in the total number of hours on Sundays. Secondly, I am definitely in favour of a split hour. The best advice I can get is that there is a clear case for it and that a two-hour split is better than a one-hour one. If there is to be a split, it is better to give drinking facilities before a meal or with a meal, as that would do less harm, than when the drink is not followed by a meal.

I do not see why the Minister could not deal with clubs in this Bill, as some of the sections in the 1927 Act affect clubs. I am a member of two clubs in Dublin, but am not in favour of clubs being used for drinking purposes in order to take away the legitimate business of the licensed trade. If we are to deal with illicit drinking and the breaking of rules in a club or public house, we must change the method of penalty and put it on the person who breaks the law, not solely on the club or licensed trader.

Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7 p.m.

Comment on this

There is no desire on the part of Senator Campbell or myself to press our amendment in view of the suggestion made by Senator Douglas, that all the amendments should be withdrawn for the time being in order to see if a reasonable compromise could be reached between the parties who have amendments down. I have reason to believe that if such a course were adopted we might be able to reach an agreement. I do not want to take up the time of the House arguing the merits of any particular amendment in which I might be interested and, therefore, I say that all the parties concerned should agree to the suggestion made by Senator Douglas, that these amendments should be suspended in order that we will have a chance of coming together and arriving at some compromise. So far as our people are concerned, we believe we could go some distance to meet the arguments advanced in favour of other amendments.

Comment on this

In my opinion, it is scarcely necessary to do what Senator Douglas and Senator Foran suggest. In so far as we could get any indication from the House, I think most people here are agreed that the hours suggested in Senator Conlon's amendment are all right; that is, from 1 to 3 and 5 to 7, and that we should have those hours spread over all the cities. During the tea adjournment I discussed this matter with other people. Some were inclined to think the hours should be 1 to 2 and 5 to 7, so as to give a break of three hours; but if my information is correct, that would not be desirable, from several points of view. In the first place, it would be against the interests of the employees to cut the time so as to have it under four hours, and, in the second place, I believe a two hours' break is quite sufficient anyhow and that there is no necessity for a break of three hours.

Comment on this

We have not argued the merits of our case, I should like to point out. I want to know if there is any reasonable hope, should these amendments be withdrawn, that the parties concerned will consult in order to see how far it is possible to put down an agreed amendment for the Report Stage. Surely that is a reasonable suggestion.

Comment on this

That is quite reasonable.

Comment on this

If some decision could be arrived at with regard to these amendments, it will enable us to get through the business more quickly. I have a feeling that some arrangement could be arrived at on the subject of the split hours. I think the majority of the House are in favour of having split hours. If that point is decided, we could then deal with what hours would be most suitable. Senator O'Donovan and others seem to be in favour of having uniformity. If we could reach agreement on those points we could get on with the other business. I think the matter has been fairly well discussed.

Comment on this

I think it should be possible to reach agreement in relation to some of these amendments. It seems to me that most Senators are inclined to agree we should have a split hour and that we should shorten the time between the hours of closing public houses here and in the country districts.

Comment on this

During the tea interval I had conversations with other Senators, who put forward suggestions with regard to this matter. I think we are making a mistake if we assume that this will not come up in some other form on the Report Stage. I believe, however, that there will be a large measure of agreement, so that you will have only one or two issues to deal with. At the same time, if Senators are anxious to press their amendments we cannot force them to withdraw.

Comment on this

If the amendments are withdrawn now they could be reintroduced on the Report Stage, if necessary; that is, if agreed hours do not emerge.

Comment on this

If all the amendments relating to this matter are withdrawn there will remain only three on which there will be a clear issue and on which we could have a division. If we were to divide on all the amendments we might adopt ideas actually contrary to each other.

Comment on this

If these amendments are withdrawn now and no agreement is reached, on the next stage we shall find ourselves confined to one speech. Could they not be recommitted—would that not be feasible? If we cannot do something like that, the debate will be exceedingly limited.

Comment on this

That will be purely a matter for the Seanad.

Comment on this

I think Senators should know where they stand in this matter, what they are being committed to. I should like to feel that the Seanad is not irrevocably against recommittal, if that point should arise.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille Pádraic O Máille Fianna Fáil

On a matter of procedure, I should like to know what arrangements there are for holding meetings of the different groups in order to reach some agreement on this matter. So far as I understand, there is fairly general agreement on the amendment moved by Senator Conlon, and if we could get that matter settled it would be very advisable, because there is no use going over this ground again and again. If we were to settle that point we might be able to reach agreement on the remaining questions. I think it would be better to put Senator Conlon's amendment to the House.

Comment on this

I am quite agreeable to withdraw my amendment in favour of Senator Conlon's and I agree with Senator O Máille that that will help to put things more in order. Not alone is there a possibility, but there is a great probability that we will find it difficult to reach agreement on all the amendments.

Comment on this

The one thing I do not like in this amendment is the reference to 1 o'clock. I have in view the G.A.A.——

Comment on this

I suggest that the merits of this matter should not be discussed just now, and that the House should consider Senator Douglas's suggestion to postpone consideration of these particular amendments with the object of having a substitute amendment or substitute amendments introduced on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

My point is that there will be one or two clear amendments upon which we can decide.

Comment on this

The matters at issue have been very well discussed all day and if they are to come up again it will mean a new discussion, with various interests watching, and a lot of time will be occupied before the matter can be decided.

Comment on this

As I understand it, there are only three amendments before the House and one is now being withdrawn.

Comment on this

I am quite prepared to withdraw amendment No. 10, provided that the other Senators are prepared to withdraw theirs, but I should like to make it clear that I reserve the right to propose an alternative on Report Stage, even though it would upset the amendment carried.

Comment on this

If the Seanad decides to proceed with the discussion of these amendments, three separate questions will be put to elucidate the matter: one on the opening hour; another on the split hour, and a third on the closing hour.

Comment on this

What are we discussing now?

Comment on this

We are discussing the three aspects of the matter, but there will be separate decisions if they are called for.

Comment on this

The Minister told us that he had agreed to 2 o'clock because the assistants interested in the national games had asked for it. I personally am quite satisfied to have the split period of two hours, but I would oppose an opening at 1 o'clock under these considerations.

Comment on this

I was about to make a somewhat similar suggestion. If we could agree to a 1.30 opening, it would give the G.A.A. men more time for their forenoon games. I have been given to understand that if we accept this proposal of a 1 o'clock opening, it will practically kill the G.A.A. in Dublin, and that is something which I should be very sorry to see happen. These men would find it impossible to fit in their forenoon games with a 1 o'clock opening, and, however anxious we are to consider the interests of the general public, we have to consider the question of the national games, which is very important.

Comment on this

Of course, Senator, you are now dealing with the merits.

Comment on this

The point raised by Senator Goulding is very important from the national standpoint. These men who play G.A.A. games play them in the morning and they will find it very difficult to finish before 1 o'clock. It would mean rushing through their games and I suggest that Senator Douglas's proposal be supported and a joint conference can then be held before Report Stage.

Comment on this

There is apparently no agreement in respect of Senator Douglas's suggestion.

Comment on this

We had a somewhat similar debate in the other House and it was hard to confine it to a particular amendment, as there were several proposals. The procedure there was that when everyone expressed agreement, I undertook to bring in an amendment providing for what had been agreed to. I suggest that that might meet the case here. If there was a general acceptance of an opening from 1.30 to 3 o'clock and from 5 to 7 o'clock, we could avoid a lot of trouble and shorten the debate considerably. I throw that suggestion out for the consideration of the House.

Comment on this

What the Minister has said is exactly what was in my mind. I know it is being canvassed outside and it was in the hope that that might be proposed and the amendment withdrawn that I made my suggestion. If, however, Senator Conlon wishes to press the matter, he is entitled to do so. Those against it for any reason will then be free on the next stage.

Comment on this

Exactly what the Minister said, with a slight alteration, would meet the views of our people here, that is, an opening from 1.30 to 3 o'clock and from 4.30 to 7 o'clock. It was with that in mind that I agreed to Senator Douglas's suggestion and if the Minister is undertaking to bring in an amendment on these lines, it was perhaps worth while raising the matter.

Comment on this

My position is that if I hear general acceptance of something not on the Order Paper, of something in the nature of a compromise, I say that I will bring in an amendment to meet that object. The principal points I have been aiming at are the split hours and the 7 o'clock closing.

Comment on this

There is not much difference between the Minister's suggestion and Senator Foran's proposal.

Comment on this

That would operate all round? We could not agree to that.

Comment on this

All amendments would be withdrawn and I could bring in an amendment to meet the point if there was agreement, but it would apply to Dublin only.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille Pádraic O Máille Fianna Fáil

For the whole lot.

Comment on this

I would hesitate to agree to that. I made a definite agreement with representatives from different constituencies who spoke for the Cork trade and I will not willingly go back on it. I agreed to vary the arrangement in Dublin only because of the special circumstances obtaining here. So far as I know, the people in Cork and Limerick are hurlers, while in Dublin they are more soccer players. It is only the rare Dublin man who is a hurler. They are nearly all boys from the country, but, in Cork and Limerick, they all play hurling and I think I would be letting down the representatives in the Dáil very badly if I undertook to introduce an amendment which would apply all round. I ask the Seanad to do it for Dublin only and to let the other three boroughs stand.

Comment on this

Would it not be possible for the Minister to introduce an amendment as suggested, providing for an opening from 4.30 to 7 or from 5 to 7, which would leave, so far as Dublin is concerned, one simple issue which could be decided without any further debate? Then, on the question of the country, Senators who feel strongly on the matter could put down one amendment disagreeing with the proposal on which we could vote, and settle the matter.

Comment on this

On that basis, am I to understand that the amendments are being withdrawn?

Comment on this

I do not want to go against the wishes of the House and particularly those of the Minister, but I should like to point out that a 1.30 opening will not get over the point of clubs being open for an hour before that.

Comment on this

I think that too much stress is being laid on the question of the clubs.

Comment on this

We cannot have a discussion on the merits at this point.

Comment on this

Do I understand that the Minister is undertaking to bring in an amendment on these lines?

Comment on this

Let me be sure about what I am undertaking to do. I am undertaking to bring in an amendment —Senators can do what they please about it, but there is general agreement on these lines, apart from what Senator Conlon may do—providing for an opening from 1.30 to 3 o'clock and from 4.30 to 7 o'clock. If any Senator wishes to put down an amendment he is free to do so. The amendment will be in respect of Dublin only and will not interfere with the other boroughs.

Comment on this

That undertaking refers to amendments Nos. 6, 8, 9 and 10.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 5:—

In page 2, Section 4, paragraph (a), after the word and bracket "mentioned)" in line 36, to insert the words "except in the case of the county borough of Limerick".

The object of the amendment is to abolish the weekday closing hour in Limerick City. The original intention of the inclusion of that closing hour in the 1927 Act was to eliminate certain evils which were supposed to exist in connection with the licensed trade as a whole. The principal evil was perhaps the evil of what is known as the "long sitter". It was also intended to facilitate the managements of the big places here in Dublin and their assistants in respect of providing them with a break in the day's work. While it could be said that the arrangement has achieved its purpose here in Dublin and, to a lesser extent, in Cork City, it has certainly outlived its usefulness so far as Limerick is concerned. I am sure the same applies to Waterford, although no step, so far, has been taken by Waterford to abolish this closing hour.

Licensed houses in Limerick are in almost every case grocery premises as well. There are something like 230 licensed houses in Limerick, and 90 per cent. of them are grocery shops as well. The weekday closing hour gives the unlicensed grocer an unfair advantage over the licensed grocer, who is required to close his premises during that hour, while the others, including all the chain shops, are open to do business. This hour is the busiest hour in Limerick City. It is the hour during which many people are preparing to leave the city by bus or train, and although the concession has been made of allowing bona fide trade to be carried on, at the same time, there is a large number of people within the three-mile limit who have to be accommodated. As the law stands, these people cannot enter a licensed premises to get groceries or to do ordinary business, and, in normal times, they go to the non-licensed grocer.

It can be argued that at present, under the rationing system, people have their ration cards in certain shops and are compelled to go to these shops. Then again the customer is precluded from going to the shop where his ration card is because of this closing hour. Furthermore, the publican is required to keep a man on the door if he has to admit bona fide travellers so as to distinguish between the bona fide and the non-bona fide. That leaves him open to prosecution, because it is quite impossible in a rush hour like that to distinguish between the person who is a bona fide traveller and the person who is not.

So far as the principal evil which it was sought to eliminate by the imposition of this hour is concerned, that is the evil of the "long sitter," I think it will be agreed that in a city like Limerick you have not the element in the population which provides that type of gentleman or lady, as the case may be. We have not so many gentlemen of leisure there.

The business carried on in Limerick is mainly done with people from the outlying agricultural districts and in that respect there is no analogy between Limerick and Dublin. Dublin is predominantly an industrial city with an industrial and professional population and the evils that are supposed to exist in Dublin I am quite satisfied do not exist in Limerick. But I think the greatest objection to the continuance of this closing hour in a city like Limerick is the fact that although bona fide traffic is permitted, I am informed that, as the law stands, even a bona fide traveller, if he is permitted to enter a licensed premises, is not allowed to purchase anything in the line of groceries and the licensed grocer is not allowed to sell groceries, so that he might as well close down his premises completely. If I am wrong in that I should like to be corrected. These are the chief points which I wish to make in support of this amendment. I claim that, so far as Limerick is concerned, this closing hour has been found to be very difficult, that it has been the cause of disruption in trade, and that it gives an unfair advantage to the non-licensed grocer as against the licensed grocer. Therefore, I ask the Minister to accept the amendment which, I think, is a very fair one so far as Limerick is concerned.

Comment on this

I second the amendment. I may say that I would not do so if I thought for a moment that the abolition of the midday closing hour would lead to more drinking. I am satisfied that it would not. I feel quite sure that in Limerick City and in rural districts generally there is no excessive drinking. Senator Colbert has stated very fairly the reasons for this amendment and the peculiar position in Limerick, which is the centre of a large agricultural district and is unlike Dublin in that respect. I am sure, from what I have seen of the working of this midday closing hour, that it does no good from the point of view of temperance or sobriety, but rather that it is vexatious and, to a large extent, unworkable, and I think everybody would be better pleased if we abolished it.

Comment on this

I mentioned this particular point about Limerick on the Second Stage and I should, therefore, like to support the amendment. Like the proposer and the seconder, if I thought it would lead to any excessive drinking or anything of that kind, I would not support it. The worst feature of this partial closing and partial opening is that it may encourage the breaking of the law. It is very hard to differentiate at that hour of the day between the bona fide traveller and the person who is not a bona fide traveller. The people of Limerick, I think, would prefer to have it one way or the other, either a complete closing down or a complete opening. Limerick, situated as it is in the midst of a great agricultural area and living mostly on farmers and others who come from country districts, is quite different from the City of Dublin. I think no harm would be done to the cause of temperance if the Minister accepted the amendment.

Comment on this

A similar amendment to this was moved in the Dáil. I resisted it there, and I propose to do the same here. If the Bill had remained as first introduced in the Dáil, undoubtedly the people of Limerick, Cork and Waterford would have had a grievance —principally the people of Limerick and Waterford—because the custom there is for people outside the city to buy their groceries as well as getting drink in these houses in the city. That has been the custom, as I say, and even bona fide travellers were entitled to do that. Under the Bill as introduced, the bona fide trade was done away with altogether except on Sundays and, consequently, I am satisfied a serious hardship would have been inflicted on people from outside these cities. I met a deputation representative of the licensed trade of the whole country and they raised that point. They pointed out what the effect of it would be, and I promised that on the Committee Stage in the Dáil I would take care that the status quo would be maintained.

I am not prepared to depart from the principle of the split hour in respect of the boroughs. I am greatly surprised at Senator Colbert and Senator O'Dwyer referring to Limerick as a country town. My idea is that in the very near future Limerick will be one of the finest cities in the country. With the airport so near it, I believe that it has a very big future, and I would not like to have the inferiority complex in respect of one of our principal cities that these Senators have. I believe that in the future it will be a very big city. I believe that this principle of the split hour is a very good one, and if it had been in general operation throughout the country I would not have interfered with it.

I am not bringing in anything new so far as the split hour is concerned; I am merely leaving it as it is. I would not be prepared to depart from that principle, because wherever it has been in existence I certainly think it has had very good results. I do not know if I heard the Senator aright, but if he thinks that bona fide travellers cannot buy groceries as well as drink, I can tell him that that is not so. There is no restriction on their buying groceries or provisions of any kind during the bona fide hours. I should like to be as agreeable as I could, but I am not going to break through that principle if I can help it. Therefore I cannot accept the amendment.

Comment on this

There is one point to which I should like to refer. The Minister says that he believes that Limerick will be a very big city in the future. I think, however, that that will be a long way off, and would it not be time enough to have this matter of the closing hour as regards Limerick decided when Limerick does become a bigger city? So far as the conditions in Limerick at the moment are concerned, my information, from the licensed trade, from the assistants and from the general public, is that this closing hour there is a severe hardship, and a greater hardship, I think, so far as concerns the agricultural community who use Limerick as a shopping centre. I think that it is unnecessary in the case of Limerick and, as Senator O'Dwyer has pointed out, it will not advance the cause of temperance. The object of the amendment is simply to facilitate the people in their ordinary trading, and if I thought for a moment that the acceptance of this amendment would lead to excessive drinking, I certainly would not propose it.

Comment on this

Is the amendment being withdrawn?

Comment on this

No, Sir.

Comment on this

Well, then, I shall put the question, which is: "That the words proposed to be inserted in the section be therein inserted."

Comment on this

I think the amendment is lost.

Comment on this
A Senator

Division.

Comment on this

Will Senators desiring a division please rise in their places?

Senators Colbert and Honan rose.

Comment on this

The amendment is lost. The names of Senators Colbert and Honan will be recorded as dissenting.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

In page 2, Section 4, paragraph (b) (i), after the word "area" in line 40 to insert the words and brackets "(in which for the purpose of this section the urban district of Bray shall be deemed to form part)".

I thoroughly endorse the Minister's attitude on the Second Reading which was to the effect that we should only concern ourselves with the general public—the ordinary man in the street —and not with any particular section of the licensed trade or any other section that may have a particular interest in this matter. In bringing forward this amendment I believe that I am acting in the interests, not alone of the man in the street, but of temperance also. What I want to emphasise is that, so far as Bray is concerned, there should be no bona fide traffic at all. Anybody conversant with the area will know that even with the present restricted transport very large numbers of people, not only from Dublin, but from neighbouring places, such as Dun Laoghaire, Dalkey, Killiney, and so on, have very little difficulty in getting into Bray after the ordinary closing hours there, and when we do come back to normal times and the present transport restrictions are removed after the emergency, I suggest that Bray is very peculiarly situated so far as its close connection with Dublin is concerned. There are about three routes of buses running all the time from Dublin to Bray and there is also the service of the railways.

Comment on this

Not on Sundays.

Comment on this

Not at the present time, as a result of the emergency, but even with the present restricted traffic, there are plenty of facilities for travelling to Bray, especially from Dun Laoghaire, Dalkey, Killiney and other such neighbouring places. In the course of the discussion about Limerick, it was pointed out that it was hard to distinguish between one person and another, but it must be remembered that the normal population of Bray is well over 10,000, and during the summer season its population is almost doubled. The result is that it is almost impossible for a publican in Bray to find out who is a bona fide traveller and who is not.

People may say that the Gárdaí will not be too strict, but I think that that is a very bad principle, so far as the Gárdaí, the Minister, or other people are concerned. The Minister may say that I am arguing for special legislation for Bray, but I would remind him that when butter was rationed, certain places were specially included, and one of these places was Bray. I am moving this amendment simply for the reason that I think it would be better for everybody concerned—both from the temperance point of view as well as that of the licensed trade in Bray—and that it would be quite fair from the point of view of the general public.

Comment on this

This seems to me to raise an interesting point, because I take it that the object would be to allow the public houses in Bray to remain open from 1 to 3 and 5 to 7 on Sundays, and have no bona fide traffic at all.

Comment on this

Yes, that is my intention.

Comment on this

Well, what I should like the Minister to concede would be to make that applicable to the whole country instead of to Bray alone. I am not, for a moment, committing myself, but I do not see how you could make it applicable to Bray alone.

Comment on this

That is the point.

Comment on this

With regard to this particular amendment, I do not see how it would work. I want to get rid altogether of the bona fide traffic which, I believe, is a curse to the trade itself, and is not in the interest either of the temperance movement or of the whole moral standard of the country. I personally would be tempted to concede something in the matter of an extension of the hours if it would mean a complete abolition of the bona fide trade.

Comment on this

Are we going to discuss amendments Nos. 15 and 16?

Comment on this

I think it would be better. I think we could deal with the question of Bray separately.

Comment on this

My point is that, even with the present restricted transport, you can get to Bray from Dublin, Dun Laoghaire, and other adjacent places, quite easily, and that when we get back to normal times it will be much easier to get to Bray from these districts. Certainly, at present conditions in Bray are a disgrace so far as the bona fide traffic is concerned, and I suggest that since Bray is so near Dublin it is in many ways part of Dublin.

Comment on this

My objection to including Bray is that there would be no case whatever for excluding other towns, such as Dundalk, Drogheda, Sligo, and so on, and, of course, if I were to include Bray I would be asked why I excluded these other towns. This very point was debated very much in the Dáil in connection with one part of the Bill, and I was adamant on it. I refused to make any change, and I do not think I would be justified in dealing with Bray as a special case. I shall have to discuss the question of a general opening, but I could not see how I could justify agreeing to include Bray unless it was incorporated in the Borough of Dublin in the way that Howth has been incorporated. If that were the case, it would be a different matter, but it is not so, and I do not see how we can differentiate in the case of Bray and leave out these other towns. On the face of it, it would be very difficult for me, logically, to defend not opening in other towns, but that is the code at present and it has been in actual effect for a great number of years. I do not know for how many years, but it has been the code, and I certainly would not be prepared to stand over a Bill that would lead to greater facilities. The extra facilities that we have granted—one of which has been taken off already by the Seanad—have been very adversely criticised here and in certain quarters of the country, but they have been taken away by the Seanad, and if we were to have general opening in the principal towns, I do not see how you can have an exception made in the case of a smaller town. In the Dáil, a very good case was made for opening in the country places, and there were also some very good arguments against it. Logically, however, I think it would be very hard to make a case against opening in the country, but there must have been some very good reason for it. At any rate, I found it there, and I am not prepared to take the responsibility for changing it. This matter is more or less on a par with the increased facilities for betting, which I mentioned before.

I remember years ago, before that Betting Act was passed, there was a lot of illegal betting going on, but I am quite convinced that at least 30 or 40 people bet now for every one that used to bet at that time. It was not everybody that was prepared to run down a laneway to place a bet. The vast majority of people who now have no hesitation in walking into a betting shop and placing a bet would never dream of taking the chance of being caught in one of those occasional raids that used to be made on the illegal "bookie" in the laneway. There may be a certain amount of illegal drinking going on now. There may be; I daresay there is. But I am perfectly satisfied that, if we were to have general opening, there would be an enormous increase in drinking all through the country. I firmly believe that. The cost of drink in 1924 was very much the same as it is now; one of the big reasons why there has been a decrease in consumption since then is that the facilities have not been as great. The licensing laws brought in by my predecessor, Mr. Kevin O'Higgins, were very largely responsible for reducing the consumption of drink. If we had a general opening, I have no doubt whatever that there would be an enormous increase in the amount of drinking. Even illegal drinking would go on when the public houses closed. I am quite certain that, when the closing hour came, the people who are drinking illegally now would do the same. That is a very serious aspect of the matter.

I would remind Senator Byrne, and other Senators who have those amendments down in regard to the other towns, of the matter that was raised in the first instance by Deputy Allen, and taken up by Deputy Dillon and others. Most of the country public houses—I do not know if this applies so much to Bray—are general stores as well. The case made by one Deputy—he was quite genuine about it—was that people come in on a Sunday who want to buy groceries, clothes or boots or something of that kind, and who, perhaps, do not want a drink at all. Deputy Allen pointed out that, if that were allowed to any great extent, the people who sell only those goods— drapery shops and hardware shops— would say: "Are we to remain closed on Sundays while other people are selling goods that might otherwise be bought from us?"

Eventually the observance of the Sabbath would disappear altogether. That was a good point. Deputy O'Higgins insisted on putting the onus on me. He said: "You are going to discriminate against the country, and it is up to you as Minister to justify it." As I said, I am not going to accept that onus at all. Since the Oireachtas was set up, two Licensing Bills were passed. This provision was there even in the British time, and on the whole, I believe it has worked fairly well. I am quite satisfied that, if it were departed from, we would have a big increase in the consumption of drink. I know what Senator Byrne's point is; I know that Bray is very near Dublin, but I do not think it would be possible to make that exception. If Bray were treated in that way, there certainly would be an unanswerable case from Dundalk and other towns. Then again, there would be the line ball. Other places would be coming near to the 10,000 mark, and eventually you would have this demand from the whole country. There was a very strong demand in the Dáil to have an opening for a limited number of hours. I resisted that very strongly, and I said so here when last we discussed this matter. I do not know if I have made a good case, but I have given the reasons as far as I could. It may be hard to make a case on ordinary grounds of fair play, but precedent and the practice that has grown up I think justify me in refusing to agree to those amendments. Consequently, I will resist as far as I can the amendments which suggest opening outside the county boroughs.

Comment on this

I did not mention general opening. I am altogether in agreement with the Minister's references to betting. It has spread throughout the country amongst people who would hardly know a Clydesdale from any other kind of horse. But there is no analogy here. I am not trying to increase the hours. Under the present system, Bray would be entitled to a bona fide trade from 1 o'clock to 8 o'clock, and they have thousands of people coming in there in the summer time. I am proposing that they only be allowed to trade during whatever are the hours in Dublin. I might say that I have every sympathy with what Senator Douglas has said. I would go very far in agreement with any system to do away with the bona fide trade as existing at present.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:—

In page 2, Section 4, paragraph (b) (ii), after the word "Borough" in line 44 to insert the following words:—"or any town the population of which according to the census which is for the time being the last census exceeds 10,000".

This amendment suggests that towns with over 10,000 inhabitants should be treated in the same way as county boroughs. It is not usual, perhaps, to make sacrifices on behalf of the publicans, but that is what I am doing. They are willing to sacrifice the bona fide hours completely in order to have the split hours of 1 to 3 o'clock and 5 to 7 o'clock, as provided in the Bill in regard to county boroughs. In some towns in my own county, particularly in Dundalk, which has a population of not far short of 25,000 if you go out a couple of miles, on practically every Sunday in the year we have an influx of from 5,000 to 8,000 people. We want to bring in the split hours there so that those people will go out and patronise the sports which are provided in the locality. In many instances, the assistants in those premises are interested in the different forms of sport, and, if the Minister accepts the amendment which I have moved, the assistants in those towns and in the other towns which I have in mind will have an opportunity of contributing to them. In addition, the various visitors will attend them. Not all of those people who come from Belfast are strangers; they are our own, with very close associations with us, and with many friends in the area. If my amendment is accepted it will mean that we are showing some encouragement to our citizens in the North to come back and spend a couple of hours in association with their friends, as well as attending the various sports which are provided locally.

In this instance I suggest that there is an unanswerable case on behalf of the assistants in the premises, on behalf of the residents of Dundalk, and on behalf of visitors who come to us each week, whom we are glad to see and whom I, personally, would go a long way to encourage to keep up their association with us. I think the case is a very strong one and we put it to the Minister for acceptance.

Comment on this

I have no interest in this amendment other than the interest of the ordinary citizen looking at a very peculiar problem which, I believe, exists in Dundalk and exists nowhere else in the country. The difficulty I see about the amendment is that the Minister has been asked to apply it to the whole country. I believe there is a very difficult problem in the town of Dundalk as far as the licensing laws are concerned. There is a difficulty for the authorities and for the district justice whose function it is to administer the law in that particular area. While I have no suggestions as to how it ought to be dealt with, I definitely feel that it is an ugly sort of problem. Thousands of people come across the Border Sunday after Sunday. They have quite a lot of money. They come in there. They are bona fide travellers and can stay. They have rights. It is not good for them. It is not good from the point of view of the impression they get of conditions here. It is not good for our own citizens. I believe that Drogheda is quite different. I think the conditions in Dundalk are of such a nature, and have been for some years and, obviously, will be for some time to come, as to demand particular and special legislation to deal with them. I feel the Minister would be quite justified in dealing with Dundalk in this measure in a way that would not be justified in regard to any other town of its size or even of twice its size. I think the conditions require something different from what has been the custom up to the present because our laws, as they exist and as they are administered, are not satisfactory. Senator McGee knows the conditions much better than I do, but I know enough about them to realise that we ought to do something about it, that it is not to our credit as the law exists and as it is possible to administer it. The Minister, I am quite certain, in his own Department, must have taken notice of the conditions that exist there.

It is a smuggling centre and there are elements that require special treatment. I am not supporting the amendment as it stands, to apply these conditions to the country as a whole, but I think if Senator McGee asked to have it applied to Dundalk, because there is a particular problem there, he would be getting nearer to the root of the trouble in that part of Louth, which does not exist to the same extent anywhere else and does not call for the same kind of treatment anywhere else.

Comment on this

I have a great deal of sympathy with the attitude taken by the Minister and I confess quite frankly that if I were in his position I would probably take the same view. He has knowledge from police reports which I have not got and if he has evidence that the drinking as a result of bona fide traffic, and the evasion of the law in various towns all over the place, is not more than it would probably be during the hours of 1 and 3 and 5 and 7, then I think he is bound to take the line he has taken. At the same time I have to confess that if that is not so, I would be terribly tempted to provide some reasonable hours—I shall not pledge myself to the exact hours—for Sunday opening and abolish bona fide trade everywhere and every time and get rid of what I regard as a curse.

I am not prepared to put down an amendment because I think the Minister, in his position, has information and I quite recognise that there is a definite risk with regard to any change. But, from what I hear from people who live in the neighbourhood of certain country towns—I am not going to quote any towns and I do not want to be accused of specifically referring to any towns—I have got the impression that it is not only in the case of Dundalk but that there are certain other places where drinking between the hours of 1 and 7, or 1 and 8 is more or less continuous and that it is extremely difficult, if not impossible, for the police to enforce the law. If the bona fide laws can be enforced by the police, and if that is the Minister's opinion, I would certainly not be one to press it because I do not want to have any substantial increase in Sunday drinking. I want to be honest about it and to say that I have often seriously wondered whether it would not be better for everyone concerned to fix a reasonable hour, abolish bona fide traffic and ask the trade, the public and the police to combine to see it was carried out and, if necessary, to take drastic action to see it was carried out.

Comment on this

The Minister, in connection with the case put to him in regard to Bray, said he could not deal with one particular area. This amendment proposes to deal with all areas outside the boroughs that have a population of 10,000 or over. I have not looked it up to see what areas would have a population of 10,000 or over. I presume the Minister would know. There is one area, namely, Galway and I think the amendment would be welcome there. There are a great many hotels in Galway and it is not very difficult to get drink in Galway at any particular hour. I would like to support the amendment and I would ask the Minister to consider accepting it.

Comment on this

I would like to support the amendment. I do not agree with the Minister. I do not think he is getting anywhere by adopting the attitude he has adopted. Towns of over 10,000 population are not in the same category as an ordinary country village. I have every sympathy with the Minister in not having widespread opening. I believe that he would get rid of the biggest evil of the bona fide trade by giving these towns what Senator McGee's amendment proposes to give them. I think, instead of having any ill effect, it would mean less drinking.

Comment on this

The moment you start on this figure of 10,000—which is an entirely arbitrary figure—you will have the case of the town with a population of 9,999 and there is no end to it. It seems to me far better to have something on the lines of Senator Douglas's suggestion.

Comment on this

I have made the best case I can against this proposal. I think what Senator The McGillycuddy says is right: you cannot draw the line. It is a case of having general opening or leaving things as they are. I would not agree to the general opening and I do not see any half-way house.

As far as I can ascertain the towns that would be affected by this amendment would be Galway, Dundalk, Drogheda, Sligo, Wexford, Tralee, Kilkenny and Bray. These are towns with a population of 10,000 or over. I shall just repeat that I believe if illegal drinking is carried on at present in these places, there would be no diminution in such drinking if the arrangements proposed in this amendment were carried into effect.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not really believe that one of the greatest barriers against the enforcement of the closing hours is the existence of the bona fide traffic? If you want to get rid of abuses, I suggest that the only way to do so is to get rid of the bona fide traveller. It would then be possible to enforce the law. At the same time, I would not vote for this amendment because it only partially gets rid of that problem. If we could get rid of the bona fide traffic all over Ireland, we would be doing something of real value.

Comment on this

There is one objection to the abolition of the bona fide traffic, and it is this. There are two classes of traveller, the genuine traveller and the bogus traveller. We must remember that quite a considerable number of people have to travel through the country, the vast majority of them legitimate travellers. It would be distinctly unfair to rule these out altogether and prevent their getting refreshment for the sake of getting at the man who is not a genuine traveller. For that reason, I would be slow to rule out the bona fide traffic altogether because, especially in the neighbourhood of tourist resorts throughout the country, there are a very considerable number of genuine travellers every Sunday during the summer. I think we should not penalise a very respectable class in the community in order to curtail the abuses of an objectionable class.

Comment on this

I think the Senator pointed out earlier in the debate that he was prepared to do that.

Comment on this

I did not suppose that I would have to put all my arguments into one bottle nor did I think that in order to get this amendment accepted it would be necessary to do away with the bona fide traffic. Some people find it necessary to travel on legitimate business over all parts of the country on Sundays and we know that many places in the West of Ireland are attractive resorts for tourists from other parts of the country. I myself have crossed from Sligo and Galway at various times, leaving these towns at times which made it absolutely necessary for me to get some refreshment on the way. If there are in various parts of Ireland citizens whose minds are warped through improper teaching, or probably from the lack of proper preaching, that is no reason why law-abiding citizens should be hampered or hindered. Have we not all free consciences? I submit that the whole approach to this problem is wrong. I think everybody should be taught the essentials of good citizenship, but if a man's conscience cannot guide him I do not believe that the rest of the community should be put into a straitjacket. Common sense is common law. I submit to the Minister that I have put up a case which needs a better answer than that provided by Senator The McGillycuddy, who suggests that because a town with a population of 10,000 gets these facilities, towns with populations under this figure will have a grievance. Are shop assistants in towns such as I have described never to see a football match or a cycle race or are they to be prevented from enjoying, on a Sunday afternoon, the amenities provided at bathing resorts in the vicinity of towns in which they are employed? I submit I have made an unanswerable case. I have submitted good reasons for giving special consideration to towns such as Dun-dalk. If the bugbear of the North is to be introduced, it will provide just another excuse for people in the North who wish to act similarly.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, I think the Senator did not give quite an accurate interpretation of what I said. I said that if you give this concession to towns with a population of 10,000 or over why should it not be given to the whole country?

Comment on this

Might I point out to Senator McGee that travellers on Sunday can get refreshment? That refreshment need not necessarily be alcoholic. There are other refreshments.

Amendment put and declared negatived.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13:—

In page 2, immediately after line 48 to insert the following paragraph:—

(c) On Saint Patrick's Day—

(i) in the case of the County Borough of Dublin or the Dublin Metropolitan area, before the hour of five o'clock in the afternoon or after the hour of eight o'clock in the evening, and

(ii) in the case of any other county borough before the hour of five o'clock in the afternoon or after the hour of eight o'clock in the evening, or

(iii) at any time on Christmas Day or Good Friday.

I have submitted this amendment for two reasons. The first reason is that a very considerable number of people have queried why there should not be facilities on St. Patrick's Day such as are allowed on Sundays. Whether these people are sufficiently numerous to justify one in describing the demand as a popular demand I am not in a position to say. As far as that aspect of the case is concerned, I have myself a very open mind and no very fixed convictions as to whether or not there should be such facilities on Patrick's Day. The real reason I have tabled the amendment is to try to induce the Minister between now and the Report Stage to rationalise the position on Patrick's Day.

I would suggest to him there are two logical courses open to him. Firstly, if he feels so inclined, and if the House is of the same opinion, he could allow the same opening hours as on Sunday on that day. Secondly, if the House and the Minister feel that there should be no opening on St. Patrick's Day, then the Minister should take steps to put that into effect and to abolish the rather absurd position that exists at the moment. At the moment, as far as St. Patrick's Day is concerned, the 1927 Act might very definitely be described as class legislation. The position is that on that day no drink may be sold in any public house nor in any non-sports club, but drink may be sold nearly everywhere else. In hotels and restaurants, for instance, drink can be sold from 1 p.m. to 3 p.m. and from 6 p.m. to 9 p.m., admittedly with meals. It can be sold, with or without meals, in sports clubs from 1 p.m. to 7 p.m. It can be sold at race meetings, at dog shows, at theatres and at dances with or without meals. I submit to the Minister that that is a type of legislation that is unfair. While it does not tend exactly to cause social unrest, it certainly gives ground for gross social irritation on the part of members of the public who are debarred for one reason or another from enjoying the same facilities that the favoured few are enabled to enjoy on that day.

I am quite prepared to abide by the decision of this House and the views of the Minister on this matter, but I suggest to him that, between now and the Report Stage, he should make up his mind as to what he is going to do about St. Patrick's Day—whether he is going to have the public houses open or shut. If he is going to have them shut, then licensed establishments should be shut for all and sundry and there should be no differentiation as between sections or classes.

Comment on this

This amendment seems to me to make things much worse than they were before. St. Patrick's Day, Christmas Day and Good Friday are mentioned and I understand that sub-section (3) of the amendment means that licensed premises can be kept open all day on Christmas Day and Good Friday.

Comment on this

Oh, no. There is apparently a typographical error in the amendment which I had not noticed. Sub-paragraph (iii) should be a fresh paragraph lettered (d.).

Comment on this

It means, then, that the public houses can be open only from 5 o'clock to 8 o'clock?

Comment on this

My amendment does not propose that drink be sold at any time on Christmas Day or Good Friday. The position on Christmas Day and Good Friday remains as it is.

Comment on this

Then, it was not necessary to include them.

Comment on this

They had to be included for purposes of amendment of the 1927 Act.

Comment on this

In these circumstances, we are discussing only St. Patrick's Day. I think that the same position would obtain if this amendment were accepted that would obtain if Senator McGee's amendment had been accepted; you would have general trading on St. Patrick's Day. St. Patrick's Day, as our national holiday, should be observed as a closed day for trading, including trading in drink.

If Senator Crosbie had put forward an amendment on the lines he suggested in the latter portion of his speech, I should be prepared to consider it but I could not give any consideration to the amendment as it is on the Order Paper. Some of the things he read out are, certainly, anomalies and, if an amendment to remedy those defects had been introduced by him, we could have discussed it and, perhaps, supported it. One of the items mentioned was the supply of drink at meal hours in hotels and restaurants. I think that that is reasonable. A person who is unfortunate enough to have to take a meal on St. Patrick's Day, which is like Christmas Day, outside his own home is entitled to a drink or other refreshment with it. Refreshment, alcoholic or otherwise, with meals, is never as objectionable as drinking on an empty stomach.

The Senator referred to drinking at dog shows and such places. I think that it is necessary to have licences specially granted for the supply of drink at these places. I am open to correction on that. I would be opposed to anything in the nature of increased facilities for drinking on St. Patrick's Day, such as would be provided by opening the public houses at any time on that day. However, the principal argument against the proposal is the same as against the last amendment, that you would facilitate general trading. I do not want to see general trading on St. Patrick's Day, nor do I want to see trading in intoxicating liquor.

Comment on this

Before proceeding further, may I point out that the amendment refers to St. Patrick's Day only? There has, apparently, been an error as I have stated.

Comment on this

Is there a typographical error?

Comment on this

Yes; there should be two paragraphs (c) and (d).

Comment on this

Whether there is a typographical error or not, I am not in a position positively to say, as I have not a copy of the Act before me, but it certainly was never at any time my intention to suggest that there should be any opening on Christmas Day or Good Friday.

Comment on this

The proposal is that there should be opening on St. Patrick's Day from 5 o'clock to 8 o'clock.

Comment on this

In amendment No. 16, the intention is made very clear.

Comment on this

This is a matter of history. St. Patrick's Day has been treated in a strange way by the Oireachtas in respect of the different Bills brought before it—one in 1924, another in 1927, and an ill-fated one in 1931. The Government was afraid to go on with the 1931 Bill. The law has its roots in the sentiment of the early Sinn Féin days, when we were, perhaps, more enthusiastic than wise. We tried to stop the sale of drink on St. Patrick's Day. That was because there used to be a great deal of drunkenness on that day. Drink was then cheap. In 1924, the then Minister for Justice brought in a Bill in which he proposed that there should be complete closing on St. Patrick's Day and that bona fide trading should be prohibited. The Dáil would not have that. When the Bill came to the Seanad, the Seanad reinserted the provision for closing but placed no restriction on the bona fide trade. After considerable discussion, the Dáil accepted the Seanad amendment. The Intoxicating Liquor Commission recommended that St. Patrick's Day be treated as Sunday. The Minister included that recommendation in his 1927 Bill.

The Dáil accepted the proposal, but the Seanad introduced an amendment providing for complete closing and prohibition of bona fide trading on St. Patrick's Day. The idea was to make St. Patrick's Day a completely dry day. A few loopholes were, however, left. Hotels and restaurants were allowed to supply drink with meals between 1 o'clock and 3 o'clock, and 6 o'clock and 9 o'clock. Sports clubs were allowed, as Senator Crosbie pointed out, to supply drink, with or without meals, between 1 o'clock and 8 o'clock. No provision was made for granting for St. Patrick's Day occasional licences or special exemption Orders under Section 5 of the 1927 Act. The Intoxicating Liquor Commission was reconstituted and it recommended again that St. Patrick's Day be placed on the same footing as Sunday. The Government of the day brought in a Bill which included this recommendation. Our Party was very much against it. There must have been a great deal of division in the Government Party, too, because the Bill was hung up.

I confess that I have learned from the experience of my predecessor and I have not touched St. Patrick's Day except to a very small extent. I had not the necessary courage so far as St. Patrick's Day was concerned. I cannot see why it should not be treated the same as Sunday, but I was not prepared to run counter to the views which are held. I do not want to be unfair to the Seanad, but I had the feeling that, if I agreed to such a proposition in the Dáil, a number of Senators would object and the decision would be reversed. The position seems to me to be a bit ridiculous and I confess to moral cowardice in respect of it. The little concession given, to allow wine to be supplied with meals, created a furore all over the country. I got more protests about that than I got about anything else, and I felt that it was a good job I had not tackled the bigger question. Nobody knows what would have happened if I had. The situation is a survival of our younger and more enthusiastic days. The reason I have given is not an adequate reason and it may not be a proper reason to come from a Minister. However, I must have regard to opinion and sentiment. Consequently, I did not touch St. Patrick's Day, nor do I propose to do so.

Comment on this

I was a member of the Seanad at the time the Minister speaks of. I have a very clear recollection of what occurred, and have very great sympathy with the Minister. I like his method of approach to this. I do not believe that he, any more than any of the rest of us, is afraid to admit that he has shed some of the sentiment that all of us had in our more youthful and enthusiastic days. It is very doubtful if we can decide these things on a purely logical basis. I think that until we know what the attitude of the Dáil is we would be well advised to follow the Minister and leave this alone.

Comment on this

I felt that the anomalies that existed should be ventilated. Having done that, I am prepared to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 14:—

In page 3, line 5, to delete the word "half-past".

Is not this really a necessary amendment following the action of the Seanad in adopting amendment No. 10?

Comment on this

Is it also the Senator's idea to make the morning opening 10 o'clock?

Comment on this

My original amendment only dealt with the evening. I was leaving the morning opening to be dealt with afterwards. I think it is necessary to make the hour here 10 o'clock, and to make the morning 10 o'clock. I think the proper thing to do would be to ask the Minister to put in what is necessary.

Comment on this

Although I do not like a difference in the hours as between the city and country, I think that, in the Dáil, a good case was made by the rural representatives for allowing a 10.30 closing in the country. I think that if the Senator were to withdraw his amendment he would not be doing any harm. The country T.D.s did make an excellent case for the 10.30 closing so far as the country is concerned.

Comment on this

The Minister is aware that I have been a member of this House for a considerable time. His attitude on this Bill reminds one of the debates we used to have here in the old days when the Seanad was free to put in all the amendments which it thought wise. I have very little doubt that there is a great deal in what the Minister has said. I had hoped that this would go back to the Dáil. If the Minister were in a position to say that amendment No. 10 would be carried in the other House, I would withdraw this amendment at once.

Comment on this

I would feel greatly fortified if the Senator did that and I would stand over this in the Dáil. I think I would be able to get agreement on it because the country Deputies pressed the point very strongly.

Comment on this

If that is the case I am prepared to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

Why should we make this alteration? We have been discussing this question under the headings of town and country. The suggestion that we have adopted for the county boroughs is 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. Are the hours for the country to be from 10.30 to 10.30? Why say 10.30 as the opening hour for the country?

Comment on this

In order to facilitate the assistants and the publicans in coming to an arrangement about a 48 hour week. If the Seanad cares to have the hours 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. in official winter time, and 10.30 a.m. to 10.30 p.m. in official summer time as regards public houses in the country, I will bring in an amendment to deal with that.

Comment on this

That, I think, would be a better arrangement.

Comment on this

To my mind the opening of country public houses at 10.30 in the morning would not suit at all, especially on fair or market days. The result of it will be that applications will have to be made to the courts for exemption orders to open at a much earlier hour.

Comment on this

There is nothing to prevent them doing that.

Comment on this

If this were put forward as a Labour question I could understand it, but, as I said earlier, a 10.30 opening means practically opening in the middle of the day.

Comment on this

So far as fairs and markets are concerned, opening at 10 o'clock or 10.30 will not make much difference because, in any event, the people will be going to their dinner at that hour.

Comment on this

As I have already indicated, publicans can apply for exemtion orders to enable them to open at an earlier hour, if there is a necessity for it, on special occasions. So far as the country is concerned I am prepared to bring in an amendment making the opening hours 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. during official winter time, and 10.30 a.m. to 10.30 p.m. during official summer time, leaving the hours for the county boroughs 10 a.m. to 10 p.m.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 15:—

In page 3 to delete paragraph (b), lines 7 and 8, and substitute therefor the following paragraph:—

(b) on any Sunday before the hour of two o'clock in the afternoon or after the hour of five o'clock in the afternoon.

In moving this amendment I am in the fortunate position that the Minister has already replied to it. Senator Douglas has twice already, more or less, moved the amendment on my behalf. The object of it is to have a general opening on Sundays in the rural areas. I may say at the outset that I am not particularly enamoured of the hours I mention in this amendment. I am more concerned with the principle of having an opening of some kind in the country on Sunday. There should be equal treatment for all. The Minister has already made his case against this amendment, so I will not delay the House too long.

The Minister would have been doing a very good job of work for the licensing laws in general if he adopted Senator The McGillycuddy's amendment to abolish the bona fide traffic altogether and in return allow one or two hours' legitimate opening on Sunday in all the rural areas throughout the country. My objection to the bona fide traffic is that it is a direct invitation to members of the public— and occasionally to members of the licensed trade—to break the law. I would like the Minister to give his attention to one particular aspect of that law-breaking. When a member of the general public falsely represents himself as a traveller, he commits two breaches of the law: first of all, he breaks the moral law by telling a lie to the publican and, secondly, he breaks the law of the land by entering on licensed premises during prohibited hours. To my mind, any act that holds out an inducement to the general public to commit breaches of both the moral law and the law of the land is, in itself, bad and should be discouraged as having a tendency to promote very loose thinking indeed on the part of a large section of the public.

Where the licensing laws are concerned, virtue does not always bring its own reward. To illustrate that, I will mention a case—which is true, and being true, I will disguise the name of the place where it occurred—where there was a certain dance hall which was not licensed. Next door to it, there was a licensed premises, and it was customary for dancers to visit the licensed premises after 10 o'clock. In order to safeguard himself from prosecution, the publican was in the habit of asking those people, before admitting them, where they had slept the night before. It became customary to name a village ten or 12 miles distant. On this particular occasion, three men were engaged in breaking the law. The first man said that he slept in the village of X on the previous night, and he was admitted; the second man said he slept in the village of Y, and he was admitted; the third man—the only truthful member of the party—when asked where he had slept the night before, replied: "If you want to know, I did not sleep a wink," and he was thrown out on his neck. That is the kind of thing that results from this bona fide traffic. In the interests of truth and justice the Minister would be well advised to come to a compromise in the House and, in return for total abolition of the bona fide traffic, to permit a short general opening throughout the country on Sundays. The bona fide traffic always reminds me of what the cowboy said when he saw the giraffe: “There ain't no such animal”.

Comment on this

I would like to second Senator Crosbie's amendment. I am 100 per cent. with him on this subject, as I do not see how the Minister can stand over the differentiation between town and country and between man and man. With all due respect to him, this Bill is one mass of contradictions. The Minister started off by giving Dublin longer hours and he stopped the bona fide traffic for six hours in the day to make up for that.

He allows drinking on Sundays in one town and yet continues the situation which obtains in the country today. His arguments in the Dáil did not impress me at all. He started off by saying that he found the situation satisfactory as regards Sundays and did not want to change it, and he said he was quite determined not to give way on that point. Then, without giving any reasons, he said he was very much impressed by the arguments which several Deputies put up, that it would lead to general trade, as people would go into houses where there were groceries on one side and liquor on the other.

Comment on this

I think I said it would lead to more drinking, too, which is very important.

Comment on this

I accept that. I did not want to leave out the context. I will give an instance of what happened in our local town last Sunday. A man came down from the mountain with sheep. I went to meet him and bought them. When the deal, helped by another man, was over, we went off to have a drink. This man had to stand on the platform outside, as he was living in the town. He had no intention of getting a drink. In the same town there were, I suppose, 200 mountainy men—sheep men—walking into houses for sugar and tea, while this man could not go in. I suggest that the Minister should not let this situation continue, simply because he found it so. He should correct it, in fairness to the townsman and to the countryman.

I took the trouble to discuss this with some of the clergy—intelligent men who know the country people well— and with the Gárdaí. One and all, they would infinitely prefer a short opening after second Mass to this bona fide traffic which goes on from morning till night during the hours it is allowed and which is abused, as we all know, in every possible way.

I do not think the Minister has taken a sound stand on this Bill. He talked a great deal in the Dáil, though not so much here, of going down the slippery slope; but before he brought in this legislation he should have made sure that the ground on which he was standing was reasonably firm. Instead of bringing in legislation which he could not stand over, it would have been much better for him to have asked somebody's advice beforehand. Then he would not have to give way on everything before coming to this House, and give way again here, and then discuss the result with the Dáil. I hope the Minister will see that there is some sense in the suggestion that has been made.

Comment on this

Some Senators have remarked that I gave way with regard to certain sections of the Bill. I should like to mention that when I introduced this Bill it was my intention to deal only with certain abuses which really required to be dealt with and I was hopeful of being able to remedy the situation. I knew that an attempt would be made to force me to have what I might term a general amendment of the licensing laws, and that was the very thing I was anxious to avoid. That is what I really meant when I stated that I found myself slipping. I was not able to resist the pressure of various Parties in the Dáil, including supporters of my own Party, and I felt obliged to enlarge the scope of the Bill to an extent far greater than I had intended.

My main object when introducing the Bill was to put an end to the abuse of the bona fide traffic. I know now that every Government will have to think twice before introducing any legislation to deal with licensing evils, for the reason that they may not be able to confine the legislation to the point they desire to deal with. That is the position I found myself in. An attempt was made to keep me moving in a certain direction once the Licensing Bill was introduced in the Dáil. The Dáil is a very democratic Assembly, and I could not prevent Deputies carrying their proposals. If I were a dictator and could ignore the votes in the Dáil, I could do exactly as I wished; but I am not in that position, and I had to accept the views of the majority of Deputies. I think I have given very good reasons why there should not be a general opening. I am satisfied on that point.

Comment on this

Senator The McGillycuddy did not put forward any good argument for a general opening. The proposal is that from 2 to 5 should be the opening hours. He did not support Senator Crosbie, because he suggested the opening should be after second Mass, and the time for second Mass varies throughout the country.

Comment on this

I was merely trying to get at the principle. It is not worth splitting hairs over.

Comment on this

It is, because the sheep might be driven down from the mountains at different hours and the men driving them might like to have a drink and in those circumstances you might have difficulty in deciding on the hours. It would not be desirable to have the public houses open at all hours. Senator The McGillycuddy did not support Senator Crosbie's motion at all.

Comment on this

I trust the House will not entertain this proposal, because I believe it would be disastrous to insert it in the Bill. We have had an indication of the result of legalising betting. The evil has grown to be 40 times as bad as it was. The very same thing will occur if we grant additional facilities for drinking by extending the hours. So far as the bona fide traffic is concerned, if you decide to open the public houses for two hours in order to permit those people who would ordinarily become bona fide travellers to get the drink they require, is there any reason to suppose that there will be just the same amount of drinking? In my opinion such opening would only tend to increase the consumption of drink.

We must try to realise the position in the country. It is said that there is excessive drinking arising out of the bona fide traffic. There may be, but we must remember that the number of people who drink to excess in these circumstances represents a very small portion of the population. But if the public houses are allowed legally to open, I believe that many people will be tempted to go in for a drink, and once they get accustomed to going into the public houses there will be drinking far in excess of what is experienced at the moment and that would be a disastrous state of affairs. All over the rural areas, outside the large towns, there is a bona fide traffic carried on, but there are very few people taking advantage of it. There can be absolutely no case made for opening in the rural districts on Sundays.

Comment on this

I wonder if any Senators have asked themselves why Sunday closing was enforced in the rural areas. I knew quite a lot of people who lived during the period when Sunday opening was quite common, and they told me of the rows that used to take place on Sunday evenings when people were returning to their homes. It was because of these rows, and the unseemly behaviour on Sunday evenings in rural districts, that legislation was put in force compelling those places to close.

I know quite a lot about the licensed trade, and I have not the slightest hesitation in saying that if you allow the public houses to open again on Sundays you will once more have these unseemly scenes. There is, undoubtedly, a certain amount of dodging of the licensing laws on the part of bogus travellers, but the position is far less dangerous than it would be if you were to allow public houses to open on Sundays for any period. Senator O'Dwyer is quite right. If you allow public houses to open for three hours, five minutes after the closing time you will have men seeking to enter by the backdoor. We all know that that would be the position. The safest plan is to adhere to the present arrangement. With regard to the bona fide traffic, there are genuine travellers on Sundays, farmers engaged looking after cattle and sheep and men genuinely travelling on business, and you want to penalise these people because of the actions of a small number who try to get drink in spite of any law. I do not think that would be reasonable and the present arrangements, defective though they may be, are much better than what is now being proposed.

Comment on this

I am in the same frame of mind as the Minister with regard to this matter. I do not think the House should let pass without some comment the statement that Senator Goulding has made. So far as rural Ireland is concerned, I must repudiate the Senator's suggestion that if we open public houses for some hours on a Sunday unseemly scenes are likely to take place. I do not think so. Public houses are opened on fair days all over the country. Men who travel long distances, sometimes fasting, need to have a little nourishment when they reach their destination, and some may take a little more than is good for them, but there are no unseemly scenes. I suggest that Senator Goulding is misrepresenting the people in the country districts.

There is a great deal to be said for the case made by Senator The McGillycuddy and also by Senator Crosbie, but there are some of us who feel that certain preliminaries ought to be gone through before we decide on any general practice. I think, in our approach to this question of liquor consumption, it would be well to work in conjunction with the liquor trade, allowing those engaged in it to be as much the guardians of the law as the members of the Gárda Síochána. I do not know if we could urge the Minister to depart from the position he has taken up, but I would not like to think that he has taken up such a position for any reason such as Senator Goulding has put before the House.

Comment on this

At least three points arise out of the case put forward by the Senator Goulding.

Comment on this

Would the Senator permit me to remind him that it is now 9 o'clock, the hour at which the Seanad usually adjourns?

Comment on this

In that case I move to report progress.

Comment on this