We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

The Republic of Ireland Bill, 1948—Second Reading (Resumed).

Contributions 1–102 of 219. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill The Republic of Ireland Bill, 1948
Enacted

No. 19 of 1948 ›

With the echoes of the '98 celebrations still vibrating through the air, it would be a poor Irish heart that would not feel its pulse quicken when a Bill with a title like that which is in our hands comes before the House—the Republic of Ireland Bill, 1948. Listening to Senator Bigger last night, I asked myself what would the men of '98, the men of '48 or the men of '16 have given to be assured that the day would come, even if it were 150 years later or 100 years later, when an Irish Parliament would meet to discuss and to pass a Bill with such a title. What would Senator Bigger's ancestor who gave his life for Ireland in '98 have said if he had known that we would be meeting in this free Parliament to discuss such a Bill? What would his uncle, Francis Joseph Bigger, my good friend, have said if he knew this day had come? For the thrill the title gives us and the proof that the death and the sufferings of those who fought in '98, in '48, in '67 and in '16 were not in vain, I think we owe thanks to the Taoiseach and to the Government for the introduction of this Bill. For my part I render that thanks in the most whole-hearted spirit.

It required bigness on their part to admit that since 1936, or certainly since 1937, when the majority of the Irish people in the Referendum of that year adopted the Constitution, we have had what Article 5 claims for this State, that it is an independent, sovereign and democratic State. I believe that that is an authoritative definition of a republic. It is comforting to think that those who sneered at the "dictionary republic" as well as Britain and the nations formerly called the British Commonwealth have accepted it. We can put our label to it then one of these days without the fear of having it pulled down. This hour sees a vindication of those who stood for the Constitution. It shows bigness for the Taoiseach to admit he has been in the wrong. Let us who supported the Constitution show bigness too. I stood for the Constitution and merely lost my seat in the Seanad through my support of the Constitution. We must be big and let bygones be bygones. The interpretation which was put on subsection (2) of Section 1 of Article 41 of the Constitution had such an effect on the women in Ireland that they mustered in battle array to defeat the Constitution in the Referendum. It would have been a great disaster if they had done so and we must thank God, and thank God doubly to-day when we are discussing this Bill, that the Constitution was not rejected. I admit whole-heartedly that it is a real advance that we can take the name republic and attach it to the State which the Constitution set up in 1937. I admit that that is a great advantage, and, if I had any doubts about it, I was convinced by Senator Lavery's admirable speech last night.

It is a good thing to get rid of the External Relations Act and it a good thing that there is no King's name in any of our laws. That is a decided advance, but, alas, portion of Ireland is still portion of the Royal Title—King of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. This we must not forget, that this republic we are setting up—we are not setting it up—this republic which we describe in this Bill, is a republic for only Twenty-Six Counties. I think, too, that the name "Republic of Ireland" is a misnomer in the circumstances. I listened to the Taoiseach last night and he made a very good point. I think his reasoning was that, as in the Constitution we say that the name of the State is Ireland, or Eire, in the Irish language, we can call this republic the Republic of Ireland. Some of his Ministers, the Minister for External Affairs, who I am glad is listening to me, went further when speaking on the Second Reading in the Dáil and Deputy Major de Valera agreed with him. He said:

"The new Act will extend to the whole country in accordance with the provisions of the Constitution."

That appears at column 704 of Volume 113 of the Dáil Debates. But surely it is difficult to accept that opinion or to believe it is justified in view of the "self-denying ordinance" embodied in Article 3 of the Constitution, which declares:

"Pending the reintegration of the national territory and without prejudice to the right of the Parliament and Government established by this Constitution to exercise jurisdiction over the whole of that territory the laws enacted by that Parliament shall have the like area and extent of application as the laws of Saorstát Éireann and the like extra-territorial effect."

That seems to me to limit the area and extent of application of our ordinary legislation to the Twenty-Six Counties. This Bill is just a piece of ordinary legislation and no more applies to the Six Counties than do our licensing laws.

The Minister for External Affairs, in the same speech, claimed, as an important fruit of this Bill, that this will be the first time that the Republic of Ireland will, as a separate State and entity, take its place among the nations of the world. But will he claim that the nations of the world will recognise it as the Republic of Ireland, in the full historic sense of those words? I do not think he can, and the British Premier made it quite plain that he does not accept it in that sense. I think I read in some of the papers that a member of the Northern Ireland Parliament described Mr. Attlee, when he was making his declaration on the Bill to the British House of Commons, as having behaved towards us with the excessive indulgence of a benign parent to a spoiled child, but he lost no time in assuring the British House of Commons that there would be no change in the constitutional position of Northern Ireland and reiterated a former promise of his that there would be no change in that position until Northern Ireland consented to come in with us.

He may have behaved with the benign indulgence of a parent to a spoiled child, but I think he thought he was just giving us a Christmas toy to keep us happy in our corner, because we would not be happy till we got it. He did not see any objection to letting us have this name as we already have the reality. But, for my part, that ought to put us very much on our guard. I cannot escape the suspicion that the British Premier would not have been so forthcoming and benign, had he not thought that the passing of this Bill would lengthen and strengthen Partition. That is something we must guard against, and one way of guarding against it is by not having any premature rejoicings. There was a lot of discussion in the Dáil with regard to calling the day on which this Bill comes into force Independence Day. We have not got independence, so long as six of our counties are under the British Crown, held by British troops and the whole frontier manned by British customs officers. We have not got the freedom which the men of '48, '98 and '16 died for, so long as that is the case.

I give the House an instance of a personal type. I wrote a book some time ago and my own brother in Northern Ireland cannot import that book on a commercial basis for sale in his shop. He must take it in in twos and threes. Is that the Republic of Ireland? I think it would be most unsuitable if we were to rejoice so long as our territory is not united. Pearse prayed for an Ireland Gaelic and free, but there was not a divided Ireland in his time and our prayer must be for an Ireland free, Gaelic and undivided.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

The Republic of Ireland Bill is put forward by the Taoiseach and the Government as something which gets rid of pretence and enables us to face realities. It surely clears the road for us to make economic and social progress. It removes doubts and removes confusion, and, before I go any further on that point of confusion, let me quote the present Leader of the Opposition, speaking in University College in December, 1938. He said:—

"I, for one, am sorry...because I feel that if we were able to say that we were an independent republic there would be none of this confusion which exists at the moment and which is helping to cause dissatisfaction and is in a sense a source of danger."

That was quoted by the Minister for External Affairs in the Dáil on 26th of last month and surely, by itself, it goes to show that there was confusion and that that confusion was acknowledged by the head of the Government responsible for the Constitution of 1937 and the External Relations Act of 1936. This Bill removes that confusion and we remove, therefore, from Parties and from politics certain shibboleths and catchcries which have done us harm and tended to impede our social, economic, and cultural progress. In the future, Parties must base themselves upon their achievements in the economic, social, cultural and educational fields. That is a great argument in favour of this Bill. The statement that there was no confusion is, of course, quite contrary to the facts, as acknowledged by Deputy de Valera himself.

The Bill has been attacked on three different grounds. The first ground— in which all the English newspapers, joined by at least one Irish newspaper, united—was that the declaration of a republic would be followed by dire consequences to Irish citizens, dire consequences in the realm of citizenship, dire consequences in the realm of trade, and with the further insinuation and sometimes explicit statement that the new State, the republic, would not be internationally recognised. Before the Bill came to its final stages in the Dáil, all these doubts had been resolved, all these fears had been dissipated and it had been proved by statements made in Great Britain, in Canada, Australia and other places that all the prophets of evil were quite foolish and that their prophecies were quite groundless.

There is a great deal of misunderstanding of what Dominion status was or of what the link with the Crown meant, both by those opposed to Dominion status and by some, like Professor Bigger here, who favour it. There is no such thing as having the same King and having necessarily, because we have the same King, good economic relations. We had the same King with Great Britain in 1933—there can be no doubt about it—but we had an economic war and economic sanctions and economic loss, although we were within the Commonwealth without any doubt then and had the same King as Great Britain. Having the same King does not mean, either, a free interchange of citizens.

I attended for four or five weeks a conference of parliamentary delegates from various Commonwealth countries, and one of the great bones of contention there was the colour bar, the difficulty between certain parts of the Commonwealth where, in spite of having the same King and quite freely and clearly acknowledging the same King, people are not able freely to travel within the King's Dominions. The same applies to currency. Canada and Great Britain acknowledge the same King but have two different currencies. Neither does it mean going to war together. South Africa went to war on the last occasion, after the proposal was actually opposed and only carried on a division in the South African Parliament. That being so, it should be recognised that, without recognising the King—because for historic reasons we cannot do it and never wanted to do it—there is no reason why, having come to that conclusion and having now actually named the State the republic, we should not continue to enjoy whatever advantages we have been enjoying heretofore.

Another argument against the Bill is that it makes no real change at all. The truth is that those who put forward that argument are bewildered and annoyed at the introduction of this Bill and as a result of their bewilderment and annoyance they are floundering about in a mass of false and absurd history and ridiculous constitutional law—including, of course, abuse of constitutional lawyers. One of the strange things in this debate is that the word "lawyer" appears to be a term of abuse and opprobrium. Senator Ó Buachalla when speaking yesterday struck me as suffering from a very acute inferiority complex. He was talking about constitutional law points but seemed to regard the possession of legal knowledge and professional ability in constitutional law to be a drawback from which the Taoiseach and the Minister for External Affairs and the Attorney-General were suffering. Senator Bigger, although himself also a university man and a university teacher, seemed to suffer from the same peculiar inferiority complex, which I regret to see in any university man.

The name "Ireland" has been mentioned. Surely Senator Bigger—or, for that matter, Senator Quirke or anyone else—does not think that the people who accepted the Treaty were Unionists? They certainly were not. They were Nationalists but they were realists as well. They included many who had fought hard against His Majesty and His Majesty's forces. Some of them are dead now, some happily alive. Collins, Mulcahy, MacEoin, Gearóid O'Sullivan and others— they looked the facts in the face and never said that the settlement of 1921 was a final or an ideal settlement. They never concealed their desire to make progress to absolute freedom, not only in fact but in form.

In spite of that a good deal of our history has been misunderstood and not only misunderstood but wilfully misrepresented. Surely we should regard our history as progress and regard what everybody did at a particular moment as something worthy of praise—where credit should be given when credit is due? I am tried of hearing people talking about Daniel O'Connell and criticising him because he was not out in 1916.

Comment on this

It is what he did in 1798 we were talking about.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

If Senator Colgan had read his history about Daniel O'Connell, he would find out that he could not have been out in 1916.

Comment on this

He was out in Dublin, raiding rebels' houses.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

O'Connell was able to do something for the Irish people in his own time and in his own way. I was reared a strong, violent, relentless, opponent of the Irish Party. Everything I have read since has led me to believe that what they did was a necessary preliminary to what was done afterwards. What O'Connell did was a necessary preliminary to the Land War and to what came after.

Comment on this

I admit that, but I will not whitewash O'Connell.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

I am not whitewashing anyone—not even myself. I think we should get a view of Irish history that shows men as doing their best in their own way and in their own time and making substantial progress, until this point we have reached to-day which leaves only one step of progress still to be made, as Senator Mrs. Concannon has explained. That is what we have to do and to say, as was said yesterday, that progress was made after 1932 and no progress was made before that is just childish, futile, absurd and false history.

Progress was made before 1932. For Senator Quirke's information, I quote him an authority I am sure he is willing to accept. In this very House, on the Second Stage of the Constitution (Removal of Oath) Bill, 1932, Senator Seán Milroy asked a question of the then President of the Executive Council, Deputy de Valera, and it is given in the Seanad Debates, Volume 15, column 938, 2nd June, 1932, as follows:—

"The President:... I thought for one, at any rate, that the 26 Counties here, as a result of the 1926 and 1930 Conferences, had practically got into the position—with the sole exception that instead of being a republic it was a monarchy—that I was aiming at in 1921 for the whole of Ireland."

You could not have greater praise than that.

"Mr. Milroy: As a result of the Treaty?

"Mr. de Valera: I am quite willing to give to Senator Milroy or anybody else any credit that can be got for the policy they aimed at, and I am prepared to confess that there have been advances made that I did not believe would be made at the time."

There is an authority that my friends on the opposite side will surely accept for the advances that were made. From 1932 further advances were made, particularly from the point of view of taking out forms and symbols which no longer enshrined within them any substance or fact. As was quoted here yesterday, a Scotsman, Mr. Berriedale Keith, an authority on constitutional law, said in 1933 that Mr. Cosgrave in 1932 had deprived the King of every vestige of influence and of all legal power. You cannot do anything better than that.

Fianna Fáil continued that particular kind of progress and they continued it and were able to continue it because the Statute of Westminster had been passed in 1931 through the efforts of people like the present Taoiseach and the present Minister for Finance, Deputy McGilligan. Therefore, we can look at the whole as a record of progress. To shut our eyes to the fact that that progress was based on the transfer of power from the British to us in 1922 and the evacuation of the Twenty-Six Counties by British troops is to blind oneself wilfully to the obvious truth. At any rate, the ex-Taoiseach was not blinding himself to the obvious facts. We should give credit all round and we should recognise that progress was possible in 1921 that was not possible in 1914; in 1937 that was not possible in 1922; and in 1948 progress is possible that perhaps was not possible in 1937. But we will have to get rid of this business of thinking that certain people, because they use certain catchcries, have a monopoly of intelligence and patriotism. They have not.

Why all the solicitude on the part of the Opposition and other people about the Fine Gael Party? What is their anxiety about that Party? It is quite touching to find so many people so interested in our Party and its position now. The whole trouble with these people is that they thought the Fine Gael Party was dead, and they find it alive now, proclaiming a republic. They are very hurt. I can understand that, but they would be very well advised not to talk so much about it. When I hear people abusing lawyers my mind goes back to the Sinn Féin and volunteer days, when we were very glad indeed to have the services of lawyers, the services of constitutional lawyers, the services of ingenious and patriotic lawyers who used their ingenuity without fee or reward to save Irishmen from the firing squad. One of the people who did that was the present Taoiseach, and the Attorney-General who spoke last night. Senator Ó Buachalla at that time would not have spoken with contempt of constitutional lawyers who were using their brains and experience for that very great and very laudable purpose. I am sure that the Senator has heard of cases of that kind.

There is another objection to this Bill by those who say that they have a sentimental attachment to the Crown and that this Bill is taking the Crown away from them. I think the Attorney-General very successfully disposed of that argument yesterday. It is very interesting to find that those who are attached to the Crown all seem to have ancestors who died for Ireland. It is a very remarkable thing that Senator Bigger, who, I am afraid, was rather confused in what he said, began by explaining what his ancestors had done and then went on to deprecate anybody talking about 1916. In other words, if your great grand-uncle or your great grandfather died in the Battle of Antrim, it is all very good, but if Senator Colgan said he was out in 1916, that is very bad. That is reaping up old things which we should not reap up.

Senator Bigger demonstrated that he was neither a lawyer nor a politician. If a politician is a person who should have given study to these matters, then Senator Bigger certainly does not qualify for that particular title. Surely Senator Bigger, if he followed the progress of our operations since 1922, would have realised that under the Fine Gael Party for which he voted, as he says, and for which he is never going to vote again—it is a very foolish thing for a politician to say how he is going to vote at the next election; the best people reserve their judgment until they see the circumstances and hear the speeches—as I have said, progress was made in every possible way towards practical republicanism from 1922 until 1932 under Mr. Cosgrave.

Perhaps Senator Bigger will listen to me as I am not a constitutional lawyer, but I presided over the Dáil when the Constitution of 1922 was passed. One of the most interesting things about it was the extraordinary efforts made to create a republican constitution combined with a king. Constitutional lawyers or historians who study the Constitution will be struck by the constant endeavour, so to speak, to put the King in his place as a servant of the Executive and to give as much as possible of a republican form to the Constitution. There was a proposal to have a Constitution in which the King would not enter at all. Only for the unhappy civil war it might have been possible to do that. It was not done, however. Certainly there can be no doubt that that was the idea then, and there is nothing new in the present Taoiseach or anyone who supports him coming forward with this Bill for the Republic of Ireland now.

There has been some talk about people's election pledges. Surely Senator Bigger has regard for Edmund Burke, a great Irishman who was attached to the British Crown and who was a member of the British Parliament. Surely he is a great authority for the theory that when you get into Parliament you must do your best; that you are a representative and not a delegate. I take it Senator Bigger has heard that. The promise, if it were a promise, that the Taoiseach as a candidate for election gave was a promise which depended on the Fine Gael Party getting a majority, and they did not get a majority. A new situation arose and new opportunities. The new opportunities had to be grasped and the new opportunities are being grasped in this Bill, not for the good of a Party, but for the good of the whole country. Surely there is nothing constitutionally wrong, nothing undemocratic, and nothing dishonest in any such operation.

If the Senator or any other Senator will look back at the history of any Parliament he will find, over and over, things done for which no explicit mandate had been demanded at the previous general election. The theory that you must do nothing in Parliament except something you have a mandate for would be very crippling and very bad for Parliamentary government. Many feel that it is a pity we could not have loyalty to the Crown but, if loyalty to the Crown is an essential factor in membership of the British Commonwealth of Nations, then we must remember what loyalty is. Loyalty, surely, is a growth. Senator Bigger will appreciate that loyalty is a growth, a natural growth and not a synthesis. You cannot make up loyalty to the Crown in a laboratory. You cannot compound it in a vessel. You cannot make it with machinery. You cannot create a sentiment of loyalty to the Crown by Parliamentary resolution. If every single one of us here, for the purpose of satisfying Senator Bigger or some other people with sentimental attachment to the British Crown, were unanimously to resolve that we were loyal, we would not be a bit more loyal walking out of the door than we were walking in. It must be a genuine feeling, and for reasons which there is no use arguing about and which everybody knows there is no such real feeling here. The Oath of Allegiance that was devised in the Treaty was, according to Lord Birkenhead, "the greatest prevarication in history," so great a prevarication that people who took it said they did not take it at all.

On that point, I may say this, when the Fianna Fáil Party came into the Dáil in 1927 they took the oath as much as anybody else did. If they did not take it, nobody took it. It was taken exactly in the same way by everybody of all Parties. Nothing has given rise to more prevarication, to more public scandal, than that discussion over that particular formula of words, created because the Irish did not want to take a full-blooded Oath of Allegiance to the Crown.

It is arguable that we should never have been put into this Dominion pattern. The British desired in 1921 that Ireland should go into the pattern of the British Dominions. We did a good deal since 1922 to break the pattern up. The British should have made it a sine qua non for our getting certain powers in this country but the realists who accepted that position accepted that position as a step towards getting what the Irish people wanted and what the Irish people cannot help wanting and what this Bill gives us for Twenty-Six Counties at any rate.

Let me say one other word on Partition. We are told that the removal of the King from this discreditable and by no means dignified position as an organ or instrument that he occupied in the External Relations Act, is going to put an obstacle in the way of union with our fellow-countrymen in the North. I wonder have we forgotten all so soon what it is that our fellow-countrymen in the North object to, those of them who do object. I remember the last Home Rule Bill. It became a suspended Act, eventually, in 1914. It contained a full-blooded Oath of Allegiance to the King. There was no Irish army in it, no Irish flag, no anthem, no fiscal powers, no power in it to protect Irish industry or impose a tariff on British goods. The control of the very police force was postponed, and not given to the Irish Parliament in Dublin at once. It was to that Bill that objection was taken, and it was against that Bill that the Ulster Volunteers organised. It was to prevent that Bill from coming into operation that they threatened to throw the King's Crown into the Boyne, consorted with the King's enemy and created a mutiny in the King's army.

People like myself, reared as I was reared, will have to be allowed to be rather sceptical about the loyalty of those people for whom Senator Bigger says he speaks, because their loyalty was such that they would not accept from the British Crown for this country what we now consider to be so mean and so miserable and so poor an instalment of freedom as that. The people who would not accept that, we are told, would be prepared to consider unity if we would retain the undignified position of the British Crown which is enshrined in the External Relations Act of 1936.

Surely, Sir, if these people in the North are, as I believe they are, the bluff, honest, sincere people that we are told so much about, surely they will appreciate honesty and sincerity and straight republicanism better than they will appreciate the milk and water combination which combines royalty with republicanism. Surely we can speak to them now on a clearer basis. Surely they will have more regard for us in our new position than they could ever have had for us in the position we occupied when the External Relations Act enabled people to say that we were something or that we were not something, as they wished, that we were one thing here and another thing there.

This Bill appears to me to be an honest effort to clear up a tangled and confused situation. I have had experience of the confusion. Although I have some understanding of it, I could not explain it to anybody, to Parliamentarians from Canada, Australia, New Zealand and South Africa whom I met recently except on the basis that the people of this country had no regard for the Crown for historical reasons, which the South Africans understood very well—some of them— and that an endeavour had been made to have a republican form of government and retain the slenderest possible link with the Crown. When we have cleared away that difficulty we will enable all Irishmen to co-operate for cultural, social and economic purposes and give fair play to everybody.

Senator Bigger has already told us that fair play is being given. For my part the thing I liked least in Senator Bigger's speech was his statement that the minority here were getting more than their due. I hope not. I hope that what the minority is getting it merits by its intelligence and zeal. It does no good to give back-handed compliments of that particular character. This Bill will enable us to co-operate better, and will prevent, as the Taoiseach has said, controversy which bears no fruit, which is arid and barren. It will enable us to treat with the majority in the Six Counties on a franker and more honest basis, and they like frankness, they like straight-forwardness, and they like blunt honesty. It will also enable us to have more intelligent co-operation and better economic relationship with Great Britain and the British Dominions. If that is so, we should all be satisfied. We should all accept this Bill for what it is, and not try to belittle the Bill or explain that it is taking something from people that they had and that they cherished. It is taking nothing from people who cherished the King because the King was in no position here that anybody who reveres him or honours the British Crown could have agreed with. This Bill is going to set us forward to a new era of co-operation between ourselves, and with our nearest neighbours and greatest friends.

Comment on this

I rise as a Six County Protestant to support and welcome this Bill. The House will pardon me if I advert in the beginning to the already very much publicised remarks of Senator Bigger last night, simply because we have to clear away false thinking about the position of the minority in the Six Counties. I hope to show you very shortly that the title of this Bill is a perfectly accurate one, and Senator Bigger's remarks last night confirmed me in my opinion. Senator Bigger claimed not to be a constitutional lawyer or a politician, and I am afraid that he is not a scientist in politics. His speech was one of the most inaccurate I have heard produced in a public debate for a long time.

What did Senator Bigger ask us to believe? He wants us to believe that this Government here which is based on the will of the people, this present Government which is making every effort to clear away trial by special tribunal and imprisonment without charge, is exactly equivalent to the Government under which I live, a Government which claims that it cannot govern without the Special Powers Act which is an abrogation of every decency of ordinary civil law. Senator Bigger asks us to assume that we must treat the one Government with the same deference and the same delicacy as we treat the other. One thing I know about Senator Bigger is that he is not living in the Six Counties and I am. He says that there is no coercion in the Six Counties. There is a fascist police force, armed and paid for by all the people who live in the Six Counties, including us Nationalists, and I could tell Senator Bigger a long story about their treatment of myself. There was no open coercion against me although I know from the inside records— because I have my own intelligence service—that it was said by police authorities: we will have to put this man, Ireland, in jail during the war. The matter was discussed and they came to the conclusion that they could not put me in jail because I knew too many influential people. Short of that, my telephone was tapped, my mail was interfered with, the police visited my house and searched my papers simply because I was an opponent of the Government, an opponent who suggested that what we should do at that time was for all of us to get into green uniforms and help to defend the country. Yet Senator Bigger tells me that I must treat that Government up there with the same deference and delicacy as I would treat this seat of Government here. I submit that the comparison of unlikes is the father of all faulty reasoning. Here in this House, however, we have a scientist comparing the most blatant unlikes and asking us to accept the reasoning. If Senator Bigger performed experiments in his laboratory on that basis he would not get very far, but here we have an experiment affecting the lives of people and that is the reasoning on which it is based.

I knew that at some time in Senator Bigger's remarks he would come to deal with the old question of the British Navy. I knew that it was inevitable that it would come out. Why did the British Navy protect this country and our shores during the war? Was it for love of Ireland or was it to protect their own interests? Senator Professor Bigger did not tell us that the British Navy also protected the coasts of Holland, France and Belgium. Does Senator Bigger ask us to draw the conclusion that because the British Navy defended those coasts, the people of those countries owe loyalty to the British Crown? While the British Navy was protecting the coast of France one of the things that was worrying Britain and America was the cleavage of France into two sections and the splitting of French political opinion. That was their one bugbear. But the people of Britain and America did not subsidise and protect the interests making for division in France and yet they do it in Ireland. Senator Bigger did not bring that out in his allusions to the British Navy. I am afraid that Senator Bigger has confirmed me in my opinion. If scientists in politics would only bring into their outlook the same hard reasoning— because Senator Bigger is a distinguished scientist—that they devote to their scientific pursuits, all would be well, but I am afraid that they lead us astray when they come into politics and lead themselves astray. Senator Bigger made great play of loyalty to the Crown. He spoke of the Crown as being a centre for the British Commonwealth of Nations. I happen to be a Presbyterian, and we Presbyterians, I think, are ipso facto republicans. If a Six-County Presbyterian is not republican in politics it is due to the fact that he has not carried his thinking to a logical conclusion. In any event, the Six Counties is a much more republican area from a social point of view and in our outlook on life than this area down here.

The very philosophy of life in the Six Counties is republican. The very structure, the very government of our Presbyterian Church is republican. What I say to my Protestant friends who are not Presbyterians is that the problem facing you at the moment is perfectly simple. The problem facing the loyalist Protestants is under which King will you serve, the King of England or the King of Kings? If we want a centre for the real Commonwealth of freedom-loving nations, which I hope is going to come about in Western Europe, for all of us who follow the Christian ethic as a basis of society, is it not perfectly obvious that if we need a centre for that greater Commonwealth to which this Bill contributes, the centre for that co-operation of nations based on Christian ideals should be the King of Kings? Will the King of Kings not serve much better as a centre for that Christian effort than any earthly king? When one thinks of that, it puts these matters of loyalty to earthly kings in their proper perspective.

Senator Bigger also referred to the economic issues that might impede the reunion of this nation. He spoke of the economy and the great industries of the Six Counties and I think he mentioned social services. The trouble with Senator Bigger's reasoning is that it is so much after the fair. He tells us that he is not an ex-Unionist, but the brand of sentimentality and false reasoning to which he treated us last night bears such close relationship to ex-Unionist reasoning that I am afraid it is suspect, and to ram home that suspicion we have only to look at this morning's issue of an ex-Unionist paper and see the pæans of joy with which Senator Bigger's remarks were greeted.

On this question of the social services and of fitting the industries of the Six Counties into the framework of this country he was very much after the fair. The Ulster Union Club, a club of Protestant republicans, has published a booklet on that subject, and I have noticed that Ministers who have always referred to these social services as something which makes reunion impossible are now silent. I grant that the social services down here are coming up to the level of the Six Counties, and shortly they will be practically on a level with British social services, but even if they were not, the matter could be dealt with in the meantime so that there would be no falling off in the standard in the Six Counties. I have dealt with these matters that Senator Bigger raised, because I think that we have had a certain amount of false reasoning to clear away.

Let us come to this question of the loyalty of the Six Counties. Down here the King was treated as an office boy. In the Six Counties, I am afraid it is becoming increasingly clear that the Crown is becoming simply a counter in a political game, and if I were an Englishman I would very much deplore the so-called loyalty, the exploitation of loyalty in the Six Counties. I think it is most undignified from the point of view of the English Crown, and I am delighted to see that point of view creeping around in England and in responsible journals which I read, so that again Senator Bigger and this ex-Unionist form of argument—I am not saying that Senator Bigger is an ex-Unionist—are completely late for the fair.

Loyalty is exploited in the North of Ireland. A sentimental attachment to something is exploited by a group of men who ought to know better. The Ministers of the Six-County Government are men of leisure, education and solid financial background. Surely, from those of us who have these advantages all the greater responsibility in public affairs is asked? What do these men up there do? At the very moment when it would be absolutely into Britain's basket that we should have a united Ireland, at the very moment in the history of Europe when we stand in great danger on account of the division of this country, at that moment these so-called loyalists are exploiting loyalty for their own ends, because they are out for nothing else but a position of social and economic privilege. That is what it boils down to in the long run. All this pretty talk about loyalty cuts no ice with me—I live in the place, and I know.

There are many other points made in what Senator Bigger said which I could take up, but I want to get on now to my main reason for welcoming this Bill. I do not come to meet this Bill—this Bill comes to meet me, because I have been a republican in politics for the past 20 years, ever since I took an interest in politics. I welcome the Bill for that reason, and I welcome it for a wider reason, because I think that this Parliament, with the passage of this Bill, is throwing a searchlight on this condition of affairs in the Six Counties. You are, as the Taoiseach very ably and very clearly showed us yesterday, bringing this question on to an international basis, and, when this question is on an international basis, a searchlight will be projected on the state of affairs in the Six Counties. It is for that reason that I welcome the Bill.

If I may revert for one moment to the condition of affairs in the Six Counties, Sir Basil Brooke tries to make out that the issue is that "Ulster" is not for sale. That is not the issue at all, when you analyse the situation. The issue is: Is "Ulster" capable of recognising a moral issue in the history of Western Europe? That is the real issue. Are they capable of realising? Are these men of education, leisure and background capable of seeing that facing them is a great moral issue, because to me the moral issue is perfectly plain and has been plain to me ever since I thought about these matters? If we are the fine fellows we say we are, the place for us to prove that is in the united councils of Ireland. As soon as we take our place in these united councils, I am perfectly sure we will play our part and possibly a little more than our part.

That is the issue. Will the Six-County leaders see at the last moment the danger in which all Western Europe stands at the moment, because this island off the coast of Europe is just the same as the divided France of the last war? The conquest of space, the new supersonic planes and so on make this island strategically a portion of Western Europe, and at that very moment these leaders exploit these differences in Ireland. I welcome the Bill for the reason that here we have a framework within which we can honestly build for the future. I welcome the Bill as a Six-County Protestant republican. I welcome the Bill as a president of the Association of Young Ulster Protestants who are republican to a man. I welcome the Bill as a citizen of the Irish city in which republicanism, as such, first took shape and in which the social atmosphere is profoundly republican to this day. I welcome the Bill for all these reasons, and I believe it opens the way towards a fruitful future not only for us in Ireland but for our relations with Britain and the Commonwealth. At last we have put them on a basis of honesty and complete truthfulness.

Comment on this

I rise to support the Bill and I do so because I had the honour of being associated, in my own very humble way, with every forward movement towards the Republic of Ireland since 1916. I am proud that this day has come and proud of the unanimity shown by members of the Seanad in relation to this Bill. There was a time when such unanimity seemed impossible, but happily the day has come when we are all at one in the republican movement. Would to God it had happened earlier in our careers as public men. It is true that the Treaty was handed to us labelled as the stepping-stone to the republic, but it is also true that, during the ten years of Cumann na nGaedheal government, not one step was taken or one yard of advance made towards that republic. The Oath of Allegiance to England had to be removed from the Treaty and we had then, on behalf of the Irish people, to see that the land annuities earned in Ireland by the Irish farmers were kept at home and used here for the benefit of the Irish people. The next stepping-stone was the return of the ports and it is unnecessary to tell the House or the people of the country what might have happened during the recent war, were it not for the fact that these ports were in the hands of the Irish people. Then we had the External Relations Act, which was necessary, too, and which almost established the republic completely, at least for Twenty-Six Counties and, following that, the Constitution.

The extraordinary thing about all these forward steps which were mainly or entirely taken during the Government of Fianna Fáil is that unanimity was not gained in respect of any of them. Every one of these steps had to be taken against violent opposition from the other side. I have no desire to have an acrimonious discussion. If this Bill is found sufficient, if the constitutional lawyers find there is an "i" left undotted or a "t" uncrossed and wish to bring in a further Bill, I am sure they will find the same unanimity from this side of the House as they find on the present occasion.

I am afraid I have to get into a discussion which I did not wish to get into. We older people in the movement, some of us before 1916, never thought we would see this day, or the honour and pleasure of doing this thing. I congratulate everyone on all sides, past and present, and hope it will stand as it should stand, for the Government of this country as a republican Government. There are some slight fears in the minds of the people since this has come so suddenly on them, and they ask how it is that, all of a sudden, the English people and the Commonwealth of Nations have become so solicitous about us, how it is that during the discussion in the Dáil on this subject, at a certain psychological moment the Prime Minister of England, Australia, Canada and New Zealand were standing poised, ready to send a message to the Dáil, to the Minister for External Affairs, or the Taoiseach, assuring them in the middle of the debate that this country would suffer no ill-effects as regards trade or commerce or otherwise with those nations.

Comment on this

Who were the people who were suspicious about this?

Comment on this

The people of the country.

Comment on this

What people? Have you met them?

Comment on this

I meet them every day at the cross-roads, in shops and villages.

Comment on this

You must have facility for meeting queer people that no one else has.

Comment on this

The Senator meets them too, I am sure.

Comment on this

Not one. This is one of the Fianna Fáil humbugs we have to put up with.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Duffy must not be interrupting.

Comment on this

Can we correct him if he makes a mistake?

Comment on this

You cannot. There is the Cathaoirleach for that purpose.

Comment on this

That is not his function at all.

Comment on this

It has been already explained, but the Minister for External Affairs cannot too often reiterate the fact, that there is no quid pro quo for this Bill.

Comment on this

Why create that kind of suspicion in the public mind? Is that not treachery to the country?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator is entitled to make his point.

Comment on this

I am entitled to protest against treachery to this country.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Duffy can follow later on.

Comment on this

People in glass-houses should not throw stones.

Comment on this

There is no harm at all in the Minister or the Taoiseach or anyone else reiterating the fact, because that suspicion is in the country, no matter even what Senator Duffy may think. He must be in an extremely fine glass-house.

Comment on this

That is furthering and spreading the suspicion.

Comment on this

It is a natural suspicion.

Comment on this
A Senator

Now it is out.

Comment on this

It is natural suspicion —because Fianna Fáil is not in office.

Comment on this

There was no sign of a republic or anything of that kind in the minds of my friends on the other side of the House up to the last three or four months. They were completely opposed to an Irish Republic.

Comment on this

The Labour Party voted against the External Relations Act, 1936.

Comment on this

They voted against every measure——

Comment on this

Including the External Relations Act, which put the King in the Constitution.

Comment on this

Probably he was there by some silken thread capable of being snapped at any second.

Comment on this

It was never snapped in the last 16 years.

Comment on this

I think it was explained explicitly by Senator Lavery that the King was not in the Constitution.

Comment on this

Surely Senator Lavery explained the opposite?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senators will get time to rebut these statements later on, if they wish. Interruptions of this nature are not in order.

Comment on this

There is a widespread suspicion that there is some quid pro quo behind the scenes. Whether I believe it or not—and I really do not, because I accept the Minister's words always—he cannot too often reiterate that fact, for the contentment of the people of the State, that there is no quid pro quo, no military alliance, now or in the future.

Mr. Baxter rose.

Comment on this

May I interrupt Senator Baxter? I was third on the list last night. What has happened in the meantime? On a point of order, I am entitled to ask in what order the speakers are called here.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Baxter.

Comment on this
Seán MacBride Minister for External Affairs (Mr. MacBride) Clann na Poblachta

I wonder if I might put a question before Senator Baxter proceeds? May I ask Senator Honan, as he asks for assurances from the Government, if he could specify the kind of suspicions he had in mind, so that I may be able to deal with them in replying?

Comment on this

I will give just a rough idea of the kind of suspicion. The people I have listened to speaking— and I could not tell 50 per cent. of their political affiliations, as I do not question people about that and do not mind—seem to have the general idea that this Republic of Ireland Bill would not have come on so suddenly and with such great unanimity from all sources were it not for the possibility of some quid pro quo, that there is some contract or some kind of military alliance or some accommodation in times of war or conflict with other countries.

Comment on this

These are, for all of us, no matter what we think about this Bill, very historic days. There are many, probably on both sides of the House, who hardly dreamt they would live to see this situation come about. I have listened to a great many of the speeches delivered for and against this measure, but the truth is that some of apparently the most vigorous speeches made in defence of it were actually against it. Strangely enough, I heard three very unpleasant speeches delivered on it, and those three. I am ashamed to say, came from the mouths of Ulstermen. Two of them were Ulster Catholics in the other House, the ex-Minister for Finance and the ex-Minister for Local Government; and the other was Senator Bigger in this House. I am an Ulster Catholic and so is Senator Lavery. I would hope that, at this period in our country's history, there would be evidence from the people of Ulster of a better spirit of toleration, but if those whose names I have mentioned before Senator Lavery's and my own are typical of the spirit of Ulster, then Ulster has a great deal to learn, indeed, about Christian principles.

We listened to Senator Honan, who rarely talks very long in this House and who is never very aggressive. He expressed certain fears with regard to the consequences of this measure. The first thing I ought to say, as it has not yet been said and should be put on record, is that the people of this country at this historic moment were very fortunate indeed when this big step had to be taken that they were able to call to their service and the service of the nation the galaxy of legal talent which has been collected together in this Government. Probably never before in our country's history had we available men with the same genius, the same commanding intellect, the same firm purpose and resolution to do what they saw it was necessary to do, and do it in the right way. They had also the aid of the Attorney-General. I think everybody who listened to him last night will subscribe to the statement that he is a man who stands out among his fellows. When you think of the situation that has presented itself to us, with men like Senator Lavery and the Taoiseach and the Minister for External Affairs abandoning their calling, the Bar, to come and serve the nation, you can see why people paid so much for these services, and we ought to have an appreciation of the great sacrifice these people are making for the Ireland of to-day and to-morrow in placing their great abilities so unreservedly at the nation's disposal.

When I listened to the ex-Minister for Finance and the ex-Minister for Local Government in the other House and when I listened earlier to Deputy de Valera and now to Senator Honan, whom I like and respect and know for a very long time, I felt that there you had the whole story all of a piece. He revealed certain suspicions to-day. He did not express disappointment. But, in the other House, and in the Fianna Fáil Party everywhere throughout the country—they may say what they like —there is evidence of disappointment. Some conceal their disappointment better than others and some exploded, as these ex-Ministers did, in a way which is no credit to them or their Party or the country.

I suggest that when this Bill first appeared it was a shock to Fianna Fáil —so Senator Honan expressed himself, if I judge aright. The ex-Taoiseach received it then with a calm, gentle spirit that was rather enigmatical, and the general conduct of Fianna Fáil in the early stages of the discussion was not too unfavourable, until they heard the Taoiseach and the Minister for External Affairs in reply, until the story came of the reception of this decision in Great Britain, Canada, Australia and New Zealand, and then they were astonished. They could not believe their ears that this great step had been taken, this coping-stone on the arch put on without any consequences whatever. They looked into their own hearts and minds and probably thought of the things that would have happened had they attempted to do the same thing. They would have done it in such an unmannerly, discourteous fashion that they would have got us into another economic war and the storms that would be raised about our citizens in other lands would have so disturbed the people of the country that they would be able to give the cry again, "the old enemy, England".

When that has not happened, they are astonished. Why has it not happened? Because the men responsible are men of competence and ability, men with a clear outlook and, above all, men with no inferiority complex; modest men all of them no doubt, but men who when they go out of this country, are very good judges of the capacity and capabilities of those others whom they have to meet. They have been able to meet them at least on level terms, standing up for the rights of the people here in a courteous, civilised and learned way.

Senator Honan asks us what they got and what have they given. They have given nothing in exchange only the things that we were giving before. What have they got? They have got just what we had before, what we were enjoying under the other statutes of this Parliament and the Parliament of Great Britain and the Parliaments of the other States of the Dominions. But that astonishes Fianna Fáil. It adds to their disappointment. It should not be so. It is very unfortunate that that should be the reaction of the Opposition Party to this decision. It may be that they suffered keen disappointment that it was not possible for them to take this decision to repeal the External Relations Act. But how could Deputy de Valera do that, because that would have given support to all who said we were not a republic? He had his republic out of the Encyclopædia Britannica and, having got it, there was no need from his point of view, or at least the point of view of his political prestige, to repeal this Act. Therefore, it is left to others. They have had the courage to do it, and, if there is credit to be given, it should not have been grudged and the hares that Senator Honan raised should not have been raised.

This Bill embodies the dream of people over the generations. I can recall a March morning in Mountjoy Prison in 1921 when I, with a number of others, were coming in from the exercise ground. I walked up the passage, and Frank Flood said to me: "I wonder will we ever get a republic?" A few days afterwards Frank Flood and five of his companions were executed. While they and many others died so that this day should come about, the son of one of the leaders of Easter Week, and many others who fought in Easter Week, are playing their part in this achievement. Some people are troubled about those who supported the Commonwealth in the Fine Gael Party. Who are they? Why did they do it? I travelled strange ways myself, and, until I found myself amongst these people, there were days when I believed in Deputy Eamon de Valera. Until 1925, I still had a lingering belief that there were some of the things in him that we believed were in him after 1916. But, at a conference which I was responsible for summoning in the Shelbourne Hotel in 1925, when the ultimate financial settlement was coming before the Dáil, when I heard the solution that Deputy de Valera had to offer us then, when he told us that, in order to put on record the fact that when this Bill was passed in Dáil Éireann, the majority of the elected representatives of the people were against it, we would simply go and sign our names in a book; when I heard him say that, instead of saying: "We the majority, will go in and vote against it," I was so completely disillusioned that I saw the man for the humbug that he was. That is what I believe he has been doing all along, since. Where was one going to find oneself then? Eventually, I found myself associating with the people who had accepted the Treaty, who had fought for it. There were amongst those who backed that Party then, a great many of the people who were what was known as ex-Unionists. I feel there are some who are not even "ex" to-day.

I could not help feeling, when Professor Bigger was speaking, that if he represented his true self, there was another place that would suit his type of mind and his attitude much better than this, that is, the Unionist Party in the Northern Parliament. I have heard a great many of the people who have spoken in the name of the minority in this country since 1922 and I must say that his speech was by far the most unpleasant. At this time it is astonishing, more astonishing still from a man named Bigger, who tells us that his ancestors were Joe Bigger and James Hope, and others. I have very good reason to have very great respect for the name of Joe Bigger. My grandfather, my namesake, at the end of the last century was, with a few others, responsible for bringing Joe Bigger to Cavan and helping to elect him to the British Parliament. Joe Bigger was the master obstructionist, not a great orator, but a gallant Irishman and he was associated with another Protestant leader who in those years declared that no man had the right to set a boundary to the march of a nation. In the genetical sense there are such expressions as "true to type" and "throwbacks", but I do not think that Senator Bigger is a throwback to Joe Bigger. If Joe Bigger were here to-day there would not be anyone more proud than he that other generations have made the contributions they have made to bring this day about.

The people of this country in every generation wanted liberty and freedom. They wanted peace. They wanted stability, a chance to make progress. These are the things that are being given to us under this measure. We are going to be given stability.

I hope we are taking the guns out of Irish politics. I believe we are— not out of all Irish politics because there are far more guns in the politics of the Six Counties than there are in the Twenty-Six Counties, and Senator Bigger knows that. When he speaks to this House of the toleration that is here, it makes one feel that he is playing with words. There was not so much necessity to make that speech here yesterday, but there has been many a time over the years when a statement like that from him or his likes in this country, repudiating the charges that have been made by the bigoted Northern leaders would have carried a good deal of weight. When recently a minister at a church assembly spoke about the intolerance of the Catholics, that would be the time for one of the Trinity professors to contradict that, and to express the view that Irish Catholics are indeed tolerant.

When I heard him on this I could not help recalling a speech that I read when I was a boy. In the election of 1910 or 1909, the same charges were being levelled as are being levelled to-day. There was an election in County Monaghan. One of the candidates was the late James Lardner and the other was M.E. Knight. The present Bishop of Ardagh was then a young priest in Clones and he addressed himself to this very same charge. He said something like this in answer to these people: In God's name, when were Irish Catholics intolerant? Go into the humblest cot on the countryside and what picture will you most often find on the walls— the picture of Robert Emmet, that young Irish Protestant patriot who, because he laid down his young life in a heroic, perhaps a foolish, attempt to free his country from the chains of slavery, young Ireland has taken to her heart and written his name in letters of gold in the roll of her martyred dead. Now, 50 years after, we have to answer the same charges. Is it not time that these people grew up? Senator Bigger thinks that the people in Fine Gael have abandoned a position they had occupied for a long time and that he and his supporters have a grievance. He apparently voted for the Taoiseach in the last election and now he is going to vote for Deputy MacEntee in future. They have the same type of mind and Deputy MacEntee is welcome to him. I would feel very hurt indeed if the attitude of people with the outlook of Senator Bigger was to influence Mr. John A. Costello or the part he was to play in Fine Gael or in the inter-Party-Government.

I do not know what these people did in one or two constituencies, but I do know that, on the whole, they did nothing but vote for Fianna Fáil. In my own constituency, after they had voted for their Protestant candidate, they voted for Fianna Fáil. It was the same in the adjoining constituency of Monaghan and the same in Longford. In Westmeath they voted for non-Catholic Fianna Fáil Deputies. They did it in Meath and everywhere in the country, north and south, and yet now they make a claim on us. That attitude of mind cannot prevent the nation from marching on. We are exercising rights now that we are free to exercise because we are led by men of competence and courage, and none of the fears that these people have expressed are going to come to us. No longer are we going to give allegiance to kings except to one King, and I think that this is a time when we should rejoice. I do not want to take from what the people over there did or from the contribution they made, but I want to correct Senator Honan when he said that nothing was done for the whole ten years previous to their coming into office to hasten us along the road to this day. Surely the Statute of Westminster was of itself a great achievement. I heard the ex-Minister for Industry and Commerce say something similar. I can make no claim to having given support to the Treaty, but I wonder if the Treaty had not been accepted where would we be standing and would we have had any place to stand? I do not know, and history cannot record because that experiment was not tried.

This stage we have reached was brought about by the efforts of many generations and Fianna Fáil, in its way, has made its contribution. I suggest that when the people who worked together and drafted the Statute of Westminster achieved their object, they did something for the British Commonwealth of Nations that it took Irishmen to do. I believe sincerely that this new decision which has been taken by the Government, these new foundations they are laying, are opening up possibilities for many other nations as well as ourselves. I believe that not alone is it holding the nations that were in the Commonwealth and people like ourselves who were outside such as the people of India and elsewhere, together, but it is opening up vistas and possibilities to other nations who see the dangers ahead to rally round an idea. Above everything, Irishmen stand for the supremacy of Christain principles and ideals and it is in that spirit that this Bill was introduced and that it will be passed. If it is debated and implemented in that way by all of us, I believe that it will lay the foundation for much better relations between this country and Britain and it will do something more, it is creating a situation when the possibility of the nations of Western Europe rallying round this idea is far greater than it was before. That, I think, is a major reason why this Bill should be accepted by all of us with unanimity.

Comment on this

I would like to put my interpretation of history on record, since so many have already done so from their own point of view. I have no past to apologise for; I would not even have to apologise for my presence here; I have no particular Party to defend. It is fairly well known that when the inter-Party Government was first suggested, I did not approve of the proposal, not because I thought it was undesirable for Irishmen of different points of view and different political allegiances to come together and work together, but because I thought the thing was done hastily and that no good could come out of it; I confess I was mistaken. As an unrepentant republican who can trace his ancestry much further back even than Senator Bigger—we can trace ours back to the Battle of Clontarf—I say, as others have said, that we are not now asked to proclaim a republic; the republic was proclaimed a long time ago and all we are doing is putting a name on the State or christening the child. Some people may dispute when the child was born; some cannot agree who its parents were; Senator Bigger goes on a different line and says that the child is not legitimate. Instead of christening the child, he would have vaccinated it and used a Union Jack instead of a vaccination mark.

I want to go back on history, and relate the history of the past with the history of the last few weeks. I read, as we all did when this proposal was first made known in the papers, the hullabaloo that was started about the disasters that were going to fall on this country because the King was being put out of the State, and because we were declaring a republic. The people who started the agitation have not, in my opinion, any great regard for the King of England. They have regard for their own interests and nothing else. When an assurance was given on this side and on the British side that it would make no fundamental change in ordinary commercial and industrial relations between the two countries, the hullabaloo was dropped by the Unionists and the ex-Unionists. If they protested, they protested that the Protestants had been betrayed.

We know that there are various sorts of Protestants, and, in my opinion, the Protestant religion is a very easy one; you can make a religion to suit yourself and still have it. I do not think that the Protestant religion is a political idea, but we are asked to accept the Protestant outlook. If Protestants want to have a religion, let them have it and let them live up to it, but I am not going to have a Protestant point of view rammed down my neck under the pretence of its being a political outlook. I have one objection to the External Relations Act, and it is that if we had to choose an instrument or agent to carry on for us and to sign our diplomatic credentials, and if, as Deputy de Valera stated recently, we were at liberty to choose any instrument we liked, why, of all people in the world, did we choose the King of England? Look what a hullabaloo would be kicked up by Trinity College, and by the Unionists had we chosen the Pope, and yet we are supposed to be acquiescent and agreeable when they choose the head of an alien church, a Church which says we are— but I do not want to repeat the things they call us. One can read their Oath of Succession, and see what they have to say about the Catholics.

I have no love for the King, or any desire to be under the King of England, because he was the King of England and I am an Irishman. Although I was born and reared in the tradition that the King of England was no friend of Ireland, it became more than a tradition, and almost an instinct, with the plain people of Ireland, and I dislike the King of England and the English Government instinctively. For that reason, when we get rid of the King out of our affairs, I can look on the English with tolerance, and I will have no reason to hate them unless I go back again on the past. We should not approach it in the attitude some Senators have taken; an attempt should not be made to make Party capital out of it, but Party capital has been made out of it, or an attempt has been made to do so. Even when the Taoiseach was appointing his 11 nominees to this House, one of whom I am, that same paper, the Irish Times, protested against the Taoiseach's right to exercise his constitutional privilege and to appoint whom he thought fit to this House. They specifically mentioned some of the people of whom they approved, and carefully pointed out that these were Protestants, and so were all right, but just as directly they excluded me from their list, and a few others. They mistakenly included Senator Miss Butler as a Protestant, and could not very well back out of approving of her afterwards, when they discovered their mistake.

I was one of the people who was not approved of by the Irish Times. I was one of the people who was described by the editor of the Irish Times as a political hack. I would never have bothered about defending myself against the editor of the Irish Times or anybody else, but for the fact that I have now got to the stage when I can tell what a political hack means in this country. I was for a great many years on the editorial staff of an Irish newspaper. That newspaper cried out in Easter Week, before I went on its staff, that enough men had not been executed and that paper has never been allowed to forget that since. That was done because the paper was owned by political hacks. It was not done because it was the desire of the journalists to write that sort of stuff and the men who wrote that had to write it to dictation, just as the present editor of the Irish Times, being a political hack, has to write what the owner of his paper tells him to write.

People like myself who were described as political hacks worked on that paper. We influenced the policy of the paper. I, as one of the editorial staff, refused to write things which I thought should not be written. I refused to write things which I thought unpatriotic and undesirable. I, frequently, as other men on that staff did, took the risk of being sacked, and eventually we altered the policy of that paper somewhat and you only have to go back and read what that paper published and what I wrote in that paper when Terence MacSwiney was dying on hunger-strike. We altered the policy of that paper and we did our best, even at the risk of our jobs, to see that the rights of the nation and the rights of the Irish people would always take precedence over our own personal rights and our own jobs. I do not want to blow my own trumpet, but if that be the type of thing that marks the political hack I am proud to be a political hack.

My record in the Irish movement, like that of Senator Hayes, goes back a long time. He and I were boys together and, as far back as 1907, we were in the earliest of the Sinn Féin movements. We were in the same branch of Connradh na Gaeilge and I have still the newspaper cuttings from Sinn Féin—a few fugitive sheets they were then—of our meetings, in which his name and mine are mentioned, as well as those of a few other men, some of whom are dead and some of whom still live. We were only boys and we were there at that time defying the British Empire and defying the British Crown, and we kept it up. We took different roads afterwards, but we never became political hacks. I go back because I want to show who are the people who are backing this Bill and this Government.

I was in the Howth gun-running. I was out in 1916 and I was arrested, but I thought I was very clever and I escaped from the City Hall while under arrest. I did not kill anybody in Easter Week because the job was not given to me to kill anybody. I went out and was prepared to do whatever fell to me to do. The job they gave me might have been considered a menial job by others; it was not so considered by me. The Countess handed me a bundle of proclamations and said: "Will you get these posted up?" I posted them up in the streets of Dublin and while going around I met Sheehy Skeffington. He and I walked together and parted outside Jacob's. He said to me: "Will you come up this way?" And I said: "No; I am going down to my mother's to get paste to put these up." Sheehy Skeffington went the other way, was arrested within 20 minutes, and was shot by Bowen-Colthurst, one of the King's officers in this country. I escaped while under arrest and so escaped deportation.

I never claimed credit for it. I never asked for a pension and never even applied for a medal, but we were the unknown people, the rank and file, the ordinary people who kept the fight going when the leaders were interned and deported. In 1917, we kept it going and I kept the only Sinn Féin paper that was in existence at that time going. I kept Irish Fun going when Brian O'Higgins was deported and interned. In 1918, it was unimportant people like myself and the man who is now District Justice Reddin, together with one or two others like us, who could scarcely make a speech, who went out and stood at the cross-roads, who went through the whole of County Dublin, and particularly North County Dublin, stood on ditches and defied the British Empire and their constabulary, although it was only a very short time before that the men who had declared the republic, who had fought for the republic and who had declared their allegiance to Ireland had been executed, imprisoned or deported.

We went out, and we did our share at that time. I am not, as I say, blowing my own trumpet. I was only doing what I thought should have been done and what thousands of others did —I claim no credit for it—and what we would have been discredited for not doing. We came then to the Treaty debates and I sat through the whole of them. I listened to the speeches and I was influenced by the leaders of the time, and I took sides when sides were taken. I took the anti-Treaty side. I risked my job and I lost my job, and I had to do menial work but I stuck to my principles and, like the rest of the people, I never flinched.

I thought the Free State was a bad bargain and I stood with Deputy de Valera, as he is now, and with the anti-Treatyites. When it came to the occupation of the Four Courts, I went into the Four Courts and I talked with Rory O'Connor. I say this now, from that conversation with Rory O'Connor that Rory O'Connor and these men who went out with guns at that time did not go out to start a civil war. They went out to show that if there was any attempt at watering down, if there was any possibility of improving the terms England was offering, there were men there to see that a better bargain was got, if it could be got, and that, if all else failed, there would always be men to see that the best was made of whatever bargain was got. They never intended that brothers should turn guns on brothers, but it happened, and neither one side nor the other can be blamed for it. Both must be blamed for it.

Capital has been made in this debate and in the debate in the other House as to this Bill taking the gun out of politics. The gun came into Irish politics long ago. As I said, I was on the side of the men who brought the guns into politics, but they were brought in by both sides. I will say something now which probably nobody else is in a position to say. I saw what happened and I saw, to quote Deputy de Valera's words, which have often been misinterpreted since, brother shooting brother and I saw them wading through brother's blood. Deputy de Valera did not say that should be done; he said it might be done, and it was done. It was a prophecy and not a suggestion that it should be done. I saw it happen. Two boys of 16 years of age left my house one day. They were members of Fianna Éireann and they had no arms. They were acting as messengers for the republicans. They were picked up on the road by some Free State troops and that was the last seen of them alive. Their next appearance was in the morgue in the Mater Hospital and I have here in my hand the photograph of them lying there dead. They were two boys of 16 years of age, shot down by Irishmen because they were carrying messages for the anti-Treatyies.

The horror of that came to me and I said this thing should not go on, and I used what influence I could to stop it. Eventually it was stopped, not through my influence, but I approved of the stopping of it, and I approved of the laying down of the guns. To make it worse, while the shooting was going on, we, the anti-Treatyites, paid for and had printed, this document. It is a document which I will read:—

"Dáil Éireann.

Government of the Republic of Ireland.

Oifig an Uachtaráin,

Baile Atha Cliath,

...............1923.

To:......................

A Chara,

On behalf of the Government and the Army of the Republic, I beg to tender to you and to the other relatives of...........................our sincere sympathy with you in your sorrow. .........................died nobly defending the independence of our country. His devotion will be an inspiration and an incentive to all his comrades to persevere faithfully until the objects for which he gave his life are achieved. A Free Ireland will pay tribute to his sacrifice, and his memory will be cherished for ever to the triumph of the cause which he championed."

I did not think that was a thing to give any Irish parent in exchange for the life of their son. Even that was not given, because immediately it was printed, we got orders—and I happened to hold those things at the time—not to send out any more of them.

I have a letter here from the Office of the Assistant Adjutant-General, Óglaigh na hÉireann:—

29/1/'23.

"Enclosed from the President. The condolence letters will have to be scrapped. You will learn from his note what the President wants."

The President's note was—I will not read the whole of it:—

"As given in my draft the last paragraph runs: ‘A free Ireland will pay tribute to his sacrifice and his memory will be cherished for ever in the triumph of the cause which he championed.'

As it will have to be reprinted, owing to the mistake ‘to' instead of ‘in'...."

We had a quibble about words and we forgot the realities. We have forgotten about the guns in politics and I hope there will be no going back to them now. Let us confess our sins instead of the sins of our neighbours. The gun came into politics in the time of the civil war and I have a letter here from the Department of the Quartermaster-General. He was asked: "Will you buy a .45 Webley revolver for 30/-?" The reply was: "I will, of course, buy the article. It is well that you be sure that you are not buying one of our own from one of our men." The gun came into politics, and the 30/- was paid for a gun from one Irishman to shoot another.

I believe the Bill we are passing to-day has taken the gun out of politics, just as it has taken the King out of the law. I think it is desirable that from now on we should think of the future rather than the past. I am confessing that we were wrong, but I want to say this, that we were wrong on both sides, when he started fighting each other over the Treaty, when we started fighting about oaths; because there were oaths both in Document No. 2 and in the Treaty. We fought about oaths in 1922, and we are fighting about oats in Donegal in 1948. We are always fighting about something that does not seem to be very important.

In 1927 on July 2nd there had been an election. Fianna Fáil went to the electors as a new Party. I cannot remember how many Fianna Fáil Deputies were elected. They got about one-third of the total votes, but they did not go into the Dáil. They were still denying that the Treaty gave us any machinery which could be used for improving the status of this country. Henry Harrison was publishing Irish Truth, and he asked the late Cruise O'Brien and myself to carry on his paper while he was conducting his campaign. We carried on that paper for him, and in that paper on July 2nd I wrote an article addressed to Fianna Fáil. The heading was “A Republican's View.” In the course of the article, I said:—

"The future can be based only on the present, as the existing conditions grew out of those which preceded them. In the Treaty and in the Free State Constitution, there are admittedly defects that might well be remedied, but the Treaty is a valuable tool which, properly used, will bring peace and, at least, some fair measure of prosperity to the country. We republicans must realise this and, knowing it, must also know that the time for constructive work is the present moment."

I wrote that. Fianna Fáil had adopted the policy of abstention up to then, but within a couple of weeks Fianna Fáil changed its policy and went into the Dáil. I had some share in the shaping of Fianna Fáil policy then. I have had some share in the shaping of it since. I see Senator Hawkins laughing quite contentedly to himself, that anyone should claim that he had done anything to advance the status of this country, or that anyone had done anything for this country but de Valera. I have done more, have possibly sacrificed more, through loyalty to de Valera, than any member of the present Fianna Fáil Party. I have done it willingly and I make no boast about it and no complaint about it. Even as late as 1935, when Fianna Fáil wanted propaganda done for them, they came to me and I wrote their propaganda though not a member of their Party. So do not let it be said that the people bringing in this Bill are a body of ex-Unionists who betrayed the country in the past. I want to show that, whatever Party one belonged to, the history of Ireland did not begin with the present members of the Fianna Fáil Party. They should not begrudge a share of the honour to everybody else who helped to shape the destinies of this country.

Although I believe in the infallibility of the Pope in matters of faith and morals, I believe in no man's political infallibility and I follow no leader blindly. There has been too much hero-worship in this country in recent years and too little consideration for the rights of the people. I did not want to go on the lines on which I have gone, but I believe it was right that these things should be said, to show that, if we stand now for an inter-Party Government, we have neither betrayed our principles nor do we intend to betray the nation in the future.

I never thought I would come to defend a Cumann na nGaedheal Party or a Fine Gael Party, but it has been said that the electors have been betrayed by that Party. Can we never think of anything else in Ireland? Captain Henry Harrison, no enemy of Mr. de Valera, in Irish Truth, on the 25th June, 1927, wrote:—

"A widespread impression was created throughout the country by speech, by poster, by handbills and by the common say-so of their supporters, that Fianna Fáil were going into the Dáil with an elaborate programme either as a majority to form a Government or as a minority to form an active constructive Opposition. A very large section of those who voted for his candidates will feel that they have been cheated by Mr. de Valera's delusive propaganda."

The same thing was said then—there was always somebody being deluded, someone being misled. We have come to a new era in Irish history, a time for stocktaking. Since we are all looking back, I took the liberty of looking back, too, but I think it is more important that we should look forward.

I think there are other things which we will have to get rid of as well as the British Crown and the British Government's interference in our affairs. If we could not tolerate the King as an external agent, as an office boy, a rubber stamp, I wonder are we going to tolerate for ever the interference of the British trade unions in our affairs. I know the way we are supposed to bow down and genuflect if anyone raises a copy of the Constitution in his hand. The Constitution can be a dangerous thing, as the trade unions the right to operate freely in which is a republican Constitution, I am sure, gave and maintains and establishes for the British trade unions the right to operate freely in this country, a right not conceded to them in any part of the British Empire outside Great Britain itself. They cannot run their branches in Canada, India, Australia or New Zealand. But, by this sacrosanct Constitution, this republican Constitution, out of which the King was taken, the British unions were formally established and left there.

I want to know whether in the formal declaration of our republic that we are making now we are doing more than formally declaring the title of this State to be a republic. We have got an assurance that it will be formally recognised by other nations, a thing never done up to now. But, having got that status, are we going to take a subordinate position to any part of the British Empire by allowing Great Britain to interfere in our trade union affairs and to dominate and dictate to us in matters of finance?

Comment on this

Would the Senator coerce his fellow-citizens?

Comment on this

I will coerce no man to do anything. I never coerced with a gun or with economic pressure. I have been subject to coercion for my opinions, and the coercion which was put on us, when it was not the guns, was the threat of starvation. We were sacked. I approved of the Fianna Fáil Government's policy more than I did of their predecessors, because I thought that in a great many things they were more national, because I knew they were anxious, if it could be done, to find a way to get rid of British trade union interference in this country. They did put up a proposal which would have met it. They said that no man would sacrifice any benefits, and, as was done in the case of the insurance companies, they guaranteed that a fund would be established by which men could carry over their benefits if they left the British unions. Some of the British unions were agreeable that it should be done. But, if we have a republic, and if we have the right to manage our own affairs, that right should not be restricted in any shape or form by an alien agency.

I do not want to go into other matters, but I want to say that I was for a while connected with one of these British unions, because we had no choice at the time. It was a long time ago, and there was no other union catering for journalists. We had the choice of two British unions and we had to stick to one of them. We did, however, try on every possible occasion to limit its interference with our affairs. We had to join it for our own industrial and economic safety.

Comment on this

I think the Senator is going a long way outside this Bill.

Comment on this

I do not think I am. I am dealing with the status of this country. If the status of this country is to be a republic in future, it should be a free and independent nation. So long as the republic which we are declaring in this Bill is hampered in its control of its own industrial affairs by British trade union officials who have the right to operate here, a right they do not claim in Canada and cannot exercise in the British Empire——

Comment on this

That is a matter for future legislation.

Comment on this

It is within anybody's right to set me right. I know the Constitution declares that men have the right to choose unions of their own choice. I want to make sure that the British unions will not undermine the national movement here, as some of them were attempting to do. There was a great attempt made to undermine the national movement by agitation carried on in the trade union movement under the banner of the Labour Party. We formed a separate independent Labour Party because we thought there was interference.

Comment on this

That is going outside the provisions of the Bill.

Comment on this

If it is going outside the Bill, I am sorry, but it seems to me to affect the status of this nation. I want to know what the republic is and what the republic will do——

Comment on this

That is a matter for future legislation.

Comment on this

Do not go back to Brian Boru.

Comment on this

I might go back to Brian Boru or further, but I shall make my own speech and the Senator has a right to make his afterwards. I am neither the paid official nor the mouthpiece of any foreign union.

Comment on this

Neither am I.

Comment on this

I cannot see that it is out of order, when we have a Bill to declare the Republic of Ireland, when we are taking the King out of our affairs and declaring ourselves a free, unfettered nation, that I should point out that we do not become a free and unfettered nation merely by the passing of this Bill, that there are other steps which must be taken. I do not want to have the gun brought back into politics. I do not want that Irishmen should have to fight about trade union matters. But, if we are capable of governing the nation, we ought to be capable of running our own trade unions.

Comment on this

May I intervene to say that the Minister for External Affairs will be concluding the debate? I wonder if we could fix a time at which he could conclude the debate. Perhaps if we said 4 o'clock we might do our best to reach a situation in which the Minister might rise at 4 o'clock.

Comment on this

Will that be concluding the debate?

Comment on this

Yes, on the Second Stage.

Comment on this

There are a number of Senators anxious to take part.

Comment on this

There is no desire to restrict the debate, but just to have, so to speak, an ideal that the Minister would conclude at 4 o'clock.

Comment on this

Of course, we could not make a definite arrangement that he should conclude at 4 o'clock. I would ask Senators, however, to bear that in mind and to endeavour to shorten their speeches so that the Minister for External Affairs may conclude about 4 o'clock.

Comment on this

First of all, I must say that I welcome this Bill, as I feel every nationally-minded Irishman does, whether he is at home here or in one of the far corners of the world. I have to admit that I am in agreement with those who have felt in recent years that there was doubt and confusion about the position in which we were. It humiliated me when abroad to have this constant taunt thrown at me, "You claim to be Irish, but you are British; you still use the British King." In saying that, we have to recall the time when the External Relations Act was introduced, when the world atmosphere was entirely different from what it is to-day. I doubt if any Senator would be bold enough to declare that what we are doing now would be possible to achieve when that Act was passed. We have to-day a ready acceptance of this attitude and decision of ours by Great Britain herself and by her constituent dominions and selfgoverning colonies. Would we have that before the war? Of course, we would not.

Now that we have got it, I want to join with those who paid tribute to the understanding and friendly gesture shown in the utterances of the Prime Ministers of Great Britain, Australia, Canada, South Africa, India, and the rest who so readily accepted the position, which at any rate has been clarified for them without question or doubt. But, when we listened last night to Senator Bigger, who declared that his roots go back 300 years, I had the feeling that the roots have not struck yet. What would have been the feelings of a Frenchman, a Spaniard, or a German proud to be called a Frenchman, a Spaniard, or German, if he heard a man declare that he and his forebears were here for 300 years, but they had not yet readily fallen in with the wishes and desires of the people amongst whom they live? Are they ever going to be absorbed? Does not his Bill indicate that from now on a man, if he claims to be Irish, must prove that he is Irish, and that there can be no divided loyalties, that an Englishman owes loyalty to his own country, that a Frenchman owes loyalty to France? Is not this Bill simply asserting that and, without any hostility to any, is it not asking for an Irishman to declare and prove and act just as an Irishman and not as a compromise, as something else?

There are one or two points that come up, and I think we must ask for information on them. In this new and friendly atmosphere that has been envisaged, and which I am one of those who firmly believe will happen—I believe we are going to have stronger association with those people who think as we do, when this association can be offered by us as friendly equals based on common interest and on friendship rather than on forced loyalty that was always fictitious and never worth a hoot. Having got that, though, are we consciously or unconsciously opening the way to any dangers to ourselves?

I have heard loose statements about new facilities, equality of citizenship, and the rest. I only mention these so that the Taoiseach can answer them, because they are of importance to us all. We have here a small, newly created industrial and commercial arm. A Control of Manufactures Act was introduced for the purpose of enabling these infant industries to maintain themselves against the inroads of our more powerful industrial neighbour. I would like to know, and I think the Taoiseach might thank me for giving him an opportunity to make it clear, whether the position of the real Irishman under these Acts is going to be maintained, whether his position is going to be loosened or worsened in any way, and, furthermore, as regards that other important matter, the acquisition of property tax, which put an Irishman in the position that he could hope to get some of his own property at a reasonable price, and be protected in some measure against these people coming from across-Channel who get money easier than any of us have discovered a way of getting it, whether that position is to be maintained.

Comment on this

That is entirely a matter for the Legislature of this country, and has nothing whatever to do with the arrangement. It is entirely a matter for the Legislature.

Comment on this

In any case, of itself, this Act of ours does not worsen the position?

Comment on this

No, it has no effect on it whatever. It is a matter for the Legislature what they will do subsequently, if they do anything. I am not saying anything about that.

Comment on this

I hope the Bill is going to make us, ourselves, restore the words Ireland and Irish to their proper place in our national life. I am appalled every time I get a copy of a Bill that we have to discuss, even the present one, when the word "Éire" is used in the English context of the Bill. I often wonder why we have played into the hands of those who want to damage us by using the word "Éire" both in Irish and English. I do hope we are going to have an assurance now that in so far as the Government can do it, the word "Ireland" is coming back to the place which it should never have been taken out of and that we are not going to make it possible for the Daily Mail and other newspapers to describe us by that appalling adjective “Eirish”.

Propaganda to-day is a subtle and powerful weapon. I think we have not made the fullest possible use of it. The one regret I have, and it is the one regret that has been shared by those who, like me, support this Bill, is that to-day, instead of having this Republic of Ireland covering our 32 counties, it only covers Twenty-Six Counties. In travelling about one finds people who would be horrified at the suggestion that they were not well informed, who do not know that a majority of the people in the whole 32 counties of Ireland want an all-Ireland, 32-county Parliament. We have to do something to put that matter right.

I have here, under the date 2nd December, a statement by the Minister for Commerce of Northern Ireland in which he describes Éire as a foreign country and proposes to say nothing further as it was "improper for this House"—that is Stormont—"to discuss the affairs of a foreign country." Would that Minister dare to go to the Glens of Antrim and tell the Irish-speaking residents there that he regarded them as alien because they claim to be Irish? That is propaganda that is going on day after day and I do hope that having established, as we are doing to-day, the republic for the Twenty-Six Counties, we will use it as a new base for a steady and very determined effort to let the rest of the world know that Partition was imposed on this country, not 100 years ago, nor 150 years ago, but in the life-time of every man and woman in this room, that it is a recent thing that no Irishman asked for. When we make that fact known by properly prepared propaganda we will hasten the day we all hope for when this Republic of Ireland will extend from shore to shore of the whole 32 counties. I can say a lot more but I know the desire is to give the Minister a chance to conclude early and I will content myself with these few remarks. I heartily endorse the Bill.

Comment on this

I am a non-republican and there are a certain number of people in this country who are also non-republicans. How are we approaching this matter? First of all I would like to say that I am going to try to stick to the Bill and the matters arising out of the Bill. Some people in this country feel that there was an alternative to this Bill. They felt, and feel, that the framework of the Commonwealth is at present being remoulded. That it is going to be extended to include not only the Dominions like Canada, Australia and New Zealand, but also other countries such as India and Pakistan. I do not know if the revised Commonwealth would have suited our aspirations. Certainly, there are people who are apparently going to be in that Commonwealth, if they are satisfied, namely, India and Pakistan, who would have ideas about the sovereignty of their State and who would have to have their aspirations satisfied. My personal feeling is that that position should have been explored. I do not know how far the Government considered that matter, but in any case a different course has been adopted. The leader of the Government assures us that the change will make little or no difference. This may be true in the main, but undoubtedly there will be cases of individual hardship. I think this cannot be denied and all that can be done is to endeavour to mitigate that.

I am trying to approach the Bill as a realist and, having left the Commonwealth, how are we to ensure our defence or with whom are we going to be associated? Are we going to join a group which may be possibly the Commonwealth or some larger group? It is no use for us to hide our head in the sand, for some measures will have to be taken for an associated defence. Apparently rumour has been busy—I suppose you cannot prevent people from considering that—and I feel that this country must be associated for the purpose of defence with other people. It is no use for us to think that we can rely on our own strong right arm. Belgium wished to remain neutral in the last two wars and she was caught in the vortex before she even made any preparations. In the course of this discussion, I have listened to arguments from people who know far more than I do about the matter and I have listened to arguments on the question of whether we are in the Commonwealth or have left it or whether this was a republic or was not a republic. These questions can be argued if you take different points of view. This Bill, however, is going to settle that matter. One of the things that I deprecate in this discussion is that everybody seems to be trying to claim a certain amount of credit for himself or for somebody associated with him or to cast discredit on what someone else has done. There is no doubt that this country, like other countries, is in a process of evolution. I listened to speakers who contended that all the people who joined in various movements for centuries past were entitled to be given full credit. I would go still further than that and say that I do not think even that is wide enough. My concept would be that everybody who has contributed to the life of this country as a useful citizen in no matter what walk of life, whether actively engaged in politics or in trade or commerce, is entitled to his due share in the advancement of this country.

I believe that the real development of a country depends on the building up of the moral force and fibre of the country. When a moral force can be built up, the barriers seem to crumble. No movement or no country could be united or get anywhere if people start bickering about how far each person has contributed. We can look around at the gradual growth all over the world of an informed and ordered opinion. I am rather weak on history, but I think that all movements throughout the world have started with freedom. That is the most important thing of all, and without freedom you cannot get anywhere. Of course, there are various freedoms. There is religious, political and economic freedom. Everybody seems to approach their ideal and the problem of how it is to be obtained with a consideration of what physical force can be mustered in support of it, and they only think secondly of moral force. I would like to mention, for the consideration of the House—and possibly some of the historians will correct me if I am wrong— the fact that slavery was abolished without fighting. I do not mean to say that there are not slaves at the present time, but no one in the world supports that. Slavery disappeared through the moral force of the people who advocated that measure. I would like to urge upon this House that the most important question is how we can muster our moral force for the advancement of this country's best interests. Everybody does not see eye to eye, but a whole lot of people may see eye to eye with a movement, and cannot a percentage of them be brought in in support of the status of the country.

One thing that has astonished me in connection with this Bill is how little thought has been given or explanation offered as to the quality of the republic that it is proposed to set up. I take it that when this Bill has passed, as those introducing this measure have stated, a republic will have been set up; we will have passed through a door, and the question then will be what quality of a republic is it proposed to support? Is it the status quo? We have all listened to various republicans in the past, some of whom advocated that no foreign goods should be allowed into this country, some that there should be no commitments in regard to defence; others, a national currency free from any link with sterling, and yet others, that the Irish language should be made compulsory. In the last few minutes I think I heard it advocated that British trade unions here should be abolished. The realists, and I claim that I belong to the realists, would like some satisfaction on these points.

What I would urge on the people is to give up arguing about a whole lot of matters which, in my opinion, do not matter, such as the past and what happened in the past. Remember that what this country will be is not what it was in the past but what we will make it in the future. Let us try to unite on a programme which we can all accept and work for whatever progress we can achieve. We will make far greater progress as a united people, a people united in our ideals, having sacrificed possibly some of them, or having left them in abeyance, than we will make by continuing to argue about things which do not matter.

Comment on this

I approach this matter with a certain amount of pride and a certain amount of sorrow. I am an old republican. For the information of the Seanad, I joined the Irish Republican Brotherhood in 1911, when I was 19 years of age, and I tried all my life to be consistent in my republicanism. I am sad that this Bill does not embrace Ireland, as we know it, but is confined to Twenty-Six Counties. I accepted the Treaty of 1921 because I had on more than one occasion heard the constitution of the Irish Republican Brotherhood read and the members of that organisation were prepared to accept any measure of freedom as a means to an end. That was not the sole reason for my acceptance of the Treaty, but it was an important reason. I want to be quite honest—I do not want to be offensive—and say that I withdrew my support of that Treaty because I believed the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, of which I was never actually a member, was going holus-bolus into the British Empire. When I saw a photograph in the papers of Irish Ministers dressed in court attire in Buckingham Palace, I felt it was no place for me and I got out of it.

Senator Honan to-day was jumped on because he voiced a suspicion that there might be some other reason for what might be called the change of front on the part of certain people making up the present Government. I personally would like an explanation because to me it appears that there has been something in the nature of a political somersault, and when I hear people complaining that they did not expect this from the Fine Gael Party, at any rate, I feel that there is a certain amount of justification for their complaint. For the past 25 years, or prior to Fianna Fáil coming into power, we knew that we were fairly closely connected with the British Empire in the matter of attending Imperial Conferences and so on.

The Taoiseach has said, and I want to compliment him on his speech introducing this measure, that the main reason for this Bill was that it would bring peace into Irish political life. Everybody in the House will hope that he is correct in that view, but I do not know whether he is correct in believing that the confused state of affairs in connection with the External Relations Act of 1936 was responsible for the gun being in Irish politics in later years. My recollection is that, subsequent to the enactment of the Constitution—I do not say because of it—we had a fairly peaceful time, and certain people then decided to make war on Britain. And for what? To compel Britain to get out of the Six Counties. It was because of that making of war—attacks on British cities and so on—that the Irish Government had to take measures against these people.

The point I am putting to the Taoiseach is that if that was the attitude of these people in 1938—and their attacks on the British Government might have involved this country in very serious consequences—what is to prevent them adopting the same attitude in 1948 in relation to this question of Partition? I have come now to the stage at which my fighting days are over. I am a man of peace and I hope the Taoiseach is correct in his view that we will have a peaceful future.

Not alone are we rather bewildered as to the attitude that has been taken up. I opened the Sunday Independent a couple of weeks ago, and was amazed to see a great article there advocating the establishment of the Irish republic. Abuse has been thrown on the Irish Times, for certain things it has said. We all know what to expect from the Irish Times, and at least this can be said in its favour, that it has been consistent through all the years. But a paper which hounded Redmond, fomented the 1913 strike, condemned the 1916 rebellion, and indicated certain leaders that should be executed, that called Martin Savage an assassin, and had his place destroyed as a result, that has been opposed to every advance of extreme nationalism in this country —when I saw that paper advocating a whole-hog attitude on this question of the republic, I felt it was time to examine my conscience.

I wanted to know, and am still anxious to know, what is the reason. I know that when the Taoiseach was finishing up—I may be taking him up wrongly—he spoke of siding and cooperating and standing with other people. I personally hope that this country is not committed to anything. If it is a question of defending western democracy and Christendom against attacks of Communism, I am wholeheartedly with the Government, and stand for the people who take that attitude; but I would like to know if this country is being committed, or if there is any possibility of being committed, beforehand as a quid pro quo in connection with that action.

Comment on this

None whatever. I made that perfectly clear in the Dáil, and the Senator need not worry his head about it.

Comment on this

I accept that unreservedly. We had a very fine speech, from his standpoint, from Senator Bigger. He started off by saying he represented nobody, he was independent, and then he proceeded to speak on behalf of what I describe as the King's Irish in this country. These people are not concerned with their rights, no more than the people of Northern Ireland are concerned with the rights that they might secure or might be deprived of under an All-Ireland Republic. What they are concerned about is their privileges. These people for centuries have enjoyed privileges in this country when the mere Irish did not count for anything. Any of us who lived prior to the much-abused Treaty of 1921 know the position. The mere Irish, and particularly the mere Catholics, counted for nothing in the scheme of things, as far as the British Government in this country were concerned. That is the trouble with these people to-day. They are not looking for rights, but they are resenting the loss of their privileges.

These people are not Irish, they do not accept Ireland; their first loyalty is to Britain. That is our grievance with them. There is no lack of toleration of the Catholic to the Protestant, but we object to these people living here, and living well here and living out of all proportion to their numbers here. We object to these people refusing their first loyalty to this country and giving their first loyalty to Britain. There is no change in that attitude. There has never been any change in it and we see the planter stock in Senator Professor Bigger, despite his ancestors who went before him. I knew Francis Joseph Bigger, a man who did much for Irish culture and Irish nationality.

I have read of the Earl of Warwick, and I know much of Jemmy Hope, and I know what those men would say to-day, those republicans of that time, if they had listened here to-day to the speech of their descendant, Professor Bigger, who was speaking on behalf of the irreconcilables as far as this country is concerned. I want to know, if we establish an Irish Republic, what we are going to do to make these people be loyal to us. If they will not be loyal to us, let them get out. You could not have such a position in any other country in the world. What did the Yankees, the Americans do—they put them to Canada. After the American War of Independence, those people who were the King's Americans in America were chased out to Canada.

When you talk about Canada and Australia and New Zealand being loyal, why would they not be loyal to Britain, since they are the one flesh and blood? These people, in their conquest, went over the world and deprived the rightful owners of those countries. The unfortunate blacks in South Africa were deprived by the South African Government of their legitimate rights as human beings, not to mind as citizens. These are the people who talk of us, a country that has sent its sons and daughters throughout the ages to every part of the world; and then we are expected to show loyalty, to what? To something that we were never loyal to, something we never owned loyalty to, something we could not own allegiance to. Independent of our history, independent of what has gone before, will any man here tell me why any Irishman should be loyal to a British King? What is the reason? Any rights they ever had they had here by conquest, by superior force. There was never any question of loyalty in the hearts of the people of this country to the British King. Why should we profess a sham allegiance, a sham loyalty, that none of us ever felt? I ask the question of the Taoiseach—I do not expect him to answer it now— what is going to be done to see that the people who live and have their being in this country give their first loyalty to it.

There are other matters that must be attended to also. If we are going to cut the painter, it ought to be cut completely. If we are going to be Irish, let us be Irish, let us be whole-hoggers, sea-green republicans, and let us have no half measures. There are many British institutions in this country of ours that ought to be got rid of—if possible, by peaceful means, if not by peaceful means, well, we will have to use other methods.

Senator O'Farrell referred to the trade union movement and the Leas-Chathaoirleach was inclined to think him out of order. I suggest that this matter is very germane to what we are discussing. Actually, there is no use in us declaring ourselves free, no use in saying we are free politically, if we are not free industrially. The position at present is that the country is split in this matter of British or foreign unions and Irish unions. No matter what any man says, no matter what any man with a spark of Irish nationality in him may say, he must admit in his heart that it is a bad thing for the country. The people who hold there should be only Irish trade unions in this country are following in a royal tradition, the tradition of the men who said over the centuries: "We stand for Irish control". It would be a good thing for Ireland if a way out, a settlement of this problem, could be found. The present position can be very dangerous. It is quite possible for vital services of this country to be dislocated as a result of a decision, or want of a decision, in Britain, outside the control of this country altogether. We had a clear example of that during the Black and Tan war—we had Irishmen, railway employees, refusing to handle munitions to be used by the Black and Tans against their own people. That was a laudable and patriotic action on the part of those railway men, but the British executive in London looked at the matter simply from the point of view of Englishmen and refused to sanction that strike or condone it. They refused to sanction or condone that strike or pay strike benefit to the people who, in spite of the decision of the British executive, refused to handle the stuff. They allowed them to be dismissed and, like Pontius Pilate, they washed their hands of any responsibility for these people. That position affected a vital service which this country could not do without—the railway service. It is quite possible that the British executive in London to-morrow or the next day can paralyse the Irish railways without any reference to——

Comment on this

I am afraid the Senator is getting very far away from the Bill.

Comment on this

I suppose we are all rambling a bit. I did not think you would let me go so far. I think the Government should consider that question. I hope this Bill will be accepted unanimously by the Seanad. We should not be trying to score petty points off each other in debate. I want to pay tribute to the Taoiseach for the way in which he introduced the measure, but I think—and I say this without any offence—he was a bit ungenerous in picking out certain statements by Deputy de Valera when he was Taoiseach. I think it rather cheapened the speech that he was making debating points out of things that possibly would have another explanation if Deputy de Valera were here to answer them.

All Irishmen who have done their little bit, I think, should get the credit. As a boy I was violently opposed to the principles and the policy of the late John Redmond and the Irish Party. But, looking back from middle life, I can say that it is possible that only for them other things would not have happened; that they have brought us along the road we find ourselves on to-day. We called them pro-British and all sorts of things. I suppose we can say now, at any rate, that, no matter what they were, they did what they considered best in their time for the country, that they did what they considered they could do and that they did it willingly and well. That also applies to the men who came after them in the Sinn Féin days. I was a member of Sinn Féin when I was only 14. I tramped the city and country when there were baton charges. Then we had the 1916 Rising and the Black-and-Tan movement, and then the unfortunate split over the Treaty. We were at one another's throats for a long time. Let us, however, be generous and admit that we all did what we believed to be in the best interests of Ireland. If we accept that, we will realise, at any rate, that we can look forward to the day when politics here will be an internal matter, when we will not have to be worrying about international situations.

I should also like to say that circumstances govern people and the British Government which refused to recognise the passage of the External Relations Act 1936, was not as strong as the British Government in 1948. We should remember this in our tribute to the British. I pay them no tribute. I believe that what they do is simply a matter of expediency and in their own selfish interests. If they are acquiescing in this matter, they are doing it because it suits them and because they cannot afford to do anything else. The British Empire is not the British Empire that many of us knew 30 years ago. The British Empire is a very sick one to-day. What it did in 1914, 1916, 1921 and 1936, it could not afford to do in 1948.

Let us always remember, when we want to give credit to Great Britain, that she is responsible for the division of our country. She created the present position in the North by the 1920 Act and she maintains it, and we have got to put the responsibility on her. It is her responsibility to bring it to an end. Let us not fool ourselves or be fooled by anyone, the British people or others, who say that this is a matter for Irishmen to settle. This is a matter for Great Britain to settle. It has been proved over and over again in debate that Great Britain will suit herself. If it suits her to-morrow to throw the North of Ireland there, she would throw it. If it suits the North of Ireland to come into this State to-morrow, it will come in. If there is any question of the responsibility for this, let us put our finger on where it belongs. The responsibility for Partition is Great Britain's and nobody else's. I welcome the Bill. I hope it will get whole-hearted support here, that it will be unanimously passed, and that we can look forward to a day of rejoicing for the country. I hope there will be no Independence Day declared. Independence Day should be postponed until we declare a republic for the 32 counties of Ireland.

Comment on this

During the course of the debates the term ex-Unionist has been frequently used. Some people have been at pains to deny that they were ex-Unionists, that they were ever Unionists. I want to say at the outset that I am a Unionist, unashamedly and unrepentantly. I am a Unionist because I believe passionately in the unity of this country. I believe that within these Twenty-Six Counties over which we have at present control unity is essential amongst ourselves for our well-being. I passionately believe in the ultimate union of the whole country. That is my form of unionism, and that, I think, is unionism to which every Irishman can subscribe cheerfully. It is for that reason that I welcome the Bill.

I do not intend to follow the very many red herrings that Senator Bigger trailed across this discussion, but I should like to take him up on one small but important point, because I think the fact that Senator Bigger made it demonstrates that he and possibly many other people have rather a confused mind on this issue. Senator Bigger takes objection to the title of this Bill as being inaccurate. He says that it is inaccurate to describe this country as the Republic of Ireland, and he makes great play about the geographical definition of Ireland as an island, and the republic now is only going to be twenty-six-thirty-seconds of Ireland.

I would like to put this to Professor Bigger. In the year 1870 there was a war between Germany and France and during the course of that war the German armies invaded France, and in the ultimate peace the Germans remained in occupation of two of the French provinces, Alsace and Lorraine, and they remained in occupation of these two provinces until the year 1918. Was it inaccurate during that period to use the words the Republic of France as the title of France or was it inaccurate to use the word France as descriptive of that country, simply and solely because a foreign Power was occupying by armed force two or three provinces? I put it that there is no difference between the situation of France then and Ireland now.

It is, I think, only quite natural in a democratic country that a measure of this kind should have been subjected to a great deal of criticism and that many points of view should have been expressed. It is rather strange, though, that this criticism has been so confused on the one hand and on the other hand, at times, scurrilous. One would have expected and one would have respected intelligent criticism of this measure. One would have respected and have been willing to meet in argument criticism that was based on, for instance, whether or not this was an opportune time to repeal the External Relations Act and formally declare this country a republic. But, unfortunately, that has not been the type of criticism that has been put up. It has all the time been a criticism of propaganda and confusion. Surprise has been expressed that the Fine Gael Party should have undertaken a measure such as this. People's memories must indeed be very short if they have forgotten that the Fine Gael Party, which is the lineal descendant of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, who were the Party that worked the Treaty, only accepted that Treaty, as Michael Collins expressed it, as a stepping-stone to the ultimate, complete and sovereign freedom of this country.

Probably the most dishonest line of attack that has been made upon the Taoiseach and his Ministers who have undertaken to steer this Bill through our Parliament has been the line of attack that claims that the people were swindled. I think Professor Bigger used that rather vulgar if expressive word, made "suckers" of, that this Government had no mandate for this action. That is a particularly dishonest type of argument. Mandates are things that it is not always possible to have. Government action is very often governed, not by mandates that they receive or do not receive during the course of an election, but by force of circumstances. I would like to remind this House, and I speak from memory and subject to contradiction if I am wrong, that the late Government had no specific mandate at the beginning of the European war to declare neutrality, that the Fine Gael Party had no specific mandate at that time to support them in their declaration of neutrality, that the Labour Party and all the other Parties in the Parliament had no specific mandate for the declaration of neutrality, simply and solely because at the time that they were elected the question of neutrality or non-neutrality was not of immediate political importance. Nevertheless, that does not say that the Fianna Fáil Government were not quite correct and quite right in declaring neutrality at that time, and it does not say that they did not reflect the wishes of the vast majority of the people. I think that is accepted without question. All this business of a mandate is completely dishonest and beside the point.

Senator Lavery, I think, demonstrated clearly last night that, from a legal point of view, what we are doing to-day could have been done in 1936. Play should not be made on that. I do not think we, in the Fine Gael Party, wish to claim any particular political advantage that it was not done in 1936, because I personally feel that there must have been some very good reason why a formal declaration of a republic was not made in 1936. We have never actually been given that explanation. There is no reason why we should have been given it, but I am quite convinced that there was a reason for it. If I were to speculate I would think that it was this, that, in 1936, the same friendly relations did not exist between ourselves and the neighbouring island as exist to-day, and on that subject I would like to give credit where credit is due. From 1938 onward the Fianna Fáil Government did improve friendly relations between this country and Great Britain. This Government is carrying that tradition on.

The memories of many of the people who criticised this measure and who criticised the political Parties who are introducing this measure must be exceedingly short. Nationalist progress in this country has always been a gradual one, one of step by step. Nationalist Parties in this country have started from time to time with different objectives, sometimes a limited objective. The old Parliamentary Parties that Professor Bigger referred to last night had for their policy a limited objective consisting of a limited form of home rule. That was their objective.

Mind you, even in those days there were men at the top of the nationalist Parties who were before their time, and Parnell was one. Although the Party that he led at the time had for its objective a limited form of home rule, Parnell distinctly stated that a limited form of home rule would not necessarily be a final settlement when he made his famous statement that no man shall set bounds to the onward march of a nation, etc. Truly, no Irishman would expect Fine Gael to-day, or any other Party, to have a limited national objective. Unfortunately, we in this part of the country are not the only people who have short memories, and it is regrettable that our Northern brethren appear to have very short memories too, and to overlook and to blind themselves to certain indisputable facts. For people who are supposed to take an extremely realistic and materialistic outlook on their problems, they have successfully blinded themselves to the fact that they have reached that peak of industrial prosperity that they enjoy to-day, not with the assistance of the British or the English, but in spite of the British and the English. They seem to forget that they had to build up those industries which are so prosperous there to-day in the face of cut-throat competition from the shipyards of the Clyde and the industrial districts of central England. They do not appear to be capable of realising, from a materialistic point of view—which, admittedly, is not putting things on a very high plane—that they have something to gain by joining with us.

To-day their industrialists must be in a rather unenviable position. Their every action, their every attempt at enterprise or to sell their goods is controlled, not by their own Government but by a Government sitting in London, by an official of the Board of Trade in London, over whom they exercise no control. I suggest to some of the businessmen and industrialists in the North that it might be well for them to consider that position they are in and the possible fruits they might gain and the protection they might receive from us down here.

I do not want to say much more on this subject of the North, but if Senators wish for a statesmanlike attitude on this problem, I would recommend to them the speech of the Minister for External Affairs on the Vote for his Department in the Dáil this year before the adjournment. I only wish to say in conclusion that when the dream of every Irishman comes true and a union is brought about between ourselves and our fellow countrymen—because no matter what anyone may say, they are our fellow countrymen in the North-East—I think that the people of the North-East will be a great asset to Ireland and that they will have a very big part to play. Economically they will be in an unassailable position and it will be time then to talk about the defence of this country. To defend the country as a whole is one problem, a problem that might not be too difficult, but the defence of the country divided is difficult. The relations between ourselves and our neighbours at present are friendly and good. Once there is a united Ireland, I think there could be no limit to the friendship that could exist between the two islands.

Comment on this

It is with some temerity that I approach this Bill for the reason that I have no history behind me to connect me in any way with the efforts of other generations to achieve a measure of freedom for this country. I am of an age group that did not have the privilege of joining Patrick Pearse and which, thanks be to God, was saved from the tragedy of civil war, an age group that can now treat those years as history, an age group for which it is easy to accept the position created by the Bill as the only natural step that could be taken at this stage. We of the age group to which I belong have no hesitation in doing all the honour we possibly can to all the political Parties who have combined in all the years of our history to achieve the measure of freedom we have to-day. We are prepared to acknowledge all the heroic deeds of all our people, but we claim that we have a right to expect now that the intention of our statesmen shall be concentrated and directed to the future and not to what has happened in the past.

Yesterday afternoon and this morning I have listened patiently and with great interest to the various speeches and the impact of the controversy that has grown up about this Bill has not made any impression on my view that the Bill is the only natural one that could be brought before us for consideration. Anyone who cares to direct his attention to the opening speech of the Taoiseach must realise that the Taoiseach gave a very able résumé of the history of our constitutional development in this country over the past 25 years, and, to my mind, as a man who was not associated with any of the steps in that constitutional development, he gave a very fair comment. He took us through the various steps in the course of that constitutional development and I think that we people can look back dispassionately on the reports of imperial conferences, reports of Dáil Debates and look back on the circumstances surrounding the enactment of the Constitution of 1937 and consider the necessity for the Act which we talk of as the External Relations Act. We people can consider all these as natural steps, one following the other as the night follows the day, and for that reason there is no alternative to-day but the passage into law of this Bill.

If the two streams of opposition or controversy which the Taoiseach referred to cannot in any way make me withdraw from my belief that this is the only natural step we can take, it is because I believe that political Parties or groups of any nature have no right to-day, any more than they had in Parnell's day, to set a boundary to our onward march, irrespective of the fact that this natural progression of ours might in some way interfere with what some groups may consider their rights. I believe that political Parties or political groups may react to this Bill. We have listened to a complaint—or so it appears to me— from one section.: "The Crown has been stolen away from us," and I have a feeling in my heart, listening to speakers on this side, that they feel that their particular republic has been stolen from them. That is the position which confronts me, and before I finish I should like to appeal to all those groups to give their unreserved approval to this Bill, to be bigger than their own group, because, so far as I am concerned, this measure is just as big a thing in my life as Pádraig Pearse's declaration was to him. I should like to see it passed into law, because it certainly removes from our midst the dissipation of our national energies which we have witnessed for many a year. I have witnessed that more in print than in fact. I should like to see all our energies devoted to and concentrated on following our star and backing up that moral compelling force which must find its answer in the application de facto of this measure to all Ireland.

Comment on this

Let me say at once that, convinced by a study of the Dáil debates and by the speeches made in this House, I intend to give this Bill my support, and I believe that in doing so I express the decision of a large number of my constituents, namely, the graduates, and especially the younger graduates, of Dublin University, men and women eager to contribute wholeheartedly to our country's welfare. Let me say, too, that I must dissociate myself most emphatically from the disparaging remarks which have been made here on all sides and in the Dáil about lawyers in general and constitutional lawyers in particular, though the prejudice, I regret to say, goes back to Plato. In a matter of law, if we cannot trust the consensus of legal opinion, we had better emigrate to some jungle where the rule of law is still unknown. If, in a matter of constitutional law, we, as the supreme jury of this nation, do not base our decisions on the most careful and unprejudiced arguments of constitutional lawyers, we are repudiating the essentials of civilisation. In the dangers and perplexities inherent in the Government of every country, the commonsense politician and the learned lawyer should be in the closest and sincerest alliance. Such an alliance, I believe, is nearer full achievement now than ever since 1921, and I welcome its approach. Speaking, therefore, as a neophyte in politics, as one who is learning the difficult and perplexing art of politics, let me say that I dissociate myself from the disparaging remarks about politicians, and, speaking as the representative of a university which has given many legal luminaries to this country in the past and is doing so at present and will, I hope, do so in the future, I dissociate myself from any prejudice against the lawyers of our country.

Only a few weeks ago, the Taoiseach did us the honour of visiting Trinity College twice, and may I say that the members of Trinity College deeply appreciate these visits by the head of our State, and Ministers of our State? The time and energy they spend in coming to visit us is deeply appreciated. On the occasion of his visit, the Taoiseach appealed to the younger people in Ireland to rid themselves of this prejudice against politics, and he appealed in a way which struck a chord in the hearts of many of his audience, and, if I can do anything to help the Taoiseach's wishes in that matter, I will do it gladly.

I have said that I believe I represent a large number of my fellow-graduates. I think that I had better present my credentials as an informed spokesman for the younger generation of the religious minority. In the past ten years, I have addressed and argued with audiences, large and small, in Belfast, my native city, Derry, Armagh, Dublin, Mullingar, Portarlington, Waterford, Cork, Limerick and Tralee, on the problems of our religious minority. What I have to say in what follows is an honest attempt to express the opinions I met in these frank and vigorous debates. May I say with emphasis that among the thousands of young Protestants with whom I spoke and argued, there was a cordial and ungrudging recognition of the scrupulous fairness of our successive Governments to us? Without any sense of inferiority, and without any sense of superiority, as free Irishmen to free Irishmen, we accept that consistent maintenance of impartial justice as worthy of our country's most honourable traditions.

I have said that I intend to support this Bill, but I cannot end simply with that affirmation. My support is based on reasoned conviction and not on passion, not on education, not on environment, and not on heredity, though I, too, can claim, as many have claimed, a distant connection with an Irish leader who died in '98, and I, too, was born in Belfast. But since my support is based on reasoning and reasoning through a very complex situation, reasoning which I believe most of my constituents are going through as well, I must, with your indulgence, take this opportunity of clarifying the causes of that reasoning. May I say that I think one of the best functions of this Seanad is to promote a mutual understanding in a sympathetic and intimate atmosphere of this kind? If I can do anything in the future to promote that understanding, I will do it with all my heart.

In the debate in the Dáil and Seanad, there have been many references to the views of the religious and political minorities. In almost every case, the comments from both Government and Opposition have shown that scrupulous regard for democratic justice to which I have already referred. But, with the best goodwill in the world, many of the speeches suggested a rather confused notion of the nature of the political opinions of the religious minority. May I, both for the sake of better understanding and as a preface to my comments on the Bill, clarify this point? Take, for example, the use of the term "ex-Unionist." It has been commented on already in these debates. It applies to one class and one class only, that is, the class of people who came to political maturity before the Treaty, and who, after the Treaty, gave up the Unionism that they held before that. It is a precise term, and should not be used either loosely or in abuse.

The fact is that there are four main sections in the religious minority of this country. There are what I may call the revolutionary republicans, those who are in the tradition of Tone and Emmet. Let me emphasise that some of those still living fought and suffered for the republic from 1916 on and suffered for it till very recent times. Some of my own friends are amongst those and I speak for them. This was a section of the religious minority to which a man who lived in this House belonged, who sat at these fireplaces with his republican wife from France. I refer to Lord Edward Fitzgerald. I am sure that, at the debates this evening and yesterday his shade must have been watching us with the acutest interest and sympathy, because we are doing something to-day that he died to do in 1798. I do not think that, when we speak disparagingly, as some do, of the religious minority, we should forget such revolutionary republicans as he.

There is another group, what I call the constitutional republicans, more in the tradition of Davis and Parnell. These in most cases have suffered less in the past and, as a result, have less credit now, but I would emphasise that these are as strong in their loyalty and conviction in favour of the republic as any member of the Irish nation. They are ruled by reason rather than by feeling, by head rather than by heart; but, honestly, in the long run, I think we can rely for endurance and firmness on the reasoning republican rather than on the unreasoning republican, if such there be.

The third group—and this is the group for which I ask for sympathy here—is that which may be called the Free Staters or the ex-Free Staters, members of the Commonwealth Party. These are more in the tradition of Grattan and Butt. They had no antagonism to England in so far as England was prepared to allow complete freedom to Ireland. These are the people who are in perplexity and difficulty now and I ask you to help them. They are trying to find their way, to strike a balance between a genuine desire for independence and a genuine desire for co-operation in the Commonwealth. I will speak more of them later, as I believe we must consider them thoroughly here to-day.

The fourth group is that of the Unionists—Unionists, plain and simple. A graduate of my own university was Edward Carson, a southern Irishman, a Unionist. They believed, and still believe, that the Union of Ireland with Great Britain is the best thing.

To apply the term ex-Unionist to any of these is manifestly misleading.

There is another difference to be considered, a difference in age. The post-Treaty generation, to which a recent speaker has referred, the young men and women who grew up and came to political maturity after 1922, the under-forties on the whole, did not begin to think or feel in any real sense politically till about 18 or 15 years ago. It is a ridiculous anachronism to call these ex-Unionists. These anachronisms are not confined to one side of the country at all. It is some 12 years only since I was accused of being a Home Ruler in 1936 in my mother's drawing room—a Home Ruler in 1936! It is as futile to call these people ex-Unionists as to call many of the respected members of our present Government Home Rulers. In fact, it comes to this: the same shades of political opinion that are found in the majority are found in the minority, though it is quite clear the proportions of the extreme left and the extreme right are different.

An earlier speaker has referred to another misunderstanding about that section of our people in the Twenty-Six Counties who are properly described as Unionists, not ex-Unionists. The Unionists are not confined to the religious minority. That point must be emphasised. I know more than a few of the religious majority in this country who hold staunchly to Unionism in the full sense. Though I do not share their views, I think it my duty to emphasise that the political convictions of these southern Unionists should have our respect and genuine consideration, not only because we are a democracy, but also because our hopes for a truly peaceful settlement of the Partition problem are enmeshed in the destinies of these Unionists, North and South. One Senator very recently, I regret to say, has suggested that such people should be driven out —I use his own term. Frankly, this sounds to me more like totalitarianism than Irish democracy. I am satisfied that it is not the voice of our ruling statesmen, and I mention it only to dismiss it.

Such is the complexity of the politics of the religious minority that to suggest that their attitude to this Bill is simple and undifferentiated is gravely misleading. I am sorry if I seem to be complicating matters, but it is my business to disentangle complications.

All this is more complicated by the fact that the Bill is complex, too. The Bill involves the setting up of a sovereign republic, but it also involves our relationship with the nations inside the Commonwealth and, by implication, our whole foreign policy. A decision on this Bill is clear for two sections of the religious minority. The republicans accept it gladly, the Unionists reject it firmly, but the remaining group, those who value our connection with the Commonwealth, have been perplexed and troubled and, in some cases, misled on this Bill. I do not say they have been misled simply by members of the Dáil and Seanad, but misled by other sources of information, too. In my opinion, many of those, like myself, would support this Bill, but they need reassurance on certain points.

Let me be entirely frank about this. The political thinking of what would once be described as Anglo-Irishmen, now properly described as Irishmen, in this country is not easy. It is not easy for a young politician to find his way between the conflicting elements in our State, North and South. Family interests may pull him in one direction, education in another, his reason and his passions in another direction. I am voicing my own particular feelings when I ask for your sympathetic attention in this matter, because I represent a generation that is slowly taking up its definite orientation in Irish politics. We must do it with caution; we will do it with sincerity. I appeal to you then as a neophyte in politics and as a representative of that minority for your sympathetic hearing.

There are three difficulties in this Bill, and I want to face them frankly. The first is the question of secession from the Commonwealth, so-called. That term has been challenged and been challenged rightly. The second is the need that has been expressed by some for a definite mandate from the people for this Bill. The third is the suggestion which has been made that our foreign policy in future may be progressively isolationst until the country is united. These are the three difficulties I think we must face.

This Bill has been represented in some quarters as a precipitate and injudicious secession from the Commonwealth. Until I studied the debates in the Dáil and heard the Taoiseach's exposition and that of Senator Douglas and others in this House, I took this view, and intended to oppose such a secession on the ground that it would curtail our practical freedom. I am now satisfied that the Commonwealth connection has been, as the Taoiseach said yesterday, a dead root for 16 years, and, as far as international co-operation from this side of the Channel was concerned, it did more harm than good. Secondly, the declaration of the English Prime Minister seems to safeguard the privileges of our nationals for the present at least and, from the Taoiseach's introductory speech, I am convinced that he will do all in his power to preserve those privileges. For let me emphasise as a representative of men and women who sometimes like to go abroad, and often go abroad to come home again better and wiser people, that all these privileges of free come and go with every continent in the world mean a great deal to our graduates. For those who seek a livelihood or vocation abroad to lose that freedom of movement and employment which we have enjoyed in Great Britain and the Commonwealth would be calamitous for all the Irish universities. I believe my colleague in the National University will support me on that.

I do appeal to the Taoiseach or the Minister for External Affairs, if they can see their way to do it, to give me and those for whom I speak a clearer promise of active efforts to widen and strengthen these links, these practical, personal, golden links, with the nations of the Commonwealth. If that is possible, it will be a great reassurance to people who are trying to find their way in a complex situation. Personally, if it were possible, I should like to see the republic in a new, fully constitutional relationship with the Commonwealth, without any question of qualified sovereignty, as a mother nation of millions of Commonwealth citizens outside our own boundaries.

Perhaps I may be permitted to quote from a book which has just appeared, and which I do not think has reached this country, by a distinguished Irishman, Dr. Nicholas Mansergh, who was born and educated in this country. It is a fair-minded and impartial survey of the position. He calls it The Commonwealth and the Nations. His final paragraph is this:—

"The implications of Eire's relationship with the Commonwealth have led us, therefore, into new fields. They suggest a Commonwealth of the future in which there are both member States and associate States, the distinction between them being one, not of status, but of histroy, tradition and cultural background. By such a development, the Commonwealth could only be strengthened, for it would mean that political and constitutional realities would once again be brought into harmony. In this great community there would be a natural place for nations peopled by many races and speaking many tongues, but all, from their vast store of varied experience, contributing to the common good of the whole, and thereby to the peace of the world."

I wish we could bring ourselves at least close to that ideal.

The second difficulty is this. There have been accusations of false election pledges. Many sincerely patriotic voters are disturbed by this, not through malice, not through ancestral bitterness, but simply in terms of honesty. These sincerely patriotic voters do not wish to denounce or deplore or condemn; but they do wish for a better explanation. I, with them, know that our Taoiseach and our Ministers of State must have some good and honourable reason for their decision. If the Taoiseach would give us a clearer statement on this, I and they would welcome it. I wish it were possible for politicians to say: "I changed my mind." If he does not, I, for my part, will be satisfied that his silence or his vagueness is justified by reasons of high policy, or the greater good of the State. I am prepared to accept that, for I respect both his professional and his political integrity.

With these qualifications and one more which I must mention, I am convinced that some three-fourths at least of the younger generation of the religious minority will support this Bill and will give the new era that it should inaugurate in Irish politics their firm support. And I personally, though I cannot describe myself as a republican, welcome the proclamation of an unambiguous, sovereign republican, Ireland. I welcome it as a representative of the college whose members laid the foundation stones of this structure that has been almost completed to-day—Tone, Emmet, Mitchel, Davis, to name only a few. I welcome this decision as a member of the Church of Ireland whose sons also have had a distinguished record in Ireland's struggle for political and intellectual independence for over 200 years, from Dean Swift on through Grattan, Tone, Lord Edward, Smith O'Brien, Parnell and others whom I have named before.

Here in parenthesis I must take up Senator O'Farrell's reference to what he rather loosely called the Protestant religion. I deplore the introduction of any sectarian controversy into this House, but if it is introduced I mean to fight as hard as I can against it. He described the Protestant religion, as he calls it, as an easy one. I protest against this superficial and hurtful remark. I shall not argue it out here, but let me say that, apart from the sectarian issue involved, this is not the time in Ireland or Europe for quarrels or hard words among Christians. I will say no more on this, but I am sorry that Senator O'Farrell, whose speeches I have learned to admire in this House, should take it on himself to make a gratuitously hurtful remark of this kind. But let me add that I entirely agree with him for reasons I have already given, that the sooner the term Protestant is discarded as an equivalent term for Unionist or ex-Unionist the better for the clear thinking of us all.

One difficulty remains, and in a sense. I think it is the most constructive difficulty that I have to offer, if any difficulty can be described as constructive. This is the question of our international and external policy in general. Some remarks which I have read have suggested that the republic will not agree to full co-operation with the freedom-loving and peace-loving nations of the world until we achieve what is called the reintegration of our national territory. The Taoiseach's closing remarks yesterday contradicted this, but, frankly, I think we need a firmer and more definite assurance if we are to decide on this Bill with a full understanding of its international consequences. By the election of our country to the United Nations Assembly on Wednesday last, our Government has been given a unique opportunity of making such an assurance now. Am I wrong, Sir?

Comment on this
Seán MacBride Minister for External Affairs (Mr. MacBride) Clann na Poblachta

No, we are not elected.

Comment on this

What is the position?

Comment on this

The position is that our application has gone before the General Assembly of the Security Council, but there is power of veto which, no doubt, will be exercised.

Comment on this

Then I will say the steps towards our election to the United Nations Organisation give us, or may soon give us, an opportunity of seeing that, without bargaining or without holding back, we will devote all our energies to fostering international unity and goodwill. Partition or no Partition, we cannot as Europeans and Christians repudiate our share, no matter how small, in the supreme responsibility of preserving European Christendom, its faith, its culture and its freedom. For, let me emphasise, Partition is not the worst evil that a country can suffer. Other nations, besides this nation, have suffered Partition. Poland, that country so similar to our own, suffered Partition, and now in a sense has achieved the reintegration of her national territory. Do we envy Poland now? Do we desire national unification at the price that Poland is paying? If we adopt and isolationist policy now we may increase the risk that we may have to pay that appalling price for reunion of our country. If by our decisions in the coming critical months and by short-sighted narrowness of vision we do anything to bring about such a reintegration of our national territory as Poland or Czechoslovakia or Roumania have achieved, future generations of Irishmen may have cause to blame us more bitterly than any Parliament in the tragic history of our country.

Our external relations are not just matters of our internal political and economic convenience. Moral obligations are also involved. We have responsibilities to meet as well as rights to demand. No sovereign and independent nation has the moral right, especially in so critical an era as this, to stand apart and say: "Am I my brother's keeper?" Our recent, not election, but progress perhaps towards election to the United Nations Organisation, as I have already mentioned, does give us an opportunity of declaring an unselfish and disinterested determination to unite in preserving Christendom and Western European civilisation. Best of all would be a declared all-Party foreign policy of full international co-operation. The Dáil and the Seanad have never been united in such unanimity as they have been in the last few weeks. I appeal to our leaders to seize this chance to present a firm united front to the international enemies of our way of life. Then and only then will our neighbours across the Atlantic, our neighbours across the channel and I believe many of our neighbours across the boundary, salute with respect and welcome the new era of Irish politics as I and those for whom I speak salute it with hope and determination now.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator's reference in his speech to Senator O'Farrell was to Senator Seamus O'Farrell. That is understood?

Comment on this

Yes, Sir. That is the Senator to whom I intended it.

Comment on this

I have very little to say and I am afraid I am going to bring this debate down to a much lower level than the very high level which it has reached in the speech of Senator Stanford. I am not going to deal with the politics of the Bill at all. I accept it as a fait accompli and I am simply concerned with one or two factual possible results on which I would like to get an assurance from the Minister that certain interests, especially those of my own constituents, have not been overlooked. I fully accept, of course, the statement of goodwill by the British Prime Minister and Dominion Prime Ministers but, at the same time, there are certain technical administrative problems which all the goodwill in the world will not solve. I also accept that most of these have probably been already considered by the Irish Government or will be considered by the Irish Government, but I do not think that it is any harm to put on record some of these practical questions that may arise on the repeal of the External Relations Act, simply in order to draw the attention of Ministers to them, if they have not already considered them, and to draw the attention of the House and the public to them because they certainly have not considered them.

Although, as I say, I am reducing the level of the debate to the lower level, I think possibly I am doing something for which the Seanad is peculiarly fitted. The high politics of this measure have been adequately and amply debated here and elsewhere and I simply propose to ask the Minister to address his mind to three or four of the consequences of this Bill which will automatically arise because I accept of course all that the Taoiseach has said to the effect that most of our rights arise out of agreement and not out of status.

There are one or two matters in which, as far as I know, Ireland will suffer by going outside the Commonwealth unless measures are taken by British legislation and I have no doubt at all that these measures will be taken. The first is a matter which Senator Stafford has already eloquently referred to, that is, the position of our graduates abroad, including my own constituents, because it is not only the graduates of Dublin University who go abroad and earn honourable livings in all parts of the world; there are certain positions, in particular in the consular and diplomatic service, and the judicial service in the British colonies and Dominions to which our graduates occasionally go. I would like the Minister to assure us that even in the case of appointments of that kind where oaths are necessary that our citizens, our nationals, will not be precluded from taking such oaths of allegiance as may be called for in the British diplomatic, military and other services. That is a matter to which I would like to call attention.

Furthermore, I would like to call attention to the fact that Irish nationals may wish to sit in the British or Dominion Parliaments, in either House. Members of Parliament are expected to take the Oath of Allegiance, and I would like the Minister to consider whether there is anything repugnant to Irish nationality under our new republican status in taking the Oath of Allegiance in the British Parliament, in either House. That question may arise.

Another concrete question I would like an answer to is, can an Irish national, after this Bill is passed, own a British ship without further legislation? The Merchant Shipping Acts, as far as I know, are extremely categorical regarding British nationality and the ownership of British ships.

Another matter to which I would like to draw attention—it is a small matter —is the subsidiary register in Dublin of certain important British companies. Three or four of the banks which are associated with the Central Bank of Ireland have their head offices outside this State. Under the provisions of the Central Bank Act, those banks are required to have subsidiary share registers in Dublin. There are certain other important British companies which have a large number of Irish shareholders, and which also have subsidiary registers here. I am informed that under British legislation the setting up of subsidiary registers is confined to countries which are dominions or colonies. I am informed that unless appropriate legislation takes place, the minute this Bill is passed the subsidiary registers will cease to be recognised as legal by British legislation.

I am also informed that in that event, the Irish Exchequer would suffer severely because there is some arrangement, which I am afraid I am not able to describe very fully, in relation to death duties, by means of which shares registered in the Irish register of these companies pay death duties to the Irish, and not to the British Government. That is a matter to which I wish to call attention.

Another small matter to which I wish to call attention is our position in regard to the sterling areas. Of course, I will not enter into that highly contentious question at the moment, whether it is desirable to be a member of the sterling area or not. Assuming it is desirable, assuming the free movement of funds throughout a very large part of the world is desirable in this country, access to the central sterling-dollar pool is a matter which confers advantage on our businessmen and nationals generally, and any unintended exclusion from the sterling area would be a source of considerable inconvenience. Therefore, I would suggest that whatever we may do regarding leaving the sterling area as a matter of deliberate policy, the accidental cessation of membership would not be a desirable step.

Under the Exchange Control Act, 1947, a British Act, Ireland is not included by name as a country in the sterling area. The words "sterling area" no longer appear. The First Schedule of the Exchange Control Act defines as scheduled territories all Dominions of the British Commonwealth of Nations, with the exception of Canada and Newfoundland. I simply call attention to the fact that unless that section is amended before this Act comes into operation, this country will automatically cease to be a member of the sterling area. It should be included in the Second Schedule of the Act, which includes countries belonging to the sterling area but not in the Commonwealth.

Comment on this

Is Iceland in the Commonwealth?

Comment on this

No, but it is in the Second Schedule. We are nowhere —we are not mentioned. The drafters of the Act, not having heard the debates here within the past three weeks, imagined that Éire was in the Commonwealth and, therefore, we are in the sterling area because we are in the Commonwealth. After the passage of this Bill we cease to be that and, therefore, we should seek inclusion with Iceland, the Faroe Islands and other humble islands outside the Commonwealth.

Comment on this

I do not think we are in the sterling area because we are in the Commonwealth. But the Senator need not worry about that. The position will be very carefully safeguarded.

Comment on this

I am merely mentioning these points in order that they will not be overlooked. I know they are minor administrative points, but they are of some importance, and I wish to put them on record so that they will not be overlooked.

Comment on this

The Senator may rest assured that they have not been overlooked.

Comment on this

Therefore, the purpose of my speech has been achieved. There is one other matter that may involve consequential legislation, not perhaps in Great Britain, but in some of the Dominions. Some of the preferences which are enjoyed in Canada, New Zealand and Australia are not specifically granted to Éire. They are, however, granted to Commonwealth countries, and we have enjoyed them automatically without question in the past. When we cease to be a member of the Commonwealth it is clear that those preferences will no longer be automatically conceded. I am simply drawing attention to the necessity for safeguarding these minor matters which will automatically arise. Every matter to which I have referred to-day is a matter which will automatically arise. I perfectly accept what the Taoiseach has said, that the greater part of our international preferences rest on agreements and not on status. I have confined my remarks to a small group of privileges which rest on Commonwealth status, and I respectfully suggest that the Government should see that these minor gaps are filled.

Comment on this

I can assure Senator O'Brien that we are obliged to him for calling attention to these matters. In so far as they may not have been considered, I assure him they will certainly be considered. I can also assure him that all these matters to which he has referred have been very carefully considered and will be safeguarded.

Comment on this

My remarks will be directed to the relation of this measure to the one remaining problem which has to be solved and which, I think, those interested in its solution should bear in mind. It has been stated repeatedly and emphasised not only in these debates but outside on many occasions that the sole responsibility for the Partition of this country rests on the British Government. The responsibility rests on the British Government for Partition in so far as it was responsible for introducing and passing through the British House of Commons the Act of 1920, but older members of this House will remember there was talk about Partition long before 1920 and that it was not the British Government that raised the question of Partition in the first instance. It was the people who are now insisting on the maintenance of Partition. Senator Hayes referred to the Home Rule Bills of 1912 and 1914. I remember an earlier Home Rule Bill and older men will remember an earlier one still. In 1886 and in 1893 there were proposals to grant a limited measure of Home Rule to this country.

Senator Bigger in the course of his speech stated that 50 years ago there were people in Northern Ireland who wanted to remain in the United Kingdom and he said that they wanted that still. In 1886 nobody had a word to say about putting them out of the United Kingdom. In 1893 nobody proposed to put them out, nor in 1912 did anybody propose to put them out, but they were as opposed at that time to the measure of Home Rule which was proposed to be granted, as they are now, and anybody who would think for a moment that this slender tenuous link that we are removing to-day would go any distance whatsoever in influencing these people in Northern Ireland are living in a fool's paradise.

Much has been said about the loyalty of these people but whenever their real loyalty was tested they showed what it was worth. I understand loyalty to mean not alone sentimental respect and love for the person of the sovereign but loyalty to the laws of the Government of the country in which one lives. As I say, in 1886 and in 1893 and especially in 1912, they showed exactly what their loyalty was worth. We have had talk of the gun in politics. So far as I understand my history, the gun was first introduced into politics by that distinguished son of Trinity College to whom Senator Professor Stanford referred.

Comment on this

He did not introduce it; it was introduced very much earlier.

Comment on this

I understood that the Senator wanted us to believe that he was following in the footsteps of Tone.

Comment on this

The point I wanted to make was that while the British Government did, because of pressure from those people in the North, introduce that Act, the responsibility was not theirs alone. I am sure Senator Bigger has heard of the Buckingham Palace Conference in 1913, convened by King George himself. Why did that conference break down? The Redmondite Party at the time were willing as a compromise to agree to the exclusion of four counties from the Bill but the conference broke down because the partitionists wanted to claim Fermanagh and Tyrone as well as the other four counties. What claim had these people to Fermanagh and Tyrone? None, any more than they have to-day.

I agree with Senator Bigger to this extent in his suggested solution of this problem. I do not believe that if Britain to-morrow were to repeal the 1920 Act and were even to withdraw their forces from the North, we would be any nearer to a united 32 Counties than we are now. Therefore I believe that a solution of Partition will not lie along these lines. It will lie along the lines suggested on many occasions before, that we must make it worth while for the people in the North to come in. No matter what may be said or pretended about their loyalty, they look first of all to their own privileges. It is because they want to preserve the privileges granted to them in the past that they are maintaining the present position. I think therefore our policy should be to make this State in which we have now, and have had indeed for 25 years, practically complete and absolute control, such a State that this big class — I think it was Senator Bigger or Senator Stanford said that it was not the mass of the people but the middle-class people who are open to argument—will see that it is to their personal advantage to become citizens of a republic for the 32 Counties.

There are one or two small points to which I also wish to refer. Most of them have been dealt with already. I should like to refer to the point made by Senator Bigger, and indeed by many others outside this House, that the Government had no mandate, and that they did not consult the people before they decided to introduce this Bill. That is nothing new in the case of Governments, even in our own time. I remember that in 1932, for instance, the Fianna Fáil Party came into power largely because of the promises of what they were going to do in the matter of taxation and in the matter of salaries of public officials of one kind or another. They were not very long in power when they discovered that many of the promises they made were not capable of being fulfilled. They had to act, as all Governments have to act, in accordance with what they thought were the best interests of the country. As has been said, they are not delegates; they are representatives. Senator Hayes quoted a statement of Edmund Burke. I might also quote another distinguished man, the late President Roosevelt, who had been badgered and criticised for doing something for which it was said he had got no mandate from the people. His retort was: "When a policeman sees a felony being committed, is he to go to the town hall and consult the mayor before he takes action?" The Government, when elected, was put in a responsible position to do what they thought best under the conditions as they found them when they took over the reins of Government. That is what they are obliged to do, and what they should do.

Senator Colgan introduced, rather irrelevantly, a matter in which, as a great advocate of freedom, he showed that he would be prepared, in certain circumstances, to advocate coercion. If there are a number of people in this country who desire to join an organisation which they think is to their best interests, why should Senator Colgan or anybody else prevent them from doing that?

The very case that he quoted, that of the railwaymen, was an example that Irishmen who may be members of what he calls British unions were not prepared to sacrifice the interests of their own country even at the behest of the executive of their unions. The railwaymen showed that spirit in 1918, 1919 and 1920. I do not think it is right to advocate, especially when it comes from a great lover of freedom like Senator Colgan, that men who, for their own reasons and for good reasons wish to remain associated with fellowworkmen in other countries because of circumstances and traditions of many years' standing, should be coerced and compelled by law to do something that they do not want to do. I do not think that comes very well from such a great lover of freedom as Senator Colgan.

Comment on this

What about Senator Bigger's constituents when the same thing is being done now?

Comment on this

I support this Bill for the reasons so well stated in the speeches made by the Taoiseach not only in this House but in the Dáil. I feel with him and with those who support him that the removal of the confusion we have had is going to be helpful to this country. Something has been said, not in this House but outside it, suggesting that it was rather generous on the part of the British people not to impose the penalties which the prophets said would be imposed on us if we took this step. Now, whatever we may think of the British people they are a far-seeing people. They have long traditions, and they can look ahead. I have the idea that, in acquiescing to this proposal, they are looking into the future when they see some new countries at the present time engaged in making their own constitutions. There is no doubt whatever but that the tendency in these new countries which have no blood relationship whatever with Britain will be to establish full sovereign republics. I am sure it would be to the advantage of Britain that these countries would remain in the family—you can call it the Commonwealth or anything else you like—and they saw that by admitting Ireland into that family as a republic rather than as a Dominion, there would be the inducement to those new countries also to remain in the family and not join up with a different group of nations. If they did that it would be to the detriment of Britain. I believe that may have, to some extent, influenced the decision of the British Government, because as I have said, they are a people who look ahead, and are wise in their generation as a result of their long traditions.

In conclusion, I want to refer to the name of this State. I have always considered it a most unfortunate thing that the name "Éire" found its way into the English version of our Constitution. If it had not been there we would never have heard of these sneering titles such as "Eirish" that we so much object to. I think it was a pity that was done. I think it was wrong. If it had remained in its proper place in the Irish version it would be all right, and we could assume that this State would always have been know as "Ireland". In my opinion what is being done now will have the effect of giving back to this old nation its ancient name, and that as a result we will hear no more of these belittling statements. I hope that the Government will do everything within its power to wipe out the name "Éire" when speaking in English. Of course, when speaking in Irish we must use the proper name. I trust that, in the case of official communications and on the forms used in the Government service that it is the name "Ireland", not "Éire", that will appear.

Comment on this