Transport (No. 2) Bill, 1944—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 234–475 of 475. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 15 of 1944 ›
I presume that in so far as the Minister may have made an Order fixing maximum charges, the matter could be raised here because there would be definite Ministerial responsibility, but it would be difficult to say where the functions of the Minister would come up against the functions of management. The matter of the provision of trucks is a matter of management.
Comment on this
If Senator Counihan feels that the transport services are not adequate for the needs of the trade, would it not be in his power to table a motion and to deal with the matter by focussing attention on it here?
Comment on this
Say that a person applied for a specific purpose for an augmentation of a specific service——
Comment on this
My point is that supposing some Senators feel that this arrangement will not work out, as the Minister and most of us believe it will, there is always power to focus public attention on it through the medium of this House.
Comment on this
If somebody had applied for the provision of a new service and if the application were refused by the Minister, following the report of the advisory committee, or without reference to the committee, the matter could be raised here, but if it was raised here in the first instance I do not think the Minister could be held responsible for that.
Comment on this
If the Minister refused to submit it to the advisory committee it could then be raised?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 50, which is in the name of Senator Kyle:—
To insert at the end of the section the following new sub-section:—
( ) The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the 31st day of March in each year (except in the year 1945) lay before each House of the Oireachtas a statement in such form as he thinks proper, setting out the matters referred to and dealt with by the advisory committee during the previous calendar year.
I do not know whether there is any point in pressing this matter. The purpose of the amendment is to secure that a report of the proceedings of the advisory committee would be tabled periodically. That is to say, that an annual report of the proceedings should be tabled in both Houses. If the Minister is resisting this proposal, of course it is no use proceeding with it.
Comment on this
The Senator appreciates that every application considered by the advisory committee must be published and that every Order made by the Minister following receipt of the report must also be published. There is, therefore, full publicity arranged for everything that will come before the committee.
Comment on this
Before we pass this section, I should like to put in a plea in connection with the singling of the line from Athlone to Dublin. I intended to put down an amendment dealing with this matter but I was told that as it would interfere with the management it would not be in order. I shall try, however, to frame an amendment for the Report Stage. If the Minister would give me an assurance that he will bring the matter before the advisory committee, it would please me and please the cattle traders. We wish to have the line from Dublin to Athlone reconverted into a double track. As I pointed out on the Second Reading of this Bill, the cattle trade is as much interested in a quick, efficient service as it is in cheap rates. Before this line was singled, I moved in this House a motion to get the Government to prevent the railway company from singling the line. At that time we had a director of the railway a member of this House and, against all my protests, he pointed out to the Minister in attendance and to the members of the Seanad that when this line from Dublin to Athlone would be converted into a single track, with new signalling methods and other improvements, we would have a better service on the single line than we had at that time with the double track. While he did not convince me or the cattle trade, he convinced a number of industrialists that we would have a better service. Since that time there has been the greatest congestion that could possibly be imagined on the line from Athlone to Dublin.
A good many lines converge at that particular point. We have the Galway to Dublin line, and the Mayo line joining there. The Galway line takes a big percentage of live stock from the Limerick to Ennis area. A large amount of traffic from West Clare is also carried by that line. Then on the Mayo line very heavy traffic from the North-West of Ireland comes through Athlone and at Mullingar you have a still further influx of traffic from Cavan and the north-west. The cattle trade wants a quick and efficient service, but it is impossible to get it with a single track. I would be satisfied if the Minister would refer the matter to the advisory committee with a view to having a recommendation sent to the Great Southern Railways Company to have the line, at least from Athlone to Dublin, reconverted into a double track.
Comment on this
On some previous occasion I expressed doubts as to whether the singling of that line was a wise economy, but it has been done, and that fact must now influence decisions in relation to it. I suggest that the cattle traders could not presume to be transport experts any more than this advisory committee will be a committee of transport experts. What they want is a quicker and a better transport service, and it will be the function of the transport company to see that they will get a quicker and a better service, but whether that can be done by doubling a line, singling a line, or by other means, is not a matter on which I myself could offer an opinion, and I suggest that it is a matter on which the cattle traders could not offer an opinion either. That is a matter for the management, and whether it is done by one method or another is not a matter for me or the cattle traders. I think that the management of the company will take all the necessary steps that are required to see that a proper service is provided, and we should leave it to them to decide which one of these steps should be taken— whether by providing a second line or by singling a line, or any other method which seems best to them.
Comment on this
Will the Minister leave it to the advisory committee to decide such matters?
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister for information in regard to Section 65. Provision is made in sub-section (5) of the section to the effect that if any person who is summoned as a witness before the advisory committee fails to attend or refuses to take an oath or to produce any document in his power or control, legally required by the advisory committee to be produced by him, or to answer any question which the committee are legally entitled to ask, he will be guilty of an offence. It seems to me that the method of enforcing the penalty is to proceed in the District Court against that person for having been in default and, on conviction, he is liable to a penalty. I do not know whether that is the best form or not, but I have a recollection with regard to a somewhat similar body that was set up some years ago—I am referring now to the Prices Commission—in which some difficulty was experienced in enforcing a somewhat similar provision. I have not checked up to see if this draft is in precisely the same terms as the corresponding section of the Prices Commission Act, but the Department has had the experience of administering that Act, and perhaps they have made good its deficiencies, if there were deficiencies. There was, however, a weakness discovered in that Act in regard to the enforcement of the provision dealt with here.
Comment on this
I do not know if there will be any difficulty in enforcing this. The alternative would be to give this committee power to deal with an offence, but I doubt if that would be wise. I do not think it would be wise to make failure to meet the wishes of the committee an offence, unless it is proven in court.
Comment on this
Would it be possible, in the event of an offence, to make it competent for the committee to inflict the punishment?
Comment on this
No, that would be very undesirable. What happened in the case of the Prices Tribunal was that they sent a man to the High Court and the court found him guilty or not, but the tribunal itself had no power.
Comment on this
I remember the case of a man who refused to give evidence, and it is my recollection that the case against him did not succeed in the court.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 51, standing in the name of Senator Sweetman:—
To add to the section a new sub-section as follows:—
( ) Such regulations shall not exclude the right of any person or persons or body of persons directly or indirectly interested in the matters upon which the advisory committee have been asked to report, appearing in person or by solicitor or counsel before such advisory committee.
Senator Sweetman has informed me that this amendment is put down for the purpose of seeing that no persons interested in matters on which the advisory committee have been asked to report shall be precluded from appearing before the committee either in person or by solicitor or counsel. There is a proviso already in Section 65 (2), but I do not know whether the actual power of making regulations here could in any way interfere with what is in Section 65 (2).
Comment on this
It is proposed to give the committee full power in this regard. Senators may recollect that the Prices Commission, to which reference has been made already and which had similar powers, decided that they would not hear people through solicitors or counsel. They said, in effect, that they were not concerned with arguments or opinions, and that their function was merely to ascertain the facts and come to their own conclusion on the facts. In the case of this committee I think it is probable that they would be concerned with the arguments that might be advanced in favour of a particular course rather than with the actual circumstances. In this particular case I think the position would be likely to be the reverse of that of the Prices Commission, and they would be concerned with the case that could be made for the alteration of some existing order or the provision of new facilities.
Comment on this
I have no brief for the legal profession, although they sometimes assist in elucidating facts as well as putting forward arguments, but in this case I think it might be necessary to have legal assistance, because you may have groups or a specific organisation which would come together in order to have a case put in relation to the provision of a new service, and, naturally enough, they would employ counsel. From what Senator Sweetman told me, his sole object is that he thought there was a power here to prevent that, and he thought that they should not have power to prevent it.
Comment on this
The section is in standard form, and even if it would permit of the committee making regulations preventing people being represented by counsel, I should say that it is extremely improbable that that power would be used in that way. If a county council or borough council were making a case that certain facilities should be provided, it would be more convenient for everybody to have them represented by counsel.
Comment on this
Is not this section precisely similar to sections in all the other Acts of the same kind?
Comment on this
On that section, Sir, I wonder if there is some special reason why the Minister should provide that the secretary of the advisory council should, in fact, be an officer of the Department of Industry and Commerce. I think that that is an unusual stipulation.
Comment on this
Well, it was the practice in relation to the Railway Tribunal. It is not a whole-time job, and I think it is desirable that the person to occupy that position should be an official of the Department. One could not very well envisage its being a whole-time job, but at the same time it is desirable that the person occupying the position should not be in non-State employment. In the case of the 1924 Act, the secretary was an official of the Department of Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
In the case of other bodies of this kind permission is given to the Minister to appoint a secretary without any limitation as to choice and, no doubt, he is going to choose one of his own staff, who will probably be conversant with transport problems. I admit that, but I wondered why it was necessary to insert in the Act itself that the secretary must be an officer of the Department of Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
The only reason is that the committee in this case is part of the administrative machinery of the Department, and I think it is natural, in those circumstances, that the person to be appointed should be an official of the Department.
Comment on this
I should like to know if the Minister intends to reserve power to fix different charges for particular areas? I refer particularly to areas in which the railway service has been discontinued, and where the public have suffered as a result of that discontinuance. I think those are special cases, and that the people ought to get special terms in those areas. I do not want any such provision put into the Bill if the Minister will give me an assurance that he will consider the matter favourably.
Comment on this
The Minister's powers under the Bill are confined to determining maximum charges. It would be open to the company to provide for different charges in different areas, if the circumstances in their opinion justify it, but the Minister would have no power to require them to charge less for the transportation of the same goods over the same distance in one area as compared with another.
Comment on this
No. The schedule of maximum charges would apply to the whole system; it would be a charge for the conveyance of a stated quantity of the specified goods over a mile.
Comment on this
The company could, in fact, charge a special rate in a special area, but they could not be required to do it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 52 standing in the name of Senator Sweetman:—
In sub-section (1) to delete paragraph (c), and to insert therefor the following paragraph:—
(c) the Minister after consideration of the said proposal and of any representations made by interested persons or, in case the said proposal has been referred to the advisory committee, after consideration of their report and advice, shall determine the classification of merchandise applicable to the company for the said purpose.
This amendment appears to be much better drafting and much clearer than paragraph (c) of sub-section (1) in the Bill.
Comment on this
I do not read it that way. As I read it, the purpose of the amendment is to provide that the Minister would consider the representations of interested parties unless he referred the matter to the committee, in which case he would be open to consider only the report of the committee.
Comment on this
I do not think that would be right. I think the Minister would have to consider the report of the committee in relation to the representations which had been made and to the relevant facts, including his own policy in connection with transport generally. I think it would be wrong to say that the Minister could only consider the report of the committee and could not have regard to any other representations that might be made.
Comment on this
That is how I read it. The amendment says: "the Minister after consideration of the said proposal and of any representations made by interested persons or, in case the said proposal has been referred to the advisory committee, after consideration of their report." I must say that I interpret the amendment to mean that the Senator desired to confine the Minister to making his decision upon the report of the committee, if the matter had been referred to the committee, and I would dispute the wisdom of that. I would say that, while the report of the committee would undoubtedly have most influence, the Minister should not be precluded from giving consideration to any other representations that might be made by the parties concerned.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 53:—
In sub-section (1), page 32, line 43, to delete the words "if he thinks fit, may," and substitute the word "shall."
In this case I want to draw attention to what seems to me to be the procedure under Sections 71 and 72. Section 71 confers upon the Minister power to revise the classification of merchandise carried over the railway system. Section 72 confers upon the Minister authority to revise the schedule of maximum charges. He is authorised in both instances to refer the matter to the advisory committee before reaching a decision. I think there is not much case for urging that he should in fact refer the revised classification to the committee. It may be desirable to do so, but I would not say that there should be an obligation on the Minister to do it. But I think when it is a question of revising the schedule of maximum railway charges, there ought to be an understanding that, except in a very minor instance, the matter would in fact be referred to the advisory committee, and that is what I am seeking to do here. If the Minister says that in fact, where there is a substantial modification, reference will be made to the committee, I am satisfied.
Comment on this
That is the intention In the preparation of the general schedule, or any widespread change in the schedule, reference will be made to the committee, and through that reference interested parties will be given an opportunity of making whatever case they wish to have considered. It would be only where comparatively minor charges of a purely formal or unimportant kind were in contemplation that the committee may not be consulted.
Comment on this
In regard to this section, there is one point which I should like to raise. There is a provision in sub-section (3) that "the company shall, if required by any interested person, use all proper endeavours to provide a reasonable system of through bookings with through rates, fares and facilities by all reasonable routes". But in an earlier section it is contemplated that Córas Iompair Éireann may in fact discontinue its associations with the clearing house. I am wondering if it is a settled policy that the company shall not be associated with the railway clearing house, because if that is so, I cannot see any means by which the intention of sub-section (3) can be implemented.
Comment on this
The Senator, I think, is confusing the British Railway Clearing House with the Irish Railway Clearing House. The Great Southern Railways Company is a member of the British Railway Clearing House, but so far as I know all the clearing done in respect of cross-Channel traffic is through the Irish Railway Clearing House. There may be some section of the British line—I think there is portion of the Midland line—which is still cleared through the British Railway Clearing House, but that is an anachronism which I think should be ended. The bulk of the clearing business in respect of cross-Channel traffic is done through the Irish Railway Clearing House. The only effective result of the membership of the Great Southern Railways Company in the British Railway Clearing House is participation in the railway clearance system superannuation fund, and arrangement which I think it is also proper to end.
Comment on this
I merely wished to draw attention to the fact that this sub-section imposes an obligation to endeavour to provide through bookings and through rates.
Comment on this
I may be entirely wrong, but I had an idea that you could not implement this provision except through a clearing house arrangement with Britain.
Comment on this
There is that arrangement. The Irish Railway Clearing House does that, if not for all the traffic, for the great proportion of the traffic. I think there is some part of the British railway system—the London, Midland and Scottish or the Midland Great Western Railway—where the clearing is still done through the British house, but that is an anomaly which should be disposed of, I think, at an early date. In respect of the bulk of the traffic passing between this country and Great Britain the clearing arrangements are effected by the Irish Railway Clearing House.
Comment on this
So that, in fact, if the Great Southern Railways Company today has a through booking to Leeds, the booking would be done through the Irish Clearing House.
Comment on this
There is another point which, I think, is of importance to which I should like to refer on this section. Sub-section (5) deals with disputes which may be determined by the High Court. In most Acts containing similar provisions, provision is made for the making of rules of court to carry over until rules of court are made in the ordinary course. Is that necessary in this case?
Comment on this
I should like to have an assurance from the Minister that there will be no alteration by the new company of the rates for live stock— that they will still be carried at owner's risk, as at present.
Comment on this
I could not say that there will be no alteration. That is one of the matters which could be dealt with by Order under the Bill. The purpose of this section is to provide that, in the case of live stock carried at owner's risk conditions before the established date, the position will be unchanged by the enactment of this measure. It may, of course, be changed by an Order made by the Minister subsequently.
Comment on this
I take it that the Minister has power to vary the determination under sub-section (2).
Comment on this
Sub-section (5) deals with by-laws which are being carried over under the Act of 1924. I take it that there is no need for a provision to enable the company to make by-laws— that they have inherited that power?
Comment on this
They will have that power. We are simply providing that the by-laws of the existing company will continue in force after that company has been dissolved and will be the by-laws of the new company until changed.
Comment on this
Is it contemplated that the proposed charges dealt with here would be referred to the advisory committee?
Comment on this
Not necessarily. The position of those other companies is different from that of this company. They will be operating mainly under existing legislation and they will not have the same rights or obligations as Córas Iompair Eireann. We make provision here for alteration of the maximum charges of railway companies other than this company, but the circumstances, as the Deputy appreciates, are fundamentally different.
Comment on this
In the case of the Great Northern Railway Company, is there any system of publication or reference similar to that in the case of Córas Iompair Eireann?
Comment on this
There is an obligation on the company to maintain, available for inspection, at all their depots the rates of charge in operation and the conditions of carriage. That is their obligation at present, and it remains unchanged.
Comment on this
I am not sure that I did not mislead Senator Duffy just now in regard to alterations of maximum railway charges of companies other than Córas Iompair Éireann. The alteration of the schedule of maximum charges for other railway companies, when application is made, is covered by the Seventh Schedule. There is provision there for the publication by the applicant of the nature of his application. Consideration will be given to it in accordance with the terms of that schedule.
Comment on this
That is the point about which I was anxious—whether the Seventh Schedule covered outside companies.
Comment on this
In sub-section (4) of Section 92, there is a phrase which causes me some trouble. The sub-section states: "Where a schedule of maximum road charges of a statutory carrier is enforced, the charges appearing therein shall, subject to any alterations made under this Chapter, be the maximum charges which that carrier shall be entitled to make..." It seems to me that, if there is a schedule of maximum charges, it will be the schedule settled by the Minister. I cannot see the reason for inserting the words "subject to any alternation made by the Minister", because the alterations will have been made and the schedule published will be that revised by the Minister.
Comment on this
There will be an elaborate schedule of maximum charges relating to various classes of goods. That schedule may be amended in respect of one classification without putting upon the company the obligation to print a new schedule in respect of one alteration. If the schedule is amended in one particular, it is the schedule, as amended, which will be operative.
Comment on this
And any other schedule will be unofficial. If the company keeps exhibited a schedule which has been revised without inserting the revised particulars, it will be an obsolete schedule. It will, in fact, no longer be the schedule. The schedule will be the revised document in which the Minister has made his corrections or substituted one set of figures for another.
Comment on this
There seems to be something peculiar about the drafting.
Comment on this
I want to raise a point on this section. It is an omnibus section which says that all statutory provisions in force immediately before the establishment of the company in respect of the fixing or altering of charges chargeable by canal undertakings shall be repealed. Is there a reason for inserting this section here, as distinct from including it in the Schedule?
Comment on this
There may be. It is necessary to make a clean sweep. No doubt, we could go through all the private Acts and other legislation and provide for the deletion of a particular section or part of a section relating to canal charges but, conceivably, we might miss some provision, and it is desired to make it clear that all previous legislation relating to canal charges, some of which is very archaic, should be repealed and that only this system of maximum charges will operate in future.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 56 standing in the name of Senator Douglas who, unfortunately, cannot be here:-
In sub-section (1), paragraph (a), line 50, page 43, to delete the words "are, in the opinion of the Minister" and substitute the words "have been recommended to the Minister by the Council of the Federation of Irish Manufacturers or the Council of the Associated Chambers of Commerce as persons".
The attitude of the Minister on previous amendments regarding the advisory committee would indicate that he would not accept this amendment, but the circumstances are rather different here. This is a case where he is appointing assessors to the High Court to deal with certain matters and it would appear that he ought to appoint assessors from people nominated to him by the Council of the Federation of Irish Manufacturers or the Council of the Associated Chambers of Commerce. Senator Douglas is interested to see that persons experienced in industrial and commercial affairs should be given an opportunity of presenting their views. That would seem, in its context, to be reasonable, and it is not contrary to the principles stated by the Minister.
Comment on this
It would probably produce indignant protest from Senator Counihan if it were accepted, on the ground that the industrial and commercial people would not cover the agricultural aspects. I think it is extremely probable that all these bodies would be asked to submit names for inclusion on the panel. I doubt if it is wise to confine the Minister to these two particular bodies.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 57:-
In sub-section (1), after the word "aggrieved" in line 20, to insert the following words and brackets: "(but without prejudice to the right of any such person himself to appear as complainant)".
I was not absolutely happy with the provision that the Minister for Agriculture could appear on behalf of another person, lest it would take away from another person the right himself to appear, and I was rather supported in that view by some of my colleagues.
Comment on this
The section merely permits of the appearance of the Minister for Agriculture and it does not take anyone's rights away.
Comment on this
One of the other legal members of the House called my attention to it. He felt there was some doubt and that the matter should be cleared up. If the Minister is satisfied I am satisfied.
Comment on this
The matter was considered, and I was advised that the section in no way affects the right of other persons to appear.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 58:—
In sub-section (8), line 45, to delete the word "may" and substitute therefor the words "shall not except with the consent of the Minister who shall consult the advisory committee before giving his consent."
The object of this amendment is to secure that an abandoned line cannot be sold without the consent of the Minister who, before giving that consent, shall consult the advisory committee. I think that is only common sense. The Minister said in the Dáil that, looking forward, there may be different means of transport in a very short time. In this House he said we are taking too much out of that statement, but I felt that it was only common sense. None of us can visualise what improvements, or what different modes of transport will be developed in ten, or even five years, and, by keeping the abandoned lines intact, they would be available for use as light railways for passenger services. They could ease the burden on the roads between many centres whether the carriages were drawn by motor or electrical power. For instance, between Claremorris and Ballinrobe, and between Galway and Clifden, there are branch lines and these serve centres which are greatly patronised by tourists.
I do not think that the selling value of these branch lines to the railway company would amount to very much, and for agricultural purposes the site of the abandoned track would be practically useless. The upkeep of the bridges would not cost a great deal, and level crossings could be closed at each side. The rent of the lodges on the abandoned lines would make as much as would pay for the upkeep expenditure. I do not think the company would have to pay any rates, because the owners of abandoned houses are not required to pay rates. The amount of money the company would get by selling the sites of these abandoned lines would be very small, and if there is a possibility of a change in the mode of transport in the next five or ten years it would be unwise to dispose of them. I suggest, therefore, the Minister should consult the advisory committee before he would give permission to the management of the company to get rid of these lines in any way.
Comment on this
The order cannot be made by the Minister for the abandonment of a railway line unless he has previously made an order for the closing of the line under the 1933 Act. Under the 1933 Act he cannot make any order for the complete cessation of rail services on the line unless he is satisfied that public transport facilities, constituting an adequate substitute for the abandoned services, will be provided by the company. The position is, therefore, that there must first be an order closing the line. That order has been made in a number of cases, and in each case the local interests concerned were given full opportunity of making their representations in the matter. At some subsequent stage after the services have ceased on the line, but only if there has been the closing order, the Minister can make the abandonment order. The purpose of making the abandonment order is not merely to give to the company certain money which will accrue from the disposal of the company's property, but mainly and primarily to release the company from its liabilities in respect of the line; its liability to maintain bridges, under the road and over the road, provide level crossings and other facilities, and to permit of the transfer to the local authorities of the maintenance of these bridges on terms which are reasonable to both parties, It has also to provide for the removal of bridges over the road, or at least for the removal of the superstructure which is no longer required, and in order to enable the local authority to do that subject to payment by the company, authority is provided in this section.
The advisory committee does not come into this picture at all, because there can be no question of an abandonment order at all until there has been a closing order previously. A closing order is made under the 1933 Act, all the provisions of which must be observed before that order is made. To sum up, the position is that there cannot be an abandonment order until there is a closing order and the 1933 Act provides that there cannot be a closing order until there is an arrangement to provide adequate substitute services for the railway services which have been terminated. The purpose of the abandonment order is to enable the company to relieve itself of the liabilities it previously had in relation to the line.
Some of these branch lines, notably the Clifden line, were closed because they had got into such a state of disrepair. The Clifden line was closed because it was unsafe and could not be made safe without substantial capital expenditure. To put the Clifden line into a position in which it would be safe for traffic would require an expenditure of £800,000. The company could not face that expenditure nor would the revenue it was getting from the line justify that expenditure, but we could not leave the line there until some bridge fell in on a railway engine. The Department of Industry and Commerce has obligations to see that railway lines were not used unless they were safe and it could have required the company to undertake expenditure to make that line safe. As it was quite obvious that the company could not undertake that expenditure the alternative of closing the line and of substituting road services was resorted to.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider the advisability of relieving the company of those liabilities by allowing their lines to remain intact for ten years, say, so that they may see what lines they would require?
Comment on this
The Senator may take it there will be no abandonment Order made in relation to any line unless it is quite clear that it is not likely to be required.
Comment on this
But the Bill is not passed yet. Cannot you put in any alteration you like yet?
Comment on this
The railway company have sold the line and the bridges relating to the Clifden line. There is no line there now.
Comment on this
I think Senator Counihan's trouble is that he thinks a closing Order and an abandonment Order can be made simultaneously.
Comment on this
No, they are not made simultaneously. You have the closing Order first and then the abandonment Order. The abandonment Order enables the company to get rid of a lot of the responsibilities in connection with the lines. It enables it to remove bridges if not required by a local authority and to take other steps necessary to ensure that the company will have no obligations of any kind in relation to the place where the line was before.
Comment on this
On the section, I would like to mention that in the other House the Minister dealt with sub-section (8). I think he introduced it as an amendment himself in the other House. He said there that the amendment proposed that the land would be offered in the first instance to adjoining landowners, and only if they declined to buy it will it be sold by public auction. The section, however, does not say that. It says that the land may be sold either by private treaty to the owners of land on both sides, or by public auction. It does not say that the people on either side will get first option for the buying of the land by private treaty.
Comment on this
The intention is that the company will sell to the owners adjacent to the line. I think the obligation imposed on them in this section requires them to negotiate by private treaty for sale to these owners before the public auction. I think the private treaty must come first.
Comment on this
It says "either or". It is, of course, a very small point, but let us be clear on it. The company could say that they preferred to sell by public auction.
Comment on this
What we set out to do is to empower the company to sell by private treaty instead of selling by public auction. Originally, the provision was to enable them to sell by public auction, but it was realised that if that was provided, and if people were to come in and buy the land which is beside the local landowners, that we would be starting a few local land wars. All we can provide is for the local people to buy it first if they want to.
Comment on this
Surely it is only common sense to allow the local owners to buy the portion of the line running through their land?
Comment on this
We are empowering the railway company to offer it to them before having the public auction—to offer it to them if they want it, and if not, to have the auction.
Comment on this
The suggestion is that there will be a mandatory condition on the company to have the land offered by private treaty, but the time would come when the Minister is no longer Minister for Industry and Commerce, when his directions would no longer be operative, and when there might be a different chairman.
Comment on this
I think you cannot have it more definitely than it is there You cannot, I think, by amendment make it more clear.
Comment on this
I would suggest that this land should be sold to the Land Commission and that they would be the proper people to divide it. There would then be no rows about people coming in and buying the land beside the local owners because the Land Commission would know who are the suitable people for the land. The land could be acquired by compulsion from the railway company and let the Land Commission divide it.
Comment on this
Supposing for a moment that the Senator had a railway line running through his farm in Ballyboughal. Would it not be common sense that he should have the first right to purchase it by agreement? Would it not be quite reasonable that if that were the case, he should have the right to purchase the land?
Comment on this
What we are really setting out to provide is this: that only the adjoining landowner would have the right to buy by private treaty.
Comment on this
I think it should be given to the Land Commission.
Comment on this
Does the sub-section also mean that where there is an auction it must be sold to the adjoining owner?
Comment on this
Are not the words "by public auction" governed by the words "to the owner of the land on both sides of such line".
Comment on this
Would it not be necessary to say "the owners of the land on both sides"? There might be two owners.
Comment on this
On this part of the Bill I want to ask the Minister what the policy of the Government is with reference to the issue of new road transport licences. Obviously one of the difficulties of our transport situation is the fact that we have more transport facilities than we have goods to transport, and one of the conditions of the success of the new company will be if it is able to absorb to itself a lot of the existing road haulier transport concerns. The more of these there are in existence, the greater will be the commitment by way of compensation that must be made by the new company in taking them over. I think the Minister, therefore, should be very chary of adding to the number of road transport haulier's licences throughout the country.
Comment on this
This section has the effect of bringing the Road Transport Act of 1933 within the ambit of the Bill. I should like to put a few points to the Minister on the administration of this Act, particularly Sections 54 and 55, which deal with the measure of compensation to be paid to hauliers whose business is taken over. It has been suggested in the past that when road transport businesses were being acquired by the Great Southern Railways Company, very often prices were offered by the railway company to these hauliers that were very much too low. I might put it this way, that advantage was taken in the past of the fact that certain hauliers were not too well up in what they were entitled to get and, in consequence, they were made to accept sums much smaller than would have been considered reasonable. The suggestion was put to me that there should be some statutory provision that the terms upon which a haulier's business would be taken over should be based upon a minimum number of years of purchase of the profits that the business had been making for a number of years. I can quite appreciate the Minister's point of view that that might not always work out satisfactorily because even on the profits basis, a business would vary, but I think it would make for easier working of the Act and would preclude any possibility of people suggesting that the large concern was taking an unfair advantage of the small owner. This matter was referred to in the report of the Transport Tribunal and, with all respect, as the Minister has differed from that report on many other occasions during the last few days, I am going to take the liberty of differing with the report in so far as it affects the fixing of compensation at four years' purchase. It does seem to me that if a man has built up a business over a period of years and that a concern established by the State is going to take that from him as a monopoly, one should not be small in the ideas one has about the compensation to be paid. It means that a man has to go out of the way of living to which he has been accustomed for many years and start in a new occupation. It is not always easy to make such a start. For that reason I would urge the Minister to consider the matter in the light of my suggestion.
I make another suggestion, that though the effect of the Report of the Transport Tribunal is not statutory, it must nevertheless to some degree work on the mind of the arbitrator, and I suggest that, in dealing with that, the Department would see that it is borne in mind that to take anybody's figures of the profits over emergency years as compared with pre-war years might mean a very unfair discrimination. It might mean that in certain cases that a man would have higher profits during the emergency years because there was less transport in his area, but it might also mean that he would have smaller profits because of the curtailment in supplies of petrol. I am told —the Minister can tell me if I am correct—that there was one case where the railway company offered a man £250 and in which the arbitrator subsequently fixed the compensation at £1,400. If the railway company were in the habit of making offers like that, it would seem that there is a very strong case for some statutory minimum so as to ensure that the small man would know exactly where he stood and would not have continually to fight his case through arbitration.
Comment on this
With regard to the issue of new licences it will, of course, be necessary under the provisions of the Bill to grant such licences to persons who have been carrying on a haulage business in the exempted areas abolished under the Bill. Apart from that, it is extremely unlikely that any new licences will be issued. In fact, new licences cannot be issued unless the Minister is satisfied that the statutory transport undertakers have failed to supply, or refuse to supply, transport facilities which are reasonably required in any locality. It is only in very exceptional cases that such circumstances will arise involving the issue of new licences. I agree fully that it is undesirable that we should increase the number of licences except in agreement with the company and except where the licenses is to be confined to conducting the type of business in which the statutory company is not interested.
With regard to the price paid for acquired businesses I think the position has been that the company has had to pay far too much and not far too little. In fact the policy of the 1933 Act very largely broke down because of the fact that the cost of acquiring these licences proved so much greater than we had anticipated by reason of the awards of the arbitrator, and that the company was not able to complete the process without greatly depleting its resources. Under the 1933 Act compensation was determined not on the basis of past profits but on the basis of future losses which the licensee might suffer by reason of the transfer licence.
I think that was a more equitable basis than to attempt to assess compensation upon the basis of past profits particularly in regard to licences that may in future be acquired when one has to have regard to the abnormal experience of the emergency period. It will be appreciated that in most of these cases the company got very little value for its expenditure. It simply got the transfer of some ramshackle vehicles. Apart from property which is of little use, it succeeded in getting little more than the extinction of the licences; it did not even get the trade which the licensees had previously conducted, because when a licence was extinguished the individual concerned used the compensation money to buy himself a new lorry and set up as a wholesaler or in some other capacity and continued in the business that he had previously.
Comment on this
Well, that is, in fact, what happened. The Transport Tribunal was concerned with the fact that the company actually had to pay too much in connection with the transferred licences instead of too little, and suggested that the compensation to be paid should be based on the, aggregate profits of the previous four years, but while that suggestion might have been considered a good suggestion in 1939, I doubt if it could now be considered to be a good suggestion in view of our war-time experience, and I still consider that the basis of the 1933 Act, which had to do with the future losses or expenses which the licensee might suffer, is still the best basis on which to go. It may be that, in the future, the company may have to pay more, as I already explained, but the position is that it is the large-scale operators on the road who are affected by this, and in the case of the comparatively small number of small operators, it may be that the company will decide not to interfere any further.
Comment on this
Will the Minister explain to the House exactly why these two differential dates are taken in, in the first sub-paragraph of sub-section (2). I could not quite understand why there is a dividing period like this. First of all, you take a period referring to any merchandise road transport business which was commenced after the 1st day of June, 1939, and before the 31st day of May, 1940, and then in the next sub-clause you come on to the whole period beginning on the 1st day of June, 1939, and ending on the date of the passing of the Act. I am referring to Section 114, sub-section (2), paragraph (a), clauses (i) and (ii).
Comment on this
In order to get a fair list of the people who would be entitled to an existing merchandise licence under the provisions of the Bill we had to go back to the period beginning with the commencement of the war, and that is what is provided for here; to see that each of the following shall be an existing merchandise road transport business: any merchandise road transport business which was commenced after 1st June, 1939, and before 31st May, 1940, and which was carried on in the manner required by the sub-section during the whole of the period beginning on the date of the commencement of the business and ending on the date of the passing of the Act; and, secondly, any merchandise road transport business which was carried on in the manner required during the whole of the period beginning on 1st June, 1939, and ending on the date of the passing of the Act. We give the licence to the existing carrier as well as to those who were in the business at the commencement of the war, but who, for reasons associated with the war, may have ceased to be in the business.
Comment on this
But it says, in the first clause: "any merchandise road transport business which was commenced after 1st June, 1939, and before 31st May, 1940, and ending on the date of the passing of this Act," and then, in the second clause it says: "during the whole period beginning on 1st June, 1939, and ending on the date of the passing of this Act." What additional case does this second clause give that is not covered by the first? It is only a matter of construction, I admit, but I am afraid that I cannot follow it, and there must be some reason for it.
Comment on this
I take the meaning to be that, first of all, the licence was applied for before the 1st June, 1939, and that after the 1st June, 1939, and before 31st May, 1940, the person concerned is entitled to a licence, if the business was carried on in the manner required during the period between the commencement of the business and the passing of the Act. Then, the second clause refers to any merchandise road transport business which was carried on in the manner required by the sub-section during the whole of the period. In other words, in order to carry on before the period, if a man had a licence before that date, that would be sufficient. I think that would explain it.
Comment on this
No, I do not think so, because in the case of the first clause he applied for the licence after 1st June, 1939, whereas in the other case he carried on the business during the whole of the period beginning then, and therefore he must have had a licence before that date.
Comment on this
It would be easier if the Minister would consider the point between this and the Report Stage. There must be some reason for this.
Comment on this
I am afraid I cannot put my finger on the exact point at the moment, but the intention is that people who were engaged in this business before the war, and who had to cease because of war conditions, will not be deprived of a licence. It also affects other people, such as those who, as a result of war conditions, had to cease their ordinary activities, but who, in the meantime, may have become turf carriers, and so on, and who will not, on that account, become entitled to a licence.
Comment on this
If he had been in the business before, and if it can be shown that he was in it, even though it was interrupted as a result of the war, he is still entitled to a licence.
Comment on this
You limit the date for making the application to the first day of April, 1945, assuming that the Act, comes into operation on 1st January, 1945. Supposing that a man wants to make an application, I do not think there is any provision here for giving notice or making it known to the people concerned, by publication in the newspapers or otherwise, that they have this right of application.
Comment on this
I think I can assure the Senator that all necessary steps will be taken to give the requisite notification to the parties concerned. As a matter of fact, it will not be so difficult now as it was formerly, because we now have a list of these people. When starting off, in 1933, we did not know how many of these people there were, but now we have a list of them, and there should be no difficulty in sending notification to them.
Comment on this
In the case of an exempted area, where the owner of a licence dies or is unable to carry on the business any longer, would the Minister give the licence to a fresh applicant?
Comment on this
In certain circumstances the licence may be transferred to the person who succeeds to the business.
Comment on this
But take the case of the owner of a licence who is not carrying on the business satisfactorily?
Comment on this
Would the Minister give a new licence in that case?
Comment on this
Well, my point is that it would be a great hardship on many farmers. Let me give a case, which is quite common. Suppose that somebody, living within 12 or 14 miles of Dublin, wanted to bring a lorry-load of cattle, sheep or pigs into Dublin on the Monday morning previous to this date in 1939. We used to be able to get them in on a lorry for 12/6 a load, but if we have to go to the railway company, and if they have to send out two men—or even three men, as might be required by a regulation of the transport union—it would not pay half the wages of the men, not to mind paying for the lorry, in order to make any profit.
Anybody living within 12 or 14 miles of Dublin may get it into their heads to send a load of sheep or pigs to Dublin—it is not usual to send cattle in that way—and they would go to their nearest carrier and say: "We want you in the morning to bring a load into Dublin." That man would come at four o'clock in the morning and run three or four trips to Dublin and back between that and 12 o'clock. He works hard, but he is getting a fair living out of it. It would be a great imposition on the farmers within a 12 or 15 miles radius of one of the big centres if they had to apply to the railway company for such transport as that.
Comment on this
And so far as a former exempted area is concerned, the Minister must give a licence to a person who carries on business there or whose predecessor in title carried it on.
Comment on this
But if such a person dies or has not been carrying on the business satisfactorily?
Comment on this
If this company cannot provide a better service than an independent operator provided in the past, then it will, in my opinion, have failed in the responsibility placed upon it. I do not say it will provide as cheap a service, because, of course, at one period transport facilities of that kind were sold at an entirely uneconomic cost, a cost which I am sure did not cover the actual expenses involved to the owner of the lorry, or provide anything like a reasonable wage to the operator of the lorry. But in so far as an independent operator was able to give an intimate, personal service, meeting the actual requirements of each individual customer, it should be possible for a public company such as this to give the same service if it has the right kind of organisation. It is not doing so at present, I agree, but the present service is restricted by lack of equipment and so on.
Comment on this
You would have to go in to the railway company and notify them before five or six o'clock in the evening, giving perhaps a couple of days' notice; whereas, in the other case, you could give notification at 10 o'clock at night in regard to the following morning.
Comment on this
Of course, the present service is restricted by abnormal conditions, and I think most of the persons concerned have realised that the private haulier was not carrying at a lower rate in the past out of love for the farmers. He is not charging a lower rate now; in fact, public transport is much cheaper.
Comment on this
I am afraid the only alternative will be for every farmer to get a lorry of his own.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that the area to which the Senator is referring is not affected by the section at all? Dublin is an exempted area.
Comment on this
I should like to say in this connection that many people who engage in farming production have found the private service very much more flexible than the services supplied in the past by the railway company. The private lorry went into the farmyard for the wheat and beet, whereas the railway company required it put out on the roadside. On the return journey they stipulated that they will pick up the pulp on the roadside. I submit that pulp is a perishable article, and that that arrangement is hardly in keeping with what is right and proper in connection with a perishable article.
Comment on this
One of the difficulties, of course, in the whole Bill is the monopoly service. It is perfectly obvious to everybody that a small, private man who has got to produce a really good service—and when I say "service" I am not considering any question of charges—or go out of business altogether is going to have more personal concern in meeting the requirements of the people of his area than any large company can ever have. It is for that reason that I am very keen on trying to see, so far as we can, that at least the existing hauliers are retained in the areas where their business is largely one arising from personal contact with their customers.
Comment on this
Before we pass from Section 114, I want to refer to the fact that in sub-section (5) there is a definition of an exempted area. I do not see Galway mentioned in that sub-section. It was named as an exempted area in former Acts.
Comment on this
The Minister has power under the previous section to extend the operation of any merchandise licence or grant a merchandise licence to any person if he thinks it advisable in the public interest to do so. That power appears to be taken from him in sub-section (2) of this section. If I am right in that contention—
Comment on this
No. The intention is to grant certain easements to enable the Minister to extend the classes of goods or the areas in which the licence may operate where it is desirable to do so for the removal of hardship, but he cannot do that in relation to a person who has a licence to carry one commodity only. In that case he can still carry one commodity only. But there were a number of cases where persons engaged in a general carrying business omitted to state some obvious class of goods that they previously carried, or made some error in prescribing the area in which they were going to operate. It is to give the Minister power to deal with cases of hardship of this kind that this provision is inserted. It is not intended to enable a person who has merely a licence to engage in the transportation of one kind of goods to go into the general carrying business.
Comment on this
What would happen in the case of a man who has a lorry operating between an auxiliary creamery and a general creamery?
Comment on this
It seems to be a pity that a lorry like that could not, for instance, carry lime to that locality to fertilise the land and enable it to grow wheat. If it is done, of course, it will be done in an illegal way. I am afraid it will be done in an illegal way.
Comment on this
Of course, we are making it more difficult under this Act. The principle of the 1933 Act is being retained, except that we now know of cases where applicants made mistakes and suffered for those mistakes. I can remember a case of an applicant living on the borders of Roscommon and Galway who, through a misunderstanding, applied only for a licence to carry for hire in County Galway, whereas in fact half his business was in County Roscommon. This section enables the Minister to relieve him of the hardship caused through that misunderstanding. Other people who had carried bag-stuffs or commodities of that kind gave an inadequate description of the classes of goods concerned, and were precluded from carrying those they did not specify. We can modify a hardship of that kind. Apart from getting rid of anomalies, difficulties and hardships, we are not departing from the policy of the 1933 Act, and it would be a complete departure from the policy of that Act to allow a person who was engaged in a very limited business to extend the type of business in which he was engaged.
Comment on this
I should like to point out that transport in this country is of a seasonal type. There is a great deal of road transport required during the harvest period, and during the beet growing period for delivering beet to the factories, and I do not know whether or not the Minister would be agreeable to make the harvest period and the beet growing period what might be called an open period, without any restrictions whatever on any transport in any locality. It is very important to save the harvest, and consequently it is important to put all the road transport available into the saving of the harvest. The same applies to beet.
Comment on this
Certain easements have been given because of the emergency, but that would not be the policy in normal times.
Comment on this
I think it would be as well if the Minister would restate what he might do in any case where it is shown that the Transport Act does not provide adequate facilities. Where the Transport Act does not provide adequate facilities, has the Minister power to authorise other carriers to operate?
Comment on this
We can require the transport company to provide facilities and that would be the course normally adopted if the facilities required were of the type the transport company could provide. If the services needed were of a very special type in which a general transport organisation would not be interested—if they were of a purely local kind—and if the company, having been informed, intimated that they were not interested in providing the facilities, then an additional licence could be, and would be, given.
Comment on this
I think that that should meet Senator O'Callaghan's point.
Comment on this
It might happen that, during that season, the transport company would not be willing to provide a service.
Comment on this
In normal times, I do not think that that is likely. At present, they might have a physical difficulty in doing so and that is why we released turf and, in certain respects, grain, from the restrictions of the 1933 Act. In normal times, that business would be catered for by the transport organisation or the merchants engaged in the business, who would be entitled to operate their own lorries for their own business. Ordinarily, we should contemplate that the traffic which would arise then and which would require to be carried on public services would be carried by this company. After all, it is the company's harvest as well as the farmer's harvest.
Comment on this
I want the Minister to confirm my belief as to what will be done under this section. Discretion is left with the Minister—quite properly. Would the Minister say that it is his intention, where classes of merchandise were wrongly described or where a wrong description was given of the areas, to amend the licence?
Comment on this
That would be the intention where they are wrongly described to the extent of producing hardship. If somebody with a lorry had it licensed for Galway, Mayo and Roscommon and sought to extend the licence to the whole of Ireland, we might say that he had not suffered any hardship and refuse his request.
Comment on this
Does the Minister hope to deal with the case of the carrier whose vehicle was acquired by the company in the past, who ceased to be a carrier and who has since acquired a new fleet of lorries?
Comment on this
We have a number of provisions in this Bill by which we hope to deal with cases of that kind. These provisions represent the experience both of the Department of Industry and Commerce and the Gárda Síochána in trying to enforce the 1933 Act.
Comment on this
Suppose an area had been a barley-growing area and that very little wheat was grown in it. If the position is now changed and wheat is grown, would the Minister extend the licence to cover wheat?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 59:—
In Part VII, immediately after Section 124 to insert the following new section:-
125.—Sub-section (2) of Section 25 of the Road Transport Act, 1933, is hereby amended by the insertion after sub-paragraph (i) of paragraph (a) and before sub-paragraph (ii) of the said paragraph of the following new sub-paragraph:—
(ii) in case such person has become entitled to such business by purchase and the Minister is satisfied that such person is a suitable person to carry on such business and that when so carried on by such person at least as satisfactory a service as is then in operation in such area will be operated, the Minister shall on the application of such person, transfer such licence to such person.
The purpose of this amendment is to deal with the provisions of Section 25 of the Road Transport Act, 1933. Under that Act, the Minister has a certain discretionary power to grant a transfer of a licence. More than inserting a mandatory section in the Bill, I should like to ascertain from the Minister the terms on which he is prepared to use that discretion. I want to make perfectly clear that I am entirely with the Minister if he uses his discretion in such a way as to prevent a man who has sold his business to the dissolved company or to Córas Iompair Eireann coming in and trying to get the benefit of the traffic as if he had never sold it. But supposing a man ran a business between Limerick and Cork and sold that business to Córas Iompair or the dissolved company. He might still have a liking for the road transport business and he might find a man whose business ran from Dundalk to Cavan. His purchase of that business could not possibly affect the good-will already sold to the company. Yet, I understand that, in such circumstances, the Minister is not prepared to grant a transfer. I suggest that it is better for him, as, of course, to grant a transfer where there is a sale of a road transport business—provided the statutory company does not want it—to a person already experienced in the business. That would mean a more efficient service. The users would get better service than they would get from a complete stranger to the business—always provided that the transferor, having sold his good-will, was not trying to cadge the good-will back.
Comment on this
The objection I have to that is: when looking for compensation one of the points raised is whether a man is put completely out of business and cannot engage in that business again. I raised that point once and the compensation was increased by the arbitrator substantially.
Comment on this
Under the 1933 Act, the Minister is required to transfer a licence, on application, to a relative the statutory company or a beneficiary under a will. In all other cases, he has complete discretion. In fact, that discretion has rarely been exercised. I think that it would be wrong to require the Minister automatically to transfer the licence to a purchaser. It might mean considerable inflation of the value of the business.
We can imagine a small, unimportant business, operated with very limited or defective equipment in some town, being purchased by the largest trader in the town and built up into a highly remunerative concern, attracting a great deal of traffic and necessitating compulsory acquisition by the railway company at a considerably inflated cost. This matter was raised by the Licensed Haulage Contractors' Association, and I intimated to them that I should be prepared to consider favourably applications for transfers of licences, on acquisition of businesses, if the railway company concerned was not prepared to acquire the licence, if the licensee had no relative able and willing to accept the transfer, and subject to the production of satisfactory evidence that the proposed transferee was a suitable person to operate the service and was not himself already the holder of a merchandise transport licence. The latter provision is necessary to ensure that no person can proceed, by the process of buying up licences, to establish a multiple road transport business in substitution for a number of individual businesses carried on with single lorries.
I subsequently pointed out to the Licensed Haulage Contractors' Association that these considerations which I laid down, did not preclude the exercise of discretion in cases where the facts were such as to justify the use of that discretion to permit of the transfer of a licence. The principle is, therefore, that a licence must be transferred to a relative, to a beneficiary under a will, or, of course, to a railway company acquiring the licence. It may be transferred to another person who has bought the business if there is no relative, if the railway company are not willing to acquire the licence, and if the proposed transferee is in every respect suitable to hold a licence and is not already the holder of a licence.
Over and above all that, there is a discretion which has been exercised only in two or three cases, cases of particular hardship, where it was obviously in the interest of justice that the licensee should be allowed to sell his licence. Apart from these considerations, the policy will be the same as that in the 1933 Act—that the licence will not be transferred on purchase except in very limited circumstances.
Comment on this
That is my point. I do not see why a licence should not be transferred on purchase, always subject to the provision, like that in the Intoxicating Liquor Acts, that the man taking over the licence is suitable and is going to carry it on in a proper manner. The whole purpose of the 1933 Act is the same as the Intoxicating Liquor Act of 1902—that there were enough licences and no room for any more. That was the whole purpose of the 1902 Act, and I am entirely in agreement with the Minister that we should not have circumstances arising by which the values of licences could be inflated. But, it does seem to me the matter should be dealt with a little more flexibly. The Minister has the discretion but he is not going to use it. I submit that the matter should be dealt with on the same lines as the Intoxicating Liquor Act, that if a man is suitable and is going to carry on a good business for the users he should be allowed to acquire the licence. I am not going to say, automatically, but I submit that the Minister in exercise of his powers should assure the country that where a man is suitable to take over a licence, he would be granted the transfer.
Comment on this
The Senator will see that that would be unfair to the company. One can imagine the conditions in a provincial town where there are two transport licences, one held by an energetic hard-working individual who has built up a profitable connection, and the other held by a thriftless individual working with decrepit equipment, the value of whose business in relation to earning capacity would be very low. If the company buy out the energetic individual who has got the bulk of the business in any event, it can contemplate acquiring the remaining business at a lower value, but if the first licensee whose business has been acquired by the company can purchase the second licence and resume his business, the purpose of the Act is defeated.
Comment on this
I quite see the Minister's point that the second licensee would be trying to take back the goodwill which he had sold to the company. In acquiring the second licence he would obviously be trying to pull back some of the business he had lost. I am with the Minister in that.
Comment on this
Of course there is also the consideration of the individual who has bought a number of businesses and established himself in a substantial way, but to make a comparison with the Intoxicating Liquor Acts is wrong. The State is concerned to limit the number of licences, but it is also concerned with the maintenance of the number. It does not want to see businesses disappearing, because there are other considerations of public policy involved. In the case of transport these considerations do not arise.
Comment on this
The policy of acquiring road transport licences has not been fully implemented mainly because of the abnormal cost which the company had to bear in carrying out its policy, and also because in a number of places the nature of the business was such that the company was not interested, but if anybody else acquired a licence, and developed the business, then the company might be forced to acquire the licence even at a substantial price. That is why we have confined the transfer of the licence to beneficiaries under a will or to a relative, or in the very limited number of cases where the Minister, in the exercise of his discretion, felt it was the fairest course to adopt.
Comment on this
This is really tied up with compensation for acquisition, and what I would like to suggest to the Minister is that, where he was satisfied that there was a genuine offer made for a business, Córas Iompair Eireann must give the amount of the genuine offer, but it would be a practical impossibility to work that out in practice, because it would be quite impossible ever to satisfy anybody beyond yea or nay that a certain offer was genuine. You would get fake offers put in for the purpose of inflating the price.
Comment on this
I was thinking that the arbitrator must give the price offered by the genuine bidder.
Comment on this
The position, as I have explained, is that the licence may be transferred to the company if there is no relative, or if there is no hardship of the kind I have already mentioned.
Comment on this
I thought that this would ensure that in genuine cases he will get fair compensation and in fake cases he would get cut out.
Comment on this
On the First Schedule, has the Minister ascertained how the seal of Córas Iompair Eireann is going to be affixed? It might necessitate the repeal of some section of the 1845 Act.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 60:—
In Part I, page 60, to delete in the fourth column, opposite Reference No. 1 the figure 100, and substitute therefor the figure 75; opposite Reference No. 2 the figure 50, and substitute therefor the figure 25.
I have put down two other amendments, Nos. 61 and 62:-
In Part I, page 61, to delete the figure 100 now appearing in the fourth column opposite Reference Nos. 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 and substitute therefor the figure 75.
In Part II of the Third Schedule, page 61, opposite Reference No. 1, to delete the figure 145 in the fourth column and substitute therefor the figure 113; and opposite Reference No. 2, to delete the figure 145 in the fourth column and substitute therefor the figure 100.
I take it that the three amendments may be discussed together. What is aimed at here is to curcail the compensation provided for the holders of stock surrendered to the new company and substituted by the stock of that company. Actually, what is proposed is that the compensation by way of substitute stock will be reduced by 25 per cent. The matter of the value of the property that is being transferred has been considered during the last two or three days in this debate. I think the Minister himself recognises that it is difficult to say whether some of the property has much value for the purpose of a new concern.
The committee which was appointed by the Labour Party and the Trade Union Congress last year made a very close examination of the stock exchange quotations for the Great Southern Railways stocks and the Dublin Transport stocks during the period that elapsed from the time the Act of 1933 came into force until the end of last year. They found that in that period of ten years the ordinary stock of the Dublin United Transport Company was at one period quoted at 7/6 and the ordinary stock of the Great Southern Railways was quoted as low as £3 10s. The price to-day of the ordinary stock is 27/6 in the case of the Dublin United Transport Company and the price of the ordinary stock of the Great Southern Railway is around £60.
The effect of the proposals contained in the three amendments now before the House would be to reduce the obligations transferred to the new company from £13,500,000 to £8,250,000 representing a saving of £75,000 a year in dividends and interest. At this stage of the proceedings I imagine it is futile to spend much time in elaborating the different proposals. The Minister and the Government are committed to certain arrangements proposed to the directors of both companies and I imagine that they will regard these arrangements as an essential part of this measure. If that is so, I do not imagine we can secure the Minister's acquiescence for the proposals made here, but I think the proposal to pay £13,500,000 to the debenture shareholders of these two concerns is entirely extravagant in the circumstances.
Comment on this
I do not see why the Senator who has just spoken should not suggest that the shareholders' interest should be wiped out altogether. If you confiscate £20,000,000 worth of shareholding interest in a company there is no objection to confiscating the other £10,000,000. I would like to remind the House that some 22 years ago there was a railway inquiry which submitted a report to the Government, a report which was signed by a distinguished Labour leader who was a colleague of our friend on the right. That report recommended that the State should nationalise the Irish railway system and that the shareholders and stockholders should receive compensation in the form of Government stock on the basis of the then stock exchange value of railway stocks and shares which was said to be £25,000,000 to £30,000,000. I think the Labour Senator and his colleague should congratulate themselves that that particular Labour policy of acquiring the railways for £25,000,000 or £30,000,000 of Government stock 22 years ago was not carried out. They should be extremely thankful that they are getting the railways now in the form of a virtually nationalised company for a mere fraction of the sum which would have had to be paid then by the taxpayer.
Comment on this
I would like to point out that the Senator has omitted one important consideration in telling us what was done in 1922. In 1922 the commission to which he referred was dealing with a concern having valuable assets. That concern is now 22 years older, and its assets have very largely been dissipated. The Minister told us a while ago that the Department was obliged to close down a railway line between Galway and Clifden because it was too dangerous to run railway engines on it. That is the kind of concern that is being handed over now for £13,500,000. It is conceivable that the concern which was under review in 1922 was worth the money; in other words, you were getting valuable assets. The whole history of transport has changed apart from the deterioration of the assets. It is questionable whether much of the assets there are of much use. If, for instance, Córas Iompair Eireann were to decide that it is unwise to continue the use of the railway between Dublin and Bray or Dublin and Dun Laoghaire, then that system would be abandoned even if it was first-class stock. Even if the engines and rolling stock were first class, which of course, they are not, they would still be scrapped.
One of the things that most people who come to this country have to say is that the poorest type of railway equipment awaits the boats at Dun Laoghaire. There you find old carriages in bad condition, never cleaned, so far as one can judge. That is the kind of equipment used on that section of the railway between Westland Row and Dun Laoghaire. I think Senator Johnston should have taken into account the important change that has come about in the history of the transport system during the past 22 years. The question of writing down stock or of confiscating shareholders' property is not new, and it is not entirely a prerogative of Government. I remember the rumpus that was caused in this country some years ago when the directors of Dunlop's wrote away 13/4 out of every pound of stock. Two-thirds of the shareholders' property was written away at the time, and a number of important people in Dublin formed a shareholders' protection association to protect themselves against the ruthless confiscation practised against them by the directors of the company. There is a case where £13,500,000 of the shareholders' property was written off by the shareholders' directors, so we see it is not merely a prerogative of Government to write down stock or to confiscate it if the Senator prefers that phrase.
Comment on this
The Labour Party had at least some responsibility for the dissipation of the assets of the Great Southern Railways though I am not pretending that they were the only confiscators of the stock. There were other interests which battened on the vitals of the old railway company. Surely the Senator is not trying to make a case that because Labour policy and other factors as well have succeeded in making the railway company a poor concern that, therefore, they should give it poor compensation, having, themselves, been the principal cause of its impoverishment.
Comment on this
The real moral of Senator Johnston's observations is that in 1922 neither the railway company, the stockholders nor the Labour Party fully appreciated that the railways were not worth what the stocks were quoted on the market. None of them was able to see the writing on the wall. Whether we had an amalgamated concern or a number of separate and individual concerns, the history of transport in this country, in the ensuing years, would not be much different. A great part of the capital invested in the railways has been lost. The property of the stockholders was lost, railway lines closed down and assets which had been previously earning revenue proved to be a liability. The change that took place in the capital construction of the company is merely an illustration of the changes which took place throughout these years. It would be an impossible burden to put on the company to ask them to earn out of the remaining assets sufficient to make provision for the capital that has been lost. If we determine that these assets are to be valued upon the basis of the revenue they can earn, I do not think so. If we determine the value of what it would cost to replace them, those that one would replace, I do not think so. If you can determine them on another basis you might possibly say that we are overvaluing them, but I do not think that is important.
It is important that the proposals for the substitution of stock contained in this Bill have been agreed to by the shareholders. I think it was desirable to get the agreement of the shareholders. There are a variety of reasons for that, not merely the co-operation which was subsequently forthcoming in the preparation of the Bill and the putting of the Bill into operation, but also the general effect upon the credit of the country. I think it would be wrong now for the Legislature to alter the terms which were agreed upon. I do not think these terms unduly generous. The shareholders, it is true, are possibly getting somewhat better terms than an arbitrator would have given them. We gave somewhat better terms in order to get their agreement and I think the getting of that agreement was worth the better terms. Senator Duffy, I think, is wrong in assuming that the inflation in the stock market quotations for Great Southern Railways shares which took place this year as compared with last year was due entirely to the provisions of this Bill.
I think it would be wrong to leave out of account the satisfactory financial results of last year's working. I think, even if this Bill had never been produced, the improvement in the revenue position shown as a result of last year's working, the payment for the first time over a long number of years of a dividend on the ordinary shares and the wiping out of arrears of dividends on the guaranteed shares, would have undoubtedly resulted in substantial improvements in the price of these shares on the stock market. Therefore the determination of the amount of substituted debenture stock to be given in exchange for the cancelled stock of the amalgamated companies upon the basis of last year as compared with this year would, I think, be unfair.
I could imagine a shareholder of the Great Southern Railways Company contending that the affairs of that company were in bad shape because of the deficiencies of its management and urging that the company were entitled to the opportunity of themselves repairing the management and getting the benefits of improved management without the Government intervening in the manner which is proposed in this Bill. One could argue, on the other hand, that the country had waited long enough for that shareholder to exert himself to effect the improved management he talked about, but it could be argued by the shareholder that the knowledge of the condition of the company would have produced sufficient stimulus in these shareholders themselves to put the affairs of the company in order just as the shareholders of the Dublin United Transport Company had done previously.
Comment on this
Would the shares have appreciated if the company had not been given this monopoly?
Comment on this
Of course, we are not giving the company any greater monopoly than it had already. The decision to establish public transport on a monopoly basis was taken 11 years ago. This company will have no greater monopoly in the area in which it will operate than it had before this Bill was introduced nor will the Dublin United Transport Company.
Comment on this
But you tie up the alleged wholesaler who utilised the compensation to support rival companies.
Comment on this
In that respect we are merely doing what we intended to do in 1933. People found ways to evade the 1933 Act, and we would have been obliged to produce proposals for amended legislation even if we had not decided upon a plan of general reorganisation of transport. However, I think that has been sufficiently discussed in the past few months to enable most Senators to make up their minds without listening to further argument. We propose these terms for the substitution of stock. We proposed them to the shareholders of each company, and notwithstanding some opposition we got a substantial majority to agree to them. On the basis of that agreement, we are putting them into this Bill, and we could not depart from them now without dropping the measure as a whole.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 63:—
In paragraph (c), page 64, line 23, after the word "suspended" to insert the words and brackets "or (being a person in the service of the company on the critical date) was dismissed".
This is a paragraph which I think gave a good deal of concern to the Minister and to others in the Dáil. It deals with the period which has to be reckoned in certain cases as pensionable service. Paragraph (c) of the Schedule says: "If that person was suspended from the service of a former transport undertaker on or after the 1st day of April, 1916, and before the 6th day of December, 1921, and the Minister certifies that his suspension was due to his national sympathies, the period of suspension shall be included in the period of his pensionable service." It was pointed out to the Minister in the Dáil that these men were, in fact, dismissed. I have been making inquiries and I am informed that the men who are likely to be affected by the provision were, in fact, not suspended, but dismissed. The Minister agreed with that view and, said that if a form of words could be found which was not too difficult and did not require too much elaboration, he was willing to make provision for the inclusion of that period in the calculation of pensionable service. I do not know whether I have succeeded in getting the form of words for which the Minister expressed a desire in the Dáil. I am trying to make it clear that the person concerned must have been reinstated in his position, and that he was actually in the service of the dissolved companies on the critical date, which in this case is the 1st July, 1944, and I am proposing to insert the words "suspended or dismissed." I do not think the Minister will have much difficulty in accepting the amendment.
Comment on this
There are difficulties. I tried to get over these difficulties in a simple way, namely, by giving the Dáil the assurance that in any case that arose where a person had been dismissed and reinstated, where he was dismissed by reason of his national sympathies and was reinstated at the earliest time at which the objection to his national sympathies ceased to operate, I would take it up with the railway company and ensure that that period during which he was absent from the company's service would be regarded as service with the company for the purpose of calculating the compensation payable under the Bill. I do not think that merely using the word "dismissed" without putting any time limit would get over the difficulty. A person may have been dismissed from the company's service and he may not have rejoined the company's service because he did not want to, because he had other employment of a more profitable kind, in which he remained so long as it lasted, and subsequently rejoined the company's services only when that employment terminated.
Comment on this
But the Minister, I take it, would not give a certificate in that case?
Comment on this
I could not refuse to give a certificate because he was dismissed on account of his national sympathies, but the question of the date on which he again went into employment with the company might be difficult. There is the question of whether the whole of the time during which he was absent from the company's service was due to his national sympathies. This matter came up in the Dáil, as I have said, and the Dáil was satisfied, and I think this House should be satisfied, that if such a case should arise, I personally will undertake to raise the matter with the company so as to ensure that full provision will be made for such an individual in respect of the period during which he was out of employment by reason of his national sympathies. I think that paragraph (d) will give me sufficient power to approach the company in that regard. However, I think it is a very remote possibility that such a case would arise, but if such a case should arise, I think the House can take it that my assurance is a better guarantee than anything that you can get into the Bill.
Comment on this
I am quite satisfied with the Minister's statement of his intentions, but there is a period referred to here, and that is the period between the 1st April, 1916, and 6th December, 1921, and paragraph (c) says that if the person concerned were suspended from the company between those dates, and if the Minister certifies that his suspension was due to his national sympathies, the period of suspension shall be included in the period of his pensionable service. I am wondering what would be the legal construction if the company were to meet such a case by saying that the man was not suspended, that he was dismissed.
Comment on this
What I would say to the company in that case is that if the man's dismissal was due to his national sympathies, and if he rejoined the service of the company as soon as his national sympathies ceased to be an objection to the company, they should arrange to give him that whole period for service and pensionable purposes. I do not think that I shall have any difficulty in arranging that with the company if such cases should arise, but obviously, it would be very difficult to frame a section or sub-section to meet such a case.
Comment on this
I am quite satisfied as to the Minister's intentions, but if the legal advisers of the company say that it would be unlawful to take this period into account, since the person concerned was not suspended but actually dismissed, what would be the position then?
Comment on this
It is merely a matter of wording. I know that I went to the railway company in 1924 and said, in effect: "What about taking all these people back?" They agreed to do so, but there was a difficulty in one or two individual cases here and there. Eventually, they were all taken back, but if my recollection is correct, they were taken back as new entrants. Certainly, the people in whom I was interested got no credit for their absence, and it is to remedy that situation that we have this clause here.
In connection with the Civil War, there were two angles to this question. Some of these people went into the National Army, while others of them took the other side. Those who went into the National Army went back to the company's service with their period of absence counting for pensionable purposes, retirement benefits, and so on, whereas those who went back to the company's service from the other side did get that period of absense counted as service with the company for pensionable purposes. That is what we are trying to deal with here, that those who were absent from the service of the company as a result of their national sympathies for a given time, from 1916 onwards, should have that period counted as service with the company for the purpose of determining pensionable rights, and so on.
Comment on this
I am quite satisfied, but the only anxiety I have is that the company's legal advisers may think that it is unlawful.
Comment on this
What we are concerned with here is to see that they must not pay less than they should.
Comment on this
Is the Minsiter quite aware that there is no provision in the superannuation scheme that they cannot pay more?
Comment on this
There is nothing to prevent their paying more. There is nothing which says that they cannot pay more.
Comment on this
I take it that what is in the Schedule is the minimum?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 64:-
In page 64, before line 55, to insert the following new paragraph:—
( ) If, with the consent of the company, that person was temporarily absent from his employment for the purpose of performing functions of a public character, such temporary absence shall be included in the period of his pensionable service.
This is my last amendment. It affects a small group of people, and I want to preface my remarks by saying that the amendment has not been submitted at the request of the persons concerned, and I have not discussed it with them. I did mention to one of the persons concerned that this matter had come to my notice in connection with other matters, and that I thought it wise to include in this Bill the cases of these three people. There are only three people concerned, one of whom is a friend of the Minister, and two of whom are friends of mine, and all are members of the Legislature. I do not know whether the period of absence in such a case will be taken into consideration.
Comment on this
I do not think the case is likely to arise. I considered this fully, and I would have put it in if I thought that it would be of use to the individuals concerned, but I do not think it would be. If these individuals take up public duties which make it impossible for them to continue in the company's service, I suppose it may be presumed that they will go back to the company's service if they cease to perform these public duties, but they are not paid by the company in the meantime.
Comment on this
yes, but they are not paid. What we are considering here is the case of persons whose employment is abolished, but the company will not abolish offices if they would be liable to pay pensions to people holding that office but not actually in receipt of pay. I would say that the people whose offices would not be abolished are people where the company has not to pay them anything at all now. However, this concerns only the abolition of an office because of the amalgamation, and it does not affect the rights of these people to pensions.
Comment on this
I realise that it is entirely problematical, but I have in mind one particular case where an individual has held a particular kind of office for a period of years, and I assume, although I do not know, that there is a corresponding office in the other absorbed company. Now, the two offices will not be continued. One will be abolished. That, I think, is pretty clear, and in that case one of two people will be entitled to compensation. Let us assume that the office held by the person I have in mind is abolished, rather than the corresponding office in the other company; if he wants to resume work, and if his office is abolished in the meantime, that clearly is a case which comes under the Bill.
Comment on this
Yes, but the company cannot say that the office is going to be abolished in five, six or eight years' time. In fact, if the company wants to say that the office was redundant in 1945, then the provisions begin to operate, but this contingency was so improbable that I did not consider it necessary to legislate in respect of it. The Senator will understand that there is a certain hesitation in proposing legislation of this kind which will affect, personally, members of the Oireachtas. If I felt that there would be a possibility, of injustice, I would have introduced an amendment to deal with persons loaned, so to speak, to the public service. I think, therefore, that they would not in fact benefit from the provision, and in that case it is better not to have the provision.
Comment on this
Is there any reason why the charges mentioned in the Tenth Schedule should not be set out in full rather than in this manner? I take it that those charges are actually spread over various documents which are not available to everybody?
Comment on this
The Senator will understand that all those old provisions in relation to canal charges are being abolished, and that we are proposing to substitute a new schedule of maximum charges.
Comment on this
It is an Order which was confirmed by the Canal Rates, Tolls and Charges, No. 11 (Grand Canal) Order, Confirmation Act, 1894.
Comment on this
Those charges are to continue until the new schedule of maximum charges is prepared. The present system of determining canal charges is only understandable by a few individuals who are in control of it. What we are providing here is that those charges will continue to be in force until there has been prepared a new schedule of maximum charges which will become operative when the Minister makes an Order to that effect.
Comment on this
Is it expected that the schedule will be ready at an early date?