We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Irish News Agency Bill, 1949—Committee Stage.

Contributions 185–369 of 369. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Irish News Agency Bill, 1949
Enacted

No. 22 of 1949 ›

Against the news agency. Once the news agency is set up the Minister has nothing more to do with it. It is a child out on its own.

Comment on this

I would like to put the position as I see it before the House. This House is providing £25,000 for the establishment of a news agency to send news of Irish interest throughout the world and at the same time we are creating the peculiar position that not one person in the Irish State can procure a copy, either by purchasing it or because of being a member of this or the other House, of that bulletin which is being sent out in the name of the Irish nation.

Comment on this

It is not a bulletin.

Comment on this

Or a copy of any script.

Comment on this

Sub-section (3) of this section states that no stamp duty shall be payable on any transfer of shares of the agency. The plea has been made here that this agency will not be a Government Department, but will be outside the ordinary ambit of any Government Department. I would like the Minister to say why it should be exempt from the ordinary stamp duties payable on the transfer of shares by members of a limited liability company incorporated under the Companies Acts. On the one side we have the plea that of necessity it must not be a Government Department—and I accept entirely that it is desirable that this should be an independent organisation, free from the restrictions of the Civil Service code—but on the other side I cannot understand why, if we accept that plea, it should be exempt from stamp duty. Many Senators know that the ordinary transfer of shares is subject to 2 per cent. ad valorem duty. To be consistent, that should be the position under this agency.

If it is argued that the amount of the stamp duty might impose a charge on the Exchequer, my answer is that the nominal capital is only £100 and the transfer of even one share at the rate of £2 per cent. would be a negligible charge. It would be better if sub-section (3) were eliminated from the Bill. It would be only a matter of shillings, so no argument can be advanced on financial grounds. If it is regarded as outside the Civil Service, it should not have advantages which are not enjoyed by an ordinary company. The inclusion of sub-section (3) will taint the agency with being a Government-sponsored company absolving itself from obligations that an outside agency would have if incorporated under the Companies Acts.

Further in support of my argument, I may add that Section 6 provides that the ordinary addition which the Companies Acts demand to the name of a company of the word "limited" is eliminated. As far as I can see, that is the sole purpose of Section 6. Beyond elimination of "limited" and exemption from liability to the Stamps Acts, I do not see any other exclusions from the provisions of the Companies Acts. It seems that we are trying to have it both ways. We are trying to have a company that is deemed to be apart from the Civil Service and not a Government-controlled concern, as far as we can, and at the same time we have this provision that payment of stamp duty on the transfer of the shares shall not be made. The amount is only a matter of shillings, but the principle is important. The Minister would be well advised to reconsider Section 4, and particularly sub-section (3).

Comment on this

I should like to have from the Minister an explanation of what is intended under sub-sections (2) and (3) of Section 4.

Comment on this

The inclusion of these sub-sections has been standard practice in the case of Government measures and the provisions are similar to those in numerous other Acts adopted by the Oireachtas. There is considerable difference between building up a Civil Service machine and creating a corporation which is financed and to a degree controlled by Government, but free from Civil Service red tape. That is what has been done in this Bill, and that is what has been done in other Bills of a similar nature adopted by the Oireachtas. I am afraid I cannot accept objections put forward on no other ground than for obstructive purposes.

Comment on this

I have been for a long time a member of this House. I think I can say that my membership has never been used either in this House or in Committee of this House, for obstructive purposes. If any member, who has been with me since I was elected in 1938 a member of the Seanad can say otherwise I will sit down. I think the Minister's attitude was entirely deplorable in saying that my point was raised for purely obstructionist purposes. It was no such thing. I hold this country as dear as the Minister and even the smiles of my colleague on the County Councils General Council, Senator McGee, will not take one whit from the rôle I propose to play. This Bill, if it is to be successful, must essentially have the support of the Irish people, of whom almost 50 per cent. support Fianna Fáil. I know quite well that this Bill can be steamrolled through this House. Of course it can. There is a loyal majority on the other side, made up of diverse elements, who will object, and object successfully, to any amendment that we may put down.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Senator would deal with the section now.

Comment on this

I am answering the Minister.

Comment on this

The Minister did not follow up his references. The Minister made a statement in reply. If the Senator comes to the question now I will be obliged.

Comment on this

Do you think it was fair on the part of the Minister to accuse the Senator of being obstructive?

Comment on this

If some things are said the Chair cannot help it. If we came to the business to be dealt with on the section as it stands it would be much better.

Comment on this

The Chair agrees that it is difficult for me to deal objectively with a point raised from a purely objective point of view when I find the responsible Minister to this House, a person who, no matter what way I may regard his politics, is placed in charge of the Department of External Affairs by the Irish people, questioning my motives. It is very difficult to be objective when one finds one's motives questioned. If the motives of members of this House are to be questioned by a Minister who comes here, then let us know it beforehand, and there will be an answer, a fitting answer, to charges of insincerity and of obstruction. Coming back to the point I raised, the plea has been made, and I accept it, that this Bill, when it becomes an Act, if it is to be entirely beneficial to the Irish people, must have the support, not only of those on the Government Benches, of those of us who represent almost 50 per cent. of the Irish people. I ask the Minister, through the Chair: Would it be desirable, in the interests of the Irish people that we all claim to have at heart, that the functions of the authority to be established by this Bill should be the subject of Party politics across this House or the other House?

Comment on this

What has this to do with it?

Comment on this

If the Minister is asked a question through the Chair——

Comment on this

The Minister has drawn this up by the charge of obstruction against me.

Comment on this

The Senator asked me a question through the Chair. Of course, I want, and the Government want, this Bill to be used for national purposes, irrespective of Party politics. I cannot say that, however, of some of the tactics used by the Opposition in the Dáil and which has shown its head here, unfortunately——

Comment on this

For instance?

Comment on this

For instance, that the House has been sitting since 3 o'clock and has only dealt with three formal sections without addressing itself to the subject.

Comment on this

What has the Chair been doing?

Comment on this

The Chair has quite certainly performed its duties fairly and impartially, by letting the House know that it is within the province of any members here or in the Dáil to talk on the Committee Stage as often and as long as they like.

The question the Senator asked me was whether it was desired to use the news agency for national purposes. My answer is, categorically, yes and I will welcome the assistance of the other side of the House in seeing that that is done. I had thought from the attitude of the Senators who spoke on the Second Stage that I was receiving that assistance——

Comment on this

The Minister has not answered my point at all. I am trying to devote myself to Section 4 (3). The Minister has adverted to my sincerity, and he appeared to suggest that this side of the House was being obstructive in its contributions to the debate.

Comment on this

The Senator has already refuted the statement twice.

Comment on this

And I will continue to refute it, on behalf of the people who have elected me and to do my best in their interests. No animadversions of people, however highly placed they may be, will make me take back one word of what I have said.

I will now come back to Section 4 (3). The Minister has not yet thought it worth his while, and I repeat that, to give me an answer to the question I ask: Why should the Irish News Agency be exempt from the ordinary stamp duty payable on the transfer of shares among its members to which similar companies incorporated under the Companies Acts are liable? I repeat that the whole purpose, so far as I can gather from the Minister's opening remarks on the Second Stage— and I have read the Report of the debates in the Dáil too, and I entirely agree with the expressions of opinion made there that it is very desirable— is that this agency should not be regarded as a Government agency or a Civil Service agency or as a branch of the Civil Service.

It is desirable then, as far as it is incorporated under the Companies Acts, that the ordinary law should prevail. Why, then, should we give a handle to people outside this country, and indeed in this country who want to say, and may say, that this is merely a Government organisation because the Government has taken powers under this Act to exempt the agency from the ordinary stamp duty on the transfer of shares among its members? You cannot have it both ways. What reason has been advanced why stamp duty should not be paid? The amount of money involved is negligible. As the Minister is aware, in another capacity, the ordinary duty payable on the transfer of shares is £2 per cent. per share. The ordinary capital of this company is £100. The transfer of one, five or 500 shares of the company would cost the State only £2 per cent. stamp duty.

Is it not very desirable to establish a principle and make it clear to everyone, and to remove doubts in many people's minds, that this is an ordinary company incorporated under the Companies Acts? Is it not better to let the company be liable to the £2 per cent. stamp duty rather than give the handle to people who will say that it is purely a Government concern and that they are taking power to themselves that no ordinary company enjoys?

I think the Minister would be well advised to reconsider sub-section (3) and leave the company liable to the ordinary operations of the Companies Acts under which it purports to be incorporated. I will end on this note— the Minister has impugned the motives of those who have spoken on this side of the House. He gave no reason why stamp duty should not be payable, and I would ask him now to tell us if there is any special reason why stamp duty should not be payable.

Comment on this

It is obviously the duty of the Minister to answer the question which has been asked by Senator Hearne. I am not an authority on company law, but I do not see any evidence even in the Bill itself that we need justification for exempting this agency from stamp duty. Senator Hearne has pointed out that the capital of the agency is only £100 and that he wants the same regulations to apply on the transfer of shares as if it were an ordinary company. But this is not an ordinary company. Any transfer of shares that would take place could only be done from the Minister to his nominees and back again to the Minister. There are not to be any transactions in the public market—the Minister for Finance will control the whole of the share capital and will issue sufficient shares to qualify people for positions in the company. The shares will never be on the market in the ordinary way, and why should we go through the fiction of charging stamp duty?

This Bill does not propose to set up an ordinary commercial company but once we have accepted the principle of setting up a commercial company with an allotment of a sufficient number of shares to individuals with special qualifications, I do not see any reason why the ordinary procedure should not operate. I do not think there is any question that this company will aim immediately at producing dividends and be responsible to its shareholders, although the shareholders are not in the Bill.

Comment on this

Indeed, they are.

Comment on this

Section 15 deals with the payment of dividends into the Exchequer but it deals only with £100 capital.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

I am afraid you cannot be recommended as a member of the board.

Comment on this

Section 15 provides that every dividend bonus and other money received by the Minister for Finance in respect of shares in the agency held by or in trust for him shall be paid into it, or disposed of for the benefit of the Exchequer, in such manner as the said Minister may direct. I remember taking shares in a newspaper once which promised to pay a dividend. I still have the shares, but I have not yet got a dividend.

Comment on this

You may be terribly sorry, but the newspaper is still in existence.

Comment on this

I suppose I will get my money back.

Comment on this

The Minister, to conclude.

Comment on this

Before you call on the Minister, Sir, there are one or two points I wish to make. I would like him to make an explanation on Section 4 relating to exemption from stamp duties. He has not given an explanation to the satisfaction of the House——

Comment on this

I do not feel there is any necessity to labour that point at this stage.

Comment on this

We have not got the explanation.

Comment on this

It is the right of every member of this House to raise any question of public importance on any Bill before it——

Comment on this

Subject to the ruling of the Chair.

Comment on this

Of course, Sir, but it is stated in Section 4 of this Bill that Section 12 of the Finance Act, 1895, shall not operate so as to require the agency to deliver to the Revenue Commissioners a copy of this Act or the paying of stamp duty under that section on any copy of this Act. Will the Minister put forward to the House any valid reason why a copy of this Act should not be furnished and why the necessary stamp duty should not be paid to the Revenue Commissioners?

Comment on this

I indicated already, in relation to Section 4, that this is a standard provision included in all Bills setting up State-sponsored companies.

Comment on this

I do not like to interrupt the Minister, but would the Minister give us the names of the State-sponsored companies similar to that?

Comment on this

Certainly. I think the National Stud Act is one such example, off hand. I think Senators will find that in all these State companies there are similar provisions.

Comment on this

It would not be similar to this Bill.

Comment on this

There are similar provisions, I said. The National Stud Act, Section 5 is the same. The argument that Senator Hearne advanced was on the basis, that by relieving this company from paying stamp duty we were, in fact, doing something which was unusual, or something that would indicate that this company was State sponsored. This company is State sponsored.

Comment on this

I accept the latter part. I do not accept the "something unusual".

Comment on this

A State-sponsored company is obviously sponsored by the State. It has not grown like a mushroom by itself.

Comment on this

The Minister is as aware as I am that——

Comment on this

I think the Senator might let me reply.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Inasmuch as this is a State company, it has embodied in it the provisions that are normal for State-sponsored companies.

Comment on this

That is my entire objection.

Comment on this

On a point of order, may I point out that this is the fourth occasion on which Senator Hearne has made a speech.

Comment on this

And within his rights.

Comment on this

I say he is not in order.

Comment on this

I submit that under the rules of this House, which are binding on all members of the House, including the Minister, who may speak in the House, that the rules of the House allow me to speak as often as I like on a section of the Bill.

Comment on this

But, not a repetition of the same speech. The ordinary procedure does not.

Comment on this

As long as I do not repeat myself, and if I am not satisfied, or if I feel I have not been explicit enough, or the Minister, in reply to my point, has not been explicit enough, I am entitled to get up again. I think it would be deplorable if this House is going to closure, as they can by a majority vote, the right of a Senator to speak as often as he feels he is entitled to speak, within the rules of of order. My point was this, Sir, and at the risk of being repetitious, I will repeat it, that Section 4, sub-section (3), gives a handle to people outside this House who want to say, whether they are right or whether they are wrong, that this Bill, when it becomes law, will be used for the building up of a certain political Party and certain political personages. I deplore that approach. The Minister's asides are heard on this side of the House as well.

Comment on this

The question I did ask——

Comment on this

Where they are contemptuous they will be treated with contempt from this side of the House, but when they go too far there are provisions under the rules of order of this House that this House can adjourn if a member of this House is treated with contempt.

Comment on this

May I say this: Nobody would be more against a member of this House being treated with contempt than I would be?

Comment on this

The Minister has done it from the time he came in.

Comment on this

May I assure the Senator, that it is not within the power of a majority of this House to deprive him of his rights? It is not within the power of a majority of this House to deprive Senator Hearne of his rights, particularly, at a quarter to eight. It would require very elaborate preparations which nobody has made, which nobody intends to make, and which nobody contemplates. It was never done. It is not proposed to do it now. The Senator can exercise his rights. There is nobody in any plot to prevent him from so doing. I should like to make that clear.

Comment on this

On the point raised by Senator Hayes, if Senator Hayes can convince the Minister that objections made by this side of the House are objective for the purpose of bettering the Bill, and induces the Minister not to make allegations against the probity of members of this side of the House, then, we will get on much quicker.

Comment on this

One of the most honoured names in Irish history is Charles Stewart Parnell. He was a great obstructionist. It is not a reflection on the Senator's probity to say he is an obstructionist. It may, in fact, be a term of admiration if he does it right.

Comment on this

I resent that very much.

Comment on this

Sit down, please.

Comment on this

The rules of this House provide——

Comment on this

Will the Senator sit down?

Comment on this

Unless the Chairman stands I am not going to sit. Very well, Sir, I abide by the rules of the House, and the Chairman in speaking to the House must stand.

Comment on this

We want to go back to Section 4. It has been repeated over and over, the case made for and the case made against, and if we are satisfied, and if there are no further words to be added to what has been said, I will put the section.

Comment on this

I still insist that the Minister should give us a more explicit explanation.

Comment on this

The Chair cannot force anybody to make a statement if he does not want to.

Comment on this

Then, those of us on this side of the House must take it, that the Minister refuses to reply to the question put to him as to why stamp duty in this case should not be paid.

Comment on this

I must ask the Senator again. That has been repeated so often.

Comment on this

Has not the Minister spoken twice?

Comment on this

I am putting the question: "That Section 4 stand part of the Bill."

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 24
·
Níl 14
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

On this section I wonder would the Minister indicate to the House the type of persons whom he proposes to appoint to this agency, their qualifications, and so on.

Comment on this

With respect to the Senator, I do not think that arises on this section. The section is merely one enabling the Minister for External Affairs, after consultation with the Minister for Finance, to take the necessary steps to procure the formation of a limited company.

Comment on this

Before the Minister asks us to pass this section, I would like to put an almost personal plea to him to consider the suggestion that the name of the agency should be in Irish. I appeal to him as the Minister was largely responsible for the passing of the Poblacht na hEireann Act. It is deplorable that the first Bill of this nature dealing with a State sponsored company should have merely an English name. I followed carefully the arguments the Minister advanced as to the number of people speaking English and the number of people speaking French. I would not object to giving it a French name but I think it is deplorable that it should go without an Irish name at a time when we are trying to convey to the outside world that we are a separate nation from England, that we have our own language. I do not want to repeat the arguments, but they are very cogent, especially in connection with a Bill of this nature, which is really designed to tell the outside world who we are, what we are and what we are aiming at. In these circumstances, it is a great pity that the company should have only an English name and I would like the Minister, if he possibly can, to change his mind about it. There is an idea that all the feeling for the Irish language has died away, but anybody who thinks that is making a sad mistake. There is a fighting spirit still left amongst people who are interested in the Irish language, and, if we do commit this solecism—I use a mild word—of establishing the agency with only an English name, we will be doing a bad day's work.

Like all those who have spoken, I should like to see this Bill a tremendous success. My only fear is that the Minister's ambitions are too small— you cannot do an awful lot with £25,000. I want to see it a great success, but I would like to ensure that it will not be vitiated at the source. I should like the Minister to consider giving it an Irish name.

Comment on this

I think this question of the name was debated at length on Section 2. I allowed Senator Mrs. Concannon to speak now, because she did not intervene in the debate on that section. The Chair cannot prevent any Senator from speaking again on it, but I think it has been debated at such length already that perhaps Senators would agree with the Chair that there is no necessity to speak further on it.

Comment on this

There is the further point that sub-section (1) of Section 6 provides that the agency shall be called the Irish News Agency, leaving out the word "Limited". It merely provides that whatever the name is it shall not contain the word "Limited".

Comment on this

I thought, when we were debating the statement that: "This Act may be cited as the Irish News Agency Act", it really referred only to the Title of the Bill and that the name of the agency did not arise for discussion until now. I am subject to correction by the Chair in saying that, but that was my reason for reserving my speech until now.

Comment on this

Section 2 deals with the agency and with the agency alone, and on that section we had a long debate.

Comment on this

I was unavoidably absent when the Seanad was discussing Section 2. I wish to associate myself very strongly and wholeheartedly with Mrs. Concannon and her remarks concerning the title of this news agency, and I plead with the Minister to consider even now giving it an Irish title.

Comment on this

The Leas-Chathaoirleach ruled this matter would be discussed on Section 2. That was the ruling given.

Comment on this

Not at all—he could not do that.

Comment on this

It was so ruled by the Leas-Chathaoirleach, and I suggest that this discussion is therefore out of order.

Comment on this

I was in the Chair when Section 2 was being debated.

Comment on this

I submit that the section on which the other side of the House depend, Section 2, merely says: "The ‘agency' means the Irish News Agency." That is all it says. There is no name given to it there. Here in Section 6, we are told that the name of the agency shall be the Irish News Agency, which, I think, disposes of the objection that the matter has already been discussed. I quite agree that this provision seems to provide for the elimination of the word "Limited". Otherwise, under the Companies Acts, the word "Limited" would have to be added to the words "Irish News Agency". My plea may be regarded as obstructionist by the Minister, and it may not be received at all—probably I am worsening Mrs. Concannon's case by speaking at all— but I can only add my small voice to hers in suggesting that here, now, we are given a chance of altering the name of the agency. This is the first time in the Bill it is set out that the agency is to be called—shall be called—the Irish News Agency and the Minister is given a second opportunity of deciding whether it would be advisable even at this stage to change the name. I fully appreciate that, from the legal point of view, it means the elimination of the word "Limited", which would, of necessity, have to be added. May I submit, purely on a point of order, that Section 2 merely states: "The expression ‘the agency' means the Irish News Agency"? It merely defines what will be known as the agency, but here in Section 6 we are given for the first time the title of the agency, when it states that the name of the agency shall be the Irish News Agency. If the first line were eliminated, of necessity, the name of the agency would have to be the Irish News Agency, Limited.

Comment on this

The rules for Committee procedure give a member of the House the right to speak as often as he pleases, the idea being that there will be a certain amount of give and take and brief discussion, but it frequently happens in Committee that it is not clear whether a particular point arises on Section 7 or Section 11 and it is in the discretion of the Chair and within the commonsense of the House to have the discussion on either of the sections, but obviously it is contrary to commonsense that the discussion should be taken on both. Whatever the wording of Section 2 may be and whatever one may understand from sub-section (1) of Section 6, the truth is, as we all know, that this afternoon we had quite a long discussion in English, and indeed in Irish, on the question whether this news agency should have an English or an Irish name. From the point of view of order and from the point of view of commonsense among ourselves, I submit that we have already discussed the matter and decided it on a division. That is what the division meant. I know that formal objection can be made as to what the division meant, but, in effect, it meant a particular thing, and I suggest that, having done that once in Committee, it would be a travesty of our rules and a mistake from our own point of view here to do it again.

Comment on this

The Chair tried to explain the position after Senator Mrs. Concannon had spoken on the particular point. The Chair is not in a position to curb any Senator in the matter of speaking again, except where it is repetition, and the Chair did appeal to Senators who had spoken on Section 2 to agree that it might be the commonsense way of doing things to abstain from speaking on this sub-section. it again.

Comment on this

We do not wish to prolong the proceedings in any way, and if at this late stage we could get an assurance from the Minister that he would introduce on the Report Stage an amendment to meet the wishes of this side of the House we would be prepared to proceed to the other sections of the Bill. As there has been a misunderstanding as to what Section 2 and Section 6 of the Bill meant, I am afraid that if we do not get that assurance we will have to decide the issue in the only way it can be decided in this House, by a vote.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Very simple.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 24
·
Níl 13
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

On the Second Reading, I raised a number of points and I have not seen that the Minister replied to the questions. The first question was whether it was proposed to make this a paying agency or whether it will exist entirely on moneys provided by the Oireachtas. He said in the Dáil that he visualised that at some time the agency would be in a position to sell news and make a profit. If it is proposed that it should go into the market as a commercial news agency and sell news as against the existing commercial agencies, what will be the position? What foreign organs are going to accept the news provided on a commercial basis by the Irish News Agency as against the news provided by the existing commercial agencies in this and in other countries? If it is not proposed that it should become a paying proposition, we will have to question, at a later stage of the Bill, some of the other provisions. I would like the Minister to give us a clean statement on this matter—and, I hope, a more definite statement than he gave on the Second Reading.

Comment on this

The only alternative to not entering into competition with other news agencies would be to leave ourselves, as we have been hitherto, completely in the hands of foreign news agencies for the dissemination of our news. The agency will put forward to the world Irish news from an Irish angle. To the extent to which it will be contradicting a wrong perspective or giving a proper perspective on news from Ireland, it will be competing with other news agencies—and I make no apology for doing that.

As to its financial future, I have indicated here and in the Dáil that I did not rule out the possibility that it would become a sound financial proposition, but I am not proposing it to the House on that basis. In so far as it can sell its services, it will do so. The extent to which it can become a financial proposition will depend largely on the extent to which it is able to sell its news service throughout the world.

Comment on this

On the Second Reading the Minister made it quite clear— and he agreed with me when I put it before the House—that the important question in putting the Irish point of view across was not so much the collecting of the news as—he himself used the term—"putting the Irish news on the desk of the news editor of every foreign paper". We accept that that is the purpose of this organisation. At what period of the activities of this organisation is the Minister going to decide—since a decision must be made at some point—that we have succeeded in placing on the desks of the many editors of the many papers sufficient Irish news, and that they are sufficiently interested in giving publication to that news, that the time has arrived now when we might reverse our outlook and charge them for news which formerly we were prepared to give them free, gratis and for nothing and which we were very grateful that they would give space to in their papers?

It would be more honest if the Minister would come before the House, and before the people of the country who must face the payment of this bill, and say that at no time in the history of this organisation which we are setting up here to-night will it be possible to make it a paying proposition. The more that this organisation of ours succeeds in its task, the more important will it be for us to feed the organisation and feed the papers that are prepared to give us space. It would, indeed, be a very wrong approach on the part of those charged with the responsibility of directing this organisation at a particular stage to decide that we have got so far in having free information about this country of ours spread through the nations of the world, that we are now going to charge those people for doing that particular job. Therefore, at no stage in the development of this organisation will it be possible for this organisation to pay.

A sum of £25,000 has been estimated for the first year. I have been told that it costs at least 1/- a word to transmit information to any of our American or foreign newspapers. If that is the case, how far will this £25,000 go in carrying out the work of this organisation? On the other hand, if we are going into competition with the existing commercial agencies, we are going to run up against tremendous difficulties, as I have pointed out on the Second Stage.

There is another point which the Minister has not made quite clear, that is, the question of the collection and distribution of news inside the country. What really does he propose that this agency will accomplish in that direction? Earlier to-night he made reference to Radio Eireann, that this organisation would be a supply agency, as it were, for Radio Eireann. From my experience of what has emanated from Radio Eireann during the last few months—and the experience of the Irish people as a whole, not alone those who might be supporters of a political organisation but those who may be supporters of many Parties now comprising the Government, and who have expressed their views to me—Radio Eireann is being run entirely as a political organisation, and I hope the Minister will take all the steps he can take to ensure that this agency will not be run on the same lines as Radio Eireann is being run at the present time.

Comment on this

It seems to me that it is difficult to discuss any one section of the Bill without making reference to other sections. Senator Hawkins has, in effect, discussed several sections, because he talked about the possibility of this agency earning money, and eventually earning dividends. The Senator does not mean that it will pay dividends. I think it will never be likely to pay dividends in cash, although provision is made for it to do so. I am not concerned with those who speak of it entering into competition with existing news agencies for the purpose of becoming a financial success. In a sense it will be in competition with existing news agencies, because it will be doing publicity for this country of a kind that nobody else is in a position to undertake, and that nobody else, apparently, is disposed to undertake.

Reference has been made that the intention is to put this news service on the desk of every news editor in the world. I am sure that will be done. Let there, however, be no misunderstanding, when I point out that that does not mean that every sentence and every paragraph that goes out will be seen by every news editor. Every news editor I hope will get from time to time such news as he is likely to print. If it is something that is likely to be of no interest to a country we are going to waste money sending it.

Reference has also been made to the cost of cabling. There are many ways by which that cost can be reduced. It is not to be assumed that if we send news to the rest of the world it is going to be sent by cable at a cost of 1/- or 2/- a word. The Minister stated in the other House, in part of the debate to which I listened, that he did not propose to enter into competition with agencies in the way of "hot news". I do not exactly know what "hot news" is. I have heard of hard currency, soft currency, hot news and cold news, names that did not exist in my time on the Press. I assume the Minister means that he is not going to issue first-hand accounts of sensational occurrences, but that the news will be of interest to the places to which it is sent, and of value to us, if published. Such news can very often go by a much cheaper method than cabling, in the form of a news letter relayed from our London office or New York office.

I am speaking, not of what the Minister intends to do, because I do not know any more than any other Senator about the details of what he proposes. I know what I would do, or what anybody who has had journalistic experience would do if in charge of such a Department. I would not send everything to every paper every day, and would not send it by cable. Accordingly I hope to make Senators at ease about the cost. The agency will be of great value to this country in putting the truth over in news about questions now not widely known. It can put over propaganda which would meet with the approval of everybody, if it was to the advantage of this country, in such matters as Ireland for holidays. It can also do a great deal, not only to improve the reputation of this country, but to impart knowledge of this country's grievances. In that way it would be a commercial asset.

Some Senators asked what news it was proposed to issue inside the country. That is a question to which time will supply the answer. News issued inside this country will be news that our people are likely to want to get, and for which they now have to rely on the Press Association or some other agency. Very often news that we get in Irish newspapers comes here in a roundabout fashion. It goes out of the country first, being filtered through to the Press Association or some outside agency, and then comes back to us, not in the original form, not even in correct form, but sometimes in a garbled fashion, either intentionally or unintentionally, or it is suppressed. It may not be considered worthy of being sent out by an agency on the other side, but it might be well worthy of publication if an Irish agency had charge.

To give an instance. Some years ago the sweekstakes prize results were issued in Abbey Street, next door to the Irish Independent office. The results were sent out from Dublin and were sent back from London to Dublin evening papers. That was done as quickly as if the paper had a man on the spot. If news that we want to be published about this country does not seem suitable to an outside agency or if a local correspondent thinks it is not worth telegraphing, he will not send it. If he sends news to the Press Association or the Exchange Telegraph, or some other agency, someone there has to decide whether it is worth reissuing and in what form. Local news, unless collected by newspapers' own men, that comes in from outside in some form, can be coloured by the outlook, political or temperamental, of the person who handles it.

If we want a news agency to deal with Irish affairs carefully, and without prejudice, one that will give us essential news that is valuable to our people, but that has no sensational value for those outside, it will not be published outside. Even if news were sent from here, as it will be, to the ends of the earth, there is no guarantee, nor expectation that everything sent out will be printed. Everything sent out by an agency and that has to be paid for is not printed. Every news paper office that pays for such service gets three or four times the amount of copy it can use. It throws away three-fourths of what it pays for, and makes its own news selection. News editors will throw away a lot of "copy" that we think is valuable. That can go on for years and then we may reasonably expect they will begin to realise the value of Irish news and use more of it. Even people abroad with no local correspondent here might in time request the Irish News Agency to act as their special agents for special research purposes.

Comment on this

Sub-section 2 reads:—

"The objects of the agency shall be so stated in a memorandum of association that the principal function of the agency shall be to ensure the collection, dissemination, distribution and publication of news and intelligence inside and outside the State."

Senator O'Farrell has dealt with what he considered to be the definition of what "inside information" might be. As the sub-section indicates, the Irish News Agency will be used mainly for propaganda purposes. Many Senators and Deputies, too, particularly the Opposition Deputies and Senators, were under the impression that the instrument which this Bill proposes to establish will be used primarily for propaganda purposes for a particular Government. I feel that that idea no longer prevails among Deputies and Senators—that they are now in agreement that the agency will not be used for propaganda only. So far, those who have contributed to the debate in this House have agreed that this news agency can usefully be employed in disseminating news which will counteract, largely, many statements made outside the House, and, perhaps, inside the country, that would probably have a very bad influence on the youth of our country, and on many grown-ups too.

The agency will have a great deal to do with counteracting falsehoods and statements of that character which are made from time to time by people outside the State, as well as by people inside the State. I was reminded rather forcibly of it this morning when I saw a hoarding with two slogans beside other matter. I did not read the other matter, but I noticed that, in outstanding letters, one of the slogans called for a boycott of English publications. The kind of publication to be boycotted was not stated on the hoarding. There was no attempt to classify them. Another of these slogans and, to my mind, a most objectionable slogan, called—and I would like it to be put in quotation marks—for the abolition of "Compulsory English". I mention it as an instance of the false impressions that may be created in the minds of visitors to this country that such slogans represent the views of responsible people in the country. It is very undesirable that any such false impressions should be left without an attempt being made to counteract them, and I think that this agency could do useful work in assuring the people that such slogans painted or printed on our public walls and hoardings around Dublin do not represent the views of even a decent minority of people in this country. The people responsible for them are usually composed of disgruntled and disappointed politicians. They are not people who are engaged in public life as we know it, and they are subversive in their activities in their attempts to create the impression that the ordinary people of this country support them. Their main support comes from the elements in this country who hate the very name of England, but is that any reason why they should plaster the streets of Dublin with subversive slogans of that character? They could well have a very detrimental effect on our people who have to go abroad to seek their livelihoods. I would suggest to the Minister that his Department might well engage in useful activities in showing that these slogans painted and printed on walls and hoardings in Dublin do not represent the considered thought of anyone but a noisy minority of people in this country.

Comment on this

I think the House will be very glad to hear the Minister replying to the last Senator in relation to the matters he has raised.

Comment on this

Ba mhaith liom cúpla ceist a chur ar an Aire ag súil go bhfuighimid a thuille eolais i dtaobh an chineál eolais atá ar intinn aige a bhailiú agus a fhoilsiú ó thaobh na gníomhaireachta seo. Rinne mé tagairt, an tseachtain seo caite, don cheist sin. Ní dóigh liom go bhfuair mé mórán sásaimh ó shoin. Dúirt an tAire nuair a bhí sé ag tabhairt an Bhille isteach nach mbainfeadh sé le go leor rudaí a mbeadh spéis ag daoine iontu. Dúirt sé:

"It is not intended to cover such things as accidents, crimes, court trials, racing, stock exchange reports or even debates in the Oireachtas."

Agus annsin téann sé ar aghaidh agus deireann sé nach é cuspóir na gníomhaireachta foilsiú a thabhairt do bheartais phoilitíochta ná "internal politics." Muna bhfuil sé ag braith eolas den tsórt sin a bhailiú agus a scaipeadh, cé'n sórt eolais atá braith aige a bhailiú agus a chur ar fáil? Sé an fá atá agam leis an gceist a chur agus an fá a bhí agam an cheist cheana a chur an tseachtain seo caite, go bhfuil mé in aimhreas go bhfuil gá le gníomhaireacht den tsórt seo ar chor ar bith. Dúirt an tAire go bhfuil sé ar intinn aige go bhfoilseofaí eolas. Dúirt sé:

"In the first place its function will be to give accurate information and news concerning Ireland, concerning matters of a cultural interest, of a trade interest or of general interest which are calculated to promote goodwill towards Ireland, to promote tourism, to encourage the development of trade and cultural relations between Ireland and the particular country where the news is circulated."

Feictear dom, maidir le nuaíocht den tsóirt sin, nach fundúireacht nó institiúd mar é seo is fearr le dul in a bun. Is dóigh liom gurb é an rud a b'fhearr go dtoghfaí amach daoine cáilithe le haistí spéisiúla a scríobh ar na nithe sin agus iarracht a dhéanamh iad a chur á bhfoilsiú ins na tíortha coigríche i dteangacha na dtíortha sin. Luaigh mé cás nó dhó an tseachtain seo caite mar shompla—an foilsiúcháin a chuireann Rialtas na Portingéile amach cúpla uair sa mbliain. Cuireann siad bulletins amach ina mbíonn eolas le fáil ar chúrsaí sóisialachta, ar chúrsaí airgeadais, ar chúrsaí tráchtála, ar chúrsaí geilleagair, ar shláinte phoiblí agus mar sin de. Ar an gcaoi chéanna, sílim gur thagair mé do Rialtas na Danmhairge a chuireann foilsiúchán mór amach ina mbíonn gach eolas ar imeachtaí na tíre. Ar an gcaoi chéanna —caithidh go gcuimhneoidh an tAire air—chuireas i gcás an iris atá á foilsiú ag Rialtas na hAstráile ina mbíonn cur síos ar chúrsaí tráchtála, cúrsaí tionscail, ar chuile shórt dá mbaineann leis an tír sin.

Do réir mar a thuigim, má bheartaíonn sé ar na rudaí sin go léir, níl fágtha le déanamh ach foilsiú ar an mbealach atá mé a rá. Más mar sin é, ba cheart a rá linn cén saghas daoine atá ar intinn aige leis an eolas a bhailiú, leis an eolas a chur síos, na haistí a chur le chéile agus mar sin de.

An chuid is mó den eolas gheobhfaidh sé é as na Foilsiúcháin Rialtais, gheobhfaidh sé é san Statistical Abstract. Gheobhfaidh sé é, b'fhéidir, ón Federation of Industries, ón mBord Cuartaíochta agus mar sin de.

Ba mhaith liom go n-inseodh sé dhúinn chomh maith agus atá ar a chumas céard díreach atá ar intinn aige. Eisean a cheap an Bille. Caithfidh go bhfuil fhios aige go beacht in a intinn céard atá uaidh. Ba mhaith liom go dtiubhradh sé dhúinn lide ar céard faoi a mbaileofaí an t-eolas agus cén sórt eolas é. Ba mhaith liom fios a bheith agam ar cén chaoi a cuirfear an t-eolas amach, sé sin le rá, an mbeidh san ngníomhaireacht nua baill nó members ar an gcaoi a bhfuil baill nó "subscribers" ann ins na comhluchtaí éagsúla, Press Association, Reuter, agus mar sin de. An bhfuil sé ag súil go n-íocfaidh institiúidí eile nuaíochta agus páipéirí, agus mar sin de, táillí le go mbeidh siad in a mbaill den ghníomhaireacht nua seo agus go bhfuighidh siad an t-eolas do réir mar atá sé ar fáil mar chuid dá gceart mar bhaill den ghníomhaireacht?

Sin, is dóigh liom, an méid. Tá poinntí eile luaite ag Seanadóirí eile. Ná ceapadh aon duine gur d'aon turas le cose a chur le cúrsaí an Bhille ins an Seanad atáim ag cur na gceisteanna seo. Tá mé á gcur chun go bhfuighmid lide ar an alt an-tábhachtach seo faoi cén chaoi is dóigh leis an Aire a gcuirfí an rud ar fad i bhfeidhm.

Comment on this

The type of news I visualise will be any news calculated to create an atmosphere of sympathetic interest in Ireland. Under the heading of cultural news, for instance, there would be reviews of new Irish books that may be of interest abroad, reviews of new plays, reviews of new works of art produced here, news items concerning various international events that occur here. It is a thing that I often feel has not been exploited enough from a news point of view. We have, in the course of the year, a number of international congresses of one kind or another, with delegates coming from different parts of the world to them. Antiquarians, astronomers, and medical congresses of one kind or another, and one of the things I hope the news agency would be able to do would be to send back to the countries from which these delegates come, news items concerning the activities of such gatherings here. Economic news, an economic survey, a thing that can be done much better by short articles on economic questions, and by publishing separate publications. We may produce a statistical survey here by our Stationery Office. I have no doubt it would be well produced, but how is that going to reach the hands of only but a few? Obviously, if you can secure publication in one big American paper, even of such an economic survey, it will reach far more eyes than if we published it through our Stationery Office here. If we can get into several hundred papers throughout the world we will get a far wider circulation than we could ever dream of obtaining by circulating it ourselves; trade information of a general nature, and specialised trade information for trade papers; political information of a non-contentious type in so far as our home political events are concerned.

I do not think, with respect to Senator Anthony, that the type of political matter to which he referred should be the subject matter of any comment by us, by a news agency, outside the country. These are matters concerning our own internal home politics. Tourist information, if I may take one instance where, I think, there is a tremendous field open to us, photographs. I am fairly familiar with the American Press and the Press of many countries. One thing which is striking is the number of photographs of Alpine scenes or scenery in Switzerland, or something connected with Switzerland that appear systematically in the Press of the world, all supplied by a Swiss news agency. One photograph of a spot in Ireland, be it a well-known spot like Killarney or somewhere else, is worth, published in some big newspaper, thousands of pounds of advertising. The House will remember, that at the time of the Council of Europe meeting in Strasbourg, we were largely, and a great many of the papers in the western world at large were dependent on other newspaper agencies for reports of what our own delegates were doing there. I think we would get better reports if these were produced by an Irish news agency.

A question was asked by a Senator as to the distribution of news inside the State; what was meant by that. I thought I had dealt with that before, but let me explain it again. Inevitably, the news agency will distribute news inside the State. A corporation or a company is strictly bound by its articles of association. It cannot do anything it is not empowered to do. It is an artificial creature, and those members who are familiar with the articles of association of any kind of company will be amazed at seeing the number of activities which are covered by it. That is because, of course, a lawyer in drawing up the memorandum of association of a company will include in it all the various things it has to do, for fear you might come to a position where there was some particular thing that was not covered by it. Now, likewise with the news agency. The news agency has to envisage every possible eventuality and in the course of its work as a news agency, even if it were only circulating information exclusively abroad, it is bound to disseminate some information in Ireland. If it supplies news to the shortwave wireless station it will be disseminating news in Ireland. If it supplies, as I hope it will, its service or part of its service to the correspondents of foreign papers working in Ireland it will be disseminating news in Ireland. If it gives, as I hope it will, news to our home papers here concerning things which happen abroad, from time to time, it will be disseminating news in Ireland. Unless they were provided for in the Bill and in the memorandum of association it would be acting ultra vires as regards its powers and, therefore, would be restrained from so doing.

I do not want to raise this as a controversial matter—I do not think it arises here—but, in passing, I should like to dissociate myself completely from any suggestion that Radio Eireann is being used improperly by the Government. The actual distribution of the news will be carried out, probably, in the main, through the offices of the company abroad. News will be transmitted to the New York office and it will then be the function of the New York office to disseminate that news to a certain number of newspapers in America. Likewise, in the case of London, the offices of the news agency there will be charged with keeping in contact with the various news agencies of other countries which also operate from London and exchange news with them there.

Comment on this

The news will be distributed free of all cost?

Comment on this

I would say that the bulk of it probably will, but, in so far as the news agency can sell a service, I think it should do so. It will be a matter entirely for the news agency itself to determine to what extent it can. I take it it will have three or four categories of services. It may have a free service and it may offer a special service for papers that want more news and want it more quickly. It may have a telegraphic service and may provide a feature service. It may have a photographic service, for which it may or may not make a nominal charge. These are things, however, that will have to be dealt with ad hoc as they arise. It will be mainly a matter for the news agency, into which I will not enter—a matter for the newspapermen dealing with it.

Comment on this

Is it not quite evident to the Minister that, if this procedure is adopted, the news agency is going to be left in a position to decide for itself when news will be made available free and when it will be made available at a particular charge to a particular newspaper, and that favouritism will enter into it? It is quite possible that if a particular newspaper in a foreign country enters into an agreement with this news agency to supply it with information on a charge basis, the news agency will not alone be giving the information, the hot news, if you like, but will also be giving news at greater speed and much sooner than it reaches the people who are not prepared to pay these charges.

Comment on this

The same thing could be said of other concerns, because you can impute ill motives to anybody.

Comment on this

These are business motives.

Comment on this

The same might be said of Irish Shipping, or Aer Lingus, or any other company that sells it services. You must leave to them judgment and discretion in the matter of how much they can charge for their services, what way they should develop them and what way they should build them. Somebody has to decide these things and surely the experts of the company itself are in a better position to decide it than the House or I.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister will agree that Aer Lingus or Irish Shipping are all the time selling their services. Here is an organisation which has a twofold purpose. One of these purposes is to give news which they think is valuable to the nation and which they would like to have made available to other countries, and then there is the purpose of selling other news. There is no comparison at all as between this news agency and Aer Lingus or Irish Shipping.

Comment on this

I should like to assure Senator Hawkins again that there could not be any favouritism in the running of an agency of this sort. I speak with inside knowledge. If news is offered free to any one paper, it is offered free to every paper. If anybody wants to buy news, the news is there for sale. There is no favouritism. That system works at present—different rates are charged by existing agencies for different services. There are States and countries which send out information which is free. There are sometimes commercial houses which send out paragraphs which are free and sometimes paragraphs and special articles—they may be interviews and so on—come into the offices, with the statement on them that a fee of so much is charged if the article is published. In the case of others, the statement is that the article can be published without any fee.

There is no new principle set out in the Bill. This system is in existence and has worked satisfactorily all over the world in the case of existing agencies. I do not see why it should not work with equal satisfaction in the case of this agency. This agency, if it has different services, will have the different services because they serve different purposes, but they will be available to everybody who wants them, I assume.

Comment on this

Ní thógfadh an tAire orm má abraim go bhfeictear dom nach dtuigeann sé féin gur rómhaith cén chaoi a n-oibreoidh an ghníomhaireacht seo amach. Ní thógfadh sé sin orm agus ní thógfainn air ach oiread nach bhfuil tuigsint chruinn aige ar cén chaoi a n-oibreoidh sé amach. Feictear dom gurb é an chaoi gur chuimhnigh sé go mba mhaith an rud gníomaireacht nuachta Eireannach a bheith ann agus go ndúirt sé go ndéanfadh sé a dhícheall chun a leithéid a chur ar bun. Thairis sin, feictear dom nach bhfuil sé cruinn ina intinn ar cén chaoi a n-oibreoidh sé amach. Tá fhios agam an rud ba mhaith leis. Tá fhios agam an rud ba mhaith liom agus an rud ba mhaith linn go léir, ach níor tugadh aon eolas dúinn, aon eolas ar féidir leat a rá gur eolas beacht nó réasúnach é, ar cén chaoi a n-oibreoidh sé amach.

Chítear dom gurb é an rud is mó atá ar intinn ag an Aire go scríofar sraith aistí, go scríobhfar go maith agus go taitneamhach iad, agus go gcuirfear iad ar fáil sa riocht go bhfeileoidh siad ar an "magazine page" ar pháipéirí agus irisí éagsúla. An tuairim atá agam, más mar sin a bheas an scéal, in áit na bpáipéirí sin, cé is moite de na "digests," bheith ag iarraidh na rudaí seo d'fáil agus a fhoilsiú agus airgead a íoc astu, go mbeidh siad a súil le híocaíocht uainn ar iad d'fhoilsiú. Má dheineann an beartas sin maitheas don tír, beidh mé sásta, ach ní miste liom a rá go bhfuil mé fós in aimhreas ar cén chaoi a n-oibreoidh an rud amach agus má abrann an tAire nach bhfuil sé ach ag tógáil seans go n-oibreoidh sé amach, deirim nach bhfuil mórán lochta agam air agus go bhfuil súil agam go bhfuighidh an coiste a bheas in a mbun slí leis an obair a dhéanamh agus go n-eireoidh go maith leo.

Comment on this

There is one type of news which has not been mentioned and which I think would be of great benefit to the country if it were circulated abroad, that is, news of any improvements in social conditions which have been brought about in this country recently or which are being brought about. I am not for one moment suggesting that such news should be put in such a way as to benefit one particular Party; it should be put as coming from the nation as a whole. During recent years I have seen articles in newspapers published outside the country which have laid great stress and emphasis upon certain unfortunate things that happen in this country, including articles referring to the large numbers of people of this country who are living in appalling slums, and giving detailed descriptions of overcrowding and bad conditions. Newspapers have also referred to people living in extreme poverty, but I have scarcely ever seen an article showing what is being done to eradicate the slums and improve the conditions of the people. I think that we should let the world know that efforts are now being made in Ireland to eliminate the slums, to give people better housing conditions, to raise the standard of living of the poorer sections of the community and to establish more Christian social conditions throughout the country. It would be very desirable that the people of other nations should know that we in this country are making an effort to improve the social and economic conditions of the masses of the people.

Comment on this

I quite agree with Senator Burke's suggestion. The only limitation upon it is the extent to which that news can be made of sufficient interest to secure publication and that is quite an art in itself. Undoubtedly, it is very important. Unfortunately, as Senator Burke has pointed out, a proportion of the feature articles published outside this country has been insulting to the country. I have some particular instances in mind recently and possibly Senator Burke has the same instances in mind, a most damaging article published recently on the social and economic conditions in this country.

In regard to a matter raised by Senator O Buachalla, the method of transmission of the news will have to vary in different cases. The main task is to get the news on the news desks of the papers. The question of how it is paid for depends on our ability to secure payment, that is, if it is sufficiently interesting. Probably the news agency may decide after initiating completely free services to send out news on a publication basis, that is, if the newspapers used news they would pay so much for it. They may also undertake to supply special services for news of special importance or a certain quantity of news at fixed intervals or to provide news at a great speed, but the aim is to get the news published.

Comment on this

I think the House would like to have some indication from the Minister as to the type of persons he proposes to appoint as directors of this board. After all, that is important.

Comment on this

The board of directors will be mainly concerned with the business side and the smooth running of the company. It will, in addition, have to tie in with existing Government Departments which deal to a certain degree with news. For instance, if it is going to supply news to the shortwave broadcasting station it will be convenient to have somebody from the broadcasting station on the board. I do not want to be tied to this because I have not really examined it in detail. It might be necessary, I think, to have someone tying in with the Government Information Bureau and also with the Department of External Affairs. The directors' job will be to look after the business side and the integration of the work. The advisory board, as the Seanad will see, is to be composed of representatives of newspaper editors, journalists, correspondents, and so on.

Comment on this

I should like to make one suggestion to the Minister in connection with the appointment of the board. I quite appreciate the fact that it will be necessary to have members of various organisations like Radio Eireann and the Minister's own Department on the board, but in order that the board might command the confidence of all sections in this House and in the country, no person should be appointed as director, if possible, who has taken an active part in Party politics. I dislike making this suggestion because people in this country who do not take part in politics are not worthy to be talked about, but it would be well if no such person were appointed to this responsible position.

Comment on this

It would be a poor board, according to the Senator's own standard.

Comment on this

Sub-section (2) (b) is:—

"The said articles shall provide that a member of either House of the Oireachtas shall not, except with the prior approval of Dáil Éireann, be appointed a director of the agency."

I do not envisage the appointment of a member of Seanad Éireann as a director, but I think the principle we in this House should establish is that the prior approval of Seanad Éireann should be necessary for the appointment of a member of Seanad Éireann. I am giving expression to a purely personal point of view. I do not believe in this exclusion of members of the Oireachtas from membership of public or Government-sponsored boards. I fully realise that, in most cases, a very valid objection can be raised. I think it is most undesirable that a member of either House, particularly of Dáil Éireann, should be a member of the board of a Government company for which a Minister in Dáil Éireann might have to account some day, but I think we are going a little bit too far in excluding members of the Oireachtas from membership of boards of this type which would be different, say, from Bord na Móna the Agricultural Credit Corporation or similar companies which operate mainly inside the country. Probably, on the balance, examining the question; we would come to the same conclusion as the Minister has come to when he included this sub-section in Section 8, but if we grant that, I submit to the Minister that this House should at least be given an opportunity of giving prior approval to the appointment of a member of this House who might, possibly, be deemed worthy to become a member of this board. At present the position is that a Senator can only be appointed with the prior approval of Dáil Éireann and from a constitutional point of view I think that is undesirable. If the Minister would consider, on the Report Stage, inserting the words "except with the prior approval of Dáil Éireann or Seanad Eireann, as the case may be", it would meet the small point I have made.

Comment on this

I rather agree with Senator Hearne. I have heard him express these views before. It has been argued that it is unthinkable that a member of either House should be a member of such a board. It is too prevalent an idea that a person who becomes a member of the Dáil or Seanad becomes an untouchable and is doing something dishonourable or wrong. Naturally, I do not accept that view. This amendment was, I think, an opposition amendment and it seemed to me that there were grave objections to it, but if it is going to be here I accept Senator Hearne's view. I think it should read "a member of either House shall not, without the prior approval of the House of which he is a member, be appointed a director". That would meet Senator Hearne's point of view. I think it is most objectionable that if a member of the Dáil is going to be appointed, there should be a motion in the Dáil about him. I think it is quite unprecedented that a motion should concern one single individual. A motion often concerns a Minister but it concerns the Minister in his public or administrative capacity. Here we are going to discuss whether A.B. is suitable, on the grounds of general qualifications and character, for a post of this kind. Unless paragraph (b) means that no Minister will ever appoint a member of the Dáil or Seanad, the provision seems to be a most objectionable one.

Whatever Government was in office, and whatever side of the House I sat on, I would find great difficulty in discussing a proposal that Seanad Éireann approves of the nomination of Senator A.B. to be a director of the Irish News Agency. The kind of speech you would have to make on it, unless you developed into fulsome praise of the person, would get you into a position which Senators should not be in. My own inclination would be to delete paragraph (b) altogether and leave the Minister free to appoint anyone he pleases. If he appointed a member of the Dáil or Seanad, that could be discussed, but perhaps not on a definite motion. Alternatively, there could be a rule that a member of the Dáil or Seanad cannot be a member of the board. The notion that the Dáil is going to discuss Deputy A.B., or that the Seanad is going to discuss Senator A. B., his capacity or qualifications for membership of this board, is most revolting. I do not like it at all and I cannot see what kind of speech could be made if there were objection. I can think of the plamás end—that would be grand—but the critical end would be difficult. It would do great damage to the person and would be discreditable to everyone.

Comment on this

The Senator will agree with me that, under this section, Dáil Éireann could discuss a member of this House without this House being able to express an opinion at all.

Comment on this

I am in agreement with the Senator that this provision was hastily inserted. We could put in "except with the prior approval of the House of which he is a member". That would keep the Dáil to members of the Dáil and the Seanad to members of the Seanad. It is a fantastic proposition that the Dáil should engage in solemn discussion as to whether Senator X.Y. should be something or other.

Comment on this

If the principle were accepted, I would agree with Senator Hayes, but the principle is not accepted by me.

Comment on this

If my memory serves me aright, when this amendment was introduced by the Minister in the Dáil it was as a result of a point made by a member of the Opposition, that no member of the Dáil should be appointed. I think the Minister pointed out then that when this came before the Seanad it would not receive a very easy passage. I agree with what Senator Hayes and Senator Hearne have said on that.

In the event of a member of either House being appointed, it would be only fair that they should be called upon to resign from membership of the House. I can see difficulties arising if a question is put down and the Minister is called upon to answer for the activities of the board while there is in the House a member of the board who may have views of his own. It would be in keeping with good government if the Minister thinks it proper to appoint a member of either House that that person should be free to accept the appointment without any approval of either House. We have already had Senators appointed to various boards and we were never asked for approval or disapproval. It should be the same in this case. The person then appointed should cease to be a member of this. House or the other House.

Comment on this

To operate Senator Hawkins' idea, there would need to be a prohibition on membership of the Dáil or Seanad. If the Minister wanted to appoint a particular Senator, the Senator would resign and then be appointed. For my own part, I am inclined, as a public man, to resent the whole idea. I would say: "Let the Minister do what seems good to him and let him answer for it". As a matter of fact, the public have been misled to a great extent into thinking that the members of the Dáil detest one another and do not recognise any merits in one another because they are on different sides of the House. That is not so, nor is it so in this House. It is quite conceivable that a particular Deputy or Senator might be good for this board. I do not know. It is quite obvious that I am not an eligible person and I am not bothering about it. If you go the whole hog, you prevent police, army officers, civil servants, perhaps servants of local authorities, employees of the Electricity Board or other boards, from becoming members of the Dáil or Seanad. You widen the scope of government and narrow the scope of people from whom you can get governors. To some extent you did it in the other House, and there was a certain amount of acrimony about it. What I would like to do with paragraph (b) is to take it out, and to say to the other House: "If you do not like what the Minister does—this Minister or any other Minister—have your crack at him."

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Hayes. I have no personal interest in this matter, and I do not expect that I ever will have one. I think the best thing to do is to delete paragraph (b) entirely. I do not see why there should be a specific article in this Bill providing that everybody is eligible for a directorship of the agency excepting a member of the Oireachtas. It is particularly objectionable in the form it is in here, that while it might be possible to appoint or to suggest the appointment of a member of the Oireachtas or of the Seanad, the Seanad might not be consulted. I feel that it would be much better to delete the clause altogether, and that would meet the points raised by Senator Hawkins and by members on the other side of the House. There is no good reason for keeping in paragraph (b) in its present form, where it deprives this House of asserting rights unless they are conferred by the Dáil. The sub-clause of Section 8 provides that a member of either House of the Oireachtas shall not be appointed a director of the agency except with the prior approval of Dáil Éireann, and it will be much better if the Minister will agree to delete it.

Comment on this

The difficulty with regard to this is that the Dáil agreed to insert this sub-section on representations from Deputy Lemass—I think it was he who made them.

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

I think the Dáil met Deputy Lemass in that.

Comment on this

But, Deputy Lemass pointed out that when the matter came before the Seanad it was entirely a matter for the Seanad.

Comment on this

Apart from anything said already in either House, I feel, with other Senators, that if there is somebody suitable for the board of directors for the agency from this House or from the other House there is no reason why he should not be appointed. After all, that man must be the keeper of his own conscience when he is on the board and despite the manner in which we criticise him, we must assume he will do his best when he is appointed to the board, irrespective of his political views.

Comment on this

I subscribe to that entirely.

Comment on this

It is not a wrong point of view for members of the Oireachtas to assent to suggestions that that is not the attitude that will be taken up by one of its members who may be placed in such a position. There has been a great deal of propaganda against the appointment of members of the Oireachtas but we should not take up the attitude of continually protesting against it. As Senator Hayes has pointed out the more restrictions you put on individuals as to their places in public life, the narrower you make the possible choices.

Comment on this

Leave it until the Report Stage. I would like to make it clear that the restricting amendment to which I take objection was inserted by the Minister as a result of the views expressed in the Dáil by some members, but Deputy Lemass made it clear that the Seanad should consider it: that it was a matter entirely for the Seanad, and there was also the question raised as to whether it might be deemed impertinent on the part of Dáil Éireann to insert such a provision.

Comment on this

I think that the House might accept the suggestion that we have got, to defer paragraph (b). We might have some decision about it to-night.

Comment on this

If this House was unanimous on it——

Comment on this

Unanimous on what?

Comment on this

On the deletion of (b) altogether. I have not had an opportunity of consulting the Minister, and I do not know his views.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We are not discussing it now. Perhaps we could leave it over until the next day.

Comment on this

Let Section 8 stand, and let us go ahead and see what happens later on.

Comment on this

The only objection I have to make to this section is on the same grounds as before, that it seems wrong that this agency should be excluded from the ordinary operations of the Companies Acts. This agency should, I think, be divorced as far as possible, from Government control.

Comment on this

You have put that on record already.

Comment on this

I would like to know why is there a provision enabling the Oireachtas to lend a particular sum to enable the formation of this company when we have already, from the Minister himself, an assurance that this company is never going to be a paying concern?

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

I understand that the procedure in these cases is that the money must be advanced by way of loan to the promoters. This company, like every company, will have formation expenses to meet.

Comment on this

I agree that ordinary promotion expenses must often remain to be met for a long time after the company has been formed. I would far prefer that instead of giving a loan to the company, a grant should be made to avoid using the word "loan". Section 10 provides that—

"the Minister may, out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas, lend to the agency upon such terms and conditions as to time and manner of repayment, rate of interest, security and other matters whatsoever as he shall think proper, a sum not exceeding £250 to be applied by the agency in or towards paying the expenses of the promotion, formation and registration of the agency ..."

I would far prefer that instead of a loan a grant should be made.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

The Minister knows, as Senator Hearne knows, that that section deals with the Department of Finance. The Department of Finance is a Department which has very great regard for long precedents and it has very decided views on these matters. In the Supplementary Estimate the word "loan" was used and that being so, the word "loan" is used in the Bill. That is the method of the Department of Finance. The Minister for External Affairs may not have succeeded in persuading the Department of Finance to alter its courses, but perhaps Senator Hearne may have better luck if he ever becomes a Minister.

Comment on this

Let the section go.

Comment on this

I yield to no one in my admiration of the Department of Finance as a watch-dog of public finance, but I will not yield to them in a matter of principle.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Maybe, with the help of God, if Senator Hearne ever becomes a Minister he will make the Department of Finance toe the line.

Comment on this

I have no hope of doing that, but I did hope that the astuteness of the Minister for External Affairs might enable him to evade the watch-dog of the Department of Finance in this. I think it will be far more preferable, and that the Minister for External Affairs will be much more happy, if a grant is made instead of a loan. After all, principles are not subject to finance.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Maybe—I am not so sure. I have listened for a long time, and I have a feeling that everything is subject to finance now.

Comment on this

This, I understand, is merely a continuation of the practice that has been formulated in the case of Comhlucht Siuicre Eireann Teo. It is a continuation of that practice.

Comment on this

That is quite correct.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister this question? The qualification holding is one share. Section 14 says that every member of the agency shall hold, in effect, a share by virtue of the permission of the Minister for Finance. I have gathered from the Minister that his idea was that the board, while they might out of ordinary business reasons have associations with, say, the Department of External Affairs, Radio Éireann, and some other bodies, I cannot recall for the moment, that they would have a certain amount of independence or to use the Minister's own expression when the Bill went through "This was a child who would have to stand on his own legs." Does there not seem to be there a certain circumscribing of the possible freedom of the news agency? I myself am not too sure in my own mind whether it really does circumscribe. Take, for example, that I was a member of the board. I would hold one share, and I would hold it by virtue of the fact that the Minister for Finance made it available. If I felt there was something going on, with which I disagreed, I would resign and hand back the share. The Minister has sufficient experience to know that most boards are not run that way. I mean, you would not always lead with your chin or dig your heels in. There must be a certain amount of give and take. I think it would be very dangerous if the board had this feeling that there was some circumscribing of their rights and freedom. I think that would be undesirable. I am sure the Minister would agree with me on that. Whether this section will give that power or not I am not sure. I merely asked the Minister's view on the section, on the possibility of what I said happening.

Comment on this

I see the difficulty the Senator raises. The section deals with members of a company, not necessarily directors. There are members of the company who have their annual formal shareholders' meetings. One of the difficulties, in any measure of this kind, is that, naturally, the Department of Finance is the watchdog of the public purse and enforces certain rules fairly strictly and once a precedent is set in one particular company, or in one particular statute, they insist on maintaining the precedent and the safeguards they have established for themselves. Section 14 is a replica of numerous similar sections in other Acts. I do not think there is anything in the section that does, in fact, circumscribe the freedom of action of members of the company. It casts upon them the onus of holding shares in trust for the Minister for Finance and of not being able to kick over their responsibility completely and say: "Here is my share. I can sell it, or do what I like with it."

Comment on this

If I were in charge of this Bill I would probably go much further than the Minister, because I regard this Bill as much more important than any other Bill that establishes a Government-sponsored concern and, because of that, I would fight Finance to the limits on a question like that.

Comment on this

The Bill got here. Senator, and I am lucky to have got it so far.

Comment on this

An bhfuil dóchas ar bith go mbeidh ar chumas na Gníomhaireachta Nuachta, díbhinn nó bónas d'íoc laistigh de thréimhse réasúnach nó an amhlaidh nach bhfuil sa rud go léir ach cur i gcéill nó, mar deirtear sa nGaeltacht, "mada sa bhfuinneoig"?

Comment on this

I sympathise with the Senator. I assure the Senator it is not window dressing. We are setting up a news agency that will be operating ten, 20, 30 or 50 years hence. You never know how successful it may be. You never know what action may make this country the centre of news for Europe, for instance, at some stage. There is a possibility it may make money on some occasions.

Comment on this

Just a possibility.

Comment on this

And it is just to cover that possibility, because we are not now legislating for six months hence. We are legislating for ten or 20 years hence.

Comment on this

It is seldom I disagree with Senator Ó Buachalla, but I would not be at all anxious, and this is my own personal opinion, about the possibility of dividends being paid as far as money is concerned. The position that the Minister envisages may come to pass. We do not know. Queer things are happening in the world to-day, very, very queer things and, as the Minister has said, you may possibly find this country a centre for the disseminaton of news to Europe. Leaving all these possibilities aside, and taking the broad view if this Bill does work, despite a certain doubt that was cast on the approach to it from our side of the House as to what we hope will be done by the Bill when it becomes an Act then, as far as I am concerned, and I am sure as far as the people of Ireland are concerned, it will not matter a hoot whether there is 1/- or £1,000,000 dividend paid. The dividends we are really looking for will be on a far higher plane than mere money. It is with all sincerity I say that the things we hoped for in years gone by, the things we hoped for when we got liberty and we became more cynical, are not measured in terms of dividends, but the dividend I would like to see paid to the Irish people would be the spreading abroad, and to the rest of the world, of what this country stands for, not to-day, but in centuries past.

Comment on this

On an earlier section I asked the Minister would the board follow the example of Bord na Móna and other State-sponsored companies and give a report? He referred me to Section 16. That, as far as I can make out, would only give us information about the finances of the board and would not give us any of these tangible results for which Senator Hearne hopes. It would not tell us what we would like to hear. It would stir enthusiasm and interest in the agency if we could have once a year at least an informative and interesting report of their work. Otherwise, we would be very much in the dark.

I share Senator Hearne's belief that the people would appreciate the good work that we hope the agency will do, but if we are to have interest in it, we would need to know about it and it is only through an annual report that that objective could be obtained.

Comment on this
Captain Orpen

The Minister, in his Second Reading speech, following possibly a suggestion by Senator Douglas, seemed agreed to the idea that in semi-State companies it might be desirable to have some method of examining the working that was a little more comprehensive than merely a balance sheet produced by the company. It is suggested that possibly something along the lines of what they do in Sweden might be desirable. Whether it is necessary in this particular State company to have this elaborate machinery or not, one does not know, but certainly, in general, we want something more than exists to-day to investigate the operations of these companies because we are only given the information that they wish to present. We cannot in any way demand the information that we require. In an ordinary company the shareholders are entitled to ask for information at least once a year and, presumably, they get it. These semi-State companies, however, present reports. Those reports are drawn up by the company and we have no method of questioning them. I would hope that possibly the Minister could see his way to provide some machinery whereby we could question the workings of these companies. It is not merely enough to say that we can discuss the thing on his Estimate. This House cannot discuss it on his Estimate, for one thing, and secondly, in the Dáil it may be overlooked as there are so many other things that the Minister may be asked on his Estimate. Therefore, I suggest, that, if it is possible for him to carry out—it was not a promise—his agreement on principle, it would be desirable to have some sort of machinery for the semi-State and State companies so that they could be investigated periodically while, at the same time, maintaining day to day control.

Comment on this

Bhfuil aon rud le rá ag an Aire i dtaobh an méid atá ráite ag an Seanadóir Bean Uí Choincheannain maidir le socrú a dhéanamh tuarascáil fháil on mBord i dtaobh oibriú na gníomhaireachta?

Comment on this

I sympathise entirely with the point made both by Senator Mrs. Concannon and Senator Orpen. Certainly, it is my intention that the company should produce a report with its balance sheet. I am afraid I cannot say whether there is a specific provision contained in the Turf Board Act or the other Acts saying that but I know there is specific provision for the laying of the accounts on the Table of both Houses. I think the report is a supplementary thing that the companies furnish themselves. It is obviously to the advantage of the company to furnish with its accounts a report of its activities so as to justify its expenditure, so that when the Estimates come up before the Dáil, they can say: "There is all the good work we have done. Please vote us more money." I agree entirely with the advisability of doing that and I think it should be done. I do not think it is necessary to incorporate it in the Bill.

As to Senator Hawkins' suggestion, it does not really affect very much this particular Bill but I think it is a matter of very considerable importance. I think the time has come when methods of examining the affairs of all State-sponsored companies should be provided by the Oireachtas. It is a matter that should be considered and discussed objectively on a non-Party basis and it is a matter, I feel, of very considerable importance because the big failure of nationalisation in a great many cases has been the tendency towards bureaucracy, very often towards inefficiency and in some cases, I think, towards some kind of political preferment. So that I think here we should try to forearm ourselves to prevent such a position from arising in the future.

It is going completely outside the scope, possibly, of the Bill but the mere fact that now we are taking over our transport and that the news agency and numerous other undertakings are developing and acquiring more power, renders it all the more necessary that some provisions should be made to investigate the affairs of each of these companies at regular intervals. I know I am probably trespassing on the House and going outside the scope of the discussion. I feel, however, that neither the Dáil nor the Seanad is the most efficient body for providing such machinery because it may very often require very minute examination and it should also be some form of investigation that will enable any citizen to go in with his complaint and to say that he is not getting the service he is entitled to or that he is being overcharged for the service he is getting and have that investigated.

It occurred to me that the more satisfactory way of dealing with it would be through the setting up of an administrative court, which is a practice which has been followed in many other countries, where any citizen could go in with his complaint and have it dealt with on the spot, publicly. I am sorry if I have transgressed but I thought I should mention that. It is a matter of some interest.

Comment on this

In connection with the provision in Section 16 for the tabling of balance sheet, profit and loss account, and so on, I think similar provisions apply in respect of Bord na Móna. Again, strictly within the limits of the law, they could merely present a balance sheet. They go much further. The last report was an admirable report.

Comment on this

Splendid.

Comment on this

It was one of the best reports I have seen for many a long day.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

If the balance sheet and profit and loss account to be furnished under this section will include something like that, I am sure it would meet the wishes of Senator Mrs. Concannon and myself. While I admit that it is slightly outside the ambit of this Bill, I was very glad that the Minister dealt with this business of Government-sponsored boards, and the feeling that there is that the ordinary individual is becoming more and more powerless as far as these big organisations are concerned. It is very desirable that that expression of opinion should be given by the Minister. I am not tying him down now to any responsibility for a Government statement in this matter. It is very desirable and very welcome to hear from the Minister his opinion that the matter is one that should be the subject of consideration, objectively, apart from any political Party affiliations.

Again I will crave the indulgence of the House. It is accepted, I think, by all Parties in the State that there are certain things that must be done by the State where private individuals would be either incompetent or unable to command the resources necessary to make the project a success. Generally speaking, I think it is accepted that the development of our turf industry demands such great resources that a private concern, actuated solely by the motive of possible profits or dividends, could not undertake the huge work involved. It is essential, and I think it is agreed by all Parties in the State, that it is eminently desirable in the national interest, that there should be development of our bogs. We are agreed on that, but there is a difficulty. I remember that the Electricity Supply Board was established on the basis of much the same consideration and the growing feeling has been that they have acquired power so great that the ordinary private citizen, who, in the final analysis, is going to decide whether they will stay there or not——

Comment on this

He is their shareholder.

Comment on this

He is their shareholder, and he is unable to get the information necessary for him to decide whether the existing set-up should last or should be modified. The statement of the Minister on the general principle is very welcome, so far as I am concerned. It is a matter about which the public mind should be agitated to a greater extent than it is at present. One of the things on which we can find agreement is an approach to this problem, which is one of our biggest problems, from a purely objective non-Party point of view.

Comment on this

The House would like to have a little more information with regard to this section. The section provides that an advisory board may be set up to advise and assist the agency in the conduct of its functions, as and when requested by the managing director of the agency. I take it we are making provision for the setting up of an advisory board consisting of certain classes of people engaged in the business of collecting news. This board, which I assume will be paid out of State funds, is to advise the managing director, but only on such occasions as he requests their advice. We have already a board of directors and we have already made provision for the recruitment of staff, which, we understand, are to be a highly skilled staff of qualified journalists who know their business from A to Z and paid proper trade union wages.

This advisory board which it is proposed to set up is to be called into consultation only when the manging director requests. The board may be set up and it may hold one meeting. The managing director may not see eye to eye with the views of some of the members of the board and may decide that it would be better if the board were not called into consultation any more. I do not know what provision the Minister proposes to make—how he proposes that the members of the board are to be reimbursed for their attendance and whether they are to be paid a specified salary or merely travelling expenses. The House would like to have more definite information from the Minister as to what the functions of the board are to be and also with regard to the proposal that the board should be called in to give advice, only when the managing director so requests.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say why the managing director is given the power instead of the chairman? One would imagine that in the hierarchy of officers the chairman would be above the managing director.

Comment on this
Captain Orpen

This board is to function in the matter of giving advice when requested to do so by the managing director of the company. Surely one can envisage the possibility of its being desirable that the board should function at some time when the managing director does not want it to do so. I suggest that the Minister, as well as the managing director, should have power to get the board to functions. As I read it, the board only functions at the request of the managing director, and I can envisage a time when the Minister might like it to function. He has no power to get it to do so and I suggest he should take that power.

Comment on this

I drew attention to that on the Second Reading because it seemed to me that the advisory board was put in at the end of the Bill as a sort of afterthought and was in no way linked with the board of directors or the news agency itself. I cannot even now see how it will be linked up. Desirable as it is to have some body of experts who will act in an advisory capacity, the possibility, and almost the probability, is there that the managing director may decide that he is the man who knows all about it. Even the board may decide that they will not ask for advice, and if advice were given, it probably would not be accepted. But having been given and having been turned down, I could imagine the members of the advisory board resigning and saying that there was no sense in remaining there any longer.

I should like to see some advisory body, because I think it will be necessary. A hundred difficulties are bound to arise which none of us can visualise at the moment and it would be well that as representative a body of experienced people as possible should be there ready to help to untangle any tangle which might arise and whose advice would be accepted in the spirit in which it was given.

Sub-section 2 says that the Minister shall appoint the members of the board. It seems to be inevitable and desirable that he should, but, assuming that a method of working is devised and that you can get the advisory board to co-operate with the board of directors and the company, for how long is the appointment to last? Is this the usual form in which provision is made in Bills for the appointment of members of boards? Is there any way in which the appointments can be limited or terminated? As it reads here—I read it merely as I read any other statement, that is, without knowing what legal implications may have grown up through custom—the advisory board shall consist of so many and they shall be appointed by the Minister. That might mean that they shall be appointed for life, and, once appointed, are as immovable as the Mountains of Mourne.

Comment on this

I do not pretend to know a lot about this matter. I do not pretend, in fact, to know anything about it, but it struck me from glancing through the Bill that the real intention was to make provision for a censorship on the activities of the news agency, that the Government wished to have this board as a kind of adjunct to the whole structure of the agency, so that they might have a general supervision over its activities. It struck me that it was a sort of superstructure on the ordinary structure of the news agency.

Comment on this

I think Senator O'Farrell has something in the last point he made and I will look into it between now and Report Stage. There is nothing in the fact that the advisory board happens to feature in the last part of the Bill. That is the Parliamentary draftsman's way of doing it. The advisory board is essentially an integral part of the whole scheme. My idea in having an advisory board was threefold. The first object was to have a body which would as far as possible be representative of all shades of opinion in the newspaper world, so as to make this a national news agency which would be above reproach or suspicion. Secondly, in so far as the news agency was capable of assisting our own newspapers, I wanted to provide some link whereby they could be consulted as to what help could be given to them in their work here and abroad. The third object was the obtaining of advice on technical matters and the creation of some formal method of contact with them.

As is always the case whenever you set up more than one body, the difficulty of divided control arises immediately and it is necessary to give full powers to one body and limited powers to another. Hence the provision in the section limiting the functions of the advisory board to giving advice, as and when requested by the managing director. The managing director will probably be chairman at the same time and will be the man most familiar with all the affairs of the news agency, and it was felt that the easiest thing to do was to give him the job of framing the questions and seeking advice. But there is one thing that we must be careful about, that we do not have a clash between the two bodies, and we, therefore, had to give full powers to one and limit the powers of the other to purely advisory functions.

In some countries news agencies have developed into co-operatives between the newspapers and the journalists for the provision of new services. That is the ideal position, of course, and I hope, possibly through the advisory board and through the work of the agency, that we might develop on those lines. I think that the advisory board is useful and is an addition to the ordinary State-sponsored company. It provides a form of link with the interests concerned and it ensures as far as possible harmonious working. It will be the job of the managing director to try to avail of the services of the advisory board as often as possible. In passing, I should like to say that I have had experience of the Advisory Committee on Cultural Relations during the past year in the Department of External Affairs and they have been of very considerable assistance. They are a voluntary body who have given their assistance freely and have worked very hard and they have been of considerable assistance and use to the Department. It would be a good thing if the system developed more and more. We do not know the assistance we could obtain in administration from people who are not civil servants on a voluntary basis. I think their assistance would often be very useful and would help to make the Civil Service machine run more smoothly and more humanly.

Comment on this

Before you proceed to the Title, I should like to point out that in the absence of the Minister we discussed Section 8 sub-section (2) (b) and let it go. I assume that the remarks made here will be conveyed to the Minister, or do we repeat them?

Comment on this

I will put down two amendments without prejudice for the next Stage, one to delete sub-section (2) paragraph (b) of Section 8 and the other to delete from the sub-section, line 40, "Dáil Éireann" and insert "The House of which he is a member". Then if the House wants to delete the paragraph it can or if it wishes to make this change it can do so, but I have not consulted the Minister.

Comment on this

I should like to give an explanation of how that paragraph arose. An amendment was proposed in the other House which excluded completely members of either House of the Oireachtas from being directors, and this second position was a compromise, a condition upon which I accepted the amendment. It is always a difficult question but I felt a certain amount of sympathy with the amendment. On the other hand, I felt that circumstances might arise in which a member of the Oireachtas would obviously be the best person to appoint and the fact of his being a member of the Oireachtas should not preclude him from appointment. Dáil Éireann only was included. There was a suggestion of including both Houses but I felt that too many difficulties would be added by having a member of the Oireachtas debated in the two Houses. That would be too much of a barrier and I felt it would be a sufficient barrier if he were debated in one House. Senator Hayes's amendment would be acceptable, if the House wishes it, as far as I am concerned.

Comment on this

I do not want to delay the House at this hour of the night. I only want to make clear that we are accepting the principle that it is desirable that the prior approval of this House should be obtained. I am not saying that I accept it entirely, but I certainly think that in the possible case of a Senator being appointed, the approval of the Seanad would in most cases be sufficient and that it would not be necessary to have his appointment discussed in Dáil Eireann. We can deal with this on the lines of the amendment.

Comment on this

It is a matter of opinion, but as a result of the barrier to the appointment of elected representatives to such services, people who have any chance of such an appointment never seek election to local authorities. We here are creating the position which has been created with regard to local authorities. There are many people who would make valuable members of a local authority or Parliament——

Comment on this

Might I suggest that this matter be left over to the Report Stage?

Comment on this

Fair enough, but I think it is an undesirable practice.

Comment on this