We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Appropriation Bill, 1949 ( Certified Money Bill )— Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 110–219 of 219. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Appropriation Bill, 1949
Enacted

No. 36 of 1949 ›

I have said that Senator Ryan made the statement that black-marketing ended with Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

If Senator Ryan made a mistake, I assume Senator O'Reilly will not follow. We are dealing with administration and expenditure.

Comment on this

I understand that all matters affecting Government policy are debatable on this measure.

Comment on this

Surely a reference made by another Senator may not be debated at length.

Comment on this

I do not propose to debate it at length, but I say that I want to repudiate that statement, because I think it is an unwarranted statement. There are people who are better able to safeguard the interests of Fianna Fáil than I, but I take exception to that sort of statement, and I say that it is hardly fair, nor is it in the best interest of debate in this House, that such statements should be made. We must all agree, if we are honest, that the former Minister for Industry and Commerce took every possible step to ensure that there would be a proper rationing system, and, when there was a danger of that system breaking down, the most severe penalties were inflicted. Were it not for the ability with which that Minister administered the Department of Supplies, it is doubtful if our rationing system would not have broken down, and, if it had, this country would have been in chaos.

Comment on this

The Senator may not proceed further along that line, because rationing does not arise on this Bill.

Comment on this

If rationing ended with the change of Government, it was because there had been a return to normal conditions and because the flow of goods was such as to ensure that vital commodities like tea——

Comment on this

I remind the Senator again that we are not discussing the rationing system on this Bill.

Comment on this

I accept your ruling, Sir. Senator O'Callaghan asked for a statement from the Minister with regard to sterling assets. That is ground on which I do not like to enter, but, in view of the fact that Senator O'Brien indicated by statistics that the balance of payments would not appear to be in our favour, I should like to hear the Minister make some reference in his reply to how far the dollar crisis will affect us. I do not think our people regard it as being as serious as the people across the Channel appear to regard it, judging by the storm which has been raised there. Either the people do not take it seriously, or the Government do not take it seriously. Perhaps it is a matter of vital importance, but our people do not seem to think it is. Only to-day my attention was drawn to a statement in the morning papers—it was done in a sneeringly jocose manner because I was a member of the Oireachtas—to the fact that the State was acquiring a number of American motor cars for the use of Ministers.

Men in the position of Ministers are entitled to a type of vehicle which will bring them from place to place at a reasonably fast speed, and I would be the last person to make capital out of it, because, if I sought to do so, I should merely be following the sort of suggestions which have been made; but it was put to me in a sneeringly jocose manner: "How do you account for that? Ministers are getting American motor-cars and what about the people who cannot get dollars to buy machinery?" I do not know if that is so or not, but, if it is so, I am quite sure there is a good explanation for it, because it would appear from that that the dollar scarcity is not regarded here as seriously as it is across the Channel.

Comment on this

On the occasion of the debate on the Appropriation Bill last year, the Minister promised to introduce a savings campaign. He has done so, and he deserves the thanks of the House for it. We see posters on the hoardings and announcements in the papers—they might be better designed, but they are good posters—encouraging the country to save. I hope the Minister will keep up the pressure in that campaign. I noticed only to-day that posters have appeared urging hard work, both for the sake of Ireland and for the sake of European recovery. These two qualities, thrift and hard work—simple terms; you may think I am a simpleton to use them, but I propose to be a simpleton for a moment or two if the House will forgive me—are the only solution of our economic and industrial problems. At the risk of being regarded as a simpleton for using such simple terms, I should like to emphasise one rather neglected aspect of our national hard work and our national slackness. What I want to emphasise is that it is not merely an economic and financial problem. It is also a psychological problem. Our hard work and slackness do not depend only on the rise and fall of wages; they depend quite as much on our attitude of mind towards work, its honour and dishonour, its contribution to our happiness and our unhappiness. It is a complete error, as every employer and every worker knows—and I do not mean to imply that employers are not workers—to think that higher wages always secure harder and better work. In fact, the reverse is very often true— higher wages often produce slacker work. Senator Hearne, during the debate last year, told us that in the building trade they were paying twice the wages paid 20 years ago and getting about half the return in terms of work. That is, we are getting one-quarter of the value of work in terms of money. I insist that the problem lies not merely in the purses of the employers and workers but also in their minds and the Minister will have to face this, if he is to get really to the root of our problem.

The House, I know, would not thank me at this eleventh hour of a hardworking session—I emphasise the phrase—if I tried to discuss psychological incentives to work. Such organisations as Muintir na Tíre, the Royal Dublin Society and the local agricultural societies, deserve the highest praise for the great work they are doing in encouraging industry and pride in work, but I should like for a moment or so to speak briefly of certain psychological disincentives to work, certain insidious disincentives to work, that are very current in our country at present. I suggest that thoughtful and patriotic men should give more attention to these insidious disincentives to work. They come to us freely and fully and powerfully in many potent propaganda forms. Take, for example—it is the only example I will take—certain kinds of extravagant and ambitious advertisements. What feelings do these appeal to in their efforts to make us spend instead of save? Take, for example, the advertisements of the Irish Hospital Sweepstakes. What are the implications of these advertisements which are plastered over the whole country? The implications, I suggest, of these are: "Get rich quick without working for it. Idleness and extravagant living may be ours if Lady Luck wills it." Lady Luck! They imply that work is bad and that wealth is possible and desirable without it. We wonder then in the face of this propaganda that one woman speaking from Radio Éireann some years ago said that she had spent her children's allowance on buying sweepstake tickets and had been successful in winning a good deal of money. The implication was that the women of Ireland should spend their children's allowance on buying sweepstake tickets. How does that fit in with the Minister's campaign for wiser saving and harder work? I suggest that it does not fit in at all. Let me illustrate by simply pointing to any hoarding in the country. One of the posters will be the Minister's excellent design and slogan saying: "Work and save"; the next to it will be the sweepstake advertisement saying: "Spend and win idleness"; and the next to it perhaps the Minister for Health's advertisement saying: "You cannot afford to gamble with tuberculosis". What kind of mental confusion does that cause? Spend, save, gamble, do not gamble. Take another example. The prominent brewer Mr. X produces a most ingenious and persuasive set of advertisements and persuades the country to take an extra glass of beer or possibly stout, three times a day. He finds in a few months that the standard of work in his factory has gone down deplorably and he says that Irish workmen are slack and inefficient. Gentlemen, I suggest that it is due to the mental confusion caused by telling people to work and not to work.

We have a very active censorship board to check on one of the seven deadly sins, one of them, gentlemen, but there has been no political attempt to curb the other six deadly sins, greed, sloth, envy, gluttony, pride and anger. They are being deliberately fostered by advertisements and by many films too which the film censor does not stop. They encourage us to indulge in the six deadly sins. You may ask where does anger come in—if you have been counting the sins very carefully and I doubt if you have—to these advertisements. It does not in a sense, gentlemen, out it does come in somewhere else. I speak seriously and I say that every angry politician and every of anger-provoking politics are seriously destructive of the energy and peace of mind needed for steady hard work in this country. I would appeal to politicians in general to remember that the more they make us angry, you and me, the less steady industry they will get out of the country. The patriotism we need to-day is not that of anger or provocation to anger, to my mind, but it is the patriotism of making two blades of grass—perhaps the gentlemen on the other side would prefer two blades of wheat—grow where one grew before, in other words hard work and thrift. I am not going to suggest any cure for these insidious disincentives to work, these incentives to underwork and ever-spending which are all round us in the newspapers, on the hoardings, the wireless and the films, but I do think it is something—and I think the Minister will admit it—to recognise some of the causes of our economic ills, that they are psychological, even theological, as well as economic. I do not mean to disparage the expert advice of financiers and economists. I would not trouble to say all this if I thought that the Minister would just shrug his shoulders and say: "I am only Minister for Finance. What you want is a Minister for industrial psychology." I know both from what the Minister has said and from what he has done that he is anxious to attack this problem in all its roots and will not be deterred from trying to eradicate them by the fact that some cannot be assessed in terms of pounds, shillings and pence. He has begun his savings campaign well and we hope he will undertake the far more complex task of a campaign for better work. If he succeeds in the harder undertaking he will, in my opinion, do more for a prosperous and united Ireland than all the flag wavers and to his great credit it will be said that he was reasserting what was best in the old Cumann na nGaedheal policy—I speak as a non-Party man in this matter—of sober, industrious reconstruction in a distracted and divided country. I emphasise that that kind of policy is needed as much now in the 1940's as it was in the 1920's.

I want to say one more thing. I hope that the Minister will explain to us why this book embargo—the matter already raised by Senator Mrs. Concannon— has been allowed to continue.

Comment on this

As usual, I find myself faced with such a variety of topics that I cannot promise that I will deal with them all. If I appear to be inadequate in my comments on some of the points raised by Senators I expect that Senators will excuse me, realising the amount of ground that has been covered. I have been asked to deal with what has been called "a grave situation". That phrase apparently comes from a mis-reading of the speech. I made in Donegal over the week-end when I said that certain things might happen that would upset our plans. I am not going to anticipate disaster. I know that there may be difficulties ahead and I feel that those difficulties would be increased if I made a statement which was ahead of time and therefore a mere matter of speculation. I might easily cause confusion, and if my political opponents got to work in mischievous ways on the things I did say, it might be alleged that I had caused panic and something in the nature of disaster. On the other hand, I realise that if I want public co-operation in the dangerous times that may lie ahead a statement has to be made at the appropriate time. If I do not make any statement now it is because I think that the time is not opportune for it, but I do want the House to know that I am not unaware of my obligations to the public and that if I want public co-operation in these matters the public must be advised in good time ahead. The speaker raised the matter of the "grave situation" because we are alleged to be purchasing with borrowed moneys goods that could be secured at home. I do not want general statements. I would like precise information if a charge is to be made. A statement has been made which was rather precise in connection with wheat. This country is, I think, producing—certainly last year produced —for the millers of this country more wheat than it produced for many years. That is done, not under the stress of compulsion but because the price is guaranteed for a period of five years, and was so guaranteed by the present Minister for Agriculture since the present Government came to control things. It was only natural that, once the price incentive was there, a better yield might be obtained from the land of this country. It is clear that when the element of compulsion enters in, the compulsion has to be applied on a percentage basis to almost all equally. Consequently, many who would not grow wheat in the ordinary way at any price were forced to do so and when marginal land was brought into production, for a rather specialised type of crop, the average yield per acre over the years went down and down. Last year, under the incentive of price, everybody went into wheat who had land suitable for growing wheat; and although the acreage might have fallen, the yield has been probably the best there has been in the history of this country.

Consequent on that type of phrase, the other criticism followed here that, on account of the decision to allow people to use whiter flour, more money was being spent for the purchase of wheat in the dollar countries. That, of course, is not the case. There are fewer dollars being spent on what than ever before. That is partly due to the fact that, under the International Wheat Agreement, the price of wheat is going down; but it is also due to the fact that there is nothing like the same type of improvident purchasing being done as characterised the early part of 1948. If whiter flour is being used and whiter bread is being eaten by some people, at a price which they think fit to pay for it, that does not mean that more wheat is being brought into this country or even that more wheat is being used. As far as I am concerned, the only value in the change over to white flour is when the white flour is taken, not as an addition to the ration but in substitution for it—and that is happening, and happening despite the deliberate antagonism of bakers and some millers on this matter, at an increasing rate; and the saving to the State through subsidy, and the saving then to the taxpayer, will, I hope, be considerable.

I have been asked about the two railway companies. As far as the Great Northern Railway is concerned, the public are pretty nearly in possession of as much of the facts as I am and the public will, one of these days, be asked to pass judgment on what has brought about this bad condition in the fortunes of the Great Northern Railway. I personally would hate to see the day when the Great Northern Railway had to be nationalised. It was an excellent concern. It was the last remnant we had in this country of transport under private enterprise and while it lasted it was something of a stimulus, and should have been an example to Córas Iompair Éireann. It has been brought to its present position mainly because of the increased demands made upon it in a failing situation; and if those demands are persisted in, it means that, while the same amount of money may be spent on labour, fewer employees will get the money that has to be spent on them—but that will be a matter on which the employees concerned, through their unions, will be able to make up their own minds.

With regard to Córas Iompair Éireann, the complaint is that, while the policy of nationalisation in connection with it was announced some time ago, all that has happened since is that the First Reading of a Bill has been taken. To those who complain of delay, I would say that it is not an easy matter to deal with the main transport concern of any country and it is particularly difficult in connection with Córas Iompair Éireann, when one does not enter on a clear situation but on a situation that has been confused and complicated by the errors and mistakes of the past. It will be no easy matter to extricate the new transport concern from all these difficulties and to start it on a new line, with some hope that, in the end, we may get an efficient transport service here—which we have not had for many years—and that the public will get that transport at a moderate rate.

In that connection, I have been asked about my views on nationalisation and that query has been put in the framework of "a change of mind on my part". I do not suppose it has very much importance what I think about nationalisation, but since the matter has been made a point of controversy here, I would say I do not think I have at any point said that nationalisation is in itself bad. Certainly, I will never be brought to say that nationalisation is in itself good. I take my stand on this on particular teachings I have derived from my own Church. There is a certain moral law which governs all this question of nationalisation; it is to be derived partly from St. Thomas and partly from various social Encyclicals. The principle that guides most people who are of the Christian Faith is fairly clear, that is, that indiscriminate nationalisation is condemned and selective nationalisation is approved. When it comes to the selection, there are quite definite rules and standards laid down. For instance, it is quite clear that nationalisation is allowed and permitted and even has a benediction given to it, where, whatever the concern may be, those in charge of it lack the vision, or the will, or the capital, that is necessary to bring about a good situation where a bad one exists. I think it is also regarded as sound that nationalisation might take place where some commodity vital to the country has drifted under the control of a ring or of a cartel, or of some group that goes in for monopoly control and for the huge profits that could easily be gained from monopolies. In addition to that, there are certain things like armaments and such matters that are of vital importance to the public; or, even though there may not be price fixing or anything like that, where it is still regarded as a good thing that they should be under public control, that is, under Governmental control.

Those are the tests I would apply to any scheme of nationalisation. At the same time, I would like to state—and this is possibly what is in the mind of the Senator who misunderstood my remarks—another position, that is, as between nationalisation and other forms of ownership, I will give a preference to widely diffused private ownership, particularly on a co-operative or corporative basis; and I think that is the objective of most of the schemes that one finds praised from time to time. There is also a point to be recognised—and here, I suppose, there is more controversy than anywhere else—that under private capitalis both producers and consumers have more personal independence, more freedom, more responsibility and everything else, than they would have under nationalised concerns. If there is, so to speak, a borderline case, my option all the time would be for the operation of private enterprise; and I think that on that I have a good deal of Church authority. May I add that I do not think it can be put against me that I have any academic view against nationalisation? I was happy to be associated with the biggest scheme of nationalisation this country ever had, the Shannon scheme. It was very definitely condemned by people who thought it was a mad scheme from the financial angle and that the whole credit of the country was being seriously mortgaged by what was described as "a hare-brained scheme". The people who described it in that way have at least learned to know better even if they do not say anything different.

I have been asked also about social security schemes. I welcome every opportunity in this House or any House or at any public meeting to get a point of view displayed with regard to social security. At the moment there is a certain amount of propaganda that a White Paper on social security was promised and that there has been delay in producing it. The more seriously that whole scheme is considered the greater is the likelihood of delay.

When this matter was first mooted in the Dáil it was as late as the month of March, 1947. The Minister who was then in charge of the matter, Dr. Ryan, spoke in the following terms in Dáil Éireann on the 27th March, 1947. I quote from the Official Report, Volume 105, column 441 and onwards of that debate:—

"I should like to remind Deputies that there is no readymade solution available from any other country that could be applied here, because we find that our conditions are not exactly the same as they are in any other country. The problem here is more difficult, for one reason or another, because of the general upset with regard to distribution of population, distribution of employment and so on, and, in common with other countries, we have the aftermath of the war to deal with, so that I am not, therefore, in a position to make any detailed statement on future policy with regard to social services unless to say, as I said before, that I should like to see a unified scheme under which we could insure a person against sickness, unemployment, old age, widowhood of his wife and, perhaps, against a large family; I should like to see as many of these as possible being brought into one unified scheme which will be dealt with by one card and one stamp for each period of a week or whatever it might be, and dealt with by one official or agent at the field end and centrally through the one fund, and through the one system of filing, and so on."

That is the aim which he said then they had in view. That was a mere unification of services. There is no question there of any vast extension of social services—just a mere unification. The object was not so much to bring in the whole mass of the population under social security schemes as to save the expense in administration in having separate schemes operating under different Departments. Dr. Ryan then went on to say that he was personally very much in favour of a contributory scheme for all these various items but that it would be a difficult problem to draw up a contributory scheme for the greater part of the population because a big part of the population are not working for wages. He added that it is not easy to devise a contributory scheme where people are not wage earners because it is not so easy to collect the contributions that would be due from week to week. All that was in March, 1947.

All the last Government had in mind then was, as I say, a unification of existing services—together with the phrase I have read: "Insure against a large family". That was the Fianna Fáil objective in social security. They now complain because the whole country is not brought under what some people call a "welfare system". Other people have condemned a welfare system as being a good step towards and not very far removed from a servile system. There is a good deal to be said for that point of view. It is one I uphold and will uphold hereafter. That does not mean that I am to be regarded individually, or representing the group for which I speak, as against the amalgamation of the services or even speaking or even thinking against an extension of such services. But if the services are to be extended to the point where we are all to be paying for benefits which some of us may not require, well, a good deal of thought has to be given to that matter. During a Dáil debate recently a Fianna Fáil Deputy who comes from a Border county said that he would like to have a good deal of consideration given to this matter before it was brought into legislative form. He said he derives his doubts from conversations he has had with people across the Border who were living under the social security scheme which was there. He gave as an example the case of a small farmer in County Fermanagh who had calculated that his contributions to the social security scheme in the North amounted to £16 a year. His return, so far, had been something which previously had cost him £2, free false teeth which he did not require and free spectacles which he did not need. He paid £16 for £2 worth of medicine and, of course, an enormous number of people would have to pay £16 for £2 worth of medicine if all the people were to get the free spectacles, dental treatment and so forth, that the enthusiasts of social security schemes want. Social security has been worked out very deliberately and with great attention to detail and the scheme will be produced when we as a Government feel that we have a scheme we can stand over. The pace will not be accelerated in the slightest by any niggling questions that are going on as to when the White Paper will make its appearance. It will not appear until after great thought and consideration has been given to it.

I have been told that, as a result of action by the present Government, unemployment has increased in the Gaeltacht areas and in that connection the matter of hand-won turf has again been brought into the picture. I have so many quotations about hand-won turf, and about what was intended, that I despair of getting a simple one to bring before the minds of Senators what was intended by the last Government. Possibly, at least, this will show the mentality there was around the middle of 1947. Deputy Lemass is reported in the Irish Times of the 22nd July, 1947, as saying, in the course of a speech: “This year the bulk of their production would be hand-won. It was, however, the last year of hand-won turf for industrial purposes and retail sale in eastern areas. At least, so they hoped.” That is borne out by other documentation. That is borne out by all the matter disclosed on the files. Hand-won turf was coming to an end except in areas where there was always hand-won turf and where it should have been—where, by tradition, the people cut it and used it and where, now and again, the people sold a bit of it. That situation ought to develop again and we ought to get back to normal. A suggestion has been made here—it was put in a more, precise way here than I ever heard it before — that one should prevent the importation of coal of any type into Connacht. I should like to have a little bit of a tour through the area of Connacht to see how well that suggestion would be received among certain of the people who make a livelihood out of hand-won turf. It might go down all right, but amongst the people who would have to use and be compelled to use hand-won turf and nothing else there might not be exactly the same enthusiasm as is alleged here about it.

It is also said that the road grants are a great source of complaint in regard to the Gaeltacht and other areas. It will take, I suppose, many repetitions to get this matter clear but I suppose I am entitled to say this for at least the third time. There was never any promise, in fact the whole of the statements went to the contrary, that road grants would be continued on anything like the scale on which they were given in 1946-7 and 1947-8. The late Minister for Local Government went into great detail in connection with this matter in Dáil Éireann on the 23rd February, 1949, when there was a motion in that House with regard to these road grants. The situation as he outlined it is easy to understand. For a quarter of a century the roads in this country have been financed out of the Road Fund. That is the only source out of which finances came. In fact, from time to time, the moneys in the Road Fund were raided by Governments. I raided it last year and again this year. I am following a precedent Fianna Fáil had and they can say they were following a precedent which Mr. Cosgrave's Government gave. However, the Road Fund was sufficient to supply all the finances that the making and the keeping of roads here required and to provide a little bit for the State when the Central Fund was in need.

During the war, first of all the same amount of money was not coming into the Road Fund because the same number of motor vehicles were not travelling the roads. The roads did not require the same amount of maintenance and they did not get it. Again, there was a lack of materials for rebuilding, constructing and maintaining the roads. Therefore the same amount was not spent as had been spent in pre-war years. Even though the fund was depleted to some extent, still it mounted up until towards the end of the war there was a fair amount of money left in it.

It was recognised that a good deal of damage had been done to the roads during the war years on account of turf lorries and other unusual traffic. It was also calculated that if there was not heavy expenditure on the restoration of the roads for a yearly period after the war, the roads would have to be reconstructed later at a very heavy cost. It was therefore decided to carry out a reconstruction and maintenance programme on a sort of capital costs basis and that it should be done by moneys contributed from the Road Fund. It was definitely started for a year only and when the point was first taken up by the then Minister for Local Government his colleague, the then Minister for Finance, Deputy Aiken, expressed his dislike of the idea of making any grants for county roads and his sanction for road restoration grants for either main or county roads was given on the strict understanding that the revised basis of allocation as between the Road Fund and the rates would apply for one financial year only. When an effort was made to have a similar grant operated for a second year, it was strenously resisted by the then Minister for Finance to such an extent that the programme was very considerably delayed and local authorities were faced with great difficulties because of the delay that Deputy Aiken, the Minister for Finance, had imposed on the whole programme.

After two years, the approach was to the critical period early in 1948. A political situation that I need not go into had developed at that time. The late Government were anxious to appear in a good light before the local authorities, so a new proposal was made to have a third year's "go" by way of extra grants for the roads. The Minister for Finance, however, in his office was not a politician and he expressed astonishment at the new proposal. He wrote a rather brusque letter reminding the then Minister for Local Government that the special grants had only been reluctantly agreed to for the year then current and that that was an extension of the original programme. However, a few days before the last Government left office they came to the conclusion that they should make an arrangement about the roads. They decided to make a grant, but the one thing that follows a Government decision, namely, the provivision of the money, did not follow. That was left over to a later date.

If the last Government had been reelected they would have made their plans and they would presumably have duly informed local authorities eventually but they took the unusual procedure of telling them by telegram that the programme should go ahead. That was about a week before they left office. The Minister for Finance, however, left behind him in his office a letter to the Minister for Local Government, from which I should like to give the following quotation:—

"The position should be faced that grants on the existing scale cannot be continued and that the rate at which new commitments in respect of road maintenance can be undertaken must be accommodated to the resources of the Road Fund and of the local authority."

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister would give the reference.

Comment on this

I am quoting from Volume 114 of the Dáil Debates, columns 381-2. That again is the situation. There is no question of continuing these grants. It is somewhat similar to the turf situation. Nobody could reasonably consider the piling up of more fuel, the piling up of dust in the Park, in the way it was being accumulated, and nobody could consider the handing out of millions indefinitely from the Road Fund for this road restoration work. In any event, we decided that the period of reconstruction was very nearly over and that the Road Fund should again be the source of the moneys that were to be expended on road maintenance and on road restoration and on nothing else. We thought of an exchange for that. We thought of a better plan by which we would provide money for doing work that had been regarded as more productive than merely the maintenance of roads. We therefore went ahead with the land reclamation project and the project that is enshrined in the Local Authorities (Works) Bill which we consider will give as much employment as used to be given on the roads. The employment on the roads could never have lasted more than a certain limited time. We think we have got another way of giving employment, employment that can last over the years and that will be of use.

Certain Senators have referred to the question of the Gaeltacht Services and the sale of tweeds. If Senators will look at the Estimates they will see that the Estimate for the Gaeltacht Services is down a little bit. Incidentally the Gaeltacht Services was one Department that I thought should disappear from the Book of Estimates very soon, that it should be a self-contained sort of business and should be able to make its own expenses. The Government, of course, would provide buildings and give it certain office facilities, but the Gaeltacht Services Vote is not a Vote that I think should be there as a permanency. Senators will have observed that the provision under the various sub-heads is somewhat reduced, but if Senators will go through the details they will find that the reduction occurs in nearly all the different sub-heads under the heading of materials. In other words, not as much materials are being purchased this year as last year and the reason for that is that there was so much in the way of made-up materials left that we were faced with a similar situation as that in connection with the turf dumps in the Park. We had a substantial amount of material which we could not get rid of. There does not seem to be any value in piling up stuff merely to put it on the shelves. Therefore it was decided to provide only whatever they could usefully make up in materials for sale this year. That explains why there is a reduction in the Vote.

There is another explanation that has to be borne in mind, and that is, that the Appropriations-in-Aid this year are down considerably. The reason is that the stocks which were left there are being cleared. They are being cleared more rapidly by us than ever they were by Fianna Fáil. The Appropriations-in-Aid will not be as big as last year because the Gaeltacht Services got rid of a big amount of the stuff left there. There is a certain amount of the material which it is not easy to sell. That has certainly nothing to do with the trade agreement made with Britain.

Senator Hawkins raised the point last year about there being some mistake made in the trade agreement with England and that something had turned out unfortunately for us. He changed his thought on that afterwards and said the same mistake was made in connection with the trade agreement with France. Neither of the agreements referred to the Gaeltacht tweeds. What happened was that the purchasers both in France and England wanted tweeds of a certain width and they were not manufactured to that width. The mistake lay with those who allowed to be manufactured tweeds that were not in common sale. We shall get over that difficulty in time, but nobody can say when those tweeds which are left will be finally cleared.

There is no prohibition in England with regard to the sale of those tweeds. Senator Hawkins referred to the loss this country suffered through the absence of the sale of these materials through the parcels post. It was not that they were prohibited. That was always illegal. When we were in negotiation with the British Government in 1948, they drew our attention to this. They pointed out that it was a cause of a great deal of friction and jealousy in England. People came here and, if they purchased material here, they avoided the payment of a heavy purchase tax in England. If they took these things back with them and their baggage was opened and they were discovered, they were made to pay the same tax as any ordinary citizen buying through the shops in England. But there was an evasion which the British Government knew was going on by sending these goods through the medium of the parcels post. They warned us that they were going to take measures to stop that, and they have taken these measures. But the whole practice was illegal according to their law. To ask them to abandon that would be asking them to give a sort of privilege to people who were well enough off to visit this country and buy tweeds and bring them back. We did not think it was a good demand to make. In any event, we felt it was a useless demand to make. If that traffic has been stopped, it was decided to stop it because it was decided to prevent illegality occurring.

I need not make any further comment with regard to the Commission on Emigration which was discussed very often. I have given the quotations and the volumes and the statements that are on record from the files. The last Government, seeing themselves faced with the withdrawal of certain regulations with regard to permits, decided that the best way out of their difficulty was to establish a commission on emigration.

Senator Hawkins quoted me with regard to the Tourist Board when I said it was lingering last year and that I should like to get an opportunity of deciding when it would be put out of action, so to speak, or have a chance of looking forward to the future. It has had a chance of looking forward to the future. We reconstructed that board, and I think we have a better board now as a result of the better personnel that we have on the board. We are also taking away from that board anything to do with hotels, asking them to get rid of hotels, and we are even getting rid of them at a loss. We thought it better to suffer a loss in capital recoupment than to have a continuing loss, as that was what we were threatened with so long as the board, or a subordinate body of that board, Failte Teo., ran these hotels. The objective of any tourist board ought to be to inspect hotels, to grade them and to indulge in a certain amount of publicity with regard to the benefit that people would get here if they liked to visit us. We have the present board setting itself to these three tasks.

Personally, I should like to see the board abolished. If there was ever an occasion upon which a vocational organisation should take control and look after the grading and inspection of hotels and indulge in a certain amount of publicity, which, in the main, brings grist to the hotel keepers, it is surely one for the hotel industry. I cannot see why a strong group, a fairly well-to-do group like those who are in the hotel and restaurant business in this country should not be able to do this work for themselves. For the time being, however, we are letting the board carry on and giving them a fair amount of money. We are directing their attention to the three main duties of inspecting hotels, grading them as a result of inspection, and then getting publicity with regard to what is being done. We will certainly dispose of the hotels no matter what clamour is made about them and it will be a very happy day when we have got rid of the whole of them.

Take Ballinahinch. Somebody said it cost £35,000. It cost the best part of £70,000. We have sold it at a considerable loss and it was a great day when we decided to get rid of it. As to the method adopted, it was done by public auction. Advertisements were put widely through the Press here in Ireland and the auction date was postponed for a period in order to enable publicity to be given in America to the sale of the Ballinahinch properties— there are three of them. The public auction was abortive. The amount of money offered at the public auction was certainly not attractive. After the method of public auction had been tried, those who were around the public auction, or their representatives, knew that a date was fixed and that offers would be received by letter, that they would be opened on a particular date, and that then we would decide whether we would sell to the highest bidder or else hold these Ballinahinch properties in the hope that we might get more money for them. The offer, although not a very good one, was an improvement on what could have been secured at the public auction. The decision was taken to sell and I am, personally, very glad to have these properties sold, and I hope the day will soon come when we will be able to say that we have sold the last of the hotel property which the Tourist Board was foolish enough to take on hands.

Contrast will have to be made between the price we got and the price paid for the property, plus the moneys put into the reconstruction, furnishing and adaptation of them. There was a scandalous waste of money both with regard to the purchasing and the equipment, reconstruction and adaptation of them. How any group could ever have promised that these hotels were going to be profit-making concerns passes all comprehension. Yet, solemnly, on every occasion when any of these hotels came forward for purchase, the Tourist Board was always found signing on the dotted line its assurance that these concerns would be profit-making. Experience showed that under the particular company that ran them they were not profit-making. At a time when every boarding-house keeper found it possible to make a good profit, when tourists were coming in here flush with money and anxious to get the good things that this money could buy, the Tourist Board were able to give an example and show that it was possible to lose money on running hotels at that very extraordinarily flush period.

Senator Hawkins was the first to raise the comment which has been repeated by so many others, that the burden of local rates has now got to an oppressive point, that burdens are being passed from the central funds to the rates, and that this is all having an aggravated effect on the country generally and on business in the country. I have a very simple answer to that. There are tables circulated in connection with the Budget and I ask Senators to read them. If they look at Table 4 attached to the Budget of this year, these figures leap to the eye. The aid given by Government grants to local authorities in 1946-7 was £7,040,000; in 1947-8, it was £9,096,000; in 1948-9, it was £9,773,000, and this year it is £12,290,000. We have increased the amount by £2,000,000 on last year when it was up by almost £700,000 on the year before. If you take the comparison with 1946-7, the increase is of the order of £5,250,000 by way of subventions to local rates. How, in the face of these figures, can anybody tell me that the State is passing on a burden to the local authorities? If anybody tells me that, I will await his explanation of the figures.

Senator Hawkins congratulated me on my conversion to the short-wave station. He should hold his breath for a little bit. My conversion may not be found to be either very complete or very lasting. I should like Senators to understand what has happened with regard to the short-wave station. Last year I decided to spend the amount of money in the Estimate on completing the mast rather than sending out a whole lot of material. At that time we had no wavelength. The whole air was cluttered by people trying to broadcast on short-wave stations, and all short-wave wireless was full of interference. In addition, we had been advised that the people whom we wanted to reach in America were installing sets that did not allow them to tune in to short-wave radiation. A conference took place in Mexico towards the end of last year. We sent delegates there to see if it were possible to get short-wave frequencies. What we have got out of the Mexico City conference is a share of short-wave frequencies under a basic plan. That basic plan has to be technically developed and will not come into operation until the middle of 1951. In the meantime, there is to be an attempt to use the frequencies that this country registered some years ago for experimental purposes. The experiment on the short-wave transmission from Athlone was found to be so bad that it was cut out after some months.

There is the possibility that we may be able to achieve a temporary sharing arrangement with the United States of America. We have a sort of understanding with that country and we may be able to make it a real understanding. The best that has been achieved up to date is that we have hopes that by 1951 we will be able to have a sharing of certain short-wave frequencies. That does not get over other difficulties. Short-wave transmissions are far from perfect anywhere and congestion on the waveband is so very severe that no guarantee can be given by anybody or to anybody as regards reception free from interference. That is leaving out altogether the question whether the sets in America will be so tuned as to be able to receive what we send out. These are technical difficulties that were found to be there by the Department of Posts and Telegraphs round about the year 1945. All the other difficulties are still there. There is no international agreement that you can get free a particular wavelength. Any wavelength that you may decide to share appears to be subject to those difficulties. Any country that has a defined band under which it does a short-wave transmission, generally uses two or three wavelengths. Each wavelength means a new station and means in the end competition of one kind or another. Therefore, you have to build not one station but two or three stations in order to get yourself into a really strong position from the point of view of transmission. That is all set out in the memorandum of 1945.

One high power transmitter would appear to be ludicrous. That was set out in 1945 by the then Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and so I suppose the same technical advice would be given now, so that while we are going to have a certain amount of experimentation, let no one think that a short-wave station has a bright career ahead of it. It may have a very brief career and it may be a very costly sort of experiment that we are having, but there are so many people who feel that it was an easy matter to arrange and get transmission that we have decided, even, I think, at an extravagant cost, to make the experiment.

Senator Miss Pearse questioned my attitude towards the Irish language. She said that "economy means wise spending", a definition with which I thoroughly agree of course. The Senator questioned my cutting of subventions to certain papers published in the Irish language. A saving of £17,000 has been mentioned. I have looked through the Estimates to see whether there was, in fact, such a saving, but I cannot find it.

Comment on this

I gave the figures.

Comment on this

I am prepared to guarantee that, by the end of the year, there will have been spent just as much as last year on anything that has to do with Irish. There are economies here and there. When I was before the House with the Finance Bill and when a case was made with regard to the subventions to these papers I said I thought it was right that something should be done in order to bring these people to a better sense of business, and that I would have another look at the matter. With the assistance of the Minister for Education, I did have another look at the matter, and I have agreed to give them subventions as before. There is an extra £5,000 for what, I am instructed, is almost the best way in which Irish can be aided, and that is through the Folklore Commission which is operating in University College, Dublin. I do not find any economies amounting to £17,000—not as far as I can make out from the Book of Estimates. There were economies of a couple of thousand pounds on the Estimates, but I have given that back since. I spoke on this matter before, but possibly it would be interesting if I were to deal with it again. There are three papers, mainly, to which subventions are given.

Comment on this

They are Indiu, Comhar and Feasta. The normal subsidy given to these for years was £1,000 between them. In the year 1948-49 they were given what was expressed to be a very special subsidy to enable them to get their feet under them and so that they could carry on. The full tot of the subsidy in 1948-49 was £7,230, which was expressed to be a very special grant. The circulation of these three papers—and this is only an estimate—is 5,772 copies. That estimate is got by taking the figure for their best week and multiplying it out over the year. We are taking the estimate given to us. There is no accurate calculation because we do not get any figure for returns. If one takes it that all the copies sent out to the country for sale are sold, one would run to 1,700 copies and the others to 1,500 copies.

In no case, in regard to these three papers, did the sales pay even for the printing expenditure. In connection with one of them, Indiu, the receipts were £874, while the printing expenditure alone was £2,000. The full expenditure was £4,295. The sales do not meet the printing expenditure in that case or anything like it. With regard to Comhar, the full sales, advertising, etc., amounted to £253, and the full expenditure to £660, of which the printing accounted for £389. In the case of Feasta, the advertisements and sales amounted to £511, the printing to £657, and the total expenditure to £1,517. The subsidy in the case of Indiu amounts to 1/- a copy. The sale price was 2d. a copy. The subsidy in the case of Comhar is 1/9 a copy, and of Feasta ? a copy.

Comment on this

The Minister did not refer to Ar Aghaidh.

Comment on this

There is a smaller amount for it. It got something in the neighbourhood of £8 a month. There are others, An tUltach and Our Boys, but I have been dealing with the three main ones. I interrupted Senator Mrs. Concannon, when she was speaking, to say that a circulation of 5,000 would get them in the clear. In that I was wrong. The calculation has been made that one would require a circulation of 7,000 copies for its revival.

A calculation was also made with regard to these three Irish papers. There are some people who buy two of them and some people who buy all three. The circulation for the whole lot does not go above 4,000 people; at any rate, the people who buy them, who pay for them, are not more than 4,000 in number. It is a question whether it is worth while keeping on these subventions when there are only 4,000 persons sufficiently interested in the Irish language to buy those papers, which are cheap enough, and as Senator Mrs. Concannon says, are very well produced. The format is excellent and the material in them, I am advised, is very good. The illustrations, and those are the things I understand, are certainly attractive. That is the situation with regard to these Irish publications.

On the opposite side, one has to consider that it is hoped in sufficient time there will be a sufficient number of people interested in Irish who would like to buy these papers in order to get something more than what is in the ordinary textbooks. If these papers were to disappear, there will be nothing but the school textbooks. These publications give an outlet for writers in Irish who may not get an opportunity to circulate their thoughts if these papers were to disappear. It has been explained to me that through these three papers one gets a better flexibility brought about in the Irish language; through them Irish has been adapted to modern needs and a certain literary use has been achieved.

Comment on this

Has any attempt been made to have them used in the schools? If they were circulated in the schools it would be very helpful.

Comment on this

It would be for Comhdháil Náisiúnta to take that up. It was the view in the end which the Minister for Education explained to me, that if we dropped these papers now those people who learn Irish are simply left to the school textbooks and nothing else. It is necessary, therefore, to continue this subvention for some time in order to see if a little more enthusiasm could not be worked up about it. I thought it was necessary that we should bring it home to the people who are enthusiastic about the language that they ought to back up their enthusiasm with a few pence more if they want these papers kept alive. I do not think that State help should be so completely out of proportion to the assistance given by these people, whose enthusiasm about Irish ought to be more marked in relation to these papers. That is the special point so far as those papers are concerned. I will ask the Seanad to accept my assurance that when the end of the financial year comes it will be found that there has not been any saving so far as those Irish papers are concerned. Certain moneys go to to the Foclóir Commission. There is no saving there. The taxpayer has not gained anything because of any attack on the Irish language or on any of the institutions for the encouragement of Irish or that depend on Irish.

Senator Miss Pearse referred to the Government black market. I am very proud of what was done in that connection. So far as subsidised flour and bread are concerned, there is a generous ration and, according to medical authorities, the subsidised flour is the best, and the bread that is made from it is equally the best that one can take. There are people who like white flour, whether it is because of their palates or through some sort of snobbery. The fact remains that there are people who want to buy it and it is lucky for me that they are demanding the production of white flour more and more. It saves a good deal by way of subvention if people want to pay more for that article than for an article that the medical profession will tell you is better. If those people wish to pay more, I think that is an attitude of mind on their part that we should favour and acclaim and we should not annoy them by saying they are going into the black market. They are quite entitled to buy it if they want to, just as any person is entitled to buy a very highly priced motor car while others are obliged to purchase a cheap one.

With regard to sugar, manufacturers get sugar at the economic price. There is a practice of allowing sugar at certain periods of the year in connection with honey-making. If it goes beyond using sugar for honey-making, and if people want to buy quantities of sugar over and above the ration, well and good; as long as they pay me the higher price for it, I will be in a position to use that to cover the rationing of sugar at the cheaper price. As regards tea, it ought to be regarded as another progressive movement instead of being condemned as a black market device.

I would like to answer Senator Buckley but I think I will leave it over to another occasion. Senator Summer-field has spoken critically of the application of the phrase "luxury hotels". I feel when that phrase is used it is used deliberately to criticise expenditure by the State on hotels of the type beyond the reach of the means of most of the population. We are catering for the luxury type and even there they miss their aim. They are the type of people who do not want to go to the type of hotel that they can get in abundance in their own countries; they want something more racy of the soil. I think I agree that there could be an improvement.

Senator Honan was the first Senator to raise this matter of valuation. May I say comprehensively that there is not a word of truth in what was alleged here with regard to a secret and confidential circular to put the valuation officers on the track of premises? There has been no movement on the part of any official of my Department to get a revaluation. Senator Honan and Senator Fitzsimons spoke about it and Senator O'Reilly made a little reference to it—Senator O'Reilly spoke more mildly. If the truth were known, Senator Honan and Senator Fitzsimons should be rail-roaded out of their respective towns, because it is the local authorities to which they belong that start the whole thing. I said that by way of interruption, and it is perfectly sound. The secretary of the local authority writes and asks to have a valuation officer sent down to look after certain buildings. That is how it starts.

The Valuation Office do not take the initiative. They may take the initiative with regard to a new licensed premises that was an ordinary dwelling house and that obtained a licence and, in consequence, has assumed a new character, or where a building is extended —where a person purchases it and puts on an extension and parades it possibly as a hotel. They will take the initiative where some spectacular thing attracts the attention of the valuation people, but in the main—I am speaking as I am advised—there was no circular, confidential or otherwise, no whispering, no hinting. Nothing has gone from the officials of the Department of Finance or the Revenue Commissioners endeavouring to encourage the local authorities to get busy about revaluation. Wherever that takes place, it is the local authority that is responsible.

Comment on this

Is not the local secretary liable to severe penalties if he does not take the initiative?

Comment on this

I never heard of that. Does the Senator discriminate between new buildings or a place like a new licensed house?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

I will look into that because I must have an amazing amount of heavy penalties to collect from secretaries of local authorities.

Comment on this

Suppose the local authority give no direction by way of resolution to their secretary to make a request for the revaluation of any properties within the jurisdiction of the local authority, what view would the Minister take then? He has put one side of it.

Comment on this

I would certainly be very annoyed, but whether or not I could do anything about it I do not know. That, however, is getting away from the original point. The allegation here is that the local authority does not do it. I do not do it. I have nothing to do with it.

Comment on this

The official has his eye on the Customs House rather than on the local authority that pays him.

Comment on this

It is not for me to advise the local authority to get into bad ways. I am merely saying what the facts are. It was also alleged that these increased valuations had resulted in very, heavy extra payments to the Electricity Supply Board. I tried to get some advice from the Electricity Supply Board about that last night, but I was not able to make contact with anyone in the Electricity Supply Board, and I do not know what exactly the situation is. I did, however, hear this matter discussed some time ago and I was told by a member of the board that increased money from revaluation of premises is inconsiderable. With regard to the public-houses, I quoted here last night in an interruption the relevant figures for the last six years. In six years the receipts from the duties paid on licensed premises had only increased by £3,000, that was the increase in the total revenue collected from licensed premises over that period. In that period the number of retailers, and the total number is something less than 15,000 people in the entire community, had increased by something short of 200. On the figures I have here the average valuation works out at about £9. If you take the new off-licensed or fully licensed premises and multiply that by eight it makes up practically the whole of the extra £3,000. In that six years, therefore, nothing certainly accrued to revenue through licensed premises having been brought under the sway of the Revenue Commissioners.

I am sorry that Senator Honan is not here because I would like to talk to him about the property tax. I refer to the famous five-fourths. Property is now valued at one-quarter over its real valuation for certain taxation purposes. I would have liked to remind both Senator Honan and Senator Fitzsimons that they were for many years associated with the Minister who put on that extra one-fourth and they encouraged him to do that. They were also behind that Minister when he previously withdrew the allowance on house property for repairs. That meant in the end that, not merely had he increased the property notionally for tax purposes by one-fourth, but he had also increased it by 50 per cent. I do not know whether Senators will remember, but those who were members of the Dáil will remember, the great flourish with which the then Minister introduced that tax. He talked of it being like the little grain of mustard seed which "will grow into a mighty tree, beneath whose foliage luckier Ministers for Finance than I will sit at ease to catch the glittering prizes as they fall". If I am getting the glittering prizes I must put it to the glittering credit of Deputy MacEntee, who put on that tax.

Senator Fearon raised the matter of the civil list. That has been considered here over and over again. In the end the decision of many Ministers in many Governments has been against it. It would not be of very much help. The subvention given in the English civil list at the moment on a budget of £3,500,000,000 is in the neighbourhood of £32,000. If we reduce that down to our modest budget here it would mean that we would give something in the neighbourhood of £700 by way of civil list. There would be too many applicants for it and one would find it quite impossible to give anything really valuable. On the whole, it has been decided that there is no case for a civil list here. Possibly another view will prevail hereafter.

Senator Fearon also raised the subject of the tax on musical instruments. I know that it is not a sufficient answer to tell him that those instruments have been taxed for many years. That tax is part of the old "McKenna Duties" taken over in 1922. They have lasted ever since. I do not know if anybody has ever drawn attention to them before as being detrimental to culture. We will look into that matter before this time next year.

He also spoke about emigration in a rather persuasive way. He said that there was an attraction overseas and that that attraction was the pull. He said that we must try to equalise that pull. I cannot agree that we shall ever do that. As far as material considerations are concerned we cannot offer anything in the region of the scale that America holds out. Senator Fearon said that we were exploiting the love of home and country. I can reply to that by saying that all countries do that; otherwise, there would be a complete intellectual and cultural flight to the United States or to South America, where material conditions are undoubtedly far better than either impoverished Europe or this country can provide. We are trying to equalise that by improving amenities at home and giving incentives to people to remain here and work here.

With regard to Senator Quirke's contribution I want to say that I feel no great shame in having helped to get rid of the cavalry escort. Senator Quirke and other Senators may like to know that it was not any antagonism to horses that caused that escort to be dispensed with. I was in Government when the escort was first established. I found to my amazement and horror that some of the uniforms that the first cavalry escort were dressed in were still in existence. It was a question of uniforms having to be remade. It was a question whether it was wise in these days to start to bring out these "Blue Hussars" again, as they were called, or whether we would not become more modern and go in for the motor-cyclist and his peculiar uniform. The change was made. I think it is a good change. I do not think that those who come to buy horses will be annoyed because we escort a diplomat through the streets of Dublin with a fleet of motor-cycles instead of horses. We have plenty of use for our horses in other ways and we show them to great purpose in other ways.

Senator O'Farrell referred to juvenile delinquents. I must ask him to excuse me from going into that subject at the moment. It is a very technical matter. I am sure the Senator knows that my colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, has spoken on this subject on many occasions both before he became a Minister and since. The Senator must wait and see what improvements are made. I agree with what is said with regard to the segregation he would like to have as between the ordinary delinquent and the person who is steeped in crime. That is something we would like to have but, as will be appreciated, there are difficulties in the way.

With regard to Senator Mrs. Concannon's plea for teachers' pensions and the way in which they will be paid, I understand that the Department will pay the lowest group first. That will merely be in accordance with charity. I am also informed by the Department that the payment of these new pensions will cause a good deal of administrative difficulty and there may be some delay. To use a trite phrase, there will be no avoidable delay. The Department is concerned to make the payments. At the moment it is in touch with my Department, in an effort to evolve a more simplified procedure to enable pensions to be paid more rapidly.

With regard to the harbours, I would draw the Senator's attention to the fact that the provision for harbours this year is up by £43,000. Whether Galway is specially provided for in that I cannot say. I rather think it is not. If it is not included, it is because the Department mainly concerned is interested in certain other harbours. I think that Arklow is included in the provision that has been made.

Senator Burke also spoke on the question of the ratepayers and the heavy burden that is placed on them. He went to the point of indicating reliefs that could be given, reliefs which could be secured by taking more from, so to speak, the people of large incomes. People with large incomes are fairly heavily taxed at the moment. Some of these days I will get a table made out to show how taxation impacts upon the people of £2,000 income and over. From that I except businesses. It may be that certain businesses making profits of, say, something in the supertax area could afford to pay more although I doubt if any of them would be willing to pay much more, but I can keep that as a programme in mind for the future.

Senator McCartan spoke of the musicians. I asked for some advice on that and have been told—and I am speaking entirely on the advice I have got—that it is incorrect for the Senator to say that none of the foreign musicians brought in here recently has an international reputation. The present conductor, undoubtedly, is a man of good international repute. He was engaged by the Department on the advice of an expert committee. They wanted a person, not so much from the point of view of what he would do in connection with the orchestra, but of being able to train.

Comment on this

I did not mean to say that there was none of them. What I meant was the majority.

Comment on this

That would be in agreement with what I have been told. The phrase used was that none was of international reputation.

Comment on this

Maybe I said that but I do not think I did.

Comment on this

The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs advises me that he is very anxious to use native talent to the fullest but that he, on the advice of people whom he regards as entitled to advise him in this matter, feels it is better to proceed along the lines he is going, that is, to bring in certain foreign players to train some of the others and also conductors to conduct and also to train. The Department wants it to be understood that it is the intention to promote all facilities possible for the training of native talent and the hope is that they will be able to provide their own conductors and players as required and to do that in a very short space of time.

I think I may remark to the Senator that the Department of Posts and Telegraphs are only doing what was done in other concerns that were founded here. When the Shannon scheme was first inaugurated there was a good deal of controversy over the fact that certain German engineers were brought on to the job. The same explanation was given then and was not accepted then. The purpose of bringing in those German engineers, who were very, very expert in certain types of work, was to train the young Irish engineers so that they could replace them. The argument was that once you let them into the country you would not be able to get rid of them. The situation as it developed was that during the war years, so far as the power-house at Ardnacrusha was concerned, all the machinery that was there, and which was very much overworked, all the sets of turbines, were put out of commission during the dry season—the period that is operating now—and were in turn taken to bits, overhauled, repaired and put back again in full condition with such good results that there was not a solitary hour lost during the whole period of the war through failure in machinery. The fact that that machinery was kept up to trim in the way it was was entirely due to the work of the Irish technicians who had been trained by the Germans. The suggestion was that we brought the Germans here to train when we could have sent our people abroad to get trained. We took the line of bringing the Germans here and the Department of Posts and Telegraphs, possibly because they were sending this to me, give that as an example of precedent with regard to the foreign musicians.

Comment on this

The Minister has a sympathetic audience here to-night. I find, perhaps in my old age, that I cannot hear as well as I could. Might I appeal to the Minister to raise his voice slightly, without causing any distress to himself? One of the few speeches I am prepared to read in the Official Debates is the speech of the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

I am sorry. If I had only known, I would have talked much more loudly, even with less effect. Senator Fitzsimons was mainly on the question of the valuations. That I have dealt with. On this matter about the grants for the reconstruction of houses—a point that I had not known anything about—I have been instructed since that the reason why the grant is not given to farmers of £35 valuation and over is because a farmer of that type is supposed to be in such comfortable circumstances that he can, so to speak, fend for himself. The £35 is the limit now. It had been £25 up to a couple of years ago.

I will leave Senator O'Brien over for the moment, because he dealt with general tax and finance and the general set up of the country and I would like to end on that.

Senator Colgan complained of the Industrial Development Authority on the ground that there is no representative of the trade union movement. I would point out to him, in contrast to what he has said, that there is no representative of the employers' side either. There are people who are chosen, so to speak, as being from the two sides but they are not chosen to represent and there was no association with, say, the Employers' Federation or the Federation of Irish Manufacturers when the two people whom he referred to as employers' representatives were put on.

Comment on this

It worked that way. They are two employers. There are no trade union people.

Comment on this

The build up is that way. The individual was chosen. I can understand the Senator's criticism of him. He was chosen as a person who stood for employees.

Comment on this

He never did stand for employees.

Comment on this

Well, now!

Comment on this

Shame.

Comment on this

He was Secretary of the Labour Party. He has not been connected with the trade union movement as such for the last 20 years.

Comment on this

He has been, as long as I have known him, which is a fair while, associated with workers and I think he would have their viewpoint and that is why he was put on to represent. Senators asked me about stopping the income-tax at the source in the case of various workers, that is to say, the low income groups. I can give that some consideration but, in opposition to it, there is the fact that a strike broke out in Belfast over the application of that particular system and, secondly, the experience of "pay as you earn" in England has been none too happy. I have seen many comments—they may be prejudiced comments of people with particular viewpoints—that that system has led to a good deal of absenteeism and slackness, that people work up to a certain point and then find that something is being cut off their wages and they stop at that point. There is also the other point and it is one that affects me more as a consideration. I have heard it said that in England it developed to this point, that people looked at what they got in their pay packet, that is to say, the amount less income-tax, and said "that is my wages" and then asked for more. I would rather give them more and take a little back from them. At least, then, there can be no doubt as to what they are getting as wages. I do not want to have that psychological element working against us.

Comment on this

It is like the juggler— there would be no deception whatever.

Comment on this

There is no deception, and it also makes them a little more careful about calling for increases in income-tax because it is going to hit themselves.

Senator Lynch I found hard to follow. His statements about emigration were just too ludicrous to be believed. I would like to be referred to any statement made by members of the present Government that they had an immediate remedy or even an early remedy for such things as emigration, unemployment or Partition. They said they thought there were better approaches to these problems—I have said it myself—than what had been previously and I think we have a better approach at the moment. When the Senator spoke of the reduction in the subventions for fertilisers, and the moneys for farm building schemes, I despaired of him. The fertiliser subvention was to bring fertilisers down to a certain point. Fertilisers are now down to that point. Is it demanded that we should continue to subsidise fertilisers even to the point where we would be giving a man some money back with fertilisers? I think when you have got it down below the point to which the subsidy would bring it, enough has been done.

As to the farm buildings scheme, it has been debated over and over again. The farm buildings scheme as projected was a sham. The Minister for Industry and Commerce wrote to the Minister for Agriculture and said: "You may talk all you like about the farm buildings scheme and write any amount of money into the Estimate, but, if it means cement, you will not get a bag". In fact, he got no cement. There were no farm buildings schemes stopped for the sake of money. It was a scheme that never could be operated because there was not enough cement in the country. We are getting enough cement now and the scheme will be operated.

Senator McCrea complained of rates being too high, but he also gave a good deal of information which I will have brought to the notice of some of my colleagues in regard to these building costs. With regard to the harbours on the east coast, attention is being paid to these, but they have to be taken in a certain order of priority. The Senator certainly cannot claim that Arklow has not got enough dredging apparatus at particular times. There are certain critical periods when I am always being called to the phone because a new silting has occurred in Arklow and a dredger has to be diverted from Waterford or some other port and ordered to go to Arklow. I feel that the dredger has a home from home in Arklow.

Comment on this

I am perfectly satisfied that too much money has been spent on dredging in Arklow, without any result.

Comment on this

Maybe there is too much patching and possibly we will have to do a thorough scheme of reconstruction. I am glad to get the Senator's approval and that of certain other Senators of the scheme in regard to the prices of flour, sugar and all the other things that were condemned.

Senator O'Callaghan asked me about devaluation of the £ and spoke about our sterling assets.

Comment on this

External assets.

Comment on this

I do not know what he wants me to say about it. Does he want me to say whether the £ is going to be devalued or not? I do not think anybody could say at the moment. In that connection, what does he ask me to say about sterling assets?

Comment on this

Our external assets.

Comment on this

They are sterling assets. I find in a paper which I got to-night a comment which the Senator might ponder over. It is an excerpt from a lecture delivered on October 15th, 1948, in University College, Dublin, under the auspices of the Institute of Bankers, its title being: "The Future of the Sterling Area." The lecture was given by Mr. Paul Bareau, Assistant City Editor of the News Chronicle, and this is an extract from it, in reference to the circumstances surrounding our currency:

"As a result, sterling balances leaped up. The mechanism did a job for which it was never intended. How would you in Ireland have reacted in 1939 to a suggestion that you should lend Britain £200,000,000 for an indefinite period and at around ½ per cent.? Why, the people to whom such a proposition was put would never have recovered from the impudence and apparent impracticability of that proposal. Yet that is exactly what you have done—imperceptibly, unconsciously, merely by going on using traditional methods, by trusting to the old banking mechanism..."

—and this is where I bring the Senator more or less to my reply to him:—

"...and, by doing so, you have forged new links between yourselves and the sterling area, more than 200,000,000 of them, which you will find it more difficult to sever than their counterpart in the political field."

Would the Senator consider that an answer, because all that was done in the face of opposition which the then Deputy Mulcahy, myself and others raised against the Central Bank Bill when it was going through Dáil Éireann?

The Senator has asked about removing control from, I suppose, pigs and bacon. I personally wish that we could get rid of the Pigs and Bacon Board and I hope we will have the Senator's support when the happy day arrives when we shall be moving towards that. As was explained long ago, a scheme was set on foot of having what was called a hypothetical price for pigs. The Senator will remember what the other phrase was— I forget it at the moment—but somebody said that it resulted not in the price becoming hypothetical but in the pig becoming hypothetical, and there is no doubt that the Pigs and Bacon Board caused havoc in the whole pig and bacon industry. It is a sign of the times to see Senator O'Callaghan sitting where he sits and encouraging the removal of control. When I look at the grounds on which he asks that control be removed, however, I begin to be doubtful, because I am not credulous enough to take in the story of the bacon curer who continued in business losing £100,000 in five years and who is going to continue in business this year at a loss of £50,000.

Comment on this

During the emergency, I served on many wages tribunals and we dealt on more than one occasion with the bacon curing industry and certainly the figures given to us of the losses of these people were colossal. I have no interest in saying that beyond my wish to bear out the statement of Senator O'Callaghan. They were losing money in twenties of thousands of pounds yearly. They were losing money for a long period and we did not believe the statements made by them until they produced the figures.

Comment on this

If these people are going to continue in business in that way——

Comment on this

My concern is with the pig producer.

Comment on this

I want to give the Senator an example. I know one person who recently set out to buy a bacon factory. He was paying a big price for it and I think the deal has gone through by this time. A man is not going to go down to buy a curer's concern if the whole business is as bad as the Senator makes out. The other matter of fact of which he spoke—at least, he spoke of it as a matter of fact—was this point, that, if you build a poultry house with foreign timber, you get a subsidy, but you get no subsidy if it is built of native timber. Senator Hawkins spoke of that, too—he knew it. There is not a word of truth in it.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that.

Comment on this

Why say it?

Comment on this

Because I have been refused a subsidy in respect of a poultry house made of native timber.

Comment on this

Was it because it was made of native timber? The statement made was that there was a system under which no subsidy was paid in respect of a poultry house, if native timber was used. I have had inquiries made in the Department of Agriculture in the meantime and there is not a word of truth in it.

Comment on this

There is a difference between a poultry house and a hatchery to which the Senator referred.

Comment on this

There is not a particle of truth, either, in the suggestion with regard to hatcheries. Is there a mistake about this? In the case of egg boxes——

Comment on this

I am not referring to egg boxes.

Comment on this

I need not bother about it, then. There is not a scintilla of truth in the suggestion that there is a subsidy for poultry houses built of foreign timber, and——

Comment on this

I have no documents with me to prove it.

Comment on this

You could not prove it.

Comment on this

Will the Senator be paid the grant now?

Comment on this

No, because the grant is given on the basis of what is called suitable timber. There might be unsuitable native timber and unsuitable foreign timber, but there is no distinction between native and foreign timber. So I am assured, and I cannot do any more than give the Senator what I have been told by the Department concerned. I have too many of these statements flung at me here which, on investigation, prove to be as completely wrong as this.

Comment on this

Will the Minister accept that what I say is true, that I was refused a subsidy myself?

Comment on this

I want to be assured by the Senator that he was refused on the ground that there was a principle of giving subsidies in respect of foreign timber poultry houses and refusing a subsidy if the poultry house was built of timber of native origin. I do not think he would be able to produce any such document or statement.

Comment on this

Well, we will see.

Comment on this

For the time being, I am authorised by the Department of Agriculture to say that the statements to that effect made to-night are what James Stephens used to call "a tissue". There is not a word of truth in them.

I was glad to hear Senator Ryan come out with what has been spoken of often and often with regard to unemployment. We have an amazing situation in which we have a register which has varied between 40,000 and 60,000 people over the last 20 years and it has been explained that the hard core of that unemployment is about 20,000. While that is there still, it is less and has been reduced from time to time but the various boards such as Bord na Móna and the Electricity Supply Board have still jobs open and cannot get men to go to them. Why is that? There is no doubt about it; a habit of mind has been induced in the people here during the last Administration and they think that they are entitled to get work more or less around their own neighbourhood or homes and more or less at the rates of pay which they think fit for them to work at. That is not the unemployment assistance code. If they are willing to work and available for work they ought to take work and if not they have no right to demand public assistance.

Senator O'Reilly has in the main travelled over ground which is unfamiliar to me. Therefore I cannot reply to him. There was one point which I brought before one of my colleagues who is conversant with the matter, that is, that rating between counties is unfair and that a new system ought to be established and modifications made by a series of grants. I do not mind what happens as long as the round sum of the grant is the same or less. While Senator O'Reilly was talking he turned to Senator Fitzsimons as though he were a rich neighbour who should be bled for the needs of Leitrim.

Comment on this

You do that with the richer people when you collect income-tax.

Comment on this

I hope that Senator Fitzsimons recognises himself in the rôle of rich neighbour who must be bled in order to satisfy Senator O'Reilly's needs. I will have the matter examined, however. I do not know what difficulties are attendant on it.

The Senator went on to say that the grants in aid of the Transition Development Fund had been cut. I felt inclined to question him at the time and I want to question him now. There has been no reduction in those grants. There is money in that fund and the money has been allocated in the same way as always obtained. A rough and ready percentage which should be the subject of intricate calculation cannot work out a precise valuation of the old costs to the new costs. That is only done when there is some new element of increased costs, but certainly they have not changed downwards since I came in contact with them.

He referred, I think by way of criticism, to a statement that appeared in the papers, a statement that does naturally occur in the Irish Press, about motor cars for Ministers. There have been three new motor cars. The Irish Press would want us to believe that there were a whole fleet of new motor cars. There are three new motor cars on the road, of which one is to replace a secondhand Chevrolet which was purchased in 1945 and was used as a taxi. Since then it has done something short of 50,000 miles and there is no record of the mileage before purchase. The second was also purchased secondhand in 1945. There is no record of mileage before purchase and since it has done about 30,000 miles. The other is a very old bird which was purchased in 1945 and has done 100,000 miles.

Comment on this

Time to put it out on grass.

Comment on this

About time. The Irish Press makes a point about radio sets. Radio sets were not asked for. There was a ruling that radio sets would not be put in Ministers' cars and it was only done when they were demanded by the last Administration. Now they are supplied because they are part of the standard equipment of these cars and you cannot get these cars without them.

Comment on this

Oh, no. For goodness' sake. You can buy Dodge cars without a wireless.

Comment on this

You cannot get these cars without it, and if the Senator wants it I will sell him one from these cars.

Comment on this

I will accept that offer, but it is untrue——

Comment on this

There has been no talk of the cost. The Senator will take it.

Comment on this

There speaks the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

I will pass him the radio and he will pass back whatever is on the bill.

Comment on this

I am sure it will be a first-class set, but I want to place on record that I am in entire disagreement with the Minister when he says that cars of the type supplied to Ministers cannot be got without a radio attached.

Comment on this

I have information, as against that, that cars cannot be purchased without a wireless attached.

Comment on this

It is a difference of opinion.

Comment on this

A difference of accuracy and the Senator's group has not a good reputation.

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest that I am telling a lie?

Comment on this

Not at all. I say that it is a record of misstatement—I have made that statement of many people without accusing them of lying. The Senator is badly instructed.

Comment on this

No, the Senator is not badly instructed. The Minister is speaking of his own knowledge, but time will tell.

Comment on this

Senator O'Reilly was not complaining at all——

Comment on this

When the attention of people down town is drawn to the fact that present members of the Oireachtas, Ministers, can buy cars, they ask what about the saving of dollars.

Comment on this

The answer is that these motor cars were purchased from stock and no dollars were supplied for the purchase of motor cars for members of the Government. They were in stock, in other words, the traders had got a previous allocation of dollars. There are allocations for the purchase of motor cars. Senators will realise that if all dollar motor cars were to be kept out certain firms would be thrown on the road. Therefore, very small allocations have been given. There has been an attempt to get these people to go to some other agency or assemblers.

Comment on this

I can state therefore that no particular allocations have been made for the purchase of these cars?

Comment on this

Quite definitely. Senator Professor Stanford was on the same point, I think, that Senator Professor O'Brien was on, on the general point with regard to the finances of the State. I agree that a good deal of confusion must be caused in the minds of citizens by the various appeals to save on the one hand and to have a bit of a gamble on the other. At the same time the appeals to the people to work, produce and save appear to have more effect than the others. The Senator will no doubt have learned that small savings are up, and up considerably, and certainly the record we have regarding production both in field and factory and the amount we have exported away to England and elsewhere all tend to show that the savings campaign and the campaign to work more and produce more have effect. I do not say this in any spirit of joy, but one has also seen for some time that the sweepstake is on the decline. It has taken a new turn and in the situation in which we find ourselves we ought to congratulate the board of the Hospitals' Trust that they have been able to get the decline arrested. Efforts have been made here and people are looking to get the old habits of sober industry, saving and thrift by setting aside a certain amount for their old age and insecurity of various kinds. The greatest confusion is caused, to my mind, by all the talk that goes on about trying to bribe the people in Northern Ireland to come down to us by offers of social security and schemes with higher and higher rates all the time. I do not think we are ever going to get these people in on that basis; or at least the people you would get in might not be worth while if you got them here.

If we could get a better type of life and a different standard of life, we could get a better alternative to all these matters of social services, namely, a system in which we try to get workers into good employment, to give them their footing on the managerial side of whatever the employment may be, to operate, in other words, along the lines of the Vocational Organisation Commission Report and try to raise the wages standard to the point where people would be enabled to provide for themselves. That is a far better type of life and a far more attractive and more wholesome type of life to give them than the life in which, in the end, it would come to the State taking over all that a man earns, giving him a little bit by way of pocket money and providing the medical, dental and other services for him.

Senator Stanford asked about the book embargo. I suppose he refers to the prohibition on the entry of Irish books into England. I am not saying that this is the explanation that ought to be accepted, but the explanation that has been given about it is that part of the terms of the Anglo-American Loan, the loan that came before Marshall Aid, was that there should be no discrimination. I recall a very vivid phrase that was used to me in a conference I attended—"that you know very little about religious zealotry or enthusiasm until you meet an American fired with ‘non-discrimination'—it is almost a religion". The Americans have apparently decided—at least, the United Kingdom authorities say that if they admit freely books from this country they must open the flood gates to all the American literature that would pour in. They have no objection to books coming from this country, but once they make a breach in the dykes everything else will flood in. I know that they can point to the clauses about non-discrimination attached to the American Loan, but whether that is the real case or what someone says it is, that is the explanation given.

Comment on this

I wonder could the Minister say whether there is the same embargo on French or Belgian books going into England; and, secondly, whether a direct effort has been made with the British Government to free us from this clause, as I do think the effort is worth making.

Comment on this

I know that in June, 1948, a good deal of effort was made on that point and whoever was representing the British authorities in this matter made the case to us as I have made it. It was said: "If you people can use your good influence and your authority with the Americans to get them to the point of saying that they would not regard entry of books from Ireland as contravening the non-discrimination clause, we would be prepared to let the books in."

Comment on this

Has that been done?

Comment on this

Efforts have been made with the Americans, but unsuccessfully.

Comment on this

I understand that the Minister for External Affairs raised it.

Comment on this

It has been pursued from both quarters. There is a good deal of suspicion that the whole case has not been stated, that a different case can be made.

Comment on this

It has been stated frequently that American did insert a "most favoured nation" clause in that agreement and it prevented anybody else from getting literature into England unless the Americans could do so as well.

Comment on this

There is no doubt that the clause is there and it would operate if the Americans would like to make it operate. I understand that the same situation does hold with regard to books from other countries, but on that point I am not speaking with the same background of information as I have on the other matter.

Senator O'Brien has spoken about the height of taxation. In anything he says on that, I fully agree and wish to be in association with him. The fact is that high taxes are undoubtedly a discouragement to savings and investment. It may be that one of these days the real problem which will develop will be the dearth of savings. We require a vast amount of money for the projects that are ahead of us. In another connection, I have drawn Senators' attention to the amount of money we have made available this year for capital projects—in the region of £20,000,000. We require money to finance that. There is £12,600,000 shown in "under the line" expenditure in the White Paper issued in connection with the Budget this year, but that £12,600,000 must, on the explanation given in the Budget, be reckoned as almost £16,000,000, and if one adds in the £1,500,000 under the Local Authorities (Works) Act and another £1,000,000, at least, under the land reclamation project, there is a figure of nearly £20,000,000.

Now, that sum requires a good deal of getting, and when I went to the public this year I did not get all that I asked for from them. I got as much as, with the money from public funds, gave me the amount required for the year. There are quite big sums required for capital development here, and the getting of those sums may become a very serious and difficult matter in the near future. In the end, it all goes back to whether we are spending, even on these capital projects, at a rate that has far outpaced the savings of the community. That, of course, carries its own repercussions in other ways folk do not like to talk of here, as one could collapse a good deal of the expenditure but there would be hardship caused. For the time being we have decided to look at one side of the picture, while not neglecting the other, and to try to get production up, to get exports up, and to rectify the balance of payments. Therefore, we decided we could take a certain chance on the two aspects, that we may be delving too deeply into savings and going beyond savings, and, on the other hand, we may be aggravating an inflationary tendency already present. We took that chance in the hope of getting increased production, which we have since secured.

The Senator also raised the point of certain economies in the public service and asked as to whether we had too many civil servants. I have that under definite investigation in the last year and a half. One might not merely ask about the increase in the number of civil servants there are in the State. The public generally do not know that, in addition to the increased numbers in the public service, there is quite a big amount of money paid for overtime to those who are in the service. In fact, it has been represented to me that some of the economies that were attempted, in the way of preventing recruitment of new civil servants, had an uneconomic result, as it meant that we paid in overtime more than we would have paid in getting new civil servants.

The Senator went on to ask whether civil servants did as much work as a person in an outside occupation. On that point, I think there is a good deal of popular misconception. There is often in comic papers a view presented of civil servants as people who come in very late to the office and spend the morning reading the newspapers and then go out to lunch and on coming back in the afternoon doze a bit and take things as easy as possible until it is time to sign off. These people are paraded as civil servants. It is not a correct statement with regard to any civil servant that I know of, and I doubt if amongst the vast multitude that I cannot know it applies to any but a very small fraction of people who are not anxious to work, the kind that you will find anywhere. Civil servants are being made do more work than they ought to be made do and not, in the main, made do useful work. But again, Deputies, Senators, the Comptroller and Auditor-General and the whole framework of the State are responsible for that. If I as Minister have to be in a position that I may have to answer a question on any point affecting the various sections of my Department, then at each point there must be some civil servant who has his files marked in such a way that, first of all, he is trying to prevent errors happening and again trying to secure that, whenever errors happen, the responsibility can be laid immediately at somebody's door. All that has grown up in our Civil Service.

There is no doubt that the system needs considerable overhauling and we are attempting to get it done, but only in a very slight way. In the main, it is the system Deputies and Senators and the Comptroller and Auditor-General helped to operate. That is responsible for the Civil Service doing all this meticulous work—aiming at perfect accuracy, trying to prevent the slightest mistake, and so forth. No business firm would stand that. The boss would take responsibility all the time. In his case he is his own boss and would not have to answer to the public. But you have a situation where everything has to be done with the opinion that at some time or another a bit of a public search may be cast upon some recess of the Department.

Comment on this

The defect is in the system, not in the individuals.

Comment on this

It is in the system and the people who operate the system. Firstly, Deputies and Senators then——

Comment on this

It is in Parliamentary Government.

Comment on this

I do not think that it is, but we have it in the Parliamentary Government we have here. I can assure the Senator, however, that in a very limited way I am trying to get certain things done which I hope will ease the amount of work of little or no value that a lot of civil servants have imposed upon them, and let these people of great ability occupy themselves in more useful ways. I take the Senator's remark to heart that we should not go too rapidly. I do not care if anybody pins that on social services and writes letters to the effect that I am responsible for all the great delay. Social services want a good deal of consideration and they will get it and, even when they have got it, it may be that an excellent scheme cannot be put into force immediately because the State cannot stand it just now.

The Senator came to a conclusion on the matter of university education and financial help. I have heard it said over and over again that nearly every Minister for Finance has some special bee in his bonnet. With regard to a predecessor of mine it was said that his particular bee was the Irish language. I need not mention what the others were. It was alleged against me to be university education although some of my former colleagues have said that they have not seen much signs of it yet. I hope, however, to give them some earnest of it, possibly in the near future. Senator O'Brien need not talk to me about the scandalous position of higher education in this country and most particularly in the institution to which both he and I belong, University College, Dublin. It never got a proper building grant. Even the meagre building grant it got more or less did not cover what it was intended to cover because of the outbreak of the 1914-18 war. That university system has now gone through two wars. All that happened between was not a great deal— almost nothing was added in the way of a general endowment. The college never got a chance. It never got a proper building. It was described in a certain newspaper article which caused a good deal of offence as something in the nature of a cultural slum. The building is certainly not a building one would like to show visitors around. All the staff have been kept on very definite rations for a very long time. When I find myself approached from time to time about pensions schemes for impoverished people who have given service in the different walks of life in this country, I still think of the fund University College, Dublin, has with regard to those who retire from its service. Some of the best informed, most cultured, most educated men—and good teachers and professors in their different subjects—are landed out at the end of their lives on benefactions one would hate to mention in any civilised company. It is scandalous to think of some men I know who are walking round this city on miserable pension allowances.

Comment on this

The Minister, in his excess of enthusiasm, may have exaggerated the position of certain pensioners of University College, Dublin. Those of us who are members of the governing body have always had that before our minds and I do not think it should be let go through this House without contradiction that the Minister for Finance should say that there are former professors of University College, Dublin, who are walking about Dublin City with miserable pensions. It is not true.

Comment on this

It depends on the standard of misery in relation to the talent bought at the particular rate. I still stick to my phrase. Senator O'Brien wound up with the question of the balance of payments. He said that we had improved in that respect. We have improved considerably. Counting the invisibles, the adverse balance was brought down—comparing 1948 with 1947—from a £30,000,000 gap to a £15,000,000 gap. In addition to that, the trade returns for the first five months of this year show that in comparison with the first five months of 1948 exports have risen by £5,000,000 and imports have been brought down by £10,000,000. The returns that are just out for June show that the tendencies that were marked in the first five months of this year have not merely continued but have increased and increased beneficially to us, in the month of June. All the general matters of our export trade have seen an increase in the first five months of this year and, very particularly, in this month. Therefore, the balance of payments has been brought down but, as the Senator has said, there is still a disquieting gap. It is getting as much attention as we can give it.

I have left over one matter, the question of the cost of living. The cost-of-living figure at mid-May of this year was down ten points on the cost-of-living figure of mid-May of the year before. The cost-of-living figure—I am speaking of the old figure—as at mid-May of this year was the lowest it had been since May, 1947. I am pointing to that at the end of this rather lengthy speech because I have admitted to Senator O'Brien that some of the projects we embarked on, meaning the spreading of a good deal of money through the country, might have caused inflation. It is rather a notable thing and some people may say it is a mere matter of luck but we can congratulate ourselves on the fact that, while we have stabilised at a high point wages and emoluments throughout the country and increased emoluments to civil servants, and so forth, of all types, we have still been able to reduce the cost of living by ten points.

There is another cost-of-living figure, the new cost-of-living figure. Recently the Government to which I belong was criticised in that it was alleged that we had cut certain items out of the index figure and in that way had brought about a fictitious change. We have done nothing of the sort. No instruction was issued to the Director of Statistics about how to compile the cost-of-living figure. He compiled it on the orders which he had previously got. But he got orders previously. It is rather interesting to see the growth of a particular idea and the germ of a rather bad idea, I am sorry to say, brought about here in this Seanad. Speaking in the Seanad on the 16th January, 1947, the then Minister for Industry and Commerce, now Deputy Lemass, comparing the index figure here with the figure in England, spoke of our figure as being a realistic figure and said that the English figure was a bit of a fictitious one. He said:—

"What I want to point out is that much lower allowance in the British index for clothing and sundries— sundries, including tobacco, drink, amusement and travel, the costs of which have risen enormously in Great Britain—and the much higher allowance for rent,..."

He added:—

"The British Government deliberately endeavoured to keep down the cost-of-living index, not to keep down the cost of living."

Remember, that this speech was made in the Seanad on the 16th January, 1947. He continued:—

"They imposed heavy taxation upon tobacco and drink which were weighted very lightly in their cost-of-living index, and used the revenue secured from these heavy taxes to subsidise food prices which were weighted highly."

In June, 1947, the then Minister for Finance, now Deputy Aiken, objecting to a comparison that was made in the Seanad between the various income levels and payments made in England and here, said, speaking of taxation in England:—

"All those matters have to be taken into account as well as the taxation on things like beer and whiskey which is much less here than it is in England. We have all heard of the English tobacco and cigarette prices—much too often recently—not to realise that the man who gets a few pounds in England and who wants to enjoy himself or live on any reasonable standard, has to pay a lot more money for certain articles in England than he has to pay here and if he wants to get more than what will fill the miserable corner of the little yellow basket, he will have to pay far more for the things than he would have to pay here."

That idea sprouted until October, 1947, when the Government here decided to do what Deputy Lemass had discovered the English Government had done. They endeavoured to keep down the cost-of-living index by imposing taxation on tobacco, spirits and beer "and used the revenue to subsidise food prices which were weighted highly". The Seanad will remember that in the autumn Budget of 1947 very heavy taxation was imposed on tobacco and drink but the snag in the situation was that they were weighted in the cost-of-living figure here and the Government decided to carry out the English plan by another device. So the Director of Statistics was given orders to take drink and tobacco out of the computation of the cost-of-living figure. In the Trade Journal for December, 1947, on page 146 there is an article on the Interim Cost-of-Living Index and a paragraph in the second column of the article runs in this way:—

"The Government have decided that an index number representing the trend of prices of essential items of household expenditure would be the most useful in present circumstances. By definition ‘essential' items are those in the groups food, clothing, fuel and light, and rent. Expenditure on these items is estimated to constitute, as at mid-August, 1947, about 66 per cent. of employee household expenditure."

It continues:—

"Other items, of which the principal are alcoholic beverages, tobacco, amusements and direct taxation, are not priced in the new computation."

So we had arrived at the English situation. We had taxed these things and then ordered the Director of Statistics to take them out of the cost-of-living index figure and the people who did that mischievously and dishonestly say that we ordered the same Director of Statistics to take them out.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say how bread and flour are priced in the cost-of-living index?

Comment on this

They are included in whatever way the Director of Statistics puts them in.

Comment on this

At the controlled price?

Comment on this

Would the Senator not shake his gory locks at me for the moment? There are about 147 places at which enumeration takes place. One goes to the shops and finds what a particular commodity there is sold at, and the returns are made to the Director of Statistics who weights these items in different ways. He is given no instructions about that. I would certainly hope that white flour would not be regarded as an item entering into the cost of living any more than cake would be. If a person is getting a sufficient ration of subsidised flour, it is the price of that that should be counted, but certainly, no directions have been given to the director in regard to these matters. I do not think the sale of white flour has been on such a scale that it would raise the computation in regard to the price of flour or bread as returned by the director.

Comment on this