We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Transport Bill, 1949—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 121–258 of 258. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Transport Bill, 1949
Enacted

No. 32 of 1949 ›

I do not know.

Comment on this

The Minister does not know. I would like the Minister to give us some indication as to what he thinks the prospects are. After all, he has been in office for two and a half years, and he must have had during that time a considerable amount of information available to him. From the time he assumed office I think he has been taking a special interest in the affairs of Córas Iompair Eireann.

Comment on this

I have had to.

Comment on this

He may now be able to give us some indication as to what population density is likely to be in the years to come. That is a factor of considerable importance in relation to transport. He may have some idea as to the possibilities of industrial expansion and the extent to which that will affect the transport organisation. He may possibly have made up his mind by this as to what he thinks ought to be done with regard to public and private hauliers and with regard to the extent to which they should be made to contribute more than they are contributing or to what extent their activities should be curtailed.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Senator would help me in that matter.

Comment on this

I cannot help the Minister. The Minister is in office in order to look after matters of that kind and inform the public with regard to them. He is there to give a lead on these things.

Comment on this

I am not above asking for advice and taking it.

Comment on this

The Minister has all the resources of the State at his disposal to aid him in coming to a conclusion in this matter. We do not ask for a precise figure. The least we ought to get is some indication as to what he thinks the trend will be. He should have a better idea than we can have as to what the trend is likely to be in regard to the various factors on which an organisation such as this is dependent. In view of the time the Minister has spent in his present exalted office and in view of his interest in transport affairs, surely he could give us now some indication as to the possibility of this company reaching the stage where it will pay its way. Taking one year with another may mean a period of 100 years.

Yesterday I sought some information on Section 7 under the provisions of which we debar members of the board from owning stock in the company. I suggested that in this particular case there is no reason why a director should be debarred from holding stock because of the peculiar conditions attaching to the stock and to the organisation itself, namely, that the rate of interest is fixed and guaranteed. I suggested to the Parliamentary Secretary, who was acting for the Minister, that this concern was to be a non-profit-earning one in the commercial sense. Before the Parliamentary Secretary had an opportunity of replying there was a chorus from the other side of the house that it was, of course, intended to be a profit-earning concern. Now, I have read the Bill, and the reason why I mention the matter is because I have been wondering whether or not it is to be a profit-earning concern. The wording here is that "its income shall be not less than sufficient to meet the charges properly chargeable to revenue". I took it from that that there would be no profit.

Comment on this

Not less.

Comment on this

I took it that it would be the duty of the board to watch its income and ensure that, if there is a possibility of income exceeding the amounts properly chargeable to revenue, it would apply anything it might have——

Comment on this

That is a most amazing interpretation.

Comment on this

Why should it be?

Comment on this

It is extraordinary.

Comment on this

It would apply anything it might have to giving relief immediately to the users of the transport system. If the company reaches a stage where income is likely to exceed the amounts properly chargeable to revenue, then fares and freights should be reduced. Assume that the Minister is right and that the statement is amazing, is there anywhere in the Bill a provision for the handling of surpluses, apart from the provision governing reserves for the repayment of capital and apart from the provision governing reserves to repay the Minister for Finance any loans he may advance?

Comment on this

If the Senator read the Bill——

Comment on this

I have read the Bill. I may have overlooked that. In what section does it occur?

Comment on this

I do not know. Read the Bill again.

Comment on this

There you are. I have been quite frank. I have read the Bill. There are a number of points with regard to the disposal of profits. Profits have a very definite meaning; they are the residue left after payment of contractual charges. Are there to be profits? If there are profits, where will they go? Will they go to general reserve? Will they go to the Minister for Finance, quite apart from the repayment of any loans or advances he may make. I think that matter needs some clarification. The Minister may smile and he may try to deride the points I and some of my colleagues raise, but that is not an answer to the question put to him.

This Bill is one of the most important that has come before us. It deals with a matter upon which the economic and commercial life of the country is dependent to a great extent. The Minister should spare no pains in procuring all the information he can and subsequently informing the House as to what he thinks the prospects of the company are likely to be when this Bill becomes law. I would not like to think that we may have to go on for all time subsidising the company. At the same time it may be necessary in the general interests of both the community and the company to continue subsidising. It might be unreasonable to expect the company to pay its way and ultimately the State may have to step in and help it, as it has had to do on occasions in the past. There are other points I would like to deal with, but I know there is a certain urgency in getting this Bill through. However, I would like to have some clarification of the position.

Comment on this

I have listened to a good many speeches by Senator Ó Buachalla, but I do not think I have ever listened to one with which I found myself in more definite and profound disagreement. I disagree with his whole attitude. He thinks that in discussing the details of this Bill on Committee Stage what we should really be concerned with is the mind of the Minister. I do not think the mind of the Minister matters. What matters is what the Minister is proposing that the House should put in this Bill, and what powers it will give to him or to his successors, or what powers are lacking in the Bill. Indeed, what is in Senator Ó Buachalla's mind or the mind of any other Senator, is really more important from the point of view of the Seanad. Senator Ó Buachalla thinks, unless I misunderstand him, that it would be desirable to have some provision in this Bill by which there would have to be — I think he used the word consultation — between the chairman and the Minister, either constantly or frequently——

Comment on this

I am not asking that that should be incorporated in the Bill. I want to get from the Minister a statement as to how the thing is going to operate. I am not asking that it should be incorporated in the Bill.

Comment on this

If it is not to be incorporated in the Bill I cannot see how it can arise on the Committee Stage, which deals with provisions which are to be made in the Bill with regard to the functions of the board. I am trying to understand the Senator's position and I am trying to deal with the principles dealt with by the Senator. We are concerned with what is in the Bill, and not with what the Minister may forecast about the future. How is the Minister to tell us in advance whether this new State company will have to be subsidised for one year or for 100 years? I suggest it would be wrong for the Minister to say that it would have to be subsidised for one or 100 years and wrong for the Minister to set out in advance what the board should do or what it should not do. It would be extremely foolish for the Minister to attempt to do that. I am not a bit enamoured of the idea of a State owned company, but when we have decided to set up a State owned company, let us, for goodness sake, give it every chance to be a success, and do not let it be crippled in advance by what this Minister, or any other Minister thinks at the present time, or whether Senators think the best or the worst may happen. Let us examine this Bill to see if its provisions are workable, and to see that it provides powers which will be fully adequate to make this company a success, but which will not take away the ultimate responsibility of the shareholders which, in future, will be the State. I suggest that to a large extent anything you put in Section 15 must be experimental. You cannot put into Section 15 everything which should be done after experience. I firmly believe that in the working of a State company of this kind it will be necessary, as it was with the Electricity Supply Board, to produce new Bills to deal with conditions as they may arise. Senator Ó Buachalla seems to be anxious to know if the Minister could insist on the board doing something he wants done whether the board likes it or not. I do not think that is a matter on which you can give a specific answer, yes, or no. The Minister can certainly indicate the policy of the Government to the new board. The board must give it its consideration with full responsibility as a board which has to manage this large and difficult undertaking. The board must remember first that it has responsibility and second, that the shareholders are the State and that ultimately, like any other board, it must carry out the wishes of the shareholders, but it is not obliged to do what any Minister for the time being indicates. Obviously, if it has any sense, it will pay close attention to it, but if there should be disagreement, if the Government of the day considers it wise, the power, undoubtedly, is in the hands of the Minister because the shareholders are the State as represented by the Oireachtas, and the Oireachtas has the ultimate power. But, to say that a Minister should be a dictator, that he should order the board to do something that it felt to be undesirable, would be wrong. If that were to happen it would not give your State-owned concern a chance, and that is why I say I am in fundamental disagreement with Senator Ó Buachalla. He wants the Minister to tell us what he thinks will happen in future. He wants to know whether it will be one or 100 years. That is the kind of statement that would cripple any board of this kind if it were made in all seriousness.

Comment on this

May I say that I feel that Senator Douglas has on many occasions made feeble efforts in this House? His effort on this occasion is about one of the feeblest I have ever heard from him. Is it not true that the Minister, having considered this whole problem, has stated that it is to be the duty of the board to provide an efficient, economical and so on transport service——

Comment on this

Let the Minister reply. You asked him all the questions.

Comment on this

I do not quite understand the remark of Senator O'Farrell. The Minister has considered this first matter, and he has put into this Bill a duty to be carried out by the board to provide an efficient and economical transport service. Either he knew when he was putting that in, or he did not know, that such a thing could be done. That is the point. I expect that the Minister believes it can be done. In order to do that, he proceeds to appoint a new transport board. That, I suppose, is the only outstanding change — not the only one — but one of the most outstanding of the few changes to be introduced in regard to the transport system. He is going to appoint a new board. Is it sensible of Senator Douglas to ask me to believe that by merely appointing a new board with the objects set out in this section, these objects are to be achieved? When the Minister was giving consideration to these things, he knew what the old board had attempted to do. He decided, in view of what it had attempted to achieve, that it should be dismissed and that a new board should come into its place. What is going to be done in the future? Is there a great deal different to be done in the future from what was done in the past in this transport company, and how is it going to achieve the excellent objects which have been set down in Section 15, sub-sections (1) and (2)? One other word. I think it is time that people on the other side of the House learned something about the procedure of the House——

Comment on this

Why confine it to the other side?

Comment on this

——we are entitled on this Stage to put down amendments and we put them down as a rule because we believe that the words in our amendments should go in as they are. On other occasions we put amendments down because we are not sure that the words are the exact words that will meet the situation and we leave it to the Minister to provide a proper draft. Another reason why amendments are put down is to get information on certain specific points. Having disposed of the amendments, a Senator has the right to come along and raise relevant matters on the section itself.

Comment on this

The Senator has raised those matters already, and did not even wait for a reply. He might have waited for a reply from the Minister before he got on his feet again.

Comment on this

There is a certain custom in the House, I think, that Senators themselves engage in discussion and that we leave to the Minister the duty of coming along to deal with the arguments, summing up and giving his conclusion. If it would have been better to have allowed the Minister to speak after Senator Douglas, then I am sorry I did not adopt that course. Perhaps in future I shall do that and then we shall have the Minister, like some of ourselves, bobbing up and down every other minute.

Comment on this

This section is the most important section of the Bill in my opinion, because it is the section which sets out the duties of the board. The duties, as Senator Ó Buachalla has pointed out, are contained in subsections (1) and (2). The Bill itself originated in the fact that an inquiry was held into the working of the present transport company. A report was made by persons whom the Government and the Minister thought fully qualified to inquire into the position and make certain recommendations. When we examine that report we find that a recommendation was made by Sir James Milne that the board should be strengthened and the directors as a whole made responsible for the affairs of the company.

"The duties of the board in relation to the Government and of the chief officers in relation to the board, should be defined and the policy to be pursued in regard to future developments should be clearly laid down for their guidance."

I suggest that in this section we should have some indication or provision made for that relationship with the Government and the board. We should have set out for the guidance of the board and their staff what the future policy is to be. It would be difficult, I know, to put into the Bill every detail, but the line of approach — what it was the board was required to give immediate attention to—should be set out.

We have already dealt with the composition of the board. The composition of the board is not on the lines suggested in the report. Neither are the duties as contained in Section 15 set out in the manner Sir James Milne would have liked to see them. Certainly there must have been some good reason for recommending to the Minister that the duties of the board in relation to the Government and the chief officers in relation to the board should be defined and that the future policy to be pursued should be laid down. It is in this section that these provisions should be made. At this stage I should like to express my deep regret that Senator Miss Butler has not found it possible to be present while the discussion on this section, in which she was so interested in the early part of the day was taking place. While expressing that regret, I do not propose to deal with the section further in detail.

Comment on this

I think in Section 15 (1), the Minister makes clear what the duties, which the board is to perform, will be. If the members appointed to the board are to perform these duties, the less interference they will have from the Minister or from political influence through the Minister, the better for the board. If they can provide a cheap, economic, convenient and efficient system of transport, that will, in turn, create an atmosphere in which industry can survive and live. In some quarters the idea seems to prevail that the proper way to develop industry is to allow a lot of cranks, who know nothing about industry, to impede the conduct of industry by a series of theoretical provisions, but the way to provide employment in industry, I submit, it to create the atmosphere in which industry can thrive in an efficient and economic way. That is the true business approach if we have the courage to face it. It has been found in any country that has made any substantial progress that an efficient and effective transport system is one of the essentials to such progress.

I hope that the Minister will not give any cognisance to the points raised by some Senators on the opposite benches. I am strongly of the opinion that he should not interfere in the day-to-day affairs of the company and that he should not let economics alone be the guide by which the affairs of the company would be administered, because industry will have to pay for the service that this company is providing. If industrialists do not get an efficient and an effective transport service, in the long run their industries will not be able to compete in the export market or even to produce goods for our people here at home at the price at which the people would like to have them. All these items of 1d. here and 1/- there are the things which ultimately affect the cost of living.

One matter was discussed rather fully here to-day, though I did not engage in that discussion. I do not believe that we should aim at a policy of concentrating all our traffic in the centre of the city by a system under which we have motor buses dropping their passengers in the immediate vicinity of O'Connell Bridge. I think that is madness. Dublin City is twice the size it was 50 years ago and I think there should be a wider destination for traffic than can be provided within that particular area. I think that the board should take steps to prevent that.

Comment on this

The Senator is diverging somewhat from the matter under discussion.

Comment on this

Section 15 is the matter under discussion.

Comment on this

The Senator is getting away from it.

Comment on this

The Minister can see the problem that is created by bringing all the buses and all the different forms of transport into the middle of the city where everybody has to contact that transport. There should be some other centres in the city to which that transport could be directed. For example, it might be better if some buses went down the North Circular Road and the South Circular Road instead of coming right into the centre of the city to a point within 100 yards of O'Connell Bridge.

Comment on this

That was dealt with on a previous section.

Comment on this

Another matter which struck me in connection with this transport problem, particularly in the City of Dublin, is that we make little or no use of the railways we have to transport people to suburban areas. In all modern cities of Britain and other European countries, electric transport has been found most efficient and economic in dealing with suburban passengers. All the lines around the City of London and around all the cities on the Continent——

Comment on this

The Senator is now making a Second Reading speech: he is dealing with transport in general instead of with the section.

Comment on this

I am speaking of the general duties of the board. I do not think I have delayed the House very considerably on this aspect of the transport problem. Some Senators have spoken on the same subject on at least five different occasions.

Comment on this

The Senator should have made this speech at the proper time.

Comment on this

If the Cathaoirleach thinks I should not mention this matter of electric transport, then I will not refer to it any further.

Comment on this

It should have been mentioned at the right time.

Comment on this

I have nothing further to say at the moment, but I will mention the matter on another stage of the Bill.

Comment on this

I rise merely to ask the Minister a question which seems to suggest itself from the words contained in line 24. The wording there is "the maintenance of reasonable conditions of employment for its employees". What is meant there by "reasonable employment"? If there is any difference of opinion between the employees and the board, will there be any machinery of arbitration in order to avoid what we are all afraid of in a monopoly, and especially a transport monopoly — a strike?

I do not know whether the Minister would think it wise to embody in the Bill some sort of provision so as to make it easy for the board and the employees to settle differences without tremendous loss and inconvenience to the public. We must remember that the public are the real owners of this thing, yet they are in the position that they have not a word to say. We would all feel happier if we thought that there was a chance of settling disputes between the board and its employees through some form of arbitration which both parties would consider it a duty to accept. I would like the Minister to tell us what he thinks could be done about it.

Comment on this
Captain Orpen

This Section 15 seems to me to be one of the important sections, as it indicates the minds of the Government and of the Minister as to what they expect the board to do, what they expect the board to provide, and, presumably, what they hope the board will achieve. The section refers to "an efficient, economical, convenient and properly integrated system of public transport for passengers and merchandise by rail, road and water". Well, we all hope that it will achieve what is laid down in Section 15, but one rather wonders why in the past our efforts to achieve any one of these desirable objectives so signally failed. We certainly never have had what could be called an efficient transport; it has not always been economical; it has never been convenient and it has never been properly integrated.

We had a competitive system at one time, so competitive, one against the other, that it looked as if each section tried to damage rather than help its neighbour. One hopes that when we have the integrated system that is adumbrated here, it will not follow the precedent of a neighbouring country where, when the railways got control of the canals, they closed most of them. Curious as it may seem, the canal to-day, even in this country, serves a very useful purpose. Quite recently I wanted to bring a girder from Dublin down to my place in Wexford. The girder was 20 feet long and it required either a long truck or two trucks. The rail charge would have been £6 or £7. I tried the road service, but they would not touch it, as it was 20 feet long, unless I could get a special truck. I then bethought of the canal system and eventually it was sent down to New Ross for 10/6. So there is some use in the old canals.

The last line in Section 15 (1) is most interesting because there we see laid down "so as to provide for the needs of the public, agriculture, commerce and industry". I hope there is some meaning in that order—the public, agriculture, commerce and industry. Presumably, that is in the order of importance, the public first, then agriculture and then commerce and industry. Curiously enough, no attempt has ever yet been made in this country to deal in our public transport with the peculiar needs of agriculture.

Many years ago, like, at any rate, two Senators in this room, I spent a short time associated with a railway company—in fact, with three or four railway companies—and I learned some things from the general officer commanding transportation. He was the general manager of the railway company and he said to me that the secret of a successful railway company is to develop volume — volume of traffic and volume of goods. Do not, he said, bother about anything else but volume. That was his first aphorism. The second was that volume is something that does not exist; it has to be created. The third one was that the only way you could ever achieve volume of traffic is by flexibility in your freight classification. Now, we might go back 30 years to what Geddes said then and it is curious that the one thing that is observable in our public transport in this country is that we have never gone after volume; we have always gone after receipts.

Comment on this

Does this come under the general duties of the board, Senator, as set out in this section?

Comment on this
Captain Orpen

Yes, I suggest it does. Go after volume, create the traffic and then you may achieve what is set out in sub-section (2). All our transport concerns previously, when they got into difficulties, asked for higher fares. We have never gone after volume either in passengers or in goods. We even recently—I think it was in the 1944 Act—made the fatal mistake of simplifying classification, which absolutely precludes, therefore, the creation of new traffic in goods. Classification is the foundation for building the volume you have got and of searching for more of it.

It is hoped that this new board will take the broadest possible view of the needs of the public, the needs of agriculture, the needs of commerce and of industry and that they will take care, in their initial stage, not to be too restricted in the things they do merely because it was the previous practice of Córas Iompair Eireann or of the railways with which they may have been familiar. Anybody who has had experience of railway work in other countries realises that to a large extent. A railway company, as a transport concern, by providing the facilities required creates traffic. Sir James Milne says in his report that passenger traffic is largely created. Admittedly, he does not say the same of freight traffic, but in this country, where quite a large part of our potential freight traffic must come from agriculture, there is the opportunity to create traffic, to move goods from where they are to where they are wanted, goods that do not at present move. I also suggest that a wider outlook be taken than was taken hitherto.

I make these suggestions as one who hopes that the narrow view of immediate earnings will not restrict the possibility of looking for traffic and looking for goods, thereby building up a volume of traffic out of which ultimately one should be able to get sufficient revenue to cover costs. It is in that particular aspect of transport that railway work completely differs from road traffic. Road costs and volume more or less increase proportionately. Rail costs do not go up in direct proportion to volume handled, but unfortunately our rail charges here do tend that way, but costs do not. The greater part of rail costs are fixed costs independent of volume haul, and it is for that reason I urge that we should take a wide view of the transport problem with regard to what can be carried on rail, looking to a large increase of volume to cover total costs, rather than an immediate result of increased earnings following increased charges.

Comment on this

Am I to understand that the Minister is concluding on the section?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Minister is to conclude.

Comment on this

May I be allowed a moment to deal with one matter that was raised by Senator Mrs. Concannon? She asked for an explanation of some of the wording in sub-section (1) of Section 15. I think the wording of that sub-section, in so far as it deals with the conditions of employment for the staff, is a vast improvement on Section 9 of the Act of 1933 which imposed on the railway company the obligation to settle all disputes with the trade unions. In the Fifth Schedule to this Bill that particular portion of Section 9 of the 1933 Act will be repealed. Something had to be substituted for it. What I understand is being substituted for it is that it shall be the general duty of the board so to exercise their powers under this Bill as to secure or promote the maintenance of reasonable conditions of employment and to ask them to arrange conditions of employment and wages with the trade unions. What was in the 1933 Act was ridiculous and impracticable. This merely asks the board to approach the matter in a spirit of good will and to do the best they can.

Comment on this

Before the Minister concludes, may I ask if there is any objection to sitting late to finish the Committee Stage of this Bill?

Comment on this

May I say on behalf of myself and of other Senators that we do not wish to sit late this evening? Many of us have work to do early to-morrow. We consider that if the business is not finished at the usual hour to-night, it should be taken next week.

Comment on this

There will be opposition from this side to sitting after 10 o'clock to-night. We have had two hard days here. Some of us have other parliamentary engagements. There are committees of the Seanad of which members of this House are members, and I do not think it would be fair to ask us to sit late to-night.

Comment on this

I take it that no committees will be sitting to-night?

Comment on this

No. For my part I will not agree to sit after 10 o'clock.

Comment on this

It was pretty clearly understood that the Committee Stage of this Bill would be finished to-day. If every section is going to be discussed on the basis on which Section 15 was discussed there is no hope of finishing until the small hours of the morning. Senator O'Brien says that he has work to do in the morning. I also have work to do in the morning, and I think in the same place as the Senator. I think we ought to get on with the business and get it finished to-night—otherwise we will become a laughing stock—or meet to-morrow. We have this business to do, and I think we are quite capable of doing it if we confine ourselves to what is relevant on the sections. I suggest that we finish the Committee Stage to-night.

Comment on this

We are prepared at all times to meet Ministers and to meet the Government Party, but this is a very important Bill.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

It is one of the most important Bills that has come before the House for some time. There is no urgency about the completion of the Committee Stage, or of any other stage, of the Bill to-night, this week or even this month. We have quite a number of amendments to it that have not yet been reached. Therefore, it means that if the suggestion to sit late to-night were accepted the consideration of the remaining amendments and sections is going to be skimped over. We are prepared to meet to-morrow to complete the Committee Stage, if necessary, but we are not prepared to sit after 10 o'clock to-night. We must have regard to the fact that there are a number of country Senators who have to get to their hotels to-night. If we sit late there will be no bus service to take them. Some people seem to think that we from the country have no interest in the transport system, but I want to put it that we are the people who utilise the national transport system, both rail and bus, because we have no other means of transporting ourselves.

Comment on this

I did not suggest that anything should be skimped. What I did suggest was that we should take time, by sitting late, to complete the business. If we are to adjourn at 10 o'clock and resume the Committee Stage next week, can we have any understanding that the Committee Stage will be finished next week?

Comment on this

I agree with Senator Hayes that Section 15 gave rise to a long discussion—to what were, in the main, Second Reading speeches. The terms of the section are so wide that the Chair, I think, found it very hard to rule anyone out of order. There was a brush between the Chair and Senator Burke. I myself had intended to raise certain questions on Section 15, and I am hoping to be able to do so on later sections. There is nothing we can do here, if members get up, and keep talking. They are entitled to talk.

Comment on this

I suggest, Sir, that as a House we should collectively be able to do something to show that we are able to transact business, without skimping the business, and without hammering business through in any very rapid manner. I agree, that we ought to sit until the usual hour to-night and adjourn until next Wednesday, and I hope, Sir, it will be possible next Wednesday to complete the Committee Stage, because I suggest that if we were to meet three days next week, and the week after, at the rate we are going at present, we would not even finish the Committee Stage.

Comment on this

That would not be worth while.

Comment on this

I do not think it would be worth while. I have some experience of parliamentary debate, and futility in parliamentary debate is never worth anything, and neither is repetition. If I were to devote myself to the same kind of debate, as there has been on this section, I could keep it going for a long time. I do not intend to do so. However, Sir, we can go on until 10 o'clock.

Comment on this

Perhaps, I should make it clear that, as far as I am concerned, I have no desire to rush Senators in their consideration of this Bill. I have been nursing this particular baby so long, that I would nearly be lonely, if I were deprived of it now. I agree with Senator Hawkins, that it is a very important Bill and, perhaps, if it had been approached here in the Seanad by certain Senators, as an important public measure, we might have reached the stage when it would not be necessary for anybody to suggest sitting after 10 o'clock to-night or to sit to-morrow. We have been told this section is a very wide section. It is. Do Senators object to that?

Apparently, wide and extensive as it is, it is not sufficiently wide or sufficiently comprehensive for Senator Ó Buachalla. I do not believe it would be within the power of the officers of my Department or the parliamentary draftsman to so draft a section that it would meet the points or the fears which were expressed by Senator Ó Buachalla. Perhaps I would not be too far wrong if I suggested that the fears were really wishes. Perhaps the Senator would be easier in his mind if there was no section of this kind in the Bill, as there was no section of this kind in the 1944 Act, but merely that the Minister for Industry and Commerce should have power on his own initiative, should have power to request or direct the board to do anything in relation to the services, charges, the closing or the abandoning of lines. I must confess, listening to Senator Ó Buachalla, I had to wonder whether he had read this Bill at all or whether he had read any section of the Bill. The Senator said that practically the only change that was made was that we were dispensing with one board and appointing another. Has the Senator not yet grasped this fact that, in this Bill, the State is acquiring a private concern?

Comment on this

No, Sir, the records of the House will show that my statement was that this was one of the few outstanding changes.

Comment on this

The fundamental difference is that what was, and is at the present moment, a privately-owned company is being acquired by the State and will in future be operated for the State and for the community. Senator Hawkins did not seem to have grasped that either. He was quoting Sir James Milne against me. Again, it is amazing how fond some members on the other side have got of Sir James. He said that Sir James talked about the relationship that obtained between the Government and the board and that the powers which I am suggesting are not along the lines suggested by Sir James Milne. Sir James Milne was writing and talking about the board of a private company and not the board of a company which was going to be acquired by the State and going to be operated by the State. Sir James Milne merely mentioned that the Government representation on the board of Córas Iompair Éireann, as a private company, should be strengthened. That was one of the recommendations which was not acceptable to the Government. Of course, we had from Senator Ó Buachalla these rather sneering references to which I had to listen for so long and so often in the Dáil from the Opposition there. Subsidy, subsidy for Córas Iompair Éireann, subsidy, subsidy—something rather shameful about subsidy, something we should be ashamed of.

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

One would imagine that none of the State sponsored companies, which had been formed by the predecessors of this Government required or had got subsidy. On the one hand, the Senator decried the idea of subsidy, the necessity for subsidy; and, on the other hand, he was advocating, himself, and would so impose his will on the new board, as to make it impossible for them to operate without a subsidy. The Senator cannot have it both ways. The only difference between me and the people who take that line is that I face the facts, as I find them, and I do not attempt to hide from the public, that if it is considered, as it has been considered necessary in the national interest to maintain and to improve the railways, then the people must be prepared to pay for that. I am saying that, and I have never tried to hide from the Dáil, and I am not trying to hide from the Seanad nor am I trying to hide from the public, the fact, that if this company is to carry out the duties which are laid down in Section 15, then, unquestionably, having regard to the way in which they are shackled at the start, it would certainly be some time before they reach the position indicated in sub-section (2) of this section. Let us remember that we are handing over to this new board a transport system which was described by the previous chairman as being almost entirely obsolete, rolling stock, some of which is over half a century old, equipment which is largely out of date, some of it, which has been badly maintained, in so far as it was maintained at all. Do not forget that notwithstanding all the activities of the previous and the present board, not as much as one single railway carriage has been built in this country since 1937.

This is a very important section. Senators should realise that it is so important and we should not have this endless repetition of purely frivolous questions. Senator Ó Buachalla is very concerned to pin me down in order to get on the record something he subsequently hopes he will be able to wave under my nose. The Senator is very anxious that I would not deprive myself of any power to dictate to the board at any time it pleases me to do so. I approach this in a different fashion altogether. If I were to look upon my responsibility in this matter in the way in which the Senator thinks I should, and if the relationship between the board and myself in the carrying out of its duties were such as the Senator thinks it should be, then I would very justly fear it would be impossible for me to get a board of the type of men best fitted to sit on such a board because no self-respecting citizen, in my opinion, would accept a seat on that board if he was to be merely the mouthpiece of the Minister and if he was to move solely at the whim and pleasure of the Minister.

What will happen is that the Government will endeavour to get the best board it can. I am quite satisfied, before ever we start to select the members of the board, that they will ultimately be criticised and I will be criticised. I shall endeavour to get the best board I can. I shall endeavour to get a board interested in carrying out the duties laid down in this section and interested in implementing the policy contained in this section. I shall endeavour to get a board that will bring to its assistance the best experts and the greatest technical skill available, either inside or outside the country. I shall then be prepared to leave it to the board since the board will know far more about how the railways and the transport services should be run than I know or will know. I shall endeavour to get a board which will have at its disposal in considering the lines upon which this policy should be operated that expert advice, knowledge and experience which neither the Senators nor I have at our disposal.

If Senator Ó Buachalla will look at Section 16 he will see there that the Minister will not be entirely unconcerned about the board. The Senator is not correct in saying that I have stated that this board will be entirely free and fully and completely independent. I never said any such thing. I have indicated that matters which were formerly determined by the Minister will in future be determined by the board or by the tribunal. I think most Senators will agree that that is important. Unquestionably the Minister for Industry and Commerce must have close contact with this board just as he must have close contact with the Electricity Supply Board, with Bord na Móna, with Mianraí Teoranta, with Céimici Teo., or any of the other State companies at present in existence. Surely it is not suggested that it will make for efficiency and economy and for the best possible public transport service to have a Minister for Industry and Commerce tugged by the sleeve, the elbow or the shoulder by every T.D. or Senator at every hour and minute of the day retailing the Senator's or the Deputy's complaint to the chairman or general manager of the company. That is the distinction I make.

Let me say again, and will Senators please get it clearly into their minds, that what we are doing under this Bill is acquiring for the community a national transport system, with a board which will not consist of the appointees of any private interests in the country but will consist of the appointees of the Government of the State for the time being. The Senator will notice in this section that the national development aspect has not been excluded. May I point out to the Senator that that was included in this section as the result of an amendment moved by a member of his own Party in the Dáil? The responsibilities of the board towards the public, towards agriculture, towards industry and commerce have not been ignored.

The responsibilities of the board for ensuring reasonable conditions of employment, to which Senator Mrs. Concannon referred, will not be ignored. On the point raised by Senator Mrs. Concannon, may I say that there is machinery which, I hope, will give us fewer strikes than we might otherwise have; that machinery is being extended and improved every day? I am perfectly satisfied that it is being approached in the proper spirit by both the board and the representatives of the employees and I believe that we shall in time get a common understanding as to what reasonable conditions of employment mean. I do not even want to attempt to meet all the points raised by Senator Ó Buachalla. Frankly, I doubt very much if he was serious——

Comment on this

Very serious.

Comment on this

I find it very hard to believe that the Senator was serious in a number of the points he raised. I say this without any desire or intention of being offensive; most of the points were just footling.

Comment on this

If the Minister finds it difficult to answer the questions, that is one way of doing it.

Comment on this

I find no difficulty whatsoever. The Senator's difficulty is that he has apparently failed to grasp even my plain speech and, goodness knows, I speak plainly enough.

Comment on this

I am afraid you do not. If you spoke plainly enough, this Bill would not have taken from last November until now to go through.

Comment on this

It was not lack of plain speech on my part that was responsible for that.

Comment on this

It was lack of plain drafting in the first instance.

Comment on this

I think that is a remark that should not be made. If there is anything wrong with the contents of the Bill I take full responsibility for it. I cannot, of course, take responsibility for the drafting of the Bill.

Comment on this

It was in that sense I made the remark.

Comment on this

So long as the Senator is hitting only at me that is quite all right and we can be perfectly happy.

Comment on this

Like the tinkers, we keep the fight between ourselves.

Comment on this

Quite so. I do not know that there is anything else that I can say at this stage. If the Senator has any doubts I want to assure him that, in so far as the Government may think it desirable to give a direction or outline a policy to the board, the Government is fully empowered to do that. I want to warn Senators and everybody else that my whole idea, so long as I am the Minister, will be to keep as far away from the board as I possibly can and let them do their job.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:—

In line 43, page 11, to delete the words "other than day-to-day administration".

This is a very brief amendment and, as Mr. Gladstone said, I will not weary the House with the dreary drip and the dilatory declamation in moving it.

Comment on this

Bedad, wait until you see!

Comment on this

Section 16 says that the board shall furnish to the Minister such information as he may from time to time require regarding matters which relate to its activities, other than day to day administration, and which appear to him to affect the national interest. I take it that he will look only for information on matters which affect the national interest, but if any of these can be said to be a matter of day to day administration, is he preventing himself from seeking information with regard to it? Day to day administration is not defined, and it is not easy to distinguish between day to day administration and what might be called acts of policy. In fact, some day to day administrative acts might be of very serious import, and might conceivably affect the national interest, but according to this section, as drafted, the Minister would not, in that case, have the power to request information. At least, he would not be expected to request it. I do not attach a tremendous lot of importance to this amendment, and I do not want to provoke a long discussion on it, but I am asking the Minister if he is satisfied that the leaving in of these words will not stultify him in making inquiries regarding matters which may affect the national interest. I agree that matters of day to day administration should not be matters for the Minister unless such acts do affect the national interest.

Comment on this

This point, of course, was raised in the Dáil also, but I am advised that there is no fear that I will not be able to get the details of administration at any time if I require them. Quite frankly, that limitation is put in because I do not want to be answering questions day after day why John Ryan was made head porter instead of James O'Brien or somebody else, or why somebody was removed from his post or why parcels were not delivered, or why a particular train was five minutes late. It is to avoid that sort of question that I put in this provision. I should say that it was with some reluctance that I agreed to go as far as I am going. Of course, it is a new departure altogether in State companies and takes us further in relation to many things we have to deal with in these State companies.

Comment on this

If the Minister is satisfied with the section as it is, I would ask the leave of the House to withdraw my amendment.

Comment on this

On this section, I was going to ask a question, a similar question to one I asked on the Air Navigation Bill, in relation to the manner of serving notices in certain cases. The Minister will send out notification by prepaid post addressed to a person at his usual or last known address—I am referring to sub-section (5) (C). If the letter is not delivered, it is, of course, returned to the Minister, but what happens then? This may be purely a legal matter with which I am not familiar. Would it be necessary, or would it be advisable to make provision for the publication of a notice to the effect that this letter has been returned and that within so many days the Minister will take over the ownership of the property in question? It may be that it is the usual thing to send out a letter and if there is no response, and the letter comes back, to assume that everything is all right. It seems to me reasonable that, if this letter does not reach the person to whom it is addressed, there should be some further step by way of the publication of a notice that this letter has been posted and has been returned, and that the Minister is proceeding with the taking over of the land. There may be nothing in that point but something, it seems to me, ought to be done.

Comment on this

I would be anxious to meet that point so far as I could, but I am advised that this sub-section meets it very fully and I do not think it would be very desirable to have public notification by way of the Press. I doubt if it would be desirable.

Comment on this

I am thinking of the possibility of a person having the right of certain lands being away in England or elsewhere, with an unknown address, so that he is not in consequence receiving the notice.

Comment on this

The Senator will appreciate that in such cases as are mentioned in the section, there will, in addition to the letter, be the usual investigation beforehand on the spot by the local officers who are concerned—personal contact.

Comment on this

I think these are the usual provisions which have been established, perhaps, for 100 years, providing for the compulsory acquisition of lands. They are employed in many cases under the Labourers Acts and the proposals are quite in accordance with the modern practice.

Comment on this

Does the Senator think that no hardship might result from this procedure?

Comment on this

Hardship often results when lands are compulsorily acquired.

Comment on this

I knew of this to happen where land was proposed to be compulsorily acquired: certain people had interests in the land and were precluded from obtaining certain benefits because, perhaps, of bad advice or of not taking the proper steps in time. Certainly I know that has happened.

Comment on this

I would like to say in regard to this principle of the acquisition of land or of private property of any kind that I feel that for a long time there is a tendency, a growing tendency, for the State merely to make an arbitrary settlement with the owner and to pay only arbitrary compensation. It does seem to me that there should be some provision for an appeal against the compensation awarded by the State. It does not seem fair that the State should not only acquire the property but be the assessors of the amount to be paid for it.

Comment on this

The Act of 1919 provides for an arbitrator who assesses the compensation as between the parties, on the basis laid down in that Act. The basis is the price which a willing buyer would pay to a willing seller in an open market. There is a referee to assess the compensation, an entirely independent person.

Comment on this

Perhaps this is not relevant, but how does that apply to the taking over of property in which there are other people interested?

Comment on this

This relates to land; not to companies.

Comment on this

I am glad to know that there is some appeal when it is a question of taking land against the compensation offered by the State.

Comment on this

The State does not decide the amount. When land is acquired compulsorily, there is a standing arbitrator before whom the parties go, and it is his duty to determine the various interests and the value of the various interests. The arbitrator fixes the compensation and makes an award accordingly.

Comment on this

I think that what Senator McGuire has in mind is that if land is acquired by anybody under authority from the State, the principle of compensation is recognised and has been recognised all along. The question of the amount that may be paid is decided, in the event of there being disagreement between the persons and the authority acquiring the land, by arbitration. What I gather from Senator McGuire's comments is that even the State cannot acquire property—in this particular instance land—either through a local authority or bodies like Córas Iompair Éireann, without recognising the principle that compensation in terms of money or otherwise should be paid to the owner. The question of the amount is decided by arbitration in the event of disagreement.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied that a court of arbitration can be set up to decide what should be paid and the only point on which I wanted information was whether there was any appeal. Supposing the owner does not want to be removed from his land, that he is quite happy in the possession of it, there is the mental aspect of the matter to be considered as well as the question of monetary payments, in the case of an individual's rights. If he is not satisfied, it seems to me that he should have an appeal to the courts. I am only asking that question. Apparently, he has not an appeal.

Comment on this

I wonder would the Minister be able to give us some clarification as to what is meant by sub-section (3) of this section?

Comment on this

The board may enter into an agreement with a trader or with a local motor lorry owner.

Comment on this

I can quite understand giving power to the board to enter into an agreement with other transport undertakers such as lorry owners or transport undertakers of any kind, but when it comes to the question of entering into an agreement for the carrying of merchandise, then I think we open a very big field.

Comment on this

Perhaps I can relieve the Senator's fears. I am afraid that I was unconsciously misdirecting the Senator. This deals with the question of a flat rate and there is nothing new in it. It is in operation at the moment. For instance, the company may agree with, say, Guinness's, in return for getting the carriage of their entire output, that they shall have a flat rate all over the country. The Senator knows that the product of that particular firm is sold at a flat price.

Comment on this

It is sometimes even flat itself.

Comment on this

Very rarely, I think. As I say there is nothing new in it. It is merely continuing a policy that is already there.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister this question? The section refers to railway classification of merchandise. Is it intended that the railway classification of merchandise shall apply to freight carried by road?

Comment on this

No. This is railway traffic.

Comment on this

I do know that one of the greatest difficulties that Córas Iompair Éireann and its predecessors had to deal with was offers made by private hauliers for the transport of certain goods at a certain rate when the railway company and the freight department of the railway company were prevented from carrying at anything like that figure.

Comment on this

The railway company are given more freedom in relation to classification now than they had before.

Comment on this

I understand it has been the custom to give preferential rates to Limerick and some of the western towns in view of their remoteness. I should like to ask the Minister will such a practice be continued in future.

Comment on this

I could not give the Senator an assurance on that. It will be a matter for the company and its officers to arrange the classification and the charges but I should certainly hope that if the new board are not able to give better concessions, they will not make conditions any harsher than they are at the moment.

Comment on this

May I say on this section that the people in my district are interested in the fate of the West and South Clare Railways? These railways are somewhat different from the ordinary railways because they were constructed by an independent company formed about 65 years ago. They were passed by the grand jury which reigned at the time and an interest of 4 per cent. was guaranteed by the rates on the capital invested in the first part of the line, a sum of £170,000. Later there was a further £40,000 added and the rates guaranteed the interest at 4 per cent. up to the time of the passing of the 1944 Act. At that time there was an amalgamation of all the lines and it was agreed that the ratepayers of the county would be relieved of the responsibility of guaranteeing this interest on the payment of about £32,000 for a period of seven years. I mention these facts so that the House and the Minister may know that the people of Clare have paid a very considerable sum for the maintenance of these lines.

During the last few years of the reign of the late Government a rumour was spread—without much foundation, as far as I know—that the lines were going to be closed, and there was a big campaign against such a development by the people in the various towns which these railways serve— Ennistymon, Lahinch, Lisdoonvarna, Miltown-Malbay, Kilkee, Kilrush, etc. There were meetings held against the idea of closing the line but, so far as I am aware, that proposal did not exist at all. At any rate, it showed the inclination of the people and how they felt about it.

I would not say it is a very economical line. It skirts all the way round the coast. There is a big store cattle business around there and the railway brings turf from West Clare to Ennis and various other centres. I would like to know if there is any proposal in mind to close down that line. If there is, there should be a substitute service, perhaps of a better kind. At that time those who were campaigning against the closing of that line—it is a narrow gauge line—suggested that it should be made a broad gauge line so as to synchronise with the other railway lines. But I understand that that would be a very expensive operation. I merely wish to know if that matter has been considered at all and, if it has, how is it proposed to deal with the situation.

Comment on this

I should like to deal with the points raised by Senator Honan. It is true to say that this is somewhat different from the other branch lines in the sense that it has a narrow gauge. Also, it is probably one of the longest branch lines, being about 53 miles long. So far as the question arises of its being closed down or kept open, if there is any application or any desire by the board to close it, that would have to come before the tribunal, like any other branch line. The board could not close it on its own initiative. All the interests concerned in keeping the line open would be free to act and to put a case before the tribunal, just as would be done in the case of other branch lines. The Senator is quite right—it would be an expensive operation to put a broad instead of a narrow gauge there; it would probably cost somewhere in the neighbourhood of £1,000,000.

Comment on this

This section covers the point where an abandonment order is made and authority given to the board to close down a branch line and abandon the service. Certain provision is made. If it is a question of the maintenance of bridges or any roadways that the railways pass over, an obligation is placed on the local authority to do certain things. Provision is made in this Bill for an agreement between the transport company and the local authority. If no such agreement is executed, and if the superstructure of the bridge is not removed, the liability of the board to maintain the bridge shall cease on the appointed day and the road authority shall be liable to maintain the bridge.

I am not so much interested in the payment. What I am interested in is that provision is made for the doing of certain work under an agreement between the transport company and the local authority. If, for one reason or another, the local authority declines to enter into that agreement to carry out that particular work, then an order is made and a day appointed on which the responsibility of the board ceases entirely. The responsibility is then placed on the local authority, without its having agreed to accept that responsibility. It must follow from that that the board shall pay to the road authority compensation for any expense which the road authority may incur by reason of the liability so imposed on them.

I would like some clarification as to whether that would include payment of compensation for any accidents that may happen at that bridge arising out of the fact that the transport authority has abandoned it and the local authority has not agreed to take it over. It seems a roundabout way of doing a particular job. The company is the authority to maintain the bridges and the roadways over which the rails run. A decision is arrived at to abandon the service over such bridges and roadways and an attempt is made to have an agreement with the local authority to take responsibility and have the bridges removed or, in the case of the roads, I expect that the rails would be lifted and the road made good. I know places where I am very doubtful if the local authority would take the responsibility and I would like to know what then happens under this section.

Comment on this

I had an amendment down to this section, but it was ruled out of order and I am not going to refer to it. My principal object in putting down that amendment was this. I do not think that the railway lines should be sold to the farmers on each side of the line, as the section states. I believe the railway lines should be kept intact for at least ten years until this mad craze for road transport wears off. When that wears off there will be an outery in the country to get back to the railways again. If the railway tracks are kept intact, they will be preserved at very little expense for the reopening of the railways when people get back to normal.

I intend to move an amendment on the Report Stage to that effect and, therefore, I will not discuss the matter further now.

Comment on this

I am largely in agreement with the idea underlying Senator Counihan's amendment. I agree with him that it is a very serious matter if such a thing could happen as that the railway lines would be taken up altogether. When I talk about the railway lines I mean those branch lines. It would appear to me that the whole policy of the Government, not alone the Department of Industry and Commerce but every other Department, is based on the supposition that we have seen the last of wars. I hope that is a fact, but I do not believe it is. I think the general belief of thinking people all over the world is that we have not by any means seen the last of wars and that, in fact, the day is not far distant when we will have to be making preparations again to deal with a war situation.

It is a very serious matter to suggest that the branch lines which may be regarded as unprofitable in peace times or at the present moment should be put in such a way that they cannot be used again. In the last war there were all kinds of appeals made to keep the lines open and, in a good many cases, those appeals were dealt with sympathetically and the lines were kept open at great inconvenience and considerable expense to the railway company at the time. I believe that, while a lot of people on his own side of the House seem to find amusement in the suggestion made by Senator Counihan that these lines be not interfered with for at least ten years, there is a lot of sanity in that suggestion.

The question may arise as to why that amount of land should be left unproductive, if you like, for a number of years, and perhaps ten years may seem a long time to some people, but, with all the will in the world, I say it would be a very hard thing to use the ground on which a railway line exists for any other purpose for a considerable number of years. Anybody who knows what the construction of a railway line is like must know that it is a combination of several materials, deliberately designed not to grow any kind of vegetation. Every effort is being made to produce that sort of soil underneath the railway lines. If that is so, and I believe it is, it would cost a tremendous amount of money to convert that land to any other use. The alternative would seem to be to allow it to become derelict. That would be a disastrous policy. I am referring to the branch lines which may be considered to be redundant. I think it would be a far saner policy to keep them in the best repair possible, at the smallest expense, for a number of years at any rate, in the belief that we may again reach a situation when it may be impossible to supply the transport requirements of the country by any other method than the use of these branch lines.

Senator Counihan referred to the craze for road transport—motor lorries and the rest. I saw some Senators laugh at that suggestion. The fact is the people generally have a craze for motor transport. It may be said that I have myself because I drive a car. We all have got the craze for doing things in the easiest possible way without paying sufficient attention to the expense involved, even to ourselves as individuals. It is quite understandable, therefore, that farmers and cattle dealers are inclined to take the easy method for the transport of their stock as against using the railways which served such a very useful purpose over a long number of years.

I suppose one may say that another war is definitely not outside the bounds of possibility. I think most people would say that it is highly probable within the next five or six years. In that situation we will have to say to ourselves "the worst has happened and what are we going to do about it?" Most sensible people would say that one of the first things to be looked to was transport to meet the food requirements of the country. Defence, I suppose, would be the very first thing to be looked to, but we are not dealing with that on this Bill At any rate transport for food supplies for man and beast would be a first essential. There would be very little use in producing wheat in the County Waterford to feed the people in the City of Limerick unless we had the transport to take it there or in growing wheat in the County Galway for the people in Dublin if we had no means of transporting it to this city. It follows from that, that if we are to depend on road transport that, in turn, we will be dependent on outside sources for the fuel required for it—supplies of petrol and of crude oil from Central Europe or America. If we have a policy of self-sufficiency to produce our own requirements in food we must be careful to see that we are able to deliver that food at the points where it is required.

We all know that during the last war we had a number of people grumbling and complaining that the railways were not giving a good service, completely overlooking the fact that they were working under a terrific handicap. They had not available the kind of fuel that would enable them to make speed on long journeys. I think it is up to Senators interested in agriculture or in industry generally to ensure that none of these branch lines will be put out of commission or reduced to such a point that they cannot be brought into service in the case of an emergency.

During the last war some of them had to be closed down owing to the lack of fuel supplies, but they were again pressed into service when we were not able to get petrol for the transport of turf, agricultural produce and various other things by road. We found then that the railways were our only reliable method of transport. It was well for us that these branch lines had not been torn up as the line from Galway to Clifden had been many years ago. It is worthy of mention, too, that during the last emergency these branch lines provided a means of transport for our live-stock industry in which I include cattle, horses, pigs and everything that is produced on the land. If we had not that method of transport the country would have been deprived of the substantial income that was derived from the export of our cattle and horses.

Of course, we always have cynical sneers from people who try to use politics for any purpose. Unfortunately we have them in this House. On the last day, when discussing this Bill, it was suggested that special trains were run to the Curragh to provide transport for one individual. Well, I think a remark of that kind does not deserve any notice beyond saying that were it not for the fact that the railway lines were there our bloodstock industry would probably have suffered very considerable damage. I believe that if we bear in mind the lessons that are to be learned from what occurred during the last war, and if we recall the difficulties which we came up against at that time, we will all agree that the branch lines should be maintained even if it should prove a costly job to do so. The fact is that if the last war had not started for another ten or 15 years, the branch lines would have been torn up and our horse machinery would have gone out of action and so we would have been left like people on a desert island without any means for the production of food for man or beast.

Comment on this

Senator Quirke certainly makes the best possible use of the very brief period he spends in the House.

Comment on this

Thank you.

Comment on this

If the Senator wanted to give effect to the suggestions made by him he should have put down amendments, because the law will be as it is stated in the Bill when it becomes an Act. The provision relating to branch lines is that if the board desires to close down one or more branch lines it will make an application to the Transport Tribunal and, having given time for any objections that may be raised, the tribunal then has the power to issue an order authorising the board to close the line or lines in question. There is a further provision which enables the land on which these lines are laid to be disposed of, so that speeches urging what should or should not be done are sheer futility unless amendments embodying those views are inserted in the Bill.

It is suggested that these branch lines should be left undisturbed for a period of years, say ten years or so. I wonder have Senators ever heard the story of the Birr-Portumna branch line. Through some dispute with the old Great Southern and Western Railway, it ceased to run trains on the Portumna-Birr line, and it was left there for a certain number of years. After a while the Board of Works, having reconsidered the matter, decided to reopen the line, but when they went to find the line they found it had been stolen. They found that every rail, and sleeper, and fish-plate, every fitment, gates and fences had disappeared mysteriously. That is precisely what would happen on a railway that is left without a maintenance staff or permanent way gang to look after it.

Comment on this

Is it the suggestion that the Board of Works were so careless about Board of Works property or the property of the people of this country that they allowed a whole railway line to be taken away before they made a report to the Guards?

Comment on this

Whether it is or not, it was stolen, and that was before the Guards.

Comment on this

That is the fact. The Guards were not here at all. If the Senator, before he talks authoritatively on transport, would read the history of it——

Comment on this

I have travelled on a lot more transport systems than the Senator has.

Comment on this

You may have travelled, but you will not see much from the inside of a motor car or a first-class carriage.

Comment on this

The ticket, I take, is a third class.

Comment on this

In any event, I am talking as an ordinary member of the Seanad, and I do not propose to lay down wisdom for anybody in regard to transport, but you cannot leave a line unattended. You must either maintain it in full, maintain a full staff or get rid of it, in order to avoid complete loss. Very naturally, I am railway-minded and in sympathy with those who would like every line of railway maintained. Public opinion will, no doubt, manifest itself, locally at all events, when any of these cases come before the tribunal; and, it may be, that the Transport Tribunal will insist on lines which are making a considerable loss each year being kept open. The difference between now and the future will be that that loss will have to be borne by the community, not by the railway company, as such. Previously, it was the private shareholders who bore the loss or the workers on the line had to accept lower conditions of service. In the future we can afford to be more generous, because it will be paid either by increased rates, freights or fares or it will be paid for by subsidy direct from the State. We can afford to be generous.

It is rather futile, also, in a matter of this kind, to discuss in lurid prognostication the possibilties of another war. If another war comes well, I do not think branch lines are going to save us. We must remember that we closed down more branch lines in the emergency than we ever closed down in times of peace, because we were unable to get the fuel from England, the only place we could get it from in time of war. Is it suggested that Britain will be so protected in the next war that we are going to have sufficient to run our railways in full? My wish, of course, is that we shall, but let us not live in a fool's paradise and imagine that any provision we can make, whether neutral or belligerent, that we are going to avoid suffering of a very violent and terrible character. Whilst we should make every possible provision to alleviate the suffering that the community may suffer in such a calamity, it is rather a tall order to suggest that that depends on the maintenance of branch lines. I hope there will be no more branch lines closed down. Already, a very considerable number has been closed, some of them temporarily, and an extension of the process would soon leave only the main lines existing. As I have said, we will have the Transport Tribunal, and we will have the knowledge, that if they are kept open, working at a loss, that the State or the community will bear the loss; consequently, we should all be happier about it.

Comment on this

This is rather an interesting point. I have not spoken in this debate so far, but I am tempted into saying something on this. I have sympathy with Senator Counihan and, indeed, with Senator Quirke on the proposal envisaged about keeping the line for ten years. I do not think it would be practicable altogether. I can see difficulties; that is, the provision as to keeping fences and one thing or another. One suggestion does occur to me, in connection with the maintenance of lines, if it does take place. I think it would be rather a pity that the lines or the property would be altogether destroyed; that is, that the fences should be taken up, everything else, and destroyed or given away, or as they would be, sold for a very small sum.

If I were to suggest anything, I would suggest, that if the railways or any portion of them are closed down, it will be because they are not paying, because goods and passengers are being transported in some other way. That leads to the further use of the roads by motor vehicles of some sort or another, lorries and so on. That brings me to the point I am anxious about. The railways are, generally, the shortest line between two important points, two villages or two towns. They were built between important places, villages or towns, and they are, generally, the shortest way between these two points. I suggest, if the railways are going to be abandoned, and if the roads are going to be subjected to increased traffic every day, that the position for the ordinary pedestrian and the man using horse traffic, with a valuable horse and a cart, will be almost impossible. I suggest, as Senator Quirke has said, that these lines are mostly manufactured of hard substance, and they can be easily converted by the local authorities, if they are passed on to the local authorities, into a road for horse traffic and pedestrians. That would preserve these people from the increasing menace of fast traffic. I suggest they can be utilised in that way, if not, indeed, preserved, passed on to the local authorities at a small sum, and the local authorities could easily convert them into a road good enough for the local man, and the local man who has a horse and cart.

Comment on this

I am afraid, Sir, that I was out for some of the discussion that, I understand, has developed along the question of branch lines, and if they are to be closed, maintaining them for ten years after they had been closed. That, as has been said, will be a matter, that under this Bill, will have to go before the tribunal, before which the company and the outside interests who will be concerned in the maintenance of the line can be represented.

May I say to Senators, and to other people, in that connection, that there is one certain way of ensuring that a branch line will not close down; and, that is, by the people in the locality using it? Remember, if a branch line has to be abandoned, it will not be, abandoned by the board. It will be, because it has been abandoned by the public themselves; and, perhaps, people would keep that a little more in mind and have some regard to their own responsibility for keeping a line going. I would like to say that, I think, all of us are anxious that branch lines should be kept open. I think that in this country, particularly, branch lines are very essential, particularly for dealing with live stock and for clearing fairs. We cannot, however, be entirely neglectful or forgetful of the economics or the finances of the matter. I do not want to go into it any further beyond saying that, I think, there are in the Bill as reasonable safeguards as one could ask for in relation to the closing or proposed closing of any particular branch line.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, I would like to say this, that while we have been discussing branch lines and the closing of branch lines this section, to my mind, is not the section dealing with the closing of branch lines at all. The question that I was anxious to have the Minister's view on is this: this makes provision for what happens when the abandonment order is given. I want clarification of the position that may arise where a local authority refuses to enter into an agreement to remove such a structure as, say, a bridge. In certain circumstances I can see that a local authority might not be prepared to enter into such an agreement. An appointed day is fixed and from that appointed day the matter becomes the responsibility of the local authority. Provision is made that the local authority shall be compensated by the board. What happens when a local authority refuses to enter into an agreement? Will the structure be allowed to remain there until it falls into decay or until some serious accident occurs? Will the board be compelled to undertake its removal?

Comment on this

In that connection I can only point out that there is no change in the existing law. This is merely a re-enactment of what is contained in the 1944 Act. So far as I am aware no new obligation is placed upon the local authority.

Comment on this

I am not concerned with the imposition of some new obligation. I can visualise the position where an abandonment order is given to the board and negotiations are entered into between the board and the local authority for the removal of a bridge. The local authority engineer, for one reason or another, does not recommend the council to undertake the removal of this structure; but from the appointed day the local authority shall be liable to maintain the bridge or to remove it. The board is compelled to make good the cost but that may not be a sufficient inducement to the local authority. Possibly they might not have the equipment or staff necessary to do the work. What happens then? Who is responsible after the appointed day where there is no agreement with the local authority?

Comment on this

That situation could only arise where a local authority was being pigheaded. I think ample provision is made here. There is no undue or unfair obligation placed upon the local authority at all. If they are asked to do the work they will be compensated for it. It is no argument to say that they may not have the equipment or machinery to do the work. I am sure there are many competent contractors who would be very glad to carry it out for them.

Comment on this

On Section 22, the board is here given power to make by-laws and regulate the times of arrival and departure of trains and vehicular traffic. Sub-section (2) provides:—

"The board shall submit to the Minister for confirmation any by-laws made by it under this section."

I thoroughly agree with this sub-section, and it is because I do agree with it that I ask the support of the House in having a similar amendment entered in another more important section; that is, that before a regulation affecting the lives of the people, as a regulation made by Córas Iompair Éireann must, is made it must be submitted to the Minister and he should have power to either confirm, modify or amend such regulation as he thinks fit. Not alone should the by-laws made by the board be submitted but proposals to increase fares and freight charges or make changes in the activity of the board should also be submitted to him. There will be a discussion later on another section of this Bill and I am anxious, therefore, to draw the attention of the House to this particular provision. This gives the Minister power to amend or perhaps revise regulations submitted to him.

Comment on this

There is a very big difference. In the other case the Senator wants to make the Minister a court of appeal.

Comment on this

I think that if the Minister directs his attention to sub-section (b) (iii) he will find there that he will really be in the position of a court of appeal because orders submitted to him for his approval must be published in no less than two morning papers circulating throughout the State and persons will have an opportunity of submitting their case. The Minister may, as he thinks fit, refuse to confirm, and so on. Before the by-laws become effective the public is made aware of them so that the people may understand what their implications are.

Comment on this

The Senator will have some difficulty in proving an analogy there.

Comment on this