Transport (No. 2) Bill, 1944—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 1–233 of 475. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 15 of 1944 ›
The case was made last night that there should be an appeal from the arbitrator appointed under this section to the High Court. I am opposed to that suggestion. So far as I know there is no example of legislation where an appeal is allowed from the decisions of a legal arbitrator. Frequently statutes providing for arbitration in technical matters by engineers, surveyors, architects or persons of that kind allow for an appeal on issues of law to a court. In this case where the arbitrator will be presumably a legal personage an appeal upon questions of law to the courts would be contrary to practice. It is true that the section does not require that the arbitrator will be a person possessing legal qualifications but the arbitrator has to be appointed by the Chief Justice and, again, there is no known case where the Chief Justice has not appointed a person of legal experience as arbitrator in such matters. I think it is desirable that the arbitration proceedings contemplated by the section should not be unduly costly and that there should be finality in the arbitrator's decision. I am reinforced in my view in that regard by reason of the fact that in previous transport legislation, both in the 1924 and 1933 Acts, the procedure was precisely as contemplated here and while there were proceedings in the court arising out of the provisions of these Acts, I do not think it could be said that the finality of the arbitrator's decision proved unjust to anyone.
Comment on this
It is because of the similarity between the legislation in the 1933 Act and this Act that this amendment is submitted. It is very unsatisfactory when you find arbitrators taking exactly opposite views of the same set of words. In one case it was held by the arbitrator that if there was a reduction in the cash value of the traffic handled, irrespective of the grounds on which that reduction arose, that was a case of diminution of traffic which put the applicant outside the Act. Another arbitrator held a totally different view as to the meaning of the same set of words. I think the Minister will find in the long run that it would mean less litigation to permit an appeal on a question of law or on the interpretation of the law. It is not a question of the facts. The arbitrator is qualified to determine the facts or he should not be an arbitrator at all. I think it was Senator Kingsmill Moore pointed out last night that where you have an idea of an appeal in the background it does impose a certain responsibility on the arbitrator, the court or whoever is deciding the case. I do not think the Minister will find that the amendment will lead to litigation. On the contrary, in my opinion, it will secure that there will be a common pattern throughout the proceedings, irrespective of who the arbitrator will be, and in the long run it will save time.
Comment on this
May I suggest to the Minister that these are the very questions on which there should be a case stated? The provisions of the Common Law Procedure Act make it possible——
Comment on this
I know of no case of legislation passed by the Oireachtas providing for a legal arbitrator where that is done.
Comment on this
I am suggesting, in case of arbitration, the principle that there should be a case stated if necessary. You have it in the Common Law Procedure Act, you have it in the Arbitration Act in England and there seems to be no reason why there should not be a similar procedure where the arbitrator is appointed by statute. The case stated is not subject to any of the objections which I think the Minister has in mind. The facts are set down shortly and the question of law only is submitted to a higher court. It is really designed to assist arbitrators and to avoid difficulty which may be created by the fact that arbitrators may take different points of view. The courts shall merely be asked to state what the law is on a given set of facts submitted in writing by the arbitrator. The facts are agreed to by the various parties and it is a comparatively inexpensive matter. The only case in which it may be at all expensive is where the question of law is so complicated that it involves a rather lengthy argument. I do urge on the Minister, in spite of what he said, that not only is it not in any way contrary to arbitration proceedings, but it is of the essence of arbitration proceedings that the opinion of a higher court can be sought on a question of law, both in deciding a particular case and also for the purpose of guiding the arbitrator in future proceedings.
Comment on this
I would say that it is of the essence of arbitration that the decision of the arbitrator should be final, and I would go further and say that the view that an arbitrator would give a better judgment because of the possibility of an appeal against his decision is contrary to commonsense. It is far more likely that the arbitrator will be concerned with the validity of his decision, and give greater care to the matter, if he knows that there is no appeal from his decision, that if he knows that there is, and I think that commonsense would suggest that.
Comment on this
I disagree. I say that it has been the practice, not only amongst arbitrators but amongst the judiciary. As regards the interpretation of those words, I want to point out, in reference to what Senator Duffy said, that the decision of the arbitrator in the Kerins case, which was quoted last night, was not given simply on a question of economic causes, but on the grounds of maintenance.
Comment on this
I argued that although these were company decisions the facts were substantially the same in both the Peate case and the Kerins case.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 35:—
In sub-section (8), paragraph (b), page 21, before the word "measure" in line 2, to insert the word "and"; and to delete all words after the word "costs" in line 3 to the end of the paragraph, line 5.
I should like to press this amendment rather strongly on the Minister. The effect of the amendment is that the provision in the Bill under which the arbitrator, I do not say shall, but might require a person of limited means to give security is contrary to everything that we know of in our legislation and in our legal procedure in this country with a few very minor and insignificant exceptions. So far as the principle is concerned, I am afraid that there is already too much truth in the belief that even so far as justice is concerned it is heavily weighted on the side of the big corporation against the man of limited means. It does not matter to the big corporation whether it goes to the expense of consulting a solicitor, a junior counsel or a senior counsel, or even bringing in more than one senior counsel, but for the small man it may be a matter of absolute vital urgency to him whether he can provide for the proper advocates to argue his case, and to put in the proviso that, in addition to that, he can be asked to put down security for the costs of the arbitration appears to me to be most unreasonable. It is a peculiar analogy that in the High Court the only case where security can be asked for is where the person does not reside within the jurisdiction. That is the only case where an individual, suing, can be asked for security. Even if the individual is an undischarged bankrupt he cannot be asked, according to the proceeding under the Judicature Act, to give security in the High Court, and it does not seem reasonable to me, in those circumstances, that we should allow, not direct, as I admit, but even allow the arbitrator to get into the position of having Córas Iompair Éireann requesting him, in any case, to weight the scales even further in its favour by asking a man who feels that he has a grievance to put down the cost of the proposed action before it has been decided.
Comment on this
The provision proposed here is precisely similar to that contained in the 1926 Act and the 1933 Act, and there is obviously a good reason for such a provision. It is to be assumed that after the amalgamation takes place certain employees will lose their employment for a variety of reasons. If there is no risk involved, clearly, every such employee will at least take his chance before the arbitrator of having a decision in his favour on a claim for compensation in accordance with this measure, and it is to ensure that the proceedings before the arbitrator will be limited to bona fide cases that this provision is inserted. I assume that it was for a similar reason that it was inserted in the 1926 Act, and the 1933 Act was modelled upon the previous measure. I know that in the majority of cases where proceedings were taken under these earlier measures the workers concerned were supported by their trade unions and most of the important cases were fought by the trade unions with a full array of counsel, and not by individual workers, but it is possible to contemplate that there would be workers who might feel that they could make a claim even though their unions were not prepared to support the claim, and in such cases it would be obviously unfair to put the company in the position of having to defend every case, no matter how unsubstantial the claim might be, if it had already been decided upon or else was outside the scope of the measure. It would be unfair to expect the company to defend every case unless there were good grounds for contending that disemployment was the result of the amalgamation.
Comment on this
The Minister's case is, first of all, that the arbitrator will prejudge the case before it is heard, because to argue that the necessity for these sentences is that there is no possibility of the case succeeding is prejudicing the issue. Secondly, the Minister's point is that otherwise there would be no deterrent on a man bringing before the arbitrator a case which he knew had no chance of succeeding; but if a man knows that his case will not succeed, then he also feels that, after the case is thrown out, at the end of the hearing, he is going to get a judgment against him, and the company can if necessary, by the application of court orders, obtain weekly deductions from his wages to meet the costs that have been awarded against him. It does not appear to me that, in those circumstances, the Minister can say that there is no deterrent. I would suggest to him that, no matter whether it was accepted in previous legislation or not, he should strike the right note in this legislation.
Comment on this
Has the Minister any information as to what was the effect of a similar provision in earlier legislation?
Comment on this
I wonder though were there any applications turned down because of the requirement to make provision for costs?
Comment on this
I would ask the Minister to give way on this point. What I do not like about the Minister's attitude towards this measure is that, where he wants to get his way, he pleads some previous legislation, and where he sees fit he simply cuts away from that altogether and starts the most striking innovations, like the giving of those powers to the chairman. Surely it is rather petty on a matter of this kind to ignore human values and take your stand on some previous legislation. Could not the Minister take a little more wide and generous attitude? I dislike the bringing up of all those petty things like that matter yesterday about sending out a report to the shareholders— trifling little items of that kind. Here is another trifling little concession, and the Minister's attitude is to ignore the human values altogether. Is it not a pity to try to put those obstacles in the way of a person who feels he has a grievance? I think it is altogether unworthy of the Government to adopt this unyielding, implacable attitude.
Comment on this
I quoted previous legislation to show that I am not here introducing a new provision. I wanted to make it clear that this is not something thought out for the purposes of this Bill—something which did not apply in respect of previous legislation. I think it is desirable that there should be some deterrent on people taking proceedings in cases that are frivolous, or so far removed from the provisions of the Bill that they could not possibly succeed. Senator Duffy asked if there were any persons whose cases were not brought to decision because of a similar provision in other legislation. I do not think so. I am aware, and, no doubt, the Senator is also aware, that there was a large number of workers whose cases were not fought because their trade unions decided that there was no possibility of succeeding.
Comment on this
The difficulty about the whole matter here is that you have, on the one hand, a big railway company, a company bigger than any contemplated by previous Acts. This new company, Córas Iompair Éireann, will be a very big company indeed. You have that on the one hand, and the big trade unions on the other hand. This is a piece of legislation which wipes out the individual who does not happen to be agreeing with the company and does not happen to be agreeing with the trade unions, and there is a very interesting light on the discussion in this agreement between the Minister and Senator Duffy, who is in sympathy with the amendment, because the amendment stands for individuals as against trade unions.
Comment on this
There is a deterrent here. Supposing I think I have a grievance against the company and I want to bring my case before the arbitrator. My trade union refuses. I must convince some lawyer that he ought to appear for me. I cannot appear myself; if I do, I will get scant hearing, I presume. The individual must be given as much help as he possibly can get against all the various things that are pressing against him. If a man wants to appear before this arbitrator he surely must have a counsel. There are certain deterrents. He cannot bring forward his case without incurring any liability. He must incur liabilities. He must have his case argued legally before the arbitrator, and to do that he must incur costs. As Senator Sweetman has pointed out, he will incur certain liabilities, even if they are only for paying costs by instalments. It does seem to me that that is going to prevent any individual from making a frivolous claim. You may say that the individual may be cranky. He may be disagreeing with the trade union on the one hand and with the railway company on the other. Mind you, even though he is, he should get a fair hearing. He should have an opportunity of having his case put. If one or two cases are put and fail, that is a great deterrent in itself. I do not think there are any grounds for the Minister's fear that a whole flood of cases will be brought before the arbitrator. I do not think it will work like that at all. It may be that one or two cranks— they may be cranks from the Minister's point of view—will bring cases before the arbitrator and be thrown out. But what harm?
Comment on this
If the individual is in the position of having everything to gain and nothing to lose?
Comment on this
On the contrary, the individual has everything to lose. He is going to have to pay his own costs and the company's costs.
Comment on this
While I do not entirely admire the old-time, rugged individualism of Senator Hayes, I do not approve of the steamrolling of the individual, but I have the feeling that no matter what you do put in the Bill—there are so many things in the Bill that I dislike now, it does not very much matter— you will not enable the ordinary individual to go into court if he has not some backing from some of the combinations. There is no doubt about that. I would point out that this section does not provide that security for costs must be given. It is provided that the arbitrator may, amongst other things, require security for costs, but I draw a distinction between those two things.
Comment on this
The Minister has stated, with perfect accuracy, fairness and courtesy one side of the question, and I admit at once the cogency of his remarks, but I do not think he has given sufficient attention to the other side of the question. Quite recently, if I may illustrate my argument by an example, a certain gentleman failed to get any support for his case from his official union. I may say, too, that he failed to convince certain members of the Bar that he had any case. He persisted, and, with the aid of other members of the Bar, finally got a decision from the Supreme Court which was worth over £2,000 to him. It is quite possible that an individual may not get assistance from his trade union because they do not think his case is one which is either legally correct or in all respects worthy of support. It is possible for even trade unions to have a somewhat constricted outlook, either from the legal point of view or the point of view of policy. I am interested in preserving the right of the individual. It has been suggested that he cannot bring his case without backing. I do not think that is so. Every day cases are taken up by members of the Bar for people who have no means, because the members of the Bar are convinced that the case is one which is either so just that it ought to succeed, or, at all events, is so just and has such a chance of succeeding that it should be fought in the interests of ordinary fairness.
I join with Senator Hayes in making this plea for the individual who thinks he has got a case, and who can convince some lawyer that anyhow the case is a statable one as opposed to a big railway company on the one side, acting perfectly fairly and perfectly honestly within its own lights, and a big trade union on the other side, acting equally fairly and equally honestly. They may both be mistaken and the individual may be right, and it is unjust to say that, because of his poverty, he cannot have his case heard, owing to the fact that he has to give security for costs. Could we not take a line on this from the courts? As has been pointed out by Senator Sweetman, the courts will never make an individual give security for costs because he has no money, nor will they make him give security for costs because his case looks on the face of it unsustainable. It is true that there is a method of bringing a motion to have an action struck out on the grounds that it is an abuse of the process of the court, and frivolous. I have only known that to be done twice during the time that I have been at the Bar. That shows that it is not a matter of very great importance that there should be such a procedure. The fact remains that the court, either for poverty or the apparent unsustainability of the case, has to give grounds for making a person give costs. I suggest that in these matters the courts have been going for a long time. We have a large number of capable judges and wise men who have considered this procedure. They have set a headline which, I think, it is not desirable to depart from.
Comment on this
I suggest that is overstating the case. It is not proposed here that the applicant should be required to give security for costs. What is proposed is that the arbitrator can so require that if he considers that it is in the interests of justice.
Comment on this
I think Senators have not adverted sufficiently to the importance of the word "may" in the section. It is not inherent in the section that the arbitrator will have to insist on security for costs. It is at his discretion. He may demand security for costs, but I think, in view of the statement of the Minister and the freedom allowed to the arbitrator, that the House would be well advised to leave this matter as it is.
Comment on this
Surely, the arbitration will not cover a big number of cases at this particular stage?
Comment on this
The difficulty mentioned of arbitrators taking different views will probably not arise. The likelihood is that there will be only one arbitrator, and he will act for a comparatively short time. The possibility of any harm being done by accepting the amendment now is very much smaller than it was in 1926. Suppose an individual cannot get a trade union to support him and suppose he gets senior counsel to say that he has no case, he may find himself required to give security for costs. Not only does he require the advice of senior counsel who may be a specially skilled person like Senator Ryan who, for some years, was an arbitrator himself, to prosecute his case before the arbitrator, but he will further require that someone should go security for him in the bank. All our experience shows that is a very difficult thing to get. He should not be put in the position of having to get the first thing which gives him the probability of succeeding as well as the second thing which we all know is very difficult to get.
Comment on this
It is reasonable to assume that the arbitrator will act reasonably and will not require security for costs unless there is a good reason for it. I should say that, in my opinion, it is almost improbable that any case will come before this arbitrator at all. The circumstances are so different from what they were under the 1926 Act that it is extremely unlikely there will be a dispute except in a very limited number of cases. The position will be that certain people will obviously be redundant as a result of this amalgamation, and they will be compensated. It is only the cases of persons who are subsequently disemployed, and who think that their disemployment was due to amalgamation, and not due to some other cause, that may lead to disputes. It is desirable, in the general interest, that there should not be frivolous cases kept on over a long number of years, particularly in relation to this Bill which provides for the amalgamation of two self-contained units where any redundancy will appear almost at once. Under the Bill as it was framed originally the provision was that these cases would have to be decided within six months. There was opposition to that. That was put in because whatever reorganisation, producing redundancy, would become necessary following the amalgamation would have to be completed within that period. There is no time limit now. The machinery in the Bill as originally framed gave an indication of what I thought the situation would be.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 36:—
In sub-section (8), page 21, line 11, before the word "which" to insert the words "or in the power or control of any party of which he is an employee or servant".
This is a difficult amendment for a layman to explain. During the progress of the Bill through the Dáil the Minister re-wrote the section more or less. Sub-section (8) is drafted in a new form. Paragraph (c) provides that the arbitrator may summon witnesses and require them to produce any documents in their power or control which he considers necessary. It has been suggested to me that there is still a weakness in the section. Let us assume the case of an applicant coming before the arbitrator. The man has been dismissed by the company because his office was discontinued. There is the question to decide whether the office was discontinued because of amalgamation. There may be a number of things involved in that. I cannot say what would be the technical aspects, but I believe there are a number of things involved regarding accounts and other matters which have to be taken into consideration, particularly under paragraph (d) of sub-section (1), by the arbitrator. The position may be that it is not possible for the applicant, or even for his union, to go to court with all the facts: that actually the information has to be derived from the company's own records. There would be no difficulty, perhaps, if one were proceeding against an individual. He could be subpoenaed and asked to produce documents. I think he could be compelled to answer questions. I believe there was a case in the Irish courts some years ago in which the plaintiff succeeded in proving his case only because the defendant happened to be in court. The plaintiff took the precaution of calling the defendant and of putting him in the box to prove his case. That, I understand, cannot happen in the case of a body corporate.
Let us assume that Córas Iompair Éireann has been defending an application before the arbitrator. A clerk, or some other official in charge of the records, appears to give evidence, but he may not have the documents under his control. It is desirable that there should be some process by which the applicant could get the information for which he is looking.
Comment on this
There are two difficulties. He may not know who has the records and, secondly, the person summoned will be his witness and may not be a friendly witness.
Comment on this
He can require any witness summoned to produce any document in his control. In the last resort, he can summon the secretary, the manager or the chairman of the company. I do not think that there is any need for this amendment.
Comment on this
I do not think that any difficulty will arise in this connection. He can require the secretary to attend and produce the necessary documents. The secretary, being a busy man, will, probably, ask if he may produce the documents through the person who has immediate charge of them. Everybody will agree to that.
Comment on this
I am in a personal difficulty because I thought that, under the ordinary law, you could always put interrogatories to the other party, but I understand that there was actually some difficulty in obtaining compensation because of the non-production of documents or the non-supply of information.
Comment on this
I do not think that that is so. There is full power to summon any person as a witness——
Comment on this
If the arbitrator considers that certain information is necessary to his decision or that certain documents are necessary, he can summon the person concerned and require him to produce the documents.
Comment on this
I think that the section, as it now stands, is a great improvement on the previous draft.
Comment on this
To show my ignorance, I wish to put a question and to get a free legal opinion here. Does not the doctrine of the discovery of documents apply to proceedings before an arbitrator?
Comment on this
Generally speaking, the proceedings before an arbitrator are governed by the Common Law Procedure Act, which deals with a great many things. Whether discovery would apply in this case, I am not quite certain.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37:—
In sub-section (8), paragraph (d), after the word "time" in line 13, page 21, to insert the words "on notice to any person affected".
I think the Minister will agree that the arbitrator would, virtually, always do what is required here. However, I think that it is desirable he should be required to give notice to anybody affected if there has been a clerical mistake.
Comment on this
The view of my advisers is that the amendment is unnecessary. Again, we have followed the wording of the earlier Acts and no difficulty has arisen on this score. I have no objection to the insertion of the words, but they are not regarded as necessary.
Comment on this
On the section. Like Senator Sir John Keane, in my profound ignorance, I should like to know what the practice is in regard to the enactment of the Schedules. I notice that the Bill seems to enact the Fourth Schedule and the Sixth Schedule. The Fifth Schedule comes in on this section and there is no reference to that Schedule, except in sub-section (1), where the words occur
"he shall be paid by the company compensation calculated in the manner set out in the Fifth Schedule to this Act".
I do not know whether it is necessary to make the Fifth Schedule part of the Act by specific words.
Comment on this
I notice that in Section 41 it is stated that
"the provisions set out in the Fourth Schedule to this Act shall apply in respect of the stockholders' directors".
In section 57 it is provided that
"the enactment specified in the Sixth Schedule to this Act shall, to the extent mentioned in the third column of that Schedule, not apply to the company".
That seems to incorporate the Schedule. I do not know whether or not it is necessary to incorporate the Fifth Schedule in the same way.
Comment on this
This section deals with the superannuation scheme. The company may prepare a scheme and, if the Minister so requests, shall prepare a scheme. I think the procedure is that, when a scheme is submitted to the Minister, if he approves, he confirms it and it becomes a statutory obligation. If he dislikes it, he can send it back and require the company to make alterations until he is satisfied. In regard to the existing scheme, two bodies have made representations to me. One is a society of railway employees. They have had a pension scheme in existence over a number of years. I think that the fund is known by the secretary's name, although it has a legal name. It has been made clear, I understand, to the members of that society that they must wind up their business and I think that some proceedings are pending in the court regarding the matter. I am not very much concerned with that scheme but I have received communications from other sources. One is from members of the National Foresters' Organisation who are railway employees. My attention was drawn to the sick benefit fund in the Great Southern Railways scheme. The last paragraph of that scheme states:—
"Should an employee be a member of any society or body, excluding the National Health Insurance Society, as a result of which membership he receives benefit while ill, he shall be debarred automatically from this scheme."
So that, if a person is a member of the Foresters and entitled to 5/- or 6/- per week benefit, he is debarred from participating in this scheme which, I take it, will be submitted to the Minister under Section 44.
The scheme promoted by the company is a contributory scheme. It may not be contributory in respect of all the services provided, but they are not dissevered. There is one application form. A person who desires to join the fund will sign an application form for membership. That membership confers on him certain benefits for which he is paying, but he is obliged to pay contributions in respect of the other benefits under the scheme. It seems to me a monstrous thing that the Great Southern Railways Company would prepare a scheme the contributions under which are compulsory and say to a member: "You are a member of the National Foresters or some other friendly society and you will be debarred from benefit under this scheme." I do not suggest that anything can be done in regard to that in the Bill, but I suggest that the Minister should take note that this type of complaint exists and that he should ensure, before the scheme is approved, that the persons concerned will know its implications and that he himself will be satisfied that no injustice will be done.
Comment on this
So far as existing superannuation funds are concerned, they are covered by Section 45. Section 45 provides that every existing superannuation fund of the dissolved company shall continue as if the dissolved company had not been dissolved and that the obligations, whether legal or arising out of customary practice, of a dissolved company in respect of any existing superannuation fund shall be binding upon the new company. With regard to the scheme from which the Senator has been quoting, I want to make it clear that the only part of that scheme that has to be submitted for approval is the superannuation part. This Bill deals with superannuation schemes only. In so far as the company may have other proposals for medical benefits or sickness benefits, they do not arise in this Bill. This Bill is concerned only with superannuation and, consequently, it is only the portions of that scheme that deal with superannuation that would require to be submitted for approval under Section 45.
Comment on this
I want to draw attention to a matter which seems to me to suggest very loose drafting in this Bill. For instance, in Section 46 provision is made for the establishment and support of associations calculated to promote the welfare of the employees. You give power to the company to expend money on services of that kind. Then you go on to deal with appointment to clerical grades and when one comes to Section 59 one finds power given to the company to subscribe to charities. It seems to me that the Bill was drafted in a loose manner, more or less slung together, and I think references made here would suggest that the phrasing is not the happiest phrasing. For instance, in Section 46, the phrasing is:
"The company may make payments towards insurance for the benefit of all or any of its employees or ex-employees or the dependents or connections of all or any of such employees or ex-employees."
I do not know whether there is a legal definition of "connections" or not, but it would seem to me to be a new phrase and there is a good deal of such phrasing through the Bill. As originally drafted, there was more of it, but a number of changes were made by way of amendment in the Dáil. I am drawing attention to it for two reasons. The first is as to the meaning "of dependents or connections." I do not know whether that has any significance or not. Secondly, as to why it is that there should be three or four pages between Sections 46 and 59, both of which deal with matters which are related.
Comment on this
The proposal here is to enable the company to contribute to the insurance of its employees to secure, benefits on death to their relatives or other persons who may have an insurable interest or who would be the beneficiaries under an insurance policy. I do not quite fully appreciate what the Senator's difficulty is. I presume the term "dependents or connections" is the phrase ordinarily used in that regard—whoever would be the beneficiary under an insurance policy.
Comment on this
If it meant beneficiary it would say so. Everybody has not an insurable interest in another person's life.
Comment on this
I agree. What powers are we giving them to contribute to connections of somebody?
Comment on this
We are giving power to the company to contribute towards the cost of insurance policies for their employees or ex-employees.
Comment on this
For the employees or the ex-employees of the company or their dependents or connections.
Comment on this
Clearly, if it is a life insurance policy, the benefit will be derived by some dependent or connection. The benefit will be payable only on decease.
Comment on this
Yes. It would not include persons who are now ex-employees of one of the dissolved companies. It would include persons who were transferred to the service of this company on amalgamation and at some subsequent date became ex-employees.
Comment on this
Could that possibly exclude a person employed by the Great Southern Railways who is not going to be an employee of Córas Iompair Éireann, from being a member of one of the clubs that are going to be assisted?
Comment on this
Do not mix up the question of the clubs with this, because I think they are separate matters. The section relating to clubs is to enable the company to subscribe to sports clubs, dramatic societies and things of that kind, which the employees might organise for their own social welfare. If we had not got such a section the company could not use its funds to contribute to these purposes. I do not say that the company is going to contribute but we do not want to prevent them if they want to do it. It may also use funds to contribute towards the cost of insurance for its employees, apart from the scheme arranged for medical and sickness benefits and other things besides superannuation. We just enable the company to use its funds for that purpose.
Comment on this
I think the Minister might inquire as to the meaning of "connections" in relation to this section. I cannot imagine a draftsman putting that in without some meaning.
Comment on this
A wife could be a connection but not a dependent. I think there is an obvious distinction.
Comment on this
I agree, but what is a connection? Who are the connections of ex-railway employees?
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, I have some experience of a Post Office Benevolent Fund. I happen to be chairman of the trustees of the Roland Hill Fund. We interpret it more widely than relatives and, as a matter of fact, we would like the word "connections". I am speaking from the point of view of the employees and ex-employees themselves. The word "connections" is a wider word and, I think, from the point of view of the employees, the wider the word the better.
Comment on this
Give the company the widest possible power, because you may trust the company not to spend its money in any lavish manner. But the company should not be prevented from having wide power to help any particular kind of club or charity. I think the word "connection", therefore, is looser and wider and would be more widely construed. It would be for the benefit of the employees and possibly was put in for that reason.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 38:—
In sub-section (3), lines 38-39, to delete the words "ordinarily resident in Ireland" and insert in lieu thereof the words "citizens of Éire".
In this amendment I was trying to provide for the case of somebody who had gone to England during this emergency and who is anxious to return to this country and take up a job in Córas Iompair Éireann. As the Minister's section is, he will not be entitled to do it.
Comment on this
I do not think that is correct. I think a person who had gone temporarily to England would be regarded as being ordinarily resident in Ireland.
Comment on this
Ordinarily domiciled but not ordinarily resident. If the Minister had "ordinarily domiciled", certainly it would do. I will take another case which I think the Minister would probably like to meet. Supposing a man had gone to England with his children, who were aged about ten years, and supposing one of the boys when he reached 17 or 18 years of age wanted to come back to this country, he certainly could not be regarded as ordinarily resident here. He would be a citizen. I think the Minister would say that in that case the boy should be able to compete for these examinations.
Comment on this
I should like to ask for certain information with regard to this section. Sub-section (1) provides that all appointments to any office or situation in the clerical grades of the service of the company shall be made by means of open competitive examination. I should like to know why the clerical grades have been singled out for examination. This is a matter of more than ordinary importance. Section 2 provides that Irish would be a compulsory subject at every open examination but what is likely to happen under this is that recruitment to the various grades in the service of Córas Iompair Éireann may be made without reference to a knowledge of the Irish language at all. The clerical officers of the railway companies have very little to do with what one might call the public life of the companies and I think it is absolutely essential that a knowledge of Irish should be required for servants of the company, especially those who have dealings with the public.
If I want to travel by bus, for instance, while, under the Constitution I am assured of the right to use the Irish language, in practice I find that I cannot do it. If I go to the railways to make inquiries in regard to timetables or other such matters I find I am held up if I use Irish. If I want to make out a consignment note in Irish I find I am held up in the same way. The people I deal with generally in these matters are foremen, porters, carriers and bus conductors. I do not quite understand why some regulation has not been made to ensure that the people in these grades coming into the service would have a knowledge of Irish.
We have great difficulties, especially in Galway where there is such an influx of Irish speakers all through the summer. The position is most embarrassing and most unfair to them. I think if the Minister had any idea of the difficulty experienced by native Irish speakers very often in banks and other public institutions in Galway in trying to transact their business in Irish, he would appreciate the force of what I am saying in regard to this section. In regard to the question of recruitment for what one might call the lower grades we expect that the language should be provided for. Whether such a thing should be incorporated in the Bill, I cannot say, but I feel that Córas Iompair Éireann should have the right to insist that recruitment through the lower services should be from the schools only. I do not specify what schools the boys should come from, but I think that when the company are taking in apprentices or young people for platform work or such duties they should only take them from a panel provided by the schools.
I think some consideration ought to be given when the question of openings in the clerical grades come up, to the fixing of examinations in such a way that university graduates would be enabled to compete. What I have in mind is that there is a possibility that examinations may be fixed in regard to a certain standard—say Leaving Certificate—and a very brilliant university graduate may not be able to take the Leaving Certificate examination when, for four or five years in the university, he is working on specialised lines.
Comment on this
Yes, the age limit will have to be taken into consideration. I am not sure whether these things ought to be incorporated in the Bill, but it should go out as an expression from this House that they are matters of importance which should be seriously looked into by the management of the company.
Comment on this
I am interested in this matter from rather a different point of view from that of Senator O Buachalla. I personally think that these provisions for compulsory Irish— the teaching through the medium of Irish—are creating a disastrous effect on our standards of intelligence and on our general standards of education. But it is the policy of the Government and if it is then it should be applied fairly and without discrimination. I think if we are to have our intellectual standards lowered we should all be made suffer in the process.
Comment on this
I will make my case my own way. Why are the clerical grades singled out in this matter of penalty and preference? Preference is given to people who are native speakers, or have the desire to learn and further the Irish language, as against those who are not. They will have the penalty and why are they singled out for that treatment? I take it that there are grades in the railway and the Minister could tell us how many executive grades there are. If executive grades are recruited from the young people leaving secondary schools, are they recruited by public examination, and, if they are, why should they all not equally go through this process, which I say is either penalising or preferential, as the case may be? Why are the ordinary operative grades exempt from the same treatment in relation to the Irish language? If you are going to apply this compulsory Irish, which is a preference to some and a penalty to others, the application should be indiscriminate. Apply it to all who are more or less of the same age and could be expected to have the same qualifications. I do not say that in regard to a general manager or an elderly man like that, you should apply that system of qualification, but for all of the same age, you should insist on a knowledge of Irish, or compulsory Irish, as the case may be.
Comment on this
Claíonn an Seanadóir O Catháin le saol atá imithe ar fad, agus ní saol ar fónamh a bhí ann ach saol aineolach. Ní thuigeann sé an chaoi ina bhfuil an teanga Ghaeilge ag snaimeadh na ndaoine le chéile, ó thuaidh agus ó dheas. Ní hé amháin go bhfuil an Rialtas ar thaoibh na Gaeilge ach go bhfuil gach uile dhream poilitíochta sa tír ar thaoibh na Gaeilge, agus luigheann sé le réasún go mba cheart agus cóir toil na ndaoine do chur in éifeacht. Ní hiarracht é sin cúl nó éagóir do chur ar aon duine. Tá deis ag na Béarlóirí thar na Gaeilgoirí, mar tá siad comhgarach do na coláistí agus na scoltacha is fearr sa tír. Bhí éagcóir á dhéanamh ar na Gaeilgoirí le fada agus is cóir agus is ceart cothrom a thabhairt dóibh ins an saol atá le teacht.
Comment on this
I do not intend to take up the time of the House by following Senator Sir John Keane through the questions he has raised. I am sure, however, that he would be interested in an examination as to the effect of teaching in Irish. I might suggest that he refer to the results of the last examination conducted by the Great Southern Railways in regard to the efficiency of teaching in Irish as against teaching in English and as to the results achieved by the students doing their work in both languages.
Comment on this
I am not going to follow the Senator on that point but I could give him some astounding examples of the effect of this teaching through Irish. I do not want to bring that in now.
Comment on this
I just want to intervene to say that the matters raised by Senator O Buachalla are matters of management and representations which he thinks should be made, must, I think, be addressed to the management of the new company. I feel sure that the management will give very careful consideration to these representations. I would, in fact, have said that even the matters dealt with in Section 47 should be left to the discretion of the management, were it not for the fact that in previous legislation relating to the Great Southern Railways there were somewhat similar provisions—provisions for competitive examinations for clerical grades and particularly a provision which required the reservation of certain of the posts for the sons and daughters of existing employees of the company.
I would have preferred to leave Section 47 out altogether and to leave even the method of recruiting the clerical grades to the management of the company, just as the recruitment of the manual and executive grades is left to their discretion, but because there had been legislation previously in this matter, because certain rights had been secured by legislation and the dropping of the section at this stage might lead to misunderstanding, I felt it was wiser to insert the section confirming the existing position. The company recruits its executive grades mainly by promotion from the clerical grades, but occasionally by bringing in people from the service of other firms. Senators may have seen recently an announcement in the Press of the intention of the management to form a cadet corps, the members of which will be given special training with a view to their ultimate appointment to executive posts, if they prove suitable. So far as manual workers are concerned, I think competitive examination would be an unsuitable method of selecting them, but if it is desired to suggest that, in particular parts of the country or generally, they should have special qualifications in Irish, I feel sure the company will consider any representations made to them in that connection.
Comment on this
I feel that the Minister's answer is profoundly unsatisfactory. Whenever it suits his case, he says: "This is a question of management; we cannot interfere," and then we suddenly find that, for some reason I cannot follow, he places this obligation on the management of insisting on Irish for one grade only, the management being free to do what they like about the other grades. He imposes the obligation in regard to Irish on one grade only. I think it is profoundly unjust and for that reason I propose to put down an amendment on Report Stage to leave this question of Irish to the management. It is very unfair to apply this obligation to one grade only. With regard to what Senator O Buachalla has said, I travel on the railways—not so much as he does, perhaps—and I never find that I am hampered by not knowing Irish.
Comment on this
I am inclined to agree with the Minister on this matter generally. The point which Senator O Buachalla makes that university people might be recruited to the railways is one which we could scarcely provide for by legislation. There is, as the Minister says, a proposal to set up a cadet system and it may very well be that the only way in which university people, apart from engineers, could come in is by having in the railway a grade equivalent to the administrative grade in the Civil Service; but, quite clearly, the Minister is right in saying that we could not provide for that by legislation.
Comment on this
We are in agreement about that. I think we should leave the railway as much liberty as possible. Open competitive examination might not necessarily be a written examination. Engineers might be recruited by way of selection boards as in the case of Government service, which would almost be, of its own kind, an open competitive examination.
With regard to Irish for the clerical grades and not for other grades, I am rather inclined—I hope he will not be surpri ed—to agree with Senator Sir John Keane that we should have, for people of the same type and the same age, the same obligations, but I think he will find, if he examines it, that the only rule we can make is the one which the Minister makes here and the one made in previous Acts, that people of an age for clerical work recruited fresh from school should be subjected to this test, which, in their case, is in no sense an unjust test.
Comment on this
These are the people who will be doing executive work. The people recruited by clerical examination are the people who will be doing it.
Comment on this
I do not think they are entirely drawn from the clerical grades.
Comment on this
But by this new proposal which is not yet actually settled. Is that not the position?
Comment on this
That is so. In the past, the executive grades were recruited mainly by promotion from the clerical grade, but on occasion people with special qualifications were brought in from the Railway Clearing House, independent road transport companies and so forth, and that may arise in the future. This new proposal to train a special cadre of people in executive work is not yet in operation. The clerical grades include stationmasters and ticket clerks and people of the kind, and it would be correct to say that, apart from porters and station hands, they are the class of railway employees who come most frequently and directly in contact with the public.
Comment on this
If it is suggested that the executive grades should be recruited not from the existing railway employees but from the outside and at a particular age, like the school-leaving age, then presumably provision of this character will be made with regard to Irish. Speaking for myself, I would hope that it would be made, but I do realise that the company should be left to do its own business as best it can itself. Senator Sir John Keane rather misunderstands Senator O Buachalla's point. It is not that Senator Sir John Keane's lack of Irish hampers him on the railways, but the lack of knowledge of English of certain people hampers them on the railways.
Comment on this
I am quite prepared to accept that correction.
Comment on this
With regard to the general proposition that our intellectual capacity is failing because we are interested in Irish, that is very difficult to prove, and it is quite clear that the intellectual capacity of the country does not reside in the people who do not know Irish and have no interest in it.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 39 in the name of Senator Douglas to this section reads:—
In sub-section (1), line 56, page 23, after the word "may" to insert the words "after consultation with the board."
The Minister has power to direct the company to do certain things. I take it that he could scarcely do that without consulting the board.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 40:—
In sub-section (3), page 24, line 5, to delete the word "may" and substitute the word "shall".
As Senator Hayes has indicated, the Minister may, under this section, require the company to provide transport facilities where they are needed. Before making an Order under the section, it is provided in sub-section (3) that he may refer the proposed Order to the advisory committee, and the purpose of the amendment is to ensure that the Minister shall refer it to the advisory committee. The matter is one of considerable importance, as the Minister's Order may affect very many interests, and it seems right and proper that it should be the subject of examination by a committee outside his Department. This is one of a number of amendments which endeavour to insert the mandatory instead of the permissive word.
Comment on this
Why should we have all the apparatus of a public inquiry to do something which is of a comparatively unimportant character and which everybody agrees should be done? There may be, of course, many completely frivolous applications. I can imagine an individual applying to have a bus service every hour to his own door in some cul-de-sac. If we accepted the amendment, that application must go to the advisory committee, there must be a public inquiry into it and a report from the advisory committee.
Comment on this
Before making the Order. There will be other cases where the application will appear on the face of it to be reasonable and where the case made by the applicant is such that no further inquiry appears to be necessary, in which case the Minister may proceed upon his own initiative to make an Order and get the service provided. It is only where there will be a conflict of interests, where some inquiry must be held, where the views of the different parties must be weighed and judgment formed upon them that the committee procedure will be necessary. In such a case I assume it will be the normal practice to refer this question to the committee. If there is no need for that elaborate inquiry, then there should be no compulsion upon the Minister to arrange for it.
Comment on this
I should like to know if the Minister has in view particularly in regard to this section areas in which the train service was discontinued, because we have had the experience in the West, where the line from Clifden to Galway was discontinued, that the farmers in the Clifden area complain very bitterly that they cannot send cattle to the market in Galway because the rates are so high. I was wondering if the Minister would consider the advisability of putting into this section after the word "conditions""at such rates as he shall prescribe for the carriage of animals and goods". This is a very serious matter. I do not know whether the Minister would prefer to deal with it in Part 4, dealing with the question of charges.
Comment on this
I am afraid that will not be sufficient for a particular service. I think that for a particular service there ought to be particular charges—that is for particular areas.
Comment on this
It will be in the company's power to charge less than the maximum in any case, but I do not want the Minister to be put in the position that he can by Order require the company to charge less for the conveyance of cattle in Galway than in Mayo. Everybody would appreciate the difficulty of the Minister if he had that power. In the case of Galway, what happened was that an exceptionally low rate which had operated for a time was dropped and the standard rate, which farmers in every other part of Ireland had previously been given, came into operation.
Comment on this
I do not know if the Minister appreciates that the farmers suffered very considerably by the discontinuance of the line from Galway to Clifden. They have now to pay several times more per head of the cattle than they formerly paid. That is a grave injustice to them. In fact, we are told that some farmers in the Clifden area have cattle on their hands up to four years old because they could not send them to Galway to be sold.
Comment on this
Will the Senator leave that aspect over until Part 4 of the Bill is being considered?
Comment on this
I should like the Minister to prescribe special charges for special areas. I am satisfied to leave it over until Part 4 is taken.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 41:—
In sub-section (4), page 25, to delete all words after the word "case" in line 24 to the end of the sub-section.
In this section provision is being made for the cesser of wayleaves payable to the Dublin and Dun Laoghaire Corporations. Provision is made for the settlement of any dispute which may arise between Córas Iompair Éireann and the two corporations concerned. A direction is given, however, in sub-section (4), the latter part of which is not very clear to me. The sub-section commences by saying:
"In fixing the compensation payable to any road authority under this section the arbitrator shall have regard to all the circumstances of the case ..."
That is a very reasonable and understandable direction. Then it goes on to say:
"... and may have regard, so far as he considers equitable, to the extent to which the roadways of that road authority have ceased to be used or will cease to be used for the purpose of tramways".
I cannot see any point in putting in these words. If the arbitrator is to have regard to all the circumstances of the case, that seems clear enough. What I am endeavouring to do in the amendment is to take out these latter words which certainly will add to the difficulty of interpretation and be very much less satisfactory for the arbitrator and for the parties appearing before him. I do not think that the deletion of the words would in any way take away from what was intended originally. It would remove the ambiguity, and that is desirable.
Comment on this
I do not think the arbitrator could have regard to the circumstances of the case unless these words were put in. The position concerning these wayleaves is that they were paid under an agreement between the Dublin United Tramways Company and the Dublin Corporation as something equivalent to rent for the use of the streets. There was no legal recognition of that, however, until 1925, when the Dublin United Tramways Company promoted a Private Bill for the purpose of getting power to run omnibuses. The position at that time was that omnibuses were coming on the streets operated by private individuals and companies, but the Dublin United Tramways Company had no power to run omnibuses and could not get the power except by way of a Private Bill. For reasons which are not quite clear at this stage, the Private Bill of the Dublin United Tramways Company was opposed by the Dublin Corporation and, in the course of the negotiations which took place between the company and the corporation directed towards securing the withdrawal of that opposition, there was an agreement to insert in the Bill a provision which would require the Dublin United Tramways Company to continue to pay to the Dublin Corporation indefinitely wayleaves at the amount at which they were paid in 1925. Previously that amount fluctuated with the mileage of tracks. No doubt the corporation had in mind the possibility that omnibuses would replace trams to an extent which would interfere with their revenue from wayleaves and, as we know, that has in fact happened since.
The company was also obliged to meet costs in respect of the maintenance of the roadway in the vicinity of the tram tracks and, subsequent to the enactment of the 1925 Act, there was a new agreement between the company and the corporation by which the company's contribution towards road maintenance was reduced as the track lines were reduced. That was a much larger item than wayleaves. In consequence of this provision in the 1925 Act, the company continues to pay wayleaves at the 1925 level and would presumably have to continue to pay them indefinitely, even if the tramways had disappeared, unless there was some relief given by way of legislation. That the Oireachtas in 1925 contemplated that such relief might be given, was clear from the phraseology put by the Private Bill Committee into the Bill following the agreement between the company and the corporation, because the Bill contains wording which must have been decided upon for some unusual reason. It provided that, notwithstanding the discontinuance or the abandonment in whole or in part of the tramlines operated by the company, the company should, nevertheless, continue to pay these wayleaves at the respective amounts being paid in 1925, unless and until provision to the contrary was made by the Oireachtas.
If we were merely to determine what capital sum would represent a perpetual payment of that kind, we would not need an arbitrator; any mathematician would probably be able to give you the figure. But there are certain considerations of equity which arise. It is clear it would be unfair to impose on the national transport organisation an obligation to pay a perpetual pension amounting to several thousands of pounds per year to certain local authorities merely because at one time in history these local authorities had leased their streets to a tramways company. We do not say to the arbitrator: "You must determine the compensation to be paid in the light of the fact that the tramways have, since the 1925 Act became operative, substantially disappeared, and may completely disappear in the future." We say to him that to the extent to which he regards it as fair to do so, he may have regard to this consideration—the extent to which the roadways will cease to be used for the purposes of tramways. If the arbitrator considers it fair to take that point into account, we give him permission to do so. It is by no means clear that he could otherwise take it into account, having regard to the provisions of the 1925 Act.
Comment on this
My point is that the words mentioned in the sub-section will make the position more complicated. In preparing the Bill, the Minister was able to arrange for a settlement of whatever claims were outstanding to the Great Northern Railway Company; that is provided for to the complete satisfaction of any claims made. I do not know whether any effort was made to do the same in the case of the two corporations. But it is not going to make matters easy for the arbitrator, unless, of course, the Minister's wording has particular significance. If that is so, it means that the company that was paying rent had been paying for a particular purpose. They are no longer availing of the facilities they enjoyed, and therefore they cease paying. In that case there is no compensation.
Comment on this
That would have been the situation if that provision had not been inserted in the 1925 Act. If the Dublin Tramways Company had succeeded in getting, in the Act passed in 1925, power to run omnibuses without this condition in relation to wayleaves, the obligation to pay would disappear as the tramways disappeared. But, because of the opposition offered by the Dublin Corporation to that Act, an agreement was made which required the company to continue to pay wayleaves at the rate paid in 1925, unless and until the Oireachtas made provision to the contrary. The Oireachtas has not made provision to the contrary.
Comment on this
But the Oireachtas is being asked to provide to the contrary.
Comment on this
No. Now, the company will get rid of this obligation to pay wayleaves at the 1925 level on payment of a capital sum to the local authorities. If they cannot get agreement as to the capital sum, then the matter must be referred to an arbitrator and the arbitrator will decide what capital sum will represent fair compensation to the local authorities, having regard to all the circumstances of the case —having taken into account, if he thinks it fair to do so, the extent to which the roadways may cease to be used for the purposes of tramways. In so far as it might be held that he could not take that matter into account, it is desirable to put that provision in. We do not say to him "You must take it into account," but we do say "If you consider it fair to do so, you may take it into account."
Comment on this
When is this section likely to be operative? Will it become operative immediately the new company is formed?
Comment on this
I should say the new company will endeavour to secure agreement with the corporation and the Dun Laoghaire Borough Council for the payment of the capital sum.
Comment on this
I am rather surprised the Minister recognises this question of compensation at all for these wayleaves. Look back on the past. You took hold of the Dublin electricity outfit completely without any compensation at all and you merged it in the national effort and deprived the corporation of the very considerable revenues they might have expected. In this undertaking you are relieving the Dublin citizens of an encumbrance in the form of trams and you are paying compensation. I cannot see that compensation is justified in view of the numbers of people who have suffered in the whole of this new transport policy. Look at the way the shareholders in the railways have suffered through the action of the Government. I think the Government would be fully justified in not giving any compensation to the corporation for the cesser of these wayleaves.
Comment on this
After hearing Senator Sir John Keane, I could not remain silent. He draws an analogy between the corporation electricity supply station at the Pigeon House and the Dublin United Transport Company. There was a reasonable hope, if the Dublin United Transport Company had continued as a separate organisation, of reduced fares and greater facilities for the citizens of Dublin. It appears to me that this profit-making value of the Dublin Transport Company will be utilised to relieve unprofitable railway undertakings throughout the country and to that extent the citizens of Dublin will for all time lose the possibility of cheaper fares and better transport facilities. Will it be competent for the arbitrator to take notice of that disadvantage that the Dublin Corporation and the citizens will suffer as a result of this merger? That is an important aspect.
There is another feature. By the withdrawal of this annual sum for wayleaves the whole valuation of the City of Dublin will be altered and the loss of the amount paid in wayleaves will have to be passed on to the rates in Dublin City. Will it be competent for the arbitrator to take due notice of this disadvantage? The Dublin Corporation, of course, will be mulcted because of the merger. Since we are having arbitration on the matter, it is well that we should know, as far as we can, what the arbitrator will have to decide, and I would like the Minister to deal with that aspect of the case.
Comment on this
I heard the arguments put up by Senator Foran now put forward on every occasion when Dublin came into the picture. I remember the discussion of the Electricity Supply Bill and the outcry of those interested in Dublin, saying that the citizens would have to pay higher rates for electricity supply, as the private company in Rathmines would be completely wiped out, and so on. I would remind Senator Foran and some of those others interested in the citizens of Dublin, that there would be no Dublin if we had not a prosperous country.
Comment on this
On a point of order, if the Senator reads what I said on the Second Reading of this Bill, he will see that I said that Dublin was becoming top-heavy, that we would have to take due notice of the country and have to make sacrifices in the interests of the country at large; so that does not bear out what Senator Counihan is attributing to me now. The same thing applied to the Electricity Supply Bill, when I drew attention to that point also.
Comment on this
I am sorry if I misunderstood the Senator, but the fact remains that, during the passage of the Electricity Supply Bill, dealing with the Shannon scheme, the same arguments were used in this House over and over again, about the citizens of Dublin; and Senators emphasised that they would have to pay higher tram fares under the new scheme. In the end, the Shannon scheme has proved a blessing in disguise for the citizens of Dublin, and I am sure the same thing will happen under this Transport Bill. Where would they be during the emergency, when they cannot get any coal, if they had not the Shannon scheme? They should not be making such a row now about the higher fares they may have to pay under the new Transport Bill, as they may have lower fares.
Comment on this
In reply to Senator Foran's point, the Dublin United Transport Company pay to the Dublin Corporation rent, rates and a contribution to road maintenance. In the case of the rates, there was, by agreement with the corporation, a reduction in the rateable value of the undertaking with the disappearance of the tramways. In the case of the road maintenance contribution, which was substantially greater than the wayleaves, there was a similar agreement with the Dublin Corporation for a reduction of the amount as the tramways disappeared. The Dublin Corporation formally recognised that they could not get revenue at the same rate if the tramways disappeared. In the case of the wayleaves, they were frozen by the 1925 Act and have remained unchanged ever since. We are now going to get rid of them by paying a capital sum, but in determining the capital sum — assuming the case goes to arbitration — the arbitrator also can have regard to the considerations which the corporation had regard to when they made the new agreement relating to rates and road maintenance contributions.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say what happens to the money lodged in court as a guarantee when the City of Dublin Junction Railways was liquidated? As well as I remember the position, that railway was guaranteed by the Great Northern Railway, the Great Southern Railways and the City of Dublin Steampacket Company. The last mentioned was liquidated and some £35,000 was lodged in court. Does it go to the new company or is it paid out to the liquidators of the old one?
Comment on this
In sub-section (1) (c), there is an obligation on the company to maintain a certain service until an agreement is reached with the Great Northern Railway. It says:—
"(c) the company shall continue to operate the normal system of trains run before the said date for the purposes of, and in connection with, the mails services of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, over the Dublin Junction Railways and the company's railway between Westland Row in the City of Dublin and Dun Laoghaire Mail Pier, until the company and the Northern Railway Company, with the consent of the said Minister agree otherwise;"
I do not wish to attach any more importance to this point than the Minister did himself, but I think there is a likelihood that the rail service may be abolished, not next year but in five or seven years, with the disappearance of the suburban services. If that is so, there may be difficulty on account of this paragraph in sub-section (1). For instance, the Great Northern Railway may withhold consent to agreement for the abandonment of the mail service. There seems to be no way out of it except by new legislation.
Comment on this
That may be so. The amount lodged in court by the Dublin Steampacket Company, which was one of the guarantors of the City of Dublin Junction Railways, was £65,000, and an application is being made by the Great Southern Railways to the court for the money.
Comment on this
In the copy of the Bill I read, there was no mention of hotel licences. I should like to know if the transfer of licences mentioned here would refer to hotel licences.
Comment on this
An intoxicating liquor licence cannot be given to a company, but must be to an officer.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 42:—
In sub-section (4) to add at the end of the sub-section the words "but the company shall not by reason of any diversion of traffic from the railway to its road services have the valuation of its railway assets for rating purposes reduced below the figure operative for profits for the dissolved railway company for the year ending the 31st March, 1944".
The phraseology of this amendment is not very happy but the amendment was merely put down to draw the Minister's attention to a particular circumstance that may arise. The Railways (Valuation for Rating) Act, 1931, is not satisfactory in its operation, for a variety of reasons of which the Minister is probably just as well aware as I am. There will be a very severe time-lag in the operation of the fixing of the valuation under that Act, which means that a county council or any other local authority may have gone over into a new financial year before it actually knows the exact amount the company may have to pay under the preceding year.
Comment on this
The company has been paying the minimum, under the decisions of Judge Davitt and the Supreme Court, in the cases that were taken the first time. My feeling is that, at some stage or other, there may be a suggestion that the minimum should be changed and the point will then come up that Córas Iompair Éireann has transferred from the railways to the roads a great deal of its services. In that event, there would be the local dislocation caused to local authorities by a railway line being closed down, though at the same time they would not get compensatory provision in the rates. It is not a thing that can be dealt with in this Bill, and the amendment is introduced for the purpose of raising the matter, so that it may be considered by the Minister and the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, on the question of the delay that will arise after the next quinquennial valuation. Some other system might be adopted in the future for the greater convenience of local authorities.
Comment on this
The Senator understands that the railway pays rates upon calculations which are based on its net receipts.
Comment on this
I agree. Nevertheless, it is a different method of calculation from that which applies to other classes of property which pays on a valuation of the letting value of the property. In this case the net receipts are taken as the basis but there are deductions from the net receipts representing the proportion attributable to movable assets. It is on that calculation the company pays. There is also the minimum provision.
Comment on this
The minimum provision has been in operation for a long time. There will be a revision, however, at the end of the quinquennial period.
Comment on this
The intention is to leave the Act unchanged. If there should be a complete transference of railway traffic to roads, and consequently a situation created in which the revenue earning capacity of the railway part of the system would be completely altered, we would have to consider that under the 1931 Act.
Comment on this
In connection with this section I want to draw the Minister's attention to Section 135 of the 1925 Act. This is one of the typical things we have met throughout the whole Bill which impressed me very much with the point of view that while this Bill has been drafted on the instructions of people who presumably understand the transport situation and understand Parliamentary draftmanship, it has not been considered at any time by a person who understands company law or who is used to the practice of company law. Section 61 and Section 135 deal more or less with the same thing in slightly different words and with slightly different provisions. I think it is grossly unfair that a person who has got to understand all the regulations which Córas Iompair Éireann may make, should have to try to construe these two different sections. Either Section 61 should not have been inserted or Section 135 should have been excepted from the operation of the Bill by the initial section of the Bill. I would direct the Minister's attention to these two sections as an example of the somewhat loose drafting of the Bill from the company law angle, and I would suggest that between now and the Report Stage he should get a draftsman to look at the Bill who is accustomed to company law as apart from one who is accustomed merely to Parliamentary procedure and transport conditions.
Comment on this
This is a typical instance of what has happened in connection with the Bill. The whole thing has been considered by a person well versed in Parliamentary procedure and transport conditions, but it has not obviously been considered by a person versed in company law.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 43:—
In sub-section (3), immediately after the words "the Company", in line 34, to insert the words "at any place habitually used in the past for that purpose or".
The difficulty I had in this particular instance was on the question of the definition of "level crossing". I can recollect one particular place, not on the Great Southern Railways, but on the Great Northern Railway, where people used to walk across the line. There was a stile, placed there obviously by the railway company, to enable people to get over the fence on either side, but it was not a level crossing. If there was a similar arrangement on the Great Southern Railways Company, it would be held that a person would be trespassing by going across the line.
Comment on this
As the amendment stands, it would have the effect of legalising what was trespass in the past. The provisions of this section are taken from the Private Acts of the various railway companies which were amalgamated in 1924. In fact, the sole reason for legislating in relation to this matter is that we found on examining these Acts that they contained varying conditions, and the situation since 1924 in relation to trespass has been different upon some parts of the Great Southern Railways Company from what it was on others. It was felt that, as we were dealing with the matter now, we should make one law to, cover all parts of the system. As the matter has been raised, I should like to say that I have been giving consideration to the question of whether it is not desirable to ensure that the right to use accommodation level crossings is fully preserved. It will be understood that when the line was being constructed the company was under an obligation to make good any interruptions caused by the railway in the use of lands through which the line passed. It may be necessary to propose in relation to this sub-section some modification of the wording which will ensure that the right to use level crossings is more effectively preserved than at present. That matter is being examined.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister the object of paragraph (2) (b)— all this elaboration about the notice not to trespass? Surely everybody knows that he cannot trespass on a railway line, without having all these elaborate provisions about notice. The whole thing seems to me to be an empty formula.
Comment on this
Under this section, where a person is charged with an offence of this kind it will not be necessary for the company to establish that a personal warning was delivered to the offender. It will be regarded as a sufficient warning if the company erects a sign at the level crossing.
Comment on this
There is one point in connection with these notices that I should like to bring to the notice of the Minister. Occasionally one sees notices on railway premises and vehicles—there may be lawful authority for them though I doubt it—saying that if a person does so and so he will be fined 40/-. I understand that these are not in the correct form.
Comment on this
I suggest that they are in the wrong form. I suggest that all they are entitled to say is that a person who contravenes the by-laws is liable to be prosecuted and on conviction may be fined a certain amount. In one particular case I have in mind the notice is a very old one, because the name still on the enamel plate is the Midland Great Western Railway Company, which disappeared in 1924. These notices are in a most improper form.
Comment on this
We cannot be too technical. One sees in railway carriages a warning that the fine for improper use of the chain is £5, but I never tried to pull the chain to see if that would be the fine.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 44, 45 and 46 all deal with the composition of the advisory committee and perhaps could be discussed together, though it may be necessary to put separate questions on them.
Amendments were as follows:—
44. To delete sub-section (2) and substitute therefor the following new sub-section:—
(2) The advisory committee shall consist of five members, namely:—
(a) a chairman who shall be nominated by and may be removed from office by the Taoiseach;
(b) two ordinary members who shall be nominated by and may be removed from office by the Minister, and
(c) two ordinary members who shall be nominated by and may be removed from office by the Minister for Agriculture.—(Senator Duffy.)
45. In sub-section (2), to delete paragraphs (b) and (c) and substitute therefor the following paragraph:—
(b) four ordinary members who shall be nominated by organised interests under regulations to be made by the Minister.—(Senator Sir John Keane.)
46. In sub-section (2), paragraph (b) after the word "who" to insert the words "shall be a member of the National Executive of the Irish Live-stock Trade and".—(Senator Counihan.)
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 44.
As the House is aware, the proposal here is to establish an advisory committee consisting of five members, composed of the chairman and four other members—the chairman to be nominated by the Taoiseach, two of the members to be nominated by the Minister, and two to be nominated by the Minister for Agriculture. I have a feeling that this advisory committee may be a very important body in relation to the operation of this Bill. I feel that it should be given all the authority and influence that we could bestow upon it in the legislation. For that reason, the amendment proposes that the chairman would be nominated by the head of the Government, and that the other four members be nominated, as to two by the Minister, and as to the remaining two by the Minister for Agriculture. The Minister will be directly responsible for very many things that will be done under this Bill. He is taking power to refer a number of matters to the committee before taking action in regard to them, such as, for instance, the fixing of a scale of charges, the classification of merchandise, and other matters that may come before him, and which may be referred to the committee. I have a feeling, however, that if that committee is a body that is more or less apart from the Department of Industry and Commerce it would be a better thing both from the point of view of the Minister and of the public. Other committees have been appointed from time to time to which wide powers were given, much on the lines suggested here, and it appeared to me that the more independent the committee is, the better it will be for the Minister himself and for everybody else.
This committee is more or less analogous to the Rates Advisory Committee, which was set up in 1924, in connection with the Harbours and Piers Act, and the applications in regard to various charges. While that committee was constituted entirely of members appointed by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, at the same time it was representative of various points of view rather than of interests. I do not think anybody was selected because he represented a particular interest, and I think it is a bad thing that it should be so. I think it is a bad thing that sub-section (3) should make it obligatory on the Minister to have reference to anybody's interest. I may say that, actually, a committee with which I was associated considered proposals in relation to the reorganisation of transport towards the end of last year and at the beginning of this year. The Minister got a copy of the findings of that committee. On the question of a board of directors, in which some people favoured a board representing certain interests, on the assumption that it was a State concern, and even after consulting with the representatives of those acting on behalf of railway transport workers, the committee rejected the proposal that interests should be represented on the board.
The same is true of this advisory committee, and if the Minister wants advice on matters arising under this Bill, he ought to select a committee whose members are capable of offering that advice and, if the necessity arises, of conducting an inquiry, because that is what you are doing here. You want a committee that will conduct an inquiry, take evidence, form an opinion and make a report to the Minister. That report, no doubt, will influence the Minister's decision very clearly, and, therefore, I am endeavouring to make this committee detached and to have it clothed with authority and influence.
The proposals I am making in the amendment are reasonable from that point of view. The chairman of the committee would be selected by the head of the Government, and this amendment seeks to give authority and influence to that committee, if you have a committee. The Minister himself would select two members of the committee, and the Minister for Agriculture would select the remaining two, and I think that such a committee would meet what is wanted in the Bill.
Comment on this
My amendment, No. 45, is not intended to be legally water-tight, but to raise a principle. If the principle is accepted, then the Minister can put it into proper form. What I have in mind in connection with the whole of this Bill is that the attitude of the Government in regard to this whole matter is totalitarian. I do not want to enlarge on that subject, but I say that this shows a totalitarian attitude on the part of the Government towards the country. Here we have a case where the Government are taking a monopoly of the railway and giving no voice whatever to the people using the railway, the people who will be most affected by the operations of the transport company. The Minister, in effect, says: "No. My appointees will be docile dummies, whom I shall call in." Surely, the Minister wants to know what the ordinary people, the users of the railway, feel about the matter, and surely he should get somebody to give him some kind of independent judgment on their grievances. When you had the Railway Tribunal they had at least an independent attitude towards the grievances of traders, although I do not mean that that was altogether an independent body. Perhaps they were slow in their operations and in the making of their reports, but at least they did adopt an independent attitude towards such grievances.
Here, however, the Minister steps in and takes a sort of Codling and Short attitude and says, in effect: "Codling is your friend, not Short". In other words, he says: "I am your friend; I have a chairman who will safeguard the interests of your company, and I am not going to have any independent voice made effective regarding any grievances the public may feel." I say that the whole thing is wrong and antidemocratic. I say that the spirit of it is totalitarian. We have a facile democracy, I know; we have a Dáil, an Oireachtas, and a tribunal of courts of law, but still there is this totalitarian spirit, reinforced, I may say, abundantly, by the censorship, and it is against that totalitarian spirit that this amendment is put forward. The object of the amendment is that you should make at least this minor concession to the ordinary man in the street. It is not easy to get access to the Minister. Of course, I do not say that the Minister is inaccessible— perhaps it is one of the advantages of a small country that he is accessible— but the Minister here has complete power. He has the power to say "No" to any proposal. I do not say that the Minister will be tyrannical, but he may say, in regard to any proposal: "The chairman does not like it, or somebody else does not like it, and therefore I refuse to hear any impartial complaint." Not alone that, but the Minister says: "I will put in my own nominee."
I think that the spirit of the thing is all wrong, and not only the spirit, but the letter. All through this Bill we have been up against the letter. It is the spirit I am after. The Government should recognise the plain people of the country, and give them at least some rights in this very important matter of transport. That is the purpose of my amendment. If the Minister is prepared to accept it, there will be no real difficulty in deciding who are the organised interests. I ask the Minister not to say: "We cannot select the organised interests." It can be done if the Minister wants to do it. I only ask at this stage that the principle be accepted; the rest is only a matter of machinery.
Comment on this
We will now hear Senator Counihan on amendment No. 46.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 46. I am sorry I was not here when the ruling was given. Will those three amendments be voted on separately?
Comment on this
There is an alteration which I wish to make in my amendment. The amendment refers to a member of the national executive of the Irish live-stock trade; what I meant was a member nominated by that body. The national executive varies every year.
With regard to the amendment in my name, I think I can put forward a very much better case for having a member nominated by the national executive of the live-stock trade than can be put forward in the case of any other section of traders. It is true to say that the live-stock trade are the greatest users of the railway, and that apart from passenger traffic they yield the greatest revenue to the railway, but that is not the principle on which I rely when I ask that a member should be nominated by the national executive. As every Senator knows, the cattle trade has had long experience of the workings of the railway. Every other trader simply sends his carter to the railway station; he does not actually see the goods loaded—all he is concerned with is the question of freights. Our main consideration—of course we are as interested in freights as anybody else—is that we want better services. We want to be in a position to put up our claims, and show the Minister how the services can be improved. As I said, we have had long experience of the running of the railways. Every cattle trader goes to the railway station, sees the cattle loaded and unloaded, and knows where the snags are. He has travelled sometimes in the van, with the cattle; he knows where the delays occur, and the causes of the delays. On many occasions we have been consulted by the railway management, and our advice was accepted.
I will give one example to show how our advice was helpful to the railway company in the old days. Tipperary fair was a very big one, and the accommodation at the railway station in Tipperary town was very limited. It is a very small railway yard and the banks are not very extensive. Only a small number of wagons could be accommodated in the yard at the one time. When the cattle were loaded there, no empty wagons could be brought in until the first lot was despatched. For years they were marshalling those wagons in the yard in Tipperary, and we had to wait there the whole day and sometimes into the night. The cattle trade, seeing that something had to be done, put up the suggestion that as soon as every wagon was loaded and booked it should be despatched to Limerick junction for marshalling; the same arrangement to apply in regard to the Waterford section. That suggestion was adopted; it expedited the transport of the cattle, and saved an enormous amount of hardship to the farmers, cattle traders, and everybody concerned. The position had been so bad that a good many of the cattle buyers refused to attend Tipperary fair. Those are some of the reasons why I urge that we are entitled to special consideration, apart altogether from the claims of any other traders.
There is one point which I should like to make with regard to general policy. We have heard a good deal of talk about the dictatorship powers of the chairman, and comparisons have been made with the old Railway Tribunal. We had experience of that tribunal and we were not enamoured of it. If this advisory committee is to be effective, they should have some permanency of office, and not be removable at the whim of any Minister. I do not object to the Minister having power to remove the chairman. We will all have an opportunity of going to the Minister with regard to any work done by the chairman, and that power on the part of the Minister will keep us right as far as the chairman is concerned. We want the advisory committee to have more independence. If they are to be removable at the whim of the Minister, I do not think you will get the best men on the committee. I do not think an independent, self-respecting man would go forward in those circumstances.
Comment on this
Do not forget that he is paid; he gets a salary.
Comment on this
We will remove the salary; I hope the Minister will agree to that. We have had experience of other advisory committees. The Agricultural Advisory Committee, when elected, can work out their term, and it is not within the province of the Minister for Agriculture to say to any of them: "I will retire you. You are creating a bit of a disturbance on this committee, so you need not come any more." Why should the committee which we are discussing here be put in a different position? Why should it be open to the Minister for Industry and Commerce to keep only "yes-men" on that committee? If the committee are to have any independence we should remove from the Bill the clause which gives the Minister power to retire them, and I hope the Minister will agree to bring in an amendment on the Report Stage to meet that point.
Comment on this
Those of us who are interested in agriculture are rather disappointed that there is not some mention of a representative of agriculture on this advisory committee. The section specifies that one shall be experienced in transport, one in labour and one in industry and commerce. There is no mention of agriculture.
Comment on this
It may be that, in selecting the person versed in industry and commerce, somebody experienced in agriculture may be called in. Agriculture is our principal industry. It provides a great lot of revenue for the railway through the carriage of beet, wheat, turf and live stock. Senator Counihan pleaded to have a representative of the cattle trade on the committee. Of course, the cattle trade provides a good deal of revenue for the transport services, but the money that they pay to the railway company is really collected from the producers of cattle. I suggest to the Minister that he should consider putting somebody on the committee who will be a representative of agriculture.
Comment on this
Behind these three amendments there is the common idea of giving this committee an existence independent of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. We had under the 1924 Act a completely independent tribunal, one which, in fact, was presided over by a judge, and which had the powers of the High Court in discharging its functions. That system was not satisfactory, and anyone who had experience of it approves of the proposal to abolish it. It is now proposed that the obligations which were formerly discharged by the Railway Tribunal, obligations of a non-legal character, will fall in future on the Minister and not upon this advisory committee. I think that if Senators could get that distinction clear in their minds it would help them to understand why I am resisting their amendments. These functions of deciding on maximum charges, standards of classification, various determinations on what constitutes dangerous goods, the conditions under which goods may be carried at owner's risk rates and various other matters of that kind, formerly settled by the Railway Tribunal, will in future be settled by the Minister. That is the proposal: that the Minister for Industry and Commerce will make Orders dealing with these matters. The Minister, however, will have the assistance of this advisory committee. It is not going to be set up to carry on an independent and continuing inquiry into transport affairs, nor will it have anything to say to railway management. It will not be for that committee to say whether cattle marshalling yards should be in Tipperary instead of at the Limerick Junction. If suggestions have to be made by the Cattle Traders' Association in future they will, as in the past, be made to the railway company's management and not to this committee.
This committee will not be concerned with details of management. It will be concerned with giving advice to the Minister upon matters in relation to which the Minister is given power to make Orders which will be binding upon the company. I think it would be extremely inadvisable to constitute the committee on any other basis than that proposed here. Senator Duffy's suggestion was that the chairman should be appointed by the Taoiseach. Senator Sir John Keane suggested that members should be chosen representing organised interests. Senator Counihan insisted that members should be chosen by the Cattle Traders' Association.
Comment on this
Senator O'Callaghan suggested that members should be chosen by the Beet Growers' Association. All these suggestions are the product of the same idea: that this committee should be set up independently of the Minister, and that, in some way, he should be required to act in accordance with their recommendations, and that they could decide on questions of policy and give effect to their decisions even against the wishes of the Minister.
Comment on this
I am saying that is the idea behind the suggestions. We could have an independent tribunal again. We could have a continuing inquiry into transport affairs again, but I do not think that we should. I would strongly resent the idea that the chairman should be appointed by the Taoiseach or the Government because behind that there is clearly the implication that the Minister for Industry and Commerce, whoever he might be, would be distrusted by the head of the Government or the Government as a whole, and that, consequently, they would be bound to consider some other person than the person that the Minister would appoint. Otherwise, there is no reason for the suggestion at all. Unless we assume that the Minister is going to get the most suitable person as chairman that is available, it is quite clear that the Minister is not being trusted, and that is why the suggestion is made, that as we cannot trust him to get that person we will go to the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
I do not see any other reason why the suggestion should be made. Senator Sir John Keane spoke a lot about his concern for the ordinary citizen, and proposed to give organised interests the right to nominate members to this body. That is an arrangement that I dislike most of all because, in so far as the members of the committee would owe their membership to these organised interests and not to the Minister's nomination, they would naturally regard themselves as being independent of the Minister and under obligations to take a point of view on questions that came before it different from that which would be in accordance with Government policy. The proposal that one of the members should be nominated by the Cattle Traders' Association, or by the Beet Growers' Association, has behind it the same suggestion modified to a considerable extent.
It is because the Minister may, in the discharge of his functions under this Act, require to have a public inquiry held to give the ordinary citizen the right of access to somebody with whom he can discuss his application, that this advisory committee is being set up. It is being set up to conduct that public inquiry, to give that free facility to the ordinary citizen of making his case before a body with power to advise the Minister. If you try to make the committee anything more than what is proposed here—a body of persons chosen by the Minister to help him to discharge his functions and to be in contact with people who may wish to make representations—you are embarking on an entirely different scheme to what I had in mind when framing the Bill. Any other system of securing a committee, any other type of constitution for the committee, would, I think, inevitably lead at some stage to conflict between the Minister and the committee, and that should be avoided. Questions of policy will not arise here at all. Matters which may be referred to the committee, while they may be of great interest to particular localities or particular trade interests in the country, do not necessarily impinge upon transport policy. If the members of the committee are chosen by some other authority than the Minister, if they are chosen for some other reason than the desire of the Minister to get the most suitable type of person to investigate the facts for him, then inevitably questions of policy will arise, and with questions of policy a conflict which cannot be easily resolved.
Senator Counihan suggested that members of the committee should not be capable of being removed, even though they proved to be so divergent in their ideas from the Minister and so inspired by a contrary policy that their value to him was nil. Nevertheless, the Senator suggested that they should continue to be members of the committee. I think that is a complete reversal of the intentions of the section. It is, of course, intended that there will be a representative of agriculture. The Minister for Agriculture will have direct nomination, and while that arrangement was not necessary to the scheme of the Bill it is one which ensures that the person chosen to membership of the committee, because of his knowledge of agricultural conditions, will be one who is fully equipped to discharge the functions of membership. I want to be clear on this, that the person appointed by the Minister for Agriculture will not be appointed as a representative of agriculture nor will the other persons appointed be the representatives of particular interests. They will be appointed because they have specialised knowledge of a particular kind, and the provisions in the section are so framed as to ensure that the committee will be composed of members with that specialised knowledge.
They will be appointed as members of the committee and not as representatives of any particular interest. It is the committee as a whole and not individual members of it who will advise the Minister. I think it will summarise what I have said when I contend that the committee, as provided for, is an administrative device, and is not intended to be anything more than an administrative device, to help the Minister in the discharge of his functions. It is not intended to be an independent authority, a continuing inquiry or a centre of agitation for altered conditions of transport. It is intended to be an instrument by which the functions of the Minister under the Bill may be the more effectively discharged.
Business suspended at 1 p.m., and resumed at 2.30 p.m.
Comment on this
I should like to say a final word on my amendment. The position I visualise is, I suppose, totally contrary to the Government's attitude on a matter of this kind. I contemplate a body of four or five representatives of organised interests— people who know the country. It is fantastic for the Minister to suggest that they would be obstructive and would be trying to create trouble and agitation and cut across policy. They would be people very much in touch with the life of the country. Moving around, they would have heard criticism of the railway. Every month or two, the Minister would say: "We shall have these people in and have a talk with them." They will come along. The Minister himself need not necessarily be present. One of his senior executives and the chairman of the company would meet them and would ask them what they desired to have considered. They might mention the accommodation in the way of cattle trucks in Tipperary or some such matter. The chairman, who would have the general manager present, would give the reasons for the position and would promise to look into the matter. Surely, that is the human approach to the problem. What is the objection to that type of attitude?
Comment on this
None whatever except that it is an entirely different matter from that which this committee is intended to deal with.
Comment on this
The Minister's attitude seems to be directed towards keeping everybody at arm's length. He wants to have himself tucked away, and to make difficult any informal approach of that kind. Those people would have no power to impose their views, but you would, by this means, establish a human relationship, and you would have a useful interchange of views. The thing would be set going more successfully from the human point of view if that were done, but the whole spirit of the Government's attitude is against this way of doing business. That is why I put down the amendment.
Comment on this
There is no restriction on organised interests making any representations they consider necessary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the management of the company, or on their appearing before this committee when any matter affecting them is under consideration there. I should say that that is the way organised interests should act— not by having seats on the advisory committee but by making their case before the advisory committee.
Comment on this
What Senator Sir John Keane has said indicates that he does not quite appreciate the functions of the committee. As I understand, the committee will have no function except some matter is referred to them. If the Minister has an application before him, or if, on his own initiative, he desires to make some change, he may refer the matter to the committee. If he were considering the introduction of a new transport service in some district, or if he were thinking of revising the scale of charges, he might consider that the proper course would be to have the matter examined by this committee. The committee would be called to consider the referred matter, and they would take whatever steps they considered necessary to make themselves aware of the facts. They would then submit a report to the Minister, which he might, or might not, accept. I think that that is the position.
My own attitude is somewhat different. I think that the committee should be of such a character as to distinguish it from the Department of Industry and Commerce. There is no question of distrust in my mind. It is merely a question of the manner in which the committee is to be appointed. I have no doubt that, in the long run, the people to serve on the committee would be suggested by the Minister. Even in the case of the nominees of the Department of Agriculture, regard would be had to what the Minister had in mind respecting the constitution of the committee. The Minister for Agriculture would bear in mind the requirements of the Minister, having regard to the functions to be performed by the committee.
There is no suggestion of distrust at all. It is a question of clothing the committee with certain authority, and it appears to me that if the Taoiseach is to nominate the chairman, it is an indication to everybody that here is a very independent committee, but independent only in so far as they are required to report to the Minister for Industry and Commerce in regard to matters of public import. So far as the suggestions of Senator Sir John Keane and Senator Counihan are concerned, I am entirely at variance with them.
I think the Minister himself has probably some experience of other committees where it was found that an obligation to appoint a representative of certain interests was not satisfactory. One of my recollections goes back to the original Prices Commission. The Act under which that commission was set up in 1933, contained certain provisions requiring the Minister to have regard to certain things when making appointments. I doubt if the Minister is satisfied whether the appointments which he was obliged to make were in every way satisfactory. At least, it is common knowledge that he revised the Act subsequently, and took out every provision which imposed obligations upon him regarding the personnel of the commission. I think that, in itself, is an indication that he thought that the original method was not the best.
Comment on this
With regard to my amendment, I contend that we have a special claim to representation, a greater claim than any other section of the community, because, as I pointed out, of our experience in railway working. Most of the members of the cattle trade know a great deal more about what should be done in their own jobs than most of the so-called experts on the railways. Members of the cattle trade are fully aware of the faults which occur and how to remedy them. There is no use in putting up a case that an ordinary citizen can know all the requirements of the cattle trade: only a man who is in the job himself can fully understand it. I do not think that, from his experience, the Minister could say that we would be disagreeable or aggressive on this committee, and I urge him that he would be wise to select members nominated by the national executive of the live-stock trade—that is, if he wants efficient management. The Minister seems to feel that he should have people who would always be agreeable, people who would not put up proposals unacceptable by the management.
We do not care whether the manager agrees to the suggestion or not, but we want to put our point of view through the advisory committee to the manager. If the recommendations we put up are not acceptable to the manager he need not accept them, and therefore I do not see why the Minister should have such an objection to this amendment to secure representation for the national executive of the cattle trade on the board. I still feel strongly that the members of the advisory committee should have more independence. It would create more independence if they were not liable to be removed from office at the whim of any Minister. As I said, we have the precedent of the advisory committee on agriculture. The live-stock trade is looking for something on the same lines. The Minister for Agriculture need not accept the proposals or suggestions made by the advisory committee but, at the same time, he has no power to remove them from office, no matter how disagreeable some of them may make themselves from time to time.
Comment on this
They meet two or three times a year. The fact re- mains the precedent is there and I do not see why this amendment should be resisted in the case of the cattle trade.
Comment on this
I just want to say that the Senator is under a complete misunderstanding as to the functions of the advisory committee. It will have no responsibility for putting up suggestions or recommendations to the chairman. It will deal only with applications for alterations in the classification of merchandise, the schedules of maximum charges, the conditions and terms of carriage, and the provision of additional services.
Comment on this
The provision of additional services would involve not merely the type of equipment, or the mode of handling, but the question of new services linking to new centres. It will deal also with similar questions dealing with road transport and canal transport. It is on these things, which will be ultimately prescribed by statutory orders as part of the legislation to which the company must conform, that this committee will advise. It will have nothing to do with management, nor will it have any contact with the manager.
Comment on this
I want to ask Senator Counihan a question—how many members are there on this executive?
Comment on this
There are the chairmen and vice-chairmen of six associations scattered all over Ireland.
Comment on this
I think the Minister misunderstood my point. I asked that there should be a representative of agriculture generally.
Comment on this
But that is hardly good enough. The Minister for Agriculture does not always nominate persons experienced in agriculture. That is the only point. I am not asking for a representative of the Beet Growers' Association. I am asking for somebody who can represent agriculture generally, embracing all forms of agriculture.
Comment on this
Does the Minister still consider that he should retain sub-section (3)?
Comment on this
I want to be put on record as emphasising the principle that I tried to explain to the House.
Comment on this
I would like to have a division on the amendment.
Comment on this
I am afraid it is hopeless. I will let it go by default.
Comment on this
I am not withdrawing it. I will let it go by default.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 47:—
In sub-section (6), lines 9-10, to delete the words "such remuneration and"; in line 10 after the word "expenses" to insert the word "and"; and in line 11 to delete the words "and other expenses".
The idea in this amendment is that there should be no remuneration for services to any member of the tribunal or the committee. My reason for that is that I feel we would have a very much more competent body selected if they were not paid members. If they are going to be paid you will have a host of people of all shades of politics rushing the Minister to be put on the tribunal, and I do not think that this should be made a job for any section or any Party.
I have been on some committees and on none of these did we ever get a farthing's remuneration except sustenance and out-of-pocket allowances. The same thing should apply in this case. I have been appointed on committees of selection and we have often been engaged for a couple of days but we never got anything but sustenance allowance. That allowance was so small that if we had an afternoon session we were told by the official we could only spend 3/6 on our lunch. From my experience on these committees you will get as good, if not better, men without paying them any remuneration for their services, and in that case it does not look like being a job for anyone.
Comment on this
I do not dispute the fact that one can get for various committees of this kind people fully qualified who will give their services without remuneration, but the number of such people is limited, and the effect of a provision preventing the payment of remuneration to these members would be to confine the selection of them to a very limited circle. I can say from experience, particularly from the experience of recent years—because there have been a number of tribunals acting—that it is probably a better principle to insist on paying members of a tribunal than to confine yourself to getting people who are willing to act without being paid. Those who are willing to act without remuneration are, as a rule, permanent officials of organisations or other people who have got some special reason for aspiring to membership.
I know that difficulties arose in connection with many of the tribunals now operating under the Department of Industry and Commerce, and which had, necessarily, to meet outside Dublin, in getting labour representatives and others willing to undertake membership, because it was obvious that the subsistence allowance sanctioned by the Department of Finance was completely inadequate for the purpose of meeting out-of-pocket expenses. It was, therefore, unfair to many of them to ask them to leave their employment, or whatever work they might be engaged in, to undertake the work of these tribunals in circumstances which meant that they would lose money. The principle of providing some remuneration for members of committees of this kind is sound. I contemplate that the remuneration would take the form of a fee paid per day upon which the committee met. That is the normal practice involved in cases of this kind. It is not an annual salary or a monthly allowance. The fee is designed to ensure that an individual member will not be at any loss by reason of membership of the committee. I would strongly resist the idea that the Bill should be amended to make it impossible to pay an allowance to members of this committee. On the contrary it is a much better system to have power to pay the allowance, and it is a better practice to pay it, particularly in view of the fact that that gives a much wider field of selection for membership.
Comment on this
On Section 63 I intended to put down an amendment with regard to the doubling of——
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 49:—
At the end of the section to add the following words "or on any matter which in their opinion is deserving of the attention of the Minister".
This is really my last shot, but I am afraid as far as I can see there is not much more than blank ammunition in it. Could the Minister even go so far, now that he has got an advisory committee of his own choosing, to allow that advisory committee to bring forward any matter which they think is deserving of his attention? I am sorry to have to labour the principle I am after. I would like to put it from another angle. Not very long ago— a couple of years—the Government set up a body to go into the question of the vocational principle in governing the affairs of the country. It produced an enormous report, most of which I think is pure ideology, but that is by the way. Here, however, was an attempt in the very simplest practical manner to try to embody in our affairs the principle of vocational representation. It was a very small attempt, but if the Government has got any sympathy with this vocational ideal it should go so far as to let it operate in the management of the railways. It is a small thing but I want some means of bringing matters to the notice of the Government through a constituted body. Just now the Minister said he would be glad that these people should come together, but surely they are not going to come together unless they have a status. People coming together with a status should be given more scope than to deal with the limited number of matters the Minister mentioned. If they feel there is dissatisfaction in regard to transport matters they should have power to go to the Minister and say: "We hear there is a good deal of discontent about that." Surely it is not asking for very much to ask for that provision.
Comment on this
This is not a commission of inquiry. It is an instrument of administration. The members are not selected on any vocational principle. They will be selected because of their specialised knowledge and they will not be in any sense representative of certain interests. They will be people chosen because they are personally suited and have the experience and qualifications which will make them useful members. This committee is established for one reason, and one reason only, and that is, to facilitate the Minister for Industry and Commerce in the discharge of certain functions. It is not intended that they should have any powers of inquiry outside the range of matters which the Minister may refer to them.
Comment on this
I am not asking for powers of inquiry, but that you should simply give them access or initiative to go to the Minister and say: "Look here, we feel that this is wrong or that is wrong. Can you do anything further about it?"
Comment on this
The Senator says that this and that is wrong. What does he mean by "this" and "that"?
Comment on this
I am referring to the feeling there may be in the country, say, amongst cattle traders. Let us say that the cattle traders are not satisfied or that agriculture is badly hit. The committee should have the right to say: "We feel that agriculture is too heavily penalised by these rates and that something should be done about it." There may be a very heavy rate on fresh butter, salt butter, potatoes or anything you like. There may be a lot of feeling on the matter and you may have people coming from the co-operative societies to complain about these matters.
Comment on this
Does the Senator appreciate that any of the parties interested in rates can apply at any time for a revision of the rates and get their application considered by the committee?
Comment on this
Could not these matters be raised in the ordinary course of procedure in this House by way of motion?
Comment on this
For instance if Senator Counihan feels aggrieved with regard to the provision of cattle trucks, or with regard to the charges made for the transport of cattle, is it not within his power to table a motion here and have it discussed?