Appropriation Bill, 1949 ( Certified Money Bill )— Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–109 of 219. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 36 of 1949 ›
It will, I am sure, be admitted that he would be a very resourceful Senator who could find a new topic for discussion to-day after the exhaustive survey we had yesterday. If there be any bitter opponent of the Minister on any side of the House, he must sympathise with him in having had to listen to all the suggestions made to him during that debate. The most important topic which came up for discussion yesterday was the Border, and I do not propose to deal at any great length with that matter. I should like, however, to express my humble opinion that the question of the Border should be looked at in a commonsense, practical way.
I have always heard that the people of the North of Ireland were hardheaded, keen, intelligent, business-minded people and I believe they are so to-day. Consequently, I hold that, if we are to attract the people of the Six Counties into a united Ireland, we will have to attract them by convincing them that it would be to their own economic and social advantage to come in here. It will not be denied that, in many respects, social services and conditions are better in the Six Counties than here, and the obvious solution, therefore, is to bring our social services not alone up to the standard of those obtaining in the Six Counties but above that standard, so that it will be in the economic and social interests of the people of the Six Counties to become part of a united Ireland. The alternative would be to wait until such time as the social services in the Six Counties fell below the standard obtaining here. That is my view of the situation and I think it is a commonsense view.
The question which interested me most was the question of local rates, which was referred to by some Senators. The position with regard to rates is one which is at the moment disturbing both rural and urban Ireland. Year after year, the tendency has been to increase the burden on the ratepayers, whether urban or rural, and I honestly believe that we are arriving at the stage now when the ratepayers will no longer be able to carry that burden. Various causes have been advanced for that and various solutions have been offered. In my opinion, having been a member of a local authority for a number of years and having examined this question carefully, there are two items of local expenditure which should be discharged by the national Exchequer. It would reduce very appreciably and in a bearable way the present intolerable burden on the local rates.
These items are the maintenance of main roads and the upkeep of mental hospitals. The latter, I think, is the more serious of the two and is a question that has not been tackled in a sane way at all. I understand that about 100 years ago, roughly 1851, a capitation grant was made available to mental hospitals by the British Government. The sum was 4/- per head of the inmates and was then intended to represent 50 per cent. of the maintenance cost. That would mean that it cost 8/- per week in 1851 to maintain a patient. There is nobody who would suggest now that 8/- or 24/- a week would maintain a patient in a mental hospital. The first step is either to make mental hospitals a national charge or to increase appreciably the capitation grant from the Central Fund.
Main roads are the main arteries of the country. In times of emergency or war they are not regarded as being the property of any local authority, but as the property of the nation. I think it is correct to say that in olden days under the British Government main roads were not maintained by a local authority but by the War Office, as it was recognised that they were important militarily. If that be so, I think no further argument is required to convince any Government that the upkeep of the main roads should be made a national charge.
The question of housing also arises and I must say that I was rather amazed to hear Senator Tunney say last night that you could get here in Dublin artisans' dwellings for £1,400. Lately my council advertised for tenders to build 60 cottages and the lowest tender was £152,000 or over £2,000 per house. We had to abandon the idea of erecting them by contract and are now endeavouring to erect them by direct labour. I do not think that labour costs are really the whole problem. It may be correct, as Senator Tunney suggested, that output per man per hour is not what it should be. I am not in a position to give an opinion on that, but I am afraid that there is a tendency to make good profit while money is available and too much return is expected from investment in the erection of a house. I believe that in our county we will be able to erect at slightly over £1,000 houses for which over £2,000 has been asked and we are paying the current rate of wages to tradesmen and labourers.
I should like to refer to what Senator Quirke said with regard to the horse-breeding industry. That is a matter, I think, which could not be over-stressed. It would be sad to think that the action taken by any Government, any Minister or even by the Irish people themselves would lead to the ultimate disappearance of the horse here. I do not think we are so far removed from the last war as to forget what might have been the condition of things here were we entirely dependent on tractors for the sowing of our crops.
If in 1941, 1942 or 1943, those terrible years, we were entirely dependent on tractors to plough our land, what would be the position? We would be entirely dependent for propulsion power on an outside country and I think that would be a very undesirable state of affairs. Of course, it could be argued that it would be to the advantage of the people across the Channel to supply our petrol and oil requisites for tractors, but if they did they would make definite concrete proposals by which we would have to abide and that is a position in which I would not like to see this country. It would be a bad day for this country if man deserted the horse to go over to mechanical aid. There is not alone the question of the danger it would involve in war time, but you must remember the various types of employment the horse gives —the farrier in his forge, the carpenter in his shop and the saddler in his workshop. All these people are maintained because of the fact that we possess horses. Are they going to be thrown out of employment while we go over to a new idea and every penny for purchase and upkeep of the machines leaves the country? I hope that no sane man will ever encourage that, and strangely enough I do not agree with Senator Quirke that that is likely to take place on the larger farms first. In my view it would happen first on the smaller farms because the larger farm can afford to feed a horse or two while it would be a strain on a small farm to keep a horse and the small farmer might tend to rely on private contractors who would have a tractor and plough and sell his horse. It is surprising the speed at which that tendency might spread and the horse might disappear.
I think that any fair-minded man must admit that the present Government is making a fair effort to make this country progressive, and while good sound constructive criticism is the best thing a Government can have, I believe that it should be well intended. Looking at things in an entirely impartial way—I have no bitter Party politics —I think we have in this country a Parliament which should be the finest in the world because in the Government of this country you have representatives of every section of the community no matter who they may be. In opposition you have intelligent front bench ex-Ministers with 16 years' experience of administrative power. If they give of their best and if the Government give of their best I think that this should be the good, healthy, prosperous country which every one of us would like to see it.
Comment on this
I should like to preface my remarks by congratulating the Minister upon his efforts to keep expenditure down. It is true that actually the expenditure is still very high, but it is a good deal lower than it would have been if certain events had not taken place during the last 18 months. The Minister deserves congratulations for having abandoned certain wasteful, unproductive projects and for having sold certain white elephants— although, if I may mix the metaphor, possibly a bear market is not the best time to sell elephants, white or otherwise.
The expenditure in the Appropriation Bill represents something in the nature of a switch from wasteful to productive purposes. That is why, in a general way, it is deserving of the congratulations of the Seanad. However, I do not think it is injudicious for a detached person to refer to the fact that public expenditure of the central and local authorities is rather disquientingly high. That is the case stated by the Minister himself in his Budget statement in the Dáil and I do not think he can reasonably object if attention is called to it in a critical and constructive way in this Chamber. At the present time, as far as we know in the absence of any authoritative figures on national income and expenditure, central and local expenditure to-day represents about 25 per cent. of the estimated national income. That is generally accepted by public authorities on finance in other countries as the maximum safe percentage of the public expenditure to national income in peace time. It is very important, in the event of a country being threatened with war or other emergency, that there should be some margin. If public expenditure is more than about 25 per cent., the margin is not there. It is estimated that at present in Great Britain about 44 per cent. of the national income is reflected in public expenditure and it is recognised by detached observers that that is dangerously high, allowing for no expansion in war time, except by means of dangerous inflationary devices. Therefore, the Minister will admit that the public expenditure in this country has reached almost the danger point.
In a debate where everything from Partition to housing and industrial schools has been dealt with, I noticed that the one Senator who was called to order and forbidden to proceed was the Senator who mentioned taxation. Looking at it in a detached way, it seemed to me that taxation was at least as relevant to this debate as some of the matters which were so interestingly discussed. At the same time, I see the distinction between expenditure and taxation, but I crave the leave of the House to make one observation and I think it will be admitted when it is made that it is relevant. I admit that to discuss particular taxes on this motion would be completely disorderly, but, to use a term now being used by economists, I would like to take a macrocosmic view rather than a microcosmic view of the matter. I think that when discussing expenditure as a whole, we are entitled to make some reference to taxation as a whole. If one objects to high expenditure, it is not because of the high expenditure, but because of the sacrifices that have to be made by the community for it. High expenditure by Government authorities involves two things, or perhaps a little bit of each —either high taxation, which may be oppressive, or borrowing, which may be inflationary. My suggestion is that taxation in this country has reached a point where it is discouraging to saving and to enterprise, and that some of the public borrowing—indeed, private borrowing, too, for that matter—has got a somewhat inflationary effect. These are matters to which I would like to direct the attention of the Minister, hoping he may deal with some of them in his reply.
I realise that taxes are not quite relevant in this discussion, except to the degree I have already suggested; but perhaps I may be allowed to refer in passing to the reduction in the standard rate of income-tax which took place in the current financial year. Because the Irish rate is 2/6 less than the English rate, we are asked more or less to felicitate ourselves on our comparative immunity from direct taxation. I suggest that to compare the two rates is fallacious. In the first place, the English rate is, by any ordinary criterion, inordinately high. It represents food subsidies, which have brought a completely artificial price structure into the English economic system, which most people agree are very unsound and should be reduced. In the second place, it represents egalitarianism and socialism in action. Therefore, if taxation is 2/6 less here than the standard rate in Britain, it does not necessarily follow that it is at a sufficiently low level to suit our requirements, as we are comparing it with something which is inflated too highly. Secondly, Irish gross incomes on which the taxes are levied are, on the whole, lower than British. Professional and business incomes are lower.
I suggest that the rate of income-tax in this country which is necessary to support this rather high expenditure has had a bad effect on personal savings. I am not aware that any statistics have been published of the personal savings of our people, as distinct from the enforced savings caused by high taxation, by insurance savings and by the ploughing back of profits into company reserves. I would ask the Minister to publish some figures of that kind, if possible. In England, personal savings of a voluntary kind were reduced last year to something like £6,000,000 a year. In relation to English income, that is a paltry figure. Another change of the same kind, but not on the same scale, was taking place here.
It is necessary to make some positive contribution in this debate and I ask the Minister to assure the Seanad as to whether the cost of administration of the public services is not capable of further economy. I cannot help feeling, merely as an onlooker and observer, that it takes a lot of people to govern this small country. I am informed that if you are around the Merrion Street neighbourhood at 9.30 any weekday morning you will see large numbers of people hastening into Government offices. I often ask what these people do. Do we need all these people to govern this small State, and are we as lawless as all that? I cannot help feeling that, if there were something in the nature of a detailed inquiry into what goes on in every Government office, there would be room for further saving.
The Minister referred to this sympathetically in his Budget speech. I remind him of what he said then. I cannot help feeling that, not owing to the dereliction of any individual person—certainly it is not the fault of the Government nor of the heads of Departments nor of the Civil Service Commissioners nor of civil servants themselves—but owing to a certain tradition of red tape, the ordinary public servant does not get through as much work in the day as the employee of a corporation or of a private company. I suggest that in that respect there might be room for certain economies in the administration of the country.
I quite see that the Minister for Finance is burdened with certain obligations which, in the nature of things, in regard to social services and so forth, he cannot cut down. Therefore, the room at his disposal for economies is circumscribed and limited. Everybody will admit that. However, he still has it in his power not to go forward too fast. Therefore, I hope that the plea which was made by Senator Finan—that in order to bring the North in we should raise our social services to a much higher level than they are—will not tempt us to do so unless we can afford it. I believe that we should be able to get Partition solved without bribing the people of the North to come in with us. If the people of Northern Ireland think it worth their while to come in, they should come in and, if necessary, be prepared to be worse off rather than better off. I would not be inclined to hold out bribes to the people in Northern Ireland. They are holding out bribes to our people to stay out. I would not be tempted to outbid for the favours and suffrages of the people in Northern Ireland.
I hope that the Minister, in regard to the further extension of social services, will try to ensure that such further extension will keep pace with the national income. I hope that we shall not be induced, by the hope of electoral popularity or by any consideration of that kind, to push social services further than the national income will stand. I hope that, in the extension of social services, the Minister will, as far as possible, distinguish between what I might call the productive social services and what I might call the eleemosynary social services. I hope that the Minister will distinguish between them in order to build something up and not merely give relief to suffering. It is far easier to justify services for the benefit of the young than of the old. Health services and housing services, looked at from this particular point of view, have a particular justification.
While I am dealing with the question of services for the young, I should like to draw attention to the necessity in the agricultural programme for increased agricultural education. The Minister for Agriculture has outlined in this House very far-reaching and constructive schemes for the improvement of Irish land—for the reclamation of farms, for the increase in farm land and the increase in the fertility of the farm land of the country. I am sorry, in view of the rebuke which I received from the Minister for Agriculture the other day, to refer to Sir Horace Plunkett, but, in spite of that rebuke, I shall continue to do so. In spite of having been rapped on the knuckles for having spoken of this pioneer who founded the system of co-operation in this country, which the present Minister for Agriculture so warmly praised in this House within the last few weeks, I make no apology for quoting Sir Horace Plunkett in the Seanad, of which he was once a very distinguished member. I remember that on one occasion Sir Horace told me that when he came back to Ireland he found that the Land Commission scheme of land purchase was creating farms and that he felt that there was no use in having farms without having farmers. He founded the Department of Agriculture and the co-operative movement to improve the agricultural skill of people in this country. Side by side with the building up of agricultural productivity, there should be increased technical education of Irish farmers. That is a social service which not only has a social justification but a productive justification as well.
I do not wish to be accused of having a King Charles' head. Therefore, I am not going to harp on a question to which I referred before. At the same time, I am going to refer to it. I hope the Minister, in the course of the year, will attempt to be a little more generous with universities in this country than Governments have been in the past. University expenditure has the justification that it builds up science and technique. I do not think any country can really have modern progress where higher education is treated as the Cinderella of the public services. I do not wish to say more about that. I know the Minister is sympathetic. Therefore, all I wish to do is to remind him of it and I hope I am not saying too much when I describe it as his obligation towards the universities of this country.
I should like to endorse the remarks made by Senator McGuire regarding the enlightened attitude of the Government revealed recently by increased expenditure on general objects of culture. I welcome, both on public and private grounds, the invitation to Professor Bodkin, one of our most distinguished men, to give us the benefit of his experience and advice on the improvement of galleries and museums and so forth. I also welcome the signs that the Government realise the importance of welding art and industry.
What I said about science and technique in relation to universities is equally true regarding art. Most of the small countries in Europe have built up export trades in products which have been characterised either by great expert technique or by the more artistic elements to which Senator McGuire referred. In particular, I should like to endorse what he said regarding the desirability of trying to bring about some sort of architectural value and quality in our new housing schemes. I cannot see why small houses should be ugly. I cannot see why, when we are planning for the housing of the poor, we cannot have at least as much architectural beauty as we had in this country when we were planning the houses for the rich in the 18th century. The idea that planning is modern is wrong. Look at the Pembroke estate. Look at the Fitzwilliam estate. Look at the Longford and the De Vesci estates in Dun Laoghaire. They are all excellently planned; they are all excellent examples. They were planned for the rich and by the rich rather than for the poor and the poor's representatives. One of the great lessons which democracy has to learn is how a democratic community with a more or less egalitarian system of wealth can learn to live with the same sort of aesthetic satisfaction with which the richer people lived in the 18th century. I think the secret of the good planning of Dublin—the Wide Streets Commissioners and so forth—was, first of all, that large areas were planned as a single whole, and secondly, that the people who planned them had recourse to experts, to architects of quality and so forth—that they were not afraid to take expert advice and to spend a certain amount of money. The result is that Ireland now is, in many ways, a very beautiful country. It would be a great pity, now that we have achieved independence in this part of the country and that the balance of power has swung from the small privileged class to the people, that the people should not house themselves with a certain amount of taste as well as comfort. I simply wish to add my word to what Senator McGuire has said.
I should like now to refer to something which has been mentioned already. I would point out that high public expenditure, in so far as it does not lead to high public taxation, involves borrowing, and borrowing may be inflationary. If there is inflation in borrowing, the symptoms begin to appear very soon in the balance of payments. It is pretty generally agreed that the weakest point in our structure in this country is the balance of payments. The balance of payments is improving—we all agree about that— largely owing to the efforts of the Minister and of his colleagues. However, although it is improving, it still gives rise to a certain amount of disquiet amongst people who study these things. The large volume of imports could be regarded with more equanimity if it contained a larger proportion of capital goods—if it still represented restocking after the war. But I do not think it is. The import list seems to consist very largely of consumer goods and, to some extent, of luxury goods. The exports on the other side contain certain dangerous elements. Tourist expenditure is, in its very nature, ephemeral and is not to be relied on too long. Another element which one must regard with a certain amount of doubt is the income derived from Irish sweepstakes. The Royal Commission on Betting in England, which is sitting at present, may recommend that English law should be altered in such a way that there will not be the same temptation or inducement for English people to buy tickets in the sweepstake. These are two sources of external revenue on which it would not be quite safe to rely too much in future.
When a country finds itself with a disequilibrium in its balance of payments, whatever euphemisms may be found to describe that disagreeable state of facts, the only remedy for the situation is deflation. To call it disinflation does not make it less deflation than to refer to inflation, a very unpopular word, as reflation, makes it any less inflation. That is simply a method of using new words to describe old things. In the old days, deflation was imposed by the central banking system but for various reasons which I need not go into, that is not fashionable to-day and even if it were fashionable, it would not be very effective in this country. In modern times, deflation is usually regarded as the duty of the Department of Finance. Deflation is imposed by the Budget. The report of the Central Bank has drawn attention to the fact that a good deal of the capital expenditure in this country both by private investors and by the Government is of an inflationary kind. As regards private investors, an undue proportion of expenditure is incurred building cinemas and things of that kind. As regards public authorities, an undue proportion is incurred in housing and things of that kind which, however desirable, do nothing to help in some degree the balance of payments. As Senator Finan pointed out, even the expansion of transport had its effect on the balance of payments.
I think it is very interesting to look back on the way in which, in the last 200 years, the transport system of this country, instead of providing a great market for farmers' produce has proved a great burden to the country. With the gradual disappearance of the horse and the old type of road vehicle, instead of the transport system of the country providing a great market for farmers, it has become a serious burden on the balance of payments which farmers, in the long run, have to make good by producing more. I do not wish to go into that matter too deeply. I simply want to point out that many of the investments which the Government are sponsoring have a depressing effect on the balance of payments. Even the land reclamation scheme to which I referred with commendation a short time ago, while, no doubt, it will eventually add to the wealth of the country, will, while it is going forward and while the work is being done, also have an inflationary effect. The purchase of bulldozers and other types of machinery which it is proposed to utilise in operating that scheme, must have a depressing effect on the balance of payments. Therefore, I should like to end this statement by asking the Minister, if he can, to reassure the Seanad that the high expenditure shown in these accounts is not producing effects on the taxation side by having adverse effects on savings, and effects on the borrowing side which are having an adverse effect on the balance of payments. Having drawn attention to these possible dangers, I should like to end by congratulating the Minister on a very fine performance.
Comment on this
I should like at the outset to criticise the Minister's action in reducing the grants to organisations which have for their object the restoration of the language and also for his action in reducing the grants to certain Gaeltacht areas. I believe that at the moment the language is in a parlous condition. We have had much agitation about Partition. We have had speech-making and all sorts of propaganda and suggestions that Partition can be ended, but I suggest to the Minister and to the Government that the question of the language is more urgent. I would hate to think that the members of this Government as a body are opposed to the restoration of the language. I do not believe they are, but the position, as I see it, is that unless something is done, and done quickly, the native speaker will have disappeared in practically 50 years' time, and when the native speaker disappears the language will disappear. We have spent a large amount of money for the past 25 years in an endeavour to make Irish the spoken language of the country. Admittedly, many young boys and girls have learned the language, but they have not learned to speak it. I am suggesting to the Minister that the restoration of the language as the spoken language of the country is the most urgent matter we have in the national programme to-day. Partition, as I say, can wait. Many of us in this House have seen more important changes taking place in the last 30 years than the mere shifting of the Border between Northern and Southern Ireland. We have seen a complete revolution in this country come about, and, as I say, the Border can wait.
Much dissatisfaction has been expressed at the fact that the British Government have attempted to stereotype the position in Northern Ireland. Anyone who was reared in the Sinn Féin movement will recollect that we were always told that the Englishman, whether he be Tory, Liberal or Labour, is an Imperialist at heart. He will keep the Border in being until it suits him to remove it. As I have said, we have seen greater revolutionary changes than the removal of the Border in the last 30 years. The Border can wait, but the restoration of the language cannot wait, and I want to voice my objection against any attempt to halt the work which is being done to try to restore the language.
I should like also to criticise the position of the broadcasting service. I think that none of us is satisfied with that service and I am going to suggest the reason why we have such a comparatively poor service is that the Government are not prepared to pay the people who have to maintain that service. You have actors getting seven guineas a week and musicians who are getting little more, and I think that most of us who listen to Radio Eireann, when we realise the type of programme we are getting, are satisfied that there is something wrong. I suggest that is where the trouble lies, that we are not prepared to offer our artists proper fees and we are not getting the proper type of artist.
I should like to mention a matter in regard to the Industrial Development Authority. The setting up of this authority is a very fine thing. If it helps to develop the industry of the country, I think we will be all agreed that it is something we should support but I should like to offer some criticism of the way in which that authority was set up and of the personnel—not the individuals. Some of you may have noticed that Senator Summerfield has been under fire for alleged statements he made in connection with the question of the joint management of industry as between workers and employers. I heard him say that he was in favour of such a system by which the employer and the worker could get together and help to manage an industry, that he believed that would be essential, and I agree with him. But, in the setting up of this authority, no attempt was made to select any one from the organised trade union movement. So far as I know, two representatives of employers' associations were put on the authority, but no representation of any kind was put on this authority that could be claimed as representing the organised trade union movement. I suggest to the Minister and the Government that, if they think they are going to make a success of such an authority without the co-operation of the trade union movement, they are making a very great mistake.
What I said with regard to the salaries being paid in Radio Eireann would also apply to the salaries of certain of the engineering staff of the Electricity Supply Board. There are civil engineers employed by the Electricity Supply Board being paid as low a salary as seven guineas per week, plus 16/- cost-of-living bonus. These are professional men and they are not beginners. Some of them have eight, nine or ten years' professional experience, not necessarily with the Electricity Supply Board. I suggest that, if the Government and the public at large want people to put their backs into their jobs and give a greater output, they ought to be prepared to pay for that.
Senator O'Brien mentioned the question of income-tax. I am going to relate that to the question of housing. It was suggested to me very forcibly that the cause of the low output in housing so far as the worker is concerned—it is alleged that there is a low output and, possibly, those who are in a position to know will agree that there is—was that workers will not work overtime because much of the money earned at it goes back to the income-tax collector. The system at present is that the worker works for some months or, possibly, a year and then gets a bill for income-tax which he is not able to meet. I have a suggestion to make to the Minister which he might consider favourably and might be able to carry out, and that is the stopping of income-tax at its source— that the income-tax of a worker should be stopped as he earns the money and not be waiting for six or 12 months when he may get a bill for £25 or £30 and not be able to meet it.
Comment on this
That suggestion was put up at a meeting of the Congress of Irish Unions—that if we have to pay income-tax, and none of us likes to pay income-tax, it is easier to stop it at the source rather than to be sending a bill for a huge amount subsequently.
I am going to mention a matter which I referred to last year, because I believe that if you talk about a thing sufficiently often something may eventually be done about it. I refer to the conditions obtaining in sub-post offices, which is something that the Minister and the Government as a body ought to attend to. These sub-post offices are relics of the British régime when the work of the post office was not anything like it is now. In cities, particularly, you will find these sub-post offices carried on in shops hardly big enough for their ordinary business and it is not very easy for the public to transact their business in them. Over the years, as a result of legislation passed by the Oireachtas, the work of these sub-post offices has been greatly increased. The present system is altogether wrong. There ought to be an independent building housing a post office and a post office only, and not have this makeshift business which, as I say, is a relic of the British régime when the work of the post office was not anything like it is to-day. What I said with regard to salaries also applies to these sub-post offices. I understand that the maximum salary of a postmistress after a long number of years is £3 10s. per week. For the varied work which she has to do, a postmistress is deserving of a better salary.
Comment on this
This Appropriation Bill gives us an opportunity of talking in detail and I am glad that we can use this opportunity to ask for a review of the general economy of the country. I want to bring certain aspects of the economy of the country into prominence. I noticed recently that the Government have made a very fundamental alteration by extending and enlarging the Department of Statistics into a separate Statistics Office. I take it that that is in the hope that the statistician will no longer merely rest content with being a historian and telling us where we were born and, possibly, even where we are. I hope that, with an augmented staff and a wider vision, the statistician of to-day will tell us where we are going. Until he can do that, he is only doing half the job that a Statistics Department, headed by good statisticians, ought to be able to do. In this country the economy is comparatively simple. The chief source from which we draw our wealth is, obviously, agriculture and, though it suffers seriously from seasonal changes, the profound economic changes are slow. Therefore, in a simple economy, it should be possible to make reasonably good forecasts of where we are going and what the future holds for us. Therefore, I welcome this new departure in the central Statistics Office.
I also note that it proposed to set up an advisory council in this connection. That also is a good thing. Now that we have the Minister for Finance here, I should like if he could enlarge on capital expenditure in this country when replying. Speaking in this House on a motion dealing with credits, Senator O'Brien—the reference is Volume 36, No. 5, column 565, of the Seanad Debates—said:—
"I think that investment in the improvement of Irish agriculture is the most productive type of investment which the Government could encourage, and I think that debt of that kind, which may be deadweight debt in the sense that in the first few years the taxpayer may have to find the interest on it, in the long run will yield abundant return."
I quote that because Senator O'Brien, when he was speaking a few moments ago, rather hinted that this land reclamation project, which has just gone through the House, will be of an inflationary character in its infancy. Of course, it will. There is no help for that, but one hopes that the inflationary character of such a project will diminish as soon as it becomes effective in increasing the productivity of the country. I like to look on this land rehabilitation project as nationally good husbandry whereby some of the assets of the nation are being ploughed back into the land. That seems to me to be a type of State expenditure which can be justified even if, as it appears, this expenditure is coming from borrowed money.
One of our problems, when we try to view the economy of this State as a whole, is that of labour. In the past it has been the habit of the Government to provide employment as an end in itself. The Taoiseach, when introducing the Estimate for his Department—the reference is Volume 117, No. 10, column 1367 of the Dáil debates—said:
"We have had in this country for a long time the attitude that work, or the provision of work for our people is an end in itself. That is not the policy that we have adopted or that we hope to bring to fruition."
Now, of course, in periods of acute unemployment it is often necessary to have to resort to unproductive types of employment, but the real difficulty that seems to face such a project as the land rehabilitation scheme is that where the potential work is forthcoming there is insufficient labour to meet it. It is the non-fluidity of labour to-day that makes it so difficult to ensure that, at all times, when there is work available there is labour to meet it. In the old days—50 years ago or so— labour was more fluid than it is to-day.
When, to-day, the Government says it is aiming at productive employment that, obviously, is a very desirable aim, but it is not so easy of achievement because many of the facilities for expansion in employment in this country are, unfortunately, lacking, and that is especially so in agriculture. We find that when we want certain new tools— I suppose one might use that phrase when we are now trying to rehabilitate the land, and, further, I suppose we might say that this is the moment when we ought to be retooling agriculture— we cannot get them. When I speak of the tools that agriculture requires, I do not mean merely machinery but all the things that agriculture requires. When we look to our animals we find that the breeding of animals does not always mean that animals have been bred in the interests of agricultural production. We find the same thing when we look for seeds—that the seed has been produced very often and for very many years in the interests of the seedsmen rather than in the interests of the person who uses that product. Hence, as I say, when we look for the tools that agriculture requires we find that we cannot get what we want. Therefore, we require, as I say, an almost over-all retooling of our agriculture if we are to get that rapid expansion that we all hope for.
I wonder, when the Minister is replying, if he could give us any information on the rise in farm incomes. I noticed that when he was speaking on his Budget—the reference is Volume 115, No. 4, column 494 of the Dáil Debates —he said in the course of an economic review which is available at the end of his Budget speech:—
"It is clear that the position of farmers has markedly improved as compared with pre-war, both absolutely and in relation to wage and salary earners. This adjustment was a necessary correction of their previously depressed conditions, but with world prices for wheat and other commodities falling further below the guaranteed domestic price, it would be unrealistic for farmers to expect a continued increase in agricultural prices. Improvement in incomes must be sought in increased output and lower costs of production."
Now, I imagine that all people who think on economic problems will agree with the Minister on that, even in the last sentence wherein he stresses that the improved position of our farmers depends on increased production and on lower costs. Unfortunately we find that a great percentage of farm costs are outside the control of the producer.
Some of these costs that have to be borne by the farmers are determined by others; some of these costs, one can almost say, can be attributed to the Minister for Finance. To a large extent, the cost of agricultural production is determined by labour, small sundries like seeds and fertilisers, machinery and transport. Our transport costs have been forced up by definite efforts on the part of the previous Administration to bolster up a monopoly that could not earn a dividend. That is a cost that has been forced on agriculture, whose output has to face world competition with its exports. Freight is a first charge on the gross income of farmers, quite irrespective of any profit. Such things as transport costs, the system of allotting plates to hauliers, the creation of a monopoly, all bear heavily on a scattered rural community that obviously requires the services of a good transport system.
I am only pointing out to the Minister that it may be inevitable, but there is a feeling that, while the farmer should do everything he possibly can to reduce costs and to increase output, other sections of the community are quite prepared to saddle him with extra charges, growing charges, charges that bear no relation to his ability to pay. I suggest, in this period we are going through, that if we are going to meet growing competition, we must realise the period of scarcity prices is over, and that competition is going to increase. As regards world events and world markets, it is hoped to some extent to stabilise them by having a wheat agreement which will bring the price of wheat progressively diminishing with the years. That may have a stabilising effect on other prices. The trend of prices is going to be downwards. I would like to see the downward trend of some of these non-agricultural costs that are foisted on the farmer. Perhaps when the Minister is replying and making a review of our economic situation, he will advert to that aspect of our agricultural difficulty.
Comment on this
I believe that this Government have failed as regards the serious problems that confront the country, such as emigration, unemployment and Partition. Each of the Parties comprising the present Government went to the country saying they had a cure for these problems. What is the result? The result is that in the the present year more people have emigrated from our shores than in any one year since the years of the Famine.
Comment on this
It is no such thing. According to the last figures I have seen, that is the position. Not since the Famine years have so many gone away. Unemployment has in this year increased by up to 20,000 over 1947. I find it very hard to understand the Labour Party standing for so many reductions. It amazed me to find that Party opposing a motion against reductions amounting to £2,000,000 in the rural grants. A special meeting of the General Council of County Councils, of which I am a member, was called to protest against that action, and a resolution was unanimously passed calling on the Government to restore those grants.
Deputy Seán Dunne, who poses as the representative of the rural workers of Ireland, told those people who spoke on behalf of the persons who were thrown out of employment that they were hypocrites to talk on behalf of labourers. I have been connected with public life for many years. Coming from a labouring part of the country, I always championed the cause of the labourer. I have done whatever was possible for them anywhere I went, irrespective of the consequences. Deputy Dunne told us there would be unemployment in this country until the whole social fabric of the State would be changed. I would like to hear him explaining how that could be done.
The people were told that they would get alternative employment: those who were thrown out of work when the hand-won turf scheme ceased were told they would have alternative employment. That was one-and-a-half years ago, but no alternative employment has been given to them. There has been a reduction of £2,000,000 in the rural grants. The road grants gave employment to small farmers living on uneconomic holdings; they gave employment to cottiers with long families, and alternative work was promised to these men. The only alternative they have is the emigrant ship. When they do undertake alternative work they are far away from our shores.
I want to refer to the official black market, against which the Labour Party has not protested. The small wage earner and poor people generally have to live on rations, while the rich and the people with big salaries can buy food anywhere they like. The wage earner has to be content with such vital commodities as tea, sugar and bread, including Mr. Dillon's white loaf. All these things can be bought, in any quantities that are required, by the rich and the well-to-do. We have the one-time Leader of the Labour Party, now the Minister for Social Welfare, going around on circuit telling the people what he has done for social services, how he has increased old age pensions and widows' and orphans' pensions. But he never tells the people that part of the cost of his scheme has to come from the poor, the small wage earners and the labourers. He does not tell them that there is a decrease of 6d. in the £ in income-tax in order to help the people with large salaries and big incomes.
I pass on now to the Department of Agriculture. I think the greatest disaster that ever overwhelmed the farming industry in this country was the appointment of the present Minister for Agriculture. What has he done in the past year for the small uneconomic holders, the majority of Irish farmers, living on the mountainsides in isolated districts? Every scheme brought in by the last Government to help these farmers has been thrown out by the present Minister. He has done away with the subsidy on farmers' butter. Many of the small farmers were dependent upon the subsidy paid on this butter in order to eke out a living. The farm improvements scheme has gone by the board. This was of definite benefit to the small farmer living on an uneconomic holding in a congested area. The Minister's whole endeavour seems to be to turn the country into grass land to raise live stock to feed mother England.
Yesterday I heard Senator Douglas suggest that conferences should be arranged with the Government of the Six Counties and other Governments in order to find a solution for the problem of Partition. He suggested that the Minister for Agriculture should find a place at that conference. I think the majority of the people would not agree to that selection. I think very few would hold that he should have anything to do with the solution of that problem. I understand that he is about to appoint Deputy Flanagan as his Parliamentary Secretary. The most honest contribution that ever came from Deputy Flanagan in the Dáil was the statement that he made asking the then Government to put Deputy Dillon behind bars after he had been fired out of the Defence Committee set up during the emergency. I suppose that was the only sensible remark I ever heard Deputy Flanagan make.
Comment on this
It may have been. I presume that when Senator Douglas suggested him, he knew well that the Minister for Agriculture was the most complaisant choice that could be made in order to continue Partition. Deputy Dillon has never contested any constituency other than one in which he can be assured of a degree of support from a Conservative element. That is true of both Donegal and Monaghan.
I had great respect at one time for the present Minister for Health. Unfortunately, he is now trying to cash in for political advantage on our sick and infirm people. Because of that I have nothing but contempt for him. He has compelled us in Roscommon to place a further burden on the already over-burdened ratepayers because he insists that a county clinic must be provided. I think that clinic will, to some extent, interfere with the work already done by our very competent county surgeon and his staff. There is a county hospital in Boyle. Boyle, as everyone knows, was an old garrison town and, like all other garrison towns, there are quite a few poor and diseased people in it. There is a district hospital there in part of the old workhouse. It is really not a fit place in which to treat animals, let alone human beings. Prior to 1939 we had several deputations to the Minister for Local Government. In 1939 we had revised plans ready. We met the Parliamentary Secretary then and he assured us that our hospital would be the first to receive attention after the emergency, when materials were again available. We have had some deputations since the new Minister took office. He did not have the courtesy to meet us, but he sent some of his officials. They told us that the hospital will have to remain as it is because the Hospitals' Trust will be barely able to meet its commitments even for improvements over the next ten years. I take it that the people in that congested area must continue to avail of the terrible institution there at the moment.
I come now to the man of destiny, Mr. Seán MacBride, Minister for External Affairs. He was the man who had a solution for the problem of Partition when he went to the people. What has happened since? Because of all his blundering, Partition has become even more permanent than it was at any time since 1920. He is busy flying about the world getting prestige for himself. He now wants a news agency to advertise himself still further. It seemingly does not matter where the money comes from or where it goes. For once, I agree with Deputy Captain Cowan. I think a younger generation of Irishmen must take up where we have failed in this respect. Sooner or later that will happen. I hope that the day is not too far distant when the Irish people will be asked again for their decision and we shall be given a chance of bringing back as our leader the man who steered the ship of State successfully through the troubled waters of the emergency years.
Comment on this
Senators on the other side of the House, in particular Senator Lynch, have expressed grave disquiet and dissatisfaction with what they have quite wrongfully described as the Government black market. Each Senator has based his or her objection to this alleged black market on the grounds of the unfair situation that it creates for the poor person of this country. One of two things is the position. Either the Senators on the other side of the House who have made reference to this alleged black market do not fully understand the position as to why this state of affairs was brought into existence or else their arguments about it are thoroughly dishonest. What they describe as a black market in white flour was deliberately created in the interests of the poorer people of this country. It was created in order that the wealthy people, if they so desire, could eat white bread or consume white flour and thereby help to subsidise the rationed commodity for the ordinary man in the street. To talk about a black market is the greatest nonsense. I am sorry Senator Lynch has left the Chamber. One might describe the Minister for whom he appears to have such great admiration, the Minister for Agriculture, as the Robin Hood of this country, who has been robbing the rich to help the poor.
I would like to add my congratulations to those of other Senators to the Minister on his achievements for the year and to add to that particularly my congratulations to himself and to his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, on the industrial progress that has been made and the industrial peace that has been maintained during the last 12 months.
From time to time we hear from the other side of the House various criticisms of the régime. Senator Hawkins was very perturbed about the fate of the Tourist Board and the tourist hotels. Senator Summerfield was at pains to explain that there was no such thing in this country as luxury hotels by American or continental standards. Personally I congratulate the Minister for seeing that the Tourist Board hotels were sold. They should never have been bought or started. If Senator Hawkins is worried about the price that was received for these hotels, I can only suggest to him that in the first instance the board as it existed under the late Government paid too much for the properties they acquired and that when they were subsequently sold they were sold at what was probably their market value at the particular time.
I agree with Senator Summerfield that, probably, according to American standards, there is no such thing as a luxury hotel in this country and to call the Tourist Board hotels luxury hotels was probably a misnomer in every respect except one, that is, that the prices that were charged were certainly luxury prices but the service they gave was not of a luxury standard.
Senator Hawkins argued that an official of the European Recovery Programme has expressed the opinion that if this country was to assist in European recovery it was absolutely necessary that its hotels should be brought to American standards. I would suggest to Senator Hawkins that the talking of balderdash is not entirely the privilege of Senators and that even an American European Recovery official can occasionally talk balderdash.
Comment on this
If I visit France on my holidays I make it a point to stay in a French hotel, a hotel that will have all the characteristics of the country. Our Irish hotels may have faults. There may be room for improvement, but our best Irish hotels have certain features that are characteristic of the country and its way of life. I would suggest that foreign tourists, be they from America or the Continent of Europe or the neighbouring island, like to stay in hotels in this country that are characteristic of Ireland and that have an Irish atmosphere. What holiday is it for a visitor from New York if when he arrives in this country which he has read about and heard about as having certain characteristics that are different from the characteristics of his own country to find an Americanised hotel with shoe-shine parlours, soda fountains and all the other alleged amenities of western civilisation?
I would like to say one word about shipping. I must express my disappointment and astonishment at the fact that Irish Shipping, which has now been running quite successfully over a number of years, which did a very useful service to this country during the war and in carrying out that service must have learned certain facts, and has built some very fine ships, has neglected one very important thing to which I would like to draw the attention of the Minister and the House. They have not yet built or acquired a sea-going oil tanker. I would have thought, from the experience that this country met during the war, that one of the first things Irish Shipping would do would be either to build or acquire at least two large ocean-going oil tankers. They would be an insurance against a future war period. They would ensure the supply of petrol and fuel oil to this country in times of peace and when not actually engaged in carrying fuel oil and petrol to this country could be chartered at a profit to other countries and other companies. If they want any example as to how effectively that system works, they need only study the Norwegian mercantile marine's shipping success.
I should like to congratulate the Minister for Industry and Commerce on the setting up of the Industrial Development Authority. I think it is a step in the right direction, and I personally hope that this authority will, from its many terms of reference, concentrate primarily on the starting, and the encouragement of the starting, of new industries, and preferably industries that are not centralised in Dublin, because there is a very dangerous tendency for too many of these industries to grow up around the capital city, with the result that the capital city is extending unduly and likely to become unwieldy in proportion to the size of the country and the population. I also hope that, in considering the encouragement and starting of new industries, this authority will give every thought and effort to finding industries which will be indigenous to the soil and to the district and which will, so far as possible, depend not only upon local labour but on local raw materials for their purposes—such industries as the processing of agricultural products, the canning of fish and so on—because I am firmly convinced that it is on a great increase in that type of industry that our future all-round balance of industrial prosperity will rest.
As the next item on the authority's programme, I trust that they will give serious study to tariffs, both existing and future tariffs, and particularly the repercussions of one tariff upon another tariff, and investigate whether each individual tariff achieves what it was originally intended to achieve and whether it might not in certain cases be wiser to abandon a tariff and replace it with a quota, or, if necessary, an embargo, because tariffs, as we know from experience, do not always achieve exactly the protection which they were designed to achieve and sometimes have repercussions which they were not intended to have.
Comment on this
I am afraid that tariffs are more suitable on the Finance Bill than on the Appropriation Bill.
Comment on this
Very well, Sir; I will get away from tariffs and merely say that it has been known that a tariff imposed to protect one industry has unwittingly created unemployment in another.
The third item to which I trust this authority will devote its attention is the encouragement of Irish manufactures, both existing and future, to leave no stone unturned to find an export market for their products. In a recent debate here, Senator Summerfield who is usually to be found in this House defending the interests of the Irish industrialists and manufacturers—not that I would attack either body—took Senator Baxter to task for criticising Irish industry and Irish industrialists. I think that was rather a pity because Senator Baxter is a representative of the principal industry and surely one industrialist is entitled to offer criticism of another. In the course of his remarks to Senator Baxter, he complained rather bitterly that we should remember that there was only a very limited market of 3,000,000 people for the manufactured goods produced in this country.
Comment on this
I said that the domestic market was that size.
Comment on this
The domestic market— that is perfectly true. I think the Senator put his finger on the possible weak spot in the future of Irish industry when he drew attention to that. If Irish industry is to become really prosperous, it must find an export market for its consumer goods. That should not be outside the bounds of possibility. Other countries have done it. We claim that we can produce certain types of goods which are equalled by none and it surely is only a question of concentration of effort on the export market rather than on the home market to bring this about.
Senator Colgan found fault with the personnel of the Industrial Development Authority and stated that it was representative of the employers, but not of the trade unions. So far as I know, the authority consists of an economist or statistician, the secretary of an employers' organisation and the secretary of a labour organisation.
Comment on this
No, a political Party— not a labour organisation.
Comment on this
If I were to criticise the personnel, I would say that it is a pity that there is not on it a man who earns his living by manufacturing something.
Comment on this
Having listened to Tone's lament from the opposite benches, we will get on to something more refreshing. The only thing I have to say with regard to the Senator's reference to the Labour Party is that there is no use in his putting on a January fly to fish in July, because we are not biting, we are not rising. What I am concerned with here is housing, and I was astounded at the last meeting of the Seanad when a Senator, whose name I do not know but who, I presume, comes from Kerry, because he mentioned Kerry, said that the lowest contract price they could obtain for a labourer's cottage was in the region of £2,000.
Comment on this
It was Senator Meighan from Roscommon who said it.
Comment on this
A similar statement was made here to-day. Mr. Davin, T.D. for Laoighis, told me during the week that the lowest tender his council could obtain was £1,450 and a somewhat similar statement was made by Senator Tunney last night after having left a meeting of the Dublin County Council Housing Committee. I am astounded by these statements, but I think I can give the Seanad some very useful information in this connection. I can show how houses can be built at much less than £1,000 and at much less than £700 possibly. The Wicklow County Council since the passing of the Local Government Act built houses by contract down to the year of our Lord 1934 but the then board of health switched over to direct labour; they are being built since by direct labour and we will continue to build in future. Even during the war period, with the plant and the system we had established, we built a scheme of 400 houses meeting all the difficulties of supply and labour at a cost of £644 per house. To-day we have a scheme of 450 houses sanctioned by the Local Government Department and a further scheme of 350 ready for presentation to the Local Government Department, making a total of about 800. We have been working on 100 of the 450 houses since last March and they are in a very forward state of construction. Thirteen of these houses have been completed at Ballywaltron, Bray. These houses are already occupied and their tenants have taken possession. Sewerage and water has been laid on and sanitary fittings of the most modern design have been fitted. They are four-roomed houses and are wired and lighted from the public lighting supply and the cost was only £764 per cottage. Ballywaltron is only 1/- bus drive from Dublin and is beside the urban area of Bray. Anybody who is interested can visit and inspect the houses which have been completed within the past month. Ninety per cent. of labourers' cottages are not, of course, in a position to have these amenities and the price without them would have been £650.
With a view to expediting the building of houses the county council recently decided to put up a third of the 450 houses for contract. The tenders received were from something under £800 to £1,100 and some pounds. The council at its following meeting decided to seal down the contract price to £800 and tenders for 34 houses have been accepted at £800 and under. Even at that money I opposed it and so did some other members of the council because we were expending £4,000 over and above the direct labour price. If we took the 800 houses even at £800 per house we would be spending something like £80,000 over and above the direct labour price. If we take Dublin or Laoighis, where the prices are the lowest we have heard of under the contract system, the amount of money involved would be about £750,000 over and above the direct labour price. That is a statement I am prepared to stand over and any Senator who is a member of a local authority is welcome to come to Wicklow and get all the information and details he inquires from the engineering staff and he can inspect the houses which have been erected and those which are in course of erection. They are possibly second to no labourers' cottages in Ireland. They are well planned and the best of materials were used. I want to assure the Seanad that no cheap-john methods were employed. Every tradesman did his own job and was paid the trade union rates of wages. Every worker, no matter what his job, was paid the trade union rates of wages and yet we are building at something under £700 per house. There must be something wrong in Denmark when we hear the contract prices put before us here. This is not confined to the rural areas. Wicklow urban area has a scheme of 83 houses and the lowest tender was £1,750 per house which was rejected. They built a group as a test under our own council engineers and the houses were built for something less than £900. These are hard facts. Some Senators have asked me about this scheme and I got the county council people to give them details and I will be very happy to give the same data to anyone who wishes to inquire.
I want to get back to the roads. Twenty-one years ago, owing to the shocking condition of the county roads, we switched to a system of direct labour on both main and county roads. Main roads were being done under direct labour. Any of you who have visited Wicklow from time to time will agree that the roads are equal to, or better than, any in this country. I am safe, I think, in making that statement. I am not one who believes that our clothes should be cleaned and pressed from the Central Fund. I know that when the Minister puts his hand into his pocket and takes it out he is going to get back a similar amount or perhaps a little more, but there is no doubt that we have reached a stage, as far as rates are concerned, when we cannot move much further. The popular idea is the Central Fund as far as roads and mental hospitals are concerned, but I will get out of the mental hospitals and off the roads as quickly as I can. We in Wicklow have a case to make regarding the question of whether the main roads should be maintained out of the Central Fund or otherwise and I think we are entitled to some consideration. Killarney may be our show window but Wicklow is still the Garden of Ireland. We lie beside a city of 500,000 people and our doors are open to the 32 Counties and to foreign visitors. The Córas Iompair Eireann buses parade our roads night and day and a survey is being made at the moment to ascertain how many cars pass our roads in one day or one week. If our roads are to be maintained at their present high level some consideration must be given either from State funds or other funds.
I hope that the Government will take steps in connection with our harbours and particularly the harbours on the east coast that are actually being silted up by the south-east wind. In County Wicklow there are four. Two are not of any great importance and I do not believe the people take very much interest in them and one of them may be in a dilapidated condition. They are Bray and Greystones. Wicklow harbour is reasonably good and dredging has been carried out on a very large scale during the past 12 months. I would say that the conditions there are fair and I believe that other works of improvement are in hand. The commission takes a lively interest in the harbour. Fishing interests are limited and it is mostly coastal and cross-Channel trade that Wicklow is concerned with.
I am interested principally in Arklow, as I happen to be a commissioner an Arklow. Representing the local authority and attending their meetings is a continuous headache. The bar is in a dangerous condition, silted up, and in the past 20 years we have spent something like £60,000 on dredging alone. That has been without result. After six weeks' work, the dredger ran aground at Wicklow Head on the way back to Dublin, and the south-east winds create currents and we are back to where we started. In spite of that, we have one of the finest fishing fleets in the country and also one of the finest coastal fleets. These people going in and out to sea are in danger from the time they leave the docks until they get out into the harbour, and when they are out they can never tell when they can come back again. I have gone into the whole matter very carefully. There are two potteries depending on the harbour and when they are working there is a total of some 1,100 people, that is, more than half the population of Arklow, depending on the harbour. Arklow people are seaminded, and whether it is the business man or the professional man he will "talk harbour" with you. Arklow sailors will be found in mercantile fleets on all the seas the world over, where you will find Arklow names cropping up from time to time. The port is important also for imports and exports for people in South Wicklow, North Wexford and the adjoining counties of Carlow and Kildare.
I mention the matter here now because recently we have bidden goodbye to dredging, if we can, and we have had an expert from the Continent, a Dutch engineer who, with our own engineer, has made a thorough survey of the harbour. The report and plans have been submitted to the harbour commissioners. They will be completed and submitted to the proper Departments within the next few weeks and I hope that the Minister for Finance will put his hand to his heart when we approach his Department. The idea is that the piers which were built for some mining company should be extended a couple of yards further and this is the suggestion agreed on with the Dutch expert. We hope to get the work under way and to make a success of it, as there has been a public waste of £60,000 in dredging over the past 20 years.
Some remarks have been passed from the opposite benches about black market tea and sugar. I have been in business all my life and was during the emergency, and I can assure the Minister or whoever is responsible that there is not the slightest objection to the arrangements regarding tea, sugar and flour. The ration supplied is sufficient for any family and they can get all they want. They can come in now with their heads up, if they have a function on, whether it is a marriage or a funeral, threshing or hay making, and get a half a pound of tea or extra sugar. They look upon it as a very pleasant change from the time when the Irish Jew and the Fianna Fáil Jew were going around the country selling tea at 38/- a lb. and sugar at 25/- a bag. Supplies are plentiful now. Bacon is available, too, and as was said in the other House, there is no necessity to-day to salute a pig. They are rolling into the bacon factories and to the markets in increasing numbers and bacon is available now for everybody. I think the Minister would be very wise to consider even exporting bacon in the near future. I will not go further into those matters raised on the other side—I do not wish to raise them at all, but when people look for something they have to get it.
Comment on this
I would ask the Minister to give us, when replying, his views on the devaluation of the £ and also on our external assets, as these matters are being discussed all over the country. I would like to verify what Senator McCrea has said about building costs in County Wicklow. I am on the North Cork Board of Health and we have had the same experience. We find that local cottages can be built for £750 or £800, either by contract or by direct labour. There was some hesitation on the part of the usual contractors to take up this, but smaller contractors are now taking up the work and it is being done at around the figure the Senator mentioned.
The rates are the burden about which everyone is grumbling, as they have gone up to an alarming extent. We in North Cork have applications for water supplies from every hamlet and village and they appear to be as entitled to a water supply as any other section of the community; but if the burden falls on the board of health it will cost an enormous sum of money and will break the backs of the unfortunate ratepayers. I am wondering whether any scheme could be devised to give the people water in the same way as they get electric light. The Electricity Supply Board is providing rural Ireland with light at fairly reasonable cost. In my opinion, water is more necessary, and I wonder if any scheme could be devised to provide water in the same way as light is provided and let the people pay for it. I suggested, on a previous occasion, that grants should be given under the farm improvements scheme for the provision of water in local areas. That suggestion fell on deaf ears. I now make the suggestion that water be provided in the same way as electric light is provided in rural Ireland. The people demand it, the people will have it, and no one can say they are not entitled to it. I do not know if it is the same in other parts of the country, but in North Cork it is a very serious and pressing problem and at every meeting of the board delegations are heard from one district or another. The whole countryside is demanding a supply of water and, in my opinion, they are entitled to make that demand.
I do not know whether the Minister is aware that there is a possibility that some of our bacon factories may close down in the near future. I understand that some Members of this House and of the other House have been briefed in connection with the matter. I have not been briefed in any way but certain things have come before me which I feel I ought to bring to the attention of this House. I understand that a number of pig producers are getting very jumpy for fear some of the bacon factories may close down. In that event they would be left with the pigs on their hands and they would be put in the position of suffering serious losses which they are not able to bear. Four interests are involved in this matter—the pig producer, the bacon curer, the retailer and the consumer. These four interests have to be considered. The bacon curers state that they are losing £1 on every pig they are curing at the moment. One bacon factory states that it has lost £100,000 in the last six years in the curing of pigs alone. It is taking in from 800 to 1,000 pigs per week at present and, on that basis, they stand to lose £52,000 this year. I suggest, and I think it is obvious to everybody, that that state of affairs cannot continue, that it will not continue and that that factory will definitely close down in the near future. If that happens, it will be a very serious matter for the people of this country.
As I say, I have not been briefed. I have not all the data connected with the matter but it would appear that the bacon curer has to pay 190/- to the pig producer—and anybody producing pigs will need to get 190/-each for them. Then, I understand, the curer has to sell the pig to the retailer at 210/-. It is stated that the retailer has a profit of £2 per side on every side of bacon which he retails. I do not know whether that is so or not but that is the statement that is made. I think that the matter ought to be looked into by the Government and looked into very soon. If it is not looked into a situation will arise which will prove to be a very serious set-back to pig production in the country. If the control —there is a control which provides that the bacon curer must sell at 210/—-were removed it might meet the case. I do not know whether it would or not. I do not know whether it would be a hardship on the retailer or the distributor. However, something ought to be done and must be done. A bacon factory that has lost £100,000 in the last six years in the curing of pigs, and which is likely to lose £52,000 in the coming year, will not indefinitely continue to function.
Comment on this
Because they have another side to their business.
Comment on this
They have been able to keep floating it at any rate. However, there are a lot of bacon factories which have not another side to their business.
Comment on this
No, because many of them have their own retail shops.
Comment on this
That means, then that they should cut out the wholesalers? The remedy would appear to be to cut out the intermediary?
Comment on this
I am not advocating that. I am giving you the little bit of information I have in connection with the matter. I am not saying that it is all correct, but if anybody will tell me that I am wrong at any point I shall be glad to be corrected.
Comment on this
I was only wondering if the Senator could provide the solution. I was wondering whether the suggestion was to reduce the price paid for the pig or to put up the price paid for bacon.
Comment on this
I would never suggest reducing a price paid for the pig because that would cut the ground from under the pig producer.
Comment on this
A very small increase might meet the case. That might be so. I suggest that the Government ought to look into the matter. The position is very serious.
I shall deal now with the question of flooding. I live in the valley of the Blackwater and the flooding there is very serious. Three towns are very badly affected—Kanturk, Mallow and Fermoy. The people who farm near the banks of the river are also very seriously affected. Flooding has become far more intensive in the last few years than it was previously. The second last flooding was 12 inches higher than any flood which occurred there within the memory of any person in the district. The last flood that took place there swept away bridges all over the county. The cutting down of all the trees in the locality during the war crisis and the draining of the bogs was probably responsible for creating the intense floods we have been having. I should like to know from the Minister what is being done or will be done or when anything will be done. The two last floods, which were very serious and bad floods, took place in the day-time. If they had taken place at night there would have been serious loss of life. I want to put what I say on the records of the House. The matter needs to be looked into as urgently as possible.
Forestry is closely bound up with flooding. I believe that if the countryside were adequately planted there would be less flooding. Experts say that tillage land holds twice as much water as grassland and that woodland holds three times as much water as grassland. In that way one type of land will delay the progress of water to the river and minimise flooding considerably. I think that forestry ought to be speeded up. I have seen the statements which were made by the Minister in the other House of the intention to plant 25,000 acres of land within a period of about three years from now. That is a very laudable programme and I give the Minister full credit for his intentions. However, I should like to feel that that programme will be carried out. For that reason I should like to know if the Minister has some reasonable quantity of land on hands or if there is some prospect of acquiring the land on which these trees can be planted.
Whilst I am dealing with forestry, there is another aspect of the matter to which I should like to refer. Two types of timber are used in this country—native timber and foreign timber. Native timber costs about half the price of foreign timber. There is a controlled price and native timber costs about half the price of foreign timber.
A great many people, a great many experts, would prefer native timber, properly seasoned, to foreign timber. I am not saying that all the native timber is of that high standard but I am saying that a considerable quantity of it is of a good standard and I think that the controlled price should be removed. The sale of native timber at half the price of foreign timber is no encouragement whatsoever to forestry. People who are engaged in poultry production find that if they build a poultry house of native timber they will not get the subsidy for it. The subsidy will not be given unless the poultry houses are built with foreign timber. That is not right.
Comment on this
I have not, but the Minister may take my word for it.
Comment on this
I have never heard of the question of foreign timber.
Comment on this
My statement will stand any challenge that is made. My statement is correct.
Comment on this
In accordance with the specification drawn up by the Department of Agriculture.
Comment on this
May I intervene to say that, while I am not aware that there is a definite Order to that effect, I had the feeling that it was considered desirable that poultry houses should be made of imported timber? I know something about this matter, but I am not aware that there is a definite ruling to that effect.
Comment on this
I am referring to poultry houses which are being built under the hatchery scheme. I am not referring to houses which are being built under the county committees of agriculture. There is very little more I have to say and I am grateful to the Minister for listening so patiently to me. Many Senators have referred to the big increase in local rates. That is a matter which calls for urgent attention. Other speakers have advocated that the maintenance of mental hospitals and roads should be put on the Central Fund. Something will have to be done because the ratepayers are getting very uneasy and very unhappy about the huge increase in rates.
There is just one other matter to which I should like to refer. I think if turf can be produced at an economic price, we should be prepared to advocate its use in all our public institutions. It is a native product and it would give considerable employment. I think our public institutions should set a headline in that regard.
Comment on this
In conclusion, I merely wish to repeat that I hope the Minister will make some statement as to the position of our external assets.
Comment on this
While I am sure Senator O'Callaghan made the statements to which we have just listened in all good faith, it is very hard to understand how a bacon factory could lose £100,000 in six years during which there were practically no pigs in the country. Now that pigs have become plentiful again, and that everybody is going in for the production of pigs, we are told that this same factory is going to give up business because they would lose £50,000 in the coming year. It is a remarkable fact that at the same time the Waterford Meat Factory is buying up another bacon factory. I accept what the Senator has said as being put forward in all good faith, but I am at least somewhat sceptical as to the authenticity of his information. My opinion in regard to bacon and pigs is that during the last eight or nine months we have been doing ten times better than ever we did before and everybody is satisfied.
Somebody, I think it was Senator Lynch, referred to the black market in flour and other commodities. I say that we have no black market whatsoever now. The black market has been done away with, except perhaps in regard to housing. The black market finished with Fianna Fáil and the abolition of controls. Looking around me in my own county of Tipperary, I can see that people are doing a good flourishing business although there are plenty of inspectors floating around. We remember the days not so very long ago when people were charged 2/- a lb. for sugar and 1/- an ounce for tea. All that disappeared with Fianna Fáil. People on the opposite side are trying to suggest that there is a black market because poor people are getting their rations at the regular subsidised price while the rich people are made to pay extra if they want white flour or want extra sugar.
I am in thorough agreement with the statement of Senator McCrea with regard to housing. If a house can be built in rural Ireland for £800, there is no reason why the ratepayers or anybody else should be mulcted by having to pay £1,100 per house. Most of our contracts in Tipperary run to £1,100 or £1,050 per house. I am afraid that engineers of councils do not want to take any responsibility whatever in this matter. Wherever there is a chance of giving a building to a contractor, they will not have it done by direct labour. I think it is about time that the Minister for Local Government took some action in this matter because if we are losing 33 per cent. on the building of each house, in the aggregate that represents a terrible burden on the people who have to pay the piper, whether through the Central Fund or through the local rates. Nowadays many people are making money so fast that they are not anxious to see these schemes brought to completion and they want to keep them within certain circles. I think it is about time that the Government should put its foot down and say that if the cost of these houses exceeds a certain price, they will build no more houses. We have waited so many years to house these people that we can wait for another six or 12 months to ascertain if the job can be done at a more reasonable figure. The officials of local authorities should be urged to go more keenly into these matters. No matter how pressing or urgent the problem in I would not agree that we should pay £200 or £300 more per house simply in order to have these houses built in a hurry. That is part of the black market under which we have been suffering for too long.
In regard to the question of inflation and deflation, Senator Hawkins yesterday evening advised that we should not buy so much on the dollar market, that we should produce more. The inference, I take it, from Senator Hawkins' speech is that we should produce more wheat. As it is, the Government have done their best to promote the growing of wheat by increasing the price by 5/- a barrel. Does Senator Hawkins want us to go back to compulsion? I know very well he does not, nor anybody in this House or in this country. Even with the 5/- increase, the people are not inclined to grow a terrible lot of wheat. However we might like to see more wheat grown, the people must be left to themselves. I think any Party in this House who would try to go back to compulsory growing of wheat would be very foolish.
There is another matter which ought to be looked into by the Government. It is a serious matter. At present the position is most confusing. Every day we hear the cry about unemployment. I have heard Senators talking about unemployment and emigration. Notwithstanding that, in Tipperary farmers are looking for men to work for them every day and cannot get them. Officials employed by Government bodies are out every week looking for men, but the men cannot be got. Still, if you go down to the labour exchange you will find that there are a couple of hundred men registered as unemployed. That is a most extraordinary position. The Turf Development Board are looking for men and the men will not take the work. They say that they never worked at that job. They want some other kind of job, some casual labour. Yet they are registered as unemployed and are drawing some kind of benefit. The other day a man came to me wanting a job with the county council on the roads and I had to tell him that I had no say with the county council. These men will not go to work on the bogs. Any good workman can earn up to £8 a week on the bogs. He would be a very poor workman if he could not earn £5. Whatever has come over a certain section of our workmen, they will not work on the bogs. They say the work is too hard and they want to get work on the roads. That is our whole unemployment problem.
In most districts in rural Ireland farmers are looking for men but they cannot get them. Yet we are told there are large numbers unemployed. It is a problem for the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Industry and Commerce and everybody in this House to know what we are going to do with these people who are signing on at the labour exchange. Whether the labour exchange officials are wrong or whether the Government officials are wrong, or whether the people are wrong, I do not know. It is one of the matters that I should like to have inquired into because it is impossible to understand. You will find that 100 men are required for some work and, although 200 are signing on at the labour exchange, the 100 men cannot be found for the work.
As to the contracts for houses, they ought to be put a stop to until we reach some reasonable level. The time has come when people should give up the idea of becoming millionaires in six months. People should not be looking for 300 per cent. profit, and that is what is happening in connection with contracts for houses. The Government should ignore propaganda and try to get at the root of this matter. When that is done there will be nobody unemployed except the floating population which has always been unemployed. I am putting these matters before the Minister so that he may consider them when bringing in his next Budget. I do not believe that Senator Hawkins and other Senators were in earnest in regard to the matters they talked about. That is the position in the country. It is a matter for the Government and the taxpayer. Unless we all put our heads together and try to do something, the position will be worse in 12 months' time. It would be better for Senator Hawkins to try to get those people who will not work to do a decent day's work and other people to be satisfied with an ordinary profit and not be trying to become rich quickly.
Comment on this
This discussion has covered so many different topics that it would hardly be possible to say anything at this stage without touching on what has already been referred to by some other Senator. In the West of Ireland we say, when a conversation or a discussion on any matter has covered a very wide field, that "everything was discussed from pigs to Parliament". In this debate we can say that everything was discussed from our collection of Rembrandts in Merrion Street to the twisting of a bullock's tail in some laneway off Prussia Street. There was one feature of the debate which I am worried about. Senator Counihan stated that he had nothing to complain about.
Senator Counihan, like myself, was elected on the agricultural panel. I have yet to learn whether he represents the live-stock trade or the farming community. At any rate, when a farmer or a representative of the farming community ceases to have something to complain about, I feel there is something terribly wrong, because it was always the right of the agricultural industry to have something to complain about. That was borne out by Senator Fearon who so ably described the right of free people to complain, particularly when they do not suffer, just as in totalitarian countries they suffer but do not complain. When I hear Senator Counihan say that he has nothing to complain about, I think we are not progressing. It may even have this effect—that we shall miss that feature from the Seanad Order Paper—a motion in the name of Senator Counihan.
One matter which I should like to refer to, as it has been spoken of so often, is the question of rating and rates. It would be very hard for serious thinking people to devise a system that would be more equitable within a county, that would collect the same amount of money for the local authority, and that would not create greater hardship than the present system. It would be very hard for people to think out a better system which would create fewer hardships. I suppose there will be hardships and inequalities under any system of taxation. But I do argue that except for these hardships which you will have under any system, the present system is equitable, generally speaking, in a county as between the different occupiers of property in that county. I am prepared to state, however, that it is not equitable as between counties because of the varying taxable capacity in different counties. I should like the Minister, if he is giving any study to this matter, to give serious consideration to the fact that rating as it exists at present is not equitable as between counties. By reason of that, you have this position in the poorer counties where the land is somewhat more uneconomic than it is in the richer counties, that the local authorities are compelled to levy very high rates on property in those counties. But even where high taxation is levied in a poor county, the local authority there is not in as good a position to provide services up to the standard of those given in richer counties where the rates are much lower.
I am sure the Minister is aware of that. I would suggest to him, as an alternative to the present system, that a change should be made to have something like a basic rate that would operate over the whole country. Let us suppose that it would be X shillings in the £. The figure would be decided upon by the Departments of Finance and Local Government together with the representatives of the local authorities, and, following on that, grants should be made available from the State after a proper survey had been made. I think the alternative I suggest would be more equitable in so far as it would provide for the payment of the same rate by the occupiers of property in the different counties. It would also enable the local authorities to give equality of service. Surely, we are all agreed that the people in the whole nation should have equal treatment. We are all agreed, I am sure, that people who live in counties like Donegal, Leitrim, the western parts of Mayo and parts of Galway are as much entitled to decent conditions of life as the people living in areas of the country where the land is much better and more valuable and where conditions generally are more prosperous. I suggest that there will have to be a levelling up in that matter. Take the position in my own County of Leitrim. A rate of 1d. in the £ there produces something like £600. We could not hope even with a much higher rate than we are paying at present, to provide services equal to those which can be provided in a wealthy county like Meath where my friend here, Senator Fitzsimons, comes from.
Comment on this
I think that something such as I suggest should be done if we are to treat all the people of the country alike. I think it is the duty of the State to do that.
Comment on this
From the taxation point of view, there should be equality of treatment.
Comment on this
There should be, as far as the expenditure of money or the giving of services is concerned.
Comment on this
The man with a couple of thousand pounds a year pays far more than the man with £200.
Comment on this
I seriously suggest to the Minister that there is a need for a levelling up in the direction that I speak of. Even if there was a much higher rate than there is in the County Leitrim, the local authority there could never hope to maintain the same high standard of services that, say, would be possible in the richer counties. I am sure the Minister is well aware of another tendency that has been observable for some time. It is this, that as a result of quite a number of the new Acts that are passed through the Oireachtas added burdens are placed on local authorities. Each one, so to speak, puts another straw on the camel's back. I am not suggesting that it was during the period of office of the present Government that this tendency was introduced. One may put it this way, that it has been a tendency with the State, when it proposes to do something, to shift part of the cost and the responsibility on to the back of the local authorities. Quite a number of those measures may be very desirable in themselves, but there is that tendency there.
When the Local Authorities (Works) Bill, which was passed recently, becomes an Act, it will have the effect of placing an added burden on the local authorities in so far as that any compensation that has to be paid under it will have to be borne by them. I agree that the Minister could make a case why that should be so. He would probably argue that local authorities would not undertake the execution of works without having regard to the risks which might be involved. The Nurses Bill is another measure that will add on a little bit to the backs of local authorities. The same happened in the case of the Arterial Drainage Act which was passed by the previous Government in 1945.
Comment on this
When that Bill becomes an Act the local authority will be responsible for paying. It may be recouped what it pays.
Comment on this
Is there not some reason why the same responsibility is being placed on the shoulders of local authorities under the Health Act? That is my point.
Comment on this
I understand it is a well-known technique with lawyers never to show the trump card up your cuff until it is demanded. I was aware that, under the Health Act, local authorities would be indemnified up to a point.
Comment on this
It is arguable as to how soon the point will be reached when counties which are backward in the matter of health services will be called upon to provide a standard of health services equal to that which could be provided, say, in Meath. I have heard an official in my county say that the point will be reached in ten years' time. I hope that is not so.
Comment on this
The Minister must remember that in Leitrim we have a rate of over 26/- in the £. That is why I am arguing that something will have to be done because saturation point is being reached in counties which may be described as uneconomic. I do not want to create any wrong impression by saying that. What I mean is that there are areas in the country where the conditions are wholly uneconomic. The average poor law valuation in the County Leitrim is between £9 and £10. It is because I fear that the tendency of which I have been speaking is going to keep on increasing that I suggest there should be an examination of the whole position so as to try and have a more equitable distribution in the matter of rating between the counties. While I agree that it would be hard to find a better system than the present one within a county—that is allowing for an odd hardship—I do hold that it is not equitable as between counties. It would be much better to do what I suggest than to be giving relief under one heading or another. I could argue, for example, that local authorities should be indemnified to a greater extent than they are in the matter of the cost of mental treatment. I feel that some system of a basic rate with grants, after a proper survey had been made, would be a much better approach to these matters than what we have at present.
There has been a lot said about housing. I would like to know from the Minister whether, in the light of the experience that has been gained since the Act was passed, he thinks that the cottage-tenant purchase scheme needs amendment. I agree that that Act was an attempt to reconcile two principles. There were two principles involved. It was considered a desirable thing that the tenant of a county council house should ultimately become the owner, and there was an effort made to ensure that the house would be maintained for the type of person for whom it was originally built as a subsidised house. An attempt was made to reconcile those principles. It is not so easy to do so and, in the light of experience, I wonder whether that Act would need amendment at the present time.
If a position should arise whereby these houses, which were subsidised by the local authority and the taxpayers, should pass out of the hands of the people for whom they were intended, it would not be a desirable thing. I am not suggesting that the cottage tenants should not become the owners of their houses, but if once a cottage tenant became vested, or acquired a very slight interest by reason of some payments of the purchase annuity, and sold that house to the highest bidder, and exploited a possible scarcity of housing in the area and also exploited his fellow worker who might be looking for that type of house, that also would not be desirable. If there was a tendency in that direction it should be promptly stopped.
I agree it is a knotty problem to reconcile the two principles. An attempt was made to reconcile them in the original Act. I think the matter should be examined in order to prevent any abuse and to ensure that when local authorities build houses, even though they are subject to a purchase scheme, they do not pass out of the hands of the people they were originally built for. If that were to happen, one result would be that the local authorities would have to continue building, because the cottages would pass from the people for whom they were built, and more and more houses would have to be erected under the Housing of the Working Classes Act.
The erection of houses is a very serious drain on the finances of a local authority. I am not too clear as to what the position is in regard to capital works such as house construction, sewerage and water supplies. So far as County Leitrim is concerned, I would like some clarification of the position, especially with reference to grants from the Transition Fund. It would appear that that is decided by the Minister of Finance, or by the Minister for Local Government, or by both. I will say that members of local authorities—and I would like to feel that the same applied in the Seanad—irrespective of their political views, try to tackle a job with all sincerity and they realise the difficulties and the responsibilities they have to face. Political issues do not occupy any great position in the affairs of local authorities, and I think that is a good thing.
As regards Government grants, particularly from the Transition Fund, I am aware that the Leitrim County Council have been notified that there will be a substantial reduction in the amount to be received in respect of housing and there will also be reductions in the amounts given by way of State grants towards any schemes that may be carried out. This will make such a difference in a county like Leitrim that it is doubtful if the council could continue to play the part they would like to play in providing more houses and sewerage and water supplies and the other amenities that the people of Leitrim are entitled to just as much as the people of any other county, even though it might have a higher taxable capacity.
The Minister may say he is not responsible for the running of the Local Government Department, but I am sure he is responsible for the financial commitments of that Department. That is one reason why there are so many different matters to be discussed here. What is really the purpose of all this discussion? Perhaps it would be vain to hope that the various Ministers would go to the trouble of reading this debate. It might be too much to expect that the Minister would bring the different matters raised here to the notice of the Departments concerned. If that were the practice, there would be some point in talking on the various aspects of Government policy that have been mentioned here. It is only natural that Senators should feel they are entitled to discuss varied matters at this time, since it is one of the few opportunities they get of doing so.
With regard to the rents of houses that are let by local authorities, Senators are aware that in some cases houses are let at the full economic rent while other dwellings erected under the same scheme may be let at a subsidised rent. I have been wondering recently how far that is equitable. You will have a man of the middle income group, such as a teacher or a Garda, and if he is recommended for a house by the medical officer, who plays a big part in the letting of houses by local authorities, he is charged the full economic rent—17/6, 18/6 or £1 per week. A man with smaller family commitments, who may be in relatively well paid employment, say as a carpenter or a tradesman of some sort, earning a good wage, may succeed in getting a house at the subsidised rent, which may be 4/-, 5/- or 6/- a week. There should be some levelling up there. There should be some direction from the Government that the houses ought to be let, having regard to the ability of the person to pay. I suggest that hardships can be created under the existing system.
I hope more generous grants will be given to local authorities in counties like Leitrim, where the people are not able to bear the expense of carrying out housing, sewerage and water supply schemes.
Reference has been made to drainage. At all times when a county council election is near, candidates will tell the people that certain drainage works will be undertaken. That is one of the things held out at a local or Parliamentary election. Drainage has long been exploited. Since I first took part in public life I have always heard candidates at elections talk about drainage, but as a rule very little work of that type is carried out. I wonder how soon it will be when arterial drainage will be carried out on the upper reaches of the Shannon? I do not know if any survey has been made or if there has been any progress. I argue that if other types of drainage work, such as rural improvement schemes, minor employment schemes and works executed under the Local Authorities (Works) Act are carried out, serious flooding will result if the catchment area is not in a condition to carry off the increased flow of water. I move the adjournment of the debate.
Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7 p.m.
Comment on this
At the interval I was suggesting that there is a possibility that drainage works of a minor character carried out under the Local Authority (Works) Act and the rural improvement schemes and minor employment schemes will have the effect of concentrating the flow of water into arterial drainage systems which have not been reconstructed and will, therefore, cause greater flooding because of the more concentrated outfall. That brings me to the point of inquiring how soon the Government hope to complete the reconstruction of our arterial drainage system. Drainage was one of the subjects that particularly interested me when I first took any small part in public affairs. It has always been the practice at elections, both local and general, for candidates to advocate arterial drainage. It is a pet subject at election time. No great progress has so far been made and I would like some indication as to how soon the Government hope to be in a position to carry out arterial drainage and complete the reconstruction of our present drainage system. I am particularly interested in the upper reaches of the Shannon and in the Erne.
Unless a very careful survey is made expenditure on arterial drainage may be quite useless. I want to bring the Minister's attention to a particular matter affecting a particular area. I refer to the Ballinamore-Ballyconnell canal. I could talk for a long time on that matter but I shall be as brief as possible by saying that in the Counties Cavan and Leitrim and in a small portion of Roscommon a monstrosity exists. Special legislative provision had to be made in the 1945 Arterial Drainage Act to ensure that the drainage districts which are partly within and partly outside that canal would not be handed over to the county councils for maintenance. It was decided that the Ballinamore-Ballyconnell drainage board would continue in existence and that that board would levy any rate they liked on the riparian owners and the ratepayers would subsequently be indemnified by the local authorities concerned. The result is that the county councils of Cavan, Leitrim and, to a small degree, Roscommon are compelled to pay back to the drainage ratepayers the amount collected by the drainage board or, alternatively, credit them with that amount in their ordinary rates. I raised this matter, as did also Senator Baxter, when the Arterial Drainage Act was going through. Apparently no agreement was reached on the matter but I daresay agreement can be reached on matters affecting the trans-Border hydro-electric scheme. It would appear that agreement could not be reached on a plan that would make it more workable.
The rivers in that drainage district have an outfall into the Ballinamore-Ballyconnell canal. The canal is governed by a board known as the Ballinamore - Ballyconnell Navigation Board. That board was set up by a British Act of 1854. Under that Act the grand juries, who were the precursors of the county councils, have power to levy a maintenance charge on the Counties of Cavan, Leitrim, Roscommon and Fermanagh. There is a case of an authority outside the State levying taxes within the State. It has been suggested that taxation without representation is tyranny. If that is not tyranny, it is a position that should be attended to, even though the tax may be small and whatever steps can be taken in the matter should be taken.
The board is appointed solely and absolutely by the Fermanagh County Council and the Act of 1854 provided that its members should be possessed of property of an annual value of not less than £100. It is quite obvious the type of person appointed. The original trustees were appointed and named under the Act and their successors were to be appointed by the grand juries of the Counties Fermanagh, Leitrim, Cavan and Roscommon. That position still obtains. Actually the work was a famine relief scheme and had no value as a navigation scheme. It is on record that one boat went up the canal and got stuck and had to wait for a rainfall to get out. A commission sat about 1880 and decided that the canal had no commercial value as a navigation work but suggested that it should be maintained as a drainage work. The Leitrim County Council, before I became a member, fought a very costly law action.
Comment on this
I am suggesting, respectfully, that it is possible to discuss on this measure anything affecting Government policy or anything which should be drawn to the attention of the Minister.
Comment on this
The Senator could do that by way of motion, if the matter is so important. It is doubtful if it comes in on the Appropriation Bill. It is an area over which the Minister has no authority.
Comment on this
The Government, I suggest, have responsibility to introduce proposals for legislation to remedy the existing position.
Comment on this
It cannot be done under the Appropriation Bill. Legislation cannot be advocated on the Appropriation Bill.
Comment on this
I accept your ruling, Sir. I understood that discussion on this Bill would give members of the House an opportunity to raise the many and varied matters we would like to raise, just as members of the Dáil have an opportunity to raise various matters on the Estimates.
Comment on this
Yes. That is why so many and so varied matters are being raised on this particular measure. It is unfortunate, and it is unusual in this House, that references were made that would seem to carry high political venom. I do not regard myself as the guardian of Parliamentary procedure but I have always protested against that sort of thing. I listened to that sort of thing again to-day. I made particular note of a statement made by Senator Jerry Ryan. He said that black-marketing ended with Fianna Fáil. I do not think that the level of discussion in the House is aided by statements of that sort. If that were to be taken seriously, it would mean that the former Government——