We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1950—Second Stage.

Contributions 1–100 of 225. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1950
Enacted

No. 34 of 1950 ›

Michael Joseph O'Higgins Minister for Defence (Dr. O'Higgins) (for the Minister for Industry and Commerce) Fine Gael

I should like, as far as possible, to confine and to relate my remarks with strict relevancy to the Bill before us. This Bill, which is one of those hardy annuals that the Seanad is over-familiar with, and which has been coming before the Seanad for a great number of years, is comparatively unchanged this year, with the exception of one particular section to which I shall refer. In Dáil Eireann, the debate lasted about four weeks and it centred on the cost of living—on whether the cost of living had or had not gone up and, if it had gone up, on whether it had gone up prior or subsequent to August last. It was a very interesting and instructive debate but definitely it was not a debate on the Bill which we have before us to-day and which it is necessary to have passed into law by the 31st of this month. It was a discussion about very important matters, but, on moving up to the Division Lobby prior to the division on the Bill, an Opposition Deputy, with a droll sense of humour, remarked quite seriously that he really did not think the Bill was strictly relevant to the debate.

This Bill, which is before the Seanad this evening, is a continuation or a renewal of the powers contained in the Supplies and Services Act which has come before the Dáil and Seanad on numerous occasions. There is one additional section to it. It is an important section around which I think the main part of the discussion should take place. With regard to the general position, and to the necessity for having a Bill such as this, I think it is within the knowledge of the Seanad that the ambition of Governments, past and present, is to get back, as rapidly as possible, to normal conditions. Control or interference with trade and industry is normally undesirable. It may be necessary at times, but the outcrop of that necessity is not always good. Very frequently, it produces an outcrop that is evil and damaging in itself.

The last Government went out of office shortly after the war had ended. When the present Government took over, war appeared to be behind us. It was our desire that the State should, as rapidly as possible, pull out of interference with industry and with commerce. Such a pull-out could have been effected too rapidly. We were conscious of the arguments advanced that, in the long run, the best way of controlling prices, and of bringing about a reduction in prices, was to let the ordinary laws of supply and demand apply, and that, once they began to operate, the ordinary competitive spirit would result in reduced prices. From time to time, over the last two and a half years, we have decontrolled and we have pulled out the State to meet the arguments advanced in order to see to what extent the ordinary laws of supply and demand, and the competitive spirit, would effect satisfactory results.

It is within the experience of every single member of the Seanad that, in all cases, the results were not entirely happy. One of the normal effects of State control, State penetration and State interference was the organisation of bodies and communities, with a related interest, into a more solidified form, so that when controls, and the power of control over prices, were removed, and the ordinary laws of supply and demand were left to operate, and when the competitive spirit was left to pull down prices, in some respects, certainly, we found that the organised spirit was supreme over the competitive spirit and that the removal of control resulted in an increase in prices, even where the article was somewhat surplus to production. It is only fair to say that when I give that particular illustration, I am not applying it to the general organisation of commercial life. But, here and there, we did find that the removal of controls resulted in increased prices, even where the article was surplus, more or less, to requirement.

With regard to traders generally, we have gone through a couple of years in which there were certain increases in overhead charges: where rates increased and where wages increased. We had something like a national increase in wages and we had something approaching a national increase in rates. These added heavily to the overhead charges on industry and business generally. In addition, we had the devaluation of the £, which meant a certain increase in costs in certain directions. The quantity of goods that we bought from the Western Hemisphere, and, in fact, all the goods that we bought from the hard-currency countries—the extent to which we in this country purchased them either from the Western Hemisphere or the hard-currency countries—was rather big—that is, within the scope of our daily lives. Maize, which is the raw product of very much of our agricultural production; wheat, which enters, to a greater or a lesser extent, into every slice of bread eaten; petrol, fuel oil, tobacco, and, to a great extent, machinery, and, to a certain extent, other items which are more or less in daily use, all came either from the Western Hemisphere or from the hard-currency countries. Yet, with rate increases, with wage increases, with the increases flowing out from hard-currency and dollar purchases, we had not anything like a commensurate increase in the cost of living. In fact, up to some time at the end of the summer, in spite of all these factors, we had a cost of living remaining somewhat about stationary. It is due to the industrial and commercial classes of the country to state that as a matter of official opinion and as a matter of ascertainable fact. During the latter end of the period I refer to, in addition to the factors I mention which might contribute to an increase in prices, we had, to a very great extent, the world turning from normal, domestic or economic production back towards war production, and that turn in the world trend of production meant, in turn, shortages of certain lines of goods and, where the demand is greater than the article in production, normally you do get an increase in price. Nevertheless, up to the end of the summer you had all these factors operating and you had no tilt in the cost-of-living index figure.

In recent months we had a sudden very, very grave and completely unexpected turn in world events. You had the Korean War apparently being worked out to a standstill. Then, completely unexpectedly, you had the break-through of the Chinese armies and you had the whole of the western world and the whole of Europe suddenly changing their policy, changing their outlook, and deciding, not as so many individuals, but as so many people welded into a solid community to get back rapidly to war production. As a result of that sudden and unexpected turn in the world's economy, you had this country, the same as any other country, suddenly faced with a gigantic jump in the price of very, very many war materials and with shortages in very, very many directions.

With that state of affairs staring us in the face and with a crisis that may be just around the corner, it was clear that the procedure of decontrol, in fact that the deliberate policy of gradual but progressive decontrol, had got to be abandoned; that we had got to turn right about and face a regrettable but, nevertheless, real and new emergency. In an emergency when prices might sky-rocket and supplies decline beyond normal visibility, it was necessary to re-enact every one of the previous emergency controls and, acting in the light of experience, to add to them further controls where experience would direct those charged with responsibility to feel that there was a deficiency in the pre-existing machine.

Controls are imposed in the public interest, in the interest of the general consumer. So far as the general consumer goes, controls operate (1) in order to get as fair and reasonable distribution of goods as it is possible to effect; and (2) to have those goods supplied at the most reasonable price taking into account all the conditions that operate on the level of prices. We were confronted with a position in which the whole situation changed quite suddenly and we found certain raw materials going up with an unexpected jump and to a very considerable height. We found industrialists keeping pace with the jump in raw material long before that raw material went into the make-up of the goods. We had a situation a couple of months ago where the prices of wool sky-rocketed, and immediately afterwards the price of every sock in Ireland jumped higher than the wool when it was well within the knowledge of everyone that that highly expensive wool would not go into the Irish sock for a considerable number of months. Retailers were blamed for that by some; manufacturers were blamed for that by many. Some are blameless; some are blameworthy. It is in the public interest and in the interest of those who are playing the game in a straightforward manner by the public to ascertain accurately exactly where the blame rests.

We have different commodities going up because world prices are rising. We have producers and retailers in this country being blamed for every single increase in the price of any article. Yet, when a proposal is made to publicise fully the reasons for every increase, to show that this article increased because of factors completely outside the control of anybody in this country and that the price of another article increased because the raw material from abroad going into it has increased; to show clearly and fairly to the public where the cause originates and where the blame, if any, rests, we have a panic in industrial circles and, to an extent, a panic in commercial circles that is difficult to understand. It is difficult to understand why any industrialist, where the price of his raw material from an outside source goes up, and his finished product must go up in proportion, should get into a tail-spin because the public are going to be told that the product of his industry goes up because rubber or something else goes up in price abroad. You have that planning and you have every evidence of opposition to the proposals made; and you have that opposition progressing along two lines of attack, each line being directly contradictory and in conflict with the other line of attack. We had evidence of both approaches in the debates on this measure in the Dáil.

One line of attack to the proposal to establish an advisory prices committee is that such a committee, in so far as it is outlined in this Bill, will be quite powerless and will prove wholly impotent and inoperative from the very beginning because it has not sufficient powers. It was said that it was, after all, only an advisory committee and, in so far as it is only an advisory committee, it will be quite surplus to requirements and will serve no useful function. That is one line of attack. The other line of attack was that this is the most brutal and ruthless proposal ever made in the history of a democratic State; that this proposal will ride roughshod over the interests of industrialists and those engaged in commerce. In matters of this kind, irrespective of what Government happens to be in power, the body most concerned with the progress, development and expansion of industry is that group of men who form the Government. They are more concerned than any chambers of commerce or federations of industry. There is no tendency apparent in any of our organisations or in any of our political Parties to commit sudden political suicide or completely ruin ourselves in so far as the desired national expansion in the fields of industry, agriculture, commerce and everything else is concerned. The Government as a government has as great a sense of responsibility as any group of citizens in the State or as any group that one could get together anywhere. When a proposal is tabled before both the Dáil and the Seanad, after full and mature consideration and in the light of experience over years of emergency and post-emergency, that proposal is not put down in any spirit of reckless folly or in order to make more trouble for some particular Minister in piloting such a measure through the Oireachtas. That proposal is put down because, in the considered opinion of the people who are charged in the last analysis with full responsibility, it is desirable in the public interest, in the interests of the consumer, in the interests of the producer and in the interests of the retailer. It is desirable to have a new body such as that outlined in this Bill to take over the work of control and to ensure that the work of price fixing will be done as far as possible in such manner as will not militate against normal trading operations or desirable industrial expansion and production. As far as reasonable, it is desirable to have it done in the broad light of day.

It is a very, very simple matter for any one of us to put ourselves up as a prophet. Some people have presumed to be prophets who take greater pleasure in prophesying gloom rather than bliss. Amongst the people who constitute themselves prophets in relation to this proposal, there have been those who framed their prophecies in the most gloomy terms. It is presumed and prophesied that the Government will establish a price-fixing committee and that that committee will consist of a group of irresponsible lunatics who have no sense of proportion and who do not place any value on the normal development and expansion of industry. It is presumed and prophesied that that committee will fix prices at such a level that one industry after another will be put out of business. Furthermore, it is prophesied that the Government will act on the advice of that committee and then lean back happily to watch the doors of one industry after another close up and down the country, and watch the miserable men put out of work through the lunacy of this advisory committee.

When we come into the Dáil and Seanad, we are supposed to have reached a certain age and, in reaching that age, we are presumed to have reached the use of reason. All reason would have long since departed from this institution as an institution of the State, and from the Government as a Government, if such a lunatic proposal was within the bounds of consideration. It must be presumed, and I am entitled to ask the Seanad to assume that, before the Government considered the establishment of an advisory body to advise the Minister in relation to prices, that body will consist of people with a responsible outlook and of people, in so far as they can be found, with considerable experience of the particular type of business upon which they are asked to advise; that body will be as conscious as any body would be of the necessity for keeping industry going in difficult times and of the fact that, if any death blow is struck at an industrialist, the industrialist may be the first to fall but he will be only one; the casualties behind the industrialist will be every single worker with a vested interest in the particular line of business.

I have to ask the Seanad in dealing with this particular section of the Bill to have a certain amount of trust. Obviously before a Bill becomes law no Minister is in a position to announce the names of those people who will constitute a tribunal or committee of this kind. The Government has under consideration a panel of names. From that panel a suitable selection will be made. When the names are ultimately published I am inclined to guarantee that that committee or tribunal will not only have the confidence of the consumer but will have at the same time the confidence of every honest industrialist and of every individual engaged in trade up and down the country. Judgment on the suitability of the personnel of a committee of this kind must naturally be reserved until the names are available.

I would merely ask the Seanad at this stage to accept it as a fact that any Government constituting such a body would naturally aim at constituting a body that would have the maximum confidence of the people as a whole.

In the work which will fall on this particular body you have three interests—the producer, the retailer and the consumer. It would be a tragic mistake for the Government to constitute a body of this kind where the dice would be heavily loaded in the interests of one section of these three to the prejudice of any other section. There has been a certain amount of discussion and a certain amount of uneasiness with regard to the public nature of the work which will be done by this particular body. The purpose behind having such a body as this operating in public is, firstly, that where the price of any commodity is increased, the public will be told the reason for the increase. If the reason is because of increased prices of the raw material outside this country, then is it not in the interest of the industrialist or in the interest of the trader in this country that his customers should not blame him, that his customers should know and have published that that increase was due to the fact that there was an increase in the price of the raw material from some foreign source? If the increase is due to increased wages, to increased rates, to increased overhead charges within the country, then is it not unfair to have the trader blamed for the increased prices? Is it not in his interests to publicise the fact that this increase is because the cost of printing went up, the cost of rates went up or wages went up? What we are aiming at in this is not only to have public confidence in the price-fixing authority but to have public confidence in the honesty, reliability and national outlook of industrialists, retailers and others concerned in the supply of commodities to the people.

So far, I take it, there is no objection to publicity. No industrialist will object, where his products increase in price, to having a body that will say in the public Press: "That increased because of the price of the raw material," or to having a representative committee putting their stamp on the increased price rather than the producer's own stamp. No retailer would object to it so far. The next question —there is a lot of uneasiness with regard to this—is to what extent information secured from industrialists and traders, which must be made available to the committee, will be made public. Obviously any of us can see that, in so far as there is competitive business in any country, if you publish all the intimate details of the work of any particular industry or business and give competitors the advantage of the closest and most confidential information as to the inner workings of a competitive firm, that would completely deprive the business supplying the information of any advantage acquired through ability, organisation or initiative and would, in fact, so much undermine the confidence of business men in dealing with the Department of Industry and Commerce or through any advisory committee, that business men would keep their money in their pockets rather than speculate it in a business where every trade secret was to be published to the whole world. I would suggest that these fears are as groundless and unreal as the fears I referred to with regard to the type of person we shall put on this body.

Obviously the Minister for Industry and Commerce has got to have a sense of responsibility. Obviously he has got to consider whether the publication of any information would militate against or be damaging to industry as a whole. The chairman of this particular body has got to be selected with much greater care than we sometimes take when selecting the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The chairman of that body, in consultation with the Minister, is the person who is going to decide what exactly will be made public and what will not. The terms of reference of this body have got to be drafted if and when the Bill becomes law. The procedure has got to be defined if and when this Bill becomes law. Representations that are in the public interest and in the interest of the community generally can be made and will be considered fully and reasonably after this Bill becomes law and before any body such as is outlined here begins to operate. I do not know, within the limits of reason, what there is to fear in these proposals. Every Senator knows that the old method of fixing prices within the Department was resisted, condemned and criticised by industrialists and business people. It was challenged in the very beginning. It was consistently challenged up to the time that new proposals were made. It was challenged by consumers generally. Their line of approach was: "What do civil servants know about prices? What do they know about business?" So long as any work affecting the lives of many people is done behind closed doors, then you never get the degree of confidence which we should get as a community possibly facing a really grave emergency. It is public confidence in the machine, public confidence in our business men, public confidence in our industrialists, that is the object of the suggestions made here.

We had price control based on controlling prices via the margin of profits and prices have been controlled, whether effectively or otherwise, via the margin of profits ever since price control started. Consistently, that was challenged by the producer and by the man engaged in business from the very beginning. It was challenged by the consumer from the very beginning. The consumer's challenge to that system of price control was that in effect and in practice what you are doing—there is a certain amount of truth in this—was that you were guaranteeing the profit of every individual that handled or saw the article from the raw material until it was passed to the consumer across a retailer's counter. Every single intermediate profit was guaranteed and everyone was insured against loss or hardship, except the consumer at the other end of the spout.

That criticism was a fair criticism. It was true, at least, to the extent that you guaranteed against loss or hardship everybody that touched the article from the raw material to the finished article on the retailer's counter, except the purchaser. There was a certain amount of justice in that criticism but, in so far as it was not abused, there was also a sound and reasonable defence of that system of price control. But when, under a system such as that, you see group profits in certain groups, not just increasing, but going up by 400 or 500 per cent. in two or three years, and, commensurate with the increase in group profits by 400 or 500 per cent. in two or three years, you see the price of the article to the consumer increasing, then any Minister with a broad sense of justice would say to himself, "Something has to be done."

In the face of those facts and those figures, and if those facts prove to be facts reliably demonstrated and those figures prove to be correct and authentic, then surely there is nobody in Seanad Eireann or elsewhere that would say: "Jog along happily; that is the ideal arrangement; profits quadruple, prices go up, the consumer pays more." Surely industrialists or people concerned with commerce as a whole, seeing that graph—steeply bounding profits, progressively rising prices— would say to themselves, in the interest of the industry and in the interest of commerce as a whole, that some of these profits should be plugged back towards reducing prices. That is the picture. It is a picture that everyone will read in the published revenue returns. A Minister gets no more information than is available to the general public. We do not know the concerns of any particular industry. We do not know the position of any individual businessman. The returns are laid out by groups, by classifications, and the picture that I have given the House is a real picture based on real figures. Could anyone, in face of those figures, contemplate a real Government carrying on, being perfectly content and sitting placidly over that state of affairs?

There is in this Bill a proposal to have advice, to have a liaison group between the Government centre, where prices are fixed, the business people, the industrialists and the consumer outside, an organisation that will sift certain information, that will give certain advice to the Minister. The Minister is free either to act or not on that advice. It is a body calculated to throw a certain amount of light on the mystery of price fixation.

Some people criticise this by saying that there is an expert body inside the Department of Industry and Commerce, experienced in its work, having studied trade, prices and produce over a great number of years and they ask, why discard all those experts, why throw them aside and begin to lean on a group of completely inexperienced people who do not understand trade, produce or price fixation? Of course, that is more of the imaginary bogies that people are mentally producing. The hard core of the centre staff operating in conjunction with and behind this advisory committee will be that prices staff that have been experienced over a great number of years.

I have taken a considerable length of time to deal with that particular section of the Bill. I have endeavoured to confine my remarks to the Bill. I believe that I would be wasting time in referring to portions of the Bill that have been before the House time and again, that have had approval from various geographical seats in this Assembly down through the years. Therefore, I have related my remarks exclusively to the one portion of the Bill which is new and have explained to the Seanad as best I could the proposals contained here, the meaning of those proposals, the intentions behind them and the spirit in which they will be carried out.

Comment on this

I do not know whether it is generally known or not, but you often hear a good yarn out in the anteroom or around the House here and there, and this Bill reminds me of a story I heard from my friend and colleague, Senator Ó Buachalla, not so very long ago. He was visiting a mental hospital in the West and, walking around the grounds, he saw one of the inmates riding a bicycle. The bicycle obviously got out of control and the inmate got a fall. Another inmate came up to him and said: "What is wrong with you that you cannot ride the bicycle?" He replied: "The seat is too high for me.""Well," said the other inmate, "I will fix that for you," and he walked over, unscrewed the valves, and let the wind out of the tubes. "Now," be said, "off you go and you will be all right." The other inmate got a few more falls and then he gave up riding the bicycle as a bad job.

This Bill reminds me very forcibly of that story told to me by Senator Liam Ó Buachalla. I am quite convinced that this Bill is really another method of bluffing the workers in the hope, the forlorn hope, that in the forthcoming election, which, according to general opinion, is not very far off, the workers will again be fooled by the Coalition Government. I have the greatest possible confidence in the workers and in their wisdom, as a result of the experience they have had for the past three years, and I am quite satisfied that anybody who thinks that the workers are going to be directed by the plump-fed political leaders of Labour is merely barking up the wrong tree.

I have often said in private, and I do not mind saying it in public, that the Minister who is conducting this Bill through the House can make an excellent speech practically on any subject. I do not mind congratulating him on the speech he made on this Bill. I have read the debates in the other House and, while I think anybody would be justified in saying that in practically any debate certain speakers stray a little bit off the beaten track, I think it comes very badly from the Minister for Defence to tell us to please confine our remarks to the Bill. In actual fact, that is what the Minister said.

Comment on this

It is sincerely to be hoped that Senators will confine themselves to the Bill.

Comment on this

If the Chair will excuse me, I was really about to defend the Chair and the House. What I intended to say was that the Minister could have saved his remarks. In this House we very seldom stray from what is under discussion; we seldom stray from the subject-matter of Bills or anything connected with them and, if we do, we are usually brought to order by the Chair. If the Chair be a little bit lenient with the Minister or with other Ministers, or once and again with odd speakers, then we are not going to condemn the Chair or the House because of that liberty. I feel, at any rate, and I think most Senators will feel the same way, to use Lincoln's phrase:—

"I pray that my country may always be right; but, right or wrong, my country."

We must defend this House and our methods of conducting debate against any opposition, even that of the Minister.

The Minister says that nobody could possibly imagine any Government doing certain things which would indicate a tendency on the part of that Government to commit political suicide. My own opinion is that there is a very grave tendency on the part of this Government to commit political suicide. In the opinion of most people, this Government has practically completed the job.

Comment on this

It is very much alive at the moment, for a corpse.

Comment on this

Not so much alive as the Minister might think—and, mind you, the Minister is pretty wise. The Government have fallen out with most people in the country and, if we are to take the Minister seriously in the speech he made to-day, and the Parliamentary Secretary in the speech he made in the other House, we can only come to the conclusion that they now propose to fall out with the Civil Service. I never heard such a condemnation of the Civil Service as I heard from the Minister to-day. He suggests, as an alternative to the method heretofore in force, that an advisory committee will now be set up. These people are going to be supermen; they will not be like civil servants; they will not be criticised by the consumers and manufacturers and the various other people interested.

I have never accused, and I have not heard anybody else accusing, the Minister for Defence of simplicity, but I suggest now that he must be a very simple man if he believes that anybody in the capacity he proposes to put members of this committee will not be criticised. Of course, they will be criticised; they will be condemned and told they do not know what they are talking about. When provision was being made by the previous Government to set up a tribunal to deal adequately with problems facing the country, problems such as those they propose to handle by the measure before the House, it was strongly opposed by Fine Gael.

In my opinion, this Bill is entirely unnecessary. We have not been told what powers will be given to this committee. The Minister tells us that no Minister can give the names of the people beforehand. I respectfully suggest that, even if the Minister did give us the names beforehand, that would not be without precedent. We had a Bill last week or the week before and we had the names connected with it a year ago; in fact, the committee was actually sitting, and it was working, so far as we know, for a considerable length of time and nobody criticised individual members of it. We all wished them good luck in the debate here. I do not think there is anything wrong with the Minister now telling us the names of the people whom it is proposed to nominate as members of this committee.

So far as I gather from the Minister's speech here and the Parliamentary Secretary's speech in the other House, this committee is not likely to have any great power. This is called the Supplies and Services Bill. The question of supplies is a very serious one at the moment. The fact of the matter is that we have so little in the way of supplies, it will be very easy to handle the services. It was most interesting to hear the Minister coming to the rescue of the Parliamentary Secretary arising out of his speech in connection with prices. I have nothing whatever against the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. In fact, I like him—he is one of the few people I do like in the Coalition Government—and I really felt sorry for him when I saw the speech he made, but I cannot arouse any sympathy for the Minister for Defence, as I know he knows better, when he tries to justify here the speech made by the Parliamentary Secretary on prices.

On the 23rd November, the Parliamentary Secretary made a speech which will go down in the history of this or the other House for a considerable number of years as the greatest piece of nonsense ever talked. Now the Minister for Defence tells us, without any reference to that speech, of course, that until the late summer there was no appreciable rise in prices. I do not know what he thinks, but if he thinks there has been no rise in the past couple of years he must not take any notice of what bills he is paying to grocers, drapers and others. It is the greatest nonsense ever talked, as everyone knows that prices have risen. One paper—I do not like to throw bouquets at any paper—very wisely said that if the Parliamentary Secretary were right in his speech, the best thing the Government could do would be to set up a board of psychiatrists to examine the women of the country, as they were all convinced that prices had risen.

Comment on this

Will the Senator quote some of the items in respect of which prices went up before August, 1950?

Comment on this

Off the ration sugar.

Comment on this

It could not be bought in your time; it was not there.

Comment on this

Suits of clothes, tobacco, whiskey, and 150 other things went up.

Comment on this

Tobacco?

Comment on this

As against what year?

Comment on this

The price in 1947, say, or 1948. I ought to know, as I am buying as much tobacco as any other man in this House. If Senator Baxter seriously wants anyone to quote the prices of items which have gone up, it would take two hours to do it. There is no use in flogging a dead horse any longer. Everyone knows that the prices have gone up for practically everything.

Comment on this

The Senator should have brought the list with him.

Comment on this

The only thing that has not gone up is the price of wind and hot air. You can get your tyres pumped for the same price as you could a couple of years ago, and you can get more wind in this House than some years ago, particularly from Senator Baxter.

The Minister goes on to say that the chairman of this body will naturally be selected with the utmost care. I do not want to cast any reflection on anyone or upon the chairman of any particular body, but I hope the Minister and the Government will be a little bit more careful than they were when they selected the chairman of the Tourist Board. Again, I have nothing to say against the chairman of the Tourist Board.

Comment on this

The Tourist Board has nothing to do with supplies and services.

Comment on this

The Minister has said that the chairman of this board will be selected with the greatest possible care and it is up to the members of this House to help him and warn him against mistakes by other Ministers in the past—with all respect to you, a Chathaoirligh.

One of the greatest indications we have as to what the results of this measure will be is that given by the Minister for Social Welfare. We must take it that any Minister speaking in public is speaking on behalf of the Government and we have a promise from the Minister for Social Welfare that he is prepared to freeze prices. He was talking in very good weather, before the thaw set in, but if the Minister and the Government are prepared to freeze prices, it is an extraordinary thing that they are prepared to do it for some commodities at 100 per cent. more than last year. It will be generally admitted that the price of woollen goods, such as blankets, has increased 100 per cent. since this Government took office. It is poor consolation for people now in need of blankets—particularly within the last week or two, and a good number have been in need in that time—for them to know that if they possibly can stick it out and stand the racket until the thaw sets in, the prices will then be frozen at 100 per cent. more than they were when this Government came into office. It is poor consolation for those people, and I do not believe they will allow themselves to be fooled again.

Some months ago we had a statement by the Minister for Defence on the war situation. He was being criticised in the Dáil then because of the preparations which were being made— or perhaps I should say the preparations which were not being made—for the defence of this country in case of serious emergency. At that time the Minister said—and he was not the only Minister who said it—that the Government was basing its policy on continuing peace. Now we have the Taoiseach saying in Wexford the other day that anybody who did not realise the seriousness of the situation was a terrible optimist, or some words to that effect. I suggest with all respect that if the Government did not realise that a war situation was developing in the world within the past 12 months they were just the very few people who did not realise it. Take the average man who reads the paper every day, the average worker going out to work with spade and shovel, when chatting with his co-workers at lunch-time and when he went home to his own house in the evening and read the paper: 99 out of every 100 came to the conclusion that the world was heading for war.

One would think that, as a result of the travelling done by the various Ministers forming the present Government and particularly the thousands or even millions of miles travelled by the Minister for External Affairs, the Government would at least be kept in touch with the world situation. The Minister tells us, by way of explanation for the increase in prices, that as soon as the Korean situation developed prices began to rise. Surely nobody had to wait for the reverses to the United Nations armies in Korea to know that a very serious situation had developed already? Surely no one had to wait for the landing of the first troops in Korea to know that we were entering on a very serious situation?

Comment on this

You were not out in Korea yourself? You have been a good deal out of the House.

Comment on this

I would not be with Senator Baxter if I were. When we were fighting before, Senator Baxter succeeded in getting into jail and that is as far he got, as far as I know.

Comment on this

He had not any greyhounds to raffle.

Comment on this

Senator Baxter has passed the stage of fight and he is now in the position of the woman and child: "Hit me now and the child in my arms." The fact is that anyone looking at the world situation for the past 12 months or two years could not help knowing there was a very serious and dangerous position arising. Now, as a result of the developments in Korea we find ourselves in a very serious position. We all remember the time when we were facing the last general election. We had a series of alleged scandals publicised through the country.

Comment on this

They were not alleged. They were scandals.

Comment on this

We are coming to that.

Comment on this

This has nothing to do with it.

Comment on this

It has all to do with it, because, as a result of these alleged scandals and of this false propaganda, the stores which were laid by in case of an emergency were disposed of. Allegations were made that coal was purchased at outlandish prices and stored in the Phænix Park. In this campaign by scandalmongers, allegations were made that wood was also bought at outlandish prices and piled in the Phænix Park. I think that the reason why that stuff which was there was disposed of at ridiculously low prices——

Comment on this

Was there? It is there yet. I pass it daily.

Comment on this

And you would also pass coal in the houses of a few people along Infirmary Road, and if Senator Baxter is in touch with conditions in this country, he will know that coal was sold out of the park in order to prove that Fianna Fáil was wrong. If Senator Baxter had driven through the park, walked through the park, or ridden through the park every day for the past two years as I have done, he would know that the piles of turf we had on the main road from the main gate practically at Kingsbridge to the gate at Castleknock have disappeared from both sides of that main road. He would also realise that the coal was being hauled out of the park to such an extent that it was not safe to pass up by Kingsbridge with all the lorries. Immediately the reverse started in Korea, it was impossible to get a load of turf or a load of coal. It is being guarded there now like gold dust. Even now the people who tried to carry on this scandalmongering have not the decency to come along and say: "We made a mistake and thought Fianna Fáil were wrong in storing that turf and coal in the park." The fact of the matter is that no Government can continue to live on false charges. This Government got into power largely on false accusations against other people.

Comment on this

I am afraid they were not false.

Comment on this

Senator Baxter cannot take his medicine.

Comment on this

I will have a little medicine to give after a while and you will not like it.

Comment on this

We do not want to go back on the roaring of the wild ass which was followed up by the intelligentsia in the Dáil and which resulted in the Locke Tribunal being set up. If Senator Baxter and others want to go into that I am at their service. There were no depths to which the members of the present Coalition did not sink at that time. They got into power on false promises. We had Fine Gael at that time, through its present leader, promising the people, if they sent them back to power, that they would maintain the connection with England.

Comment on this

Will the Senator deal with the Supplies and Services Bill? The Chair would like him to do so.

Comment on this

I am merely dealing with the reduction in the cost of living as promised by one political Party at that time. I suggest that the cost of living was not reduced since then, and even the Minister conducting the Bill agrees with me on that. Provision should be made, even now, to try to keep the cost of living where it is, to stop it from rising any further. The only way to do that is by producing in this country and manufacturing in this country the necessaries of life for the people of the country. I cannot see that, as a result of this Bill, any improvement will be made in the production of those necessaries.

We had the Minister for Social Welfare in his famous attack on the industrialists of this country a few weeks ago referring to the people who were manufacturing the various commodities which we needed in this country as racketeers. I suppose there are black sheep in every fold. We have a few of them in this House on the other side of the room. It is ridiculous for any Minister to make such a sweeping statement. I believe, generally speaking, the industrialists of this country are giving good results and are entitled to make a living and are entitled to charge fair prices for their products, because if they are not, they will not be in a position to maintain a decent level of wages for their workers. This matter has been dealt with by other speakers in public, and I do not think it is necessary for me to deal with that any further. As far as I can see, the results which we are likely to get from this advisory body is that they will call before them the business people and the manufacturers of this country and ask them a whole lot of questions. They will insist, in so far as they can insist, on getting confidential information and the only result I can see coming from that will be a slowing down of the production of the necessaries of life for the people of this country.

I do not know why it is, when we have a discussion on industrial development or industries generally, we confine ourselves to what may be called manufacturing industries. I would like to hear, before this debate is over, a few words from Senator Counihan in defence of the cattle trade and the agricultural community of this country. The prices of cattle at present all will admit are pretty good. Senator Counihan will agree with me when I say that were it not for the muddling of the present Minister for Agriculture in the deal he made with regard to live cattle to Britain, the prices of cattle would be much better to-day. As a result of that deal, the foreign buyers, to a great extent, were eliminated from the markets of this country. If they were here, it would be to the good, so far as the farming community is concerned.

All kinds of arguments have been put up as to why we have not turf or wheat.

Comment on this

We never had as much wheat.

Comment on this

Senator Quirke might continue his speech.

Comment on this

It is very difficult when you are being interrupted and if Senator Baxter turns around, he will get his photograph taken.

Comment on this

Perhaps Senator Quirke would take the advice of the Chair and proceed with his speech.

Comment on this

Various Ministers and spokesmen of the Coalition Parties stated that, as a result of very bad weather, supplies of turf have been reduced and that supplies of wheat are also not what they should be. A person is always fairly safe in accusing the weather, particularly in this country. I do not think it is right to say that the scarcity of turf, or the scarcity of wheat for that matter, is attributable to the bad weather. Admittedly, we had bad weather, but turf has been saved in this country in the worst years that ever came, and so has wheat. The reason for the scarcity of turf and wheat at the present time is the discouragement given to the people, as far as the production of both these commodities is concerned.

We are told by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce and other speakers that turf workers cannot be got. They have advertised in the daily papers for these workers and have found it impossible to get them, and, even at the best time, so far as the turf industry was concerned, there was a shortage of something like 800 workers. The figure varied from 800 up to 1,000 and 1,200. The fact of the matter is that, if they had left in operation the turf schemes initiated by Fianna Fáil, there would be no scarcity of turf or turf workers. The reason the Government have found it hard to get turf workers is that they eliminated the production of turf by machine methods in areas where workers could be got. With all the talk they had during the election campaign, they decided they must do something to prove that they were sincere and they said: "We will do away with this; we will stop that machine; and we will eliminate turf production in this area and in that area."

They were not very long in office, however, when they realised that the turf industry was a very important industry and they proceeded to produce turf, if you like, at long distance. They called for workers, but because they found that the workers from Kerry did not feel anxious to work in Kildare and that the workers in Galway and along the western seaboard were not satisfied to work in Offaly, we had all this cry by the Government about being unable to get workers. I suggest that it is not reasonable to complain that you cannot get workers if you do not at least make an effort to provide work within a reasonable distance of the workers' homes. It is, perhaps, traditional in other countries for workers to travel long distances. Workers on the Continent travel long distances, but it is not traditional in this country that workers go even from one county to another, because they have been used in the past to obtaining work within reasonable distance of their homes. They built their families on that basis and now, when they are not anxious to travel 100, 150 and 200 miles to get work, they are accused by this Government of being unreasonable.

Workers in other countries have been forced—physical force has actually been used to get workers in the dictator countries—to travel long distances. They have been shifted from one end of Russia to the other and quite a number of them have gone to Siberia. We have not reached that stage yet and I hope we never will. The Government, even at this stage, should make up their mind to put these machines back where they found them and start the production of turf in these areas and store that turf when the weather is good. There is an old saying about making hay while the sun shines, and that turf should be cut in a good year and stored in a good year against a possible bad year or two years.

The same applies to everything else —wheat, for instance. The Parliamentary Secretary told us that the stores of the country were bulging with wheat at present. I hope he is right, even if it is imported wheat, but I should like to hear from the Minister how many months' supply of wheat we have stored to maintain a normal bread ration for the people. If it is not a matter of months, perhaps he will tell us how many weeks' supply we have. The sooner the Government realise that we must, in the last analysis, fall back on the farmers to provide the necessaries of life for the people, the better.

The Minister for Agriculture, unfortunately, started off on the wrong foot. In the Irish Press of May 7th, 1948, the Minister is reported as saying:—

"Only for the sake of freedom he would make it illegal for any man to plough the land of this country with horses and a plough. Let no one pull them into a career of taking up agriculture on the terms of the handloom and the spinning-wheel."

That is the statement we had from the Minister for Agriculture and still we are told that no Government would commit political suicide. It was political suicide for the Minister for Agriculture to make that speech and it was political suicide for the Coalition Government to let him get away with making that speech.

Comment on this

Did they not live a long time after committing suicide? That was 1948.

Comment on this

It would be economic suicide for the people to follow that policy and I do not believe they will stand for it very much longer. At the time the Minister and his backers in the Government and out of it said they were basing their policy on the hypothesis of peace and that, mind you, at a time when most people knew that any man with any common sense would base his policy for the future on the possibility of a war developing in Europe. I suggest, and I have often said it here before, that it is insanity nationally for this country to allow the production of its food supply to get into the hands of people in other countries. It is insanity for the people of this country to allow themselves to be put into a position in which they have to depend on shipping for the production of the necessaries of life. The Minister for Agriculture in the same speech said that, in ten years' time, the only place a plough would be found would be the museum. It would be ridiculous to begin to count up the numerous fantastic statements made by that Minister, but any man in his senses—even Senator Baxter will agree —that it is sound policy for the people not alone to maintain the plough in its proper place——

Comment on this

And the Minister be lieves that and says it.

Comment on this

The Minister will be in the museum and so will Senator Baxter and his Party and the ploughs will still be on the farms of Ireland.

Comment on this

That is where you will never be.

Comment on this

Not if I can keep as I am, and I am hoping that Senator Baxter and the Minister, in their combined wisdom, will be able to develop some system that will enable us to live forever. The fact of the matter is that the whole economy of this country is dependent on the horse and the plough, and on the people who follow the horse and the plough, the people whom the Minister, according to his own statement, would put into jail were it not that he thought he might be accused of being unjust. According to himself, he would put into jail the man who would attempt to plough with a horse and plough.

I want to impress on the Minister—I am sorry he has gone because I am sure he would take serious notice of what I am saying—that the quicker he gets back to the horse and plough the better for the people. If a war starts, anybody with any sense knows that, no matter what storage we put in, no matter what tanks we build for the storage of fuel oil and petrol, inside a very short time, these supplies will have run out. If the war develops along the lines on which most sensible people think it may——

Comment on this

Is it really coming?

Comment on this

The election is really coming, and let Senator Baxter make no mistake about it.

Comment on this

Is the war really coming?

Comment on this

I think the war is coming, but I am sure the election is coming.

Comment on this

When is the war coming?

Comment on this

The election will come about 11th March next. I hope it will not come any sooner because this is very bad weather. The position, if a world war developed, would be that, no matter how far we went in our preparation, within a year we would find ourselves dependent on the methods of production that kept us alive during the recent war. There is no reason why we should not use tractors in an emergency or in the absence of an emergency. I believe it is a good thing, and, from the point of view of the individual farmer, it is very hard to put up an argument against the use of tractors. But at the same time as we use tractors we should maintain the nucleus of an organisation in this country on which we could fall back in case the supply of fuel for our tractors disappeared overnight.

One of the greatest exports we have from this country, in fact the second most important, is the horse. If the policy of the Minister for Agriculture to make it a crime punishable by death for a man to follow horses and the plough were put into effective operation, I suggest that it would be a matter of a very short time until the horse population of the country had dwindled alarmingly. Anybody who knows anything at all about the horse industry knows that the majority of our Army jumpers—the Minister for Defence will bear me out on this—are bred from mares worked on the farms of Ireland. Some of them may be thoroughbreds, but the vast majority, 75 per cent. of the horses which jump in the Irish jumping team, are bred from mares which did their day's work on the agricultural holdings of the country at the same time as they bred the horses we are all proud of to-day. If we wish to maintain the hunter type of horse and our show jumping stock, which is a very valuable asset, we are mad to get rid of our working mares. God help the farmers, their workers and the ploughmen if the Minister for Agriculture got where he thinks he should be and could run them into jail. He has said that he would make it a crime punishable by law and I am satisfied he would carry that out but, thank God, there are a few wise men in the Government who put on the brake.

I have very little confidence in this committee and I believe, as I said at an earlier stage, that it is merely a piece of bluff to try to satisfy the workers of the country. It is significant that whenever this Government got into difficulties since they took office, they seemed to hope to get out of them by setting up a commission, a committee of inquiry or something of that kind. The same thing applied to emigration. In the election campaign, at least two of the Parties now forming the Government promised us that if or when they got into power they would stop emigration. Emigration has gone on and the only thing, as far as I can see, that the Government did to satisfy the people who swallowed that pill at that time was to set up a Commission on Emigration. We also had a Commission on Flour Milling and we all know the result of that.

Comment on this

And the Banking Commission.

Comment on this

Yes, and the Locke Tribunal.

Comment on this

And the Vocational Organisation Commission.

Comment on this

And the Roe Commission. I am not saying that we have not had other commissions which were not satisfactory. I am not referring to the Locke Tribunal, which was entirely satisfactory. The only unsatisfactory thing about it—I was talking to the people—was that the Government refused to pay what people thought were their lawful debts.

I do not think that this committee which it is proposed to set up under the Bill will have any power, but if it will I would like the Minister to elaborate on that in his reply or perhaps Senator Baxter will, seeing that he is apparently talking for the whole Government while the Minister is talking only for one Department. If this tribunal—as it was referred to in the other House—is to have any powers, by means of an emergency powers Order from the Minister or some other method, seriously to interfere with any industry, I should like to ask the Minister if the manufacturer, retailer or wholesaler who is to be brought before this tribunal will have the right to have legal assistance or advice and if he is acquitted before it if he will be compensated for such expenses as he may have incurred in defending himself.

Perhaps that will not be necessary but if the committee is to have the power to inflict any grave sentences I suggest that the people appearing before it should have the right to legal assistance and if they have that right I suggest that there should be a departure from the procedure adopted in the past in connection with the Locke Tribunal and that any man at least who is acquitted should be compensated for his out-of-pocket expenses. Senator Baxter wants to talk? No, he is dumb.

Comment on this

I was going to say that people were not acquitted in the public estimation even if they were by the court.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The debate must not follow along those lines. Will the Senator proceed?

Comment on this

I agree. It is very unfortunate that we should have these interruptions from Senator Baxter particularly as I am coming to the most important part of my speech.

Comment on this

It is nearly time.

Comment on this

Provision should also be made so that when members of the Oireachtas are summoned to appear before the tribunal they should not have the right to claim privilege. That is one of the reasons to my mind why members of the Dáil have been very seriously criticised. It is all right for members of the present Government to criticise judges. We have had a statement from the Minister for Lands which to my mind is tantamount to contempt of court. As far as I am concerned I am quite satisfied. I have nothing to grumble about. I could not be more whitewashed than I was by three judges, two of whom were appointed by the present Government, and I am glad that I am not in the position some people are in—present company excluded—who might be and are regarded as perjurers by the people of the country.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The debate must not continue on these matters.

Comment on this

If it is to have any control over prices or the cost of living, I think it necessary that this committee or tribunal should have considerably more powers than it has. The Parliamentary Secretary said in the other House that the Minister, under an emergency powers Order, has the right to confer certain powers on the individuals who will form this committee. I could not find it in the Bill but, if he has that right, what is to stop him from conferring these powers on three or four individuals either in the Department of Industry and Commerce or outside it? I refuse to believe that the senior officers in the Department of Industry and Commerce are so incompetent as to be incapable of acting on this committee. I believe they are capable and, further, I believe that a committee formed of civil servants, senior officers in the Department of Industry and Commerce, would inspire more confidence in the people of the country than people picked, as I am quite sure they will be picked, from the various Parties forming the present Coalition Government. We can only assume that that is so. I should like an assurance from the Minister before he finishes his speech, that no member of the Fianna Fáil Party will be appointed to this committee, because I should not like to see him take the blame. I am sure the Minister can give that assurance even though he cannot give the names of the people who will eventually form the committee.

I do not believe that this committee will really stabilise the prices of the necessaries of life for the people of this country. Unless we proceed to grow the necessaries of life for man and beast, in so far as it is possible to do so, we cannot continue to control the prices. For instance, we are importing maize. The price of maize has gone up by one third in the past couple of months—possibly, again, as a result of the Korean War—I do not know. It has gone up from £18 a ton to £27 a ton: that is, by a third. We have heard numerous statements by various people to the effect that the price of eggs will come down from 3/- per dozen to 2/- per dozen: that means a reduction in the price of eggs. As long as that situation exists and, at the same time, the price of raw materials continues to increase, we cannot hope to maintain the cost of living at a reasonable point.

I believe that all we can expect from this committee is that it will have a very bad effect: the best, I think, they can hope to do is to poke their noses into the affairs of the manufacturers and business people of this country. According to the statements of the Parliamentary Secretary in the other House, it will be within the powers of the Minister to get from those people—whether they be manufacturers, wholesalers or retailers— confidential information. We are told in the next breath that the Minister can, and probably will, pass on that information to this committee. If he does not do that, the committee will have no business in being there. If he does pass on the information, then, according to the rules setting up this committee, it will have a right to publish these statements—statements which, in the first instance, were made to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, or his deputy, in confidence. That will not make for the better working of industry in this country and, therefore, I am against the adoption of any such methods.

This Government, composed as it is of five or six or seven Parties—I do not know how many—including the Independents, mar dheadh, could not possibly carry out the promises which they made. One Party promised to reduce the cost of living and another Party promised that if they were elected, or elected as individuals, in so far as they could do so, they would reduce taxation. That policy has been carried out, in so far as it was possible to carry out a policy to please the numerous political Parties, but the only way in which it was possible to do so was to continue to borrow. The Government have had to continue to borrow instead of tackling the situation seriously, and they have borrowed more than any other country of the size of this country could possibly carry. I believe that it is a crazy policy. I appeal to the Government not to continue to evade their responsibility by appointing such committees as is proposed under this Bill. I appeal to the Government to tackle the situation seriously and to set about correcting some of the mistakes which they must surely know they have made. For instance, if the Minister for Defence realises now that he was wrong in his attitude towards the building up of our Army, I appeal to him to admit his mistake and to set about correcting it immediately. Anybody can make a mistake—that is, anybody but Senator Baxter.

Comment on this

Our defences are stronger to-day than they were in your time.

Comment on this

"Our defences are stronger to-day than they were in your time." Nobody knows that better than Senator Baxter. He was part of the defence of this country at that time. You cannot eliminate a man like Senator Baxter and say that the defences of the country are still the same.

I do not think it is unreasonable for anybody, whether he be an individual outside this House, a member of this House, or a Minister to say: "Well, we based our policy on the hypothesis of peace. We thought that the situation would continue to improve in Korea, as it seemed it would in the early stages. We now find that we were wrong. We did not build on the Chinese coming into the picture. We were wrong. Also, we made certain statements in the past—some of them, probably, for political reasons." Be big enough to admit that you made these statements and that you made these mistakes. Be big enough to admit how wrong you were when you accused Deputy Seán Lemass of graft when he filled the Phænix Park with coal and turf. Be big enough to admit that you should not have accused various other people of graft because they did things which they believed it was necessary for them to do in the interests of this country. Be big enough to adopt the plans which were laid on the tables of Government Buildings when you took over office and in that way put this country into the position in which it should be, namely, of being capable of defending itself in case of emergency. Big enough to come out into the open and to apologise, as you must have done—bunch of craw-thumpers that you are—when you went to confession. Admit that you were wrong. I may say that I do not mind fellows being craw-thumpers—lest that reference of mine might be deemed by one of the pillars of the Church, Senator Baxter, an irreligious statement. This Government got into office on false promises and I say that 75 per cent. of them are a bunch of craw-thumping gangsters, and nothing else.

Comment on this

With the exception of his last few remarks, I thoroughly enjoyed hearing Senator Quirke in action and in his old form again. I imagine that most members of the House will agree with me. It is a pleasure to hear him leading the Opposition. I do not propose to follow him in detail, but I would remind the House that, first of all, he told us that the present Government was about to commit suicide and, later on in his speech, he said that it had committed suicide. He then continued as if he believed that the Government had committed suicide. He followed up—as he used to when he was sitting on this side of the House—by defending the late Government and he did that for at least half of his speech. I do not blame him at all for doing so, particularly if he believes his own earlier remarks. I am very tempted, though I do not think I shall yield to the temptation, to follow up his references to a tribunal which the previous Government proposed to set up under a Bill that did not become law—except to say that not a single argument that he put forward against the proposed tribunal under this Bill did not apply equally, if not more so, to the proposal that was contained in the previous Bill. However, I do not want to follow that line in any great detail.

As the Minister pointed out, this is a comparatively simple Bill, but it provides us with an opportunity to discuss a great number of important questions. However, I do not think that that means that we should discuss everything that has happened in the past. The Bill itself continues certain emergency powers which this Government and its predecessors believed to be necessary, and, in addition, it gives the Government power to provide by Order for the establishment of bodies to advise in the exercise of the powers which are continued under the provisions of the Bill. I do not think that any member of this House would take the responsibility of refusing these powers to the Government under present circumstances. There is a restriction as to what the body can do and it is certainly clear that it is to advise in relation to the powers which this Bill gives the Government.

A few days ago I was looking through some old correspondence, and I found a letter from the late Deputy Bryan Cooper, dated December, 1925, in which he asked me to speak at a meeting which he had invited his constituents to attend. He said he would be very glad if I could speak, and that he proposed to discuss the cost of living and tariffs. I could not attend the meeting, so I do not know what he said, but I have a shrewd suspicion that a discussion on the cost of living 25 years ago was not so very different from the kind of discussion we have to-day.

In spite of what has been said by some speakers, I am satisfied that, for a period of about two years, up to July or August last, retail prices remained reasonably stationary. There was a slight rise in the retail price of some articles and a slight fall in other prices. If we could only have maintained that position, I believe we could have looked forward to a period of increasing prosperity for all classes. Since mid-summer there, has been a serious rise in the price of a large number of important commodities, and it is only partly shown in to-day's retail prices.

Some of us who are connected with trade or industry, where orders have to be placed a long time before the delivery date, are very seriously perturbed at the effect which increased prices may have on our whole economy. Personally, I have been bitterly disappointed at the discussions in the Dáil, and that applies, to a considerable extent, to the discussions in the newspapers. There has been far too great a tendency to talk what is only Party politics, and to mix it with irresponsible charges against trade and industry. In my considered opinion, there is no person, or group of persons in this country, who can be blamed for the sudden and serious increase in price levels. I am satisfied that the main causes are the after-effects of devaluation and the international situation as a result of unexpected developments in Korea. The "cold war" suddenly developed into a threat of actual war, and the decision of many nations to re-arm caused unexpected shortages in many goods.

This has created serious difficulties for every democratic country. One would almost think, judging by some of our debates, that Ireland was alone in having its economy upset by an increase in world price levels. Unfortunately, a small country like Ireland can do very little to improve the international situation. I think the only sensible thing that we can do is to face the situation calmly without internal strife or bitterness, and see what we can do so that our people will suffer as little as possible. If we were involved in an actual war, all classes would undoubtedly co-operate in the national interest. I seriously suggest to the House that we, against our will, are involved in a situation that is mainly caused by war and by preparations for war, and that we should regard it as a serious national problem which should be met in the same spirit as if we were at war.

When a general rise takes place in world prices, there is very little indeed that any one Government can do about it. Our Government does not fix the price of most raw materials and, with the best will in the world, it cannot reduce them. The most the Government can do is to see what steps can be taken to prevent some individuals from gaining an unfair advantage at the expense of others, and to see, as far as possible, that our home production is kept at the highest possible level. If we are going to dissipate our energies by calling each other names, and if everyone fights only for himself and for his own interest, the people are bound to suffer. There is always the danger that groups of persons with large financial resources may look after their own interests at the expense of the rest of the people. This applies quite as much, in my opinion, to powerful and wealthy trade unions as it does to well-organised and rich businesses. While I agree that, under present circumstances, it may be necessary to have State controls of various kinds, I do not believe that State control by itself can solve our problems or our immediate difficulties. We cannot ignore the possibility of State interference, but if it is not the result of a carefully thought out policy it may make matters worse instead of better, and may defeat its own purpose.

If there is a sudden rise in prices, serious difficulties are created for every class of the community. These are felt by everybody except, possibly, by rich individuals or very powerful companies. There are only very few such companies in Ireland, and, as compared with other countries, we have comparatively few rich individuals. But we must not overlook the fact that the hardships due to rising prices are felt more acutely by persons of the lower income class, especially those with families who have no savings and who have to buy necessities at current prices from week to week. They are also felt acutely by small businesses which have not the capital to cope with the higher price levels and which find expenses rising, without any means of increasing profits to meet them.

I would like to suggest that, in facing this problem, we should take an overall view of the situation. In considering the cost of living, important as it is, we must not forget that the maintenance of the standard of living is even more important. Low cost-of-living figures do not necessarily mean a high standard of living. Many of us can remember the period, between the two wars, when prices fell and there was widespread unemployment. To maintain a reasonable standard of living there must be steady employment, regular wages and people must be able to obtain the things they need. It would be quite useless to fix prices at a level which would stop imports of necessities and raw materials for industry at a time when everyone knows that many of these goods are becoming scarce.

I think that the first duty of the Government, the overriding duty of the Government, is to do all in its power to maintain home production of every kind at the highest possible level and to secure the imports which are necessary to our economy. But, no matter what steps the Government may take, it will fail if it does not receive the co-operation of all classes of the people. Next to the danger of being involved in war, I believe that the danger of a fall in production and consequent unemployment is our greatest immediate danger. After all, we cannot share what we have not got, and if we allow our agricultural or industrial production to fall, there will be less to go round. I think we must face up to the fact that, until we can know exactly how the international situation, with a vast expenditure on armaments, is going to affect our economy, there should be caution and restraint on all sides.

The rise in price levels makes inevitable a rise in the level of wages as expressed in terms of pounds, shillings and pence, and unless we can further increase our actual production, I do not believe it would be possible to have any general rise in the real value of wages. To meet increased costs there may have to be a rise in profits as expressed in terms of money, but I am satisfied that no general rise in actual profits can be justified in the next year or two except as a result of increased production. I do not think we should be unduly alarmed because there are many demands for increased wages. If, however, these demands are to be settled on the basis of the relative strength of the particular organised workers as against the relative strength or financial strength of the employers, then we should be seriously concerned, because the result on our whole economy may be disastrous. The people who most urgently need increases to meet the increased cost of living are the lower-paid workers. Strikes or lock-outs can only reduce production, which will reduce the capacity to pay wages. If comparatively well-off workers use their economic power to enforce their maximum demands it can only result in worsening the position of lower-paid workers.

Every demand for increased wages should be considered on its merits. There is no general rule which can be applied all round. During the next year, the Labour Court may have a difficult period and I believe it will play an even more important part in our national economy than it has in the past. It is reasonable that the public should expect, particularly in a situation of this kind, both employers and workers to accept the recommendations of the court as a general rule and that they should not be rejected except in very exceptional circumstances. In making its recommendations, the Labour Court has to take into consideration not only the position of workers and of the trade or industry concerned. It has also to consider the effect of increased prices on the public generally.

In considering the general question of prices and profits, certain speakers have indulged in wild generalisations which can do a great deal of harm under the present circumstances. It is simply not true to suggest that our present difficulties have been caused because Irish manufacturers and traders generally are fleecing the public. I know that this is not true of all manufacturers and I do not believe it is true of the majority. If excessive profits are being made in some cases, by all means get after them, but do not make the mistake of thinking, as some people seem to think, that Irish manufacturers suddenly started profiteering in July and August last and that that is the cause of the price rise with which we are very much concerned. Whatever profiteering there may or may not have been—I think it has been nothing like what people believe—certainly did not suddenly start then. Our problem cannot be solved by that kind of wild talk, which only tends to injure those of our manufacturers—and they are many—who are doing their best to serve the public in very difficult circumstances.

Too many people already think that when prices rise it must be due to profiteering somewhere in this country. It is a mistake to assume that high prices and high profits necessarily go together. The aim of every responsible manufacturer is to reduce prices and increase overall, profits through increased production. I wish it were possible to obtain figures to show the percentage of the price of each article of common use made in Ireland which represents manufacturers' profit. In the business of which I have personal knowledge the percentage is very low. It is quite possible to have high prices and low profits or no profits at all. It is by no means unusual to find that companies who sell at low prices make very good profits. The two are not necessarily related. Factors which can cause prices to be high are many and various. They include high cost of basic raw materials, production on too small a scale to be economic, inefficiency of management or of operatives, low output per worker, high cost of distribution, etc., etc. I need not go into all the details in order to demonstrate that each case must be considered separately on its merits and cannot be dealt with by generalities such as are becoming too common to-day. It is also true that high prices can be caused by too little capital and not enough profits to keep machinery and plant in a high state of efficiency. Too low profits can be just as injurious to our national economy as excessive profits.

The control of prices by the State is not the simple matter that some people would have us believe. If it is not done scientifically with full consideration of all the circumstances it can do very great harm. If prices fixed are too low it may result in the virtual disappearance of the articles from the market as manufacturers and traders cannot and will not continue to sell at a loss. It may also result in unemployment. If the price fixed is too high it may cause the public to pay more than they would pay in open competition. To be really satisfactory and fair, price controls should be revised every few months to allow for changes in costs and overheads, either upwards or downwards. This is, of course, quite impracticable. To do so would require an enormous staff of experts.

It has been suggested that the Government should immediately freeze all prices. In my opinion such a step would have disastrous results, and I was glad to see that the Tánaiste, in his speech in the Dáil, recognised the difficulty. It would only be practicable to make a standstill Order on commodities which are entirely produced in this country and not in any way affected by the prices of imports. I do not know whether there are any. When prices began to rise, most manufacturers placed orders for raw-materials at prices which showed an increase but which are now much lower than current prices. For many commodities which we import orders have to be placed nine to 12 months in advance. A price stand still Order suddenly imposed on everything, as some people have suggested, would mean the cancellation of these orders until the Government fixed an increased price. The suppliers outside Ireland in nearly every case I know of would be only too delighted to cancel the orders as they can easily sell their full production elsewhere or get more orders from us when we come back into the market. No one with a full knowledge of the situation would think of cancelling these orders which could only result in unemployment in 1951.

The position is very much the same in the distributive trades which deal partly or wholly in imported goods. They have placed orders ahead which if cancelled could only be replaced at higher prices later on. I am quite convinced that a general freeze of all prices is not practical politics and would only defeat its own purpose. It may be possible to make a standstill Order for some articles but every case would have to be considered on its merits. This is a highly complicated problem and there is no short-cut or general principle which can be applied all round.

We hear a great deal about excessive profits and there is a demand for an excess profits tax. I have not yet met anyone who can give me an adequate definition of what are excessive profits. As far as I can see, the general attitude is that excess profits are the profits which everyone else is making except yourself.

The late Government imposed an excess corporation profits tax during the emergency. This proved a most inequitable tax and I do not believe any responsible company would stand over its reimposition in anything like its old form. The underlying principle of the excess corporation profits tax was that if a company was profiteering before the war it could go on profiteering forever; and, if a company was making inadequate profits before the war, it must not exceed a certain statutory standard which every accountant that I know of regarded as much too low for safety. Before excess profits can be taxed fairly and equitably without injury to industrial production here, it will be necessary to arrive at some agreed standard as to what is a necessary and proper profit. You cannot tax excessive profits without some standard as to what are reasonable profits. An adequate profit for industry is just as essential to the future economy of the country as is an adequate standard of wages. I regard both as essential. One cannot hope for successful industrial development unless we can get fair wages and fair profits. State owned industries may perhaps run at a loss for a few years, but they cannot do it forever. Private enterprise cannot carry on without a profit and very few private companies can survive a loss even over a period of two or three years.

On several occasions here I have urged the Minister for Finance to set up an expert committee, inclusive of businessmen and accountants, as well as officials, to consider and report on the amendments required in the income-tax code with special reference to the method of assessing business profits. No company could continue in a state of efficiency if it only made profits on the basis on which it is assessed for income-tax. I dealt with my reasons at length for the appointment of such a committee on two occasions. I shall not take up the time of the House now by repeating them again, except to urge upon the Government that it should seriously consider the early appointment of some such committee. If the position should get worse and if it should become necessary by means of taxation to tax profits that taxation should be made on a practicable basis and we should not be faced with some sudden ad hoc legislation which would be almost certain to be inequitable.

I am still strongly of the opinion that there should be a distinction made between profits distributed to shareholders and profits bona fide retained for use in business which, if properly used, should increase efficiency with consequent larger output and more employment. It is not easy to decide what is a fair distribution of profit to shareholders. People will not risk their money in the ordinary shares of industrial companies if they cannot hope for a reasonably good return should the company prove successful. All political Parties are agreed that there is room for further industrial development. But this will require capital and, if prices go on rising, it will require much more capital than heretofore. I think we are all agreed that we want to see Irish capital invested at home. I wish it were possible to obtain reliable information as to the extent to which small investors have invested their savings in Irish companies. I have no definite data to go on, but I have seen some lists of shareholders and I am inclined to think that the smaller investors show much more faith in their own country and its prospects than do the people with large sums invest. Now, if I am right in that, and I think I am, these small investors are just as likely to be hit by increased prices as any other section of the community, and we shall always have to think twice before we step in and take action to reduce their incomes.

The Government proposes to appoint an advisory body with an independent chairman and representatives of consumers and business. They may possibly appoint more than one advisory body. The value of such an advisory body, or bodies, will almost entirely depend on the personnel and the discretion and common sense that that body exercises in carrying out its duties. I can think of a lot of information which could not be made public without doing a great deal of harm. The suggestion, for instance, that the profits of a group of industries should be published might be grossly unfair to the more efficient members of the group. I sincerely hope that the Government will be successful in finding people with the necessary experience and ability.

The public must not expect this new advisory body to work miracles in a few weeks but, slowly and steadily, it may be able to gain public confidence if it publishes such facts as can suitably be given to the public as the reasons for price changes. There is quite a lot of information which I think could usefully be given to the public, information which they do not usually get at the present time. This information can be and is occasionally given by individual manufacturers, but I doubt if people believe it. As an instance of what I have in mind, I think it would be useful if the public knew what proportion of the selling-price of articles in common use is represented by raw materials, what percentage is represented by salaries and wages, what percentage is represented by overhead charges and what percentage by taxation. I think all that would be information which, perhaps not in every case, but certainly in some cases, might be wisely and usefully given. I certainly do not know of any reason why the public should not know what percentage of the cost of manufacture is represented by distributive profits and what percentage by profits that are retained in the business as reserves or for some other reason.

Prices can best be controlled by free competition. Where the Government is satisfied that open competition exists I think they may do more harm than good in fixing prices. The attention of the new advisory body should, at any rate in the first instance, be directed to goods where competition is limited as a result of shortage, tariffs, import restrictions or for some other causes. We all know that rightly or wrongly the public is not satisfied with the present system of price control. This is so mainly because they know very little about it. For that reason I think the Government had no option but to appoint some new body. I imagine that one of the first duties of the new body will be to examine the present price control machinery. I would like, therefore, to say a word or two about the general charge that is made that price controls are not being enforced at the present time. I do not believe that is true to any great extent. There are three methods of price control: one is to fix the maximum wholesale and retail prices of certain goods and publish those prices; another, which is, I think, normal in the case of manufacturers, is to fix the over-all annual profit which will be permitted, and a third is to fix the maximum percentage of profit over cost for both the wholesale and the retail trade. I have only a limited knowledge of the working of the over-all profit system, but I do know that the prices branch closely watches the profits of every manufacturer that I know of or have spoken to and endeavours to keep those manufacturers' prices as low as oracticable. In the case of marginal profits, my experience is that these controls are definitely being carried out, and I would point out to the House that, no trader who employs a number of persons can take profits in excess of the permitted margin without the collusion of his employees. Irish manufacturers have to, and do, mark the controlled price on the goods they supply, and it would be quite impracticable to alter these prices without the knowledge of the employees except perhaps in a very small business employing only one or two persons. I do not believe there is any such collusion.

The system of marginal profit control may be in some cases the only practicable method but it is not wholly satisfactory and has a tendency to operate in favour of people who have money as against the poorer classes. Before the last war, it was a normal practice in the lower class drapery trades to take a very low rate of profit on the cheapest articles and to make up for these by a higher rate of profit on more expensive goods. Under the present system of control, the percentage margin is the same on all kinds of goods. It is not easy to see how this can be remedied but it is not wholly satisfactory. It also leads to great variations in price levels, with resultant dissatisfaction to the public, as it is not permissible to average costs—and probably it is right that it should not be, having regard to all the difficulties—so as to sell articles at a fixed price over a period of time.

As an illustration of what I have in mind, I shall take the case of woollen blankets which have risen to almost prohibitive prices in a few months' time. Orders for blankets placed last spring for delivery in the early autumn were accepted at reasonable prices. Prices had risen some what even then, and traders generally were unwilling to order large quantities in the hope that prices might fall. I have not met any one manufacturer or trader in Ireland who guessed what was going to happen in mid-summer with regard to wool. When they came to place further orders for later delivery, they had to pay steep increases in price. If there had been no price control, most traders would have averaged the cost and sold all their blankets for the season at the same price. The newspapers, unfortunately, featured the spectacular rise in wool prices with the result that there was a scare and people with money rushed in and bought all the early delivery of blankets at the cheaper prices. Poorer people who had not ready cash found that prices of blankets had become almost prohibitive when they tried to buy them later on when the weather became colder. Almost the same thing happened in the case of knitting wool. There was a panic and retail shops were cleared in a very short time of the stocks they had bought at lower prices.

In this connection, I should like to suggest to the new advisory body when it is appointed that it is not always wise to inform the public of rises in raw materials until after these rises are shown actually in the retail prices. There is always the danger of panic buying by people with more money than consideration for the public interest. In conclusion, I should like to make it quite clear that I welcome the proposal to appoint a new advisory body, if only for the purpose of a new examination of price-control machinery. I am not satisfied that they are going to make very drastic changes, but I think the result will be that the public will know a good deal more about the price-control machinery that is being operated and that they will have more reason to believe that it is in operation. I do not believe that this new body can reduce prices generally, unless and until the whole world situation improves, but it may, and I hope it will, be able to prevent individuals from taking an unfair advantage of the abnormal situation for their own private advantage. I think we may as well face the fact that this new body will have the unpleasant task of sanctioning further increased prices in many cases because there are many manufacturers and traders who cannot pay increased wages and meet increased costs without increasing prices. It is not altogether popular at the moment to say this, but I believe it to be true and I think it only right that one should say so in public. The new advisory body will have enormous responsibility. It is not only going to advise on prices, but the advice which it gives on prices, if adopted by the Government, may also fix the standard of wages and may further influence the extent of employment. These three things are so closely allied that you cannot separate them. I would suggest to the House that this whole problem of prices, wages and employment is so serious and so difficult that in order to be fair to all classes, all Parties should enter into a solemn pact and say: "No matter who is in power, we should take this matter out of Party politics and see if it is not possible to combine and make a success of it."

Comment on this

At the outset, I should like to say that I agree with 95 per cent. of what Senator Douglas has said. I would even go further and make one recommendation and that is, to advise the Clerk of the Seanad to send a copy of the Senator's speech to a few particular Ministers. It may have a very useful effect. The Bill before the House to-night asks that powers given to the then Government some 11 years ago be continued in operation. It is not a new measure in any way. It is merely continuing the powers which were given to the former Government 11 years ago. We must regret that after 11 years the present Government has found it necessary to come before the House and ask for a continuation of these powers. As Senator Douglas has referred to the cost of living and particularly to the effect of rising costs on the weaker sections of the community, it may be no harm for a few moments to go back and see how the powers given to the Government during the emergency were operated. There was price control then and we well remember the many complaints that were made, both in this and the other House, as to the drastic manner in which these controls were enforced. We saw objection taken to the appointment of the necessary inspectors to carry out the orders. We saw objection to the necessary steps taken by the then Government to give effect to the controls. We had protests against the fact that people were being taken to court. We had protests at their being taken to a particular court because of the nature of their offences. While Senator Douglas also stated that price control, no matter how operated, particularly in a time of scarcity of commodities, is not going to have the effect of satisfying all sections, it is well to remember that steps were also taken to assist in another way the weaker sections of our people. Large sums were spent on the subsidisation of foodstuffs. Special provision was made whereby the weaker sections, old age pensioners, widows and orphands, recipients of national health insurance and unemployment insurance or recipients of assistance of any kind from the State would get, in addition to the normal ration, a special allowance of bread, butter, tea, sugar and other rationed commodities. That was considered a better way of dealing with the position at that time than cash payments. I think the majority of the members of this House will agree with me that it was.

There was a very experienced staff in the Department of Industry and Commerce dealing with the question of price control. I am not saying, and I do not think that those who were in charge would say, that it was perfect, I am sure that the Minister responsible for setting up this advisory council will not be foolish enough to claim that it will give satisfaction to all people. Price control was in operation. The Parliamentary Secretary, when introducing the Bill in the Dáil, indicated that it was necessary that the Government should have powers to continue and to give effect to the rationing of certain commodities.

I want to avail of this opportunity to place on record again my objection to the dual price system adopted by the Government in respect of bread, tea, butter and sugar. It has been argued in public and in private by those who accept that policy that it is a policy of extracting from the rich the money to subsidise food for the poor and the working class. I would put it this way: We all agree that it is the working class and the middle class in general who have the largest families in this country and who are, therefore, the greatest consumers of the commodities that I have mentioned. That being so, the second price payable for bread, tea, sugar and butter must have a greater effect on their cost of living than on the cost of living of the section of the community which is supposed to be paying this extra contribution. It is a bad principle for a Government to enforce. If there are supplies available of bread, tea, sugar and other commodities that are rationed, there should be equal distribution of these commodities, at the same price, between all sections of our people.

When the previous Government were in power and were inviting tourists to this country, it was pointed out by the people who were in opposition then that the Government were making available to tourists supplies of food that should be reserved for our own people and were inducing foreigners to come in and consume them. That was held to be a bad thing. If that was a bad thing, I suggest that the system of making these commodities available to our own people at two prices, certainly, is bad.

Senator Baxter interjected when Senator Quirke was referring to the commodities that are on ration. The same interrjections were made in the Dáil and I expected that they would be made here. They were to the effect that while the present Opposition were in office, rationing was of a more severe nature and that there is now a more plentiful supply of bread, butter, tea and, in particular, sugar. That is no argument. During the war years, bread was not rationed in this country and it was only on the termination of the war, when and attempt was being made by all European nations to assist those who needed assistance, that it was found necessary to ration bread in this country. We have had a statement from the Parliamentary Secretary and from various members of the Government that there was never a greater supply of wheat and other commodities in this country than there is at the present time. If that is the case, the dual price system should be abolished.

If the principal reason advanced by the Minister for the passing of this Bill is that it is in order that the Government should have power to continue in force the present rationing system, we should have it clear from the Government that it is their policy to continue the present schemes in relation to these commodities, no matter what the supply position is. If that is so, I would suggest that it would be better that this Bill should not pass but that we should ask the Government to bring in two separate measures, one giving them the powers they seek to continue the scheme that they believe in, and a separate Bill setting up the advisory council that is suggested in this measure. I put it to the House that it is a bad thing to incorporate in a measure of this kind just one section and to ask this House to pass the Bill containing that one section without giving an opportunity to members of Parliament of giving their views on the type of organisation that should be set up, the powers that should be given to that organisation and to discuss what their functions in general would be. We cannot do that on this Bill because all we are doing is giving power to the Minister to set up an advisory council or councils.

The Minister put forward many very valid reasons for the setting up of this council, but it is an extraordinary thing that this proposal should come before the—House at the end of term and on the eve of the adjournment of this House and of Parliament. The public and the Government are well aware that there has been a tendency to rises, in prices over a considerable time, that no steps have been taken by the Government, if they could have been taken, to control or to stop these rises in prices. During the last year or one and a half years, many controls have been removed. I think the controls have been removed in respect of about 30 articles. In almost every case where control was removed, the effect was that there was a rise in price. It may be suggested that that is an argument in favour of the continuation of control. I think the Minister referred to that in his statement and he pointed out that prices did rise when controls were removed. If the Government were serious in the control of prices, surely, in cases of that kind, the thing to do would be to reimpose the controls. It should not be necessary to wait 18 months for the setting up of this council, so that the council would advise the Minister as to whether controls should be reimposed or not. I do not wish to detain the House in going over lists. There was a fairly lengthy discussion on this matter in the Dáil. I say that, if the effect of removing control was an increase in price, the controls should have been reimposed.

I would like to have from the Minister a clearer explanation as to how the advisory council will work. The last day we met we gave final approval to a Bill setting up another body. Many of the powers given to that body, the Industrial Development Authority, are powers that must be given to this new body that the Government propose to set up. When the Industrial Development Authority give their approval for the imposition of a certain tariff, I wonder must they go before the advisory council and give evidence as to why a certain Order was made and stress the advisability of making it? If that is not so, I do not see how this proposal is going to work.

Certain charges have been made—I think this matter was referred to by the Minister, and also by Senator Douglas—against our industrialists. No less a person than the Tánaiste quite recently made very grave charges against those engaged in Irish industry, charges that are not well founded, charges that are bound to have a serious effect on industrial development. If the people who put their money into Irish industry are going to be accused, as they have been by the Tánaiste, then, to say the least of it, there will not be much encouragement for people to become in any way associated with Irish industry.

Charges have also been levelled against wholesale and retail traders. It is time that somebody uttered a word of appreciation for the services rendered, particularly during the emergency years, by these sections of our people. It would have been impossible to give effect to the controls necessary at that time were it not for the wholehearted co-operation given by those in the wholesale and retail trades, by those connected with the commercial life of the country generally. The operation of controls puts a grave responsibility and much additional work and worry on those engaged in the retail trade, and it is not at all fitting for a Minister to say that they have lined their pockets at the expense of the weaker sections of the people and that each and every person engaged as an industrialist or connected with the commercial life of the country should be put into separate cells in Mountjoy. Statements of that kind coming from responsible persons do not offer any encouragement and it would be well, even at this late stage, if the Minister advised his colleagues, when they are tempted to make such statements, to refrain from doing so.

The Minister gave, as reasons for the increase in prices of various commodities recently, the war in Korea and devaluation. It is an extraordinary thing that when devaluation was first agreed to we were told by the Minister then responsible that it would have no effect.

Comment on this

No immediate effect.

Comment on this

I remember hearing certain statements here and I was almost convinced that it was going to be one of the greatest benefits ever conferred on this country.

Comment on this

Either the Senator did not hear me properly or I did not make my statement sufficiently clear. I pointed out that in spite of devaluation and the early period of the war in Korea, the cost-of-living index figure had been held firmly, although there was partial war production; but in the last couple of months the whole world had swung towards total war production and away from normal domestic economy and, as a result, there was an increase.

Comment on this

We were told by the Minister for Agriculture that so far as the needs of the farming community were concerned, in the matter of fertilisers and maize, there would be no scarcity. Speaking in County Galway he assured the farmers in this manner:—

"I as Minister for maize can guarantee to the farmers of this country that there will be no increase as regards maize and that they will have an abundance, more than they will require, and I hope to encourage them in every way in its use."

He did the same in connection with fertilisers.

On that point, we have heard the Minister abusing the people engaged in the sale and distribution of fertilisers. Every attempt was made to create in the minds of the people the belief that these merchants were making such great profits out of the farming community that steps should and would be taken by the Government to control the business entirely.

We had the Minister for Industry and Commerce referring to the cement industry. For a period of three years the Minister has failed to make up his mind on the subject of cement. He has failed to give the necessary guidance to the factories engaged in the manufacture of cement; he has failed to indicate what should be done to provide this country with an adequate supply of cement. The position is that there is a subsidy being paid by the Irish people of 15/-per ton for foreign cement. Because of lack of direction from the Minister, the cement company is not in a position to go ahead either with an enlargement of the existing factories or the building of an additional factory.

When some of us on this side of the House not so very long ago reminded the Government that the interational situation was serious, we were accused of raising the bogey-man of war and were told that we were doing it for a political purpose. We were told we should direct the people's minds to peace and that we should not be distracting them by talking of war or preparations for war. Now we are told the position is serious, but we cannot elicit from the Government what steps they are taking to make the necessary provisions to meet an emergency.

I have referred to fertilisers and cement, but there are many other activities in relation to which we could have progressed if various Ministers had only stopped talking about them. It would not have been necessary for the Minister for Agriculture to have taken any step in relation to the matters I have referred to if only he did not abuse the people engaged in industry, people who were doing their best to get the necessary supplies.

We were fold that those engaged in the flour-milling industry were lining their pockets at the public expense, that a great scandal would one day be unfolded, and action would be taken to recover whatever amount was involved and that the people concerned would be dealt with in the way any Government should deal with them.

Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7 p.m.

Comment on this

When adjourning, I was referring to the charges that had been made against the flour and milling industry, arising out of which a commission was appointed under the chairmanship of Senator Lavery. We looked forward to finding in that body's report some substantiation of the charges made, but having received a copy of it during the last few days we have failed to see in it any substantiation whatever. Here again the bubble has been burst that that section of the community were lining their pockets at public expense. The same is true of the various other industries. Persons in responsible positions, who are for the time being in charge of the destinies of this country, should bear that in mind and should be more careful in their statements. Those engaged in Irish industry are not foreigners: they are public-spirited Irish people who have invested their money here and provided employment for our people, at the same time producing the many articles we require.

The same is also true of the charges that the products of Irish industry are inferior to the imported article. On various occasions here we have had criticism and suggestions that because Irish industry is given protection there is a certain amount of what one might term carelessness about their products. Last week, the Minister said here that it was no harm to be urging them on and to be criticising. If the criticism is not well founded, it will have the opposite effect to what the Minister might desire. During the last few weeks, we have seen more than one Minister make statements in the Dáil against those engaged, in industry—at a time when we were passing a Bill here to set up an organisation to develop Irish industry. If there is any doubt created in the minds of those who would put in their money, or if suspicion is created that certain members of the Government look very unfavourably on their activities, it will not encourage them but will deter them from going ahead with many projects. More care should be exercised in this respect. If any encouragement can be given or any suggestion made to any particular industry as to how the industry can be run with greater benefit to the community, that is all right; but we should not go out and launch from the house tops a condemanation of the very thing we are trying to develop. The Minister stated that there was a crisis probably around the corner but I am sure that the House and the country at large would welcome some statement from the Minister to-night as to what preparation has been made to meet that crisis. In the greater part of the country at the present time there is a crisis. There is a transport crisis on the one hand and there is a fuel crisis on the other.

We on this side of the House, drew the attention of the Government and of the Ministers as they came before us, as we got the opportunity, to the urgency of providing fuel for our people. We urged the Government to proceed as fast as possible with turf production. Some suggestion has been made that the fall in production is due on the one hand to it not being found possible to get sufficient men on the bogs, and that excuse is coupled with weather conditions. Neither is correct. The position in regard to fuel production has been this—one of the first acts of the present Government was to cancel or drop the hand-won turf scheme. That was to be substituted by a machine-won scheme. Bord na Móna were to take over production formerly carried out by the county councils and as far as possible that production was to be in the nature of machine-won turf. What really happened, particularly in the area with which I am familiar, was that no less than 38 hand-won machines—machines. that were in operation the previous. year—in the first week of January of last year were cancelled out and not put into production at all. So, no matter how the weather came, the machine-won turf scheme in Galway, Kerry and Mayo was dropped.

The second excuse made by the Government is that the labour was not there to cut the turf. During the emergency the previous Government, in order that the turf producers would be retained during the winter months in the turf district, made provision that they would receive some little cash allowance to encourage them to stay in these particular districts. With the dropping of the hand-won turf scheme and the failure to provide alternative employment, there was emigration on a very large scale from the turf-producing districts and when a person, a family man, in particular, was forced to emigrate it meant very little to him whether it was to Scotland, Wales or Kildare. He had an idea that the conditions of employment, probably the working conditions in general and the wages, would be more attractive across the water. But once he was forced to leave his own little homestead he thought at least he would get better conditions.

I have here a table of figures that I took down some time ago. They are not up-to-date but they are useful to prove that we have had serious emigration from the particular areas. The figures are issued by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Travel permits issued, 1948, 40,076 persons; 1949, 25,000; from 1st January to end March this year 4,873. I have not the figures for the remainder of the year but the total of the figures I have mentioned amounts to 70,000 odd. I think the Minister and the members opposite will admit that the majority of the persons who were issued with travel permits to find employment abroad were from the turf-producing areas.

The next excuse given by the Government is that there was no market for the turf. That excuse was given in the other House a short time ago. The Government, if it were interested in the development of fuel resources to ensure that our people would have supplies when necessary, should have encouraged and should have taken steps to see that particularly the institutions under Government control and under public control would use turf as a fuel rather than imported coal. We have a statement given, I think, by the Minister himself of the amount of coal purchased by the Army. I am not for the moment suggesting that the Army should not have a supply of coal, but I say that if they must have a supply of fuel that supply of fuel as far as possible should be our native production.

When questions were asked in the Dáil as to what was being done to procure fuel supplies and coal imports these queries were all met with the one approach—"there is going to be no shortage; there is going to be no scarcity, and there will be ample supplies". The first thing that should have been done by the Government knowing that a scarcity was in the offing was that steps should have been taken to ensure that the poorer sections of the community would have some small supplies of fuel available. For some months past we have had in some places in the country a real fuel scarcity. Some people have been lucky enough to have some stocks in previously but the poor people are left uncatered for.

There was a great deal of criticism about the supplies of coal and turf and fire blocks in the park when the present Government took over. We admit it was a liability but we said, and we say now, that it was a good insurance policy. I put it to the House that the Government should have taken our advice based on the experience of the war years, and should have taken steps to ensure that the same insurance policy would be taken out for the people of this city and the other cities of our country during the last 12 months. That has not been done, and the question to be put to the Government now is what steps they propose to take in the coming year.

You cannot start producing turf in October or November and you cannot start organising the workers in those months. It is not sufficient for the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary to say: "We propose to go ahead; we propose to ensure that steps will be taken next year and that turf production will be increased." We heard that last year and the year before, and we saw a decline each year. It is the Government's responsibility, even at this late hour, to take some steps to ensure that, when the crisis to which the Minister referred as being just around the corner comes, the country will be in a position to stand up to it in some way.

The same may be said of supplies in general. In this connection, I suggest. that the criticism levelled at our manufacturers, our wholesalers, our retailers and everybody connected with the industrial or commercial life of the country is bad at this stage. What we should be doing now is encouraging every industrialist, every importer and everybody in a position to help to get into the country as large supplies of all commodities and articles as they possibly can.

That brings me to a suggestion made by the Tánaiste last week in connection with the freezing of prices, to which Senator Douglas has referred. I do not think anybody took his statement too seriously, but it can be said that he has already succeeded in freezing quite a large section of our people who have to wait on Aston's Quay by depriving them of the accommodation they would have if he had not taken over Store Street. That is the only freezing he will succeed in doing. If threats of that kind, threats about the Government taking steps the nature of which these people do not know, are directed against that section of our people who are in a position to get in supplies, they will not put their money into the procuring of these supplies.

The public would like to know also what is the Government's policy in relation to labour disputes, pending and taking place at present. We have seen from day to day reports of meetings between various groups, presided over by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and we have read of threats of strikes and demands for increased wages, and it is up to the Government to give a lead and to avoid, so far as possible, any labour disputes which may threaten the progress we should be making in the matter of the provision of essentials for our people. As I say, we do not know what the Government is doing.

We have speakers, both inside and outside the House, referring to the position now as compared with the position which obtained during the emergency, but we must bear in mind that, at the outset of the emergency, we had not got the limited amount of shipping which we had towards the end of the emergency. We know the difficulties which attended the getting in of whatever supplies were got in—the difficulties created by having to land these supplies in Lisbon, and then bring them here and so on, and by the fact that a great part of our imports were not imported direct from the country of origin but through importers in England. We had that difficulty, particularly in regard to tea. When different speakers refer to the increased ration of tea now compared with what it was at that time, they should bear in mind the cause. That cause was the failure of the British Minister at the time to keep the agreement made with the Government here that the amount of tea necessary to provide the same ration for our people as was provided for people in England would be provided.

The questions arising out of the Bill, therefore, are, first, when did the Government decide to set up this advisory council which is proposed? Senators will remember that, when the original Bill was introduced, it contained no such provision. That Bill was withdrawn and a new Bill containing this provision introduced. The only excuse that can be put forward is that the Government were forced by pressure from various directions to recognise that there was arising throughout the country a big volume of protest against the continued rise in prices and the Minister decided to pass on his responsibility to some body of persons. When the original emergency legislation was passed, it empowered the Minister to do certain things. The Minister was the person responsible, but now the Minister, having failed to take any action for the past 18 months or two years to control or to arrest the rise in prices, has decided that an advisory council should be set up. What is that council going to do? It is going to carry out a long and detailed examination. It is to be composed of persons with a knowledge of industry and of commerce, with representatives of labour and a representative of the consumers, but there is no provision in the Bill for the taking of any active steps to control those prices which have already risen, prices which, according to the Minister, have risen since the withdrawal of the control that operated previously.

The next question is how this advisory council is going to work with the Industrial Development Authority, the setting up of which we discussed last week. This authority, as has been said already, has been in existence for 18 or 20 months. It must have carried out a number of inquiries; it must have examined all the Orders which were withdrawn and must have satisfied itself that it was necessary to withdraw these Orders or to make a new Order, and that the new Order would, of necessity, mean an increase in the price of the particular commodity. Rather than take the responsibility of making an Order increasing the price of any commodity, the Minister took the easy way out. He withdrew the Order and let the commodity rise in price and the public were given no indication whatever as to whether that rise was justified or not.

There was even a worse case, sugar. By Order, the price of sugar was increased from 7d. to 8½d. per lb. It was explained that the increase was due to an increase in the cost of freight and in the cost of the sugar. It was justified in every possible way. Off-ration sugar was increased to 8½d. and inside three weeks another Order was made reducing it by a halfpenny. The explanation was that the outlook was a bit brighter in regard to sugar. It is easy to see the difficulties and dislocations Orders of that kind may cause in business. If the price of such a commodity is either reduced or increased it should not be done without good reason and consultation with the trade concerned. Swift changes from one price to another are found to have an effect both on the public and on persons dealing in that particular commodity.

Senator Quirke stated that when the price of a number of commodities was decontrolled the price had risen. Senator Baxter queried that and asked to be told the items. It is a fairly long list but if the Senator wants the information it is no harm that he should have it. You might say perhaps that the first increase did not affect the cost of living very much. It was the increase imposed by the hero of Baltinglass, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, on postage. As a result of the bakers' strike in Dublin we had an increase in the price of bread. We had an increase in the price of meat of between a penny and twopence. We had an increase in bus fares. The price of off-ration tea was increased to 6/-. We all know how bacon went up. Other important items which increased in price were fertilisers, flakemeal which went up to 2/8 a lb., petrol which was increased by the Minister for Finance, tyres and tubes and cement which is subsidised by 15/- per ton.

Comment on this

All these articles are not controlled in price?

Comment on this

They are articles from which the control was removed by the Minister.

Comment on this

I thought some were still controlled. I do not want to interrupt; I want to be clear.

Comment on this

Each of the articles I have mentioned was previously controlled. In reply to a question in the Dáil the Parliamentary Secretary gave a list of articles from which the control was removed. The list, which is a fairly lengthy one, includes the items I have mentioned, coffee and leather and, in order that we might get some little thing out of the 70,000 people who were forced to emigrate, the fee for a passport was increased from 12/6 to £1. I suppose it was felt that they would be more comfortable if they got it at a higher price.

Comment on this

Does the Senator suggest that that increased the cost of living?

Comment on this

Surely that is a State-controlled price.

Comment on this

I realise that the facts annoy some people. Senator Baxter asked for figures; he is now getting them and he does not like them too well.

Comment on this

Does that affect the cost-of-living figure?

Comment on this

The cost-of-leaving figure.

Comment on this

The item the Senator has mentioned does not affect the cost-of-living figure.

Comment on this

It affects the people whom the nation is sacrificing. After all the promises we heard, 70,000 people were forced to emigrate and find employment abroad; 59,000 are drawing unemployment assistance at the present time. Promises were made, not to keep the cost of living at its existing figure, but to reduce it by no less than 30 per cent. When confirmation is sought of the fact that not alone has the Government failed to reduce the cost of living, as it promised, but has allowed it to increase——

Comment on this

That is no confirmation.

Comment on this

They have adopted the means of withdrawing control so that the Minister need not assume the responsibility of having the price of these articles increased. I assume that the increases could be justified and that there was some reason for them when the control was removed, but the Minister did not take the responsibility which he would have had to bear if he made an Order permitting an increase in the price of the article.

Will Senator Baxter agree that the price of clothes form some little part of the cost of living and that when a man has a large family he must provide boots, clothing and all other necessaries? We know that ourselves and it is not necessary to set up a special council to tell us so. We have a commission to discover why 70,000 people went abroad. We have not heard the reasons yet but we know they have gone. We know also from experience that the price of boots, clothing and household utensils of almost every kind has increased in the last two and a half years, particularly in the last 12 months. In most households the price of oatenmeal, flakemeal, jam, butter and sugar contributes something to the cost of living and all these articles have gone up in price.

Comment on this

They have not.

Comment on this

The Senator can make his case afterwards.

Comment on this

On the 29th September, 1948, flakemeal went up by 8d. a packet.

Comment on this

What about butter?

Comment on this

Butter went up from 2/8 to 3/6 a lb.

Comment on this

Has your rationed butter price gone up?

Comment on this

Butter has gone up to 3/6 a lb. for many persons, persons who, it has been authoritatively proven to the satisfaction of Senators to-night, could not be termed under any stretch of the imagination as the rich of this country. Senator Baxter knows that as well as I do. The price of soap has gone up, and coal in this city at present is 11/6 a cwt. to the persons who can get it. During the emergency the Government subsidised fuel for the majority of our people in the city together with oatenmeal, margarine and all other commodities in general use. There is no use in Senator Baxter or anybody else suggesting that the cost of living has not increased because nobody will believe them any more than they believed the Parliamentary Secretary when he stated in the Dáil that it had not gone up. My complaint is that, having had all this information before them, the Government took no steps until almost the end of the year and, even yet, they have taken no really effective steps to curb the rise in the cost of living. All they have done is to tell us that they are going to appoint this advisory council. The advisory council will not and cannot do anything to reduce the cost of living. Probably, it will do what the Minister says it will do—that if the hearing of the evidence is in public and the interested person is making an application for an increase, which is granted, he will probably be able to find more justification for the increase. I would point out, however, that that is not taking steps to reduce the cost of living or to reduce the cost of government.

The various parties who now compose the Government told us that the cost of living and the cost of government would be reduced. On that point I should like to point out that this year we have had the greatest demand ever—it was something in the region of £20,000,000 greater than it was at the time the previous Government went out of office. On three different occasions this Government has appealed to the public in order to borrow money. Not alone were there appeals to borrow from our own people but, through Marshall Aid, a considerable amount of money has come into the hands of the Government in the past two years.

Notwithstanding all that, we have the unemployment figure to which I have already referred; emigration is still continuing and now the Minister who is responsible admits that there is a crisis round the corner. Hitherto, every opportunity was availed of to direct the minds of the people from the crisis that is now so near us. That has been the line of approach whenever we asked for information as to what was being done to combat that crisis, should it materialise, in order to be able to provide our people with the necessaries of life and to build up our defences, by preparing our people to defend themselves against whatever might come and to build up their morale.

When concluding the debate on this Bill in the Dáil, the Parliamentary Secretary, in order to get the support of the various members of the Dáil, intimidated them by saying that every member supporting the Government was elected to do one thing, namely, to keep Fianna Fáil out of office. He emphasised that they should be very careful to bear that point in mind and that any little independent action on their part—any little independent expression of their feelings or those of their constituents—might have a very serious effect. I submit that that statement is not true. I submit to the Minister and I want to have it on the records of the House that no Party in the Coalition Government, except one, informed their supporters during the election campaign that they would be prepared to enter into a Coalition or an inter-Party Government, and that one Party was the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Now let us deal with the Supplies and Services Bill. The inter-Party Government or the Parties who comprise it are not relevant now.

Comment on this

I submit that it is relevant to the Bill in so far as this Bill has been presented by a Government who made the promises I have referred to.

Comment on this

Would the Chair allow me to extend that, on a point of order?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

What is the point of order?

Comment on this

The principle which the Senator has stated. Would the Chair make a point of order about it? On Senator Hawkins's reasoning, every Bill or Order introduced by a Government could be related to advertisements and speeches made during the previous general election and all such advertisements and speeches could be read on every Bill— which, I take it, would be absurd.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Hawkins will now deal with the Bill.

Comment on this

I submit that the Minister has failed to make a case. In his opening speech he said he would only deal with that part of the Bill which related to the setting-up of the advisory council. He has failed to give us any information whatsoever as to how that council will be selected, how it will operate and what effect it will have on the job which the responsible Minister is shirking. In setting up this council, the Minister is evading his responsibility and is trying to foist it on some group of people who will be selected. He is doing so in the hope that he will thereby avoid the criticism that should justly be levelled at himself and have it directed, instead, at this new body.

Arising out of the passage of this Bill, many Orders will be made by the Government during the year. Many Orders have been made during the past year and since the powers were first given to the previous Government under the previous Act. I urge the Minister to give effect to the recommendation of the particular committee that was appointed to examine such Orders, namely, that on the face of each Order there should be some intimation as to what it relates.

Comment on this
Senators

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

From time to time various Orders are made, confirming or amending Orders. That notice conveys nothing to the people who are interested. Only last week we had an instance of the introduction of an Order which affected a particular industry. Without going to considerable trouble and looking up the various Orders, one would not know to what the new Order referred. I urge also that if the necessity to make an Order should arise, some reasons for the making of that Order should be given to the public. In that way, if the Order is necessary, it will get more support from the section of the people affected. It will lead to a better understanding as to why the Minister has found it necessary to make the Order and the people will be more cooperative in giving effect to it if they really understand its purpose.

Comment on this