The Republic of Ireland Bill, 1948—Second Reading (Resumed).
Contributions 103–219 of 219. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 19 of 1948 ›
I welcome this Bill very sincerely. I am also glad that, when the present Government decided to repeal the External Relations Act, they agreed to go a step further, and put in the name "republic" in this Bill, thereby making it clear to the world beyond all doubt that we here actually have a republic. I have been a believer in the independence of my country since the days of my childhood. Since 1915 I have worked to the best of my ability for the establishment of an Irish republic. I believe that republic has existed since the passing of the Constitution. I know, of course, that the External Relations Act constituted a certain element of confusion, and that the republic was not internationally recognised. Why I welcome the Bill so much is because, though we were a republic without a doubt, the fact that we lacked the name might have meant danger in the future. We were losing the effect of the inspiration that that name will be to coming generations.
Many of us would have wished that this External Relations Act had been repealed by the previous Government when in office. When we take a broad view of things perhaps it may have been as well that they did not do that. If the previous Government had brought forward this Bill it might have caused a certain amount of opposition internally and perhaps outside. Now that it has been brought before us by the present Government, the Bill has secured the unanimous assent of the people. Perhaps it is in the fitness of things that these two Parties which worked for and laid the foundations of this State should now come together and put the final touches to it.
Senator Baxter spoke about the reception that this Bill got from the Opposition Parties. I do not want to strike any jarring note in this debate. At the same time, I do want to make a reply to some of the Senator's remarks not for the sake of scoring any debating points but rather to bring ourselves back to the realities of the situation. The Senator stated that there was bitter disappointment amongst the Fianna Fáil Party at the introduction of this Bill. I said that, as a matter of fact, we were disappointed that the previous Government had not brought it in. The feeling amongst the members of Fianna Fáil and amongst the public in general was this: that they were stunned with amazement when the present Government decided to bring in a Bill to set up a republic. That is the real fact. It created as much amazement as if we were to read in the newspapers some morning that the Russian Government had decided to send an ambassador to the Pope.
I would ask the members, especially the Fine Gael members, to realise that in opposing Fianna Fáil they opposed the very idea of the republic. Remember the way they jeered at the "dictionary republic" and so forth. The general impression all over the country, and accepted by their supporters and by their opponents, was that that Party stood for membership of the British Commonwealth. You must understand that to find a sudden change like that without any explanation of how it came about could not be received with anything else but with amazement. You must not wonder if some people were suspicious. I mention these points just to get back to reality. The Government must realise that such could only be the effect. I am disappointed that we did not do this, but we are glad that it has been done. These are only small points; they have nothing to do with the main point, which is the good that has been done for the country.
I should like to make clear the fact that the republic already existed although it was not externally recognised. The speech made by Senator Lavery last night has relieved me of the necessity of elaborating that point. I listened very carefully to his exposition, which was clear and lucid. What he said could be grasped by even the weakest intelligence. The House and the country owe him a debt of gratitude for the explanation he gave of the External Relations Act and the Constitution and the position in general. From Senator Lavery's explanation and the explanation of others such as that of Senator Douglas, who gave details, we can form a clear picture of what actually happened and of the present position. It is well that that should be so, as we are, perhaps, facing a new era.
Many of us were opposed to the acceptance of the Treaty and still believe that it was a mistake. At the same time, we believe that it was accepted by the Party that accepted it with the intention of using it as a stepping-stone. I think it was Senator Lavery who explained the many alterations which had been made in it during the Fine Gael term of office and I think Mr. de Valera said that he was surprised at the extent to which they had used their powers. We must give them credit for that. On the other hand, all Parties must agree that when the Fianna Fáil Government came into office they made a very rapid advance towards complete independence of the British Government and of the Crown. The final result was that they had established a republic in all but name. Unfortunately, members of the present Government, who were then in opposition, opposed their efforts. Now that we look back we can realise that it was, perhaps, opposition for opposition's sake. It was unfortunate, but human nature is human nature and I suppose it will be that way always. The main fact is that to-day we can give credit to all Parties for contributing their share and that we have come together to complete the final step as far as the Twenty-Six Counties are concerned.
It has been objected that this measure will adversely affect the question of Partition. I think any student of history will realise that such will not be the case. If we look back, we will find that the British element in this country always possessed a superiority complex in regard to the people of this country. It is a common thing with that element everywhere. They look down upon those whom they have conquered. The more we tried to appease them at any stage in our history, the less they thought about us. By asserting to-day our complete independence as a sovereign republic we are bringing ourselves nearer the abolition of the Border. The position will be understood abroad, and it was not clearly understood heretofore. The English Government and the English people will learn to respect this country more than they did when they thought it was part of their empire. I believe that common sense alone will, in the course of time, solve the problem of Partition. I believe that, eventually, the Northern people will have their own local Parliament, which can govern them according to their ideas, but that the British Government will not have the sovereign rights which they possess in this country. We can leave the rest to time to reunite the two peoples. It may be difficult to believe that, but 20 years ago no one would have thought that India and other countries would be completely free to-day. We cannot foresee what will happen in the next ten years.
I was very interested in the speech made by Senator Professor Bigger. I have always had a great love for minorities; the smaller they are the more I like them. I have such an amount of admiration for a minority of one that if the Senator had not been so completely wrong I should like to be able to say that I stand beside him in his statement that he had been badly let down in voting for the Fine Gael Party. I felt a kindred feeling with him, because I must admit that I, too, got something of a drop. I always thought that if that Party got into office they would immediately head for the Empire with bands beating, and when I found they were going to set up a republic I naturally got the drop of my life. The only trouble is that I am afraid that I am dreaming and that I shall wake up. I liked the speech made by Senator Professor Bigger, because I know that he spoke sincerely and that he expressed the sentiments of many thousands of people, whom we shall call strangers, who are in our midst. I would ask them to consider the present position. We have a passionate love for our country and a passionate hatred for the institutions that have kept us in subjection for so many hundreds of years. At the same time, I can well understand the feelings of those strangers who came over here generations ago and who have retained the loyalty of their forefathers. We can respect them, because in every generation they have given freely of their blood for the Empire and the King to whom they are loyal. For that reason, we would ask them to understand the situation as it is to-day. Times have changed and standards in the world have gone. Let us look round us. Empires have gone. Things that 50 years ago seemed impossible have happened. These strangers are fortunate that their home to-day is amongst the Irish people. They must realise that, taken all in all, the Irish are a kindly peace-loving race whose only object is to be at peace with the whole world. We would gladly welcome those who have hitherto been strangers in our midst into our brotherhood. The passage of this Bill will open for them a new era. Hitherto they have retained the loyalties of their forefathers to a foreign country and a foreign King. Hitherto those loyalties have been incompatible with their loyalty to their country because the interests of the two loyalties were diametrically opposed. With the passing of this Bill those interests will no longer be in opposition only in so far as the problem of Partition is concerned.
Senator Lavery pointed out the way in which the Irish had worked for England in the past and yet had remained loyal to their own country. A more apt comparison might have been made with the United States of America. Thousands of the descendants of those who emigrated to America in bygone days retain as great a love for the mother country of their forefathers as do the Unionists for England. But that does not prevent them giving their loyalties and their service and their love to the country of their adoption. For the first time the position is clarified. For the first time it is possible for the Unionists to give an undivided allegiance to their own country. There is no reason why they should not retain their love for England, her traditions and her institutions while, at the same time, becoming good Irish citizens. To-day there is no reason for any further antagonism between England and Ireland except in so far as Partition is concerned any more than there is any reason for antagonism between Ireland and America. The reason why the descendants of the Irish exiles in America can give so great an allegiance to the country of their adoption is because there are no conflicting interests between Ireland and America. From this day forward the same situation should obtain between England and Ireland. We are a peace-loving country and, unless some catastrophe occurs, we shall never enter into war that might create friction between us and our nearest neighbour. There is an opportunity offered to-day to the erstwhile strangers in our midst to play their part with us and we assure them of a welcome when they do that.
I would like again to say that I sincerely welcome the introduction of this Bill and I am glad that it has received the general assent of the country. But I do want to advert at this stage to one fact which has not so far been stressed. Once this Bill is passed we must be brought to a proper realisation of our position as a republic. We must ensure that that position will obtain international recognition. In order to do that the Irish people must fit themselves to be good citizens of the republic. There was a time when I regarded the idea of a republic from a somewhat sentimental point of view. Later I studied the question of a republic, and now I believe that a republican Government is the only fit and proper régime for a free people and the only proper Government for man created in the image of God's likeness. I believe that even a limited monarchy savours of feudalism and is alien to the nature of man. I believe that the people must now be fitted to carry on the work of a republic. A republic requires educated, intelligent citizens with a fitting appreciation of civic duties. I believe, too, that this Bill will prove a great incentive to the study of the Irish language and the fostering of Irish culture. Our hopes will be centred in the generations to come, but the young people and the children of to-day must be made to realise that they stand for the first time in an Irish republic in which they must play their part. Part of that task will be to bring about the reintegration of our country as a whole and then to make the country an example to the other Christian States throughout the world.
Comment on this
For the benefit of the House, at what time is it hoped to conclude?
Comment on this
No decision has yet been reached on that point, but 4 o'clock has been suggested.
Comment on this
Is there a definite ruling that the debate much conclude at 4 o'clock?
Comment on this
May I take it then that the debate may continue after 4 o'clock?
Comment on this
It may continue until 10 o'clock to-night.
Comment on this
I believe that there are a number of people in this country who, when they are discussing the Republic of Ireland Bill, are under a completely wrong impression, and an impression which, in my view, is definitely harmful to the country. I refer to the people who seem to imagine that all the members of the Protestant churches in this country are opposed to this Bill, and to the idea of a republic. That, of course, is not the case. I am convinced that the people who foster that idea, though they may not intend to do so, cause bitterness and ill-feeling, and unwittingly do a great deal of harm. I believe that some of the speeches made to-day on this subject, particularly those of Senators Stanford, Ireland and Douglas, will do a great deal of good, and will help to dissipate the wrong impressions that have been created, provided they get plenty of publicity. The people will then see that a large section of the Protestant community are wholly in favour of this Bill.
It is most important, in my opinion, that both the Catholics and Protestants in this country should work together in co-operation in every possible way under a republic. I believe that both speeches and actions which tend to cause bitterness and ill-feeling between Catholics and Protestants are harmful to the country. We should do all in our power, therefore, to bring about peace and goodwill and a close co-operation between the peoples of the various denominations. We are all Irishmen, and I believe we should all be united in the common object of trying to make our republic the best possible republic it can be.
In introducing this measure, the Taoiseach stated that it would put an end to a great deal of the barren and futile discussion which has in the past distracted people from economic issues. I believe that is one reason why the majority of the people will welcome this Bill, and I feel that we are now at the beginning of a new era in Irish politics. I welcome this Bill from many points of view. There is no need for me to go into detail with regard to them, since I would merely be repeating what so many have already said here to-day. From now onwards, our principal aim should be to devote more of our time and energy to establishing in this country the best possible republic from both a social and an economic point of view; a republic in which poverty and slums and other social evils will be eliminated, in which both wealth and work will be more equitably distributed and in which we can all work together for the common good. From now on, the people should put aside all past bitternesses and ill-feeling, and work together in harmony for the abolition of injustices, and for the establishment of a more just social order based on Christian principles. I believe that the type of republic for which we should all work together, in peace and goodwill, is one based on social justice.
Comment on this
I wish briefly to raise two points which have not been raised before. I must admit that I was somewhat surprised that they were not raised up to this in the debate. They are important points since they touch upon the responsibilities with which we shall be faced under this enactment. I was sorry that on a measure such as this the debate was not kept wholly above the level of Party politics. When it descended into the arena of personal justification it was inevitable that we should be treated to biographical details, political post-mortems and an examination as to motives. All these things have, no doubt, some interest but they are really matters that fall more appositely into the province of the historian. Now I should like to turn right round in the other direction and look towards the road we are going and not to the shadows that we are leaving. In fact, in listening to the remarks this evening, a line from McDonald's play, When The Dawn Has Come, which was produced in the Abbey Theatre in 1908, came into my mind. Somebody is saying towards the end of this moving tragedy: “What is going to happen when all this has come to pass?”; the reply: “Well, whatever happens, we will have left this eternal twilight and have got into the daylight.” I think we are leaving the twilight and entering the daylight, and I should just like to be sure that our eyes are upon our responsibilities.
It might be argued that one of these responsibilities is not really the responsibility of the Government. It is the responsibility of more than the Government; it is the responsibility of the entire two Houses, and that is the maintenance of our democratic system. At the moment I think it is generally agreed that it requires a two-Party Government. If you have one-Party Government, you have merely a dictatorship, which may be good or may not be good. If you have a multiple-Party Government, as on the Continent, it is difficult to ensure stability. By the removal of one of the difficulties between the two main Parties in this country, I think we will have to look to a new alignment. I am not expecting an answer to this, but it will have to be in our minds in the next few years: what will be the natural Party division in this country? We have to run the country on good Party lines, so that the Party which is out will be in effective opposition to the Party which is in, and so maintain the essential change that keeps the nation's blood alive. I cannot suggest what the division will be, whether it will be capital and labour or Liberal and Tory; but we will have to keep our minds on what way the division will come about.
The second responsibility concerns external relations, notably, of course, with the Commonwealth. The Attlee declaration eased the minds of a great many people, but supposing another British Government came into power and the incoming Government said: "You are claiming alien rights and we are going to give you alien rights", what can we do to avert the danger? In one way we cannot do very much. We can endeavour to exchange rights as far as possible and afford reciprocal citizenship rights. But I feel that the best way to obviate the possibility is by increasing the quality of our general or temporary exports as much as possible.
I remember when the late Lord Birkenhead was over here. His speech attracted a good deal of interest, because this was the speech of "the Galloper," who had rounded the corner and come back to his old notions, and had participated in signing the Treaty. His speech was made with the intention of being reported, but there were no reporters there. To speak without reporters on these issues means that you might just as well talk to yourself. What impressed me most in his arguments, as one of the signatories of the Treaty, was when he said:—"We began to realise that we were dealing, not with a dominion, but with another mother country." I think it is the fact that we are a mother country which is largely responsible for our unique position in Western Europe to-day. Of course, we have been a mother country for a tremendously long time. I feel that this great achievement which we are now seeking to bring about brings to us the additional responsibility of ensuring that our children are in the best condition to go round the world and come home again. They will probably have to face greater competition. But certainly it is our privilege and responsibility to see where we are going and to turn out the best we can. These are the two issues raised by this Bill. One is the future of Party Government, and the other the necessity of screwing up our standard and seeing that we keep to it.
Comment on this
I am glad to say that the tone of the debate in this House has been different from the tone of the debate in the Dáil. In my recollection no Bill has met with so little opposition as this measure. In my 25 years in Parliamentary life in this country I do not remember any Bill to receive so little actual opposition. There was indirect opposition from the people from whom one would have least expected it. Reading the Dáil Debates and listening to a great many speeches in the Dáil what struck me most forcibly was the intense desire of the opponents of the Government to express their satisfaction with the measure, but they had a most peculiar way of expressing it. I have never in my Parliamentary experience had a feeling of pleasure so queerly defined as it was in the Dáil. My worthy friend and political opponent, Senator O'Dwyer, struck a different attitude in the Seanad to-day. But there was complete misrepresentation of the facts in the debate in the Seanad in many ways. The Government Party were represented as being non-republican and then as being pro-British and pro-Commonwealth in the same breath. It was represented that the Protestant minority were altogether opposed to this Bill. These are two complete inaccuracies. The Taoiseach and his colleagues were represented indirectly as being non-republicans. My answer to that is: did Mulcahy, Cosgrave, MacEoin and others go out in 1916 just for fun? Most of them are members of the Fine Gael Party and the Government still. I do not think anyone will suggest that they have changed their spots. Are the Taoiseach and the Government and the Fine Gael Party in general to be described as pro-British or as pro-Commonwealth because in the years following 1922, when the Treaty was accepted, even according to the admission of Deputy de Valera, they did their part to further the course to complete independence? If in those days Mr. Cosgrave kindled the spark of friendship with a country at which we were hitherto at loggerheads and if that friendship grew practically into a flame of regard, were those people to be represented as non-Irish in their attitude?
I resent the attitude of the Opposition in that regard during the debate and I resent more than anything else the implication that our Protestant fellow-countrymen are opposed to this measure. I was glad to see that representatives of that minority refuted that statement in this House to-day.
I was particularly struck by the speech of Senator Stanford. The Senator referred to matters that I would have liked to refer to. Like Senator Bigger, I have among my constituents a considerable number of people of different religious denominations. I am glad to say that I have the support, almost the affection, of the majority of the Protestant community in my county. I have yet to learn that the majority of those people are opposed to this measure. I am glad to hear from the representative of one of the universities of this city that the bulk of the Protestant people he represents are not opposed to this measure. The attitude of the chief opponents of the Government, the people who claim to accept the measure with pleasure but who conveniently and indirectly oppose it, reminds me of the attitude of a petulant schoolboy who gets into a fit of temper because his brother got the jam. I do not think there is any necessity to refer at length to the opposition, if it was an opposition, of the biggest Party in the Dáil.
The Bill is quite simple. Even though Senator Lavery gave us a wonderful exposition of its purposes and consequences, I do not think that the average man has failed to realise what the Bill means. The Taoiseach put it very well in the Dáil and Seanad when he said that it was to clarify the position. Nobody knew where we stood, what our position was, whether we were republican or non-republican or what political position we held. Mr. de Valera took up the attitude in regard to our position with Britain and the Commonwealth that though we were in we were out and though we were out we were in, and when the Taoiseach liked we were neither out nor in. If this Bill has done nothing else, it has made our position clear; it shows that we are out now, at any rate.
That change had to come. The aim of centuries of agitation in this country is now realised. The ideal of the people is at last fulfilled. Senator O'Dwyer expressed it adequately when he said that all Parties in this House are really pleased with this measure. I believe most of the speeches in the Dáil were so much fraud—there was no reality behind them. I believe that almost every Deputy and Senator who spoke feels in his heart that he must welcome the Bill as a settlement of an age-long agitation between ourselves and the people across the water. If it only brought Irish men and Irish women together again in this country, it would have achieved a great deal.
We had divisions, I am sorry to say, very fierce divisions, of opinion during the past quarter of a century; brother fought brother, sister fought sister, fathers and children fell out and people of different religions fell out. It would not be fair to say that it was a religious affair in this country because religion had nothing to do with it. There were differences of opinion amongst the people and if this Bill did nothing else but clarify the situation and do away with the cause of disruption, it would have served a good end. I believe the Taoiseach is blamed for bringing in this measure without an appeal to the country. This is not the first time such action was taken; it is not the first time that grave action was taken without reference to the people. I remember when the last Government came into office they proceeded to withhold the annuities. I think they needed some mandate from the people for that particular action. They proceeded with the economic war, and they plunged the country into great trouble for a number of years, and they had no mandate for it.
Comment on this
It was, at any rate, one of the things the last Government did without a mandate from the people.
Comment on this
I did not say there was not, but there was no mandate for starting the economic war.
Comment on this
It was the British who started the economic war.
Comment on this
There was no mandate for the Blueshirt campaign.
Comment on this
There can be little doubt that every self-respecting person in this country approves the action taken by the Taoiseach. If the thing has to be done, 'twere well 'twere done wisely. The thing that probably troubles our political opponents is that it was done so wisely, and that the change came about with such little agitation from people outside this country. I believe that if it had not been for the artificial atmosphere that was created here in opposition to the measure, it would probably be accepted with acclamation internationally. There is no opposition to this measure internationally. The British, the Canadian, the Australian, South African and New Zealand people have not opposed the measure. They did not voice opposition to it, except in a very small way. It was left to the people of this country, the people from whom one would not have expected opposition, to create an insidious campaign against the Government.
Professor Bigger alone in this House, so far as I heard the speeches, came out in actual opposition to the Bill. I respect an opponent who comes out like that, fearlessly to oppose something, even though it is a thing I might have set my heart upon. I disagree with Senator Bigger, but I respect him for his speech. I think he misrepresents the feelings of the people whom he represents here. Nevertheless, I believe that Senator Bigger was honest in his speech.
We have heard the terms "pro-British" and "anti-British", but this Bill removes any necessity for any of us in future being called pro-British. As the Taoiseach said so forcibly in his speech in the Dáil, antagonism to the British Crown in this country was not to the person of the British Crown, but to the symbol of the Crown because, unfortunately, for 700 years every act of oppression in this country was associated with that Crown and it came to be an accepted fact that the Crown was synonymous with oppression in this country. I think it is well, both for the Irish and the British people, that we put an end to that state of affairs. When we come to consider it, is there not a grain of Saxon blood in all of us? What Senator, looking back as far as I can look back, can say that there is not a drop of Saxon blood in his veins? I cannot and I do not know of any other Senator, no matter how Irish his name may be, who has not a drop of Saxon blood in his veins. After all, our proximity to Britain makes it inevitable that there should be inter-marriage between our people. We are all kin when you come down to bedrock, but even though we are kin, we have a natural desire for possession. The desire of the smallest holder in the country or even the person who has nothing is to rule in his own little home, to own something some day. The desire of every national in any State, if he is a person of commonsense and of any fair ideals, is to see himself a member of a free State, a State that is not controlled by any outside Government. The non-fulfilment of that right has been the cause of all the wars that ever arose.
We should be thankful that, in our time, we have been able to achieve, or that we shall have achieved when the Seanad has passed this measure, what generations of Irishmen have fought for and that we are privileged to see the realisation of that dream, because it was a dream to most of them. It was said of us in the dark days of the past that we were not fit for government, that the Irish were not fit for government because they could not cooperate. I think in the last 50 years we have learned the ideals of co-operation. We were always imbued with these ideals, but political divisions prevented their expression and fulfilment. In later years, however, we have shown our attachment to these ideals in many ways, in the management of our dairies, in the great co-operative movement, in the co-operation amongst beet growers, and latterly in the formation of the Government itself. By the formation of that Government we have shown the greatest effort of co-operation and the most sensible co-operation we have had in this country for many a day. I hope that effort is going to expand and that not only shall we have the co-operation of the Parties who formed the Government, but that we shall also have the co-operation of the main Party opposed to it and the minority who distrust us, the small minority represented by Professor Bigger. If we have so far co-operated in the matters which I have mentioned, is it a vain dream or hope that we can in the near future co-operate with our brethren in the North?
Mention of the North brings to my mind something that was not so far mentioned in the debate. The North has been referred to as the dismembered part of this country. I should like to refer to the Northern Government as the Government of part of a dismembered Ulster because, after all, it is only part of Ulster, the major part if you like. Ulster itself was dismembered and when one comes to apportion the blame, I think it is wrongly ascribed to both Parties in this country. Neither Fine Gael nor Fianna Fáil were responsible for the dismemberment of Ulster. It was achieved in some of those negotiations when a famous representative of this country who was nurtured and reared in Trinity College proved himself, both as a political advocate and as a lawyer, too smart for the people who opposed him. He led the people who represented us in those days—who sincerely represented us, I am sure— into the belief that by surrendering two counties, he had given them something of a Pyrrhic victory—and it was a Pyrrhic victory. They accepted it and for a time—I hope not for all time but for a long time now—they converted the majority in Ulster, as I believe there would be a majority in favour of the action we are taking here, into a minority. Poor dismembered Ulster! I believe that if Donegal, Monaghan and Cavan could be returned to Ulster, if we could make, as it were, a present to Ulster of these three counties, Partition would be solved and if we could only have Ulster as the entity it was for 700 years in this country, the question of Partition would not only not arise, but that a free vote of the people of Northern Ireland—and I think even Professor Bigger will agree with me in this— would show that their best interests would be served by co-operating with what has been called the Free State. Is it too vain to dream of the day when the majority of even the six dismembered counties will come to realise that the best hope of advancement lies in their co-operating with us? This is a day that most of us will live to be proud of—most of the younger members anyhow. Some of the older members will pass on before the full significance of this Bill is realised but future generations will bless the day when some Government in this country brought to fulfilment the dreams and the hopes of several centuries.
Comment on this
I did not propose to take part in this debate as I had an idea the debate would have been concluded some hours ago. The Bill before the House is a short measure and it is not a Bill to declare a republic. It is a Bill providing that certain functions carried on a behalf of the Irish people by the King will from the date of the passing of this measure, be carried on by the President of this country. It also provides that the name of the State shall be the Republic of Ireland.
We are not in this Bill declaring a republic. The people of this country declared a republic in 1937 when they enacted a Constitution and we support this Bill with great pride, pride in the knowledge that those people who opposed that Constitution and who stood in the way of every advancement we were making during those years, have now admitted both in this House and in public, not alone admitted to the Irish people but to the nations of the world, that every step we took was taken in order to bring our institutions into harmony with Irish traditions. That is why we feel proud. The last speaker suggested that our support for the Bill was being given in a stinted manner: that while we were giving lip service to it we were placing obstacles in the way of its going through. It would have been a grand and a glorious chapter in our history if, in the years from 1932 to 1939, the people who were then in Opposition had given the support and encouragement to the then Government in doing things that we are prepared now and in the future to give to any measure that is brought forward for the benefit of the country.
It has been suggested that the enactment of this Bill will remove the gun from Irish politics. We know that many tragic events took place. Everybody is sorry that these things happened. We quite well realise that lives were taken unnecessarily, but I never heard the excuse put forward that these lives were taken just because the Government of the day refused to annual the External Relations Act or to declare a republic for the Twenty-Six Counties. The excuse given on every occasion was that those men were doing what they were doing and were encouraged by people to do it; that they were advised that they were doing the best thing for the advancement not of a Twenty-Six County republic but of a 32-county republic. I hope and trust that this Bill, when passed into law, may have the effect, as others have said, of putting the gun out of politics in this country, and that each and every person will realise, as many have in the last few years, that their aims and objects can best be secured by coming in and co-operating, as the elected representatives of the people, to advance the interests of the nation.
Senator Baxter, in the course of his speech, made certain remarks. I do not think it is necessary, either here or elsewhere, to tell the members of this House, the country or the world as a whole what Eamon de Valera has done for this nation. I think that what Senator Baxter said came very badly from him when a Bill like this was under consideration. Every obstacle that stood in the way of bringing in a Bill of this nature, and every obstacle that created difficulties between this nation and Britain, with the exception of Partition, had been removed by the Fianna Fáil Government under the leadership of Eamon de Valera. Therefore the suggestions that have been made about our support of the Bill were not fair.
We would like to get answers to certain questions, and to have more definite knowledge as to why the Bill is being introduced at this time, in view of the fact that on the day this Government was formed the present Minister for External Affairs stated that while this was one of the planks in the platform on which he stood as leader, he was prepared to put it in abeyance as he had not got the necessary vote of confidence to put such a measure into effect. We should also like to know when the Bill is going to be put into operation. When are we to have the great day that we have heard so much about? Why is the putting of the Bill into operation to be delayed? Is it that a decision to that has to be taken in consultation with other people? We should all be very glad, I am sure, if the Minister for External Affairs could assure us, as he partly assured the other House, that this Bill will take the guns out of public life. Has he got an assurance from the people using the guns that they will no longer be used if this Bill is passed?
In conclusion, I hope that in a very short time the jurisdiction deriving from this Bill will extend not to the Twenty-Six Counties but to the 32 counties. Every action and step taken either by the Government or by individual Ministers, or indeed by any section of the people to bring that day nearer, will get our support.
Comment on this
It is regrettable that Party points of view or Party arguments have crept into the discussion on a Bill such as this, which is essentially national and has no relation to Party politics at all. We all have our Party differences. At any rate, on this occasion, the House, with very few exceptions, is united so far as this Bill is concerned. Consequently, there should not be any attempt to make Party capital out of it.
In the course of the debate, Senators have gone back as far as the Treaty, dragging in things that were altogether unnecessary. My friend, Senator Quirke, said that the Taoiseach did not give enough credit to his Party for the part it had played in this respect. As I told the Senator outside, I think that the Taoiseach did give credit to the late Government. I do not bother reading Bills. I never did so until I came into the Seanad. I am not a constitutional lawyer, but I knew that the King was still connected with the Twenty-Six Counties, or with Éire, or whatever you like to call it. I assumed that we were still in the Commonwealth. Deputy de Valera's resort to a dictionary did not do anything to convince me to the contrary. Now, it was the constitutional lawyers who surprised me. I did not realise, until I listened to their speeches, that we were so near a republic as we had been before this Bill was introduced. In that respect, I think they gave full credit to the late Government for the advancement which they had made.
Senator Bigger, and some people outside this House, seemed to have some confused ideas about the republicans lately in prisons and in internment camps and ordinary criminals. Senator Bigger quoted from Deputy MacEntee, and Deputy MacEntee also confused republicans with criminals. Some people may not like republicans who continued to fight up to the present. Some of them had been described outside this House as murderers. Now, they are not murderers. They are honest to God republicans like Wolfe Tone, Pearse, Tom Clarke and the others. We may not agree with their methods. Personally I did not, but while my head was against them my heart was with them in prison. I think that a great many of our people on both sides of the House feel the same way about them. Senator Bigger also suggested that they were an insignificant minority, and, consequently, did not require or deserve much attention. He also said that the republican tradition is very short. It is a very short tradition in the history of this nation, but it has been consistent. It has often been a very small minority since the days of Wolfe Tone. It was a very small minority when the late W.B. Yeats and Maud Gonne MacBride were celebrating the centenary of 1798. I know for a fact that they and John O'Leary and a few other intellectuals, who were the intelligent part of the Party, represented a small minority in comparison with the whole country. They were a small minority when I first took the oath to the Irish Republican Brotherhood in 1901. They were a minority also before Sir Edward Carson decided to form his provisional Government in the North and get guns for his men. They very soon became a majority—and a minority any time, any day, may become a majority in a very short time. They had the republican tradition behind them which, as I have said, has been consistent. With that tradition behind them nobody can tell when they may become more than the despised minority. The main reason for introducing this Bill, as has been pointed out by the Taoiseach, was to satisfy that element. A lot has been said about taking the guns out of politics. When these men used the guns, may be unwisely, they used them because they believed that they were doing so in the interests of an Irish republic. If we have an Irish republic now there is no reason for any guns, and that, I submit, will take the guns out of Irish politics as far as the Twenty-Six Counties are concerned.
Senator Honan referred to a quid pro quo which implied that there is something behind this measure about which the House has not been told. The implication is that the present Government has committed itself so far as a European war, which is in the offing, is concerned. I would point out that only one power in this country can say whether we will enter into a war or stay out of it, and that power is the Oireachtas. No matter what the Cabinet may have done—and I do not imply or wish to suggest that they have done anything behind the back of the Oireachtas—the only power in this country which can declare war is the Oireachtas. Consequently, nothing can have been done behind its back by the Cabinet, and the Senator's fears may be allayed. That point was mentioned by others in this debate, too, but I do not think it was mentioned in the belief that it exists. I think that they are afraid to give credit to each other for anything that is done.
Senator O'Connell referred to Northerners as being Partitionists. I say that Northerners are not Partitionists. Carson was not a Partitionist. He was for Partition, not for the sake of Partition but because he thought it would block Home Rule. I do not believe he was ever a Partitionist. He told the late Kevin O'Higgins that he believed as much in a united Ireland as O'Higgins himself did. That may surprise some Senators. He also said that he did not believe Partition would be abolished while Lord Craigavon was alive. A Senator wanted to know why the Bill was introduced at this particular time. I think the Taoiseach made quite clear the reason for that. He gave the secondary reasons and concluded with the primary reason to which I have referred. I am sorry that anyone should create the impression that he is not wholeheartedly for the Bill. Somehow the impression is created that it is supported with qualifications of some kind. I know that that is not a fact, but unfortunately that is the impression some of the speakers who do not support the Government have created.
There is no necessity to discuss the Bill itself. I merely wanted to correct some points such as the question of minorities and the question of gunmen being criminals. I distinguish between criminals and the men who were republicans and who were fighting for a republic. As I said, I have a great respect for them. This Bill, as Senator Quirke said yesterday, gives us an opportunity to work together for the future benefit of the country and join hand-in-hand in obtaining a republic for the 32 counties of Ireland.
Comment on this
I should like to ask one question of Dr. McCartan. Does he hold that the people who shot Gardaí and the other officers of the established Government of this State since this Constitution was established were within their rights in doing so?
Comment on this
No. In sympathising with them, I realise that they believed they were as justified in shooting Gardaí as Senator Quirke believed in shooting an R.I.C. man.
Comment on this
I am not going to speak at any length because most of the sentiments and views I have on this problem have been expressed and re-expressed during this debate. It has, however, been said by some Senators that we cannot have unity for all of this island until we have more to offer to the people of the Six Counties. We in this country have had a tradition of human liberty and a tradition of people who suffered and fought for that liberty. Now that we have achieved that liberty we bear no bitterness or malice or ill will towards any section. We have preached that principle all over the world. We have preached it to the Hindus, to South and North America, to the black man, and so forth. That is a great heritage to have. I think it is wonderful that we who have been subject to religious persecution, to economic persecution and to every form of persecution have emerged from that ordeal in a way that I believe no other country could emerge from it. It has been said that the people in the North are republicans and liberty-loving people. If they have that great feeling for liberty, and if their kith and kin were the people whose names are enshrined in the great American Constitution, let them come in with us and be one with us in this great historical nation and have, in this generation when freedom seems to be passing from the earth, one country that is united in holding that torch. I say that in all sincerity and with deep feeling, because it has been said that we have nothing to offer to them. That is a great mission.
My friend Senator Quirke said that at one time you could always find the King. He said in a different vein later that one would want to play the three-card trick in order to find the King. One thing I believe the Fine Gael Party will never stand for is playing a trick to find anything. As a Party Fine Gael has been over and above-board since its inception. We say to the minority and to the majority and to every one else in this country that these are the things we stand for in office and out of office.
I believe that the time of the full realisation of our national status is a great time for our country. I believe that as a result of this measure nothing but strength and dignity and the complete fulfilment of our national aspirations, both politically and economically, will come to this generation and the generations that are to succeed us.
Comment on this
It is not my intention to make any lengthy speech in this debate; firstly, because I am not able to, and secondly, because it is, perhaps, not desirable to say too much. There are, however, two points I would like to emphasise. As a member of the Fine Gael Party, I think it is only proper that I should express to our leader our admiration for the work he has done since he took office, particularly in the last six months, culminating in this particular Bill. Those of us who worked with him back in the early 20's, and who watched his subsequent professional career soar to the heights to which it did, expected much from him; but none of us anticipated that he would lead us to the great height on which we find ourselves to-day, and none of us believed that he would leave behind him the atmosphere he has left, both here and throughout the world. I am proud to have been associated with him down through all the years. I am proud of the dignity he has maintained everywhere he went. I am proud of the atmosphere he has created. There is just one thing I would like to say in that respect, and that is that much has been said that could well have been left unsaid, because, after all, Ireland belongs to all of us.
It is the dearest wish of all of us to have a united Ireland. No one, as I have said on many occasions, will bask more gloriously in an independent Ireland than I shall. If it is the dream of the most advanced Irishmen to have an Irish republic, I bow to them in that respect. But republicanism has no particular attraction for me. I wanted an independent Ireland at all times. Irrespective of the form or method, an independent 32-county Ireland is the greatest achievement we may hope to attain. The late Kevin O'Higgins, with whom I was closely associated, accomplished much. The Statute of Westminster widened considerably the scope of the British Empire. My inclinations prompt me to the belief that we may not lightly despise the British. Au Contraire, in the changing world in which we find ourselves to-day they would be the people with whom I would be most anxious to associate, provided always that they appreciated my association. In the years subsequent to 1926 and again recently Fine Gael attended meetings with the British Government and gave there of their best. I wonder how far that Government appreciated them and how far it went in meeting their needs and their desires.
Partition has been maintained under the ægis of the Crown. No contribution was made in that association to the ultimate unity of Ireland. We must remember, too, that General Smuts played a not too glorious part at the inception of Partition. There was no other option left after the last meeting but to walk out. The Christian world might perhaps be the better for a strong Commonwealth of Nations; but if that Commonwealth has no room for a united Ireland, then Ireland has no alternative except to walk out. Is the Commonwealth of Nations, then, anything the richer and are the ties that bind South Africa, New Zealand, Australia and Canada to Britain any the stronger by Ireland walking out? I would like to think that perhaps they were. It seems to me that they are not. To-day they are without India. They are without Ireland. There are hints that there may be further defections in the near future. Since there appears to be no room for Ireland in the Commonwealth, then the only alternative left to the Government was to take the step they have taken.
If a United Ireland cannot be achieved within the Commonwealth then there is no option left to us except to leave the Commonwealth. It would appear then that Britain must be weakened before Ireland can achieve unity. To my mind that is not a pleasant thought. Yet it is the only option that is left. Senator Bigger adverted to the fact that there was no coercion in the North. I am associated with scores of people of the same convictions to which Senator Bigger subscribed. I realise their position in the North. My ambition would be to see the people of the North here. My ambition would be to bring in here their brains, their industry and their courage. Sometimes I almost feel that if they did come in they might themselves become the Government of Ireland. But we all seem to lack commonsense with regard to this problem. I sit here and I listen to a member of a distinguished institution tell us that there is no coercion in the North. Yet I know, as does everybody else, that there is a subject race in the North; that there is in the North a race condemned to be, like the Gabaonites of old, hewers of wood and drawers of water; and, in that knowledge, I sit and listen to a distinguished member of our oldest university say that there is no coercion in the North. I would not say an offensive word because I regard the position as one in which we must forget the Party ties that bind us here. We must do the best we can to promote the unity of Ireland. We all have to bend in certain ways in order to meet one another, to facilitate justice and commonsense. There is too much patriotism and too much Irish warmness in our people to stand for anything but tolerance.
Comment on this
A lot of humbug has taken place since this Bill was first mooted. I feel proud to belong to the Party which has introduced this Bill. As I say, a lot of cant and humbug has been indulged in in reference to this Bill. This Bill is a very short one and should not have provoked all the propaganda that surrounded it since it was introduced. The two-edged sword was used all the time. People who supported the Bill tried to drive a dagger into the hearts of those who introduced it. Let us hope all that is at an end, that the Bill will be passed and that we will do our best to help in bringing about a 32-county republic as soon as we can, instead of trying to score off one another.
As to Senator Bigger who spoke yesterday, I was surprised that a man of his eminence and ability should take the line he did. Looking back over the past 28 years, I can say that when I was a young fellow I was the enemy of the people of Senator Bigger's persuasion. When the Treaty came, however, everything possible was done to see that these people got all the protection possible. When two undisciplined armies were fighting one another here nobody got more protection from every section than Deputy Bigger's people got. I hope that in speaking yesterday he did not express the feelings of the people to whom he belongs and who call themselves the minority. I have the same love for all of them. Since our Civil War, I have learned the necessity for Christian charity. It is very hard to understand the line which Senator Bigger took. He insinuated that the North could not come in because Protestants would not get a fair share of control. Since the Treaty our Government has given to the minority all the help and protection it possibly could. We are all one people and why should they imagine that any Government here will try to tyrannise over people because they are of a different religion and are of a different outlook?
I am certain Senator Bigger knows very well that those who have brought in this Bill are absolutely honest. I would appeal to him, instead of taking that line, in future not to try to alienate his brother Northern, but rather try to make this Bill such a success that it will help to bring about a 32-county republic. That is the aim of all of us and I am sure this Bill will not hamper it. As the Taoiseach said some time ago, the hand of friendship was extended to the people in the North, but it was spurned and thrown aside. I feel that this Bill will do away with Partition. We may have had a republic in the Twenty-Six Counties before the Bill was brought in, but now at least we have an independent republic so far as outside countries are concerned. Our influence will be much greater with them, and might be the means of forcing the North to come in. I cannot agree with Senator Bigger that there will be any shooting or any civil war, or that there is anybody in this House who wants to start shooting in the North. I cannot understand his mentality if he thinks that would be the case. I believe we are now in a much stronger position to get a 32-county republic established through the influence of outside countries. Their influence helped to bring about the Treaty in 1922 more than the shooting by a lot of us did.
I should also like to refer to statements about the shooting of policemen. I hold that there is no difference between the shooting of policemen in 1926 and in 1937 and 1938. It was as big a crime to shoot a policeman in 1925, 1926 or 1927 as it was to shoot a policeman in 1937 or in 1938 or 1939. If Senator Quirke thinks it was a crime to shoot policemen in 1937 and 1938, I say it was a crime in 1926. The sooner we forget about all that the better. We should try to help one another, even though we may differ as to politics or economics. We should bend our minds towards helping the Government in power, no matter what Government it is, rather than be harping on the past and trying to gain kudos by talking about what we did. If we could forget all about that and look to the future, we would be a lot better off and much happier people. We should not be thinking of who will be in power in one, two or three years. Since this Bill was introduced the discussion has centred around: "How long will it be until I am in power and have you out?" I ask that that should be forgotten and that we should bend our minds to helping one another, no matter what Government is in power.
Comment on this
I think it is quite clear we are all agreed that this Bill is a good one. As Senator Ryan has just said, there has been an attempt on the part of some people to get a share of the praise. The choice between the Parties has not been one of the direction in which the policy should move, but of the speed at which it should travel. Leaving out certain details of this debate, we have, I think, travelled the road every one of us wanted to travel in our different ways and we have now arrived at a republic for Ireland. I will not say much more on that point but, as a Fine Gael supporter since the Treaty, and up to quite recently as an ordinary rank and file one. I feel there are certain things that have been said quite wrongly about the Party. There has been in some cases unconscious confusion and in many other cases very conscious confusion of our aims.
We have had all this talk about the Commonwealth and that we were not republicans. It was not a question of being labelled a republic. What we were concerned with was real freedom. It was not a question whether we were a republic or a co-equal member of the Commonwealth. We have now reached the stage where we are definitely declaring a republic. Thank God we have a Government that is prepared to declare full freedom for Ireland. On this occasion to please everybody it is being called an Irish republic, which it always was.
We have been accused of letting down the people interested in the Commonwealth. This has not been very clearly dealt with, and I am not saying that I can clearly deal with it. As regards the Commonwealth, there are two kinds of people who profess to support our participation in it. First of all, there are those who would do so for the good of Ireland, for the mutual advantage of associating with a particular group of nations. Secondly, there are those who are unnational in outlook and who see in the Commonwealth something that will perpetuate the Crown and something that will frustrate the acquisition of full Irish independence. These people were anti-Treaty in 1921 and 1922; they were anti-Statute of Westminister and anti-External Relations Act, and now they are anti-repeal of the External Relations Act. These are the kind of commonwealthers who criticise us and describe us as doing a volte face.
These people's conception of the Commonwealth is one where we would have a proper allegiance to the Crown; they are the people who would like to see the Commonwealth imposing penalties on the Irish people because we are acting as a free and independent Irish nation. Surely, according to the definition of the British Commonwealth, it is supposed to be a group of co-equal and fully independent nations? Surely, if one of those nations does exercise its full nationality, as we propose to do, that is the time for the Commonwealth to show itself as a really free association of nations? There is the point that there are numbers of people in this country who think the Commonwealth has got more out of us than we get out of it, but that is another point.
If it should be desirable for us in the future to join the Commonwealth, it might be no harm for me to say a few words on some points that were raised. It is believed by some people that the symbol of the Crown is the essential bond of the Commonwealth and because we have abolished the Crown we, therefore, must be debarred from the Commonwealth. I think this conception is really built upon the historical fact that the Commonwealth of Nations has evolved from the old Imperial conferences where definitely the countries going to the conferences were subservient and Great Britain was really the dominating country, if not the mother country. She was, at any rate, in a dominating position and she was dictating on what terms people were to go there. All this talk about the Crown is a hangover from that particular conception.
The concept of the Crown as the source of common citizenship is a British one. We must consider how the Commonwealth evolved from being an Empire conference. Since the Statute of Westminster in 1926 and the conferences, to which the Taoiseach referred, of 1929 and 1930, the character of this association has been rapidly changing. Instead of a group of dominions and colonies foregathering under the wing of a dominating Great Britain, we now have a group of co-equal, separate, independent States.
Ireland and Canada were leaders in this movement of change and advance to a more and more individual independence. I have not heard anybody referring, except in critical terms, to the Taoiseach's visit to Canada, and I think it is in this we will find some explanation, and I think the real explanation of the wise action of the Taoiseach in doing what he did in Canada and saying what he said there.
There has always been, since those days of the Statute of Westminister, a very close similarity of views on national status and inter-Commonwealth relations between Ireland and Canada. It might interest the House to hear what appeared in the Observer of Sunday, October 3rd, while the Commonwealth Conference was meeting in London. It was an article written on Commonwealth viewpoints by a Martin Ross. This apparently has been accepted, because it has been quoted on several occasions and it has never been disagreed with by the Canadian Government. It says:—
"The strength of the Commonwealth, in Ottawa's eyes, is that it is a loose association of like-minded but separate and distinct States.
There is therefore nothing inherently objectionable to Canada in the idea of new constitutional arrangements to include in the association States which do not recognise the Crown. Admittedly it seems paradoxical that a Commonwealth whose only formal link is the Crown should seek to include countries which do not recognise that link. But the Commonwealth has never objected to paradox and if the Prime Ministers can devise a new formula it will be accepted here."
That comes to this point. We are being told that we are going to be thrown out of the Commonwealth. We are not going to be thrown out unless the people who are urging so strongly that we should be, merely to punish us, get their way.
But the Taoiseach, before he brought this Bill forward, and when he was in Canada, took the trouble to consult with other members of the Commonwealth and how anybody can criticise him because he did that and suggest that he did not realise the importance of the thing, is beyond my conception. Obviously what the Taoiseach was doing was the wise thing. He had made up his mind that we were going to declare a republic. The last Government did not declare a republic because they knew there were grave reasons why they could not, and these grave reasons had to deal with external relations, relations between this country and other countries. That is what the Taoiseach was doing. He was preparing the ground.
There was no reason why we should not have a republic and at the same time convince the other members of the Commonwealth that it was not only necessary here but that it would be in the general interest and fully in conformity with the march of progress that was being made in the Commonwealth itself in regard to relationships that we should be a republic and at the same time in the Commonwealth and that they should make it possible for us to be in that position. I understand from the statements made by the different members that they have the greatest sympathy with our move here.
I think they have almost bluntly said so, that they are going to set about creating such a situation that we can, if we wish, be still members of the Commonwealth. Therefore, I feel that by the Taoiseach's action in that way, he has fully justified our stand as commonwealthers, that is commonwealthers for the good of Ireland and not commonwealthers for the love of the Crown. He has particularly justified the stand of Fine Gael and we have no apology to make to those who voted for us as commonwealthers. There is a far bigger body of supporters of Fine Gael whom I know who have been nothing if not republicans but they did not call themselves republicans. The term "republican" is merely a name, but they stood for the essence of republicanism.
As I am on that point, I should like to point out that we are not alone in this kind of approach to this situation. Deputy Gerry Boland speaking in the Dáil, on this Bill, as reported in Volume 113, No. 4, page 559, said: "I, personally, would not be one bit disturbed about our status, provided we had a united Ireland." The phrase, I grant, was used in connection with a different thing, but it is the same principle. Deputy Boland is not a bit concerned about our status so long as the essence is all right. We, in Fine Gael, were never worried about calling ourselves big names so long as we had the essence of freedom. That is what we claim we have had. The future, therefore, would seem to hold out a position where the wishes of the Irish people for full independence and the desire for inclusion in the Commonwealth can be settled at one and the same time.
In the debate yesterday, there was a reference to a statement made by Deputy de Valera to the effect that "there is a lot who want to be in and a lot who want to be out". I claim that this Bill is going to satisfy both these people and I, therefore, support the Bill. I think the action of the Taoiseach and his Government in preparing the ground for this Bill with care without walking into all the dangers and traps that existed, is to be commended. I welcome that action and I have great pleasure in supporting the Bill. I think it is a highly patriotic Bill and it is what the nation desires.
Senator Tunney rose.
Comment on this
Before Senator Tunney speaks, I should like to know whether we are to conclude at 6 p.m. or whether there is to be a tea adjournment. I wonder how many Senators desire to speak apart from Senator Tunney?
Comment on this
If there are a number of other speakers to follow, it is desirable that we should adjourn for tea. It is not fair to members of the House nor is it fair to Ministers that we should continue without a tea adjournment. The House has always been accommodating to Ministers.
Comment on this
I suggest that we might carry on if the Taoiseach gets in before 6 p.m.
Comment on this
But we have a tradition to live up to in the tea adjournment.
Comment on this
There are also two other Bills to be taken this evening.
Comment on this
Yes. If the Minister could get in before 6 o'clock we could carry on instead of adjourning. If the Minister cannot get in at 6 o'clock or before that hour, I suggest that we adjourn at 6 o'clock.
Agreed.
Comment on this
I am not going to detain the House more than about five minutes, as there is nothing that I have to say on the Bill that has not already been stated by some other Senators. So far as I am concerned, however, I feel that I am constrained to take exception to the statement made here by Senator Bigger. People may say that it is not manly to attack a person who is, as it were, speaking alone, but after all his statement was so serious and there was so much behind it that I could not conscientiously allow it to go unchallenged. Senator Bigger and his co-religionists in this country are persons for whom I had always the greatest respect, even though we do differ in religion. I always believed that they were people who, when they did make statements. at least spoke according to the light of their consciences and made an honest effort to speak the truth. I am satisfied, however, that Senator Bigger's statements last night in every shape and form were false, very false. He painted a wrong picture of the position of this country and what is still worse, I am convinced that there is nobody in this House who was more satisfied that they were false, than Senator Bigger himself.
Comment on this
I have not intervened so far, but may I have the protection of the Chair?
Comment on this
I am commenting, as I am entitled to comment, on the speech of the Senator. Senator Bigger stated that the Northern problem was our domestic affair. Certainly it is our domestic affair, but let England withdraw her forces out of this country. Senator Bigger did not suggest that. Senator Bigger tried to show to the people of the world that the Partition of this country was due to differences in the religious beliefs of the people. That is a false statement, and while I am one of those who believe in justice for every minority and in justice for every individual, I could not allow Senator Bigger's statement to go unchallenged.
Senator Bigger wanted it to go out to the world that this trouble was of our own making. It is no such thing. Is Senator Bigger not well aware that England invaded this country and conquered it by force and that it is England's rule that has kept it down for 700 years? What right in this country has the British Government which claims to be the defender of democracy all over the world? If they believe in honest democracy, why do they not clear out of Ireland?
I say the people by a free vote in 1918 decided the type of Government this country should have. Senator Bigger has stated that on a free vote of the people to-morrow, they would vote for remaining in the British Empire. That is entirely wrong unless the people have changed very much since 1918. If Senator Bigger could use his influence with the British Government to leave this question to the free vote of the Irish people, I am quite prepared to abide by their decision and I know in advance what that decision would be. Let us be honest and have no beating about the bush. I would say to those who differ from us in religion that they have nothing to fear from a sovereign Ireland.
We are a peace-loving people but a people who will stand against any oppression. I think it is up to men of the type of Senator Bigger to use their influence with the British Government, whether they be a Tory Government or a Labour Government, to end this problem. I am sorry to say that the Labour Government has done very little, so far as the removal of the unnatural Border in this country is concerned. It is wrong that any member should come in here and make the statement that he is not a constitutional lawyer and that he is not a politician, but as a politician he takes advantage of this House to put forth a statement all over the world that the difference between us and his co-religionists is of our own making. It is no such thing, and Senator Bigger should realise that.
I am not trying to stir up any bitterness, but I feel that if the British Government was in earnest in what they say—that they stand for democracy all over the world and object to the acts of tyranny practised by strong nations on weak ones—they would show good example themselves by clearing out of this country. They have no right to be here except the right of the conqueror. I can tell Senator Bigger that I believe this Bill will take the gun out of Irish politics as far as this portion of the country is concerned. I want to tell him, too, that as long as liberty-loving Irishmen are born here they will never be content to sit down and allow the British Empire to domineer over any part of our country. It has no right here except the right of the conqueror and of the tyrant and the scoundrel.
This Bill will show the nations of the world that the majority of the Irish people stand for a republican form of government. We showed that by our majority vote in 1918. We are showing it now by the unanimous vote that is behind the Government on this Bill. If one were to add the members elected for Northern Ireland you would have a huge majority in favour of the republic. If we are to practise democracy, as well as talk about it, there is no answer to what I say, that the majority of the Irish people are in favour of a republican form of government. This Bill will prove that to the peoples of the world, and, further, that the British Government will not allow this measure to function in a certain portion of the country.
I congratulate the Taoiseach and the Minister for External Affairs for having brought forward this Bill. I believe that, even though certain things have been said, it will go a long way in doing good for the people of this country and among Irish people the world over.
I congratulate Senator O'Dwyer on the honest to God speech he made this evening. If I had spoken on the Bill last evening I might have made somewhat different statements, but having heard Senator O'Dwyer's speech, I feel that it is due to me to thank him for it. I would hope that he would use his influence with other members of his Party to be as honest in their statements as he was in his. I could not understand the attitude of certain Fianna Fáil members in the Dáil on this Bill. I would like to deal with some of the statements that were made last evening by Senator Quirke, but I feel that it would not be good for the country if I were to do so, particularly after the speech we had this evening from Senator O'Dwyer.
This Bill will prove that the leaders of the Fianna Fáil Party were not all as wise prophets as they pretended to be. I want to say that in my opinion this Bill will vindicate the men who accepted the Treaty as a stepping stone to the republic. That is a point that we have all been shutting our eyes to. It has not been emphasised sufficiently in this debate. I say that as one who opposed the Treaty. I am honest enough to say that. It has been said by all those who have spoken from one side of this House, and also in the Dáil, that we had a republic since 1937, except in name. Well, if we had how did it come about except through the Treaty? I would say that even though I and all belonging to me opposed the Treaty. I would not be here if I had not been born. If a certain position had not been accepted at a certain time it follows that a republican Constitution could not have been enacted in 1937. That should be said in recognition of the great men who gave such service to this country. They were reviled and the phrase was even used in this country that they were "traitors" and should be treated as such. We are now told by the Fianna Fáil Party that we have a republic. I am not going to dwell on that because it would not be good for the country if I were to go into it too much.
A lot has been said about the Commonwealth Party, and unkind things about the Fine Gael Party—as to whether it was the Commonwealth Party. I read a statement made about two weeks ago by Deputy Oscar Traynor, the Minister for Defence in the last Government. He was referring to the strength of our Army. He said that, during the emergency, it was up to such strength that if Germany invaded this country it could hold them until the British came along. All I will say about that statement is that if it were made by a Fine Gael Minister for Defence certain people would take objection to it.
Comment on this
The Minister for Defence said that our Army during the war was only sufficiently strong—he was complaining about the fact that it was small at the present time—if Germany invaded the country to hold them until the British came along. If that statement did not appear in the Sunday Independent a fortnight or three weeks ago I will resign from the Seanad to-morrow.
Comment on this
Are you trying to cast a reflection on the Irish Army because they would be able to hold the German army for a week?
Comment on this
No, I am not. I joined the Irish Republican Army in 1913 under the late Joseph MacBride of Westport, and I have been a true Irish republican ever since. I would be the last man to cast a reflection on any soldier of Ireland. I should just like to say to the people who have so much talk about the Commonwealth that I am afraid that if that statement was made by one of the Fine Gael Ministers we would take a very serious view of it.
Comment on this
There is a lot in that point. I should like to say—only for the records of the House, since Senator Quirke stated yesterday that I was expelled from the Fianna Fáil Party— that I resigned from the Fianna Fáil Party and one of the four reasons that I gave to the then Secretary, Mr. Davin, to put before the National Executive for my resignation was that I was not satisfied with the republican position.
Comment on this
I should also like to have it on the records of the House that Senator Tunney was the only one, to my knowledge, who was expelled from the Fianna Fáil Party by public proclamation—and I did it myself in this House. He resigned a couple of days later.
Comment on this
I would ask Senator Quirke to sit down and not interrupt me. I did not speak yesterday evening. If I had done so my speech would have been different to what it is this evening. I do not like to be personal but I would say that if the Fianna Fáil Party had expelled Senator Quirke they might be in office to-day.
Comment on this
What about coming to the Bill which is before the House?
Comment on this
Let the Senator examine his conscience. However, that kind of talk does not get us anywhere and I have nothing against Senator Quirke any more than against Senator Smyth. If Senator Quirke had not mentioned expulsion I would not have corrected him but, in the circumstances, I had to reply. I wanted to have it on the records of the House.
Comment on this
A lot has been said about rejoicing on the day this Bill becomes law. I would appeal to the Government to postpone rejoicing until we have a 32-county republic and, when that day comes, the Irish people will rejoice. After all, though the day on which this Bill becomes law is a day on which there could be rejoicing, nevertheless it could also be a day of mourning. While I am delighted that we have gone this distance along the road, at the same time I am satisfied that the true Irish people will never be satisfied until we have a 32-county republic. I would ask Senator Professor Bigger to use his influence with his colleagues across the water favourably in our regard. Mention was made of coercion. It would be bad enough if a majority coerced a minority but it would be very bad indeed if a minority coerced a majority—and that is what has taken place.
I am very pleased with the speeches that have been made during this debate, even those made by the Senators who are sitting on the Opposition side of this House. The majority of them were good and reasonable speeches. I believe that out of this Bill will come good for Ireland. With regard to credit I say that from 1916 onwards a certain amount of credit is due to all Parties. I am one of those who will say that when the Fianna Fáil Party took office they moved and moved quickly a certain distance along the road. I am satisfied now that the people who accepted the Treaty accepted it in the belief that it would be a stepping-stone towards the republic. I am satisfied that the Minister who has introduced this Bill has done so with a good intention. As one of those who has done his part in the struggle for the freedom of this country since 1913 I wish to say that I am delighted and happy this evening —and not only now, but a week ago— to think that we have reached the point where every member of Dáil Éireann has agreed to the Republic of Ireland Bill.
Comment on this
I support this Bill because I felt at the time the Executive Authority (External Relations) Act was before the Dáil that that Act was a subterfuge, a dodge, to try and make those people who wished to believe that the King had disappeared out of Ireland believe he was gone and to try and make those who wanted to believe that a link still existed believe it was still there. I felt that the Bill was an attempt to satisfy conflicting views. Any Bill of that nature is apt to bring about confusion and is, therefore, unsatisfactory. I think subsequent events have proved that the Bill was not satisfactory. It satisfied nobody except those who were prepared to be satisfied with anything. That is one of the reasons why I welcome the repeal of the Executive Authority (External Relations) Act. I never believed that in that Bill there was any satisfactory link with the Crown that could be said to be anything in the nature of allegiance to the Crown and those who thought there was—well, if it satisfied them, well and good. I feel, however, that it is a good thing that the position has now been made clear to all.
Some of us feel that the Commonwealth of Nations was a group of nations who made a valuable contribution to world stability. Some of us feel that now, owing to world changes, the basis on which that Commonwealth of Nations used to rest must be broadened. We have seen—nobody knows this better than does the Taoiseach—the gradual development of the Commonwealth of Nations from a nebulous idea into something much more concrete on the completion of the Statute of Westminster. But we must go further than the Statute of Westminster to-day if that Commonwealth of Nations is to survive. Symbolic links were all very well in the past. To-day we must be realists. No group of nations can possibly hold together if the physical stepping-stones between them are removed. It is possible that both India and South Africa may shortly alter their associations with the Commonwealth of Nations unless that Commonwealth changes the basis upon which association rests at present.
This declaration of a republic has had rather peculiar reactions in certain quarters in Britain. I should like to quote now from a publication known as The National Newsletter. It is the King-Hall letter of December 2nd, 1948. Under the heading “A Vision or Policy” he says:—
"We are now about to enter a phase and story of the Commonwealth in which for the first time it will be openly recognised that the people of a republic are in many special ways in a privileged relationship with the peoples of monarchies, and vice-versa. This special relationship is going to be accepted because it is commonsense to create it and because it is also a peaceful way of proceeding and good business. But Eire is not the only republic in the world which has citizens which share with those of the United Kingdom a number of common outlooks. What about the United States?”
I quote that to show that some people in Britain think that our action in declaring a republic here may have considerable reactions on world organisation. We should remember that, small as we are, a nation of this size can sometimes contribute more and risk more than larger nations can when it comes to questions of alteration in international relationships. While technically, no doubt, we are outside the Commonwealth of Nations as it is constituted to-day I hope that a new association of nations on a broader basis may find for us a place in which we can usefully serve and contribute to the well-being both of ourselves and others. Let us remember that small nations in the future cannot hope to exist alone. They must have the goodwill of others. They will only have that goodwill when they are themselves prepared to co-operate and do their best to help others.
While it is quite clear for historical and other reasons that many people in this country could not willingly co-operate with the British Commonwealth of Nations in its old form, because of the special form of association now, I see no reason why, if this vision comes to pass, we cannot co-operate and play our part in a wider association of nations. This Bill clears the air and allows us to take part with other nations without the necessity in the future of making excuses or giving explanations. I feel, therefore, that we can now move forward into the future prepared to play our part without let or hindrance.
Comment on this
On behalf of those whom I represent I fully support this Bill. The people whom I represent are for the greater part those who look upon the Crown as a symbol of oppression. I represent the small farming community whose sons emigrate to England every year and are compelled to make their living there. I believe the relations that will exist after the passage of this Bill between these migrants and the English people with whom they come in contact will not be worsened in any way. I believe that those relations will improve because of this Bill. That is one of the reasons why I support it.
I support it also because it has brought unity to our country. I speak with first hand knowledge of a large part of the West of Ireland where in the past neighbours have been divided. I say without fear of contradiction that very few measures have been introduced in this House which have been received by the people with so much satisfaction and so much hope. The people believe that the unity we once had will be restored to us under this Bill.
I would like to commend to the House the speeches of both the Taoiseach and the Leader of the Opposition in the other House on this Bill. They were very fair. They gave credit where credit was due. They gave thanks to those people who made it possible to introduce this Bill at this stage. They gave thanks to the Irish Parliamentary Party prior to 1916 and to all those connected with the national movement, irrespective of Party. I think it would be well for the country if the general body of Deputies and Senators followed the headlines set by them. Personally I think that nothing would go so far to restore unity or to give our country a higher status than if the debates in both Houses had been conducted according to the headlines set by the Taoiseach and the ex-Taoiseach. Things would be very much improved to my mind.
Yesterday evening, Senator Bigger was looking for concessions to his sentiments and to those of his friends. He told us that he was in the British Army during the war when France was defeated, before Russia came in and before America came in. All credit to him for that. But I would point out to him that he was not there alone; that there were thousands of Irishmen belonging to the class which I represent, who were not possessed of worldly goods and had not very much to defend in that way, who gave their services and their lives in what they believed to be the cause of world freedom.
I would suggest to Senator Bigger, if he is looking for a concession to his sentiments and to those of the minority he represents, that I think I have an equal claim or a much stronger claim to make, the claim of those people who looked upon the Crown as the symbol of oppression and yet who gave their services and their lives to the British Empire when it was in danger. I certainly hold that we are entitled to some concession to our sentiments.
Senator Bigger when speaking yesterday made a good many charges and told us that the Taoiseach, like Deputy de Valera, had been travelling round foreign lands. He suggested that they should have remained at home and directed their speeches and their energies to Northern Ireland. He did not say that he is prepared to accompany them. If he believes the unity of Ireland can be achieved by that means, it is up to him as a good Irishman to address himself seriously to the possibility of putting his views before the Taoiseach and making some suggestions as to what he considers the best means of reuniting the whole of Ireland. I am sure that there is nobody in this or the other House or even in the nation who will be slow to give Senator Bigger credit if he is the means of solving the partition of this country. Therefore, I suggest, if he has something in mind, or if he thinks that speech-making and explaining the position to his friends in the Six Counties can be done by the Taoiseach or members of the Government or with the co-operation of the previous Government, he will have willing helpers in all these. As I said, not alone the members of the Government and of both Houses but the entire nation would be grateful to him or any other man who would be the instrument of solving the question of Partition.
Comment on this
After the very many speeches which have been made both yesterday and since 10.30 this morning in welcoming the introduction of this
Bill, there is very little left for me to say. As one, however, who, for the past 40 years, had the honour of the confidence of many of those people whose patriotism and sacrifices and endeavours made it possible for this Bill to be introduced and paved the way for it, I feel that I should like to be personally associated with the welcome that is being given to it. I welcome the Bill for many reasons, a few of which I shall give you. First and before all I welcome it because, as has been pointed out by the Taoiseach, it does away once and for all with the trouble that divided families, homesteads and villages in this country for the past quarter of a century and it prevents the possibility of a recurrence at any time of the tragic episodes that marked our history during that period.
I welcome the Bill also because of the manner in which the achievement has been brought about. People opposed to the idea of a republic visualised repercussions against the many of our nationals who, unfortunately, up to the present could not get a living at home and had to go to Great Britain and other countries of the Commonwealth which would make their position anything but comfortable. Thanks to the Taoiseach and his Ministers, that ground was pretty well cleared before the Bill was introduced.
Thirdly, I welcome it because of the manner of its introduction. I consider it proper that a Bill of this kind should be introduced by the Leader of an inter-Party Government; that it will do away, as Senator Hayes pointed out, with the possibility of any people in the near future or in years to come claiming a monopoly of patriotism in this country. As a supporter of the Treaty and a helper of Cumann na nGaedheal and its successor Fine Gael, I welcome this Bill, though Fine Gael latterly has come in for a certain amount of notoriety. It looked to me as if the only opposition that certain people in the Dáil and a few here had to the particular measure was that it was introduced by a Government which had a strong leavening of the Fine Gael Party. But, as Senator Hayes and I think Senator Douglas pointed out, the people of the Fine Gael Party were realists and they accepted the Treaty as freedom to achieve freedom, the freedom that this Bill will bring to this country once is is enacted. The symbol of the Crown was just as repugnant to members of the Cumann na Gaedheal Party as it was to those who took exception to the Treaty because the symbol was introduced. Fine Gael followers had no personal animosity to those who wore the Crown. What they objected to was that the Crown stood for—acts of aggression, repression and injustice, the actions of the crow-bar brigade that figured so much in my native county, and their crimes against a defenceless people, all justified by the Crown.
It has been pointed out that the symbol of the Crown could never be a cause of unity, but Fine Gael accepted it. They accepted it because they felt it would be an inducement to those in the Six Counties who still feel that they would not like a united Ireland or who would prefer to be tacked on to the British Empire. For the past 25 years, as has been pointed out, concessions have been made by two successive Governments, but no good has come of it and the only alternative is what is being done now—and that should have been done years ago. However, it is better late than never. I believe that as a result of the peace and contentment that this measure will bring about, and the fact that the youth of the country can bend their energies towards developing our natural resources, the circumstances will be such that in the near future the North will be asking to come in to join us and we will be only too glad to give them a hearty welcome when that opportunity arrives. There is no talk about civil war. The guns have been taken out of politics by this Bill and, please God. they will remain out of politics.
I think it was Senator Hayes who referred to the fact that several Parties for many years have contributed their share towards securing the status which this Bill will now give our country. I believe, and I am not alone in that belief, that were it not for the realism and foresight of those great men who, in 1921, had the courage to make a settlement with England, it is very doubtful if things would have reached the very happy pass they have reached to-day. These men were misrepresented by several, misunderstood by not a few, but they carried on and the justification of the faith they had in the future of their country is to be found in the introduction of this Bill which, I believe, will bring peace and happiness and will eventually bring about conditions that will do away with the unnatural boundary that divides the people of the six northern counties from this State.
Comment on this
I came in here this morning with the avowed—well, perhaps, not avowed, but the latent —intention of crossing swords with Senator Bigger. Though he is looking remarkably fresh and well, he has taken rather a beating to-day, so I am not going to add anything that I might have to say to the attack made upon him—not upon him personally, but upon what he has said. I would like to devote the few remarks that I have to make to a congratulatory phrase to a younger colleague of Senator Bigger, Senator Stanford. If this debate did nothing else, it did produce a speech from Senator Stanford showing that he, as a younger member of the same institution, is taking a line which, I believe, will show tremendous results in the near future.
In the university which he represents and amongst the people of whom he is one it has been said, and possibly with some justice, that to a large extent they have held aloof from Irish politics since the Treaty and a paper that possibly favours the minority, or possibly thought up to this debate to voice the views of the minority, must feel in a sorry pass to-night, having heard the speech of Senator Stanford. He has said a thing that I believed for the past five or six years, and that is that the minority to which he belongs votes for three or four Parties, or possibly for independents, but that at no time did it give its complete or universal support to any Party. I think that that would be an extremely healthy sign in Irish politics and when I tramped the roads of County Wicklow looking for votes, if Senator Stanford's minority had voted for me I would have got a quota and a half and probably brought in another candidate. However, I bear no grudge against them that they did not vote for me. They had more able and experienced candidates that they did vote for.
I belong to a generation whose tradition is that of Sinn Féin, but whose memory does not stretch back beyond 1918 or 1919. I consider it inconceivable that there should be any suggestion that the Leader of this Government could be doing what he is doing to-day motivated by anything other than patriotism of the highest order.
I have no intention of bringing Party politics into this and neither have I any intention of ever apologising for the Party I belong to, for the man who leads it, or for the man who leads this Government. In my Party our tradition needs no praise and the members of it need never, have never and will never apologise for themselves.
One Senator made a remark which I would like to endorse. He was possibly paraphrasing the speech made by the Taoiseach some weeks ago. Surely, this day was not achieved solely by the men who died heroically in 1916; surely, it was not achieved solely by the men who fought up to 1921 and who regrettably fought each other after 1921? He raised his voice in praise of Parnell, Redmond, and the men under Redmond who went out and died upon foreign fields in the belief that they were helping, as they have helped, to achieved this Bill. A well known and very experienced Parliamentarian said to me when I was coming in here that he wears a scarlet poppy—I have never done it, nor any member of my family— in memory of those men who did their part in the belief that they were fighting on these foreign fields for this day and, he said, after this Bill passes into law, a man may wear that poppy and be as good an Irishman as the man who wears the Easter Lily, because both are remembering something that is noble and fine.
Comment on this
If I have any enthusiasm in supporting this Bill it is because we are united, or practically united, on it. Perhaps the tragedy of the past ten or 12 years might never have taken place if Fine Gael, when our Party got into power, stood behind them in dealing with international problems, such as the removal of the oath and the Governor-General and the other things that, perhaps, caused the civil war. If they took the stand that Deputy de Valera is taking now, in supporting the inter-Party Government in the introduction of this Bill, I do believe that some of the things that have happened within the last ten or 12 years would not have arisen. I am certain that Fine Gael has learned its lesson now but had they taken the stand that Deputy de Valera is taking now and had supported him in his policy, this country would be very much better off.
It is quite obvious that if the Government had not the support of the Opposition at the present time on this Bill, it would not be so favourably received by the Commonwealth nations. If Fine Gael had supported Deputy de Valera when he was the head of the Government in removing the most obnoxious features of the Treaty of 1921, for which I am not blaming anyone, then all the strife of the last ten or 12 years would not have arisen and their would be no need for all this talk, which we have recently heard, about "taking the gun out of Irish politics". Unfortunately, Deputy de Valera did not get that support and we have had the gun in Irish politics. The Government now in their wisdom in 1948 introduce this Bill which has the support of the majority of the Irish people.
Were it not for the support that the Government is getting from the largest Party in this House, the Bill would not be so well received at home, any more than abroad, but because of that support, this Bill has been received favourably, internationally and elsewhere. If I have any enthusiasm in supporting this Bill it is mainly for this reason. It is extraordinary what unity can do. I think everyone will agree that in dealing with major matters like these or in dealing with an international problem, the Government of the day should have the support of the Irish people. You have got that support from the Leader of the majority Party in the Seanad and in the other House and therefore the Bill has been well received.
At the risk of repeating myself, I say that the gun would have long gone out of Irish politics if the Fine Gael Party had supported Deputy de Valera in the removal of the oath and the other objectionable features of the Treaty. I am sure that if that Party had to face the same problem again they would not act in the same way as they did.
The major problem now confronting the Irish people is the undoing of Partition and I am sure every Senator hopes that in our time Partition will be undone. We may have various ideas as to how that is to be achieved. Some people think that it is unwise at the present time to repeal the External Relations Act, that, if that Act remained, perhaps it would be a bargaining basis so far as the North of Ireland or England is concerned. The External Relations Act has gone and therefore that bargaining power, if it was a bargaining power, has vanished. Other ways and means will have to be adopted to get our nationalist and unionist friends in the North to come into a united Ireland.
I believe that the economic position here is as good and perhaps much better when you take everything into consideration, than it is in the North, no matter what you may hear from various political platforms from time to time. If you had the whole thing analysed by economic experts who would give the pros and cons, both here and in the North, I believe they would show that the economic and social conditions of the people of the North would be very much better if they threw in their lot with us than remaining as they are. I hope that the things which the Minister for External Affairs visualised as a result of this Bill will be fully realised and that in our time at least the gun will remain out of Irish politics. It is something that should not have been in politics for a very long time now. Unfortunately some people in this country were told otherwise with the result that for a number of years certain sections of the Irish people went their way and did more harm than good perhaps to the Irish cause so far as the Partition problem was concerned. Had they accepted the decision of the country after the introduction of the Constitution we would have been in a much better position to-day. They did not do so with the result that we had all this bitterness, about which we have heard so much, amongst a certain section. It was a very limited section and perhaps it was exaggerated.
It is my ardent wish and the wish of all sincere Irishmen that we shall have unity in this country henceforward so that we can concentrate on economic and social problems, so that we can get the things done for our people that need to be done, things that probably would have been done by now were it not that we had a civil war and economic war. Then during the late war many of these things had to remain in abeyance. We shall have to face these problems now and complete the schemes enshrined in all our programmes. If we do that in the spirit in which it is expected that all Irishmen should act, we shall not, unlike Senator Professor Bigger, have anybody coming along and telling us that we were mugs, dupes and "suckers". As it is now approaching 6 o'clock, I do not wish to detain the House further but I hope that the principles enshrined in the Bill will have the success which the sponsors of the Bill expect.
Comment on this
It is now 6 o'clock. Does the House wish to carry on or to adjourn for an interval? I would remind Senators that there are two other Bills to be dealt with.
Comment on this
I do not know whether there is very much that can be added to what has been already said in the other House and in this House in the course of this debate. I would like at the outset to congratulate the House and to express a deep sense of appreciation at the way in which this Bill was dealt with by all sides in this House. I think it was approached in a constructive and helpful manner generally, more so than in the other House. I am possibly in a more difficult position than anybody else in the House or than any of my colleagues in the Government in dealing with this matter because I have to look at it not merely from the point of view of the different Parties in this House, and not merely from the point of view of the country, but I have to look at it a little bit from the point of view of other countries. Therefore, I possibly have a more difficult task in some respects in taking part in a debate of this kind.
Senator Fearon made a remark which I think is very true, and which I think, to a certain degree, approaches the fundamentals that made the introduction of this Bill essential. He pointed out that we have had no normality in politics and that, possibly, a new alignment would result, after the passage of this Bill, in the political life of the country. That, I think, is very true. Ever since the establishment, if you like, of the republic by the votes of the people in 1918, subsequently ratified by the Dáil in 1919, we have had no normal political development. The people have not decided political issues on their merits. They have approached them on the basis of the particular Party they were affiliated to and very often on the basis of the particular side that their family, or some member of it, took in the civil war. Probably the greatest misfortune that can befall any country is a civil war. That misfortune befell us. It lasted a short time and ended officially sometime in 1923, but its after effects have survived right up to the present day; they survived right up to the debates in the Dáil the other day and were it not for the discretion of the members of this House, they would even have survived up to to-day in the debate in this House. Accordingly, I think it is essential to approach the whole of this matter on the basis that we have not had a normal political development, and this measure, if accepted by all sections of the community, does form the basis upon which normal political development will result as far as this part of the country is concerned.
Now, I do not want to represent the Bill to be anything more than it is, nor do I want suggestions to go by unchallenged that it is anything less than what, in fact, it is. The Bill declares the status of Ireland to be a republic. It declares that unequivocally, and to those who, possibly, partly in self-justification seek to minimise the effects of this Bill, I would put this simple test, if they would care to examine it themselves, that this is the first time that the word "republic" appears in any Statute of this State other than in a Pensions Act or a Coercion Act: it is the first time in which the words "Republic of Ireland" are mentioned in any Act passed in the Dáil or in the Seanad, other than incidentally in a Pensions Act or a Coercion Act. I think that illustrates the lack of normality that we have had in our political life. We have awarded pensions to people who fought for the republic on the one hand and in the Acts dealing with that, the word "republic" appears. On the other hand, we have outraged every canon of justice by passing Coercion Acts in which the word "republic" also appears. I am not laying that at the door of any particular Government. I am not blaming anybody for it. As Senator Mrs. Concannon said: "Let bygones be bygones". It applies to both Governments who ruled the country in the past 25 years, but it is, if you look at the thing philosophically—if you like in retrospect—typical of the lack of normality that has been in the political development of our country. We hope that this Bill will put an end to that position.
Many Senators have gone back in retrospect over their political reactions over various periods. I do not want to do so at any length. I think it is probably unwise to do so in detail. While Senator O'Farrell and other Senators were talking, many pictures flashed through my mind, not so much of my own acts but of contacts that I had with various people who featured during those years. I remember long talks that I had with Rory O'Connor, shortly before he was executed in Mountjoy, about Kevin O'Higgins for whom he had a tremendous affection and regard. I realised then as I realise now the tragedy of the position which resulted from the civil war. I remember long talks that I had with George Plant shortly before he was executed, and with Senator Quirke who, I think was one of his best friends, in another period of time. Did we want that situation to continue? Is that the situation we want to continue? We have an opportunity of ending it now. Senators on the Fianna Fáil Benches asked if we had any assurance that guns would not again be used. I think that that question has been put, not very sincerely.
I think it has merely been an attempt to play a little bit of Party politics but I suppose it is very hard for politicians to refrain from Party politics occasionally and I think that guns could be used in Party politics. The only answer I can give is that I can give no assurance for what men in the future will do—no more than Deputy de Valera, when he decided to enter the Dáil, could give any assurance as to the future conduct of subsequent generations of young men with whom he subsequently came into conflict. But having been associated for a fairly long time with the movement for independence in this country; having had opportunity to think about it and having, I think, analysed fairly carefully the various factors involved, I think that the cause of guns in politics was not an internal cause. It was due, purely and simply, to the various attempts that had to be made to reconcile the traditional ideals of the Irish people with the requirements of British policy as regards this country. As I have said before in the other House, I am prepared to give full credit to what was done both by Mr. Cosgrave's Government and by Mr. de Valera's Government in trying to enlarge our sovereignty. But at all times they were always placed in the position of reaching a certain point and being told they could not go further. Having reached that position they then inevitably came into conflict with a section of the people who believed in the ideal of an Irish republic. Indeed I need not go further to demonstrate that than to rely on a speech which was made by Mr. de Valera at the National University. Let me quote from the Irish Press of the 3rd December, 1938:
"I say deliberately that it would be better for the nation if we were an independent republic.... I, for one, am sorry because I feel that if we were able to say that we were an independent republic there would be none of this division which exists at the moment which is helping to cause dissatisfaction and is in a sense a source of danger."
I think Deputy de Valera was perfectly correct then. I think that the events that have occurred since have proved that he was correct. That the confusion continued to exist can, I think, be evidenced by a statement made by Deputy de Valera on the 18th July, 1945, in the Dáil. I am quoting from Volume 97, column 2734:
"There are Deputies in the House who have suggested that we should repeal that Act. If any group of people in this country want to take that as their programme they can do so, but all they will do as far as this State is concerned is to remove an element of confusion. It is, I am admitting, an element of confusion, because the average person is not going to examine exactly its full meaning or anything else."
What is the good of saying now in 1948 that it was not an element of confusion and that everybody knew where we stood? Let us be frank and big and broad-minded about it. Let us realise that it is a good thing nationally. I am perfectly willing to grant that possibly a situation and circumstances may not have existed that made it easy to get rid of this measure. We are getting rid of it now and let us do so without recrimination and let us make it a basis for unity. One thing that we shall require to do is this. In Britain the Crown is a symbol around which the people rally. The same applies to a large extent in countries such as Australia, New Zealand, and Canada where the Crown is a symbol of their mother country to a large extent. We here have had no symbol around which the people could rally. Our history, our tradition, made the Crown anything but a rallying point for our people. Now let us make the Republic of Ireland the symbolic rallying point around which our people can rally. Let us all agree that it is above Party politics, that we can all give our allegiance to it and that we will utilise it as a national rallying point.
Senator Mrs. Concannon was rather troubled, I think, this morning, as to whether this was a 26-county or a 32-county republic. I thought that that position had been dealt with by Deputy de Valera in his Constitution—by Article 2 of the Constitution which has been praised a good deal, I understand, by the Fianna Fáil Benches. Article 2 of the Constitution provides that:
"The national territory consists of the whole island of Ireland, its islands and the territorial seas."
That is, the national territory of the State. This Act declares the State to be the Republic of Ireland.
Comment on this
Article 3 provides— and surely there is nothing else we can do about it, and I take it that Senator Mrs. Concannon voted for it at the time—
Comment on this
Article 3 provides that pending the reintegration of the whole territory the laws can only apply in that portion—
Comment on this
That was my point. The law we are passing now only applies, in accordance with that portion of Article 3, to the area laid down in that Article.
Comment on this
The law we are passing applies to the State. The State is the whole island of Ireland.
Comment on this
Might I put this parallel both to Senator Mrs. Concannon and to Senator Professor Bigger who share the same problems—though from different angles, I take it. I do not know whether they are merely debating points or real points.
Comment on this
Very well. Let me put it this way.
In 1870 France lost Alsace-Lorraine. Alsace-Lorraine was occupied by Germany and remained occupied by Germany from 1870 until 1918. France nevertheless remained France and the name of France did not change because two of her provinces were occupied by a foreign country. There are many other parallels in the history of European countries where a similar position prevailed. Surely, because another country takes over or occupies a portion of our country, we are not going to surrender the name of our country.
Comment on this
Assuming that the making of the State gave Ireland her name and Ireland is subsequently deprived of six of her counties, that does not deprive Ireland of the right to use her original name. That is quite true. But we are now passing into law a measure that declares us to be the Republic of Ireland. I know that it is ridiculous for me to pit myself against a constitutional lawyer, but I would like some constitutional lawyer to prove how a law now made can change the effect of the self-denying ordinance embodied in Article 3 of the Constitution.
Comment on this
I shall put it simply. I do not think it is a matter of constitutional law. Article 2 of the Constitution prescribed the national territory of the State and Article 4 gives the name to that State. This Bill describes the status of the State: it is the same State with the same national territory.
Many remarks have been made about constitutional lawyers. I am not going to deal with them because I think they were rather petty and unworthy of the speakers. I would like to say, however, that I, as Minister for External Affairs, was extremely happy to have as my leader in the Government the present Taoiseach, Mr. Costello, who is an eminent lawyer. I was likewise extremely happy—and you probably can appreciate this having listened to him yesterday in this House—to have with me the present Attorney-General, Senator Cecil Lavery, at the various conferences that took place both in Paris and elsewhere. Having listened to him yesterday, you probably now realise what assistance a man of his calibre was to me and how glad I was to have him at my side.
It would be wrong for me not to take this opportunity of paying a special tribute to the work done by the Taoiseach in this matter. He is a man of tremendous humility, of tremendous honesty, ability and courage. He knew perfectly well when this decision was taken by the Government that he would be the target for the bricks and jibes of Professor Bigger and his political opponents. But he was not afraid to face these jibes because he realised that, as the head of the Government and as an Irishman, it was his duty to bring the country forward and to maintain peace and unity in the country. He felt this was the best way in which to achieve that object and he would allow no political jibes to deter him in that task.
I am not a member of the Fine Gael Party. I hold no brief for the Fine Gael Party. A great deal has been said about not having had a mandate on this measure. I approach that in two ways. I am not aware that the Fianna Fáil Party had a mandate for introducing the External Relations Act at the time it was introduced. On the contrary, their mandate was to establish an independent republic without any connection with the Crown. As the Attorney-General explained to you yesterday, they did carry out that mandate for one day and for one day we had no King; and the next day they reintroduced the King. They did that without a mandate.
Comment on this
Nonsense—read the Attorney-General's speech last night.
Comment on this
Read the Act: "Immediately on the passing of this Act, the instrument of abdication executed by his Majesty, King Edward VIII, on the 10th December, 1936, a copy whereof is set out in the Schedule to this Act, shall have effect according to the tenor thereof." The effect of those words is to make that Act of Abdication part of our law. The Act of Abdication is then set out in the Act. The first words of the Act of Abdication are: "Edward VIII, King of Great Britain, Ireland and the British Dominions." The effect of those words is to make Edward VIII King of Ireland. It does not require a constitutional lawyer to point that out to anybody who has taken the trouble to read the Act.
I do not like to pursue Senator Bigger farther than he has already been pursued, but I think there are a few points to which a reply is necessary. He, first of all, explained at length that he had no mandate for the attitude he was adopting here and that he was not speaking for Trinity College. What right then had he to speak at all in opposition to this measure? Much less, what right had he got to throw stones? He then made the claim that he was better entitled to speak of Ireland as the mother-country than anybody else. I do not want in any way to minimise the number of our graduates who go abroad but they form a very, very small percentage of the total number of emigrants who had to leave the country over the years gone by. I think Professor Bigger must not have thought out what he was going to say on this Bill and what his attitude was going to be or, alternatively, he must be completely lacking in a sense of humour. He commenced by taking great pride in his ancestors who were associated with '98 and in his uncle who, if I am not mistaken, was a member of the Supreme Council of the Fenian Brotherhood.
Comment on this
At all events, he introduced Tone into his speech. I could not but wonder at his inability to realise how incongruous it was for him to bring in Tone and the United Irishmen in support of his views. Surely, his views are diametrically opposed to those held by Tone and the United Irishmen. He mentioned some of the founders of the Sinn Féin movement. Surely, their views differed fundamentally from the views expressed here by Professor Bigger. Apart from the debating points he made, apart from the personal attack he made upon the Taoiseach, apart from throwing a few bricks here and there, his attitude was —I hope I am not being unfair to him— that he wanted to remain a British subject, that he had an affection for Britain and for the British Crown. As I understood Tone and the United Irishmen, they wanted to break the connection with Britain and the British Crown, at least so their writings would seem to indicate when one reads them now. He made then a rather extraordinary statement in which he accused this Government and Deputy de Valera's Government, and I take it also Mr. Cosgrave's Government, though I do not think he mentioned it specifically, of closing the possibility of securing the unity of the country by seeking to obtain the maximum amount of freedom. Are we then to take it that we are only allowed freedom on certain conditions, or that we are only allowed unity without freedom? Is that the up-to-date doctrine of democracy, that freedom is conditional, that the right to self-determination is conditional, that one can only enjoy democratic rights provided one is prepared to forego one's right to national unity or to national sovereignty?
Senator Bigger throughout declared himself to be a lover of freedom and I do not think that as a lover of freedom he can have thought the matter out very carefully because, if he were a lover of freedom, he would not look upon freedom as a thing which was conditional. If one loves freedom, one loves freedom absolutely. It seems to me that freedom which is conditional ceases to be freedom. It seems to me rather odd that, as a lover of freedom, he should in any way condone or seek to excuse the denial of the elementary democratic rights of the people of, say, Tyrone, or Fermanagh, or Armagh, or Derry—a majority in four counties and a minority in two counties. Are they not entitled to as much freedom as we are? Why should it be necessary for Senator Bigger to condone a denial of freedom in their case? I take it he would be up in arms if we here denied elementary democratic rights to the minority whom he represents. If we arranged the electoral laws in such a way as to deprive them of representation on county councils or deprived them of Parliamentary representation, I take it that Senator Bigger would quite likely protest against such a denial of democratic rights. Why then does he condone these infringements of democratic rights when they occur in the Six Counties? Why can he not in honesty, as a lover of freedom, denounce this denial of democratic rights in the Six Counties?
I am afraid I am possibly spending too long a time in dealing with Senator Bigger. I am doing so in the hope that he may realise that in his speech he was not always consistent and that possibly he may have thrown out some of his arguments hurriedly without due consideration. But one thing which I think is rather damaging was stated by Senator Bigger. I do not propose to quote his words, but the purport was that Partition was a purely Irish matter which concerned Ireland and Irishmen and nobody else. That is not correct. It is unnational and it is not in accordance with the facts. As Senator Bigger knows, Partition exists by virtue of a British Act of Parliament. The Border is operated by the British customs. The Six Counties are occupied by British troops. The finances of the Six-County Government are inextricably mixed with those of the British Government. There have been no declarations by the British Government that they wish to see Partition ended. In these circumstances, it is futile to suggest that Britain has no responsibility for Partition.
Senator Honan asked some questions. I think he asked them generally, though I have been somewhat irritated by a lot of the suspicion which was cast deliberately by some of the members of Senator Honan's Party. He wanted to know if there was a bargain, if there was a quid pro quo, if there was any understanding that there was to be a military alliance or military accommodation in case of war. The answer is quite categorical. There is no quid pro quo, no understanding about a military alliance or military accommodation in time of war or at any other time—absolutely none. That was made clear throughout—that the question of our status, of our national sovereignty was one about which there could be no bargain of any kind.
The same matter cropped up in the Dáil and was dealt with by the Taoiseach. In reply to a question by Deputy Dunne, who drew attention to certain newspaper reports, the Taoiseach said:
"No representative of this State has either directly or indirectly, by implication or otherwise, entered into any commitment on defence matters with any other country or with any Government or authority whatsoever outside this State."
Is that categorical or not?
Comment on this
Now I think that if this Bill has served no other useful purpose it achieved one extremely useful purpose. I feel that every Senator will agree with me when I say—I am not saying it for the purpose of paying an empty tribute—that it produced the speech we had to-day from Senator Stanford which I think was a most valuable contribution. It is time that the minority which has been so often wrongly described as the ex-Unionist minority should play an active part in the national life of the country. We shall welcome them as citizens of the republic. We believe that they will be better citizens of the republic than many of us and we shall be prepared at all times to welcome them in our counsels. It certainly made me feel very hopeful when listening to Senator Stanford to-day that that development was about to take place.
Senator Stanford raised a few matters in his speech. He raised the question of the exchanges which have existed hitherto between Ireland and the Commonwealth countries and whether they would continue. He hoped that we would not become too isolationist. In point of fact, as the Taoiseach explained to the House, one of the reasons which prompted the Government so that it would enable a more normal relationship with Britain, was that as soon as we removed the two main points of friction in our relationship with Britain, Partition and the maintenance of outworn constitutional forms that were repugnant to national sentiment and that had no place in our history—that by removing, at any rate, one of these points of friction, the only one we could remove, we were making it possible for a more normal relationship to develop between ourselves and Britain and the other Commonwealth countries. We will now have no quarrel of any kind with the other Commonwealth countries. The only quarrel, the only point of friction that will remain, will be the point of friction between Britain and ourselves in relation to Partition. So far as the other Commonwealth countries are concerned, there will be no quarrel or friction or difficulty, and it will be our desire to have the friendliest and closest relationship with the Commonwealth countries.
Comment on this
Is the Minister prepared to give an undertaking, or to make a statement, that some active effort on our part will be made towards that co-operation? I think we have played a rather passive or an internal part up to the present, and I would welcome some hope that active overtures will be made to heal the breach.
Comment on this
I am quite prepared to give that assurance to the Senator, that everything will be done by the Government to develop the closest co-operation with the various Commonwealth countries. I want to make myself quite clear, lest there be any misunderstanding. As has been stated by the Taoiseach and myself, there can be no question of a military alliance while Partition remains. I have, even in discussing the thing in newspaper interviews and elsewhere, put the position this way. We are in the position of a man who has one of his arms tied behind his back and he is then approached by the man who tied that arm behind his back and asked to join in and fight with him. Our answer is: "Let go of our arm first." Did I hear my friends on the Fianna Fáil Benches asking a question?
Comment on this
We were saying: "Even then"—we must be free to make up our minds even then.
Comment on this
I am saying this not in any sense of derogation; I do not want to suggest that the last Government in any way failed in its duties in matters touching on international relations, but I will say this, and I am saying it in no critical sense of my predecessor, that I think we have in the last six months in European politics played a fairly active part. My view has been that far more important than military alliances and pacts based upon political reasons is the development of economic co-operation in Europe. That, to my mind, is the most fundamental way in which to create a situation where war will not result. We have, therefore, taken a very active part in the promotion of that idea in Europe.
I am on a special committee that was set up, a council of Ministers charged with responsibility to try to speed up the development of economic co-operation in Europe. I am not letting out any secret that I should not let out when I am saying this, that a number of countries in Europe, including ourselves, believe that a greater degree of energy should be brought into play to secure economic co-operation in Europe. A greater drive is needed and, in effect, this council of Ministers should aim at a kind of economic committee or cabinet for Western Europe. I would also like to see linked with that some of the Commonwealth countries. I have made that suggestion and I hope it will bear fruit. I can assure the Senator that we have played a very active part. I think I can say, again without letting out any secret, that we have played a more active part than most of the countries in Western Europe.
Senator O'Brien and some other Senators mentioned various points of difficulty. Of course, there are a great many points of difficulty and they are all being examined. We were asked, on the other hand, by Senator Hawkins, I think, why was the application of this Bill being delayed. If Senator Hawkins and my friends on the Fianna Fáil benches want this Bill to come into operation at once, irrespective of the consequences—say, before the 1st January, when the British Nationality Act comes into operation—and are prepared to take all the consequences that will follow, then the Bill can be brought into operation at once.
Senator O'Brien and some of the other Senators who dealt with possible difficulties seemed to have overlooked the existence of the new British Nationality Act. I think very few people, including Senator Bigger, realise that at the moment they are not, under British law, Irish citizens. Under British law at the moment all of us are looked upon as British subjects. Irish citizenship as such was never recognised by British law and will not be until this new Act comes into operation. It comes into operation on 1st January next and it creates four categories of citizens. It creates, firstly, United Kingdom subjects, and Commonwealth or British citizens are in the second category. The third category covers Irish citizens and the fourth category, aliens.
That will be the first time that Irish citizens as such will be recognised under British law. Irish citizens are then given under the Act the same rights and privileges as British or Commonwealth citizens, but they get these privileges by virtue of their Irish citizenship and not by virtue of being British citizens. The position from that point of view will not be altered.
The same applies to some of the remarks made by other Senators who asked what will be the position when there is a change of Government in Britain—does that mean that a new British Government can alter this position and victimise or punish our people at some future date? Of course they could. They can do that at the moment, if you like, but they cannot do it without defeating their own Act of Parliament or altering their own law because, under their own law, Irish citizens are recognised as such and are given certain rights. Membership of the Commonwealth, or the nebulous position we had hitherto, was absolutely no guarantee that we enjoyed any particular rights. As a matter of fact the position we found when we came into office was that we had trouble in getting for our agricultural produce the same price as was being paid to Denmark. The struggle was, not to get a preferential rate, but to get the same price as was being paid to Denmark. On the other hand, a lesser price was being paid for our cattle than we could get from Continental countries. We found that practically all our manufactured goods were being excluded completely. It was not a question of getting a preference, they just were not being let in. These have been the benefits of membership of the Commonwealth.
Senator Professor O'Brien mentioned the question of membership of the sterling area. There seems to be a good deal of confusion about that because in the sterling area there are many countries that are not members of the Commonwealth. Likewise there are some countries in the Commonwealth that are not in the sterling area. Canada, for instance, is not in the sterling area. Iceland is not in the Commonwealth but it is in the sterling area.
Some Senators referred to British trade unions operating in Ireland. I am not going to deal with such a controversial topic now but might I suggest to Senators, who did mention the subject here, that they might read some references that were made, I think by Deputy Connolly, in the other House to that topic on the Second Reading of this Bill. It occurred to him that possibly this Bill might also provide a solution for that problem. I would appeal to these two Senators here to explore that avenue to see whether it could also provide a solution for that particular difficulty.
Comment on this
That was our attitude, that under this Bill something might be done.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Connolly in the other House made some references that I felt provided at least a basis for discussion.
Comment on this
The difficulty I see is that they have a right established under the Constitution.
Comment on this
I do not think I should be drawn into that. I think the Senator misunderstood the decision given in the courts.
Comment on this
I think the Minister had something to say to the establishment of that right.
Comment on this
I was an advocate certainly. I was on the opposite side to the Taoiseach when the Taoiseach was upholding the Act.
Comment on this
I was preventing the Government at that time from declaring that a person had not got a right to join any union he liked.
Comment on this
Perhaps, between the two Ministers, we might get a solution of the trouble now.
Comment on this
I think the two Ministers will have to settle it.
Comment on this
It all turned on the meaning of the word "regulate". The Government wanted the court to hold that it meant "abrogate".
Comment on this
I think that something might be done by the two Ministers towards finding a solution.
Comment on this
I am sorry that I mentioned the matter. I mentioned it because I was afraid that Senators might have missed what I thought was an olive branch held out by a Deputy in the other House. I do not think I need say anything more. I think everything that could be said about the Act has been said. I want to repeat that it is brought in in no sense of hostility towards Britain or the Commonwealth countries. It is our desire to maintain the friendliest relationship with them, and we believe that this Bill is a constructive step in the development of that relationship.
I should like to pay a very special tribute to the assistance which we received throughout, not merely from the British Ministers but from the Commonwealth Ministers—from Dr. Evatt, from Mr. Fraser, the New Zealand Prime Minister, who I am glad to say is going to spend a few days with us next week; from the Canadian Ministers, from the South African Ministers, with whom I was in close contact throughout but who were not present at the conference, and from the Indian Prime Minister, Mr. Nehru, with whom I was also in contact throughout. They all gave us invaluable help and advice and certainly we felt at the end of this conference that Ireland had a great many friends throughout the world.
I think before I sit down that I should say this. There has been a great deal of controversy as to who should and should not get tribute for the passing of this Act. It occurs to me that it would be well if we realised, in passing this Act, that it has been made possible largely by the sacrifices made by a great many people of past generations and of this generation who are no longer alive and who laid down their lives so that the passing of such an Act as this might be possible. The best tribute we can pay them is to work in unity to try to secure the complete integration of the national territory.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister this question. Are we to take it that on the passing of the Bill the use of the word "Eire" where English is used will be discontinued? I think the nation is looking for some definite assurance on that point.
Comment on this
That is the intention. There was a suggestion originally of doing the same thing in Section 2 of the Bill as was done in the Constitution, of saying that the description of the State in English shall be "the Republic of Ireland" and in Irish "Poblacht na hEireann." We felt that if that were done we would slip into all sorts of trouble and that the country would be described by all sorts of queer names. Accordingly it was not done. It is the intention to use in English the name "The Republic of Ireland". The question of the extent to which the "Republic of Ireland" will be used as against "Ireland" is a matter that will have to be examined in some detail. Different considerations will apply, and these will have to be examined by an inter-departmental committee.
Comment on this
Will the Minister take steps to see that formal representations are made to ensure that this State shall be described as "Ireland" by foreign countries and by Britain in her broadcasting system? It is rather annoying to hear this State described as Eire by the British in their newspapers and in their broadcasts, in the hope of suggesting—I trust I am not judging them wrongly—that Eire and Northern Ireland are two separate States. It was the intention, when the Constitution was passed, that this State should be described as "Ireland", and in the Irish language as "Eire". I would be glad if the Minister would give an assurance to indicate that it is intended to raise that point and see that it is settled.
Comment on this
The Senator can rest assured that everything that can be done to achieve that position is being done and has been done. I do not know if Senators noticed that, in the trade agreement we had recently with Britain, there are two versions—in ours the State and the country are described as "Ireland", and in the British copy they described the country as "Eire".
Comment on this
If their assurances of goodwill are sincere, and if we describe this State as "Ireland", then I suggest that common courtesy would seem to demand that they would accept our description of the State.
Comment on this
I should like to know from the Minister if there is any intention of issuing a stamp. I think it would give great hope to people all over the world if there was an issue of stamps with "Poblacht na hEireann" printed on them, though I am afraid that expression does not apply to all Ireland. Still, we have the right to call it the Republic of Ireland. It would be a splendid thing to have these stamps issued if it could be done.