Transport Bill, 1949—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–120 of 258. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 32 of 1949 ›
I move amendment No. 5:—
Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
In the course of the performance of the duties imposed on the board by the previous sub-section, the board shall, within a period of two years from the date of the commencement of this Act, restore the double line of railway tracks between the railway stations at Athlone and Liffey Junction.
The changing of the railway line from Liffey Junction to Athlone was the most foolish proposal that was ever carried out by any responsible railway management. When that proposal was made, I remember protesting against it in this House. I was backed by Senator J.T. O'Farrell at the time. It was stated by the then chairman, who was a member of this House, that the new system of single lines would be a great improvement on the double track with their new system of signalling. Of course, that may have deceived some members of the Seanad at the time, but it did not deceive Senator O'Farrell or myself. We know now the disastrous effect that that singling of the line had, and particularly on the livestock trade. We know the serious losses that have occurred to the cattle trade by reason of cattle specials being held up at railway sidings, by the bruising of beef cattle which are for shipment, and by the deterioration even of store cattle. All this loss has to come out of the farmer-producer's pocket.
At present, we are exporting beef. It is becoming more and more a sellers' market. I want to point out the great losses that are sustained by the holding up of cattle on these sidings as a result of not having a double track which would allow of a clear run through for cattle to be shipped. At present, cattle are bruised and possibly the smallest loss would be 1/2d a lb. on being downgraded from "special" to "A," which means 25/-. They may be down-graded to "B," which means a loss to the producer of £11 10s. 0d. per beast. These losses are excessive and the cattle trade cannot afford them. All this down-grading is also a national loss. The West of Ireland is a great cattle country, and is almost entirely dependent on the cattle trade for existence. The cattle trade can never be carried on successfully unless there is efficient and quick transport. Cheap rates would be another important factor. We cannot have efficient and quick transport unless the track is doubled from Liffey Junction to Athlone. It is nearly impossible to get efficient transport of cattle on a single line. I would not suggest that the whole line should be doubled right away, but I would ask the Minister to consider giving an instruction that the double line would start off, say, at Mullingar or at Enfield and then Mullingar, and that the process of doubling the track would be continued, so that it would all be doubled in a few years. Unless that is done, there will never be efficient or quick transport from the West of Ireland.
Comment on this
I would like to support the amendment by Senator Counihan, because this matter affects the cattle trade in the West of Ireland. Senator Counihan has given some arguments in favour of a double track. I want to give another argument. Because of delays that occur in order to facilitate passenger traffic on the main lines, cattle and other live stock that are marketed in the West of Ireland and sent on to Dublin suffer greatly. If those who owned the cattle, sheep or pigs before they were sold treated them as cruelly as they are being treated in transit, it is very doubtful if they would not be prosecuted for it by the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals.
Senator Counihan rightly referred to deterioration in the value of stock because of delays in transport. There is just a danger that cattle shippers purchasing cattle at West of Ireland fairs might be tempted—and it would be a serious temptation—to pay less for the stock than they would pay if they could guarantee that the stock would be delivered at their destination in the condition in which they were purchased.
The laying down of a double track would be a rather expensive matter, but the cattle trade is a very important branch of our industry, and the maintenance of the good name of Irish stock would be a matter of interest to the Government. For passenger transport the railway company may be able to substitute buses for trains, but the only satisfactory method of transporting live stock is by railway. Any help that could be given towards preventing serious loss in the value of stock because of delays arising from a singletrack system should be given. For that reason, I have great pleasure in supporting Senator Counihan's amendment.
Comment on this
I wish to support Senator Counihan's amendment, but I would suggest that it should be amended to read that the line from Galway to Liffey Junction be relaid. We remember the agitation that was carried on when the old Great Southern and Western Railway Board proposed the singling of the track. This is one of the matters that cannot be laid at the door of Córas Iompair Eireann or the late chairman of the board of the present organisation set up under the 1944 Act. This was carried out against the wishes and protests not only of the people of Western Ireland but of many interested parties in Dublin. The double line was taken up. The people were guaranteed that they would be provided with as efficient a service as that which was then in operation. One sometimes wonders how it is expected that people would ever be induced back to the railways from the roads. Previous speakers have referred to the importance of a double line in order to have a fast and efficient service for live stock, but while that is very important, if we are ever to induce people back to the railways we must have a quick and efficient passenger service. The Minister, I am sure, and members of the House will agree, that because of the delay of two hours or one and a half hours in the journey between Galway and Dublin as a result of taking up the double lines, people will not, if they can possibly avoid it, travel by rail.
I am glad that Senator Counihan put down this amendment because the Minister's reply will give us some idea of what the future policy of the new board is to be. If the Minister's attitude is that the board, which is already bankrupt, has to start over again and that it would be unfair to ask them to undertake the laying of a line between Galway and Dublin as they must seek to make the system pay, then I say that there is no future for Irish railways, particularly for that section of it operating in the West. If, however, the Minister accepts the amendment or, without incorporating its terms in the Bill, undertakes to put before the board that this line should be relaid, it would be a great help to people in the West, and if the railways of the country are ever to pay it would contribute greatly to that.
Comment on this
My sympathy in this case is more with the cattle than with the cattle dealers. In the course of my varied career I spent every Wednesday for two years at Liffey Junction unloading cattle, and even with a double or treble track the animals suffered considerably through delay. It will be a surprise, I am sure, to Senators to know that more harm and damage are done to live stock during waiting periods than when the train is travelling. When the train is travelling, whether it contains cattle or sheep, they are quiet enough in the wagon, but the minute the wagon stops they become restless and injure each other and considerable damage is caused. If the track has been raised— I have not been there recently—I cannot understand why. It may be because at one time it was thought that the cattle market was going to be shifted from Prussia Street to the North Wall. I know that on Wednesdays they were taken to the lairs in Cabra, and when the cattle trade was not so heavy as it is now I have often opened wagons and found sheep dead or dying. If they have to be shunted on to sidings, particularly in the summer, there will be great loss and hardship that could be avoided. We do not pay sufficient attention—we did not in the past, at least—to the suffering of animals in transit. Cattle can be a long time in transit to England and they get no food during that time, which is not so bad, but neither do they get anything to drink. Anything that would speed up the cattle trade and by speeding it up reduce the losses of the people engaged in that trade and the suffering of the animals should be recommended to the new board. I know that the Minister has no power to impose on the board that they should relay the tracks, but he should ask them to consider very sympathetically the question that something should be done to improve the transport of animals from one part of the country to another, speed it up and improve the type of cattle wagons. Some of the cattle wagons in this country are obsolete and the wagons are in need of improvement as well as the permanent way.
Comment on this
I have a good deal of sympathy with the amendment for obvious reasons, but I do not think that we would be justified in passing it and thus giving a direction to the new board without having a very much more scientific inquiry than we can possibly make here. This piece of economy was obviously an exceedingly bad one, and, as Senator Counihan pointed out, I personally was one of those who protested against it. At the same time one has to realise that when the line was singled it was in the early days of the economic war when the company was in dire distress. Some thousands of men had been dispensed with because of the falling off in traffic and the general depression that existed and they resorted to absolutely abnormal methods of trying to save money. They used the rails and sleepers and other fittings which they took up from this line to relay other portions of the line which were in an exceedingly dangerous condition and they were unable to buy materials. They were able to make a plausible case, but one has to admit that it was a deplorable necessity, if it were a necessity, and I am afraid it was. I know that an approach was made to the banks for credit, because it was impossible to raise capital, and the banks were quite unprepared to give any credit to buy new materials in the existing circumstances. We were told at the time that the new system of signalling would make the single track as efficient, if not more so, than the old double line. The new system did unquestionably effect a considerable improvement, but there is one obvious shortcoming that must be apparent to everybody. If there is an engine breakdown on any section of the line, when you have only a single line you hold up traffic in both directions, while with the double line you could switch off at the nearest station and use the up or down line as the case might be as an alternative by resorting to pilot work.
That all happened a long time ago and many things have happened since then. There have been various developments in railway transport and it would be unwise for the Oireachtas to give a specific direction to the board on one particular item of this kind. After all, they are charged under Section 15 and other sections to give efficient and economic service for both merchandise and passengers to the community. I think we should place on them the responsibility of carrying out these instructions to the best of their ability and with all the necessary knowledge at their disposal. It might be found to be quite unwise and perhaps unnecessary to do what the amendment suggests should be done. I know that in all probability the doubling of the line is the obvious thing to do, but I certainly, as one member of the Oireachtas, would not be prepared to say that I could prove it. There may be another alternative and in the circumstances I would suggest that Senator Counihan, having stated his case, which is a very strong one, should not press the amendment to a division.
Comment on this
On this amendment Senator Counihan has pointed out that the singling of the line has created delays and difficulties and Senator J. T. O'Farrell has pointed out why it was done. If I recollect aright the singling of the line was carried through for economy in order to use the lines to relay tracks elsewhere. New signalling was put in with a view to enabling single line work to be done efficiently but they never completed what was necessary when the single line was put in, that is, the provision of a sufficient number of pass sidings in conjunction with the signalling. The result was that on that line we still have unnecessarily long blocks so that once the volume of traffic increases beyond a certain limit delays are bound to occur. The full programme of resignalling and pass sidings was never completed.
While on this amendment are we at liberty to make a few observations on Section 15, sub-section (1), which seems to me to be one of the most important sections of the Bill?
Comment on this
We are now dealing with the amendment but will we be allowed to deal with it later?
Comment on this
Referring merely to the amendment, it seems to me that it would be very unwise, as Senator J.T. O'Farrell said, to lay down to the board the specific remedy of doubling the line, but we are at liberty to point out that the existing mechanism is very unsatisfactory and that something should be done about it. Let us not say that we as non-technicians recommend that the line should be doubled or that there should be an alternative method of signalling or that pass sidings should be put down. That is not our business; our business is to point out the drawbacks of the existing system.
Comment on this
I should like to say at the outset that I appreciate the point made by Senator Counihan and other Senators regarding the effects of long delays in the transport of live stock. I would naturally be anxious that whatever steps can be taken to obviate those long delays should be taken. I cannot, however, agree to accept the amendment. I am prepared to represent to the new board that one of their first duties should be to investigate the position between Galway and Dublin and to see what better facilities can be provided to obviate delays. It is obviously undesirable, not merely from the point of view of the cattle owners and purchasers but from the national point of view, that cattle and other live stock should arrive on the market in a damaged condition. Therefore, we should all be anxious to take whatever steps are necessary to overcome that.
May I say also that one of the duties of the new board will be so to improve all their services as to attract to the new transport company the maximum amount of freight and traffic? But I think it will be admitted that it would be very wrong and undesirable, as Senator O'Farrell said, in the absence of detailed information to tie the board to doubling the line and to doing it within the short period of two years, leaving out altogether the cost of doing it. I could not, any more than the Senator, say what the cost would be, but I think I would not be far wrong in saying that it would cost some millions of pounds.
Comment on this
The track is made and only sleepers and rails would be necessary.
Comment on this
I have got estimates in connection with other parts of rail operations, and it would not surprise me if I were not very far out in saying that it would run into millions of pounds. If we can get by other means improvements which will bring about what the Senator desires, without involving the company in this very heavy expenditure, which at the moment they are not in a position to undertake, I can and will readily give an assurance to the Seanad that I will ask the board as one of their first duties to undertake a special investigation of this matter, with a view to seeing what they can do as soon as possible to provide better facilities, particularly for the transport of live stock.
Comment on this
I feel that there is no use in pressing the amendment. If we propose to hand over the complete management of the undertaking to this board and instruct them at the same time to go in for the strictest economy in regard to the railways, I feel that there is no hope of this line being doubled. I have a fair experience of railway transport, particularly in the matter of live stock, and I am convinced that unless the railway there is doubled there is very little hope of getting any improvement. We have heard about all the gadgets and all the improvements that were to be brought about, but there is only one possible way of improving it, that is, the laying of a double track. I am not asking that it be laid as far as Athlone right away. Let it be done in small sections —even as far as Enfield. Even if it were doubled for a distance of ten miles it would be a great help.
Senator S. O'Farrell has spoken of his personal experience of the terrible losses inflicted on the live-stock trade, even when there was a double track. We can imagine what the losses are now. As I have said, they often run as high as £11 per head. The Minister says he will make representations to the board, but if the board do not do it, I think it is the duty of the Minister to instruct them to do it. If we are going to work strictly on a basis of economy and to say: "We have no money to do this," we can never hope for any improvement. There is money available for everything else, and if we are to neglect the most important industry we have merely for the sake of money, I think it is a very foolish economy.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:—
Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
The board shall, within one year from the establishment date, complete the central omnibus station at Store Street, Dublin, providing therein suitable accommodation, including waiting rooms, refreshment rooms and amenities for passengers.
In the very early days of road passenger transport, it became evident that proper facilities and accommodation would have to be provided for bus passengers. Many inquiries and investigations were carried out, and, after an examination of all the possible sites in the city, all the authorities concerned, the Dublin town planning authorities, the police and the transport authorities, agreed on a particular site. The site was accepted, and architects' plans and specifications were drawn up, and eventually a building was erected on it. It is not necessary to remind Senators of the appalling conditions under which bus passengers were compelled to queue up on Aston's Quay in the most unfavourable weather conditions. After long agitation, a shelter, which fell far short of what was adequate, was provided, in the form of galvanised roofing along the path beside the Liffey, which gave shelter on one side. The Minister has said on more than one occasion that he was quite aware of the conditions which bus passengers had to endure.
I do not wish to go into the whole history of the acquiring of the site and the building of the bus station at Store Street, except to say that the experts agreed that it was the most suitable site available. It is quite possible that there were other sites which, with the expenditure of more money and the acquisition of more property, might have provided more accommodation, but the fact is, that having examined every possible site in Dublin they agreed on Store Street, and a building was erected on that site. That building is partly completed. It would provide garaging space for the bus, waiting rooms and refreshment rooms for the passengers, and, I understand, a cinema for those passengers who might have to wait for long periods.
There are one or two questions in this connection to which I am sure the Minister will be able to give very satisfactory answers. Córas Iompair Éireann undertook the erection of this building. A change of Government took place, and Córas Iompair Éireann found themselves in some difficulty because of a certain set of circumstances over which they had absolutely no control. A decision was reached to abandon the completion of this building, or to abandon it for the purpose for which it was being erected. Was it the board of Córas Iompair Éireann which came to that decision? Were they consulted before the decision was come to? Was it the Minister himself who made the decision, and what is the present position with regard to the amount of money already expended on that building?
We are told that it is now proposed to hand this building over to a Department of State. The reason advanced by the Minister for the non-completion of the building is that the money is not available, but, in reply to a question in the Dáil, the Minister for Social Welfare said that arrangements would be made with the board of Córas Iompair Éireann to complete the building. The building will have to be completed, not for the purposes for which it was originally intended, but in accordance with new plans and specifications drawn up, so that it will be suitable for the purposes for which it is now required. The money must be found, and it is an extraordinary thing that, with all the interest we pretend we have in providing facilities for the travelling public, we must deprive them of what would be available for their accommodation at latest by the end of this year, and must search around for a new site.
In this connection also there are one or two questions on which I am sure the Minister will be able to give us very definite information. It is now suggested that a bus station be provided at Smithfield. I hold that the right approach to this matter would have been that no decision should have been come to and announced. The Oireachtas is asked to provide for the setting up of a new board, which is to be empowered to carry out the functions and duties of an Irish transport organisation. One of the principal functions of that board must be the provision of adequate facilities for the travelling public, and one would have thought that the proper way of handling it would have been to leave it for the consideration of the new board. That has not been done. Somebody has made a decision. Somebody has said there is going to be no bus station, and, as a matter of fact, the Minister has stated most emphatically that Store Street is out.
Comment on this
That Store Street is out, and the same statement has been made in connection with many of the other proposed undertakings of the former board. If the Minister, in his wisdom, considered that Store Street should be out, one would have imagined again that the proper thing to do was to have left the matter of the proposed new site to the new board. We have seen that the present chairman of Córas Iompair Éireann has been instructed to go around the city, and has done so, for the purpose of having interviews with the city authorities, the town planning authorities, the city council and the police authorities. We have also seen one of the strangest things in connection with this business, that decisions made have been reconsidered and changes brought about. The police authorities refused to approve of the proposed site at Smithfield. We know that interviews and consultations took place and that the accommodation to be provided at Smithfield has been reduced to the barest minimum, and, by a strange coincidence, the police authorities, who first refused to approve the site, have now approved it. What is all this going to mean? It is going to mean that the travelling public are to be deprived of the facilities which would be theirs if the Store Street project was proceeded with and completed. If a bus station is to be provided at Smithfield, a bus station designed merely to accommodate the buses and where bus passengers will be enabled to board and alight from buses, it means that some 106 families are to be removed from their dwellings.
Comment on this
And it means that each of these families will be compensated. It means also that street widening to the extent of some £50,000 will have to be undertaken and the total cost on the Dublin Corporation, as estimated by their own engineers, will be in the region of £309,000. I submit that that is something which the ratepayers of Dublin should not be called on to bear.
Comment on this
If the Dublin ratepayers are not called upon to bear the cost it must be borne by Córas Iompair Éireann.
Comment on this
We shall see. I would like to have the reasons given for the decision not to proceed with Store Street. If we read the Milne Report we will find there a statement that:—
"The building will provide a terminus for long-distance omnibuses to be accommodated in 17 reception bays. Circulating space, lavatories, a refreshment bar, shops and a cinema will be available to passengers and the general public. The upper part of the building is designed to accommodate the whole of the company's headquarters staff, at present scattered in five separate buildings.
Wages and material costs have risen since the scheme was authorised and the ultimate total outlay may prove to be considerably more than the original estimate.
The centralisation of headquarters should facilitate the general administration of the company's business."
The Tánaiste also agrees that centralisation does fulfil the purpose stated in the Milne Report.
"If, in carrying out the scheme, there is surplus accommodation available, the additional revenue to be derived from the provision of a refreshment bar, cinema and shops may reasonably be expected to justify the additional expenditure involved in making use of the available space."
Comment on this
—
"These are the main objectives of the scheme, but it is doubtful whether they can be regarded as sufficiently important to have justified the company in embarking upon such an ambitious project when capital resources are limited and large expenditure is required for the rehabilitation and improvement of railway facilities."
The Minister informs us that the proposed station at Smithfield will be merely a bus station. I am sure we shall have reference to the expenditure involved in the proposed station at Store Street. It is very important that adequate facilities should be provided for long-distance passengers in particular and these facilities should be convenient to their point of embarkation or disembarkation. If this project were to be carried out by a private concern it would be called upon to provide such facilities, side by side with the facilities provided under this Bill. The revenue arising from such facilities would help to clear the initial cost of construction.
The Minister can give no good reason for the abandonment of Store Street. I have here a newspaper, the Irish Times of 15th April of this year, in which there is a map. With that map is the following statement:—
"In view of the current decision on the site of a central bus station for Dublin, this plan should be of interest to our readers. It was published in the Irish Builder and Engineer 13 years ago by the Traffic and Safety First Association, a nonpolitical body including people of eminent technical and civil standing, and indicates how early the suitability of the Store Street site was recognised.”
On the 28th October last there also appeared an article in the Irish Times in the column headed “London Letter”:—
"Modern Transport, a technical journal, which enjoys a high standing in the transport world, has recently had two members of its staff in Dublin to make an investigation on the spot into the question of the central bus station.
In an article in the current issue it is held that the decision to turn the Store Street building into Governnment offices and to put the bus station instead at Smithfield is mistaken. Smithfield, it is pointed out, is three-quarters of a mile from O'Connell Bridge, and if it were to be used a connecting bus service to Smithfield would be necessary. This would cause as much congestion as the provincial buses are said to be in danger of causing at O'Connell Bridge, particularly to passengers with luggage, and the advantages of a concentrated loading area would be wiped out.
The conversion of the building to Government offices, the article suggests, will probably involve much additional expense, while there will be no return, such as Córas Iompair Éireann would have received from rent of shops, catering, etc., at the station.
Whatever may be the final decision, Dublin's need for a bus station is urgent, and the hope may be earnestly expressed that in the wider public interest and, indeed, in the cost of national economy the Government will feel that there now seems to be every reason to use Store Street and the Store Street building for the purposes for which it was originally intended."
Comment on this
It is taken from an article published in Modern Transport. I think I have covered in broad outline the case that can be made. I am not interested in any particular section. I am interested in the travelling public as a whole, particularly those from rural Ireland. If Smithfield is adopted very little consideration will be shown to the people coming from Galway, Cork, and Donegal. Store Street would leave them practically in the centre of the city and would provide them with the facilities they would require. I do not wish to enter into a discussion on the conversion of Store Street since we shall have an opportunity of debating that matter on another Bill. This is the last opportunity we have to vent our feelings on the decision to abandon Store Street. If the Minister and the Government were aware of the strong public feeling on this matter, even at this late hour they might reverse their decision and complete the project for the purpose for which it was intended.
I am sure that Smithfield will commence on very modest lines for the sake of economy. I am sure nothing will be done, at any rate immediately, to upset Senator Counihan and his friends, who have an interest in the market there. But year by year that will have to be enlarged in order to provide proper facilities for the travelling public. It may be said that they will not go into this project in an elaborate way, but developments must take place and further space will have to be acquired in time. Whether or not that acquisition will be done by means of compulsory powers I do not know. Those who are upset will have to be compensated and provided with accommodation elsewhere. The case cannot be made that, because the national health office in O'Connell Street or the Department of Social Welfare is too small to accommodate what will in time be one of the largest industries in this country, the Government must take over Store Street. What will be done with that portion of the premises originally intended to be used as a bus terminus to accommodate 17 tiers of buses, as is mentioned in the Milne Report, unless it is proposed to use that space to accommodate the applicants for social welfare? I think it is in the national interest that the Store Street project should be utilised for the purpose for which it was intended.
Comment on this
This discussion as to the relative merits of Store Street and Smithfield has become a modern saga. It reminds one of the war waged in the stories of Gulliver's travels between those who argued as to whether the big or the little end of an egg was the top. It has been saturated with personalities and history. The result is that very few people approach it merely from the point of view of the merits of the case. I do not profess to speak with very much expert knowledge of the merits of the case, but I say that it would appear to the average man that to cause the whole of the bus traffic from the East, South and West to converge on and radiate from a point down near the Custom House seems an extraordinary unbusinesslike proposal. It means that you have to swing all that body of traffic right across O'Connell Street, or, avoiding O'Connell Street, you must approach Store Street by narrow and thickly-populated streets. Anybody who has had occasion to use Butt Bridge in recent years will realise that it is becoming an impossible tangle of traffic, and if, in addition to that, you are going to bring in other buses with which the rest of the country is to be served by Córas Iompair Éireann, then I suggest that the position would become impossible altogether.
Every person conversant with Dublin traffic knows that the whole of the Great Northern buses, and all those that serve Fairview and Clontarf areas, pass through that district and it is already so congested that there have been numerous demands for the widening of the streets in that direction. As to the relative merits of Smithfield, I cannot speak with very much knowledge, because I do not know precisely what the expenditure might be. I understand, however, that it is only a fraction of what is suggested for Store Street, but, at all events, it has the merit that you do not have to drag the long-distance traffic right across all the main arteries of the city. Smithfield is more on the outskirts than Store Street, and to that extent it has definite merit as compared with Store Street. Senator Hawkins has referred to a map published many years ago regarding a central bus station for Dublin. He does not advert to the fact that there has been a considerable change in traffic conditions since then. Traffic, particularly in private motor cars and lorries, has developed enormously on a scale which was not thought of years ago, and what might be a tolerable site then has become quite impracticable at this particular date.
A great deal of play has been made as to the desirability of having the headquarters of the staffs in one building. I suggest that has never been done, and it is not practicable in the case of a transport service. No railway company of which I am aware has ever concentrated the whole of its headquarters staff in one building. For instance, the whole of the locomotive and chief mechanical engineer's section must naturally be stationed at Inchicore, where the shops are, and where thousands of men are employed, where all the rolling stock and locomotives are made, and where they are in touch with the men and with the engineering arrangements. They could not possibly operate at a distance. The same applies to the running staffs. They must be at their stations near the turntables and the sheds in order to be able to do their work. The general stores staff, which is a very large staff, have to be on the spot where the stores are, and it must be remembered that you have about 100,000 different items of railway stores and about 80,000 types of road vehicle stores, and the staff have to be on the spot where they are receiving and issuing those stores, and where the complete supervision, check and audit takes place, so they could not possibly be brought down to Store Street. You could not, of course, bring the goods staff, the parcels staff or the booking staff away from Kingsbridge. They have to be on the spot and the same applies to the very large staff which is maintained at the North Wall, and to the accountants' department. They, too, must be on the spot, and you must have Westland Row, Harcourt Street and the district superintendent's offices where they are required. To suggest that you could concentrate the whole of the staff in one office is not a practical proposition. Because of the number of old railway headquarters, you have splendid offices at Broadstone, where the accountant's department is stationed. Is it suggested that these offices can be given up? They are fine, solidly-built offices, much more roomy than anything that could be provided in the newer building. Are they to be vacated? You cannot very well set them to anybody else because there are sections of road transport working there which cannot be removed. If you brought the Kingsbridge staff to Store Street, what would you do with these fine suites of offices? You would not find it possible to bring in outsiders to tenant these offices because some of them would inevitably have to be occupied. You have a splendid new suite of offices on Bachelor's Walk in recent years. They are fitted out with the last word in appointment and with machinery of all kinds, and it is suggested that they should be given up although they are on the spot where the long-distance lorries are loaded, where the manifests are made out, and where the whole of the clerical and accountancy work is done, so that from the point of view of providing a headquarters for the staff the Store Street plan was unnecessary. Even if it were very large, the building could not be fully occupied unless you were prepared to disorganise the whole transport system. Railway organisation is like the organisation of an army. You must have various sections of headquarters at the points where they are most effective, so that from that point of view I suggest that there was no necessity at all to build a new headquarters building. Nothing would be saved for the reason I have stated, but the expenditure would take place and from that point of view I would suggest that the whole question of accommodation for staff should be left out of the discussion because it is not a relevant issue in the matter and should never have been brought in.
I suggest that so far as other accommodation is concerned, the geographical position of Store Street does not make it the best site that could be chosen. I do not know why a site outside the city should be regarded as impracticable for long-distance bus traffic. You could have regular city services to take passengers to and from every single site. We cannot dump every passenger where he wants to be dumped and I do not see much virtue in dragging him to Store Street when he really wants to go to the centre of the city. The same thing would apply to Smithfield so that on the whole an outside site with plenty of room for moving buses about would be much cheaper.
Comment on this
In view of the fact that the Minister has already stated that Store Street is out, there must be a good deal of unreality about the discussion on the amendment we are considering at the moment. I do not propose, therefore, to enter into a discussion on the lines of Senator O'Farrell, as to the relative merits of Store Street and Smithfield, beyond saying this that everyone who has given at least five minutes' thought to the problem must agree that there is, to say the least of it, as great a volume of support among traffic experts in favour of Store Street as there is in favour of Smithfield. There is one point I feel rather strongly about. It has not been mentioned in either House, and it is well that it should be mentioned now. A building has been designed by an architect who is well known and competent. An architect designs a building, on instruc- tions from his employers, for a specific purpose. The design of a cinema is entirely different from the design of a lecture hall. This building has been designed as a long-distance bus terminus. Provision has been made for the reception of these buses. Use has been made of a material that was not available before this century, a modern material, reinforced concrete. It is something that has been attempted, I think, on a similar scale only once before in this country. That was in the case of the building designed as an air terminus at Collinstown — designed again by an Irish architect who has been eminently successful in his design and whose name is not unknown in the public life of this country. Once a building is designed for a specific purpose and once the work has gone so far on that building that it would be a major operation to alter the building itself to any large extent, it is entirely wrong that such alteration should be permitted.
The only argument that might validly be advanced against my statement would be that the amount of money involved would be so great that the concern for whom the building was being erected would be unable to provide it or that it would be utterly economic. That may be in the present position of Córas Iompair Eireann a fairly valid argument, but in view of the fact that the development of road passenger traffic over the years, to the detriment of the railways as such, has led to a big reduction in the number of passengers travelling by train, it is absolutely essential that there should be a central bus station for all those passengers who, in the main, come in on the long-distance buses. I submit that a very bad day's work has been done for Irish architecture in preventing the completion of a building designed for a specific purpose, making use of modern materials—a building that, in my opinion, would become as well known and as widely appreciated as the airway terminus at Collinstown.
Comment on this
In the interests of accuracy, I should like to mention a few points. First of all, I should like to say that the opening remarks of Senator Hawkins were untrue. The site for the bus station was not decided upon, as he stated, with the agreement of the traffic and the town planning experts. The previous Government introduced the town planning legislation in this country. They thought fit to include in the Town Planning Act a provision giving the right to certain statutory bodies to remain exempt from the planning authority of whatever area they wished to plan or build in. That was the position of Córas Iompair Éireann in regard to the choice of a site in this case. The site was chosen by the directors of the board of Córas Iompair Éireann and was presented to the planning authority as a fait accompli. It was against the advice of the town planning consultant, Sir Patrick Abercrombie, who had already drawn up a plan for the City of Dublin. The town planning authority had no alternative, in fact they had no say in the choice of the site. So to say, in the first instance, that it was chosen with the agreement of the planning authority and of the traffic authority is just untrue or else the statement shows a lack of knowledge of the position. That is the first point.
Secondly, I should like to say that I have been interested in this project since I became a member of the planning committee of the Dublin Corporation. I have been interested from two points of view, firstly, from the point of view of town planning and the suitability of the site as a bus terminus; and, secondly, from the point of view of the beauty of a city such as Dublin, where every new building — and, goodness knows, few enough have been erected by us since we have had our own Government — should be considered with the greatest care and every step should be taken to protect and keep intact one of the most beautiful Georgian cities in the world. At the stage when I became a member of the town planning committee the site had been agreed to by the statutory body and the town planning authority had no say in it. They had still power to reject the buildings as such, and from an architectural and planning point of view I have fought against this building on a number of occasions. Senator J.T. O'Farrell has given some reasons as to why he considered it unsuitable. In a city, where most of the traffic comes from the South, the South-East or the South-West, it is absolutely ridiculous to place the terminus for all the incoming traffic almost at the extreme east on the edge of the sea, so that everything coming from the whole hinterland has to be brought right across the city. It is just plain stupid to begin with.
Senator O'Farrell has mentioned the fact that to reach this terminus the buses would have to cross the main traffic routes such as O'Connell Street. Anybody who knows the traffic problem that already exists at present, realises the shortage of bridges and the impossibility of placing bridges below the Custom House, has already complicated the situation without bringing all the traffic from the country to that point. Again practically all the heavy cross-Channel traffic comes in at the North Wall and has to be brought along the quays to the city. Imagine the confusion and congestion that would result if all the bus traffic were obliged to converge on the one point where the heavy traffic is conveyed from the cross-Channel steamers. The thing was wrong from the beginning. A wrong site was chosen and it was chosen against the advice of the consultants. I personally am opposed to the selection of Smithfield but I do not think that enters into the matter. The original site suggested was on the quays.
Somebody mentioned that the town planning consultant eventually agreed to the site. He did not eventually agree to the site but he eventually agreed to the building. As I say that was the only matter in which the corporation had any say — the question of the suitability of the building. I was a member of the town planning committee and my experience was that an average of five or six members out of a total membership of 18 attended the ordinary meetings. However, on the day that the design for this building was submitted every single member of the town planning committee attended and every one of those who had not been in the habit of attending regularly, voted for the new building. I personally pressed for sending to England for the town planning consultant. He came across to one of our meetings and three times I asked him in the presence of members of the committee:—
"Do you advise the City of Dublin to pass this building as a suitable building for a bus terminus for Dublin?"
Three times he evaded the question but finally, in the end, being pressed by the Lord Mayor, he said:—
"Since you have ruined my plan for Dublin and since you have no intention of carrying out my plan I suppose there is nothing to do but to pass the building which has been passed by the Córas Iompair Éireann authorities."
That is the way the town planning consultant was persuaded under pressure to say something which would enable the committee to pass it. As regards Senator Hearne's remarks as to the suitability of the building, it was designed with seven floors of offices and with a ground floor for buses. I see no difference between that and a proposal to use the ground floor for parking cars, and using the seven storeys of offices for the Department of Health instead of offices for Córas Iompair Eireann officials. The Senator had also something to say about the use of reinforced concrete as a modern material. There is nothing new about reinforced concrete. It was used even by the Romans, and is not only applicable to the uses of Córas Iompair Eireann.
Comment on this
I should like to hear you make that statement before the Institute of Architects.
Comment on this
To this day ancient reinforced concrete remains can be seen in Rome. In fact I have just come back from Rome and I have seen them there, so that the idea of using reinforced concrete is not so modern as the Senator suggests. So much for the argument of unsuitability of the building for the Department of Health — it was designed essentially as an office block. In fact it is doubtful if it could accommodate more than 18 buses which, in my opinion, would be utterly inadequate to accommodate all the buses required for the future needs of the City of Dublin.
There can be no argument at all about the suitability of the proposed bus station. I think if ever there was a monument built to the memory of people who have no concern for the beauty of the city, it is that Córas Iompair Eireann building. The unfortunate thing is that it has got so far. We are fortunate in having in Dublin very many important buildings. Amongst them we have the Custom House. The Custom House is illustrated in every architectural book in every language as the finest renaissance building in Europe. It was thought fit to erect beside it a monster building of seven storeys which not only is out of character but is completely out of scale. It spoils the whole view of the Custom House either from up or across the river. In the matter of suitability it is only equalled by the loop line bridge which runs along one side of the Custom House and the gasometer on the other side of the river.
I feel very strongly on this point. It is unfortunate that one can do nothing about this building at this stage; but at least one can do something about the traffic. One can find an alternative terminus for the bus traffic and stop all this madness. From every point of view, from the point of view of the convenience of the citizen, from the traffic point of view, and from the town planning point of view, this structure is most unsuitable.
Comment on this
I would like to add my voice to the protests made by Senator Miss Butler and Senator O'Farrell. I am satisfied that Senator Hearne and Senator Hawkins do not understand the position in Dublin or they would never have tabled such an amendment. I challenge either of those Senators to go down there to-morrow morning or afternoon, and I suggest that if they do they will be prepared to say the same thing as I am going to say. That is, that the people who are responsible for the erection of the central bus station on that site are getting away too lightly when they cannot be charged.
Comment on this
They definitely should be charged. Take the people in the north-east of Dublin who have to cross to this side of the city — people from Coolock or Malahide, for instance. Will Senator Hearne or Senator Hawkins tell us how these people are to cross to the south side of the city? As some one has suggested, they would need to come by boat or aeroplane.
Senator Hawkins mentioned a private concern. If somebody was responsible for the erection and management of this building on behalf of any private concern I am sure that person would be charged, and the only thing that would prevent him from receiving severe punishment would be his mental deficiency or lunacy. I am astonished that any member of this House would put down an amendment for the reconsideration of this matter.
As Senator Miss Butler has stated, are you going to take the buses that come from Wexford right across the city in order to drop your passengers in Store Street, or the buses that come from Cork? It would be suitable enough for buses from the northern side. But what will you do with the existing traffic? It cannot go through there. Will you put it right across O'Connell Street? You could not pick on a more unsuitable site. If one were to suggest O'Connell Street it would not be even as unsuitable as this site.
Senator Hawkins mentioned that people were going to save a lot by this place entering into the catering business. If they could not make a better job of catering than they have made of the erection of this Córas Iompair Eireann building, then God help them as caterers.
I am glad the Minister has taken up such a strong attitude in connection with Store Street. With Senator Butler, I feel it is a tragedy that that building it there. The Minister who allowed it to be erected there definitely made a mistake. Someone suggested a name for that building. I suggest it should be called Fianna's Folly. We have many follies up and down the country and this would be another added to the list. That would be the most suitable title for it. I would even go so far as to suggest that the title should be Fianna's Fatal Folly.
There are many Fianna Fáil supporters in the city in full agreement with my view that that building should not have been erected there. In the recent general election it had an effect on many people in the city. They felt that any Government that would allow such a building to be constructed would not be fit to rule the country. Some people may laugh at me for saying that.
Comment on this
Senator Tunney can see only a few of those who are laughing.
Comment on this
I do not mind if every Senator in the House laughs at me. I say that this site should never have been chosen. It is not suitable as a site for offices. It would be unfair to persons in the Government service to have them put over there into that part of the city when you have such beautiful suburbs around Dublin which, from the health point of view, would be much more suitable. The only persons for whom Store Street would be suitable are the incoming travellers and the outgoing emigrants or holiday makers, but these are not the only people in the country.
Comment on this
It would not be big enough to contain them now.
Comment on this
Not at the time it was being erected but, thank God, the position is changed, though it is not as good as we would like to see it. These are the only people for whom it would be suitable. If there are people coming to our markets or to our hospitals or to do business in the city, I do not think Store Street would be a suitable terminus for them at all. It is not a central site. I do not believe in Smithfield as a good site either. My opinion is that you should have a site on the north side for the buses coming from the north and the north-west, and you should have an average-sized building on the south side for the buses coming from the east and the south.
I do not see that there was any reason for this big nonsensical building. If all the experts of this nation were to get together with the police authorities and the traffic inspectors, I do not believe any man could pick out a suitable site for a central bus station in Dublin in view of the existing condition of traffic in the city. Therefore, I suggest that there should be an average-sized bus station on the north side and another on the south side. I have sympathy for the Minister or for anybody trying to build up Córas Iompair Eireann, because I am satisfied that whatever Minister is here in two years' time, he will be bringing forward another Bill of this kind. You cannot have a sound industry where you have one section of it competing against another.
Comment on this
In view of the discussion which we had on the Second Reading on Store Street and the question which was put to me, to state definitely what was the intention regarding it and the very emphatic answer which I gave then, I was wondering why this amendment was put on the Order Paper. Senator Hawkins, however, was not speaking very long when I had the answer. It was to provide the opportunity to get across another piece of Fianna Fáil propaganda. Senator Hawkins repeated here statements which have been made by Fianna Fáil members of the Dublin Corporation and which are entirely untrue. These statements which have been refuted publicly by the responsible officers of Córas Iompair Eireann, are in opposition to the views expressed by Senator Hawkins and by certain members of his Party on the Dublin Corporation regarding the widening of streets, the demolition of houses, the eviction of families and compensation. There is not a shred of truth in any of those statements. They were officially denied when they were first made by certain members of the Dublin Corporation.
There were many conversations between the responsible officers of Córas Iompair Eireann and the responsible officers of the Dublin Corporation, and Córas Iompair Eireann stated quite clearly and specifically the position in relation to Smithfield and to the thoroughfares leading to it. Notwithstanding that, statements similar to those made by Senator Hawkins to-day were repeated in Dáil Eireann by Fianna Fáil spokesmen. In Dáil Eireann I again described those statements as false. I showed that they were false. I thought that would be enough, but we know the technique — go on repeating a falsehood over and over again in the knowledge that if you repeat it sufficiently often and say it sufficiently loudly, a number of people will be forced to believe it, particularly if you are in the happy position of having that false statement reported in full in a newspaper which is read by a considerable number of people, 95 per cent. of whom read no other newspaper. That was the purpose in putting this amendment on the Order Paper.
Comment on this
The Irish Times and the Irish Press and this famous London journal, this journal whose owners are so interested in the architectural beauty of Dublin and who are so concerned about the convenience and comfort of rural passengers in this country that they go to the trouble and expense of sending two special representatives to Dublin to report on what this Government is guilty of and what the company is guilty of in forsaking Store Street station. Someone has said that, when the Irish Press and the Irish Times find themselves in entire agreement, it is time for someone to look out — which side I do not know.
Comment on this
And the journal of the Irish builders and engineers.
Comment on this
I notice that the Senator placed far more reliance on the London journal than he did on the Irish journal. Incidentally, one refrains from pointing out the inconsistency of the Senators opposite, who denounce in one breath the bringing in of experts from outside, while, in the next breath, they do so in order to support their case.
The Senator said that I could not give any good reason for leaving Store Street. I gave two excellent reasons. The first was that the company could not afford it — that is a very good reason — and, secondly, they did not need it. I am not going to argue, though I could argue, the suitability of location, but I did say this: that for a company in the financial position in which Córas Iompair Eireann was, to embark on a building which was to cost when finally finished and ready for use £1,000,000 was fantastic; but that they should rear on top of the bus station six storeys of offices which they did not require and which they could not fully occupy unless, as Senator O'Farrell said, they were to take their clerical staffs and their technical staffs away from where they should be if they were to get their work properly done, was, of course, absurd.
Córas Iompair Eireann are not staying in Store Street because they cannot afford to stay there. Every penny which has been spent or will be spent by Córas Iompair Eireann on this building will be repaid to them when the building is taken over by the Department of Social Welfare — every penny of it — and they will be very badly in need of it. Are they, merely for the sake of going into a luxurious suite of offices in Store Street, to leave empty and derelict the very fine suites of offices which they already have and which have been described by Senator O'Farrell? Are they to have empty rooms in Kingsbridge and pay money for office accommodation in Store Street, money which they have not got? Have I to remind Senators that less than three months ago I had to go to Dáil Eireann with the largest Supplementary Estimate that was ever introduced there since this State was founded, a Supplementary Estimate of over £4,000,000, in order to keep this concern going? I think I can retort to the Senator opposite by saying that not one good reason has been advanced as to why this building was ever contemplated. Not one good reason has been advanced as to why Store Street was selected as a location. Nobody has advanced to me, either inside or outside the House, any good reason why it was decided to put six storeys of offices on top of what was originally decided on.
We hear a lot of loose talk about abandoning the building and leaving it uncompleted. There is no intention of leaving the building uncompleted, and every inch of space within that building will be required, and will be used, by the Department of Social Welfare. The portion of it which was intended for the tiers of buses, to which reference has been made, will be used for the accommodation of the public who will require to visit the headquarters of the Social Security or Social Service Department. Deputy Hawkins, I think, wanted to make rather a cheap crack at that, as if that was something we ought to be ashamed of, that people would be going there to seek social service and social security. We have them already. We always had them, lining up, and queueing up at the labour exchanges and various other places, for widows' and orphans' pensions and so on. I do not see anything wrong in adapting the ground floor of this building, so that citizens of this city, who have to go there in connection with blind pensions, old age pensions, widows' and orphans' pensions, unemployment assistance, unemployment insurance, and national health insurance—I do not see why they should not go there, and have convenience there, and where the members of the staff of the Department, whose task will be to deal with the members of the public who go there, will be properly serviced, and properly equipped, to give a quick and fast service to the members of the public. The Senator said that Smithfield would be, of course, a mere bus station, and deplored the fact that we had not even sufficient thought for the convenience of rural travellers as to provide a meal for them. I can assure the Senator, that if and when he travels to the new bus station in Smithfield, he will get a very fine meal there, a very hot meal, and I hope at a very reasonable price; but, the difference is this, that it will cost, approximately, £150,000 to provide a bus station with reasonable and comfortable accommodation there for bus passengers, instead of providing it at Store Street at a cost of £1,000,000.
Now, we have heard an awful lot of talk about a central station. I think that there is too much talk about a central station, a lot too much of it. Mind you, passengers were a long way from the city, passengers from the south and south-west when they arrived at Kingsbridge in the old days. You can carry this question of a central station, and dropping people in the middle of O'Connell Street, a bit too far. If this goes on, the next thing will be, that somebody will be making a suggestion that we ought to turn St. Stephen's Green into an airport, so that, instead of dropping them at Collinstown, we can drop them in the middle of St. Stephen's Green. The fact of the matter is, of course, that for people coming from the south or the west or, indeed, from parts of the north, and the Midlands, they are in a position to get to the centre of the city more easily from Smithfield, than they would from Store Street. When you get off a bus at Store Street, and you want to get to O'Connell Street or Nelson Pillar, how do you get there? By walking, and carrying your luggage with you. I suggest that it will be found possible to have a service of buses circulating, city services circulating, to take passengers to Smithfield and bring them from Smithfield, so organised, that it can, instead of cutting across the traffic arteries, fit into the flow of traffic and, I suggest, that we can give the people a more convenient service than they have at the moment, and by the provision of a contact service, which would link with the long-distance buses at Smithfield, it would be possible to drop people at the various city bus stops. It will take them, if they want to, to the No. 9, No. 10, No. 3 or No. 15 bus stops, drop them at the particular bus stop they want with their luggage, and then all they will have to do will be to step off the bus at whichever stop they want, and step on to whatever bus they want. There would be no necessity for walking. I suggest it will cause the least possible increase in the existing heavy traffic, and the least possible dislocation. I want, again, to support what has been said by Senator O'Farrell and Senator Tunney. I do not claim to know the city nearly as well as most Senators here, but any of us who have occasion to go down around Amiens Street, Beresford Place, down to try to cross that bridge there, any part of that into Abbey Street and across to Talbot Street; do we not know that it is one of the busiest sections of the city? Do we not know that there is probably greater congestion of traffic there than in any other part of the city, that not alone have we the heaviest traffic there, but we also have the slowest moving traffic in the city? There is a bigger concentration of horse traffic around that particular area than in any other part of the city.
Senators know that as well as I do. I do not want to make any reference to the statement which was made by Senator Hawkins about the police. I could if I wished to. I do not propose to make any reference as to how Store Street was originally selected. I could, if I wished. Senator Miss Butler has given some account of what happened at the time, on one side of it. There are other sides, to which I could refer, but I do not propose to do so. I want to say, that as far as we are concerned, and I think it is only fair to the people who are concerned — there are people who are concerned in the location of this bus station; there are people who have vested interests and there is also, of course, the question of serving the people's convenience—to say, that so far as we are concerned, Store Street is out. May I make this appeal to those who are so concerned about the rural travellers, that the sooner we get the co-operation we are entitled to get in having the new bus station erected at Smithfield, the sooner we will be in a position to give bus travellers that service, convenience, protection, and shelter to which they are entitled? May I say, also, in connection with the amendment "the board shall within one year complete" that it cannot be done? I want to say, further, that if we had got the co-operation, which we should have got, in our efforts to start building a bus station at Smithfield, that station would by now be half-way towards completion. Well, I can only give the Seanad the advice and information which has come to me. I am assured that a bus station can be built within 12 months or at the very outside 18 months, a bus station that will make full provision for travellers at a cost not exceeding £150,000.
Comment on this
Where are you going to find that money, Minister?
Comment on this
Would it not be much better if you were to use Broadstone station that is lying derelict? I am surprised Senator O'Farrell did not mention that in his statement in connection with the palatial offices. There are offices at the Broadstone, also, and you would save the money.
Comment on this
If that had been thought of about three years ago we would have saved both £1,000,000 and £150,000, and we would have the bus station. The trouble is that the eyes of the people in those days were turned rather on Glengarriff than on Broadstone.
Comment on this
I am merely suggesting a way out since the Minister says a complete omnibus headquarters will not be built at Smithfield. It will certainly not be built in a year. Broadstone is lying derelict. There is an alternative there which would save £150,000. I suggest the Minister should consider that and save the town-planning and streets committee of the Dublin Corporation unnecessary expense while providing accommodation for rural visitors.
Comment on this
Let me nail that again. Save the Dublin Corporation unnecessary expense — will the Senator say whether the Dublin Corporation has been notified by Córas Iompair Eireann, or anybody else, that it will be involved in any expense?
Comment on this
It would not be fair. We had a confidential conference with Mr. Courtney and it would not be fair to say here and now what happened. I am suggesting certain things the Minister might consider to find a way out of his difficulties.
Comment on this
That is one of those statements that just goes on the record. The Senator says it would not be fair, they held a conference with Mr. Courtney, it was confidential, but the Minister might find a way out of the difficulty. He has said that in reply to my question as to whether Córas Iompair Eireann, or anybody else, told the Dublin Corporation they would be involved in any expense. Is he now insinuating that the Dublin Corporation, or any of its officials, were told that they would be involved in any expense?
Comment on this
No such thing, but in the course of the discussion ways and means were pointed out to Mr. Courtney in relation to an omnibus station and we felt he would come back to the Dublin Corporation Town Planning Committee and discuss the suggestions in connection with the Broadstone station.
Comment on this
The Minister should be allowed to continue his speech.
Comment on this
It is very important that these matters should appear clearly on the record, if they are to appear on the record at all. If there is in the possession of the company a building, or buildings, which can be considered suitable as a bus station by them from the point of view of the company, the travelling public and the Dublin Corporation, we shall be very glad to use it, or them.
Comment on this
Is not that my point? I have suggested, and Senator O'Farrell is aware of the fact, that the Broadstone station is derelict.
Comment on this
At the moment it is. For the amount of omnibus traffic from the country to the city there is ample accommodation there, as I pointed out to Mr. Courtney at that interview.
Comment on this
The Minister must be allowed to continue his speech without interruption.
Comment on this
Senator Clarkin, if I may say so, has been extremely helpful. I do not think I need say anything further beyond stating that, as far as we are concerned, Store Street will not be used as the headquarters of Córas Iompair Eireann.
Comment on this
It is a pity that Senator George O'Brien was not present for some of the later speeches on this matter. I think he would have appreciated, had he been present, why members of this House were put in a particular place on the scale indicated by the Minister in Section 7. As an old Dublin man I am very much concerned as to where the bus station is placed. The headquarters of the trade union to which I had the honour to belong at one time was situated in the Smithfield area. I know the area very well and I have always had a sneaking regard for it. Nothing that will ever be done for Smithfield will ever be half good enough for it in my opinion.
As to the location of a central omnibus terminus, we must look at realities. I am afraid realities were overlooked in this discussion so far. Let us try to reduce this whole matter to something like simplicity. The first question is, is it desirable that we should have a central omnibus station? Is it desirable that we should have centralisation of the headquarters administrative staff? Senator O'Farrell, and in due course the Minister echoed his views, argued that there is no great advantage in that especially as there is alternative accommodation of good quality available. The fact of the matter is that anybody who has any experience of administration, or made a study of the problem of administration, has come to the conclusion that there is everything to be said for centralisation of administrative staff. Sir James Milne, of whom the Minister has spoken so highly and so often——
Comment on this
——and I have quoted so frequently — has indicated that there would be advantages to be gained and economies through the establishment of a headquarters such as is visualised in the Store Street project. Sir James Milne put in a plea against Store Street, not on the grounds that it would not be an economic proposition, but on the grounds that in the present financial circumstances of Córas Iompair Eireann it would not be desirable to go ahead with the scheme. The only point that remains then for decision is whether the financial circumstances of the company were such that it should not have gone ahead with that project. Before I pass on to the question of cost, let me advert to the advisability of having this terminus. For years the public has been demanding such a service as would have been provided in the proposed Store Street terminus. The public is entitled to that. It may be that the public has not been paying up to this for such an amenity. It may be that if we went ahead with the project that we would then come to the conclusion that, having provided such an amenity, the public ought to contribute something towards it. Be that as it may, the point is that the public has been demanding facilities such as were generally envisaged in the Store Street proposition. We have efficiency of administration as an argument in favour of it. We have economy in administration as an argument in favour of it, and we have the public demand for such an amenity and the public right to it as another argument in favour of it.
Sir James Milne—he is not specific— said it was doubtful whether in the existing state of the company's finances that it should have gone on with this scheme. It is worth while remembering that he did not declare definitely against it. In fact, the relevant paragraph in the report would indicate that if the financial side of the matter were all right he would approve of it. The cost has been mentioned by the Minister as £1,000,000. We ought to get clear on this question of the £1,000,000. When the company decided to go ahead with the project the cost then estimated was somewhere about £500,000, somewhat under £500,000. Time went on, changes occurred, prices apparently altered, wages altered, and we may say, generally, that all costs altered. As I understand it, in contracts in these days, nobody will tender a firm figure. He will tender a certain amount, with the right to adjust if prices alter unfavourably for him as contractor, so that one might say that £1,000,000 at the time the contract was entered into would be somewhat unreasonable. But in the circumstances, in the way that things changed, it can hardly be said, even if it were to cost £1,000,000 that the company should be blamed or that the proposed cost was unreasonable, but from the financial point of view and the effect of this building on the company, would it have made a very great difference one way or another to the financial position of the company if this project had not been mooted and started?
Assume that the building was to cost £1,000,000. Assume that the company had not, from resources of its own, the money required, that it had to go outside and get them, and the House will remember that Sir James Milne has not indicated that this was a bankrupt concern. I think, as well as I can remember, looking over the figures, he indicated that the company was in a position to provide something about £3,000,000 to £3,500,000 off its own bat for capital projects, but if it had to raise £1,000,000 the question was: at what rate would it get the money? I think if circumstances had been normal it would have been able to raise the money at pretty much the same rates as those at which it had been raising money up to the start of this whole financial trouble — at or about 3 per cent. Assuming that it had to go to 4 per cent. for the £1,000,000, that would cost the company £40,000 per year. The £40,000 would have to be provided by the company on account of this project. Would the company be able to raise that £40,000? What economies might accrue? Obviously I am not in a position to indicate what precise economies would accrue, but of one thing I am certain, that if one were to examine it objectively, one would have no difficulty in coming to the conclusion that the company would have little difficulty in servicing that £1,000,000.
In the first place, even if the company had to impose something in the nature of a fine or a tax on passengers using the terminus, the public would hardly complain if they were to get the amenities they had been demanding for so long and to which we are all agreed they are entitled. What the company might have got from that I cannot say. I might attempt a calculation on the basis of the Milne Report which indicates the number of passengers arriving in Dublin on the long-distance bus service. I could calculate from those figures what even a penny per head would be likely to bring in, but there is no point in my doing it. I want to indicate that the idea of this project should not have been rejected on the grounds suggested by Sir James Milne, or on the grounds that have been argued to the extent that they have been by the Minister a few minutes ago. There would have been a saving of rates. The Minister has declared, I think, in the Dáil, that from information given to him the amount of rates that would be saved would be somewhere about £4,500, or something like that. I do not know whether that is a firm figure. I do not know whether the Minister has got all the relevant information or whether he has considered the alterations that are accruing from time to time in rates. The tendency, taking things by and large, is upwards. However, that has to be taken into account. The project envisaged the provision of restaurants. Senator Tunney remarked — perhaps I should not try to quote him—but he indicated that the company did not make a good job of its present catering services. I think the truth is — I have just looked at the figures for Córas Iompair Eireann in the balance sheets for 1946 to 1949 and in each year the catering services of Córas Iompair Eireann did pay. In any case, the intention was to provide catering services. I have no doubt that having regard to the number of passengers arriving and the conditions under which they would arrive, and the conditions under which they would assemble to take buses going out, the restaurant would have proved to be a very successful venture.
I have little hesitation in saying that if Coras Iompair Eireann were to farm out that particular aspect of the project, it would have little difficulty in getting a very considerable offer. How much I cannot say. But I have indicated that £40,000 would have serviced this project. I am trying to indicate that the company would have very little difficulty, taking things by and large, in collecting the requisite funds to service the project. There would be an economy of buses, an economy in the handling of buses, in fuel, in loading and in regulating the flow of buses in and out. How much that would be worth I am not attempting to say, but it must be obvious to anybody who has any little understanding at all of business administration that that must lead to very considerable economy. There would be, apart from the economy in buses, an economy in staff—the staff not merely of the buses themselves like drivers, conductors and other personnel but the economies that would accrue from the better organisation of the staff itself in single central headquarters. How much that would be worth I have no means of calculating, but in a vast organisation like Córas Iompair Eireann, an organisation which is spread, I understand, over six different buildings in the city, the staff organisation as envisaged in the Store Street project must have led to very considerable economy.
The Minister has argued that the project was properly rejected on the grounds of the financial difficulties of the company. I have tried to indicate more than once in this House that we should be very careful in our approach to this aspect of the problem. We do know that Córas Iompair Eireann got into difficulties, very considerable difficulties. What I hope Senators will realise is that Córas Iompair Eireann's getting into these difficulties was not the fault of its management. Why? The loss in 1947, which is the key year, was, to the best of my recollection, £912,000, but in that year the company had to face a coal crisis which every one of us remembers and remembers well. In consequence of that crisis, railway transport came almost to a standstill for a considerable period. I remember reading the financial report for that year and the company estimated that it lost in or about £450,000 because of that crisis. The second difficulty that the company had to contend with was that there was a protracted bus strike. Notwithstanding the existence of the Labour Court, this strike developed, and I remember that the company estimated that it lost about £500,000 because of that strike. Put these losses together and you find that the £950,000 loss was due to causes over which the company had no control and for which it was very unfair to blame the company. In other words, if the company had not run into these unfortunate difficulties instead of a loss it most likely would have made a profit. Yet we are basing all our attacks on Córas Iompair Eireann, all our assessments of its success or otherwise, on that very exceptional year.
The difficulties of the company were bad enough because of these factors over which it had no control, but the company was not a free agent to do as it wished in order to overtake these difficulties. It could not alter fares or charges without the consent of the Minister. Here is the point. If Córas Iompair Eireann could not have gone on with these particular projects, which have been criticised to the extent they have, and with this particular project of a central bus station on the lines indicated in the Store Street project, the fault is not the fault of the company but the fault of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. My saying that will evoke the reply from the Minister that I am a Fianna Fáil propagandist. No doubt the Minister will protest that all the ballyhoo we have heard from the other side is not Coalition Party propaganda. I have here a document which I understand was posted to every member of the Seanad. There is an address to it, a Dublin address, and it bears the signatures of two very well-known people. One of them was for a very long time a member of this House—ex-Senator Joseph Johnston. He was a very useful member of the House and a grand colleague, but he will not be remembered for his sympathy with Fianna Fáil or the Fianna Fáil Government. The other signatory to this document is a Mr. Heffernan who, I understand, was formerly a member of Dáil Eireann. I may be wrong in that, and if so perhaps Senators who have a longer connection with the Oireachtas than I, will correct me. I understand that Mr. Heffernan was a member of the Dáil for a long time, a Parliamentary Secretary, and a member of the old Fine Gael party. These men have circulated to each Senator their views on certain matters in connection with Córas Iompair Eireann. I want to quote a few lines from this communication. On page 2 of the memorandum, which is issued from 4 Clare Street, Dublin, there is this remark:—
"Further, the application made by the directors early in 1948 for authority to increase charges has been shown by the report to have been fully justified."
The board of Córas Iompair Eireann asked for permission to do certain things in order that it might retrieve the position. Sir James Milne has declared in very definite terms that the board ought to be allowed to increase its charges in order to cover increased wages and increased costs. If the board did not overtake those difficulties, with whom does the blame lie? Clearly, the blame lies with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who dug his heels in the ground and rejected the arguments of the ex-chairman and of the board for authority to do what they had a perfect right to do in the circumstances, namely, to get in by extra charges, by extra fares, the amount necessary to cover the increased costs that the company had to contend with.
The Minister said with regard to the new project: "The company did not need it." I said before that one of the things which I think most unfortunate about this whole matter is that when investigation was being made into the position of Córas Iompair Eireann those charged with the duty of making the investigation did not meet the ex-chairman and the directors of the company and get their views on these matters. In this we have a one-sided view. The Minister says it was not wanted — I would like something more than the Minister's statement that this project is not required. The company could not afford it — I do not think I need say any more on that.
The Minister got a certain satisfaction out of pin-pricking Senator Hawkins because the Senator quoted the views of a London journal on this matter of a central bus station. He indicated that it was unworthy of Senator Hawkins to rely on the views of outside people. But the peculiar thing about it all is that the Minister himself has relied on the views of outside people who could hardly have been familiar with the peculiar economic circumstances of this country, people whose views and whose approach were coloured, were influenced, by their association with a totally different set of circumstances. The Minister argued that Senator Hawkins wanted to have it both ways. If anybody wanted to have it both ways, or if anybody wants to have it both ways, clearly it is the Minister.
If it is agreed that we should have a bus station — and I think the arguments are all there that we should have it — then the only question is, where should it be located? I am not in a position to say. The Minister has again waved the big stick and told us that he has a lot of information that, if he cared to give it, would not be very nice. For my part, I have appealed to Ministers in the House more than once that they ought to put an end to this. They are over two years in office, they have the files at their disposal in their Departments, they have a very able Attorney-General, they have an excellent Civil Service, and it is about time they put their cards on the table, and told us specifically what those charges are that can be laid against worthy citizens of this State. So far as I am concerned, I am sick of such statements as "I have information which I will give if I am driven to give it". Perhaps the Minister will influence his colleagues to have some kind of tribunal or commission set up in order to settle this thing one way or the other.
On a recent occasion it suited me to use the public transport service. I met railway workers, railway officials. I assure the Minister I did not canvass their views on this question of Córas Iompair Éireann or Store Street. They themselves introduced the subject and the thing that intrigued me was that these men, both railmen and busmen, were of the same opinion, that Store Street was an ideal situation for the terminus. They may not be experts, but at any rate they were men who had long service with the transport company, men whose views, after all, might not be despised. I, for one, would not be anxious to despise them.
Senator Miss Butler had some information for the House with regard to what happened at the Dublin Corporation Planning Committee. All I can say is that I am very disappointed that a person of the high qualifications and distinction of the town planner in question did not think it worth his while, if he felt strongly on this project, to state in writing his objections. I think, in view of what has been said, this must have been a matter of very great importance. He must have realised the extent of its importance. I am sorry that all we have so far about his views on the matter is that he says: "Well, if you must have it, then let it be." I think that when men are appointed to responsible offices of this kind, they ought to realise the heavy duty that devolves upon them. If they have serious objections to any particular matter they ought to put them on record and lodge their protest with the Lord Mayor, stating in definite and specific terms what their objection is. Perhaps the eminent authority in question has done that, but, in the absence of information that he has, then, for my part, I am not prepared to pay much attention to what happened at the Committee's meeting on that particular matter.
Again, the question of the type of building has been mentioned as a reason why the Store Street project should be rejected. I am not an architect. I would not know, from looking at the plan of a building, how beautiful it might appear, or otherwise, when finished. All I know is that the gentleman who prepared the plans is a gentleman of eminence in his profession, and I would be sorry to think that one of his eminence and experience would be a party to the erection of a building of this kind that would ruin the city to the extent indicated by Senator Butler. If the building were to be the eyesore which the Senator has indicated, and if it would injure the city in the way she says, then there is a lot to be said for rejecting the project. However, I am not inclined to agree with Senator Tunney that those responsible for the project ought to be shot.
Comment on this
May I withdraw the charge that I made against Senator Tunney that he indicated those responsible ought to be shot? I have tried to reduce this thing to simplicity, firstly, whether the service indicated was called for, and, secondly, whether in all the circumstances, the financial circumstances, of the company it was wrong for it to go ahead with the venture. With regard to the location, I have to make up my mind on that. From what I know of Smithfield, and from what I know of the Store Street area and of the possibility of a "getaway" from that area via the North Circular Road or, for that matter, via the South Circular Road——
Comment on this
With the enforcement of traffic regulations there is no reason why either Senator Hayes or I could not do it, or why it could not be done in the case of buses with proper organisation.
Comment on this
However, the point remains that it is not essential that all incoming and outgoing buses must cross O'Connell Street. Taking things by and large, as I see them I have to decide in the light of my knowledge at the moment, in the light of what is being said on the other side and in the light of what has been said by the Minister, and if I have to decide then I say that Store Street is the proper location for this project.
Comment on this
The Minister, when replying to the amendment, thought fit to open his remarks in a way that seems to be usual now with Ministers when they come to this House. He challenged the motive that prompted me to put down this amendment and said that it was false Fianna Fáil propaganda, based on the idea that the oftener you repeat a falsehood and the more widespread it becomes known the more likely people are to believe it. Other Ministers coming to this House have given expression to the same view. I, therefore, have come to the conclusion that the charges of corruption, the charges in regard to Locke's Distillery and to the railway tribunal and the other charges that were made during the last few years, were founded on that ground which is this: "We know these charges to be false, but we are firmly convinced that the oftener we repeat them the greater is the hope that people will believe them."
I have stated before that Bills are brought here so that Senators may have an opportunity of considering them and of giving expression to their views on the principles underlying them. It is the duty of Senators to examine Bills in detail and, if they think it necessary either in the national interest or in the interest of the section of the people they represent, to submit amendments for consideration. It is wrong for a Minister either in the Dáil or particularly in the case of this House to come here and say: "I have made up my mind," as the Minister did say on the Second Reading of this Bill, "on the question of a bus station at Store Street", and, having given expression to that point of view, to say that it was propaganda, something for which the functions of this House should not be utilised, for any Senator to suggest that the Bill might be amended — for example by directing the board to undertake the completion of a work that had already been begun by the board of Córas Iompair Eireann.
The Minister expressed surprise that I should take a keen interest in the views expressed by London experts. We have had views put forward inside and outside of this House by people, whether they are native or foreign, who cannot be said to be experts on transport, the provision of accommodation in general or the design of any particular building. Two representatives were sent here by this journal's organisation because of the fact that a controversy had arisen as to the suitability of this particular site. I put the views expressed in that journal before the House, as well as the views expressed in the March issue of the Irish Builders' and Engineers' Journal. The Minister failed to give a satisfactory answer, or otherwise, to the questions which I put to him. I asked him when it was decided to acquire the site in Store Street. Rather than answer that question, a threat was issued — I do not propose to deal with it — regarding the circumstances surrounding the acquisition of the site in Store Street in such a manner as to give the feeling that: “ Well, it is better that I would not ask that”.
But we want to hear the whole story. I put the question in very plain language. Was it the decision of the board of Córas Iompair Eireann that this site should be acquired, and was it not a fact that the matter was under consideration by the Dublin Corporation? Was it not also a fact that the site was approved of not only by the town planner to the Dublin Corporation but by the corporation itself? The second question I asked was, when, and by whom, was the decision made to abandon Store Street? The Minister failed to answer that question. From the manner of his reply, I take it that the decision was made by him as Minister for Industry and Commerce. He put forward the only reasons that have been advanced, which are not at all reasons, that owing to the circumstances in which Córas Iompair Éireann found itself at the particular time, it was not well that the work should be proceeded with. He did make this admission. He admitted that the burden of completing the building is going to be placed on the new board of Córas Iompair Eireann, that they must find the money to complete the building. Senators have made a reference already to the standard of the building. Some have termed it as being unsightly and an unworthy building to be erected in this grand City of Dublin. In connection with that matter, I should like to ask the Minister whether an arrangement has been entered into with the Department of Social Welfare to have the necessary alterations carried out that will suit their requirements and, if such an arrangement has been entered into, who is the architct employed to do the new planning, to draw up the new specifications, and to see the work is carried out in a proper manner?
In connection with Smithfield I, also, made reference to the amounts that will be involved in, first of all, acquiring the property, and then necessary demolition of buildings, and removal of persons. I gave a certain figure. The Minister will, I am quite sure, make this allowance, that this matter has been brought before the Dublin Corporation. Surely, the chairman of Córas Iompair Eireann has gone into the question of the additional cost. Some particular ground must be acquired. What will the cost of that ground be, and what is the area of the ground? What will the acquisition of the site and the erection of the building entail? On the Second Reading, and earlier, to-day; I pointed out the great benefit it would be to complete Store Street because of the fact that there was provision made for the supply of refreshments, and the other amenities for the travelling public. In his concluding statement, the Minister pointed out that I need not have any fear in this connection, and that at Smithfield, there is also going to be refreshment accommodation. Now, the Minister has, at least, changed his mind in that small regard.
Comment on this
The Minister has stated both in the Dáil and here in this House that it was fantastic for any board to undertake a building of the nature of Store Street, that it could be well understood for a board like Córas Iompair Eireann to undertake the provision of mere bus accommodation, a bus terminus station, but no one must take it from the Minister, when he referred to it in that manner, that there was any other undertaking to be attached to it. Senator Tunney put forward the view that Córas Iompair Eireann should not engage in the catering business. If he holds that view strongly, then, before this House passes the Committee Stage of the Bill, he should, at least, put down an amendment to remove the section of the Bill making provision for the board to engage in the catering and hotel business throughout the country.
The Minister also gave us the information, that when the building is completed by the board of Córas Iompair Eireann it will be handed over to the Social Welfare Department. When earlier to-day I inquired as to what use the ground floor portion, which was originally planned to contain 17 tiers of buses, would be utilised for, I ventured to remark, that I could not see any use, other than for the public who might be making application for any one or other of the social welfare schemes. The Minister, in his reply, admitted that that was the purpose to which the ground floor portion of this building was going to be put. He put forward the plea that it was quite justifiable to do so, that the applicants for any of the social services had a right to have accommodation. I agree with that, but when we examine the building, and the purpose for which it was built, and the number of people waiting to be received by one or other sections of the Department, it would give us the picture that the whole City of Dublin would be applicants at the one time. While Dublin is a great part of Ireland, we must remember that it is only a fifth of the country. What are the other applicants throughout the country going to do?
Comment on this
Surely it is enough to discuss railway affairs, and the whole railway system on one sub-section, without going into social services in addition. I suggest it is out of order.
Comment on this
The only other purpose, I believe it will be put to, assuming it is taken over by the Social Welfare Department, is, that this space provided for the 17 tiers of buses, will provide ample accommodation for the staff cars of this new Department, while the bus travelling public from all parts of Ireland can look on at this, while they wait for the new station to be provided at Smithfield. Now, the Minister made a charge. He said that if co-operation was given, the Smithfield station would now be ready.
Comment on this
What progress has been made to acquire it, and what are the opposing factors? Surely, the Minister cannot contend that the expression of views in this and the other House by members, or some articles written by persons in the local or daily Press have little to do with the acquiring of the site. There must be some other difficulties in the way. If the Minister has given a direction to the chairman of Córas Iompair Eireann to acquire this site, and if there is something holding up the progress of the acquisition, we would like to hear it. If the site has been acquired, then, we would like to hear what the price was, what the area of ground was, and where exactly it is situated and particularly what influence was brought to bear on the police authorities to make them change their view in relation to the site at Smithfield when, on the first occasion, they were not prepared to approve of it. I believe this is a serious matter and one of national interest. It is a matter in which the rural people are vitally interested. Even at this late stage I urge on the Minister that he should reconsider his decision and have the Store Street premises completed for the purpose for which they were first intended.
Comment on this
This discussion has gone on so long I do not like to prolong it much further. Like Senator Ó Buachalla, I know my Dublin. I know of no part of Dublin as open as the Smithfield area. Were we considering now for the first time the selection of a site and were there no prejudices one way or the other and the decision lay between Store Street and Smithfield, I would declare Smithfield to be the more suitable in my opinion. I wonder how many here know that area. Do they know it was the haymarket and that it accommodated up to 1,000 loads of hay coming into Dublin on horses and carts from Meath and Kildare even in our own lifetime? It is a big open space. No buildings will require to be demolished. Plenty of buildings can be constructed. There are at least ten openings into that area. If it is necessary to widen one, as it probably will be, the only premises that might be interfered with are slum property which should have been demolished long ago. That does not apply to the Store Street area. If one had to widen that area one would be up against vested interests and business concerns demanding fabulous compensation for their property.
Comment on this
That is quite true. Finally, if the House will excuse a rather mixed metaphor, we know that this amendment would not be accepted and, in putting it down and arguing for it, Senator Hawkins was merely flogging a dead horse.
Comment on this
It has been suggested that the House continue after 6 o'clock in order to finish this amendment.
Comment on this
That is on the presumption that we shall finish it shortly after 6 o'clock.
Comment on this
May I say that a completely wrong impression is being given to the House and support is being sought for this amendment by implying that there is only one choice, Smithfield or Store Street? That is entirely wrong. It has been pointed out by Senator Clarkin that in the course of certain discussions he suggested Broadstone. In the course of those discussions I suggested Kings-bridge, because there there is room for expansion and possibility of approach from all directions, plus the added possibility of bringing short-distance buses to the same terminus as long-distance ones. But I do not think all this arises on a particular section of a Bill such as this. I want to draw attention to the fact that it is not a question of choice between two sites. Those who tabled this amendment are trying to get support for it on that basis. The Town Planning Committee suggested that the site should be on the esplanade along the quays.
I would also like to say that I was present at the various discussions referred to by Senator Clarkin and at no time was there any suggestion made by anybody representing Córas Iompair Eireann that the Dublin Corporation would be involved in any expense in whatever site was chosen.
I would like to make one request. There are only two reasons, as I have said, for putting down this amendment. One is either interested in the proposed site for a specific and definite reason or else one wants to air a particular point of view. I think it is unreasonable to expect us to sit here while the person who proposes the amendment leaves the House, having put his point of view, while other members are expressing their opinion and while the Minister answers the questions put to him, and subsequently returns to have the last word, restates his original point of view, asks the same questions, and restates things that have already been denied publicly, such as whether or not the town planning authority had given their sanction to the original site. If Senator Hawkins cannot stay for the whole debate or is not interested in hearing the other side he should at least read the debates and not keep us here until 6 o'clock repeating his original statement and asking questions that have already been answered by the Minister.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation. It is true that I was absent during portion of the Senator's remarks, but it is not true to say that it is the practice to introduce amendments and then walk out of the House. I was here practically all the time the Minister was replying. I was here when the Senator who last spoke was not here.
Comment on this
Arising out of what has been said, a statement which reflects on the probity of certain members, may I say there is a method under which the conduct of members can be challenged? It is quite improper that such a matter should be brought up in the way in which it has been this evening.
Comment on this
I am more than surprised at the statement made by Senator Miss Butler. This Bill has been before the House for the past two days and this is the first appearance Senator Miss Butler has made in the House.
Comment on this
Senator Miss Butler was here yesterday at 3 o'clock and remained here. She was also here at 3 o'clock to-day.
Comment on this
I must say this debate has taken a most unpleasant turn as a result of the statements made by Senator Miss Butler.
Comment on this
It is only made more unpleasant by continuing it.
Amendment put and negatived.
Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7 p.m.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:—
Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
The board shall contract for the purchase of 50,000 tons of Irish coal in each year to be used on Córas Iompair Eireann services;
Provided always that the Minister may, after due notice, direct the board to contract for such higher quantity than 50,000 tons as he may think proper.
I have put down this amendment because I believe that provision should be made that the board should purchase Irish coal. Arigna coal, from various reports of analyses, has been proven to be as good steam coal as any coal imported in this country. I know that during the emergency large quantities of Irish coal were purchased by Córas Iompair Eireann and a lot of that coal was found to be of very favourable quality, but during the time of the extended market, and when there was a heavy demand for coal, a third-crop coal was then mined in Arigna which should never have been allowed on the market. That coal, I believe, brought Irish coal in general into great disrepute, but at present coal of a very high quality is being mined in Arigna and it has to be crushed with crushers into slack in order to get a market for it with the Irish Sugar Company. Now, that is sold at an uneconomic price. For some time past, since 1947, the market has been dwindling for Irish coal, with the result that many of the people who were engaged in coal production in previous years, from 1934 onwards, have had to emigrate to Britain to hew coal there to be imported back into this country.
Roscommon County Council, in the years past, erected many houses for the miners working in Arigna. I think they put up 24 or 25 houses in the years 1936 and 1937, and when employment increased in 1939 and 1942, a scheme was mooted for the erection of 40 more houses to accommodate the miners, and 20 of those 40 houses were erected at a cost of £1,200 or £1,300 each to the ratepayers. With a falling market in Irish coal, these houses have now become white elephants and a burden on the over-taxed ratepayers, all because of the failure of the Government to find a market in their industries for that Irish product. Deputations have waited on the former Minister and on the present Minister as regards finding a market with the railway company. These deputations consisted of coal mine owners, trade union officials and public representatives, but they all met with the same reply from the Minister and his officials, that they have no control over the Irish railways or Córas Iompair Eireann.
For that reason, I believe that the Minister should make this provision in the Bill in order to foster an Irish industry where, after the emergency, there were 600 people employed. But now, with a falling market there are only about 350, and if this falling market for Irish coal continues, I see very little hope for the industry. It has had many obstacles in its struggle for existence during the last 200 years, but it came from that struggling existence when the miners were in poverty, into a period of prosperity. I do not like to see the miners going back into the same rut because of a falling market for Irish coal. Railway companies in this country were never favourable to Irish coal. Although locomotives went up to the mines to take coal to the sugar company's factories, you always found that foreign coal was used in the locomotives. I ask the Minister because of the reasons I have given to include this amendment in the Bill providing that the board shall purchase a certain amount of Irish coal.
Comment on this
Anxious and all as I am to see the fullest possible development of the Arigna coalfield, I cannot accept this amendment. I think it would be entirely unfair to bind the board in the way which the amendment proposes. While it is true to say, of course, that the output and sale of coal in Arigna are not now as great as during the war period, when you had an abnormal expansion, due entirely to war conditions, it is a fact that the output and sale of coal from Arigna, even at the present time, is very substantially greater than it was prior to the war. I think also it is only fair to say that over 60 per cent. of the entire output of Arigna is taken up by three State or semi-State companies, if for the moment you can describe Córas Iompair Éireann as a State company. Between the Electricity Supply Board, the Sugar Company and Córas Iompair Éireann they take, as I say, something in excess of 60 per cent. of the entire output. I am anxious that, as far as possible, native fuel would be used. As a matter of fact, I was concerned to such an extent about Arigna coal being used by the transport company that I asked Sir James Milne and his experts when they were here if they would have a special look at Arigna, and see if they could make any recommendations in connection with it. In so far as I have had any authority whatever up to the moment to give a direction or make a suggestion to Córas Iompair Eireann, that suggestion has been that so far as they possibly could they should use Arigna coal.
I am quite sure if the coal is as good and as suitable as the Senator says it is, the new board will be more than anxious to avail of it to the fullest possible extent. There are many reasons why that should be so. I might mention in that connection that, as recently as a fortnight ago, the colliery owners from that area were received in my Department at my suggestion, with a view to seeing exactly what their difficulties were, and to what extent, if any, we in the Department could be helpful to them. The suggestions which they made during the interview are at the moment under consideration in the Department, and if there are any steps which we can take to improve the position there, they certainly will be taken. I think, however, it would be undesirable, and not right, to put into legislation an amendment such as that proposed by the Senator.
Comment on this
I should like to know from the Minister or Senator Lynch whether the Arigna mines were working during the war or how many mines there are in that district. Are there two mines or one mine and was that mine in existence during the emergency?
Comment on this
Anyone who has had experience of travelling on the Great Southern Railway system during the war will remember that the company at that time were using turf and timber to fuel their locomotives. Anyone who has had experience, as you, a Chathaoirligh, and I had, during the war of travelling from Cork to Dublin, when the journey on one occasion occupied 16¾ hours, must know that the engines were not using Arigna coal at that time. I am altogether in sympathy with the object of this amendment but if these mines had been operated to the extent necessary during the war it would have saved a lot of time, not to talk about saving some of our souls because some of us perforce had to use very bad language at that time. It would have been helpful to know if the company were using Arigna coal at that time.
Comment on this
I wish to support the amendment moved by Senator Lynch. I know that it is difficult at this stage to confine the board to purchasing a particular quality or quantity of coal but if we look at the report of Sir James Milne we find that in 1941 about 2,132 tons of Arigna coal were consumed by Córas Iompair Eireann. In 1947, when there was a fuel crisis, the amount of Arigna coal consumed by Córas Iompair Eireann was 47,876 tons. In 1948, for a period of nine months, which was the only period for which figures were available at the time the report was compiled, the amount of Arigna coal consumed was 8,587 tons. Examining the report, we find that certain recommendations were made in regard to the steps that the collieries should take in order to improve the quality of the coal. We understand that these recommendations have been carried out. Whatever difficulties might have existed during the war years were due to the difficulty of securing machinery in order to have the coal properly screened and a proper quality delivered. These conditions have passed and, as Senator Lynch has pointed out, these mines are situated in a part of the country where it is almost impossible to find alternative employment for persons who formerly worked in the mines. I have not the figures in respect of the quantity of coal consumed by the Sugar Company and the other State or semi-State organisations which might utilise this coal. We can see that if the drop from 40,000 to 8,000 is allowed to continue, it will mean a considerable amount of unemployment. Again, that unemployment will be brought about in districts where no alternative schemes can be put forward. The only avenue open to these people is to seek employment in the coalfields of other countries.
This is really a national question and it is one which, I am sure, the Minister will direct the attention of the new board to, in the hope that they will do all they can to ensure that as large a quantity of coal as possible will be taken from the mines Senator Lynch has in mind.
Comment on this
I rise to support the amendment moved by Senator Lynch. The district to which the Senator has referred is a very poor one and mining is practically the only form of employment that is given there. Every type of coal that could be produced during the emergency was produced there and given to the railways. It is admitted that in their anxiety to produce a good deal of coal at a time when everything in the way of fuel was so necessary, what might be termed a third-grade article did, perhaps, get on the market. It is better to be honest about these things. That grade of coal did not, perhaps, find favour with a good many people who happened to use it, and that sort of thing might be likely to give the whole project a bad name. I have been reliably informed that the coal that is being produced now is of first-class quality. That being so, I suggest the Minister should ask the board to investigate this matter, and if the coal is as satisfactory as the producers say, the Minister might use his good offices with the company and get them to utilise this coal to the fullest extent possible. My colleague, Senator Finan, asked me to say that his views on this matter are somewhat the same as my own.
Comment on this
I understand that one of the difficulties with this particular coal is its high ash content and liability to clinker. I was informed that an experimental firebox was being made on one or two locomotives in order to see if they could get rid of the difficulties created by the ash and clinker. I should like to know if this firebox was tested out, and with what result.
Comment on this
As I indicated on the Second Reading, a very special effort is being made to see if it is possible to design a locomotive that will economically utilise native fuel. That fuel may not necessarily be coal; it may, but not necessarily.
I can assure the three Senators who spoke in favour of this amendment that I have urged, and will continue to urge, State companies to use native fuel to the fullest possible extent. I have indicated that 60 per cent. of the entire output of the Arigna coalfield is being taken up by State companies. Might, I, in turn, make an appeal to Senators who are members of local authorities, particularly in that area? If the local authorities and the local institutions in the counties surrounding the Arigna coalfield would do their part of the job and give preference to the coal produced, which is, I have been informed, suitable for at least some of their requirements, it would be very helpful.
I think it is right to say that one of the main complaints that I got from Arigna is not so much with reference to the amount of coal purchased by State companies as that the purchases are not spread all over the mines. The smaller mine-owners are complaining that the State companies take their supplies from one or two mines. There is probably a very good reason for that, but I do not want to go into that matter at the moment.
All these points were put before my officers and they are being examined in order to see what we can do to help. I have no hesitation in giving an assurance to the Seanad that in so far as I can urge State companies to take coal from the Arigna area or to utilise every native fuel to the fullest extent, I shall do so, but I suggest if the State companies are taking 60 per cent. of the output that with a little effort in the locality itself and in the counties immediately surrounding Arigna they might be able to dispose of the remaining 40 per cent. or a great part of it.
Comment on this
I agree that the State companies are utilising some of the Arigna coal, and that includes the sugar company. But the sugar company uses a considerable amount of slack. There would be, perhaps, 40 to 50 per cent. of round coal. Some of the mines have installed coal-cutters, and aerial routes for the transport of coal have been established, and this has been done in order to put the coal on the market at a price that would enable it to compete with the foreign coal. Some of the mines find themselves in bad financial circumstances. They were always hoping that the market they had at one time would continue, but they find themselves now in a difficult position.
I am not making any case with regard to the smaller mines. The people who produce the most coal, the mines that give the greatest amount of employment — these are the people who kept coal-mining in existence when the output had dwindled practically to nothing. It is lamentable at the present time to see mountains of foreign coal at Sligo, some 20 miles from Arigna, and to see the local coal-miners cycling over the roads for their unemployment benefit. They are out one week and in another and in the meantime mountains of foreign coal are being built up at Sligo. It is a disgraceful thing.
They have made appeals to the former Minister and to the present Minister to find them a market with the railway company. The market they had with the railway company during the emergency has dwindled to something like 100 tons a month. I think the Electricity Supply Board has also cut down its demand. For these reasons I hope the Minister will use his influence with the new board and will give sympathetic consideration to the claims of the Arigna miners. I propose to withdraw the amendment if he gives us an assurance that he will do so.
Comment on this
The Minister appealed to members of local authorities in the adjoining counties to encourage a greater use of Arigna coal. Coming as I do from a neighbouring county to the one in which the Arigna mines are situated, I can say we are doing as much as we can to purchase Arigna coal. My own experience, as a member of the county council during the economic war period, was that we used both Arigna coal and turf. The county engineers experienced the same difficulties as regards fire bars as are mentioned in the Milne Report. We found that the fire bars in the engines and boilers burned out much more quickly than when we used British steam coal. I am satisfied, however, that, as a result of the efforts made by the engineering staff of the Longford County Council, we have overcome those difficulties to a large extent. I am satisfied, too, that Córas Iompair Eireann, with the research facilities which will be at the disposal of their engineering staff, will also be able to overcome this difficulty about excessive clinkers and excessive ash.
I would ask the Minister to bear this also in mind, that there is the impression that Arigna coal vis-a-vis similar quality English coal is less valuable. I do not think we could accept that as being 100 per cent. correct. Let me give an example. I am sure most of us read in the newspapers recently a statement which was made by a person connected with the British coal mines, a person who, we must assume, was in a position to know what he was talking about. His statement was that one-third of the output of the British nationalised coal mines was fit for roofing only. We know what that means, that there is an excessive amount of shale and slate in it which is unfit for burning but eminently suitable for roofing. We know, too, that both the quality and the quantity of coal available to us from England have been reduced very considerably. Whatever the reasons are, we know that the requirements of this country in coal have had to be met from Poland and other foreign countries.
I think in view of the expenditure of foreign currency and that sort of thing it would be very desirable — I must say that the Minister's attitude to this amendment was very sympathetic and gives me very great hope — if the Minister would follow up the request that he has made and have the position of the Arigna coal examined very carefully. I hope he will ask the board to be appointed under this Bill to be active in investigating the possibilities of an intensive use of Arigna or other Irish coal. As regards price, I know that if Arigna coal was available at say, 70/- a ton and imported coal at 65/-, I would, if the decision were left with me, certainly decide in favour of the Irish coal at that difference in price.
Comment on this
I should like to support the amendment. I think if there is anything the Minister can do to induce the company to absorb as much as possible of Irish coal it would be a step in the right direction. I know it used to be argued that the quality of Irish coal was unsuitable for certain forms of public transport. I am prepared to admit that, possibly, at one period that was so. I am reliably informed now that the quality of Arigna coal, particularly, is equal to that of any other coal produced within the country and is, in fact, almost as good as any imported coal. I think that, in the interests of Irish industry and of Irish employment, it would be a fatal mistake to use imported fuel where native fuel could be used.
I am interested in this matter mainly on account of the Arigna coal. The production of coal there is about the only form of employment in the area. Quite a large number of breadwinners and their families are dependent on the continued production of coal there. It is a pity that we, in this country, are more or less inclined to deride the home-produced article. I am glad to say that the Minister has publicly given a lead against that evil habit. I remember that, in 1926, no English coal could be procured here because there was a big coal strike in England at the time. The Dublin people at that time were forced to rely on Arigna coal. I was living in Dublin at the time. I will admit that it was more difficult to start a fire with Arigna coal than with Wigan coal, but once the fire was started I would say that it would take a clever man to see any difference — to say whether it was Arigna or Wigan coal that was being used. Since that period Arigna coal has improved very much. I am sure that if Córas Iompair Éireann give it a decent trial they will find it possible to use practically all the coal produced there. I am told that if the company would use 1 cwt. of Arigna coal to every ton of other coal they use they would be able to absorb practically all the output of that mine. That may not be quite correct, but if it is anyway nearly accurate I think it would not impose a very heavy burden on the company to buy their coal in Arigna. If the Minister could see his way to make a recommendation, or even to give a direction to the company that it was in the public interest to use Irish coal, wherever possible, it would be a step that would meet with the approval of everyone in this House.
Comment on this
It has, and we have since had two speeches on it.
Comment on this
What I think Senator Lynch said was that he would be prepared to withdraw it.
Comment on this
On the section, I endeavoured yesterday to raise a question on Section 6 which had to do with the particular functions of the chairman. The discussion on the amendment that has just been disposed of bears out quite fully, I think, that I was quite relevant in attempting to raise the matter that I had intended to raise on that section. The chairman of the new board, the whole board, is to be appointed by the Government. The chairman of the old board was also appointed by the Government. I think it is understood that there was a special reason for that, namely, that the chairman would pay particular attention to the public interest as against private interests, and that, in order to fulfil that function, he would have consultations from time to time with the Minister. What I want to know is whether the Minister has anything similar in mind to what obtained under the old board. The reason I am asking that is that the Minister has indicated quite clearly that this board is going to be completely independent and that he is not going to interfere with it. He may refer me to Section 14 and say that, by Order, he can get the board to do certain things. What I want to get clear is this: If the board does not approach him for an Order, will he be within his rights in insisting that in making an Order the board shall carry it out? I want to draw attention to a few words in sub-section (1). The board is to exercise its powers in the provision "of an efficient, economical", and so on, system of public transport, and the board is to operate "in such manner as it considers necessary". What I want to get is this: supposing the members of the Dáil and Seanad and the public outside come to the conclusion that a number of things should be done by this board. For instance, we have now the question of the provision of Arigna coal. The board may come along and say: "We are expected to run this undertaking on the most efficient and economical lines, and our view is that asking us to take Arigna coal to assist in the development of that area clashes with this view." They may say: "We consider a certain course necessary and, consequently, it is unreasonable to ask this board that is charged with the duty of providing an economic and efficient service to engage in work of this kind, taking over Arigna coal for the purpose of developing that particular area." Now, the importance of the coal industry in that area has been stressed. Some of us are familiar with the district along from Drumshambo to Drumkeerin. We know the extent to which hundreds of families are depending on the industry in that area. I merely mention it as something the Minister may have to attend to. I want to get from the Minister an indication as to whether he will be able to ensure that the board will attend to his directions on this matter. Now, again, it is quite conceivable that the public will demand, in view of our experience in the emergency, that the transport undertaking should push ahead with experiments in the use of native fuel. The Minister has referred to that. That will necessitate the provision of engines. That will necessitate the building up of a reserve of engines, a costly business. The Minister has indicated that the investigations are going on. It is possible that we will be able to work up turf, say, in such a way that it would be used in locomotives. Well and good. We arrive at the stage where we are satisfied that the fuel can be used. It will not do to wait until an emergency arises to have that reserve of locomotives essential to maintain the economic and efficient transport of the country.
Comment on this
Why should the Senator assume we would wait? We have not waited even for this Bill to start the investigation.
Comment on this
No. I am quite satisfied, from what you say, and from what I know, that research is going on all the time, but the company may come along and say: "You asked us to run this concern in the most efficient and economic way, and in asking us to build up reserves of locomotives, you are asking us to do something that is unreasonable, and it is going to be very costly". Will the Minister be able to come along and insist that his directions with regard to research, and with regard to the provision of the required number of locomotives will be carried out? It is always possible to say that if the board does not do it we will put in another board. That is true. What I have in mind is whether it would not be better to have something such as we have had before, that there will be consultation continuously between the Minister and the board, that these things will go on, this work will go on, without having it done or brought about as a result of public agitation. Again, there is the question of the doubling of the line. The Minister mentioned to us to-day that, from his knowledge, that is a tremendous task. He indicated to us that it would cost millions, many millions, I think he said, and that he does not expect that the company could undertake that within any reasonable time. If the public comes to the conclusion, and presses for the doing of that work, the doubling of the line between Dublin and Galway, as Senator Hawkins mentioned, what is the position if the company says: "You are asking us to do too much; if you want to run efficient services on the lines indicated in this section, then you are asking us to do too much". This point relates to the encouragement of national economic development that is incorporated in the section. You will remember this, that business men approach problems from a business angle, and do not take the same view as other people. We would consider certain things well worth while, the imposition of tariffs, and the imposition, say, of compulsory tillage. Some experts may say you should not do that, but the public will have other views. For myself, if I am asked what is my view on a certain problem, I can reply: "If you ask me to judge it on the basis of pure economics, then do such and such a thing," but as soon as I come into this House, I must think of other considerations. I must think of people. I must think of their employment. I must think of the break-up of their homes, something I see every day in Connemara, in the area in which I am particularly interested, people having to leave home. That is what I want to get clear, and that is why I want to raise the question as to whether there should not be full liaison between the Minister and the board, where things will be discussed and the board and the Minister will work in the fullest co-operation. The next thing I want to refer to is in connection with sub-section (2), that it is the duty of the board—
"to secure, as soon as may be, that, taking one year with another, the revenue of the board shall not be less than sufficient to meet the charges properly chargeable to revenue".
Senators will remember that that section was referred to at considerable length in the Dáil. Perhaps it may be said that all that is to be said on it was said in the Dáil. I only want to say that I am not satisfied. I think this sub-section gives the Minister a fair opportunity to indicate to us what he thinks are the prospects for the new transport company. He referred yesterday to the fact that Córas Iompair Eireann is being subsidised at the moment and I think he believes it will have to be subsidised for some time to come. He did not indicate how long.