Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1950—Second Stage.
Contributions 101–225 of 225. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 34 of 1950 ›
I shall endeavour to meet the Minister's wishes by confining my remarks to the particular subjects which he dealt with, namely, the prices tribunal, the rise in prices and the various problems connected with that rise in prices, how it has been caused and how, to some extent, it may be prevented from developing further. That there has been a rise in prices is undeniable. As the Minister said in introducing the Bill, that rise has principally taken place since the early autumn of this year. It is common knowledge that a rise has taken place. There is no necessity for people to labour that point. Everybody who lives in Dublin and the country is aware of it and no doubt it will be shown when the official index number for the November cost-of-living figure appears. The last published figure for August fails to show the rise because, as is generally admitted, the causes of the rise became apparent only after the date at which the figure was compiled. What was said in this debate was that these rises will continue. That seems to suggest that the rise in prices will go on getting worse. If that is so, it is a very serious position for the country. It stresses the urgency of providing some machinery, either of the kind proposed by the Minister or some other kind, for dealing with the situation.
I do not think the public generally appreciate the true magnitude of a scarcity crisis which is the result of large-scale rearmament in the biggest and richest countries in the world. There have been conditions of world-wide scarcity and of world-wide inflation, and no matter what we do in this country we cannot avoid the backwash of these great world movements. Therefore, it is a matter of major political and national importance that something should be done to try and reduce, at any rate to the minimum, the evil consequences of this trend of events which everything seems to indicate is about to occur.
There has not been, in the discussion here this evening, any reference made to matters which engaged considerable attention in the other House, namely, how far the cost-of-living index number truly reflects the rise in prices. As the matter has not been raised in the debate here, I do not propose to say very much about it. What I will say about it is that the cost-of-living index number is something really in the nature of an indicator of what has happened, and to spend public time wrangling and arguing at a time like this, when the cost-of-living index number is just a method for making a statistical measurement, would be rather as if a congress of physicists in Rome, when Rome was burning, were to enter on a discussion of the best type of thermometer for measuring the heat of the fire. We have heard of Nero being criticised for fiddling while Rome was burning. If a congress of physicists were to spend their time discussing the best type of thermometer in such a situation, I think they could be criticised for doing something which could not be said to be very helpful.
I rather thought that we would be treated to a certain amount of criticism of the cost-of-living index number. I had prepared to say certain things about it, but as the subject was not raised in the debate, all I will say is that the cost-of-living index number must not be asked to do what it never was intended to do. The cost-of-living index number is nothing more or less than an index of the retail prices of certain named commodities. It is not intended to measure the changes in the standard of living. The statisticians responsible for it would, I am sure, admit that it has a strictly limited application. It serves its purpose as far as it goes, that inside the limited field which it is intended to serve, it serves its purpose very well. There could be a very interesting academic discussion regarding the inclusion or the exclusion of certain different weights, of different cost-of-living index numbers for different localities in the country, or for different sections of the population. All these are statistical refinements which would be very welcome, no doubt, in an academic discussion; but, as I say, an academic discussion regarding the refinements of the cost-of-living index number, at a time like this, would be rather like as if physicians in a case around the bed of a patient with a raging fever were to have a discussion regarding improvements in the thermometer which would not do very much more than the less perfect clinical thermometer to lessen the patient's high fever, and which certainly would not do anything to prevent the fever getting worse or to cure it. I do not propose to say anything more about the cost-of-living index number. It was given an importance in the discussion in the other House, in the newspapers and in the country which it really did not deserve.
Of course, the significance of a rise in the cost of living, whether great or small, is that it helps certain sections of the population at the expense of others. If all prices and all incomes were to rise equally with a change in the price level, the cost of living would be a nuisance to accountants and bookkeepers, and nothing else. What makes it really significant is that it benefits certain people and injures others. The people who, it injures are those whose incomes are fixed for a shorter or a longer period in terms of monetary sums, people receiving weekly wages, people on annual salaries, people who live on old age pensions, people who live on investment income, rentiers and pensioners. They would be injured automatically, whereas people who are in a position to raise the prices of what they have to sell, possibly farmers, manufacturers and commercial people inside certain limits, they would be able to neutralise or escape to some extent, at any rate, the impact of a rise in prices.
In other words, the real significance of a change in the cost of living is that it affects, unconsciously and automatically, people without their being made aware of what is taking place. The redistribution of income makes some people better off and others worse off. I am not saying that the incomes of people should be redistributed. Every modern State does redistribute the income of the community from the rich to the poor to a greater or lesser extent. What I say is that, when a change takes place in the cost of living, it is not a conscious deliberate process. It is a by-product of something else. The direction that it takes may not be a desirable one. In other words, that instead of being a distribution of the national income in favour of the poor, a rise in the cost of living makes it much more difficult for people on a weekly wage to live. It actually redistributes the national income away from the poor in favour of the rich. In other words, it offends all the accepted canons of a desire for a redistribution of the national income.
The fact is, whether we like it or not, that from the national point of view, when the terms of trade go against us, as they have gone against us owing to a rise in import prices, the standard of living of the community as a whole must suffer in some way. There is no necessity to discuss at length why import prices have risen. The subject has been mentioned already in the course of the debate. I think people are fairly well agreed on what the causes are. Devaluation and the effects of it are now becoming apparent for the first time. Rearmament abroad, inflation abroad, the scarcity of certain raw materials, stock-piling in the United States—all these various factors have contributed to a rise in the price of all imports to this country. There has not been a corresponding rise in export prices, and, therefore, the terms of trade have moved against us. No nation can hope in an integrated world, in a dynamic world, to maintain the standard of living unchanged and insensitive to outside causes. One must accept the fact, whether one likes it or not, that in a dynamic world, in a world where there are great political and international convulsions taking place, no international price level and no national standard is safe. We have all seen the standard of living in many countries fall during the war years, while the standard of living in many countries to-day is falling during a period of rearmament, over which we in this country have no control and for which we are not responsible. The point I want to make is that, if we are going through a period of a fall in the standard of living, it is only right and equitable that that fall in the standard of living should be as far as possible equally diffused and spread over the whole population, and not confined to one class of people.
Wage earners on the whole are the first to be affected by a fall in the standard of living. At the same time, some wage earners are in a stronger position than others. In so far as any section of wage earners are in a position to raise their money wages almost automatically when the cost of living rises they are in a position to maintain their real income in spite of the change in prices. That is a very desirable position to be in.
Some people seem to accept as almost axiomatic or part of the order of nature that wages should rise every time the cost of living rises. Variations in wage rates have become so common in contracts in recent years that it is taken almost as axiomatic that when the cost of living rises there should be almost some sort of thermostatic adjustment in wage rates. Just as no nation can hope to maintain its standard of living intact, no group of labour has got any particular right in a general national crisis to maintain its standard of living at the expense of other sections of the community. Thus, it is not a national right of people who are highly organised in a trade union to vary their money income in such a way that they will always have the same real income whatever the cost of living may be.
As I said in the beginning, prices must be taken on their merits and wages must be taken on their merits too. All the factors affecting wage rates, productivity of labour, demand for products, and the purchasing power of money must be taken into account in fixing the standard of wages. If any group of labour is sufficiently strong as a result of its organisation to raise its money wages to compensate for changes in the cost of living, it is maintaining its standard of living at the expense of other sections of the population. In other words, there is a distribution of wealth between the different sections of the population not based on any particular equity or merit.
The people at whose expense this gain is obtained are, first of all, the less highly organised manual workers, and the poorer classes of workers in the unskilled trades who are not so unionised or protected. If the stronger workers succeed in getting a large part of the national cake, the poorer workers who are not so well organised must inevitably get less. People living on pensions, people who live on the social services, old people who live on small incomes, will all be poorer if certain sections of the population can push their money income up.
One class of people who were referred to in the debate in the Dáil are a class with whom I have considerable sympathy because they are amongst the citizens who return members to the Seanad. They are the white collar workers, the clerical classes and the people who, although they earn their living by the sweat of their brow, are not highly organised in trade unions. They are a section of the population who have to keep up a certain standard of expenses of a conventional kind and their incomes are very far from sufficient. Many of them pay direct taxation which is not paid by the manual worker. These people are very severely hit with the general rise in the cost of living. Other groups of the population are able to raise their money income in a way that this group is not.
Another section of the population who are injured are the farmers. I have said already that the farmers are able to shift the burden of rising prices to some extent. Irish agricultural prices have risen; Irish agricultural incomes have risen, but they have risen from a very low level. Even at present, with the rise which has taken place, the ordinary producer in Irish agriculture, whether he is a small farmer or the son of a small farmer, still enjoys a comparatively small real income compared with many sections of the urban population.
Another group of people who are injured unreasonably by action of this kind are people in the export trades. Irish wages are high compared with British wages. If Irish wages in the export trades are raised or pushed up automatically every time the cost-of-living index number shows a rise, exporters in this country will find themselves in difficulties and the balance of payments which is already in not too good a condition will further deteriorate.
Finally, in so far as the people in the highly organised skilled trades consume each other's products, to that extent the standard of living of every group of skilled workers is reduced by every rise in money income of every other group. Then we get to this vicious spiral of inflation. When wages go up, costs go up, prices go up, and then the favoured sections of the population find themselves unable to get commodities. In other words, the stability which is so much sought, and which, as I have said, is axiomatic now, is an unreal stability. That stability is referred to in an article in this week's Economist in striking words one sentence of which I shall quote:
"The stability of the wages in the skilled trades is a deceptive stability based on an ingenious statistical artifact. It is not a real stability at all because it has inside itself the seeds of its own decay."
All I have said, I think, is generally true and generally accepted—that if a group of workers tends to benefit itself owing to its superior strength by being highly unionised, it is injuring other sections of the population, the poorer workers, the white collar workers, the farmer, the people in the export trades and the people living on pensions. I think that is true. But when pressure of that kind is enforced by strike action which brings essential public utilities to a standstill or nearly to a standstill, that is a type of pressure and a type of force which amounts to an abuse of economic power.
People in this country at the present moment are pretty generally agreed that what is going on in the Irish railway system is an anti-social exhibition of economic power. A certain section of the railway workers are using their power in order to press their claims, not on their employers, not on capitalists, because the Irish railways are owned by the Irish nation; they are pressing their claims on a nationalised industry, an essential public service in mid-winter when everybody wants railway services. They are using economic pressure to better their position at a time when the whole nation is doomed to a fall in the standard of living. I do not for one moment suggest that the claims which are being made by railway workers are in any way unfair. I do not know enough about the case. But I do say that to press or enforce even a just claim by certain methods is in itself wrong. Ends do not justify means, and just ends do not justify unjust means. All history shows that when power is abused public opinion insists on that power being reduced. There have been many examples in modern Europe of abuses of power by economically strong groups which have been followed in some cases by a very stringent Nemesis indeed. I do not think we need go further than the history of our own country in the last 100 years. We have all read, and it is a commonplace of Irish history, of the way in which landlords abused their power. They were a privileged class. They lost their power ultimately because they abused it. Public opinion forced legislation to reduce their power. That should be a lesson to-day to other privileged groups. The centre of gravity of privilege may move from century to century but every class which abuses its power will eventually suffer defeat.
These are rather important issues though I do not wish to delay the House too long upon them. I have suggested that rises in wages by organised groups may have deleterious effects on other groups. A rise in the general wage level, far from remedying a situation, may make things even worse. A rise in the general level of money wages at a time when the price level is rising does not really do anybody much good. I cannot help feeling, therefore, that the Government is right in the attack it is making on this problem by trying, so far as it can, to keep down a further advance in prices. This claim for higher wages is based on rising prices. It is a very natural claim and one which it is very hard to resist. Everything that can be done to hold down prices is important at the present time. I am perfectly aware of the difficulties inherent in the situation. They have been referred to by Senator Douglas and by other speakers to-day. I quite agree that certain price levels are altogether outside our control. Many imports have gone up as a result of world causes, but that is a situation over which we can exercise no control. I suppose one could substitute home-produced commodities within certain limits for imports but, in all fairness, without raising too many questions, I think most people will agree that complete and 100 per cent. substitution is too much to hope for. In so far, therefore, as the price of imports enters into the general price level it is somewhat difficult to see what can be done about it. Subsidies may be the answer up to a certain point, but subsidies are expensive and, owing to the type of distribution of income here, it is very hard to find anybody to tax to pay such subsidies other than the people who enjoy them. Therefore I think the possibilities of holding down prices here by means of subsidy are very remote.
Furthermore, I agree with everything Senator Douglas said in relation to not discouraging business people. In general, profits must be allowed, since they act as a stimulus to enterprise. If profits are taxed out of existence by keeping prices too low there will be an insufficiency of investment and a lack of enterprise. People will no longer have the stimulus to economise or be efficient and they will no longer have the stimulus to make profits. One must remember that there must always be sufficient funds for industry to meet its replacements and carry out its repairs at a time when prices are undoubtedly rising and therefore the depreciation allowed now and the replacement allowance made must be on a generous scale.
Another point to which I would like to refer, though it is one which may not receive universal agreement, is that I do not see why dividends should not be allowed to rise. We have not yet accepted here the principle of dividend limitation in relation to our fiscal policy and I do not see why people who invest money in Irish companies should not be compensated to some extent for the rise in the cost of living, at least to the same extent as labourers and the poorer sections of the population.
Circumstances are constantly changing. Irish industry has been through very difficult times in the last few years. To go too far back in examining accounts, too far back in an effort to make industry now pay in some way or other for a period of prosperity it may have enjoyed in the past would, in my opinion, undermine business confidence. I think this process of dealing with prices and profits ought to be a very, very carefully controlled one. As Senator Douglas has said, if prices are set too low, commodities go under the counter. Supplies dry up and the last situation is worse than the first. People are driven into the black market and the very poor find themselves unsatisfied.
Having said all that, I still think there is a case for a strict control over prices in the present situation. But I think there has been a certain slight confusion introduced into this debate by the constant slipping from the word "excess" to the word "excessive" in regard to profits. I do not think excess profits and excessive profits are necessarily one and the same thing. The terms have been used interchangeably in the course of this debate. If evidence can be found of profiteering in the general sense of the word, that is of people who are taking advantage of a scarcity in order to make unreasonable profits or to increase prices unduly, I think that situation should be remedied and those who suffer must be afforded protection.
Some weeks ago, speaking on the Industrial Development Authority Bill. I referred to rings, monopolies and trade cartels. I think they should be inquired into. I think that possibly most of the allegations are exaggerated or unfounded but, at the same time, the public believes in them. If they are not true they should be shown to be untrue. I think they should certainly be investigated. Earlier this evening I referred to restrictive practices in trade unions. There are restrictive practices in business too. All such restrictive practices, whether on the part of labour or on the part of commerce, should be investigated with a not too friendly eye. I think all protected industries should be examined. They are in a sheltered position. I do not think it is fair that business people should expect shelter and unlimited profits at the same time. As was said here to-day, the essence of price reduction is healthy competition. That is perfectly true. In some of the sheltered industries there is no healthy competition. Where that does not exist vigilance and inquiry are vitally essential. Indeed, one should almost view such industries with suspicion.
As regards the proposed committee or tribunal, it is probably as good as anything else we can get. One must admit, of course, that difficulties exist. I quite agree that the difficulties have not been exaggerated either by the spokesman on this side of the House, who put forward the business point of view, or on the Opposition side of the House putting forward the Opposition view. There are one or two suggestions I would like to make in relation to this proposed committee or tribunal which might possibly increase its effectiveness within certain limits. In the first place, I think it should be constituted very rapidly.
I think the problem is urgent and the need is great. The institution of a tribunal of this kind is one of those things which depends for its effectiveness on being done rapidly. A great deal of damage can take place before its institution if it is talked about too much. The problem of prices and the problem of scarcities are problems which are going to get worse and not better in such a situation. I think that the tribunal should be, not only one which should be rapidly instituted but one which should be as rapid in its proceedings as is consistent with efficiency. The suggestion that by appointing a tribunal the Government is in some way or other evading its own responsibility would, I think, possibly be substantiated to some extent, if the tribunal were one that operated with endless delays and if every time a question was asked regarding prices in the Oireachtas, Deputies were told that the tribunal was still investigating the matter it would give a certain colour to that suggestion. Therefore, I do suggest to the Minister to press on the tribunal the necessity for rapid action. In order that it should be rapid in its action, it should have certain powers. Something that was said about the Industrial Development Authority is true of this tribunal—that it should have power to get all the information required, to summon witnesses, to get evidence on oath and so on.
Subject to what I have said already, the proceedings should be as public as possible. This tribunal is meant to allay public suspicion. Therefore, as the Minister said himself this evening, the proceedings should be as far as possible, conducted in public. The public are at the present moment in a very suspicious mood and the best way to prevent further labour trouble and further pressure to increase wages, is to convince public opinion that an honest effort is being made, as far as possible in public, to keep the cost of living down and to prevent other sections of the population from benefiting themselves in a time of national emergency.
The tribunal must command confidence and confidence in the tribunal will depend on its personnel. I do urge on the Minister very strongly to choose for this tribunal personnel of a kind which will inspire confidence. I have got no idea of the sort of people he proposes to put on the tribunal but I do suggest to him that the success of the tribunal will depend very largely on the personality of the people who compose it but, above all, on the chairman. I furthermore, suggest to him that he should be prepared to revise his plans in regard to the tribunal. It is being asked to do a difficult job in a rapidly changing world and I think he should be prepared to change his policy if necessary, in the interests of efficiency. It is more important to get this job properly done than to be entirely consistent.
May I make a final suggestion, that the Government as far as possible—I know there may be exceptions—should follow the recommendations of their own tribunal? If the public feel that the tribunal will sit and make recommendations and that the recommendations will not be followed by the Government, they will begin to lose confidence in the tribunal. I do think it very important that the public must have some idea that the Government will feel itself almost as much bound by the findings of the tribunal as they do by decisions of the courts of law— in other words, that the tribunal should be a quasi-judicial authority with the same dignity, the same status and the same independence as the law courts.
I want to say only one other thing before I sit down because I do not want to give any impression of lack of sympathy with the social problem and what I said about labour a moment ago might be so interpreted. In so far as the line cannot be held, in so far as the price of articles that do enter into the cost of living cannot be held—I think we shall have to admit that they can be in some instances—the Government should make it part of its declared policy to define a minimum income for all the poorer sections of the population, employed and unemployed. The nutritional surveys provide ample material for showing the types of food which are required by different sections of the population. I do think that regard should be had to the minimum requirements of the poorer sections.
Organised trade unionists are able to look after themselves—I think I have already dealt with that—but there is a submerged tenth in the population of poor people with small incomes. If the cost of living goes up in spite of all that can be done by the tribunal, then I do think that these people should be protected against hardship. I think that that will involve, in the case of people in employment, a certain amount of subsidisation of foodstuffs, even if it should cost the taxpayers something, and in the case of people out of employment, some sort of rise in the level of social services. These are the only suggestions I can make to the Minister. I fully sympathise with him in his difficulties and I think his attempt to solve them will receive sympathetic consideration from every member of the House.
Comment on this
In my capacity as President of the Dublin Chamber of Commerce, I yesterday headed a rather representative deputation to the Taoiseach and at that interview we had also present the Minister who is in charge of the Bill in the House to-night. The interview lasted nearly two hours and practically every phase of the situation that those constituting the delegation could think of was covered in the course of the interview. We went there in no hostile sense and I am glad that the debate was in no sense personal. I do feel, also, that much of what we said there yesterday helped Dr. O'Higgins, the Minister with us to-night, to present this problem to us in the reasoned and moderate language in which he did present it. The matter is so vital to us all that I feel I am entitled to ask, and the country will be entitled to know, whether we are to accept as the voice of the Government, the speech which we have had in this House or the entirely different speech on the same Bill which was made by the Tánaiste in the Dáil on the 6th of this month. At a time when I, in common with other representative employers, was spending hours and hours of our time, day after day, meeting representatives of organised labour in this country in an effort to think out conciliation machinery so that wage demands would be made in an orderly fashion, we had in that very morning's papers a speech from the Deputy Head of the Government that I am going to describe as vulgar, inflammatory and not worthy of the position that man occupies. This is no time for anyone in the position of Tánaiste in this country to come out with what was obviously an envenomed attack on the industrialists of this country.
As has been said in the course of the debate, the vast majority of the industrialists of this country are just as eager to keep prices down as any Minister of State or any of the vast body of the people described by the term "consumers." It may be a matter of surprise to the House to know that voluntary price control is already in operation by many representative manufacturers in this country. There are plenty of factors that are making it impossible for prices to be kept at present levels and that is why we at the deputation yesterday expressed the fears that we have, and which I am going to voice now, not about price-control machinery, but about this particular type of price-control machinery, if we are to accept the description as given by the Tánaiste, at column 1819 of Dáil Debates of 6th December:
"That tribunal will be expected to undertake the most critical and the most microscopic examination of every claim for an increase made to it, and there must be no increase given by that tribunal unless the case for such an increase is proved beyond all possibility of doubt. If there is to be a doubt, it is the public and not the applicant who will get the benefit of that doubt."
Is it using too strong language to say that that kind of speech will bring this advisory tribunal into being in an atmosphere of suspicion and will give it a loaded dice to play with? Is it any wonder that those of us who have industries now and who at the present minute are trying to create and bring into being here other industries look with fear on a new body, the composition of which is yet unknown, that is going to be given these microscopic powers? The speech of the Tánaiste goes on:
"——the public Press will be available to report the applications for increases and to read the examination of the witnesses before that tribunal."
There are various definitions of communism. I think that could rightly be described as the first lesson in communism in a State that puts its faith in private enterprise. Who is going to create private enterprise and to maintain it in the light of that speech? To get any increase at all, whether due to wage increases, increases in raw material or any other increases, every applicant must go before this mysterious quintette with powers as wide as that.
Neither this Government nor any other Government can control services which are based on contract estimates but which have an immediate impact on the manufacturing industries that have to utilise these services. Take printing, for instance—an important and very costly item in any business. Nothing that the Government can do will control the price of printing. If a manufacturer wants 10,000 envelopes to-day and he must pay to-day's price, then he has to absorb that price somewhere. If on top of that he has to have a building erected to extend his works or maintain his existing works, he has to pay the builder's estimate on the day he gets the job done. Then he has to go, cap in hand, to this body which is going to have further powers—I will not burden the House by giving the whole of the Tánaiste's speech—to compel that unfortunate applicant to go through every item of his costings to satisfy this tribunal that a rise in price is in fact necessary.
I am nearly 50 years in business and I have spent a good deal of time in organised business, in representative organised associations, and I am saying now that the thing is impracticable and it will not work, and that if it is going to operate in the way that is indicated in the Tánaiste's speech, you can bury the Industrial Development Authority now because it will have no function.
In common with other representative businessmen, I am at present personally engaged in the exploration of schemes calculated to bring new industries to that part of our country that needs them most, the West of Ireland, and to bring them to areas where there is no industry at present. It will surprise you to know that I have got the draft scheme here in my pocket and that is where it is going to stay while we have the suspicions and the doubts that are engendered by the Tánaiste's speech. In fairness to Dr. O'Higgins, the Minister who is here to-night, I must say that he did not use this extravagant language, this envenomed class hatred, that is evidenced in every line of the Tánaiste's speech.
The Minister here to-night gave a reasoned case why price control is necessary. We fully agree that price control is necessary but microscopic examination of the confidential information applicable to all private business is neither necessary nor wise, and it will defeat itself. I am sorry to speak so strongly. Because I expressed my fears yesterday, backed up by my fellow delegates, I hope that does not justify the description of "gloomy prophet," which was used by the Minister in the House to-night. If it is to be a gloomy prophet to base your forecast on what may happen, on life experience, and to express that before the tragedy occurs, then I am a gloomy prophet, but up to now I have been alleged to have the average degree of foresight and business acumen.
There is heavy capital investment in respect of supplies forward. The only way in which a supplier will accept an order to-day is that the price will be the price ruling on the day of delivery. Will anybody tell me what the delivered price of £20,000 worth of goods ordered this week—that is, raw materials for industry here—will be on the scheduled delivery date of next April or May, that is, assuming that the world will not be at war? When that material comes in, prices may be up 20, 25 or 50 per cent. because, if the present atmosphere of tension continues, this country, in common with every other country, will be glad to get supplies at any price, and we may not be able to get them at any price. But, suppose that we do get them and that, in order to keep our own businesses going and to keep our men employed, we have to pay the prices then prevailing, have we got to wait in a queue to go before this new body to justify the inevitable increase that world conditions have imposed on us?
These are practical things. There is no theory in any of this. It is hard fact, based, as I say, on the experience that is common to every business man. This is not any form of political criticism. This is not, I hope, anything in the nature of destructive criticism. It is merely an explanation of the fears that are entertained by the vast body of industrialists in this country at the setting-up of a tribunal that has been described in terms that have not yet been repudiated by any responsible member of the Government and we are entitled to assume that Deputy Norton in the speech I have quoted was in fact speaking with the full authority of the Government. I hope he was not.
To the underlying principles we do not object, as I have already said, but if this new body will be brought into being in an atmosphere as poisoned as this and given a loaded dice—there is no other meaning to "where there is a doubt that has to be given against the applicant"—then I say, with a full sense of responsibility, it will not get the co-operation that it would otherwise cheerfully get and which has been offered as recently as yesterday, at the interview, the co-operation of responsible industrialists. Price control is necessary. I have said that but there is something that I doubt any democratic constitution, any Government, can do, and that is, tear away all the veils of secrecy that are necessary in individual business. The business man, for very good reasons, does not want his trade secrets, his whole costings set-up, everything that is peculiar to his business exposed, not merely to his competitor but in as widespread a manner as is indicated here, through the public Press.
I could go on but I have no intention of going into all the things that were dealt with yesterday. I wanted to concentrate on one or two things. In saying all that, I must not be quoted as having any animosity to price control as such. Price control over the past few years has been applied far more rigorously than the man in the street has any idea about and, in addition to official control, we have had, and we are having now, a degree of voluntary control by the individual manufacturer to a degree that nobody in this House or in the other House has any conception of.
Comment on this
The speeches of Senator O'Brien and Senator Summerfield, after the speech of Senator Hawkins, brought back some sense of realisation into this debate. Listening to Senator Summerfield, it was not quite clear that he was at variance to any great extent with the ideas enunciated by the Minister in his speech when introducing this measure. The Senator may have certain fears, and in that sense perhaps he was justified. At least, it is natural that anyone speaking for industrialists here would approach a proposition like this with a certain amount of doubt. I cannot, however, imagine that he or any other practical person could for a moment dream that the secrets of a man's business are going to be revealed to the public. At any rate, we are not debating this issue on the speech of the Tánaiste in the other House. I did not actually read the Tánaiste's speech, but I suggest that were he here to defend and interpret that speech, perhaps it would present a somewhat different complexion.
I should like to congratulate Senator O'Brien on his very clear and precise definition of what he called the misuse of economic power. He said something that I think ought to be repeated by every good citizen in and outside this House. The misuse of economic power, either by those who possess it in such a way as that they are charged with the responsibility of handling the financial affairs of a country, by those captains of industry, or by the workers in any particular undertaking that affects the lives and fortunes, the comfort and the happiness, of a great section of the community, is a very serious matter for all of us. I think Senator O'Brien will to-morrow have his views re-echoed in many a cottage in Connemara, where the boys and girls from England who are in Dublin to-night cannot get home because one of our public services will not operate to take them home.
From the Opposition side to-night we had, first of all, Senator Quirke. I am not going to spend much time on him. To me he sounded as if he spoke with all the bitterness of the dispossessed. He rambled over years of history and went away back to the Locke Tribunal and, although he appeared to think that he was vindicated, it did not seem to me that he was particularly enjoying the vindication. I feel he got little comfort out of the result of that inquiry. He went on to refer to speeches made by Ministers and to the actions of different members of the Government which, in his view, were suicidal—that is how he described them. There again it did not strike me that he was particularly happy about what he called the suicidal actions of, the Government. I would have expected him to be in a more joyous mood. If your team wins an All-Ireland final, you will be expected to come out cheering and with a happy smile. But the Senator did not have any of that spirit at all. He came out with a strange prophecy—it seemed to me to be more of a statement of fact —that we were to have a general election on 11th March. I would like to remind the Senator that that will be a Sunday. There was something peculiarly continental in his declaration that we are going to have an election in Ireland on a Sunday.
Comment on this
I wonder where the Senator got his inspiration? The whole problem that has been debated round this measure in the other House and, to a certain extent, in this House, is one that concerns every citizen. The matters involved in the debate are matters to which we should give our most intimate and thoughtful attention. As far as possible we ought to bring an air of realism into our discussion. If we make statements about the situation, they should be as close as possible to fact and there ought not, even on the part of the Government's political opponents, to be too much extravagant exaggeration.
One cannot help observing the desperate efforts of the Opposition and of the propagandist organ of the Opposition over a long period to destroy the people's morale, especially on this question of the cost of living. The utmost effort is being made to create disorder in the minds of the people, and those who ought to be leading the way, trying to bring light to those who may be somewhat in darkness, are not setting an example that patriotic Irishmen can speak proudly of. There is no question about it, I would not attempt to deny that there has been an increase in the cost of living.
Comment on this
Therefore the Parliamentary Secretary was wrong?
Comment on this
The truth, of course, is, as the Minister said here to-night, that external conditions are operating to raise the cost of many products that go into the calculation in making up the cost-of-living figure. The Parliamentary Secretary's statement was to the effect that up to mid-August the cost-of-living figure was approximately stationary. Now, there have been changes in this country and in the outside world since August. If you study the newspapers you will find this sort of contradiction. One of the commodities discussed here to-night was bacon. If you read to-day's Irish Press you will find an article indicating that the price of pigs in England is better than it is in Ireland and if our pigs are to be exported they will have to be subsidised. After consideration you will discover that that article was written for the purpose of causing disquiet amongst the farmers, convincing them that they are not half as well off as farmers across the Border or in Britain, and it is playing its part in discouraging our farmers from continuing in pig production. That should be taken into account, but the purpose of doing that is something that perhaps only the mind of Senator Quirke could reveal.
Having gone on that line, they are talking about the Minister for Agriculture lifting the ban on the export of pigs to the Six Counties and, lo and behold, the farmer here who was only getting £10 a cwt. for the pig before the ban was raised is getting £12 now. Yes, it is true; we got it. Then the next day that something has happened to please the farmers, you find another article telling how a bacon factory is closing down and the workers are to be thrown out of employment, because the ban has been raised and the pigs of the Republic are being driven across the Border; and side by side with that you are told the price of bacon is going up.
Comment on this
Senator Burke is not here to-night. I hope he is not leaving you, too.
Comment on this
I can manage to make my speech without Senator Burke or Senator Quirke, and I am going to make it in my own way. I would like those opposite to tell us what they want. Do they want the farmers of Ireland to get an economic price for pigs, do they want the farmers to be encouraged to produce pigs; what price do they want the farmers to sell their pigs at? If that be their attitude, who is going to buy the bacon? Who but the Irish consumers? Are the Irish consumers prepared to pay the farmers the economic price for raising pigs or are they not? The people who write these propagandist sheets cannot have it both ways, and that is something we should try to get clear as quickly as we can.
You go from pigs and find a complaint about butter. Senator Hawkins talked about the price of butter here to-night. He could have told the House, if he wanted the House to have all the facts, that while we are subsidising the eight ounces of butter to-day which the Irish consumer is buying at 2/8 a lb., in his day, when he sat on this side, we were getting only four ounces.
Comment on this
Bacon is 4/4 a lb. to-day. What is that due to?
Comment on this
Some time ago, when the Minister for Agriculture made a trade agreement, since the present Government came into office, it was made possible to export to Germany a quantity of butter, valued I think for close on £1,000,000, and sold at the full economic price. Then the outcry goes up that the people of Ireland are left without butter. At the same time, the same organ will be trying to convince the farmers that if they do not get a higher price for milk at least the present price must not be reduced.
Comment on this
Is the Senator in favour of reducing the present price?
Comment on this
No, he is not. I am pointing out the line being taken by the Fianna Fáil propagandist sheet and I want to know what the purpose is, as it is clear to me that it is not a patriotic purpose.
Take the price of beef. Senator Quirke referred to the bargain made by the Minister for Agriculture in regard to the sale of our beef. The price to-day for beef sold to the foreigner is at least £5 or £6 per beast more than it was when Senator Quirke's colleague made a bargain with Britain.
Comment on this
The Tánaiste said that the £ being paid for it is worth only 13/5 as against 20/- when we were sending beef across.
Comment on this
What is said in regard to sugar? Sugar was being subsidised in your day and it is not any dearer, as far as the ration is concerned, than it was in your time and there is more sugar available for the consumers, since less of it is going into the black market. That is the real truth and I do not want to go any further, but I could say something that would be rather startling.
Comment on this
The Senator had better not be holding back anything. We are waiting for three years for some of those scandals.
Comment on this
You had one good go at me, in trying to put me out of the country, but I am in it still. You had the Locke tribunal. Everyone associated with the Coalition Government and everyone who sat around the table to concoct that gangster compact is equally guilty.
Comment on this
With regard to turf, we have Senator Hawkins declaring that the policy of this Government has reduced the amount of turf available. I do not know what Senator Hawkins knows, but I know that none of those who were in hand-won turf this year in any part of my county got their own turf themselves—and that is true as far as I know it from one end of the country to another. I challenge Senator Hawkins to contradict me. In the case of every farmer around me—and all of us are making turf—every sod of turf we made is in the bog.
Comment on this
They might be, in Senator Hawkins's mind, but I assure him that they are just as industrious as they are anywhere else in the country and I can say that of wide areas in my own county and in Donegal and elsewhere; and I have inquired from one end of the country to another and as far as I know the story is much the same. The truth is that the situation in regard to turf supplies is entirely due to the unhappy season through which we have gone. Where is the use in coming to this House with a cock-and-bull story about the infamies of the Coalition Government in regard to turf policy? I am not going over that old story again, but we all know that the files in the Government offices reveal that there was a decision taken in regard to hand-won turf by the predecessors of the present Government, before they left office.
Comment on this
I know, of course, there is a great deal of talk. Senator Quirke himself talked about the coal in the park.
Comment on this
It is not. If the Senator will be good enough to drive myself and himself up to the park to-morrow in his posh car, I will show him thousands of tons of coal.
Comment on this
If it will burn, the citizens of Dublin need not have fear of empty grates. I am not saying that there will be a blaze in the grates.
Comment on this
I am not discussing that. It is there anyhow. Its value is another matter. We are not the only country in which there is a fuel crisis and, mind you, we were to a greater extent than most depending on peat and whatever you may do with coal in a wet season, you cannot make much hand of peat.
Comment on this
You did not do half as much with it nor with anything else.
Comment on this
You had statements made yesterday that the coal output in Britain is responsible for the fuel crisis on the continent at present. I have here a copy of the Belfast Telegraph of Thursday last, which gives figures in respect of the imports of coal into the Six Counties. It says: “Northern Ireland received 12 per cent. less than its allocation of domestic coal and 16 per cent. less than its quota of industrial coal over the past three years. It was allocated 590,500 tons of industrial coal for 1950, and it received 496,888 tons, and of other coal it was allocated 1,098,000 tons and it received 900,000 tons.” The Statesman and Nation has this to say about production in Britain, and it is full of sympathy for the Coal Board. It is a very Leftist organ and stands for all this idea of nationalisation. It says:—
"Did the present coal crisis take the National Coal Board by surprise? It is a serious crisis which threatens to involve much greater consequences for Britain's whole economy than it has experienced as a result of the severe freeze-up in 1947."
You have it there. They are trying to import coals to Newcastle. We, are trying to get coal from Newcastle. The people on the continent are short of coal because the miners are leaving the mines in England. Where is the use in blaming the Minister because our fuel supplies are low? Would it not be much better to face the facts?
Comment on this
Would it not have been better for him to make hay while the sun was shining?
Comment on this
You are a lucky man you have old hay. It is value for money this year. We are all spending more living during the reign of the present Government than we did in the days of its predecessors. That is true. We have more to spend. One of the first things that happened when the Government came into office was that there was a general increase——
Comment on this
In wages, and all-round increase amounting to millions of pounds in the year. What did the people do?
Comment on this
They went out and spent their money on better living. You can see that everywhere around you.
Comment on this
I thought there was no increase in the cost of living?
Comment on this
This debate must not develop into a cross-talk between Senators Baxter and Quirke.
Comment on this
Go up and down the country and see the conditions as they exist to-day and let anybody, after studying the situation, come back and make allegations that things are not better than they were three years ago.
Comment on this
And we are paying the interest on it. If it is being invested in Ireland, it is the best possible job that any Government could do. It is showing confidence in Ireland and in its people and that is what we saw very little of a few years ago. You could take out an insurance policy on the prospects of the few, but not in the case of the many. We had Senator Hawkins talking about emigration.
Comment on this
I was afraid the Senator might forget about the petrol.
Comment on this
You will not make the Senator forget what he is going to say. We have been talking about emigration over the years. According to Senator Hawkins, 70,000 emigrated. Do not we all know that 250,000 people emigrated during the war period when Fianna Fáil were in office? It is a problem to which we have got to face up to and it is not a problem that can be solved by any one group.
Comment on this
What did the Commission on Emigration do about it?
Comment on this
Apparently they have not reported yet. I hope, when they report, they will get better treatment than some of the commissions received during your time.
Comment on this
Oh, they will report all right—after the election.
Comment on this
You have to take into account the fact, as pointed out by Senator O'Brien, that you are going to have increases in living costs from external causes over which we have no control. A lot was talked about provision being made by the Government against these days. I do not know whether you people want peace or war.
Comment on this
You want peace, but all the time you are trying to make war and produce an atmosphere in the minds of our own people by diverting their attention from the things they ought to do for the sake of peace to something else that is not going to be of benefits even in the time of crisis. We are asked: "What are the Government doing?" It is not any use trying to inform some of the Senators because they would not accept it. Senator Quirke referred to things the Government ought to do. I am not in disagreement with him on that. I never was. I was saying them before Senator Quirke, but I did more about it than Senator Quirke, in the physical sense, at any rate. When he was selling land to Englishmen, I was trying to do a spot of work on my own land.
Comment on this
We take it that it is accepted generally that, when the Minister for Agriculture says that the stocks of wheat in the country are greater than ever before that is something on which the Government ought to be congratulated. There are limitations to the quantity of grain we can import into the country. We cannot store grain here as they do in parts of the Middle West of America, by leaving it out in the fields. We have not got these climatic conditions here, and we know how little was done over the year to make any provision for a time of crisis like that.
Comment on this
There should be some provision made for fine weather, anyway.
Comment on this
What about the stocks of coal and turf that were in the Phoenix Park? Is there not any gratitude whatever due to Deputy Lemass?
Comment on this
It was the people of the country that produced that. Deputy Lemass never cut a sod of turf in his life.
Comment on this
The nation paid well for whatever stocks were in the park and the taxpayers of the country have been losing money ever since.
Comment on this
If Senator Quirke were depending on the slack coal in the park for his breakfast, I am afraid he would come in hungry. Somebody was talking about fertilisers. I notice the Minister for Agriculture is making provision to import 100,000 tons of fertilisers. That is something for which the Senator should applaud the Minister because it is something which was not done by any of his predecessors. I was on that side of the House when I tried to urge the Minister to make provision against a war that was obviously inevitable, but there was nothing like that in store in this country when the last war broke out. Now it is urged that we should have stocks of fertilisers, so far as we can lay in stocks. We can import certain quantities of superphosphates, but obviously supplies of nitrogen are going to be difficult to obtain, but they are going to be difficult, and are difficult, to obtain in Britain. That is the true position and that is one of the difficulties with regard to stocks of fertilisers.
I am not contradicting Senator Quirke with regard to the value of the horse. I believe in the value of the horse. I believe in the value of every bit of power, whether it comes from man, horse or machine. I believe that all these have to be utilised in a time of crisis and it is on the basis of the capacity of our people to improvise, to organise and to co-ordinate these various forces that we will get the best out of the land and out of the people.
Comment on this
So therefore the Minister for Agriculture was wrong?
Comment on this
He was not. That is just the Senator's usual effort to distort everything the Minister says.
Comment on this
I want to say that there are internal causes for price rises that have to be taken account of. Senator O'Brien has referred to the dislocation of our transport organisation to-day. I passed men carrying placards up and down one of our main streets to-day and these placards are apparently being carried for the purpose of preventing men from going to work, men who are willing to work at the wage. Did I hear an interruption by Senator Quirke?
Comment on this
Those placards are about the Baltinglass Post Office, I think.
Comment on this
No, nor about the post office in Stradone, County Cavan, either. Inquire into that when you get time.
Comment on this
I have already done so. There is nothing wrong with it.
Comment on this
If the people who are carrying banners changed the mottoes on their banners or changed the story these banners tell and said something like this: "Any increase which we receive means that the rate for carrying beet, wheat and peat must be raised, as must also the rates for carrying cattle, pigs, butter and bacon, and, when we achieve that, we are going to increase the cost of living," they would be nearer the truth.
Comment on this
When the Minister for Industry and Commerce compelled the railways to keep on 3,000 men who were redundant, that did not mean any increase in the cost of freight?
Comment on this
The Senator is admitting they were redundant, so that it is a fact, after all, that his colleague, when in office, was going to let these 3,000 men go?
Comment on this
I do not know whether these people are trying to make themselves redundant or not, but the net result of every increase which any of us demand for our hire is that costs somewhere must go up. If you increase costs on farmers, make no mistake, the price of their product must be raised, and when it comes to the people, to the consumers in the towns and cities, they must pay a share of that burden which these people have imposed. There has to be more attention paid to this factor—I think it is a vital factor—in the cost of living. The strange thing about it is that these very people who, by their economic power, insist on imposing this burden on the community, will come back the next day and tell you that the price of milk, of bacon and of butter is too high. We are not going to get anywhere along those lines. I should have hoped that there would be a realisation on the part of this House that there are difficulties abroad in the world. Senator Quirke and his colleagues think we are on the brink of war. Pray God, we are not.
Comment on this
If we are on the brink of an election, Senator Quirke does not appear to be too happy about it, because I never saw him in a more disagreeable mood.
Comment on this
There is no election mentioned in this Bill.
Comment on this
The truth of the matter is that we are only a small community with limited resources. If difficulties come upon us through external causes over which we have no control, they are going to bear harshly on all of us. The Minister in this measure has introduced a new section which appears to have come in for a good deal of criticism. So far as the members of the commercial community who are affected by it are concerned, I do not see why any man with a straight case should have any fears. I hope that none of the industries in which Senator Quirke is interested will come before this tribunal and not get a fair deal.
Comment on this
One of them will not, because the Minister for Agriculture put it out of business because I was chairman. The Minister for Defence knows all about it.
Comment on this
You will accept it before I am finished, and a lot more things along with it.
Comment on this
It is true that there is disquiet amongst a considerable section of the community about the rise in prices.
Comment on this
They have risen recently. No one is denying that. All that I can say is that if the Senator were where I am now, he would not have prevented them rising.
Comment on this
They probably would have risen long ago and to a much higher level. They have risen because of factors outside the control of this Government. That is the truth and Senators opposite know it. In the quietness of their own corners, they will admit it, while pretending to be great fellows for putting over such and such a story, but that is not acceptable and is not accepted.
Comment on this
Would the Senator give us some information as to what steps this advisory council will be able to take in respect of these increased prices over which the Government have no control?
Comment on this
The Government have no control in regard to certain increases in prices because some of the commodities involved in production have to be imported either at an increased price, as has been the case recently, or from the hard currency area where, because of devaluation, prices have risen, or, as I believe with Senator O'Brien, for other reasons. If you take men away from various activities in which they have been engaged over the past two or three years, if you take them away from industry and productive enterprise and put them into the armed services, naturally the commodities they were producing, the raw materials of industry, are going to be in short supply and prices inevitably are going to rise. It is quite right that a Government should take control of a situation like that.
Why should the man who is able to justify himself with regard to his demand for an increase—I take it that it is a legitimate increase—be ashamed to come before any tribunal and justify his action? If his case is straight, nobody will stand for any body that will not deal fairly with the industrialist, the producer when he comes before the court and puts his cards on the table. If his case is straight, his case will be accepted. If he is making undue profits—and there possibly are people who are making undue profits— the sooner that is ended, the better, in the interests of all decent industrialists.
I would hope that that is the approach we would all make because we are all consumers—some may be consumers and producers—and we are all interested in this. I think that in the situation confronting them the Government are doing the right thing. I believe that they will set up a body which will be able to arrive at the facts and, having the facts before them, will adjudicate upon them with an impartiality which will command the respect of the country and that when that time comes these propagandists will have the legs taken from under them. The reason for the increase in prices will be revealed and whether it is a legitimate increase or not and whether they are friends or foes the decision of this body advising the Minister will be accepted. I would hope that instead of taking this stand that this authority will be unjust, this authority composed of Irishmen as it will be——
Comment on this
I would hope that instead of that it will be accepted as what it is meant by the Government to be, an authority coming between producer and consumer which will examine the situation, which will be able to hold the scales fairly between the various sections interested, which will set the country's mind at ease and destroy once and for all this propagandist campaign which has been going on for months, which is detrimental to the national interest, and which is no credit to the political Party responsible for carrying it on.
Comment on this
I promised the Senator I would allow him to elaborate on the petrol scandal.
Comment on this
The Senator will not be allowed to do so.
Comment on this
The Senator made a suggestion by innuendo that I was implicated in a petrol scandal and I insist on thrashing it out.
Comment on this
That is like the other scandals we have had, they cannot be proved.
Comment on this
Ní bheidh sé éascaí, tar éis a bhfuil cloiste againn, teacht ar ais go dtí atmosféar ceart na díospóireachta. Dá gcloisimis an óráid deiridh an tseachtain seo chugainn nuair a bheas na geamaireachtaí ar bun bo mhó ba feiliunaí é, ach tar éis a bhfuil ráite ag an Seanadóir, agus ráite sa mbealach ar labhair sé, caithfidhmuid ár ndícheall a dhéanamh dearmad a dhéanamh air agus teacht ar ais go dtí brí cheart na díospóireachta.
Chuir sé ionadh ar chuid de na Seanadóirí a labhair tráthnóna go raibh an oiread sin spéise sa mBille seo is atá, go raibh an oiread sin díospóireachta ina thaobh is atá. Ní mheasaim go bhfuil na daoine dáiríre go bhfuil ionadh orthu faoin ní sin, mar dá mbeadh siad dáiríre, thuigfaidis an fáth go bhfuil spéis sa mBille ní amháin sa Dáil agus sa Seanad, ach taobh amuigh i measc an phobhail.
Some of the speakers this evening have shown some surprise that this Bill should have received the attention it has received in the Dáil and in the Seanad and outside. I do not quite appreciate why they should be surprised that interest has been shown and that this Bill has been subjected to the amount of criticism to which it has been subjected since it came before the Oireachtas. The House will have noticed that the Supplies and Services Bill was originally introduced on the 8th November of this year. Authorisation was then given by Dáil Eireann to have it printed, and it was in due course printed and circulated. No sooner was that done than the voice of the community was raised in protest to such an extent that the Bill was withdrawn and a new Bill brought in in its place. The second Bill was ordered to be printed on the 22nd November and contained one extra provision, and that provision has to do with the setting up of this advisory body. It is clear that the Government had neglected to fulfil its duty regarding this question of prices and the general question of supplies. It is no wonder that the people outside and many people in the Dáil and Seanad felt that they should not let the occasion, pass without making a most solemn protest against the failure of the Government to attend to these urgent, these grave matters.
It may be said that we on this side of the House have not been very constructive and I am not going to spend a whole lot of time making recommendations to the Minister, but I want to remind the Seanad that I subscribe and my colleagues here subscribe fully to the proposals contained in the Industrial Efficiency Bill which was introduced towards the end of the last session.
Notice taken that 12 members were not present; House counted, and 12 members being present,
Comment on this
I quite realise I am not at liberty to discuss that Bill, but I mention the matter so that the House will realise that we on this side of the House are not merely destructive in our views on these matters.
Senator Professor O'Brien said that the public is suspicious. He is quite right. The public is suspicious and gravely suspicious. I think it would be true to say that a great many of those who hold some measure of confidence in the present Government now feel that their confidence is misplaced. The public is suspicious and not without grave reason. The question of the cost of living has been mentioned frequently in the debate here and it occupied a good deal of the attention of the Dáil. Certainly, it is a burning topic among the people outside. It is one of the most important questions to which attention might be directed in these days and perhaps the main advantage of this Bill is that it has focussed attention in a proper and an orderly manner on that particular question. There is a good deal of confusion with regard to the cost of living and Senator Professor O'Brien dealt fairly fully with it. It is quite true that it would be better if greater scope were given in this discussion for a review of the whole question of the cost-of-living index. However, the main trouble is that people are mistaking the retail prices index for the cost-of-living index.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, certain spokesmen for the Government did not seem to realise that there was a serious difference between the two terms and they used this retail prices index as if it were a cost-of-living index. I am not going to go into the shortcomings of the cost-of-living index. Its outstanding faults are well known. In the first place—I think Senator Professor O'Brien adverted to it—by the time we get the figures relating to retail prices and to the cost of living, they are out of date. Again, changes in the weighting of certain items ought to be made, I think, much more frequently than has been the case so far. We know that new items should be introduced and that there are change levels that have to be taken into consideration. The public is unhappy about the whole question of the cost of living. The public was promised very definitely by certain people that in certain eventualities the cost of living would be brought down by 30 per cent. The people who made that promise have had pretty well the power to enforce their view during the past period of almost three years, if they had cared to remember their promise and if they had cared to make a genuine effort to have it fulfilled. That promise was not made lightly. The people who made it were people who claimed to be experienced in public affairs. They had some experience in Parliament. Apparently they had advisers of some standing. Failure to keep that promise or even an effort to keep that promise has undoubtedly shocked the people of this country.
On occasions, we were told by a very responsible member of the Fine Gael Party that our difficulties could be surmounted by manipulating the monetary system of the country. It was clearly indicated on one occasion that it was merely a matter of printing more money and all the difficulties of the people would be got rid of. It has been said that the cost of living has been held steady. That, of course, is not true. On balance, the retail prices index has remained fairly steady: it did show a slight rise but, in reality, the cost of living of very many people has changed, and changed for the worse. I know of very many people who, because of Government policy, have lost their livelihood. The question of a rise or a fall in the cost of living was, in its way, of very big consequence to them. The income and the supplements to their income that they had been enjoying and for which they gave valuable service were snatched from them. That is true not of isolated individuals but it is true of very many thousands along the seaboard from Donegal around to Cork.
Senator Baxter told us that the people have more money to spend. I am sure some people have more money to spend but I am sure, from interviews with people who came to me on occasions—not merely road workers and builders' labourers but tradesmen, such as butchers and professional people, such as teachers, and so forth—whatever Senator Baxter may say about more money, that these people have experienced increasing difficulties during the past two and a half or three years. Senator Baxter talked about more cars on the roads as being an indication of the prosperity of the people. I only hope that I shall see the day when every man who wishes to have a car may have one. However, I can remember very vividly the occasions when Senator Baxter and his colleagues denounced the Fianna Fáil Government because motor cars appeared in considerable numbers in O'Connell Street after the war. Fianna Fáil was denounced at the time as being responsible for providing people with gains of an ill-gotten nature, and it was said by certain people that the presence of these cars and the ability of people to run them was an indication of the failure of the Fianna Fáil Government. If that is true of Fianna Fáil, then I can only say that the huge increase in the numbers of cars in recent years is a downright condemnation of the present Government.
Senator Professor O'Brien said that the public is suspicious—and why should it not be suspicious? The failure to implement election promises with regard to the cost of living, the failure to reduce taxation, the failure to carry out the recommendations of the commissions or committees appointed by the Government, when, from the manner in which these commissions were appointed, it was understood their recommendations would be implemented, all these things have created not alone suspicion in the minds of the people but have shocked them.
Anyway, this Bill has led to the criticism of the Government which we have had during the past three or four weeks. As an instance, some one mentioned here this evening, I think it was Senator O'Brien, the Roe Committee. From the way that committee was appointed, it was evident what the recommendations would be. The majority of its members were of a certain mind. Yet, the treatment of that committee's recommendations was nothing less than scandalous when all the circumstances are taken into account.
Reference has been made to the attacks on industry by the Tánaiste and by other people supporting the Coalition during the last year or two. Surely, the information relating to industries must be available to the Government already. During the term of office of the last Government, the Leader of the Labour Party, the present Tánaiste, was very vocal on the profits that were being made by industrialists. After assuming the office of Tánaiste, he indicated that he had examined the balance sheets of Irish industries, and said that from his investigations of these balance sheets, he had come to the conclusion that the owners of these businesses had got away with exorbitant profits—to such an extent that they ought to be imprisoned. He was either honest or dishonest in his criticisms of these people. If he knew that Irish industrialists had been acting unfairly and unjustly towards the community when he was in opposition and when he became Tánaiste, why did he wait for three years to take some steps to rectify, what he considered to be a grievous wrong?
There has been a prices section in the Department of Industry and Commerce for a long time. It seems to be a growing habit with us to throw bouquets at our higher civil servants. I do not think these bouquets are out of place. As regards the civil servants whom we have met we have learned to respect them, and, by and large, we have learned to trust them. They must have gathered a considerable amount of information from their practical investigations and from their reports of various kinds regarding the level of prices and profits. We have had for some years now a Labour Court functioning. One of its duties is to report on price trends, to consider wage levels and wage values. If the Government wanted specific information it might have gone there and asked for it. We have had functioning for about 20 months the authority which is known as the Industrial Development Authority. Last week, when the Seanad was discussing the Bill dealing with that authority, it noticed that, in several places, the question of prices was adverted to, and that the duty was placed on this authority to investigate prices, the effect of tariffs on prices and so on and duly to report to the Government.
We have had ad hoc committees. We have had a special committee of eminent people appointed to investigate the prices of flour and bread. We all remember the speech which the Minister for External Affairs delivered in County Cork—in Youghal, to the best of my recollection—in which he threatened to expose the people engaged in this industry. He indicated that if the public knew of the gains accruing to those people it would be shocked. He had ample opportunity of bringing forth this evidence himself or of placing it before the three gentlemen who comprised this flour and bread inquiry committee. Certainly, as far as the Minister for External Affairs is concerned, and as far as those who have been levelling these charges of excessive profits against those engaged in the bread and flour industry are concerned, their whole case has been a flop.
Further information is obtainable, if necessary, from the revenue commissioners. They have pretty full information on the results of the trading of businesses, not alone of registered companies but of all types of business, and they would have been in a position to indicate fairly generally to the Government what the position was with regard to this question of profits. Why did the Government wait so long to take this action? It seems to me that the Government simply buried its head in the sand and refused to listen to the appeals made to it to make some effort to fulfil its promises, and so the position has deteriorated to what it is to-day.
The question has been asked—I need not debate it now—as to whether prices are reasonable or not, whether profits are reasonable or not, and as to what constitutes a reasonable level of profit. I agree with Senator O'Brien that this question of profits is one of very great importance. I believe that people who are willing to save and put their money into business are entitled to a reasonable return on their money. If 5 per cent. was a reasonable return in, say, 1938, would it be held that 5 per cent. is a reasonable return at present? I am aware of a few cases, at any rate, where people are dependent on what comes to them in the way of dividends and interest. I can only say that in these cases where the rates have not changed the situation of these people is anything but one to be envied. I believe that people ought to get a reasonable level of profit. Who is going to decide what that level should be? If the Government has strong views about it, and from the speeches of some of its members during the term of office of the last Government and from their speeches during the last general election one must conclude that they had strong and definite views, why did they not do something about these matters in the meantime? It is a crime against the nation that the Government has failed to make adequate provision to meet the crisis.
Fuel has been mentioned. One would think that the fuel difficulty is one that arose only the other day. On several occasions in this House I adverted to the fact that fuel was in short supply, in Galway one day, in Sligo another day and in Ennis another day, and that has been the position for some years past. When one goes to the merchants' offices, if the notice is not already hanging up "No coal, no turf, no blocks," then you are politely told on making the inquiry that the fuel is not available. That is something which has arisen time and again during the past two and a half or three years. It is something of much longer than recent development.
The failure to make provision for certain industrial supplies is also one on which the Government must be censured. Senator Hawkins referred to the question of cement supplies. One might mention others. Senator Baxter would probably be interested in the supply of nitrates. Surely an investigation into the possibility of supplying that valuable fertiliser should, instead of being curtailed, be pushed ahead. Should anything happen, it certainly will be a commodity which will be hard to get. We know what its absence meant to us during the last war.
It is true that the Government has failed to take adequate steps to ensure this country's food supply, as it has failed to take proper steps to ensure reasonable supplies of feeding stuffs. I only wish that we had a somewhat saner Minister for Agriculture than we have had in the last few years. Might I quote this gem from one of his speeches? Talking of a tillage policy, and so on, he said:—
"If that policy involves growing barley and brewing it into beer to intoxicate the British people in order to get their money to spend it in France or America, I will do it. I will glory in that policy of brewing beer that will intoxicate quicker than any beer in the world."
It surely would have been much more in keeping with his responsibilities, with his dignity and with his duty to this country if he had taken some steps to ensure an adequate supply of the essential foodstuffs for this country should the emergency which we all dread develop.
Reference has been made to the question of the balance of trade and the balance of payments. During the period of Fianna Fáil these were matters that were continually adverted to. The Government of the day was accused of failure because these accounts were not in balance and were not more favourable to the nation than they were. Certainly, in view of the opportunities given, in view of the easing in supplies over most of the period of office of the present Government, much more might be expected in these matters than has materialised.
Labour unrest is as grave now as it ever was. I want to join with those who have expressed the hope that the sanest of counsels will prevail among the trade union leaders and the trade unions. I realise, like the speakers who adverted to the matter this evening, the grave danger that may flow to the whole Irish economy if the greatest care is not exercised in regard to the claims which are being made. It is not for me at this juncture to pass judgment on anything that has been done or that has been projected. I only hope that the sanest counsels will prevail and that the nation will not be pushed into a much more dangerous condition than it is in at the present time.
In that connection, I do not know whether the trade unions are still against the idea of incentives in the way of piece work. There are many ways in which workers might be encouraged to do more in their own interests and in the interests of the nation. As one who has worked under the time system and who has worked and worked hard under the piece rate system, I plump for the piece rate system. I have not yet heard any argument to convince me that it is not a good system. It is not applicable in all cases, but, where it is applicable, I should like to see both labour leaders and employers sit down to a discussion of the matter and I would like to see and would hope to see the introduction of the system in consequence of that discussion.
We have had endless commissions and committees appointed to deal with matters which the Government itself should have dealt with. It is because of the failure of the Government to deal with these things that the suspicion to which Senator O'Brien adverted exists.
I move the Adjournment of the debate.