Censorship of Publications Bill, 1945—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 196–395 of 395. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 31 of 1945 ›
I move amendment No. 38:—
To add to the section a subsection as follows:—
(2) In this section the word "advocates" shall be construed to include advertises or in any other manner recommends to a reader, any method, treatment or appliance for use as aforementioned in paragraph (b) of the foregoing subsection.
It is important, in my opinion, thus to extend the meaning of "advocacy". So far as the law stands in England, advertisements are not considered as anything more than mere notifications that things are to be had, and they do not come within the criminal law if they stop at advertising. I hold that to use the circulation of a newspaper, periodical or book to draw attention to the fact that there are such appliances, and that there are such procedures for the destruction of life and for various other purposes to avoid the results of vicious acts, is in a measurable degree an advocacy of their use. If in ordinary conversation A says to B that he is suffering from a bad cold and B tells him of a remedy, who would deny that B is advocating the remedy as something useful for the purpose of getting rid of the cold?
In the case, especially, of such a heinous matter as is here concerned it seems to me not unreasonable but eminently reasonable to say that to publish an advertisement, even though the matter is left at that, is one stage to the writing of a book setting out the uses, the modus operandi and the technique of the employment of that appliance. Therefore, if the intention is really to stamp out these practices, everything that is any aid to the practices should be kept from the notice of the general public.
Comment on this
I am doubtful whether this amendment is necessary, but I will look into it, and, if the Attorney-General thinks it is, I will bring in an amendment accordingly.
Comment on this
The section seems to me to raise a general question as to what should be the public attitude to sex as such and to the size of families. I am quite prepared to accept the doctrine involved in this section that there should be no unnatural method used for the limitation of the size of families. Indeed, it would be ill-becoming on my part, being a seventh child, to advocate any such methods.
I think that all through this discussion there has been implied rather than suggested the idea that sex itself is indecent and was probably the invention of the devil. I would remind Deputies that sex happens to be a divine institution, a particular machinery by which an all-wise Deity devised that the species should be continued. I am reminded of a story, which I think I told on a former occasion, about one of the mistakes which, in the North of Ireland, it is commonly believed the Deity made, and that was when he made the people of the majority religion in this country. I can well imagine that when Senator Magennis was at Sunday school, and when he learned that sex had indeed been created by the Deity, he retorted to his teacher: "He will rue it." I think, though, in his more broadminded moments the Senator would probably agree that sex is a divine institution, and I am sure he would agree that it is a privilege——
Comment on this
Is it in order for a Senator to impute anything of the kind to another member of this House, that, in his better moments, he would accept the Divine Revelation, the words of the Bible, and in his ordinary moods he is a different character?
Comment on this
Even men are variable in their moods, and some of our moods are more elevated than others. I think, however, the Senator will agree that it is a privilege to hand on the torch of life and in that respect the human being has the supreme privilege of co-operating with the Deity in the continued work of creation; but at the same time it is a personal and a social responsibility that the quality as well as the quantity of life that is created should be as good as possible. Consequently, there is another problem constantly before us. Assuming that there must be no unnatural limitation of the size of families, do we approve of the principle of breeding up to the biological maximum?
Comment on this
The Senator is drawing very near to the border line. He is dealing with matters that do not come under this section.
Comment on this
If I am out of order, the Chair is quite capable of stopping me, but I shall try to keep as much within the rules of order as I can. The object of this section is to maintain the purity of the sex life of our people and this Bill is a continuation of an Act which has been on the Statue Book ever since 1929. I submit that, if that Act had been effective in its purpose, it should have shown some results in the improvement of our social behaviour in the matter of sexual relations. If you refer to the statistics connected with these matters you will find that there has been, in fact, no such improvement, or at all events, it is difficult to relate any improvement to the incidence of this legislation. In 1940 there were 54 indecent assaults on females and there were 123 other sexual or unnatural offences, and I do not think that this section, or this Bill as a whole, is likely to show any results which will reflect themselves in those very unpleasant statistics. On the other hand, I do think that there is some relation between crimes of sex and a low marriage rate.
Comment on this
The Senator's remarks would be more appropriate to another stage. He is making a Second Reading speech.
Comment on this
I will postpone my remarks in that regard if I can bring them forward in a more general statement on the Third Reading. There are certain statistics to which I wish to refer.
Comment on this
The Second Reading was the occasion on which the Senator could have done that.
Comment on this
The occasion on which the Senator could have made those remarks has passed.
Comment on this
With your permission, Sir, I should like to suggest that our procedure would be simplified if we were to discuss all the amendments to this section. They could then be put separately and the Minister could indicate whether he was prepared to accept them or not. If you look at the amendments, you will see that they overlap to a certain extent, and it would be much easier if Senator Magennis and I could speak in turn on the amendments without reference to any of the other sections. I suggest that we would get on more quickly and it would be simpler for all concerned.
Comment on this
It is, of course, a departure from the usual procedure, but I understand that there is a general desire to finish the Committee Stage to-night. If we adjourn at the normal hour we have only two hours. Is the House agreeable to adopt the course suggested by Senator Douglas?
Comment on this
Yes.
Agreed.
The following amendments were on the Order Paper:—
39. In sub-section (1), after the word "author" in line 21, to insert the words "the editor".—Senator Douglas.
40. In sub-section (1), page 5, line 21, after the word "publisher" to insert the words "or any club, society, association or other body having among its objects the study and promotion of literature or art". —Senator Kingsmill Moore.
41. In sub-section (1), lines 21-23, to delete the words "or any five persons (each of whom is a member of Dáil Eireann or Seanad Eireann) acting jointly".—Senator Magennis.
42. In sub-section (1), line 23, to delete the words "at any time".— Senator Magennis.
43. In sub-section (1), line 24, after the word "order" to insert the words "issued by the Censorship Board".—Senator Magennis.
44. In sub-section (2), line 25, to delete the words "on an appeal under this section" and substitute instead the words "having duly heard such appeal in accordance with regulations as prescribed".— Senator Magennis.
45. To delete sub-section (3), and substitute instead the following sub-section:—
(3) No second appeal shall lie to the appeal board against a prohibition order, on the plea of being a new, or later, edition of a prohibited book unless the later edition bears a new title not readily confused with the former title of the prohibited book.—Senator Magennis.
46. To delete sub-section (4).— Senator Magennis.
47. In sub-section (4), after the word "author" in line 33, to insert the words "the editor".—Senator Douglas.
48. In sub-section (4), lines 34 and 35, to delete the words "the joint application of any five persons (each of whom is a member of Dáil Eireann or Seanad Eireann)" and to insert instead the words "any of the persons set out in sub-section (5) of this section".—Senator Douglas.
49. To add to the section a new sub-section (5) as follows:—
(5) Any of the following persons may appeal to the appeal board from a prohibition order in respect of a book—
(a) Any Archbishop or Bishop of the Holy Catholic Apostolic and Roman Church.
(b) Any Archbishop or Bishop of the Church of Ireland.
(c) Any person acting on the authority of the Governing Body of any religious denomination existing in Ireland.
(d) Any person acting on the authority of any association in Ireland which, in the opinion of the Minister, was formed for the promotion of culture or the study of literature.
(e) Any person acting on the authority of a trade union.— Senator Douglas.
Comment on this
Amendment 39 in my name deals with a comparatively simple matter. It seems to me that amongst the persons with power to appeal should be an editor, if the book happens to be a book of short stories. He is in a similar position to that of an author. It is a drafting matter which does not require much discussion. I imagine the Minister will not object—at least, I do not know of any reason why an editor should not have the right to appeal. I think it was rather an accident more than anything else that the point was omitted. It is not a matter on which I feel very strongly, but, on reading the Bill, it occurred to me that an editor in such circumstances should have the right.
Comment on this
All the other amendments which I have tabled to this section deal with the question of who should have the right of appeal. I quite agree that an author, an editor and a publisher must have the right to appeal. The question is whether there should be anybody else, and, if so, who. I should imagine, although I have not heard him speak on the subject, that the Minister does not want everybody in Ireland to have the right to appeal, and, if so, I completely agree. A possibly unworkable situation could be created on that basis, but I do not like or approve of the proposal that the onus should be placed on five members of the Dáil and Seanad acting together and I want to give briefly my reasons—I gave some of them on the Second Reading, but the Minister was not here—for objecting.
In the first place, I do not think it fair to put the peculiar duty on members of the Oireachtas of being a kind of guardian of the correctness or otherwise of the operation of the censorship, and I should like the Minister to realise that, whereas this will not be a matter of much importance to quite a large number of Deputies and Senators, there are a certain number who will naturally be appealed to by persons outside to exercise this duty. I may be a person who would be appealed to and frankly I am not going to ask for an appeal in respect of a book, unless I have read it.
I do not want to spend time, which I might otherwise give to public work, reading Bills, etc., on reading books that people, who might be more or less my constituents, think I should read for the purpose of seeing whether they were properly censored or not. It would be worse if I were a member of the Dáil, and had, as many members have, a number of constituents dissatisfied with censorship. I do not think Senator Magennis really meant, in part of his oratory yesterday, to accuse some of us of representing publishers outside the State. It could be almost thought that he did. If he, in the heat of debate, made a speech which would seem to make that suggestion, I think the Minister will agree with me that any Deputy who is asked by a number of constituents to appeal in respect of a book would be placed in an impossible position. If he appeals in respect of a book, he will be accused of trying to introduce filth into the country. I do not think there is the slightest doubt but people will say that he wanted a filthy book made free, and if he refuses he will be accused by another section of his constituents of being narrow-minded and intolerant, and in doubtful cases that he would not be willing even to allow an appeal. After all, it was not for him to say whether it should or should not be censored, but it might be said that he would not even allow a competent board chosen by the Minister to express an opinion, because he would not put his name to an appeal. I am convinced that that is not a position in which members of the two Houses should be placed as, I think, it would operate unfortunately. I do not think the Minister realises that this provision in the Bill means that you are putting on members of the Oireachtas duties with regard to appeal that are not their function. I do not think they are peculiarly suited for it.
What is important is this, that I do not think men representing a constituency should be placed in a position of possible misunderstanding. I do not think it is fair to ask us to take a book which is a borderline one, about which we possibly have doubts, and to decide whether we would put our names down or whether there would be an appeal. I cannot help feeling that the arguments against the insertion of a section of this kind are greater than any arguments that could be advanced in its favour.
The Minister suggested that it was taking the place of the present provision, in which you could bring up and debate in the House the Minister's action with regard to a particular book. I respectfully suggest that it does not do anything of the kind; that it is putting an onus and a responsibility in relation to books which was on the Minister in the past on individual members of the House, whereas the Minister has a staff, has collective responsibility, as well as the Government to protect him in his action while members of the House have nothing of the kind. Assuming that the House agrees with me, and that the Minister or the Dáil could be persuaded that that is not a desirable provision, the question arises: is anybody else other than the author, editor or publisher to have the right of appeal? I think that should be strictly limited. An amendment in my name to Section 8 provides a set of persons who might be entitled to appeal. I do not think there is the slightest danger that an Archbishop or Bishop, or persons acting on behalf of the Churches, would abuse this privilege. I put it down, particularly in view of the suggestion that some churches might be aggrieved. If they have a grievance the proper way is to give them power to make the appeal themselves. I do not want to have an Archbishop or a Bishop, if he has a grievance, ask me to use my name as one of the five. I am not saying that there is anything wrong about it, but I much prefer to give power to defined persons and in addition to the Churches. I suggest persons acting on behalf of an authority or an association, which the Minister believes has been formed to promote the study of literature, and a person acting on the authority of a trade union.
I may be asked why I put in trades unions. I do not see trade unions appealing on books, but my reason is that if authors in Ireland want to have the right of appeal, let them form a properly organised trade union, when they would have that right as a trade union. I think that would turn out to be a much better way of appealing than the individual right. That covers the main points of the amendments to Section 8.
Comment on this
Senator Douglas in amendment No. 48 has already moved my amendment No. 41, and I accept altogether the argument which he made, though I do not accept everything he said. He recalled some speech in which I was so rash in the heat of debate—a thing of which I have no experience whatever—to declare that members of this House who are opposing me were acting on behalf of foreign culture.
I plead not guilty, first of all, to the charge of intemperate heat in debate, and not guilty to using language such as the Senator has attributed to me. I do ask why this solicitude for the foreign publisher. I put that care in contrast with my solicitude for the Irish citizen. However, we will let that pass on this particular amendment. I think that everything that was said in the Dáil against this was absolutely sound. It is not reasonable to add to the other duties and responsibilities of a member of the Oireachtas this: that he can be resorted to in aid of someone who has a particular grievance while the editor and publisher have a statutory right given them in the matter. I think that would be to impose on members a work called by theologians, a work of supererogation.
The next amendment for which I am guilty is amendment No. 42:—
In sub-section (1), line 23, to delete the words "at any time".
Sub-section (1) of the section provides:—
"The author or the publisher, or any five persons... acting jointly, may at any time appeal to the appeal board from a prohibition order in respect of a book."
Surely, that is not reasonable. It is asking too much unless the Censorship Board is to become a court of record and there is no such idea in the Minister's mind with regard to it. I am suggesting that the sub-section might be drafted otherwise to serve its purpose by deleting the words "at any time", so as not to leave it open to an author or a publisher two years or ten years after the event to lodge an appeal. That is exactly what the section as drafted provides.
By amendment No. 43, in sub-section (1), line 24, after the word "order" I am proposing to insert the words "issued by the Censorship Board". The object of this amendment is that, as we are entering upon a new machinery and a new mode of working the machinery, it is highly undesirable to provide for appeals to go back to 1930 when the Act of 1929 began to operate. The acceptance of my amendment, as the Minister will see, would limit appeals to what the new board is responsible for. Otherwise, we shall have retrospective legislation, and I think the whole of civilised opinion is against retrospective legislation where it can be avoided.
Theoretically, as a piece of abstract theory, undoubtedly, I should say that if a wrong has been done it ought to be righted. That would be the principle; but, again on the lines of empirical consideration, the consideration for fact and actuality, I do not see how the section, as drafted, would work, since the members of the board who examined these books and discussed them—and remember discussion was the chief part—are practically all dead. There are only two survivors, so that we have no record of what led in the discussion to the determination of the vote in respect of any book. Furthermore, in the case of an appeal taken back to 1930 one has to think of what has happened in the meantime: all the discussion about books mentioned by name in periodicals, newspapers, and in speeches in the Mansion House and in various other ways. You have had attacks upon the board and on the Minister, and a whole lot of allegations about these books, so that you cannot have a clear appeal as you could have where an appeal is understood as a regular legal transaction. Otherwise you would have contempt of court. The one great excellence in regard to the hearing of an appeal, especially in a matter which is practically a criminal matter, is that there is no contempt of court allowed. The public are not permitted to exercise their right of free utterance and free publication in prejudging a matter that is to be heard by an appeal court, and practically dictate to the court what decision it must arrive at. That is how the whole thing in point of fact exists. While to my mind, on the one side, is the theory and, I hold, a sound theory, that if an injustice has been done a remedy should be open, but the question here is: Can you have a fair, a genuinely fair, unprejudiced and impartial appeal in the circumstances that I have described? Therefore I am introducing this amendment to limit appeals to the appeal from a prohibition Order issued by the new board which the Minister will set up when this Bill becomes an Act.
Amendment No. 44 is:—
In sub-section (2), line 25, to delete the words "on an appeal under this section" and substitute instead the words "having duly heard such appeal in accordance with regulations as prescribed".
Once again I return to this question of regulations. It will crop up in its turn again. The Minister is to make regulations. Many would contend that the board to have freedom and independence should frame its own regulations but I certainly think that this appeal board should have the regulations framed for it by the Minister. Consequently, I introduced this amendment for the purpose of bringing under the notice of the House that this is a desirable matter as regards an appeal that is to proceed on regular lines.
Amendment No. 45 is:—
To delete sub-section (3), and substitute instead the following sub-section:—
(3) No second appeal shall lie to the appeal board against a prohibition order, on the plea of being a new, or later, edition of a prohibited book unless the later edition bears a new title not readily confused with the former title of the prohibited book.
I am afraid that is not quite happily expressed but, with your permission, Sir, I will give an account of the genesis of it. In the first five years of its existence I was chairman of the appeal board for films, and it frequently happened that when the State censor was in difficulties about the issue of a certificate of exhibition he persuaded the film renter to appeal on it and frequently, as the result of our consideration of the film and of the film censor's views about it, we suggested cuts. At that time it was quite easy for portions of the celluloid to be cut out and the remaining sections connected and to show films from which the deleterious or objectionable matter was eliminated. It sometimes happened that we affirmed the refusal of a certificate made by the State censor but agreed to let the film renter bring on a new edition of his film that would be unobjectionable, provided that he changed the title of his film. The reason for that stipulation was that on the grant of a certificate of exhibition to the new, re-edited film, it would be possible for a dishonest exhibitor to exhibit the State certificate on the screen and show the original condemned film. That was quite possible and it had happened.
So, with that experience before me, it occurred to me to suggest—the Minister might make more of it I confess than I, perhaps—that in the case of a second appeal, with regard to a new edition, new in the sense of having new matter in it or new in the sense of being of different format or a cheaper edition, or something of that kind, while it might be allowed by the appeal board to have circulation, it should not be allowed to circulate unless under a different title. Otherwise, one would read or find out on inquiry that such-and-such a book had passed the censor and then the book that had not passed the censor would be substituted in its place. That, frankly, is the origin of my idea and I have explained the object that I am trying to secure.
The next amendment is No. 46:—
To delete sub-section (4).
Sub-section (4) of Section 8 is:—
The appeal board may, on the application of the author or the publisher, or any five persons (each of whom is a member of Dáil Eireann or Seanad Eireann) acting jointly, from time to time vary a prohibition order in respect of a book so as to exclude from the order any edition of that book published after the date of the order and in respect of which no application has previously been made under this sub-section.
I allege that the draftsman has failed in that, that what it is intended to secure is already secured in the preceding portions of the section; that it is quite unnecessary and, furthermore, it is very, very difficult to comprehend.
With regard to Senator Douglas's proposal in amendments Nos. 48 and 49, may I speak for a moment? Again, he proposes to give State recognition to this, that and the other "literary" or artistic society that may be of mushroom growth. If you allow it by Statute to become of right a nominator of a member, in that way you accord it a statutory status which it should not possess. There are bodies in other countries that have that status, that are recognised authorities. That is the objection that I make. "Any of the following persons may appeal to the appeal board from a prohibition Order in respect of a book". Why should we arbitrarily select a person acting on the authority of a trade union? I think I am as consistent and persistent an advocate of trade unionism as any trade unionist in the land, but I cannot see any particular aptitude for judgment upon books and morals belonging to a trade union rather than to any other association. The employers' association might say: "Well, thanks to the labour of the trade union, we have leisure hours; we are patrons of literature".
Comment on this
I should like to ask Senator Douglas does the term "trade union" in his amendment include employers' trade unions as well as workers' trade unions?
Comment on this
"Trade union" to the best of my belief has a legal statutory meaning. It would apply only to a body that is registered as a trade union.
Comment on this
I do not think I need labour the point. Senator Douglas and I agree upon one of the main themes and, for the sake of that agreement, I will refrain from further criticism.
Comment on this
I find myself in a very distinct difficulty because I would be prepared to support both Senator Douglas and Senator Magennis in taking out the provision whereby an appeal can be made by five members of the Oireachtas, being perfectly well aware of the fact that it would be an intolerable nuisance but a nuisance to which I would be prepared to expose myself unless I felt that there were some other provisions being made giving an opportunity to appeal to persons other than the author or the editor or the publisher.
For instance, where a book is not likely to have a large sale in Ireland, it is highly probable that neither author, nor editor nor publisher would worry about putting down £5 and taking an appeal. I have already—on the Second Reading—referred to the banning of some volumes of Proust. There are probably not more than 40 persons in Ireland who would be likely to read Proust although his is recognised by everyone as being amongst the half-dozen great novels of the world. It would not be worth while for the editor of a translation of Proust to appeal and yet it might be vital to ensure that Proust would not be eliminated for all time from the consciousness of the Irish people. The saying came to me when Senator Magennis was speaking, a saying which, I think, is somewhat inaccurate but which he, with his greater knowledge, will be able to correct—"He who kills a man kills a reasonable creature, made in the image of God, but he who kills a good book kills Reason itself, the image of God itself, as it were, in the eye." Therefore, it is absolutely necessary that there should be an opportunity of appeal in those people who are interested in great literature and in great books. For that reason, I should deem it intolerable that this Bill should not be extended to allow the questioning of some of the monstrous bannings which have taken place. Further, I think that an appeal should be open in respect of each edition, because, otherwise, you are definitely ensuring that there will be taken out of the consciousness of this nation books whose value may be infinite for literature, for science and for art.
I have been much impressed, in the course of this debate, by the fact that, with the exception of Senator Magennis, Senator Douglas, Senator Fearon and myself, no person here had made the least attempt to read the index of censored publications, analyse it or consider what books had been banned. Instead of that, it seemed to me that we, in this House, did, in fact, give what might be truly called an indecent exhibition, because, whenever the word "censorship" was mentioned, together with the highly-coloured and meaningless adjective, "filthy," everybody rose and followed the standard. They did not examine the standard; they did not inspect it to see whether it bore the cross of freedom or the crooked cross of repression. In my opinion, there are people here, people who represent bodies of culture, people who represent the forces of labour, who are crying for freedom but who have unwittingly followed the banner of the Swastika and lent their voices in favour of repression, not knowing what they were repressing, not considering what was being repressed but thoughtlessly and helplessly, because they made no attempt to ascertain——
Comment on this
It is not advisable to comment on past proceedings of the House.
Comment on this
I shall not do so, but I do not think that one of those people knew or realised what he was doing. It is for that reason I am so anxious to have this appeal available for each edition. I do believe that, if people who have spoken here in favour of the principle and practice of this censorship had done what it fell to my lot to do—to spend about a fortnight of my time endeavouring to analyse the nature of the books which had been banned, endeavouring to read some of them, endeavouring to make cross-analysis of them by authors and by subjects—they would not have spoken in favour of the provisions of the Bill but would have been supporting my amendments. Therefore, if this provision in respect of five members of the Oireachtas is taken out, I appeal to the House and to the Minister to secure that people who have the time to consider these matters and who are interested in literature and culture will be enabled to appeal. Otherwise, you may be doing a very great injury in wiping out of the consideration of our people a book which may be a great book and a good book and a wholesome book. I consider that books which are great and good and wholesome have fallen under the ban of censorship.
Comment on this
I do not know that the arrangement made for dealing with those amendments was the arrangement best suited to me. However, I shall do my best to deal with them. I shall take the amendment dealing with the five members of the Oireachtas first. I brought in that provision for much the same reasons as those stated by Senator Kingsmill Moore. It might happen that the publisher and author of a book would have no interest in the reading public in Ireland. The circulation here might consist only of a few volumes and they might not bother about it. I imagine that that provision will not be extensively used. Authors and publishers will, I think, appeal if they consider they have a case. It is only in the circumstances mentioned by Senator Kingsmill Moore that it might be used—circumstances in which only a few people would be interested and in which it might be desirable—I do not say it would—that there should be an appeal againt the decision of the censorship board. I do not know any persons more representative of public opinion than the members of the two Houses of the Oireachtas. It is suggested that this provision may put members into difficulties but we are all in difficulties at times. We have to turn down applications of many kinds every day of the week. If we are not prepared to do that, the sooner we make up our minds to leave public life the better.
Comment on this
There is no compulsion on a Deputy or a Senator to act in this regard. They are perfectly free. Having been elected by the people, we are the most representative persons in the country, and I think that we shall have a due sense of responsibility—much more responsibility than would be forthcoming under Senator Kingsmill Moore's amendment, No. 40. If I were to accept that amendment, I could imagine an association being formed which would appeal in respect of virtually every banned book. I doubt very much that those referred to in amendment No. 48—the heads of churches—would be anxious to have those powers. I think they are quite satisfied with the representation provided in the two Houses of the Oireachtas.
I agree that this proposal entails an extra responsibility for Senators and Deputies, but I think I am right in saying—I do not know whether I mentioned it in the other House—that up to the present, and until this Bill is passed, every Deputy or Senator has a right to put down a motion calling on the Minister to revoke a prohibition. That right was availed of only once, but still the right was there and it is as some sort of compensation for the loss of that right that the present proposal is brought forward. I am not inclined to give way on it at all. Very few cases will arise in my opinion in which it will be necessary to avail of that provision. I think it is a remote possibility, but it might happen that some book might be banned which, in the opinion of some five Senators or five Deputies, should not have been banned, and if they did feel that way about it, they ought to have the right to ask the appeal board to review the prohibition. The editor or the author might be foreigners and might not be at all interested in the reading public here. After all, it is our business to look after the rights of the ordinary citizen. If five responsible elected representatives feel that a wrong has been done, I think they should be at liberty to have the matter reconsidered. That was the reason I put down that amendment. I think they are the only type of persons who should have that right of appeal outside the publisher, the author and the editor. So much for that proposal.
There is then the question of the phrase "at any time". As the Bill stands at present, any book or publication that has been banned at any time by the censorship board will become a banned book or publication under this Bill and, consequently, there will be the same right of appeal in respect of such books as in respect of books which will be banned in future. I think that is a reasonable proposition. I am not going to admit for one moment that even one book that has been banned by the censorship board ought not to have been banned, but if there is any great feeling abroad that a book has been unreasonably banned, I can see no reason in the world why the decision in regard to that book ought not be subject to review as well as decisions in regard to books which may be banned in future. If a wrong has been done—and I am not admitting that there has—means should be provided by way of an appeal to have the matter remedied. As far as the members of the board who banned the book are concerned, I do not think it makes very much difference that some of them may not be now on the Board, because the printed book is there. It is either obscene and indecent or it is not, and the appeal board will be the body to decide that. I cannot see any justification, therefore, for limiting appeals to books that will be banned in future.
Reverting to the question of "at any time", I think it will be agreed that it might be awkward to have too long a period between the banning of the book and the time within which an appeal could be taken. I am taking it that when this Bill passes each banned book, no matter when banned, will be deemed to have been banned at the date of the passing of the Bill. They will all become banned books under this Bill. I agree, however, that the right of appeal should not be extended for too long a period, say, for not more than six months, at the same time safeguarding the right to appeal in respect of all banned books.
Comment on this
Might I make a suggestion? Would not a better wording be "at any time within six months of the banning of the book or the passing of the Act, whichever is the later".
Comment on this
Yes. If I understood Senator Magennis aright, he wants to exclude all books that had been banned already, but I do not think that would be justifiable. I think we shall have to make it clear that this provision will apply to all books that have been banned at the time of the passing of the Bill and then fix a period, say, of six months or 12 months as the maximum within which an appeal can be taken. I imagine that anyone who takes an interest in this question will certainly move within six months.
Comment on this
I can see no way out of that. I do not think the public are so depraved that there will be such a great stampede for a book if people find that it is banned.
Comment on this
I hope we have not gone that far, that the fact that a book is banned means that it will be a great "boost" for it and that we are going to see a rush for that book. Anyway, until the appeal board decides the matter the book will still be banned. We do not know what the appeal board will do; they have got to make the decision. I would say that the words "at any time" should be deleted and that some reasonable period should be provided.
Comment on this
Has the Minister considered the possibility of a mass appeal, seeing that we have a Senator in the House who considers all censorship evil? If he can get four other members of the Seanad or the Dáil to join with him, what is to prevent him appealing against every prohibition Order since the censorship was established? Will we not then have a mass of appeals coming before the appeal board which will keep them going for the next three years? If that is a possible result of what we are doing now, I think the number on the appeal board should be increased to ten instead of five.
Comment on this
I have already indicated to the Senator that I am accepting one—that is in regard to "any time". That does not look as if I were going to reject them all. As I said at the beginning, I was not at all so happy, although I was willing to fall in with the suggestion that we might expedite the business and finish this debate, that this arrangement would be the best for myself because I might possibly miss some of the points raised. I had better resume my seat now and leave it to Senators to remind me of any points I may have missed.
Comment on this
When the amendments are put, the Minister will have an opportunity of dealing with any point which has not already been met.
Comment on this
If you are going to put any limited time to books which are already on the list—there is a tremendous lot of them—I think there should be some kind of circular sent around calling attention to the fact, because it might take some time for this legislation to trickle around.
Comment on this
Will it amount to an appeal for an appeal?
Comment on this
I was really only calling attention to this point, that I am rather inclined to stress that there should be no absolute guillotine. People may not wake up for some time to the fact that this is being done. I regret to say that it was something like two years, or a year, anyway, before I realised that certain books had been banned. With regard to 90 per cent. of the books, it does not very much matter, but there should be some loophole whereby a type of book which is least likely to be appealed—that is to say, probably the greatest and most unusual one—should be open to appeal at any time. I ask the Minister very seriously to consider that, because you are providing no way of getting out of it. Once the time has elapsed and the Censorship Board has made its mistake, you may have a book of inestimable value shut out.
Comment on this
What Senator Kingsmill Moore suggests is not possible, because the Minister, as I pointed out in my Second Reading speech, has the power to grant a permit, and has exercised that power beneficially. To say, therefore, that the Irish race in Ireland is to be shut out from contact with this book or access to this book is pure nonsense, in view of the fact that both under the Principal Act and under the amending Act the Minister has power to grant exemption in special circumstances.
What just now I rose to deal with was the Minister's comment on my fears of a "boost". The Minister is very much more innocent of life in the City of Dublin than I have ever imagined. I knew he had many virtues, but I did not know that this aloofness from ugly facts of the city life was one of his many virtues. There is hardly a man you meet who will not tell you that the Censorship Act is a fiasco. Quite recently, a friend of mine was with his wife in a city shop when a man entered and whispered to the saleswoman. The young woman at once handed to him from beneath the counter a book which, from its "jacket", my friend recognised as a recently prohibited book. My friend asked her: Is that such-and-such, naming the book. She said "Yes," and then said hurriedly: "What is your interest in the matter?" Everywhere you hear these stories. Other friends tell me similar stories, and I have no reason to believe they are lying. Senator Sir John Keane told us openly here in the 1942 debate that you can get any banned book if you know how to go about it. That was his positive declaration, and a Senator knows of a society which exists to bring in banned books, and lend them to one another and to their friends.
Comment on this
Of course it is illegal, but it is done, and I am interested in trying to close that back door to the frustration of the Act. I heartily appreciate what Senator O'Donovan has said about this mass appeal. The Minister himself showed in his speech on amendment No. 40 that a society might be got up for the purpose of neutralising censorship by appealing. How more effectively could they do it than by bringing appeal after appeal against prohibition Orders, and going back year by year to 1930? There is a society called the Council of Action which on one occasion issued a very elaborate memoranda to members of the board, and it is quite possible for that society or some successor of it to set up as one of the objects of its activities the neutralising of all that has been done in the past by precipitating appeal after appeal until the appeal board will resign, and everyone else asked to act in their place will refuse. I ask the Minister to consider this seriously —I am speaking from facts of which I am well aware, and I am sure there are others who know them, too—he is putting his head under a suspended axe, and concerted action can make the axe fall. Censorship is doomed if a voluntary Censorship Appeal Board is subjected to appeal after appeal. That can be done, and Senator Kingsmill Moore showed us what the modus operandi might be, an appeal through the public Press to ask for subscriptions. All the people—and they are many—interested in preserving this safeguard of the Irish race against contamination and depravity will be made the subject of these attacks I begged of the Minister on one occasion to allow for the possibility of the Censorship Board going wrong in the other direction. We have heard so much testimony to-day as to the fallibility of the Censorship Board and its liability to make mistaken judgments, why not entertain the possibility of its failing to ban a book which it ought to have banned, and why should not the citizens who feel their moral sensibilities offended by that have an opportunity to appeal against the non-prohibition of the book? That is why I asked again and again: Why this assiduity, this constant concern with regard to the interests of a foreign publisher and not equal regard for the moral interest?
Comment on this
I thought it was. I thought the Senator was deliberately putting my head under an axe. It looked very personal indeed. I am glad it is not to me, because I repudiate it.
Comment on this
I will answer. The Minister is supporting a piece of legislation which will have that effect. I am not attacking the Minister: I caution him. I do not know how he is getting this idea. I do not attack; I caution him.
Comment on this
I have served the Minister loyally all this time on the Censorship Board. The Minister is too sensitive, or perhaps I am in fault by indulging in figurative speech, and, therefore, liable to be misunderstood.
Comment on this
As my speech is an annoyance to the Minister, there is no remedy for it but to sit down.
Comment on this
I do not think there would be any object in following the discussion of motives or possible effects. I believe that the members of the Oireachtas generally, with scarcely any exceptions, treat their duties seriously. That any five members are going to combine to make legislation ridiculous I do not believe for one second. That does not mean that I am in favour of this scheme, but I think that is a suggestion which ought not to be made here. I do not believe there is the slightest possibility of it, but, if in any odd case it does happen, the Minister will have his remedy. He will not have very much trouble in getting through both Houses of the Oireachtas in one day a Bill to prevent gross abuse by members of any privileges conferred or any duties placed upon them.
I do not believe that that is a serious danger or one that is worth consideration. I, personally, have tried to put forward suggestions which, I believed, were good suggestions from the point of view of improving the Bill, and I believe that the Minister has been trying to consider them in the same spirit. I am sorry that he is so wedded to this provision for five members, but he has the responsibility in that case, and I am not going to press this, although I am convinced that he is making a mistake. I believe that it would be far better and far more workable to have a smaller number of persons who, because of their responsibilities and duties outside, would be better qualified to deal with this matter.
I do not wish to stand over every detail of my suggestions, but I would ask the Minister carefully to consider that viewpoint. I still do not think that he appreciates the position of certain members of the House who may be asked to put their names to an appeal in regard to certain books. As far as my knowledge of books goes, in the case of 90 per cent. of them—99 per cent. of them, as far as I know— I would feel insulted if anybody asked me to put my name to an appeal; but I admit that there are books which I hare read, which are border-line cases, as has been mentioned, in which I would have difficulty in deciding. Senator Magennis might not agree, but it has been put to me by certain people that a certain number of books —a relatively small portion—have been banned, which ought not to have been banned. That, however, is not a matter for heat; it is a question of whether it was wise policy or good policy for the Censorship Board to include certain books. I think that if the Minister insists, as I think he is going to do, on placing that responsibility on five members of the Oireachtas, he will have to allow a period of at least 12 months or longer in the case of books already banned. He says that it would be extremely easy to say "No". I agree, but if people whom you respect, and greatly respect, put before you a certain number of books, and you are not going to take their word for it and irresponsibly put your name down, then you will have to read these books, and, from what I have heard, one would have to be prepared to read at least a dozen such books.
Of course, Senator O'Donovan has suggested that one might be asked to read a few thousand books, but I do not accept that. However, in the case of a small number of books, if the responsibility is placed on members of the Oireachtas to read that certain number of books, they should accept that responsibility. I agree with Senator Magennis that there should be some time limit, not alone with regard to books that have been banned in the past, but particularly with regard to books that may be published in the future. I would suggest to the Minister that there should be a period of 18 months for books that were censored prior to this Act, and that that should end the matter, but that so far as new books are concerned a period of 12 months would be quite sufficient.
Comment on this
I do not want to follow Senator Magennis either, but I must say that one thought that occurred to me, in the course of the Senator's speech, was that—I am very sorry to say—the result of such inquiries as there have been into banned books has not been the success that I thought it would have been. If, however, the result of the banning of books has been what Senator Magennis has said, then it is a very serious state of affairs. I should like to repeat, however, that I do not want to force any further responsibilities or duties on Deputies or Senators. If there is a general feeling amongst Deputies and Senators that this ought not to be done, I do not want to force them to accept these responsibilities or duties, but they had the right in the past to ask to have a prohibition order revoked, and I thought that this was a sort of alternative, to give Deputies or Senators the right to appeal if they thought it was in the public interest to do so. My whole object is to make this Censorship Bill effective and workable, and not to have organisations, if such exist, springing up and bringing in books and keeping them under the counter, so to speak, for sale or distribution. That kind of thing might happen in the whole country. We are supposed to be public representatives.
Comment on this
Well, perhaps, not the whole country, but if you have people whispering around that they have such-and-such a book and that it can be got, it is quite possible that there might be deplorable results. I hope that I am not as innocent as I appear to be. I do know that there is a section—a small section—of our people who do look for that kind of literature, but I think that the vast majority of the people of Ireland, and, indeed, of most other countries, are not of that type. I may be wrong there, but if I am wrong, I admit that I am out of touch. However, I undertake to consider this matter between now and the Report Stage.
Comment on this
Well, I shall withdraw my amendment, and we can consider it on the Report Stage, but I do agree with all Senator Kingsmill Moore has said, although I would not necessarily agree to certain other points.
Comment on this
I am putting these amendments individually. Is amendment No. 39 agreed to?
Comment on this
I understand from Senator Kingsmill Moore that he is withdrawing that amendment.
Comment on this
With regard to amendment No. 41, I have not withdrawn it yet, but I shall be quite satisfied to hear what the Minister has to say about it on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I do not wish to press it. I want to say this: that the Minister seems to be disappointed that the Act has been a comparative failure.
Comment on this
I want to know what the Senator's position is on this amendment. Is he withdrawing it or not?
Comment on this
With regard to amendment No. 42, proposed by Senator Magennis, I said that I would consider a reasonable time, and if the Senator is not satisfied with that, we can consider it on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
With regard to amendment No. 43, what does the Minister propose to do on that? The purpose there was to confine the matter of appeal.
Comment on this
No, I shall not agree with that. It would mean that the appeal should only apply to books in the future, and I would not agree to that.
Comment on this
I think the Minister will accept amendment No. 44, as it is merely drawing attention to certain provisions that would be necessary.
Comment on this
If the Senator will look at Section 20, I think he will see that the Minister has certain powers under that section to deal with that. I think the Senator will agree, if he looks at Section 20, that the Minister has power to make regulations under that section and that this is unnecessary.
Comment on this
That is another point. If the Minister thinks it necessary to make regulations, he may make them. Heretofore, the board arranged its own procedure. If that was thought desirable by either board, I would not be prepared to impose regulations on them but, if they wish me to consider the matter, I have power under Section 20.
Comment on this
The Minister, I think, agreed to consider this matter and, therefore, I withdraw it.
Comment on this
I understand the Minister is willing to accept it.
Comment on this
All the amendments from No. 50 to No. 60 can be considered together.
The amendments were:—
50. In sub-section (1), line 40, to delete the word "issues" and insert instead the word "issue"; and to delete the word "recently"—(Senator Campbell).
51. In sub-section (1), line 41, to delete the words "theretofore published"—(Senator Campbell).
52. In sub-section (1), line 41, page 5, to delete the word "theretofore"—(Senator Magennis).
53. In sub-section (1), line 43, to delete the word "issues" and insert instead the word "issue"—(Senator Campbell).
54. In sub-section (1), line 44, to delete the word "have" and insert instead the word "has"; and to delete the words "usually or frequently"; and after the word "obscene" in that line to insert the words "or subversive of public morals"—(Senator Campbell).
55. In sub-section (1), line 45, to delete the word "have" and insert instead the word "has"—(Senator Campbell).
56. In sub-section (1), line 45, page 5, after the word "advocated" to insert the words "directly or otherwise recommended, as by advertisement"—(Senator Magennis).
57. In sub-section (1), line 48, page 5, after the word "procurement" to insert the words "or contain advertising matter intended to promote the sale or employment of instruments and appliances in aid of those practices"—Senator Magennis.
58. In sub-section (1), line 49, to delete the word "have" and insert instead the word "has"—(Senator Campbell).
59. In sub-section (1), line 52, to delete the word "issues" and insert instead the word "issue" and to delete the words "and future issues"—(Senator Campbell).
60. In sub-section (1), line 53, after the word "shall" to insert the words "notify the publisher thereof in writing of such opinion and inform him that on receipt of any such complaint in respect of any subsequent issue of said periodical, made in the prescribed manner, on which the board shall be of like opinion, they shall"—(Senator Campbell).
Comment on this
My amendments propose to alter the obligation imposed on the complainant to collect several issues of the paper before it can go before the board for consideration as to whether they shall prohibit the sale and distribution thereof. I think the proposal I make is a much more satisfactory one. It suggests that one issue of the paper should be sufficient for the board to consider whether they should prohibit the sale and distribution of it. It is also, I think, much more satisfactory in the sense that it gives the publisher of that paper a chance to mend his ways if he so desires, because it proposes to insert that, having considered the single issue of a periodical or publication, the publisher should be notified in writing of the opinion of the Censorship Board that the sale and distribution of the publication should be prohibited and that "on receipt of any such complaint in respect of any subsequent issues of said periodical, made in the prescribed manner, on which the board shall be of like opinion" the Censorship Board shall, by order, prohibit the sale and distribution of the publication. I think it is too much of an obligation to impose on the ordinary citizen that he must collect several issues of the paper before bringing it before the Censorship Board, and I think what is proposed in my amendments is a much more satisfactory method of dealing with the matter. I think it would be considered fairer to the publisher to notify him that in future, if he shall offend in that respect, subsequent issues of the paper will be banned. I also propose in line 44, after the word "obscene", to insert the words "or subversive of public morals". I think that is much more important in the case of these publications than in the case of books. After all, we have been told that 90 per cent. of the population read only newspapers and periodicals, and I think it is more necessary to insert these words here in Section 9 even than in Section 7.
Comment on this
I do not think the Senator's amendments are necessary. I think it is a fact that this part of the Censorship Act has worked very well. I remember before this Act was passed that when going along the streets you saw these objectionable things, generally in Sunday papers. So far as I know they have ceased. I understand that there are Irish editions of these papers now in order to keep that sort of thing out of these papers. I think the amendments are really academic and unnecessary. I think it will be admitted by everybody that the big object in view has been achieved. There are no complaints now, except that it is said there is this organisation for bringing in banned books. The newspapers have to come in in bulk every week. I am told that there are special editions of them for this country. Of all the parts of the Act, I think this is one the Censorship Board can be congratulated upon having made a big success of.
Comment on this
I have pretty much the same amendment down. My amendment reads:
In sub-section (1), line 41, page 5, to delete the word "theretofore".
I hope I shall not give further offence to the Minister if I mention that, successful as has been the effort to stem the tide of this filth that used to be brought in on Sundays and on other days, there were means devised to frustrate the Act. The Minister may not be aware of this, and he may. If I draw his attention to it and he has already been aware of it, he will pardon me for excessive zeal. Publishers send here huge editions of most objectionable periodicals. Following a course suggested to them, they hit upon the device of having the indecent stuff, say, in No. 2. For a fortnight they became virtuous; they glorified God in special devotional issues, and then again they came out with the indecent. Now, what is prescribed in the 1929 Act is that there had to be a number of issues offending, and so, by breaking the continuity of the offence, they escaped from the Act. That was one of the drawbacks. It is to secure that it is not necessary to have unbroken continuity of offending issues before the board that I introduce my amendment. I am speaking from experience.
Comment on this
On amendment No. 56, the argument that I used on a previous amendment applies to this. The Bill has been arranged to deal with books first and then with periodicals, but all I have said in connection with advertising as a mode of advocating applies even more to the periodical.
Comment on this
The provisions in this section have been most successful in the past and I think it appropriate at this moment to say that the section, and particularly the part contained in paragraph (c), was suggested in the Dáil in 1929 by Professor Tierney, who was then a member of the Dáil and who was for some time Leas-Chathaoirleach here. He put forward certain amendments to the original Bill about which he was very viciously maligned. It should be stated to his credit that this particular section, which has been very effective in preventing something we all want to prevent, is largely the handiwork of Professor Tierney.
Comment on this
On behalf of Senator Kingsmill Moore, I move amendment No. 61:—
In sub-section (1), page 6, line 20, after the word "publisher" to insert the words "or any club, society, association or other body having among its objects the study and promotion of literature or art".
Senator Kingsmill Moore is not here and, though it seems to me that this is consequential on a previous amendment and should not be moved, he has asked me to move it, so that he can put it down again on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 62:—
To delete paragraph (c), lines 37 to 40, and substitute therefor the following paragraph:—
(c) a prohibition order shall not be made unless at a meeting at which a quorum is present, and the majority of those present and voting vote in favour of it. In the event, however, of a tie, the chairman, or acting chairman, may exercise a casting vote.
I have already expressed my mind on the question of majority votes and will not weary and detain the House in repeating the arguments. It will be remembered that the quorum is four and two might vote on one side and two on the other. I think this amendment maintains in the working of the board the whole idea of democracy— that where matters are decided by vote the majority vote shall prevail.
Comment on this
This does not seem to be a case where that could be wisely introduced. In censoring a book, I do not think one person should have two votes. It is a case where the member exercises his individual judgment, and this would mean the exercise of two judgments. I oppose it.
Comment on this
What, in Senator Douglas's view, would be the consequence of an even vote, where the meeting of the board is quite legal? No prohibition order is issued?
Comment on this
It may be that I am completely misreading it. This states that a prohibition order shall not be made unless at such meeting three at least of the members vote in favour of the making of the order and not more than one member votes against it; so that, if a second member votes against it, these two votes prevail.
Comment on this
Yes, in this respect, that if only four turned up and two voted against, the remaining person who was not present would get an opportunity to assent or dissent. He would be communicated with. If four are present and one votes against, the majority—the three—will prevail. I would not agree to give anyone a second vote.
Comment on this
If such a case arose, the board could refrain from taking a decision on that particular book and could arrange for a full meeting. It is better as it is at present, as there is more facility for banning than there was in the past.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider having inserted on Report what he has just suggested— that, in the event of a tie, the decision be postponed to a full meeting?
Comment on this
I know. I will examine it and, if necessary, I will put it in. I do not imagine it is necessary.
Comment on this
Surely it is a matter affecting procedure, as to whether a matter being considered by a committee can be adjourned, there being no decision, and considered afterwards? The Minister can make regulations. It does not seem to be a matter which can be dealt with here.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 63:—
In paragraph (a), page 6, line 46, after the word "appeals" to add the following words "and any appellant or appellants or his or their representative may appear before the appeal board and adduce reasons why a prohibition order should be revoked."
I mentioned earlier that all my amendments were really devoted to the one main object of ensuring that the trial—I still use the word—should be a fair one and that opportunity should be given to put forward the case. I think a good deal could be said here for the view that, where you are interfering with a person's right to speak and to think, and where you are interfering with economic conditions, if there is any doubt, or even one dissentient person, the interest of freedom should prevail. Surely it is necessary that we should not condemn a person unheard? Therefore, my suggestion is that, at the final hearing, notice should be given to the person or persons who are affected and they should have an opportunity of being heard.
Now, let us face this position. Unless this amendment is accepted in principle—with such alteration of wording as might seem fit—we are, in fact, laying down that a person may be condemned without an opportunity of pleading his own case. As the Minister is aware, even outside the law courts, when one is dealing with the opinion of a domestic tribunal, such as a club or society of accountants or something like that, it is an absolute, cardinal rule that no decision can stand unless the person against whom it is given has had an opportunity, not merely of knowing the charge but of answering it. The only reason that I can see for refusing an amendment such as this, would be a fear that the person who knows most about it might succeed in convincing people that he was right. If it is refused it must be from a desire to prevent the case being put forward, a desire that the board should decide to a certain degree in blinkers, and a refusal to accept the position that if you are interfering with either liberty or ordinary rights of property the onus is upon the people who seek to do it and that not only is the onus upon them, but that there is an obligation, if you want to give even a semblance of fairness to the thing, that the other side should be heard.
Comment on this
In this case it is a book and not a person that is being considered. The book is there and it speaks for itself. The board will read it and they do not require any advocacy in so doing. The existing position is that if the board want to hear anybody, there is nothing to prevent them from doing so. I do not think there is any case for comparing an investigation as to whether a book is obscene or indecent with the trial of an individual for some offence which he may or may not have committed. A book is submitted, and you want the opinions of five persons as to whether it is indecent or not, and they ought to be able to come to a decision without any particular advocacy. I do not think the Senator has made a convincing case.
Comment on this
The Minister is surely overlooking one point. If I write a book, and if people condemn it as indecent and obscene, it is not the book which is condemned; it is my reputation which is condemned, and it is not only my reputation, but my immediate financial prospects and my future financial prospects which are affected. You are putting a slur on the author, and you are doing so without giving him a chance to defend himself. Surely he should be entitled to attend and point out the general effect of the book?
Take a book which Senator Magennis will know of. His views and mine may not coincide, but I regard it as one of the greatest of modern tracts. He regards it as indecent and obscene. It is a book in respect of which the author should certainly be allowed to put forward his views. I regard the book as the greatest work written against a civilisation of a purely materialistic kind. The book is "Brave New World." I regard it as a most profound piece of thinking. It is in the form of an ironical analogy and I have been greatly affected in my own thinking by reading it. Rightly considered, it is a devastating argument against a purely materialistic conception of life, the over-governing ordinances of human life, and its purely mechanical regulations.
I can see the other point of view. In order to bring that out the author has pushed to its logical conclusion what the effect of certain theories would be. I think it was a terrific mistake to ban the book, which I regard as more or less a modern tract. Surely the author ought to be able to attend and point out the effects which it would be likely to have and point out the motives behind it? If not, you label the person who has written a most valuable book as being a person who has written a thing that is indecent and obscene. It is very hard to justify that kind of thing.
I feel it is wrong and I think a great many of the mistakes which have been made by the Censorship Board have been made because there was nobody there to point out to them the opposite point of view. I confess that if I were asked to put my name to an appeal in respect of a number of books, not only would I like to have an opportunity of reading them first—which seems an onerous task enough—but I should like in many cases to have an opportunity of appearing and pointing out the reasons why I have thought it right to appeal. Therefore, I think this opportunity should be afforded. It probably will not very often be availed of, but it certainly should be afforded.
Comment on this
There is a lot to be said for the arguments of Senator Kingsmill Moore in respect of this amendment. It is one of the elementary principles of natural justice that no man should be condemned unheard. On the Second Reading of the Bill I objected to the principle of allowing members of the Oireachtas to become appellants to this tribunal. I asked the question on the Second Reading: What were they do after they had appealed to the appeal board against a prohibition Order—were they to allow it to rest there? I instanced the case of a representative who received a letter from a constituent asking him to do a favour. The representative replies immediately, promising to do everything and finally he does nothing.
I think an appeal is a farce unless the reasons for the appeal are put before the appellant tribunal and, therefore, I suggest it is merely a logical consequence of the right of appeal that the persons who appeal should have an opportunity of putting before the appeal board their reasons why a prohibition Order should be revoked. I think it cannot do anybody any harm. The mere fact that a book is there means that the appeal board has to do the work over again which the censorship board did.
The functions of the appeal board are simply to deal with disputed points. On an appeal from a lower to a higher court the appellant court deals only with the matters which are the subject of dispute; it does not deal with routine matters. I think unless on an appeal the points in dispute are narrowed down, the appellant board will be merely a replica of the Censorship Board and will not in the true sense be an appeal board. Therefore, I suggest that the Minister ought to accept the amendment or, if he does not accept it, he ought to consider favourably the principle involved in it.
Comment on this
Is it intended to continue beyond 9 o'clock? I think there is a reasonable chance of finishing the Committee Stage of this Bill if we continue. May I take it that we will not stop at 9 o'clock?
Comment on this
If there is agreement on that matter the House can sit beyond 9 o'clock. When the Committee Stage is concluded, there is then the question by Senator Douglas to be taken.
Comment on this
Senator Douglas may be agreeable to waive that matter if the House decides to sit after 9 o'clock in order to complete the Committee Stage.
Comment on this
I am rather in favour of the amendment but rather suspicious of it in view of its sponsors. I have a feeling that the Censorship Board would be overawed by an array of counsel on behalf of the people making the appeal. If we give the right to appeal to these people, they ought to be able to make their own case.
Comment on this
You could hardly interpret the mind of a man in England or America.
Comment on this
The Senator may think he could, but I have grave doubts about it. It is Senator Kingsmill Moore's rather than the author's views which would be put before the board. I think that the man who is going to be condemned—the principle in this regard is solid—should have the right to defend himself, if he wishes to avail of it.
Comment on this
I must say that, having listened to Senator Kingsmill Moore, Senator Ryan and the Minister, I am inclined to agree with the Minister. There is not a real analogy between censoring a book and sentencing Patrick Murphy to a term of imprisonment, or even inflicting a fine on him. They are two different things. Censorship is one of those things which, by its nature, is difficult to work, and the scheme in this Bill may not be a good scheme, but we must have some kind of scheme. The position previously was a censorship board of five people with no appeal and, by the way, with no right to appear before the board, so far as I remember. What has been substituted in this Bill is what may very well prove too cumbersome to be workable. The Minister, I think, is in agreement with that.
Comment on this
To some extent, it is a leap in the dark. We ask five people, who are difficult to get, to say whether they think a particular book, as they find it, should be let loose on the Irish public, as they know them. In this Bill we are amending the principle Act by providing an appeal board of five people. I think three people would probably have been better because they would have been more inclined to act in a judicial capacity. These five people have a particular duty to perform which will be difficult, and they are bound to make mistakes and bound to dissatisfy somebody, including perhaps myself on occasions. What they are asked to do is to consider a printed book and say whether that book, as they find it, is fit to be in circulation here under the terms of this measure.
I do not think that the author's view when writing the book, or the defence which a very skilful and learned lawyer, such as either of our two friends here, would make should influence the board, because it is not what the author thinks, it is not his view, which is of any importance. What is of importance for the board—I am not arguing for or against censorship—is whether what they find should get into the hands of the ordinary public. If it does get into the hands of the ordinary public, it gets into the hands of the ordinary public without the explanation given by the author and without the very skilful defence which Senator Ryan, Senator Kingsmill Moore or any other counsel could make for it.
The problem the board have to consider is whether a book, as they find it, should be censored or not, and for that reason it appears to me there is not an analogy between the ordinary court of appeal—where of course the litigant has the right to appeal, not only in person, but as represented by counsel— and this appeal, so that, on the whole, the notion that there should be a right to appear in person and make explanations would only tend to make the whole business more cumbersome, and would favour a certain type of person as against another I do not think there is an analogy. I agree at once, if anybody wants me to do so, that it is a serious financial business for an author whose book is censored, but that is inherent in the whole idea of censorship. It cannot be helped, I am afraid, and I do not think that, on the whole, you will do any more justice by dragging the thing out, and by having appearances by counsel, representatives, and so on.
What these people have to do is their best, as five individuals. They need not be five lawyers, although it is prescribed that some of them must be. The Minister will find it very difficult to get these people, but when he has got them, a voluntary board, they certainly will not be prepared to have a long-drawn-out hearing before they decide whether a particular book which has been banned should remain banned or whether the ban should be removed. The analogy with ordinary court procedure is not a sound one, and I am therefore inclined to think that the amendment is unsound.
Comment on this
I suppose the Minister has not weakened?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 65:—
In paragraph (c), page 6, line 50, to delete the word "may" and substitute instead the word "shall".
I hope I will get this amendment through. Anybody who proposes to appeal has to put down five good-looking pounds. It is perfectly reasonable that, if the appeal board, having considered the appeal, thinks it absurd, the appellant should lose that amount: but if the board think that the appeal is either a good one, or that, although it is one which they are not quite satisfied should go through, was, at the same time, a perfectly reasonable and proper appeal to take, the £5 should be given back, because, substantially, the opinion of the appeal board is that, although they may not in all respects agree with him, he has done a public service by bringing an appeal which was substantial and which might very well have succeeded. And so I ask that the appeal board, if satisfied that the appeal was not frivolous, shall direct that the deposit be refunded.
Comment on this
I think the Senator ought to trust the common sense and generosity of the board. He should agree to give them power to do it, if they wish—to leave it optional.
Comment on this
Surely if the board is satisfied that it is not a frivolous appeal——
Comment on this
For the moment, the Minister has taken the place of the Minister for Finance. He does not want to be collecting the £5, if the board is satisfied that it is not a frivolous appeal. Surely he sees what may happen. If a lot of sensible appeals are taken, but the board does not wish to go quite so far as to return the money, for any reasons of policy, it may have the effect of preventing the taking of proper appeals which would be granted, because people may be poor people and they would run the risk of losing their £5. Surely the distinction which should be made is not as between an appeal which succeeds and an appeal which fails, but between an appeal which, on the face of it, is untenable and an appeal which, on the face of it, is very reasonable.
There are some authors who are poor, and I suggest it should be made mandatory on the board, unless they are willing to certify that an appeal is frivolous, to refund the deposit. The Minister is particularly familiar with the origin of this phrase. You can refuse a case stated if the application for it is frivolous, but not otherwise. It would only be logical, if you want to make this appeal system work, if you want to make it a genuine appeal, if you want to avoid people being shut off from an appeal by reason of the fact that they have not got much of the world's goods, if you do not want to give undue power to the appeal board to shut people out because they feel they are busy and do not want any more appeals for the time being, that you should make it mandatory.
Comment on this
I hope the House will support Senator Kingsmill Moore in this amendment, not because I share all his arguments, but because it is not clear that "may" means that it is obligatory. Then you are providing three types for decision, one type in which the board considers the appeal frivolous, the second type that it considers not to be frivolous and gives back the money, and the third type that it considers not frivolous, but will not give back the money. The board should be fair to everybody. To give an option with regard to appeals, if they are not frivolous, is a mistake, as it suggests a differentiation between types of persons which, I think, is not intended or desirable.
Comment on this
I remember that on the Johnstown Castle Bill the Minister for Agriculture told us that in the opinion of the draftsman the word "may" and the word "shall" meant exactly the same thing.
Comment on this
If the board does not think the appeal frivolous, they are bound to give back the £5.
Comment on this
With a voluntary board we want to leave as much discretion as possible. It will be within the province of the board to say whether they consider an appeal frivolous or not. It is a matter for the board.
Comment on this
There is nothing between the Minister and Senator Kingsmill Moore. If I were a member of the appeal board I would read the section. A member of the board is bound to read the section and, if he does, and if he considers the appeal is not frivolous, surely the board will give back the money.
Comment on this
The only thing frivolous about the amendment is the Minister's opinion of it. I do not understand how the board would ever come to the conclusion that an appeal was not frivolous and then make an order that the fees be forfeited. I think Senator Kingsmill Moore is going to get what he wants. Although I have listened to it for over 20 years, I do not understand this affection for the word "may"—the affection for it that the Parliamentary draftsman has battled for for generations.
Comment on this
Although I agree that an appellant who has not put forward a frivolous appeal should be refunded his money, I am rather a devotee of the word "may" in legislation where Ministers and public departments are concerned. It has been the practice in almost every appeal, in which a Minister is given power, to use the word "may", of course always on the assumption that the Minister will use his power properly and in accordance with justice. I think in this case the Parliamentary draftsman has placed the appeal board in the same position as the Minister.
While I think the person should recover the fee of £5, I am not disposed to press the Minister to use the word "shall", and I suggest that the amendment should not be pressed by Senator Kingsmill Moore. I think the appeal board will, in the event of the appeal not being frivolous, refund the £5. The appeal board will be presided over by a lawyer who will understand the import of the word "may" in the section, and I am confident that he will rule that the sum of £5 should be refunded in the event of the board considering that the appeal was not frivolous. Therefore, I ask the Senator not to press the amendment.
Comment on this
I am not inclined to withdraw. The Minister said that when appointing a voluntary board he did not like compulsion. If the word "shall" is put in, it will avoid discussion and make the position a lot easier.
Comment on this
I should like to point out, particularly in regard to what Senator Ryan said, that paragraph (c) goes on to say: "and, if they do not so direct, the deposit shall be forfeited". I am still inclined to think that "may" may mean "shall", but I am not convinced that this is a case where it is certain that it would be so held.
Comment on this
I will withdraw the amendment and put it down for the Report Stage.
Comment on this
What about amendments Nos. 68 and 69 in view of the change in the membership of the board?
Comment on this
Amendment No. 68 is now not pertinent, and I wish to withdraw it. The same applies to amendment No. 69.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 71:—
In page 7, line 2, after the word "order" to insert the words "together with the name of any person or persons who shall have made a complaint in respect of the prohibited book or periodical."
I put down this amendment for the sake of calling the attention of the House to what is really an abuse, but I did not have any sanguine expectation that everyone would be with me. I have got a certain objection to felon setting, and I have a certain objection to officious and meddlesome people nosing about to see if they can find anything wrong. I am rather of the opinion that a great many of these books are bought by people who are what used to be known when I was young, as "Nosey Parkers", and if there are people engaged upon that very edifying pursuit, it is just as well, when giving the name of the author, to know the name of the person who is raking around to see if he could find something to complain of. I did not think the House would be unanimous about the matter and, if the Minister does not agree, I will not press it.
Comment on this
On the section, I see that it provides that the Censorship Board shall cause to be prepared and kept a register, in the prescribed form, to be called the Register of Prohibited Publications. I would like to know if this register is available to any member of the public to buy. It was referred to here as a best seller. Other references were made to it to-day. I cannot see what purpose is served by having this register available for sale to the public. I would like to know if that is the position, that it is available for people to buy it.
Comment on this
The present register is out of date. I asked if there was a recent one available, and I was told that there was not.
Comment on this
I suggest that it should not be available for sale. It should be sufficient to have publication, in regard to banned books, in the Iris Oifigiúl. If, however, you prepare a list of banned books for certain perverted people to buy—some Senators have referred to that list as every man's guide to the modern classics— I do not think it is right. As I say, I cannot see any purpose in preparing this register for sale to the public. I agree, of course, that if customs officials or other officers concerned require it for the purpose of carrying out their duties, it should be available to them, but I cannot see why it should be available for sale amongst news-agents. To do that is to publicise the fact that here is a list of books that are banned. That will present the opportunity to people who are interested in nullifying the provisions of this measure of getting the information they want. I suggest to the Minister that this register should not be available for sale to the public.
Comment on this
If that were done, how would the libraries and booksellers keep a check on the books that were banned?
Comment on this
The effect of Senator O'Donovan's proposal would be to increase the circulation of banned books, because it would be quite impossible for booksellers to memorise the names of such books and carry them in their minds. The list is required by them to enable them to check up on the books that have been banned. If this provision were not in the Bill, the result would be that banned books would be on sale and it would be impossible to watch them. I have spoken to certain booksellers about this, and they tell me that their difficulty is due to the fact that such long periods elapse between one issue of the register and the next.
Comment on this
It was only this morning that I was looking for the latest edition of the register. I bought one over a year ago, and there has been no edition since then. In fact, the present register is nearly two years out of date. I have been told by a number of people that one of the latest efforts of the Censorship Board has been to ban The Three Musketeers. During the past three days I have made attempts to find out if that is so, but I have not succeeded in doing so.
Comment on this
Well, three people have told me that, although personally I think it is unlikely. The fact, however, is that the present register is so much out of date that I have no opportunity of finding out. Senator O'Donovan has made no study of this matter. I have made an extensive study of it, and I have been very patient in listening to him. Obviously he does not know what books are banned. The Senator has been shouting on this subject, but he has made no attempt to study it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 73:—
In sub-section (2), at the end of the sub-section, to add the words "or that the book or periodical was not prohibited at the time he ordered it."
The object of the amendment is to ensure that it shall not be a punishable offence if you can prove that a book was sent to you before the date it was actually censored. The amendment fits in with the rest of the section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 74:—
To add to the section a new sub-section (3) as follows:—
(3) Nothing in this section shall prevent a person who is a member of Dáil Eireann or Seanad Eireann from importing any prohibited book.
I think that amendments Nos. 74 and 76 go together. Both depend entirely on whether the Minister is going to insist on the five members of the Oireachtas. Personally, I prefer amendment No. 76. My principal reason for putting down the amendments is that there will have to be some sort of facilities for members of the Oireachtas who are charged with the duty of reading books. It may be that the Minister has a stock of them or that there is a library in the Department where we could borrow them. I have a suspicion that there may be, somewhere in connection with the board, a collection of books, but if that is not so, then quite definitely some proviso should be inserted in the Bill which will not make it improper for a member of the Oireachtas to get a book and see whether he should appeal on it. Perhaps the matter could be considered on the Report Stage. Some amendment is necessary if the intention is to maintain the five members. Otherwise there would be no case for it.
Comment on this
I can borrow mine from Senator Kingsmill Moore.
Comment on this
Perhaps in the meantime Senator Kingsmill Moore will give us a short course on the matter.
Comment on this
Provided the Senator promises to be an apt pupil.
Comment on this
In view of the levity that has developed in the House on this important subject, I am not moving amendment No. 75.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 77:—
In sub-section (1), line 27, to insert after the word "may" the words "in consultation with the Censorship Board".
I think the amendment speaks for itself: that the regulations that are to direct and control a voluntary board should be framed after consultation with members of the board, especially if some of them have had no previous experience of the working of the Principal Act.
Comment on this
I think the amendment is reasonable, but should not it be "after consultation with the Censorship Board"?
Comment on this
Should the appeal board be the people to be consulted for any regulation in regard to the appeal board?
Comment on this
The Minister will put his own wording in the Bill?