Censorship of Publications Bill, 1945—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 1–195 of 395. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 31 of 1945 ›
I move amendment No. 17:—
In sub-section (2), lines 40-41, to delete the words "a person to be".
This is really a verbal improvement. "Appoint a person to be the chairman", superficially, at any rate, competes with the words in sub-section (1) "there shall be a censorship of publications appeal board consisting of three members, namely:—(a) a chairman who shall be a judge of the Supreme Court, High Court or Circuit Court...." In sub-section (2), we have the words "the Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act and thereafter as occasion requires, appoint a person to be the chairman". It would be sufficient to say here "the Minister shall... appoint the chairman", in view of what I have just read from sub-section (1) (a).
Comment on this
I shall look into the matter. The wording in the Bill is that of the Parliamentary draftsman.
Comment on this
The sub-section with which I am dealing puts the duty on the Minister to "appoint a person". Already, the duty is on the Minister to appoint a chairman who shall be a judge. One provision is specific; the other is general.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:—
In sub-section (2), line 41, after the words "chairman and" to insert the words "four fit and proper".
We have already argued this qualification "fit and proper" and the Minister has dealt with it fairly enough. Still, I contend that, in regard to the appeal board, it is requisite to put in the qualification "fit and proper" even more than in the case of the readers of the books. The Minister has accepted my amendment to have a larger appeal board since I argued this question previously and I think that, with that larger body to which to refer appeals, we may take it that control of appointments to the appeal board is sufficiently assured. Therefore, I shall withdraw this amendment.
Comment on this
I do not think that it will be sufficient to withdraw it. In view of the other amendment, I think that it will be necessary to insert the word "four". It will be sufficient if the Minister will think over the matter before the next stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:—
To delete sub-section (7).
The sub-section which I moved to delete reads as follows:—
If in the opinion of the Minister, a member of the appeal board is temporarily unable to act as such member the Minister may appoint a person to be, if such member was the chairman, the chairman and, if such member was an ordinary member, an ordinary member of the appeal board during a specified period, not exceeding six months, in place of such member."
I think that such an arrangement would lend itself to abuse.
Comment on this
Seeing that we now propose to have a larger membership of the boards, I do not think that it would be necessary to retain this sub-section. I was thinking of a position in which you might have only two members of the board able to act but seeing that we are now to have a total of five members, I do not think that the sub-section is necessary. I am, therefore, accepting the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 22:—
In page 4, line 15, to delete the words "he thinks" and insert instead the words "the boards consider".
This amendment is put down merely for the purpose of affording an opportunity to discuss procedure. I recognise, of course, that appointments must be by the Minister but the Minister in my amendment is superseded by the boards. That is just an emphatic way of suggesting that recommendations of the boards should be taken into account. In the Principal Act we have the words, "the Minister after consultation with the board". I should be quite satisfied with that. Further my amendments in respect of officers and servants of the board are out of order on account of their imposing a tax and increasing the financial burden.
Comment on this
In connection with this amendment, I am afforded an opportunity of drawing attention to the fact that the board which has been at work since 1929, has for example no typist-clerk as well as having no office. I might say in passing that it is a sort of sub-tenant of an office occupied normally by the Irish Manuscripts Commission. There is a number of things of that sort in connection with the appointment of officers and servants that need to be looked into. I think the members of the board would be best able to advise the Minister on these matters. It was merely to ventilate that point that I put down the amendment.
Comment on this
Before the Minister replies, may I ask if it has not been the practice to consult the board in the past? Whereas I never knew any board or any Department which prevailed against the Department of Finance in these matters—not that I think they should, because it would not be in the public interest—I think it would be the practice for the Department to consult with the board beforehand. The amendment as it goes would be almost revolutionary because it would force the Minister to appoint as many officials as in the view of the board were necessary for the performance of their work. They might for instance suggest the appointment of 1,000 inspectors to go into every home and to examine every book there and the Minister would have to agree under this amendment. Possibly he might be able to save himself by the words "with the sanction of the Minister for Finance" but it would put the Minister in an absurd position. At the same time, it is desirable that the Minister should consult the board with regard to appointments.
Comment on this
—— because the Minister for Justice is not the person to decide these questions. The Minister for Finance is in charge of establishment.
Comment on this
I do not think that any trouble has ever arisen from the commencement on matters of this kind. There may have been some questions as to the remuneration of the staffs, but even in that case any representations which I received I passed on to the Minister for Finance. Whether these views impressed him I do not know, but no other consultation was necessary. If such consultations were necessary the Minister for Justice would be always glad to receive from the board any representations they had to make. The last word naturally does not lie with the Minister.
Comment on this
It is to be hoped that this Bill will last longer than the life of even the youngest person present here.
Comment on this
I said "the Minister for Justice". I was not referring to myself at all. I probably will not be left there too long.
Comment on this
I could not dream of accepting that amendment. The most I can promise is that what has been done up to the present will continue. If the board has anything to suggest, say, on the question of staff, I—and I am sure anyone else in my place—will be only too anxious to do all I can to make the voluntary work of the board as easy as possible. Naturally, that would be the Minister's attitude, but I cannot bind myself to anything like this, which would be impossible.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:—
To delete all words after the word "may" in line 20 to the end of the section and to substitute instead the words "note the name of any book in the course of importation and the name of the author or editor thereof for the purpose of referring the name of such book to the Censorship Board with a view to the examination of the book by the board".
In moving this amendment, in order to make my position clear, I think I ought to say that I am against the section, but I cannot challenge a division on the section until the section has been debated. I am of the opinion that the section could be bettered, even if it is retained.
The idea of seizing from visitors to the country, or citizens coming into the country, books which have not been censored, is an entirely new one. It does not appear anywhere in the old Act, and I think it is a very dangerous proposal. It is a proposal to which there are many objections. From the point of view of visitors, I cannot think of any argument in favour of it, and there is a very grave danger that it might almost make us a laughingstock. If, as is happening at the moment and may happen very much more frequently before long, a visitor arrives at Rineanna, comes through to Dublin, and after a few days goes on to England or somewhere else, he will certainly have a decided grievance if the gentleman who examines his bag seizes a book which he finds there, having decided, by means of some mysterious X-ray qualities he is supposed to have, that the book may possibly be indecent, or perhaps that he does not like the name of the author or the title of the book. I think that is wrong. I also think it will cause a good deal of unpleasantness. It surely is not necessary to censorship to provide that the books which are to be censored have to be stolen from a visitor, or seized, if you like. First of all, they are that person's property. There is no provision in the Act giving power to anybody to go into bookshops and seize books. In fact, there is no provision anywhere inside the State to seize books when you get a report that somebody thinks they are books which should be censored. Personally, I think this section is introducing a really bad principle. Assuming that the object that the Minister had in introducing this section was not really to take books from people but to get another way by which names of books could be submitted to the Censorship Board, I have put down this amendment which would have the effect of giving the preventive officer the power of taking down the name of the book for the purpose of submitting it with a view to examination, and I really think that should meet the case.
There is a proviso that censored books may be taken. That is quite different. A book which has been censored, or a book which is obviously obscene, can be seized. The provision that you can seize censored books has applied ever since the last Censorship Act. The provision that you can seize obviously obscene books has been, I think, 50 or 60 years in existence. It is in an old British Act. But where an indecent book which is not on the censored list is being seized, the customs officer will naturally be careful, and will probably consult his senior. We all know the kind of book which can be seized under that provision, and I doubt if there is anybody in the State who objects to it.
My suggestion, first of all, is that it is bad to seize books; secondly, that it will cause unpleasantness with visitors who are passing through. A book could not possibly be censored in the couple of days they are here. Surely it will meet the purposes of the Censorship Act to give powers to take down the name of the book. I think it is pretty well known that the preventive officers who examine baggage at the ports are one of the lowest-paid classes under the Department of Finance. It would be out of order if I were to develop that point, but I think they are rather underpaid having regard to the kind of work they have to do. I believe that for some time they get a commission on any articles the export of which is prohibited, and which they seize. I do not know whether the Minister intends to give them a commission on the number of books they may seize. Altogether, they are not the kind of persons who have the peculiar adaptability or the peculiar qualifications—I doubt if there are any persons who have—necessary to judge a book in the couple of minutes spent in examining a bag, and to decide: "This is a book which I ought to seize". No harm can be done by taking the name of the author and the name of the publisher of the book. It could be dealt with by the Department of Justice, or possibly by the Censorship Board itself, in cases where they would like to get a copy of the book for examination. I cannot see any possible objection to that.
Comment on this
I rise to support this amendment, and I do hope it is one which the Minister will see his way to accept. It occurs to me that what we are really being asked to do is to legalise the haphazard confiscation of personal reading matter by people who, as Senator Douglas has said, from the very nature of their work have not got the training which would be necessary to enable them to do the work that this clause would give them power to do. Frankly, I am very much concerned about the effect on the increasing number of people who are coming into the country, for short or long stays as the case may be. I think they would be so indignant at the embarrassment that this action would cause that they would constitute a very bad advertisement for the country. I am wondering whether the Minister himself does not hold the same view as I am trying to express —that this is a case where, in our efforts to get at the few who may transgress by bringing in their personal luggage something to which reasonable objection might be taken, we would incur the animosity and rightful indignation of the many thousands who would be bringing in books that could be put on the table of this House or of any other house as being "fit and proper", to use the words which have become hackneyed here in the last few days. We spent a lot of time yesterday debating whether the Censorship Board shall consist of three people or of five people, and whether their acts should then be subject to supervision by another board consisting of three or of five people. Does not this clause, as it stands at the moment, in fact set up hundreds of unknown censors, because once a book is seized the censorship is in operation? Whether the book is returned or not does not really matter to the person who has had his property taken. So I do sincerely hope that the Minister will see his way to accept this amendment, if, indeed, as has been suggested, he cannot see his way to delete the section entirely.
Comment on this
I hope that this amendment will not commend itself to the House. The supporters of the amendment, so far, have really made a case for its rejection, to this extent: that they visualise a big influx of visitors to the country—it may be just for a few hours' stay or it may be for a few days' stay or a few weeks' stay, but they are not going to be ordinarily resident in the country. Now, if each person decides to take in a book of the kind the circulation of which we wish to prevent, does it not follow that we might as well drop altogether this idea of the control of the circulation of books? For that reason, I do not think there is any necessity to debate this, and I think the people supporting the amendment have made a case against it. We have accepted the principle of censorship, and the acceptance of this amendment would cut across that principle and prevent us from doing the thing we want to do.
Comment on this
I wonder has Senator Liam O Buachalla understood what Senator Douglas and Senator Summerfield said? The particular question here is that when my luggage is being examined a custom officer who, as has been pointed out already, is underpaid and over-worked, may take out of my luggage a book which I am not bringing in for sale or distribution, but for my own personal use, in order to refer that book to the Censorship Board. Let me point out to Senator Ó Buachalla that if the book is on the list of censored books, the customs officer can take it out, but not under this section. This amendment does not interfere with the right to take out books that have been already banned by the board. The section here refers to other books, and surely it is an extraordinary power to give an unfortunate man who, as I say, is over-worked and underpaid and who, in the nature of things, can have no qualifications whatsoever for judging whether a book is fit or proper reading matter for me or, indeed, for my children.
The Minister himself is well aware of, and his predecessor was aware of, and we all recognise the great difficulty that there is in finding members for a censorship board. Everybody agrees with the principle of censorship. It has been agreed to in practically every country in the world. The difficulty is the difficulty of operating a Censorship Act, and here you leave it to one of the lowest-paid officers in the State to decide, on a summary examination at a port on a winter's morning, whether a book is indecent or not. You leave it in his hands to say: "I am taking this book and sending it to the Censorship Board". I think that anybody who would have to undergo such a thing would regard it as a very insulting personal performance. It is very degrading for a person to be told: "This book is unfit and I am going to take it from you and send it to the Censorship Board". The result from that would be very bad indeed.
Let me say also that the whole purpose of the Bill is to prevent the sale and distribution of such books. If I have in my house books which have been censored, nobody can come in and take them from me, as long as I am not selling or distributing them, and therefore the answer of the person concerned at the port: "I am bringing in this book for myself", should be a sufficient answer, but the section makes no reservation whatsoever. Another point that strikes me is in connection with Section 6, which directs the board as to what it has to do when it is coming to its decision, and there are a number of provisos. For instance, it says that the board, when examining a book, shall have regard to the following matters: "the literary, artistic, scientific or historic merit or importance, and the general tenor of the book." Now, how can an unfortunate customs officer in Dun Laoghaire have any regard to "the literary, artistic, scientific or historic merit or importance, and the general tenor of a book"? All he sees is something that he does not like and that he thinks the board may be interested in, and he stops the book. I think it is entirely unworkable. What makes me more anxious to support Senator Douglas' amendment is this: I do not really have any qualms about this section because I do not think it will work, and I am really sure— although one should never make prophecies even in the case of a Dublinman like the Minister—that the Minister himself feels that nothing new will happen. In other words, you are putting into the law a dead letter, and that is what strangers would call very Irish. There is also a proviso about the language in which the book is written. Now, the customs officer, I am pretty sure, is a person who knows English, but possibly does not know Irish. He probably would not know Irish, but if he did, would he allow me to take in a copy of "Cúirt an Mheadhon-oidche"? because I do not think he should.
Comment on this
First of all, I should like to point out to Senators that there is nothing new about this at all. As a matter of fact, under the Customs Consolidation Act of 1876, a customs officer could seize books which were obscene, and that power has been there ever since and has been exercised by customs officials since this Censorship Act was passed. There is just a doubt as to whether the rights they had under the 1876 Act survive when there is a Censorship Board. That is really all that arises here. I certainly do not like the idea of anyone's personal luggage being searched in that way, but my information, notwithstanding what we heard from Deputy Dillon in the other House, is that it very rarely happens. By far the greater number of the books which do go to the board are stopped at the ports by customs officers when they are coming through the post or on consignment to booksellers.
Comment on this
I know that it is not, and, as I say, the taking of a book out from personal luggage only occurs in the case of a book which is obviously obscene. Not alone has that been the practice here, but I am told that in every country in the world there is such a power to stop grossly obscene books. That power has been exercised here ever since 1876. There is nothing here to interfere with that power if a book of that kind comes along, and it is only a question as to whether it would be legal. Of course, the question is more complicated now when you have an appeal board. If I could find some way of seeing that a passenger's personal luggage would not be searched or that a book which he had in his hand would not be taken from him, I should like to do so, but I would certainly not like to allow people an opportunity of evading the old Act.
Comment on this
No. I daresay, of course, that it would be difficult for an officer to decide whether a book was obscene or not—I suppose it would have to be illustrated before he could say offhand that it was obscene. Otherwise, I do not see how a person, unless he had read the book, could say that it was obscene. I would again remind Senators that that power was there already and has been exercised by the same type of persons they are complaining about now. I do not think we have had any complaints about this thing, except from Deputy Dillon in the other House, and I think he was imagining a lot of it. He said, I think, that a Reverend Mother gave a certain book to some old lady. Personally, I do not believe it, and I think that was only his imagination. However, the purpose of this section is only to remove any doubts as to the powers of these people. I am told that they very rarely stop books, and the Revenue people, with whom we have consulted on the matter, say that this is necessary in order that the provisions of the other Act would be effective. Nobody wants that type of book brought in. I do not see how I can provide that nothing, will prevent the operation of the 1876 Act and, at the same time, stop people interfering with personal luggage. I think it would be very difficult.
Comment on this
Perhaps it is not fair to ask the Minister, but has he got by him the term of reference in the 1876 Act? Is it "grossly obscene"?
Comment on this
"Indecent and obscene". Of course, there is a provision that it is a good defence to prove that the book is not for sale or distribution.
Comment on this
But still a book could always be seized under the old Act. We would be really going back on something which was here before the censorship of publications was thought of at all. I am sure Senator Douglas does not want that either.
Comment on this
I have a great respect for the eloquence and imagination of Deputy Dillon, but I object to this proposal being associated with him or having it suggested that this has got anything to do with him. I did not hear his speech and I did not read the debate that took place in the Dáil. The Minister may be astonished at that, but I did not happen to read it.
Comment on this
As we are all concerned with preventing people reading certain things, I will take the hint. I am glad to find that we can recommend something worth reading. In practice, I may say that I do not read debates in the Dáil on Bills which are to come before us, because I find it is far better to take a Bill and put your mind to it. In that way you are far more likely to light on something which may be important. I find, in practice, that the reading of debates has the effect sometimes of making me think this is hopeless unless I read something in the Minister's reply. When the thing is put in a completely different way, very often it meets with approval. If the Minister would provide that nothing in this Act shall be held to invalidate the operation of this old section, I would not object.
Comment on this
That is not an unusual form or practice. I do not want to stop what is happening at present. There may be odd cases of some ultrazealous officials who can give a bit of trouble when they see a book being brought in. In the majority of cases they only look at the title and, if they are doubtful, they will look up the list. I do not think there has been any abuse of this. I certainly would not like any remark of mine to suggest that, in general, there has been any abuse of it or want of courtesy on the part of our preventive officers. Taken on the whole, I think they are a very good set of officials, having regard to all the circumstances. Even during the war I had to make trips out of this country about four times each year and therefore I have a certain amount of experience. I respectfully suggest to the Minister that, while I do not doubt what he intends, he is doing considerably more in this section than maintaining the present position.
If the Minister will look into the matter, I suggest to him that the first step simply is to see whether it will not meet the case to put in, "Nothing in this Act shall invalidate or be held to invalidate the operation of" and then quote the old section. I believe that will meet the case so far as the operation of the old Act is concerned. If he is not prepared to do that and if he insists on this section, then I suggest that he should amend it—I am assuming that it is to remain as it is in general terms—to provide that, if the book is found in the personal luggage of any person, it shall not be removed and that only the name of the person shall be taken. It would not have the same serious effect if there was the right to take one book out of 100 books consigned to Messrs. Eason. Messrs. Eason would have a different view about that, but it would not have the same effect, at any rate. It would not be quoted outside and we would not be described as low meddlesome busybodies. A book, copies of which come into a firm in quantities, is obviously intended for ultimate circulation. If there was a delay so that it should be censored— I am not speaking in favour of it— it would not have the detrimental effects which could occur in the case of a book which is seized from personal luggage. It is important to remember that the reason I used "stealing it from a person" was because it is not an offence to have a book even if it happens to be censored. It certainly is not an offence to have a book which might conceivably be censored. It is still less an offence to have a book which a preventive officer thinks might be sent to the Censorship Board and that is all we are dealing with as the Bill stands. It is an offence to import it for circulation or distribution. I have no reason to think that there is any extensive importation of single books in personal luggage for the purpose of distribution. But I should like again to make it clear that I am not proposing and there is nothing in these amendments to suggest that the present provision by which a censored book can be seized——
Comment on this
I know there is a case to be made for that. I am not dealing with it for the moment. It might save time if, with your permission, Sir, I briefly refer to the next amendment, which I will not move. It has relation to the same matter and the case I want to argue is that the Minister should look into it. If, as I say, he is not prepared to adopt my suggestion and provide simply that the provisions of the old section shall be maintained, then I suggest that he should certainly make it clear that you cannot seize a book which is the property of a person who demonstrates, by showing his passport, that he is not a citizen of this State. That would, I think, be better than nothing. With your leave, Sir, I propose to withdraw these two amendments and put them down again for the Report Stage, not for the purpose of arguing them again, but in order to see whether the Minister will provide some alternative.
Comment on this
Before the House agrees to allow these amendments to be withdrawn, I want to make one or two comments. In the first place, I am amazed at times at the extent to which some Senators allow their imaginations to run riot. On other occasions I am amazed at how simple they can be. It has been suggested here that the main objection to this is that the ordinary customs official is not a fit and proper person to make an examination of the kind intended in this section. The same thing might be said with regard to customs inspections generally—that these officials are not competent to decide whether certain articles are contraband or not. The argument that these men are not littérateurs or linguists does not hold water, because at any customs station where there is reason to believe that there is likely to be imports of certain articles which are contraband there is surely a senior officer to whom these things have to be referred. Surely in the service there are linguists and men capable of seeing by a glance at a book whether it is one which should be referred to the Censorship Board or not.
I am not speaking of this in any vague sense, as I have experience of it to some extent. It is not so easy as some Senators may think to shock me in regard to some of these matters. Some years ago, as I mentioned before, a small very unofficial body of Senators inquired into this question of censorship and the circulation of certain books and periodicals, and I saw placed on a table here a load of literature that was shocking. You merely had to turn over one page of some books to find that they were grossly indecent. No man can tell me that the ordinary customs official by turning over the pages of a magazine and seeing, on occasions, pictures, which are included in the scope of this Bill, is not a competent person to decide whether such a periodical or publication is one which should be referred to the Censorship Board. Within the last few days a certain publication was put into my hand and I was told to look through it. I looked at its table of contents and, acting according to that table, I read just two pages, page 9 and page 12. Any man who had gone through the fourth or fifth book in the national school, glancing through those pages, would have no hesitation in the world in deciding immediately that this was something which should never be allowed to circulate in the country, but was a document or publication that should be referred to the Censorship Board for review. The Minister has promised to examine this point, but I hope he will consider very carefully whether he should weaken his Bill by altering one syllable of the section as it stands.
Comment on this
In the course of this discussion, all Senators have referred to one book in personal luggage. I do not see anything in the section referring to personal luggage and I assume that "book" can be interpreted in the plural. Those who have tried to pass customs officials know that it is not a case of one, but of several articles where there may be an endeavour to pass them through. I would like to have that point clarified. This may be a question of a trunk full of books in the custody of some individual. Does that mean that, because it is personal luggage, it cannot be interfered with? Again, the definition "book" in the beginning of the Bill does not include a periodical. It says "every printed publication which is not a periodical publication". It seems to me the section is not wide enough at all unless it covers both periodicals and books, so as to deal with a trunk full of periodicals brought in here with an ulterior motive as well as a trunk full of books. To my mind, this section is very necessary. It is not a case where we are drawing the long bow about one book in one person's luggage or in one person's hand. We must interpret the section to include any number of books, and I would like it to be interpreted to include any number of periodicals also.
Comment on this
It seems to me that Senator Douglas is more than usually näive in the language of his amendment No. 26:—
To add to the section a new sub-section (3) as follows:—
(3) Nothing in this section shall authorise an officer of customs and excise to seize a book which is the property of a person who is not a citizen of the State and who states that he does not intend to take up residence within the State.
He may be a "bagman" or a commercial agent and this may be a specimen copy which, though he is not a State citizen, he will show to citizens of the State, with a view to getting orders therefor. There is a way of getting the ordered stuff through and evading the Act. A bookseller here may book orders for a book selling in London and send to the publishers the names and addresses of the various persons who have booked with him and direct that a copy is to be posted to that person, to the private address given. In that way many copies may come in.
Again, if we are to have this amendment reconsidered, something stronger than "not State citizen" ought to be introduced. I quite agree that he can show that he is not a citizen of the State by producing his passport, but there should be something equally efficient to show that he is just passing through.
A consequence of sending the name of a book instead of the book has not been considered by itself. If the book, not the name of a book, is to be censored, then the Censorship Board must secure a copy of the book. What does that entail? I know that, during the war period, it was impossible frequently to get a book of which we had been made aware. A friend comes to me and says there is an abominable book circulating in one of the libraries here and that he himself got it out to test it. Well, the board is helpless. It is aware of the circulation of this book, it is aware that there are lists of waiting readers with this particular library, but the board can do nothing.
I mentioned on the Second Reading the allowance that is provided for books. Would it be in order to refer to that again? I think it is closely connected with the working of this proposal, namely, what capacity the censorship board will have, without further expenditure. In 1941 and 1942, the board was provided with £20 per annum for the purchase of books. In subsequent years, by the generosity of the present Minister for Justice, it was increased to £25, but in 1945/46 it was reduced again to £20. It may be remembered that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs——
Comment on this
I would like to ask if the money allowed actually was spent. I understand it was not spent and so the amount was reduced.
Comment on this
I was coming to that. The money was not all spent. That is perfectly true. The library subscription for the board amounts to £12 12s. 0d. When that is subtracted from the amount, £20, it does not leave very much. When you remember that we had to receive from one Office the enabling of the purchase, and that conditioned also by obtaining another Department's permission, it works out that, in the last few years, during the emergency period, the surplus money was practically useless: By the time the board had the money, the book was no longer to be had—"sold out". I am merely raising that to show that the amendment does, in effect, propose an increase in State expenditure. My amendment was ruled out of order, on the point that it proposed to involve more expenditure of taxpayers' money. So does this, because the books must be provided. There is another important consideration. There are five members of the Censorship Board under this Bill. Almost invariably in the previous operations of the Censorship Board only one book was available, which had to be circulated among the five members, several of them, if not all, busy men. That accounted for the delay, which has been censured so often by our various critics—the delay between publication of a very objectionable book and the appearance of its name in Iris Oifigiúil. There is bound to be a lapse of time. So that, as a matter of fact, there should be an amendment by the Minister to the effect that the board should be supplied with sufficient funds. I think that was in the mind of Senator Summerfield—that the board might achieve more than it did; that it should get, as we say, a move on. That necessitates the supply to the Board of Censorship of more than one book; yet here is a proposal that it is sufficient to initiate proceedings by supplying the name of the book. There is a conspiracy against a book being got, because it has frequently happened that we have attempted to buy a book—does someone challenge my term “conspiracy”?
Comment on this
Not quite the same thing. Shall I put it that there is concerted action to frustrate our getting a book? All these practical considerations have to be taken into account, I humbly suggest to the Minister, before he considers this amendment anterior to the Fourth Reading.
Comment on this
I think the Minister's explanation with regard to the Act of 1876 would indicate that I was right in thinking that comparatively few instances occur, particularly with regard to personal luggage. I sympathise with the Minister's position under the Act of 1876, but I suggest that what Senator Douglas has said is probably sound, that it would be better to provide that the section of the 1876 Act will still be operative rather than give the matter new life by what might be a wider interpretation of the beginning of sub-section (1) of Section 5 of the Bill.
I did not imply, in any way, any criticism of customs officers. My experience of them is that they are both competent and courteous in their own sphere but, excepting the Censorship Board people, who are carefully selected and difficult to get, they are the only people under this Bill who are entrusted with this kind of duty. Nor am I actuated, as I think has been suggested, with any desire to increase the number of indecent or obscene books in circulation in the country. That is not my desire. I am the kind of person who can arrive at Dun Laoghaire with a trunk of books—I have arrived there from Paris with a case full of books—and I would hate to have Senator O Buachalla censoring them. I may add that the books I brought from Paris were not purely for pleasure—they were part of my job; French was my job. I think the Minister's suggestion is a sound one and we can leave the matter over; but nobody criticises the operations of the customs officers.
Comment on this
I would like to point out that the reason the customs officers are mentioned is that it is mainly through importation that these books are brought in, and they are the people who handle them. As regards expenditure, I would not like to think that any board would be held up by the niggardliness of the Department. I asked was the money that was allowed expended, and it was admitted it was not spent, although it was not very much. Within certain limits—I cannot make a promise that every request by the board will be met; I have somebody else to consult before I could do that—any reasonable request will be met. I would like to say that, because we may have difficulty in getting people to accept membership of the board, and if they believed that they were to be starved, as it were, it might be more difficult still.
Comment on this
No member of the board attributes niggardliness to the Minister for Justice; we blame the Department of Finance.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27:—
In sub-section (1), line 46, before the word "examine" to insert the words "read and".
The object of this amendment is to strike at a practice which, I understand, has been prevalent, of presenting the Censorship Board with a book in which passages are marked, so inviting the busy members of the Censorship Board to take a rapid glance at the passages, to judge the book upon these passages and not to consider whether it is, in its general tendency, indecent and obscene. I venture to suggest that there is not a play of Shakespeare's, and probably there is not a part of the Old Testament in which you could not mark passages and, if you presented them, and the books were not considered as a whole, they could be classed as indecent and obscene. The reason of the amendment is that I am anxious that there should be a statutory obligation on the censors to read the book and see whether, taken as a whole, it could be regarded as, in its general tendency, indecent and obscene. I need say no more.
Comment on this
This—and I hope it is not unparliamentary language to continue what I was about to say—is particularly silly. It has no regard to the situation as an actuality. There are more books submitted to the Censorship Board than books complained of as indecent and obscene. There are books that, from the first page to the last, are devoted exclusively to the advocacy of contraceptives. All books do not require to be read from cover to cover; it is quite sufficient to see that it is devoted to the advocacy of the extinction of life and the book is condemned. If Senator Kingsmill Moore thinks that is a violation of the law, we all plead guilty to having violated the law. It is unnecessary to read any further than to discover the fact that it is the advocate of murder or of abortion or any of these things mentioned in a subsequent section.
Again, there are other books in which are at intervals continuous pages, five pages, seven pages, of the grossest obscenity. Has that book necessarily to be read right through to discover if it is indecent and obscene? The Senator insults the board by adding "read" to the requirement "examine", as if under the term "examination" is not to be included all that is involved to fulfil the purposes of the Act. I hold that where the law lays it down, the members of the board are to do certain things, the demand made upon them by the Act is a reasonable demand and, consequently, can be carried out reasonably.
Comment on this
In answer to the Senator, I think his point seems to be perfectly good in regard to these books which are submitted for censorship under (b) of Section 7. But that does not cover books which are submitted for censorship on the ground that they are, in their general tendency, indecent and obscene. I again say that it would be very possible to submit—in fact, there would be no difficulty at all in submitting—the majority of the plays of Shakespeare with marked passages in which you could find things that, taken in their isolated context, are indecent and obscene — and no one knows that better than the great Shakespearean scholar who has spoken. But, if you regard the play as a whole, those passages fall into their natural perspective and the context, so far from being indecent and obscene, may have an entirely different effect. I object to many of the books on the present censorship list being on it for that particular reason.
I would like to know what the attitude of the learned professor would be to the remarks of the nurse in Romeo and Juliet, or to some of the remarks of Hamlet when he was addressing Ophelia. They are indecent and obscene taken by themselves, but in their contexts they preserve a true picture of human nature which it is the great object of the dramatist and the novelist to present. The learned professor says, in regard to the books he is talking of, that from the first page to the last page they are advocating contraception or advocating abortion. Well, if he knows they do it from the first page to the last page, I presume the learned professor is one of the noble exceptions who does read every book from beginning to end.
Comment on this
If that is so, the Senator should really support me, because he accepts my view that it is a duty to read a book through; but I do not think the Senator will go so far as to say that, in his opinion, all books which have been condemned as indecent and obscene have in fact received that thorough examination by all members of the Censorship Board. If a book is presented with definite marked passages, human nature being what it is—none of us wants to do much more than he has to do, because we all have a lot to do—you are inviting people, quite frankly, to take the short and easy way, just as I fear the House is inclined to take the short and easy way of interfering by prevention instead of the positive way of teaching and exhortation, you have no provision in the Bill which imposes it as a definite statutory duty on people to read the book as a whole and to form their opinion of it as a whole, where they have to decide whether it is in general tendency indecent and obscene, you are inviting people to succumb to the weaknesses of human nature.
Comment on this
I think the amendment is entirely unnecessary. Surely the board will do everything necessary to come to the conclusion as to whether a book is or is not indecent and obscene? I am sure the Senator did not intend to insult any member of the board, and if the provision had been put in in the beginning, it might have gone unnoticed, but after a debate like this, if it were to be accepted, there would be a direct implication that the board had not properly examined a book, and, therefore, I think the Senator should not press it. I could not accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I feel that something on the lines of this amendment is necessary and I so feel by reason of past experience. How, for instance, could a book like Land of Spices ever have been banned, if it had been properly read as a whole? I do not think the Senator intended by the literal expression “read” that it should be read without skipping a word, but I do think that what he has in mind is the attitude of the conscientious reviewer. I once said to a reviewer: “How do you do your work? Do you read all books from cover to cover?” He replied: “I cannot say exactly that I do, but I always turn every page and I have the facility of taking in the substance of every page without reading it literally.” That is what we want the censors to do and I do not think we have had that done in the past. If it had been done in the past, I cannot conceive how certain books which are on the censorship list ever found their way there, after being examined by men who had any conscientious approach to their duty.
Comment on this
It is undoubtedly ruled by amendment No. 25. I thought that, if the amendment by Senator Douglas were accepted, it would be necessary to introduce this as a consequence.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:—
Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section (2) as follows:—
(2) When examining under this section a book in respect of which the complaint made is that it is indecent or obscene, the Censorship Board shall have regard to the following:—
(a) The Constitution, Article 40, Section 6, sub-section 1º, with especial reference to:
"The State shall endeavour to ensure that organs of public opinion.... shall not be used to undermine public order or morality. The publication of... indecent matter is an offence which shall be punishable in accordance with law".
(b) The expression "indecent or obscene" as applied to a book includes, besides its accepted meaning whatever is of lecherous, lewd or lustful character; or of a nature likely to deprave and corrupt readers whose minds are open to such immoral influences, and into whose hands the publication might fall, thus ultimately subverting morality in the State.
(c) Due care is to be taken to distinguish what are bona fide contributions to scholarships and the sciences, works for use in the learned professions, from publications which masquerading under the guise of imparting instruction, present to the general public details of sexual relations and sex aberrations; likewise to distinguish from literature what under the pretext of realism in Art gives undue preponderance to the sex element.
This is a proposal to introduce still further injunctions to members of the Censorship Board. In Section 6 (2) of the Bill as it stands, injunctions directive of the members of the board in their work of examination are set out in detail. The sub-section says:—
"When examining a book under this section the Censorship Board shall have regard to the following matters..."
I venture to add, in this new sub-section, still further considerations which I suggest should be present to the minds of those who censor books officially.
Comment on this
I wonder if the Senator will allow me to make a point of order with regard to part of his amendment? I do so not with any ill-feeling towards the Senator but on the general issue.
Comment on this
I should like to put it to you, Sir, that the quotation of an Article of the Constitution, or any part of an Article of the Constitution, in an amendment is undesirable, for this reason, that the Constitution is a fundamental and overriding document. All Acts of the Oireachtas must be read in the light of the Constitution and all boards must work under the Constitution. Therefore, if the practice of citing the Constitution by way of special direction to particular boards, set up under Acts of the Oireachtas, were to be allowed, it could be carried so far that a great many Acts would be burdened with such unnecessary quotations.
I put it to you, Sir, that a quotation from the Constitution is never necessary in an Act, because the Constitution is always present. It is always an overriding consideration and therefore must always be taken into account. To take a particular part of the Constitution and to say: "You must consider this", is unnecessary, and, therefore, I suggest, not in order. I make the point with no reference to the merits of this amendment, but because I think that, when we have a written Constitution, we should not quote that written Constitution in our Acts. It is unnecessary to do so.
Comment on this
On that point of order, I may say that I was myself in doubt about the admissibility of this amendment in which portion of an Article of the Constitution is recited. I would view with uneasiness the introduction of a practice under which in amendments to Bills of a general character, it was considered necessary to include excerpts from the Constitution. The Constitution is fundamental law and in the light of it all ordinary legislation must be construed. However, as the recitation in this instance is by way of terms of reference to the Censorship Board, I am prepared to give the Senator the benefit of the doubt and to allow the amendment to be moved in the terms in which it appears on the Order Paper.
Comment on this
The quotation here is part of an Article which the mover of the amendment deems to be pertinent. I suggest that that introduces an element of doubt and uncertainty and that it is not the proper way in which the Constitution should be used. The Constitution is a document which has to be considered as a whole. It is always present. It must be present to the mind of a judge when giving a decision or to the mind of a board when carrying out its functions. If we are to be allowed to discuss particular parts of the Constitution set down by way of amendment, the practice, as you have yourself indicated, is a bad one.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, there is no proposal to discuss the Constitution. My amendment presupposes that the Constitution is accepted in every word as the fundamental, organic law in this State. I have permitted my friend, Senator Hayes, to speak against my amendment before I had an opportunity of explaining it.
Comment on this
The laws of God are supposed to be present to the mind of everyone who professes to be a Christian and yet we have a Censorship Board to prohibit the sale and circulation of obscene books.
Comment on this
May I make this point before you rule, Sir? I did not say a single word about the merits of this amendment and it is most improper for Senator Magennis to say that I spoke against his amendment before he had explained it. I did no such thing. Independent of the merits of this amendment, I deprecate the insertion of part of the Constitution in an Act. With regard to discussing the Constitution, we can, of course, discuss the Constitution. Anybody who likes can say: "There is another part of the Constitution quite different from this."
Comment on this
On the point of order, may I make this point that it is inadmissible to quote in another Act as if it were an isolated sentence a portion of a sentence which does not stand by itself? I am not suggesting that the Senator has in any way deliberately left out portions of it. In fact he has so indicated by dots, although he has not striven to conceal that he has not sedulously striven to reveal all. The Article begins:—
"The State guarantees the right of the citizens to express freely their convictions and opinions..."
Then come the exceptions:—
"The education of public opinion being however a matter of such grave import to the common good, the State shall endeavour to ensure..."
The learned professor has not only left out the leading part of the Article but also the portion of the sentence which explains the subsequent part, the word "The" with capital T as if his quotation were the beginning of a sentence, whereas in the text the word "the" comes after a comma and is a subordinate sentence.
Comment on this
I had already adverted to these points. The point of order taken by Senator Hayes is, in my view, well taken, and I think we have had a fairly good indication of what the practice would lead to, if it were to continue. If discussion such as this were permitted, then we might have pages of the Constitution read to the House, and that could only end in confusion of debate. The Constitution is fundamental law.
Comment on this
Yes, in this particular instance, but I am glad to have been afforded an opportunity of stating the views of the Chair.
Comment on this
If Senator Hayes is not too subtle to allow his intelligence to work he will see from the amendment that it begins: "When examining a book under this section." This is an exhortation to be mindful of what is quoted. I could quote Senator Hayes, if this discussion is to proceed, against Senator Kingsmill Moore. According to Senator Hayes every word and syllable of the Constitution is present to the mind of every law-abiding citizen.
Comment on this
According to Senator Kingsmill Moore it seems to be offensive to call the attention of citizens to the fact that there is a Constitution.
Comment on this
May we get clear what the ruling is? The ruling is that the amendment may be moved but that it initiates a very undesirable practice. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Yes. The reference to portion of the Constitution is allowed as a term of reference, but the fact that it is, is not to be taken as a precedent for the future. This is the first occasion on which a case of this kind has arisen in this House. The Chair could not allow this to become a settled practice for the reasons I have stated.
Comment on this
In the Principal Act and in the present amending Bill, the Censorship of Publications Board is exhorted to keep certain things in mind, to entertain in fact all relevant circumstances and considerations in respect of a book undergoing examination, and I, by this amendment, seek to remind them of what they must take account of, the great broad principle set out in that Article of the Constitution. If in examining a book the charge is made that it is indecent and obscene, then they must note what was the intention of the Legislature generally in respect to books that contain indecent matter. I deny that the introduction of this as something to be taken into consideration invites in the slightest measure eager members to discuss the Constitution. No one can stand up—not even Senator Hayes—and say: "I deny the overruling consideration put forward here." He would really be out of order at once. He would be considered a very bad citizen. This reminds the censors that there is a Constitution and that they should conduct themselves agreeably with its terms.
The main consideration I desire to impress upon the attention of the Censorship Board is this:—
"The expression ‘indecent or obscene' as applied to a book includes, besides its accepted meaning, whatever is of lecherous, lewd or lustful character; or of a nature likely to deprave and corrupt readers whose minds are open to such immoral influences, and into whose hands the publication might fall, thus ultimately subverting morality in the State."
I owe the passage beginning "or of a nature...", which I have quoted, to a lecture on "Obscene Literature" given by Sir Edward Tindal Atkinson, K.C.B., C.B.E., Director of Public Prosecutions. It was published in London by Christophers. May I quote further from the work from which I have taken this expression? He refers to the case of Reg v. Hicklin, 1868, and says:—
"The case is of much importance as containing a statement by way of definition of obscenity, viz., ‘the test of obscenity is whether the tendency of the matter published is to deprave and corrupt those whose minds are open to such immoral influences and into whose hands the publication might fall'."
The statement is taken from Judge Cockburn's findings in his determination of the case in 1868. Perhaps Senator Kingsmill Moore requires the reference. It is from law reports, 3, Queen's Bench, page 367. This statement says:—
"The director of prosecutions is still recognised"
—that is in England—
"as laying down as the test to be applied."
I may have occasion to refer to that again. The test that is thus adopted in the English courts was approved of in Geneva at an International Conference with a view to having an international code in respect of obscene publications, for suppressing them. It was quoted with approval by the French representative and the Indian representative as the most successful attempt to do what is very difficult, almost to the extent of impossible. That is to define what is obscene. "The expression ‘indecent or obscene' as applied to a book, includes, besides its accepted meaning, whatever is of a lecherous"—that is an exceptionally gross form of indecency —"lewd or lustful character; or of a nature likely to deprave and corrupt readers whose minds are open to such immoral influences, and into whose hands the publication might fall, thus ultimately subverting morality in the State." Paragraph (c) of the amendment might be regarded as a parody, in some respects, of the injunctions already made in the principal Act and in the amending Bill. It says:—
"(c) Due care is to be taken to distinguish what are called bona fide contributions to scholarship and the sciences, works for use in the learned professions——”
That reservation, by the way, if I may interrupt my reading of the paragraph, is contained in the first part of the Principal Act.
"from publications, which, masquerading under the guise of imparting instruction, present to the general public details of sexual relations and sex aberrations; likewise to distinguish from literature what, under the pretext of realism in Art gives undue preponderance to the sex element."
Comment on this
I do not think this amendment is necessary. I think that the matters which the board is expected to have regard to, and which are set out in Section 6, are very wide, especially when one bears in mind that under paragraph (e) the board is to have regard to any other matters which appear to them to be relevant. I think, therefore, that everything is covered, and that due regard will be had to the Articles of the Constitution. I think that the amendment, if accepted, would overburden the measure with something that is not necessary at all. I think that any person who is considered fit to be a member of the Censorship Board will feel bound to take these matters into consideration in deciding whether a book is indecent or not. I consider the amendment unnecessary, and, therefore, unacceptable.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 30:—
In sub-section (2), to delete lines 51 to 54, and substitute instead the following:—
(2) The Censorship Board when examining under this section a book the subject of any of the complaints implied or contemplated in Section 7 of this Act should take proper account of the following, or any other relevant considerations:—
(a) the literary or historic importance of the work.
In the amending Bill it is provided, in sub-section (2), paragraph (a), that the Censorship Board when examining a book under this section—remember, that includes all the books that are to undergo examination; it includes not only those which are complained of as being indecent and obscene but those which, under Section 7, which follows, are to be condemned as advocating the unnatural prevention of conception and so on, shall have regard to
"the literary, artistic, scientific or historic merit or importance, and the general tenor of, the book".
What I am proposing in this amendment is that:—
"The Censorship Board when examining under this section a book the subject of any of the complaints implied or contemplated in Section 7 of this Act should take proper account of the following or any other relevant consideration".
That is to say, I am lifting up what is now paragraph (e), and including it in the general note. I am proposing to amend by substituting for "the literary, artistic, scientific or historic merit or importance, and the general tenor of, the book", the words "the literary or historic importance of the work". I object to the "general tenor" of the book because it implies that every book to be examined has a general tenor. That may appear to be meticulous criticism to anyone who has not been engaged in this work, taking into account beforehand what criticism of his censorship might be made by his fellow citizen. In any case, it is a misuse of language to say "literary or artistic" because literature is one of the fine arts, in the eyes of many the foremost. To say, "literary and artistic" is to help in the corruption of the English language. Ignorant writers apply the term "artistic" only to painting. There are Fine Arts, and literature and painting are two of them. We are concerned here purely with what is printed matter—"book" is defined here as printed matter. The amendment proposes that the Censorship Board shall have regard to the literary or historic importance of the work. If they have due regard to these two considerations Senator Moore's fears for Shakespeare and the Bible will disappear. Since the legislation now known as the Act of 1929 was first proposed, that suggestion of fears for the Bible has been in general circulation. Some have suggested that the board set up now might ban the Bible and ban great literary masterpieces.
I have a more serious objection which, in the course of that deputation to the Minister that previously I referred to, I presented to him. The implication in this is—in the Principal Act it was —that in some way the examiner of the book in connection with which the complaint is made that it is indecent or obscene was to set off the indecency by considerations of literary, artistic quality. I pointed out to the Minister and I have the happiness to have lived many years since to make it to him again for his consideration—we are the only civilised country in the world that declares in its legislation that indecency, obscenity, may be set off by artistic considerations. The words that I used to the Minister then, I repeat. We have not been provided with a table book. We have not been provided with a sliding rule. I know the table book says: "16 ounces one lb.; 14 lbs. one stone" but I do not know how much of obscenity is to be set off by a corresponding amount of literary quality.
I was rung up, by the way—I hope the anecdote will be forgiven—by a journalist to inform me that the Censorship Board uniformly breaks the law. I had the patience to listen to him although I could have put the telephone out of operation instantaneously. His point was that we did not set off literary quality against indecency. I pointed out to him, as I point out again to any similar critic, that the Act which we were working under was an Act to prohibit the sale and circulation of unwholesome literature; we were not literary critics to any further extent than to consider while a work was obscene, it was so fine a masterpiece that it might be considered that ordinary readers ordinarily susceptible of unwholesome influences would be repelled by its very excellence and would not desire to read it and so escape.
Comment on this
It could happen. As a matter of fact, on many occasions we took into account the cost of the book. If the book was published at 18/6 or at 12/- we considered that was not likely to have circulation except possibly through a library and that at the same time the library might not care to invest in it as it would not be likely to be taken out except by special readers. I think that all the precautions that are needed to protect the Bible and Shakespeare are contained in my amendment—"they shall take into account the literary or historic importance of the work."
Comment on this
I may be unduly stupid but I cannot understand this particular amendment. It seems to me that Section 7 provides the only action that can be taken by way of censorship. Therefore, every book that is submitted can be dealt with by means of Section 7. Where this amendment differs from the Bill as submitted in that respect, I cannot understand.
Comment on this
My suggestion is that Section 7 provides two grounds on which a book can be censored and the only two grounds that are provided in the Bill. Therefore, any books submitted, it must be contemplated, can be dealt with under Section 7. I, therefore, do not understand what the Senator is driving at by introducing a reference to Section 7 in amendment No. 30, which applies to Section 6.
Comment on this
Would the Senator permit me to correct him? I had introduced a new sub-section which was devoted exclusively to works complained of as indecent and obscene and in view of that I had to make the other reference clear.
Comment on this
I understand that this has reference to an amendment that has since been withdrawn?
Comment on this
That means that the real effect of the amendment is in the substitution of the words "literary or historic" for the words "literary, artistic, scientific or historic merit or importance, and the general tenor of the book". I cannot see that that is any improvement. I do not at all agree that the inclusion of these words in an Act means that this State is stating that you are to allow a book through which is indecent because it is historic or because it is literary. It means that in deciding whether it is or is not indecent you take all these various considerations into effect. If the Senator's argument is that you decide a book is indecent and then you let it off because it is artistic, that applies equally to the words he retains, if his argument is sound, which I do not think it is. I think he has rather argued against himself. I see now the reason for the amendment—it is connected with a previous amendment that has since been withdrawn—but I do not see what possible gain you have by reducing the words in paragraph (a), and I hope the Minister will retain the words in the Bill.
Comment on this
Senator Magennis made a remark which made me think and urged me to seek for further information. I understood him to say that this Act is confined to printed matter.
Comment on this
I should like to have further information as to the extent to which this Bill applies to artistic reproduction. There is one book that has been censored and the only grounds that I could discover for its censorship were that it contained certain illustrations. The book was entirely free from any sexual suggestions whatever. I refer to Shaw's Black Girl in Search of God— blasphemous, I grant you, but in no way dealing with matters of sexual morality. I should like to know where we stand in the matter of artistic reproduction. For instance, possibly from Senator Magennis's rather victorian, old-fashioned outlook——
Comment on this
——he would condemn certain works of French artists. Would he consider that the picture, "Olympia", by Manet, was indecent? Certainly many people would. Would he consider that the board had power to censor a work containing pictures of that kind, irrespective of their undoubted artistic merit? I do think this is an important matter because we are not within reach of the end of the depredations that censors may commit and I am now very concerned as to what action the censors are likely to take and what their attitude is towards works of purely artistic reproductions.
Comment on this
I thought that this amendment would have fallen with the other amendment, because they provide for much the same thing. The experience of the board has, I think, been that the direction in Section 6 was sufficient to enable them effectively to deal with any books they considered obscene or indecent. I imagine that everything contained in Section 6 would be present to their minds and, probably, other factors would be present to their minds as well. Therefore, it is not necessary to change the provision nor is it necessary to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I am very glad to have the Minister's approval, so graciously expressed, of the Censorship Board. I am trying to remove, so far as possible, the future censorship board from the range of unjust criticisms. If the Minister is satisfied that this provision which, as operated by the Censorship Board, has been effective in the past, will be quite sufficient for the future, I shall not contest that opinion and, out of respect for the Minister's view, I shall withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I should not like to predict that this will stop criticism. I am quite satisfied that, whether deserved or not, you will get somebody to criticise.
Comment on this
I move amendments Nos. 32 and 33:—
32. In sub-section (3), page 5, line 8, to delete the word "may" and substitute instead the word "shall".
33. In sub-section (3), page 5, line 9, to delete the word "may" and substitute instead the word "shall".
The Minister is either going to accept both these amendments or he is not. I suggest that the word "may" should go out in those two places in sub-section (3) and that the word "shall" should go in. The sub-section would then read: "When examining a book under this section, the Censorship Board shall communicate with the author, editor or publisher of the book...". If you are about to destroy the fruits of a man's labour, you should, at least, let him know. In the second place, if the author, editor or publisher makes a representation, the board, under my amendment, "shall" take it into account. It is no use asking a person to make a representation if it is to be thrown into the wastepaper basket.
Comment on this
I think that this would be an unreasonable burden to place on the board. The vast majority of those books are not worth bothering about. They are mere rubbish and I do not think an obligation should be placed on the board to notify every author, editor or publisher that they propose to ban this book. If the book be of a type which suggests that that course should be taken, then the board have power to take such action. It is better to have the power permissive than mandatory.
Comment on this
That is as regards the first "may". If the board do get a representation, it should be mandatory on them to consider it.
Comment on this
It is not encouraging to authors, editors or publishers to tell them that, if they send in a representation, it may be entirely ignored and thrown into the wastepaper basket without being taken out of the envelope. That does not suggest that atmosphere of fair-mindedness which should characterise the operation of the Act.
Comment on this
I am certain that if a board, consisting of responsible persons, receive such a representation, they will consider it.
Comment on this
If that be so, there should be no objection to putting in the word "shall".
Comment on this
The objection is to making it obligatory on the board to do so. I think that it is better to leave the matter optional.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 34:—
At the end of sub-section (3), line 10, to add the following words:—
"In every case where the author, editor, or publisher is known to have an address in Ireland the Censorship Board shall send a letter to that address stating that the book is being examined and shall allow a reasonable time during which representations may be made to it."
I have a slightly different point of view from that of Senator Kingsmill Moore. I am not so much concerned with sending notification to authors from all over the world whose books may be under examination as I am with the sending of notification to Irish authors whose address is known. That is a perfectly reasonable proposal. The other proposal would, I think, be too wide, seeing that books may be printed anywhere and many of those under examination would not be of much importance. In dealing with our own citizens, there should be an obligation on the board to send such notification if the author is resident in Ireland— and, by "Ireland", I mean not the Twenty-Six Counties but the Thirty-Two Counties.
Comment on this
The same objection applies to this proposal as applied to the last proposal. If the board think that there is nothing to be inquired into, that the book should obviously be banned, they should not be compelled to send such a notification. If there is any doubt about the matter, I have no doubt that they will communicate with the author. The same objection applies to this amendment as to the last amendments, though the burden would not be so great under this amendment.
Comment on this
There is a peculiar difficulty regarding this procedure. The moment the Censorship Board notifies the publisher that such a work is under examination, the publisher, well aware of the spicy stuff it contains, will have ample time to notify the booksellers to clear off their stocks. He may advertise, by suggestion, without reference to the fact that it is being examined, that the book may, possibly, be banned and that it would be better to make a purchase now. I do not think that he would be so frank as that, but some of the more daring of the publishers might. It is not at all desirable, in the public interest, that publishers should be notified that a work is under examination, but I agree with Senator Douglas that, in a case where the Censorship Board has decided to issue a prohibition order, especially where an Irish author or publisher is concerned, it would be well for the board to notify him that they intend to issue such an order. I have an amendment down to that effect later—the issue of a prohibition order unless, within ten days, certain things, which are set out, happen.
Comment on this
I am not satisfied with the Minister's attitude towards Irish authors. The number of Irish books examined, according to the information we have had, is but a small proportion of the total. If Senator Magennis's argument is to be taken literally, then it is an objection to the whole section and the section should be taken out.
Comment on this
There is no sense in using the word "may" if the thing proposed is a dangerous thing to do. It is a mistake to give the idea that this will be done in a number of cases, as you do when you use the word "may". I am reasonable enough—the Senator may not agree—to admit that there are certain kinds of books, very few of which are written by persons resident in Ireland, to which his remarks might apply. The books by Irish authors I have seen—they are only a small proportion of those censored—were, at least, open to argument. They were border-line cases. They were not books which the public would rush to buy because of a rumour that they were about to be banned. So far as my information goes, certain libraries have whispered around that such a book has gone to the Censorship Board. That may be done without any ulterior motive. It may be done as a matter of ordinary gossip, but it would be calculated to do more harm than would a note sent by the board to the author or editor. I have in my amendment the word "publisher". I appreciate the Minister's point with regard to publishers and I would be quite willing to take that word out, because frankly I do not think that, as a rule, the same conditions apply as in the case of authors or editors. I think that in the case of an author or editor, if he is resident in Ireland notice should be sent to him.
Comment on this
I am not saying that it should not. What I am saying is that the board should have a discretion. If they wish to send notice, they have power to do so under the sub-section. What I am objecting to is the proposal to make it mandatory because even an Irish author may write a book of such a character that the board may not think it worth while to communicate with him in this way.
Comment on this
I merely want to have the word "shall" inserted because I do not think that one Irish author should be treated differently from another.
Comment on this
In connection with the next amendment in the name of Senator Campbell, I think the House might also consider the second part of amendment No. 54 in the name of the same Senator.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 35:—
In sub-paragraph (a), line 13, to delete the words "in its general tendency" and after the word "obscene" in that line to insert the words "or subversive of public morals."
I am moving this amendment for the purpose of making more definitive the form of words which the Bill proposes should be applied as a test by the Censorship Board as to whether a book shall, in their opinion, having been duly examined by them, be prohibited sale and distribution in the State. Briefly, my amendment is intended to get rid of that contentious formula which constitutes the test that must be applied before an indecent or an obscene book or a periodical publication is permitted to set out on its mission of disseminating its obscenity and its indecency throughout the State.
Those who have so far taken part in the debates on this Bill have expressed a wide difference of opinion—an honest difference of interpretation, maybe—as to what this formula really means. Apparently it satisfies neither those who favour censorship of indecent and obscene literature nor those who are not opposed to the sale and distribution of such literature. That there has been a wide difference of opinion in regard to the interpretation of the formula which forms the basis for the board's report on a book or a publication, and which the amendment I am submitting to the House proposes to delete, is clearly evident from the widely-divergent views expressed during the Second Reading debate by, on the one hand, Senator Kingsmill Moore, and, on the other, by Senator Professor Magennis. During that discussion Senator Kingsmill Moore stated that the Act had been operated with complete disregard to the wording of the Act which, he contended, required that, before a book could be banned, it should be in its general tendency indecent or obscene. The learned and distinguished Senator went on to say:—
"I maintain that no five rational men could have banned, under that formula, the books which have been banned and that if the question had been open to be put before the courts as to whether it was conceivable that the books could come within that description, the decision would have been reversed by the courts, not merely because they differed from the Censorship Board but because they considered that no five men, regarding the words of the Act, could reasonably have come to such a conclusion."
On the other hand, Senator Magennis, dealing with the report formula—"in its general tendency obscene or indecent"—told the House:—
"This phrase ‘in its general tendency indecent', is one of the bugbears of the Press, of authors, of members of the board and of the Department of Justice. It is an artificial thing. A citizen complains that a book is indecent or obscene. Surely the issue to be tried is ‘Is it indecent or obscene?' and the report should be ‘complaint sustained' or ‘complaint rejected'. Why are we confined to an artificial finding—that the book in its general tendency, is indecent? The board has reported to the Minister and to the Department again and again— both personally and in writing— against this but no regard is paid. There it is in the new, supposedly amending, Bill..."
Thus we find two members of this House, eminent in their own respective professional spheres, diametrically opposed in their conception of what the words "in its general tendency" are intended to convey. It does seem to me, then, right and proper, after the 16 years' experience gained in the operation of the 1929 Act, that now, when the working of the Act during that period has made manifest the weaknesses in it—weaknesses some of which the Bill before the House proposes to remedy — the opportunity should be availed of to remedy the outstanding defect and weakness in the whole measure.
There is, I submit, ample evidence available, and we have it on the authority of those best qualified to give an expression of opinion on the matter, and whose views cannot lightly be thrust aside or disregarded, that most of the difficulties which have arisen in the administration of the present Act have been due in no small measure to the difference in interpretation as applied to the words "in its general tendency", in so far as these words condition the formula to be applied as to whether a book or a publication should be prohibited sale or circulation within the State.
This formula seems to me to be the pivot round which the whole question of censorship of obscene and indecent literature revolves, and unless it is altered in the Bill before the House in no unequivocal manner and in such a way as to obviate any further need for argument or inquiry as to what the words do mean, then I suggest our last position in respect of censorship of obscene and indecent literature will be worse than that which obtained under the 1929 Act, and I am greatly afraid that censorship of evil literature will not operate, as I think it originally was intended it should operate, to the common good of the overwhelming majority of the people.
Apparently, the interpretation of these words which constitute the report formula has provided a constant conflict between those who stand, and, in my opinion, rightly stand, for a rigid censorship of obscene and indecent literature, and those who are opposed to any censorship, even of obscene and indecent literature, and who contend, as we were told in the Second Reading debate, that all censorship is a thing which in principle is rooted in evil and that the system of censorship that has obtained up to this has produced nothing but irritation for the people of Ireland and amusement for cultured people outside our country. Personally I have failed to notice any manifestation of irritation on the part of the people of Ireland in regard to the censorship of obscene and indecent literature; but perhaps the learned and distinguished Senator who made that statement and I are just as much at variance in our conception of who constitute the people of Ireland as we are in our interpretation of what is obscene and indecent literature. So far as the amusement which the worthy Senator says we have provided for those whom he describes as "cultured people outside our country" is concerned, they are welcome to all the pleasure to which their possibly perverted sense of humour entitles them. If we are contributing something to the gaiety of nations by adding new names to the list of what the Senator has told us has come to be known as "everyman's guide to the modern classics," but what most people in this country call indecent and obscene literature, then I think the least that those who are striving to stop the circulation of this filth are entitled to do is just to smile complacently.
The amendment which I am submitting to the House is intended to make the report formula simple to understand and easy to interpret. The one which it seeks to replace has been, as I have shown, a bone of contention since it first appeared in the Act of 1929. How such a formula ever came to appear in that Act passes my comprehension, having regard to the Constitution of this State. If the report formula is permitted to remain in its present form in the new Bill, then I think our difficulties in defining what is indecent and obscene literature will increase rather than diminish. Those increasing difficulties will arise from a variety of causes. This Bill proposes for the first time to set up a censorship board of appeal. To that proposition in itself, as I said during the Second Reading debate, I have no objection, but I did warn the House that in my opinion there was inherent in the setting up of such an appeal board a number of difficulties that might endanger and frustrate the whole purpose which the Bill was intended to serve. It would appear to me, at any rate, that unless the present formula is replaced by something along the lines suggested in the amendment which I have just proposed, there inevitably will be many and serious conflicts of opinion in regard to the interpretation of the words I am moving to delete. Inevitably, I think, the Censorship Board will come into conflict with the appeal board.
Again, difficulties will arise from the fact that abroad there has been a general lowering of moral standards, and a change in outlook in regard to what is decent and what is indecent. I cited in the Second Reading debate a case which was listed in the United States Court of Appeal, in which it was ruled that there were no absolute and enduring standards as to what was indecent and what was obscene, and that the border-line between obscenity and decency changes with the times, with the public taste in literature, and with the public attitude towards sex matters. I think we may feel pretty certain, therefore, that cross-Channel publishers, and those with financial interests in those undertakings, will not be slow to avail of every opportunity before the appeal board to secure a change in the order first issued by the Censorship Board. The position will be materially changed when, under this Bill, those publishers will be entitled to go before the appeal board. Under the Act as at present administered, the Minister himself constituted the appeal board, and had power to revoke or alter an order made by the Censorship Board. I have much more confidence in the Minister, who is noted for his sound common-sense and courage, than I would have in any appeal board. The Minister probably does not want the job, and I do not blame him; it is not a very enviable job.
The line of arguments advanced in this House has convinced me that a determined effort will be made to wipe out censorship in this State, and I will not be surprised if at the end of five years censorship has disappeared. Some people profess not to be very worried about this. I think it was Senator Baxter who said last night that the people of the country are more concerned about material things. I must say I was amazed to hear a statement of that kind coming from Senator Baxter, whose background I think I know. I think he is somewhat of an expert on social and, if I may say so, moral questions.
We have had references to the opinions of the Archbishop of Canterbury and of the Archbishop of Dublin. When we cite the Archbishop of Dublin, I think it ought to be made plain that a particular Archbishop of Dublin is referred to. Senator Kingsmill Moore, on the Second Reading debate, mentioned the Archbishop of Canterbury—we all knew whom he was referring to there—and then referred to the Archbishop of Dublin. Yesterday he told us that in the daily Press there were letters from clergymen protesting against censorship. Anyone listening to those references in the House would be liable to assume that those were clergymen of the Catholic faith. I think it is desirable that there should be a distinction made in those matters.
Comment on this
There were protests from them, too—in person.
Comment on this
I have never seen any reference to them. However, that does not make them right. They can be wrong just as the Archbishop of Canterbury or the Archbishop of Dublin can be wrong.
Comment on this
To my mind, if this is allowed to go through in its present form, censorship is in jeopardy. Perhaps I was wrong in my interpretation of Senator Baxter's reference to the matters in which the people of this country are interested. So far as I understand the people of this country, I would say that they have more regard to purely moral considerations than to material considerations. Pope Pius XI himself says in regard to politics and politicians that one ought not to be disinterested in politics when politics means the interest of the common good and not the interests of particular individuals. That is the attitude I take in regard to the Censorship Bill. It may be due to my ignorance, or probably to other reasons, but I feel very keenly about this matter. As I said, it passes my understanding how such a formula could have found its way into the legislation of this country. Senator Sir John Keane yesterday told us that 90 per cent. of the people of this country read only the newspapers. That is a most exaggerated statement. If he said that only 10 per cent. of the population bought books I might agree with him, but when he says that only 10 per cent. of the people read books I think he is understanding the position.
Comment on this
Well, I accept that. I do not want to make any point about it, but the percentage struck me as rather significant. Listening to all the points made here about "everyman's guide to the classics", one would imagine that there are no decent writers in this country or in Britain. There must be a considerable volume of literature extent both here and in Britain, but, listening to the speeches here, one would imagine that nothing was worth reading except those books listed in "everyman's guide to the modern classics". I am quite certain that a considerable percentage of the 10 per cent. has already read the modern classics. We all know the onslaughts on morals which have been made in this country. Every bit of filth that could be shifted into this country was shifted in. We know of the difficulties——
Comment on this
Being shifted in at present, yes. Well, if the people who have advocated the abolition of censorship had their way, we would be flooded with that filth. There are difficulties, but the Government is only the servant of the people, and I should imagine that the commonsense of the great mass of our people, who have no use for this filth, would show deep public resentment at the abolition of censorship and would resist any attempt to do away with it. I would prefer to have the Censorship Board, even with the difficulties that, in my opinion, will become manifest as soon as it gets into operation, along with the appeal board. We had references on the Second Reading from Senator Magennis in regard to the Censorship Board itself. He said: "There is no possible censorship——"
Comment on this
We are not dealing with the Censorship Board in this amendment, Senator. Would the Senator try to come to the amendment?
Comment on this
Well, if I am out of order, Sir, I shall say no more.
Comment on this
Perhaps, Sir, it would help to shorten the debate if I would be permitted to indicate my attitude to the amendment?
Comment on this
I would be prepared to agree to part of the amendment: that is, the part which proposes to delete the words "in its general tendency", but I could not agree to the other part of the amendment, which is, to insert the words "or subversive of public morals". I think that what Senator Kingsmill Moore said about that was quite correct: that it could include such things as drunkenness, gambling, and other such things, and, accordingly, the amendment would be too all-embracing as it stands. However, as I have said, I would be prepared to accept the part of it referring to a general tendency towards indecency. I say that I am prepared to accept that if it would shorten the debate.
Comment on this
That would also meet amendment No. 36.
Comment on this
I understand that the amendment is not withdrawn?
Comment on this
Senator Campbell would have been more convincing to me if he had named even one book that escaped censorship under the Act which should have been censored in the interests of public morals. I feel that the Act should be operated in a way that would show how vast its activities have been and how, in spite of this limitation of "general tendency", it can practically censor any book it pleases. Does the Senator want to censor classics which may be obscene in one page or two pages, or even in a few lines? Would he say what books he has now in mind that are not covered by the present Act, and that would be covered by his amendment? In any case, the Minister has stated that he is prepared, to accept portion of the Senator's amendment, and so I do not think it makes much difference, but I do not think it would be possible for the Minister to accept the whole of the Senator's amendment, because the amendment uses the word "or" and not the word "and". A book might be subversive of public morals on matters outside sex altogether. The words in the book, as Senator Kingsmill Moore has pointed out, might not be indecent or obscene, but might be held to be subversive of public morals in such matters as drinking, gambling, and so on. If the amendment is accepted in its present form, it would mean that every form of morals—sexual, social or otherwise—would come within the ambit of the Censorship Board.
Professor Magennis rose.
Comment on this
I am sorry, Senator. I had called Senator Douglas.
Comment on this
I was quite willing to give way to Senator Magennis. However, I should like, first of all, to say that I do not share in any sense the extraordinary pessimism displayed by Senator Campbell. I do not believe that the Minister, or any other Minister who may succeed him, will appoint five members of an appeal board who, to take the Senator's word, will allow this country to be flooded by filth. If I thought that for a moment, I would try, to the best of my ability, to get rid of that Government immediately, instead of wasting my time on a discussion of the Bill.
As far as I am concerned, I do not think it matters whether you have the words "general tendency" there or not, and my reading of this matter is that you are going to make it harder by this to get a book censored. For instance, if there are three or four sentences in a book, or one page of a book, which might be objectionable, a strict interpretation of the words would say that that book is not obscene in its general tendency. Quite obviously, one sentence, or even one page that might be objectionable, would not mean that the book was obscene in its general tendency; but that might be the interpretation. Personally, I do not feel that it is necessary to tighten this up, because I do not believe that the interpretation of words will mean much unless it is a judicial interpretation, and I think that a judicial interpretation would make it clear whether a book comes under the Act or not. If the Minister is prepared to accept that portion of the amendment, well and good, but as regards the second part of the amendment—and I do not think Senator Campbell was present when it was discussed previously—there is scarcely anything that could not come under it. As an example, I have a very large number of friends who hold, very deeply and sincerely that sweepstakes and advertisements for sweepstakes are subversive of public morals. That is an arguable point. It was argued at length in connection with another matter in the other House. Now, it would be quite possible to have members on the appeal board who sincerely believed that it was their duty to prevent the sale of any book or periodical which had advertisements for the sale of sweepstake tickets. I do not think that Senator Campbell realised that.
Comment on this
May I deal with my amendment No. 36 at the same time as Senator Campbell's amendment?
Comment on this
The Minister has accepted portion of that amendment.
Comment on this
Well, I was hoping that, by accepting that portion of the amendment, I might save time, but I was evidently wrong—it was a vain hope.
Comment on this
The fact is that I have a contribution to make to the debate on a matter that has not been heard before this, and if the House decides against me, I shall be disappointed. May I point out that what has been overlooked is the difference between the general tenor of a book and what is called the general tendency of a book? Furthermore, a book may be indecent or obscene—grossly obscene —and yet it might be held by quite reasonable men, not trying to make acute points, that it is not in its general tendency indecent. For instance, if I may resort for support to this work that is a favourite of mine —the lecture given by the Director of Public Prosecutions in England at King's College, University of London, in a long dissertation on obscene literature—the writer draws the attention of the law students whom he was addressing to the two classes of literature, the publication of which, he says, "in the last few years has increased in a remarkable degree"; and he mentions, firstly, "books which, while masquerading under the guise of scientific works, purport in extreme detail to lay before the public the subject of sexual relations and aberrations."
Comment on this
Might I point out that the Minister has already accepted the portion of the amendment dealing with this matter of general tendency, and so there is no necessity for debating or discussing that?
Comment on this
Well, then, as regards all these clever sophistications about the term "public morality" and its range of connotation and denotation, what are we discussing? In the Principal Act and the amending Act in relation to the Principal Act, what is dealt with is sexual morality, morality in regard to the relations of men and women. One has to read every term in the amending Act as governed by that consideration and, consequently, when Senator Campbell, puts in the words "or public morals" he is drawing attention to the fact that this Parliament does not attempt to interfere with the individual life. That is the express significance of "public" in the text. It is not intruding on the vie intime as it is called. While there is permission for the importation of a book which is intended for a man's own use, it is not admitted at all that because the book is for his own use, it ceases to be an indecent and obscene book. But we are not going to dictate to the individual what he is to read or what he is not to read. In that particular sense, where we are dealing with a man and a book, the Minister can grant him a licence. I say, with all consideration of its import, that it is plain and unmitigated sophistication, sheer sophistry, to say, that the reference to “public morals” includes sweepstakes, includes betting on dogs and betting on horses. I repeat again and I have finished, we are dealing with an Act, a Principal Act as amendable, and that Principal Act declares that it is to control the sale and distribution of unwholesome literature, and all the rest of it makes it very, very clear that it is unwholesome literature with regard to sex relations.
Comment on this
Before the amendment is accepted by the Minister, I think it would be necessary to give a word of warning to the House as to what the effect of the amendment is. The effect of the amendment will be, of course, that the Censorship Board will not be able to ban books which they previously could ban.
Comment on this
I do not think it will, but I think the House should know the effect of it. If you take out the words "in its general tendency" a book will have to be on the whole indecent and obscene before it can be banned. If the House likes to do that after the warning I have given, then so be it.
Comment on this
That is not in accordance with the opinion that the board received from the Attorney-General of the time at which they made application for guidance to the Department.
Comment on this
I cannot discuss an opinion I have not seen.
Comment on this
You can discuss a great many things in the air. Senator Kingsmill Moore, in his speech on the Second Reading——
Comment on this
We are finished with these amendments. The Minister has agreed to consider amendment No. 35. He has agreed to delete the words "in its general tendency" and give consideration to the other part. He has agreed to accept the Senator's amendment No. 36 on these conditions.
Comment on this
I want to be correct in this. I do not propose to accept the latter portion of amendment No. 35.
Comment on this
Yes, of Senator Campbell's amendment.
Comment on this
It was Senator Kingsmill Moore's word of warning.
Comment on this
I suggest that if the warning came from any other Senator than Senator Kingsmill Moore we would be much more inclined to listen to it.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, Senator Kingsmill Moore, in his Second Reading speech, made the distinct suggestion that the appeal board will have to deem every book which is reported on by the formula "in its general tendency indecent" to be in itself in general tendency indecent. I think the Senator agrees with me.
Comment on this
Might I remind the Senator that the words "in its general tendency" are to be deleted by the Minister and there is no necessity to discuss the matter further? I should like the Senator to go on to the next amendment.
Comment on this
I should like Senator Kingsmill Moore's remark to be on the Official Report of the House lest readers may be deceived into thinking that that was the general understanding. That is my interest in the matter.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37:—
In lines 19-20 to delete all words after the words "they shall" to the end of the section, and substitute instead the words:—"immediately notify, by registered letter, the publisher and author, or editor concerned of their intention to publish the prohibition order unless within ten days of the posting of such letter an appeal in the prescribed form be lodged with the board. On receipt of such appeal, the board shall immediately refer it to the appeal board."
This amendment was spoken of by me incidentally in debating a previous amendment. The intention is to try to prevent as far as possible any irregularity ensuing on—what is quite possible—a lapse of time between the holding of an appeal board meeting and the issue of a notice in Iris Oifigiúil or any other lapse of time which would give the publishers too much latitude in selling off their books. It is really a precautionary measure. There is another implication in it to which I frankly draw the Minister's attention and that is: “unless within ten days of the posting of such letter an appeal in the prescribed form —an appeal in the prescribed form— be lodged with the board”. I direct his attention to the necessity of having in the regulations a prescribed form. I have not seen any provision for that except the general provision for regulations. I think it was Senator Ryan who referred yesterday to the fact that the appeal board as described in this Bill is in the nature of a tribunal and that being so, as the tribunal will be presided over by a judge, there ought to be a certain ritual in the regulations for it.
Comment on this
I think this amendment, as it stands at the moment, would not fit in with the Bill at all, as the only appeal provided in the Bill is from an Order which has been made prohibiting the sale and circulation of a book. Therefore, as the Bill stands, it would not be possible for an author to appeal before the book was prohibited as he could not appeal against an intention. Apart from that, if this were to give the author an opportunity to indicate that he intended to appeal, if the Order were made, and if the Minister thought fit to make all the necessary changes, I would not object, provided that, even if the Order were made, that did not prevent any other person from exercising the right to appeal. However, if this were to mean that the author, having appealed —or having failed to appeal, which is what I am concerned with, as I am not suggesting that, if he appealed and his appeal were upheld, he would make another appeal—another person would be deprived of the right, I would consider it objectionable.
If there is also to be a provision that an author has only ten days from the time the message is sent from the board, it would be most objectionable. It is a common thing for notices not to reach one within ten days. Even if they did arrive within two or three days, that would not give adequate or reasonable time in which to give notice of appeal, and if that were to be the only chance of appeal the author got, it would be most objectionable.
I am quite unable to appreciate the first point in Senator Magennis's argument. I do not see how, in this case, there can be any safeguard because they send a notice of intention. If they do not send any notice of intention and simply censor the book, nobody knows about it—though there may be rumours —until the notice appears, in which case it is illegal to circulate it, and there can be no circulation between then and the time of appeal. If the appeal wins, it may be circulated again, but there can be no circulation in between.
Comment on this
I cannot understand this point. I do not know whether Senator Magennis is more in favour of banning books than otherwise. If the board thought a book should be banned and if we adopt this procedure and assume we could get the publisher within ten days—we must remember he may be in America—and give him the ten days' notice, that means giving him ten days in which to circulate books. As Senator Douglas says, as the Bill stands, once a book is banned it cannot be circulated legally, unless an appeal has been upheld. I think the amendment would delay the whole procedure and make it not illegal to import a book which the Censorship Board intended to ban. The ten days would not be adequate in many cases. It might do in Ireland, but not somewhere else.
Comment on this
Even from that point of view, the Bill is better as it stands. If the board thinks a book ought to be banned, I think they should ban it, and let them take their chance on appeal. This is not an acceptable amendment.
Comment on this
I do hope the Minister will not accept this amendment, as it appears to be unworkable. If the publisher knew that an appeal was about to be made, there would be all kinds of traffic going on, and the stocks of the book would be cleared. The obvious way to do it is the way indicated in the Bill. Let the board make a substantive Order, which means prohibition in law. There can then be an appeal from that Order. That is the only practical way in which it can be done.
Comment on this
I notice that Senator Keane and Senator Magennis have changed sides.