We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Irish News Agency Bill, 1949—Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–184 of 369. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Irish News Agency Bill, 1949
Enacted

No. 22 of 1949 ›

Ba mhaith liom beagán a rá i dtaobh teidil an Bhille. Seachtain ó shoin, nuair bhí an Bille ós ár gcómhair, mhol mé don Aire machtnamh a dhéanamh ar an scéal seo arís agus féachaint an bhféadfadh sé an nós a bhí ann go dtí seo i gcás cóluchta Stáit, go mbeadh an teideal i nGaeilge i gcás an Bhille seo. Is trua liom nach raibh am agam fanacht le héiseacht leis an Aire ag tabhairt freagra ar na pointí a cuireadh os a chómhair. Bhí mé ag súil i rith na seachtaine go mbeadh an tuarascáil oifigiúil agam go bhfeicfinn cén freagra a bhí ag an Aire ar an bpointe sin go háirithe, chomh maith leis na pointí eile. Ní bhfuaireas an tuarascáil oifigiúil go dtí 1 a chlog, nuair tháinig mé isteach ins an Teach inniu. Níl mé a rá gur ar an Aire atá an milleán faoi sin ach is dóigh liom nach bhfuil sé réasúnach iarraidh orainn teacht chuig an tSeanad agus cur síos a dhéanamh ar Bhille, ar gach céim, gan an deis a bheith againn an díospóireacht a rinneadh ar an mBille roimhe a bheith ós ár gcomhair. Níl fhios agam go cruinn céard tá ráite ag an Aire i dtaobh teidil an Bhille ach, do réir mar is féidir liom a dhéanamh amach, ceapann sé nach ceart dó teideal Gaeilge a chur ar an ngníomhaireacht seo.

Dá mbeadh am agam an tuarascáil a léamh, b'fhéidir go bhfeicfinn argóint éigin ag an Aire a shásódh mé i gcoinne an teideal a bheith i nGaeilge. Sílim go rachaidh sé rite leis, dá fheabhas a mbeadh freagra air, mé a shásamh gurb é an t-aon rud amháin a dhéanamh —teideal Béarla a bheith ag an ngníomhaireacht seo.

Ba mhaith liom iarraidh ar an Aire geallúint a thabhairt dúinn idir seo agus an chéad chéim eile, go gceapfaidh sé leasú amach agus go gcuirfidh sé isteach ins an mBille é, ag cur ainm Gaeilge ar an ngníomhaireacht nua seo.

Nílmid ag iarraidh a lán air ar bhealach agus ar bhealach eile táimid ag iarraidh a lán. Is ceist prionsabail í seo. Is ceist an-mhór í seo, scéal na Gaeilge, agus úsáid a dhéanamh den Ghaeilge ar gach ócáid dár féidir linn úsáid a dhéanamh di.

Ins na blianta atá caite, nuair tháinig Bille ós ár gcomhair go mba é a chuspóir bord nó cólucht nó fonndúiracht a bhunú, cuireadh an t-ainm i nGaeilge air. Ba mhór an trua go mbrisfí ar an nós sin, ní hé amháin ó thaobh a thábhachta i gcúis na Gaeilge ach ón taobh, muna ndeintear é, gur fianaise, gur cruthú, é, gur cuma leis an Rialtas scéal seo na Gaeilge.

Nílmid ag iarraidh ar an Aire go ndéanfadh sé obair an bhoird i nGaeilge. Níl sé sin ar intinn againn agus níl sé ar intinn againn mar a ceapfaí ón méid a dúirt sé in a thaobh—níl sé léite chomh cruinn sin agam agus ba mhaith liom—gurb é atá ar intinn againn go gcraobhscaoilfí an nuacht i nGaeilge ar fud gach régiún. Mar deirim, nílmid á iarraidh sin. Nílmid ach ag iarraidh an t-ainm Gaeilge atá ar bharr an Bhille, sé sin, Gníomhaireacht Nuachta Éireannach, gurb in é a bheas mar theideal ar an gcomhlachas nua seo. Níl bac ar bith ar an gcomhlucht—rud a dhéanfadh cinnte é—leagan gearr nó coimre a dhéanamh ar an teideal. Níl bac ar bith orra é sin a dhéanamh ach beid an teideal Gaelach mar chomhartha gurb í an Ghníomhaireacht Nuachta Éireannach a bheadh i gceist.

Ní dóigh liom, ó thaobh an Bhille féin, go bhfuilmid ag iarraidh a lán ar an Aire, ach ó thaobh prionsabail de, is rud an-tábhachtach ar fad é. Ba mhaith liom go dtabharfadh an tAire an méid sin de shásamh dúinne—atá ag plé leis an nGaeilge—go ndéanfadh sé, mar a rinneadh ins na blianta roimhe, i gcásanna eile dá leithéid seo, a tháinig ós comhair an Oireachtais, an teideal a chur i nGaeilge. Tá súil agam go bhfuil machtnamh déanta ag an Aire agus go mbeidh sé réidh an méid sin a dhéanamh orainn.

Maidir leis an rud eile adúirt mé i dtaobh na dtuarascála oifigiúil, má táimid le dul ar aghaidh ar an nós seo, gan an tuarascál oifigiúil a fháil go dtí go bhfuilmíd ar tí theacht isteach ins an tSeanad, séard a mholfainn duitse, a Chathaoirligh, agus a mholfainn don Seanad: éirí as costas a chaitheamh ar an tuarascáil oifigiúil ar fad. Ní fiú deich triuf í anois. Níl a lán ama agam mar atá ag daoine eile agus caithimíd na tuarascála a léamh chun a fháil amach céard atá i gceist ins an mBille. D'iarr mé ort cheana an scéal seo a scrúdú ach tar éis do dhícheall a dhéanamh, níl feabhas ar an scéal, agus, mar deirim, ní fiú deich triuf an tuarascáil atá againn anois, an tuarascáil a tugadh dúinn agus sinne ag teacht isteach anseo. Má chítear do Chléirigh an tSeanaid am ar bith nach mbeidh an tuarascál oifigiúil réidh in am tráth——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Mícheál Ó hAodha Fine Gael

Ní dóigh liom gur cheart don tSeanadóir an cheist seo a phlé anois. Ní hé seo an t-am dó, mar níl aon bhaint aige leis an mBille. Rud a bhaineann leis an gCoiste um Nós Imeachta agus Príbhléidí é.

Comment on this

Níl mé ag plé an Choiste ach tá mé a rá nach raibh mé i ndon m'aigne a dhéanamh suas i dtaobh an scéil seo de bhrí nach raibh an tuarascál oifigiúil agam, agus is dóigh liom go bhfuil baint idir an rud sin agus an díospóireacht atá ar siúl againn faoi láthair. Sé an rud a bhí mé a rá ná seo: nuair chítear do dhaoine anseo nach féidir an tuarascál oifigiúil a thabhairt dúinn go dtí an lá a thagaimid isteach anseo, ní ceart an chéim seo den Bhille bheith ar bun. Ba cheart go mbeadh seachtain againn leis an tuarascáil a léamh agus leis an cheist ar fad a scrúdú.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Micheál Ó hAodha Fine Gael

Sé cúis nach bhfuil fhios ag an Seanadóir, mar deireann sé, ná nar fhan sé chun éisteacht leis an bhfreagra a thug an tAire air. Tá sé mar nós ag an Seanadóir óráid fhada Ghaeilge a dhéanamh agus gan fanúint le haon fhreagra ón Aire. Sin é an fáth nach bhfuil fhios aige. I dtaobh na tuarascála seo, bhí sé amuigh an tseachtain seo níos mire ná riamh. Táimid ag déanamh ár ndíchill chun í a thabhairt amach go mear agus shocraigh an Coiste um Nós Imeachta agus Príbhléidí seans eile a thabhairt don scéim atá ar bun fé láthair.

Thug an Seanadóir óráid i nGaeilge agus dhein sé roint cáineadh ar an mBille, agus annsin níor fhan sé leis an bhfreagra agus, mar deirim, tá sé mar nós ag an Seanadóir gan fanacht le haon fhreagra. Cad é an chúis gearáin atá aige? Níl aon chúis gearáin aige. Teastaíonn uaidh dul abhaile agus an freagra a tugadh dó a léamh, ach ní féidir é sin a dhéanamh. Níl sé sin cothrom agus níl sé do réir réasúin ná do réir ceílle agus ní déanfar obair an tSeanaid mar sin. Ní foláir don tSeanadóir bheith sásta leis sin. Tá fhios agam gur mhaith an rud é dá dtugtaí na tuarascála seo dúinn níos mire ná mar tugtar faoi láthair. Sé dualgas an tSeanadóra, taréis óráid a dhéanamh ag cáineadh rud éigin i mBille atá á phlé, fanacht chun éisteacht leis an bhfreagra a gheobhaidh sé. Nuair bhí mise san áit úd thall, d'fhan mé i gcónaí chun éisteacht leis an bhfreagra a thug an tAire dom agus ba cheart don tSeanadóir é sin a dhéanamh chomh maith. Muna ndéanann sé é sin, fanadh sé ina thost, mar níl aon chúis gearáin aige.

Comment on this

Bhfuil cead cainte agam?

Comment on this

Tá.

Comment on this

Is fíor é don tSeanadóir O hAodha go ndéanaim óráideacha anseo agus gur óráideacha fada iad uaireanta.

Comment on this

Níl sé sin ós ár gcómhair anois.

Comment on this

Níl sé ós ár gcómhair, agus ní mise a chuir ós do chómhair é, ach, ar a laghad ó luadh é agus ós rud é gur mise atá i gceist, sílim gur cheart go mbeadh nóiméad agam leis an scéal a mhíniú. Sé mo cheart é ins an Seanad óráideacha a dhéanamh, is cuma fada nó gearr iad agus bíonn an méid seo le rá agam i gcónaí, pé'r bith óráid a dhéanaim, gur óráid de mo chuid féin í agus nach óráid í a bhíonn déanta dom a thugaim isteach chun a léamh, pé acu fada nó gearr í.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Micheál Ó hAodha Fine Gael

An ndúirt an Seanadóir go dtugaim óráideacha isteach anseo chun iad a léamh?

Comment on this

Ní dhúirt mé a léithéid. Deireann an Seanadóir Ó hAodha gurb é an leigheas atá ar an scéal ar fad go bhfanfainn anseo ag éisteacht leis an Aire. Sílim go n-admhóidh an Seanadóir nach bhfuil aon duine is mó a bhfuil ómós aige do na hAirí ná tá agam agus nach bhfuil duine is dílse ag déanamh freastal ar an Seanad ná mise. Níl mé ar nós daoine eile. Ní chónaím i mBaile Atha Cliath; níl ioncam mór agam gur féidir dom bheith neamhspleách agus tá turas fada abhaile le taisteal agam. Tá dualgais throma ag baint lem obair agus caithfidh mé féachaint le freastal ar an dá thráigh an oiread agus is féidir liom. Cuirim sin ós cómhair an tSeanaid, ní mar leathscéal ach mar mhíniú. Más amhlaidh gurb é an prionsabal, mar chreideann an Seanadóir, go gcaithfimid fanacht anseo agus éisteacht leis an Aire agus freagra a thabhairt air do réir mar chloisimid, ansin deirim nach fiú dúinn an costas a chur orainn féin an tuarascáil seo a chur amach.

Comment on this

Tá an méid sin ráite ag an Seanadóir cheana.

Comment on this

An chéad phointe eile a luadh an Seanadóir Ó hAodha, cén fáth nár chuir mé leasú isteach ar an mBille. An fáth nár chuir mé leasú isteach ar an mBille, mar adúirt mé, nar thuig mé i gceart ceard dúirt an tAire, nar thuig mé aigne an Aire. Dá mbeadh aigne an Aire ar thuiscint agam bheadh fhios agam céard ba cheart a dhéanamh. Ní dóigh liom go bhfuil bac orm má bhíonn mé sásta leasú a chur isteach ar an gcéad chéim eile.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Micheál Ó hAodha Fine Gael

Is dóigh liom go bhfuil bac ort anois.

Comment on this

Ar aon chuma, tá fhios agat, a Chathaoirligh, cén fáth nach bhfuil leasú istigh agus cén fáth a rinne mé casaoid i dtaobh foilsiú na Tuarascála.

Comment on this

I do not want in any way to complain of being taken unawares about the point made by Senator Ó Buachalla as he mentioned it on the Second Reading of this Bill. Equally, I dealt with the matter in reply to the various comments that have been made by members of this House including Senator Ó Buachalla. I explained that as far as a news agency is concerned it would be futile and to a certain extent detrimental to use an Irish title inasmuch as the main function of the news agency is to operate in other countries where Irish is certainly not known. I do not think we can undertake the task of trying to teach the populations of the world Irish. Furthermore, we have to face the fact that a very large section of the people we want to reach in other countries are either English-speaking or can speak English, and therefore I think that English will be a useful medium for a large portion of the news. Such countries as the United States, Canada, Australia, India, and South Africa to a certain degree, are in the main, if not English-speaking, certainly familiar with the English language. I think that our news agency, being a small organisation, should not put an additional difficulty in its way to getting itself known throughout the world by having an Irish title. The practice adopted in this Bill is the practice adopted in other Bills which have come before this House. If the Senator will look through the Statute Book he will find that the titles of the Acts are in the English version given in English and in the Irish version given in Irish. Many companies spring to my mind in respect of which the same arguments could be advanced. For instance, Irish Shipping is known as Irish Shipping and I have noticed in the case of ships that they possess that Irish names have not been used, I take it more or less for the same reason, in order that people abroad if they see a ship called "Irish Poplar", "Irish Oak" or "Irish Elm" will be able to identify it as coming from Ireland more readily than if an Irish name were used. I do not propose, therefore, in this Bill to depart from the practice in this respect which has been set up by the last Government.

Comment on this

Ba mhaith liom a rá nach bhfuil mé sásta beag ná mór le freagra an Aire. Níl mise chomh díchéillí is go mbeinn ag súil go rachadh an ghníomhaireacht seo amach ag múineadh Gaeilge don domhan fré chéile, ach tá mé ag súil go mbeadh an teideal a baisteadh ar an gcomhlucht stáit seo i nGaeilge. Sin é an méid. Bheadh fhios ag an Aire é féin níos fearr ná mar a bheadh agam-sa —dá mbeadh an tuarascáil agam in am b'fhéidir go mbeadh eolas níos cruinne agam—cad iad na hainmneacha atá baistithe ag tíortha éagsúla ar na gníomhaireachta nuachta atá acu. Níor bhaist rialtas na Fraince ainm Béarla ar an ngníomhaireacht nuachta atá acu; níor bhaist Rialtas na Rúise ainm Béarla ar an ngníomhaireacht atá acu-san; níor bhaist aon tír ainm Béarla, ainm i dteanga choigríche, ar an ngníomhaireacht nuachta a cuirtear ar bun chomh fada agus a chuir na tíortha éagsúla sin a leithéid ar bun. Deireann an tAire, mar chosaint dó féin, nár bhaist Comhlucht Loingeas na hÉireann ainmneacha Gaeilge ar a gcuid long. Is mór is trua liom é sin. Níl mise sásta nár baisteadh ainmneacha Gaeilge ar a gcuid long ach sílim go raibh sé de nós ainmneacha Gaeilge a bhaisteadh ar na comhluchta stáit a cuireadh ar bun. Luaigh mé mar shampla an lá faoi dheireadh Siúcra Teoranta, Aer Lingus agus Bord na Móna. Mura bhfuil an tAire sásta— agus tá súil agam go ndéanfaidh sé ath-mhachtnamh air—caithfimid féachaint, ó tharla gur prionsabal é seo, leasú a chur isteach ar an gcéad chéim eile.

Comment on this

Section 1 states——

Comment on this

I thought that the section was agreed.

Comment on this

The question before the House, I understood, was that Section 1 stand part.

Comment on this

But the question was, I thought, agreed.

Comment on this

I do not think any such thing. I submit of course to your ruling. I have no desire to be obstreperous. I may take it that Section 1 has been agreed to.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

If there is any misunderstanding an opportunity should be given.

Comment on this

The Chair will give Senator Hearne an opportunity.

Comment on this

I have no desire to get facilities from anyone in this House. I will get the point in on Section 2.

SECTION 2.

Comment on this

This section states that the expression "the agency" means the Irish News Agency. Anyone with any experience of international news agencies knows that it will not be known throughout the world as the Irish News Agency, any more than the Press Association is known as the Press Association—it is known as P.A. —and if this section goes through, the Irish News Agency will be known throughout the world as I.N.A. or as INA, just as the United Nations Organisation is known as U.N.O.

Comment on this

What about Reuter?

Comment on this

It is known as Reuter. My objection to the expression here is that, if the Minister had agreed that there was a case where there should be an Irish name, it would be known not by the full title in Irish but by the initials of the three Irish words. It would be known internationally as G.N.E., just as K.L.M. is known internationally as KLM. Another example is one that we all know of—the Russian news agency, T.A.S.S., is known internationally as Tass—in other words, the initials of the four Russian words. We have an opportunity here, and this House would be lacking in its duty to the Irish language if we did not seize the opportunity to make known this news agency by at least the initials of the three Irish words that would form its name. The Minister mentioned Irish Shipping, Limited, as being known by the English name at whatever port our ships might call. That is true: I regret it. There is a far better example in the case of Aer Lingus, Teoranta.

Comment on this

There is no comparison.

Comment on this

It is known in London, not as Aer Lingus, Teoranta, but as A.L.T.; and similarly in Paris and Brussels as A.L.T.—the initials of the three Irish words. That is quite true: I am speaking from my own knowledge, just as I know that the Czech Airlines are known throughout the world not by the long Czech names but as the C.S.R. lines.

The Belgian airlines are known as S.A.B.E.N.A. all over the Continent. There is an opportunity given to us here, one of the few opportunities, apart from any other merits or demerits there may be in the Bill, to make known to the world that this country has a separate culture and a separate language. I do not plead very often with Ministers—I prefer to fight them—but I plead with him in this case, that he has an opportunity of putting before the world internationally the fact that we have a separate language here. This news agency will eventually be known by the initials and, as the Bill stands, it will be known as I.N.A. If the Minister wishes, he can have it known internationally by the initials of the Irish words—G.N.E. I would make a plea to him to consider the matter. It is an opportunity that very seldom arises, but it presents itself now and I would ask him to consider it seriously.

Comment on this

I think Senator Hearne has just put his finger on one of the difficulties. If we use the initials G.N.E., I venture to think that, in most cases, they will never relate that to an Irish news agency, as there is nothing to indicate to a non-Gaelic speaker that the initials have any reference to Ireland. Throughout the world, in other languages, the name of Ireland begins with an "I" and they will look for a name in which the letter "I" is incorporated if they wish to relate the news agency to Ireland. I think that the initials I.N.A. are far more likely to indicate to a foreigner that it is an Irish news agency. I do not agree with Senator Hearne when he says that Aer Lingus is known as A.L.T. or that the Czech Airlines are known as the C.S.R. Lines. I have done a good deal of travelling and never heard Aer Lingus referred to as A.L.T. I have heard it referred to as Aer Line-gus, and I have heard all kinds of translations of Aer Lingus. I never heard the Czech Airlines referred to as anything but the Czech Airlines.

I agree entirely with the desirability of using Irish wherever possible, but I think this is one occasion where the use of Irish would not be helpful and would, to a certain extent, reduce the efficiency of the news agency. It would mean that, on notepaper and so on, we would have the title in Irish. It would mean that, in countries covering a population of anything from 400,000,000 to 700,000,000 of people, you would be utilising a name that would not be understood by them; whereas if you use English it would be understood in the title.

Comment on this

I am not at all satisfied with the Minister's answer. He has not dealt with the two examples that answer effectively his statement that "I" is known internationally to stand for Ireland or that I.N.A. will have a better chance of association with Ireland than G.N.E. The one example that we know for years past, which effectively answers him, is Tass. There is no association, in my mind or in the English-speaking mind, of Tass with Russian, any more than the ordinary person down the country or in any English-speaking country knows that K.L.M. has any association with Holland. People who want to find out get to know that K.L.M. are the initials of the Dutch Airlines. I suggest seriously that I.N.A. will have at least as little effect as G.N.E. I suggest this title in order to emphasise internationally, as far as we can, that we have a separate language. The purpose of the Bill is to put before the world the fact that this is a separate nation and that, secondly, following from that, we have a separate language and a separate culture. As far as we can, we should emphasise that further by using an Irish name for the agency and let it be known eventually by the initials. I submit again that the balance is in favour of using the Irish name and that the Minister should consider the possibility and the advisability of using it.

Comment on this

I wonder if we could not be realists in this matter. The saving of the Irish language is not an international question, but a national one. It is for us and not for other people. What we do ourselves about it is all important, not what we say to others about it and not what we call ourselves before other people. I would like to suggest to Senator Hearne, in all earnestness, that it is very important for us to be known as Ireland, that we should cling as much as we possibly can, in other countries, to the two words, Ireland and Irish. Senators will recollect on many occasions hearing me here object to the use of the word Éire.

Comment on this

For very good reasons.

Comment on this

I could give extremely good reasons to prove that Éire is a very ancient name indeed and that this island was known as Éire before the English came here, but we have to recollect certain facts and they are good things for us, namely, that more than 400,000,000 people who speak English and millions of others who understand English know this island as Ireland. I would like this State to be known abroad as Ireland and I would like what we do to be known as Irish. For example, the partitionists in the North of Ireland, in Belfast, have not abandoned the word Irish for their linen and, in spite of their politics and in spite of their fanatical desire about certain things, they take very good care not to call it Ulster linen.

Comment on this

Because they are in Ireland all the time.

Comment on this

Because the word Irish is more important to them than any other title. Because they are in Ireland, I agree.

Comment on this

Because it has been known for years as Irish linen— a purely commercial reason.

Comment on this

Because the use of the word Irish is important. I do not know how many languages we are going to be able to talk in this place. It is because the word Irish is an important word internationally and so is the word Ireland. I think Senator Hearne, in his desire to support Senator Ó Buachalla in this, is not doing himself quite justice. For example, this news agency must get known first before it can get known by its initials. Before it becomes I.N.A. or G.N.E. or any thing else it must first get known and the most valuable name it could possibly have is a name which excites sympathy, for example in England, with great parts of the population, in Canada, the United States, Australia, New Zealand and India. In every one of these places you have a substantial number of people in whom the word Irish in the English language or the word Ireland excites sympathy. We could exploit these people. I hope the word "exploit" is not wrongly used there. We should use these people as best we can and we can use them best by calling this an Irish news agency. Under that title it will have the best chance of becoming known. Whether it is known afterwards as I.N.A. or G.N.E., I do not know. It will have to become known first before the initials become common. I think it is valuable for us to maintain the use of the words Ireland and Irish.

I was at a conference this year. We were known as Ireland. I noticed that certain people in referring to us, in using certain types of argument, used the word Éire but from our point of view—that is, from my point of view and Senator Hearne's point of view—the word Ireland is the important word. I do not think we are doing any harm to the Irish language but we are doing good to the Irish people by exploiting the words Ireland and Irish in our relations with the world outside.

May I repeat what I said at the beginning? The Irish language is not going to be revived by any form of label. It is going to be revived by people knowing it and using it and speaking it. People are familiar with an opinion of mine that, if it were spoken in the bar, and no word of Irish were even spoken in this House or the other, it would be safe for all time and none of us need worry at all about it any more. It would completely remove any worry I have about it. I know sufficient about it to be worried about it but all this business of attaching labels and thinking that we are of great importance internationally is looking through the wrong end of the telescope.

A great many people do not know that Tass is a Russian agency, unfortunately, but, anyhow, there is no comparison between the Russians and the power of the Russians and the power of their language and our power and the power of our language.

Comment on this

This is too dangerous. I do not want to be misunderstood. I merely mentioned the word Tass as being the name of the Russian agency, which is known internationally as such. The power of the Russians or of their language does not come into it at all and I would strongly object to even my friend Senator Hayes implying in any way that, because I made an example taken from Russia, I might be taken as in any way condoning what is happening in Russia.

Comment on this

There was no implication of that sort in the Senator's speech.

Comment on this

This kind of thing always makes me feel that we ought to be able to discuss these things in Irish. I am as innocent as the child unborn. I did not dream for a moment of associating Senator Hearne with Russia. It does not matter what the Russians call their agency. They can call it anything they like, in any language they like, it is going to be known and the name is going to be known and recognised by people who want to recognise it, because of the immense power and importance of Russia. The Americans are the same because of their power and immense importance. We are in an entirely different position and I do suggest seriously that the two words Ireland and Irish are very valuable assets for us outside this country and that we ought to cling to them and exploit them and ought not to give them up.

Comment on this

In view of what Senator Hayes has said, I would press very hard on the Minister for External Affairs to alter the definition of this Act, that it may be known as the News Agency of Ireland. I quite agree with Senator Hayes that, as there has been in the past, and probably will be in the future, misrepresentation between the Republic of Ireland and the Irish Republic, there will be misrepresentation as between the Irish News Agency and the News Agency of Ireland. We have known such misrepresentation.

We have passed from Section 1 and must come to Section 2 which says the expression, the agency, means the Irish News Agency. In introducing the Bill, the Minister put before the House certain claims, that it was essential that an organisation such as this should be set up in order that the Irish point of view should be made known abroad, that it should be made known to the nations of the world that we are a separate and independent nation, that while we may be an old nation we are a new State; that there have been in the past many misrepresentations of our position and that, in order to combat such misrepresentation, he was about to set up what he termed a news agency to make known to the people of the world that we were, as he stated, an independent nation, that we had a culture and language of our own. It surpasses my understanding when I hear the same Minister oppose a suggestion that the news agency which he proposes to set up for that purpose should have its name in the Irish language. That is something which is beyond me. In reply to the suggestion put forward on Second Reading, the Minister said:—

"Senator Ó Buachalla, Senator Hawkins and Senator Concannon suggested that the name of the news agency should be given in Irish. This is one case in which I would say "No".

I suggest that we have reached a very poor pass in an Irish legislature when a man holding the responsible position of Minister for External Affairs should say that this is one case in which he must say "No".

Comment on this

It is very difficult to deal with an Opposition like this. If one knew exactly what they were after, one could get to grips with the problem, but the impression I get is that they are so much concerned about the name this agency is to go under that they are not in the least concerned about the purposes which the news agency is to serve.

Comment on this

We have not reached those sections yet.

Comment on this

If the Opposition Front Bench had been a little more industrious and had put down an amendment, we would have something concrete to go upon. I do not know exactly what they want to do. Do they want to eliminate the section and what will the Bill look like if they succeed? Listening to Senator Hawkins, I thought I was back at the by-election in Donegal. I was there and so was he. That is the kind of claptrap we have to listen to.

So far as serving the cause of the language is concerned, it is the most utterly futile approach we could make —this introducing of the language to cloud issues and blind ourselves to the facts and to get the whole scene darkened, so far as the outside world is concerned. That is what goes on and that is why we are not making more progress with the language movement. I should like to ask, as a challenge, that both Senator Hearne and Senator Hawkins should translate the Irish title of the Bill. Let us hear them at that and then we will know what the English-speaking world——

Comment on this

It is already translated. Would the Senator read the Bill?

Comment on this

I have read it. Let us suppose that you have the Irish title as you want it. I should like to hear you translate it, and see the problem which people in other countries will be up against.

Comment on this

Poor boy!

Comment on this

Senator Hawkins and Senator Hearne are deliberately trying to waste the time of the House.

Comment on this

I protest against that suggestion. Withdraw it.

Comment on this

The Senator may protest with the utmost vehemence, but I am entitled to draw conclusions. We saw the attitude of the Opposition in the other House. They were rather meek and mild the other day. One would have expected that they would have divided on the principle on Second Reading, but they did not do so. We then expected to see amendments, but we saw none. This is another shadowy approach to prevent the Minister doing what his predecessor in office ought to have done long ago. How long will you people continue to stand in the light of Ireland making her case known to the world outside?

Comment on this

Senator Baxter has brought me to my feet. He accuses the last occupant of the position the Minister now occupies——

Comment on this

I hope we are not getting away from the section.

Comment on this

Both Senator Baxter and Senator Hayes got away from it. We got a lecture on the Irish language from Senator Hayes.

Comment on this

On a point of order, may I ask what Senator Hearne meant by saying that I got away from the question of whether the title should be in Irish or English? I surely did not. I am sorry if I know Irish, but I cannot help it.

Comment on this

Each of the Senators made his case, but we do not want to get back to the Donegal by-election or to what happened in the Dáil. We want to discuss the section on its merits.

Comment on this

I notice that you did not interrupt Senator Baxter when he drew in the Donegal by-election.

Comment on this

The purpose of a Committee Stage is to enable members to reject or to amend proposals in a Bill. It is not necessary that very definite amendments should be put down in order that a particular section may be opposed, and, therefore, I take it that we are quite within our rights in expressing our views in relation to Section 2. We had in the past many attempts to deprive the people of the opportunity of exercising their democratic rights in relation to these matters, and, while we here occupy the seats we occupy, we will always insist on our exercising these rights.

Comment on this

May I say that I do not agree with Senator Baxter——

Comment on this

I am glad.

Comment on this

——that an attempt is being made by Senator Hawkins to waste the time of the House? If he will allow me, I will give him an example of unconscious humour on the part of the Senator. He said: "Senator Hawkins was in West Donegal and so was I. This is the kind of claptrap we have to listen to."

Comment on this

It is very seldom I waste the time of the House, but I propose to waste a little of it now. Senator Hayes is well aware that the name of Erin is as well known all over Europe as Ireland. In Thomas Moore's songs and poems, which have been circulated all over the world, the name of Erin is always used in referring to this country. Our anxiety in this matter is that the news which will be circulated to the different countries will be in the languages of these countries. The news going to the English-speaking countries, Australia, New Zealand and so on, will, I take it, be in English, while news going to France will be in French, and the news going to other countries will be in the languages of these other countries. What we want to impress on these people to whom these news bulletins will go is that this country is a different country with a language of its own.

Those who have been on the Continent have, perhaps, had the same experience as I have had. I remember arguing with a Swiss about the position of this country in relation to England and he said: "What are you talking about? What are you but English? What language are you speaking? Practically all people from your country whom I meet speak English and I fail to see the difference between your people and English tourists." That is the mentality we want to get rid of amongst people of other countries. We want to let them see that this country has a language of its own and is a different country from England. With regard to Ireland and Irish, both these expressions were imposed on this country from the other side. Before English became the dominant language of this country, it was not of Irish or Ireland that we spoke, and we want to get back to that position, to get our own people to use their own language and to let it be known all over the world that this country is different from the country across the Channel.

Comment on this

Dúirt an Seanadóir Ó hAodha: "The saving of the language is a matter for us." Tá an ceart aige. Is ceist dúinn féin í, obair dár gcuid féin í an teanga a shábháil. Agus is ar an abhar sin atámuid ag iarraidh chomh láidir agus atámuid go ndéanfaimid an méid seo ar son na Gaeilge: go gcuirfimid an t-ainm sin i nGaeilge ar an gcomhlucht seo. Is obair dúinn féin í an Ghaedhilg a shábháil agus ba cheart dúinn an méid is féidir linn a dhéanamh leis an teanga a shábháil. Is beag agus is rí-bheag atáimid a iarraidh ar an Aire agus ar an Seanadóir Ó hAodha i gcúis na Gaeilge nuair a iarraimid orthu glacadh leis na trí focla seo mar theideal ar an bhfhondúireacht nó comhlucht nua. Sílim gurb é an rud atá ag cur as don Aire— go bhfuil faitíos air. Sílim gurb é an rud atá ar aigne ar an Aire, má úsáideann sé na trí focla Gaeilge seo, go gclisfidh ar an ngníomhaireacht. Ceapann an tAire nach mbeadh fhios ag an domhan cé as an nuaíocht má húsáidtear teideal Gaeilge nó má húsáidtear na cinn-litreaca mar theideal ar an ngníomhaireacht. Gach rud dá bhfuil nua ní bhíonn eolas air. Is cinnte nuair a cuireadh an "Press Association" ar bun gur thóg sé tamall ar dhaoine ar fud an domhain fios a bheith acu cad é an rud "Press Association." Bhí fhios ag eagarthóirí iris agus nuachtan taobh istigh de cheithre huaire fichead cad é an "Press Association." Tá amhras orm go raibh fhios ag a lán daoine cad é T.A.S.S., ach foghlaimeoidh siad le himeacht aimsire céard leis a mbaineann an ghníomhaireacht sin. Ach bhí fhios ag scata nó aicme amháin, na daoine a raibh dlú-bhaint acu le páipéirí nuachta, ar an bpointe nó taobh istigh de cheithre huaire fichead é agus sa chaoi cheanann chéanna leis an ngníomhaireacht seo. Má bunaítear í taobh istigh de cheithre huaire fichead beidh fhios ag na páipéirí nuachta go bhfuil gníomhaireacht eile nuachta ann agus cad a chiallaíonn "Irish News Agency" nó Gníomhaireacht Nuachta Éireannach. Ní bheidh fhios ag daoine ar fud an domhain ar an bpointe nó taobh istigh de sheachtain nó taobh istigh de bhliain, b'fhéidir, ach le himeacht aimsire gheobhfaidh siad amach cad a chiallíonn na focla Gaeilge, nó mura bhfuil eolas acu go díreach, tuigfidh siad go mbaineann sé leis an tír seo, le hÉirinn. An gcreideann an tAire gur náisiún ar leith é seo? An gcreideann sé i neamhspleáchas na hÉireann? An gcreideann sé nach mar a chéile sinn agus náisiúin eile? gur náisiún ar leith muid? Má chreideann, ní bheidh sé i bhfad ag socrú in a intinn féin nach aon rud as bealach atáimid a iarraidh agus muid ag iarraidh air géilleadh sa méid sin. Is ceist mhór, prionsabal mór é, d'ainneoin gur beag atáimid a iarraidh, agus dhéanfadh muid feall ar mhuintir na hÉireann, dhéanfadh muid feall ar gach rud dá ndearnadh ar mhaithe le cúis na Gaeilge, le cúis neamhspleáchais na hÉireann, mura gcuirfeadh muid i gcoinne chomh láidir agus is féidir linn ainm na fondúireachta seo atá le dul ós cóir an domhain a bheith i mBéarla. Faitíos atá ar an Aire. Ná bíodh faitíos air. Dúirt daoine i dtosach an chogaidh nach bhféadfadh muid fanacht amach as an gcogadh, go slugfaí sa gcogadh muid, ach d'fhoghlaim an domhan gur stát neamhspleách muid agus bhí meas agus ómós níos mó acu dúinn dá réir sin. Má bhíonn sé de mhisneach agus de fhearúlacht againn ár ndualgas a dhéanamh don Ghaeilge, d'Éirinn agus do chúis na saoirse, ní bheidh aiféala orainn. Iarraim ar an Aire, uair amháin eile, geallúint a thabhairt dúinn go ndéanfaidh sé machtnamh ath-uair agus go gcuirfidh sé leasú isteach ar an gcéad chéim eile den Bhille atá ós ar gcómhar.

Comment on this

I did not intend to speak on this section of the Bill were it not for the fact that some objections have been raised to calling the news agency by an English title. This agency is to ensure the collection, dissemination, distribution and publication of news and intelligence inside and outside the State. To come down to brass tacks, I would like to put a question to the members of the Opposition. I have made an attempt to pass an examination in Irish when I was a young fellow, but how many Senators who, I take it, represent very large sections of the community can understand a speech made by Senator Ó Buachalla? Undoubtedly he is very erudite and I should like to hear at the conclusion of his speech in Irish a translation or summary in English because it would be enlightening to many of us. It delights me to hear Irish spoken, particularly by such a wonderful exponent as Senator Ó Buachalla, but how many members of Dáil Éireann could understand a word of the Irish spoken by Senator Ó Buachalla? We must be sincere in matters of this character and should like an estimate of the members of the Seanad and Dáil who could speak Irish and make themselves understood. As the Minister said, we must correct false impressions that may be given abroad about our activities. Some of our news will go to Germany, Italy, France and other countries, but the Germans speak their own native tongue and so do the Italians, the Russians, etc., and I cannot contradict anything said by Senator Ó Buachalla or Senator Hearne speaking of initials being used in other countries. I am not concerned with our ships or other industrial or maritime undertakings, but I am concerned with the news agency and I feel that the Minister for External Affairs has done a wonderful job in introducing a measure of this kind.

I think we would stultify ourselves if, at this initial stage, when this instrument is being put into active operation, we handicap the measure in any way by accepting the suggestion made by Senator Hearne or others on the opposite side. Let us come down to realities in this matter and face the fact that not one-third of the members of this House or of the other House, or of the representatives of the people, understand Irish.

Comment on this

It is utterly beyond the question altogether as to how many in this House or the other House understand or can speak Irish.

Comment on this

The Chair is in agreement with you.

Comment on this

The whole thing is to let the other countries know—as many of them do not know—that we have our own language. Naturally, the news that is to be published will be in the language of the country to which it is going—that is common sense—but the title is a different thing. It is a disgrace—and we have already one disgrace at the moment. There are many, but one is very prominent at the moment. It is a disgrace that something could not be done, even in this small way, to let the peoples of the world know that we have our language, a language of great culture with a perfect grammar. I know some Irish, though not very much; but Irish speakers here know what a magnificent language it is. Why not let the other peoples of the world know we have that language, even in that little way? Little things count and anything that could be done to spread that language is valuable.

What Senator Goulding said in his few words was really one of the best little features of this debate. When I consider what is going on at the moment, the stamp which, for the first time since 1921, is going over the world, I presume—not with my pennies, though—with the name in English on it, I think it is a disgrace to whatever Department or Minister had to do with it. I, for one, have not yet bought it, nor will I buy a 2½d. stamp with English on it. I am buying 1d. and ½d. ones instead. Why not do something to let our Irish language go abroad? What is on the stamp, "Poblacht na hÉireann—the Irish Republic", is a disgrace.

Comment on this

It seems to me that we are making a political issue out of what should be pre-eminently a practical one. The enthusiasm of some Senators opposite encourages me, as they believe we are going to have news sent out by this agency for which there will be an immediate demand. I believe it will take a considerable time to build the agency up and that it is common sense to adopt a title for general use which would be most likely to be recognised. When it has been established, a new name could be easily introduced.

Comment on this

That is my personal opinion. I think it is absurd to send out Irish news under an Irish name which people will not understand, when all the news that we get in this country, or almost all of it on which we rely, comes from the Irish Times, the Irish Independent and the Irish Press. Not one of them has an Irish title. In sending out news to ourselves we insist on an English title, so when sending it abroad for the people who cannot understand Irish it should not be suggested that there should be an Irish title, as that would be absurd.

Comment on this

Senator Hearne mentioned K.L.M. as an instance, but it must be borne in mind that they, or any big commercial organisation that advertises a lot, find that its name or initials becomes known. I wish I could hope that the initials of our news agency would become as familiar in the world as the initials of K.L.M.; but, even so, it was an unhappy instance to take, as though they use those letters they invariably have painted on all their air-ships and invariably utilise in their advertisements the English words, "The Flying Dutchman". Apparently, a Dutch company, operating from a country with a language of its own, one of the most widely publicised concerns in the world, finds it necessary in addition to use on air-ships and advertising matter English words to describe itself.

As Senator Ó Buachalla suggested, the issue involved is whether the letters I.N.A. or G.N.E. should be utilised, as that is all that would be published in the reports. I hope that sometimes, when newspapers are utilising our publicity matter, they may say it emanates from the "Irish News Agency", in French, German, English or whatever language they may happen to write it. Apart from that, it will be only the initials; and I think the initials I.N.A. are far more likely to indicate the source of the news to the non-Irish speaker than the initials G.N.E. I can think of many combinations that those letters might denote.

Comment on this

Is it not a matter of practice or familiarity with the title?

Comment on this

We can never hope that it would be as familiar in the Press of the world as a big news agency such as Reuter or U.P., or as notorious as Tass.

Comment on this

If we accept might as right, there may be something in what the Minister says.

Comment on this

Of course, Tass is a very well known news agency, but a very notorious one. I do not think we will ever aspire to or reach the same degree of notoriety. May I mention, in passing, that if Senators saw Tass written in the Russian language they would not recognise it? Tass depart from using their own language when they are distributing abroad.

I am afraid there is a certain degree of unreality in the discussion. I am being criticised in fairly strong terms by some Senators on the basis of doing something that is new. I am following the practice set by my predecessors. I have referred already to Irish Shipping and to the names of our Irish ships. Let me go to a nearer example. Here is the Irish Press. It was quite open to those who founded the Irish Press to use an Irish name.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister is not serious?

Comment on this

I am quite serious. If an Irish name were to be used, it should be used in this country in the first place.

Comment on this

In how many foreign countries is the Irish Press circulating?

Comment on this

Surely we are not trying to teach Irish to the rest of the world? Our first job is to try to spread Irish at home. Therefore, if there is any sincerity in these arguments, the first thing would be to utilise an Irish name for an Irish paper, instead of talking about sending out news under an Irish written title. I cannot take the argument as being very sincere in this matter. I think a lot of the arguments are absolutely sincere but some of them, possibly, are not quite sincere.

Comment on this

It is very hard to segregate the sincere from the insincere, is it not?

Comment on this

Not a bit. I do not find the slightest difficulty. I could pick them straight away. If the Senator wishes, I will do it.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Senator Goulding, whom I exclude immediately from any suspicion even of insincerity in his argument, mentioned the experience he had in Switzerland, that he was talking to somebody there who said: "You speak English, sir. It is extraordinary that you do not speak your own language." Certainly Senator Goulding might have asked his Swiss friend what language did they speak in Switzerland and, if he pursued the matter further, he would have found that the Swiss News Agency uses three different titles.

Comment on this

French, Italian and German. It depends on the canton.

Comment on this

We would not object to the Irish News Agency doing that.

Comment on this

I think the Irish News Agency can do quite a lot for Irish culture and for the Irish language, incidentally, in its news matter but only by using the language which is the medium used in the country where the news is distributed, not by using a language which is not understood by the people who receive the news.

Comment on this

Before you put the section, Sir, I would like to ask the Minister is he prepared on Report Stage to introduce an amendment to meet the wishes expressed on this side of the House? Otherwise we will have to divide on this section, I am afraid.

Comment on this

There will be no amendment tabled.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 25
·
Níl 15
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Would the Minister be able to give the House an indication as to the amount of the estimated expenditure under this Bill? The section says:

"The expenses incurred by the Minister in the administration of this Act shall, to such extent as may be sanctioned by the Minister for Finance, be paid out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas."

Could the Minister give the House an indication of what the expenditure for a 12-month period might be in connection with this Bill? If the moneys provided by the Oireachtas are not sufficient, in what other manner will the money be made up?

Comment on this

The amount required in any given year will be provided for in the Estimate of the Department of External Affairs. The sum provided in the current year was £25,000, but I should not like to say that that is a fixed and firm figure.

Comment on this

In accordance with the statement of the Minister now, the Oireachtas will be obliged to provide at least £25,000 per year.

Comment on this

Not obliged—I did not say "obliged".

Comment on this

Will be called upon to provide at least £25,000 per year. Will the Oireachtas have any control over or check on the activities of this board? Will a Deputy or a Senator be entitled to put down a question or table a motion in relation to any of the activities of the board or its officers?

Comment on this

Certainly, on the Estimate. It is in exactly the same position as any other State-sponsored company.

Comment on this

I must express entire dissatisfaction with the Minister's reply. the Oireachtas is to be called upon to provide a sum of money and the House is well aware that, in the case of this House, where no Estimates are presented but where an Appropriation Bill is discussed, it would be almost impossible for a member to focus public attention on the board's activities, as distinct from any other activities of the Department.

Comment on this

What is to prevent the Senator putting down a motion?

Comment on this

If Senator Baxter is to assume the office of Cathaoirleach in this House, he will have first to be elected.

Comment on this

Answer the question.

Comment on this

Senator Baxter is not going to sidetrack me on this issue. I suggest that the Minister's statement that it is possible for a member of this or the other House to raise the matter on the Estimates does not give members sufficient opportunity to exercise control over the functions of this board or the activities of the officers of the board, which is to be established by moneys provided by the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

The provisions in this Bill are similar to those in other Bills of the same kind. This agency will not enjoy the independence, let us say, of the Electricity Supply Board, in so far as that board does enjoy independence. Its expenses will be paid for out of an Estimate, introduced, I take it, under a special heading. It will be subject to the Minister and everything the Minister does in connection with the matter will be done in the course of his duties, will be part of the administration of his Department and will be subject to review in the other House and to the usual extent in this House. There is nothing the Minister could do to put anything more into the Bill, or nothing the Minister could say by way of reply to Senator Hawkins that would make the position any better than it is in the Bill. The maximum of control, in so far as it can be got at all, will be available. If the House labours under any disability with regard to this agency, it is merely a disability under which the House labours generally owing to its lack of power over finance as compared with the other House.

Let me give the Senator an example which I think he will remember during his own period of membership. We had long discussions on the Censorship Board and on the operations of that board, although, in fact, the Censorship Board at the time was not the responsibility of the Minister, and whatever we were able to do with regard to that board, we will be able to do at least that, and, I think, more, with regard to this agency. It will be completely subject to questions in the other House and to motions in this House, and, of course, to questions on the Appropriation Bill or the Central Fund Bill in this House. Consistent with the Constitution and with our normal powers, we will have as much power over this as we have over any part of the Minister's administration. I think that is the point that Senator Hawkins wants answered.

Comment on this

If my memory serves me aright, Senator Mrs. Concannon made a suggestion to the Minister on Second Reading that scripts issued to foreign countries by this news agency might be made available to Senators and Deputies or might be placed in the Library. The Minister received that suggestion sympathetically and indicated that he was prepared to meet the wishes of the Senator.

Comment on this

I do not think I indicated that. Senator Mrs. Concannon was under the impression that the work of the news agency would consist of issuing bulletins. I pointed out that that was not so, that what would be issued would be news, beamed on different places, and that it might be sub-edited locally to suit the particular needs, and that I would not think it would be possible to lay all the copy in the Library of the House. That, I think, would entail an immense amount of work and would not be necessary, in a sense.

Comment on this

It is not proposed, therefore, to lay any such script before the members of this House or in the Library. We must face facts as they are, however. This news agency is being set up under the Department of External Affairs. The Minister for External Affairs will be the Minister responsible to this House, and particularly to the other House, for the activities of this organisation, but we cannot banish from our minds the fact that the Minister for External Affairs is also the leader of a political Party and that it is quite possible that there may come forth from this organisation matters that may be questioned by other political Parties in the country.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

How would that arise under Section 6?

Comment on this

The expenses of the organisation are provided for under this particular section, and if the expenses are not provided I assume that there will be no organisation.

Comment on this

Are we to take it as a matter of order that we are discussing everything regarding this news agency on Section 3 and, therefore, cannot discuss it anywhere later?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The point raised by the Senator would be better discussed on some other section.

Comment on this

Is there another section?

Comment on this

Ní dóigh liom go bhfuil an t-abhar chomh casta is a cheapann cuid de na Seanadóirí. Faoi an mír seo, táimid ag cur an airgid ar fáil le haghaidh na gníomhaireachta. Chuir an Seanadóir Ó hAicín an cheist: an féidir leis an Seanad nó leis an Dáil, am ar bith a feicfear do Sheanadóirí nó do Theachtaí é, ceisteanna a chur i dtaobh imeachtaí——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Mícheál Ó hAodha Fine Gael

An óráid é seo, nó an tagairt é don phointe ordú? Cé acu é?

Comment on this

Níl mé ag déanamh óráide ach ag luadh na ceiste ionas gur féidir leis an Aire "sea" nó "Ní hea" a rá.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes Mícheál Ó hAodha Fine Gael

Is ar an gCathaoir a chur mise an cheist.

Comment on this

Má táim as ordú inseoidh an Leas-Chathaoirleach dom é.

Comment on this

I asked if on Section 3 it was in order to discuss the operations of the news agency and would it also be in order on any of the other sections. Is it proposed to have a Second Reading debate on Section 3?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It would be more advisable if the matter were raised on some other section of this Bill. This section deals with money.

Comment on this

The expense incurred by the Minister in administering this to such an extent as may be sanctioned by the Minister for Finance may be paid. The Minister has intimated that his estimate for the current year will be about £25,000.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

That is problematical; it may be more or it may be less.

Comment on this

I do not want to deprive Senator Hawkins of his opportunity, but if Senator Hawkins gets an opportunity on this section then that is the end of that. He cannot repeat it on the section which sets up the agency. We cannot have it twice in Committee and if Senator Hawkins agrees I do not mind what happens.

Comment on this

I do not know what is particularly worrying Senator Hayes to-night. The Bill is before us in Committee and it is the duty of every Senator to give his or her views on every section in the Bill and if necessary to put down amendments.

Comment on this

Consistent with order.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The discussion on this section should deal with the money that is to be provided.

Comment on this

The expenses shall be provided by the Minister for Finance with the consent of the Oireachtas. The Minister has given his estimate for the current year as £25,000.

Comment on this

I have said that that is the sum that is being provided for by the Oireachtas for the current year. The sum has already been voted by the Dáil.

Comment on this

Will the Minister give us any information as to how it is proposed to spend that sum?

Comment on this

May I put again the point of order? Are we going to have a Second Reading discussion on this section and on subsequent sections? I put it to you Sir, that Senator Hawkins is entitled to one bite but not two bites, or perhaps seven.

Comment on this

Could we have a ruling on the point of order? Senator Hawkins has already spoken three times on the section.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, instead of being entitled to one bite, Senator Hawkins is entitled to 18 bites as there are 18 sections.

Comment on this

He cannot take as much with each; some are small and some are large.

Comment on this

Some may be small and some large, but he is still entitled to 18 bites.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

If the Senator deals with it on this section it cannot be dealt with on a future section.

Comment on this

I was trying to elicit from the Minister certain information which I thought would be beneficial to the members of this House. £25,000 is being provided. What is that sum provided for? Is it to set up the agency, to pay the staff, for the collection, dissemination and making available of information? Is this organisation going to be a paying organisation or does the Minister assume that it will be a paying proposition at any particular period?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

That is a question for the Minister, not a speech.

Comment on this

Is that the last question?

Comment on this

I think I dealt with most of these points in introducing this measure on the Second Reading and also at length in the Dáil. The sum required by the news agency will be spent on the provision of staff and offices, communication expenses and so on, all the things that go to the organisation, building up and maintenance of a news agency. I think that ultimately the expenditure will be capable of division into three or four main heads such as wages and salaries and office expenses—it is intended apart from the office in Dublin to have an office in London and New York—and telegraphic and telephone communication which will probably be fairly heavy too. It is very difficult at this stage to assess the exact cost of the news agency when it will be in full operation. On the whole I would hope that its cost will be rather high because that would be an indication that its news is being availed of. It is not proposed to spend money on telegraphing news unless that news is actually used. I do not think there is any other point on which the Senator wishes information.

Comment on this

Ba mhaith liom ceist a chur ar an Aire. Bhí mé ar tí í a chur air nuair a chuir an Seanadóir Ó hAodha isteach orm. D'fhéadfainn an cheist a chur faoi go leor míreanna ach tá sé chomh maith agam í a chur anois. An féidir, ám ar bith sa Dáil, ceist a chur ar an Aire i dtaobh imeachtaí na gníomhaireachta seo?

An féidir dúinn ins an Seanad rún a chur síos i dtaobh imeachtaí na gníomhaireachta? Is ceist thábhachtach í agus ba mhaith liom go mbeadh freagra agam uirthi. Mhínigh an Seanadóir Ó hAodha dúinn—níor ghá é mhíniú—nuair a thiocfas na Meastacháin ós cómhair na Dála agus nuair a bheas An Bille Leithreasa (Appropriation Bill) ós cómhair an tSeanaid, féadfaimíd ceist a chur síos an uair sin ar an ngníomhaireacht; ach, idir an dá linn, má chítear dúinn go bhfuil ceist thábhachtach ar cheart í luadh i gceachtar den dá Theach, an bhfuil sé iontuigthe gur féidir é dhéanamh, de bhrí go mbeadh airgead dá sholáthar le haghaidh na gníomhaireachta?

Comment on this

I think the position in regard to public discussion is that this company will be in exactly the same position as any other company for which direct and specific Votes are made. However, each House makes its own Standing Orders and can rule out discussion or provide for discussion. It might make the type of suggestion I made in regard to having special committees to consider the work of State companies. I have no doubt that it is a matter for the Standing Orders, where specific money is voted in the annual Budget or the Estimates.

Comment on this

What is the position?

Comment on this

A motion can be put down at any time to call upon the Minister to give an account of what he is doing.

Comment on this

Will the agency issue a report, like other Government-sponsored companies?

Comment on this

Under Section 16 (4), a copy of every balance sheet furnished to the Minister will be laid by him before each House of the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

This seems to be the only chance I will get to raise this matter, which is important in view of the Minister's statement in reply to Senator Hawkins. Senator Hawkins dealt with Senator Mrs. Concannon's request to have the script made available in the Library. The Minister indicated that he thought that would be impracticable, in view of the large volume of such script that he hoped would be sent out. I fully appreciate his further point that no one could say what will eventually appear in the foreign newspapers, as if they take from the script something worth while printing, it will be sub-edited by them. Although the Minister has questioned my sincerity, I still put it forward that there are political Parties in the country and the Minister who will be responsible for this agency is the leader of one political Party. It is obvious that something may go out to which other Parties may object. We are all old enough to realise that that can happen; whether the objection would be well-founded or not is another matter, but the position is that objection could be taken.

The Minister said that the report will be laid before the House, but Section 16 merely deals with the balance sheet and the profit and loss account. The actual matter is not dealt with. It would be extremely difficult, in fact impossible, for me to put down a motion and stand over it, if I were not aware of all the matter that was going out to foreign news agencies. I admit the practical difficulty on the one side, but on the other side it is desirable that all that goes out should be available to at least some members of the House who would take an interest in it. There is no section in the Bill that would give me an opportunity of seeing what exactly is going out. If I am to be given the answer that there are not many members of the Dáil or Seanad who will take a keen interest in what is going out, I do not think that is a good answer. There are some members of both Houses who would be very anxious about what is sent out in the name of this country. I raise this on Section 3, as I cannot see any other section on which I could do so. It is desirable that this position shall be dealt with.

Comment on this

I appreciate fully the Senator's interest in the matter and that any Minister could abuse his position.

Comment on this

I want to be quite clear. It is not a question of a Minister abusing his position. The staff may be quite all right and the news items going out may be 100 per cent. correct. I am trying to provide for the possible objection, even a wrong objection, on the part of a political Party.

Comment on this

I appreciate the Senator's reasons and I think he has put them very reasonably, but I am afraid I do not see any way of dealing with them. It would be out of the question to undertake to lay before the House or put in the Library a copy of everything sent out. If the Senator has had experience of an ordinary newspaper office he knows how very difficult it is to keep track of copy. It would mean nearly doubling the staffs. Furthermore, I visualised the likelihood that our office in New York or London would prepare copy themselves, from basic material, dealing with a particular angle or a particular thing that has happened.

Ultimately, that copy may come back here; but we want to avoid building up a kind of Civil Service bureaucracy where everything would have to come back and be duplicated and go on files. That would not be workable. I think the Senator or any member of the Oireachtas or the public generally would fairly quickly learn of any reports that were being published that would be adverse and then a motion could be put down at any time calling on the Minister to account for them.

In relation to the annual balance sheet, that is all that is provided for in the Bill. That is the usual provision in the case of all these State-sponsored companies. In addition, the company concerned usually writes a report and, naturally, being anxious to show the good work it is doing, it will give information and put its best foot forward. I would expect that the report of the news agency would give an indication of the results it has been obtaining. In so far as it is of any assistance to the House or to the Senator, I can say that, in so far as I can assure it, there will be no question of any Party politics entering into the working of the news agency. Whatever differences we may have among ourselves here, we should present outside the country a completely united front.

Comment on this

There is one other point I wish the Minister to deal with. Would it be possible for members of the Oireachtas to inspect records of the agency if they could show proper cause for doing so? Presumably this agency will keep extensive files and records. Could the Minister undertake, if good reason were shown, that members of the Oireachtas might have the privilege of looking through them?

Comment on this

That is a rather dangerous proposition, Senator. Might I put it this way, that it would be granting the members of the Oireachtas a greater privilege and right than they have in any Government Department? The purpose is to keep away from Government files and the rather cumbersome Civil Service regulations that very often slow up progress. Therefore, I am not inclined to give members of the Oireachtas more rights in relation to a non-Government Department than in relation to a Government Department.

Comment on this

This is more like a newspaper office, into which one can go and inspect files freely, but I would not suggest that the financial side or matters of policy should be left before members of the Oireachtas. It is simply a suggestion that information sent out should be available always on files. I do not think that many members would be a great nuisance in that respect. I hope not. I want to make it quite clear that a case might arise where it would be of the greatest value to members of the Oireachtas if they could satisfy themselves on some particular bulletin that was sent out. If they could go to the agency headquarters and ask if they might please check it, it might make for firmer confidence in the news agency.

Comment on this

I fully appreciate that there are two sides to the question but, on balance, the suggestion made by Senator Stanford is one that merits serious consideration. I join issue with the Minister in comparing this with a Government Department. Whatever differences we have in this House, this is going to be the Irish News Agency. It is not a Government agency and not the agency of the Government of the day, but will speak largely on behalf of the people of Ireland, to put the Irish viewpoint across. While I do not think it will happen, it would be most undesirable if this news agency became known internationally as the mouthpiece of the Government of the day rather than the mouthpiece of the Irish people, giving expression to and putting the Irish point of view over. In order that this agency should succeed, it is eminently desirable that there should be no doubt whatever about that, and, so that there could not be, no difficulty should be put in the way of any responsible person inquiring into something that was reported to have been sent out.

There are, I admit, irresponsible people in Dáil Éireann and in Seanad Éireann. But a responsible person would be able to check up on what he had been told and, if necessary, could give it the lie straight away. Supposing in 12 months time I am told that some American visitor here said that he saw such and such a report in an American paper, and that it came from the Irish News Agency, I might say that it was a misprint or that it looked like a statement that was a misprint. I would have grave doubts if a statement of that kind could come from the Irish News Agency. Would it not be desirable, if I had any doubt, that I could go somewhere to check up authoritatively on such a statement, go back to the person who made it and say that it was not a fact, that it never emanated from the Irish News Agency? Knowing the difficulties, I think consideration should be given to the suggestion.

Comment on this

As far as that is concerned I think it would be feasible. I would be only too anxious to clear up any question for any member of the Oireachtas or for any other responsible person in relation to any news item that went out. My difficulty, as Senators will appreciate, is that if members of the Oireachtas went to the news agency to inspect everything sent out, the life of the unfortunate staff would become intolerable and, after a while, I visualise that a staff of two, three or four, if they had to keep records and run the news agency as a Civil Service Department, could be doubled straight away. It would mean that we would have to keep records of everything. I assure the House that I will help any member to clear up any question that wants clearing up. My endeavour is to make this a national issue. I accept that view. That is what I want. It would defeat itself if it played at Party politics.

Comment on this

I think the suggestion made by Senator Stanford a splendid one. Like other Senators I am very anxious to see this news agency a 100 per cent. success. As Senator Hearne stated, the news going out will concern Ireland and the Irish people and, as a business man, I cannot see that access to messages sent out would mean an increased staff. If members of the Oireachtas could have access to items of news sent out, the mere fact that they have, would be one way of ensuring that this Bill would find acceptance with the people.

Comment on this

What we all want is to see a genuine Irish news agency. I think the Minister appreciates that we have that in view. It seems to me that this agency will be watched very carefully, and that, as well as news, even telephone messages might be recorded by recording machines. The Minister might find that, in the end, this would be a very great safeguard, because he could play back the record of the telephone message and say: "These are the facts." That might relieve him of disputation afterwards.

Comment on this

I have a great deal of sympathy with Senator Professor Stanford and with Senator Summerfield, but I cannot help, at the same time, feeling that we must be very careful before we provide something for members of the Oireachtas as a right. I can say, quite openly, that I would not have the slightest objection to Senator Hearne, Senator Stanford or Senator Summerfield seeing the records of my business, but if they had a right to see them, and also the right to say "you must disclose your business", my attitude would be altogether different. I am not suggesting that Senator Hearne takes this view. I am trying to deal with the suggestion of Senator Stanford that members of the Oireachtas should have a right to inspect files. I take it that Senator Hearne is concerned with the need for accuracy and for ensuring that any statements sent out by the agency should be available on request to members of the Oireachtas as a matter of right.

I must say that I have found during the last five years, both under the last Government and this one, that I have always received a courteous and straightforward reply to any query I addressed to a Government Department, and it never occurred to me that it should have been regarded as a right of members of the Oireachtas to have such requests answered. The right to inspect files, however, depends on a number of factors. Inevitably, there will be a number of files, and it would be difficult for Deputies and Senators to go to inspect them without taking up the time of the staff. It may be that the news agency will so develop that there will be many large files, but if you have only got £25,000 and you have offices in Dublin, London and New York and other places, I should say the staff would be small, and I would hesitate to ask for the right to go into their offices and to take up their time.

Surely, between the one extreme of regarding it as a right of members of the Oireachtas to inspect the files and the other extreme that we are to be in the same position as members of the public with no responsibility, it should be possible to work out something whereby members of the Oireachtas, who have responsibility, should not only be able to obtain the facts but should be in the position of being able to send in important information. If a small staff was liable to feel that they might be called upon by any of the 200 members of the Oireachtas, surely the whole thing would be unworkable.

Comment on this

I must presume on the tolerance of the House once again because I regard the Bill as terribly important. It may be that I am dealing with general principles, but the first essential is this: that we are providing money for the establishment of a news agency. The effectiveness of that news agency will depend very largely on how it is regarded at home and abroad. We want to disabuse the minds of the people in so far as it is possible of the idea that this agency will become a mere organ of Government opinion. If the Minister feels that £25,000, or even £50,000, is insufficient to do the job properly, then let him come back to the Oireachtas with a Supplementary Estimate. This is a purely personal view on my part, but I would say that if it cost £150,000 to ensure that the news agency was going to be regarded as it should be regarded in this country and abroad, then, no matter where this money was going to come from, I would support the demand for the extra money.

Comment on this

I was not present for the whole of the discussion on this section because I was called away, and perhaps what I am going to say has already been said by other Senators. But, probably, it has not. I have experience as a journalist, not only as a working journalist on newspapers, but as a person who tried to run, or helped to run, an agency of the sort envisaged in this Bill and I say from my experience that what Senator Hearne and others are asking for is absolutely impossible to give. It would be impossible for a news agency or a newspaper, however small or unambitious, to carry on in a situation in which every single item of news was subject to inspection by anybody who came in and asked for it.

I know that there are fears that something indiscreet or that something unintentionally undesirable should get out, but if that has happened, it has happened, and will have happened before we check on it; there is nothing a member of this House can do to recall it. It will be the responsibility of the people in charge of the agency to see that no objectionable matter goes out, and I think there is a good safeguard in Section 7 (2) of the Bill, which lays it down:—

"The objects of the agency shall be so stated in the memorandum of association that the principal function of the agency shall be to ensure the collection, dissemination, distribution and publication of news and intelligence inside and outside the State."

I presume that the Irish newspapers can take the Irish news agency service, and if this service is available to them, there will be plenty of chances for us to check up on it.

Comment on this

I would like to put forward this point of view. We are asked to provide £25,000 for this news agency. I agree that it may not be possible to have every single item examined by the few Senators or Deputies who ever trouble to have an inquiry made, but I would put it to the Minister that surely it is not too much to ask that the national news agency, when sending forward its scripts to the various newspapers, might also post one of the scripts in care of the Librarian of Leinster House where it could be made available to members of the Oireachtas without asking them to go to the trouble to inquire into the records or books of the agency at all. I think that is the very least we should ask—that we should ensure that there would be a script available in the Library. I would make that suggestion for two reasons. First of all, we would like to see what this organisation was doing. We would like to be sure that it was doing the work for which it was set up, and I think that by putting its accomplishments in the Librarian's care those responsible would secure support and sympathy for any activities in which they might like to engage in the future. I would press on the Minister to ensure that one copy of each script should be sent to the Oireachtas Library, and I think that that would meet the wishes of the House.

Comment on this

I think that Senator Séamus O'Farrell put his finger on the difficulties when he very briefly indicated the sort of difficulties it will create for the Minister if this is insisted upon. I think that the House and the country, in a situation like this, are prepared to take a considerable amount for granted. The Minister responsible is either competent, or he is not competent. I do not think we should be unnecessarily suspicious of the bona fides of the Minister in this matter at all. I am sure that the Minister is as concerned as any member of the House that Ireland's case should be presented to the world impartially, and presented in such a way that those at home will have no desire to cavil for any cause whatever. I think you have to give the Minister his opportunity, and that it will be time enough to come to the conclusion that the new service is not serving its purpose, or not serving it in the manner which it is hoped it will, when evidence of it is available.

If foreign newspapers present a case from Ireland in a manner or in a fashion that will not please some people on the opposite side of the House there will be many opportunities for discovering that, and, I am sure, they will be made acquainted with the fact very quickly, and that they will take the opportunity of calling the Minister to account. I do not think that is going to happen at all. I believe myself that in their hearts and minds the Opposition know quite well that no Minister is going to do justice to Ireland, and no one sitting in the Minister's chair is going to do justice to Ireland, if he attempts to present the internal situation in this country as of two warring factions with a different point of view in regard to the affairs of Ireland in relation to the world outside. I do not think we ought to anticipate that that is how the news agency is going to serve Ireland. I think if we can get that right in our minds we would be quite satisfied if, when any occasion arises when someone disagrees with some presentation of some particular news item, it is very easy to check it by communicating with the Minister and asking is this a fact or is it not. There are various other methods of having the matter raised in the House, by motion, or by motion and question in the other House. I personally have no fears about the operation of this news agency.

Comment on this

That is just exactly the point. It cannot be raised by motion in this House.

Comment on this

It can.

Comment on this

If I am not in possession of accurate information, as to what is being disseminated by the news agency, how can I put down a motion in the House saying so and so and so and so? I can put it down in terms like this: "That, in the opinion of Seanad Éireann, the rumour that so and so and so and so has been published should be contradicted by the Minister", or I could move for an expression of opinion, asking for a statement from the Minister. I do not think that it is at all desirable that that motion should be put down. What drew me to my feet is this, that I do not altogether see any proper way of raising the matter by putting down a motion in the House because, unless something further than is intimated here is given to me, I have no proper way of raising it.

Comment on this

May I suggest a way? The Senator could put down a motion for the resignation from the board of a member of the board.

Comment on this

We have had experience here of the Censorship Board. It might be as well for us to put down a motion calling for the resignation of the Censorship Board. In this case, it might be only some small thing you wanted to have elucidated. I was going to make this further suggestion, since I see there are objections, and there is a lot to be said on both sides about giving the right to members of this House and the other House. This House, since I came into it, has worked very well through Committee. Would the Minister consider the Committee on Procedure and Privileges, on which all Parties are represented, that they might have the right of asking for information and getting that information on request made to them by a member of the House? That would obviate the objection that I do not think is too valid, that a member of this House would make such a nuisance of himself that he would hold up the work of the office. There are few members who would do that, but I still think there are some members who are anxious to get information, and they should be entitled to do it, if the Minister would consider the possibility of the Committee on Procedure and Privileges having a right to do this on request from any member of the House.

There would be no question of Party politics coming into the meetings of the Committee on Procedure and Privileges. Everything raised there is dealt with very, very objectively. We can reconcile our differences and, I think, the two viewpoints expressed here, that the provision of all information is desirable, and the viewpoint that the provision of such information would be impracticable, that difficulty might be resolved by the Committee on Procedure and Privileges or some such committee. This is going to be the news agency of the Irish people, and this is where I join issue entirely with Senator Séamus O'Farrell. This is not a private concern and it is not a Government Department concern. To be successful, and it is because I desire to see the thing worth while, I would rather see it not attempted than that it should get a name in this country or outside it of being a Government organ. It would fail from the word "go". Again, speaking with sincerity, there is a very large volume of opinion in this country that will have be satisfied as to the position. I do not want to see this news agency an object of suspicion on the part of the people in this country.

Comment on this

One agrees with Senator Hearne that this agency should not be a Party matter. That is agreed, but I think it would be fatal, as Senator Séamus O'Farrell has pointed out, if it were to become a Civil Service office. It cannot be a Civil Service department. The Minister is dealing in this particular Bill with a difficulty which arises not only here but in a great many other ways. You want to do something which normally is not done by the Civil Service and retain some parliamentary control at the same time. You do not want to subject the agency or board to the ordinary Civil Service rules. I agree with Senator Hearne that not only should this news agency be right but, as far as possible, it should appear to be right. Listening to Senator Stanford and Senator Hearne, it seemed to me that there were two different things asked for.

One was for a right, for right of members of the Oireachtas to have general access to files and records. The other was a case Senator Hearne gave which, I must say, made a greater appeal to me. That is the specific inquiry with regard to a particular item of news appearing or alleged to have appeared somewhere or other at the instance of the agency. I think it would be agreed that general access to files and records is not desirable as a matter of right and, in any event, if we take the second case, the specific inquiry, what does it mean. Does it mean that in July, 1952, for example, a member of the Oireachtas may ask to see what was phoned to London or sent to London by wire or what was written to London or New York in June, 1950. Surely that would not be practicable? I take it from Senator O'Farrell's point of view, with experience of the matter, that it would be impossible.

Comment on this

Impossible.

Comment on this

If there is going to be that right you will have to have an elaborate system of filing which, I think, is undesirable, and a lot of space. I think that if it were possible, without any right, or any expression on the part of the Minister to supply a definite check, this agency, like practical people and other Government agencies I know of, would be only too willing to do the best it could. I have had no difficulty in opposition for quite a number of years in ringing up a civil servant and saying to him: "Look I have been told so-and-so. I doubt it, but I do not know anything about it, could you tell me?" He tells you on the phone or he writes to you. We all know that in the ordinary way by private access, either the Minister or civil servants, and the higher you go the better in a way, you always get information. It is suggested that people should have a right to go in and examine files. I think that is one of the things you want to get away from.

The problem we are discussing now applies not only to this agency, but to general matters. A Government takes a certain amount of power and the Opposition does not like that power, but really the fundamental difficulty is, that the Opposition feel that they would like to see the Bill worked by themselves and do not believe it is satisfactorily worked by anybody else. Senator Hearne would not mind if the Minister, instead of being an outsider, were within the fold of the elect, true and faithful. You see, it cannot be helped. The Minister, no doubt, will have a successor some time or other, but I hope it will not be for a long time. His successor will get all these powers, and his successor will not be as bad as I may fear he will be. I make that present to Senator Hearne. The only thing we can do with this particular matter is to see how it works. I do think that the judgment of the agency and what it is like will not depend upon specific cases, but rather upon a general case. You will have to see over a period of 12 or six months how it is working. One thing that I am more concerned with in giving this money than any access to the files of the agency is how the agency is going to get stuff into the papers after it supplies it, which, I think, is the real problem for the Minister and those who will be in the agency.

With regard to the general attitude towards it, as far as I am concerned, I have been outside this country when I was in opposition and I always took the line, and I think everybody in a representative capacity going abroad should take the line, that I was going to put the Irish point of view, not the point of view of my own Party. As a representative of the Government or a representative of the Opposition, I always took that line. I think it is the right line. I think it is the line for the agency.

The truth is that in the powers Governments are now taking there is not any conceivable scheme whereby this House or the other House or the Committee on Procedure and Privileges or a Joint Committee or any body we can set up can keep day-to-day watch on the activities of this kind of Government-controlled board. It simply cannot be done. All you can do is see how it works and criticise it in general at a particular moment.

I think Senator Hearne will find, as we have all found, that there is such a thing as private access. If Senator Stanford was in trouble about a particular thing which he heard had been published, and if it was comparatively recent, I do not think he would have any difficulty in finding out from the agency what they had supplied to a paper. We must not fall into the error of thinking that what is printed is what was supplied.

Comment on this

I made that clear.

Comment on this

I know that Senator Hearne understands that well. Every one of us who has gone abroad——

Comment on this

You do not have to go abroad.

Comment on this

You do not have to go abroad. You can stay where you are, but particularly when you go abroad you meet a newspaper reporter. I found myself chronicled in Canada recently as saying: "Sure, he is a grand fellow entirely" and "I do not like him at all, at all". Everyone is disappointed when we do not talk like Lady Gregory's characters. You cannot be sure that what is published is what is supplied. If you do want specific information you can get it, I am sure, from this agency, just as at the present moment every responsible member of this House, whatever Party he belongs to, can get a reasonable answer to a reasonable question from practically any civil servant. That is my experience, and the question of rights does not arise at all.

The only thing you can do with this is, once the principle is accepted by the two Houses, let us see how it works and let us all join in the hope that Senator Hearne expressed that it will work well. Senator Séamus O'Farrell has made it quite clear from his own experience that it cannot work and any one who knows anything at all about it knows it will not work if we impose upon this agency the whole elaborate Civil Service system of keeping files lest perhaps at some time in the future some member of the Dáil may put down a question and ask what did the Minister do four, five or six years ago. That is a thing that would choke this infant at its birth. We should let it grow up a bit and see how it behaves.

Comment on this

I do not wish to have any of my remarks construed in any way as obstructive. I have nothing but good wishes for this Bill. We seem to be getting at cross-purposes. I hope I am not misrepresenting what Senator Stanford meant when I interpret it in this way, that just as you can walk into any reputable newspaper office and look up the files of the newspapers— you do not need the attendance of any of the newspaper staff to do that—so you should be able without any real difficulty or expense to have access, a day or a week after, to the records of what has been sent out from this news agency, which we are all convinced can have such tremendous possibilities for the future of this country. I have no wish to be anything but constructive. If there are practical difficulties in what seems to me to be a simple thing —in spite of what Senator Seamus O'Farrell, with his inner knowledge of journalism, says—is there any practical reason why we cannot see the files, in the sense that newspaper files exist, of what passes through this Irish News Agency?

Comment on this

I think Senator Summerfield has under-estimated the technical difficulties. It is true that you can walk into any newspaper office and inspect the files of the newspaper, but after a very short time you cannot inspect the reporter's copy of the particular report in which you are interested. There would be the physical difficulty of space and staff in keeping elaborate files of all the news that might emanate from an agency such as this.

I sympathise with Senator Hearne's anxieties, but I think he is overanxious and needlessly worried on this subject. There is provision whereby the activities of this agency can be debated on the Minister's Estimate every year, and I think that is really a more desirable method. Senator Hayes suggested that the activities of the agency should be debated as an overall picture rather than that the agency should ever be judged, especially in its infancy, on isolated instances. In other words, if we were to take Senator Hearne's point of view, he is practically suggesting a censorship by the Oireachtas over the activities of the agency.

I would like to put this point on that question: If the Minister were to agree to that and to the extra staff, expenditure, and so on, and time wasted, it would, in my opinion, have a very deleterious effect upon the journalistic staff of the agency. If they felt that everything they wrote and tried to send abroad would be the subject of day-to-day criticism and censorship by either House of the Oireachtas, they would come to the stage where they would refuse to write anything. It would be like saddling them with an enormous board of directors, all holding divergent views, and I think their work would be seriously interfered with and the whole object of the agency would be imperilled.

Comment on this

I think we are genuinely trying to save the Minister trouble on this point. When Senator Hayes says that this is a matter of opposition I should like to exempt myself from that. I do not belong either to the Opposition or to the Government Party.

Comment on this

I did not say that, Sir.

Comment on this

Very well. Thank you. I must have misunderstood you. I want to put a practical case to the Minister. Suppose, after the setting up of this news agency, he sends out a certain statement. A month later this is printed in an American newspaper in a way that reflects most gravely on the honour of the people of Ireland. Someone who gets hold of it is upset and wants to check the source of this. It may be maliciously distorted; it may be distorted by accident, but it must be proved that it is a distortion or the honour of the Irish News Agency will fall by it. How will the Minister meet a case of that kind? Will he simply say "We could not have sent out anything of that kind"? I submit that that is not quite satisfactory. He must have some record, whether it was telephoned or otherwise, to say "This is what we sent out. We are certain of it." Anything short of that, I submit, would be inadequate.

I am inclined to withdraw my suggestion that we should all have access to the files. It seems to be unworkable, but I do suggest very seriously to the Minister that he may save himself hours of work and anxiety later on by reconsidering his view on this point because a major crisis may arise in the Oireachtas on this very issue.

Comment on this

I want to correct Senator Hearne in thinking that I suggested that it should be a Civil Service Department. In fact, the last day when we were discussing this Bill I insisted that it should be run by competent journalists employed in the ordinary way and not by civil servants, although there may and will be civil servants connected with it. It will not be a Civil Service Department and you cannot possibly fit it into the groove which has been worn by Civil Service Departments over a long number of years.

Senator Summerfield says that he sees no difficulty whatever in a news agency of this sort producing its files just as a newspaper does. He is as far astray in discussing newspaper offices as I should be in discussing motor car parts with him. I know nothing about motor car parts; he knows nothing about running a newspaper office; and it is quite obvious that he does not. He may go into the offices of the Independent or Cork Examiner or Irish Press and look up the files there, when they are put before him. But let him remember that these papers print by the hundred thousand. He may even take a pin out of the lapel of his coat, as some people do, and cut out a little paragraph which appeals to him. The newspaper can always replace the spoiled copy, but a news agency cannot be run in this way. It will keep a record, I presume, an office record of some sort.

There must be a copy of every message sent out. It would be the key copy, if you like and it would probably be on flimsy paper, but it is not something which will be left on the counter to be thumbed by everybody who cares to go in, and to be abstracted from the file. Without any abstraction, deliberate or not, it has been known that reporters' copy has disappeared from offices, from very well known offices, and it could disappear, if it were put up on the counter of this news agency, too. I believe that everybody wants to see this country's case being brought to the notice of the rest of the world. You cannot expect anybody in any part of the world to regard messages sent out by the Irish News Agency with anything but suspicion, if we are to launch the Bill in the atmosphere of suspicion which surrounds it here to-night.

Comment on this

The case made by many Senators in relation to the suggestions put forward would be amusing, if it were not so serious. Senator Hayes puts forward a view—and he is supported by some few other Senators —with regard to the difficulty of an agency of this kind keeping files and he spoke of the difficulty of going back in 1952 to a statement issued in 1950. If we are to provide £25,000 to set up an agency which is to be run in such a slipshod manner that it will be impossible for the officers of that agency to present to the responsible authorities a copy of a statement issued by them two years previously, it would be better that we did not set up any such organisation at all. Anybody who has had any association with organisations, whether newspaper organisations or others, must know full well that the keeping of files is a very important part of the work of any such organisation and it is ridiculous to suggest that, if, within a year or two, a question is raised here or elsewhere as to what exactly a statement issued by this agency was, the excuse is to be put forward that it was too difficult to keep files and a copy cannot, therefore, be given. Senator Baxter, with his usual wit, attempted to prove to the House how difficult it would be to give effect to the recommendations made from this side. I suggest to the Minister that it is very simple to meet the demand put forward. All we ask is that a copy of each script be put in the Library and made available to every member. That does not entail going into the office of the organisation and taking up an officer's time, or going into any detail whatever, and, as the representatives of the people who are to provide this sum of £25,000, we are entitled to at least that consideration.

Comment on this

I was wondering what interest anybody could have in 1952 in what was or was not published in 1950. Surely, nowadays, news of the greatest importance is not even a nine days' wonder and anything that went out in 1950 will be completely forgotten by 1952, and long before it. We know that much copy will go out which will never be published, but if something is published which a Deputy or Senator thinks should not have been published, surely he has an opportunity of raising the matter, and if the Minister, on being questioned, states publicly that that was not what was sent out by the news agency, that statement will get publication in its turn and, in my view, will be sufficient.

I entirely agree with Senator S. O'Farrell as to the effect it would have on the actual journalists, if they were to feel that they were continually open to the possibility of inspection in relation to everything they sent out. I wonder what interest we can have in what has already been sent out. We do not know whether it will be published or not. We may go to the Library and see what was sent out yesterday or the day before, but it may not be published at all, or it may be published in a month's time or whenever it suits the particular journal to publish it. The only thing we can question is what we see published in some newspaper somewhere, or what is brought to our notice, and, if we think it should not have been sent out, surely there is an opportunity of questioning the Minister in the Dáil about it, and of asking if his attention has been drawn to it and whether it was sent out in these terms. If the Minister is able to say "No; it was something different", it will be sufficient contradiction.

Comment on this

My main anxiety is not to bind this news agency more tightly than a Government Department is bound. For instance, at the moment —I am taking concrete examples—I am responsible for three different news bulletins which are issued—one in America, one in Australia and another for the rest of the world. No member of this House has ever claimed the right to come in and inspect these. They have just to rely on my own sense of responsibility, or the sense of responsibility of whoever it is happens to be Minister in charge of the Department. It would be a completely ridiculous position if the news agency were to be subjected to a form of censorship to which I am not subjected in my own Department.

Apart from that, I was horrified by suggestions made here by Senators and I must say I heaved a sigh of relief when Senator S. O'Farrell and Senator Crosbie pointed out the difficulties in the way. I was horrified because I worked on newspapers and in news agencies for a great many years myself and the idea of having to keep a file of everything sent out is just completely impossible to anybody knowing the way in which a newspaper office or news agency is run. Another question occurs to me and I think this is a very real and important consideration. I would ask Senators to look at it objectively. No two Senators in this room, even on the same side of the House, will agree as to the exact tone and wording of a particular item of news. It is an expert job for the journalists who will be producing it and it would be an absolutely impossible position if the work of journalists were to be subject to the censorship and criticism of every member of the Oireachtas. A great many things may not meet with the unanimous approval of the House. I think it would be impossible. I think very few would meet with unanimous approval, irrespective of Party politics.

Let me take a completely non-political example. Suppose a new play is produced in the Abbey or some other theatre, which we consider of importance. Very few people would agree with the type of review sent out. Some person must be responsible and you will destroy, if you like, the genius or the art of a particular journalist if he is going to be subject to all kinds of —I was going to say ignorant criticism —and in some cases it would be ignorant criticism. He is an expert at his job; it is his responsibility to write on one particular subject in accordance with his training and experience, and no one unless another expert is in a position to criticise him.

Likewise in the line of political statements that may be issued from time to time, we may all have different ideas as to the best way of presentation, but it has to be somebody's responsibility in the end to present it. You will never get a whole lot of people to agree exactly on the method of presentation. In the same way each individual Senator realises that he likes to make his own speech; he may have different ideas and use different words to clothe his thoughts. On that score alone I think it would be highly dangerous. I have told the House that there is no desire in any way to utilise the news agency for Party propaganda and I hope it will be possible to obviate that. As far as the keeping of records is concerned, the news agency will do whatever is the usual practice in newspaper and news agency offices, but I do not think it should be asked to do any more than that. It should be given as much freedom as possible, and the Dáil can always make use of its privilege to cut them off with a penny at any time. The results of it will be obtainable through the Press.

The suggestion was made by Senator O'Farrell that all the copy might be supplied to the Dublin newspapers, that they could take the services. That, I hope, would happen. Another idea had also occurred to me; in all likelihood it would be this news agency that would supply to the shortwave broadcasting station the type of news prepared for foreign distribution. I would like to mention, however, that you will never cover the entire news service, for instance, news or articles that would be sent to India would not be suitable for distribution in America, as they would be written from a different angle and you will be doing that sort of thing the whole time. As I indicated before, some of the material may not be prepared in Dublin. It may be prepared somewhere else and used locally.

Comment on this

Is there any chance that a copy of the news sent to America, India or any other country would be made available to any citizen in this country?

Comment on this

I think it would be very difficult to manage it.

Comment on this

You must keep everything you send out because you never know what might be asked for.

Comment on this

To take another instance, a valuable scource of news is I think Shannon, where important people from different parts of the world pass through. An important citizen from some town on the west coast passes through. You get an interview and that interview is of no use, perhaps, except to that particular district. It will go straight off from Shannon and I hope we are not going to bring it up here and have copies and files kept.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister if a person thought himself libelled or that his reputation was injured by anything broadcasted by the news agency, would the action lie against the news agency or against the Minister?

Comment on this